Latest / Blue Leader Nation Podcast / Episode 7: Micromanagement is Not Leadership
Transcript
- Edward Pallas: If you've ever thought, there's no way I can say this without it going sideways, you're wrong. Leading up is one of the hardest leadership skills to execute well, especially in a rank-based culture where authority, liability, and ego are all in the room, whether anyone names them or not. So let's be clear about the objective. This conversation It's not about proving your boss wrong. It's not about venting. It's not about winning. It's about changing behavior while preserving trust. We're here to develop those men and women in law enforcement who want to be respected leaders and to mold you into becoming a legendary leader. If it's leadership, personal growth, and self-development, we're talking about it. Whether you're new or a veteran, you've found your new home. This is the Blue Leader Nation. Now, here's your host, Dr. Ed Palus. Hello and welcome to the Blue Leader Nation podcast. I'm your host, Ed Palis. And today we're going to be talking about a leadership behavior that almost no one admits to, but everyone has experienced from one side of the equation or the other. What we're talking about today is then the dreaded term micromanager. If you've ever thought, just let me do my job. This episode is for you. If you've ever caught yourself thinking, If I don't stay on top of this guy, it's going to fall apart. This episode is for you. Here's why micromanagement is such a problem in law enforcement. Most micromanagers are not bad people. Most micromanagers don't even know they're micromanaging. They're not trying to control others, even though it looks that way. They're not waking up in the morning thinking about how to crush morale, even though comes across that way. Micromanagers are stressed. They were likely promoted because they were high performers. and they care deeply about outcomes. But here's the catch. They don't trust the system or the people to get high results, at least not without their guidance, approval and fingerprints and everything. And that my friends is where things go sideways. You see, because the moment supervision turns into babysitting, you don't get better performance. You get quieter performance, defensive performance, minimum necessary performance. And in policing, That's dangerous. So in this episode, we're going to break down how to tell the difference between legitimate supervision and true micromanagement. Also, why micromanagement always comes across from fear rather than facts and what to do about it. Whether you're on the receiving end or if you admit it, you're the one being the micromanager. This is not theory. This is street level leadership. Let's start with the question. that ends most micromanagement arguments before they even start. Let's simplify this because micromanagement debates tend to get emotional fast and when emotion gets high, clarity disappears early. Here's the question that's going to solve about 80 % of these issues. Are you competent in the job you're being asked to do? Listen to that again. Are you competent in the job that you're doing? Not, do you feel competent? Not, have you been here a long time? Not, do you mean well? Competent, can you consistently meet the standard, produce the work, make sound decisions, and do it without constant correction? Because if the answer is no, then what feels like micromanagement might actually just be management and supervision, or coaching, or accountability. Pick the word that stings the least. In law enforcement, we sometimes forget this because experience, seniority gets confused with mastery. Time in uniform or behind a desk or behind a communication console does not automatically equal competence in every role you touch, especially after promotion. Here's where things usually break down. The subordinate, the worker, the teammate believe that they are competent. They truly believe it, but the supervisor does not. We don't have a micromanagement problem just yet. What we have is a perception problem. You see, from the subordinates perspective, it feels like, are you all over me? I know how to do this. I know how to do my job. But from the supervisor's perspective, it feels like, man, if I don't stay on top of this, it's going to come back and bite me. Same behavior. to very different interpretations. This is where supervisors quietly justify micromanaging by telling themselves they're being responsible. They call it being detail-oriented. They call it being hands-on. They call it protecting the unit, the shift, or the agency. But here's the uncomfortable truth. When a supervisor inserts themselves into every detail of a competent employee's work, They're not increasing control. They're broadcasting their lack of trust. And trust is oxygen. When trust drops, initiative drops with it. Decision making narrows. People stop bringing you problems early and they start hiding them until they're forced into the open. You don't get better work. You get safer work. In policing, safe work often means checking boxes instead of thinking critically. and that should worry you. Now, before anyone starts nodding aggressively and thinking, yes, finally someone gets it, pause because the mirror comes before the microphone. If you believe you're being micromanaged, the first move is not to label your boss. The first move is to do a self audit. Audit yourself. Ask yourself some very specific questions. Are there areas in my job where I'm maybe still developing and hoping no one notices? Have I missed deadlines, details, or expectations that my supervisor now feels compelled to monitor? Did I receive feedback and assume it wasn't a big deal because it was wrapped in praise? The old praise criticized praise sandwich. Am I judging myself by my intentions while my supervisor is judging me by my outcomes? That last one stings because it's usually true. Supervisors don't live in your head. They live with your results. Now, let's say you do that self-assessment honestly. Honestly means no ego, no shortcuts. Your performance is solid. Your work is timely. Your decisions are sound. And your evaluations back it up. Your team performs and yet your supervisor is still asking for hourly updates, rewriting reports, or telling you how to do things you already do well. Now we're in the real world of micromanagement territory. And that's where the next part of this episode matters because complaining to coworkers, venting at home or mentally quitting never fixes this. Just makes you a bitter quitter. The move here is not confrontation. The move here is leadership upward, exemplary followership. And that's what we're going to break down next because the goal isn't to win an argument with your boss. The goal is to change behavior without triggering defenses. And that takes skill, not volume. If you've ever thought, there's no way I can say this without it going sideways, you're wrong. Leading up is one of the hardest leadership skills to execute well, especially in a rank-based culture where authority, liability, and ego are all in the room. whether anyone names them or not. So let's be clear about the objective. This conversation is not about proving your boss wrong. It's not about venting. It's not about winning. It's about changing behavior while preserving trust. And that requires three things. Respect, behavior-based language, and emotional regulation. If you miss any one of them, and the conversation is going to collapse under its own weight. Start with respect, not performative respect, real respect. Ask for time. Don't ambush your supervisor in the hallway or the parking lot or right after roll call when they're already juggling 10 things. Schedule a conversation. Show up on time or even early. Turn your phone off. Thank them for making the time to meet with you. All these signal maturity. You're about to give your boss feedback and feedback they've probably never heard before. If you open with irritation or sarcasm, their defensive shields are going to go up before you even finish the first or second sentence. And once those shields are up, you're done. Language matters here. This is not the moment for you statements. This is not the moment for labels. The word micromanagement would suggest shouldn't come out of your mouth. Instead, brain the issue around impact. Say something like, feel distracted and less effective when I'm required to generate multiple progress reports each day. Or, I want to make sure my time is being used in the highest value way for the unit. Or, I'm concerned that some of this oversight is pulling me away from outcomes You've told me that matter to you. You see how that language doesn't attack character? It invites discussion. Next, focus on behavior. Don't make it about personality. Don't say something like, you're always riding me. Don't say, you don't trust me. Don't say you're micromanaging everything I do. Those statements feel really satisfying, but they accomplish nothing. Instead, be specific. Say something like, the past two weeks, I've been asked to submit updates twice a day on work that's already captured in a weekly report. Those updates take an hour to prepare. That's time I could be spending on follow-ups, case reviews, or monitoring my people. Something like that. Notice what's happening here. You're not accusing. You're explaining consequences. Supervisors live in consequences. Liability. Time. and risk outcomes. When you connect behavior to impact, you're speaking their language. ⁓ Now comes the hardest part. Staying calm. Your body is going to try to sabotage you. Your heart rate will climb. Your jaw will tighten. Your face is going to feel warm. It might even be red. That's the stress response. Doing what it's designed to do. But if you let the stress response run the conversation, you're going to say something. that you wish you hadn't said and you won't be able to take it back. This is where emotional regulation matters. Slow your breathing, literally. Inhale through your nose, exhale longer than you inhale. You guys know this. This is combat breathing. This is tactical breathing. It tells your nervous system you're not under threat. Even if your rank structure says otherwise, if your supervisor pushes back, interrupts, or minimizes your concern, don't escalate. Stay anchored to behavior and impact. Say something like, understand your concern. I want to make sure I'm meeting your expectations and I'm open to feedback if there's something I'm missing. Saying something like that, that posture keeps their defenses down. And here's the irony most people miss. Many micromanagers do not realize they're micromanaging. They truly believe they're being helpful. They believe they're preventing mistakes. They believe their involvement improves outcomes. Sometimes your conversation is the first time anyone has ever connected their behavior to its unintended effects. If you handle it well, you might see change. Probably not overnight, but gradually. And if nothing changes, at least you'll know you addressed it professionally, not passively or explosively. In this final segment, we're going to flip the lens because if you're a supervisor listening right now, hopefully watching right now on YouTube and feeling slightly uncomfortable, good, this part's for you. We're going to talk about why micromanagement is so tempting after promotion, how fear disguises itself as control and how to lead without hovering. If you're a supervisor listening to this and you're thinking, ⁓ this doesn't apply to me. I just like things done right. Stay with me. That sentence, that thought is usually where micromanagement hides best. Most micromanagement does not come from arrogance. It comes from fear wearing a competence mask. Fear of mistakes. Fear of liability. Fear of being embarrassed upward. In law enforcement, those fears make sense. The consequences are real. But control is not the cure. This is where research becomes uncomfortable. Gallup has spent more than two decades studying employees' engagement across millions of workers worldwide. Their flagship engagement instrument is called the CUE. It's a set of 12 questions that consistently predict performance outcomes like productivity, retention, safety incidents, and discretionary effort. Two of these findings are especially relevant to micromanagement. First, Gallup repeatedly finds that the immediate supervisor is the single biggest driver of engagement. Listen that again. Your immediate supervisor is the single biggest driver of engagement. Not pay, not salary, not bonuses, not mission statements. not agency slogans. The person directly above you matters most. That should land hard for anyone, any one of you wearing stripes or bars or stars. Second, several Q12 items directly map out to micromanagement behavior. Even though the word micromanagement is never used. One question asked whether employees feel they have the autonomy to do their work well. When autonomy scores are low, engagement drops sharply, even when employees are technically capable. Another question asks whether employees feel their supervisors trust them and support them. Gallup data shows that when employees perceive low trust from their supervisor, they reduce discretionary effort. They do the bare minimum. They do what is required, not what is possible. And they certainly don't reach their potential. Listen to that again in your head because all of that explains a lot of station level behavior. Gallup has also found that low engagement teams experienced higher burnout, higher turnover intent, more errors and more safety incidents. Now the Gallup study is the Q12 is not specifically to law enforcement. In policing that translates to more check the box behavior, less proactive problem solving. less ownership and less proactive police work. And here's the line that should make every supervisor pause. One of Gallup's most uncomfortable conclusion for leaders is this. Employees do not disengage from the job. They disengage from the supervisor. This is not a morale problem. This is a leadership problem. Micromanagement accelerates that disengagement because it communicates, intentionally or not, it communicates the I don't trust your judgment message. Now layer that on top of what happens usually after promotion. Right after promotion, were really, think about it, you were really good at your job, really good. Now you're responsible for outcomes. You no longer directly control. That loss of control creates anxiety. And the easiest way to reduce anxiety is to insert yourself back into the work you used to do. That's when you start to rewrite reports, you double check decisions, you ask for updates you don't truly need. It feels responsible, it feels safe, but over time it teaches your people something dangerous. They learn that initiative gets corrected. They learn that ownership gets overwritten. They learn that the safest move is to wait. That's how good teams slowly become passive ones. Ask yourself this question and answer it honestly. Am I involved because there's a demonstrated performance gap or because I'm uncomfortable with uncertainty? Those are not the same thing. If there is a performance gap, your job is to coach them, train them and set clear expectations. That's leadership. If there's no performance gap and you're still inserting yourself, that's over control. and over control erodes trust faster than almost anything else you can do. Strong supervisors shift their focus from how things are done to whether standards are met, from constant monitoring to clear outcomes, from hovering to availability. Your job is not to prevent every mistake. I mean, that's impossible. Your job is to build people, people who can think, decide and recover. without you standing over their shoulder. Because one day, you're not going to be there. You're going to get promoted. You're going to transfer out. You're going to retire, God willing. The unit, the team, the squad is still going to exist. If you're a supervisor listening to this and you're thinking, this doesn't apply to me, I just like things done the right way, again, stay with me. This is usually where micromanagement hides best. Like I said, most micromanagement does not come from arrogance. comes from fear wearing a mask of competence, fear of mistakes, fear of liability, fear of being embarrassed, fear that if you loosen your grip, something's going to go wrong and your name is going to be attached to it. The consequences are real. Paperwork matters. Decisions matter. Lives and careers can be affected by small errors. But here's the paradox. The more you hover, the less capable your people become. Research backs this up. Studies grounded in self-determination theory show that autonomy is not a luxury. It's a requirement for sustained performance. When you strip autonomy away, you don't get precision. You get compliance. People stop thinking ahead and start waiting for permission. Gallup's data says the same thing in a different language. Employees who feel trusted by their supervisors are significantly more engaged and more willing to take initiative when trust drops, effort drops to the minimum safe level. That should sound familiar. If you've ever wondered why your people stop bringing you solutions and only bring you problems, look at how much space you give them to solve things without you stepping in. Here's the other hard truth. Micromanagement often shows up right after promotion. You were good at your job, really good. Now you're responsible for the work, not the work itself. And that identity shift is harder than most people admit. So you compensate the only way you know how. You keep doing the job just with more authority. You rewrite reports, you insert yourself into decisions, you double check and double check because it feels safer than letting go. It feels responsible. But over time, it teaches your people something dangerous. They learn that initiative gets corrected. They learn that ownership gets overwritten. They learn that the safest move is to wait. That's how good teams slowly become passive ones. Ask yourself this question and answer it honestly. Am I involved because there's a demonstrated performance gap or because I'm uncomfortable with uncertainty? They are not the same thing. this last segment, we're going to bring this together. What to do this week if you're being micromanaged? What to change this week? if you are micromanaging. Simple actions, no theory, no fluff. But before we get to that, I have to ask you a law enforcement trivia question. Where do rainbows go when they've been bad to prism so they have time to reflect on what they've done? These are just for me. Let's end this the right way. Not with a slogan, with action. Because micromanagement usually doesn't blow up in one dramatic moment. It erodes teams quietly, one interaction at a time. If you are being micromanaged, your move this week is not to complain louder or withdraw further, it's to get intentional. First, audit your performance. Again, brutally, look for any gap, even a small one, that gives your supervisor a reason to hover. Close the gap. Document that you've done it. Make it visible so your boss knows you've addressed whatever the shortcoming is. pick one behavior your boss does. One behavior to address, not all of them. One, choose the behavior that's the biggest drag on your time or effectiveness. Maybe it's excessive monitoring, standing over your shoulder while you work, tracking or questioning why you stepped away from your desk, even if just for a few minutes. It could also take on the perform of perfectionism, which looks like delegating work, then taking it back or asking for multiple redos over minor preferences so that the final product matches the manager's personal style. Or maybe they do something that limits your autonomy, such as requiring a review of non-sensitive communications or preventing you from directly interacting. with investigators or somebody outside your immediate chain of command. These are just a few examples. But even if you have many, many more, pick one. Then, you do. What you do is request a professional conversation, not a confrontation. Schedule it. When discussing, lead with respect. Describe the behavior. Explain the impact. Stay calm. Thank them for listening, regardless of the outcome. That's upward leadership. or as I said, the blurry followership. Now, if you're the one micromanaging, I know nobody watching or listening to this podcast is a micromanager. Hopefully you caught my eye roll. Your homework is different and it's probably harder. Pick one competent person on your team and deliberately loosen your grip. Stop rewriting their work. Stop asking for updates you don't really need. Stop inserting yourself into decisions they're already capable of making. Instead do three things set a clear outcome Define the standard make yourself available not intrusive then watch what happens if Performance holds or maybe even improves you just learn something important about your own leadership If it doesn't you now have hard evidence that coaching or clarity is needed not hovering either way It's a win leadership is not about control. It's about capacity The measure of a supervisor is not how involved they are, but how capable their people are when they're not around. If this episode made you uncomfortable, good. Growth is usually uncomfortable. If I gave you language you didn't have before, use it. And if it made you realize you've been confusing care with control, you're not alone. The fix starts with awareness. You can't beware until you're first aware. All right, final trivia question. Which night of the round table was the beefiest? Sir Loing, of course. This is Blue Leader Nation. Lead with clarity, lead with trust. And remember, leadership is a contact sport. So go out there and practice. ⁓ is anyone within the thin blue line who want to take it to the next level. We hope you didn't mind the dad jokes by the way. If you enjoyed the show make sure to like rate and review and we'll be back soon but in the meantime hit the website at www.blueleadernation.com