Latest / The Piano Maven with Jed Distler / Warts and All - Five Flawed Yet Fascinating Piano Recordings
Transcript
- 0:06This is Jed Disler, and welcome to The Piano
- 0:09Maven, your friendly podcast guide to piano recordings.
- 0:13A listener wrote to me with an interesting idea
- 0:17proposition, which was to devote an episode to
- 0:22performances that are not technically perfect,
- 0:26or they're frequently imperfect, or certainly
- 0:30less accurate than accurate, yet In spite of
- 0:35this, the performances manage to give me a thrill
- 0:38or to hold my interest, or I can just flat out
- 0:42say that I love them warts and all, or I'm at
- 0:45least fascinated by them warts and all. I'm sure
- 0:49that you have piano performances like this in
- 0:52mind, like warts and all performances, but I've
- 0:56put a list of five so -called warts and all performances.
- 1:01together, and this list of five just came off
- 1:05the top of my head. I'm sure there's so many
- 1:07more, but these ones in particular I think may
- 1:11hold some interest or pique your curiosity. First,
- 1:16I guess you have to say that any recording by
- 1:19Alfred Courtauld is warts and all, because you
- 1:22usually get a fair amount of clinkers, but this
- 1:25is especially true in his late post -war recordings.
- 1:30And some of the recordings that Courtauld made
- 1:33in the 1950s can be tough going, to put it gently.
- 1:37However, I am curiously drawn to his 1957 recordings
- 1:46of the four Chopin ballades. These were not released
- 1:50in his lifetime, and they only appeared for the
- 1:53first time in the EMI Warner. complete Courtauld
- 1:58box that came out in 2012. It goes without saying
- 2:02that in these 1957 Chopin ballades, Courtauld,
- 2:08technically speaking, is nowhere near his prime
- 2:12in his two earlier complete ballade cycles, you
- 2:16know, the ones from 1929 and 1933. And even those
- 2:21have wrong notes, but hardly to the extent of
- 2:251957. Yet, in these 1957 recordings, Courtauld's
- 2:32interpretive ideas are so interesting, and they
- 2:35carry great authority and experience. And he
- 2:40never compromises in terms of tempo. He never
- 2:44seems to take slower tempos in order to accommodate
- 2:48his hands. He still goes for broke. whether or
- 2:51not he can play certain virtuosic passages or
- 2:54not. And his sound is still quite huge and full
- 2:59and colorful and full of impact. And there are
- 3:03many magical moments and gestures. And you get
- 3:07a sense of what Courtauld wants to do and what
- 3:11he still could do, which wasn't always all that
- 3:14much. But still, I mean, it's... Is it mind over
- 3:18matter or mind over reality? I mean, I don't
- 3:22know. But I'm fascinated by these ballads in
- 3:25any case. Second, we have another warts and all
- 3:30recording. This is the live 1957 Grieg concerto
- 3:37with Percy Granger as a piano soloist. It's with
- 3:41the Argos Municipal Orchestra conducted by Per
- 3:45Dreyer. This recording originally was slated
- 3:50to be released on the Vanguard label on LP. Because
- 3:56of many technical errors and also a memory slip
- 4:00in one place, certain critics, including Harold
- 4:03C. Schoenberg, felt that releasing this would
- 4:06damage Granger's reputation. So Vanguard withdrew
- 4:12and suppressed the LP right before it was issued.
- 4:16But a few copies managed to sneak out, and it
- 4:20became one of the rarest and most sought -after
- 4:24classical LPs in existence, commanding tons of
- 4:29money on the second -hand market. I think that
- 4:32when it was reissued on CD, they did... clean
- 4:36up a few things, although I never did a comparison
- 4:40between the LP and the CD. I never owned the
- 4:44LP. I had a cassette of the LP, but then I got
- 4:48hold of the CD, of course, but I never was able
- 4:52to cross -check. Generally, there's a real nobility,
- 4:55and there's a natural rhetorical ebb and flow
- 4:59to Granger's playing. And again, the word authority,
- 5:03I think, really comes across, even though he's
- 5:07not on his best form. That said, there is a 1956
- 5:13Greek concerto that the IPA label issued only
- 5:19on LP with Percy Granger, and it has Richard
- 5:23Morse conducting the Southeast Iowa Orchestra,
- 5:28and the sound quality is pretty good. I mean,
- 5:30this is a terrible community orchestra. and Granger
- 5:35is still past his prime, but he is on better
- 5:38form in this recording than in the Arhus performance
- 5:43on Vanguard. The only problem is that this performance
- 5:47never came out on CD, and I doubt it ever will,
- 5:52and the original LPs were pressed in limited
- 5:56edition, so it's not an easy disc to source.
- 6:00I happen to have it, and I suppose I should digitize
- 6:04it eventually. Warts and all recording number
- 6:08three. I guess we have to talk about Archer Schnabel
- 6:12and his recording of Beethoven's Hammerklavier
- 6:15Sonata. Schnabel's outer movements have amazing
- 6:20brio and drive and a real sense of tension and
- 6:24release, but you do have to admit that his fingers
- 6:27often go off the rails. I mean, not in a bothersome
- 6:31way, to be sure. But I remember reading a quote
- 6:34from some writer who said that in the hammer
- 6:37clavier, Schnabel gave you less of the notes,
- 6:41but more of the music than anyone else. And I
- 6:44can understand that. Although in the slow movement,
- 6:48Schnabel has no technical problems. great eloquence
- 6:57and astute timing and expressive economy. I suspect
- 7:02that if tape editing had existed in 1935, Schnabel
- 7:07would have given us a hammer clavier on the level
- 7:10of those quick and driving outer movements that
- 7:14you hear from the recordings of Peter Serkin
- 7:17and Murray Pariah. But anyway, this is a great
- 7:21example of a warts and all recording that I love.
- 7:25Example number four. Now, when it comes to warts
- 7:29and all, and believe me, in this case, the warts
- 7:33are pretty big. We'll have to talk about that
- 7:37crazy Hungarian pianist, Irvin Nierichazi. He
- 7:42was one of the most documented child prodigies
- 7:45in history, and when he was in his late teens,
- 7:49his New York debut caused a sensation, although
- 7:52his rather extravagant and subjective style polarized
- 7:56critics as well as some musicians. Anyway, his
- 8:01early adult career ended almost as soon as it
- 8:04began, partly due to bad management and bad luck.
- 8:10mostly due on account of this pianist's volatile
- 8:13personality. He lived mostly in cheap hotels
- 8:17where he composed prolifically and he drank to
- 8:22excess, and his sexual recklessness led to numerous
- 8:27unsavory entanglements, as well as ten marriages.
- 8:32But his... idiosyncratic and hyper -romantic
- 8:37pianism did elicit serious attention every now
- 8:41and then. And there's a letter from Arnold Schoenberg
- 8:44to Otto Klemperer, who really responded positively
- 8:48to Nirajazi's playing when he heard him in 1935.
- 8:54And he recommended that Klemperer hire Nirajazi,
- 8:58but Klemperer did not like Nirajazi's playing
- 9:00when he auditioned for him. In any event, Nierichazzi
- 9:05bounced around for decades in the Los Angeles
- 9:08area. And by the 1970s, he had not owned a piano
- 9:13in years and had long given up on concertizing.
- 9:18But in order to raise funds for his ailing ninth
- 9:22wife, Nierichazzi gave a recital at San Francisco's
- 9:28Old First Church on May 6, 1973. And in 1977,
- 9:36the IPA label, distributed by Desmar, released
- 9:41an LP where on one side it contained the two
- 9:46St. Francis legends from this San Francisco recital,
- 9:50and then on the other side you had four list
- 9:53recordings made under studio conditions in 1974
- 9:57that were supervised by Gregor Banco. And these
- 10:01studio recordings have never turned up on CD,
- 10:04by the way. But the disc generated a lot of curiosity
- 10:09about Neerajhasi, and they led to further studio
- 10:13recordings in 1978, and an abundance of press
- 10:18hype and public attention. You know, most of
- 10:22it was very sensationalistic. But by 1980 or
- 10:26so, the Neerajhasi fad had kind of run its course.
- 10:30and the pianist basically retreated into the
- 10:33obscurity he preferred, except for a handful
- 10:36of performances he gave in Japan. A few years
- 10:40ago, the Soneto Classics label issued the complete
- 10:45Old First Church concert, and basically the playing
- 10:50is bizarre and self -indulgent, and there are
- 10:54fistfuls of wrong notes all over the place. However,
- 10:58From this recital, those two St. Francis legends
- 11:01are pretty astonishing. I mean, pianistically,
- 11:05they are all over the place, to put it kindly.
- 11:08And it's more like he's paraphrasing than playing
- 11:11the music. But the slow tempos and the immense
- 11:15intensity and the strong character in this playing,
- 11:20I think, cuts through all the technical problems.
- 11:24And it certainly... cuts through the crappy sound
- 11:27quality of the original cassette. And you wonder
- 11:32if Neerajasi was a genius or a madman, or probably
- 11:36both. I don't know. But these St. Francis legends
- 11:40really fascinate me and hold my attention. And
- 11:45now for my fifth warts and all recording. I can't
- 11:51really recommend it because this is something
- 11:54that's never been released. although I have broadcast
- 11:57it on my radio show Between the Keys, and I've
- 12:01posted a link to the webcast so you can actually
- 12:05hear it yourself. It's a live performance of
- 12:10the finale from the Chopin B minor sonata, the
- 12:14sonata number three. I don't know if the performance
- 12:18of the whole sonata was preserved, but the finale
- 12:22from this particular performance has been passed
- 12:25passed around the Piano Maven underground for
- 12:29years. And it features a well -known pianist
- 12:33basically having a nervous breakdown, speeding
- 12:36through the music like nobody's business, and
- 12:40omitting page after page of music. The pianist
- 12:43makes such a horrible mess of this music that...
- 12:47It makes Vladimir Horowitz's disastrous 1983
- 12:51concert sound like the young Maurizio Pellini
- 12:54by comparison. But who is this pianist? I was
- 12:59tactful enough not to identify him on my radio
- 13:03show. Okay, now you know it's a male pianist.
- 13:06I will give you a little hint. I did a podcast
- 13:10episode about a box set. containing this pianist's
- 13:15complete recordings for a certain label. I'm
- 13:19just going to leave it at that. Now, is this
- 13:22a warts and all performance that I love? Well,
- 13:26I love it as a party record. I mean, I like to
- 13:29play this for people just to see how they will
- 13:32react. I mean, it's a really tragic performance
- 13:36by a professional pianist totally losing it.
- 13:40So, I guess I love it in a mean -spirited way.
- 13:44But I still have to restrain myself and not reveal
- 13:48this pianist's identity. I know that many of
- 13:51you are going to write to me and you're going
- 13:53to tell me that you know who this pianist is.
- 13:56And you're welcome to do so. And I'm sure many
- 13:58of you do know the identity. And my response
- 14:02will simply be, you said it, I didn't. So, what
- 14:06are your favorite warts and all piano recordings?
- 14:11I'd be curious to find out, so let me know. This
- 14:15is Jed Disler, and you've been listening to The
- 14:17Piano Maven, your friendly podcast guide to piano
- 14:21recordings. And I look forward to being with
- 14:24you for our next episode.