Latest / Bourbon Bytes Podcast / Willett Pot Still Reserve Review: Does Cask Strength Fix This Bourbon?
Transcript
- 0:00Today on the Bourbon Bytes podcast, a 20 year old whiskey for about 50 bucks,
- 0:05then we have the new Barrell New Year 2027 and Stranahan's Mountain Angel 14,
- 0:11plus I have a byte-sized review of the new Willett Pot Still cask strength!
- 0:28Hello everyone and welcome back to the Bourbon Bytes Podcast. I'm your host Clifton and this
- 0:34is the week of Thursday, November 12th, 2026. So last month I talked about this brand new release
- 0:41from Willett where they were putting their Pot Still Reserve at cask strength. And there was
- 0:46some speculation, is this going to save the brand? Because a lot of us out there that drink bourbon
- 0:51for a while know that Willett Pot Still Reserve is not much more than just a fancy bottle on the
- 0:57shelf. Well, now that it's being released at cask strength, I've been curious to see if this is
- 1:02really giving this whiskey the boost that it needs to actually be a respectable bourbon. So
- 1:08I'm very excited for a chance to try it here on the podcast. As soon as I saw this hit the shelves
- 1:12in my area, I knew I had to pick it up and give it a try for you guys. But before we pour the Willett,
- 1:18we do have some news stories to talk about from across the whiskey industry. Some of these you
- 1:23guys brought up to me on our Discord server. Others I just saw hit the newswire this month.
- 1:29But most of all, I just want to share my thoughts with you guys on what's going on in the world of
- 1:34whiskey this week. And the first two stories are big comebacks, Stoli in the U.S. and the Nelson
- 1:41Brothers in Nashville. So a few of you brought this up on the Discord server. Like I said,
- 1:48there was a whiskey wash story about Stoli coming back to the U.S. and some people were wondering,
- 1:53does this mean things like Kentucky Owl are back too? So while Stoli announced on November 9th
- 1:59that they had reached a settlement after their Chapter 11 bankruptcy, they did say that markets
- 2:05will depend on distribution. And they only really named two whiskeys with this announcement,
- 2:10Writer's Tears and The Irishman. Now, if you remember back in 2024, both Kentucky Owl and
- 2:16Stoli filed for Chapter 11. And while there's a long list of brands being part of this announcement,
- 2:22Kentucky Owl is not one of them. So I wouldn't take this as news about there being another
- 2:27Kentucky Owl release anytime soon. Now, what's interesting is their chief commercial officer
- 2:32said, our products are already here. They say they already have stock in the U.S. based in their
- 2:37bonded warehouses. So local availability can vary depending on the market. So while the future of
- 2:43Kentucky Owl still is up in the air, it is nice to see that some of these products will start
- 2:47making their way back into the market. Now, over in Nashville, the people coming back are the guys
- 2:54whose name are already on the bottle. Again, thank you guys for sharing this on Discord.
- 2:59This is a really cool announcement. This is from Nelson's Green Brier Distillery,
- 3:03and they're actually buying back the brand from Constellation Brands. So Constellation took a
- 3:09minority stake in the brand back in 2016, ended up taking a majority control in 2019, and then full
- 3:15ownership in 2024. Well, now Andy and Charlie Nelson have bought back the brand and have full
- 3:21ownership of it again. Now, it's interesting because they previously bought back the Belle Meade
- 3:27portion of the brand. They actually bought that back a while ago, but the distillery itself and
- 3:32the actual Tennessee whiskey that they were making wasn't really part of their lineup again until
- 3:38right now. Some of you have noticed that Belle Meade has started returning to the older variable
- 3:44cask strength versions, which is great to see. I've always been a fan of Belle Meade. I've not seen
- 3:49it on the shelves in a long, long time, or if I have, I just haven't noticed it. But I'm excited
- 3:54to see Nelson's Green Brier going back to a family brand. I think it's really interesting to see
- 3:59these big conglomerates starting to break down and sell off their distilleries. I mean, I'd rather
- 4:06see them sell them back to the owners who created it than just close them down or just so many other
- 4:11things that could go wrong. I think this is a win for this brand, so we'll see what they have to
- 4:16bottle, but I'm very, very excited for the future of the brand to be back in their hands. Now, I
- 4:22teased this in the intro, but I thought this was pretty cool. Now, Black Velvet, who is known for
- 4:26their blended Canadian whiskey, actually caught my eye with this new product. It is a 20-year-old
- 4:31Legacy Blend coming in at 90 proof, 700-milliliter bottle, and about $50 US. Normally, I wouldn't give
- 4:40this brand a time of day, but seeing an age statement like this reminds me of some of the
- 4:45great highly aged Canadian whiskey I've had over the years. I mean, just recently, I gave that J.P.
- 4:51Weiser's 23-year a 9 out of 10 on the podcast, but that was at cast strength. I'm pretty excited to
- 4:58see this hit the market. I think it's good to see more highly aged or higher proof Canadian whiskey
- 5:03in the US in general, and a brand like Black Velvet kind of gets a bad rap for its budget-friendly
- 5:10options. I would love to give it a try and see if this really does stand out as a premium whiskey
- 5:16from their brand. Now, speaking of interesting blends, Barrell has just announced their New Year
- 5:232027 release. I've always been a fan of these. Some of them have won some of my favorite whiskeys
- 5:27of the year, so every time I hear about one of these, I get very, very excited. This is the 11th
- 5:33annual edition of Barrell New Year. It's comprised of seven different states whiskies from 5 to 16
- 5:40years old and bottled at cask strength. Now, retail on it's going to be about $85,
- 5:45and it's funny because the variety of whiskey in here is pretty crazy. So some of the whiskey is
- 5:51five-year-old distillate from Texas and Ohio, while they have some 13-year-old Wyoming whiskey
- 5:56and a 16-year-old Tennessee whiskey. I think it's fun because I feel like it really does celebrate
- 6:02all the great whiskey coming out of the U.S. We're really getting a wide breadth of different
- 6:08whiskeys, and sometimes these work together really, really well. Now, I know that the cask strength
- 6:14varies depending on the bottle. I'm seeing some people review it for 116.6 proof, while other
- 6:20people mention it's 115.34. So there is some discrepancy. I think it's just different batches
- 6:25of this particular release, but I'm still very, very excited to get my hands on a bottle like
- 6:31I am every year. So while the barrel release is seven states in one bottle, Stranahan's in Denver
- 6:38moved one malt whiskey through three different barrels. So we've got a lot of fun experimental
- 6:44blending happening in the news today. This is the announcement of Stranahan's Mountain Angel 14.
- 6:50It's their oldest release to date. So this whiskey started as a 10-year-old American single malt in
- 6:56new charred oak barrels. It then spent three years and three months in cognac casks, then an
- 7:02additional nine months in Hungarian Tokaji wine casks. Now, the Tokaji cask is what caught my attention
- 7:08because I previously reviewed a Yellowstone whiskey that used this cask, and I really liked
- 7:13what it did to the whiskey. So I'm really curious to see what it's going to do to a single malt
- 7:17that's already spent over 10 years in new American oak, and then three years in cognac cask. I feel
- 7:23like that's going to be a very complex single malt, and I'm 100% here to give it a try. Now,
- 7:29proof of it's going to be 94.6 proof. Retail is going to be about $130. And luckily, California
- 7:36is going to be one of the first markets that gets this bottle. So I'll be sure to pick it up if I
- 7:40see it on the shelves and let you know what I think of it. A little bit high in cost, but again,
- 7:44considering it's a 14-year-old American single malt, we rarely see whiskey that old that's not
- 7:50bourbon or a rye whiskey. So I'll be picking it up if I see it. If you guys tried it, let me know
- 7:56what you think. All right, well, before we get into our Byte-Sized Review, there's a barrel pick
- 8:00story that I think some of you might be into. So 15 Stars is announcing their new private selection
- 8:07program, and they're opening it up to six to 10-year-old Kentucky bourbon barrels available
- 8:13to retailers, restaurants, and private groups. Now, they're including both weeded and rye recipe
- 8:19bourbons, and each of them are going to be released at Cask Strength with minimum filtration
- 8:23to remove the barrel char. Again, I've not had 15 Stars personally, but I've heard some really great
- 8:29stories from other whiskey reviewers. I know Perry at This is My Bourbon Podcast has reviewed
- 8:33quite a lot of their products and really enjoys what they're putting out. I would love a chance
- 8:38to try it, but it's great to see that they are releasing these single barrels from six to 10
- 8:42years old and at Cask Strength. Now, I've not quite done a barrel pick on my own, which we've talked
- 8:47about here on the channel every now and then. It keeps coming up. I absolutely would love to do one.
- 8:53I just would have to find a way to, one, find a local distributor to be able to get that out to
- 8:57people, or two, just partner with another content creator or a local store, maybe go halfsies on a
- 9:04pick. Again, I would love to do it. The logistics of it kind of gives me a lot of anxiety, so maybe
- 9:10one day I will do a pick. I love being parts of picks. I did one with Jason from The Mash & Drum
- 9:15that was fantastic. It was a Jack Daniels pick, and I know there's been a few other people who
- 9:19have asked me to be parts of pick. I love helping people do a pick, but to do an official Bourbon
- 9:24Bytes pick, I would love to. It's just, I don't know. I just don't have those local connections
- 9:29to make that possible. But if you do, reach out to me. Contact at bourbonbites.com. Let's make it happen.
- 9:36All right. Well, with that being said, I may not have a barrel for you, but I do have a bottle
- 9:40to review. Let's go ahead and get to our Byte-Sized review. All right. Like I teased at the top of the
- 9:53podcast, this is a bottle that a lot of you guys have seen on the shelves and honestly ignored.
- 10:00So this is Willett Pot Still Reserve. It's constantly known as one of the prettiest bottles
- 10:06with one of the worst whiskeys. And I'm not saying that from personal experience. I have reviewed this
- 10:12on the channel and I thought it was okay. But a lot of people hate on this bottle. So when I saw
- 10:18they released a cask strength release for around $65, I had to pick it up and give it a try to let you
- 10:24guys know, is it worth it at this proof at this price? Now, while there's no age statement on
- 10:30this release, we do know that it's mash bill is 65% corn, 20% wheat, and 15% barley. It did enter
- 10:38the barrel at 115 proof and this release is 120 proof. So of course it gained some proof points in
- 10:45the barrel. So we're going to see if this helps solve the problem of it just being very thin
- 10:49and very bland of a bourbon. Let's go and get it poured and then give it a nose. Now, whether or
- 10:56not you could hear that, I will say this has a really fun glug, glug, glug when you pour it with
- 11:01that long neck. It definitely feels like you're doing a little bit of some old science experiments
- 11:06here. All right. Well, the first thing I get on the nose is a bit of a like cinnamon brown sugar
- 11:12thing. You know, it almost reminds me of a Ambarana cast whiskey. Those to me always give
- 11:18a Cinnamon Toast Crunch note. This isn't as extreme, but it does have some of those reminiscent
- 11:23elements to it. A little bit darker though, definitely more of a molasses than a typical
- 11:28sugar, but man, it almost tickles my nose with those baking spice and cinnamon notes. It's very,
- 11:33very baking spice forward. Not too much oak. Um, it's definitely a little bit perfumey,
- 11:38a little bit like very, very sweet cream cheese kind of note. Um, a little bit tart,
- 11:44a little bit sour, but overall very, very pleasant. The tartness is a little bit of a citrus zest
- 11:49kind of element to it. I would maybe guess lemon zest, but that's just because it's really
- 11:53triggering like my, my nasal passages. It makes me almost want to sneeze, but it's a good, it's
- 11:58really good nose, especially for a fall whiskey. So let's go ahead and give it a taste and see how
- 12:04it holds up. Cheers. Hmm. Okay. More or less the same in terms of flavor profile. It's still very,
- 12:12very like cinnamon sugar. I would say a little bit more on the sugar category than the sentiment on
- 12:17the palate. It goes very sweet, almost like the same sensation of putting like a spoonful of sugar
- 12:22on your tongue. It kind of has that same sensation when it hits your palate.
- 12:26I will say the cast strength does help out with the viscosity. It doesn't feel as thin
- 12:31as the regular release. It does carry some body with it. And I do appreciate that. Surprisingly,
- 12:36it has some of those mineral qualities that I typically get on a Tennessee whiskey. And while
- 12:42it's sweet up front, the mid-palate kind of lingers in this kind of savory umami kind of territory.
- 12:48It's not like Oak or, you know, age that I'm getting there. I can't quite put a finger on
- 12:53what's giving me that sensation. It kind of feels a little bit like a salty licorice kind of thing
- 12:58happening mid-palate and finish. I would say it's a medium to long finish. It's actually
- 13:03feels like an improvement over the small batch all across the board. But I think people who have
- 13:08major faults with the small batch release might still find some faults with this as well. One,
- 13:14it doesn't necessarily taste old. While it's not super sweet, like some young whiskeys are,
- 13:19it doesn't really have that oaky backbone that I really love in a well aged product,
- 13:24especially from Willett, because we know they know how to make a good aged bourbon. I was really
- 13:30hoping to find some of those like tart zesty notes that I got on the nose. I feel like that
- 13:34rounds out a wheated bourbon. I think, you know, I look for maybe a little bit of like an orange
- 13:38twist note on it. This doesn't have it. It does finish nice and intense with that high proof.
- 13:44But the flavor profile, again, is still in that like kind of salty, briny kind of note,
- 13:49which doesn't sound like something you would like on a bourbon. But again,
- 13:51I think it works. You just have to really like that flavor profile.
- 13:55So here on the Bourbon Bytes Podcast, we just give one score out of 10 based on all things like
- 14:00nose, proof, palate, availability, just overall thoughts of the whiskey. I like to keep it
- 14:06simple here on the Byte-Sized Review. With this one, I do feel like it is a significant improvement
- 14:12over the small batch. That being said, it doesn't fix all of the issues that I think some people
- 14:18would have with that whiskey. I think it bumps up the proof. It gives it more body. It gives it
- 14:22more character. But whether you like that character is entirely up to you. It's definitely a bit
- 14:28divisive still, but I think it is worth revisiting even if you didn't like the small batch version.
- 14:35For 60 bucks, no age statement, but cool bottle. I'm going to give this one a six out of 10.
- 14:41I definitely would pour myself another glass of it. I think it's one that you could actually
- 14:46give as a gift and not feel bad about, especially the cask strength version. So overall, I'm pretty
- 14:52surprised with this. It's better than I thought, but I don't think this is going to win over fans
- 14:56of people that hated the first release. As someone that thought the first release was OK,
- 15:01this definitely feels like an improvement. And I'm excited to finally have this bottle on my
- 15:05shelf and not have people make fun of me. So if you've had a chance to try this one,
- 15:09please let me know what you think. Have they broken their stigma of this Pot Still Reserve
- 15:14bottle or is it still a bit of a gag gift? Let me know your comments either on this episode
- 15:21or over on our Discord server. You can find that as well as a link to join our Byte Club for as
- 15:26little as two dollars a month at bourbonbytes.com. By the way, if you are listening to this on the
- 15:31Thursday that it comes out, I'm going to be live tonight with Brush Creek Distillery at 7 p.m.
- 15:36Pacific over on my Bourbon Bytes YouTube channel. But if you listen to this later,
- 15:41the replay will be there, too. I hope to see you guys there. I'm really excited to have those folks
- 15:44on. They sent over a really cool selection of their whiskeys and I cannot wait to give them a try.
- 15:50For those of you that are part of the Byte Club, thank you for helping me keep these episodes
- 15:54rolling. I enjoyed picking up this bottle and hope to do many more like it here soon.
- 16:00Well, that about does it. This has been the Bourbon Bytes Podcast, a whiskey podcast
- 16:04with a gaming twist. Cheers, and I'll talk to you guys next episode.