Latest / Dharma Lab / DL Ep. 31: Your Brain Is a Storyteller
Transcript
- 0:00The example you gave earlier of the brains who had kind of the
- 0:03Broca's area damage.
- 0:04SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 0:04it was almost exact finding where it's like parts of the brain
- 0:08are not talking to
- 0:08SPEAKER_00: each other.
- 0:09SPEAKER_00: And so one part of the brain clearly knows something,
- 0:11SPEAKER_00: but the part that communicates doesn't and it doesn't stay silent.
- 0:15SPEAKER_00: It makes something up.
- 0:16SPEAKER_00: That's the funny thing.
- 0:17SPEAKER_00: It's not as though in the absence of information, we just stay silent.
- 0:21SPEAKER_00: It's like, no.
- 0:22And this is the,
- 0:23again,
- 0:23the implication for our lives when we don't know something.
- 0:26we're not comfortable with not knowing there's some like
- 0:28instinctual part of us
- 0:30that will fill in the blanks almost all the time and that's
- 0:33what now we have two
- 0:34different areas of research that are basically pointed at that
- 0:37same thing yeah the
- 0:38human mind and brain is a storyteller and this is how we make
- 0:42sense of our world is
- 0:45SPEAKER_01: we we create these narratives
- 1:03welcome everyone to another episode of Dharma Lab i am Cortland
- 1:08Dahl i'm here with
- 1:09SPEAKER_00: Dr.
- 1:09Richard Davidson who we all lovingly call Richie who as i'm
- 1:14sure most of you know
- 1:16is one of the most pioneering and widely studied
- 1:21neuroscientists on the entire
- 1:22planet so a great gift to be in conversation and today actually
- 1:26we're going to have
- 1:27SPEAKER_00: a really
- 1:28a really really cool conversation that I'm very excited about I
- 1:31must say I've been
- 1:32I've known Richie for a long time I moved to Madison Wisconsin
- 1:35to study with Richie
- 1:36back in in 2012 and I've heard many many conversations at the
- 1:42Center for Healthy
- 1:42Minds where we both work with which Richie founded about the
- 1:46latest research about
- 1:48cool things that are coming up in in the world of neuroscience
- 1:52and other fields of
- 1:53SPEAKER_00: science but one thing that really has never happened
- 1:56even for those of us who work closely with Richie is that we've
- 2:00never really just
- 2:00gotten a download from him of just all of the amazing work that
- 2:05has happened over
- 2:06the years and one thing that you all listening may not know is
- 2:12that Richie of
- 2:13SPEAKER_00: course has a pioneer
- 2:16of what we now know as contemplative science and contemplative
- 2:19neuroscience,
- 2:19which is the scientific study of how practices like meditation
- 2:24affect the mind,
- 2:25SPEAKER_00: the brain and our biology.
- 2:28SPEAKER_00: But he also is equally a pioneer of
- 2:30a completely different field of neuroscience known as affective
- 2:34neuroscience,
- 2:35SPEAKER_00: which you might think of as the neuroscience of emotions.
- 2:38SPEAKER_00: So to be a pioneer of one field is kind of an incredible achievement.
- 2:42SPEAKER_00: To be the pioneer of two fields is kind of mind boggling.
- 2:46And so i've never really had the opportunity nor many of us who
- 2:49work with richie
- 2:50have ever had the opportunity just to say like we want to just
- 2:52let's dig into some
- 2:54of the key insights so i feel like this is a gift for for me as
- 2:58much as it is for
- 2:59for you listening to really just get a download uh of some of
- 3:03the the most cool
- 3:04SPEAKER_00: pioneering science scientific work that has happened about the brain
- 3:09So Richie I just want to kick it over to you I think we talked
- 3:13offline about this
- 3:15this topic of neural asymmetry and which was a huge part of
- 3:19your early career and
- 3:21this work and what I refer to as affective neuroscience but why
- 3:24don't you just take
- 3:25us back to the beginning and some of the the key insights some
- 3:28of what you were
- 3:29working on why you were even interested in what led to these
- 3:32findings and then we
- 3:33SPEAKER_00: can just we can just see where the conversation goes
- 3:36SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 3:38SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 3:38SPEAKER_01: So first,
- 3:39thank you everyone for tuning into Dharma Lab and thank you
- 3:43Cort for bringing this
- 3:46SPEAKER_01: topic up.
- 3:47SPEAKER_01: It was a topic that was near and dear to my heart.
- 3:50SPEAKER_01: It still is a topic I'm
- 3:52extremely interested in and in the early part of my career was
- 3:57replete with
- 3:58investigations and a lot of thinking about this whole issue and
- 4:04it really began
- 4:05when I was a graduate student and I had the opportunity to
- 4:09study with a very very
- 4:12SPEAKER_01: famous neurologist at Harvard Medical School
- 4:16SPEAKER_01: by the name of Norman Geschwind.
- 4:18SPEAKER_01: Viewers can go look him up at some point if they're interested.
- 4:23He was one of the great towering figures in the specialty that
- 4:29we now call behavioral neurology.
- 4:32SPEAKER_01: And I took initially a course with him that was on
- 4:37what he called functional neuroanatomy which is basically how
- 4:42different parts of
- 4:43the brain are connected to different behavioral functions and
- 4:47he's a neurologist
- 4:48and so he would look at people and he would see their behavior
- 4:54as a external
- 4:57reflection of what was going on in the brain that's how he
- 5:00looked at people and he
- 5:03SPEAKER_01: was an extremely keen observer
- 5:07SPEAKER_01: of behavior.
- 5:08SPEAKER_01: And he also was very demanding.
- 5:11SPEAKER_01: He was very much in the camp of what we would now call a localizationist.
- 5:21SPEAKER_01: And by that,
- 5:21we mean someone who really believes in the specific
- 5:26localization of different
- 5:28SPEAKER_01: functions in different parts of the brain.
- 5:31SPEAKER_01: And he used to say that
- 5:33SPEAKER_01: you know if you don't believe in localization it's because you don't know
- 5:36neuroanatomy well enough so he used to harangue us for you know
- 5:43learning more
- 5:44neuroanatomy which led to me doing for the first time a human
- 5:47brain dissection
- 5:49obviously in a dead brain but that's where I really learned
- 5:54neuroanatomy but I used
- 5:55SPEAKER_01: to go on rounds with him
- 5:58where he would visit patients you know neurological patients in
- 6:02the hospital and
- 6:04you know he would do these bedside exams that were incredible
- 6:09and just clever ways
- 6:11of interacting with a patient to reveal what might be different
- 6:16about their brain
- 6:19Did they know he was doing this or was he more it just kind of
- 6:23felt like a routine
- 6:23interaction but he was asking them things or or was it very
- 6:27clear like it's an exam
- 6:28SPEAKER_00: and he was kind of testing for different functions and so forth
- 6:31it was both so there are times when it was explicit in times
- 6:34when it was implicit
- 6:36oh you know the most famous implicit one is something that was
- 6:44not actually
- 6:45something that he invented but it was developed this simple
- 6:50technique was developed
- 6:52SPEAKER_01: by a another earlier neurologist by the name of Korsakoff
- 7:00and he discovered a syndrome of dementia that was associated
- 7:05with alcoholism.
- 7:06One of the things that Korsakoff showed is that there is a
- 7:10separation between
- 7:12SPEAKER_01: memory for declarative information and memory for emotional information.
- 7:19SPEAKER_01: So I'll give an example of how this
- 7:24was tested so for someone who has dementia if I were to visit
- 7:28them on a day just
- 7:32after I visited them the day before a normal person who has an
- 7:37intact brain would
- 7:38recognize me right as familiar that I they saw me yesterday
- 7:43someone who has
- 7:43SPEAKER_01: dementia you know severe dementia may not recognize me at all
- 7:51So a person with dementia would not recognize me if I came back
- 7:55the second day
- 7:57SPEAKER_01: after he had seen me the first day.
- 7:59And so what Korsakoff did is to ask whether the same was true
- 8:04for emotional information.
- 8:05And so what he did,
- 8:07which Geshwin also,
- 8:09you know,
- 8:09I saw Geshwin do it with a patient.
- 8:11SPEAKER_01: It's the first time that I saw it being done live.
- 8:15SPEAKER_01: He'd put a thumbtack in his hand and shake the guy's hand.
- 8:20and you know it would obviously hurt and the guy would withdraw
- 8:24his hand because it
- 8:25was you know you got pricked with the thumbtack I don't think
- 8:30you would get away
- 8:30with that these days but interesting the stuff you could
- 8:33probably pull back in the
- 8:36day so he had done that with this patient and he walked into
- 8:42the room and he asked
- 8:44the patient you know do you know who I am and the patient said
- 8:48no you know
- 8:50SPEAKER_01: And he said,
- 8:50SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 8:50SPEAKER_01: I'm Dr.
- 8:51Geschwind I saw you yesterday And he put his hand out to shake
- 8:56his hand And the
- 8:57SPEAKER_01: patient refused to shake his hand Wow,
- 9:01SPEAKER_00: wow,
- 9:02SPEAKER_01: that's cool And then he asked,
- 9:04SPEAKER_01: why don't you shake my hand?
- 9:06SPEAKER_01: And then the patient confabulated and said Well,
- 9:11I think your hand is dirty And I don't want to shake your hand
- 9:14because This is just
- 9:15SPEAKER_00: like the work with the corpus callosum and,
- 9:18SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 9:19SPEAKER_00: the
- 9:21SPEAKER_00: I don't even want to take us down a rabbit hole,
- 9:23SPEAKER_00: but very similar kind of thing,
- 9:25SPEAKER_00: very similar kind of finding.
- 9:27SPEAKER_01: Exactly, exactly.
- 9:30So,
- 9:30I mean,
- 9:31that's a beautiful demonstration that there's a complete
- 9:35dissociation
- 9:37SPEAKER_01: between the declarative memory and the emotional memory.
- 9:40SPEAKER_01: The declarative memory was gone.
- 9:42SPEAKER_00: And declarative, just maybe you could unpack that term.
- 9:44SPEAKER_00: That might be a word people are not familiar with.
- 9:46SPEAKER_01: It means more semantic information.
- 9:51SPEAKER_01: It's information about,
- 9:52SPEAKER_01: in this case,
- 9:53SPEAKER_01: it's recognizing the person's face,
- 9:55SPEAKER_01: recognizing their name.
- 9:56SPEAKER_01: And, you know, it was very clear that the patient had no memory of
- 10:03having seen this doctor before even conscious memory but some
- 10:09part of their brain
- 10:10SPEAKER_00: clearly remembered so it's like no a disconnection between your conscious
- 10:14experience and clearly what's going on exactly consciously in
- 10:18some respect exactly
- 10:19and the emotional memory you can think of as a more unconscious
- 10:22memory and you know
- 10:24SPEAKER_01: clearly
- 10:25The patient had some memory of having been pricked in his hand
- 10:30when he shook the hand.
- 10:31SPEAKER_01: And so he was able to demonstrate that really dramatic dissociation.
- 10:38SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 10:39just that one point actually has such huge implications for
- 10:44kind of our life and
- 10:45points to something that probably happens a lot where we have
- 10:49an interpretation of
- 10:51SPEAKER_00: something that we're completely convinced of.
- 10:54And it seems so real it just seems like this is what's
- 10:56happening to the degree that
- 10:57it doesn't even occur to us that it's even interpretation and
- 11:01yet it's a complete
- 11:02as you were saying confabulation it's basically the mind has
- 11:05limited information or
- 11:07it's not conscious of something and it's created a whole story
- 11:10about something but
- 11:11it's totally disconnected it's like actually not connected at
- 11:14all in some cases
- 11:15just flat out wrong but yet in the moment it feels like reality
- 11:19it feels like it's
- 11:20SPEAKER_00: just a perception of what's happening
- 11:22exactly and this as you said before court which is so
- 11:26incredibly true is that this
- 11:29is not just occurring in patients with frank damage to their
- 11:34brain this is
- 11:35happening in all of us all the time and this is the way our
- 11:39minds work that it
- 11:40creates a story about the world and it's from that story that
- 11:45we operate it's not
- 11:47SPEAKER_01: from some you know
- 11:49Veridical perception of things in the world there's no such
- 11:52thing as that our minds
- 11:54are constantly creating these stories and of course this very
- 11:58directly relates
- 12:00particularly to our insight pillar of well-being which is
- 12:04really about the
- 12:05narrative that we're constantly creating about ourselves so
- 12:09getting back to Geshwin
- 12:12SPEAKER_01: one of his great contributions as a neurologist
- 12:17SPEAKER_01: is the discovery of language-related lateralization in the human brain.
- 12:23SPEAKER_01: And so what that means is in virtually all right-handed people,
- 12:30SPEAKER_01: and I'll talk about left-handed people in a moment,
- 12:34SPEAKER_01: but in virtually all right-handed people,
- 12:36SPEAKER_01: which accounts for around 85 to 90% of the population,
- 12:42SPEAKER_01: in virtually all of those people
- 12:44It is the left hemisphere that can speak,
- 12:49but the right hemisphere can't.
- 12:50And what we mean by that is quite literally that the speech
- 12:55related centers in the
- 12:56SPEAKER_01: brain,
- 12:57SPEAKER_01: and there's a key region in the brain called Broca's area.
- 13:02SPEAKER_01: And it was named after this neurologist named Paul Broca.
- 13:07And it is an area in the left hemisphere,
- 13:10in the left temporal lobe and damage to that area
- 13:14which occurs in certain kinds of stroke will appear impair a
- 13:19person's ability
- 13:21SPEAKER_01: Now,
- 13:21SPEAKER_01: what's,
- 13:22SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 13:22SPEAKER_01: super interesting,
- 13:23SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 13:24SPEAKER_01: there are many things that are interesting about this,
- 13:26but this is one of the most clearly lateralized functions in
- 13:31the human brain.
- 13:33And what we mean by that is that if a patient has damage to
- 13:38this area in their left
- 13:39SPEAKER_01: hemisphere,
- 13:40the corresponding area in the right hemisphere doesn't
- 13:43immediately take over.
- 13:45And so the person actually will show impairments in their
- 13:49ability to speak.
- 13:51and stroke patients who have damage to that area of the brain
- 13:56will be impaired in
- 13:59SPEAKER_01: their productive language.
- 14:01SPEAKER_01: They won't be able to speak.
- 14:02SPEAKER_01: So that was one of the very, very early observations.
- 14:08SPEAKER_01: This began a whole cottage industry of research to investigate
- 14:16SPEAKER_01: the extent to which other kinds of functions are also lateralized.
- 14:20And it led to this view that while there's a lot of redundancy
- 14:26between the two
- 14:26SPEAKER_01: hemispheres of the brain,
- 14:27SPEAKER_01: I should say,
- 14:28SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 14:29SPEAKER_01: I should start off by saying that humans have two halves of their brain.
- 14:34SPEAKER_01: And it's pretty much a replica on each side of the other side.
- 14:40SPEAKER_01: with some important differences,
- 14:42SPEAKER_01: but at a gross level,
- 14:44SPEAKER_01: the left and the right hemisphere are very,
- 14:46SPEAKER_01: very similar.
- 14:47And they're connected by this massive fiber bundle that we call
- 14:52the corpus callosum
- 14:53SPEAKER_01: that you alluded to earlier,
- 14:55SPEAKER_01: which is a massive bundle of white matter.
- 14:57SPEAKER_01: And these are the connections that go
- 15:01between neurons in one hemisphere and corresponding neurons in
- 15:05the other hemisphere.
- 15:06And this is the largest pathway of connection that exists in
- 15:10the human brain,
- 15:11SPEAKER_01: the connection between the two hemispheres of the brain.
- 15:16SPEAKER_01: One of the things you alluded to earlier,
- 15:19SPEAKER_01: Cort,
- 15:19SPEAKER_01: that I'll just make explicit is that there was a time,
- 15:23SPEAKER_01: it's hardly done anymore,
- 15:26SPEAKER_01: but there was a time when it was done much more,
- 15:29SPEAKER_01: is
- 15:30Patients who have epilepsy that is restricted to one hemisphere
- 15:34of the brain,
- 15:35SPEAKER_01: let's say they have an epileptic focus in their left hemisphere,
- 15:40SPEAKER_01: what happens is because of the corpus callosum,
- 15:44SPEAKER_01: because of these connections between one hemisphere and the other,
- 15:47the electrical discharges that were initiated in the left
- 15:53hemisphere would spread
- 15:54SPEAKER_01: to the right hemisphere and would result in a much more massive seizure
- 15:59SPEAKER_01: And if somehow the seizure can be just restricted to one hemisphere,
- 16:07SPEAKER_01: it would dramatically reduce the symptoms.
- 16:09SPEAKER_01: And this is what was found.
- 16:12And what was done is patients actually went through
- 16:17neurosurgery where they had the
- 16:20SPEAKER_01: corpus callosum cut,
- 16:22SPEAKER_01: severed.
- 16:24SPEAKER_01: 200 million neurons just cut.
- 16:28SPEAKER_01: And those connections,
- 16:30SPEAKER_01: for the most part,
- 16:31SPEAKER_01: don't grow back,
- 16:33SPEAKER_01: at least,
- 16:34SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 16:35SPEAKER_01: in the time span that people,
- 16:38SPEAKER_01: because this is typically done in adults.
- 16:44And over that course of time is not enough time for the
- 16:48connections to regenerate in any way.
- 16:52SPEAKER_01: And that leaves a person
- 16:55SPEAKER_01: with two hemispheres that are disconnected.
- 16:57SPEAKER_01: And when you have two hemispheres that are disconnected,
- 17:00you can demonstrate some weird dissociations because normally
- 17:05the hemispheres talk
- 17:06SPEAKER_01: to each other.
- 17:06So normally information in one hemisphere is accessible to the
- 17:12other hemisphere and vice versa.
- 17:14And it's one of the reasons why I can pick up a glass with my
- 17:17left hand and I can
- 17:19SPEAKER_01: say what it is I'm holding,
- 17:21SPEAKER_01: even if I'm blindfolded,
- 17:23SPEAKER_01: just by the feel of it
- 17:25I'd be able to say now this if I'm picking it up with my left
- 17:29hand the left hand
- 17:30projects to the right hemisphere and we know that that's how
- 17:34the pathways work and
- 17:36so the only way I can verbally identify this is if information
- 17:41goes from the right
- 17:42SPEAKER_01: hemisphere to my left hemisphere and in a patient who has a split brain
- 17:49SPEAKER_01: If they're holding a glass and they're blindfolded,
- 17:52SPEAKER_01: they would not be able to say what it is they're holding.
- 17:56SPEAKER_01: But if you gave them a multiple choice with pictures,
- 18:00SPEAKER_01: they'd be able to pick it out easily,
- 18:02SPEAKER_01: but they wouldn't be able to verbalize it.
- 18:04SPEAKER_00: So it just,
- 18:05SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 18:05SPEAKER_00: it reminds me,
- 18:06SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 18:06SPEAKER_00: that work,
- 18:07SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 18:07Ghazanaga's work shows the example you gave earlier of the
- 18:11brains who had kind of
- 18:12SPEAKER_00: the Broca's area damage.
- 18:13SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 18:14SPEAKER_00: it was almost the exact finding where it's like the brain,
- 18:17SPEAKER_00: parts of the brain are not talking to each other.
- 18:19And so one part of the brain clearly knows something,
- 18:21but the part that communicates doesn't.
- 18:24And it doesn't say silent it makes something up that's the
- 18:27funny thing it's not as
- 18:28though in the absence of information we just stay silent it's
- 18:31like no and this is
- 18:33the again the implication for our lives when we don't know
- 18:35something we don't we're
- 18:37not comfortable with not knowing there's some like instinctual
- 18:40part of us that will
- 18:41fill in the blanks almost all the time and that's what now we
- 18:44have two different
- 18:45areas of research that are basically pointing to that same that
- 18:48same thing
- 18:49SPEAKER_01: Yeah, the human mind and brain is a storyteller.
- 18:52And this is how we make sense of our world is we,
- 18:56we create these narratives.
- 18:58SPEAKER_01: So just going back to this idea of asymmetry,
- 19:04most of the research when I first began this work was focused
- 19:09on the back of the
- 19:10SPEAKER_01: brain.
- 19:11And this is where,
- 19:12or the mid part and the back,
- 19:14and this is where language differences resided.
- 19:18SPEAKER_01: and it was also where some perceptual differences resided.
- 19:21So we know the left hemisphere is specialized for speaking and
- 19:26language and the right hemisphere
- 19:29seems to be in the back a little bit better with certain kinds
- 19:34of visual spatial
- 19:36skills and using some visual spatial kinds of tasks that really
- 19:43require your
- 19:44SPEAKER_01: visualization of something and solving a problem through visualization.
- 19:50We know from various kinds of experiments with people with
- 19:55brain damage with split
- 19:56SPEAKER_01: brain patients and with normal patients
- 20:00normal individuals using some clever behavioral methods that
- 20:05the right hemisphere
- 20:06SPEAKER_01: is better at certain of those tasks.
- 20:10So one of the other amazing observations that was very early on
- 20:15in this time is that
- 20:18When patients had damage to their left hemisphere and the
- 20:23damage was including the
- 20:25SPEAKER_01: prefrontal region of the left hemisphere,
- 20:28they were much more likely to exhibit depression as one of the
- 20:33outcomes or one of
- 20:35SPEAKER_01: the consequences of the brain damage.
- 20:37SPEAKER_01: And so two people who were normal before they had brain damage,
- 20:42SPEAKER_01: and this is often brain damage from stroke,
- 20:45SPEAKER_01: after the brain damage,
- 20:47one was much more likely to be depressed the other person had
- 20:50comparable amounts of
- 20:51damage but in a different part of the brain and they were less
- 20:55likely to be
- 20:57depressed in this way and this is true even if it was the exact
- 21:01same regions but on
- 21:02the in the right hemisphere exactly okay exactly and so this
- 21:08led to the conjecture
- 21:10SPEAKER_01: well maybe the left hemisphere is playing some role
- 21:16SPEAKER_01: in certain kinds of emotions which are antithetical to depression.
- 21:21And one of the things that seemed to be the case is that these
- 21:25patients seem to be anhedonic.
- 21:28SPEAKER_01: They're not experiencing very much pleasure.
- 21:31SPEAKER_01: And that's the kind of depression that they're
- 21:34There are also clinical reports of patients with damage to
- 21:39their right hemisphere,
- 21:41SPEAKER_01: whose left hemisphere was intact,
- 21:44showing kind of inappropriate laughter and joy in weird
- 21:49situations where it
- 21:50SPEAKER_01: wouldn't be normative to do that.
- 21:54SPEAKER_01: And so
- 21:55That was just some very early clues that there may be some
- 21:59interesting emotional differences.
- 22:03SPEAKER_00: Just a quick question.
- 22:07SPEAKER_00: Was there any clarity about,
- 22:08SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 22:08there's kind of two different things when you think about
- 22:10positive emotions.
- 22:11SPEAKER_00: One is the occurrence of the emotions in the first place.
- 22:14And a second factor is your ability to sustain them and savor
- 22:17them,
- 22:18so to speak.
- 22:20Was there any clarity about whether it's one or the other or
- 22:22both of those?
- 22:24SPEAKER_01: No.
- 22:25SPEAKER_01: So,
- 22:26SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 22:26these were really early clinical impressions and these were all
- 22:31studies published
- 22:32SPEAKER_01: in journals that are journals of neurology where they're often,
- 22:39SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 22:40take essentially like eight cases of individuals with one kind
- 22:45of brain damage and
- 22:46compare them to eight cases with another kind of brain damage
- 22:49and they're sort of
- 22:50SPEAKER_01: clinical descriptions.
- 22:52SPEAKER_01: Very little
- 22:54objective testing so but this was I for some reason really got
- 22:59interested in this I
- 23:00you know became interested in emotion because it was so
- 23:03understudied and you know
- 23:06in those days all the research on the brain and emotion almost
- 23:10100% of it was done
- 23:11SPEAKER_01: in rats
- 23:15you know it was really kind of primitive emotion related work
- 23:20and it all focused on
- 23:23primarily the hypothalamus which is very important for kind of
- 23:29basic drives like
- 23:31SPEAKER_01: hunger sex the and the hypothalamus plays an important role in regulating
- 23:37SPEAKER_01: These basic drives that are clearly related to emotion,
- 23:43SPEAKER_01: but it's also clearly not the whole story.
- 23:45So it interested me that they were seeing these emotional
- 23:50reactions from people
- 23:51that had cortical damage that didn't involve any subcortical
- 23:56regions whatsoever.
- 23:57SPEAKER_01: And that was verified with MRI scans in these patients.
- 24:01Now it could be sort of downstream functional changes in these
- 24:05subcortical structures.
- 24:06SPEAKER_01: There probably was some of that,
- 24:08SPEAKER_01: but there wasn't any frank damage to these subcortical structures.
- 24:12SPEAKER_01: So that's what was really what got us interested in this.
- 24:18SPEAKER_01: And then, you know, I began to think about ways of framing this that are
- 24:24SPEAKER_01: theoretically meaningful.
- 24:26And one of the things,
- 24:27there are a few things about asymmetry that is important to
- 24:31know.
- 24:31SPEAKER_01: One is that asymmetries are not restricted to humans.
- 24:35SPEAKER_01: You see asymmetries in other species.
- 24:40SPEAKER_01: However,
- 24:41SPEAKER_01: given that language is pretty much,
- 24:45SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 24:45SPEAKER_01: with some exceptions for certain kinds of communication,
- 24:50SPEAKER_01: but nothing
- 24:51SPEAKER_01: nearly as sophisticated as human language.
- 24:54SPEAKER_01: I mean,
- 24:54every scientist would agree that there's no species whose
- 24:58communication system
- 24:59SPEAKER_01: remotely resembles the sophistication of human language.
- 25:03SPEAKER_01: There may be primitive kinds of communication,
- 25:06SPEAKER_01: and we know in birds,
- 25:08SPEAKER_01: birds' song is a mechanism of communication among birds,
- 25:13and there are sounds that other animals emit that are used
- 25:18functionally for
- 25:19SPEAKER_01: communicative purposes.
- 25:21SPEAKER_01: But again,
- 25:21SPEAKER_01: There's nothing, you know, remotely as sophisticated as human language.
- 25:26And so the fact that there were asymmetries in other species
- 25:31suggested that maybe
- 25:33SPEAKER_01: the asymmetries are not fundamentally tied to language,
- 25:38but they may be tied to other even more basic mechanisms and
- 25:42language may be a
- 25:43SPEAKER_01: component of those.
- 25:45but may not be the kind of evolutionary driver if you will and
- 25:50so we were searching
- 25:52for what may be you know an important evolutionary driver of
- 25:56this and there's a
- 25:58very famous and very obscure paper I mean it sounds strange for
- 26:03it to be famous and
- 26:04obscure at the same time but I think it's you know both of
- 26:09those terms are apt it
- 26:11SPEAKER_01: was published by a
- 26:14SPEAKER_00: It's like a cult classic of science or something.
- 26:16SPEAKER_01: Yes, exactly.
- 26:17SPEAKER_01: It was published by an ethologist by the name of Schneeler, S-C-H-N-E.
- 26:24SPEAKER_00: I don't even know what an ethologist is.
- 26:26SPEAKER_00: What's an ethologist?
- 26:27An ethologist studies the behavior of animals in their natural
- 26:33environments.
- 26:35SPEAKER_00: Okay.
- 26:37SPEAKER_00: Hopefully I'm not the only one who doesn't know what an ethologist is.
- 26:39SPEAKER_01: Yeah, and I believe that at the time that this paper appeared, Schneeler,
- 26:44was working and this is a place where a lot of very famous
- 26:48ethologists worked in
- 26:50SPEAKER_01: their time at the Museum of Natural History in New York City.
- 26:54And I'm a kid who was born in New York City and I used to spend
- 26:59weekends holding
- 27:02SPEAKER_01: myself up in the Museum of Natural History in Manhattan.
- 27:07SPEAKER_00: We should dig up some pictures of you and that would be great.
- 27:13SPEAKER_01: I loved this museum.
- 27:15SPEAKER_01: It was really a special place for me.
- 27:17SPEAKER_01: And there was a whole research wing associated with it.
- 27:22SPEAKER_01: I don't think that it's there anymore.
- 27:24But Margaret Mead,
- 27:26the very famous anthropologist,
- 27:28worked at the Museum of Natural History.
- 27:30SPEAKER_01: Gregory Bateson worked at the Museum of Natural History.
- 27:33SPEAKER_01: So some really famous people.
- 27:36SPEAKER_01: went through the Museum of Natural History in New York.
- 27:39SPEAKER_01: It was an iconic place for some period of time.
- 27:42So there was this paper published in 1959 in a very obscure
- 27:48place called the
- 27:49SPEAKER_01: Nebraska Symposium on Motivation.
- 27:52SPEAKER_01: And the title of the paper was something like
- 27:55approach withdrawal throughout phylogeny that's not the exact
- 27:59title but it's
- 28:00something like the title and what it did is it traced
- 28:05approaching avoidance be or
- 28:07approaching withdrawal behavior at every level of phylogeny
- 28:11even in single cell
- 28:13organisms so one of the claims that she makes is that if an
- 28:18organism behaves
- 28:20SPEAKER_01: If it shows any behavior, it will approach and withdraw.
- 28:25SPEAKER_01: That's the fundamental psychological decision,
- 28:29SPEAKER_01: if you will,
- 28:29SPEAKER_01: that an organism makes with respect to its environment.
- 28:34SPEAKER_00: This is what's framing it as like the most basic thing about life.
- 28:39SPEAKER_00: Yes, exactly.
- 28:41SPEAKER_00: Exactly.
- 28:43SPEAKER_00: I can see why both of those things are definitely true.
- 28:51SPEAKER_01: So in kind of a moment of loose but really creative insight,
- 28:57it occurred to me that asymmetry is a fundamental property of
- 29:02nervous systems.
- 29:05Approach and withdrawal are fundamental is a fundamental
- 29:09psychological decision if
- 29:10you will behavioral decision that organisms make maybe these
- 29:15are connected and
- 29:16maybe those observations in brain damaged patients about
- 29:21depression and euphoria
- 29:24SPEAKER_01: maybe they have something to do with this
- 29:26SPEAKER_00: Actually,
- 29:27SPEAKER_00: as a very quick footnote,
- 29:29it's so interesting because there's nothing like this
- 29:33sophistication of the
- 29:34SPEAKER_00: understanding of human biology that you find,
- 29:37SPEAKER_00: for example,
- 29:38SPEAKER_00: in Tibetan Buddhism.
- 29:40SPEAKER_00: But what you do have is a corresponding,
- 29:42incredibly sophisticated understanding of the mind and
- 29:45psychology and what they
- 29:47SPEAKER_00: call the subtle body.
- 29:49SPEAKER_00: And there an asymmetry is all over the place in the subtle body.
- 29:53SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 29:53there's all sorts of mappings to like the left and right kind
- 29:57of the movement of
- 29:58SPEAKER_00: energy,
- 29:59SPEAKER_00: especially,
- 30:00SPEAKER_00: and even the terms approach and avoidance are not useful.
- 30:03but attachment and aversion are used and and those you can very
- 30:07much see as kind of
- 30:08like the corollaries i mean it's very it's it's like this same
- 30:13mapping but on to
- 30:14like the this anatomy of the subtle energetic body for so
- 30:18anyways it just to say
- 30:19that there's a almost a perfect correlation yeah i love i love
- 30:23that and yeah i've
- 30:24thought about that too and um and you know their breathing
- 30:28practices that we do
- 30:30SPEAKER_01: there's you know you um
- 30:32um unilateral union uni nostril breathing that um that may
- 30:39differentially activate
- 30:41each hemisphere and there's there's actual research that's been
- 30:44done on that that
- 30:45may be for another time but uh all of this is to say that this
- 30:50was really the
- 30:51SPEAKER_01: beginning of a framing of a theory of brain asymmetry and its relation
- 30:58SPEAKER_01: to these fundamental dimensions of approach and withdrawal,
- 31:02SPEAKER_01: or we can say perhaps attachment and aversion.
- 31:07And just to locate this in time,
- 31:09is this like late 70s that you're now,
- 31:11is this happening?
- 31:12SPEAKER_00: When exactly is this, mid to late 70s?
- 31:15SPEAKER_01: It's the late 1970s, yeah.
- 31:19And for a variety of reasons,
- 31:22I thought that if more specifically these asymmetries might be
- 31:27SPEAKER_01: located in the prefrontal region.
- 31:29And there was another really iconic figure who played an
- 31:34important role in my very
- 31:36SPEAKER_01: early shaping of my thinking,
- 31:39SPEAKER_01: who is one of the greatest neuroanatomists of the 20th century.
- 31:44SPEAKER_01: His name was Wally Nauta, N-A-U-T-A.
- 31:48SPEAKER_01: There are stains that have been named after him, stains of brain cells.
- 31:52SPEAKER_01: He was at MIT at the time.
- 31:56SPEAKER_01: I was a graduate student at Harvard,
- 31:59and Harvard and MIT students are allowed to take courses in
- 32:04each other's places.
- 32:06SPEAKER_01: And everyone,
- 32:07SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 32:08SPEAKER_01: Geshwin told me,
- 32:09SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 32:09SPEAKER_01: I really need to take Wally Naughta's neuroanatomy class.
- 32:13SPEAKER_01: That's where I did the human brain dissection.
- 32:16Wally Nauta he was an extraordinary neuroanatomist but his
- 32:20specific area of focus
- 32:21was the was the neuroanatomy of the prefrontal cortex and he
- 32:27published a very
- 32:29another one of these famous and obscure papers and the title of
- 32:33it was the the
- 32:34SPEAKER_01: frontal lobes of reinterpretation
- 32:37and was published in a journal called the Journal of
- 32:39Psychiatric Research,
- 32:40SPEAKER_01: which is really not a high profile paper,
- 32:43SPEAKER_01: but I don't know how many citations that paper has.
- 32:46SPEAKER_01: I suspect it has a lot,
- 32:48but it's a paper where for the first time I ever read anyone
- 32:53speculating that the
- 32:55SPEAKER_01: prefrontal cortex actually has something to do with emotion,
- 33:00SPEAKER_01: not just with cognitive function.
- 33:02SPEAKER_01: Historically, the prefrontal cortex was
- 33:06SPEAKER_01: Dr.
- 33:06SPEAKER_01: Richard Davidson and Dr.
- 33:07SPEAKER_01: Richard Davidson and Dr.
- 33:08SPEAKER_01: Richard Davidson and Dr.
- 33:10SPEAKER_01: Richard Davidson and Dr.
- 33:12SPEAKER_00: Richard Davidson and Dr.
- 33:13SPEAKER_00: Richard Davidson
- 33:24Basically,
- 33:25there's really important historical reasons why that happened.
- 33:28SPEAKER_00: And it's had such massive implications to this day,
- 33:32SPEAKER_00: even to how we talk about the mind and experience.
- 33:36SPEAKER_00: And maybe just a little quick detour,
- 33:37SPEAKER_00: and then we can put a pin in it for like a whole episode later.
- 33:41SPEAKER_01: Yeah, definitely.
- 33:42SPEAKER_01: So just to put the pin in it,
- 33:45this is really a byproduct of a philosophical dogma that
- 33:53thought and feeling
- 33:54were separated in the mind and the brain that there's rational
- 33:58thought on the one
- 34:00hand and there's emotion and feeling on the other hand and the
- 34:04two really are
- 34:07independent and often at war with each other and kind of a
- 34:10popular imagination at
- 34:12SPEAKER_01: war with each other yeah yeah
- 34:17SPEAKER_00: So what you just said about the brain,
- 34:19SPEAKER_00: like to map that onto the brain,
- 34:20SPEAKER_00: that was probably a controversial,
- 34:22I would assume that was not part of the normal conception of
- 34:25the prefrontal cortex
- 34:27SPEAKER_00: because that was a quote-unquote like rational part of the brain.
- 34:30So to think of it as involved with emotion kind of goes against
- 34:32that orthodoxy.
- 34:34I should just mention that there's a psychologist by the name
- 34:39of Herbert Simon who
- 34:41SPEAKER_01: worked at Carnegie Mellon University
- 34:43who actually received a Nobel Prize in economics because he did
- 34:49work on decision
- 34:50SPEAKER_01: making that was relevant to economics.
- 34:53He's one of two psychologists,
- 34:55I believe,
- 34:56to receive the Nobel Prize in economics.
- 34:58SPEAKER_01: The second one was Daniel Kahneman.
- 35:01SPEAKER_01: Herb Simon received the Nobel Prize earlier.
- 35:04But Herb Simon lived in the era where the metaphor for the
- 35:08human mind was the computer,
- 35:10SPEAKER_01: And it was all about rule-based rational thinking in those days.
- 35:15SPEAKER_01: And I will never forget reading this piece by Herb Simon,
- 35:20where he basically talked about emotion as the thing in the
- 35:25mind that interferes
- 35:26SPEAKER_01: with
- 35:27rationality and is to be banished and you know and he was
- 35:32enamored with computers
- 35:34because computers don't have feelings and so they're the best
- 35:38model for pure
- 35:39rationality because they're unperturbed by feelings it just
- 35:43struck me that you know
- 35:45for someone who's clearly very smart this wasn't a particularly
- 35:52wise shall we say
- 35:54SPEAKER_01: viewpoint given the
- 35:56you know the the intuition conjecture i had about the role of
- 36:00emotion um so uh i
- 36:04SPEAKER_00: mean there's so many safe to say that neuroscientists at the time
- 36:08probably intuitively all believe that there were just separate
- 36:11regions or networks
- 36:13for emotion and separate for cognition and just never the twain
- 36:16shall meet kind of
- 36:17thinking was that twins met but only competitive i mean but
- 36:21they're different i
- 36:21mean clearly they need to or it was like one exerting control
- 36:25on the other and yeah
- 36:26SPEAKER_01: and they were antagonistic in some way yeah
- 36:29The idea that they can be working synergistically together was
- 36:33just not at all in
- 36:37SPEAKER_01: the lexicon or the imagination of these scientists in those days.
- 36:43SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 36:44SPEAKER_01: So,
- 36:45SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 36:45maybe this podcast will be part one of a multi-part series
- 36:50because I know we're
- 36:51SPEAKER_01: going to have to end soon.
- 36:53SPEAKER_01: But let me just,
- 36:54SPEAKER_01: in the few minutes we have remaining,
- 36:57SPEAKER_01: say a few more things,
- 36:59getting back to asymmetry and approach and withdrawal and how
- 37:05we began to look at
- 37:07SPEAKER_01: this.
- 37:07SPEAKER_01: So in these, in the days when we began
- 37:11The only way we had to interrogate the human brain
- 37:15noninvasively was with EEG,
- 37:21SPEAKER_01: with brain electrical activity,
- 37:23where we put electrodes on the scalp surface and we try to make
- 37:27inferences about
- 37:28SPEAKER_01: what's going on in the brain from this electrical activity.
- 37:32SPEAKER_01: This is a method that is completely safe.
- 37:35It's totally noninvasive and it's been around for a while and
- 37:39there have been
- 37:40very significant developments in the precision with which we're
- 37:45able to do this
- 37:46SPEAKER_01: with this sort of thing.
- 37:48So we began a series of studies where we recording the
- 37:53electrical activity of the
- 37:55SPEAKER_01: brain in these prefrontal regions
- 37:58and we were trying to activate emotions in people that were
- 38:05associated with with
- 38:07what we thought of as approach where they'd you know have the
- 38:12disposition to move
- 38:13toward something be attracted to something so liking wanting
- 38:19like motivational
- 38:21behavior well I guess motivational could be an avoidance
- 38:24motivation but like
- 38:26SPEAKER_01: Right, or the opposite.
- 38:31And one of the ways we did this is we thought that if this is
- 38:37really fundamental,
- 38:38SPEAKER_01: it should be present very early on in life.
- 38:42And so we did a series of studies in babies,
- 38:45including in newborn infants.
- 38:48And so you might ask,
- 38:50well,
- 38:50what do you do with a newborn infant to elicit these kind of
- 38:55emotional behaviors and it's actually pretty easy in newborn
- 38:58infants so what we did
- 38:59in newborn infants is we gave them a little squirt of sugar
- 39:03water which they loved
- 39:06and we gave them a squirt of basically lemon juice you can just
- 39:10imagine their faces
- 39:11all squishing up and we recorded their facial expression so we
- 39:15had it on video and
- 39:17you know we we got the insight to do that because Darwin
- 39:21Charles Darwin wrote a
- 39:23SPEAKER_01: book in 1865
- 39:25SPEAKER_01: called The Expression of Emotion in Man and Animals.
- 39:28SPEAKER_01: And he made the claim in that book based on,
- 39:31SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 39:32very limited sort of casual observation that these facial
- 39:37expressions of pleasure
- 39:39SPEAKER_01: and disgust were innate and they were present from birth.
- 39:43SPEAKER_01: And so we tried this and
- 39:46you know sure enough you can easily elicit these different you
- 39:52know in almost every
- 39:53single infant giving them a little spritz of sugar water versus
- 39:56lemon juice you see
- 39:57very clearly different facial responses this is you know 72
- 40:02hours after birth
- 40:05And we were recording the brain electrical activity and we see
- 40:09differences in
- 40:10SPEAKER_01: asymmetries in the way that we predicted in...
- 40:14Were there any individual differences in the asymmetry or is it
- 40:17pretty much just
- 40:18SPEAKER_00: baked into the structure and there's...
- 40:21SPEAKER_01: No, they're big individual differences.
- 40:25SPEAKER_01: And that turned out to be a very fruitful area of exploration,
- 40:30SPEAKER_01: which we can talk about at another time.
- 40:33SPEAKER_01: But for the purposes now,
- 40:35SPEAKER_01: to just say that people differ in their asymmetry at baseline,
- 40:41SPEAKER_01: before you do anything.
- 40:43And people who have greater left-sided prefrontal activation
- 40:48tend to be people who
- 40:51SPEAKER_01: we think of as more approach-oriented people.
- 40:56They're people who tend to be more optimistic and who have this
- 41:02quality of what we
- 41:03SPEAKER_01: would say is more behavioral activation.
- 41:06SPEAKER_01: They're sort of ready to go when the opportunity presents itself.
- 41:10SPEAKER_01: And people who had more activation
- 41:13um in the same regions in the right hemisphere on average were
- 41:18more avoidant uh and
- 41:21they tend to be more shy for example i mean you can imagine
- 41:25studying this and you
- 41:26know in rats and animals you'd like ones that are kind of in
- 41:29the corner of the cage
- 41:30versus the ones that are running around and exploring
- 41:32everything probably very easy
- 41:34SPEAKER_00: to measure that
- 41:35SPEAKER_01: Exactly, exactly.
- 41:37SPEAKER_01: So, I mean, we didn't do that.
- 41:40SPEAKER_01: The work that we did was with humans,
- 41:44but it was easy to see these things early on in life with these
- 41:49simple kinds of
- 41:51stimuli that we can safely present to newborn infants or babies
- 41:57within the first
- 41:57SPEAKER_01: year of life.
- 42:00SPEAKER_00: I wonder,
- 42:01SPEAKER_00: I mean,
- 42:01I think there's like 10 more discussions that are going to spin
- 42:04off on this one.
- 42:05SPEAKER_00: I wonder if just to end here,
- 42:07just this current chapter of what I think will hopefully become
- 42:10a whole book.
- 42:12What what do you think are the kind of the take home messages
- 42:15aside from just it's
- 42:15kind of interesting to learn about the brain but you were also
- 42:18a meditator at this
- 42:19time I imagine you were learning things about your own mind in
- 42:23your life and and
- 42:24and insights that actually helped you or were interesting are
- 42:28there what for you
- 42:29are kind of the key take homes for like actually this is
- 42:31helpful for us to know
- 42:32SPEAKER_00: this so that we can navigate our own inner train more effectively
- 42:37SPEAKER_01: Yeah,
- 42:38SPEAKER_01: so there are lots of things to share,
- 42:41but let me just focus on one that led to a very concrete
- 42:48project that culminated in
- 42:51SPEAKER_01: an important publication,
- 42:52SPEAKER_01: not necessarily my best scientific publication,
- 42:56SPEAKER_01: but it is the most highly cited scientific publication that I have.
- 43:01SPEAKER_01: And it was a paper that was published in 2003.
- 43:08SPEAKER_01: And to the best of our knowledge,
- 43:11it is the first randomized controlled trial of
- 43:15mindfulness-based stress reduction
- 43:17SPEAKER_01: that had ever been done.
- 43:19SPEAKER_01: Mindfulness-based stress reduction was developed by Jon Kabat-Zinn.
- 43:24SPEAKER_01: We had Jon Kabat-Zinn on an earlier episode of Dharma Lab.
- 43:29SPEAKER_01: And Jon developed this as an eight-week intervention to give people
- 43:35some initial training in basic awareness practices primarily
- 43:40one of the things that
- 43:41was convenient about mindfulness based stress reduction is that
- 43:47it's taught at
- 43:48virtually every academic medical center and so it's it's very
- 43:53commonly available
- 43:55and so we studied MBSR as it's known in a group of very
- 44:00stressed employees at a
- 44:01SPEAKER_01: tech company in Madison Wisconsin and
- 44:05What we did is we brought them into the lab before and after
- 44:09they went through this
- 44:10SPEAKER_01: eight week program.
- 44:11SPEAKER_01: And one of the things that we measured is the asymmetry in their brain.
- 44:16SPEAKER_01: And we measured this because we thought,
- 44:18SPEAKER_01: wow,
- 44:19if people are more kind of optimistic and have this more
- 44:25approach orientation,
- 44:27SPEAKER_01: maybe in these beginning meditators,
- 44:31there would be a shift toward more left-sided activation with
- 44:36this training.
- 44:38SPEAKER_01: And we also happened in this particular study
- 44:43SPEAKER_01: to the study started in the beginning of September.
- 44:47SPEAKER_01: And remember, it was an eight week intervention.
- 44:50SPEAKER_01: So the intervention finished right around Thanksgiving time.
- 44:54SPEAKER_01: And in the US around this time in November is a time when
- 45:01people traditionally get flu shots if they can get a flu shot
- 45:06and a flu vaccine and
- 45:09we gave we told people at before the study that they shouldn't
- 45:14get a flu vaccine
- 45:16we're going to give them a flu vaccine ourselves at the end of
- 45:20the study which is
- 45:21SPEAKER_01: the normal time you would get such a vaccine but we would do it a little
- 45:26SPEAKER_01: differently than if they were getting the vaccine in pharmacy or
- 45:30from their local doctor because we take blood samples before
- 45:34and after the vaccine,
- 45:35which allows us to quantitatively determine the magnitude of
- 45:42antibody titers to the
- 45:45SPEAKER_01: vaccine,
- 45:45SPEAKER_01: which basically tells us how effective the vaccine is working.
- 45:49And we hypothesized that maybe people who go through this
- 45:53meditation training would
- 45:55SPEAKER_01: show a more robust response to the vaccine.
- 45:58SPEAKER_01: So what we found in this study is that yes,
- 46:02people did show a greater increase in left-sided activation
- 46:09over the course of
- 46:10SPEAKER_01: training.
- 46:11SPEAKER_01: And they also showed
- 46:13a more robust response to the flu vaccine compared to untreated
- 46:18controls.
- 46:19So these were really novel findings at the time they were
- 46:24reported in 2003,
- 46:26SPEAKER_01: which is the primary reason why this paper has such high citations,
- 46:33SPEAKER_01: not because it's a particularly great paper in terms of its methodology,
- 46:39it's limited it's we didn't have that many participants and
- 46:43there are limitations
- 46:44to what we did it was it was just the first study of its kind
- 46:48and there's a lot to
- 46:49say though about asymmetry and let me just conclude with a kind
- 46:57of puzzle and just
- 46:59SPEAKER_01: to give you a sense for why this work really hasn't continued
- 47:04SPEAKER_01: Why we're not continuing to do this work to any significant degree.
- 47:08We measured the brain electrical activity of very long term
- 47:13practitioners who have
- 47:14SPEAKER_01: been meditating,
- 47:15SPEAKER_01: you know,
- 47:16SPEAKER_01: for decades and who have tens of thousands of hours of practice.
- 47:21SPEAKER_01: and they don't show extreme left prefrontal activation.
- 47:26SPEAKER_01: And so it's not so simple.
- 47:28And this began to raise all kinds of questions for us about
- 47:34what this metric is
- 47:36SPEAKER_01: actually reflecting.
- 47:37SPEAKER_01: It's clearly reflecting something
- 47:40SPEAKER_01: It's reflecting something interesting.
- 47:42SPEAKER_01: It seems to be associated with these early stages of meditation practice.
- 47:47SPEAKER_01: But just as with other kinds of measures,
- 47:51SPEAKER_01: there may be a kind of U-shaped,
- 47:53SPEAKER_01: inverted U-shaped function.
- 47:54SPEAKER_01: And it's clearly much more complicated than we originally thought.
- 48:00SPEAKER_01: Also,
- 48:00we thought about this a lot in terms of approach and withdrawal
- 48:04and positive and
- 48:05SPEAKER_01: negative emotion.
- 48:06And one of the things that a deeper reflection in Buddhist
- 48:12psychology leads us to
- 48:13believe is that maybe the way we're parsing the emotion domain
- 48:19is very imperfect.
- 48:24SPEAKER_01: And there may be better ways of parsing this one dimension which
- 48:30comes more from the Buddhist framework that may be really a
- 48:34better way of thinking
- 48:35SPEAKER_01: about this is emotions that may be virtuous or unvirtuous.
- 48:41That is emotions that lead us toward increased kind of
- 48:47awareness and connection and
- 48:49SPEAKER_01: insight and purpose or emotions that may
- 48:53SPEAKER_01: detract from that.
- 48:55SPEAKER_01: And so this gives it much more nuance and complexity.
- 49:01And it became clear to us that it was necessary to take this
- 49:06complexity into account.
- 49:09SPEAKER_01: And so it's led to a much richer and more elaborated kind of framework.
- 49:17SPEAKER_00: Wow.
- 49:17SPEAKER_00: Well, I think we just mapped out like 10 future Dharma Lab episodes.
- 49:24SPEAKER_00: This is fantastic.
- 49:25SPEAKER_00: Thank you so much, Richie.
- 49:26SPEAKER_00: I must say,
- 49:27SPEAKER_00: you know,
- 49:27SPEAKER_00: for everybody listening,
- 49:28SPEAKER_00: I've been wanting to do this for so long,
- 49:31just kind of geek out on some of these questions and these
- 49:35lines of research
- 49:36SPEAKER_00: because they're just so fascinating.
- 49:37SPEAKER_00: There's so many implications.
- 49:38SPEAKER_00: Actually, I still have so many
- 49:39more questions now that i began with um i especially want to go
- 49:42to the 1990s when
- 49:44asymmetry kind of caught the popular imagination remember there
- 49:47was like books like
- 49:49writing from the left side of the you know there's all this
- 49:51like left brain right
- 49:52brain thing i would love to just hear like how what you i mean
- 49:55because having been
- 49:56like one of the the pioneers of that whole field and then it
- 49:59suddenly caught fire
- 50:01SPEAKER_00: in probably a way that i would guess
- 50:03SPEAKER_00: was misrepresenting and oversimplifying things.
- 50:06SPEAKER_00: But anyways, that's a whole nother episode.
- 50:07SPEAKER_00: There's many little rabbit holes we could go down.
- 50:10SPEAKER_00: So I just want to thank you, Richie.
- 50:11SPEAKER_00: This is fantastic.
- 50:13SPEAKER_00: I look forward to many future conversations and for everybody listening.
- 50:16SPEAKER_00: Thank you for tuning in.
- 50:18And I can promise that this will not be the last conversation
- 50:22that we have here of this kind.
- 50:23SPEAKER_00: So take care and see you soon.
- 50:26SPEAKER_00: Thank you.