Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Post-IPO Companies Use Secondary Offerings to Raise Capital
Transcript
- Lucas: We talk a lot on this show about what companies do after they go public — buybacks, lockup releases, dual-class shares. But there's one tool that's been getting a lot of attention lately that we haven't drilled into: the secondary offering. Luna: You mean when a company that's already public sells more shares to raise capital. Not the IPO, not a direct listing — a follow-on. Lucas: Exactly. And it's a fascinating lever because it's a signal. When a company announces a secondary, the market has to decide: are they raising money to fund growth, or are existing shareholders cashing out? The answer changes the stock reaction. Luna: So let's look at a couple of recent examples. Palantir — ticker P-L-T-R — is trading around $134 as of this morning, up slightly over the past five days. They've done secondaries before. What's the story there? Lucas: Palantir's actually an interesting case because they used a secondary offering back in 2021, right after their direct listing. They sold about 47 million shares — some from the company, some from existing shareholders. The stock actually went up initially because investors saw it as a way to increase liquidity. Luna: Right, because before that, the float was tiny. Institutions couldn't get a meaningful position. So the secondary actually helped broaden the shareholder base. Lucas: That's the optimistic scenario. The pessimistic one is when a secondary feels like a desperation move. Rivian — ticker R-I-V-N — is a cautionary tale there. They went public in late 2021 at $78 a share, popped to over $170 briefly, and then as production challenges mounted, they did a secondary in 2022. Luna: And the market punished them. I remember the stock dropped something like 15 percent the day they announced. Lucas: Because the context was different. Rivian needed cash to fund operations — they were burning through billions. So the secondary wasn't a growth signal, it was a survival signal. The stock today is around $17, down dramatically from the IPO. Luna: So the key variable is what the company says the money is for. Growth capex? That's usually received well. Paying down debt? Neutral. General corporate purposes — that's the phrase that scares people. Lucas: Exactly. And the mechanics matter too. There are different ways to structure a secondary. The most common is the 'accelerated bookbuild' — you hire an investment bank, they go out to institutional investors, and within a few hours, they've placed all the shares. Luna: Speed is critical because if the market knows a secondary is coming, the stock can drift lower as sellers front-run it. So you want to get it done overnight. Lucas: There's also the 'registered direct offering' — that's where you sell shares directly to a specific institutional investor, often at a discount to the market price. It's less common for large-cap tech, but we've seen it in biotech and smaller companies. Luna: And then there's the 'at the market' offering — an ATM — where the company sells shares gradually into the market over time. That's less disruptive but can create a constant overhang. Lucas: Right. And the choice of structure sends its own signal. An accelerated bookbuild says 'we want to get this done fast and move on.' An ATM says 'we're opportunistically raising capital as needed.' Luna: Let's talk about valuation context. Right now, we're in a market where AI and tech stocks have had a huge run — but also some pullback. NVIDIA's down 4 percent over the past five days. Tesla's down almost 7 percent. If you're a company that went public in the last couple of years, your stock might be below its IPO price. Lucas: That makes a secondary harder to execute at a good price. If you're trading below your IPO, you're selling shares at a discount to what early investors paid. That can be demoralizing and dilute existing holders more. Luna: And there's a timing game. Companies often wait until after a lockup expiration — that's when insiders can sell for the first time — to do a secondary. Because if the lockup release itself causes selling pressure, you don't want to add more shares on top of that. Lucas: Right. We did an episode on lockup release market making. The ideal scenario is to do the secondary a few months after the lockup, when the stock has stabilized and you have a clearer read on demand. Luna: One example that's in the headlines right now — Anthropic. The AI company just had a landmark one-point-five-billion-dollar copyright settlement approved. But they're still private. However, there are reports they're allowing secondary sales for employees — basically letting them sell shares on a private market. Lucas: That's a different kind of secondary — not a company offering, but a shareholder-led secondary. It provides liquidity without the company issuing new shares. And it's become very common in late-stage private tech. But if Anthropic eventually goes public, they might do a traditional secondary afterward to raise growth capital. Luna: So the secondary offering is really a flexible tool — it can be used to raise cash for expansion, to let insiders cash out, to increase float, or to fund M&A. But the market's reaction depends entirely on the story behind it. Lucas: And that's what we should leave listeners with: when you see a secondary announcement, don't just look at the number of shares. Look at who's selling — is it the company or the founders? What's the use of proceeds? And what's the valuation context? If those align, a secondary can be a positive catalyst. Luna: You know, Lucas, conversations like this — where we really get into the mechanics — are exactly why people listen to this show. It's ad-free, we don't have to pander to sponsors. And that's only possible because some listeners choose to support us directly. Lucas: Yeah, it's a good point. If you find this kind of deep dive useful for what you're building or running, and you want to keep it free of interruptions, you can throw a few bucks our way at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That helps us keep the lights on and maintain this format. Luna: And we really appreciate it. Okay, back to secondaries — one more nuance I want to hit: the role of the underwriter. When a company does a secondary, they typically hire the same banks that managed their IPO. That's a relationship play. Lucas: Absolutely. The lead underwriter gets a fee, usually around 3 to 5 percent of the offering size. For a hundred million dollar offering, that's three to five million in fees. And the bank's reputation is on the line — if they price it wrong or can't place the shares, it hurts their relationship with the company. Luna: So the secondary offering market is a huge business for Wall Street. In 2025, U.S. follow-on offerings raised over eighty billion dollars, more than IPOs did in some quarters. Lucas: That's a staggering number. And it tells you that the public markets are not just about the IPO — they're about ongoing capital access. A well-timed secondary can be the difference between a company that grows and one that stalls. Luna: Alright, so to wrap up: secondaries are a powerful but double-edged tool. Use them wisely, communicate clearly, and the market will reward you. Use them poorly, and you'll get punished. Lucas: And that's the kind of nuance we try to bring every week. Thanks for listening, and we'll catch you next time.