Latest / Huckaleros / Matt Foley of Nextcorps
Transcript
- Mike Brennan - Huckaleros: Welcome to Huckaleros. I'm Mike Brennan. And I'm joined today by Matt Foley of Nextcorps who has been really you know, a valuable resource as I've gotten into joining as a client tenant here. And you know, so I'm excited to explore your background and kind of see your entrepreneur entrepreneurial journey to that we can share the story. behind what what you've built and and how that path has led you here to this moment in time. what was your first inkling or experience with entrepreneur becoming an entrepreneur? What was it early in life? yeah, no, I wasn't one of those like you know, do the the lemonade stand kind of people. Okay. It came, it came later. actually it was in it was in college. so I went to undergrad for for business. And we had I had a really good entrepreneurship professor, Peter Russo, and he used to bring in entrepreneurs to talk to the class. Okay, cool. And you know, I'd ha we'd have different guest speakers from all walks of life. And I noticed that the entrepreneurs were, you know, by far the most passionate about what they were doing and they seemed like they owned their lives and their direction and their days. And I was like, Okay, that sounds That sounds really cool and appealing. so I I think kind of the spark came from from that. Like I didn't really know what I was supposed to do yet. Exposed to it. I didn't have my parents weren't entrepreneurs. That said, my dad worked at Kodak his entire life. or not his entire life, but a lot of his working life. And he went through, I think it was like eleven or twelve different rounds of layoffs. He made it through every one. Yeah. But his his He made it through every one. Yeah, yeah. Believe it or not, he made it through retirement. But whoa, okay, good for him. That's a that's an achievement like unlocked. Yeah, yeah, totally. Somehow he made it through. But he always told me, he's like, you know, if if if you have the chance, just go and do your own thing. Be in control. Being control. Yeah. You don't want to be like I was, always under the axe, always having that hanging over your head. It's a lot of stress. so you know that that also weighed in the And it's like being an entrepreneur, you it's self generated stress. But it's something but you but it's all within your control, I guess, as opposed to something like that is every quarter where those layoffs are coming, illuminate, you're seeing your coworkers happen. that's gotta be super stressful. Yeah. And when you have a family, it's w which stress do you wanna take which stress do you want to have like what you can have some control over, you have some agency over as opposed to I This is it's without it's outside of your control. Yeah. At that point. Yeah. Yeah. W you work for a big company, you have essentially one client. Yeah. You know, versus if I can diversify that risk over a number of customers, absolutely. At least I'm a little better off. So so that's between those two things, you know, he hearing him on my shoulders and seeing his experiences and the ups and downs, living that, you know, as a child and then and then going. To school and seeing like, okay, being exposed to these inspirational stories. I said, this this looks cool. What made you what made you decide to take the entrepreneurial class in the first place? I I had an inkling. Like I I I kind of saw it, I'm I'm I'm kind of creative by nature. I like building new things. So I also had that element of like, okay, I wanna, I like the idea of like building my own company. It feels creative. Sure. Within the business world, you know, which is not known for being creative in in many ways, but yeah, there's a saying, and I don't know who said it, but entrepreneurs are the artists of the business world, right? They're the people who create, right? And I agree with that I love this, I love this sentiment of like, okay, I can kind of shape my own way and shape my own path, but also create products and stuff. So so I I had that in the back of my mind too. and that class kind of maybe was unlock in that moment in time where it was like, Now you see the manifestation of what it looks like in a person. Yeah. It's like, okay, I I I could I could be like that. I can see yourself in that. Seeing that role model there of like, look at these these people that come in and tell these stories and like they're they're clearly successful. So so that was definitely the the inspiration for it. I had a I have a good friend that who was in the class at the same time. He's entrepreneurial as well. So, you know, the two of us did it together and yeah, it was just that was I think what really sparked it. Okay, I this is what I definitely want to do. That said, I didn't jump into it immediately after college. So I went and so graduated and then moved back to Rochester and got a job at a big market research firm called Harris Interactive. Okay. Yeah. And and so I and I I actually had like no I actually never even took a market research class. Okay. In college. I say what would what it was your degree in. Yeah. It was just a business, you know, business. Business student. Okay. So I don't know. I I had a friend that happened to work at this place and he got me in. And I actually liked it. It was like you know, it was cool kind of studying different like trends and str and talking to people and doing like I did geez, hundreds of Customer and user interviews. Okay. If not thousands over my for the years there. Would they have contracts with other brands or companies and they so they would be dip deploying market research for a client? For these huge companies. These huge yeah. Yeah. And so I was on the qualitative team, which means basically going out and talking, doing customer interviews, user interviews and things like that, which would prove to be extremely useful. later in my entrepreneurial. Yeah, yeah. That's it was kind of like, this is cool. You know, 'cause it is one of a core skill. Sure. If you get to to to do that and you're you're gonna be a lot better off. And you approach every single problem or every time you you approach a new business, you approach it from like the customer's perspective. And so that was drilled into me from working at a market research firm. Like that's what we did. Cool. So so I I spent three, three and a half years there. and just got to the point where I was like, you know, I'm making a lot of com money for this company. Like I I was I was doing it all. Like one of these projects, like a the the request would come in from the sales team and I'd price it, write the proposal, win the proposal, do the whole project, you know, report out to the client, the whole thing. And I was like, Was there any that stood out that you really like when the request came in, you're like, this is gonna be a good one? And like then or was it just kind of like You're doing so many and it was kind of all over the place. It was all over the place. Yeah, we was like B to B, it was consumer, it was you know, we were doing all different types of methods too. We were doing online, offline, in person interviews. I was I was traveling a lot, which actually got to be a little bit grindy. I didn't I didn't love it. It was like three weeks of the month, like traveling to different So you would actually do on sites at and then you would have customers. Yeah, we we would recruit there's there's weeks where I would do thirty ish customer interviews in a week. Wow. Sometimes over two cities. So I'd start in New York and then fly to LA and finish out the stuff. yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So so I so I did that for a a while. I just got kind of like burned out from doing that. But I I also at the time too developed a an expertise in doing website usability testing. So we'd have clients come through and they'd say, Hey, you know, we've got this whole like Dell was a huge client at the time. And we would say, you know, hey, we've got this whole path that we need to test to optimize conversion and we need to run users through it and just to understand like where are they encountering barriers. So I would go and do thirty ish interviews for Dell in some, you know, random US city. And I also learned a lot about like how to design user experiences. Sure. For software, it's kind of like the collateral of that. Yeah, yeah. It was another nice byproduct that I just happened to like develop this skill that would later Very useful. and so I also developed at that time an interest because I was working with so I would be the one interviewing the users, but we'd be we'd have behind like a one way mirror, we'd have designers and the developers like that actually built the product and designed the product. Taking notes, yeah, taking notes and like and so I got to interact with them a lot and I was like, that's kind of cool. Like I like that job. Like that's I like I'd like to be the person designing these experiences and then sure I can test it later, but taking what? is being shared in that in that space and for that specific thing and then okay this is what we're gonna do with it. Yeah, exactly. Like I wanted to like kinda like not just do the research and tell them here's what you need to do or change, but like be involved in the changing and the iteration. Yeah. Right. I was just like I was giving them recommendations, which would help, but I wanted to like, you know, build products. It's like so that was my first exposure to software's cool. I like software. Like you can iterate over things quickly. And I like doing this kind of user research and stuff. It's cool and and it's it's like a challenge. It's like it's always evolving. It's never done. So and there's and you could see that there was demand for it because there's a lot of the it was a lot of activity. yeah. Yeah. We were doing I I was doing a ton of these studies. So three years goes by and I'm just like kind of grindy, like too much travel. And I'm like, okay, I need to take a break. And I was realizing how much money I was making for this big yeah, this big research company. Yeah. So I said, you know what? I can go and do this on my own. So I randomly met this guy here in town that he happened to be doing the same thing. So him and I teamed up and started like a small UX user experience and usability research consulting firm. Okay. and it was within like a broader web development company, but like we we kind of started this division and we were doing a lot of the same things, but I started making more money controlling my future and started to get a taste for like Here's what entrepreneurship is like, here's what here's what it's like to to not just like price a proposal and win it and do all that sort of stuff, but like actually run right a business around that. You're taking it into your own you're taking your life into your own hands and and you're you're controlling your own future. Exactly. And that. Yeah. So that's the and what you learn from your father's experience was like, okay, that's that was the the the leap where yeah. It takes some Yeah. Takes a little bit of guts. It takes a little bit of 'cause you're you're inherently taking on risk in that stage. Yes. it's not like you everything was more risk than I had before. Right. and so I you know, I I did that for a bit. And then things kinda started to get a little wobbly there. There were some issues that with the kind of parent company that happened and some that's a whole other podcast. Sure. Okay. We come back and do that. That's a whole whole hour on that experience. But I did there's a couple things I realized out of that. And one number one was doing those interviews like that and doing those studies doesn't scale. Right? Like I was making good money. We we were making good money, but it still was a lot of travel. So I was being better compensated for it. But it was still me as the consultant going out and doing this. And I realized if I'm gonna build a scalable business I need to build a product. Right. so I was thinking to myself, okay, what can I what can I build that scales beyond me doing these studies? Like I can continue to do this for many, many, many, many years and continue to make great money doing it and grow a a a consulting business that way. But I wanted, I had ambitions to build something that was bigger than that. Yeah, so you can only sell so much of your time. You can only do so many of those engagements. And then I guess if you are looking to scale it. adds complexity. You're hiring people and you have to tr make sure they're trained and you know it's yeah that's a whole nother And a lot of times these clients were hiring me and and and my partner at the time because they liked us. Yeah. It was you. It was our hiring you were the product. Yeah I was the product at the time. That does not scale. Yeah. So I said to myself, so we we looked at ways like how can we productize the service and scale it. And ultimately what ended up happening though was kind of things fell apart. For various reasons. but at the same time, this was I'm dating myself here, but this was 2006 and social networks were starting to become a big thing. Yeah. And so I was a whole new era of the internet. A whole new era. Yeah. Like it was like, man, okay, this is gonna be Web 2.0. Web 2.0, yep. So I said, you know, this is gonna, this is gonna change the way we do things, particularly in market research. Because this was and this was the beauty of going off and working for. Big company for three years. And this is what I recommend like people coming out of college do. Like, you can't find problems in an industry until you've worked in the industry for like two to three years. Sure. you don't need much more than that. Like, I think after three years, you have three years, you have a sense of like what's what are the issues in this industry, and like what kind of things do I feel like I can tackle? So that was the perfect amount of experience that I had. I think at that year, that that point I had three to four years of experience, and I was like, okay, I know all the. the range of issues in this industry and I have a good idea how to tackle it. And by the way, here's all this new technology that's coming out, this web two point stuff. And a lot of the ways that people are starting to communicate are gonna help us tackle some of these challenges in the industry. Sure. So I I managed to convince my former manager, actually he was my manager for a bit at at the market research company, to join me to start a new venture. Okay. And it was it it was called Plugged in. which is named after a Muse song. I don't know if you're Yeah, I remember that that was happening to be listening to Plug and Baby by Muse. So the inspiration comes from in the inspiration. You know, and and that speaks to the artist artist, right? Yeah, artist, yeah, yeah. And my co-founder was also a big fan of Muse. and and he he we both were like, perfect name. Right. And it and it and it denoted what we did, which was kind of taking these big companies that were typically disconnected from their customers, consumers, or whatever. And plugging them into that voice of the customer. That kind of was like with the new technology. With this new technology. And so what we did was we we built essentially like a our own version of Facebook for las lack of a better word. Okay. Like our own software that was like a social network, but it was designed specifically for doing research. and so we got extremely lucky. We we teamed up with this local web development That no longer exists, but it was three guys. and we eventually recruited one of their their partners to become our CTO. Okay. And and to lead up the product development. but initially we were working with them, licensing the technology, and then we basically like in and building the tech with them, and then we brought it in-house. Gotcha. So we built this private social networking software that would allow these big brands to collaborate and co-create with their customers. So we we like our first customer was T Mobile. wow. It's yeah. Huge that's huge get it was a big thing. We happen to know we had a an inn at T Mobile, some a colleague that we we worked with previously, happened to go over to T Mobile and and run some research there. So we that's how we got the connection in for for the first customer. Network is important. Network your first job and that's another reason why having a few years of experience coming out of college 'cause yeah, I started building that building people that I knew and they go on to bigger companies and And they become your first customers. So we went in to T Mobile actually. The the story is we went in with a pitch deck and a dream because we did not yet have the technology built. Okay. But because we had that contact there and we were able to basically walk away with a check to say, Hey, okay, if you can deliver this in six months and get this project going in six months with this tech that you're you're building, we're they took it. They took a chance. They did take a chance. Yes. Now granted, like we knew. Him. He knew we were going to deliver right. Right. so we did deliver and that basically funded the company. because awesome. We funded the development of the product, plus my co-founder and I being able to work on the the product for a while. And we would occasionally do some consulting work to kind of pay the bills. Sure. But it was really we were trying to focus on let's build this scalable product and not the consulting stuff. Yeah. so we we did that. For a while and then we managed to just get keep getting like name brand clients. So I think Dell was our next client. Then we got Microsoft, Craft, General Mills, like College Board. Wow. we got all these types of things. Yeah, w once you get T Mobile, did that open up a lot of those doors to have those conversations with these other Hey, we just did this for T Mobile. Yeah. And that would be like what was the business development or sales processor. Was it like were you guys like cold calling? Is or Yeah. I I mean that was that was basically that became our reference client. Okay. From there on that said, one challenge that we still had was a lot of times these enterprises, and this is true today, even more so today I'd say, they can't buy from startups. Yeah. Like you're too small to go through their procurement process and their informational securities and audits and everything. So what we ended up doing For the first few years of the business was working through actually our old research company. We we actually went back to them because we didn't burn bridges, never burn bridges. We we kept those relationships going and they ended up becoming like a channel partner and we sold what this new technology that we had built through them. so you're getting access to enterprise to their enterprise. Yeah. But as a channel it through using them as a channel through which to get to their end clients. So we partnered with them on quite a few engagements and we did that with other big research companies as well, which later I'll get to proved fruitful one down the road. but I'll get to that. Sure, sure. So we we did that for a bunch of years. And then and then the more that you were able to build up that trust in those reference clients, the more then eventually we were able to go direct. Sure. Sure. so so so yeah, we did that for a bunch of years, grew our team. we were here in Rochester, which if you're here Great place to be, right? Because and here's why I I'm always so pro Rochester, right? I think if we had been in a big city, we would have had to raise money. Sure. Our overhead would have been way too high. Both in terms of personal like runway and living expenses. New York or San Francisco. New York and San Francisco, our rent would have been exorbitant. Our rent here was like nothing, right? Yeah, absolutely. Compared to bigger cities. and also we were able to, because we this was an expensive service. Our we this was six figures AR. from from each customer. From each customer. Yeah. So there's you're asking an enterprise sale. Yeah. Enterprise sale. So you gotta get on a plane or or drive. So because Rochester, where it's located in the northeast, we just get in a car in the morning, go schedule the pitch for the afternoon, right? Get in the car, drive down to New York or Boston or wherever we need to be, Toronto, whatever, and pitch these these customers. And they would be in those and Toronto's right across the lake. And you know it's huge. biggest city in Kaza also huge like center of commerce, especially for Canada. But yeah, I mean I I just went down the city like last week or was right on the edge of the city last weekend. It's like five hours you're there, five and a half. You know, it's it's not that far. I've taken the train in multiple times. If you want to work on the train, it's like yeah. Yeah. And so I think that's something of if you are a startup here, like the leverage you have in the cost of living and the and the capabilities, but you still all you gotta do is Like the access to a big market is is right a day trip. Yeah. It's a day trip. So I mean, granted, we're just talking the northeast, but there's I don't care which startup you are, there's plenty of business around here. You can start by targeting like customers around in l you know, regionally and then you can expand from there. So absolutely. interestingly, we actually never had a customer in Rochester. That's funny. All of our all of our customers were outside of Rochester and Kodak actually worked with a competitor of ours, which kinda sucked, but you know, that's That's wild and all and it's indicative though of that place and time where I don't think it maybe before that that era of web two point doing things online and being able to service people in different g geographic regions without being there physically, I think was more challenging. Yes, it was. You know, so having the technology and the the rise of that interactive element of the internet gave birth to a lot of Totally different now. Now you can pitch anybody anywhere. Right. I still think though if you're selling like we are selling stuff that's six figures, you gotta get in front of them. They're not gonna nobody sign over something unless they're It's big commitment. You come into their office and they meet you. So they wanna they wanna like look you in the eye and have someone that they know they can hold accountable. Exactly. And that you're and that you're a real person. Yeah, you're a real person, you know, and you know, that's a whole other thing was like, you know, fake identity and how where that where that's going in the AR, I'm sure that's you know, something else. But that That makes sense at that enterprise level. And so you're so you've you've built up the direct relationships, you you've gone to building out these like channel partners that allowed you access to the enterprise. Yeah. And it can you I I just want to go back to that for a second because I think as a startup, you know, there is a lot of those opportunities that maybe, you know, someone who's building a company may not realize that that's an option. And like how did you set up those those deals? Because, you know, I'm sure we're sure that they want to make margin on it as well to Yeah. We would we would quote them and we made sure that there was we would let them essentially market up however they wanted. Like some of them had really strong brands. Yeah. And so they could just take what we priced it for and just Yeah, at a zero. At the time we had a big competitor out of out of Boston. And so there was sort of a ceiling for what you could price because they had raised They all talk, right? Yeah, they all talk and they're gonna get quotes. They're gonna get quotes for the types of things that we were doing. So they had raised like sixteen, I think sixteen million dollars at the time, and we had raised zero. Like just one customer after another. And you know, so Like just as a recap, like at this point here, it's like you've like learned the business and like how to craft something by doing these customer interviews and being boots on the ground, yeah, like speaking with people and learning that process and then and then creating the business relationships that allowed you to have this product w also with the relationships to get to. enterprise level deals. It wasn't like you were selling this to to smaller firms. Like the first like you never you started big and you stayed there. Yeah. Yeah. We started big. I mean, T Mobile being your first customer out of the gate is like that's that's that was and that was a direct relationship that was in that and they stuck with us for a bunch of years. So that was the nice thing too is we it was a recurring model. That was the other thing we were looking for. when we were doing the consulting work it was project driven. Yes. It was very much like a one time thing. when we would set up these like private insight communities, they would go for years. Sure. So you get one customer, the the con the contract value of that one customer is in the the lifetime value. The lifetime value is in the millions then. So it's it's yeah, very high. So it was well worth it again, going back to getting on a plane and getting in front of them. Absolutely. It was well worth it. Absolutely. so and we were w the other we did do quite a bit of inbound as well. So we we were like one of the first HubSpot customers way, way back in the day. No kidding. Yeah. Way back in the day. Like I remember when they were tiny and just growing and I we used their s their CMS at the time and so our website and everything was on there. and so we would generate a lot of inbound reads leads by just writing about stuff. Writing and we'd like so industry fell for the whole inbound gospel and everything we talked people were talking about. At that time it was super effective though. Because because a lot of people weren't doing it. We weren't doing it. So it's like just being there and yeah, I think they had a real head start on it because they understood like the algorithms and like how Google was searching. And so it's like if you were able to I the the biggest thing right then was I and I think you know, because we we looked at it and you know we were doing some blogging and stuff like that, but never really like took it like to the length of that you guys did. But w we understood and you could see People were getting serious business off of that. yeah. Yeah. And it was also then it was like, you know, I'm getting there because I'm looking for the specific thing. You must know what you're talking about. So, okay, I'm gonna submit my email. Right. And like were those were those like they were d there were different times. Back then it was a lot easier. Yeah. Now it's so much more competitive. So especially the days of now with AI and L LMs kind of directing where where traffic goes. But back then this was even prior to Google locking down. Like you used to be able to see exactly which searches got to your website and what keywords and keywords and stuff. And then Google cut that off and then it was like, okay, now what do we Yeah, you're looking at it as now it's just like I think last time we looked at Google and it was like direct or it's just like no source. And it's like, you know they're gatekeeping. Yeah. Back back then you could tell you see everything. So we we were lucky. That definitely timing was an element in that. So we did we did inbound. We'd also do outbound, but then building these channel relationships, they would, you know, one Getting into one research company or consulting company would expose us to their entire Their whole Rolodex. The whole Rolodex. Yeah. Yeah. So it was just a smart move, especially as a startup. Like y you try to go direct, they're like, you know, you're too small for us. Yeah. but if you have a brand if you work through a brand name, the trust is already there. And then they're bringing you in as this new solution and you let them market up however however much you want. And they they didn't have to do anything. Like they we handled it everything for. You it was the same It was a matter of like it was almost like a weight label. Yeah. Really. At that point. It was like here's plu it's plu w th was it still called like plugged in when they were selling it, or were they really like white labeling and putting their own No, they we would go in and generally speaking, we didn't completely white label it. Okay. They would like, Hey, we're we're partnered with this this company plugged in. So, you know, they would bring us in and they didn't, you know, they weren't software companies. They didn't know how to so we here's the other thing too that we had to do. And and this is something I advise. startups as well as some organizations will not buy from you if it's just the software. So we learned pretty quickly, like we wanted to be a software company. We had this platform, right? But there were certain organizations where it's like, okay, that's great that you have the software and we want this. Yeah. But like we need help with implementation. And so we would either partner with the research companies and train their people on how to do the implementation on top of our software. That was one model that we had. Or we also had people that would do the implementation. And and otherwise we would not have gotten buyers. Like if we had not offered some services on top of the platform. Yeah. it's a dirty little secret. I think a lot of SaaS companies have like a a division that that is, you know, professional services and implementation. And like they they don't like to advertise it 'cause it makes them seem not scalable. But it can be in our case, it was extremely profitable to offer services on top of the software. Yeah. I I s we're seeing that a lot of companies are starting to do that because you know these large enterprise like softwares like SAS or whatever, it's like they're spending all this money, but then the team that they've sold into isn't necessarily like utilizing it to the first full capability. And so like we were we did an engagement last year where we were actually brought in to increase the utilization of said product to save their like the company paid paid for it for us to like like figure out how they can improve their utilization of the product. And it was actually wild, you know, and it was like a small contract for us, but it was like the opportunity was huge. And like I'm actually working on case study on it now. But the first the first month we like unlocked almost a quarter million dollars of like revenue that was untapped. And it was just like yeah. So but to the point of I think that there is a real trend to add the services on top of the software. It's SWAS. Software with a service. Yeah, that's subtraction. But it's also it's funny because it's like you're like, I have the software, it's like this I'm scalable, but you still have to have that deliverable as an option on top of it. So like we're only going to use this if you can help us with the implementation. I think especially everybody's talking about SaaS Armageddon right here. Where like you know if if you can just spin up your own SAS in in-house, like why would you Yeah, like we're gonna get rid of we're gonna get rid of everything. But it can be another way to defend your software saying, like, well, you can spin it up on your own, but you're still gonna need like a team to Who's gonna run it? Who's gonna run it? Yeah, who's gonna fix it? So that's another I think you know, reason why s SWAS as a as a vendor can can make sense, you know. Yeah, for sure. for sure. So So how many years that you've been building this out with The channel partners and going direct. We were grinding. We were just doing that. Like one customer after another, just you know, and socking away money and reinvesting it back in the business and the product, growing the team. and then it was twenty ten. Out of the blue. We had no intent for this, but out of the blue we had three offers for the business. Three within like a month. Whoa. We weren't shopping it. We weren't like people approached you about acquisition. Because we were The we were so early in that we were one of like the original people offering this particular product in the industry. And so when these larger research companies that we had already been working with, when they when they looked and they said, this is the hot new trend in the industry. Everybody's like talking about it. We already, we already do the classic as a big company, build versus buy. What do we do? Should we should we build our own in in-house or should we buy? And in this case, these companies were looking, okay, let's just buy. So they went and did searches of like who's out there and who's, you know. And of course we pop up because we were one of the key. Because you had so early investment. And we were yeah, yeah, yeah. yeah. You know? And so we were so early in the industry, we were you know, we were kind of I we were second to do it out of that after that company out of Boston. Sure. I won't say that we were first to market. Okay. but I I but there's that saying of like, you know. Pioneers get shot and settlers prosper. Yep. I I actually think in some ways, because they raised all this money, they they went out and educated the industry for us. And therefore, we didn't have to raise the money. We just could come in with a better solution. So we were slightly more cost effective. We weren't like, you know, half the price. We were like cost comparative, but our software, like the user experience for our software, was much better. And that goes back to. Experience that I had that you could bake that in. It was all about like, okay, how do we make sure we build the most usable? Like, we we invested a lot in design. Right. So, like our CTO, he was, you know, he was full stack, but he really had a great design background. Were you still doing those kind of like customer interviews on like you know, because it's prize for research, but it's like even the meta of that is like, okay. what are we doing on top of that to make sure usability is there? Oddly, I if this is a shoe. They it like eating your own dog food. Yeah, it was a little bit of that. I will I will say it was a little bit of a shoemaker's kid thing though. So like we didn't do enough user testing of our own platform, but but we did we did have a really good sense about how to design user user experience. And what was that built in? What was that built in? Ruby on Rails. Okay, awesome a new technology pre-Rails one. Okay. We were like early, early, early on and just kept upgrading Rails. And so that was another new tech that really I think enabled us to to bring it to market. This framework that a lot of startups are starting to like centralize around, open source, and so people are contributing to it. So we didn't have to like reinvent reinvent the wheel for seven or three. So absolutely. So it helped to be on Rails and you know, Rails is obviously still active today. So Yeah. Yeah, that's the Base camp folks, right? Yeah. Those guys are tremendous. Yeah, 30 signals, like they're tremendous entrepreneurs. They have like they're keep on pushing out. I was d a huge like DHH fan and like tried to really follow their philosophy and everything. I I think that's smart. I remember like does he po is he the one that has like that crazy like office space that like overlooks the canyon and it's like I don't know. Yeah, he's the one that races race like races and stuff, like has these on a race because I saw with he hangs with the Shopify CEO Toby Luke. Yeah. And like they're I think they're like the same racing team or something. It's like all the the billionaire club, right? Billionaire boys. so so yeah. So we we had no intent of selling. but then we heard out the offers. One went away pretty quickly, heard out the other two, kinda got them in on k in a bit of a bidding war, and then ended up going with the one. We actually and this is something I can do a whole lot whole other episode on the whole acquisition process. Yeah, no, I'd love to have you back on and talk about that. I that was like breaking that down. We we walked away from the deal three times. Okay. Every time the deal got bigger because they really Yeah like make some it's like plain hard to get almost well the other thing that we were yeah but yeah but we weren't intentionally doing it was just like there's so much upside for us. Yeah. So how do we make sure like should we stay in this industry and like where are we on the hockey stick? And that's just really hard to predict. Like you don't know how mature the market. Are we selling before it goes down? Or like you're trying to time it and you don't really know. Like we were seeing new entrants come in. Some look good, some were some were garbage. we had all that history. We had so many good examples of like customers and ki and customer stories and stuff at that point. So the technology was solid. They buying tech was solid. They're they're buying something. And was that, I guess, and just an interesting side note is like for being in being built on Ruby and it's like you don't think of that as like the normal enterprise infrastructure like I mean dot net was probably the big thing yeah. W was that a no they actually got no 'cause it's like you're getting 'cause it's it's here, it's ready to be well they here's the Acquire ended up being this company called Edelman. at the time, I don't know if they still are, but at the time, world's largest independent PR firm. Yeah, I was gonna say that's and so they massive PR. Here's what was appealing to us about Edelman at the time. was they had 55 global offices and just huge, amazing client relationships. So we were like, okay. And this sounds like one of those classic PR things, like, we'll be able to expand whatever after the acquisition. Yeah. But it really truly to us was like, okay, if we get plugged into that network, we're goal, we're going Sure. Right. Absolutely. As long as we can just structure a deal where we share on the upside, you know, we're we're cool with that. That so that was more maybe more important because you of not knowing where your trajectory was currently. Yeah. But like so baking into going with a deal that had that global distribution and we can make a lot of money on the back end for what we've built. Yeah. Yeah. That said, we didn't understand until after the acquisition that Sometimes people were not incentivized properly through bonuses and whatever structures to actually sell in our product. So that was a different story. Yeah. But so we had to do a lot of the sales as if it was just a like approaching a brand new. So when you mentioned yeah, when you mentioned you're doing the the other competitor who was well funded and educating the market, it's almost like through the acquisition that was like what you took on because it's like, you have to Educate. We had to now educate this giant network. At least we had the network. Yeah. And they knew that we were friendly in this in internal resource. But a lot of them, unfortunately, the way the s the incentive incentive and bonus instruction worked is they they just weren't incentivized to sell our product. Yeah. And then we had some kind of weird stuff with the and I I can't like I won't disclose though the the ins and outs of it, but we had some weird stuff too with the way that like our our agreements were structured. So we we had a two year earnout. and that's common. It's common two, three year earnest. It's common and you don't always have to take it. And we could have we could've just like ignored it, but we were like, you know, there's enough upside for us to stick around and do it. And but I I I caution entrepreneurs nowadays that it's the saying is it it's like selling your house and having to live with the new owners. Yeah. Yeah. You no longer technically have any control. So like decisions are now we had over the course of the two years, I think we reported to four different CEOs. Whoa. So there was restructuring a different thing. There was lot of like changes that happened. So that was a challenge. But that said, it was successful for both sides because you know we got we actually hit the earno a little after a year in. We hit our numbers. Cool. so we we crushed from that perspective and it continued to grow. And one really nice thing about the acquisition coming full circle to Rochester is they ended up locating a lot of their research operations up here in Rochester because they realized Rochester is a great place to find tal a talented workforce at a reasonable cost relative to these fifty five huge cities that they were in these guys are doing it. And they said, you know what, we can put some of our operations here in Rochester, save money and get really talented people that are loyal and stick around and like are are good folks. So they grew their research operations here, which was a nice byproduct of of the of the acquisition. That's awesome. And the those offices still exist in some after after COVID, like a lot of stuff went went remote. If it was that kind of role, it went remote. And so what they ended up doing they keep their sales infrastructure in big cities because you want to be close to the the actual customers. That makes sense. But after COVID things changed. They closed down the office here and they they there's still folks here that work for for them but they're it's more remotely. Yeah yeah. Yeah. So talk about like a net benefit though for the region and being a fan. Yeah it was great. It was great. And so again like even after the acquisition we were able to keep our overhead really low which helped us hit that earno and the whole thing. So so so yeah we did that and then Two years in it was like if you're entrepreneurial and you've already hit your earnout. Yeah. What are you still doing there? You lost the control. The baby has been is it with the new baby's with the new older like talking this story? It's like so both my my co founder and I, we left right at the the two year mark. and that's not a knock at Edelman, it's a good company. Yeah. It was just more we just wanted to do something new. You know, if you're entrepreneurial, you want to do something. I think you hear that a lot of stories of people who dough who do go get to that acquisition stage, which is which is like when you're you've already there I mean that's a huge accomplishment of like just goes to show like how are you know you had everything work for you. But also when y you know, you you hear that that's like some people don't even stay the two years or like whatever it is because no they they don't there's misalignment or whatever reason it's like people don't even get to the end of the earnout in a lot of cases. Well I actually funny story I actually did qu Okay. At one point. you did? But the CEO talked me back into that. Like he's like it's good amount of early on the table. How far in He talked me down from the ledge. I it was maybe a year in. So it's like you're halfway there. It's like, okay, you got And you know, actually I'm I'm glad he did 'cause I wasn't ready. Like I thought I was ready, but I wasn't I didn't really have baked in what I wanted to do next. And in hindsight It it helped. It helped. It helped. It was good that he talked me down. What was that like? Because then you also hear when you go through that and you're past the earnout stage, you're basically on your own again. What was that period like? I mean you know you're you're flushed with cash, you just had this acquisition. Life's good. Yeah. Yeah. But there's a loss because it is like you're giving up your baby to another entity that that is that was there. It was so I had that period of the, you know, the Golden handcuffs where I couldn't really do anything. There was a period of time where the non company after you left. Yeah, I I couldn't I couldn't work in the industry. I couldn't even think about starting a company for a period of time afterwards. So that's actually that leads that's a good segue to next score. Sure. That's how I got involved. I said, you know what? I've got time right now. Yeah, I'm like I might as well get back, help some entrepreneurs here in Rochester. You know I just went through a whole experience. It's fresh in my mind. I learned so much in that that cycle from starting from nothing, right? And and bootstrapping it to an exit. And then even after the exit, there's so many lessons I can share with other entrepreneurs here in Rochester. And so that's when I'm ended up meeting Jim Snall, runs runs Nextcore, and helped out with and Mike Riedlinger. And I helped out with they had a launch pad accelerator program. And so they were they needed help. Basically, I don't even know how I got introduced, but I they needed help with like like basically helping these entrepreneurs do market research on their ideas. there you go. Boom. That's a good fit. That's my exact fit because I had this background in market research and I had just started and sold a market research company. Yeah. Yeah. So I was like, Hey, I g I think I got the resume from an unusually solid resume for helping people with and I learned quickly that in the in the startup world, what we used to call qualitative market marketing research is called customer discovery. So it's the same thing at the end of the day. But I learned quickly, okay, you don't you don't call it that, you call it this. and and so I started helping startups with with customer discovery. And so I I started off working on that teaching team, helping them, you know, 'cause I'll I'll be honest, like coming from a professional background in in research, I I was like like aghast at like the how poorly entrepreneurs would do their own market research. Yeah. Like they would they were so biased. The questions they were asking were leading, they were horrible, and then they'd get this bad data and think they had good data, and then they'd go and launch these businesses and spend their dollar money or invest money. And you know and then you know, of course they would fail. And it's like, well, maybe it was timing, maybe it was market, but also was maybe the way that you did your customer discovery was just God awful. Like you're just biased and you thought you had signals, but you did not actually have signals. So that's where I learned like I could I can really help folks like this where where I can s like coach them through doing this kind of discovery process and serve as an objective voice and also somebody who's an expert in doing this and asking the right questions. Yeah, you have the bona fides to say, Hey, I've been there and like I and specifically this is how you approach a customer customer discovery. Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. So So I did that. And then eventually, and I I got to know Jim and Mike better. And then they said, Hey, will you be an entrepreneur in residence? Cause you know, you're not just valuable for the discovery stuff, but you've sold started and sold a company so you can work with entrepreneurs in the full circle. So I said, Sure, yeah. And so I was an entrepreneur in residence for a number of years. And then eventually they were like, Hey, you know, can you just run the whole link? Just run it. So that's where I'm at today. Yeah. and I love working with startups. I still do some select consulting work and stuff with with bigger companies. And I have since selling the business, I've gone on to launch three SaaS products. I wouldn't call them startups. At this point they're basically passive income or kind of projects. Yeah. Just like they're you're just running them yourself. Yeah. I I I built well I didn't I hired devs that I knew to to build the the core product. nowadays I work on them with Claude. Okay. so I still do some of that that work outside of my work in Xcore, but mostly it's you know, working with the startups here and just kinda helping them at everything from the very beginning to like how do you I idea selection, idea validation, doing that early customer discovery all the way through to exit, you know, which which I'm pretty passionate about in terms of like the way they do that. yeah. So so and everything in between. And so that's what I'm doing today. I love working with startups. Like I I'm always been one of those people that's like The underdog right the person. So I like, and especially with ones that that want to bootstrap, because it's kind of like I I never raised money. And I I think some part of me has always been like, you know, and and this is nothing against VCs or angel investors or anything like that. And if people want to go that right that route, yeah. More power to them. But I do think in the vast majority of cases, if you're a little bit creative, you can bootstrap and self fund your business. And and and by default, businesses start that way, right? Nobody's coming and just handing you money. Absolutely. Or I mean, even to get an investment, you typically need some traction. You need some kind of things going for you already to almost like they say it's like where you maybe don't need the money is when you can get it. Right. In the in the kind of yeah, it's it's an easier conversation for an investor at that point. Yep. Yeah. How can you be self-sufficient as quickly as possible such that when you if if and when you do have conversations with investors? you're in that much better position rather. You are you're not giving out a huge chunk of You have more leverage. You have more leverage. You have more leverage. And and and investors want to put fuel on the fire. Like right. They don't necessarily want to fund the more you can de-risk it, the the better off you are. So yeah, and and and like from that establishing it and maybe like how you did like funding your own development, if you can get creative like that and score an early customer that can help you really get to that next level and also that is the funding for what you're building. Yeah. Then I mean talk about having that as your own fuel. You know, you're you're taking it into you to to your own hands as opposed to when you take on investment all of a sudden that's you have different you have you know a lot of times you have a board that you have one of the first conversations I have with any founder that comes into Nextcore is really trying to suss out their goals, motivations, objectives, their personal like yeah, some people are entrepreneurial because they absolutely cannot be told what to do. Yeah. Like it's just this like, you know, lone wolf kind of like I'm gonna I'm gonna do it. I've got a vision for something and and you're it's gonna be a poor fit if you need to have a board investors. Like you're not gonna enjoy your life. And you see See that over time. sorry, go ahead. Well, it it's a trade off. If you're willing to make that trade off, it's fine. But one of the first things I try to do is figure out like what you're doing your own customer discovery. It's like in that market research. I want I want people to I mean it's a it's a journey and it's and it's difficult. And there's ways to ha make the journey a more enjoyable. Sure. You know? Like there's there's decisions you can make that that help shape the business around your life and your needs. necessar rather than like just yeah. going through the motions. And I think also if you can be of a resource of saying, hey, and and I've kno I've witnessed this in some of our roundtables, is that like, hey, that's not gonna cut it. You know? Like n not being afraid to like call somebody out and hold them accountable to like, hey, that's not how it's gonna work for you because XYZ and I think there's almost as much value in that, like, hey, don't do that. Yeah. Because it's not gonna work. Yeah. You know? And like b and although I tell you what, I I most of my so I don't like to just like blindly prescribe advice. Sure. I always make sure that I'm like asking good questions. And a lot of it leads back to like they'll ask like people ask me like what do think of my my idea? And I always tell them I'm like, I I can't tell I can't tell you if it's good or bad. I can tell you things that could like lead to its success or or not. But like you need to talk if I'm not one of the target customers, you need to go talk to those target customers. Like here's that's that's the right don't listen to me. Don't listen to some random investor who tells you you know what whatever. Like go and talk to those customers. Yeah. That's what you're gonna figure out if there's what makes or breaks this business. There's elements of like, is it scalable? You know, and can you d is it a big enough market? There's all that sort of stuff that I can help people with. But sure, sure. At the end of the day, it's it's the validation comes with does does a customer Does the customer need this? Is it yeah, and will they pay for it? Is there strategies that are tried and true for that discovery period? I guess also it's like, how do you find people to talk like cause outside of your own network and the people who you know, when you're talking about somebody who's not doing it right, they're probably asking the people that are closest to them that are incapable of giving them real like quality feedback? How is there are there tried and true methodologies? Well, you know, I don't know if there's a w when you're going out and trying to find people to talk to for discovery purposes, you're also lightly testing which channels and and how you're gonna go to market, right? So you might find that like doing cold emails like works either really well or just does not work at all. Yeah, right. And so you're testing like how am I gonna get in front of customers down the road anyway. I will say, so I going back to my professional market research background. When I worked with or work with big companies doing big research studies, we pay companies to go and find those people. So we were spoiled. I I will say I was spoiled back in the day when I was doing these studies. I wasn't calling people being like, hey, we will you talk for a customer interview. Yeah. We paid companies that would go out and qualify people, talk to them. okay. So they would give you the the sales qualified leads. Yeah, they would base in yeah, they would basically say, This person's gonna show up at this day and you're gonna talk to them. And they set everything up for me so that by the time they talked to me, like they were pre-qualified. I knew exactly who it was going to be and it was that exact target spec. that's that's so we had, but that was huge budgets to pay for that's huge. Yeah. And also that's part of the network. Yeah, if you build a network over years of people that you can tap into and say, Hey, I'm looking for this resource, or who is in my network of It was like that six degrees of Kevin Bacon, right? These these were big these were recruiters specifically for B2B like research studies. So they had huge panels and lists of qualified and they were probably charging they were charging us huge dollars to but the ROI on that is well, but remember with research you're not trying to sell. Okay. So keep that in mind, right? Like when they were when I was going doing those studies prior to starting my my company, we were not allowed to sell. That was like the number one thing. It was all it was a research conversation to like talk about their needs, challenges, pain points, all that sort of stuff. Sure. If they so happen to hear about the sponsor of the research and go and check out their products later. It was a passive it was a it was a very passive but the intent was never to sell and you get in trouble being a researcher if you try to like change. It's a breach of the trust network. Yeah. you know, the industry itself is very concerned about its reputation and you don't wanna be like it's called selling on slugging s selling under the guise of research. Yeah. And see these were not sales conversations. And and that's actually also importantly when I advise the entrepreneurs, I I I tell them the same thing, like don't turn it into a pitch. You'll kill any trust that you have. Like yeah. If you're gonna go out and do customer discovery, go and talk to people as if you have nothing to sell to them. Yeah. And then have these open-ended conversations and they might want to learn more about you and you're building those relationships. And if it turns into that, great. But don't go in with the don't go in with that ex attitude. Also, I think if you really are positioned, you don't know if if you're truly approaching it, that like I have this idea, I have this concept. Even if you're in those if you're in those early stages, you don't necessarily know. Yeah. And if so, if you as soon as you start steering it to what you have in your preconceived mind yeah that's where you're gonna have the bad results. It's called confirmation bias. Confirmation bias. And it's a big reason why companies go and hire somebody who's independent who doesn't have a horse in the race to go and talk to their customers for them. Yeah. It's not that that company couldn't do it themselves. It's that having somebody who's objective who doesn't, you know, at the end of the day you're gonna get the real answer. And honestly that was something going back to like when I first got into the industry, that was something I really found appealing. I had a a mentor at the time who said You know, market research is one of the few areas of the business world where you're paid to tell the unvarnished truth. Sure. And I was like, it's kinda cool, you know, like yeah. A lot of a lot of the business world is like you gotta spin things and like try to like say the right things to the right person. Create the right relationship. For it was just like I went and talked to thirty of your customers. They hate this or they love this or whatever. And that's all I I'm paid to just tell you that. Yeah. There's don't shoot the messenger. There's don't shoot the messenger. I'm just Was there any any times that somebody wanted to shoot the messenger? absolutely. Because they didn't like what they were hearing. You do have to go in like, cause there are some ethics involved. You could spin it in such a way, a a bad researcher would spin it in such a way that they would try to tell a story that would get the client to do more research with them. so you do there's definitely a a risk of like, you know. Being on blurring the lines. Blurring the lines. And like almost then you're leading like, we need to do more research because of what we found. So yeah, you know, there there were some challenges there. But but going back to entrepr working with entrepreneurs, it's like the being systematic about it, having somebody kind of check your work, okay? and making sure you're asking the right questions and talking to not your friends and family. Yeah. They're always gonna, you know Tell you what you want. They're always gonna tell you what you want. Talking to the true customer, ideally somebody that you have like a second degree connection to where it's like they don't know you, but they're soft intro, those are always the best conversations. So and those could could be end up becoming your first customers. And if they do great, that's fine. But but that's not the stated intent of doing discovery. That's that's a really just a whole journey that you've been on the path and how you know you had a lot of things line up and you know what were some of the the challenges because it's because it's not easy. It's not an easy road despite you know you you had a really positive outcome and like for the most part, you know, the like good problems to have. Yeah. what were was there any like real besides like halfway through the earnout Was w were some really pivotal or chal just a pivotal challenging time where you're like, Man, like I am I doing the right thing? Was you ever any those moments that that yeah? constantly. Yeah. Yeah. Like on the course of an afternoon sometimes. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. It's like high highs, low lows. Yeah. And I mean I I was very I and am thankful. I'm still good friends with my my co founder and you know, there were days where I was up, he was down, he was up, I was down. Like and we were able to check each other's emotions. We definitely had times where we would argue, you know. and and it was it like it's a classic trope, but it's like it's like being married. Sure. When you have a co founder. Yeah, you know, it's like you gotta manage the related. You're spending a lot of time with them, you manage the relationship the same way. Yeah. so there's a lot of self doubt, a lot of ups and downs. This is unique to me, but I succeeded in my first startup out of the gate. I kind of wish I actually hadn't. Because I had such high expectations for myself going into future projects that I was was and still am kind of seeking the perfect opportunity next. Okay. Interesting. Because you Which is a weird thing. Like I wish I had actually had a bunch of failures and then that then then the eventual success. Okay. Because you learn through each of those incremental failures and then you and then you get comfortable with failure. When you succeed out of the gate. It's it's odd. It's like winning the tour championship or like your rookie season or And then suddenly like the expectations on your own self-imposed expectations are like like crap. Like I I if I don't if I don't knock it in an even bigger success next time, like it's this weird, like you're it's you're putting pressure on yourself. And so as a result, and this is this has not been helpful to me, I evaluate every new business idea that I'm thinking about through like so many different criteria that are not really necessary. Okay. And I put it through this stage gate of like, okay, if it doesn't have all these things, like then I won't pursue it. And as a result, like I have just the n like I it's that's held me back. So that's been a weird challenge. That's to That's that is unique. That I but it's also that's part of the journey. That's part of the path, you know? It is. Yeah. It is. but I will say that for anybody out there that's that happens to be listening and you've experienced a number of failures, realize that there's actually a there's a value to learning from those failures because if you hit it right out of the gate, that's it's almost there's there's a downside to that. There yeah, it can be. And that's you know, it's something that you probably w wouldn't equate to it. Or that it's like, I gotta do this so much bigger now because of the success that I've to And then the other thing that happened has happened to me is a little this is lower over time, but like a little bit of like, I know what I'm doing now. Mm-hmm. And it's like, no, I I I don't. Yeah. You know what I mean? Like it it's like every new business is is different. Every new market is different. Every it's in a different time. And you have to approach it with almost a Zen beginner mind, regardless of your past experiences. Where it's like you have to go out and objectively learn about the market and the customer and the product and the, you know, everything and approach it as if it's your very first time. It's that you still have that zero to one. I still yeah, that you still have that zero to one challenge. And sometimes if you've had that success, you you tend to kind of like think like, I know what I'm you know, I really have some, you know, or I could skip this. Like that part. It gives you maybe some blind spots that like, I should have I should have picked up on that because I did not see that coming or like I thought I thought differently. I thought I knew better. That's that's really interesting. Where do you see you know, startups and the you know, the ecosystem right now as we're transitioning into this AI age and w you know, what's what are you what are your thoughts on kind of people who are in the early stages now or maybe they've the you know, they're toying with the idea of starting something. Yeah. So AI has Been obviously a game changer. it has changed my thinking on customer discovery. So I used to be, and I'm just talking now. this comment is just about software companies, by the way. Okay. Software. So I'm just gonna like preface that. Like if you're working on deep tech or something that is like a years-long development cycle, don't ignore what I'm about to say. But if you're working on a software company nowadays, I I used to tell people. You go out, you gotta go and talk to a bunch of customers, figure out what the problem is and and things and because you are gonna be dropping at least 30 K to get even an MVP. Yeah. Out the door. Now with AI, with Cloud Code, you learn a little bit about it, you learn how to build a an application, even if you're non technical. You could and should be putting a prototype in front of people in, you know, a month. Yeah. So it's not that I I'm saying skip the customer discovery. I it's just that it's so fast and easy to get a prototype together now in the software world that it's almost like instead of spending like if you have a hypothesis about something, yes, go out and talk to some some people and to or you can share the MVP with them. Or just share the MVP. Test this out. Like it's how are you interacting with the Because I will say, from doing years and years and years of doing research studies, it is way easier and more constructive and more actionable to have a conversation with a potential customer around an actual thing you're asking them to evaluate than it is hypotheticals and exploratory kind of open-ended qualitative type of stuff. Got it. So it's easier to just be like, hey, you know, you're in this industry. we think that people like you have. you know, this kind of problem. I'd love to just sit you down in front of this and just have you like kick the tires a little bit. Yeah. And then just tell them record just talk out loud. Yeah. And just record the session. Just record the session and just say, hey, just talk out loud as you're using it. And you're gonna get two things out of that. You're gonna get usability testing. So you're gonna understand do they know how to use the application? That's number one. But number two, you're gonna get an understanding of like, does this product actually deliver? Like is it delivered is this missing the mark or is it so my the AI Has most immediately changed my recommended approach when it comes to discovery. I used to say, you know, you got because 30K, 50K, or whatever to put together a prototype is is a is a lot, you know? especially if you're in an actor, if you're trying to bootstrap it. Yeah. You know, that's that's a significant chunk of change. A chunk of change if you're trying to f sell funding. And so so spend some time before you go and do that to understand go and do a bunch of customer discovery. I my thinking has ch honestly changed a little bit, which is weird for me because I'm a discovery guy. Like I'm a first I get that my background, but now it's like, oof, just just build a prototype. You could build a tool for a couple hundred bucks instead of like thirty Rand. Yeah. And then and then it gives somebody something to react to. And then from there you can iterate and and change the community of things. So do you do you see entrepreneurialism increasing into this phase with AI hitting its stride or do you maybe see like a a lot of people who are on the frontier are saying the opposite is that like, hey, w like money's gonna be meaningless, you know, because it's just gonna everything's gonna be done for us and blah blah blah. you know, w is there one side or the other that you lean on? Does it change? 'Cause I find myself I'm like just how you you're describing like Be an entrepreneur, you're like going through the ups and downs and yeah. I feel like I for me, I'm like back and forth between that, like constantly because of what I'm seeing and how rapid it's changing. Yeah, I d I I honestly don't know. I don't know about the whole I can't speak to the whole money meeting list thing, but yeah, I I can speak to, I mean, just by definition, if you know, more people for the first time ever, we've had people applying to the incubator here where they are non technical founders, they built prototype and Claude or whatever. They're doing exactly what you know. And and they come and they're like, hey, I've got a prototype. I put it together and I'm seeking help to now like market this and d do the other the businessy kind of stuff on top of it. Sure, sure. in Discovery stuff. Like where shall I do that? Yeah. And then they come to us for that help. But they went off on their own, figured out how to build a prototype and it's, you know, they're not perfect, but they're they're pretty good. So we I've never seen that before. So I think we're seeing like this kind of explosion of like new apps and things. Yeah. Which is both good and bad because it also has a lot of slop. I mean a lot of really poorly built products. Sure. you look at I mean, I check product hunt every day, for better or worse. And you know, just the number of products that launch every day is insane. And I I think that's only gonna get faster that and it's even like more automated too, as agents become more aware and more autonomous. Yeah. And and so differentiating your product too, like there's a certain smell to AI product. Like you look at the designs and I'm like, yeah. Like Yeah, you could you can say or if you're reading some like AI writing, it's there's a lot of tells and maybe it's that's getting better. But it's like, you know, you come think about like a couple years ago playing around with like the early GPTs and like I I what always sticks with me is like that picture or that video generated of like Will Smith like eating spaghetti. It's like all like looks like psychedelic and like very like okay, this is bizarre. It's like, what did this just create? Now they have like full cinematic. Yeah. It's like almost incredible. Like the uncanny valley is like really decimating. And I guess it's like what you know, we do a lot of work with like Shopify and like e-commerce and like, you know, like B2B things. I think there's a lot of room in certain certain like areas that still is kind of like undiscovered. And I think specifically if like you it like if you wanna build MVP or something like that, or if you wanna build an e commerce store, like it there's never been an easier time to be an entrepreneur. And there's maybe never been a better time to give it a shot if yeah the doom hypothesis is real is like, hey, you know, it's like you're gonna need to do something, you're gonna need some kind of hobby if if like we all have you know, whatever w however that looks like. Yeah. So I'm still really bullish on entrepreneurs. I'm still bullish on like doing a startup and figuring it out. Probably and like the r the resources available have never been richer or fuller in terms of like what you can do. Yeah. And, you know, can you speak to that like you know, what wasn't what is Nextcore you know, excelling at that. in terms of like the the incubator here and like yeah I I you know I think so speaking to that, myself and I think probably ninety percent of the entrepreneurs here you definitely are using AI as a quick way to retrieve knowledge about how to do something, right? Mm-hmm. And as a sounding board for some of their strategies and things. But then absolutely at the end of the day, I think there's still this yearning for talking to a human who understands you and and your goals and objectives and and serves as like a check and like Bit of accountability, and that's what our entrepreneurs and residents are are really good at is like a human being you can talk to. And then having like the round tables like we do. No, I find those very valuable bullets. Peer to peer. Like you just you don't get that from AI. No. From AI, you can learn like, I'm trying to do this. What should I do? Yeah. Or you build your MVP, you do some of the tech stuff that that like don't happen inside of those rooms or out inside of those, you know, like an EIR is gonna tell you what. They know but they're not gonna build it for you and in in a round table. When when you leave those sessions with the round table or the EIR, you can use AI to kinda help execute on those things. Because they can't do that for you. Exactly. Exactly. So build it. You're still building it. But but to have somebody to talk to just to to and another trend now that we're seeing increase exponentially is more solo founders. Yeah. Right. It's so easy nowadays to spin something up. But at the same time, I talked about how my co founder, like in He and I served as a check like an emotion more than anything else. It was like the emotional ups and downs of entrepreneurship. So being part of an incubator, I think it doesn't have to be, you know, Nextcore, but like an incubator or a a peer group of of founders is incredibly valuable because you need that AI just doesn't deliver on that. Yeah, it's like the remote. I think for me personally, as like how I discovered Nextcore, you know, was I'm like working remote and I'm just like I'm gonna I need like office, I just need to like get out of the Because like the remote is just I've been doing it too long and I like I just need that. So when I found Nextcore, it was like, you know, not just but it had those other layers on top. It's like, wait a minute, you got like I I can talk to an EIR, I can yeah, come to the round table. It's not just the space, there's a little bit more to it. And that's what I think ultimately led me here is because it's like, not only is it that you could physically come and like be out of you know, where it you you you le you leave the remote. confines of your your your your domicile and you're coming in some place that is like it's it's work. It's like you have that added layer of that I can like bounce this off this person or you know you see other people working on interesting things and it it it kind of is that brew of you know creativity. There's a lot going on here that you know some of the other I don't think I could ever be purely remote. and not have a place to go. Yeah. Like I think it's important. And most of our sixty percent of the members here are virtual. So they like they're in their home offices, but they're coming down for events and we come in Yeah, I see we see a lot of people c that floating and out and like even if it's just you know tribularly couple or w as the schedule provides as it's as it's very open. So it's been a it's been a really good resource for me and you know any from your experiences Is there anything that, you know, s let's say let's take the do like a little bit of customer discovery on like entrepreneur now, like just kind of like bring things full circle? Sure. You know, how how would does somebody kind of let's say they have that MVP, they're coming into a place like this, you know, how how do they is there you know, how what how would you Consult with them to just get the activity going and like they have something that's maybe working, yeah. something where they need to like really test it to see if it's viable in a marketplace. Yeah. You know, like what is their customer discovery? Where where should they start? I it's sitting down with them and a understanding their objectives with the business, yeah. And kind of, hey, is those things it can check off. Yeah. You know, kind of like vet a little bit. I I hear a lot of people talking nowadays about product founder fit and how you know they don't think about that. It's like, is is this a good fit for this founder? And is this product gonna be the thing that gets them to where they need to go? Or like, so there's not enough accounting for that. So trying to figure that out, number one. But then sitting down with them, coming up with a set of objective questions that are in a an approach to testing their Take it from the room and then go execute it. Even down to like here's here's a kind of silly example, but I've seen some people for years, the the accepted knowledge in the in the startup space was throw up a landing page that describes your idea, the headline, put a email capture or you know, buy now and then just see does anybody click? Right. I actually I'm not a huge fan of those smoke test landing page type of things. Okay. And here's why because Going back to my research experience, I've seen studies where we change the color of a button. And and you've probably seen this for conversion stuff, right? Sure. You change the color of a button and somebody's like, or the logo is different or whatever, and somebody reacts completely differently to a product because of that. Yeah. And so one of the things I so I I think there's too much, there's too many variables that could go into building a good landing page to suss out, like you can't build a landing page and say, And use the conversion rate on that landing page to say whether or not it's a good or bad product idea. That's I think there's some real good like alpha, if you will, in that because that was a lot of the advice that was out there. cause you can like go build a free HubSpot page that's doing an email capture lead magnet and run fifty bucks in Facebook ads and see what conversion rate. And if it like doesn't if it doesn't do well, it's crap. Right. That's not you can't actually say that. And so going back to my market research background, when we tested concepts, often it was it was done in a very systematic, unbiased, blinded like way. And so that's one of the things I try to work with entrepreneurs is like, no, no, no, no. We're not gonna build a landing page or a logo or any of this stuff. We're gonna write a concept description and that's what we're gonna present to your customer. And it's gonna be blinded and unbranded and you know, so that we can get an unbiased reaction. From your target customer to the concept behind your product. And so this is like something that not a lot of people do, unless you're a professional researcher and you have that background. You know to do it. But if don't, everybody's just like, yeah, throw up a, you know, a page and buy some Facebook ads. And it's like you're gonna get a biased, it's just not gonna tell you whether or not it's a good concept. Well, and then there's also when you're saying about the controlled environment, as soon as you like you're introducing too many variables in the beginning. Yeah. Of button colour and design choice or even the targeting. Your H one. Your H one can make or break whether people continue reading on the page. And if you don't have one that in five second test, if people don't understand what you're doing in five seconds, they'll they'll bounce. Yeah. Does that mean your product's bad? No. It just means you wrote a bad H one. Yeah. Yeah. Right? Or are you showing it to the right people? Yeah. Or maybe or maybe it's it's blind traffic and it's bots. And you know, they okay, they didn't click because it's a bot, you know. Exactly. So You gotta be systematic about the way that you test your ideas. And so I think when we work with the entrepreneurs, it's like, okay, how can we be systematic so that we can get a true read on is there something is there something there? Is there something there? And then again, nowadays though, like again, kind of coming back to my previous thing though, nowadays though, you can go so fast with AI into just building a clickable prototype. Yeah. That you can you can do a little bit of both, get people to react to the concept and then say, Okay, here's this prototype that we built, can you start using it? Maybe it would be making sure that you're validating also the the right people is it like, I I think my customer is this type of demographic and you know that's I think that the f even like firmographics they're in this they're in this industry, they're in this age group, they're that this kind of revenue they're doing. And it it feels that that is shifting as people become more sophisticated. and doing research with AI is that there there's that when somebody's showing up to a landing page, they already know. Yeah. You know, and like I think and that is that is true in e-commerce specifically is what I'm seeing is that like that there you're getting traffic to a page or if it's like a B2B site is you know maybe the Google the Google direct traffic is off yeah just down. But somebody is spending so much more time evaluating you in an in their LLM before they ever have a need to come to the page. The nature of the game is totally changed when it comes to discovery and finding new products, yeah, and evaluating what to use. it's it's it's incredible. But I one thing I do want to say, like yeah for anybody listening, is one of the pieces of advice that holds people back from doing customer discovery is and I think I don't know where this started. I it might be iCor or something like that, but they a lot of university programs will tell students you need to go and talk to a hundred people. That is really bad advice. Okay. Like I just want to get that out here. Seems like a fair number. It seems like a fair number. And what it's trying to do is quantify a fundamentally qualitative activity. And it keeps a lot of people away. Cause go to go and do a hundred customer interviews can take months. Yeah. If especially if you're not working on the business full time. So it it it it sounds like such an intimidating barrier that it's like people just don't do it. And they're like, never mind, I'll skip it and just go do it. You only need to talk to a maximum of like, and this is a max of like 30 people in one given target segment. You go talk to 30 people, a relatively homogenous group of people, like similar characteristics. You will know after like 20 whether or not there's a problem there, whether or not your solution is gonna solve the pro, you know, the how you're reacting to your solution. You don't need to talk to nearly as many p many people. And then the last ten is gonna validate that a little bit further. And the last ten ten is really just sort of like, Okay, we're hearing the same themes over and over again. Let's stop. Yeah. Or you're not hearing them at twenty yet. So it's like you really have to or you maybe you start Yeah, it's it's too early to make any assumptions at ten. By twenty you're starting to get s really suss out. Like, okay, we I know we roughly there. And thirty you're like, Okay, I got I got it. Yeah. Anything past thirty. And so what I hear I I just shudder when I these like, you gotta go talk to I recently went and I'm not gonna dump on them for this, but I went to a a demo day for a local university, and you know, they made every entrepreneur in that in the do a hundred. Some of them had done like they were reporting they had done a hundred and eighty seven, I think was the bias I saw. And I was like, great, but way overkill. Like you don't need to talk to nearly that many people to figure out if there's something there. And so that makes it so much more died up. digestible as well too. I think it's like just just don't let that hunt a barrier for anybody listening, if if if you've heard that before, because it's out there everywhere, don't let that hold you back from from doing it. Yeah. Yeah. No, that's that's that's really good advice. And then one of the things I say to the the founders here is like, yeah. Let's distill this down and make it simple for you. And then you know, get someone like yourself or one of the entrepreneurs in residence to make sure you're asking when you're when you're targeting those 30 that you're pulling out the questions that matter. Yeah. We have one EIR that has gone on discovery meeting. I've done this before too. It's like sat in on discovery meetings. Just just a like, you know, fly on the wall. We're not reading it. We're not doing it for you. We're just listening. And then you get you then that's valuable feedback for And then it's like okay, this was a little bit biased. Here's what I heard. And it's often different. Yeah. What the it's what what they thought. Yeah. Because as an entrepreneur, you are the most biased person. By definition. Yeah, you have to be a little It's called the Ikea effect. You like people love things that they had a a hand in creating. They they value them more than an anything else. And so, you fundamentally value your idea more than other people do. And so having that check of having an EAR kind of sit on a call. It doesn't have to be every call, but every once in a while sitting on a call is huge. Yeah. You know. Yeah. Just having that you c just having that be available, you know. Yeah. And having that as a resource is you can use AI to do that too. You can upload the transcripts and just say what did you hear? Yeah. That can act as a check. But I think having a human being review the findings and discuss about like what's next. I think you do both. You know, it's like and it it's you know, because AI is that tool, it's so available is that you can it like maybe you're testing things and then you you you're getting kind of one version. Or you're putting it through a lot of LLMs, you're getting a lot of feedback, that's distilled. But then like you l like you say, like full circle again, is you know, sometimes it's nice to have a human in the room and somebody that you're talking to is like that's actually gonna be the ultimate user of the product. So these A just take over everything. I think that's still an important character. I wouldn't I wouldn't act or I wouldn't ask AI to, you know, act as this target customer and react to this concept. It's like I don't know. Yeah, it's just like What maybe I'm old school, but I know it's trained on a giant set of data, but to me at the end of the day, it's like primary research is going out and talking to people and you gotta do that yourself. Yeah. Yeah. Well, and that like I think the the other piece of it is that it's also those are your connections to potentially go back and they're your customers if it's that good sped. If it's future customers, it's networking, it's you know, you name it. So yeah. Cool. Man, fully how could people thank you so much for doing this. Yeah, no problem. Man, fully next square. I'm hoping people get in touch with you and yeah, I they wanted to talk directly. Next square dot org. N E X T C O R P S dot org. Yep. so you can reach me there. if you're in the Rochester area, definitely get involved with our community here. Yeah. got a lot of monthly events and stuff going on. Yeah. If you check that's also on their web the website. If not, I don't I don't do a ton of social LinkedIn. You can find me on LinkedIn. Okay. LinkedIn. it's probably a good a good space. yeah, this is posted on LinkedIn. I think it's a primary channel. So, you know, a link you there as well too. And yeah, and then come down come down to some of the events. I know that you do st like startup drinks is a monthly drink. Yeah. And there's some there's some various like lunch and learns that are all free. You know, it's like you just gotta sign up. Those are on the website too that you can And they're very informal. Like I sometimes I think there's an intimidation factor of like is this a networking of its own? It's like just come, just have a drink, hang out. No, and it's a lot of the it's a lot of the same phases. We you know, it it's like I love trying to bring people in because there's a lot of like there's a lot of same faces, a lot of cr camaraderie, and so you're building relationships and f and f and friends who are kind of going through the same thing. As well as but it's nice when you show up and there's somebody new that that I haven't met before you know, so it's like those yeah, it always makes interesting news. Still still a very tight knit community that's that's growing here. But yeah. So I thank you again for doing this. And I I had a great time learning about your story and how you know, sounds like your entrepreneurial journey is lifelong. So it's still emerging. It's still emerging, yes. Even after that's even after all the you can do it for so many years. Yeah. Yeah, it's it was great chatting with you today. Thank you. Yeah, thanks.