Latest / Bloomberg Law / US Crackdown on Sanctions Cheats Turning to Art Works
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 1: We're gonna start with a friend of Harris who's going
- 0:12Speaker 1: to have some idea where the French art has been hidden.
- 0:14Speaker 1: How can I hope who was still stolen? Not the
- 0:18Speaker 1: Nazis are taken everything with him. So we have to
- 0:20Speaker 1: get as close to the front as we can. Look
- 0:23Speaker 1: at this. That says if Hitler dies or if Germany falls,
- 0:26Speaker 1: there to destroy everything everything. Toward the end of World
- 0:30Speaker 1: War Two, an army unit nicknamed the monuments Men race
- 0:34Speaker 1: to track down and recover priceless artwork stolen by the
- 0:38Speaker 1: Nazis before it could be destroyed or moved. The movie
- 0:41Speaker 1: aptlete titled The monuments Men, is based on their recovery
- 0:45Speaker 1: of more than five million works of art. It may
- 0:48Speaker 1: not be as dramatic as going into a war zone,
- 0:51Speaker 1: but today federal prosecutors in New York, known as the
- 0:54Speaker 1: Klepto Captured Task Force, are working to track down and
- 0:57Speaker 1: sees artworks boad or sold by Russian oligarchs as long
- 1:01Speaker 1: as ten years ago, even targeting specific works of art
- 1:05Speaker 1: like Mornes Lebasan on Nefia and serving subpoenas on high
- 1:09Speaker 1: end auction houses. The goal is to get the assets
- 1:12Speaker 1: before they can be moved to another jurisdiction. Joining me
- 1:15Speaker 1: is Bloomberg Legal reporter Eva Benny Morrison. Eva tell us
- 1:19Speaker 1: how the US expanded sanctions targeting Russian businessmen since the
- 1:25Speaker 1: invasion of Ukraine last year. Since the invasion of Ukraine,
- 1:29Speaker 1: and the US government has expanded the number of individuals
- 1:32Speaker 1: that are on the sanctions list, and this was to
- 1:36Speaker 1: put a lot of pressure on Russia and in protests
- 1:39Speaker 1: in opposition to what they were doing in Ukraine. The
- 1:42Speaker 1: US was targeting businessmen and their companies who had ties trutin.
- 1:48Speaker 1: Number of these businessmen multi billionaires. They have an interest
- 1:51Speaker 1: in the final things my real estate, artwork, yachts, cars,
- 1:56Speaker 1: and all the rest of those things. And some of
- 1:57Speaker 1: those assets have been contained and brought old traders in
- 2:00Speaker 1: the US. So it's definitely impacted some of those items.
- 2:04Speaker 1: So what are federal prosecutors looking into specifically with these
- 2:10Speaker 1: works of art and all the rest of it. The
- 2:12Speaker 1: US has had sanctions with for a long time, but
- 2:14Speaker 1: there seems to be a real laser focus at the
- 2:18Speaker 1: moment on figuring out if any of those sanctions are
- 2:22Speaker 1: being violated for federal prosecutors attached to this relatively new
- 2:27Speaker 1: task force called Clepto Capture trying to track down assets
- 2:31Speaker 1: like artwork and Middle States that was bought and sold
- 2:35Speaker 1: by Russian oligarchs anywhere from five to ten years ago.
- 2:39Speaker 1: We've seen this focus in the art world. Recently, what's
- 2:42Speaker 1: been happening is prosecutors are sending subpoenas to some of
- 2:46Speaker 1: the major auction houses based in New York asking for
- 2:49Speaker 1: any information to do with transactions with Russian oligarchs or
- 2:54Speaker 1: with any shell companies that are known to be associated
- 2:58Speaker 1: with those individuals. And over the past twelve to eighteen months,
- 3:02Speaker 1: those inquiries have narrowed, so rather than just seeing prosecutors
- 3:07Speaker 1: are asking for information about particular individuals Oleg Dairy, Pasca,
- 3:12Speaker 1: Roman and Bromovich and a few other very well known
- 3:15Speaker 1: Russian oligarchs, they're also asking for specific pieces of artwork,
- 3:20Speaker 1: So that suggests that they've got some sort of intel
- 3:22Speaker 1: about particular works that were bought and sold by these
- 3:26Speaker 1: individuals or by companies linked to them. We've seen offshore
- 3:30Speaker 1: as well. There's been a yacht owned by a Russian
- 3:35Speaker 1: olgark that has been frozen off the coast of Spain,
- 3:39Speaker 1: another one in the South Pacific, and there's also been
- 3:42Speaker 1: real estate in d C and here in New York
- 3:45Speaker 1: City that's been rated by the FBI is part of
- 3:48Speaker 1: these investigations. Prosecutors alleged that these two properties in particular
- 3:53Speaker 1: are linked to Russian billionaire by the name of ol
- 3:56Speaker 1: Dairy Pasca. So the Department of Justice has indicated recently
- 4:00Speaker 1: that they're planning to commence civil forfeiture proceedings against those properties.
- 4:06Speaker 1: So are they not only looking at sanctions violations? Are
- 4:09Speaker 1: they also looking at possible money laundering? Yes, the two
- 4:13Speaker 1: sort of go hand in hand, I guess because some
- 4:16Speaker 1: of the allegations in these types of cases usually are
- 4:19Speaker 1: based around the fact that these assets like artwork, property, yachts,
- 4:24Speaker 1: were obtained through ill gotten games, so that ties into
- 4:29Speaker 1: the offense of money laundering. It can be very difficult
- 4:32Speaker 1: to prosecute these sanctions cases, but that is definitely one
- 4:37Speaker 1: line of inquiry that prosecutors are going down, and a
- 4:41Speaker 1: bit of an associators avenue. I guess that they're looking
- 4:44Speaker 1: at is the facilitators who exist around these oligarchs. We
- 4:48Speaker 1: saw recently in the past couple of weeks there were
- 4:51Speaker 1: a couple of associates allegedly tied to that same oligarch
- 4:55Speaker 1: I mentioned earlier Oleg dairy Pasca, who are accused of
- 4:59Speaker 1: money laundering and helping that oligarch of aide transaction. As
- 5:03Speaker 1: you said that these sanctions cases are difficult to prosecute
- 5:07Speaker 1: why a lot of these individuals are based offshore to
- 5:11Speaker 1: start with, and secondly, it's not as easy as one
- 5:15Speaker 1: of certain's best friends or his lawyer or his banker
- 5:19Speaker 1: walking into an art gallery in Chelsea and buying a
- 5:23Speaker 1: magnificent piece of artwork. A lot of these transactions are
- 5:27Speaker 1: done through shell companies, relatives, names have been used in
- 5:32Speaker 1: the past to purchase these kinds of assets, so it
- 5:35Speaker 1: takes a very long time to sort of pick apart
- 5:38Speaker 1: the web of corporate structures and other obscurities to try
- 5:41Speaker 1: and figure out who the ultimate beneficial owner is of
- 5:45Speaker 1: a particular assets. And one of the defenses that has
- 5:48Speaker 1: been thrown up before from some of these oligarchs is
- 5:51Speaker 1: all that property, all that asset is owned by a
- 5:54Speaker 1: relative or a family member. It's not owned by may
- 5:57Speaker 1: So that's why it can be particularly difficult to sort
- 6:00Speaker 1: of way through all those complexities and jump over all
- 6:04Speaker 1: those legal barricades. There are some very famous artworks involved here.
- 6:09Speaker 1: When you mentioned your story, bought by fertilizer tycoon Andre
- 6:13Speaker 1: Melnichenko was a mone that he paid apparently almost fifty
- 6:19Speaker 1: million dollars for. So are they looking to prevent them
- 6:23Speaker 1: from being moved? Are they looking to seize these so
- 6:25Speaker 1: that they can stop any movement. Yes, they're going back
- 6:29Speaker 1: and looking at artwork that these oligarchs had bought or
- 6:33Speaker 1: sold many years ago and trying to figure out where
- 6:36Speaker 1: they are now. Prosecutors are going back through years and
- 6:39Speaker 1: years of records figure out whether artworks previously bought and
- 6:43Speaker 1: sold by Russian oligarchs who are now in the sanctions
- 6:46Speaker 1: list have been moved out of the country. If they
- 6:48Speaker 1: have in the past twelve months from after the most
- 6:51Speaker 1: recent round of sanctions, or even the individuals who Room
- 6:53Speaker 1: of Sanctions listens to doesn't eighteen, that would be a
- 6:56Speaker 1: violation of those sanctions. Who are trying to figure out
- 6:59Speaker 1: where those work are, if they have been moved out
- 7:02Speaker 1: of the country, how long ago they were moved out
- 7:03Speaker 1: of the country, how they got out, whose names that
- 7:06Speaker 1: they were shipped out of as well. You know a
- 7:09Speaker 1: number of these oliser, their taste for art and their
- 7:12Speaker 1: interest in art has been very well documented. And we're
- 7:15Speaker 1: talking pieces worth millions and millions and millions of dollars.
- 7:18Speaker 1: So it's been very interesting, I guess the prosecutors to
- 7:22Speaker 1: try and figure out where some of these artworks are.
- 7:25Speaker 1: And there's a recent case actually where one of the
- 7:28Speaker 1: oliser had bought more than a dozen pieces of artwork
- 7:31Speaker 1: in two thousand and eight and they just sat in
- 7:33Speaker 1: a storage facility in New York until two thousand and
- 7:37Speaker 1: eighteen nineteen, when someone who worked for him tried to
- 7:40Speaker 1: have him set out of the country. Yeah, and that
- 7:43Speaker 1: man has been indicted, Graham Bottom Carter, and he's fighting extradition,
- 7:49Speaker 1: that's right. He's based in the UK, Graham Bottom Carter,
- 7:53Speaker 1: and he was working for over Dairy Pasca, and the
- 7:57Speaker 1: prosecutors alleged that while he was based in the UK,
- 8:00Speaker 1: he contacted an auction house in New York and tried
- 8:05Speaker 1: to pass off Derry Pasker's artworks as his own. He
- 8:08Speaker 1: tried to have them shipped from the auction house in
- 8:10Speaker 1: New York to London, which would have been a clear
- 8:14Speaker 1: violation of trade sanctions, but it was actually the auction
- 8:17Speaker 1: house that raised red flag in the first place. They
- 8:20Speaker 1: went through their records and saw that the artworks had
- 8:23Speaker 1: actually been purchased from under the name of a shell
- 8:25Speaker 1: company which was linked to Derry Paska more than ten
- 8:28Speaker 1: years ago. And they challenged Graham Bonham Carter around this,
- 8:32Speaker 1: and he tried to push back. He said, just give
- 8:34Speaker 1: me a little bit more time and I'll come up
- 8:36Speaker 1: with some proof to show that it is mine. And
- 8:38Speaker 1: he's my credit card statement showing that I'm paying for
- 8:41Speaker 1: the shipping. But it just wasn't enough to convince the
- 8:44Speaker 1: auction house that the artworks were in fact his, and
- 8:47Speaker 1: they ended up reporting it to OSPAK, which is a
- 8:50Speaker 1: part of the Treasury Department in the US that looks
- 8:53Speaker 1: after the sanctions. So have all the major auction houses
- 8:56Speaker 1: cooperated with subpoenas and quest for information. When I went
- 9:02Speaker 1: to the auction houses last week as part of this reporting,
- 9:05Speaker 1: most of them said that yes, we do corporate with
- 9:07Speaker 1: law enforcement when they ask, and from what I heard
- 9:10Speaker 1: from talking to different sources and the industry and legal
- 9:13Speaker 1: sources as well, they do hand over the information when
- 9:16Speaker 1: prosecutors are asking for it. It's not good for business
- 9:19Speaker 1: to be violating trade sanctions. It comes with massive fines,
- 9:23Speaker 1: and it was already a lot of attention on the
- 9:25Speaker 1: art world. In particular, there was a Senate report in
- 9:28Speaker 1: two thousand and twenty that looked at money laundering in
- 9:31Speaker 1: the art world, and it highlighted a very high profile
- 9:35Speaker 1: example where two brothers from Russia, the Rottenberg's, very wealthy individuals,
- 9:40Speaker 1: managed to evade trade sanctions and purchase some pieces of
- 9:43Speaker 1: artwork from US based auction houses by using a shell company.
- 9:48Speaker 1: Ever since then that the industry has really made an
- 9:51Speaker 1: effort to implement their own compliance programs, even though that
- 9:55Speaker 1: it's not legislated by law, to try and make sure
- 9:58Speaker 1: that won't happen again, and because it really gives some
- 10:02Speaker 1: of parts of the industry and the auction houses a
- 10:04Speaker 1: bad name, and they definitely don't want that. So eva
- 10:07Speaker 1: despite the major auction houses implementing voluntary anti money laundering
- 10:12Speaker 1: programs and even some including in contracts that the buyer
- 10:15Speaker 1: or seller not be sanctioned or engaged in criminal activity,
- 10:20Speaker 1: it still may not be enough to prevent the true
- 10:23Speaker 1: owners of artworks from shielding themselves behind these webs of
- 10:28Speaker 1: corporate structures or relatives exactly, and there's not a huge
- 10:34Speaker 1: legal requirements on auction houses to dig very deep to
- 10:38Speaker 1: try and figure out who the ultimate beneficial owner of
- 10:41Speaker 1: an artwork is. One of the big debates that were
- 10:45Speaker 1: sparked by report was whether the art industry should be
- 10:50Speaker 1: subject to the same banking and financial regulation requirements as
- 10:55Speaker 1: the rest of the financial industry. So that would be
- 10:57Speaker 1: the same as some of the big banks and the
- 11:00Speaker 1: art industry. Different auction houses private sellers would have to
- 11:04Speaker 1: create money laundering programs which are very time intensive, cost intensive,
- 11:10Speaker 1: and it would impose a lot especially on some of
- 11:13Speaker 1: those smaller sellers which don't have the same resources as
- 11:16Speaker 1: the big financial institutions. That hasn't happened yet, so you know,
- 11:20Speaker 1: some of the big auction houses say that they make
- 11:24Speaker 1: a concerted effort to try and figure out who the
- 11:26Speaker 1: ultimate beneficial lineries of the piece of artwork, To go
- 11:30Speaker 1: and figure out who owns the company that pursues in
- 11:33Speaker 1: the artwork. They don't want to miss any red flags.
- 11:35Speaker 1: But they're doing that voluntarily. It's not a legal requirement,
- 11:39Speaker 1: so there are still some details that can fall through
- 11:42Speaker 1: the cracks. I spoke to one attorney who put it
- 11:45Speaker 1: very accurately when he said, it's not like Putain's banker
- 11:48Speaker 1: is going to walk into an art gallery on Madison
- 11:51Speaker 1: Avenue and by a percsper Is there any estimate about
- 11:54Speaker 1: how many millions or tens of millions or hundreds of
- 11:58Speaker 1: millions of dollars of art work are involved. That's a
- 12:02Speaker 1: really good question, not that I've seen, to be honest,
- 12:05Speaker 1: from the interviews that I did from this reporting, it
- 12:08Speaker 1: seemed as if prosecutors were sort of just starting to
- 12:11Speaker 1: figure out who owned what, and they were starting to
- 12:15Speaker 1: name different pieces of artwork and different scupoenas they were
- 12:17Speaker 1: setting to the auction houses so they might start to
- 12:20Speaker 1: get a better picture, I guess of how much artwork
- 12:24Speaker 1: is left in the US that is actually owned by
- 12:27Speaker 1: some of these sanctioned individuals. Just reminds me in some
- 12:30Speaker 1: ways of the monuments men who tracked down Nazi stolen
- 12:34Speaker 1: art in World War Two. And it's interesting this same U. S.
- 12:38Speaker 1: Attorney's Office in the Southern District of New York has
- 12:41Speaker 1: had a few successful investigations in seizing artwork that was
- 12:46Speaker 1: stolen by the Nazis two and they've used the same
- 12:51Speaker 1: proceedings and sort of the same approach I guess in
- 12:53Speaker 1: these cases civil asset forfeiture. Sort of interesting to see
- 12:56Speaker 1: whether they have the same results. Here. There is one
- 13:00Speaker 1: interesting example when you asked me about whether they're looking
- 13:02Speaker 1: at money laundering. One of the individuals who was named
- 13:05Speaker 1: in the subpoenas was Roman and Bromovich, who's one of
- 13:09Speaker 1: the more well known Russian oligarchs who used to own
- 13:12Speaker 1: the football team in Chelsea. He's actually not sanctioned in
- 13:16Speaker 1: the US, unlike the others who are named the subpoenas,
- 13:18Speaker 1: and Bromovich is sanctioned in the UK, which I thought
- 13:22Speaker 1: was interesting because it wouldn't be as simple as looking
- 13:26Speaker 1: at him the trade sanctions violations in the US. And
- 13:29Speaker 1: when I asked a few different attorneys about these and
- 13:31Speaker 1: who practiced in this space, they said that because he
- 13:34Speaker 1: is sanctioned in the UK, prosecutors could be looking at
- 13:37Speaker 1: whether he is trying to get around those sanctions and
- 13:41Speaker 1: use the US financial system, which would be through a
- 13:44Speaker 1: form of money laundering. So I think that's a pretty
- 13:47Speaker 1: key example as well. That's how prosecutors are looking at
- 13:51Speaker 1: trade sanctions violations as a whole money laundering definitely comes
- 13:55Speaker 1: under that. It's a great story. I know a lot
- 13:58Speaker 1: of research went into it. Thanks so much, Ava. That's
- 14:00Speaker 1: Bloomberg Legal reporter Ava Benny Morrison. Elon Musk is building
- 14:06Speaker 1: on his teflon Elon Street cred winning a case in
- 14:10Speaker 1: which it seemed like the odds were stacked against him.
- 14:13Speaker 1: Investors claimed that Musk defraunded them when he tweeted four
- 14:16Speaker 1: and a half years ago that he was considering taking
- 14:19Speaker 1: Tesla private and had funding secured to make the deal happen.
- 14:24Speaker 1: It was a risky trial that many high profile executives
- 14:27Speaker 1: would have avoided by reaching an out of court settlement,
- 14:30Speaker 1: and Musk could have been on the hook for billions,
- 14:33Speaker 1: but he escaped unscathed. After a three week trial in
- 14:37Speaker 1: which Musk was the star witness, the jury found after
- 14:41Speaker 1: just two hours of deliberations that he was not liable
- 14:44Speaker 1: for investors losses. My guest is business law expert Eric Tallely,
- 14:48Speaker 1: a professor at Columbia Law School. A jury in San
- 14:52Speaker 1: Francisco took just two hours to clear Musk, despite the
- 14:57Speaker 1: judge having decided that the funding secured tweet was false,
- 15:02Speaker 1: despite testimony showing that Musk bankers had barely been consulted,
- 15:07Speaker 1: and even a week after the treat they were still
- 15:10Speaker 1: working out how the deal would be structured and who
- 15:13Speaker 1: would pay for it. So Musk got away from a
- 15:16Speaker 1: jury verdict against him. Again, maybe you got away with it,
- 15:20Speaker 1: but I realized that there is definitely a set of
- 15:22Speaker 1: ground rules to bring one of these simple suits. You
- 15:25Speaker 1: can't just rest on your laurels with a you know,
- 15:29Speaker 1: definitely a beneficial for the plaintiffs finding that thes this
- 15:32Speaker 1: was a false and inaccurate tweet that he said there
- 15:36Speaker 1: are more ingredients, and that's what the plaintiffs we're going
- 15:38Speaker 1: to have to contend with here. There are probably two
- 15:41Speaker 1: major issues that contributed to the outcome, and possibly some more,
- 15:46Speaker 1: but you know, one of them I think was just
- 15:48Speaker 1: that there really was a sense that the jury kind
- 15:52Speaker 1: of had to, you know, figure out the compared to
- 15:56Speaker 1: what story right, If Musk's tweet the funding was secured
- 16:00Speaker 1: was incorrect, well, what would it have looked like had
- 16:04Speaker 1: it been absolutely correct? And there it seems to me
- 16:08Speaker 1: his his legal team did a good job of saying,
- 16:10Speaker 1: you know, at the time, everyone thought Elon Musk could
- 16:14Speaker 1: move mountains. So even if he had tweeded out funding
- 16:18Speaker 1: kind of close to secured, and I'm still working out
- 16:20Speaker 1: some of the details, but I'm pretty sure this is
- 16:22Speaker 1: going to happen. Maybe at the time, that kind of
- 16:26Speaker 1: is taken by just about everyone as being the rough
- 16:28Speaker 1: equivalent of funding secured, and that mattered, and matters generally
- 16:33Speaker 1: for defendants because if the nature of the misstatement, even
- 16:37Speaker 1: if it was clearly a misstatement, if the nature of
- 16:40Speaker 1: it isn't big enough to be really, really material or
- 16:44Speaker 1: to have caused any any losses, the market reaction would
- 16:48Speaker 1: have been exactly the same even if he had said
- 16:52Speaker 1: accurately where he was in this process. That is a
- 16:56Speaker 1: definitely ironclad defense to a securities lawsuit, and that seems
- 17:01Speaker 1: to be something that the defense did very effectively here.
- 17:04Speaker 1: The second factor has to do a little bit with
- 17:07Speaker 1: um how you present facts to a jury. This was
- 17:12Speaker 1: never going to be the easiest lift for the plaintiff
- 17:15Speaker 1: class in this case, in large part because it not
- 17:18Speaker 1: only involved getting to understand how these relatively complex securities
- 17:23Speaker 1: markets work, but also different plaintiffs that were part of
- 17:27Speaker 1: the plaintiff class. They had different positions in the stocks,
- 17:31Speaker 1: some of them, you know, we're buying the underlying stock.
- 17:33Speaker 1: Some of them had options positions, those themselves can be
- 17:38Speaker 1: horribly complex to try to work through, and the approach
- 17:41Speaker 1: in this case was to handle both liability and remedy
- 17:46Speaker 1: at the same time. So the sheet that the jury
- 17:49Speaker 1: was given on remedy almost looked like a math like
- 17:52Speaker 1: a high school math test, and they had to, you know,
- 17:55Speaker 1: go through month by months to try to figure out
- 17:57Speaker 1: how much that our day by day that the stock
- 18:00Speaker 1: of overpriced and so forth. And there's one quick way
- 18:04Speaker 1: to not have to do any of that math, which
- 18:06Speaker 1: is to say, I don't think the plaintiffs made their
- 18:08Speaker 1: case on the basis of liability, and therefore filling out
- 18:12Speaker 1: the rest of the math quiz is not necessary. That's
- 18:15Speaker 1: always a challenge in these cases. It's probably you know,
- 18:17Speaker 1: the big Roulette wheel spin of what's going to happen
- 18:21Speaker 1: in a damages phase of the trial is something that
- 18:23Speaker 1: both sides find hard to predict. And so this was
- 18:26Speaker 1: one of these cases where we just didn't see that
- 18:29Speaker 1: many cases that go all the way to litigation. This jury,
- 18:33Speaker 1: you know, felt evidently comfortable enough in their conclusion that
- 18:36Speaker 1: there just hadn't been enough in there to show liability
- 18:40Speaker 1: that they were able to conclude, much to their relief,
- 18:43Speaker 1: no doubt that they didn't have to then start engaging
- 18:46Speaker 1: in computations related to damages. So the format of the
- 18:49Speaker 1: jury said the case against Musk was disorganized, he wasn't
- 18:54Speaker 1: sure what the plaintiffs were driving at, and the lawsuits
- 18:57Speaker 1: seemed to be relying on just the tweets. He said
- 19:00Speaker 1: that Musk's lawyers did a better job of showing that
- 19:04Speaker 1: Musk was presenting what he believed to be true and
- 19:07Speaker 1: was acting as a genuine bidder for the going private transaction.
- 19:11Speaker 1: Did Musk just mesmerize the jury? I think there's probably
- 19:15Speaker 1: always a possibility that Musk has mesmerized someone in a
- 19:19Speaker 1: jury pool or a general investing public. He still has
- 19:23Speaker 1: some of that gravity defying power that Bloom is definitely
- 19:27Speaker 1: at least partially off the rows. Over the last six months,
- 19:30Speaker 1: and in fact, Musk's team themselves had moved to try
- 19:34Speaker 1: to relocate the trial to Texas under the theory that
- 19:37Speaker 1: he couldn't get a fair trial in the Bear That
- 19:39Speaker 1: never happened. Um, But you know, I think that was
- 19:42Speaker 1: in part an acknowledgement of the fact that the number
- 19:45Speaker 1: of folks out there that are willing to, you know,
- 19:48Speaker 1: effectively take it on faith whenever Elon Musk utters something
- 19:52Speaker 1: has gone down. That having been said, I do think
- 19:55Speaker 1: that the defense did a good job of, um, you know,
- 19:58Speaker 1: trying to make sure the jury trans order themselves back
- 20:01Speaker 1: to two thousand eighteen, where Elon must still had an
- 20:04Speaker 1: almost an unalloyed mythical, you know, sort of aura around him,
- 20:09Speaker 1: and that has more of the ability to move markets
- 20:12Speaker 1: even if you're not, you know, saying things with great
- 20:16Speaker 1: certainty like funding secured. And I think that the defense
- 20:20Speaker 1: did a good job of taking apart the different ingredients
- 20:23Speaker 1: that have to go in to a civil claim for
- 20:26Speaker 1: security spraud, finding a couple of those in which it's
- 20:30Speaker 1: not really clear that he was acting, you know, from
- 20:33Speaker 1: a desire to mislead people, and in fact, you could
- 20:36Speaker 1: tell a story as Musk himself did understand, but you know,
- 20:39Speaker 1: he was just trying to keep people informed of what
- 20:42Speaker 1: was going on, and may have in artfully chosen a
- 20:44Speaker 1: few words, but the gist of his of his message,
- 20:48Speaker 1: at least according to him, was truthful. And so you know,
- 20:51Speaker 1: it's usually the case in a lot of these business
- 20:55Speaker 1: litigation matters that there are multiple parts of a cause
- 20:59Speaker 1: of act action that defendants, if they kind of make
- 21:02Speaker 1: the world look complex, they have more of a chance
- 21:05Speaker 1: of winning on one or two of those elements and
- 21:07Speaker 1: all if all of them are required, that's gonna be
- 21:10Speaker 1: bad news for the plaintiffs. And so the defense kind
- 21:12Speaker 1: of has that built in advantage here. That advantage was
- 21:16Speaker 1: somewhat depleted because of the prior ruling on the falsity
- 21:20Speaker 1: of the statement, but the defendant, you know, still kind
- 21:22Speaker 1: of had a position of saying, look, all we have
- 21:24Speaker 1: to do is win on one of these issues materiality, loss, causation,
- 21:29Speaker 1: and the entire case of the plaintiffs is sunk. And
- 21:32Speaker 1: they did a pretty effective job of doing that. The plaintifts,
- 21:34Speaker 1: in contrast, their effort is really going to be this
- 21:37Speaker 1: is a really really simple case. This is easy to
- 21:40Speaker 1: boil down. You know, this is not complicated. This doesn't
- 21:44Speaker 1: require the jury members to do you know, double reverse,
- 21:48Speaker 1: you know, flipping twists in the air to figure out
- 21:51Speaker 1: what was going on. And there, you know, there's gonna
- 21:54Speaker 1: be a huge premium on putting on a very linear,
- 21:57Speaker 1: easy to understand case and out of the box. The
- 22:01Speaker 1: plaintiffs in this case the theory was a little bit
- 22:04Speaker 1: more circuitous to try to get to what the wrong was,
- 22:07Speaker 1: and and that can matter particularly, you know what, the
- 22:11Speaker 1: jury of your first couple of witnesses kind of you know,
- 22:14Speaker 1: send them on a wild goose chase. There's just not
- 22:16Speaker 1: a second chance to make a first impression. His lawyer,
- 22:19Speaker 1: Alex Spireau, also want a defamation lawsuit against Musk over
- 22:25Speaker 1: his tweet calling a cave explorer a pedo guy. Is
- 22:29Speaker 1: this a case of a lawyer who gets elon Musk
- 22:32Speaker 1: and knows how to present him to a jury so
- 22:35Speaker 1: they get him. Yes, maybe, um, but remember Mr Spirow
- 22:39Speaker 1: also was representing Mr Musk in the Twitter acquisition that
- 22:43Speaker 1: ended up settling with essentially a complete capitulation from Mr Musk.
- 22:48Speaker 1: So you know, in both of these cases, they've you know,
- 22:51Speaker 1: they've sort of fought it out to a successful resolution.
- 22:56Speaker 1: But you know, I think it seems to most people
- 22:58Speaker 1: that the fight against having to close the deal on
- 23:01Speaker 1: Twitter was largely a white flag operation by Team Musk,
- 23:05Speaker 1: or at least eventually became one. But you know, listen,
- 23:08Speaker 1: the quality of lawyers that Mr Musk has is very high.
- 23:11Speaker 1: Spireau as a well, regarded litigator at at Quinn Emmanuel
- 23:14Speaker 1: and as a result, you know, it shouldn't be surprising
- 23:17Speaker 1: that he's going to find someone that's good at what
- 23:20Speaker 1: they do. And Mr spirow is you know, I think
- 23:22Speaker 1: that it also a sort of testament to when do
- 23:25Speaker 1: you actually take the case into the courthouse and do
- 23:28Speaker 1: the live hearing versus decide to save your powder for
- 23:32Speaker 1: another day? And and you know, in the Twitter acquisition
- 23:35Speaker 1: they decided to save their powder. They here they decided
- 23:38Speaker 1: to fight and ended up prevailing at the end. I
- 23:42Speaker 1: wonder if the difference in the Twitter case and the
- 23:46Speaker 1: other cases is a judge hearing the case versus a
- 23:50Speaker 1: jury that can certainly matter, the judge is almost always
- 23:55Speaker 1: going to be more inclined to stick to their jurisprudential
- 23:58Speaker 1: knitting on you know, out of the key elements of
- 24:02Speaker 1: the legal claim here and what is proven versus what
- 24:05Speaker 1: is kind of you know, gesticulated as a type of
- 24:08Speaker 1: an innuendo or hint uh, And so that there may
- 24:12Speaker 1: be something to that, you know, I think this case
- 24:15Speaker 1: to the extent that this was at least in part
- 24:18Speaker 1: a process of kind of you know, appealing to a
- 24:21Speaker 1: lay jury that had hazards in both directions, right. You know,
- 24:25Speaker 1: even in picking the jury, there were many prospective jurors
- 24:29Speaker 1: that you know, described Mr Musk as being unlikable and
- 24:32Speaker 1: detestable and so so I think that you are sort of,
- 24:36Speaker 1: you know, playing a little bit more of a game
- 24:38Speaker 1: of chance when you're bringing things in front of a
- 24:40Speaker 1: lay jury. But by the same token, you do have
- 24:43Speaker 1: the opportunity to persuade them by your demeanored by your character.
- 24:48Speaker 1: That probably gets a little bit more play when there's
- 24:51Speaker 1: live testimony in front of a jury than in front
- 24:54Speaker 1: of a judge. The plaintiffs lawyer in the closing argument said,
- 24:57Speaker 1: this case ultimately is about whether rules that apply to
- 25:01Speaker 1: everyone else should also apply to Elon Musk. So if
- 25:05Speaker 1: another CEO had done this, would they have gotten off
- 25:09Speaker 1: or is it? Well, it's Elon Musk. He's tweeting all day.
- 25:13Speaker 1: He's tweeting a lot of nonsense, So you can't take
- 25:16Speaker 1: him that seriously. Well, one need not venture very far
- 25:20Speaker 1: into history to find other examples of CEOs whose tweets
- 25:23Speaker 1: have gotten them into trouble, and in some cases those
- 25:26Speaker 1: CEOs have been sued for various manifestations of securities fraud
- 25:31Speaker 1: and just about all those cases, the case is just
- 25:33Speaker 1: sort of quietly settled. We don't you sometimes know if
- 25:35Speaker 1: there was a payment made, Sometimes we don't. And so
- 25:38Speaker 1: one of the key differentiators here is that Mr Musk
- 25:42Speaker 1: was willing to just take this into the you know,
- 25:44Speaker 1: not only up to the courthouse steps, but over them
- 25:47Speaker 1: and and to to litigate the case the one you know,
- 25:51Speaker 1: it's kind of left wondering well does this leave what
- 25:53Speaker 1: does this leave in its wake for those future CEOs
- 25:56Speaker 1: who may issue improvident tweets? Uh? Is this going to
- 25:59Speaker 1: make them more likely or less likely to say we're
- 26:02Speaker 1: going to fight this out in court and not capitulate
- 26:05Speaker 1: to a settlement. And you know, my sense is that
- 26:07Speaker 1: most people who watch these sorts of cases, that's going
- 26:10Speaker 1: to be the more durable aspect of the securities fraud
- 26:12Speaker 1: lawsuit on you know, the situations, the frequency and the
- 26:17Speaker 1: contingencies under which parties will settle the case versus just
- 26:21Speaker 1: deciding they're going to duke it out in court. We've
- 26:23Speaker 1: talked about this before, how it's unusual for a securities
- 26:27Speaker 1: fraud case like this to actually get before a jury.
- 26:31Speaker 1: Did you did others watching this learn anything from this
- 26:35Speaker 1: case getting to the jury. I think one of the
- 26:38Speaker 1: key lessons is, if you're going to put a securities
- 26:40Speaker 1: fraud case in front of a jury, you better be
- 26:43Speaker 1: very very conscientious of trying to simplify things as much
- 26:47Speaker 1: as possible. That in some cases may mean that you
- 26:50Speaker 1: want to split the liability phase from the damages phase. Uh.
- 26:55Speaker 1: It's not entirely beyond one's imagination to think that this
- 26:59Speaker 1: jury was thinking, Okay, look, it's kind of a close
- 27:02Speaker 1: column liability. You know, I guess I'd lean slightly against,
- 27:07Speaker 1: but I lean even more against if I have to
- 27:10Speaker 1: do the math quiz to fill out the damages portion
- 27:13Speaker 1: of the case. So there may be, you know, one
- 27:16Speaker 1: of the lessons here is that, you know, while there
- 27:18Speaker 1: can sometimes be some advantages to just having the same
- 27:21Speaker 1: jury process both questions of liability and questions of quantifying
- 27:25Speaker 1: damages together, that can be hazardous if essentially the verdict sheet,
- 27:30Speaker 1: the verdict form uh starts to look like you're being
- 27:34Speaker 1: asked to retake the ssay T or something like that.
- 27:38Speaker 1: And so there may be a couple of takeaways here
- 27:42Speaker 1: for future cases that end up going before juries know
- 27:45Speaker 1: how to articulate your case in a you know, with
- 27:48Speaker 1: relatively few moving parts and possibly you know, try to
- 27:51Speaker 1: concentrate people's attentions on the liability phase without you know,
- 27:55Speaker 1: sort of clouding folks views on Okay, what were the
- 27:58Speaker 1: damages associated with it? So a lawyer for the investors said,
- 28:03Speaker 1: we're disappointed with the result and considering our next steps.
- 28:07Speaker 1: What are possible next steps and appeal. Any case like
- 28:11Speaker 1: this can be appealed. The problem when you appeal a
- 28:14Speaker 1: case that now has some factual findings and then has
- 28:18Speaker 1: an award is that to overturn a defense side outcome
- 28:24Speaker 1: below appellate level courts are going to be very, very
- 28:28Speaker 1: reluctant to revisit the jury's interpretation of the facts. Here
- 28:32Speaker 1: it's given an enormous amount of weight, and only if
- 28:35Speaker 1: there's just no reasonable way a juror could interpret facts
- 28:38Speaker 1: in the way that they did, would and a palate
- 28:41Speaker 1: court saying okay, we're gonna overturn that and maybe throw
- 28:44Speaker 1: this back to being relitigated. So appeal is always a possibility.
- 28:49Speaker 1: I tend to think in this case that the best
- 28:52Speaker 1: that you're going to be able to do on appeal
- 28:54Speaker 1: is retry the case. And you know, and unless you've
- 28:58Speaker 1: got a good theory about how you can make is
- 29:00Speaker 1: less complicated, uh more approachable to the jury, it may
- 29:04Speaker 1: not be worthwhile doing. After all, there is you know,
- 29:07Speaker 1: this was a fairly volatile period of time in the
- 29:11Speaker 1: life cycle of Tesla stock. You know, during this period
- 29:14Speaker 1: of time, it's definitely the case that Tesla stock was
- 29:17Speaker 1: fluctuating wildly, probably not as much as it has fluctuated
- 29:21Speaker 1: in the time since, but you know, there definitely was
- 29:24Speaker 1: a lot of movement in the stock, largely due to
- 29:28Speaker 1: speculation around this potential going private transaction. You know, at
- 29:32Speaker 1: some point you're throwing good money after bad continuing to
- 29:35Speaker 1: try to press this particular legal claim. Um. You know,
- 29:39Speaker 1: other options may simply be you know, restructuring and rethinking
- 29:42Speaker 1: the way that one invest in some of these situations,
- 29:46Speaker 1: and uh, you know, possibly placing greater pressure on companies
- 29:51Speaker 1: to uh to either audit or in some ways sense
- 29:55Speaker 1: or for certain types of tweets that might be sent
- 29:57Speaker 1: out that are informationally sensitive to appeal. Some of the
- 30:00Speaker 1: judges rulings, I think most of the judge's rulings were
- 30:04Speaker 1: favorable to the plaintiffs, weren't they certainly leading up to
- 30:08Speaker 1: the to the actual trial. The plaintiffs were looking like
- 30:12Speaker 1: they were playing a fairly strong hands, and some of
- 30:14Speaker 1: the elements that they would have to demonstrate had already
- 30:17Speaker 1: been adjudicated in their favor. That having been said, there
- 30:21Speaker 1: was a trial for a reason because not all of
- 30:23Speaker 1: the elements of the securities proud claim have been adjudicated.
- 30:27Speaker 1: And to win on liability, you gotta you gotta run
- 30:30Speaker 1: the table as a plaintiff. You can't just went on
- 30:32Speaker 1: one or two of these elements, their conjunctive elements, which
- 30:35Speaker 1: you've got to win all of So, you know, the
- 30:37Speaker 1: the odds had been evened up a little bit by
- 30:40Speaker 1: by some of those prior rulings by the judge. But
- 30:43Speaker 1: then ultimately it was clear to everyone that the judge
- 30:45Speaker 1: was going to hand over the rest of these determinations
- 30:48Speaker 1: to a jury, and there was no guarantee that this
- 30:50Speaker 1: jury was going to act in a way that was
- 30:52Speaker 1: consistent with how the judge had acted previously. Thanks so
- 30:54Speaker 1: much for being on the show. Eric. That's Eric Tallely,
- 30:57Speaker 1: a business law professor at Columbia Law School, And that's
- 31:00Speaker 1: it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember
- 31:03Speaker 1: you can always get the latest legal news on our
- 31:05Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 31:09Speaker 1: and at www dot bloomberg dot com, slash podcast slash Law,
- 31:15Speaker 1: and remember to tune in to The Bloomberg Law Show
- 31:17Speaker 1: every week night at ten p m. Wall Street Time.
- 31:20Speaker 1: I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg