Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [FOMC] Hawkish Fed Cut Shatters Consensus
Transcript
- 0:00You've given us the sources, the transcripts, the economic
- 0:02projections, the market reactions, and we are here to
- 0:05cut through the noise, synthesize the deep seated
- 0:07strategy, and deliver those indispensable insights you need
- 0:11to understand what just happened in the world of global finance.
- 0:14Today we are wading into what felt like a truly contradictory
- 0:19moment in modern monetary history.
- 0:21The December 10th, 2025 Federal Reserve meeting.
- 0:26If you were watching the market that day, you saw the consensus
- 0:29expecting a gentle, you know, predictable easing move.
- 0:33But what we actually received was a high drama, paradoxical
- 0:37maneuver that has set the stage for explosive volatility next
- 0:41year. It was the financial equivalent
- 0:43of a central bank talking out of both sides of its mouth.
- 0:45And that's what we're calling this event, the Hawkish Cut.
- 0:48That's a perfect name for it. It marked the culmination of a
- 0:50truly turbulent period. I mean, think about the
- 0:52backdrop. Opaque economic data.
- 0:55Thanks to a recent government shutdown, they were.
- 0:57Flying blind. Completely.
- 0:59And then you have a clear and undeniable fracturing of policy
- 1:03consensus within the FOMC, the Federal Open Market Committee,
- 1:06and of course, significant political pressure hovering from
- 1:09an incoming presidential administration.
- 1:11That combination created an environment of, well, maximum
- 1:14strategic ambiguity. The Fed had to move, but they
- 1:17couldn't agree on how to move, or more importantly, what to
- 1:21signal next. Our mission today is laser
- 1:24focused. We must extract the definitive
- 1:27strategic signals from all that noise.
- 1:29Esecially for you, the learner who needs a clean structure for
- 1:32highly complex information. We are zeroing in on three core
- 1:35components. First, the rate cut itself and
- 1:38the surprising official rationale right.
- 1:40Second, the truly historic three-way descent that shattered
- 1:43institutional unity. And finally, the long term
- 1:46outlook signaled by that infamous dot plot which
- 1:49completely upended expectations for 2026.
- 1:52To frame this immediately and, you know, define the paradox,
- 1:55let's state the hard numbers. The Fed lowered the target range
- 1:57for the federal funds rate by 25 basis points, or BPS, moving it
- 2:01down to 3.5 to 3.75%. 3.5 to 3.75.
- 2:06Was notably the third consecutive reduction in the
- 2:09easing cycle that began just a few months earlier.
- 2:12So on the surface, this looks dovish.
- 2:15A cut is a cut. But here is the big reveal, the
- 2:18very definition of the hawkish cut.
- 2:21It was a cut of move of accommodation paired with a
- 2:24highly resolute signal that this easing cycle is nearing its
- 2:27terminal plateau. It was the central bank saying
- 2:30we are easing right now because we see some immediate risk but
- 2:34do not under any circumstances expect us to do much more later.
- 2:38OK, let's unpack this and see how such a conflicting message
- 2:41could possibly be delivered by a single supposedly cohesive body,
- 2:45and why they moved at all if they're ultimately so hawkish.
- 2:48Let's jump straight into the policy decision and the
- 2:51fractured consensus. So why cut the rate if they are
- 2:54so concerned, as we just established, about remaining
- 2:56hawkish and fighting that last mile of inflation?
- 2:58What was the immediate, actionable rationale for moving
- 3:01rates down by 25 basis points? Well, the official rationale
- 3:04cited a shift in the balance of risks.
- 3:07For the better part of two years, the singular overwhelming
- 3:11risk was inflation. Now, they believe the risks have
- 3:15shifted heavily toward employment and the structural
- 3:18health of the economy. OK.
- 3:19So it's a pivot in focus. It is.
- 3:21The cut was thus framed as a necessary recalibration and
- 3:26insurance cut, if you will, designed to prevent real
- 3:29interest rates from becoming unintentionally restrictive as
- 3:33inflation slowly eases. If the Fed doesn't cut nominal
- 3:36rates, the real cost of borrowing goes up.
- 3:39And they didn't want that they. Didn't want that to accelerate a
- 3:42slowdown. So it was less about actively
- 3:43stimulating the economy and more about making sure their policy
- 3:46didn't accidentally get tighter as the year wrapped up, right?
- 3:50And the key to justifying that move was the language used to
- 3:53describe the job market, right? Exactly this is the critical
- 3:56textual change in the statement. For the first time in this
- 3:59easing cycle, the official statement explicitly described
- 4:02the labor market as weakening. Not cooling or moderating,
- 4:06weakening. Weakening that single word
- 4:09change acknowledged the looming threat of rapid nonlinear
- 4:13deterioration, what we call the Sam rule dynamics.
- 4:16You mentioned the Sam rule dynamics for the learner.
- 4:18Can you quickly breakdown what that rule is and why 4.5%
- 4:22unemployment is making certain committee members nervous?
- 4:26Sure, The Sam rule, named after economist Claudia Sahm, is an
- 4:29unofficial recession indicator. It states that once the three
- 4:33month moving average of the unemployment rate rises by half
- 4:36a percentage point or more relative to its low over the
- 4:39previous year. The economy is probably already
- 4:41in a recession. Exactly.
- 4:42Or heading there very quickly. With the unemployment rate now
- 4:45sitting at 4.5%, they're seeing small incremental increases that
- 4:49they fear could suddenly catalyze a collapse in consumer
- 4:52spending and corporate hiring. The 25 basis point cut was
- 4:55strategically an attempt to put a circuit breaker on that
- 4:58potential nonlinear decay. And they felt they could do this
- 5:01because they had just enough confidence in the inflation
- 5:04trajectory, which they noted was sufficient, though still
- 5:07somewhat elevated. Right enough to remove some
- 5:09restrictiveness and buy some time for the labor market.
- 5:12But if it was a necessary insurance cut, why the
- 5:15unprecedented dissent? This is where the story gets
- 5:18really interesting because this was a nine to three split.
- 5:22That nine to three vote is the most discordant outcome since
- 5:25September 2019, and it absolutely shatters the
- 5:28powerful, predictable unity of the Powell consensus.
- 5:31And what makes it so historic? It's that it wasn't a simple
- 5:35disagreement. It was a barbell of opposition.
- 5:38The three dissents pulled policy in two diametrically opposed
- 5:42directions, proving that the committee's middle ground, where
- 5:45Chair Powell operates, is incredibly narrow and fragile.
- 5:49Let's. Breakdown those 3 dissents,
- 5:50starting with the true aggressive dove, Governor Steven
- 5:54Mirren, a Trump appointee. He voted for a massive 50 basis
- 5:57point cut. Yeah, A50 Mirren's rationale was
- 6:00rooted in pure fear of the labor market and, crucially, a
- 6:03political alignment with the incoming administration's push
- 6:05for aggressive easing. So he thinks they're behind the
- 6:07curve. He argued the Fed is already
- 6:10behind the curve on employment. He looked at the cooling private
- 6:13payroll data, particularly that ADP report, and concluded that
- 6:1725 BPS was dangerously timid. His fear was that by moving
- 6:21slowly, they would allow those Sam dynamics to fully take hold,
- 6:24effectively ensuring a deeper, longer and entirely unnecessary
- 6:28recession. So for him, the jobs done on
- 6:29inflation and now the crisis is the labor market.
- 6:32That's his view. Yes.
- 6:33Then we shift to the other side of that barbell, the two who
- 6:35voted to maintain rates believing the cut was completely
- 6:38premature. And the shocker here is that one
- 6:41of them press often Goolsbee, from Chicago, is historically
- 6:45known as a reliable dove. Why did Goolsbee swing hawkish
- 6:49and oppose a cut? It's a massive, flashing tell
- 6:52about the state of financial conditions.
- 6:54Goolsbee, the typical friend of low rates, was concerned about
- 6:57the cumulative easing that had already occurred in Q42025.
- 7:00The. 75 basis points total. 75 total.
- 7:03Yes, he argued, the full effect of those cuts hadn't hit the
- 7:06real economy yet. But his major focus was the
- 7:09financial markets. Stock prices were near record
- 7:12highs. Credit spreads were tight.
- 7:14Lending standards were easing. The market was already providing
- 7:17ample stimulus. So you're saying why add more
- 7:20fuel to the fire? Exactly.
- 7:22Goolsby essentially argued that cutting into those conditions
- 7:25was unnecessary risk, akin to adding Field to a fire that was
- 7:29already burning hot, potentially reigniting asset inflation and
- 7:32speculation. And finally, the Orthodox hawk
- 7:35pressed Jeffrey Schmidt of Kansas City.
- 7:37What was his primary principled objection?
- 7:40Schmidt's objection was entirely about credibility and historical
- 7:43risk management. He voted to maintain rates,
- 7:46focusing laser like on the structural stickiness of service
- 7:49inflation, which he views as unacceptably high.
- 7:52His primary fear is the risk of D anchoring inflation
- 7:55expectations. The dreaded 1970s scenario.
- 7:58The darkest specter of monetary history, the 1970s stop go
- 8:01error, where premature easing forced the Fed to hike rates
- 8:04much higher later on, causing painful volatility.
- 8:07He does not want to repeat that mistake.
- 8:09So the central bank's decision was less a consensus view and
- 8:13more the fragile compromise between 1 faction screaming cut
- 8:17faster, the job market is collapsing, and another warning
- 8:20don't cut it all. You'll ruin credibility and
- 8:23reignite inflation. The implication for you, the
- 8:25learner, is profound. The predictable institutional
- 8:28unity that made the Fed a reliable market anchor is gone.
- 8:32Future FOMC meetings are now live, meaning they are genuinely
- 8:36unpredictable. Every data point matters.
- 8:38Now every income piece of data will be immediately weaponized
- 8:41by 1 faction or the other, drastically increasing market
- 8:44volatility and making the Feds future path inherently less
- 8:47stable. This instability is baked into
- 8:50the committee structure itself. That instability leaves us
- 8:53directly into the most shocking element of the meeting, the
- 8:56forward signal, the shock of the dot plot.
- 8:58If the 25 basis point cut was the gentle nudge, the dot plot
- 9:01was the central bank slamming the brakes on market
- 9:03expectations. Oh, it was a shock.
- 9:05The futures market had confidently priced in 75 to 100
- 9:08basis points of cuts for 2026. 75 to 100.
- 9:11Yeah, and the Summary of Economic Projections, or say, P,
- 9:15delivered a sharp, almost violent rebuke to that
- 9:17expectation. The median participant forecast
- 9:19projects the federal funds rate ending 2026 at 3.4%.
- 9:24Let's translate that 3.4% into plain English.
- 9:26For the market, that implies a target range of 3.25% to 3.50%.
- 9:32Given where rates are now, that signals only 125 basis point cut
- 9:37for the entire calendar year 2026.
- 9:39One cut for the whole year. That is a stunning contradiction
- 9:42to the dovish cut they just implemented.
- 9:44It's a fundamental declaration of the high for longer pivot by
- 9:47signaling rates will remain around 3.4% two years out.
- 9:51The Fed is fundamentally stating that the neutral rate, or start
- 9:54the theoretical interest rate that neither stimulates nor
- 9:57restricts the economy, is structurally above 3%.
- 10:00You're saying the zero rate world is over?
- 10:01They are telling the market that the era of near 0 rates is
- 10:04definitively over. This is a crucial long term
- 10:07revision of economic reality. But as we mentioned with the
- 10:11vote, the median often masks deeper, more dangerous
- 10:14divisions. The distribution of those dots
- 10:17reveals the instability that is now baked into the forward
- 10:19guidance. Let's look at the bimodal
- 10:22distribution. Yes, the dots didn't cluster
- 10:25around the median. They spread out wildly.
- 10:27Imagine the FOMC as a group engaged in a furious tug of war.
- 10:32The rope is the Fed funds rate on the hawkish wing.
- 10:35We had seven members projecting 0 cuts in 2026.
- 10:39Zero. They are the stop camp, pulling
- 10:41hard on the rope, believing 3.5 the year to 3.75% is the final
- 10:45destination and no further easing is required.
- 10:48And conversely on the dovish wing.
- 10:50We had eight members, a slight majority of the dissenters
- 10:52forecasting 2 or more cuts, aligning more closely with what
- 10:55the market had previously expected.
- 10:57And where's the middle? That's the key, the hollow
- 10:59center. Only four members projected the
- 11:01median path of exactly 1 cut. Think about that.
- 11:05The official consensus driven forecast of 1 cut is supported
- 11:08by only a tiny minority of the committee members.
- 11:11This forecast is not a stable center ground.
- 11:13It's a temporary point of compromise that almost no one
- 11:16genuinely believes in long term. So the volatility isn't just
- 11:19about waiting for data, it's about this structural fight.
- 11:23What is this tug of war mean practically for market action?
- 11:27It means that every subsequent data release will cause the
- 11:30market to violently swing. If the next employment report is
- 11:33unexpectedly strong, the market will immediately price in the 0
- 11:37cut scenario, meaning Treasury yields will jump and high growth
- 11:40stocks will suffer. And if it's weak?
- 11:42Conversely, if we see a collapse in consumer spending, the market
- 11:45will price in three or four cuts, expecting the 8 doves to
- 11:48win the day. This guarantee of sharp,
- 11:51unpredictable movement makes fixed income market instability
- 11:54in 2026 of virtual certainty. The hawkish nature of these
- 11:58dots, only one cut, must be justified by an aggressive
- 12:02economic outlook. Otherwise it makes no sense to
- 12:04cut now and then. Stop.
- 12:06What did the economic revisions in the SCE tell us?
- 12:09The Fed projected A surprisingly resilient economy.
- 12:12The most significant revision was the massive upgrade to the
- 12:142026 GDP growth forecast, moving it up significantly to 2.3% from
- 12:19the prior forecast of 1.8%. Wait 2. .3% growth is actually
- 12:24above the Fed's own long run potential growth estimate of
- 12:271.8%. That is robust growth.
- 12:30It is accelerating growth, and when you pair that accelerating
- 12:33growth forecast with an inflation forecast that is
- 12:36slowly declining, PCE inflation for 2020 26 is projected at
- 12:402.4%, still materially above the 2% target.
- 12:44You get the intellectual synthesis for the hawkish dots.
- 12:47So they're basically forecasting a soft landing plus or even a no
- 12:51landing scenario. That's it.
- 12:52A no landing implies the economy is growing robustly enough that
- 12:55it doesn't eat aggressive easing.
- 12:57If the economy is growing at 2.3% and inflation is sticky at
- 13:002.4%, there is no logical justification for a massive
- 13:05multi cut easing cycle. The GDP upgrade is the
- 13:08foundational pillar of the entire hawkish signal.
- 13:11But here's the transition challenge.
- 13:13This optimistic high growth forecast was built on incredibly
- 13:15shaky ground, leading us directly into the macroeconomic
- 13:18fog that dominated the decision room.
- 13:20That's right. We must appreciate that the
- 13:22context of the December decision was dictated by what we call the
- 13:26fog of the shutdown. The federal government shutdown
- 13:29delayed critical data releases, specifically the official Bureau
- 13:33of Labor Statistics non farm payrolls and the Consumer Price
- 13:36Index. So the body responsible for
- 13:38making the most consequential policy decisions was essentially
- 13:42flying blind, forced to make a judgement call without the
- 13:45primary indicators they usually rely upon.
- 13:48Precisely. Chair Powell himself analogized
- 13:50the situation to driving in the fog.
- 13:53When visibility is 0, you slow down and avoid sharp definitive
- 13:57turns. The 25 BP's cut was that slow,
- 14:00cautious move. It was the ultimate compromise,
- 14:03a slow, cautious move that placated the Doves who saw labor
- 14:06market risk while satisfying the Hawks who didn't want a reckless
- 14:0950 BP stimulus. They had to choose the path of
- 14:11least resistance until visibility improved.
- 14:14This meant they were forced to rely unusually heavily on
- 14:16alternative, less vetted data sources.
- 14:19They did. They became highly dependent on
- 14:22private reports, particularly the ADP National Employment
- 14:25Report, and the key data point that provided the catalyst for
- 14:29the CUT faction was the ADP report showing a loss of 32,000
- 14:33jobs in November. A negative number.
- 14:35A negative job print from ADP is a rare and ominous signal of
- 14:39contraction that the committee simply could not ignore, even
- 14:43without official BLS confirmation.
- 14:45So the labor market weakness was the emotional and rational
- 14:49catalyst for the Cut faction. It was the primary driver, the
- 14:52negative ADP print coupled with the persistent unemployment
- 14:55drift now sitting at 4.4 to 4.5% raise the Sam rule concerns that
- 15:00we discussed. The 25 BPS cut was an attempt to
- 15:03preempt a negative spiral. When Powell discussed the job
- 15:06market, he offered structural explanations beyond the cyclical
- 15:09slowdown. What did he mention that
- 15:10complicates the inflation picture?
- 15:12He pointed to a crucial structural note, reduced
- 15:14immigration. If the labor supply curve shifts
- 15:17left due to fewer workers entering the workforce, wage
- 15:20pressure can remain sticky even as job creation slows.
- 15:23The fewer jobs, but the people with jobs can still and higher
- 15:26wages. Exactly.
- 15:28This creates a difficult scenario where the job market is
- 15:31weakening, but wage inflation doesn't necessarily ease because
- 15:34the pool of available workers is shrinking.
- 15:37This structural nuance provides potent ammunition for the
- 15:39hawkish dissenters like Schmidt. Let's pivot to the other
- 15:43mandate, inflation. We keep hearing about the last
- 15:46mile problem. It's one thing to get inflation
- 15:48down from 9% to 3%, but apparently getting from 3% to 2%
- 15:53is the truly difficult part. Why is that final mile so hard?
- 15:57It is exponentially harder, and the Fed implicitly admitted this
- 16:00by projecting 2.4% PCE inflation for 2026.
- 16:04PCE not CPI. Remind us why they prefer PCE?
- 16:07PCE, or personal consumption expenditures better reflect
- 16:10structural changes in consumer behavior.
- 16:12It includes A broader, more weighted definition of services.
- 16:15And that's where the problem is. The stickiness is now
- 16:17concentrated in core services, housing, insurance, healthcare.
- 16:20Things that don't react quickly to rate hikes.
- 16:22Exactly. They're less sensitive to
- 16:24interest rate hikes and more sensitive to underlying wage
- 16:26growth and slowly adjusting contracts like rents.
- 16:30CPI tends to overstate housing inflation, whereas PCE is seen
- 16:34as a smoother, truer measure of where persistent inflation
- 16:37resides. So that final 1% of inflation,
- 16:40the last mile, is determined by the sticky, slow moving domestic
- 16:44cost that the Fed has less direct control over.
- 16:47Precisely. And this persistent stickiness
- 16:50is the entire intellectual sexual justification for the
- 16:53hawkish stance and the one cut signal.
- 16:55They fear that if they cut too aggressively while the final
- 16:58mile problem persists, they will simply cause demand to surge
- 17:00again, ensuring inflation settles permanently above the 2%
- 17:04target. We've established that the
- 17:06hawkish docks, only one cut, are predicated on an optimistic 2.3%
- 17:10GDP forecast. That kind of growth without
- 17:14inflation requires a powerful engine.
- 17:16Let's talk about the source of that optimism, the new
- 17:18productivity paradigm, AI and the neutral rate.
- 17:21The December meeting was truly noteworthy because Chair Powell
- 17:24explicitly tied the economy's resilience to structural
- 17:27productivity gains, linking the strength to the emerging impact
- 17:30of artificial intelligence. So he's suggesting that the
- 17:32underlying speed limit of the US economy, the maximum rate it can
- 17:36grow without generating inflation, is now higher.
- 17:39Exactly this resolves a long standing economic mystery known
- 17:43as the Solo Paradox. Economist Robert Solo famously
- 17:46quipped decades ago that you can see the computer age everywhere
- 17:50but in the productivity statistics.
- 17:51Right, all this tech, but no measurable productivity boost.
- 17:55For years, yes, but the Fed is suggesting that paradox is
- 17:58finally resolving thanks to generative AI and automation.
- 18:02If AI truly raises output per hour by say, 2% annually, then
- 18:07the long run potential GDP growth of the US economy is no
- 18:10longer the historical 1.8%, it moves up to perhaps 2.2 or 2.5%.
- 18:15The magic bean. It's the magic bean that allows
- 18:17the Fed to forecast 2.3% growth alongside slow falling
- 18:20inflation. Supply is keeping pace with
- 18:22demand. And this structural shift has
- 18:24massive monetary consequences, specifically for the neutral
- 18:27rate or R star. Can we take a moment to really
- 18:29breakdown R star for the learner?
- 18:32Absolutely. Think of the economy like a car
- 18:34on the highway R star. The neutral rate is the speed
- 18:37limit where the car is moving efficiently, neither
- 18:39accelerating nor hitting the brakes.
- 18:41It's the theoretical interest rate level where the economy is
- 18:44in perfect balance. So if the actual rate is above
- 18:47the R star, we're applying the brakes.
- 18:49If it's below R star, we're hitting the gas.
- 18:51Correct. Now with AI, the whole economic
- 18:54landscape has changed. If capital is suddenly more
- 18:57productive, meaning businesses get a better return on their
- 19:00investments thanks to AI efficiencies, then the natural
- 19:04non inflationary cost of that capital or the interest rate
- 19:07must rise. Why is that?
- 19:10Because businesses now have higher return opportunities, so
- 19:12they demand more investment capital, a higher interest rate,
- 19:15a higher R star is required to balance that increased demand
- 19:19for investment with the available National Savings.
- 19:22O AI driven productivity is the ultimate long term justification
- 19:26for the hawkish stands of keeping rates at 3.5%.
- 19:29That rate is no longer restrictive, it's simply the new
- 19:32normal neutral rate for a high growth, high productivity
- 19:34economy. It makes the high for longer
- 19:36strategy sustainable. It transforms it from a
- 19:39temporary crisis management mode into a structural fundamental
- 19:43economic reality. This is the intellectual
- 19:46conviction behind those seven Members who voted for zero cuts
- 19:49in 2026. This high level structural
- 19:52optimism is key, but let's look at the actual mechanics of what
- 19:56the Fed did. We need to turn our attention to
- 19:58stealth easing and political shadows.
- 20:01While the rate cut grabbed the headlines, a simultaneous
- 20:04balance sheet move was arguably just as critical.
- 20:08This is the stealth pivot. This takes us into the plumbing
- 20:11of the financial system, and it's critical for the learner to
- 20:13understand this because it affects market liquidity
- 20:15directly. The committee announced it would
- 20:17purchase $40 billion of Treasury bills in the first month.
- 20:21Wait, my understanding was that the Fed was engaged in
- 20:23quantitative tightening, or QT, which is supposed to be
- 20:26shrinking the balance sheet. Isn't buying assets the opposite
- 20:29of QT? Strategically, yes.
- 20:32Operationally, this move marks the effective end of the pure
- 20:35runoff phase of quantitative tightening.
- 20:38They are transitioning from actively shrinking the balance
- 20:41sheet to stabilizing it and even expanding it slightly through
- 20:44the purchase of short term T-bills.
- 20:46Why do this now? The stated goal is technical to
- 20:50maintain ample reserves within the banking system and manage
- 20:53cash flow in the repo market. As QT runs down the Feds
- 20:57liabilities, reserves can become scarce, which causes volatility
- 21:01in overnight funding markets. By buying T-bills, the Fed is
- 21:05injecting liquidity into the front end of the curve to keep
- 21:07that system smooth. But regardless of the technical
- 21:10justification, the strategic signal is clearly dovish
- 21:13accommodation. Absolutely.
- 21:15Injecting $40 billion a month into the system is a form of
- 21:19liquidity easing what many market observers immediately
- 21:22dubbed stealth QE. Even if the federal funds rate
- 21:24is held high at 3 point 50 percent, this liquidity supports
- 21:28risk assets. So it's easing financial
- 21:30conditions without having to commit to major headline rate
- 21:32cuts. It is, and by buying short
- 21:35duration Treasury bills, the Fed is putting direct downward
- 21:39pressure on short term rates, which serves as a sort of yield
- 21:42curve control light. It's easing the pressure without
- 21:45admitting they're easing policy. This entire complex decision was
- 21:49made, of course, under the enormous shadow of the incoming
- 21:52administration. Let's discuss the political
- 21:54economy aspect. The timing cannot be separated
- 21:57from the politics. President-elect Trump has been
- 22:00exceptionally clear about his desire for aggressive easing and
- 22:03a lower dollar. The dissent of Governor Steven
- 22:06Mirren for A50 BPS cut is the ultimate manifestation of this
- 22:09pressure. It brings politics right into
- 22:11the boardroom. It does.
- 22:12It uses the official voting record as a pressure point to
- 22:15pull the entire policy discussion toward immediate
- 22:18aggressive cuts. And chair Powell is now
- 22:20effectively a lame duck, with his term expiring in May 2026
- 22:25and reports suggesting Kevin Hassett has already been
- 22:27selected as his successor. That lame duck dynamic is
- 22:30crucial. It explains the institutional
- 22:33fragility we saw in the 9th 3 split.
- 22:36Powell's power to forge consensus is waning.
- 22:39Committee members who are positioning themselves for the
- 22:41next regime might learn more. Dovish.
- 22:44While the institutionalists are digging in their heels.
- 22:46Right. People like Schmidt are digging
- 22:48in their heels to defend the Feds independence against what
- 22:52they perceive as political interference.
- 22:54The stage is set for a major conflict in 2026, which
- 22:57economists call the problem of fiscal dominance.
- 23:01This is the inevitable collision course between monetary and
- 23:04fiscal policy. The incoming administration is
- 23:06proposing large fiscal stimuli, like the One Big Beautiful Bill
- 23:10Act, which requires substantial deficit spending.
- 23:13Traditionally, if the government is running massive fiscal
- 23:16expansion, the Fed should pursue monetary contraction to offset
- 23:19the inflationary impulse. So the Fed is accommodating the
- 23:22underlying economic strength at 2.3% GDP forecast, but is
- 23:27refusing the aggressive multi cut cycle that would effectively
- 23:30monetize that massive debt. Hence the one cut projection.
- 23:33It's a policy line drawn in the sand.
- 23:35Powell is signaling that the Fed will support underlying growth
- 23:38via productivity gains, but it will not become a subservient
- 23:42engine for printing money to fund large debt fueled fiscal
- 23:45programs. The fight over who dominates
- 23:47policy will be the most important narrative in 2026.
- 23:51Let's move to market reaction and asset allocation analysis.
- 23:54How did the sophisticated market process this confusing bundle of
- 23:58a cut, hawkish dots and stealth easing?
- 24:01It sounds like an internal contradiction that should cause
- 24:03paralysis. The market reaction was a
- 24:05complex study and selective hearing.
- 24:08It processed the conflicting signals, leading to highly
- 24:10nuanced trading patterns, not a simple up or down day.
- 24:13Let's start with the fixed income paradox.
- 24:15Despite the Fed explicitly telling the market we are only
- 24:18cutting once in 2026, Treasury yields fell.
- 24:21The two year yield dropped about 5 basis points to 3.56% and the
- 24:26benchmark 10 year yield fell to 4.16%.
- 24:29Why did bonds rally if the Fed was being hawkish?
- 24:32It's a classic case of the market betting against the Fed's
- 24:34own projections. There were three reasons.
- 24:37First, the 25 BPS cut itself confirm easing was active.
- 24:41Second, the Fed's own language about a weakening labor market
- 24:45sent bond investors flocking to safe havens.
- 24:48They believe the negative ADP job print is the real signal.
- 24:52So they think the Fed's going to have to cut more regardless of
- 24:54what they say now. They're convinced the Fed will
- 24:56blink. And the third reason is the $40
- 24:59billion T bill purchase program that structural demand for short
- 25:03term bonds creates immediate non cyclical demand and puts
- 25:07downward pressure on the front end of the curve.
- 25:10For the learner focused on fixed income strategy, where did this
- 25:13reaction push institutional money?
- 25:15Investors flock to the five year note, what we call the belly of
- 25:18the yield curve. It became the sweet spot.
- 25:21They are avoiding the long end due to inflation stickiness and
- 25:24avoiding the short end due to reinvestment risk.
- 25:26The five year note offers duration protection against a
- 25:29potential recession while insulating them somewhat from
- 25:32the sticky long term inflation outlook.
- 25:34Now let's look at equities. The Dow Jones Industrial Average
- 25:38rose 48% and the S&P 500 added .4%.
- 25:42Yet the NASDAQ was flat to down. That suggests very specific
- 25:46rotation, not a unified bull rally.
- 25:48It was a textbook cyclical rotation.
- 25:51The market cheered the confirmed 25 BPS cut and most importantly,
- 25:56the massive 2.3% GDP forecast upgrade.
- 26:00That robust growth forecast is extremely bullish for
- 26:03industrial, material and Financial stocks, the cyclicals
- 26:07that make up the Dow Jones Index.
- 26:08And why did the NASDAQ lag so conspicuously?
- 26:11Because of the higher for longer signal baked into the dot plot,
- 26:15the NASDAQ is packed with long duration assets companies whose
- 26:18expected earnings are projected far out into the future.
- 26:20Those future earnings are heavily discounted when interest
- 26:23rates are projected to remain high.
- 26:24So it hurts the valuation of non profitable or high growth tech
- 26:28stocks. It does.
- 26:29The market is shifting from growth at any cost to growth
- 26:32with present earnings. The market seems to be pricing
- 26:34in a nearly perfect outcome, high growth, managed inflation
- 26:37risk and rates that the economy can handle.
- 26:40But this soft landing narrative carries inherent valuation risks
- 26:43doesn't. It it absolutely does.
- 26:45When we look at valuations, the S&P 500 is trading near all time
- 26:49highs with valuations in the 96th percentile relative to
- 26:53historical norms. The soft landing plus the
- 26:56productivity narrative supports these lofty valuations, but it
- 27:00leaves virtually no margin for error.
- 27:02If any of the data points prove wrong, these high valuations
- 27:06could correct violently. And this is an environment where
- 27:09tracking total market temperature is crucial for
- 27:12prudent risk management. It really is.
- 27:15And Speaking of tracking that total market temperature, for
- 27:17those of you who want to monitor these high valuation levels
- 27:20against historical benchmarks, you can search and download the
- 27:23iOS app Buffett Indicator from the Apple App Store.
- 27:26It provides daily updates on one of those comprehensive market
- 27:29valuation metrics, helping you understand when the market might
- 27:32be priced for perfection. Understanding current valuation
- 27:35levels against historical norms is essential when the market is
- 27:38priced for perfection as it currently is under this soft
- 27:41Landing Plus narrative. We encourage you to download the
- 27:43Buffettt Indicator app to an ensure you are keeping an eye on
- 27:46that big picture market temperature.
- 27:48Moving to commodities in FX, gold and silver actually rallied
- 27:52into the decision, which seems counterintuitive if the global
- 27:55economy is heading for a new landing scenario.
- 27:58Gold and silver are acting as the ultimate hedge against
- 28:01policy error and institutional fragility.
- 28:04The 9 to 3 split vote creates massive policy error risk.
- 28:08If the Fed cuts too much and reignites inflation, gold wins
- 28:11as an inflation hedge. And if they cut too little and
- 28:14cause a recession? Gold wins as a safe haven.
- 28:16It's a policy agnostic wins scenario.
- 28:19They are betting on the uncertainty itself.
- 28:21And the US dollar index DXY edge lower, which also seems
- 28:26counterintuitive for a Fed that just signaled high for longer.
- 28:29A strong dollar usually follows A hawkish Fed.
- 28:32However, global risk on sentiment, the belief that the
- 28:35US cut signals global stability, weighed the dollar down.
- 28:38More fundamentally, the massive US twin deficits are a
- 28:41structural long term drag on the currency that even a relatively
- 28:44high rate can't fully counteract.
- 28:47We've covered the deep domestic complexities.
- 28:49Let's look at global implications.
- 28:51How does the Fed's hawkish cut radiate outward, forcing other
- 28:54central banks and global markets to react?
- 28:56The primary global impact is the immediate widening of the
- 29:00transatlantic divergent The European Central Bank has been
- 29:03cutting rates aggressively due to stagnation and near 0 growth
- 29:07in the eurozone. So the US is cutting but
- 29:10signaling a hard stop and structural strength, while
- 29:13Europe continues to ease aggressively because their
- 29:15economy is struggling. That divergent dramatically
- 29:18widens the interest rate differential between the USD and
- 29:21the EUR and more critically the productivity gap.
- 29:25The US, forecast to grow at 2.3% versus the Eurozone near 0%,
- 29:29will continue to attract global capital like a magnet, drawing
- 29:33it into U.S. dollar denominated assets.
- 29:35This inflow of capital sounds good for the US, as it keeps
- 29:38financial conditions looser than they might otherwise be.
- 29:41But what about emerging markets? For emerging markets, the
- 29:44initial 25 BP's cut was a brief relief.
- 29:47It lowers the cost of servicing dollar denominated debt,
- 29:50reducing immediate financial stress which is often a major
- 29:53concern for EM countries. But there's a long term risk
- 29:56baked into this specific decision, isn't there?
- 29:58Yes, the long term risk introduced by the December
- 30:01meeting is the Hassett risk, the prospect of a politicized Fed in
- 30:042026 operating under new administration guidance.
- 30:08The market fears that if the new leadership seeks a weak dollar
- 30:10policy to boost US exports and competitiveness, EMS could face
- 30:14extreme currency volatility. How would a politicized weak
- 30:18dollar policy hurt emerging markets?
- 30:20A sudden forced shift in U.S. policy aimed at dollar
- 30:23depreciation would cause massive and sudden capital outflows from
- 30:26EMS. This capital flight destabilizes their own domestic
- 30:29policy frameworks, drains their foreign reserves, and can
- 30:32potentially trigger financial crises.
- 30:35So while the 25 BPS cut was short term relief, the political
- 30:38uncertainty introduced massive long term uncertainty for the
- 30:41developing world. Time for our final synthesis.
- 30:44Pull together the findings of this deep dive for our learner.
- 30:47What did the December meeting truly mark in the broader
- 30:49cycling of monetary policy? The December 10th meeting marked
- 30:53the definitive end of the automatic phase of the easing
- 30:55cycle. The Fed is no longer operating
- 30:58under a simple cut until we hit 2% mandate.
- 31:01It has transitioned into a highly treacherous phase of fine
- 31:04tuning where the margin for error is virtually non existent.
- 31:07Let's distill the three key takeaways you must internalize
- 31:10from this deep dive. First, the bar for the next cut
- 31:13is now significantly higher. The Fed is likely to hold the
- 31:163.50 to 3.75% range, perhaps through the first half of 2026.
- 31:22They need overwhelming evidence, specifically confirmation of a
- 31:25severe labor market collapse, to move again. 2nd investors and
- 31:29economic planners must fully adapt to a high productivity,
- 31:32high rate regime. Right, The structural argument
- 31:35driven by potential AI gains means 3.50% is the new normal,
- 31:39the new SAR star, not an emergency setting.
- 31:42This favors assets tied to real, measurable growth over assets
- 31:46dependent solely on cheap leverage.
- 31:47And 3rd. And 3rd, the market is overtly
- 31:50betting the Fed's 2020 26 projections are wrong.
- 31:54The reaction in the bond market yields falling despite the one
- 31:57cut forecast shows deep skepticism that fundamental
- 32:01tension between the Fed's stated forecast and the markets
- 32:04conviction will be the driving volatility factor for 2026.
- 32:07So what does this all mean? Let's leave you with a final,
- 32:10provocative thought that ties all these threads together.
- 32:13The most dangerous signal from this meeting was not the
- 32:16interest rate itself or the dot plot, but the profound
- 32:19institutional fragility revealed by that 9 to three split vote.
- 32:23Right. A central bank relies on
- 32:24credibility and consensus to manage expectations and steer a
- 32:27massive economy. If that internal consensus
- 32:30continues to deteriorate, especially as Chair Powell
- 32:33officially becomes a lame duck and political pressure mounts,
- 32:36how will the Federal Reserve maintain its authority and
- 32:38legitimacy in the face of the next major unexpected economic
- 32:42shock? The committee will effectively
- 32:44be fighting itself while trying to fight the economic cycle.
- 32:48The question for 2026 is not if the Fed will be challenged by
- 32:51data inflation or the political sphere, but rather who will be
- 32:55leading the fight inside the Eccles building and whether they
- 32:58can ever stitch the consensus back together before the system
- 33:01fractures under pressure. That is a powerful and
- 33:04unsettling thought to chew on as we close out this deep dive.
- 33:08Thank you for walking us through these incredibly complex,
- 33:11conflicting signal. It was my.
- 33:12Pleasure and to all our learners out there, thank you for joining
- 33:15us and we'll see you on the next deep dive.