Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Q4 2025] Meta Deep Value Intelligence
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. It is Wednesday, January 28th,
- 0:032026 and today we are we are looking at something pretty
- 0:09monumental. This isn't just another
- 0:11quarterly report. No, not.
- 0:12We are looking at what might be, and I don't think this is an
- 0:17exaggeration, the single most significant changing of the
- 0:20guard in the history of the tech industry.
- 0:23It really feels that way. We're looking squarely at Meta
- 0:26Platforms, you know the company we all used to call Facebook,
- 0:28right? And their Q4 and full year 2025
- 0:31earnings release just dropped a few hours ago.
- 0:33And I've been going through it and let me tell you, it feels
- 0:35like the ground is literally shifting under our feet.
- 0:38How so? This isn't just about ad
- 0:40impressions anymore. Or, you know, daily active
- 0:42users. That's the old story.
- 0:44We are witnessing one of the most radical pivots in corporate
- 0:46history, and it's happening right now, you know, in real
- 0:49time. It really does feel that way.
- 0:50I mean, think about the narrative we've all had for the
- 0:51last 15 years. For over a decade we thought of
- 0:53Facebook and then Meta as this this ultimate software money
- 0:58printer. It was the dream business model,
- 1:00wasn't it? Absolutely.
- 1:00You build the code once, maybe in a dorm room, you ship it to
- 1:03billions of people for basically nothing.
- 1:05And the margins are just astronomical because you don't
- 1:08have to build factories or ship physical boxes.
- 1:12But the signal we got today, it suggests that whole era is dead.
- 1:17Completely dead. I think you're right.
- 1:19The entire narrative has flipped on its head.
- 1:21They are morphing from a capital light software business into a
- 1:26capital heavy industrial utility.
- 1:28That is a heavy phrase. Industrial utility.
- 1:31That sounds old, like railroads or something.
- 1:33It's the only way to describe it, though.
- 1:35It's not just about writing clever code anymore.
- 1:37No, now it's about pouring concrete.
- 1:38It's about securing nuclear energy permits.
- 1:41It's about buying silicon at a scale that frankly rivals what
- 1:46entire countries do. So they're becoming something
- 1:48closer to an electric company than the social network we grew
- 1:51up with. That's a perfect analogy.
- 1:52So, OK, our mission today is to try and parse these conflicting
- 1:57signals because on one hand we've got record revenue, I
- 2:00mean, absolute blowout numbers all.
- 2:02Right, the top line looks amazing.
- 2:03But on the other hand, there's this massive, just eye watering
- 2:07spending that makes you really question the sanity of the whole
- 2:10balance sheet. We need to decide, is this a
- 2:12visionary bet on artificial general intelligence that's
- 2:15going to secure their dominance for the next 50 years?
- 2:18Or is Mark Zuckerberg just digging A reckless money pit
- 2:21that's going to incinerate investor capital?
- 2:23That is the trillion dollar question, and I think you're
- 2:26right to frame it that way. It feels like a binding scenary
- 2:28outcome. There's not a lot of middle
- 2:30ground here. OK, before we get into the
- 2:31numbers and wow, there are a lot of numbers to get through, we
- 2:34have a quick tool for now, you know, to keep a pulse on the
- 2:37broader market while you're listening to all this to track
- 2:40total market temperature. Welcome to search and download
- 2:43the iOS app Buffett Indicator from the Apple App Store.
- 2:47It's a great way to see if the market's general mood matches
- 2:49the the craziness we're seeing in these earnings.
- 2:52And as always, we have to do our necessary reminder before we
- 2:55really dive into the weeds on this.
- 2:57Of course. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 3:00on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 3:03or differing interpretations. The content is for educational
- 3:07purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 3:11Please conduct your own due diligence before making any
- 3:13investment decisions. And finally, if you want our
- 3:17full deep dive on this or access to more of our advanced content,
- 3:20welcome to join the Deep Value Club membership.
- 3:22Or you can subscribe to us on Apple or Spotify podcasts.
- 3:26The channel is deep value investing and deep values dot
- 3:29AI. We've got the full valuation
- 3:31models we're going to touch on today available for download
- 3:33there. Great.
- 3:34OK, let's get into the meat of this.
- 3:35The headlines are flashing everywhere right now.
- 3:37What is the top line story? What's the first thing people
- 3:40are seeing? The headline story is pure
- 3:42unadulterated growth. I mean, if you're just a surface
- 3:44level investor and you only you look at revenue, right, the
- 3:47machine isn't just humming, it is roaring, Yeah.
- 3:49For the fourth quarter of 2025, revenue hit $59.89 billion.
- 3:5459.89 Let's just call it 60 billion.
- 3:57Basically 60 billion and that is up 24% year over year.
- 4:01OK. Let's just pause on that for a
- 4:02second. 24% growth for a company of this size.
- 4:06I mean, we are talking about one of the largest companies on the
- 4:08planet to grow a quarter by almost 25%.
- 4:12It's just, it's massive. It's mathematically difficult to
- 4:15do that at the scale normally, you know, the law of large
- 4:17numbers kicks in and everything just slows down to a crawl.
- 4:19But they're defying gravity somehow.
- 4:21They are, and for the full year for 2025, they crossed a huge
- 4:25psychological milestone. Revenue came in at $200.97
- 4:29billion. $200 billion. 200 billion exactly and just to give
- 4:32you some context on that, that's up 22% from 2024.
- 4:36So what this proves is that despite all the talk about a
- 4:38slowing economy, all the fears of a recession in 2026, the core
- 4:43advertising business, the engine that pays for absolutely
- 4:46everything else, it's still a monster.
- 4:49It's effectively printing money. So the revenue is fantastic, top
- 4:52line looks beautiful. But when I was looking at the
- 4:54profitability numbers, things started to get, well, weird.
- 4:58The operating margin dropped and the tax rate looked incredibly
- 5:00high. I think a lot of our listeners
- 5:01might have been confused by that.
- 5:02What in the world is going on there?
- 5:04Right. And this is where we really have
- 5:05to separate the signal from the noise.
- 5:07It's so important, OK? If you just look at the raw gap
- 5:10numbers, you know the standard accounting numbers, you might
- 5:13think profitability is just collapsing which.
- 5:15Is what I thought at first glance.
- 5:17But you have to account for the specific legislative landscape
- 5:21of 2025. Specifically, you have to
- 5:24understand the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, or OBB, The OBB,
- 5:30right? This was that massive omnibus
- 5:32legislation that got passed back in Q3 of 25, wasn't it?
- 5:35That's the one. It was a huge sweeping tax
- 5:37reform bill and that act caused massive accounting noise for big
- 5:41corporations like Meta. Also specifically it triggered a
- 5:44$15.93 billion one time non cash income tax charge.
- 5:50OK, hold on. Let's unpack that so everyone
- 5:52can follow along $16 billion just vanished from the bottom.
- 5:56Line TIF gone. But you said non cash.
- 5:59What does that mean in simple terms?
- 6:01It means they didn't literally write a check to the IRS for $16
- 6:04billion yesterday. Got it.
- 6:06It's an accounting adjustment. It's based on the value of
- 6:09assets they held for tax purposes, called deferred tax
- 6:12assets, But because of accounting rules, they have to
- 6:15report it as if it were a loss on their income statement this
- 6:18quarter. That is not small change, $16
- 6:21billion is more than most companies on the S&P 500 make in
- 6:25a lifetime. It's a huge number and it
- 6:27completely skewed the reported effective tax rate for the full
- 6:30year. It made it look like it was 30%.
- 6:32And normally for a tech company, it's what, much lower?
- 6:34Much, much lower. Historically, a company like
- 6:37Meta pays something in the neighborhood of 15% to 17%.
- 6:41If you strip out this specific OBB charge, there effective tax
- 6:44rate for the year would have been around 13%. 13 so a massive
- 6:47difference. So if I'm an investor or just
- 6:50someone trying to understand the real health of this company, I
- 6:54should basically just ignore that charge, pretend it never
- 6:56happened? You have to normalize for it,
- 6:58yes, yeah. If you want to know the true
- 7:00earnings power of the business, you absolutely have to strip out
- 7:04that one time tax bill. And if you do that, what does
- 7:06the profit look like? Well, if you do that, the net
- 7:08income wouldn't be the reported 60 billion.
- 7:11It would have been approximately $76 billion. 76 Wow, that is a
- 7:16massive difference in perceived earnings power.
- 7:19A completely different story. So the underlying engine is
- 7:22actually significantly healthier, maybe 20, 5%
- 7:25healthier than the headline profit number would suggest.
- 7:27Much healthier. The business is generating cash
- 7:30at an absolutely incredible clip, but, and this is the big
- 7:33butt of this entire deep dive here.
- 7:35It comes. Management isn't hoarding that
- 7:37cash. They aren't just putting it in
- 7:39T-bills and letting it sit there.
- 7:41They are about to spend it. All of it, and then some.
- 7:44And this brings us to the part of the report that I think made
- 7:47everyone's jaw just hit the floor.
- 7:50The guidance, the guidance. We're not just talking about a
- 7:52little increase in the R&D budget here.
- 7:54We are talking about what you could only call a CapEx shock.
- 7:59Shock is exactly the right word. I mean, when the CFO read this
- 8:04number on the earnings call, you could almost hear a pin drop
- 8:06across Wall Street. So what was the number?
- 8:09Management forecasted their capital expenditures, their
- 8:11CapEx for 2026. They are guiding for a range of
- 8:15105 billion to $117 billion. Hold on, just let me repeat that
- 8:22slowly. So it sinks in over $100 billion
- 8:27in one single year on buildings and machines.
- 8:30That's right. To put that in perspective for
- 8:32everyone listening, how does that compare to what they used
- 8:35to spend? Well, let's go back to 2023.
- 8:37It was the famous year of efficiency.
- 8:39Right when they were cutting costs and laying people.
- 8:40Off exactly. They spent roughly half of that,
- 8:43and then in 2025 they ramped up to about $70 billion, which
- 8:46everyone at the time thought was crazy high.
- 8:48And now they're almost doubling it again.
- 8:50Now they're stepping on the gas to hit almost 120 billion.
- 8:53I mean that amount of money, it rivals the entire GDP of some
- 8:57small nations. That's an incredible thought.
- 9:00It is an unprecedented level of infrastructure investment for a
- 9:03single tech company. It's more than ExxonMobil spends
- 9:07digging for oil around the entire planet.
- 9:09Where is all that money possibly going?
- 9:11Are they literally buying a small country?
- 9:13In a way, they're building a digital one.
- 9:15OK. The vast, vast majority of this
- 9:17is going into two main things, AI training clusters and then
- 9:21all the physical infrastructure you need to support them.
- 9:24AI training clusters, so we're talking about GPU's.
- 9:26We're talking about buying the absolute next generation NVIDIA
- 9:29GPU's, the B200 and the B300 series.
- 9:32These are the successors to the Blackwell chips.
- 9:35Exactly. Most powerful, most power hungry
- 9:37chips on earth. And that's not all.
- 9:39They're also manufacturing their own custom silicon.
- 9:42They're MTIA chips and. What are those for?
- 9:44Those are specifically designed to handle the workloads for
- 9:47their recommendation algorithms you know you see in your feed.
- 9:50And all those chips need a place to live.
- 9:52You can't just put these in a closet in Palo Alto.
- 9:54Exactly right. And you can't just plug them
- 9:56into a standard wall outlet. They consume massive amounts of
- 9:58power and they generate massive amounts of heat.
- 10:01So data centers. Massive new data centers.
- 10:03The report specifically called out a new facility being built
- 10:06in Richland Parish, Louisiana. And these aren't just warehouses
- 10:10with a bunch of servers in them anymore.
- 10:12These are GW scale facilities. GW scale.
- 10:15That's power plant language. It is, and that's why they are
- 10:19actively investing in nuclear and renewable energy sources.
- 10:22Not for PR, but just to power the cooling systems and the
- 10:26processors for these things. They're literally becoming
- 10:28energy brokers. This feels like a like a
- 10:30fundamental structural shift for the entire company.
- 10:33We used to talk about Facebook as this beautiful high margin
- 10:37asset light business. The whole idea was just write
- 10:40code. That era is over.
- 10:42Yeah. This is, I think, the most
- 10:43crucial insight from this entire quarter.
- 10:46Meta is no longer a software company with 80% margins, not in
- 10:50the traditional sense. It's becoming an infrastructure
- 10:52utility. An infrastructure utility like
- 10:55Con Ed or a water company. Think about it, when you build a
- 10:59utility, what's your biggest expense?
- 11:02It's not your people, it's your equipment.
- 11:04The power plant itself. Exactly.
- 11:06It's depreciation. You build a power plant, it
- 11:08costs you billions, and you write off the cost of that plant
- 11:12over say 20 years. Meta is now doing the exact same
- 11:16thing but with servers and GPU's.
- 11:19So depreciation is becoming their biggest line item.
- 11:22Depreciation is replacing cost of goods sold as the primary
- 11:25weight on their income statement.
- 11:26So for the listener, what that really means is the economics of
- 11:29the entire business are changing.
- 11:30It's getting way more expensive to make a dollar of revenue
- 11:33because you have to buy the machine first.
- 11:35That's it. It's a huge upfront cost and the
- 11:37market is looking at this in a very binary way.
- 11:39There are two camps forming around this stock right now.
- 11:41OK, what are they? Camp One says this is a
- 11:43necessary Moat widening it's. Brilliant.
- 11:46A Moat widen. Yes, the thinking is if they
- 11:50don't spend this $100 billion, they lose the AI war, their ad
- 11:54targeting gets worse, user engagement drops, and eventually
- 11:57they just die. So it's survival.
- 11:59It's survival of the fittest. And what's Camp 2?
- 12:01Camp 2 has a much scarier name for it.
- 12:03They call it Profitless Prosperity.
- 12:05Ouch, that sounds painful. It's a terrible concept for an
- 12:09investor. The idea is that sure, revenue
- 12:11will keep growing, but the free cash flow, the actual cash the
- 12:14owners of the business get to keep, it's going to evaporate
- 12:18because they have to keep buying these incredibly expensive
- 12:20hardware upgrades every single year, every two years, as a
- 12:24treadmill you can never get off of.
- 12:25You have to run faster and faster just to stay in the same
- 12:28place. That is a scary thought, but OK,
- 12:31let's look at what's fueling this treadmill.
- 12:33We established the revenue is growing like a weed.
- 12:36Where specifically is it coming from?
- 12:38Is it still all just Instagram ads?
- 12:40It is overwhelmingly the family of apps.
- 12:42So that's Facebook, Instagram. Facebook, Instagram, Messenger,
- 12:45WhatsApp and now Threads. That whole segment generates
- 12:4897.8% of their total revenue. 97.8% So for all the talk about
- 12:54the metaverse and AGI, this is still an ad company.
- 12:57At its core, it is the cash cow that funds everything else.
- 13:00Reality Labs. You know, the VR and AR stuff
- 13:03that only contributes about 1.1% to the top.
- 13:06Line 1%. It's basically a rounding error.
- 13:08A very expensive rounding error and the other category.
- 13:11That's things like the WhatsApp Business API and the Meta
- 13:13Verified Blue check subscriptions.
- 13:15That's growing fast. It's up 59%, but it's still very
- 13:18small dollars in the grand scheme of things.
- 13:20And what about the users? I feel like for years we've been
- 13:23hearing people say oh, Facebook is dead or nobody uses it
- 13:26anymore, especially not young people.
- 13:27The data just doesn't support that at all.
- 13:29As of December 2025, they hit 3.58 billion daily active
- 13:34people. 3.58 billion. That is nearly half the entire
- 13:37human population. Every single day, using one of
- 13:41their apps, that is the inventory that Meta sells to
- 13:43advertisers. They are selling the attention
- 13:45of half the planet. And here's the magic formula
- 13:48that happened with that inventory this quarter.
- 13:50In Q4, the number of ad impressions, so the number of
- 13:55ads they actually showed, went up by 18%.
- 13:57OK. So more volume.
- 13:59More volume, but at the same time the price per ad went up by
- 14:026%. Now that's the Holy Grail, isn't
- 14:04it? I mean usually in economics one
- 14:06O 1, if you flood the market with supply, if you increase
- 14:09volume by 18%, the price should crater.
- 14:12Exactly. The laws of supply and demand
- 14:14say the price has to go down. They're defying that.
- 14:17It's incredibly rare to see this kind of price times volume
- 14:20growth, especially at this kind of scale.
- 14:22What does that tell you? It shows they have immense
- 14:24pricing power and it shows that their AI, the advantage plus ad
- 14:28targeting tools is really, really working.
- 14:31Advertisers are willing to pay more for each ads because the
- 14:34ads are converting so much better.
- 14:35So this brings us to the whole idea of the Moat.
- 14:37Why are they so hard to kill? I mean, we've seen powerful
- 14:39challengers like TikTok, we've seen snap, but Meta just keeps
- 14:43getting bigger and more profitable.
- 14:44Sort of call a triple layer Moat now.
- 14:46OK, layer one. Layer one is the classic one.
- 14:48Network effects, the social graph, leaving Facebook or
- 14:53Instagram just painful because that's where all your memories
- 14:56are, it's where your friends are.
- 14:58That hasn't really changed, right?
- 15:00You leave, you're basically in a digital ghost town.
- 15:02You're alone. Layer 2 is the data advantage.
- 15:06This has become even more important since Apple changed
- 15:08their privacy rules a few years ago.
- 15:10The ACT tracking transparency thing.
- 15:11Right, That made First party data king, and Mana knows more
- 15:14about what you click on and what you like than anyone else
- 15:17because you're doing it inside their walled garden.
- 15:20They don't need Apple's permission to see what you just
- 15:22liked on Instagram. Makes sense.
- 15:23And the third layer. The third layer is this new one
- 15:26we've been talking about. It's compute scale.
- 15:28The $100 billion spending spree. Exactly.
- 15:31By spending that much money, Meta is erecting A barrier to
- 15:35entry that is almost insurmountable for anyone else.
- 15:38Because nobody else can afford to play the game at that level.
- 15:41Precisely. There are maybe, what, two or
- 15:43three other companies on Earth? Microsoft, Google, maybe Amazon
- 15:47Web Services. They're the only ones who can
- 15:49even think about spending $100 billion a year on silicon.
- 15:53So if you're a snap or a Pinterest.
- 15:55If you're a Snap or Pinterest or some hot new startup, you simply
- 15:58cannot afford the compute power needed to train the AI models
- 16:03that make the ads and the content feeds relevant.
- 16:06You get squeezed out by raw brute capital force.
- 16:09So in a weird way, the CapEx shock is actually a defensive
- 16:12move. It raises the stakes of the game
- 16:14so high that all the smaller players just have to fold their
- 16:16cards. That is the bull case in a
- 16:18nutshell. They're spending their
- 16:19competitors into oblivion. But it's not all smooth sailing.
- 16:22I mean, we have to talk about the risks.
- 16:23And there's one risk that has a very specific and very expensive
- 16:26name, Reality Labs. Ah yes, the metaverse.
- 16:30Bet the elephant in the room. We mentioned it's only about 1%
- 16:33of their revenue, but what is it doing to the bottom line?
- 16:35It is bleeding cash aggressively.
- 16:38Reality Labs is still losing approximately 15 to $20 billion
- 16:41annually. 15 to 20 billion every year, that's just gone
- 16:45incinerated. Vaporized.
- 16:47And if you look at the cumulative investment since they
- 16:50really started this big pivot into the metaverse, it is
- 16:53approaching $100 billion. That is a staggering amount of
- 16:57capital and poured into something with so little to show
- 16:59for it on the revenue side. It's historic and the risk here
- 17:03is just incredibly simple. Unless virtual reality and
- 17:06augmented reality become the dominant computing platform of
- 17:09the twenty 30s. Unless we're all walking around
- 17:12wearing Rayman Meta glasses in five years.
- 17:14Exactly. Unless that happens, this will
- 17:16go down in the history books as one of the largest single
- 17:19destructions of shareholder value in corporate history.
- 17:22It's a completely binary bet. It's the money pit that Camp 2
- 17:24was talking about, but that's an internal risk.
- 17:27What about the external threats? I know Europe in particular has
- 17:29been a real thorn in their side. Europe is a major, major
- 17:32headache for them. The EU Digital Markets Act the
- 17:35DMA is fully enforced now and. What does that do?
- 17:38It is forcing Meta to offer less personalized ad options to all
- 17:42of their European users. Basically, you can opt out of
- 17:45the deep tracking. Which means the ads they show
- 17:48you are Dumber and therefore they're worth less money.
- 17:50Exactly. If I can't target you based on
- 17:53your specific granular behavior, I can't charge the advertiser as
- 17:57much money for that ad spot. It degrades the average revenue
- 18:01per user in one of their wealthiest markets.
- 18:04It's a permanent drag on their efficiency.
- 18:05And what about here in the US? Are the regulators just leaving
- 18:08them alone? The FTC is still lurking in the
- 18:11background. They are still actively pursuing
- 18:13the antitrust case to try and break up Instagram and WhatsApp
- 18:16from Facebook. Is that likely to?
- 18:17Happen. Most analysts view a full
- 18:19breakup as a pretty low probability event at this point,
- 18:22But it's a tail risk. It's a non zero chance.
- 18:24It just hangs over the stock like a dark cloud.
- 18:27And of course, we can't forget the broader economy, right?
- 18:29Macro sensitivity Meadow relies on about 10 million active
- 18:33advertisers. A huge chunk of those are small
- 18:36and medium sized businesses. The local coffee shop.
- 18:38The person selling things on Etsy?
- 18:39The local plumber. Exactly.
- 18:41And if the economy really slows down in 2026, if we actually hit
- 18:45a meaningful recession, AD spend is the very first thing those
- 18:48small businesses cut from their budget.
- 18:49So Meta is really a proxy for the health of the global
- 18:52economy. It's.
- 18:53A great barometer for it. So OK, we have this money
- 18:55printing machine in the ad business, we have this money
- 18:57burning furnace in Reality Labs, and we have this wall of
- 19:01regulators trying to chip away at them.
- 19:03Who's the person steering the ship through all this?
- 19:06Well, it's Mark Zuckerberg, and I think steering is probably too
- 19:09light a word. He is commanding it.
- 19:12He's directing it with an iron fist.
- 19:14And he has total control, right? Because of the sheriff's.
- 19:16Total, he controls roughly 61.2% of the voting power.
- 19:20He cannot be fired. He cannot be overruled by his
- 19:23board. He is operating in what Silicon
- 19:25Valley is now calling Founder Mode.
- 19:27Founder mode. I've heard this term more and
- 19:29more recently. It basically means you ignore
- 19:31the short term noise from Wall Street and just do whatever you
- 19:33want, right? That's essentially it.
- 19:36It means ignoring Wall Street's incessant demand for smooth,
- 19:40predictable quarterly profits in order to build a long term,
- 19:44world changing vision. And his vision is AGI and the
- 19:48metaverse. Correct.
- 19:49He is willing to stomach a $100 billion CapEx bill because he
- 19:53believes he is building the fundamental infrastructure for
- 19:56the future of AGIA. Hired CEOA professional manager
- 20:00would have been fired three years ago for this level of
- 20:02spending. But Zuck answers to no one but
- 20:04himself. And he's reshuffled the deck
- 20:06around him to the board of directors looks pretty different
- 20:08than it did just a year ago. Very different.
- 20:10The changes that were made back in January of 2025 were
- 20:13extremely telling. I think the most headline
- 20:15grabbing edition was Dana White. Dana White, the CEO of the UFC.
- 20:18One and only. That seems like a very
- 20:20unexpected choice for a tech company board.
- 20:22It is, but it's incredibly strategic.
- 20:24It signals a major shift in the company's culture.
- 20:27In what way? Dana White connects Meta to the
- 20:29young male demographic and this entire alternative media
- 20:33ecosystem. You know, podcasts, YouTube, the
- 20:35so-called manosphere. A demographic that Meta has been
- 20:38losing to TikTok and other platforms.
- 20:40Badly. It's also a bridge to the
- 20:42political right and potentially the incoming US administration.
- 20:46It's a statement says that Meta isn't playing by the old polite
- 20:49coastal corporate rules anymore. That is fascinating.
- 20:52It's a cultural signal as much as it is a business one.
- 20:55Who else joined the board? John Elkan, he's the CEO of
- 20:58Exor, which is the holding company that controls Ferrari
- 21:00and Stalantis, you know, Chrysler, Jeep Joe.
- 21:05So big heavy industry, cars, steel manufacturing.
- 21:10Deep industrial experience. If you were going to become an
- 21:12infrastructure utility, you need people on your board who
- 21:15understand heavy industry, not just people who understand
- 21:17software. You need guys who know how to
- 21:19build factories. And he's European, which must
- 21:21help with the regulatory stuff we just talked about.
- 21:23A. Huge help with navigating
- 21:24Brussels. And there was 1/3 name wasn't
- 21:26there? Charlie Songhurst.
- 21:27He's a deep tech strategist, formerly a key player at
- 21:30Microsoft. He's on the board for the AI
- 21:33road map to make sure the strategy is sound.
- 21:35So you have a board that is now built for three things, culture
- 21:38war, industrial scale, and AI strategy.
- 21:41It sounds like a wartime board. It absolutely is.
- 21:44But Speaking of culture, it hasn't all been smooth.
- 21:46There have been some pretty serious integrity issues raised
- 21:49in this latest report. Yes, there are ongoing
- 21:51whistleblower allegations that are pretty disturbing.
- 21:54Specifically, they're coming out of the VR division out of
- 21:57Reality Labs. What's the claim?
- 21:59The claim is that the division actively suppress internal
- 22:01research on child safety in order to prioritize user
- 22:05engagement and growth metrics. That sounds depressingly
- 22:08familiar. It's the same story we heard
- 22:10about Instagram and teen mental health years ago.
- 22:13It is a recurring and very troubling theme and the
- 22:15shareholders are noticing it. There was a shareholder proposal
- 22:18on the latest proxy regarding anti-Semitism and hate speech
- 22:21monitoring. Did it pass?
- 22:23No, of course not. It couldn't because Zuckerberg
- 22:25controls the majority of the vote, but it received 46.8%
- 22:29support from independent shareholders.
- 22:30Wow, that's nearly half of all the independent investors
- 22:33basically saying we are not happy with how you are handling
- 22:36hate speech and content moderation.
- 22:37It is a significant protest vote.
- 22:39It shows that while investors obviously love the profits from
- 22:43the ad engine, they're getting very wary of the governance
- 22:46structure and the broader social impact of the company.
- 22:49OK, let's get down to brass tacks, then let's talk about the
- 22:51valuation. After all, this is the stock
- 22:54cheap. This is where it gets really,
- 22:55really tricky. We like to use what we call the
- 22:57Guru tracker. The Guru tracker.
- 22:59Who are the gurus in this case? We look at famous dyed in the
- 23:03wool value investors, people like Lee Liu and Monish Pobray.
- 23:07They were buying meta heavily back in 2020 and especially in
- 23:102022 when the stock was just beaten down and left for dead.
- 23:13A smart move in retrospect. Are they buying it now?
- 23:15No. They sold out in 2022, and as of
- 23:19their latest public filings, neither one of them has
- 23:21reentered the stock. They're sitting on the
- 23:22sidelines. That's a huge signal in and of
- 23:25itself. They don't see the deep obvious
- 23:27value anymore. Exactly.
- 23:29And when we run our own valuation models, we start to
- 23:32see why. Let's look at it two ways.
- 23:34First, the discounted cash flow model, or DCF if you believe the
- 23:39AI utility thesis. If you believe all this spending
- 23:43is going to pay off handsomely in the future, our model
- 23:46suggests a fair value of somewhere around 690 to $710 per
- 23:51share. And the stock is trading today
- 23:53at around $672. So according to that model, it's
- 23:57fairly valued. It's not a screening bargain,
- 23:59but it's not wildly overvalued either.
- 24:00If you believe the AI bet works out, it's priced for success.
- 24:03But there's another, maybe tougher way to look at it right
- 24:06The classic value investor view. The Warren Buffett View using a
- 24:10metric called owner's earnings. And this paints a much, much
- 24:13harsher picture. Can you walk us through that
- 24:15math? Explain it in a simple way?
- 24:16Sure. Owner's earnings is basically
- 24:18trying to answer one question, how much cash can I, the owner
- 24:21take out of this business each year without hurting its long
- 24:24term competitive position? OK.
- 24:25So you start with that adjusted net income we calculated earlier
- 24:28the $76 billion and you add back depreciation which is about 20
- 24:32billion because that's a non cash expense.
- 24:34Got it. So we're at 96 billion.
- 24:36Right. But then, and this is the
- 24:38absolute kicker for a company like better right now, you have
- 24:41to subtract what we call maintenance CapEx.
- 24:44Maintenance CapEx. So that's the cost just to keep
- 24:47the lights on and stay competitive, not the growth
- 24:49stuff. Exactly.
- 24:50With this massive infrastructure build, we estimate that their
- 24:53maintenance CapEx alone is around $35 billion a year.
- 24:57You have to spend that much just to keep the servers from falling
- 25:00apart and to replace old chips. So 76 billion plus 20 -, 35.
- 25:06Gives you owner's earnings of about $61.4 billion.
- 25:09And when you compare that to the company's total market cap?
- 25:12It means the stock is trading at nearly 28 times owner's
- 25:15earnings. 28 times and a traditional value investor
- 25:18usually wants to pay what? Less than 15, ideally something
- 25:22closer to 10 or 12. So from that perspective, it's
- 25:26very expensive. It is expensive.
- 25:27It is priced like a high growth speculative tech stock, not like
- 25:32a mature cash gushing value stock.
- 25:35What about the share buybacks I saw in the report?
- 25:37They're buying back 20 to $30 billion in stock.
- 25:40Doesn't that help the shareholder?
- 25:42It helps a little, but you have to look at why they're buying it
- 25:44back. A huge chunk of that 20 or 30
- 25:47billion is just being used to offset dilution.
- 25:49Dilution from what? From stock based compensation,
- 25:53they are hiring thousands and thousands of incredibly
- 25:56expensive AI engineers, and they're paying them largely with
- 26:00stock options. The buybacks are just soaking up
- 26:02all that new stock so that the total share count doesn't
- 26:04explode. So it's not really returning
- 26:06capital to me, the shareholder, it's just paying the employees.
- 26:09You're just treading water on the share count.
- 26:11OK, let's try to pull all of this together.
- 26:12We have unpacked a lot of information here.
- 26:15We definitely have. So what does it all mean?
- 26:17At the end of the day, we seem to have a company that is, at
- 26:20its core, a paradox. It is the ultimate paradox.
- 26:24On one side of the Ledger, you have the world's most profitable
- 26:27advertising utility. It is a cash cow that simply
- 26:30works day in and day out. And on the other side, you have
- 26:34a speculative trillion dollar science project to build
- 26:37artificial general intelligence from the ground up.
- 26:39And that year of efficiency that we all heard so much about in
- 26:422023 and 2024. It's dead.
- 26:45It's buried. We have now officially entered
- 26:47the investment super cycle. It really feels like a
- 26:49completely different company than it was even two years ago.
- 26:52It is. And here is the question that I
- 26:54really want to leave our listener with, the one to chew
- 26:56on. Go for it.
- 26:57Meta now has a $100 billion annual infrastructure budget.
- 27:02It is actively striking deals for nuclear power.
- 27:05It has a daily active population of 3.5 billion people.
- 27:08That's larger than China and India combined.
- 27:11It is, in effect, issuing its own currency credits stars
- 27:14inside its own digital ecosystem.
- 27:16OK, so where are you going with this?
- 27:18At what point does Meta cease to be a company in the way we
- 27:21traditionally understand it and instead become a sovereign
- 27:24digital nation? And if it is a nation, does our
- 27:28standard sock valuation toolkit, you know, price to earnings,
- 27:31discounted cash flow, does any of that even apply anymore?
- 27:33Yeah. Or are we really trying to value
- 27:35a GDP? That is a very heavy thought.
- 27:38A digital nation with Mark Zuckerberg as its unelected
- 27:41permanent monarch. Precisely.
- 27:43Well, on that slightly terrifying note, I think we're
- 27:46going to wrap it up for today. Remember, if you want to track
- 27:48how the broader market is handling all of this shocking
- 27:51news, go check out the Buffett Indicator app on iOS.
- 27:54And remember, please conduct your own due diligence.
- 27:56This landscape is changing in incredibly fast.
- 27:58And for our full breakdown, all the charts and the deep dive
- 28:01valuation models that we discussed, please join the Deep
- 28:03Value Club. We will see you next time.