Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 55: On the future of bars & restaurants with Josh Fontaine
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening to the new Paris At the end of 2019, the
- 0:12pension reform strikes dealt a nasty blow to businesses in
- 0:16Paris. I've reported a story for
- 0:18Fortune magazine about the economic impact for a handful of
- 0:22food and wine establishments, including those run by Josh
- 0:25Fontaine. He is the coowner of Quixotic
- 0:27Projects, the group that created Candle Area among the World's
- 0:31Top Cocktail Bars, Lumeri Celeste's Wine Bar Hero and Le
- 0:35Grand Ver. He expressed just how
- 0:37devastating the strikes were to business at a time of year that
- 0:40usually represents A sizable source of annual revenue.
- 0:44I felt for him then, and I feel for him even more so now.
- 0:48He joins me on the show to talk about how he's doing, what he's
- 0:51drinking at home, and what he believes awaits the business
- 0:54when Confinement lifts. Thanks for being here.
- 0:58Thank you for having me. Where are you right now?
- 1:02I am currently at Mary Celeste preparing to open our Cav this
- 1:07week for selling for people in the neighborhood and to go.
- 1:12And then we're selling some online as well to bring in some
- 1:16money and hopefully pay some outstanding bills that we
- 1:19haven't been able to pay. And is that because of like a
- 1:24holdover from the strikes or is that just more recent?
- 1:28Now we're pretty much recovered from the strikes, but then as as
- 1:33far as I know most of my colleagues have done, you know,
- 1:36once we got shut down, we basically froze all you know,
- 1:40money going out of the business to to keep our.
- 1:43Our cash flow in the place that we need it to be because we did
- 1:47need to front salaries and we also haven't come to terms yet
- 1:52with our landlords for rent and what's going to happen for that
- 1:56for the next few months. So we need to keep as much cash
- 1:59on hand as possible. Unfortunately for our suppliers,
- 2:02that means most of them have a couple bills that are
- 2:04outstanding that I'd like to pay for them and also for when we
- 2:09reopen not to have a big backlog.
- 2:12And have that weighing on the business.
- 2:14Do you anticipate your landlords giving some sort of rent
- 2:20forgiveness? Is that something that you think
- 2:22is possible in France? Would they do that?
- 2:24Yeah, I mean, we, our landlords are all like individuals, not
- 2:29like big corporations or anything.
- 2:30So they've been all pretty understanding up until this
- 2:34point. And you know, we haven't paid
- 2:36them the rent that we owe them and our hero landlord is
- 2:39actually pretty proactive. Saying that he's going to give
- 2:42us, you know, basically all the time that we're forced to be
- 2:46closed by the government. So from March whatever, 15th
- 2:49through 16th through, whenever we're out to reopen, they're
- 2:52going to wave. So that was pretty nice without
- 2:54having to go and hands and knees and be begging for, you know,
- 2:57some kind of rent relief, right you for the rest of the venues.
- 3:01And is it true? Because this is one of the
- 3:03things that I was reading that unlike normal times when people
- 3:07are going to go on unemployment, right now they're asking
- 3:11companies to front the partial unemployment money and then the
- 3:14government reimburses you. Yeah.
- 3:17So we were pretty. We jumped on that as fast as
- 3:21possible with our accountants. So we've actually been
- 3:23reimbursed for the second-half of March already.
- 3:27But yeah, every month, I mean, from now, I guess we're gonna
- 3:30have to. You know, you have to front
- 3:32whatever €20,000 and then wait for it to come back.
- 3:36So you, you know, not every business is in the position
- 3:39where they have 10s of thousands of years to be able to front and
- 3:42then wait two weeks, you know, for it to come back in.
- 3:46But at the same time, there's not really any other bills that
- 3:48are you at this point beside Divya and some other taxes that
- 3:54they're not waiving. So as long as you started out, I
- 3:57guess in a decent position, it should be able to continue
- 4:01unless your landlord is forcing you to pay rent, right?
- 4:03So how are you feeling right now?
- 4:05I mean, just like pure honesty, not related necessarily, even
- 4:09just to the business, but just you as a guy who lives in Paris,
- 4:15who works in Paris and has had like a lot of people, a tough
- 4:19year. Yeah.
- 4:23I mean, I'm trying to stay optimistic.
- 4:26You know, I'm doing the same as everybody else, doing pretty
- 4:28much staying at home, cooking, vacuuming.
- 4:34But I'm lucky enough to have a balcony, which is nice, so you
- 4:37can get some sun every morning and can read out there a little
- 4:40bit. But I mean, yeah, the thing
- 4:43that's preoccupying me the most is the work situation, because
- 4:47it's it's just the uncertainty where, you know, if you're just
- 4:51an employee somewhere. At least you know the
- 4:54government. You know, the government has
- 4:56come in and said Okay, we're going to guarantee 84% of your
- 5:00salary. So in general, I don't think
- 5:02people are going to go homeless or hungry if they had a job and
- 5:07then they're only paying, they're getting paid 84% of
- 5:09their salary. But you know, for me, it's the
- 5:13uncertainty that's unnerving. When I don't know when I'm going
- 5:17to be able to pay people like Spires, I don't know when we're
- 5:20going to be able to reopen. When we reopen, how is it going
- 5:24to be, you know, So what? All tourism for the rest of the
- 5:28year, I would write, you know, 50% of your business.
- 5:33So what have, I mean maybe they haven't communicated anything,
- 5:38but what has the government or whoever is in charge of sort of
- 5:40like small businesses and rolling out the guidance in
- 5:44terms of how the confinement or the deconfinement will go?
- 5:48What have you heard, if anything?
- 5:50Not much. Especially in restaurant and bar
- 5:53situations. You know, the last time the
- 5:56president spoke, he's like, you know, it's going to go slowly
- 6:00from May 11th. It's not going to be.
- 6:01Everything's reopened and we're all back to normal.
- 6:04When you know bars and restaurants are definitely not
- 6:06going to be the first places that are going to be open.
- 6:10And also the economics of a bar restaurant work, you know when
- 6:14you're full, but if they say you can only let 10 people in at a
- 6:18time. But we have to like take
- 6:20everybody back on payroll, then it doesn't work.
- 6:24I can't pay everybody their full, their full salary and then
- 6:28only have 10 or 20 people in the restaurant time.
- 6:30You know, it needs to be a certain, you need to have a
- 6:33certain volume. So I know us and a bunch of
- 6:38other people are nervous on how it's going to come back.
- 6:40And also, you know, no one really wants to hang out in the
- 6:42bar if everyone has to wear a mask and you know.
- 6:45The servers are wearing gloves and you know, it's like a weird
- 6:47vibe that's otherwise, you know, people just get food to go and
- 6:51sit on the canal or go to the park.
- 6:53I mean, that's what I would do. Like the whole point is can be
- 6:55reality and you know, friendship and good times and music and
- 7:00everything, Not a sterile gold environment.
- 7:05So that's the big question, mark.
- 7:07Yeah, that's what we're nervous about is not only reopening, but
- 7:11how is it going to be at the reopening?
- 7:13And will the government aid continue?
- 7:16You know, if they don't let us function as we were before, will
- 7:21the government aid follow us until we can?
- 7:25Surely they must know though the economics of a business like a
- 7:28restaurant. Or they they at least should be
- 7:31investigating that. You know, like unions and stuff
- 7:36and representatives have been talking to the government a
- 7:38little bit as far as I know, so hopefully that's being
- 7:41communicated, but. At the end of the day, you know,
- 7:44there's a lot of different industries and the government
- 7:46can't be an expert on all of them.
- 7:48Obviously, you know, the, the restaurant and tourist and hotel
- 7:55industry is very big in France. So I think it might get a little
- 7:59bit more FaceTime with the government and be able to push
- 8:02their priorities because obviously, you know, France is
- 8:06one of the most touristy countries in the world and it's
- 8:07a huge part of the economy and I think they know that.
- 8:11So this shift towards selling bottles and operating sort of as
- 8:15a calve, was that something that, I mean you took that first
- 8:20month to to figure out? Was that something you
- 8:22immediately thought of of doing? We didn't immediately think of
- 8:27doing it because when we first got shut down, we didn't really
- 8:30know how long it would be for what the rules are, how much
- 8:34support we're gonna get, how much support we're not gonna
- 8:36get. And also.
- 8:39You know, it's not like an easy flip to start, you know,
- 8:43changing a restaurant into a Cav East and obviously a lot of
- 8:46people are doing it. So it needs to be economically
- 8:49viable also to sell bottles much cheaper than you normally would
- 8:53and bring people in and everything.
- 8:55So it's been basically myself and my partners handling
- 8:58everything. Otherwise, you know, if we have
- 9:00to start taking people off, the shamash passion to have them
- 9:04sell bottles and the economics of that doesn't work either,
- 9:06right? So yeah, it was after a few
- 9:09weeks and after we see Okay, it's not gonna, we're not gonna
- 9:12be reopening anytime soon. We tried it out last weekend.
- 9:16It worked pretty well. Mostly just people in the
- 9:18neighborhood coming by. But we're also like selling
- 9:20cases online and that's doing pretty well and good.
- 9:23There's some merchandise and stuff like that of people that
- 9:25wanna support. So the little bit of cash flow
- 9:28helps, you know every little bit helps a lot.
- 9:31And we also reopened Hero for delivery.
- 9:34I did see that. Yeah.
- 9:35And and is that like, how do you, Because one of the big
- 9:38topics of conversation, especially in the US where
- 9:41delivery has been sort of like the only protective option for
- 9:45for food businesses is the idea of protecting the cooking staff
- 9:51and protecting the delivery workers.
- 9:53I mean, how do you reconcile all those elements?
- 9:56Yeah. I mean, that's why we didn't
- 9:57open right away because. We actually tried to stay open
- 10:01for the first couple days after we were forced to shut down for
- 10:04delivery only. But then the cook started saying
- 10:08they're uncomfortable on, you know, because in the first,
- 10:11like, weeks, no one really knew what was going on, how
- 10:14contagious this thing is, what the guidelines are.
- 10:17So we didn't force people to get out of their house.
- 10:20They're like, OK, we're going to shut it down for the moment and
- 10:23see how it goes and that, you know.
- 10:26In the last week or two, people are now pretty bored sitting at
- 10:29home. Everybody sees like, you know,
- 10:32it's not like the end of the world.
- 10:33You know, it's difficult and hard, but it's not the end of
- 10:36the world. So they're ready to go outside a
- 10:38little bit more. So we're able to get a few
- 10:41volunteers to come off the showmage and come in and work a
- 10:44few hours every night. So we're not open for lunch,
- 10:48we're just doing dinner at the moment.
- 10:49Because again, it's an economics thing where normally delivery is
- 10:52just kind of icing on the cake. But you have your regular
- 10:56business, but when it's 100% of your business and delivery and
- 11:00Uber are taking 25 or 30% of your DE fair.
- 11:04Plus you have to pay people, plus you have to pay for your
- 11:05food and everything else. Your break even come becomes a
- 11:11lot higher than it normally would be.
- 11:12So that was going to be my next question.
- 11:14I was going to ask if those platforms, those delivery
- 11:17platforms had maintained the same Commission that they always
- 11:20take. But I guess the answer is they
- 11:22they are. Yeah, definitely.
- 11:24So, so it's a start in a hard place.
- 11:27Like some, some friends are trying to do delivery like on
- 11:31their own terms and be like, OK on Monday, like you have to
- 11:36e-mail us by Wednesday, Here's the menu for Friday.
- 11:39Yeah. And we'll do this and then we'll
- 11:41deliver by bike and which I think is, you know, it's the
- 11:43ideal way, definitely. But I feel like most people's
- 11:48behavior is conditioned to, you know, when they don't want to
- 11:51cook, they just open. Uber eats or delivery when they
- 11:54scroll through and see what whatever, whatever things
- 11:57available to them. So to plan that far in advance
- 12:00is, I think it's difficult. So we've just kind of stayed on
- 12:05the classic route despite the fact that economically it's not
- 12:08the best option, right. So Legron there, for those who
- 12:12don't know, is the restaurant inside the Palli de Tokyo, What
- 12:17is that like? Because are the dynamics of that
- 12:19difference since you're part of a cultural institution?
- 12:24Not really because our, our actually there, our rent is
- 12:27based on our sales. So we have no sales, so you know
- 12:32charges there, but you know we'll see That might be a whole
- 12:37different kind of reopening situation compared to the other
- 12:40businesses because we're in the museum and maybe museums of a
- 12:44certain size. You're not going to be able to
- 12:45open or they're not going to be able to let like have capacity
- 12:49or who knows? So we have absolutely no idea
- 12:52what that's going to look like when it when it reopens.
- 12:55You have connections obviously with the US food and and wine
- 13:01industry and you have friends there.
- 13:03Are you feeling, I mean to some extent relieved that you've been
- 13:09doing business in France and that there are some protections
- 13:11or like what it what are you feeling when you're watching
- 13:14what's happening to sort of your your colleagues and some of your
- 13:17friends in the business elsewhere?
- 13:20Yeah. I mean, I think the US ended up
- 13:23stepping up a little bit more than it looked like they would
- 13:25at the beginning, but they had like, you know, this big fun to
- 13:28help out small businesses and small restaurants.
- 13:31Then a lot of that ended up going to chains.
- 13:34But yeah, I mean, we have, you know, we work with Ace Hotel on
- 13:39a bar in New Orleans. And I know a lot of people there
- 13:41are nervous for their jobs and they've had to layoff a bunch of
- 13:45people, but it's basically just like a clock that's ticking down
- 13:49and. You know, once everybody's cash
- 13:52runs out then they end up laying off or firing more people.
- 13:56So it always starts at the lower rungs and moves up to like the
- 14:02people at the management level I think are good so far, but they
- 14:07also have a ton of job insecurity.
- 14:10And I can understand that too because if, you know the
- 14:12business has no way of of getting aid from the government
- 14:16or any kind of there's no way you can just.
- 14:19Make money out of print, money out of scenarios.
- 14:20So definitely happy that the government was pretty proactive,
- 14:26even though like everywhere, it was a little bit of a mess.
- 14:29Trying to figure out what the right information is and how
- 14:33you're going to get reimbursed and who you ask and how long it
- 14:36takes and all this other stuff. And some of those details are
- 14:39still not worked out. But in general, it's not German
- 14:43efficiency, but it's been because the other thing I was
- 14:48thinking is in the US now, some of the the food stories I've
- 14:52seen written have been particularly heartbreaking
- 14:54because they talk about a future that's homogeneous in terms of a
- 14:58dining landscape. You know and do you?
- 15:01You know whatever TGI Friday is not the 30 different
- 15:05restaurants. So do you think the same could
- 15:08happen here or we really just gonna see sort of the the very
- 15:12fragile or you know the newer businesses that didn't have time
- 15:16to build up a following and maybe a bigger cash flow that
- 15:20that will happen here as well? Well, because of the size of the
- 15:24intervention and the fact that it was basically available to
- 15:27everybody, knock on wood, we'll see.
- 15:31We still haven't gotten our like.
- 15:33Guaranteed the loans yet or wants on those yet so waiting to
- 15:39hear back this week but it basically all depends on on that
- 15:43and if you have no history it might be hard to convince your
- 15:47banker to to give you one of these loans even though they're
- 15:49guaranteed by the state they just can't give them out Winnie
- 15:53nilly. So I don't know it's, I mean
- 15:58it's hard to say it's it's like yeah you can have cash flow now
- 16:01but. When you reopen, you know, maybe
- 16:03restaurants that are normally 80% tourists or they're like,
- 16:08you know, these we might see some weird things where like two
- 16:11or three Michelin star places that are not really like locals
- 16:14kind of Hangouts have the toughest time before you needed
- 16:19to reserve like two or three months in advance.
- 16:21But you know, if the global tourism economy is nonexistent
- 16:26because of you know. Either people lost their job so
- 16:30they're not going on vacation, or that there's restrictions on
- 16:33movement, but you're forced to reopen.
- 16:35What are you going to do? Because you know you're not
- 16:37going to fill your 3 Mission Star restaurant with locals 5-6
- 16:41nights a week. So those kind of things might
- 16:44be, I feel like, a weird paradox where places that are super hard
- 16:49to get into might be not hard to get in.
- 16:52Might have to change it for me a little bit, I would say like.
- 16:56Basically the same as it was with the strikes.
- 17:00The safest places are the most local, like the corner
- 17:05situation, where this corner cafe is just basically serving
- 17:10the surrounding 5 blocks, and that's 100% of their clientele
- 17:13or 95% of their clientele, right?
- 17:15There's less risk. Yeah.
- 17:17It's not based on people traveling to you.
- 17:19They're not a destination. It's not like a date place.
- 17:22It's just like. Local people drinking beer and
- 17:24wine and buying cigarettes. So I think I gotta say.
- 17:29Businesses. Well, I gotta say, I mean I
- 17:32every time I'm at the my Celeste, which is actually quite
- 17:35a lot given that it's not far from me.
- 17:39It felt like, you know there were a lot of familiar faces.
- 17:42Yes, of course there are people who you know because of you know
- 17:46your concept and and and what you're offering.
- 17:49Of course, that brings in people who are traveling.
- 17:51But do you not think that maybe there's an opportunity now for,
- 17:55you know, all the locals who maybe aren't comfortable taking
- 17:58public transport right away or won't be comfortable, will stay
- 18:02local to try to, you know, support the neighborhood.
- 18:10Interesting. With the with the transit
- 18:12strikes, you know our business was down like 40% like doing
- 18:17only 60% of your business is. Like that's the difference of
- 18:22slow death or things. That was a much different
- 18:28scenario. Yeah.
- 18:31But if we're basing it on hoping that people in your neighborhood
- 18:35are going to support you, right, Okay. 60% of our business, yes,
- 18:40is maybe people in our neighborhood that are supporting
- 18:41us, but the other 40% which is the whole.
- 18:46That's the whole difference, the whole thing that makes a
- 18:49difference. If those people are not coming
- 18:51to you, then you know man, yours was the last bar I went to
- 18:59before the shutdown. Thank you.
- 19:02I was at Marta and then I went to you.
- 19:05You were not there, unfortunately, but it.
- 19:07Wasn't there? No, no, but it was.
- 19:10Mexico. Were you still in Mexico?
- 19:13Yeah, Well, oh, that's right. That's.
- 19:16I remember now. But, you know, I felt like I
- 19:19could see people going and respecting a certain distance.
- 19:22But you're right. The one element that is remains
- 19:26a little bit unknown is about the the hygiene thing is like,
- 19:29if people have to wear masks and gloves, is that gonna like be
- 19:33such a buzzkill that, you know, people just stay home?
- 19:37We have to do that and remove half of our bar stools and.
- 19:41And then everybody has to be policeman.
- 19:42And well, I mean, right, you don't like it if we tell them
- 19:45like, not to smoke or take the drink outside.
- 19:47If we're like, you know, stay 2 meters away from your
- 19:50girlfriend, it's gonna cause some problems.
- 19:54So tell me. I mean, I obviously we're
- 19:57connected on Instagram, So I see that you've been cooking a lot.
- 20:01I see that there have been some good drinks.
- 20:03What have you been drinking? And what, like what are some
- 20:06easy cocktails? That people could make from home
- 20:09that you, that you find particularly comforting.
- 20:12Right now, I haven't been making too many cocktails.
- 20:15I would say the only cocktail I've been making is an Old
- 20:17Fashioned. But basically, you know, I have
- 20:20a pretty good wine stock in my in my basement right now.
- 20:24So I've been, I have had the time to organize it, finally so
- 20:29organized it and you know put all the stuff that's ready to
- 20:32drink on top. So I still have a good. 40 or 50
- 20:35bottles of Ready to drink wine in my basement, so I'm good for
- 20:39the next 40 or 50 days. And what are you turning to
- 20:44like? Are you?
- 20:46Is there a particular region you're drawn to right now?
- 20:50Not particular, I mean I have a good selection I would say.
- 20:53So it's basically depending on what we're eating that night
- 20:58we're eating is basically what's at Terra or Roots or at the
- 21:02butcher shop and looks good so. Eating asparagus or you know,
- 21:08nice new salads that are coming up or whatever else is coming up
- 21:11in seasons. So basically drinking based on
- 21:14that, which it's not always what I do sometimes, you know, I want
- 21:17you wanna drink something in particular, so you make
- 21:19something to go with wine. But definitely a lot of white
- 21:23and Rose A is coming up Rose A on the balcony.
- 21:25I mean, it's gonna be Rose a season and we're all gonna be
- 21:28inside. I know.
- 21:29Well, hopefully we can start to go outside and and and drink
- 21:33Rose A. You showed me that you're
- 21:35sitting in front of a bunch of bottles.
- 21:39What are some of the bottles and and producers that you're you're
- 21:43selling right now? We're gonna be selling,
- 21:46basically. Everything that I had, any
- 21:48quantity of at here or Monvere, we brought all here and have now
- 21:52organized. So we're going to do like a 10
- 21:55year old table, a 15 year old 20 and 25 year table with just a
- 21:59bunch of random delicious things, most of which are
- 22:06organic, biodynamic low sulfites from France and Croatia and
- 22:12Italy and what else, Yeah. So what could people, people who
- 22:19follow you or, you know, love the the your establishments but
- 22:23live outside of France? How can they support you?
- 22:28Well, we had ordered like Candelaria tshirts a while ago,
- 22:31came in like 3 days ago during the confinement.
- 22:34So we put those online and those are selling quite well.
- 22:36So we have a bunch of nice new tshirts.
- 22:39And sweatshirts of organic cotton and recycled polyester.
- 22:44So check out the web store I guess.
- 22:46OK, I'll link to that. Hilarious stuff.
- 22:49Corkscrew, oyster knife, sweatshirts, T-shirts, all this
- 22:55nice stuff. And then people around Paris can
- 22:59order all that. Plus cases of wine that I've put
- 23:03together along different themes. That we're delivering in Paris
- 23:08and in the immediate suburbs and then otherwise locals can walk
- 23:13by and come to the Cav Wednesday to Saturday.
- 23:17Well, good, because I can walk to you that's still in the like
- 23:20my permitted radius. One last thing, What are some of
- 23:27the places you're excited to go to when this is all over?
- 23:32And by all over I don't mean resolved.
- 23:34Yeah. In Paris or outside of the city?
- 23:37Yeah, let let's stay, let's stay in Paris.
- 23:39Because who knows what the likelihood is of of us actually
- 23:44leaving town? What would I say is the 1st
- 23:48place I'm gonna go? I mean, I guess all the usual,
- 23:52all the usual haunts around, you know, San Sebastian, Oduzami,
- 24:01Martin Rober. Clamato lobby vet You really
- 24:10don't venture far anyway. Just, you know, every time
- 24:16someone's in town, we do the same circuit.
- 24:18Verbole I need. I haven't been there in a while.
- 24:22Probably actually a place where I love to go from.
- 24:26My favorite place and the place I've been to the most, and which
- 24:30I don't have personal contact with the owners, would be
- 24:33Lobatan. Mmhmm.
- 24:35And I'd like to know actually how they're doing now.
- 24:38They're holding up because they're definitely not in my,
- 24:41you know, immediate network of sending a text and being like,
- 24:45right, how you doing? How are you paying these taxes?
- 24:50Employees kind of thing, which is, you know, with the rest of
- 24:52it. So are you part of a group like
- 24:54that? Are you?
- 24:55Do you have, like, a network of food friends?
- 24:58Friends. But then also I started like a
- 24:59couple days after the confinement happened, I started
- 25:02a big WhatsApp group and I think we're like. 50 or 60 or 70 now
- 25:07of restaurant owners and and bar owners.
- 25:12So just sharing any info people get on how to get certain help
- 25:15or you know how to fill out a certain form or things like
- 25:19that. So that's been quite helpful
- 25:21definitely in the first week or two when everyone was trying to
- 25:24figure out what was what. It was nice when people were
- 25:29sharing that information with each other and that everybody's,
- 25:31you know, coming together as a community to.
- 25:34To help each other rather than, you know, compete.
- 25:37Or in the No one's competing for anything, right?
- 25:40Now no one is competing for anything.
- 25:43That's true Josh. I really hope this lifts soon
- 25:48and that we can share a drink and you know, I'll be by
- 25:53hopefully to to buy some wine from you.
- 25:55So maybe I'll get to see you from six feet away and wearing a
- 25:58mask or something. But everyone can find the
- 26:02information to where they can support you in the show notes.
- 26:04So that's hopefully we'll bring in some extra extra goodwill and
- 26:10good love. And if there's anything else we
- 26:13can do, let us know, Will. Do thank you for joining and be
- 26:18well. Thank you.
- 26:20See you soon.