Latest / The PR Bunker / Seventy Colleges Gone: Larry Schall on Accreditation and What Families Should Look For
Transcript
- Don Martelli: Welcome back down to the PR Bunker Podcast. Today we are talking about the complicated, interesting, always in the news world of accreditation, college, university, longtime colleague, friend of mine, Dr. Larry Schall from NECHE, which we'll get to in a second. But Dr. Larry Schall, thank you for joining for the PR Bunker Podcast. Lawrence Schall: Happy to do it. Happy to do it. Don Martelli: been some quite some time since you and I caught up. you know, one, we'd love to have you introduce yourself to the audience here about the work you do at NECHE Lawrence Schall: Yeah. so I'm starting year seven as president of the New England Commission of Higher Education. We are our we date our roots back to 1885, the first quality assurance agency in the world. but have done you know that's a long time ago and things have changed a lot and we we continue to evolve and change and adapt and lead. so yeah, I lead a staff of twelve. and as we'll talk about later, we have it's probably several several thousand volunteers that really do the do the hard work. Don Martelli: Excellent. Tell us about your journey to NECHE. What what were you doing before this? Lawrence Schall: So finished college, went to law school, practiced law for almost a decade, and then ended up not by mistake, but sort of fortuitously in in higher education, wasn't not a plan, but spent 15 years as sort of the chief operating officer of a liberal arts college in Pennsylvania and then came down to Atlanta, Georgia, where I was president of a university for 15 years, and then Been here now for seven. So I for 30 years sat on the other side of the of the table, of the accreditation table where we were we were accredited, our universities were accredited by other other agencies. but yeah, delighted to be up here in New England. Don Martelli: Excellent. The the accreditation space, you know, I know it fairly well 'cause I've worked on education for quite some time. But for those that are listening that do not understand what that means and why it's important in today's day and age, would love to have you walk through it. Lawrence Schall: Yeah. So, you know, it began a hundred and fifty years ago or so as a sort of a way to this was back when it wasn't clear what the distinction was between secondary education and collegiate education. And it was a way to sort of Characterize that difference, both sort of qualitative and quantit quantitative. What what is a baccalaureate on undergraduate education look like and how's that distinguished from being in high school? over time, you know, I sort of think once that distinction was you know, you no longer need sort of needed to focus on that distinction are Mission has been to help institutions think about becoming better. We call it sort of continuous quality improvement, but then also sort of serve as the eyes and ears of the public to sort of certify that an institution that they think about attending or think about sending their sons or daughters to is of a quality worth, you know. worth joining. So it's we we do quality assurance work. and and we are there are a number of different entities that do this work. there's a group w that's called institutional accreditors. So we and that's what NECHE is we accredit the institution. So for example we accredit Harvard University and all the things that fall under Harvard their business school, their law school, their medical school, etc. Then there's a group of programmatic accreditors, specialized accreditors that in particular would look at. So there's a law school accreditor, there's a medical school accreditor, there's an engineering school accreditor. And they dive very deeply into a particular program, you know, look at the content of that program, usually tied into the to the profession. so that you know, they've got engineers trying to sort of determine. What's an appropriate engineering curriculum and how well is a school delivering that? We again we sort of accredit at the 30,000-foot level, we accredit the institution. And many of the institutions we accredit are not only have the institutional accreditation, but they, their law school has a separate accreditation, their medical school has a separate accreditation, their engineering school. Yeah. Don Martelli: Okay. Now in in the in the process, what does the you know, who who makes up the team that goes into a Merrimack univers college or Harvard University MIT? Well, who makes up that team and what are they particularly looking at? Lawrence Schall: Yeah, so the the you know, we we work globally and I'd say that among the things that distinguishes American higher education and the way that accreditation and quality assurance is done is that it's all it's not we are a non governmental five one C three. corporation. we are authorized by the federal government to do what we do, but we are non-governmental. In most countries the the quality assurance that's done of their higher education institution is done by the the state, is or, you know, done by the government in in this in the states, and this just again goes back 150 years, it was based on what we call a peer review system. So it is if we're sending a team of these are volunteers, we're sending a team to Bunker Hill Community College. We're putting a team together that has collectively has the expertise to sort of assess the quality of that institution. So we would have a Finance, chief financial officer from a like institution who understands the finances of an institution. We would have faculty or academic people who understand how curriculum is built and delivered. we'll have student services people that look at you know, the support that students get. people that focus on governance. Sometimes we'll have lawyers that go in that sort of understand how institutions are run. So we have We have five standards of quality. They're fairly broad. and when we send a team in, we'll we we'll we'll send a team of let's say five or six people in for the better part of a week that'll spend time before they go in. That the school has worked on a what we call self study that's they've worked on this for eighteen months to two years, trying to identify for themselves. What does the institution do well and where does the institution need to make improvement? And then the team takes that report and goes in to sort of verify based on conversations that they'll have when they go in with faculty and staff and students and trustees and administrators, as well as their own observations. What do they feel is supported by the evidence in that report and where Where might they add value in terms of bringing their experience? So it's a it's a peer-based process using volunteers from like institutions, sometimes in the same region, sometimes from different regions. And then we all report up to a commission. I work for the Commission of Higher Education, which is about somewhere around 30 members, again, all volunteers. Some of them representing the public, some of them representing institutions, but they come together five or six times a year to review the reports of the schools, the reports of the teams, and then to issue a decision about is the school worthy of being continued in accreditation? And if so, what does the commission think that the school's got is doing really well, and where are areas that we would like to see them improve, and then we have follow-up. Reports, follow-up visits to sort of check and see, make sure that the things that we've identified as areas of improvement are in fact being worked on. Don Martelli: Now how would you you know, you know, we're in New England, right? There's a a ton of colleges that have the the brand recognition and you know some colleges are you know still here, some aren't. How would you pulse sort of the state of just the collegiate experience for those that you know are wondering, you know. Is community college the avenue to go? Do I send my kid to school for seventy grand a a year? I mean, what's the current state? 'Cause when you and I started working together years ago, things are much different. They're much different than they were a year ago. Things have changed, put it that way. But these universities and colleges are still here and I've got two kids, one gone through it, one just about go through it. Wonderful experiences and they're better human beings because of it. But there's a narrative out there. But I you know, you are in the trenches every day. What it would be the current state of a university experience and college experience look like these days? Lawrence Schall: Yeah, I think so w one thing that I think the like the press in particular when they sort of talk about higher education, they tend to talk about it as it's like one thing. And then they and the one thing they tend to focus on is, you know, the the name brand schools, the schools that, you know, Harvard and MIT and Yale and Dartmouth and Williams and Amherst, you know, these very high, you know, sticker price. $100,000, very selective institutions, you know, taking a f accepting a fraction of the students that apply. And that, you know, people, that's sort of what the the press tends to when they talk about higher education, those are the schools they tend to write about. One thing I think it's not unique to New England, but I think one thing that is, you know, particularly special about New England is this sort of extraordinary diversity of institutions. That have been around, you know, some for 400 years. four-year institutions. Some are public, some are private. Even on the public side, you've got, you know, the flagship and there's a flagship institution in every state, UMass Amherst in Massachusetts. But then there are also four-year public regionals that are not as selective, still provide, I think, a extraordinary education at a reasonable price. For Massachusetts residents. and then on the public side, you've got two-year community colleges that you know, and and we accredit dozens and dozens of those across the six New England states. in some states like Massachusetts, that community college is free. and partly as a result of that legislative change, they've seen Collectively and individually, a huge growth in enrollment at a time when most private schools aren't seeing that. Then in New England, you've got this sort of spate of small, private, independent institutions, many of which I didn't I didn't even know the name of when I got up here. You know, 500 students, a thousand students, 1,500 students. 250 students. some of them religiously founded and and continue with a religious mission. That's I think in the New England's got a lot of those. some specialized art schools, music schools, pharmacy schools, some just some undergraduate with graduate programs, some graduate only. We accredit a master's. Degree granting program, 18 students a year they bring in. been around a very long time in landscape in sort of landscape design, you know, very sort of focused specialized. And it's so for you know, every family and every student, there's this extraordinary, just if you just think about New England, but let alone New England, you could think about the country and you can think about the globe. This is an extraordinary choice of institutions. All with different missions, all with different price points. some provide a sort of general education, a liberal arts education, some again more career focused, some focus particularly on s a single career. so and I think that's and yeah, and they go from literally free to you know north of a hundred thousand dollars. as a sticker price. people I think also don't really understand, you know, you you see these stories in the paper about, you know, Harvard now costs more than $100,000 to go to. vast majority of Harvard students aren't paying $100,000. The the the scholarship, the financial aid, both on the sort of merit side and and need-based side is is extraordinary again across the enterprise. So you know, there's this story that, you know, is college worth it? Well, if you look at the data, over a lifetime of earnings, colleges college is very very much Has a c has a terrific return on investment. you see, sometimes you see the stories about people taking out, you know, $150,000 of loans to go to an undergraduate college. There's probably a few of those people. There's no need to do that. you know, you've got lots of options, but people who choose who, you know. knowingly choose that. that you know it's a choice people make. We people have free choice here. But say I I I think even the people that sort of say, you know, boy, is college worth it, what do they do? Where are their kids going? Their kids are going to college. You know, and yeah, you get, you know, one out of every fifty million kids start some successful enterprise and but yeah. I Don Martelli: Love it. Lawrence Schall: yeah. Don Martelli: Well, I mean, because of the diversity in the experiences and costs, I mean, there is some consistency on what a accredited school provides in terms of an experience, right? So if you're speaking to you know, you and I had this conversation when my kids were still in grammar school, like what what are the th what things that, you know, parents and families are looking at in terms of that that next ex experience for their for their kid? Again, for the the free free community college to the Harvards. What what are the consistent things regardless of the experience that an accrediting body like you all are looking at and making sure exists. So regardless of the experience they they go into, that, you know, that value is there in one way, shape, or form that you all kind of, you know, take a look at it, make sure that's controlled. Lawrence Schall: So among the things that we we look at, we certainly look at what we sort of say inputs. Do they have quality faculty, do they have appropriate facilities, et cetera, et cetera? But increasingly we actually look at outcomes. What are their what are the graduates, what are the what's the rate of graduation? How many students are graduating? How long does it take them to graduate? And then what are they doing afterwards? and if you look again across our schools. there's very, very few programs, very, very few institutions that you could point to that say, you know, there's not that the the return on investment isn't there. you know, I think one of the unfortunate things that's happened over time, I mean, when universities and colleges got started, it was generally seen as Part of the value was you creating an informed citizenry who's you know, able to sort of distinguish between Things that are true and things that are not true, that are active in their community, that vote, that step up the leadership positions. There was that sense that going to college was just not about earning money, not about necessarily your first job, but more broadly speaking, about creating a healthy citizenry and a healthy country, a healthy democracy. Over time, and I think there's a lot of reasons for this, but over time, I think college is seen more as you go to college to so that when you get out you make money. And in particular, you you get out to make money in your first job. And so this it cycles at times with people, you know, it's like, well, if you majored in business at some point, you had an undergraduate degree in business, that was your pathway to work. then it was a period where now if you majored in IT, that was your pathway to work. The reality is that given the speed of change in the economy, that the most important skill you you you get from going to college is not necessarily being trained in a particular discipline, but learning how to think, learning how to problem solve, learning how to pivot. Learning how to work with others. and then it's those it's those so sort of softer skills or the skills that end up serving you well because, you know, my father, first job at a law school was basically his job. You know, he worked for forty years doing pretty much the same thing. Today, somebody getting out of college, by the time they're out ten years, they've probably been in Seven, eight, nine jobs. And very likely that the job they're in in their tenth year has no relationship to what they majored in or no relationship what their first job is. But I think that those the students that are most successful go to places that are that again focus on learning, the love of learning, continuous learning. In those soft skills of how do you how you work with other people? how do you solve problems? How do you develop the sort of the the work the work a work ethic? yeah, so it's interesting. Like right now you you know, it's not that long ago. It that's like it you should major in computer science. And now, you know, that's like five years ago, three years ago. Now it's like, no, that's the worst thing you could major in. Yeah. So and you know, Don Martelli: Yeah. Exactly. Yeah. AI. Mm-hmm. Yep. Lawrence Schall: AI is, you know, it's gonna be Now you got schools creating these programs in AI. You'd be you'd be better off. Teaching students how to think because the you know, it it's what you're gonna learn in a in an AI program is maybe useful for at the moment. Don Martelli: It'll it'll change the day you enter into classroom for sure. Now now Lawrence Schall: Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Don Martelli: going back to obviously I couldn't agree with you more. I for me when my kids were deciding where to go to school, it didn't matter to me. It was really about their experience and to learn those particular things. And like you can see accreditation, you can see where the kids go off to work and how much money they make, you see those tangible benefits. But the things that were important to us were those some of those soft things, like understanding how to work through conflict and build those soft skills. I mean, how does NECHE as an accrediting institution Like look at those softer categories such as, you know, problem solving and learning. Is is it what's that look like? Lawrence Schall: So one of the things we do is that we require every one of our institutions, whether it's a two-year school or four-year school, whether it's a engineering school or li liberal arts school, is to have one third of the courses that every student must take have to be in what we call general education. So not in your you can be a business major, and that's what you know, but you need to be taking history courses and art courses and politics courses so that you again you come out not only with you know a particular sort of hard set of skills in a in a major, but you come out broadly educated and well educated. And then as you said, we we when our teams go in, again we're looking at the whole support system for students. So not just what they're getting in classroom, but the support they're getting outside of classroom and the interaction they're having in the business community, doing internships, you know, being exposed to sort of to work, you know, while they're in school. so yeah, I I I think certainly the vast majority of our of our schools, again, whether whether they're focused on something like engineering or pharmacy, or business also understand that those graduates, you know, are gonna progress through a normal career path where they, you know, they're a worker, then then they're a manager, then they may be a leader. That it's those it's that broad education and soft skills that that matter more than, you know, some some particular course they took in marketing back when they were 19. Don Martelli: Yep. And no those marketing classes are useless, trust I've been set in all of them. it's funny 'cause, you know, y you're you're it's such an important time frame for a young person's life and that you're looking you when you're when you're buying, you're looking at all the things that you can digest, you can understand, that that you can quantify. But it's those two kind of soft categories. It's that those soft skills, being a a good adult, a good human being. And the second thing is sort of that campus experience, right? I'll never forget when my oldest went to Merrimack, just the first school that she visited, and she went to dozens of other schools, but she kept going back to the campus and just the feeling she had when she stepped onto campus. So what's from your perspective, you know, as families are, you know, obviously when the cycle starts again, as families are entering, going to different campuses, what's something that, you know, they can see or an example of that families will see on campus that means that this is a school that's Heading in the right direction, doing the right things, credited and it's creating an environment that's suitable for all the things you're talking about. What's what's some of those physical experiences look like? Lawrence Schall: Well first probably important to know that the majority of students that are in college now are not at a residential college. So that you know that that sort of four year residential experience, which I think is, you know, is an extraordinarily important experience, it's a minority of students that are able to access that prim primarily because of cost, but not not not only because of cost. and then there's also, you know, I think just a significant number of people that are in college that are working and in college. and so they don't just have that luxury of taking four years off and, you know, not bringing money in, but you know, having money go out. you know, it it I mean, I have four kids and have been through this now four you know, four times. one of my four didn't go to school and he's very he's a skilled carpenter and making a good living and I you know, I wouldn't discourage people from going into those trades, those, you know, you know, being a carpenter or plumber or electrician that, you know, they're not those they're not going away. Don Martelli: Not these days, especially the electricians, I mean and the plumbers. I they're building data centers Lawrence Schall: Yeah. Yeah. Don Martelli: and those jobs are gonna be here for a while. Lawrence Schall: Yeah. So gen you know, I I I generally try to sort of s say to my kids it you know, it when you did a school visit You know, who your tour guide was, and for my boys, like, was she cute or not cute? And for my, you know, it's like, and what was the weather? You know, it's a little hard to ignore those things. Don Martelli: How was the food? Lawrence Schall: But it's really just you know, it's do you have a sense that the people there about you and care about your success? And Don Martelli: Yeah, that's big. Lawrence Schall: my oldest son went to a you know, very high end but big public big public university out of state. Didn't do very well for the first two years when he and I would say so, Like who who reached out to you? When they sort of saw like you weren't going to class and you were you know, and he's like, No one reached out to me. You know, it was like, you know, that's you know, and I I Yeah. Don Martelli: Red flag. Red flag. Lawrence Schall: Yeah. And I I think that's probably a r a rare situation. It may have been people did reach out and he was playing basketball and playing his guitar and never picked up you know, never looked at his email, but he ended up going back and he took a year off and ended up doing really well. But Yeah, I think it's a s you you want to go to a place where people are invested in you and that you know, that can be a residential college, can be a community college, Don Martelli: Got it. No, I agree. I agree. I f we felt that way with our kids as well. What about as we pivoted towards the end, what's what are some of the challenges coming up for university presidents and those that lead these schools and families considering sending their kids to school? What what's what's on the horizon that that you 'cause clearly you're in a space where you're thinking six, twelve, nineteen, eighteen months ahead. What are those challenges looking like? Lawrence Schall: Yeah, so in New England as again, we had five of our schools closed last year. Small independent schools. some closed literally just closed their doors, some became part of another institution. But if you go back it's now twenty-six years, if you go back to the year two thousand and you looked at our roster of institutions. And you compare it to the roster of institutions today, the first thing you'd see is 70 institutions that were on our roster 26 years ago aren't on our roster today. And these are all New England institutions. Some public, some private. some of them because they closed, some of them because they became part of another institution, some of them because mostly on the public side. We used to accredit 12 community colleges in Connecticut. They're now one institution with 12 campuses. So we but you know the demographics in New England are a killer. There's just fewer and fewer people graduating high school. There's fewer kids, there's fewer people being born. 18 years ago, fewer people graduate in high school. and the infrastructure across all our institutions was built to handle X number of students and now there's not X number of students. So you know, that's something we're very focused on and and intent on. We know schools are gonna close trying to help them and their students close gracefully. So that's one big issue. The other thing that you've s you know, when If go back to, you know, before twenty twenty four, before this presidential election, there was this thing called Project 2025, which was a hundreds of hundred many hundred page document prepared by people who ended up in the current administration with the idea of sort of remaking like the world. But there was a section on remaking higher education and a section on re within that remaking accreditation. And One thing that I, you know, completely credit the administration for is that they told us what they were gonna do, and they're doing it. It's like there was no stealth here. They were very clear about it. and so in the sort of higher education space, you see really important research, research dollars being closed down, stripped away. You're seeing the significant sort of portion of i international students that chose to come to the United States being barred from coming. you're seeing sort of the attempt to I think one of the strengths of the American higher education system was the autonomy of institutions, largely, not completely autonomous, but largely autonomous, free to have their own mission and created education that aligned with that mission. and there's always been attempts from both states and federal government to sort of push and encourage certain policies, but nothing like we've seen in the last two years. So there there's there's an a there's an agenda that's got the federal government more more engaged with higher education than it has been more and more On accreditation side, there's a whole new set of regulations coming out November 1, which are trying to sort of tell accreditors these are things we want you to look at, these are things we don't want you look at. and generally, not surprisingly, the things they want you to look at are things that are sort of aligned with their political ideology, and things they don't want you to look at are things that would institutions might choose to do something that's not consistent with that ideology. So it's that. It's a big challenge for us, but that all trickles down to institutions in terms of what they've what they're required to do, what they're forbidden for did forbidden to do. Yeah, and so it's it's a it's of concern to all of us, I think, and sort of see Don Martelli: Mm-hmm. Lawrence Schall: how it plays out. But it's as I said, they were, you know, there's a lot of transparency here. It wasn't, you know, they were very clear up front. This is what we're doing. And they even use the term we're, you know, we're we're gonna we're using accreditors as this sort of agent of change. We're we we think we we g we can force accreditors to push things down to institutions. that's You know, that's sort of the biggest lever they have, so that's that's where they're headed. Don Martelli: Yeah, they were pretty overt about that for sure. as we wrap up here, pivot to you real quick. out of all the things you can do in higher education because of your experience, you know, the legal profession, you know, it's been seven years. What do you still enjoy about the work? Showing up every day and doing this work? Lawrence Schall: Yeah, I mean I get you know, I spent thirty years on campuses and I that's that was sort of the best part of of of of of, you know, working at an institution, sort of being being on a campus, being around students. we've been fortunate Starting five, six years ago, we used to be what we called a regional accreditor. So in the in the states, we were limited to accrediting institutions in one of the six New England states. those rules changed six years ago, and so we are now accrediting institutions across the United States, and institutions are free to choose their own accreditors. So we've had maybe two dozen institutions outside. New England in New York and Florida, Missouri, and Arizona, want to come to be accredited by us. And so I get to do those visits. So I end up spending a lot of time getting to know those folks. I just came back from a law school in Charleston. that's in the process of of seeking our accreditation. And then we've always been able to Accredited institutions outside the United States, although that was a pretty small part of what we did. But we've now, since I've been here, we we had 11 independent institutions outside the United States as as members. When I came, we now have 20, and we have another 20 that we're working with. So in December I'm spending a week in Thailand. There's four four institutions in Thailand that are going through. Our accreditation, we're in, we're all over the Middle East, we're in Western Europe, we're in Sub-Saharan Africa, we're in India for the first time, we're in Canada for the first time. And so I I I I'm fortunate to get to do those initial visits. So I'm on the road a lot. and I think some of the most interesting things happening in higher education are happening not in the United States, but happening outside the United States. So we can we bring that. I think that value, that innovation, entrepreneurship that we're seeing outside the United States into into the Commission, exposing that to our institutions. yeah, so that's you know, we deal with a lot of rules and regulations and reports and I gotta do all that, but I I in my position I have the I have the good fortune to be able to get on an airplane and and see something new. Don Martelli: Absolutely. And the fact that you're able to, you know, bring those key learnings from, you know, one college to another, from another country to the US and vice versa. 'cause oftentimes people I've been through the accrediting process working for schools with the past and it's this fear, but not realizing that the accrediting partner is a partner here to support and help and drive change and make sure checks and balances are there. But bringing in those best practices, I think, is probably one of the most underrated element in your work that is really ever talked about. So I'm glad you brought that up. It's good stuff. So Larry, you one, thank you for joining the PR Bunker Podcast. I could talk to you all day because this stuff is fascinating. keep up the good work. again, I've had nothing but good experiences in the colleges I work with, in the school the schools my kids have gone to. Love watching from afar and seeing you in the media from time to time on these particular topics. but thank you for joining the PR Bunker podcast. It's been a pleasure. Lawrence Schall: Happy to do it, Don. Don Martelli: Absolutely. When people can learn more about NECHE, where can they do that? What's the website address? Lawrence Schall: so it's NECHE.org. It's got some letters before that, I guess. But if you just look up N-E-C-H-E, I also do a blog called NECHE on the Road. And we Don Martelli: Nice. Lawrence Schall: just published, I think, our hundredth entry based basically Don Martelli: Very cool. Lawrence Schall: on my visit so that people people would enjoy that. Don Martelli: Remember when we we talked about that concept, I don't know how long ago that I think my kids were still in grammar school when we had that concept. But I I'm glad one, congratulations to sticking with that 'cause it content is an easy thing to do, but it's the consistency that's the hardest. And after you get to a hundred episodes and you're out traveling the world, so you're it's just that natural content is always pretty pretty cool to grab and tell that story from the inside out. So I'm glad you're sticking with it. And I agree, folks, if you're listening and want to follow the space, follow literally on the road in all his travels, the content's good. and everything else. So Larry, again, appreciate you joining me. Lawrence Schall: Thank you. Don Martelli: You're welcome.