Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Sitting w/ NADA President and CEO Mike Stanton and Liza Borches
Transcript
- 0:00Yo, it is Thursday. Thursday, June 23rd. We're still in Virginia, and we have an amazing conversation with the very important CEO [laughs] of NADA. Little role. [laughs] Everywhere I go.
- 0:13He's got a little- little bit of an important role in our industry, don't you think? I hear they talk. He does. He does.
- 0:18No, we were so, uh, so thankful to be in, uh, and hanging out with the Virginia auto dealers, and then we actually got to catch, uh, the Kentucky auto dealers kind of on- on the heels of Virginia.
- 0:28Yeah, there was no fight. There was no fight. All amicable. Which is great. If it was Tennessee and Kentucky, we'd have had problems, right? [laughs] We all know that. Basketball jerseys were flying around.
- 0:38Yeah, exactly. Exactly. No, but we got to hang out, uh, with Mike Stanton, the president and CEO of NADA, as well as Liza Borches. I've heard of that organization- Yeah... once or twice.
- 0:47And then Liza Borches, uh, who a lot of our community knows, uh, who is just a friend and, uh, we- we would consider her family in the ASOTU world. True.
- 0:55Uh, president and CEO of Carter Myers Automotive, as well as, and then we kind of go through this, the new inductee as chairman of the board of directors for VADA, which is Virginia Auto Dealers Association.
- 1:06So we won't take too much more of your time, but- No, I gotta hear what they say. Yeah. Let's, let's, uh, hear what they said and- and listen in on our conversation with them. All right, so here we are.
- 1:15Uh, we're so fortunate today to have Mike Stanton, president and CEO of NADA. Thank you for joining us. And you already know Liza Borches, um, who today you just received the- the knighting- Yes. [laughs]...
- 1:27as chairwoman of the Virginia Auto Dealers Association. Let's- let's start there. Uh, how you feeling about, like, actually having the mantle now?
- 1:35Well, I've been working pretty closely with Don Hall and VADA for a lot of years. So I think technically the title changes, but I'm not sure that the work changes.
- 1:43And we've got a really important year coming up, uh, to work with NADA and the other state associations to continue to strengthen the franchise system as the best, most efficient way to deliver the consumer experience around buying and servicing cars.
- 1:57So it's gonna be an important year, and I look forward to working with Don, with all the dealers in Virginia, and with NADA and other states. Very nice. Yeah.
- 2:04You know, I think that that's a really, uh, big thing that we're seeing.
- 2:07A- and this is, uh, kind of our first, uh, Paul and my first kind of like peer into the relationship of the dealer association and, uh, NADA, the- the more f- you know, the- the- the state association and the federal association or the national, I guess, association.
- 2:23Uh, and so it's been really neat to see and, you know, learn that- that you're home to Virginia, and so this is a very close relationship.
- 2:31But, um, you know, not just in what you're doing today and being here with the Virginia auto dealers and the Kentucky auto dealers, but what is that relationship, uh, currently, and what does the relationship over the next year look like, um, between the dealer associations and the national, uh, association?
- 2:49Well, I'm- I'm one of about 100, uh, association leaders that we work for dealers, 100%, and we all have teams. I have a team of 165 people that work for dealers.
- 2:59And as I was- was listening to- to you all speak, you know, the customer preferences are changing. They're evolving, and we're evolving with it, and we need to continue to do that.
- 3:09We need to make sure that we get our laws right, and we need to make sure in order to do that, we speak with one voice as an industry.
- 3:15So in Virginia, at national level, at the local level, and- and dealer to customer, that we're all on the same page on doing the right thing.
- 3:24And the right thing is always to take care of our customer and be able to meet them where they wanna be met in the sales process. Mike, keep the mic for a second.
- 3:32What do you think is the biggest m- the- the biggest misunderstanding that the public, when they look at franchise retail auto, what do you think the biggest misunderstanding is?
- 3:41Because there is this sentiment that exists that auto dealers are somehow not good for people, right? Not good for consumers, right? That exists, right? A lot of people think opposite, but we talk about the sentiment.
- 3:52What do you think is the biggest misunderstanding there? Well, I- I think it's almost like politicians. You know, all politicians are bad except for my politician because they know their politician.
- 4:01Who's advocating for me. Yeah. And that's what dealers do. Not only do they advocate for the customer in a warranty situation, but they compete like heck for a customer's business.
- 4:11Customer's not happy with dealer A, they can go to dealer B or dealer C. In a direct model, you don't have that. Mm-hmm. You don't have that advocate. Uh, so I think that there's a perception, but it's- it's...
- 4:22once- once you get to get behind that perception in terms of the- the bigger picture, the one-to-one and then the satisfaction scores, uh, and the one-to-one relationships that dealers have developed with their customers is actually very good.
- 4:34So I think it's much more of a myth than- than a reality. Liza, you've done a lot to overrun that perception with your work with CMA.
- 4:43Um, what are some practical ways that you actually work to move against the perception, and how do you see that actually playing out in your communities?
- 4:52I'm just gonna share a specific story, not, um, something that has, we've intentionally done to change the perception.
- 4:58But when we talk about what we do for consumers every day, and you just asked what that most common misconception might be.
- 5:05Just yesterday morning, I had an email from a customer who had purchased and leased seven vehicles from us.
- 5:11I'm not gonna use the OEM's name, but they had leased it through a captive finance company, turned in their lease last year, and somehow that captive finance company had never released them from that title and continued to send them personal property tax bills.
- 5:25This has now gone on for nine months. Their credit score has dropped 110 points, and they're a delinquent status because they haven't paid a personal property tax on a car they turned in almost a year ago.
- 5:34It finally got to- to my email yesterday. We said, without question, we're paying the personal property tax for that customer. Paid it yesterday. Told the customer, "Do not worry about this for one more moment.
- 5:44We will figure it out from here." The harder thing is gonna be making sure that we get their credit fixed. But that customer had a relationship with our dealership.
- 5:51As soon as they reached out to us, we were able to advocate on their behalf, take it off their plate, and we'll figure it out, 'cause that's what we do. He shouldn't have to be dealing with that.
- 5:58But he's been a loyal customer of this brand, of the CMA brand, and our job is to advocate and be that relationship that sometimes they can't have with an OEM who is in another state who they've never met, they've never had a conversation with.
- 6:11And we do those sorts of things for customers every day, and we look forward to doing them for many years in the future. You know, I-The, the face-to-face interaction with a customer is so important.
- 6:24You know, getting in a queue for, with an 800 number, uh, and it can be an endless loop sometimes.
- 6:30Uh, and, and the dealer will, will take, take that, that customer's consideration into account, and then in turn they, they can advocate. They can...
- 6:39There's so many things a dealer can do that an individual customer can't because of their presence in the marketpla- marketplace, the relationship they have with a lender or a manufacturer or, or a government agency, whomever.
- 6:50So it's really on many, many levels that a dealer can, can, uh, not just take care of the customer, but, but become their advocate. Yeah.
- 6:59I, I actually have a lot of, uh, friends over the years that I've had that, that conversation of like, "Ah, I don't like buying a car," you know, or, "I, I always hate going to the dealership."
- 7:08But then for some reason the conversation always turns and it goes like, "Well, how was your last car?" "Oh, I loved my car pur-" Isn't that funny?
- 7:15"The last car purchase that I had, that I had, and I, I loved that dealership, and my salesperson was amazing," right? And it, it does it once you get to that one-to-one.
- 7:23And I think that the work that, uh, that NADA and dealer associations and even just, like, communicating that on a, on a at least national if not global level is taking that one-to-one relationship and exploding it into a cultural perception of our, of our industry.
- 7:39Because that's the piece. It's... There are so many that just say, "I do, I actually enjoyed my last purchase. I actually enjoyed my last service visit. I actually like my service advisor or my...
- 7:51or, or the dealer that, that rescues me from those things." And, and so I do think, you know, exploding that to the national or even state level is really a, a big play.
- 8:00And, um, so how does, you know, the things that we're doing from a legislation perspective, which are, are, are necessary things to make sure that the ball moves forward and that the standards are in place.
- 8:11You know, we heard Don yesterday in his s- like, hey, look, there are things from a legislation perspective that protect the consumer, and they just have to be done on the background, right?
- 8:20But how can we connect that work that's getting done that is in an effort to protect that consumer experience, how can we connect that to the end user and actually tell that story better?
- 8:32Oh, that's, that's the million-dollar question. It's a very difficult, probably very expensive story to try and tell.
- 8:37I think the way, uh, the best way we can do is control what we can, and that's take care of each and every customer one at a time, the way dealers have always done. I think that's really the only approach.
- 8:48You may have a better idea, Liza. You know, I, I shared this in our board meeting yesterday.
- 8:52When COVID hit and they determined what businesses were essential across the United States, most, in most states car dealerships were considered to be essential.
- 9:02But I asked our team, I said, "If our consumers had to make a list on that day of what businesses were essential in their lives, I guarantee we would not have made the list." Wow.
- 9:14But the moment that they needed us, the moment they couldn't get to work because their car broke down, or the moment that they got pregnant with twins and they could no longer fit in their sedan, all of a sudden we become essential in their lives.
- 9:26So we've got to do a better job of helping customers understand we're essential before they need us. And we are, and we know that when we have those one-on-one relationships, that they recognize it.
- 9:37But it is our job to figure out how to tell that story, to make sure that customers understand we're essential before they lose it.
- 9:43Because if we don't have the franchise system and it becomes a direct sales model or an agency model, consumers aren't gonna recognize how important we are in their lives until it's gone.
- 9:53So it is the most important thing that we need to be working on right now.
- 9:57From a, from a hyper-local perspective, do you see any dealers, or maybe Liza as you, really exercising the leverage that they have with their employees and their staff to tell that story?
- 10:09Because, you know, it's always... There's, there's kind of these layers of story, right?
- 10:14You have the national layer that also is working with the OEM to tell the story, and then you have, you know, the state layer or the regional layer of s- of storytelling.
- 10:23And then you have the dealer level, and there's always, uh, you know, competition for acquisition of business or keeping that business.
- 10:29And then, you know, we have the, the hyper-localized layer that I, I think maybe we haven't leveraged to our, to our fullest capacity, which is the 2.1 million employees that we have in our dealerships and in our factories and in our whatever X is, that we haven't really leveraged to tell that story well.
- 10:49So how do we, how do we move that story, maybe not straight to the consumer, but how do we move the, the story from, you know, our federal or our, our national relationships that we're, that we're creating all the way down into the store to that, to that lot porter that actually gets to tell the story to their 18 friends?
- 11:08How do we move that story to that level? I, uh, you made me think of something I'd heard years and years ago. I think there's, there's been a general...
- 11:16I mean, it's, it's ridiculous to think that anybody would be in business and not wanna take care of their customers. Right. You think it's a table stake, right? [laughs] Yeah.
- 11:23I, I mean, it's definitely- It's the only way you stay in business... that's how you stay in business. Right. But we've been measured this way, that way, the other way, and I think that there's a spotlight that's...
- 11:31But I, I remember talking to a dealer, again years and years ago. He said, "Uh, Mike, it's... Why... H- how could I survive without taking care of the customer?
- 11:39Just, uh, yeah, I, I'm gonna see this person at church on Sunday." [laughs] You know? Yeah. "And I need to have a good relationship in my community with everyone, and my reputation is everything.
- 11:49My name is on the building." So it, it's just common sense, and for some reason it's all gotten twisted up ov- over the years. Uh, but, you know, I think it really comes back to, to that common sense. I mean, it...
- 12:00That's what we wanna do. It's what we have to do. Yeah.
- 12:04Kyle, when you talk about taking it to every level within the dealership and sharing that story across, not just from a dealer and general manager perspective, you know, we talk about customer experience in our dealerships, and I'll give you an example in our new hire orientation.
- 12:19I walk them through all of our expectations around customer experience and I share stories.
- 12:23And then I ask them, I said, "But there's one thingThat you have to have that is the most important thing to create the best customer experience. And they all kind of stare at me.
- 12:33[laughs] I said, "We have to have the best associate experience. We have to make sure that every single associate within Carter Myers Automotive is proud to come to work at our dealerships every day.
- 12:44They believe their morals, their ethics, and their dreams are aligned with our company.
- 12:48They have to feel that they can have a financial, um, future, that they can support everyone who counts on them, and that they can have a second phase in life with retirement."
- 12:57So if we don't have a great associate experience and they're out telling their 18 friends or the 10 friends that I think that you said is the average, if we c- don't create that, there's no way we can have a great customer experience.
- 13:07So I think you're spot on when we talk about the 2.1 million people that are employed by dealerships across our country.
- 13:13I think first we have to do a great job of making sure our dealerships are a place that people are proud to come to work with every day, and then they're out there sharing our story. Yes.
- 13:21So people, people read this shirt, and I've had several compliments. It says, "Love people more than you love cars." And I say, "I'm a pretty fancy dresser, as you can tell."
- 13:28But I was like, "Today I'm, I'm wearing Liza," right? They're always like, "Who are you wearing?" Well, this, Liza said this, "Love people more than you love cars." And it does start with the associates.
- 13:37And you, your organization exemplifies that, and then it trickles down. When we're talking, you know, Mike, you said, "That sounds like a really expensive story to tell," right?
- 13:45When you say, how do we, you know, how do we crack this nut from the top down, right?
- 13:50I mean, I can tell you from my advertising experience and creative experience, like, that's tens if not hundred million dollars to actually start to get that message through on a national level.
- 13:59However, we do have the advantage of being in every corner, right, of every c- county, of every in- community in the country.
- 14:08And I, I, I disagree a, a little bit with what you said on saying, like, w- it's common sense, right? It is business, common business sense, but I think the P&L is common sense.
- 14:19I don't know if the deployment to people, like the human element, is common sense be- it, it has to be more than it's ever been before.
- 14:26And I think adjusting to that mentality that, like, oh, the consumer has a louder voice because of social media than they've ever had. They vote with their dollars.
- 14:34Um, they sometimes vote with their votes, right, as they're electing legislators. Um, so my thought is, as, as we're talking about this, so we have store level, right, in your communities. You're in that.
- 14:45And then being around the, the dealership association, all the Virginia dealers together, I see this a lot. I, I live in New York State and, you know, you see a lot of like, "Hey, you should drink a lot of milk." Why?
- 14:55Because the New York Association of Dairy Farmers said so a lot at fairs and on media, right? And so, like, dairy farmers are great people, right? And they, we need this product. My kids need to drink milk.
- 15:06So I, I'm almost think, seeing, like, ground level, state association level. I think NADA level is, is almost like the final stop and not the first stop because, like, all the groundwork needs to be done.
- 15:19You couldn't possibly come in at NADA level and spend enough money to do it. Well, that, that's been the frustration.
- 15:25You know, they, they've spent so many unfair shots taking, uh, taking to dealers from, from the competition. Mm-hmm. Uh, very, you know, well-funded.
- 15:35Uh, not, not, not making a lot of money, but very well-funded competition. Mm-hmm. And it, it just irritates dealers because it's not true. Mm-hmm. And, and the question is, how do you combat, combat that? Mm-hmm.
- 15:45And it's, it's gotta be one-on-one. Mm-hmm. 'Cause as you mentioned, it's, it would, it would probably cost hundreds of millions of dollars to change.
- 15:51And you still- And you're still- And will you really move the needle, right? Right. Like, even so, even if you do for a season, will it stick if it's not at the ground level? Exactly. And- And we struggle with that.
- 16:01Yeah. Well, I think that's any, any large organization, legacy organization struggles with those types of things. Um, we got time for one more, I think. [laughs] One more question? One more. Yeah.
- 16:12I've got a lot more questions. [laughs] Go... I, I think we have time for one more.
- 16:15[laughs] Well, I, you know, I, uh, what I'm really interested in a- at this point is, you know, from an NADA perspective, uh, a lot of the, the, uh, like the, the visible thing that we see is, you know, the NADA convention and if you know that your stores are involved in an NADA20 group, and then, you know, a lot, there's been a lot more, especially over the last couple years, uncovered about the work that NADA is doing in, in the legislative perspective.
- 16:43Um, you know, but, but what, what more does NADA specifically need out of the dealer body right now? Mm. Good question.
- 16:51What, like, like, uh, the dealer body asks a lot of NADA, I think, but what does the, the, what does NADA need out of the dealer body?
- 16:58And, you know, we have people that will listen to this podcast that, that are everything from a salesperson to a general manager to an owner and all that.
- 17:06And so what, what can each of those types of people give back to this dealer association that is doing so much? Well, a lot of what we do, first off, I'll answer your question in, in just a minute.
- 17:19It, it goes on behind the scenes. When, uh, our team of, of, uh, our legislative team and our regulatory team, they're working with the agencies. They're working with the lawmakers.
- 17:28And when we have that influence, we don't tout it 'cause we're in a, we're educating people. We don't wanna tell 'em, "Hey, we were right, they were wrong." Mm. Same holds true with the manufacturers.
- 17:37We rarely go public. Uh, we influence through the dealer attitude survey, and we're meeting with the top levels twi- at least twice a year, sharing dealer opinion. So I think we've been a very effective organization.
- 17:49You know, you mentioned 20 Group, Academy, the show. But what we need more than ever right now is dealer engagement.
- 17:55Uh, we need dealers to get involved, not just with NADA, but with VADA, with their states, uh, to make sure that, that their voice is heard and that we're doing, you know, that our priorities are set the right way, and that when we're ready to go out and deploy that strategy, that they're on the team.
- 18:11Because it's the dealers that, that, that move the needle. They've got the relationships- Mm-hmm... with the, the lawmakers, and they've got the juice. You know, they provide the jobs, the taxes.
- 18:22All of those things are what move the needle politically in, uh, in Washington and, and around the country. So we just need them to be involved. Help us help you, as they say. Yeah.
- 18:32Actually, early, uh, actually, in December, we had Paul Walser on a live stream, and he was talking about LIFO. Yeah. [laughs] And we, we, we... A- and, and, uh, you know, Paul and I got an education and [laughs]...
- 18:44We did. We did. It was like, "I've heard about this." A super exciting topic, right? "Heard about this." And we're like, "Okay, so how does that-" He actually made it fun, though. He did.
- 18:50He had a big life-sized Grinch behind him- [laughs]... 'cause it was Christmastime. It was fantastic. It was so good.
- 18:55But what was really interesting about, uh, what, what we wanna communicate and what our desire as Automotive State of the Union, ASOTU, is, is to draw a straight line, or as straight as possible that we can, to every person in the dealership.
- 19:07And so I, I think that the call would beHey, no matter what, where you are in the dealership, where, what role you're at, is go ask your general manager, your owner, what are they doing?
- 19:19And, and, and maybe even how can you take part? Maybe it's hard for them to go to the association meeting, and they could send you because of timing, right? And you can relay that back to the dealership.
- 19:29And, and so there's multiple people working within the store to make sure that those communication lines are open and available. I, I think that's what everybody in the dealership c- has the capacity to do.
- 19:39It doesn't just have to come from the owner and the general manager. It can come from anybody. So go ask those questions. Dive in.
- 19:45And hey, you know, th- someone might, you know, lean in when you ask those questions, wondering where it came from. I, I promise I won't talk too much about LIFO.
- 19:53[laughs] But it's a great, it's a great example of, of a misperception out there that dealers are asking for a handout. They're not.
- 20:00It's just, let's get back into the, the tax deferral situation that we were in before the pandemic.
- 20:06Again, not to talk too much about LIFO, but you've got a relentless team of dealer advocates, the dealers do, that are working with Treasury, that are working with the lawmakers.
- 20:14But we need more co-sponsors on, on this legislation that's out there. There's two bills. We'll find a vehicle to attach those bills to.
- 20:22Our team is increasingly hopeful that this is gonna happen, but we need your, you to continue to amp up the, uh, the request for, for your lawmakers.
- 20:30So again, that's just an example of, of the dealer engagement that's necessary, and that's how things get done.
- 20:35And Mike, anybody in our dealerships can write a letter to their legislator on behalf of NADA, the dealerships, of themselves, to say, "This, this will help me and my dealership continue to serve our customers better."
- 20:50Exactly. Liza. I'm gonna let you have the final word. So from dealer to dealer, you're someone who involves a lot of your staff across multiple levels in industry-wide events. You expose them to industry level content.
- 21:03Um, can you... What, what would you say to other dealers in, in order to encourage them to do the same? Like, why does that work for you as a dealer? I love that question.
- 21:11We have a huge group of CMA associates here at VADA.
- 21:15Uh, we try to encourage other dealer groups to, to do the same because I think it is really important we talk about every level in our dealerships understanding the importance of what they do, how much our industry impacts the United States, everybody in this country.
- 21:29Transportation is vital, and what we do matters.
- 21:33Whether it's our controller, our lot attendant, our sales associate, our technician, our general managers, uh, we offer the opportunity for a lot of people to come to VADA because we want them to understand more than just what they do every day.
- 21:45We want them to be able to connect the dots from what they do to how it impacts lives.
- 21:51So I would encourage dealers everywhere to make sure that you let them see behind the curtain, understand every aspect of what dealerships do in our communities, how important we are to the economy of this country, and continue to educate our teams.
- 22:04So bring them to your state associations, uh, the conventions. Bring them to NADA. Let them participate in different educational opportunities that NADA and others, uh, put out there.
- 22:14The more they learn, the better we can be together. Awesome. Well, Mike, Liza, thank you so much for joining us, for taking a little bit of time, for the encouragement that we got to hear you over the last couple days.
- 22:25Uh, you know, for Paul and I, this is, uh, just, just a part of the work that we want to support you all in communicating and support anyone that's listening or watching in understanding and learning about this great industry, and like Liza said, the best, most efficient way to sell and service vehicles in our country.
- 22:43Uh, and we really believe that if we do band together, if we do draw a big circle around our whole industry, uh, that that is both a culture and perception that we can shift.
- 22:51Um, so can't wait to talk to you all again, and thank you. Thanks, guys. Okay, uh, wrapping that one up because it was a good conversation, so we played it in its entirety.
- 23:01Does something stick out to you as the most surprising thing that was said during that interview? Well, for me, I, I just love the... It's, it's a humility that you can tell when you, when you talk to Mike. Mm-hmm.
- 23:11Just the conversations that we had before and after that conversation that we showed you.
- 23:16There, there was just this genuine humility of, like, wanting to, wanting to take care of the, the things that are happening kind of behind the scenes, make sure and protect the powers that be, whether it be the political or the OEM or the dealer- Mm-hmm...
- 23:27and just make sure all the pieces are working together on the back end. And he expressed that, but he was able to express that off camera as well. Yeah.
- 23:34And just say to us, like, "Hey, you know, we are, we're caring for this in a way that we uniquely can in our position, not having to be out front and, and knowing that we're calling others to do the same and where they can."
- 23:46And that was really, that was really impactful for me. You know, I, I realize, and this is, this is just good practice anyway with a relationship, that, like, never use absolutes. Yeah. Right?
- 23:56"All people like this are that way," or, "It's always bad when..." Yes.
- 24:01And I really got the sense fro- from hearing him talk and hearing Liza and even seeing them interact, you realize how much, like, he has to, as the chair, or president CEO of, of NADA, [laughs] has to bring many groups of people together.
- 24:16Yeah. Right? And even within each segment. So you have dealers, and there are many different types of dealers.
- 24:21And he's reaching out to them in different areas with different levels of intensity because all dealers aren't the same. I don't know if you've noticed. That's right. No, definitely. I've, I've no- [laughs] I've noticed.
- 24:30Yeah. I've noticed that this week. And- All OEMs aren't the same. All industry partners aren't the same. All organizations- All legislators... different. All bills. Legislators, yes.
- 24:38S- And so recognizing that and making sure and caring for that, even in the mode of communication. Yeah. Right? Yeah, legit. So, um, we hope that... Yeah, you roll the music.
- 24:46[upbeat music] We hope that you enjoyed that conversation. There's gonna be a lot more of that coming. Um, it's been a great to just be here on site, and we're trying to bring all those little conversations to you.
- 24:54I don't care if you're a lot attendant, you should be paying attention to this 'cause it affects your future, and you can do-