Latest / The Team House / From Ground Branch to Station Chief | Dale Bendler | Ep. 265
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, guys, it's Jack. I just wanted to talk to you today
- 0:03about a way that you can help support the podcast. If you're not already,
- 0:07we would really appreciate it if you guys went and reviewed us on Apple
- 0:10or Spotify. Those reviews really help people find the podcast and help it get
- 0:15recognized, and you know, if you've been enjoying the show, we really
- 0:18appreciate your support. Another thing that you can do to support the channel is
- 0:24to become a Patreon member. So we have Patreon memberships that started just five
- 0:28dollars a month, and when you sign up, you get access to all
- 0:32of our episodes add free. That's the big bonus for that. I mean,
- 0:36we also do some Patreon bonus episodes for our subscribers, but this is
- 0:41the biggest and best way that you can support the Teamhouse channel and podcast if
- 0:47you'd like to, and we really appreciate that. So go and check us
- 0:51out at patreon dot com. Slash the Teamhouse, Special Operations, COBT SP
- 1:03and I The Team House with Your Hopes, Jack Murphy and David Park.
- 1:17Hey everyone, welcome to episode two hundred and sixty five of The Team House.
- 1:19I'm Jack here with Dave and our guest on tonight's show is Dale Bendler.
- 1:25He served as a CIA paramilitary officer and then went on to a number
- 1:29of foreign intelligence assignments, served as chief of station and a couple of locations.
- 1:34Really interesting career, Central America, Africa, West Europe. Dale,
- 1:41We're excited to have you here. This has been a long time coming.
- 1:42I feel like it's my pleasure. Thanks for coming out, my pleasure.
- 1:47So I mean, tell us a little bit about you know, your origin
- 1:49story. I'm hearing that echo, d could you mute that? Please tell
- 1:55us a little bit about like how you came up, how you grew up,
- 1:57and what sort of like propelled you towards Ward's military service. Initially,
- 2:01Oh, it's so middle class New Jersey. In fact, in the Marine
- 2:07Corps, my nickname was Turnpike. But Exit four so closer to Philadelphia than
- 2:14New York, so hence the South Jersey accent, Philadelphia accent, and we
- 2:19would be Flyers and Sixers and Eagles and Phillies, Phillies, Phillies fans.
- 2:24Really no mentor. And I don't know why, even after all these years,
- 2:30with the chance to reflect, why I had to scratch that itch and
- 2:37join, join the service and within the service. Why the Marine Corps.
- 2:42This is post Vietnam, this was post Vietnam not not really a popular time
- 2:46to join the military because you felt it. That's correct, nineteen seventy five
- 2:52to nineteen seventy nine, and I reflect back on those years and there's probably
- 2:59a journal of truth to the argument there was a hollow force that the eighty
- 3:04second existed on paper, the second Redivision existed on paper, but they may
- 3:07not have been as effective forces as we wanted them to be. Racial tensions
- 3:15on all sides, drug abuse, not much budget, no mission, and
- 3:20still an anti Vietnam sentiment. I cheated to a degree. I escaped to
- 3:29elite units, so the man to my left or right were highly motivated as
- 3:35I was at the time. So you went to boot camp as a zero
- 3:40three to eleven infantrymen. I mean, how did that come about? That
- 3:45you ended up like hearing about recon and realized this could be a possibility for
- 3:47you, right, So receiving at camp to June in the late summer early
- 3:53fall of nineteen seventy five, a E five or six came out around and
- 4:00asked who could swim? Some people raised their hand. A lot of people
- 4:03didn't. And what a GT score, So that's in the army you call
- 4:10it. Yeah, it was decent apparently. So they said you're going to
- 4:15recon and it sounded cool, and I was. I was pleased. So
- 4:19I went to Second Recon Battalion out at one Onslow Beach right there in the
- 4:27Atlantic Camp to June. I was there probably for eighteen months, and I
- 4:30understand it was an even more elite unit, second Force Recon. So I
- 4:33went to selection for Second Force and was accepted. What was that selection for
- 4:41Force Recon in nineteen seventy five seventy six, so this would have been seventy
- 4:45seven. They gave me a flat jacket, a Vietnam era flat jacket,
- 4:48a gas mask, and an sixty and we started running and running and running
- 4:55and running, avoiding all those little bridges and making sure you went through every
- 5:00creek there was. And then there was a physical fitness test and a swim
- 5:05test, I think swimming with a folding chair on the length of the pole
- 5:13and it was but like a lot of people enforced Recon, then physical fitness
- 5:19was what we did, in fact, probably at the expense of learning patrolling
- 5:26or actions at the objectives. We spent a lot of time doing PT.
- 5:30I think the platoon I was in could almost run to match the run at
- 5:33the for the Marine Corps the Physical Fitness test three miles and eighteen minutes.
- 5:41We could almost do it in formation. Wow, that's impressive. And you
- 5:46mentioned to me before earlier that you had also gotten a slot to go to
- 5:50Ranger School, which I mean, I went to Ranger School with a couple
- 5:54of recon marines, but you said it was pretty rare back in those I
- 5:57think I'm going to guess one or two a year, and there's a lot
- 6:00of pressure on us to do well. I was an E five and I
- 6:04think one because I was a Marine, and two because I was enlisted.
- 6:09I went in January and February and it was cold, and I have to
- 6:12say I greatly appreciated Ranger School, and I felt that upon graduation I finally
- 6:20had become a special operator because of the emphasis on small unit tactics and actions
- 6:30at the objective, where maybe in Force Recon, at least when I was
- 6:32there, a lot of PTA, a lot of jump, a lot of
- 6:35scuba, maybe not as much small unit operations. With an exception with amphibious
- 6:45reconnaissance school at Little Creek was also very good of learning core skills of a
- 6:50reconnaissance marine amphibious mission. And what was it like, you know, being
- 6:58in forced recon getting in mid to late nineteen seventies. I mean, what
- 7:02were you guys training for. Do you have any ideas of like missions you
- 7:05might get or deployments that might come up? So there was obviously still post
- 7:11Vietnam, so tremendous hesitancy to deploy as your generation did, but it was
- 7:25It took a year or two, but I really fell in love with the
- 7:29mission of reconnaissance and it may have led to a career in the intelligence community
- 7:35because it wasn't to engage the enemy in sort of a direct action, but
- 7:43to be the eyes and ears of the fleet and report back that back the
- 7:48information on the enemy movements. So yeah, it wasn't hard going from a
- 7:58reconnaissance mission to say, case officer espionagre mission right right, different Jammy's the
- 8:05Brooks Brothers suit. When did when did you start twying with the idea of
- 8:13the agency? Was it before you left the Marine Corps or was it during
- 8:16college? It was I was at Second Force recon in camp the June.
- 8:22And yes, there is a library. The Marines still have a library at
- 8:26there's more more than one book. And there was a book on the Bey
- 8:30of Pigs, and so beya pigs happened in nineteen sixty one. This book
- 8:35was written in probably seventy seven. And I said, this is the book
- 8:43underscored the contribution of the Paramilitary Office at CIA. And I said, I
- 8:48think I can do that, but I knew I would have to have a
- 8:52degree a little lower. I love it. See, so it's my Michael
- 9:03first, before I began answering their question. So you decide to leave the
- 9:09Marine Corps, well, already with this idea in your mind that you're going
- 9:11to apply to the agency, go to college. It's nineteen eighty at this
- 9:16point. Where'd you go to school? What'd you major in? So?
- 9:20I went to Rutgers, a state school of New Jersey. And I appreciated
- 9:26the way you framed that, Jack, because for me it wasn't so much
- 9:33as education but training that my Marine Corps time was training to become a CIA
- 9:39officer, and my time in college was training to be a CIA officer.
- 9:45Rutgers political science with as many courses on the Soviet Union as I could take.
- 9:52China was not an issue at the time, and you also got to
- 9:56do a study a broad program, that's correct. So I went to Mexico
- 10:01City and lived with a Mexican family, and I have to say a year
- 10:07abroad. Then it was probably more rewarding than it might be today for young
- 10:13people thinking of a semester abroad because of the iPhone and Google Translate and watching
- 10:22American flex on YouTube, et cetera. You had a backpack and a dog
- 10:28air dictionary in the back if you wanted to said vest or if you wanted
- 10:31to get home. So I did bring smoking good Spanish at a three level
- 10:43I never had to take to see how you never had to train me in
- 10:48Spanish. So I had these special operation skills from an elite unit and a
- 10:56degree in political science and three level Spanish. It isn't just the language skill,
- 11:03but living abroad, abroad and liking it and wanting more. Because CIA
- 11:07is an external agency, of course, and you know people always ask,
- 11:13you know, Dave and I on this show, there are people who are
- 11:16interested in joining the agency or joining some sort of governmental service, the intelligence
- 11:20community. What was your recruitment process, like, what was your application process
- 11:24like? So I remember sending in my application. Of course it was typewriters
- 11:30then and when I got that letter, I still have it that said you
- 11:35think you have we find you competitive For the first interview, and I only
- 11:41had one suit and it was a thick wool suit and it was September in
- 11:45Philadelphia, and I probably got two there two hours early for that meeting and
- 11:52stood outside sweltering and I wasn't going to be late. And I remember my
- 11:58interview. I remember the the hotel. I thought it went well. I
- 12:05thought he may have sympathized with me a little bit for being having been a
- 12:11grunt. So he said, I think you crawled around on your belly enough,
- 12:16I'm going to give you a shot. So I thought I had a
- 12:18pretty good GPA and I could write well also, but that's what it was.
- 12:24And then when I got the GS nine acceptance letter, I would have
- 12:31taken to GS five, but GS nine seemed really good. Second Lieutenant step
- 12:37five, I got step six for Spanish, and curiously, because I had
- 12:43been the jump school, they gave me another step, step seven, just
- 12:46nine step seven And it was unusual for me that I was sponsored by Special
- 12:54Activities Division, In other words, that the Ground Branch wanted me like from
- 12:58the application process they kind of set you up like this is a dude we
- 13:01want to have here. That's correct, And I was very thankful for that.
- 13:05Flattered and there were several important operations going on around the world in Central
- 13:13America and Southern Africa and the and Afghan Afghan one that I wasn't sure in
- 13:24my navy Tay, I wasn't sure. Why did I need FI Why did
- 13:31I need to spin my wheels in Washington and learn to which you tendsil to
- 13:37use at the farm. Uh, there are wars to be fought, and
- 13:43I wanted to go, but I had me and several of my colleagues,
- 13:48contemporaries. We had a the chief of Ground Branch at the time, a
- 13:54gentleman named Chuck, said no, no, you're going. You're going those
- 14:01wars that we're waiting for. You don't worry, and there would be plenty
- 14:03of wars. You're going to be OP certified. This this was your initial
- 14:07intake. When you go to the farm and they're like, no, no,
- 14:09no, You're going to do the whole thing correct, the full kind
- 14:11of the career trainee program, which was a tad unusual for a paramilitary officer
- 14:18in the day. Many were contractors or maybe paramilitary officers, but not operational
- 14:26certified, case officer certified. But this particular leader we had said you're you're
- 14:31going to go, and and many of us, many of whom he said
- 14:39that too, went on to very senior, more senior than I. We
- 14:45should all should be very very thankful. What was the relationship between special activities
- 14:50and the agency at large at that point in time? Second class citizens?
- 14:56I lived it, and I mean you point out out earlier too that you
- 15:01know, had you not gone through the full you know, study program at
- 15:05the farm, that for you and your contemporaries, your careers would have stoled
- 15:09out relatively quickly at a certain point, right, you would not have gotten
- 15:13promoted past a certain point. I'm going to say, as I understand it,
- 15:16at the GS thirteen level, Yeah, as I understand it, And
- 15:22these contemporaries I referred to went well well into the SIS ranks. But even
- 15:26though you were trained as a case officer just like everyone else, they still
- 15:30regarded you as your first and foremost a marine grunt from the FI side.
- 15:35That's that's how we were many of us were viewed. There's a stereotype,
- 15:41but certainly a persistent stereotype that impacted careers. Yeah, we had some k
- 15:48mac uh Sogzog veterans left over, and they were amazing leaders and we learned
- 16:00much from them. Just if I may, just going back to those Marine
- 16:04Corps years seventy five to seventy nine, every e sixth that we met and
- 16:08every three that we met had fallen in nasty counter insurgency in Vietnam, and
- 16:15many of us really just sucked up everything that they could impart on us,
- 16:21and they were great NCOs and officers. And as it turns out, many
- 16:26of those many of the small unit tactics that were passed down to us went
- 16:32on to be very useful in the bush Wars of the eighties, and even
- 16:36one could argue the counter insurgencies in I Rock, in Afghanistan and in the
- 16:40Sahel and other Philippines and other places. So what was it like after you
- 16:45graduate from the farm, you arrive at SAD what's that sort of experience like
- 16:52when you I mean, this was your goal, right, you were excited
- 16:53to be there. I mean, what was it like and how did you
- 16:56start getting involved in? You know, they all Salvador program. So I
- 17:00was the happiest person in the world and I couldn't believe I had a chance
- 17:07to serve my country and remember the Cold Wars on that and get paid while
- 17:17doing it, and have a certain certain prestige a Foreign Service officer working for
- 17:22the State Department. I was the first out of the gate of my CT
- 17:30career trainee class to PCs overseas, and that was to eastern El Salvador to
- 17:36a forward operating base. But before that, let me say, I think
- 17:40you both might appreciate Grand Branch sent sent several of us to Mott Lake for
- 17:45st. Oh cool. Yeah, And I remember close quarter battle and there
- 17:52were forty five's at the time handguns and they really put a lot of emphasis
- 17:57on shooting, and we did hand to hand and we did century takeout and
- 18:03it was really impressive. So this was by probably nineteen eight eighty late.
- 18:10It was actually it was early eighty five. So for the people out there
- 18:14who are listening, maybe don't know what Sotier Mott Lake was. In nineteen
- 18:18seventy seven, we had the Blue Light program, the Special Forces counter Terrorism
- 18:22Unit, and when they stood that down, they wanted to retain that capability,
- 18:27even though the CT mission went to Delta at that point, but they
- 18:30wanted to retain some of those skills, and that's why they continue to run
- 18:33the SOOT program out at Mott Lake up until somewhere in the mid nineties.
- 18:41They ran that and at the time, I mean, no, again,
- 18:42it's kind of like SF history at this point, but at the time that
- 18:47was some of the most dynamic CQB and urban warfare training that was being run
- 18:52anywhere. Excellent. Yeah, yeah, And it almost sounds as though it
- 18:56followed because if they're teaching you hand to hand and stuff like that, it
- 19:00almost sounds like it's falling like the old campbex paradigm of a little you know
- 19:03training, giving you these commando tactics. Yeah, training you you know in
- 19:08these turbo charge sort of commando tactics. Uh yeah, very cool. Yeah.
- 19:14They had the fuselages out there. There were there were like shooting lanes
- 19:21like jungle lanes and stuff, shoot houses. Yes, correct, it was.
- 19:25I thought it was excellent and go down ground Branch to send us there,
- 19:29and we were giving black T shirts. NW DE fillon and later on.
- 19:33I didn't know what it meant at the time, but I went on
- 19:34to serve in French speaking countries and we'll defend this. Yeah, excellent,
- 19:41good for the army. Yeah, it's awesome. Uh. Previous guests on
- 19:45the show ruben Garcia or in the SOT program for a while, maybe it
- 19:49was was there be it was century takeout with a garrote Yeah and k bar
- 19:56yeah, throat sled. Yeah, that's awesome. And so then talk to
- 20:07us about how El Salvador came about for you. So I mister Casey was
- 20:12the director, mister Reagan was the president. So the Cold War was on,
- 20:18that direct conflict with the Soviets out of the question, but maybe we
- 20:23can go toe to toe with them in a third world competition. And so
- 20:33Southern Africa, Central America, and Afghanistan. So I think you had mister
- 20:38Divine sitting here talked eloquently about the afghan program. So Central America was important
- 20:45and frankly closer to home. And I was assigned to the most remote and
- 20:53most violent part of the country. I was, I'd like to say I
- 20:59did it had differently that most in the paramilitary world. Then would TDY and
- 21:06not necessarily with the language, and maybe not with case officer skills. And
- 21:11I'm not saying I'm better. I'm just saying I was fortunate to be case
- 21:17officer certified, have three level Spanish, and be a recon marine and be
- 21:23and then have some special small unit tactic counterinsurgency experience. So it was all
- 21:36on counterinsurgency with ourselves orned partners, and I totally believed in the mission.
- 21:41Talk to us about what form that took, and you know what it was
- 21:44like going going down there, getting to poy down there, what the enemy
- 21:48situation was like in the friendly situation, and how you kind of evolved that
- 21:51while you PCs down there. Well, first I have to give a shout
- 21:55out to your generation because we, as dangerous as it was, we didn't
- 22:00have to deal with sfs or v bits and you two had a deal deal
- 22:06deal with that. I would also say probably like my Vietnam case officer veterans,
- 22:19my brothers and sisters who went before us in Vietnam, we similarly when
- 22:26we would have an agent meeting up country, it was it was just us
- 22:29in a thin skin vehicle and maybe a well we had the we had the
- 22:33Browning High Power was the CIA issued weapon. And I spoke the language,
- 22:41so I didn't have a linguist, and I was my own targeter, and
- 22:45I was my own analyst. So it's just me with a source. And
- 22:51I looked back on in hindsight it was it was dangerous much, yeah,
- 22:55correct, But I got to work with seals and the Seventh Group was there,
- 23:00and that by the mid eighties you had that CIA human support to counter
- 23:06insurgency with n SW and soft and from that when it grew into what it
- 23:12is today, well it's Vietnam and we continued the tradition. So who were
- 23:18the insurgents in El Salvador at that time, So it would be the FMLN
- 23:22was the umbrella group quartermastered by the Soviet Union and then supported by Cuba directly,
- 23:30and then there were several Gorolla factions underneath. One of the larger was
- 23:37called the erp Hersito Revolution Pueblo and led by a commandante named Joaquimbia Lobos and
- 23:47famous in the famous in anybody who has studied the insurgency counter insurgency in L
- 23:55Salvador. Fast forward twenty years, he had moved on to Oxford where he
- 23:59was is doing a dissertation on peace talks conflict resolution, and I went to
- 24:11see him and it was a fascinating you get fascinating one on one fascinating experience
- 24:18in insurgency and counterinsurgency, and he said some very interesting points. I documented
- 24:25it and I shared it because we were in the especially a d O D
- 24:32we're in taking on these counter insurgency missions in the Middle East. When when
- 24:36you guys met all those years later, was it like just two professionals like
- 24:40talking shop, two professionals talking shops? And I remember he said that you
- 24:47often would have that map with the red little red dots of insurgence activity.
- 24:51It's actually where there is no activity is where we have our clandestine infrastructure.
- 24:57And that's where the nurses flinging off one or two penicillin pills per week that
- 25:03goes to the insurgent hospital. This college professor ciphering it off two or three
- 25:07pages of eight by eleven that would go into the propaganda. Remember this is
- 25:11the mid eighties, or the compasina who hangs laundry on Wednesdays if government forces
- 25:19are in the area. He said, that's where we made most of our
- 25:22money, right, the insurgents aren't going to attack where their bed down site
- 25:26is. So it's like the blank site on the map is kind of where
- 25:29you want to where you needed to be. And I I'm not sure if
- 25:33that was made its way through Afghanistan and Iraq. It also underscored to me
- 25:37my experiences in El Salvador and the clandestine infrastructure. It's just how effective and
- 25:44how proud the veterans should be who participated in Phoenix Phoenix that I that really
- 25:49hurt the Vietcong brilliant, brilliant, brilliant, brilliant program. And so for
- 25:56you down there as a as a paramilitary officer or what was your partner for
- 26:00us that you worked with? What were those guys like? So Salvadorn Infantry,
- 26:10there was an elite unit called pral Petro the stance yet long distance like
- 26:19alert long distance, but they were based at a strategic asset and they were
- 26:23based in San Salvador, the capitol. And I wasn't, I didn't didn't
- 26:30didn't work for them. So I worked with the line battalions. I will
- 26:34I will say when I PCSD there. My R and R point was sant
- 26:44was San Salvador. I mean I would try to come back once every once
- 26:48every two weeks, and we was definitely a h An assignment, wearing camouflage
- 26:55and carrying a Browning no M four, but just a Browning high power.
- 27:00Right. I mean you mentioned meeting with sources, so I mean it sounds
- 27:06like you really were like the one guy out there supporting these units sort of
- 27:10on the front lines of this counterinsurgency doing helping them with their intel, helping
- 27:12them with their training. Right. I had to lead for Mortissan l and
- 27:18San Miguel, the most inflictive districts provinces in El Salvador. And police how
- 27:27are you identifying you know, if you look at sort of the agency today
- 27:32and targeters and you know, analysts and collection managers and all that, but
- 27:36you're out there on the ground in a very tactical world, how are you
- 27:41identifying sources? How are you finding them? Recruiting them for the ones that
- 27:47weren't like handed over to you regularly in the prisons of the Salvadoran police or
- 27:55military. And I spent quite a bit, in fact, I remember distinct.
- 28:00One of the proudest moments for me was Christmas Day, twenty five December
- 28:06nineteen eighty five interrogating a Communist insurgent and trying to uncover that insurgent nurse and
- 28:21compasina with the laundry and the professor, and just how fulfilling that was that
- 28:32my country could enjoy and the families could enjoy Christmas because some of us were
- 28:37in these kind of places. And I'm sure you've had those same feelings or
- 28:40Thanksgiving and Christmas. It was an honor, and I remember that I could
- 28:47I feel like I could be in the cell with that guy. Guy today
- 28:49it was just me and him needed the language. And you keep talking to
- 28:56insurgents like that, you become a very good analyst and you become a targeter.
- 29:00Yeah, to go that deep into the culture for that one, and
- 29:03it stayed with me for a couple of decades later, where I really I
- 29:08like to think I developed a mature, a sophisticated appreciation for counterinsurgency that would
- 29:15later pay dividends in places like Peru. And so you pointed out that this
- 29:19was like some of the hottest years of the insurgency in the Salvador. What
- 29:23was the enemy doing at that point and what were you guys doing to fight
- 29:27back? So that it was still post Vietnam, and it was a limited
- 29:33one. I think it was fifty five green berets, and one work around
- 29:38that would be say sending CI paramilitary officers or case officers, and that way
- 29:45it was for whole government fifty five plus maybe ten or twenty. I should
- 29:55also say I'd like to give a shout out to the officers who served the
- 29:59my I left and right in El Salvador. They went on to assume very
- 30:04senior positions at CIA, to include uh mister Jose Rodriguez became the d d
- 30:10O and he was my branch chief then. But so I mean again back
- 30:17to El Salvador, like what was the enemy activities and what were you guys
- 30:21doing to counter that insurgency? Particularly Loan, you know. And I was
- 30:23on the Gulf of Fonseca and we wanted to interdict weapons coming in across the
- 30:30golf from uh Nicaragua, and I thought, I thought the best way to
- 30:37do that wasn't flear or aircraft. Of course, we had no imagery,
- 30:48right, right and the other three D letter agency, I never heard of
- 30:52him, and I never got never got a single product for right. But
- 30:56let me say I I grew up without that, and I never needed it,
- 31:00and when I got it, I appreciated it, but it was a
- 31:03luxury what I grew out, grew up without the g RS, the analyst,
- 31:10the targeter, the reports officer, support from other three letter agencies,
- 31:18so maritime operations to interdict the flow of weapons into the country. And then
- 31:26I really wanted to try to get a spy inside of the Cuba nexus.
- 31:36And I always suspected that there was a Cuban my Cuban counterpart was in country,
- 31:41but I don't think he ever was. We've had Cuban defector since I
- 31:47talked to Cubans, a DGI or a Tropis, especially Anes, and they
- 31:52in the seventies and eighties in Cuba, they were very aggressed, noble adversaries,
- 31:59very very capable. They they did. Were you ever able to penetrate
- 32:04that in access? Not as not as well as I would have have liked
- 32:08to rankly, Yeah, but were you able to start to counter the smuggling
- 32:13routes? Yes, yes we were, and I wish Walking Beelowis had been
- 32:19my source. We could have fully ended the insurgency. But it's interesting what
- 32:23you learn from the other side post hostilities as I understand that what comes out
- 32:32of Hannoi, the the the VC and n v as UH take when some
- 32:38of our battles are absolutely fascinating for our veteran veterans. So what what did
- 32:45you take away from, like what you learned in hindsight about the conflict you
- 32:49were in UH the clan, particularly the key role of intelligence, human support
- 32:55to the counterinsurgency and the clandestine infrastructure. And I would have liked to think
- 33:01that that may have been more of a focus in places like a rock in
- 33:07Afghanistan, the person without the aka or rpg svest imagine looking at Hamas and
- 33:17what happened on seven October. You didn't really have to have a Hamas killer
- 33:22to be your source. You could have had someone selling figs in a market
- 33:29in Gaza saying, you know, my cousin barred my motorcycle and he won't
- 33:32tell me why, right right? Something innocuous? Seemingly Yeah, seemingly Were
- 33:39there any things that came up during your discussion, anything that he said that
- 33:45when you think about it in retrospect, seems obvious and you can't see how
- 33:50the US missed it. Like obviously things you know, hindsight is twenty twenty,
- 33:53but were there things that like seemed like when he said it, you're
- 33:57like, ah, yeah, that seems obvious. Well they but we didn't
- 34:00think about it back wells as I mentioned that the lack of insurgent activity is
- 34:05where you're going to have Now they won't conduct offensive operations in those areas either,
- 34:09right, we're safe. Right, we could go to the beach,
- 34:14or we can have a beer out in a Pilsner out in servece out in
- 34:20town. They're not going to start the pot, right, So that is
- 34:27and particularly that CIS job. I don't really think that are lesser degree maybe
- 34:35human certified soft n c O officer and c O maybe a little bit,
- 34:45but that's really a CIA case officer's role in a counterinsurgency is that clandestine infrastructure
- 34:52and having a source inside there because you don't have to recruit somebody with a
- 34:55weapon, right, and by definition we can't. We can't really get to
- 35:00that insurgent with an AK forty seven. We could get to that compassene and
- 35:05who hangs the laundry out, We can get to that professor, and we
- 35:08can get to the UNDERSYYUS. We can Yeah, and we did and this
- 35:16makes sense. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. So, as you know,
- 35:21you get to the end of your time in El Salvador, how had the
- 35:23situation changed? Was the insurgency starting to wind down? Like what was your
- 35:27perception of how things were going to an counterinsurgency is if at the end of
- 35:32the year, you take accumulatively, not in sequence, twenty steps forward and
- 35:38only nineteen backs, so it accounts for one step forward. That's that's that's
- 35:43a good year, right for your I'm sorry, but for your generation,
- 35:45twenty years in a rock, twenty years in afghanistand imagine if we had taken
- 35:49one step forward each, right, Yeah, So that's that's Uh, Americans
- 35:54are uncomfortable with that, but it's it's great. Maybe Columbia's fight against the
- 35:59far it may have been one step forward a few those years, and it'll
- 36:05it'll take fifty years. It takes fifty years. Yeah, sorry, yeah,
- 36:08yeah, nineteen forty eight. Yeah, We'll got that. So so,
- 36:12but your thought, your feelings were that you know, there were baby
- 36:15steps in the right direction. Correct on this thing? Correct? And how
- 36:17did it actually wind down? Was that before after or was it after you
- 36:21left that it kind of sputtered out. So that well, with the dissolution
- 36:25of the Soviet Union and what that meant for Cuba, right, and what
- 36:30that meant for and the bad name that international communism suffered. So it did
- 36:37it? Did it? Just with it? By eighty nine? It was
- 36:40probably pretty I think ninety one ninety one, Yeah, yeah, well,
- 36:45I mean in Nicaragua, it makes sense. It wasn't until like what ninety
- 36:47that the elections were held, so correct. Yeah, So all this was
- 36:50sort of coming and the Cubans were leaving Angola, and it was all sort
- 36:54of coming to a conclusion. And then before we move on to the next
- 37:04thing, and I have in my notes, I'm trying to remember exactly what
- 37:06it was that we wanted to talk about. You had some thoughts about foreign
- 37:09intelligence versus paramilitary because you've done both. Do you want did you want to
- 37:15comment on anything on that or maybe maybe after maybe talk a little bit about
- 37:22Africa, and then that's why you get onto that. Yeah. Yeah,
- 37:28So nineteen eighty seven, you're back at headquarters. You hear about the Angla
- 37:34Task Force. What's going on? So I nineteen eighty seven, nineteen eighty
- 37:42six, excuse me, the fall of eighty six. I had been out
- 37:44at El Salvador maybe a month, and I understood there was a program in
- 37:49Southern Africa, and I walked in that office without telling my chain of command.
- 37:54I said, I'm your man, I'm going how they respond and who
- 38:00are you? But it was really important that I had counterinsurgency field experience,
- 38:07that I was case officer certified, and when I had, I do have
- 38:12conditions. I want to go PCs, not TDY. I don't want to
- 38:15have the language, which wasn't a terrible stretch transitioning from Spanish to Portuguese.
- 38:22It's about takes about three months, and there's about three hundred words that are
- 38:25different, and for viewers and listeners who aren't familiar with the terms, PCs
- 38:30is a permanent change of station and then TDY is temporary duty. So there
- 38:36is a different like temporary duty that sends you over whatever the trip is three
- 38:39months, six months, and you come back and you get on rotations and
- 38:44then a PCs is they move you there and it's like a two year like
- 38:49two or three year built whatever it is, but it's so you wanted to
- 38:52be there sort of permanently correct to spot assessed develop and recruit. Can't do
- 39:00that TDY. I understand officers go to TDY and work very hard, and
- 39:05I understand they've had successes. I'm saying in general, it takes more than
- 39:09a few weeks. Right, So the same sort of questions I asked about
- 39:14al Savador, I mean, what's going on in the end goal? At
- 39:15the time, we were with Unida, and then it was mp l A
- 39:20on the other side, correct, and the and FENLA for a little bit
- 39:23they sputtered out, that's correct. Yeah. And so this was the Cold
- 39:30War was on and we didn't know, No one knew how the Cold War
- 39:37was going to end, and the Cubans had massive forces in country. And
- 39:45give credit once again, I think to mister Reagan, this is a chance
- 39:50for us to go against the Soviets, be a proxy to retard Soviet expansionism
- 39:59in the developing world, I think, And this one was Maryel Salvador was
- 40:07counterinsurgency. This was insurgency, and I can tell you one's a whole lot
- 40:09more fun than the other. That in a remote not very dangerous, but
- 40:21we didn't know that at the time. I also want to give a shout
- 40:23out to my brothers and sisters who who served in that area, and I'll
- 40:30just say their first name is Phil and Greg Scott. They're my friends to
- 40:34this day. And they did amazing work there and they went on to assume
- 40:39the highest levels of leadership that at CIA. So it's a real honor for
- 40:44me to be associated with people who who did that. Yeah, and those
- 40:52I spoke to two of the three for a piece that I've been working on
- 40:57about about Willie Murkerson. We'll get it, I mean another time, tell
- 41:01his entire story about his life and service in Vietnam and then in the CIA.
- 41:07But Willie's humility is is breathtaking. Yeah. I didn't know he was
- 41:14a DCM Distinguished Service Cross. Yeah, I didn't know he was, and
- 41:22he never told me. Yeah, he is like that. He's just like
- 41:27it's another it's another day. Yeah, it's fascinating, imagine. Yeah.
- 41:32Yeah, but well we'll again, we'll tell this story another time. But
- 41:37he, uh, he earned it. He was in combat. Okay,
- 41:43So you're in you're in Angola this time the partner forces you need, uh,
- 41:46you're up against them p l A and there's like fifty thousand Cuban troops
- 41:52that are over there as well. Soviet Union has their hands in it.
- 41:55What's going on on the ground, You said, you're in this case,
- 41:58you're sort of waging more of your playing the role more of the insurgent.
- 42:01So I did get to not work directly with, but observe the sa d
- 42:07F South African Defense Force and they were very effective. And there was one
- 42:15again Soviet quartermastered and Cuban led that if you lost the Sukho or a meg,
- 42:22we were a T fifty five or a or howitzer or the one katushas.
- 42:31Yeah, the Soviet Union would fly in replacements. So in South Africa
- 42:37it was an arms of bar U. So it was a lot. They
- 42:39were a lot. The losses weren't easily easily replaced. It had been the
- 42:45biggest tank battle in Southeast Angle, the biggest tank battle since World War Two,
- 42:52now now replaced by Ukraine. But it was a warworth worth studying.
- 42:58And we introduced sensitive surface day or mission capability. Yeah. It it as
- 43:08that. It it was a tactical weapon at having a strategic state, strategic
- 43:14impact. I've been told that we introduced that into Angola actually before Afghanistan.
- 43:20Imagine, yeah, no, beause nobody talks about or knows about it really
- 43:24imagine. Yeah, but how did that start to change the situation over there?
- 43:30It was because it restricted the way the Cubans were able to fly and
- 43:34the closer support they may have been for it. Indeed, indeed, a
- 43:37MiG twenty three was shut down and the Cuban lieutenant, colonel and captain were
- 43:43brought into that uned a base camp. And I asked permission from that I'm
- 43:49a Spanish speaker and I had some expertise on Cuba that I asked permission if
- 43:53I could participate in the interrogation, and it was denied because they were under
- 44:01the rest, they were prisoners, prisoner of war, They were uniformed,
- 44:05and they were prisoners of war. And indeed, and indeed we did ask
- 44:08VIMY to respect their human rights and they might be more valuable from a human
- 44:17perspective, propaganda perspective, and then a value in a prisoner exchange. And
- 44:22that is what happened. That's incredible, that's incredible, and I understand.
- 44:30I some months ago, I did an interview for Spanish speaking television, not
- 44:37Spanish television, Spanish speaking television in and for the Cuban American community in Miami
- 44:44and I talked about this case, and I think that the pilot rode into
- 44:50the TV station was maybe disputing some of some aspects of my story. But
- 44:58that's he's alive, So that's awesome. I'm sorry. So what other activities
- 45:07were you participating in in Angola or I mean going from like Zaire and projecting
- 45:13into Angola, I mean, what was the mission like at that time?
- 45:15So we're very small. Where I mentioned L Salvador would have been fifty five
- 45:23SF and the defense at Tache, throughout the embassy fifty five s F up
- 45:30country, probably twenty of US case officers paramilitary officers, where that Southern African
- 45:43assignment was two maybe three period wow. So, and it was no direct
- 45:52action but largely no joint patrolling, but largely let's intel and lethal support to
- 46:00the insurgents. Yeah, it's that that sort of oss mission that people think
- 46:04it's like dagger in your teeth, but a lot of times it's more you're
- 46:07acting as a coordinator and a logistician. Right, Yes, yes we were,
- 46:10and it's someone to say it's more than that, but it was heavy
- 46:14on, heavy on the on the logistics and the intel. But we we
- 46:19all certainly believed in the mission. It was very important. The South Africans
- 46:22were assisting with that effort. They were fighting and dying. Yes, I
- 46:27know their whole their whole border war, but I mean with your program,
- 46:30was there any sort of there was the understanding that we wouldn't recognize each other
- 46:35because of the political sense of these because apart I was in full, full
- 46:38full. That's really interesting because now I remember the interview we did with Kus,
- 46:45who's a South African WRECKI for the war. They were very good.
- 46:50They were very good, and I remember him saying, he's like, yeah,
- 46:52we knew the agency guys were over there, but our direction was like,
- 46:55don't even look at him, don't talk to him. I will just
- 46:58say that we had a well, I'm going to say his name, it's
- 47:05J. J. Walker was a legend the Special Forces community, one of
- 47:08those Green Berets who went to Vietnam in the mid sixties and stayed because his
- 47:14dad went away to World War Two and only came home when the war was
- 47:16over. So he's going to Vietnam and he's going to come home when the
- 47:20war was over. And it was an unfair burden of a five or six
- 47:22or seven year tour. Yeah, yeah, and he was passing kidney stones
- 47:29and we didn't know what to do in the middle of the Tallaharry Desert.
- 47:30We certainly didn't have our own aircraft. And the South African saved his life,
- 47:36or I'd better be careful with that. They came in and got him.
- 47:38They came in and got him. Yeah, and he was hard as
- 47:43nails, like many of those Vietnam era Special Forces NCOs, hard as nails,
- 47:51and the pain dropped them. I looked at one of the one of
- 47:55the stones under a microscope and it looked like a snow flake. No,
- 48:04thank you. Yeah, there's a story that I'm recalling, Dale, and
- 48:08maybe it was your story. It may have been another person I talked to,
- 48:12something about waiting on an airfield and like the South African show up and
- 48:15the agency guys had to jump into the bushes because they weren't supposed to talk
- 48:20to him. It's I that's not me, but I can see I believe
- 48:25it's another friend of mine. Yeah, but I believe it. But it
- 48:30wasn't hostile. It was just you're not supposed to have contact, right,
- 48:36And I think the condition was well as I understand the strategy and what hell
- 48:44the administration mister Eagan sold it to Congress was look, we're weaning you need
- 48:49away from the apartheid regime. Let us do this. I think I would
- 48:55just say, looking back in hindsight of a lesson learned, and I think
- 49:00kudos to your program because you often asked that of your guests, so that
- 49:06this maybe a future generation doesn't have to reinvent. Uh. Yeah, uh
- 49:14hard lessons learned and we learned that it was correct, and that is and
- 49:19maybe we could have juxtaposed it on Afghanistan and Iraq, and that is when
- 49:23we looked at Angola, we looked at East West communism and anti communism when
- 49:32it was Overbundu, Chokwe, Lingala, other other tribes, Kimbundo, and
- 49:45we looked at it as a cold war conflict and ignorant of the tribal divisions
- 49:52that are imagined Afghanistan, Ukraine. That it's uh, it's it's I did
- 50:05my best to pass that on to the next generations. Please please take under
- 50:09under considerations. Take that under consideration. I would I would say, based
- 50:15on that experience that you wouldn't hear me refer to South African as South African.
- 50:22I want to know if they're black or white and black witch tribe or
- 50:24colored with ou their their word there spelling, or if they're white, are
- 50:30they English or Afrikaans exactly? And if you're or or if they're's Lebanese,
- 50:37don't say Lebanese because we need to know trition soon imagine a Rockies, So
- 50:43we need to be a good case officer needs to be sophisticated that in that
- 50:47regard, the French intelligence officer Station Washington, DC better know the difference between
- 50:52north West Washington and southeast right, not not disparaging one or the other,
- 50:55but there's two different worlds, correct the French. Well, the French know
- 50:59West Africa pretty well, so yeah, yeah, But it's interesting because with
- 51:06you know, with the the United States, and I don't want to say
- 51:10the intelligencies because I think it's just a thing across the border in the United
- 51:14States. So our politicians are public everything like that. We you know,
- 51:19we don't understand the intricacies of other countries well, and so we could look
- 51:23at the conflicts in you know, Africa at the time as communism versus you
- 51:30know, freedom or democracy. Meanwhile, there are these are very personal conflicts
- 51:35going on with these tribes that have the pre date any political system that we're
- 51:40talking about. Even when we look at cultures that are closer to US,
- 51:44Poland Ukraine you mentioned these places, they have historical right chief going on.
- 51:49You know that goes, it does go beyond our comprehension a lot of times.
- 51:52Yeah, I'm not saying we don't go to war. I'm just saying,
- 51:53yeah, you know you need to to factor in, yeah, in
- 51:58the nuances in fact, for foreign intelligence officer allied or friendly or not so
- 52:05friendly, stationed in Washington, d C. Or at the UN or here
- 52:07across the river. The US is a very complex, complex society. Yeah,
- 52:17And it don't just because we make good movies and people watch the movies,
- 52:22they assume they they know us and we have issues. Right before we
- 52:29move on from Angola, I mean, well, I want to ask you
- 52:31how it wound down for you, But I also got to ask, like,
- 52:36do you have any hand or anything you can talk about as far as
- 52:38like interesting ops that you guys ran in Angola, Like I've heard some pretty
- 52:43cool stories about training Angolans to do sabotage operations and things that were done to
- 52:51mess with the anime. I will say that once we were going to give
- 52:55them some maritime training and we needed to know if they could swim. Back
- 53:02to my important my recruitment into Recon Battalion, Could I swim? And all
- 53:08of them said yes, And they say A platoon and Special Forces legend was
- 53:17down there at the time, Ron Franklin, and we had to well,
- 53:22we found a river and we would have them swim across it just as a
- 53:28simple test, maybe twenty five meters not much current. We did throw hand
- 53:31grenades in just to flush out crocodiles, right, weren't any and two or
- 53:43three people needed to have their lives saved. I mean it was a sheer
- 53:49terror panic and and I think back, I'm not pretending it's a big deal,
- 53:54and I don't want any credit for it. But I kind of hung
- 53:58onto a route on the uh the bank of the river and stuck my big
- 54:02long body out my big boot and I grabbed it and I pulled him out,
- 54:07and he just you know, he wasn't gonna make it as a surface
- 54:12swimmer. Somewhere were you able to identify an effective you know force eventually though?
- 54:21Correct correct that I would have to say a very little corruption, right,
- 54:29And that really was was a pleasure working with those with those insurgents,
- 54:34and they believed, they believed in their calls, and they were extraordinarily,
- 54:37extraordinarily austere all stere conditions. Yes, our mail was where it was World
- 54:43War two technology. We would get mail once every two or three weeks.
- 54:47Uh, A two week old Washington Post was a we would fund to read.
- 54:52Uh. We got our news through the radio, a short wave.
- 54:54Yeah. So how did it wind down for you in eighty eight? Where
- 55:00was the conflict at by the time you were taking off? So, as
- 55:07I recall, there had been gains for the insurgents, slight probably, I'll
- 55:14use the same analogy twenty steps forward nineteen back, and the Soviet and Communist
- 55:22forces were not going to wipe out one third of the population of an embedded
- 55:30insurgency with a safe haven across the border. Yeah, And you were making
- 55:37this costly for them, Yes, And there was because of Vietnam. And
- 55:43I mentioned me being in the seventies and learning so much from those who had
- 55:47sacrificed so much over there that it gave me frankly great professional pleasure to slow
- 55:52bleed the Soviets in revenge for what they did in Vietnam, which was a
- 55:59flow of military hardware to the viet Cong and NBA to Mame to kill and
- 56:06Mamar soldiers. It really is interesting because you bring up you bring up point
- 56:09that I don't think has been brought up on the show before because we've talked
- 56:12about insurgencies and counterinsurgencies, but you talk about the idea of an insurgency that
- 56:20has a safe haven across the border, and you know, you look at
- 56:25Vietnam, I mean we even look at Afghanistan, like you look at these
- 56:29places where the insurgents can simply flow back to a place where they are unbothered,
- 56:35unhaspbled, and and essentially untouchable in another country. And it's even worse.
- 56:42Yeah, because his name was mister marsh and I think he was a
- 56:47macth fisog s F legend and he may have been a sergeant major. And
- 56:53he came over to Ground Branch and very early on he was in eastern Afghanistan
- 57:04and he pointed at Pakistan and said that's Cambodia, and it was he kind
- 57:08of it's chilling, right right, yeah, chilling, And it was yeah,
- 57:19that's Cambodia. Yeah, so you're out of Angola and now you get
- 57:29into the foreign intelligence stuff. How does that take poise? So in my
- 57:35experience, and there might be other examples, but in the nineteen eighties,
- 57:39for a case officer certified paramilitary officer, it was important to do what was
- 57:44called an FI rotational and it was important for the agency, it was important
- 57:52for mission, it was important for the officer. And I think too many
- 57:57of them probably went to a certain Latin American country that had its own insurgency
- 58:10at the time, and I think I'll say that mister Escobar spent a lot
- 58:19of time in that country. I really thought that was really only half of
- 58:23an FI assignment, right, And it was good that they went PCs,
- 58:28and it's good that they were in an embassy, traditional embassy, and it
- 58:30was good that they learned in language Spanish really, so it's it's it's good.
- 58:37But if I'm going to do an f I rotation, I'm going to
- 58:40Europe and I'm going to be I'm not gonna be working with the local service,
- 58:49and that's why I'll be vague on the country. But that was more
- 58:52classic espionage. The wall was still up, so it was so a union
- 58:57commerce, China, Communists, North Korea, Commune, Cuba and Islamica Ron
- 59:01Islamic Uh. Terrorism was not on the radar at the time you were going
- 59:08after targets. I was, yeah, because they we had the hijackings in
- 59:15the seventies and maybe they but but terrorism had kind of fallen by the wayside,
- 59:21right I think so as you know, in terms of like a real
- 59:24strategic focus. Well, of course Buckley and the Marine barracks, right,
- 59:31yeah, that's as ballah. But at least for me in the European country,
- 59:37it was very traditional trade craft and it frankly it was my third tour,
- 59:45but it was really like my first because I was now wearing a suit
- 59:50and tie and it is different. So it's it's I think it's a good
- 59:55time to plug our sponsors. No no to go. Do we have sponsor
- 1:00:00no to go to go back to go back to the question you asked though
- 1:00:06about the stigma around foreign intelligence versus because this is where that really comes to
- 1:00:10play. Let me go ahead and just plug our patreon first for a second.
- 1:00:15I just want to let people know that if you subscribe to our Patreon
- 1:00:17and there's a link down in the description. You get access to all these
- 1:00:21episodes ad free, and we really appreciate you supporting the show. We also
- 1:00:24have a second podcast that's more current events, national security things that are in
- 1:00:30the news called ayes On, hosted by Andy Milburn and Jason Lyons. And
- 1:00:35also please check out our friends at Casa Carabeo Cigars who can find them at
- 1:00:38Casacarabeo dot com. Another great Cuban American SF veteran who owns that company.
- 1:00:47Okay, so let's jump back to your to your point about the stigma that
- 1:00:52was following around guys like you at the time in foreign intelligence. So I
- 1:00:57will welcome views to the contrary from colleagues who didn't have the experience I did.
- 1:01:02But this was post Vietnam and nineteen eighties, and there was still a
- 1:01:10knuckle dragger stereotype. And even though they had a certificate to do full cycle
- 1:01:19human recruiting, maybe it wasn't their strength and they maybe they weren't necessarily welcomed
- 1:01:28in a more traditional station. How did you cope with that? So I
- 1:01:32coped with it by being the first one in the office in the morning and
- 1:01:37the last one to leave at night. And I had to work harder,
- 1:01:40to be equal. And if I would say that, if I made a
- 1:01:50minor contribution in my career to Baria military officers who later enjoyed easier access to
- 1:02:01the FI world, maybe I helped just just shoulder the door open all just
- 1:02:06just a little bit, yeah, just a little bit. I remember one
- 1:02:08instance, I was in the office, staying late as usual. I wasn't
- 1:02:13married, right, same with L. Salvadorn Angola. So that's why,
- 1:02:17another reason for the PCs and not TDY. By the way, in Europe
- 1:02:22and the there was a this is before iPhones and internet, so there was
- 1:02:28a walk in, which is a very very big deal for CIA, and
- 1:02:32the chief of station and the SIS ranks came down a floor to the bullpen
- 1:02:39of case officers. I was in there alone, and he was talking to
- 1:02:43the deputy and he said, we have a walk in. Who's here And
- 1:02:46the deputy said only Dale. And the chief of station said, I don't
- 1:02:51want that knuckle dragger going near this case. It might be something important,
- 1:02:55and so I remember that. But he had no choice and I did fine.
- 1:03:05I'm not saying I did anything remarkable, but you did your job.
- 1:03:09I did my job, and the language skills helped. There was a low
- 1:03:15intensity conflict connection that this particular walk in. So I may have been well
- 1:03:19well suited for that. And I like to think that proving that I could
- 1:03:30do it, maybe that convinced other chief of stations and other FI leadership that,
- 1:03:39hey, some of these OP certified case officer, certified paramilitary officers give
- 1:03:45him a chance. Did that help or did that chief of station in particular
- 1:03:50kind of like open become a little more open minded after all of that.
- 1:03:52I don't think so. Well, it can't hurt to try. I don't
- 1:03:58think I don't think so. And I think that maybe today some might not
- 1:04:06even be aware of that that history. But then after eleven September, when
- 1:04:15foreign intelligence really mixed with the PM world that are up certified paramilitary officers really
- 1:04:26really became first class citizens. Then it became and maybe some FI officers serving
- 1:04:33in places like Paraguay, we're the second class citizens because you had to know
- 1:04:46a little bit about became the SAD and CTC correct. So I'm very proud
- 1:04:55of that. So it almost went from being like the redheaded step child to
- 1:05:00being like the prodigal you know, the prodigal child, where it gave you
- 1:05:05Bona Fidi's wherever else you went. Later on, we really needed those guys
- 1:05:11post eleventh September and just in time, and they did. They did remarkable,
- 1:05:16remarkable work. By that time eleventh September I had tradition transitioned to pure
- 1:05:23pure FI. So it was their turn, and I'm very very pleased that
- 1:05:28so many of them succeeded. Now in the agency. Back in those days,
- 1:05:32was there the concept of like the hardship tour that you had to do
- 1:05:36in order to further your career and was sad considered that. So I want
- 1:05:42to be fair on the definition of hardship because the Beijing, Havana, Moscow
- 1:05:51crowd, that's hardship, right, So and they are they are the pinnacle
- 1:05:58of of hard skills different, right, But if you can do that,
- 1:06:04that is I've always been impressed with those guys. I did not, yeah,
- 1:06:11but in terms of like going to a location that people didn't want to
- 1:06:15go to post eleventh September, yes, it was important and you almost had
- 1:06:19had to have done it. What about before, like before nine to eleven?
- 1:06:24Similarly, was that a thing like you have to go to Paraguay or
- 1:06:27you have to go to Somebodace. People don't really want to go. I
- 1:06:30don't know if people want to go to Paraguay. But you know, you
- 1:06:31can't just do the European Embassy circuit. You have to do something that people
- 1:06:35don't want to do in order to advance your career or you know, things
- 1:06:40like that. But she post eleventh September, okay, And what of course
- 1:06:43happened is and maybe similar to our DoD brothers and sisters, was that as
- 1:06:48the g WATT continued, many people became very senior in the director of Operations
- 1:06:56and they were keeping maybe they were less impressed with Lisband or Milan and more
- 1:07:06impressed with Candahar or Nize because I think it's important to know and you can
- 1:07:16correct me if I'm wrong, because I might be wrong. But in the
- 1:07:19military, when you get orders, you get orders when you're when your unit's
- 1:07:23moving out somewhere, like you don't get to say I don't as isn't really
- 1:07:27for me. And in the agency though, I mean, it's a civilian
- 1:07:30organization, so they can give you an assignment, but you can also say
- 1:07:33no, correct, don't excuse me, don't, but don't make it a
- 1:07:40pattern. Okay, Uh, that will hurt. That will hurt your career.
- 1:07:44I think as I towards the latter part of my career spent time in
- 1:07:48Europe, it was an operational or tactical reason I preferred Europe, and I'll
- 1:07:54tell you that in a minute. But as I moved more to Europe,
- 1:08:00I think I got something of a pass because of the hardship I did early
- 1:08:05on. Interesting, now, by the time we get to nineteen ninety one,
- 1:08:11well maybe before we move on to Peru, just one last question about
- 1:08:15you know that initial FI rotations that you did in Europe. I mean,
- 1:08:19were you over there when the wall came down? I mean I got to
- 1:08:21ask you, what was that like that? There's a colonel truth to the
- 1:08:27stereotype that a Soviet now Russian lieutenant colonel gru would show up at an embassy
- 1:08:40and offers services and we would say no thanks, because we have a two
- 1:08:45star in the walking room. Okay, so, but we probably could have
- 1:08:59done better. But these were extraordinarily hectic, hectic days with world worldwide ramifications
- 1:09:04on our operations. And remember the CIA was built created in part because of
- 1:09:10Pearl Harbor, but really to contain the Soviet Union's that was the main enemy,
- 1:09:15and that's really all we did. Any embassy anywhere would have would focus
- 1:09:19on the Soviet Union. Russian speakers were assigned to Niame Air, for example.
- 1:09:28I got the impression reading Milton Burden's book that like when the wall came
- 1:09:31down, it sort of like reshuffled the deck of cards in everyone's mind and
- 1:09:35they all had to adapt, like very very quickly to this new literally a
- 1:09:40new world that you know, especially as a CIA officer that you're living in.
- 1:09:43It was extraordinally hard for the for the operations officers who had served in
- 1:09:59those very difficult locations behind the wall and with all the trade craft that that
- 1:10:10requires that I was never qualified to do. And then worry about s fest
- 1:10:16or a v bid that is that is a revolutionary shift in focus. And
- 1:10:27many of them just couldn't do it right because you know, you talk about
- 1:10:31the advanced training and was was like high threat like it was it had a
- 1:10:36specific name, and and the threat wasn't a suicide bomber. The threat was
- 1:10:42that country, the country that you were in, like their intelligence service like
- 1:10:46disclosed, you know, finding your assets something like. It was a It
- 1:10:50was a major shift, right, Yes, that's correct. And remember threat
- 1:10:58there's a c I threat, right, that can get you asset killed,
- 1:11:00and then there's a high threat terrorist, so I think could get the case
- 1:11:02officer killed. And they're different, right, and it's it's hard to be
- 1:11:09good at both. Right, some remarkable officers where I wasn't one of them.
- 1:11:13I want to say that, right. Yeah, So by the time
- 1:11:16we get to ninety one, though, it sounds like you're back into the
- 1:11:19fray down in Peru. Correct, dealing with shining path. Correct. So
- 1:11:26this was I think that I was extraordinarily fortunate, but maybe the right officer
- 1:11:39in the right place at the right time, because I you know, I'd
- 1:11:43like to think I just didn't serve in El Salvador. I really believed in
- 1:11:46the counterinsurgency mission, and I wanted to understand counterinsurgency and I wanted to be
- 1:11:51a counter insurgeon, be good. And then in Southern Africa I wanted to
- 1:11:56be I wanted to understand insurgency and being a surgeon, and I wanted to
- 1:12:00be really good. So with studying Cha and Trenkia and all the break all,
- 1:12:09then anything and everything on low intensity conflict that I could read and then
- 1:12:14I got to practice it in those both locations and then but still I wasn't
- 1:12:20an eighteen commander. I was a CIA case officer, and I got to
- 1:12:27hone the pure human, the pure espionage piece in Europe and even under the
- 1:12:35nose of host services. So I took all that, and now I was
- 1:12:43in my mid thirties, because human and counter surgeons are not necessarily young men
- 1:12:47young women's games, and I took all that with me, and I was
- 1:12:51still single, so I could be a workaholic, opening the station and closing
- 1:12:57the station as I did every I ever worked in for thirty one years,
- 1:13:01and I read everything, and I had was gifted with competent, proving partners,
- 1:13:10and we took the fight to sende Aluminoso on their own turf and decapitated
- 1:13:14the insurgency. And I'm very proud of that. Well, talk to us
- 1:13:18again. I'm going to ask you some of the same framing questions that I
- 1:13:21asked about El Salvador and Angola. What was the Shining Path insurgency in Peru
- 1:13:26at the time. So they were malist, which complicated it because they weren't
- 1:13:30Marxist Lendiness, they weren't loyal to the Soviet Union, and they were rural
- 1:13:38based and for students of general surgeons malist your pardon, that's why they were
- 1:13:44malist. Christ correct, Jack, very good point. They from a studying
- 1:13:53a counterinsurgency and studying counter terrorism that just like we make mistakes, bad guys
- 1:14:01make mistakes too. And Abimel Renoso Guzman presumptuously thought that the insurgency was ripe
- 1:14:13enough that he could move from the rural to the urban. And I think
- 1:14:17it was t Lawrence. I'm not sure. I might be wrong on that,
- 1:14:20but it to win it, to have a successful insurgency, you don't
- 1:14:26need ten percent of the population with you. You just need ten percent of
- 1:14:30the population to look the other way when you're conducting your operations, right,
- 1:14:34And that wasn't Lima wasn't ready for Guzman. And there was a ten thousand
- 1:14:39dollars reward for his head in nineteen ninety one third World nineteen ninety one,
- 1:14:44ninety two, third world Peru. And that's fortune for most Limnos approving.
- 1:14:53So of course, I had very good Spanish now almost at the four level.
- 1:14:57And you're very you know, fluent Spanish speaker, very well versed in
- 1:15:00the history of insurgency and counterinsurgency. It sounds like maybe you took some of
- 1:15:04the Phoenix program concepts, did there? But I just couldn't tell anybody.
- 1:15:11You couldn't say that out loud. Yeah. Correct, But this was urban
- 1:15:15and the advantage was me working in an embassy and living in the city I
- 1:15:18could get to We could look for that clandestine infrastructure, and we found it
- 1:15:25and we were able to take them down. Take them, I mean,
- 1:15:28how did you take them down? Was there a sort of like counter propaganda
- 1:15:31effort or action a human source and then but human sources tell hef truths in
- 1:15:39human sources symbol and human sources fabricated and for all sorts of motivations. I
- 1:15:48also say at this stage I should add that in between all of this,
- 1:15:55I had an assignment at headquarters where I worked the Cuban issue and I was
- 1:16:02exposed to the Cuban double agent program where the communist Cubans were running. We
- 1:16:11thought we were recruiting sources in Cuba and they were double agents. And there's
- 1:16:16books written on this, but I got a first hand look look at that,
- 1:16:21and I did spend time with the defector the Cuban defector who revealed all
- 1:16:27these double agents and the tradecraft went into it. So it was also very
- 1:16:30good at counter insurgent counterintelligence its particularly Latin America. And then with the counter
- 1:16:35insurgency experience, had some paramilitary experience and my huge and my case officer skills,
- 1:16:42so it it sort of all came all came together. And none of
- 1:16:46that is lost on your your your host's partners, because they'll they'll see a
- 1:16:54charlottean. I mean, they'll know you're thin or you're not. And I
- 1:16:58went to their weddings, and I went to their funerals, and I went
- 1:17:01to the fifteenth birthday of their daughters and got drunk with them. And I
- 1:17:15was very close to my brothers proven in bros, brothers and sisters. It's
- 1:17:20interesting to me that because this was not a special Activities assignment, this was
- 1:17:27a FI assignment counter terrorism, right, oh, counter terrorism. But that's
- 1:17:33also like counter terrism is also at the time, they're like they're recruiting traditional
- 1:17:40case, they're not recruiting like I sa ideas right, no, No,
- 1:17:45I would have been the only officer in a rather medium sized station who had
- 1:17:50some who had at one time served, right and ground branch. And so
- 1:17:57you're going into a an environment that relies heavily on those skills or at least
- 1:18:05that knowledge, that knowledge for context, you know that that knowledge for rapport,
- 1:18:13things like that. But this is something that most case officers, most
- 1:18:17traditional FI case officers, cannot bring to this setting. That's true, that's
- 1:18:25correct. I wouldn't to say that I want to give a shout out to
- 1:18:30the agency. There was a course that I took before I went to Peru
- 1:18:33was called CODA Coed Operations in a Dangerous Area. So this is a decade
- 1:18:39before eleven September, and it was high threatened how to work like a be
- 1:18:46route in eighty three kind of environment. But well, maybe the Philippines,
- 1:18:50and there's a lot happening in Greece and certainly Beirut. And it was thirty
- 1:19:00eight short barrel for the ankle. And again it's still the Browning high power.
- 1:19:06And I thought the thirty eight on the ankle extraordinarily applicable to the case
- 1:19:12officer. Maybe not the special a Tier one special operator. And I'm sure
- 1:19:17it didn't happen in Afghanistan or Rock, but Ukraine or Libya. But for
- 1:19:25the case officer you're going to be seen in the car a lot, and
- 1:19:29it was extraordinarily accessible, and I'm not saying them up yeah, and or
- 1:19:35hotel meeting extraordinarily accessible because you're seated so very often. In fact, I
- 1:19:42probably spent it seemed like years of my life sitting in a car and years
- 1:19:47of my life sitting in a hotel. Well, years of my and waist
- 1:19:51carriers are horrible to draw in a car, like, they're so hard to
- 1:19:56draw. Yeah, I don't, I don't, I don't know, but
- 1:19:57yeah, the instructors were excellent. When the shoot went not uh and there
- 1:20:03was an a Narco Wars happening and so it was a it was an absolutely
- 1:20:10fantastic course. So it's interesting because you know, the agency formed the CTC
- 1:20:15based on, you know, the idea that we need track terrorists and we
- 1:20:19have you know, people who are specialized in that and begin to understand the
- 1:20:24patterns. Did the agency ever have like a counter insurgency center where they where
- 1:20:30they maintained that knowledge. I think that there was a small analytical cell of
- 1:20:36a couple of people, probably Vietnam veterans, and I think it withered.
- 1:20:44And that's that's your shame. Which is which is wild because so much of
- 1:20:47the agency's business was in that that arena. I'm sure that in South Vietnam
- 1:20:55there are case officers, paramilitary officers meeting human sources, and I would love
- 1:21:03to know their trade craft and how they did it. Communications and and and
- 1:21:10not necessarily of the NVA, no full time regulars, but but the but
- 1:21:16the Via Kong, that clandestine infrastructure, nurse villagery and the text and the
- 1:21:27university professor. Yeah, no, it's interesting because you know, John,
- 1:21:31who do we have on that was Phoenix, John Mullens, Johns right,
- 1:21:36and you know, and to have that knowledge to like work consistently against that
- 1:21:42infrastructure and then to let that knowledge go and that and that you guys didn't
- 1:21:45benefit it from an irockan Afghanistan. That's one of the reasons I'm here tonight
- 1:21:49is to pass on some of this. I want want to mention in Peru
- 1:21:55a leadership lesson that I'd like to share what not to do that After the
- 1:22:03takedown of Guzman, I was rather popular and I was promoted and was even
- 1:22:11offered an on word assignment as a chief station. Small post, but still
- 1:22:18I was at the military at to Chay's house. He was a bachelor like
- 1:22:21me, and we'd often socialized together, and he had an army buddy was
- 1:22:27visiting from Washington, and this, like quite a few people in those days,
- 1:22:31wanted to come and talk to me about the successful operation. And I
- 1:22:35was more than happy to go on and on about the success. I thought
- 1:22:44that much of the world revolved around me, and probably to an extent in
- 1:22:49that little world, it did so in this particularly even I was going on
- 1:22:55for about ten minutes and the man I was talking to was I was in
- 1:22:59my thirties, this man was probably early sixties. This is in Lima,
- 1:23:02and there's one on one conversation, and I said to him at a certain
- 1:23:08point, excuse me, I need to catch your name. He said,
- 1:23:10my name is Dick Meadows. So I nodded, And here I was talking
- 1:23:17about myself and Dick Meadows didn't talk about himself, didn't even introduce himself.
- 1:23:25So I went into the bathroom, looked in the mirror and said, never
- 1:23:28do that again. And I'd like to think I never talked about myself in
- 1:23:34that way again. Maybe for your audience, you might give a line on
- 1:23:39mister Meadows who he is, and I mean Special Forces legends served in Vietnam.
- 1:23:45He was on the suntage and he went on and played a role in
- 1:23:50Iran undercover gathering intelligence in the run up to Eagle Claw. There are not
- 1:23:57many statues at Special Forces Headquarters at Fort Bragg except Dick Meadows statue. Yeah,
- 1:24:04he's out in front of use of SoC So. Yeah, and it's
- 1:24:10you know, it's interesting because it's not like I understand where you were at
- 1:24:19in that moment. You would you had helped to facilitate the takedown of high
- 1:24:24five man. Yeah, of like the the dude, like the major player,
- 1:24:30and you know in in the agency which is small, like that has
- 1:24:40you know that has it reverberates, Right, it's a major thing. Boots
- 1:24:45on the ground. None, no need for yeah, no need for nineteen
- 1:24:54or twenty year olds from tenth Mountain Division. Right. The other point that
- 1:24:57I want to leadership lesson, I would like to pass one from Peru is
- 1:25:01you know, I'm in my sixties now, but I have a mentor in
- 1:25:03his eighties and his name is Felix Rodriguez, another patriotic human American who's of
- 1:25:11JEGO era fame. Felix would never say he captured Jego Era. He doesn't
- 1:25:15use that language. He says he assisted in the capture. So I want
- 1:25:18to say that I assisted it in the capture of I'd be my osman.
- 1:25:23So that's that's important. Can you tell us a little bit about Guzman and
- 1:25:28then sort of whatever you're whatever you're comfortable revealing about the events leading up to
- 1:25:32his capture. So we'll say, what's what's in the press, and so
- 1:25:39human is fragile, It's critical, but it's fragile, and was the source
- 1:25:45tell the truth? But let's let's see and trash analysis played a huge role
- 1:25:51because of surveillance of the safe house keepers. They never smoked, yet there
- 1:26:00were cigarette butts. I guess with modern, more modern technology, we would
- 1:26:06have been able to get a DNA read of those cigarette butts. Then also
- 1:26:15the lack of anything electronic coming or going. And then there were a few
- 1:26:21documents in English that I helped translate and enough is enough, we're going to
- 1:26:30go and we're going to raid this house. And in just like with the
- 1:26:35Cuban polt pilot pilots in Angola, we h m h m. It matters
- 1:26:45to win these insurgencies, these counter insurgencies that you can't just be You've got
- 1:26:54to be you can't just be brutal, you have to be smart as well.
- 1:26:57Yeah, and surgical. Yeah, and they spared this third world police
- 1:27:01force with a notorious reputation, spared his life. They probably could have found
- 1:27:08an excuse that he was been a lot in life, reaching for reaching for
- 1:27:13a weapon. And he died in prison probably I think a year or two
- 1:27:18ago. And when you look back on it, was that the decisive point
- 1:27:23that sort of broke the back of this Organization's correct, because it's with insurgency
- 1:27:31counter insurgency, it's you know, mewing gray ass or whack the mole.
- 1:27:35Correct with leadership, but I think if it's not just the leader, but
- 1:27:39if it's the founder and leader, they can have a profound a founder leader,
- 1:27:45profound effect, ave bin lot and takedown this issue. But with Syndetta
- 1:27:53Lemnos, so that there, and and also just to let the population know
- 1:27:59the proven the neutrals that these people aren't, these insurgents aren't ten feet tall
- 1:28:05the right because they were sort of But it's interesting that these phantom like these
- 1:28:12decapitation strikes don't always work right, like on a strategic level. You know,
- 1:28:16we tried in Iraq and afghanisans which men died in natural calls of during
- 1:28:19the war, and via kong Nva pressed on not always. Why do you
- 1:28:26think this one of Guzman? Why do you think that was that was different?
- 1:28:29I mean, you mentioned he was a founder, but also there had
- 1:28:31to be other I think also maybe as we saw in Afghanistan that insurgencies that
- 1:28:40back to t lawrence the the non combatant, but sort of trying to determine
- 1:28:47which way the winds blowing in the insurgency and with a blow like this that
- 1:28:54hey, okay, population was already on the fence, and hey I'm not
- 1:28:59going to get involved because the Breviian police are actually quite effective, might get
- 1:29:09killed or captured. And again they were not not ten feet tall, they
- 1:29:15were flesh and blood. Do you do you think part of it that does
- 1:29:18the does I mean maloism, does a maoist ideal in an agrarian you know,
- 1:29:26or communism based on agrarianism or whatever, does it appeal does it lack
- 1:29:30appeal to the like the general populace if it's an urban country. So it's
- 1:29:35a very good question. I spent a lot of time looking at that,
- 1:29:43there's well, frankly, in our own country, you got a royal rural
- 1:29:46urban divide, right, but it's a it's exacerbated. And when you add
- 1:29:58a third world because the poverty, it's it's it's the richer almost as rich
- 1:30:04as are rich, and the poor are well. Frankly, they're making away
- 1:30:09to the southern southern US border because of the dire, dire situation. And
- 1:30:14just like I told you that in in Africa, we often look at those
- 1:30:21rather symmetrical borders that Europeans drew, right and not paying attention to the tribes.
- 1:30:28In Peru, it's understated, it's a sensitive subject, but there's also
- 1:30:32a racial dimension, and fair skinned people tend to be higher socio economically,
- 1:30:39and they're coastal, and people more indigena indigenous with indigenous features tend to be
- 1:30:46in the auto plano in the in the Andes, and mestizos of course are
- 1:30:50a mix of the two. Correct, But Guzmand's safe house cleep where safe
- 1:30:57house keepers were as white as the three of us Wow Peruvians, and that
- 1:31:00mattered because a mestizo cop is not going to stop a fair skinned Peruvian walking
- 1:31:10around me to Floridas or Semi Seed, the the Upper east Side or the
- 1:31:15Chelsea or Trebecca of Lee? Was that indicative of of some sort of like
- 1:31:18a bourgeois leadership inside the organization? Correct? And remember that you know you
- 1:31:26gotta catch well, you got a it's a completely different language. And and
- 1:31:30they were living in a rather nice house. Right, So it's very interesting,
- 1:31:35so very interesting. After after all of that, you then got a
- 1:31:40chief of station position. Correct. She's a huge promotion for an agency officer.
- 1:31:44It's it's the saying goes, regardless of how small it is. Always
- 1:31:46take your first chiefs job because it can lead to lead to others. And
- 1:31:50I was back in Southern Africa, and what was that like now that you're
- 1:31:56running the whole station? So as a knuckle dragger? So correct, And
- 1:32:01there weren't money and PCs with the language and Fitzgill's but very focused on the
- 1:32:10walls down now, so I'll say Russia, not China, say Russia,
- 1:32:13not so the Union, Russia, China, Ron, North Korea and a
- 1:32:16lot of Cuba and still no Islamic jihad in ninety three, four and five.
- 1:32:24But you're still I mean, that's interesting. I never really thought about
- 1:32:27North Korea in regards to Angola, like that they have interests in that country
- 1:32:30significant. Really, I was unaware of that Angla, like Mozambique, was
- 1:32:38coming out of communists, I should say Angla communists. Josea d. Water
- 1:32:45the CENTSUS was in power, I think thirty forty thirty or forty years thirty
- 1:32:49thirty five, and I mean anything you will can or want to tell us
- 1:32:56about your first chief of station position. So only a few less people than
- 1:33:03I have on this hand, but it's command. Never Nevertheless, uh,
- 1:33:15the if Jack and Dave that I think mister Devine was sitting here and he
- 1:33:20explained that on the foreign intelligence side, it's quite a bit more sensitive,
- 1:33:30and it's easy to talk about the counter terrorism a para military operation because because
- 1:33:34there was a boom. So so that's that's sensitive and I'll pass if that's
- 1:33:41of course, I got it, thank you. So after that you're off
- 1:33:45to continue your education at the Naval Naval War College. Fact I really enjoyed
- 1:33:49it. I studied counter insurgency and insurgency surprise, surprise what. So it's
- 1:33:56interesting to me because like I don't know what rank naval officers or marine officers
- 1:34:02go to Naval War College, but here you are somebody with real world insurgency
- 1:34:10and counters insurance experience. What did you think of the course when the courses
- 1:34:15when you took on. I want to give a shout out to my uniform
- 1:34:19brothers and sisters because they were just coming from Gulf War one, and to
- 1:34:24a man and a woman, they said, let's study every other war,
- 1:34:27but don't study that one because they were never going to be given such a
- 1:34:32straightforward mission, straightforward mission, conventional and with such lead time for the logistics.
- 1:34:41So that was I was really impressed, and I really got to read
- 1:34:45now in Closewitz and I think I want to again what DoD does right is
- 1:34:51it's mid level. So I was just fourteen, so there were lieutenant colonels
- 1:34:56and or commanders in the Navy, and so you brought ten to fifteen years
- 1:35:02a practical experience and now you can maybe look at it a more strategic level.
- 1:35:06And I think that the saying goes I think in uniform or for civilian
- 1:35:13that you really don't put a lot of that education to practice as a just
- 1:35:19fourteen to fifteen, as a five or six, But once you get into
- 1:35:25the flag rank, you start looking back on it. And indeed, when
- 1:35:30I was the deputy of a component in Washington at CI Headquarters, I would
- 1:35:38dial back some of my leadership notes and lessons learned from the Naval War College.
- 1:35:45But I'm curious about because you're talking about commanders and lieutenant colonels who have
- 1:35:53a lot of experience but not in insurgency counterinsurgency in the in their respective fields.
- 1:36:01And you're also probably dealing with professors who are subject matter experts but not
- 1:36:09but maybe haven't been on the ground in these. And you are bringing a
- 1:36:15lot of real world experience having been personally involved in these. So I'm curious
- 1:36:19as to you know, outside of you know, the classic texts like class,
- 1:36:25whats whatnot? What? How was? What was your experience like?
- 1:36:30And how is your interaction with your professors and with your peers and things like
- 1:36:35that. So I was a guest there. It's their school and heavily focused
- 1:36:41on carrier batterle groups, right, and they love the Falklands War. Some
- 1:36:47marines marine right marines? Right? Uh? Interesting? Or and what I
- 1:37:00did learn from that and I passed it on to other officers and through all
- 1:37:04my insurgency counter insurgency experience was a country can be third world, It's true,
- 1:37:10but elites from that country are as late as any of us. Right,
- 1:37:14They've gone to our university, a Q Khan and nukes, and they
- 1:37:18don't ever underestimate third world elits. They are they are us. Maybe with
- 1:37:25our Cuban double agent debacle, we fell for a Banana Republic stereotype, and
- 1:37:32they are as good as we are. I mean, we mentioned some of
- 1:37:36the amazing Cuban Americans who have contributed to national security. But for the grace
- 1:37:41of God and timing, they they may have been there. Right, how
- 1:37:45would you like Felix Rodriguez to be the Minister Interior or like, yeah,
- 1:37:57we're lucky to have them, right, So, but that's it's a they
- 1:38:00are two great examples. Yeah, that don't do that. My point is
- 1:38:03I bringing up in the Malvinus or Falkland context, because the Argentine pilots,
- 1:38:09not the Argentine troops who were used to taking batons and bashing in the heads
- 1:38:14of student protesters, are disappearing. The econ professor at some university, right,
- 1:38:19but now you're going up against sas and brick Royal Marines. But the
- 1:38:29Argentine pilots. I mean I think Sheffield. They sunk a ship. There
- 1:38:34was, Yeah, there was a ship, so serious. Then off to
- 1:38:43headquarters and you got to learn French. I learned French and went to a
- 1:38:48French speaking country in the heart of Europe as the number three huh, and
- 1:38:54I was more Russia, China, Iran, North Korea and Cuba. Now
- 1:39:00let me say that Islamic jihad started percolating, particularly in Europe where there's a
- 1:39:08big Magreb population. So we we began to track that in defensive Cia.
- 1:39:17We were looking at that well before eleven September. I'd like to ask you,
- 1:39:23you know, what did you think of your French speaking liaison partners,
- 1:39:27as that intelligence service in their paramilitary guys seem to be kind of unusually aggressive
- 1:39:32for a Western European country. I was wonder if you had any thoughts,
- 1:39:36But I think they make for excellent kind of insurgency and counter terrorism partners.
- 1:39:45Different systems. We do some things, something's better. They might do some
- 1:39:49some things better, but they have an amazing history when it comes to kinter
- 1:39:56insurgency. And you mentioned West Africa or the Magreb, but don't forget Southeast
- 1:40:00st Asia when our early Vietnamese Special Forces advisors, I think some of them
- 1:40:06were reading maps in French or the v the Vietnamese elite spoke spoke French,
- 1:40:14and there's also French in the levant, so it's a very important language.
- 1:40:19And uh roi ai A is a really worth a read for insurgency, counter
- 1:40:29counterinsurgency. One who wrote the Centurions, no no, that name escapes me,
- 1:40:36but wrote a small pamphlet on into China and Algiers where the French may
- 1:40:44have won the Battle for our Giers but lost lost the War for Algeria and
- 1:40:48rolling raids based on human, harsh interrogations, a Western army largely Christian occupying
- 1:40:56a Arab country majority tremendous lessons in there. In fact, the movie The
- 1:41:03Battle The Battle for Now, there's an amazing ops test in there that could
- 1:41:10apply to insurgencies counter insurgencies where the French turner prisoner where now the insurgents want
- 1:41:21to recruit an Algerian and they test him by giving him a pistol to assassinate
- 1:41:32a French police officer. But it's uh, there's no no rounds in a
- 1:41:39revolver and it's it's it's quite interesting. There's also scenes where Western Christian soldiers
- 1:41:47need to search women in burkas and the women protests naturally uh for gender and
- 1:42:00Islamic sensitivities, but they were they were carrying. And there's also the urban
- 1:42:06terror and when does that become That's a great movie. Yeah, and we've
- 1:42:11talked about it before on the show. In fact, you know, we've
- 1:42:14talked about the Spooker set by the door and and and the idea that a
- 1:42:20lot of the like in the seventies, you know, a lot of the
- 1:42:26sort of homegrown terrorist organizations would use that movie as we use that. They
- 1:42:33showed it. We're in the Q course. Yeah, yeah, but yeah,
- 1:42:38and also if you're studying French, you can watch it maybe and remove
- 1:42:44subtitles and rewind it to work in. And it's particularly useful if you're an
- 1:42:48insurgency counter insurgency because that's the vocabulary you're going to use. Remember when it
- 1:42:54comes to the French and Africa that let me get this right that if you
- 1:43:01are from and I'm just going to pick one, if you're from Mali,
- 1:43:05and if you were born in nineteen sixty four, you were born with a
- 1:43:10French passport. I don't care what color skin you wear, what religion,
- 1:43:13You're a French passport. And by the way, in Angola, if you
- 1:43:15were born in nineteen seventy four, you were born with the Portuguese passport.
- 1:43:21I know. I grew up around a lot of them after they left the
- 1:43:24country in the northeast. Yeah, in the northeast term Westchester County, New
- 1:43:30York. Portuguese families that came from Angola immigrated. Well, I'm sure they
- 1:43:33stopped in Portugal, but then immigrated to the United States fall. Yeah,
- 1:43:39the Carnation coup. Yes, correct. So my wife's from Angola, by
- 1:43:45the way, Oh really, I didn't know that married twenty nine years.
- 1:43:48Wow. I remember once I was with her in when I was a chief
- 1:43:56of station in Europe. So rather Senior and the Cuban of Aster passed by,
- 1:44:00and he said to him, mister Senior, never had a chance to
- 1:44:05thank you for your intervention in Angola without without without your intervention, I would
- 1:44:13not have met my wife of twenty five years. And we have three,
- 1:44:17three beautiful children. And he said, because you think we're close, I
- 1:44:25said, he said, we are as close as Heaven is to Hell.
- 1:44:30I walked away. Okay, So your next assignment, I mean, this
- 1:44:40is a tough one, I know, but tell us about like where you
- 1:44:43were on nine to eleven. Okay, sure, yes, thank you.
- 1:44:47So I after that European assignment, I came to New York to work closely
- 1:44:57with our FBI brothers, brothers and sisters again on the harder targets. And
- 1:45:03everybody's in New York, right, I'll tell one war story, but I'm
- 1:45:10going to blur the nationality. But this hard target, like the fish in
- 1:45:15the East River because a brave man everything meant in a stewpot. And then
- 1:45:23they didn't have a lot of money. So we were, well, we're
- 1:45:27going to fish into East River as well and right next to him and maybe
- 1:45:32sort of develop a relationship. So we thought, maybe even better, let's
- 1:45:38let's impress him somehow. So can we get a hold of a fish,
- 1:45:43hook it and slip it in the water, and you know, look at
- 1:45:50the bait that we use, and so we even considered maybe touching base with
- 1:45:58NSW and could we possibly have divers in the water and yeahs and yeah then
- 1:46:10yeah, so I said, make sure it's something indigenous to these waters,
- 1:46:14and it's not an exotic clark from Thailand, and don't be a smart ass
- 1:46:23and go down to the buy a frozen fish and I'll get the line.
- 1:46:27Have I reel it in? Yeah, but it never never came to pass.
- 1:46:32But the excellent cooperation with our FBI brothers and sisters on on that.
- 1:46:41Yeah. So I without going too many details, why, but I happen
- 1:46:46to be in Tower seven that day and I happened to be looking out the
- 1:46:50window up Broadway, And only because I had to collect my thoughts because I
- 1:47:00was composing an email, did I notice suspecting the sky over Central Park And
- 1:47:08I didn't think anything of it. I had only been in the city.
- 1:47:11I'm not from New York City. I haven't been in the city but two
- 1:47:14or three weeks. And that speck grew bigger. But I actually went back
- 1:47:21to my note because jfk. Leguardi at Teterborough never work and knows. But
- 1:47:31really only because I had to collect my thought again, did I look out
- 1:47:35the window and it was a seven sixty seven below the Empire State Building coming
- 1:47:41down Broadway directly for me. And there was probably two or three seconds when
- 1:47:48I thought, I guess I'm going to catch this in the chest. But
- 1:47:56those two or three seconds passed and I could see the belly of the aircraft,
- 1:47:59which in which meant it was above me. I mean, it sounds
- 1:48:04extramely basic, but when your life's flashing before your eyes, basic is good.
- 1:48:11And it roared over our building, which is the Solomon Building, I
- 1:48:14think fifty five stories, and there was sort of a shudder, but I
- 1:48:17thought it was after just exhaust from the aircraft, maybe a mechanical problem,
- 1:48:27and wasn't sure what to think of it. And then I heard I thought
- 1:48:33it was female laughter, but then the second or third laugh was a scream.
- 1:48:41I said, damn the aircraft. So I was looking north up Broadway
- 1:48:45and went to look south towards the north face of Tower Ian, and there
- 1:48:51was a gaping hole. And you know how narrow those streets are, so
- 1:48:57maybe thirty forty fifty meters apart, And in that instance I recalled watching the
- 1:49:08plane, and now I could the windows are opaque, but I could tended.
- 1:49:13But of course, if I could have seen it with Muhammad Ada who
- 1:49:15was crabbing slightly left to get dead center, and which mattered because then it
- 1:49:20was we didn't know, but they were gorged with have gas and flying for
- 1:49:26Boston Muhammadad's flight from Boston to LA and we did. I was the number
- 1:49:36three, so I talked to it the chief of station, and she agreed
- 1:49:45that I would get a message out to counter tersm Center. So I called
- 1:49:51koh Black, whom I happened to know, and he was in a meeting,
- 1:49:56but I said, could I I need to talk to him. My
- 1:49:59guests, Rick Prauda was with him and he was the number three at the
- 1:50:02time, and I said, look, I can't say it's terrorism, but
- 1:50:06I could tell it was an American Airline seven sixty seven. It was deliberate,
- 1:50:12the weather's perfect, and mister Black was silent, and then he asked
- 1:50:19another question. And at that moment there was a fireball out the window and
- 1:50:24it was the second plane had hit. So I wish I had a hero's
- 1:50:30story to tell. I don't. The first responders were the heroes correct,
- 1:50:39And again a shout out to our FBI brothers and sisters. We made our
- 1:50:44way to twenty sixth Federal and hung out with the FBI, and then rather
- 1:50:53large, we have a large, rather large presence in New York. And
- 1:50:57then I'd like to thank our brothers and from the Department of State who took
- 1:51:00us in the US mission to the UN and cleared up the base missing and
- 1:51:04gave us a home. Is that because your station was destroyed in the collapse.
- 1:51:10But a sensitive topic. I think I'll pass on that. Yeah,
- 1:51:14you know, on a personal level, like this had air, This had
- 1:51:17a profound effect on you. Correct. Yeah, it's I'll have to take
- 1:51:21that to my grave. Correct, it was an intelligence Pearl Harbor before my
- 1:51:25eyes worse, civilian target worse. We had to Pearl Harbor as an experience.
- 1:51:32So it's there was precedent. It's one thing to be suffered strategic surprise,
- 1:51:38but not when there's precedent. This is what's getting eating at the Israelis
- 1:51:43right now because they had young people were and now they have a strategic surprise.
- 1:51:45Yeah, and you took it. And I'm just going off what you
- 1:51:53said prior to the show, so please correct me if I'm wrong about it.
- 1:51:56But there was you had. You took it personally because you feel as
- 1:51:59though this was the agency's Baileywick and the agency it was their wheelhouse and they
- 1:52:05missed it. How could how could you blame the FBI? How could you
- 1:52:09blame the I A. How could you blame our Tier one, two or
- 1:52:13three operators? How could you do that? So you had this intelligence failure
- 1:52:15and I'm going to guess that eleven September of course led deaf Arnistan. We
- 1:52:24get that, but it probably led to a rock. Did you serve in
- 1:52:27a rock? I've been there yet, did you serve? Yeah? And
- 1:52:33you know, and you mentioned a little bit of if you don't mind talking
- 1:52:35about it, you mentioned a little bit of sur fiber skill. You mentioned
- 1:52:40a little bit of like moral injury. Correct. Can can you talk a
- 1:52:44little bit about like what that is for you and and in how you're managing
- 1:52:50it or how how you have managed it? Can I have a little bit
- 1:52:57a little bit more scotch? Yeah, absolutely, do a lot more.
- 1:53:00You asked how I'm managed to get you? Do you want more ice?
- 1:53:02No? Okay, thank you? Sorry, No, No, that's fine,
- 1:53:06that's fine. Yeah. Obviously extraordinally humbling experience. And you know you're
- 1:53:23standing there in your books, brother sued and you're a big bad CIA officer
- 1:53:27and your civilian population depends on you to to get it right, and you
- 1:53:32let them down like that tremendously and in a certain way, I can feel
- 1:53:38for not so much misade, but chin bet for uh seven seven October politics.
- 1:53:45Aside that a former director of Operations said after that that the CIA and
- 1:53:59that in two thousand and one it produced ten thousand intelligence reports. Really we
- 1:54:05only needed one plans and intentions and activities. The mystery, one of the
- 1:54:12many mysteries, is that if there had been reporting that nineteen unarmed Arabs are
- 1:54:16going to drop the twin towers the Pentagon, it maybe Congress that it may
- 1:54:21not have been disseminated because it was sensational. So which is I mean,
- 1:54:30is exactly what we're hearing about the reports about hamas that there was accurate reporting
- 1:54:36that there was activity and potentially an eminent threat, and mid level officers felt
- 1:54:43as though it was sensational reporting and fanciful. Yes, I understand there was
- 1:54:46a FBI special agent in this case of female I think in Arizona who famously
- 1:54:54reported that we got a Middle Eastern out here wants to learn to take off
- 1:54:58and fly to not land, right, and she's she's a heroine. And
- 1:55:03I understand it was a female analyst at in the IDEF who something had had
- 1:55:13bothered her correct. Yeah, so after nine to eleven, I mean you
- 1:55:25got to uh go spend some time as an instructor at the forum, right,
- 1:55:29and I I needed some s some stability after after that. Oh sure
- 1:55:39weren't the case. And I want to thank my uh leadership at CIA for
- 1:55:44allowing me to do that. It's not always did you go there to be
- 1:55:47an instructor's at g S fifteen a full colonel when it's really a major or
- 1:55:54lieutenant colonel most slot. And it also indicated that I probably was lettauing and
- 1:56:00that was that was it for my career. And I didn't have any issues
- 1:56:05with that because I had I had failed. Remember when they took when one
- 1:56:12when Syban's referenced day in the USK day, I was the day I was
- 1:56:17in Europe when Muhammad Ada was hatching this plot. Now it's an unfair burden
- 1:56:23one officer, and I was busy and doing quite well against other other targets
- 1:56:29that are important, but missed it. Yep. But I mean to play
- 1:56:39the Devil's advocate. Was there intel or was there a piece that you were
- 1:56:45privy to ignored or was this something that just never even came up on the
- 1:56:48radar that Islamic terrorism might be onesie twosies, a dry bo i, a
- 1:57:00hand grenade, and frankly, thank you in fairness, Russia, China,
- 1:57:08Iran, North Korea, and lesser but still Cuba. And these were important,
- 1:57:15important issues, I would say. The other damage, the fallout from
- 1:57:23that intelligence failure was that, starting on twelve September, we started worrying about
- 1:57:32nineteen year old shitheads with s fests and maybe, but not maybe, I
- 1:57:38mean just sheer numbers. I'm not saying we completely took our eye off of
- 1:57:42Russia or China, or run or North Korea, But how could we right?
- 1:57:47How could we right? Right? You had to worry about a nineteen
- 1:57:53year old shithead with an S fest, an entire station, an entire liaison
- 1:58:00service, right, yeah, And an SS is a suicide vest, you
- 1:58:05know, you know somebody wears it and clacks off. How how do you
- 1:58:12not also, though, and and and I understand the idea that there was
- 1:58:16a CIA intelligence failure, but how do you also not under like, also
- 1:58:21hold the FBI to some level of responsibility in the terms that you know,
- 1:58:26like you said, it was an FBI agent who had reported on this,
- 1:58:30The FBI, the CI doesn't have any lawful arrest authority here in the United
- 1:58:35you know, in the United States, the FBI, there were elements of
- 1:58:39the FBI that were aware of these people, and it stopped there, Like,
- 1:58:44how do you not how do you not share that sort of that burden
- 1:58:46and that responsibility with them. We were a next donal service and we have
- 1:58:51the lead. And this was a foreign plot by foreigners. So the FBI,
- 1:58:56it's there only as good as what we we inform in this in this
- 1:59:00instance, in fairness to the bureau, Yeah, I would disagree with you.
- 1:59:05I feel that some others do. I feel as though the FBI really
- 1:59:09dropped the ball on this too, Like, yes, the agency missed,
- 1:59:12you know, sort of the external piece of this. Muhammadadu was in Germany.
- 1:59:16We can get to him in Germany. He wasn't in Candahar. Yeah,
- 1:59:20No, I understand the problem is that a lot of it wasn't missed,
- 1:59:24Like we actually did pick it up, but they did not coordinate all
- 1:59:27the information and put together that there was this larger plot taking place. No,
- 1:59:31I agree with you When I say missed, I mean like missed the
- 1:59:34opportunity we didn't need. We didn't need one of the nineteen hijackers, remember
- 1:59:41that clandestine infrastructure, right, somebody who to say just like you didn't need
- 1:59:45assassin the cousin who's or the motorcycle and is not telling them what it's for,
- 1:59:57hanging around with new friends or are are gone quiet? Right? You
- 2:00:01know. It's interesting to me because, like I said, the FBI has
- 2:00:04the arrest authority here. There was a report sent up by one of their
- 2:00:09agents, and none of her are higher ups. At any point they either
- 2:00:14said we don't want to focus on this individual or these individuals because they're Muslim.
- 2:00:19We don't want to appear to be, you know, xenophobic, or
- 2:00:24they said it, or they said, what like, okay, these people
- 2:00:29want to learn how to take off but not land, no problem. That's
- 2:00:33a perfectly normal request. That's a perfectly normal behavior pattern, you know.
- 2:00:40Like so, I feel as though the FBI bears every bit as much of
- 2:00:44the responsibility as the agency for missing this. The other mystery for me is
- 2:00:51that had we been on the Muhammadatta and had the bureau surveilled him and excelentit
- 2:01:00that especially more in Komas where they start to there's I think there's a possibility
- 2:01:06that they may have followed Mohammad Hoats at the Logan and allowed him the board
- 2:01:14and let Los Angeles Field Office be ready to receive him and then see who
- 2:01:19he meets over there, and there's the same would have happened. There's been
- 2:01:26a lot of stuff that's come out over the subsequent years as things are declassified
- 2:01:29that these guys were meeting with Saudi intelligence operatives and things like there's some weird
- 2:01:34stuff that I really don't have my arms around. I understand, I've heard
- 2:01:38that story. I really don't have my arms around it. Yeah. Oh,
- 2:01:41I mean people can look it up for themselves. I mean some of
- 2:01:43the stuff that's been declassified. But I mean, you had an amazing career
- 2:01:47at CIA, went up to senior intelligence staff, and then when you retired,
- 2:01:54you went right back to contracting for the agency and did some pretty cool
- 2:01:57things there too. Like to think because I think, in part because of
- 2:02:02love and September I I needed to give back a little bit because I'm maybe
- 2:02:08I could have done better that day or before, but it's just a inter
- 2:02:12i personal feeling and that I also liked. When I was retired and contracting,
- 2:02:17I was able to be very tactical. So when I was rather senior,
- 2:02:23I was in many high level meetings at the cabinet level, back sitting
- 2:02:30in the back, never at the a f not pretending I was at the
- 2:02:32at the at the table, but backbenching. Uh. And I thought a
- 2:02:38lot of those more strategic discussions were rather boring. And I really was always
- 2:02:43was a tactical, tactical person person, and as a contractor, I was
- 2:02:46able to be tactical. And I'd like to think I made a continue to
- 2:02:53make a minor contribution with sort of meeting some of our problematic human sources is
- 2:03:00and maybe turning a mediocre source good or even a good course source great,
- 2:03:05and maybe tightening things up when it when it comes to dissembling withholding information or
- 2:03:13even outright fabric. Is this I've heard that we have a program or a
- 2:03:16project where it's like our very top human guys are kind of sent after the
- 2:03:21types of people you're talking about for vetting and Jack, because human is not
- 2:03:29a young person's game. And I contend that that a serious case officer really
- 2:03:38doesn't reach his or her prime unto their forties. And the reason for that
- 2:03:42is you have you, Yespionage is a window into the soul right right,
- 2:03:46and that you have you have to have some empathy, and you have to
- 2:03:54mirro image, and you have to have been passed over for promotion, and
- 2:03:59you have to have a morege and you have to maybe you're not happy with
- 2:04:04the sexual orientation of your what you're expecting your child's sexual orientation to be or
- 2:04:10whatever, or you're buried a loved one, or you're dealing with a medical
- 2:04:14issue. When you're twenty one, two, twenty three, twenty four to
- 2:04:16twenty five, you tend not to have those experiences. And I just think
- 2:04:20I went down the list of what can really motivate. And I'm not talking
- 2:04:26about a confidential informant sort of snitch. I'm talking about a serious spies.
- 2:04:31You're talking about gift that keeps giving about building that report. But in order
- 2:04:35to build that report, it can't be fake. You have to have true
- 2:04:41empathy and that person has to know you wonder you get them. And I
- 2:04:45would add to it, and this is something I did wrong, and I
- 2:04:48would like to think that I imparted it on my students when I was an
- 2:04:56instructor that remember com comport yourself seriously and professionally when you're out about town or
- 2:05:05even at a diplomatic reception, particularly that a potential spy, someone who wants
- 2:05:14to commit trees and against their country and spy for the United States might be
- 2:05:17sizing you up as their potential handler, and it's a life or death situation
- 2:05:21for him and his family, right right? And so are you flirting with
- 2:05:28the Swedish Third Secretary? And are you panning your chests about what you did
- 2:05:34in El Salvador, Southern Africa? You're drinking too much? Are you informally
- 2:05:44dressed when everyone else is wearing a tie? That? Take it? Take
- 2:05:50it serious. And I probably could have done when I was in my European
- 2:05:55assignment. There's a I want to wear occasion. I probably could have been
- 2:05:58more profession nothing, nothing negative. But that's really important, an important aspect.
- 2:06:05And I think that twenty five or forty five and the twenty five year
- 2:06:12olds, I want to go out to the club later that night, and
- 2:06:15the forty five is going to go home and you need to commit cheese and
- 2:06:18you might want to talk to the forty five year old. Yeah, it
- 2:06:23makes sense. I mean it's like if you walk into an attorney's office and
- 2:06:25the eternity you know, for you know, to defend you in a case,
- 2:06:29and they're there wearing a suit, They're sitting there in a T shirt
- 2:06:31with with the Rito powder on their lips. It's like it honestly does not
- 2:06:36speak to their competency. But it's that. But it's right, you're talking
- 2:06:41well, my trusting Yeah, yeah, you're talking about like maintaining that professional
- 2:06:45is even in smaller things. Yeah. Maybe. And these people face jail
- 2:06:50or potential execution if you're not competent in your job of protecting them while they
- 2:06:58are spying a deal breaker. Yeah, No, that's a very good summary.
- 2:07:03Yeah that Yeah, And I've lived it, and it's extraninally extraorninally important.
- 2:07:16I do know that, as I understand it, the KGB and SVR
- 2:07:20a extraordinarily formidable noble adversary for many many years that for their big cases such
- 2:07:29as an AIM's, a particularly senior gray beard would go out and maturely handle
- 2:07:35the asset, right, because remember, agents are humans and there's all kinds
- 2:07:42of foibles and ups and downs, and being a buncular is very important,
- 2:07:47especially when you're recruiting a member of a foreign intelligence service like they know the
- 2:07:51game. Yeah, that's a totally different type of target. Yeah, it's
- 2:07:57important. Yeah, And I mean you you understandably. I mean I get
- 2:08:01it why you had to kind of beat around the bush a little bit,
- 2:08:03But I mean it sounds like you had quite a bit of experience pitching and
- 2:08:07recruiting agents around the world. Next question, better than many, but not
- 2:08:20as good as some. Sure, yeah, sure, And there's extraordinary officers,
- 2:08:22extraordinary officers out there with special skills that are whether it's a foreign language
- 2:08:30or something technical. And I've always been very very I always wish that I
- 2:08:35could do what they did. But I just but it sounds like the agency
- 2:08:39brought you in as one of those guys that could do some vetting on I
- 2:08:41think, as you described it, potentially problematic. So I mentioned also why
- 2:08:46I gravitated to Europe, and when you spend years in Europe, other officers
- 2:08:50tend to make fun of you because there's life can be nice there. But
- 2:08:56I also did it as a six y four to two hundred and forty five
- 2:08:58pound male that I just I couldn't walk around Lima, I can't. I
- 2:09:05can't walk around Bangkok. I can't. I can walk around Berlin and Brussels
- 2:09:11and Paris and Vienna and the UK. I can't even even Madrid even or
- 2:09:20I can't And that's that's you know, never be a gray man. But
- 2:09:26I'm not shocking people either, right. I remember when I was in interrogating
- 2:09:35an insurgeon Nel Salvador, I was asking age of an insurgion Colemandante. I
- 2:09:43wanted information and I said age, eye, color, et cetera. And
- 2:09:48tall and he said yeah, tall. But you know, the guy was
- 2:09:52very sophisticated and probably didn't know a lot about even theater inches and even meters.
- 2:09:58But I said tall and I stuff. I said tall like me.
- 2:10:01He said, no, tall like normal people. Not they, not not
- 2:10:05you. In fact, at an anecdote to this guy. He was so
- 2:10:07unsophisticated. We took him for a helicopter ride and we landed. It was
- 2:10:11only about five minutes, and we landed at our base. We had an
- 2:10:15American flag there at our fob, and he looked. He said, oh,
- 2:10:18we're in the United States. I said, nod. A five minute
- 2:10:20helicopter ride from the jungle of Central America. No, no, just no,
- 2:10:26no, no concept. Yeah, but that's a lot of sf people
- 2:10:33and agency paramilitary ulcers have dealt with that lack of sophistication in the developing world.
- 2:10:39Yeah yeah, I remember you had some funny stories. Yeah, like
- 2:10:43yeah, yeah, like you know Sean the keyboard elf. Yeah yeah,
- 2:10:48yeah, yeah yeah. Well, but also just showing like showing them imagery,
- 2:10:56like showing them a top down of two or three block box of their
- 2:11:00village, and it's like they just cannot conceptualize what they're looking at and it's
- 2:11:05our burden. Yeah yeah yeah. And then you also during this time also
- 2:11:11spent some time on black sites. So I was a number see so director
- 2:11:22of Counatarism deputy then the Chief Operations, and the Chief Operations had two deputies.
- 2:11:26I was one of the two deputies, and so I had peripherally was
- 2:11:31was involved in some of that. And since you bring it up, I
- 2:11:37want to give a shout out to two elements that I think did tremendous damage
- 2:11:46to this global Islamic insurgency of al Qaida and the first wins, the Seal
- 2:11:54Teams, because they ruthlessly pursued that enemy and they they smelled the enemy.
- 2:12:01I understand all sorts of other units were involved, but there was a laser
- 2:12:05focus of those guys on the enemy, and then CIA's rendition harsh interrogation smelled
- 2:12:16the enemy and the men seals men, but quite a few ladies, men
- 2:12:20and women of CIA really took it to the enemy, and both of those
- 2:12:28units took some heat for trying to make it fit within this liberal democracy of
- 2:12:35ours. How we took it just about to the limit that our society and
- 2:12:39our laws would accept, and there were some some maybe a step or two
- 2:12:46overbounds on occasion makes sense. Yeah, please push. I know I was
- 2:12:52gonna I was actually gonna say it's an unpopular opinion, but when it comes
- 2:12:58to what they called enhanced interirogate or harsh interrogation, I agree with you.
- 2:13:03And I would like to hear your ideas on people who call it torture or
- 2:13:11people people who say it wasn't an effect, it was not effective. I'd
- 2:13:16like to hear your experience or your ideas on that. Sure you'll have a
- 2:13:22vehement tenor argument for me, basically along the grounds of in the fall of
- 2:13:31two thousand and one and all of two thousand and two, it wasn't if
- 2:13:37it was when, and we weren't going to let it happen clearly in the
- 2:13:43winter and spring of twenty twenty four. I understand those arguments, but you
- 2:13:50have to I remember the fear of that time. Yeah, I mean it
- 2:13:54wasn't It wasn't if it was when and how? And it was terrible,
- 2:14:01you know, using some sleep deprivation techniques or some stress positions. It's one
- 2:14:07thing debatable whether or not it's torture, I suppose, But I mean we
- 2:14:11start like handing over detainees to like the Egyptian Intelligence Service and these black sites
- 2:14:16that are completely unaccountable, the one in Poland that was completely illegal. You
- 2:14:20do start to run into these issues, as you mentioned, like what's acceptable
- 2:14:24in a liberal democracy, and maybe maybe a liberal democracy is able to accept,
- 2:14:28you know, waterboarding a hardcore terrorist. But like where does that line
- 2:14:33exist? Like if I, as an American, start pulling out a dude's
- 2:14:35fingernails, it's like, is that well? But I I think that is
- 2:14:41the line. I think that if somebody, after you know, a few
- 2:14:45days of sleep and some good meals and whatnot, if they walk out of
- 2:14:50that detention or if you know, they're the same person, not missing fingernails,
- 2:14:54not missing body parts, not how are they the same person though,
- 2:14:56right, Like everything we know about PTSD today, I remember I read this,
- 2:15:03I think it might be true, and it might be sas selection that
- 2:15:09there was a guy, a candidate bound to a rail train track and hooded
- 2:15:20and a double rail right to two such tracks right right, and here goes
- 2:15:26a high speed train there on the other set where he was not bound.
- 2:15:31But he can but he can hear that, he can hear the train from
- 2:15:35Yeah, that's You're going to hurt people mentally with that. It's like throwing
- 2:15:41someone out of the helicopter when it's covering a foot or two. So I
- 2:15:46think with our seer training, regardless of how professional it is, you know,
- 2:15:56at the end of the day, there's a doctor there and you can
- 2:16:00you can you can quit on the waterboarding or I think there was an ABBO
- 2:16:07grab photo where it may have been wires two fingers. Yeah, that was
- 2:16:11not enhanced interrogation, to be clear, that was just torture. That was
- 2:16:13Yeah, that was just I think the detainee didn't know that no one was
- 2:16:18ever going to plug that into it two twenty okay, yeah, I in
- 2:16:26fairness to CIA, it was always always the minimum to get that piece of
- 2:16:31information. It was a farn it was a foreign FI operation to collect intelligence.
- 2:16:37It was never punitive, right right, And that was and there has
- 2:16:43to be a lot of screening. I feel that goes into programs like that,
- 2:16:46Like you cannot hire the statist, you can't hire the person who enjoys
- 2:16:52It's David's interesting you say this. I have a group of retired officers.
- 2:17:00We have a group chat. It's called pork and it's uh, Rob and
- 2:17:07Joe, Mike, Don, Gail rag And we talked about a lot of
- 2:17:15things, and I was of all that has happened with Ukraine and Russia,
- 2:17:22nothing bothered me more than Navami. Killing a caged man is an extraordinarily cowardly
- 2:17:28thing to do. Even some of these Litvinenko and the assassination of Berlin and
- 2:17:35the assassination that just happened in Spain. It took some actually took decent trade
- 2:17:39craft, some kahones to do this inside of a NATO country. The assassins
- 2:17:48in Madrid haven't been captured. But killing a caged man what a coward Before
- 2:18:00and we move on to the next thing, but I mean the last question,
- 2:18:01I just like I feel like I have to ask you, because this
- 2:18:03is always the question, right, did enhanced interrogations lead to actionable intelligence that
- 2:18:11prevented terrorist attacks on America? If yes? Are there any like examples that
- 2:18:18you can cite where I can't, but I'm confident that. And now it
- 2:18:24has of course become political and one side of the aisle and the other,
- 2:18:28and that's that's unfortunate in this divided, divided, divided country of ours to
- 2:18:37include the location of Bin Laden. Mm hmm. So I will push back
- 2:18:41one some who claim no, and that that in fairness Cia, It's very
- 2:18:54it was a brilliant piece of work, and it was rather frustrating to people
- 2:19:00like me or humans that we wanted to be a spy in his camp and
- 2:19:03really wasn't more on the the interrogation, the analytical side, and kudos and
- 2:19:09and and and great job. So then you went on, No, no,
- 2:19:15I mean I understand that's as much as you're able to say. But
- 2:19:20then you went on and did some training with the special operator or yeah,
- 2:19:22training of the special operations community, kind of like in your wheelhouse. I
- 2:19:26mean you talk about working with Swick a little bit. I really enjoyed it.
- 2:19:31I probably went Fort Bragg camp Camp Liberty, Fort Liberty now Fort Liberty,
- 2:19:37Yeah, that's what we're supposed to call it now should be Fort Cash,
- 2:19:39but it could be for many things. I spent one of my favorite
- 2:19:48speeches is uh, Master Starchy of Benavidez. Thought, that is a great
- 2:19:54motivating speech. That is really good. Are you talking about the one that
- 2:19:58it's on YouTube where he talks about the guys? Yeah, they thought he
- 2:20:01was They thought it was Vietnamese and dead, so they've if he wasn't dead,
- 2:20:05I was basically great and where's his uniform? And just agree, I
- 2:20:09remember, I remember the one you're talking about, and that I in addition
- 2:20:16to teaching at Swick Special Warfare Center and School, I helped with Operational Design
- 2:20:24course and that's really the t sock Show, and I was role players Chief
- 2:20:31Station and then but a Network Development course again role playing as chief station,
- 2:20:39so that n c O s and to include junior n c os and junior
- 2:20:46officers and a few warrants that they would and sign up civil affairs and leven
- 2:20:52Bravos SF they would the first time they'd met a CS would be in training
- 2:21:01and not in the field. And my job was to share some insider trading
- 2:21:11tips of the trade, how to get a chief of station to say yes
- 2:21:15for your for your operational operational proposal. So I think it was good for
- 2:21:18the agency and good for the intelligence community, good for the country team,
- 2:21:22and good for our soft brothers and sisters. And I did NSW as well.
- 2:21:26And some Marsak what was that like going from I mean you worked some
- 2:21:31like at a pretty strategic level doing strategic intelligence, and now like this is
- 2:21:35where the rubber meets. They asked for like a E five, E six.
- 2:21:39It's going to be doing like that sort of taxi cab driver human intelligence
- 2:21:43overseas the low level, because you know, the five is going to win
- 2:21:46the insurgency. I'm sorry, General Prets. Yeah yeah, adamal mcgraven,
- 2:21:50and it's a squad. General, I'm sorry, but they're going to what's
- 2:21:56the name of the novel for the book in Vietnam, The Village about Marine
- 2:22:01E fours and fives? Really really good. Really, I don't think I
- 2:22:05don't think we're called the Village. I think it's counterinsurgency. Yeah, really
- 2:22:09good. Well, and you know it's it's interesting because you know, earlier
- 2:22:13before the show we talked about the difference between liked I A Case s officers
- 2:22:16and CI A case saficers uh in like Iraq, and the restrictions that the
- 2:22:22c I A case officers wondered that the d I A weren't And and a
- 2:22:26lot of times, and I know a lot of like c I A case
- 2:22:30officers in Iraq, we're like bitter actually about being there, and they're like,
- 2:22:35this isn't our job, and they weren't necessarily wrong in the sense of
- 2:22:41it does take those worst this war stuff isn't what we're trating. It does
- 2:22:45take those you know, the E five, e six out there. Being
- 2:22:50able to run the low level, the tactical sources as opposed to the strategic
- 2:22:54sources. Well that was one of the revolutionary byproducts of a post eleventh September
- 2:23:01world. That my career was Cold War and then the wall came down,
- 2:23:09and then then the towers came down. So I spanned both and that and
- 2:23:18maybe why I wasn't necessarily myself a good fit for the g Watt Global war
- 2:23:24and hate and terror because because of just how very very tactical it was.
- 2:23:31And what I mean by that is I was trained and much more comfortable and
- 2:23:35rather good at producing an intelligence rule report that was four or five paragraphs long,
- 2:23:41and the plans and intentions and activities of the Taliban during the upcoming rainy
- 2:23:46season pretty important? Or do you want a geochord so you could put a
- 2:23:52warhead on a forehead? No, seriously, And that's a really good debate
- 2:23:56right now, you got you went the geochord or the street address such as
- 2:24:00a bagdaddy or a bout of bin laden, Or do you want four or
- 2:24:05five paragraphs plans, intentions, activities iron visa vise, the Talaman plans,
- 2:24:15intentions, activities of putin over the in twenty twenty four, twenty twenty four
- 2:24:20for for Ukraine pretty pretty or the location of Wagner units in Malli. I
- 2:24:28mean I still subscribe to the four or five paragraph report, right, yeah,
- 2:24:35I mean what's a geochord? What's the president going to do with that?
- 2:24:39Right? Okay? Right? What's what sex state? What sext deff
- 2:24:41going to do with that? How does that fit into the PDBA? Right?
- 2:24:45With the four or five paragraphs, it's really important. And I think
- 2:24:48we lost a little bit of that close eleventh September because we needed a street
- 2:24:52asset, an email address, or a geochord that's us imagine the FBI.
- 2:24:56Yeah, so you have since retired hired from the contracting work as well,
- 2:25:01and you know, retired a living down in Florida. You want to talk
- 2:25:07about some of the volunteer work that you do down there. So I am
- 2:25:13when I can. I help out the Cuman American community by way of the
- 2:25:20Bay of Pigs veterans there's not many left, so I participate in those activities
- 2:25:28when I can. I also do some work with wounded warriors, the Foundation
- 2:25:37and then and other veteran organizations. And I run a small LLC and I
- 2:25:43always try to in fact, I only hire veterans who are transitioning. Tell
- 2:25:50us about this startup company that you're with and what you guys do, because
- 2:25:54you've told me about it a few times and it sounds like it's something that's
- 2:25:56like really needed. It's name of Come These one point six y one.
- 2:26:01It's a Golden Ratio business partner who picked out the name, and it's cyber
- 2:26:09and urban safety and it was really geared towards high end, wealthy Latin Americans
- 2:26:16who are having issues at home, and they would come up to Miami where
- 2:26:20we live and we have a classroom and the neighborhood we would teach them uber
- 2:26:26safety and subway safety, and camera stalking and drink spiking and last resort,
- 2:26:31self defense and particularly cyber But because there's some madness in this country, not
- 2:26:39as peaceful as some say, but not as violent as others say. Again,
- 2:26:45we're divided country, but so some Americans. And so we think that
- 2:26:50you can do a whole lot to be safe without disrupting your daily life.
- 2:26:54And you don't really have to go to the whole concealed carrier out which is
- 2:26:58a lifestyle chain, sure, and not just for executives but teenagers and very
- 2:27:05important nannies. And the company was just certified by the state of Florida.
- 2:27:11Human trafficking is a big deal in Florida. The state mandates and you will
- 2:27:18be inspected that the front end of the hotel, all hotels in all of
- 2:27:24Florida, remember there's no state income tax because of the tourist industry, must
- 2:27:31be trained in human trafficking and red flags, front desk and cleaning crow.
- 2:27:37Not necessarily a chef, but but that's so we're certified to do that as
- 2:27:43well. So I think it might be a little bit different than a CIA
- 2:27:46guy doing something like this. But Jack and Dave, as you know,
- 2:27:54you know from your your time there that Dave that you know this this collection
- 2:28:01mission. So you you you avoid the X, but if you get off
- 2:28:07the A, if you get on the X, you get off the X.
- 2:28:09Right. So we think about ninety percent of what we do is to
- 2:28:15avoid trouble in the first place. But if trouble finds you once you get
- 2:28:18home, not win, just get home well, and you know you speak
- 2:28:20to the avoid trouble partner essentially, because I mean the example that comes to
- 2:28:26mind is Kim Kardashian when she posted photo in Paris. Yeah, she posts
- 2:28:31that photo of like out her hotel window, and then somebody you know,
- 2:28:37dismissed her security and they she got robbed. She got what tied up and
- 2:28:39robbed? Right, holy shit? Yeah, well because of a social media
- 2:28:43post, I think. Right, We've only been in operation eighteen months and
- 2:28:46we constantly have to upgrade our cyber because now we have artificial intelligence and voice
- 2:28:54cloning, especially from a teenager to a mom or dad. Right, yeah,
- 2:28:58they need money, and then you have I understand some cell phones are
- 2:29:01are snatched here on the streets of New York and the criminal why the person's
- 2:29:07texting or talking, which isn't uncommon, and the criminal keeps tapping the screen
- 2:29:11to keep it the phone open, and they get it to the safe house
- 2:29:16where the paypaler the zell is emptied. So we work on that as that
- 2:29:24as well. So never use face I D to open your phone and always
- 2:29:30use face ID to open the apps on the phone. It's just kind of
- 2:29:33ye. Also, never ever post anything on social media about where you are.
- 2:29:39You post about where you were like after the vacation, that's yeah.
- 2:29:46And snapshot and mister Zuckerberg's apology to parents whose children has been a suicide because
- 2:29:54of different things it's happening. So that's a sex play take, very complicated
- 2:30:03because it's really targets frankly, families that have income of one hundred and fifty
- 2:30:09thousand dollars or more a zillo truly of the house, and they know how
- 2:30:16much the house is worth, and they know if they go to the Dalton
- 2:30:20School on the Upper West Side, what tuition is and they know they can
- 2:30:24pay right. Yeah, it's it's yes, challenging, and and the thing
- 2:30:30is is the parent, you know, it's I'm not a parent, but
- 2:30:35it's very I imagine it's very hard to keep control over your children's communications.
- 2:30:39And the children aren't you know, They're just being kids, like you know,
- 2:30:45And if everybody else is posting their stuff on social media, they're going
- 2:30:48to post their stuff on social media, and that leaves them open to exploitation
- 2:30:54by very savvy, very savvy operators a lot of times. Correct, I
- 2:31:00do want to compliment the teamhouse your show and the interviewing that you do and
- 2:31:07getting opinions, experiences on the record. What we wouldn't give for some of
- 2:31:16those case officers from Vietnam and those those stations and bases and how they handled
- 2:31:24penetrations of the Vietcong. I would sit and watch every episode, even though
- 2:31:31I'm now retired. But what value they would have been to me in El
- 2:31:37Salvador or Southern Africa, and what trade craft was used that is and maybe
- 2:31:46some of them even learned Vietnamese and yeah that is that's so maybe some of
- 2:31:52this will be useful to so I that would be my dream. I mean,
- 2:31:58you know, I though after every conflict or after every you know,
- 2:32:01we've not just the military, but the intelligence community like they purge, you
- 2:32:07know, it's like we downsize or we get rid of these people and then
- 2:32:11we have to rebuild. And it's you know, fortunately we're in a time
- 2:32:16now, because how amazing would have been to talk to somebody at War one,
- 2:32:20to hear their stories about trench warfare or War II, like, to
- 2:32:24be able to interview those guys and to have that, And it's like,
- 2:32:28fortunately, we're in a time now where you know, people like yourself,
- 2:32:31people with this incredible experience, who are gracious enough to come on and share
- 2:32:37that experience with us. We hope that it's you know, that we're documenting
- 2:32:43for future generations. Great job, yeah, thank you, And it's all
- 2:32:48because of you. It's all because of you and the rest of our guests
- 2:32:50who come on and are willing to share your experiences. Do we have questions
- 2:32:54for Dale? Let me check? Indeed, did you want to check patron
- 2:33:00Dale while he's pulling that up. Do you want to tell people where they
- 2:33:03can find your your business if they want to hire you and your staff to
- 2:33:07come and give you know, classes and briefings. Sure? Sure, So
- 2:33:13the easiest is through my LinkedIn and reach out to me. You can direct
- 2:33:18message me. We just have a website one six one uh PPP dot com.
- 2:33:28Personal Protective Technique dot com one sixty one PPT dot com is our website
- 2:33:33and uh and LinkedIn is very very useful. You know, we've talked a
- 2:33:39couple of times about you know, what you guys do, and I like,
- 2:33:43so I've heard a little bit about your curriculum and what you guys go
- 2:33:46into, and I mean it's the kind of stuff like when I listen to
- 2:33:50it, it's like they should teach this to every kid. Yeh, in
- 2:33:54freaking elementary school should have this sort of information, like very basic. There's
- 2:33:58because you do everything from like situational awareness, security on the street, broad
- 2:34:05rage to the cybersecurity, like really basic things that every kid should do to
- 2:34:11protect themselves. Well. And it's interesting because like when when I was in
- 2:34:18high school and about you Jack, Like, I don't know, I think
- 2:34:20high schools have changed, but like homech was a course right home economics,
- 2:34:26like where you learn how to do basic stuff around the house, like you
- 2:34:28know, And it's almost as if I don't know if they still teach courses
- 2:34:33like that, but it's almost like courses like what you teach should be a
- 2:34:37part, just like basic finance should be a part of an education. A
- 2:34:43course like this these days, in modern times, should be a part of
- 2:34:46basic education for kids. Unfortunately, yes, but it's yeah, you can't.
- 2:34:54Can't have a bad situation present itself and flip a switch and say I
- 2:34:58wish I had had right, how do I do CPR? Right? Right?
- 2:35:03Yeah? Do I restore the breathing first or stop the bleeding? Which
- 2:35:07one? Is it? An active shooter? And yeah, this isn't like,
- 2:35:13you know, living out in the mountains survivalist nonsense. This is like,
- 2:35:16yeah, well it's very practical things. You're not telling people to get
- 2:35:20off the grid. You're saying, you're we don't expect you to be become
- 2:35:24a hermit and have no social media presence. But this is how you manage
- 2:35:28your life in these times, right, exactly? Right? Is that?
- 2:35:31Is that a minimal disruption to your existing daily routine. Otherwise, yeah,
- 2:35:39just stay home and throw your phone away. Nobody's gonna do that, right,
- 2:35:43right, We don't want finds. But but you know, and you
- 2:35:48mentioned how like Concealed Carrie is a lifestyle change, whereas you know, just
- 2:35:56taking these basic measures, you know, these prevented me isn't necessary. But
- 2:36:01it's also interesting how the people who are very concerned with concealed carry and stuff
- 2:36:05like that, not all of them, but a small population of them are
- 2:36:09also very voice for us on social media. And it's like, you're not
- 2:36:13doing this right, Like you have to protect yourself in all ways. You
- 2:36:16can't, you know, like if you're taking this this change to protect yourself
- 2:36:20with concealed carry, like stop blabbing about, oh that you conceal carry all
- 2:36:26the time everything you do, yeah, yeah, yeah, e d C
- 2:36:31is Yeah, everyday carry out. Yeah, the Spare magazine and yeah,
- 2:36:35so and I support concealed carry. I'm not saying like, don't do it.
- 2:36:39It's it's it's just that if you're doing it but everybody knows you're doing
- 2:36:43it, you don't really want to tell the bad guys that. When a
- 2:36:46client comes to us and they want to learn to shoot, and we live
- 2:36:50in Florida's the way with the Everglades and very access to great facilities, and
- 2:36:56we always say we're going to do five things in the range safety, safety,
- 2:36:58and more safety, yeah, legal considerations, and then we'll learn to
- 2:37:03shoot. Yeah, are you sure you want to do this. The link
- 2:37:05to Dale's business is down the description if you guys want to check it out.
- 2:37:09Okay, real quick, the questions and Corbyn, thank you very much.
- 2:37:11How can we bring the tried and true qualities of classical human human intelligence
- 2:37:16sourcing into the cyber realm? If I have any luck with this, I'll
- 2:37:22never see a clearance? Would any alphabet boys even notice? Very good?
- 2:37:30Questioned, and I One of the reasons I fully retired is I felt that
- 2:37:37I was losing some relevancy that I might know UAVs, but I really don't
- 2:37:41know drone swarms. And I'll get to the question a second, but that's
- 2:37:48as I understand, the Turkish drone that the Ukraine's were flying two years ago
- 2:37:54is now obsolete and the first view drone disposable four hundred dollars to the three
- 2:38:07pound warhead is now proliferating it right, I haven't done it, so I
- 2:38:11can't really lead that. I greatly admire the current generation that can work that
- 2:38:18issue, and not far behind that is cyber. I'm pretty good a defensive
- 2:38:24cyber, but offensive cyber. I'm just haven't done it, and so I
- 2:38:28don't feel and qualified to lead it. So it is blessed in the curse
- 2:38:35digitization and human source, but it's not going anywhere. I mean, it's
- 2:38:46only going to continue because, particularly Gwatt, we just can't a case officer
- 2:38:56working out of an embassy. You just can't meet some of these targets that
- 2:39:00we want to meet. Yeah, on the diplomatic circuit, So be very
- 2:39:09careful. I know there's been some issues with electronic communications, and maybe I
- 2:39:16should leave it to that. I'm just not qualified to comment on only only
- 2:39:20that it scares me. I would like for source protection, Yeah, I
- 2:39:26would like you. I'm going to ask you for pure speculation right now,
- 2:39:31just an opinion in terms of you've worked in foreign intelligence in a clandestine capacity.
- 2:39:41We've just talked about social media and things like this, things that the
- 2:39:46agency has never had to really deal with before. You know, when we
- 2:39:50start talking about biometrics, how do you think, whether it's now or ten
- 2:39:56years from now, how do you think technology is going to change the face
- 2:40:03of you know, covered activities of you know, condestine services, things like
- 2:40:07that. So I'm really not terribly qualified to expand on that, on that
- 2:40:22very complex topic, I can just say that growing up in an agency where
- 2:40:33after you left the embassy or even the fob downrange, and you completed your
- 2:40:41operational act, and once you got back to the embassy or the fob or
- 2:40:43home, it was over. Now. I mean, I if I served
- 2:40:50in Europe ten years ago and I did have a cell phone, I'm sure
- 2:40:56that eight March twenty twelve, there's a record of where my cell phone was
- 2:41:03bringing. So it's always discoverable. And that's one of the reasons I probably
- 2:41:09was not very communicative on some of some of the topics. Yeah, that
- 2:41:20it just can get right, someone could start figure out where you were when,
- 2:41:24yeah, can walk that back first. I'm sorry to not you know,
- 2:41:28that's okay. I don't. I don't know if there's one out there
- 2:41:31either. No, it's perfectly fine. I'm just curious because you know,
- 2:41:33you mentioned this idea, you know, of like kids on social media,
- 2:41:37and you know, we talk about this and kids are growing up now documenting
- 2:41:41their lives publicly, right, and we've all we all do this like we
- 2:41:46like, or most of us do, but but most of us do it,
- 2:41:50I think after our time and you know, service and whatnot, because
- 2:41:54social media wasn't really a thing prior to that. And and things like pemis
- 2:41:58and and and the you like the AI capacity to Well, this brings up
- 2:42:05late, that brings up the issue is that maybe the world isn't as messy
- 2:42:11as we think it is. Because surely one hundred years ago, two villages
- 2:42:18in eastern eastern Congo Zaire Congo, they one tribe pillaged another. We would
- 2:42:30have never heard about it twenty nineteen twenty four, March of nineteen twenty four
- 2:42:37here in New York. But if it happens tomorrow, we're going to see
- 2:42:41YouTube. Right. So what I'm saying the world has always been this this
- 2:42:46complex, but but just now that we it's now that we have that we
- 2:42:58know about it. Yeah. So I was actually checking into booking the reservation
- 2:43:05for my hotel here and we're teaching a course. We're down in Tribeca.
- 2:43:09And when I was talking to hotel management, they knew the name of my
- 2:43:13company because it was a corporate event, and they were googling it and asking
- 2:43:18me questions about from the website as as I spoke to them. I mean
- 2:43:22that just you have to be prepared for that. Yes, very interesting,
- 2:43:26stunning. What's your next question, kim Zy? Thank you very much what
- 2:43:35do you think about China investing in Mexico's surveillance technology and the New Canal project
- 2:43:41to make Mexico a new hub of commerce. So are I think that the
- 2:43:52intelligence community has it right that it's our national security threats are China, China,
- 2:43:58China, China, and then China and then some Russian. Some are
- 2:44:01round. I mean, it is a is extraordinary perplexing and I'm not so
- 2:44:07sure we're good at it that let me esq is. I mean, we
- 2:44:11know all about the Chinese military attache H two p l a officer at the
- 2:44:20Chinese embassy in Quito or the Chinese consulate in Layakil, But who's more important
- 2:44:26that individual or the Huawei rap? Right? So what do we do?
- 2:44:33I mean, how do we do that? We there's an insurgency in northern
- 2:44:37Mozambique. We send an a team and eight teams are very potent national security
- 2:44:45asset really, But the Chinese send a two star who's an engineer, and
- 2:44:50they're going to build a port. What do we do? We what do
- 2:44:54we do? And so that's and they do and they do send they do
- 2:45:03build a port and a bridge, and we're looking for a nineteen year old
- 2:45:09shithead with the nest vest right, isis West Africa? Or isis Central Africa?
- 2:45:15Africa? There's a name of the insurgency. Yeah, yeah, it's
- 2:45:18strange. Well even outside of like Africa here in the nice States, how
- 2:45:22do we deal with that? Or Whawei rep or how do we deal with
- 2:45:26fang fang or how do we you know, how do we counter like the
- 2:45:30constant like penetration that it seems as though they they're able to achieve here?
- 2:45:37Correct? Uh? And Danny thinking right, does mister Vanler have any opinions
- 2:45:43on private military companies? Were they as prominent as they are now during his
- 2:45:46career? So? Actually yes, And so I have some Southern Africa experience,
- 2:45:56and there was a Executs of Outcome was a South African post apartheid private
- 2:46:07military company and they were quite effective in Angola. So they went on the
- 2:46:13payroll of their former enemy, and the white South Africans were quite efficient in
- 2:46:18the bush that area. And I understand they also had a success in Sierra
- 2:46:24Sierra Leone. We've had we had them on the show. Yeah, it
- 2:46:33was very interesting. And then I I also think that in the case of
- 2:46:41I think I think in the case of Blackwater. Remember, I think it's
- 2:46:43more of a private security company. It was really a defensive perimeter important and
- 2:46:48they did very good work for the US government. But I don't think they
- 2:46:54were a private military company in the maneuver elements moving in the direction of fire
- 2:47:00as did you said the outcomes and Russia's Russia is Wagner, Yeah, correct,
- 2:47:05Yeah, No, I think I think Eric Prince always wished he could
- 2:47:09be I've been borlow but couldn't quite cut it. Yeah, anything else for
- 2:47:13Dale, I do think that will be. They're despised until a country needs
- 2:47:20them so and they do bing. I do think, and it wasn't my
- 2:47:26idea, but maybe in Afghanistan, where I think you two serve that maybe
- 2:47:31we could have transitioned to a model like that with some gray with some gray
- 2:47:37beards while we take out the eighteen nineteen twenty year old tenth Mountain guys patrolling
- 2:47:41villages, and let's get some guys like you out there working with the with
- 2:47:48the locals and show them some logistic and intel support, and maybe we could
- 2:47:52have given the Afghan force is a chance to sure themselves. Yeah, yeah,
- 2:48:03I'm sorry. Yeah, hindsight, it's not worth anything. No,
- 2:48:05but it makes sense. I mean especially you know you like talking to Scott
- 2:48:11Man and others about like the village stability operations and how the US government basically
- 2:48:16bailed on them, Like, well, what fills that vacuum? You got
- 2:48:22one more for Dale Kimsey, thank you. My agency caught some Russian nationals
- 2:48:26who are posing as a T T reps going into backyards to major phone balls
- 2:48:31and telecomic on equipment. Uh. Jack helped me with this millennial. Uh
- 2:48:37why w w y t say that again? D Oh what do you think
- 2:48:46the AT and T issue? Yeah, well, I mean it's I mean
- 2:48:50part of our training in my company is that when you don't have an iPhone,
- 2:48:56I mean when when when it's a Katrina or it's an eleven number,
- 2:49:00or it's your phone stolen or I mean, there was a life, there
- 2:49:05was a world without iPhones and it might happen, correct me if I'm wrong.
- 2:49:09Didn't We had iron compasses when you went through the Q course. Then
- 2:49:13GPS just came in. Now iron compasses are back. I mean we always
- 2:49:16had compasses. I don't think comp I mean they always did land nab a
- 2:49:20s F that's never going away. But Yeah, you had to because GPS
- 2:49:24if can flon a hand, the enemy has locations. Yeah, it can
- 2:49:28be spoofed. Yeah, yes, so an iron compasses. It's important.
- 2:49:33So yeah, it's also tough. I think to show shoot a quick asthmuth
- 2:49:39with with a GPS like you know WI your company. Yeah, h m,
- 2:49:45Corman said, has an original question. We talked about that. How
- 2:49:46can we bring try and true qualities classical? We talked about that. Yeah,
- 2:49:52all right, so that's dale. I mean, any any final thoughts
- 2:49:58or anything that you like you think I failed to cover here that you'd like
- 2:50:01to bring up? Oh, sorry, Corn say his first question. When
- 2:50:05we got one, we asked it. Yeah, final thoughts, Oh good,
- 2:50:13thank you. I really appreciate the opportunity and keep up the good work
- 2:50:16documenting these experiences. I hopefully I did a balance of some hard lessons learned
- 2:50:24and not necessarily uh the other way. No, we yeah, you did,
- 2:50:31and we deeply appreciate. We deeply appreciate you, like, yeah,
- 2:50:35sharing your experiences, your time with this. We actually have one more question,
- 2:50:37yeah, from Joel. Have you put an over reliance on technical means?
- 2:50:43As an extension of that, have we overshared between bureaus and agencies.
- 2:50:48Have we overshared between bureaus and agencies? Well, the scar of nine one
- 2:50:56one is not. Yeah. When I worked with my FBI partners when it
- 2:51:03came to the CT issue, they have what we have, and hopefully we
- 2:51:07had what they had. I mean, they can't. We can't let that
- 2:51:09happen again, right, And I've only had positive experience this post eleventh September.
- 2:51:15I mean, it took the vaporization of three thousand souls for us to
- 2:51:18cooperate, and we do. Yeah, so I uh, you know,
- 2:51:24Dale, thank you so much for coming in here and sharing your experiences with
- 2:51:26us. I mean, from Al Salvador to Angola to Western Europe. I
- 2:51:31mean this is like it is a it is a piece of history, and
- 2:51:35you know, it's always interesting to me because it's a it's a living history.
- 2:51:39Like you have to go and talk to the people because, as I
- 2:51:41found out, even with Foyer requests, sometimes the records don't even exist.
- 2:51:46Oh, Dal, we actually have one more comment. It's not really a
- 2:51:52question. It's from Drew Bendler Great interview Love your Dad. What was it
- 2:51:58from? You're sign Drew Brennan Bendler Great interview. Love you dad, so
- 2:52:05I have last point three voice there. One the youngest is an elite college
- 2:52:13six percent acceptance right, just to put in perspective. Middle son just graduated
- 2:52:20from a good school just north of Chicago. The three football player, and
- 2:52:26my oldest son is an E three on active duty. So I love them
- 2:52:31all equally. I'm equally proud of him. But one of them is my
- 2:52:33hero. Can you guess which one? Three a guy that's an E three
- 2:52:43he'll be deploying shortly. We're very proud of him, like his grandfather,
- 2:52:48great grandfather, grandfather, his father and his uncle. My pleasure. Well,
- 2:52:54we wish all three of them the best. Yeah, yeah, thank
- 2:52:58you for this stale Thank you. You know you're welcome back anytime, and
- 2:53:03thanks for making the trip up to see us. Like it's always it's always
- 2:53:07great to talk to you like people like you with such a storied career.
- 2:53:11It's always more fun when you can sit here with us. And yeah,
- 2:53:15for sure, you know, smoke for the cigar. Yeah, there you
- 2:53:18go. You can come for a cigar and Scott, you're not afraid to
- 2:53:20bribe. New York Times knows the podcast that gets Drunk and talks about.
- 2:53:26Yeah, so next Friday, Jim Shortens on the show Mac VI sag veteran,
- 2:53:33excited to talk to him. We we have coming up I think next
- 2:53:37month. Jona Mendez, that's amazing. Her book just came out this week,
- 2:53:43got it in the mail. So actually, Dave, that's for you
- 2:53:46man. So uh yeah, we'll be talking to her shortly as well.
- 2:53:50So thank you Dale, thank you my pleasure, thank you, thank you
- 2:53:52everyone out there. Thank you so much, really appreciate