Latest / Surrounded / What's the Future of The Democrats' Platform? | Surrounded Follow-Up w/ Luke Beasley
Transcript
- 0:00We give too much out.
- 0:02Let's just too much.
- 0:03Did you just shush me,
- 0:04Luke?
- 0:04I did.
- 0:05I apologize.
- 0:05I apologize.
- 0:06All right,
- 0:07you're forgiven.
- 0:07I apologize,
- 0:08but shushing me.
- 0:09Get out of
- 0:10here.
- 0:11I'm John.
- 0:12Uh,
- 0:12Luke,
- 0:12welcome to the surrounded follow-up,
- 0:15uh,
- 0:16on behalf of Jubilee,
- 0:17thanks for jumping into the arena.
- 0:19Are you ready to,
- 0:20you know,
- 0:21kind of get into
- 0:22the,
- 0:23the action?
- 0:24Well,
- 0:24it's great to be with you,
- 0:24John.
- 0:25I'm so ready,
- 0:26and the experience was.
- 0:29Fun and interesting and to reflect on it,
- 0:31I think will be the same.
- 0:32Excellent.
- 0:33So I've pulled some clips uh that I wanna react to,
- 0:36but before we,
- 0:37we dig into that,
- 0:37I usually just ask folks,
- 0:39you know,
- 0:40what were your thoughts going into
- 0:42the experience and
- 0:45how do they compare to how you felt coming out of it?
- 0:47Well,
- 0:47going into it,
- 0:48you know,
- 0:48I've done a lot of
- 0:50debates,
- 0:51my
- 0:52beginning getting into this space at all in politics.
- 0:55Was going to Trump rallies and debating with people
- 0:58knowing that that would just be a
- 0:59an ocean of people I disagreed with and I
- 1:01found that so stimulating and obviously those sorts of
- 1:04videos would perform well and so they kind of
- 1:07allowed for a little bit of funding to allow me to
- 1:09travel to more and that's kind of how it all started
- 1:11and so when I found out
- 1:13that specifically it was gonna be me versus folks who were
- 1:18not just supporters of Trump but also in an older demographic that's like the.
- 1:22Exact
- 1:23median age of someone at those rallies and so it felt
- 1:26going
- 1:27like I was going back home to the thing I'm most
- 1:29used to
- 1:30and so I was totally just pumped and it's a very comfortable
- 1:34environment and then.
- 1:36Reviewing the claims felt
- 1:38strong on them.
- 1:39I think my only concern going in was that it would be
- 1:42intense because of how fancy the production value seems when you watch
- 1:46the videos
- 1:47and it was very high production value and a great crew and everything,
- 1:51but it still shifted back into that gear that I'm
- 1:54used to which is a little bit more playful,
- 1:56a little bit more lighthearted
- 1:57ended up being.
- 1:58A
- 1:59pleasantly surprised experience,
- 2:01I think.
- 2:01Yeah,
- 2:02I think when the,
- 2:03when the cameras turn on,
- 2:05it's just inevitable that there's a little bit of like,
- 2:07um,
- 2:08there's a performative element to it that everybody kind of plays with
- 2:12because I felt the same way on Jubilee sets where it's like
- 2:16we're arguing about the worst or most important stuff,
- 2:18yet
- 2:19this is sort of fun.
- 2:20So there's an interesting contradiction there and that's the beautiful part.
- 2:24Another big takeaway is just.
- 2:27I could tell especially the political environment that
- 2:29we're in the security presence and just the very
- 2:34intentional
- 2:36phased approach to how it'd be recorded and how I
- 2:38when I would go out when I would be taken away
- 2:40and
- 2:41that some of the participants I think were maybe a little bit surprised that
- 2:46during and after I actually loved the idea of just chatting it up off camera
- 2:50because.
- 2:51I want to walk away from those experiences
- 2:54having plenty of negative feelings obviously about
- 2:57not
- 2:58thinking the person I was debating against was reasonable
- 3:00or not feeling like they were trying to hear me
- 3:02but also get some level of hope that we still have a common humanity and
- 3:06can
- 3:06joke and and have some level of lightheartedness.
- 3:09I think this might be the first episode where
- 3:11there was that generational element that you brought up.
- 3:14And I thought that created some interesting dynamics.
- 3:17I was having flashbacks to
- 3:19my political arguments in the past with my parents,
- 3:22um,
- 3:23because of,
- 3:24of that dynamic.
- 3:25So,
- 3:26um,
- 3:27I,
- 3:27that's actually something I'm wondering,
- 3:28are you,
- 3:29do you have the same political views
- 3:30as your parents if you're comfortable disclosing?
- 3:33Yes,
- 3:33I'm very aligned with my parents,
- 3:35but that was um.
- 3:37I would say a
- 3:38development
- 3:39that came later,
- 3:41not that they had different views but they were
- 3:42really intentional about not sharing their views with their kids
- 3:46until their kids shared their views with them
- 3:48and so the environment they fostered in our
- 3:50family was really have whatever you wanna have
- 3:52as your political views but just be ready to debate them with each other and with us
- 3:57and.
- 3:58So we set up mock debates between me and my
- 4:00brother because my brother is really different than me politically
- 4:03and
- 4:04we kind of yeah my the 3 my two brothers who are both older brothers
- 4:08we span the political spectrum completely
- 4:10and I think that came from
- 4:12the
- 4:13intentional effort by my parents to be
- 4:15very cautious about not just.
- 4:18Bringing us into their political views because obviously that's
- 4:21usually the dynamic is you just kind of copy your
- 4:23political views but then my
- 4:24parents and I
- 4:25went on our journey
- 4:27and are all kind of aligned
- 4:28uh in this current political moment but then outside of that
- 4:32extended families,
- 4:33uh,
- 4:33uncle,
- 4:34aunt,
- 4:35grandparents.
- 4:36Very different.
- 4:37A lot of
- 4:38more MAGA folks in that broader circle.
- 4:39So
- 4:40to your point,
- 4:41that's another reason why these types of conversations feel
- 4:44so comfortable.
- 4:45Like I'm just at a family function
- 4:46hashing it out with family members.
- 4:48So you're saying Thanksgiving is,
- 4:49is a throwdown.
- 4:53You know,
- 4:54ever since I started doing this,
- 4:56there's an unsaid rule
- 4:57that when Luke's around just be very mindful
- 5:00of
- 5:01unless you wanna spend the rest of the night
- 5:03talking with me about politics and it's never hostile.
- 5:05I love it it's fun it's not gonna get
- 5:08my feelings hurt or anything,
- 5:09but a lot of people aren't up for that and so it's funny since it became
- 5:13known in my broader family like Luke's the politics guy
- 5:16everyone's actually extra cautious not to bring it up with me unless they're ready
- 5:19for
- 5:20the rest of the night being about politics.
- 5:23That's great.
- 5:24Let's jump into your first clip.
- 5:28and Trump is doing the most trickle-down,
- 5:30insane redistribution of wealth from the bottom to the top with his big,
- 5:34beautiful bill,
- 5:35the largest cut to Medicaid
- 5:36ever,
- 5:37nearly $1 trillion over a decade.
- 5:39Trim things.
- 5:39We need to tighten things,
- 5:40wait,
- 5:40wait.
- 5:41He lowered.
- 5:41I'm on Social Security,
- 5:42bro.
- 5:43You think I don't worry about this?
- 5:44He lower worry about this for the richest Americans.
- 5:48I'm for that.
- 5:49Why is that taking money they're from the
- 5:51poorest Americans they have we gotta tighten.
- 5:53We gotta tighten up.
- 5:54We gotta tighten up.
- 5:55We give too much out.
- 5:57Let's just too much.
- 5:58Did you just shush me,
- 5:59Luke?
- 5:59I,
- 6:00I did come on.
- 6:00I.
- 6:01I apologize.
- 6:02All right,
- 6:02you're forgiven.
- 6:03I apologize,
- 6:03but shushing we
- 6:05get out of here.
- 6:07What are your initial reactions to your sparring with Steve?
- 6:10Well,
- 6:10Steve was a
- 6:13Nice guy,
- 6:15um,
- 6:16and obviously there was a funny banter there,
- 6:18but that's the part that I think resembles
- 6:21in a much more cordial way
- 6:24maybe then
- 6:25is more broadly true
- 6:26but the underlying
- 6:28detachment
- 6:29of
- 6:30I'm saying something
- 6:32he's not listening I'm sure he thinks I wasn't listening but I was
- 6:35um
- 6:36but that we weren't really
- 6:38that it's just too completely detached from the ears.
- 6:41Voices shouting at each other
- 6:43which does drive me crazy because
- 6:46and
- 6:46obviously you're talking to me so I'm gonna think that
- 6:48I was handling it fine
- 6:50but
- 6:51when people have a weak
- 6:53understanding maybe of what they're trying to argue or they're uncomfortable with
- 6:57the place the argument has gone it's just this free association of
- 7:01words like not.
- 7:02Grabbing onto do you agree or not with the
- 7:06data driven argument I just made about the impact of the bill,
- 7:09let's start there
- 7:10and then we can move on to health programs,
- 7:12whatever,
- 7:12but just kind of
- 7:14what happened a lot throughout the broader debate
- 7:16was,
- 7:17oh,
- 7:17you said something about health care,
- 7:19so instead of refuting or agreeing with what you just said there,
- 7:22I'm just gonna make a different point about how I want
- 7:24people to get healthy or I want people to run more,
- 7:26do more push-ups.
- 7:27It's like great,
- 7:28but that's not really connected to.
- 7:29What we're talking about and I didn't get a single person to explain
- 7:34based on actual numbers in the bill
- 7:36why what I was saying about it
- 7:38wasn't true and why it's not a complete
- 7:39betrayal of his commitment to the working class.
- 7:43Besides it being really funny,
- 7:45first of all,
- 7:45when you shush him and how he takes offense to it,
- 7:48on his end,
- 7:49I'm sensing sort of this,
- 7:50uh,
- 7:51there's a bit of a contradiction I think in the current Trump coalition.
- 7:55Let me know if you agree or,
- 7:56or disagree,
- 7:57but,
- 7:57you know,
- 7:58you have like the deficit hawks and,
- 8:00and
- 8:01uh Elon's maybe the most prominent,
- 8:03uh,
- 8:05I,
- 8:05I guess like spokesperson for that,
- 8:07and that was even maybe the source of their rift.
- 8:09And these are folks who just want to relentlessly
- 8:12cut back
- 8:13on
- 8:15social programs that cost money.
- 8:17And
- 8:17in order to tackle the deficit,
- 8:19there's a lot of
- 8:20people who say that's really the only way
- 8:23realistically you're gonna.
- 8:25Bring down the debt is if you cut aggressively into Medicaid,
- 8:29Social Security.
- 8:30On the other side,
- 8:32there's,
- 8:32um,
- 8:33just sort of the
- 8:35tax,
- 8:36the deregulation part of the Trump coalition,
- 8:38which is just like,
- 8:39let's
- 8:40lift the tax burden on the wealthy because those are the job growers,
- 8:44those are the job creators,
- 8:46um,
- 8:46those are the economy growers.
- 8:48And,
- 8:49um,
- 8:50you know,
- 8:50you're trying to kind of communicate this point like.
- 8:54The big beautiful bill
- 8:55adds to the deficit that feels like the opposite of
- 8:59the messaging,
- 9:00but I think it's only the opposite of like the,
- 9:02the deficit hawks.
- 9:04I wish we could have pulled apart that contradiction a little bit more,
- 9:06but
- 9:07is that your sort of take about uh
- 9:09the conservative view of the economy?
- 9:11Yeah,
- 9:12and
- 9:12I see kind of how you're explaining it.
- 9:14There's a lot of truth that two different.
- 9:17Categories of Trump's base.
- 9:20But what I find so fascinating about the,
- 9:22the Big Beautiful bill in particular.
- 9:25Is that it
- 9:26is wrong for both categories like you do have the more populist
- 9:30portion
- 9:31who probably don't care as much about
- 9:34debt and deficits they're not as they're actually
- 9:37getting more and more hostile toward that idea of
- 9:39trickle down economics we gotta just keep funneling more and
- 9:42more wealth to the wealthy and then eventually it'll cause
- 9:45this robust economic.
- 9:47Reaction
- 9:48a lot of the populist MAGA energy is turning against that,
- 9:52but what's so weird is they're just doing it thus far
- 9:56in rhetoric they'll talk also kind of like how liberal populists
- 9:59discuss
- 10:00the wealthy class and the
- 10:02degrading effect that's had on our political discourse,
- 10:04but then in policy
- 10:06they support something
- 10:08that
- 10:09is
- 10:10more.
- 10:11Pro-wealthy than maybe any single bill we've ever seen in the history of America
- 10:16while
- 10:17it's as you mentioned adding more to the debt than
- 10:20maybe we've ever seen in any single bill in American history
- 10:23and cutting more for Medicaid from any single bill in history
- 10:26so
- 10:27it's this series of things
- 10:30all in one
- 10:31package.
- 10:33That you would think
- 10:34because it's not a political debate,
- 10:36it's not stretchy flexible culture wars,
- 10:39it's stuff on paper
- 10:41and then rural hospitals and red areas saying because of
- 10:44that piece of paper we're gonna have to shut down,
- 10:47we won't be able to serve
- 10:48Republican voters as effectively
- 10:51different,
- 10:51you know,
- 10:51analysis this many.
- 10:53Americans in this red state or that red
- 10:55state will lose their Medicaid coverage because of that
- 10:57and it's very empirical and for even something that
- 11:00empirical that doesn't rely on liberal talking points or anything
- 11:04um to drive home that narrative
- 11:07to still not
- 11:08get
- 11:09for that word not to get
- 11:10to
- 11:11your average Trump voter
- 11:13is a part of why I get really discouraged because if he
- 11:15can even do that which is the biggest slap in the face.
- 11:17To them,
- 11:19then
- 11:19I don't know what
- 11:20would push them away.
- 11:21Obviously the
- 11:22rhetorical things from him,
- 11:24grabbed by the P word,
- 11:25the
- 11:26court case,
- 11:26like all of that has proven not to dissuade them,
- 11:30but you'd think
- 11:31him attacking their economic well-being would,
- 11:34and I think we're learning that for many of them it won't.
- 11:36You know,
- 11:37what I mostly hear from people on the left who come on the show and who I talk to,
- 11:41the core messaging around the economy is we gotta tax the wealthy.
- 11:44The wealthy have to pay.
- 11:46Their fair share.
- 11:47Well,
- 11:47I think that's a
- 11:48strong argument.
- 11:49We're probably
- 11:51seeing that resonate,
- 11:52um,
- 11:53you know,
- 11:53with the rise of Mamdani.
- 11:55What do you think are other winning positions or like great
- 11:59arguments on the economy that,
- 12:01that should become
- 12:03more well known
- 12:04for like the,
- 12:05the,
- 12:05the Democratic,
- 12:07um,
- 12:07Party?
- 12:08Well,
- 12:08first,
- 12:09let me just say,
- 12:10I don't like that some in the Democratic Party
- 12:13just brush off
- 12:15the problem of the debt.
- 12:16Because that is
- 12:17an issue
- 12:18and
- 12:19what's weird is I just somewhat recently reviewed on my show
- 12:24an analysis
- 12:25that looked at if you didn't,
- 12:27if you didn't see over the last few decades,
- 12:30the last like 3 Republican tax cut bills that all
- 12:34disproportionately benefited the top 1%,
- 12:37then
- 12:37that
- 12:38or
- 12:39as you assess that that accounts for like 90%.
- 12:44Of the debt problem
- 12:45over that period of time
- 12:47if you also exclude like crisis spending getting out of
- 12:51uh economic crises
- 12:53just during regular economic times,
- 12:54one of the major fuelers
- 12:56of our debt problem
- 12:57is constantly reducing the revenue stream which makes sense
- 13:01because you can attack that problem two ways or both,
- 13:03which is
- 13:04bringing in more revenue to address the debt or spending less
- 13:07but to
- 13:08bring in
- 13:10every time you come around and try to cut spending.
- 13:13You buy 2 or 3 fold cut revenue,
- 13:17then
- 13:17you're not actually you're actually worsening the debt problem while
- 13:21worsening
- 13:22people's immediate economic
- 13:24well-being and so I think
- 13:26then zooming out from that there's an
- 13:28underlying
- 13:30truth that drives me crazy.
- 13:33Crazy that I don't hear more Democrats messaging
- 13:35on anyone listening to this right now,
- 13:37you John,
- 13:38anyone can go fact check this
- 13:40over the last century,
- 13:41it's just
- 13:42one of the most profound and distinct
- 13:45economic trends that the economy has
- 13:48performed much better under Democrats than Republicans over the last century
- 13:52and so.
- 13:53It's fascinating to me growing up that I was certain that Republicans
- 13:56had overseen better economic conditions just because that's what you hear and just
- 14:00Republicans economy they're the economy people
- 14:01and but I care I care about social programs and I care about people,
- 14:05so Democrats,
- 14:05but
- 14:06man those Republican
- 14:07and it's just the the total
- 14:09upside downification of
- 14:11the truth on that if you look at every major economic
- 14:14indicator and again you can say well that was because of
- 14:16this in that era and that in that era and this
- 14:19it wasn't because of policy.
- 14:20Now why I
- 14:22see that to be the case with Steve
- 14:24is
- 14:25Republicans are more
- 14:27likely
- 14:28to agree with that supply side economics theory
- 14:32and
- 14:33it can sound nice the job creators,
- 14:35if we just give them the more tax cuts,
- 14:36they'll stimulate the economy in a way that
- 14:38parallels to whatever we would have lost in
- 14:40revenue,
- 14:41but it hasn't demonstrated as we've seen through
- 14:43all these Republican administrations who have underperformed,
- 14:45whereas Democrats,
- 14:46while they also make plenty of horrible decisions.
- 14:48While in power on the economy,
- 14:50they are more likely to
- 14:52lean into demand side economics,
- 14:54putting the dollar
- 14:55not only where it's most needed immediately,
- 14:57but
- 14:58people who have less money and need it
- 15:01right now
- 15:02are more likely to immediately spend that dollar,
- 15:04which is a much more.
- 15:06Quick and effective
- 15:08and dollar for dollar stimulator of the economy than hoping
- 15:12that more tax cuts will
- 15:14stimulate from the top and so that bottom up
- 15:16approach to economic policy has been the reason that
- 15:20Democrats have overseen those better economic indicators for.
- 15:24Many of my lifetimes
- 15:26and so why Democrats can't brand themselves as the
- 15:31rational ones on the Economy Party,
- 15:33I don't know
- 15:34and maybe now with Trump's tariffs he's kind of done
- 15:36a lot of damage to the Republican brand on this,
- 15:39but for a long time Republicans consistently polled as more trusted
- 15:42on the economy when you just can't make a data-driven case
- 15:46uh for that
- 15:47when you zoom out,
- 15:48get away from the culture war and the.
- 15:51Identity stuff as much as you can and see if you can pound that drum on the economy,
- 15:58especially
- 15:58in an era
- 16:00where
- 16:01Trump is
- 16:02failing on his economic approach
- 16:04and then.
- 16:05Hugely important
- 16:07acknowledge the broader failures in the system.
- 16:09A lot of Democrats have been seen as
- 16:11status quo humpers and they're really just so
- 16:13proud of themselves for the work they've done,
- 16:16yeah,
- 16:16and you have to come in with,
- 16:18hey,
- 16:19if we're making this argument about who's better,
- 16:21there is no argument really
- 16:23but
- 16:24we've seen that.
- 16:25Even in that context,
- 16:28both parties have failed
- 16:29and we're looking for a systemic generational change to our economic order
- 16:34that actually serves
- 16:35uh working class folks that's where the energy is right now for good reason
- 16:38and I think if they can capitalize on that,
- 16:40especially when there's a lot of.
- 16:41Resentment towards
- 16:42how Trump's failing on a lot of his promises,
- 16:44then
- 16:45there's a promising
- 16:46future ahead for Democrats,
- 16:48but clearly they haven't done that well yet
- 16:50because they still are in the dumps polling wise.
- 16:52I'm gonna go into your second,
- 16:54uh,
- 16:54claim in the video which is
- 16:57Trump is an authoritarian threat against democracy.
- 17:00Trump is an authoritarian threat to democracy.
- 17:02He doesn't respect elections.
- 17:04He doesn't respect
- 17:05the nonviolent principles of
- 17:07approaching our democratic process.
- 17:09Doesn't respect court rulings
- 17:11is degrading our democratic process in a lot of key ways.
- 17:13OK,
- 17:14so I want you to really think about what you're saying here.
- 17:18He's had two assassination attempts
- 17:21because of rhetoric that you're giving right now.
- 17:23I disagree.
- 17:24Charlie Kirk is dead
- 17:26because of rhetoric
- 17:27that you are stating right now.
- 17:28Don't you think it's time to take down the rhetoric?
- 17:31Yeah,
- 17:31I think absolutely,
- 17:32and I actually make an effort to lower the rhetoric,
- 17:34but me identifying someone's ideology
- 17:37and saying through peaceful means we
- 17:39should push back against someone's authoritarianism
- 17:41is exactly in line with peaceful principles.
- 17:43What happened to Charlie Kirk is an abandonment of all of the principles I hold dear.
- 17:46That was
- 17:47horrific.
- 17:48And so the way that we push back against authoritarianism,
- 17:51like for example,
- 17:52if we're saying political violence is wrong,
- 17:53and that's what I.
- 17:54I believe,
- 17:54and that's why I am horrified by what happened to Charlie Kirk.
- 17:58Then is it not
- 17:59anti-democratic,
- 18:00not in the interest of
- 18:01a peaceful approach to a democratic process for Trump to pardon January 6thers?
- 18:05Well,
- 18:05no,
- 18:06because
- 18:06a lot of violent,
- 18:08not all.
- 18:08No,
- 18:09specifically think about people who assaulted.
- 18:10I have a friend.
- 18:12No,
- 18:12I don't want to hear about your friend.
- 18:13I'm talking about specifically violent offenders.
- 18:15Daniel Rodriguez.
- 18:16Stun gunned an officer,
- 18:18he had a heart attack.
- 18:19I'm asking,
- 18:20is it correct that there were people who
- 18:22assaulted police officers violently who got pardons,
- 18:24and are you OK with that?
- 18:25Uh,
- 18:25yes,
- 18:26because their due process was violated when people,
- 18:28it wasn't.
- 18:28They had their trial,
- 18:30they had their whole due process,
- 18:31unlike the people that Trump is without you going to let me speak?
- 18:34I just don't appreciate if you're going to avoid.
- 18:36I don't feel like,
- 18:37well,
- 18:38I actually believe.
- 18:39That we should not be violent.
- 18:41It sounds like you're OK with some people who were violent,
- 18:43I'm not,
- 18:43which scares me.
- 18:44I think that's not lowering the Constitution of the United States,
- 18:47which says that you have the right to transfer of power.
- 18:50I believe that you have a right to a quick and speedy trial.
- 18:53I believe when you weren't a nonviolent offender,
- 18:58you should,
- 18:58yes,
- 18:58we are,
- 18:58we're talking about it as the question I brought up.
- 19:00No,
- 19:00you're just trying to talk over for me to be right.
- 19:02No,
- 19:02you brought up violence.
- 19:04You brought up violence specifically.
- 19:07A little bit of that Thanksgiving uh dinner table vibe,
- 19:10uh,
- 19:10towards the towards the end.
- 19:12I'm curious,
- 19:13you know,
- 19:14it,
- 19:14it goes like that for a little bit longer.
- 19:16They vote her out
- 19:18and then the next,
- 19:20uh,
- 19:20cast member who comes in.
- 19:24Uh,
- 19:24he sort of scolds you for not letting her,
- 19:25her speak.
- 19:27Do you,
- 19:27when you see it,
- 19:29when you see it back,
- 19:30do you feel like
- 19:32you should have let her
- 19:33answer your question or,
- 19:35or address what you were kind of pointing out as,
- 19:37as a contradiction?
- 19:39Well,
- 19:40I definitely wanted her to address what I was pointing out.
- 19:44The reason I kept interrupting was because she
- 19:46wasn't and what's unfortunate is especially in a debate
- 19:49that has a time
- 19:50clock,
- 19:50you know,
- 19:50like a clock ticking down
- 19:52and.
- 19:53Uh,
- 19:54time restraints,
- 19:55what's really important to me
- 19:57is that especially when
- 19:59I'm bringing a claim
- 20:01and I'm posing a specific question is that
- 20:04if they're gonna go in some other direction.
- 20:06I gotta bring them back to where we are at and I,
- 20:09if we had the time,
- 20:10I'm happy to address all the other things she was
- 20:13bringing up all that's interesting to me and important,
- 20:16but
- 20:16if we can't start with what.
- 20:19We've agreed to start with,
- 20:20which is my claim,
- 20:21then
- 20:22it's not gonna be productive and,
- 20:23and the reason that there was
- 20:25a certain level of
- 20:26uh rhetorical aggression there and
- 20:29cutting her off and,
- 20:30and trying to hold her to a specific point is because what
- 20:32I've noticed in a lot of these conversations you saw it with the
- 20:35guy before
- 20:36is
- 20:36that
- 20:38people when
- 20:39confronted with facts about their ideology that
- 20:42they start to realize are contradictory or
- 20:44aren't coming off great or not aligned with what they thought they were.
- 20:48Aligned with principle wise?
- 20:50They'll,
- 20:51as I referenced earlier,
- 20:52do kind of like free word association and just,
- 20:54oh,
- 20:55well,
- 20:55that was mentioned so that allows me to connect to this other thing
- 20:58and
- 20:59you can follow that
- 21:01logic tree as long as you want and you'll never get back
- 21:05to at least refining
- 21:08what the core of the argument is because there,
- 21:10she brought up
- 21:11political violence
- 21:12and I am
- 21:13passionate about addressing that issue
- 21:16and about having a good faith discussion about it.
- 21:18We can't do that
- 21:20if we don't lay out just
- 21:22factually some of the basic foundational things
- 21:24that we're even supposedly
- 21:26disagreeing on so like she brought up
- 21:28Charlie Kirk
- 21:29and I got the sense as people came into that debate that
- 21:32maybe because of stuff they saw online or something
- 21:34and knowing that I was gonna be a liberal
- 21:36that I wasn't gonna be as horrified as they are
- 21:39with what happened,
- 21:40which I am
- 21:41and
- 21:42so then after.
- 21:44Addressing that,
- 21:45I don't
- 21:46think
- 21:47she was comfortable maybe
- 21:49introspecting on while the guy sitting across the table
- 21:51from her is just opposed to political violence,
- 21:54whether it's against someone I disagree with or someone I agree with.
- 21:57That maybe she is not similarly consistent based on the
- 22:01example I brought up.
- 22:02Do you think there's any,
- 22:03any truth or credibility?
- 22:05Uh,
- 22:06her initial argument was like
- 22:08your rhetoric around,
- 22:09and I think it was specifically a threat to democracy.
- 22:13Um,
- 22:14that phrase I've been seeing kind of pointed out as
- 22:17Inappropriate or,
- 22:18or maybe too hyperbolic of rhetoric.
- 22:22What do you think about that argument?
- 22:25Well,
- 22:25first,
- 22:25I'm not as
- 22:27prone to go,
- 22:28ah shut up,
- 22:29like I actually wanna.
- 22:30Engage with that and think,
- 22:31is it?
- 22:32And after certain events.
- 22:34Over the last couple of years,
- 22:36Trump's assassination attempt,
- 22:37for example,
- 22:37or
- 22:38Kirk's assassination,
- 22:39I've.
- 22:41Every time it's sort of gone back through and thought about this as
- 22:45as intentionally as I can because that does matter and rhetoric does inflame
- 22:49it is
- 22:50irritating when it feels like
- 22:52the people telling you to do that introspection
- 22:55aren't doing it themselves like obviously every time someone says
- 22:59this is because people call Trump fascist
- 23:02then you play a montage of Trump calling all of his enemies fascist and it's like OK
- 23:05well it's hard to take it.
- 23:07Yeah,
- 23:08it's hard to take it seriously coming from them,
- 23:10but that doesn't mean that separate from who's
- 23:12bringing up the point you shouldn't consider it.
- 23:13And so then upon considering it,
- 23:15I've
- 23:16done my best and this might sound kind of silly,
- 23:19but
- 23:19to use the least inflammatory but accurate
- 23:22rhetoric
- 23:23as I can
- 23:24so like I don't go around saying you're a fascist,
- 23:26you're a fascist,
- 23:27I'll talk about like fascistic ideologies that
- 23:29seem to,
- 23:30but.
- 23:31You're a Nazi,
- 23:32right,
- 23:33something like that.
- 23:33I try to be as accurate as I can and to me the wording of
- 23:37not a threat.
- 23:39But a threat to democracy,
- 23:41the democracy is being threatened
- 23:43from my point of view,
- 23:45as least inflammatory as I can put it
- 23:47based on Trump's actions.
- 23:48To answer your question
- 23:50again,
- 23:50sort of in,
- 23:51in summary,
- 23:51it's a fair thing to ask whenever horrible things happen.
- 23:54Are our rhetoric is our rhetoric playing a role?
- 23:56And
- 23:57collectively as a country our political rhetoric clearly
- 23:59is playing a role in our,
- 24:01uh,
- 24:01political violence,
- 24:03but.
- 24:04In my specific wording,
- 24:06is that the best wording I can come up with
- 24:09that speaks to the facts that I see,
- 24:12people will disagree with my characterization,
- 24:13but that's how I see them,
- 24:15but
- 24:15isn't.
- 24:16Hyperbolize,
- 24:17yeah.
- 24:18I,
- 24:18I do find it interesting that both.
- 24:21Sides of the political aisle
- 24:23in recent years
- 24:25have kind of been pointing out rhetoric and it,
- 24:28it,
- 24:28it,
- 24:29it's a,
- 24:29it's a ball that has sort of changed hands.
- 24:32That's why I kind of laid that as the initial
- 24:34in an argument that's an easy way to shut it down is going,
- 24:37well,
- 24:37your side,
- 24:38right?
- 24:39That's not necessarily the most wholesome way to engage with the criticism,
- 24:42which is why part two
- 24:44of my thinking is,
- 24:45all right,
- 24:45but attached,
- 24:46detached from any of the
- 24:48political jargon like what do I actually feel about
- 24:50how I'm speaking.
- 24:51Because we're getting in this place where there are
- 24:53now enough examples on both sides of people being
- 24:56outrageous
- 24:57that
- 24:57any time either side's accused of anything they can
- 24:59just point and then we're just gonna keep doing that
- 25:01and now again the reason I,
- 25:03one of the reasons
- 25:05that I am proudly liberal
- 25:06is I do see a difference in not just random people in the
- 25:09world but people in positions of power and how they treat these issues,
- 25:12how extremism
- 25:13has taken a whole taken hold of
- 25:15the Republican Party in a way that I see is more severe than.
- 25:18Democratic Party,
- 25:19but so it's not about both sides in it,
- 25:22but there's enough extremism where
- 25:24that game of oh I can shut down your criticism of
- 25:27me by just pointing to the most crazy people on your side
- 25:29is a dangerous spiral and kind of
- 25:32race
- 25:33to the bottom.
- 25:33You know,
- 25:34there's this idea that Jubilee is obviously kind of flirting with it,
- 25:37which is platforming and the ethics of it,
- 25:40um,
- 25:41when it's appropriate inappropriate,
- 25:43uh,
- 25:43David Packman,
- 25:44another,
- 25:44uh,
- 25:45I'm sure you're familiar with him,
- 25:46um.
- 25:47I think 2 weeks ago he said he wasn't gonna
- 25:50uh
- 25:50participate in Surrounded.
- 25:52Did that factor?
- 25:53I'm,
- 25:53I'm just curious,
- 25:54you know,
- 25:55after doing the show,
- 25:56reacting to some clips.
- 25:59What do you think of kind of his stance and,
- 26:01and what are sort of your rules about engaging with.
- 26:05Debating
- 26:07opinions that
- 26:08that you find,
- 26:09you know,
- 26:09disagreeable.
- 26:10I was a little bit discouraged seeing,
- 26:13and it feels weird to name check anyone,
- 26:14but there's been kind of that thread through a lot of people,
- 26:17a lot of
- 26:17prominent folks,
- 26:19people who've gone on before,
- 26:20people who are thinking about going on,
- 26:21and then just random accounts online,
- 26:23lobbying a lot of criticism at Jubilee,
- 26:26but it's not just jubilee,
- 26:27it's at this type of format for debate
- 26:31and
- 26:32That was all kind of spiking right as I was getting ready to go do it myself
- 26:36and I was like dang what?
- 26:38right?
- 26:39right before mine?
- 26:40No,
- 26:41wait a few weeks before you get all angry
- 26:43um
- 26:44but
- 26:45then in thinking about it
- 26:47I've never really understood that criticism,
- 26:49not
- 26:51the
- 26:51you can do damage by platforming someone
- 26:54in an unprepared manner
- 26:56like there's plenty of examples of Rogan bringing on people
- 26:58that clearly he didn't like Trump prepare enough to.
- 27:02Fact check and then he just kind of lets lies
- 27:04float out into the biggest audience on
- 27:07the Internet
- 27:08and
- 27:09I just wish we'd be a little bit more intentional about.
- 27:13What we're saying because a lot of people
- 27:15make it like it was inherently wrong to platform
- 27:18whoever,
- 27:19but that's never the problem you can platform literally anybody
- 27:22it's just how then do you do it
- 27:24and there have been
- 27:26excellent interviews with horrible people,
- 27:28but the reason they were so excellent
- 27:30is the interviewer did a really good job of preparing themselves
- 27:34and making sure that it was
- 27:35uh not just a vector for misinformation
- 27:38and so then with Jubilee obviously it's not
- 27:40like an interview but this debate format.
- 27:43When people say,
- 27:45why would you give a platform to
- 27:47this extreme view?
- 27:49I've watched the ones that people that were the most upset about,
- 27:52and I'm like,
- 27:53guys,
- 27:54that's
- 27:54a really prominent view,
- 27:56we need to make sure people know that,
- 27:59and then,
- 28:00Debate it like that's our option
- 28:02and
- 28:03it would be one thing
- 28:05if.
- 28:07You aired those ideas unrefuted,
- 28:10like one of the ones that got a lot of controversy was Mehdi Hassans.
- 28:13He did an excellent job in my mind
- 28:16of
- 28:16making
- 28:18clear how absurd the radical views were that he was arguing
- 28:21against,
- 28:21so it wasn't like it was just floating out and people were gonna be radicalized.
- 28:24If anyone who wasn't familiar with those views watched it,
- 28:26I think they would come away
- 28:27thinking,
- 28:28dang,
- 28:29that's insane,
- 28:29the things that the people Meh he was arguing against in part because of how
- 28:33effective of a debater.
- 28:35Me is so
- 28:36then the other part of the.
- 28:39No,
- 28:39I wouldn't either.
- 28:40Um,
- 28:42he's,
- 28:42he's really,
- 28:43really good,
- 28:44but
- 28:45the other part of it is,
- 28:46well,
- 28:47I don't think this is,
- 28:48so there's the platform and cri criticism,
- 28:50and then,
- 28:50and I'm sure I'll get some of this once it gets released,
- 28:52but
- 28:53there's also the.
- 28:55What is this doing?
- 28:57Is this productive?
- 28:58Is this how you change people's minds?
- 29:00And it's like,
- 29:02I mean,
- 29:03in some cases,
- 29:03yeah,
- 29:04people will have their minds changed.
- 29:05I've had people who saw me on right wing platforms doing debates
- 29:09and
- 29:09went and watched my show and ended up going from like a MAGA to liberal,
- 29:12so yeah,
- 29:12it actually can happen.
- 29:14Is it gonna have some huge gravitational
- 29:17impact on
- 29:19the extremists?
- 29:20Probably not,
- 29:21and a lot of it is performative and a lot of it is kind of the,
- 29:23the sport of
- 29:25debating,
- 29:26but I see nothing.
- 29:28Inherently wrong with that,
- 29:29especially if you're responsibly platforming
- 29:31the ideas and you know,
- 29:33fact checks are being put up and all that type of
- 29:35uh stuff
- 29:37and I actually see it as such an important,
- 29:40yes,
- 29:40in a
- 29:41YouTube format
- 29:43there's gonna be a lot of elements
- 29:44that are about performance and intrigue and clickbait
- 29:48uh for anything
- 29:49but
- 29:49I do see us.
- 29:51Barely hanging on to some rare situations where we
- 29:55throw our ideas at each other,
- 29:57and we're increasingly just siloing,
- 29:59and I don't like the applauding
- 30:02of people who never put themselves
- 30:04in oppositional environments.
- 30:06But
- 30:07are facilitating really
- 30:09engraved silos which is facilitating
- 30:12one of the worst problems that's allowing people to
- 30:14get even more radicalized at least if you see your
- 30:17friendly neighborhood fascist on Jubilee you might see them exposed
- 30:21you know.
- 30:22Uh,
- 30:22otherwise,
- 30:22if they're always just alone on their show,
- 30:24you'll never see their ideas challenged.
- 30:25So I actually think it's
- 30:27really healthy,
- 30:27however
- 30:28YouTube friendly or algorithm friendly it is.
- 30:31It's good to kind of hear how you
- 30:33think about it and I'm gonna create
- 30:34a t-shirt that says friendly neighborhood fascist.
- 30:39But just to be clear,
- 30:40since,
- 30:40just in case anyone wants to clip anything,
- 30:42to be clear,
- 30:43since David was the one who prompted that,
- 30:44I ended up taking it to a bunch of other people that I was thinking about separately.
- 30:48I understand where he's coming from,
- 30:49and he's just said this isn't the right format for me,
- 30:52and that's totally reasonable.
- 30:53People should only do it if they feel like it's the right
- 30:55format for them,
- 30:56and I respect people not,
- 30:57but the broader like random people I've seen criticizing online
- 31:00of like you should never do stuff like this,
- 31:02and I've gotten that backlash when I've had when
- 31:04I've appeared on like Tim Pole or whatever.
- 31:06Um,
- 31:07I always found it silly.
- 31:09You asked,
- 31:09uh,
- 31:09Rosalind or,
- 31:10or Rosalyn to come back to the center at the end,
- 31:13and you had,
- 31:13you had argued with her at the beginning and then,
- 31:15um,
- 31:16you know,
- 31:17asked her to come back.
- 31:19I believe her claim was something along the lines of
- 31:21like
- 31:22the Democratic Party doesn't understand the American people
- 31:26and
- 31:27You know,
- 31:28you brought up kind of some criticisms of,
- 31:31uh,
- 31:31you know,
- 31:31liberals and the and the Democrats and
- 31:34That rings,
- 31:35at least if we're just reflecting on the last election,
- 31:37as,
- 31:37as
- 31:38a pretty strong claim.
- 31:39It's fiscal irresponsibility
- 31:42to cut,
- 31:43cut,
- 31:43cut taxes
- 31:44for the wealthiest Americans
- 31:46to pay for
- 31:47an attack on the working class.
- 31:49That's what it is.
- 31:49And and it balloons the debt.
- 31:51Do we all agree we should get our debt crisis under control?
- 31:54Then why does it add 4 to $5 trillion
- 31:57to the debt?
- 31:58Here's the biggest problem.
- 32:00Why does nobody answer my question what we are,
- 32:02but.
- 32:03Fortunately you have your own agenda,
- 32:05but we're trying to answer.
- 32:07So you tell me how much has it increased.
- 32:09How much does it increase the debt then?
- 32:10Here is the problem.
- 32:11Is the savior of the world?
- 32:13No,
- 32:13I'm not doing,
- 32:14he's not.
- 32:15He's not the savior of the world rally,
- 32:17but you want to know something?
- 32:18He is not the savior of the world,
- 32:20but I say he is far better than anything you could come up with
- 32:24on that side.
- 32:25They don't know money.
- 32:27The majority of them have never run a business.
- 32:29I would rather be with a president that has a
- 32:32Business,
- 32:33who knows how to make a dollar,
- 32:35who knows what it's like to have to pay bills,
- 32:38do you see,
- 32:38I wish everyone would notice this.
- 32:40I just want to talk about the numbers.
- 32:42If you have
- 32:42an alternative analysis,
- 32:44wait,
- 32:44wait,
- 32:45wait,
- 32:45if you have an alternative analysis
- 32:47of how much will be added to the debt because of Trump's one big beautiful bill,
- 32:51then you can present that,
- 32:51but you don't.
- 32:52So I give you a number based on independent analyses,
- 32:55and you respond with
- 32:57Trump's not our savior,
- 32:58but he's gonna make us better.
- 32:59That doesn't mean anything.
- 33:01There are
- 33:02analysis of that bill,
- 33:04the big beautiful bill.
- 33:06There are analysis of it that say the exact opposite.
- 33:09Guess what?
- 33:10Caroline Levitt.
- 33:11We won't know until it happens.
- 33:14Your side says,
- 33:15oh no,
- 33:16it's gonna be horrible.
- 33:17Our side says no,
- 33:19it's not.
- 33:24OK.
- 33:25First of all,
- 33:26Rosalyn was very,
- 33:27very sweet and cool.
- 33:31I want to say that before I get into anything else.
- 33:32Sorry,
- 33:32what were you gonna say?
- 33:33Well,
- 33:34OK,
- 33:34I,
- 33:34I definitely wanna hear what you
- 33:36wanna say,
- 33:37but there's an interesting contradiction here.
- 33:40So
- 33:41her claim is a,
- 33:42is a good one.
- 33:43You know,
- 33:44Democrats don't understand the American people.
- 33:47And then
- 33:48your debate with her
- 33:50kind of
- 33:51moved into like data specific arguments versus general vibey arguments
- 33:56and like she was getting applause from the other cast members as she was kind of,
- 34:00she went on some kind of speech
- 34:02rants a few times and she got,
- 34:04she got applause.
- 34:05But that in and of itself almost demonstrates.
- 34:10Or or reaffirms her claim because you know sometimes it really just is about vibes,
- 34:14no matter how good
- 34:16the data
- 34:17is
- 34:17or or how,
- 34:18um,
- 34:19you know,
- 34:20so I,
- 34:20I,
- 34:21not to,
- 34:22to throw you under the bus,
- 34:23but I,
- 34:24it was an interesting um.
- 34:26Tension
- 34:27in that moment.
- 34:29For sure that's an interesting thought.
- 34:31That little
- 34:32clip was a microcosm of how
- 34:35I see the state of America right now,
- 34:37which is like,
- 34:38hurry,
- 34:38well,
- 34:38if you look at the da da da and the latest study on
- 34:42and then
- 34:43Trump,
- 34:44woo,
- 34:45and it's just that's it,
- 34:46and I'm like sitting there like what is happening?
- 34:49Why are they cheering for this,
- 34:51um,
- 34:51and again,
- 34:52what,
- 34:52what was in that clip was as you said before.
- 34:55I laid out the reasons why I think the Democratic Party has lost
- 34:59the trust of the American people and that is a strong claim,
- 35:01but
- 35:02I will not stand for us just talking about that in a moment when
- 35:06no party has failed
- 35:08their base
- 35:09more than what we're seeing,
- 35:10right?
- 35:10So that's kind of why it shifted to that
- 35:12part of of the argument.
- 35:13You mean like I kept being like,
- 35:14wait,
- 35:15just respond to this point.
- 35:17And then it would be,
- 35:18well,
- 35:19sometimes the waters will pour and the
- 35:22ocean will rise,
- 35:24but the moon will still be there and I'm like,
- 35:27what?
- 35:28What are we talking about?
- 35:29So,
- 35:30that was upsetting.
- 35:32Did you feel like they weren't taking you seriously because of your,
- 35:34your age?
- 35:35There was another moment with another cast member where he's like,
- 35:37you're young.
- 35:39I like your spark.
- 35:40Like there was a lot of like kind of love,
- 35:42but then there would be like a big butt,
- 35:43and they're like,
- 35:44but
- 35:45once you have a little more life experience,
- 35:47you'll think this way.
- 35:48Do you think you'll get more conservative as you get older?
- 35:52No,
- 35:52I don't think so.
- 35:54I mean,
- 35:54I'm,
- 35:55I've always been pretty moderate,
- 35:56so I don't,
- 35:57I don't really know.
- 35:58I don't think that's gonna happen,
- 35:59but,
- 36:00and as already as
- 36:03my life has progressed and I'm like paying taxes,
- 36:05all those things they say I'm living in a house like that will eventually.
- 36:11Cause you to be more conservative have already
- 36:13kind of happened in my life and that hasn't
- 36:15been the political reaction so
- 36:16I don't know you never know but you hear that a lot from
- 36:19older
- 36:21conservatives right?
- 36:22which is
- 36:23my age which I do value a lot age and experience and wisdom
- 36:26and like all that is valuable and I wish that our culture was more
- 36:29loving towards aging and all of it
- 36:32but what's funny is.
- 36:34I don't know how you don't realize that's obviously gonna fall flat
- 36:38when people are old of all different political views
- 36:42so
- 36:42you can't say no,
- 36:43no,
- 36:43you'll understand that you should support Trump
- 36:46once you turn a certain age
- 36:48because a
- 36:48giant percentage of old people don't support Trump so it's not
- 36:52age doesn't.
- 36:54Then give you this complete truth,
- 36:56we're always gonna be debating whatever age we
- 36:59are and your experience gives you certain edges.
- 37:01I think
- 37:02a lot of the work I've done to try to
- 37:03catch up on understanding things at this age has also brought
- 37:07an asset,
- 37:08but it is funny when
- 37:09it feels like someone's not taking you seriously
- 37:12because of
- 37:13something like that age
- 37:15when
- 37:15on my side of the table,
- 37:17I'm feeling like.
- 37:19They're not bringing an adult's
- 37:21argument to the table.
- 37:23You have an exchange with John where he
- 37:25makes the argument that,
- 37:27and
- 37:28I think you're,
- 37:29this was in the context of the claim.
- 37:31Trump supporters are not patriotic.
- 37:35And that one was a little clickbait.
- 37:38I,
- 37:38I thought it was interesting.
- 37:39It was provocative.
- 37:40Acts of political violence to further a political goal
- 37:43is
- 37:43bad,
- 37:44and I'm against it across the board.
- 37:46You,
- 37:46many of you are not when you justify what happened on January 6th.
- 37:49Forgive a sports analogy.
- 37:50Imagine a football field.
- 37:52Most of America's on the 50-yard line.
- 37:55Republicans on the right 40 yard line,
- 37:57Democrats on the left 40 yard line,
- 37:59personally over my life.
- 38:00Cool,
- 38:01OK,
- 38:01um,
- 38:02yeah,
- 38:03I,
- 38:03I think that
- 38:05extremism has gotten worse in general
- 38:07and the big factor I see is social media,
- 38:10um,
- 38:10the
- 38:11fractured Internet
- 38:12that now we have,
- 38:13we're used to there were
- 38:15a very small number of sources of information about politics
- 38:19so then we were all agreeing on the basic facts but
- 38:21then disagreeing on what we should do with those facts.
- 38:24We have
- 38:25a disagreement about where we should go but not where we are
- 38:28now.
- 38:28You can just live in alternate universes because
- 38:30we're not all reading the same newspapers.
- 38:32We're just all in 100,000 different silos
- 38:36on the Internet
- 38:37and so that means that on the left and the right people are much more
- 38:40radicalized and there's a lot more extremism and I'm
- 38:43very concerned with left wing extremism for sure.
- 38:45My big barometer for
- 38:47given that my focus is on electoral politics and
- 38:50actual like positions of power.
- 38:54How do I judge when the extremism has become a real problem
- 38:58close to the centers of power and there's some examples of that
- 39:01with extreme left wing ideologies,
- 39:03but right now in a world where we have Trump who I
- 39:06see as the extreme manifestation of a right wing ideology as the president
- 39:10and
- 39:12Congress controlled by
- 39:13people who are at least willing to align with
- 39:15those extremist principles,
- 39:17then my.
- 39:18Concern is gonna have to be more severe towards
- 39:22the Republican Party as an institution because it as
- 39:24an institution has been more consumed by its extremist element
- 39:28than the Democratic Party that still has like so many
- 39:31some who are way too
- 39:33moderate even for me who are just kind of
- 39:36milk toast
- 39:37typical Democrats who still control kind of the center
- 39:40of the Democratic Party what people.
- 39:42Think
- 39:43of
- 39:44when they say the Democratic Party has gone more extreme than ever,
- 39:47it's not the policies,
- 39:48it's really not like what Biden's infrastructure law
- 39:51we think Joe Biden was this big extremist,
- 39:53his
- 39:54EV
- 39:55subsidies like he,
- 39:56he implemented very middle of the road policies
- 39:59that was his
- 40:00record and a lot of them were
- 40:02pretty positive,
- 40:03but
- 40:04that's a really good example of on paper.
- 40:07That's not what people are thinking of what they're
- 40:08thinking of is like the craziest video they saw online
- 40:11of some
- 40:13random college student saying whatever
- 40:15and,
- 40:17and that does have an impact and you can get radicalized being some random person
- 40:21online and then do political violence and that matters and it should be opposed,
- 40:24but I see as.
- 40:26When it comes to people who have had their hands on power,
- 40:29there's disproportionate extremists in the Republican Party,
- 40:32uh,
- 40:32than the Democratic Party,
- 40:33so I kind of agree with that field analogy
- 40:35but just
- 40:36a little bit the reverse,
- 40:38and I actually just think we had a football field and then we just kind of
- 40:41set it on fire,
- 40:42so.
- 40:44That's the better analogy.
- 40:46Who do you think's gonna be,
- 40:47because,
- 40:47you know,
- 40:48I,
- 40:48I think,
- 40:50oh no,
- 40:50don't you dare I'm gonna do it.
- 40:52Conservatives are in this position of defending
- 40:53this administration and hoping for the best.
- 40:56Democrats have to essentially envision a future and then sell it to people.
- 41:00So who do you think is gonna be
- 41:02the nominee
- 41:03for
- 41:04the Democratic Party?
- 41:06You can answer that or you can say who you want to be the nominee.
- 41:13No,
- 41:14I'm kidding.
- 41:15um,
- 41:16I don't know.
- 41:17I don't know,
- 41:18John.
- 41:18I don't know.
- 41:19It could be
- 41:21anyone,
- 41:21it could be me,
- 41:22maybe it'll be me,
- 41:22you know what?
- 41:23That's it,
- 41:23me.
- 41:24That's my answer.
- 41:24I think it should be me.
- 41:25That was actually another question.
- 41:26So are you,
- 41:27you have any political aspirations?
- 41:31Also,
- 41:31I don't know.
- 41:32I mean,
- 41:32yeah,
- 41:33I,
- 41:33I leave my options open.
- 41:34I try not to get caught up in any weird chats like we just learned
- 41:37that could cause a controversy,
- 41:39um,
- 41:39from the young Republicans.
- 41:41No,
- 41:41I,
- 41:42I definitely see that as potentially
- 41:44something,
- 41:45but right now I'm so passionate about
- 41:46the media space that I'm in.
- 41:48And then I,
- 41:49I don't wanna just completely brush off your question.
- 41:50It's a good one.
- 41:51I
- 41:52just do believe
- 41:53that
- 41:54the Democratic Party needs a real soul searching right now,
- 41:56and I think that the primary is gonna be a really good opportunity for that.
- 41:59So I don't want everyone to kind of like preordain someone.
- 42:01I think
- 42:02all the people run.
- 42:03Shapiro's gonna run.
- 42:04Newsom's gonna run.
- 42:05Maybe AOC is gonna run.
- 42:06Maybe Biden will put his hat back in the ring.
- 42:08We don't know,
- 42:09and
- 42:10then just kind of let them.
- 42:12That's my answer.
- 42:13I think I should,
- 42:13um,
- 42:15that
- 42:16they kind of all hop on the stage
- 42:18and
- 42:18the
- 42:19whoever
- 42:20gets through that crucible
- 42:22will be a much better candidate for it
- 42:24and the different parts of the party,
- 42:26a healthy disagreement about how,
- 42:28how left are we,
- 42:29how
- 42:29center are we,
- 42:30where do we stand on these different
- 42:32issues,
- 42:32foreign policy,
- 42:33otherwise
- 42:34like to really
- 42:35grapple with that
- 42:37and then.
- 42:38Through the process figure out who clearly is the better candidate
- 42:43is what we need to do this time
- 42:45clearly the
- 42:46this is the person before the primary even starts that we know has to be the candidate
- 42:50didn't work,
- 42:50it doesn't work
- 42:51and
- 42:52the competition I think is a really healthy
- 42:54process.
- 42:56Sorry to give you a very politician answer.
- 42:58It's OK.
- 42:59That's what I expected,
- 43:00um,
- 43:00and I think it's actually,
- 43:01uh,
- 43:02an accurate,
- 43:03um,
- 43:04point,
- 43:04you know,
- 43:07I,
- 43:07Chamo from,
- 43:07um,
- 43:08you know,
- 43:08all in pod,
- 43:09I,
- 43:09I don't can't remember when he said this,
- 43:10but I heard him say kind of a similar thing.
- 43:12It's like Donald,
- 43:13Donald Trump took control
- 43:15of the Republican Party very publicly.
- 43:18You know,
- 43:19I don't know,
- 43:20I don't know how old you were when he just like,
- 43:22you know,
- 43:23humiliated,
- 43:24uh,
- 43:24Jeb Bush publicly in one of the debates,
- 43:26and from that moment on he was just sort of elbowing everybody in the face,
- 43:30but it was a very public
- 43:32display of
- 43:34dominance and something like that has not happened.
- 43:37Um,
- 43:38for the Democrats since Obama.
- 43:39So I think you're right,
- 43:40like it's,
- 43:41this is gonna have to be something,
- 43:42you know,
- 43:43a wrestling match that occurs
- 43:45out in the open for everybody to,
- 43:47to witness and,
- 43:48and sort of
- 43:50Agree
- 43:51is real.
- 43:54For sure,
- 43:54and I,
- 43:55I just hope
- 43:56that the Democratic base can do that in a very competitive,
- 44:00very passionate way
- 44:02without us all
- 44:03attacking each other
- 44:04cause I
- 44:06remember kind of the should Biden drop out,
- 44:08should he not.
- 44:10If he does,
- 44:11should Harris be the nominee,
- 44:12and it felt like whatever you say,
- 44:14a third of,
- 44:15for me,
- 44:15my audience,
- 44:16or for
- 44:17a third of
- 44:18people reacting,
- 44:18if you're out there on Twitter
- 44:20would act like you are the enemy and you're
- 44:22essentially MAGA if you don't exactly agree he should
- 44:24stay in or he should drop out or it should be Kamala or it should be news.
- 44:26And so I hope that we can just really hash it out without.
- 44:30Causing ourselves to go into the general election heavily divided.
- 44:34Hm.
- 44:34OK,
- 44:35well,
- 44:36Luke,
- 44:36thanks so much.
- 44:37Thanks again for being in surrounded and thanks for doing this follow-up chat.
- 44:41And hoping to see you in another Jubilee video somewhere down the road.
- 44:45Absolutely,
- 44:45thanks so much,
- 44:46John.
- 44:46All right,
- 44:47take care.
- 44:47If you want to see more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 44:50be sure to like,
- 44:51leave us a positive review,
- 44:53comment if you're watching the video on YouTube.
- 44:55You can subscribe to Tubbilee,
- 44:56Jubilee's second channel.
- 44:58You can also subscribe to Jubilee to see full
- 45:00surrounded episodes.
- 45:02But however you want to support us,
- 45:04just thank you so much for listening.
- 45:05Remember,
- 45:06you could be wrong,
- 45:07so could I.
- 45:08Keep your mind open
- 45:10until next time.