Latest / Voices Of Life / When Freedom Dies Series - Religious Liberty: Why an Independent Church Matters to a Free Society

Transcript

When Freedom Dies Series - Religious Liberty: Why an Independent Church Matters to a Free Society · Voices Of Life

0:01
This is the Voices of Life podcast, and today
0:05
we turn to one of the oldest and most important
0:09
questions in the relationship between faith and
0:12
political power. Can a society remain free if
0:16
its churches are dependent on the government?
0:18
If the state decides what churches may teach,
0:21
whom they may appoint, and which beliefs they
0:25
may practice, what meaningful independence remains?
0:29
This is Week 12, Religious Liberty. and it may
0:34
be one of the most foundational episodes in our
0:37
series. Welcome to Voices of Life, a ministry
0:41
of the Church for Life. I'm Pastor David. Religious
0:45
liberty is not simply the right to attend church
0:47
on a Sunday. It is the freedom of conscience,
0:51
the freedom to worship, the freedom to gather,
0:53
the freedom to teach, the freedom to organize,
0:58
and the freedom to live out one's faith without
1:02
government control. An independent church does
1:06
not oppose the government, but it must retain
1:09
the freedom to fulfill its mission without the
1:12
government controlling its doctrine, its worship,
1:14
its leadership, or its ministry. Let's explore
1:18
why that independence matters. So what is religious
1:21
liberty? Religious liberty includes several interconnected
1:25
freedoms. First is the freedom of conscience.
1:28
That's the right to hold or change beliefs without
1:31
coercion. Second is the freedom of worship. The
1:36
ability to pray, gather, participate in religious
1:38
observances. The third is freedom of association.
1:43
The right to form congregations and communities.
1:48
The fourth one is freedom of religious expression.
1:52
The ability to preach, teach, write, and broadcast
1:57
beliefs. Absolutely what we're doing today. The
2:01
fifth one is freedom of religious organization.
2:04
The right to select leaders, define doctrine,
2:07
and manage internal affairs. And the sixth one
2:10
is the freedom of religious service. The ability
2:14
to operate ministries, charities, and schools
2:17
consistent with faith. A person may be allowed
2:22
to believe, yet they may be denied religious
2:25
liberty if the government forbids gathering,
2:27
teaching, or formatting or forming an independent
2:31
congregation. The Catholic Church's Dignitatis
2:34
Humanae teaches that religious freedom protects
2:37
both individuals and communities from coercion
2:40
and affirms the right of religious communities
2:43
to govern themselves. This is a crucial distinction.
2:47
Religious tolerance means the government permits
2:50
a church to exist. Religious liberty means the
2:53
government is obligated to respect the church's
2:57
freedom. One is a privilege, the other is a right.
3:02
So why does an independent church matter? Well,
3:06
the church provides an institution outside of
3:10
government control. A free society needs institutions
3:14
that do not receive their authority from political
3:17
leaders, families, charities, associations, and
3:21
churches preserve traditions, serve communities,
3:24
and provide moral guidance. An independent church
3:28
can teach its beliefs. even when those beliefs
3:31
are unpopular with elected officials. The church
3:35
can challenge government on moral grounds. Throughout
3:39
history, religious institutions have spoken into
3:41
debates about slavery, civil rights, war, poverty,
3:45
corruption, and the treatment of vulnerable people.
3:48
The church must be free to reach its own conclusions,
3:51
even when those conclusions challenge political
3:54
power. If the church can criticize the government,
3:58
Only when the government approves, it is no longer
4:01
independent. The church preserves a moral authority
4:05
distinct from the state. Governments enforce
4:09
laws. Churches proclaim moral truth. A pluralistic
4:13
society will disagree about the source of moral
4:16
authority, but religious liberty allows communities
4:18
to express their convictions without requiring
4:21
the state to endorse their theology. If the government
4:26
becomes the final authority over what the church
4:28
may believe and teach, what independence remains?
4:32
So when we look at religious liberty that protects
4:36
everyone, not just Christians, religious liberty
4:40
protects Jews, Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists, Sikhs,
4:45
and people with no religious belief at all. If
4:49
a government can suppress one religion, it can
4:51
suppress another. The principle is universal.
4:55
No government should control the conscience of
4:59
a people. I bring a point of reference here.
5:04
All religions should have the freedom to do what
5:08
their doctrine teaches them to do. Remember that
5:11
one religion's rights stop where another one's
5:15
start. So if there is a religion that tries to
5:19
destroy another religion, then that religion
5:23
needs to be looked at closely. And you have to
5:27
understand, is that truly a religion or is it
5:32
a political movement? And if it's a political
5:35
movement, then it's not protected like other
5:40
religions. And I bring that point out because
5:43
there's a lot of things today where Christianity
5:45
has been under attack. And I'm sorry to say this,
5:49
but it's mostly been by Muslims that have done
5:52
it. And they go back to the Quran that says that
5:57
Theirs is the true religion and everyone else
5:59
is infidels. And we must spread the word. And
6:04
spreading the word is fine. We spread the word
6:05
of Christianity every day. I'm fine with that.
6:08
But you can't force somebody into your religion.
6:12
And that's what's been happening a lot in several
6:16
cities around the United States. So I just bring
6:19
this exception out that you all need to think
6:21
about that and understand that. What you believe
6:26
is what you believe here and now or even tomorrow.
6:29
And that's subject to change, but it's your change.
6:32
Moving on. America's Constitutional Foundation.
6:36
Well, the First Amendment establishes two protections.
6:38
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment
6:43
of religion or prohibiting the free exercise
6:46
thereof. And that's where I say you have to look
6:51
at some religion that... calls itself a religion,
6:54
but actually is something else. The Establishment
6:59
Clause limits government involvement in religion.
7:01
The Free Exercise Clause protects religious practice.
7:05
Together they form the foundation of American
7:07
religious liberty. Separation of church and state
7:10
does not mean religion must disappear from public
7:13
life. It means government cannot coerce religion,
7:16
belief, or control religious institutions. There
7:20
have been historical warnings over time. Because
7:23
history has shown us what happens when the church
7:25
and state become too closely entangled. State
7:29
churches in Europe. Great example there. Sometimes
7:32
they provided stability. Other times they imposed
7:35
conformity and punished dissent. Let's look at
7:39
Nazi Germany. Some churches aligned with the
7:42
Nazi ideology. Others resisted. The lesson is
7:46
a church may exist, yet lose its independence.
7:50
The Soviet Union. Religious activity was permitted
7:54
only under the state's supervision. Permission
7:57
to worship is not the same as religious liberty.
8:01
China today. Official churches operate under
8:05
political oversight. Independent churches face
8:08
pressure, restrictions, or punishment. These
8:11
examples raise the same questions. Can a church
8:13
be free if it must accept political supervision?
8:17
Moving on to religious liberty is more than the
8:20
right to worship. may remain open but lose its
8:24
freedom in preaching, leadership, doctrine, education,
8:28
property, charity, communication, or association.
8:32
The deeper question is not whether the church
8:35
exists, it is whether the church possesses meaningful
8:38
freedom to carry out its mission. Now we turn
8:41
to the Christian understanding of religious independence.
8:46
Scripture offers principles that help us understand
8:49
the limits of civil authority. Render unto Caesar,
8:55
Matthew 22. Jesus distinguishes what belongs
9:00
to Caesar from what belongs to God. We must obey
9:05
God rather than men, Acts 5. When civil authority
9:10
forbids the apostles from teaching, they continue
9:13
their mission. The Great Commission, Matthew
9:17
28. The church's mission includes public proclamation,
9:22
teaching, and gathering. Pray for those in authority.
9:27
1 Timothy 2. An independent church does not treat
9:31
government as an enemy. Civil authority has a
9:36
role. That's Romans 13. Christians respect legitimate
9:40
authority, but do not treat the state as the
9:44
ultimate authority over conscience. So does religious
9:47
liberty protect only religious people? No. Freedom
9:51
of conscience protects believers and non -believers
9:53
alike. If you believe the government should not
9:56
dictate your religious beliefs, what principle
9:58
would justify giving that power over someone
10:01
else's beliefs? And I turn there to atheists,
10:05
for example. They have a belief in a deity. That's
10:09
okay. That's their beliefs. But when they take
10:12
that belief and said, well... We can't have a
10:15
moment of silence in school because that's children
10:18
praying to deity, and I don't want my child exposed
10:21
to it. That's where they've taken their beliefs
10:26
and encroached on someone else's. And the government
10:28
has knee -jerk reactions several times in different
10:31
areas, different states, where they've prohibited
10:33
the prayer, they've prohibited moments of silence,
10:37
and then they've brought it back. And I think
10:40
it was in Alabama, for example. where at the
10:43
Supreme Court in Alabama, they had the Ten Commandments.
10:47
And someone, an atheist, I believe, but don't
10:51
hold me to that, sued all the way to the Supreme
10:53
Court, and the Supreme Court of the United States
10:56
ordered the Supreme Court of Alabama to take
10:59
the Ten Commandments down. Well, from my perspective,
11:04
that's a violation of Article 10 of the Civil
11:07
Rights. That was a bad decision, because it took
11:11
away... the supreme court's independence as a
11:14
state entity but you know what the chief justice
11:17
there he said no i'm not taking it down he defied
11:21
the supreme court and rightly so he got removed
11:24
i still respect that man today i think he did
11:27
the right thing and i think the supreme court
11:29
in that decision was absolutely wrong and that
11:33
was back when the supreme court had more of a
11:35
left left of center decision making process so
11:40
Just kind of going with that so it's totally
11:43
understand. So does religious liberty protect
11:47
only people of religion? No. It protects everybody.
11:53
So we clear that up. The contemporary challenge.
11:57
Conflicts arise between religious organizations
11:59
and government over employment, education, public
12:02
funding, health care, and charitable services.
12:05
You know, we have all these charter schools now,
12:07
and they're accepting government funding. If
12:09
you accept government funding, what goes with
12:11
it? What can you say no to? So the question is
12:15
not whether enough conflicts exist. They do.
12:17
The question is how the law balances religious
12:20
exercise, institutional autonomy, equal treatment,
12:23
and public interest. But remember, those are
12:26
public dollars. Something to think about. If
12:29
you're going to take public dollars... Yeah,
12:31
I think there's a responsibility. So if this
12:33
church had a school, we don't have one right
12:35
now, but if we did, and we decided to open a
12:38
charter school and we're accepting public dollars,
12:40
there might be some strings attached to that.
12:43
And we'd have to look and say, yeah, no, maybe.
12:47
We'd have to look at what those strings are.
12:50
But I know that this is a challenge that goes
12:52
through a lot of religious, well, charter schools
12:55
run by religious institutions. That's probably
12:58
the best way to say it. Moving on to global evidence.
13:03
Pew Research Center reports rising government
13:06
restrictions and social hostilities involving
13:08
religions worldwide. Religious liberty is not
13:13
just an American issue, it's a global concern
13:15
and a warning. So what happens when a church
13:18
loses its independence? Imagine a church that
13:21
may operate only if it accepts government -approved
13:25
leadership, it restricts teachings that conflict
13:28
with official ideology, It cannot communicate
13:31
freely. Its charities must comply with political
13:34
requirements. Its pastors face punishment for
13:38
criticizing policy. That would be me. Its congregations
13:42
are denied recognition unless they accept supervision.
13:47
The church still exists, physically, but it's
13:51
no longer free. It's no longer a church of conscience.
13:55
The survival of religious institutions is not
13:57
the same as the survival of religious liberty.
14:02
So a balanced definition of an independent church
14:05
is when a church can determine its beliefs, conduct
14:10
worship, select leaders, teach its members, communicate
14:13
publicly, operate ministries, associate with
14:17
other communities, own property, criticize the
14:21
government when necessary, and obey legitimate
14:25
laws while retaining protected freedom. This
14:30
is not An unlimited privilege. It is the protected
14:34
sphere of religious mission. So what we talked
14:38
about today is religious liberty is not a political
14:41
slogan. It is the boundary that protects conscience
14:45
from coercion, faith from control, and the church
14:50
from becoming an instrument of the state. A society
14:53
cannot remain free if the churches are not free.
14:55
Because when the state becomes the final authority
14:58
over faith, That is when freedom begins to die.
15:02
We are very privileged to live in a constitutional
15:06
republic, to have the First Amendment to protect
15:10
our freedoms. And we should cherish it. We shouldn't
15:13
abuse it. We shouldn't try to overthrow it. And
15:17
when you hear voices or screams where people
15:22
make demands, yes, you know, you can have empathy
15:26
for what they're going through or what they think.
15:29
But you can't let them take over your conscience,
15:34
your beliefs. Providence has been sought in our
15:38
country from the very beginning with that first
15:40
Continental Congress. They prayed every time
15:44
they put something together, the second Continental
15:46
Congress. And finally, when they put together
15:49
the original Constitution, and then later the
15:53
Bill of Rights, and then the subsequent amendments.
15:56
Providence has always been there. Because we
15:59
started this country on a Judeo -Christian belief.
16:02
That didn't mean we're limiting religion to Jewish,
16:06
Christian, Catholic, Protestant, you know, one
16:10
particular denomination over another. What it
16:12
means is we did it with God's blessing and direction.
16:19
And I hope that that direction and blessing goes
16:22
with you wherever you go. This is Voices of Life.
16:26
a ministry of the Church for Life in this series,
16:29
When Freedom Dies. I'm Pastor David, and I look
16:33
forward to you in next week's episode. Thank
16:37
you for joining us today. This has been Voices
16:41
of Life and our series, When Freedom Dies. Remember
16:48
this truth. A society cannot remain free if its
16:54
churches are not free. Freedom of conscience
16:57
matters. Freedom of worship matters. Freedom
17:01
to teach. to gather, to believe. It all matters.
17:08
An independent church is not the enemy of the
17:10
state, but it must never become the servant of
17:13
the state. Because when government claims authority
17:17
over faith, that is when freedom begins to fade.
17:22
Thank you for listening. Thank you for standing
17:25
for truth. And thank you for being part of this
17:28
journey. Join us next time as Voices of Life
17:33
continues the story of what happens when freedom
17:40
dies.