Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Bonus: The LATEST on the quarterback battles at Alabama, UGA and Ohio State
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everybody, Tony Gerdeman here get a bonus episode for you. This is
- 0:06from our College Football Playbook show that you can find at any of your local
- 0:12podcast platforms just search college Football Playbook. This is this particular episode is Mark
- 0:19Giveler along with myself and along with Jed May of UGA sports dot com and
- 0:26Tony Sukalis of Tied Illustrated dot com. We are discussing the quarterback situations at
- 0:32what are projected to be the top three teams in the nation Alabama, Georgia
- 0:36and Ohio State, all with the quarterback competitions going on. So we discussed
- 0:41the latest going on to each of those episodes or sorry, each of those
- 0:44schools wanted to put this in the Bukay Weekly Feed so you can get a
- 0:49sample of the other content that we have a Buckeye Huddle and like I said,
- 0:52this is a college football Playbook show. Go ahead and if you want
- 0:56go and subscribe to the show via your platform. You can also find it
- 1:00on YouTube at YouTube dot com, slash at CFB Playbook. Thanks welcome to
- 1:08the College Football Playbook Podcast. I am Mark Giveler. I got a great
- 1:12show today. We've got an awesome panel. We are going to talk about
- 1:17some of the big spring quarterback battles around the country. We've got three of
- 1:21the top programs in the country replacing kind of legendary quarterbacks within their programs.
- 1:26I've got experts from all three markets here and we're going to break things down.
- 1:32We have Tony Sukilis from Tide Illustrated covering Alabama. We're gonna talk about
- 1:37Alabama situation. We have Jed May from UGA sports dot Com. I'm going
- 1:40to talk about the defending champs and what they've got going on the quarterback position
- 1:44in the spring. And we've got Tony Gardiman from Buckeye Huddle dot Com to
- 1:48break down the Buckeyes who are about to lose CJ. Stroud to the first
- 1:52round of the NFL Draft. First of all, you know, let's throw
- 1:56it right to Tony Sukilas here because there's some interesting I think the developing news
- 2:00right now. It looks like Alabama is going to be in the transfer portal
- 2:07looking for a quarterback. What what have you heard on that front so far?
- 2:10Yeah, Notre Dame quarterback Tyler Buckner, who appears to have lost the
- 2:15job to Sam Hartman enter the transfer portal and visited Alabama. I guess we're
- 2:22reporting on Wednesday, so visited Alabama Tuesday night. There's definitely interest on Tyler's
- 2:30side from what I've heard from the from Notre Dame sources. We'll see how
- 2:36interested Alabama is and what they're telling him and in terms of opportunity and if
- 2:42that fits with him. But it certainly seems like a possibility that Tyler Buckner
- 2:46would transfer to Alabama. You look, it's got the connection obviously with Tommy
- 2:50Reese who came over from Notre Dame. You look at Tyler Buckner's stats and
- 2:55his production, and it doesn't necessarily seem like someone that's gonna movement needle for
- 3:00the Crimson Tide. But you know, they had kind of an up and
- 3:04down spring in terms of finding Bryce Young's replacement. Jalen Melroe, Redchard sophomore
- 3:09and Redchard freshman, and ty Simpson both had moments during the spring, but
- 3:14they also are very inconsistent that kind of followed suit during the eight A game
- 3:20or the spring game over the weekend. So it'll be interesting to see what
- 3:23Alabama does at the quarterback position. It's kind of up in the air,
- 3:27and I know it's the biggest point of concern for our fans over at Tide
- 3:31Illustrated. Obviously, Alabama has been a recruiting machine. There's a lot of
- 3:38talent on the roster. You gotta assume whoever is the quarterback is going to
- 3:40have a lot of good infrastructure around him. But what does it say that
- 3:46they're looking at the portal and you know, it's not like, you know,
- 3:50getting like Caleb Williams last year at USC or something like that. You
- 3:53know, you're talking about someone who kind of lost out at Notre Dame.
- 3:59You know how, I guess how concerning is this um in Tuscaloosa. It
- 4:02seems pretty concerning. I mean, I think if you were expecting Album to
- 4:08get a transfer quarterback, it would be somebody that's more polished than than Tyler
- 4:14Buckner. So, I you know, on the surface, it's it's pretty
- 4:16concerning um. Nick Saban talked about them that he wants to see every position
- 4:23play winning football. I think ty Simpson and Jay Lemuro are capable of playing
- 4:28winning football, but I don't think they did so during the spring game.
- 4:32And that's all really we have. The judge on Alabama has obviously seen more
- 4:39and I've seen more optimistic reports coming out of you know, from Alabama sources
- 4:45at the two scrimmages leading up to the A day scrimmage. But I don't
- 4:49think there's obviously not a lot of confidence if you're looking at the transfer portal,
- 4:54especially without an elite name in there. So yeah, I'd say it's
- 4:58pretty wide open at the quarterback and that is a little bit concerning for Elevant.
- 5:02Let's throw it over the other side of the sec Jed, you know,
- 5:06I don't. I think it's fair to say that no quarterback in the
- 5:10history the Georgia program won more big games than Stetson Bennett. Um, how
- 5:15do you replace that leadership? And you know, he's he's probably an underrated
- 5:19talent as well. It's probably I think especially last year, he you know,
- 5:24made amazing plays in the Peach Bowl and just you know, where does
- 5:29that stand. I think it was like a three horse race down there in
- 5:32Athens. Yeah, it's it's Carson Beck who who came in the class of
- 5:38twenty twenty, Gunner Stockton, I'm sorry, Brock Vandergriff who was class of
- 5:41twenty one, and then Gunner Stockton, who was a true freshman last year.
- 5:44Um, I think when you talk about Stetson, you mentioned his leadership,
- 5:46and he's a guy even looking back to twenty twenty one when he gives
- 5:51him and JT Daniels and JT started the year and then Stetson came in and
- 5:55then was JT. Then it was Stetson. Like, Stetson's a guy who
- 5:59the team kind of allied around, and he's a guy. He was a
- 6:00great leader. He had obviously has the huge confidence and bravado and swagger and
- 6:05whatever about him, and that's huge at that position especially, and I think,
- 6:11you know, I think the front runner right now would probably be Carson
- 6:14Back, especially with the performance he had during the Georgia the spring spring game,
- 6:17especially, you know, working with the first team against the first team
- 6:20defense. He had a huge first half. But that's the one thing about
- 6:24him is that he at least from what we've seen of him, doesn't necessarily
- 6:28have that same at least outwardly, that same confidence. And he's a guy,
- 6:32you know, I actually wrote a story on him the spring, and
- 6:34he's a guy who has struggled with confidence at points in his football career.
- 6:39You know, he transferred high schools before his junior year took him a while
- 6:43to get settled in. And then at Georgia, you know, he came
- 6:45in twenty twenty thinking, okay, Jake From's gone, I've got a shot
- 6:49as good a shot as anybody right to compete for the starting job. And
- 6:51then Georgia brings in Jamie Newman and J. C. Daniels, and he's
- 6:56just he's kind of struggled. But last year when he and let me prehaps
- 7:00by saying that it's garbage time. But when he came in, he looked
- 7:01a lot more in control of the offense. Like let years passed he'd come
- 7:06in, he looked during the headlights. He you know, I played a
- 7:10stands out in through a pick six against UAB in twenty twenty one. But
- 7:14last year he completed twenty six to thirty five passes, three hundred yards,
- 7:17three hundred ten yards, four touchdowns and most importantly no interceptions. And and
- 7:21again it's garbage time. You know, eight of a lot of those stats
- 7:26came against Vanderbilt, so like it's you got to take it with a grain
- 7:29of salt, but just the outward um the poison and um, I don't
- 7:34know what I'm trying to say. He just looks a lot better to the
- 7:38naked eye, I guess than Fanny has in years passed. So as we
- 7:41come out of spring, I think it would be Carson back. That's kind
- 7:44of got the inside track there. How did they get stats and Bennett to
- 7:47leave? I mean, when they tried, they tried to get him to
- 7:51leave, what once or twice he came back he's you know, and then
- 7:55then they wanted him back, And so they finally referred with the AARP stuff
- 8:01and going with student loans, like it's hard to get all that like kind
- 8:03of figured out. But and this, and the coaching staff has said like
- 8:07and when Todd Munkin was still in Georgia, he said this, like,
- 8:09we kept telling ourselves that this Bennett kid wasn't good enough, and he kept
- 8:13proving us wrong. So that's he's like he said, he's a legend.
- 8:18He won so many big games, made big plays to win said big games,
- 8:22especially in twenty twenty two. But I think another question is he made
- 8:28so many plays with his legs right, he can scramble, he can extend
- 8:31plays. And Carson Beck is athletic, but not to the same extent that
- 8:37Bennett is. And I think when you look at Brock, Vandergriff and Gunner
- 8:39Stockton especially, that's what those guys bring. They have more of a running
- 8:43to mension to their games that that is helping them in this quarterback competition.
- 8:48I know when you look at Vandergriff with the ones during g Day, he
- 8:50struggled, he did down and passed his jobs. He threw a bad interception,
- 8:56which he told he told reporters after the game, I just got greedy
- 8:58and tried to, you know, float a ball in toward the sideline.
- 9:01Got picked off. So and that's the stuff like you can't, especially at
- 9:03Georgia wid the running game they have and obviously what they've done on defense.
- 9:09You need a quarterback who is going to take care of the ball, not
- 9:11not do stupid things like throwing interceptions into coverage. So and then this is
- 9:16a battle that's going to go through the fall. I think I'm no means
- 9:20saying that Carson Beck has this thing wrapped up. A lot can change Carson
- 9:24Beck. In twenty twenty one, Kirby Smart said he was going to be
- 9:26the starter. He was the number two if if anything happened JT. Daniels
- 9:31and then things didn't go well in practice Stetson, Bennett takes over and and
- 9:35obviously we went from there. So I think it's going to go through the
- 9:37fall. But again I think it's it's Carson Beck's job to lose. I
- 9:41would say right now, it's a pretty fair way to characterize it. No
- 9:46portal hunting, No, I don't think so. I just think if you're
- 9:50a quarterback going in the portal you want, like Tyler Butner for example,
- 9:54Okay, you want to go somewhere where. Okay, if I go to
- 9:58Alabama, I will at least have a a really good shot to compete to
- 10:01win this starting job with with Milroe and ty Simpson and Georgia. You know,
- 10:05theoretically you could tell like, hey, you've got a chance to compete
- 10:07with You're coming in, you're learning a new offense, you're having a developed
- 10:11chemistry with these receivers that all these other quarterbacks have been around for years.
- 10:13So and I don't think any quarterback would portal into into any place to be
- 10:20a knowing that you're going to be a back up our third string guys.
- 10:22So I mean, nothing's impossible in college football. I guess I don't see
- 10:26Georgia adding adding a quarterback out of the portal. I don't think Tony Gerdeman.
- 10:31We've talked about this before, maybe the most legitimate quarterback battle that Ohio
- 10:37States hadn't quite a while. Where does that snam come down of the spring?
- 10:41Yeah, it's unfortunate Devin Brown, who is competing with Kyla McCord.
- 10:45Right your freshman Devin Brown got injured the last week of spring, so we
- 10:48didn't get to see them both compete in the spring game and then draw our
- 10:50own massive conclusions about who should be starting at Ohio State. But you know,
- 10:56as Jed made Jed Jed said, you know it's the the betting favorite
- 11:01or the guy that you're probably going with right now is Kyle McCord over Devin
- 11:05Brown. And that's just based on experience. You know, he started a
- 11:09game in twenty twenty one as a true freshman against Akron, against an Acron
- 11:13team that wouldn't make the FCS playoffs that year. They're very bad, but
- 11:18still has that experience, and so I think at this point he's They split
- 11:22reps all spring long, you know, ones and two. Sometimes Devin Brown
- 11:24would be with the ones, sometimes Colm McCord would be with the ones and
- 11:28the other guy would be with the two, so they shared reps and it
- 11:31was a true competition. And Ryan Day said that he would was hoping somebody
- 11:35would step forward and take the job. That didn't happen, and so that
- 11:39will continue. The competition will continue into the fall. Right now, Devin
- 11:45Brown is going to miss about four weeks of summertime throwing as he gets his
- 11:48you know, broke his finger and gets that fixed, and so Kyle McCord
- 11:52has another opportunity to, you know, either maintain a lead or gain some
- 11:58more ground. It's just interesting to me that Karmic Coord has this this experience
- 12:05over Devin Brown, but it's still very even, and you're wondering if if
- 12:09Karmic Coord isn't pulling away at this point, will will Devin Brown catch him?
- 12:13And these next thirty practices thirty out of practices of a fall camp,
- 12:18and you know, we'll see there's plenty of weapons for both guys to look
- 12:22good, that's for sure. How harmful do you think this hand injury is
- 12:28to Devin Brown's chances of starting um? You know, I guess maybe it
- 12:33was okay timing because it was toward the end of spring, but he misses
- 12:37the spring game, and now it's gonna be McCord kind of being the man
- 12:41driving summer workouts here for the next month or so and getting with the guys.
- 12:46Yeah, And the thing you have to understand at Ohio State, a
- 12:50hand injury to a quarterback is a very significant piece of lore because it was
- 12:56a hand injury to Jump Burrow in the fall camp of twenty seventeen that led
- 13:01to Dwayne Haskins being essentially given the backup job. And then it was Dwayne
- 13:07Haskins who came into the Michigan game when JT. Barrett went down and saved
- 13:11the day. And then nothing Joe Burrow could really do in the spring of
- 13:16twenty eighteen could overtake what Dwayne Haskins did against Michigan. And so when they
- 13:22couldn't tell Joe Burrow, yeah, you're gonna be our starter in twenty eighteen,
- 13:26he left for LSU all because of this hand injury when he was the
- 13:28backup quarterback. And so when Ryan Day mentions before the spring game the week
- 13:33leading after the spring game, by the way, Devin Brown had a hand
- 13:37has a hand injury, and then you know immediately that sends up red flares,
- 13:41and so I asked Ryan, Hey, like, hey, Dwayne askins
- 13:46Joe Burrow. He's like, it's nothing like that. I know what you're
- 13:48trying to say. I know where you're going. It's nothing like that.
- 13:50This is just he missed. It's going to miss miss a week of spring
- 13:54practice. That's it. And you know, pick up fall camp. Everything
- 13:56will be even everything, He'll be fine. Don't read into it too much
- 14:00like that. But certainly didn't help Devin Brown. And you know he's a
- 14:03he's a more mobile guy, and so he uses his legs a bit more
- 14:07than Klmic Chord, but you know, not having that hand obviously, you
- 14:11know he's he's the guy Karmic Cord throws the ball better than Devin Brown,
- 14:13I think at this point. And so you know, anything to do with
- 14:18the throwing hand, throwing arm is uh. You know that's going to set
- 14:22Devin Brown back a bit, but not so much that he can't catch up.
- 14:24As Ryan Day said, let's throw up the graphic we have here because
- 14:30I want to point this out. This is the all time pass attempts of
- 14:37the most I guess experienced quarterback on each of these rosters. Um so,
- 14:41so Jalen Milrose of Alabama is the most experienced quarterback on these three rosters,
- 14:48with all sixty career pass attempts. Um. You know, the question says
- 14:54is experience necessary? Um Tony Suklis, do you do you think the lack
- 14:58of experience is the biggest factor in Alabama kind of going portal hunting here a
- 15:03little bit. It certainly has something to do with it. I mean,
- 15:09but I mean, if you're bringing in Tyler Buckner, he has what three
- 15:11starts to his name, So I don't think that that's necessarily I think it's
- 15:16just consistency. I think that, you know, I mean, Jayleen Merrow
- 15:20has already had two sec situations. I mean he's had one start against Texas
- 15:24A and M, but he came in in the second half against Arkansas basically
- 15:28played a whole half, So I guess you would call that one and a
- 15:31half starts almost I don't think that he's that experiences, you know, really
- 15:39any different than Tyler Buckner's if that's who they end up going with, obviously
- 15:43you want to have as much experience as as you can. But I think
- 15:48it boils down more to consistency and being able to perform at a winning level,
- 15:56you know, at a reliable rate, And I don't I don't know
- 16:00if Albama fields it can it has that yet with Jayleen Molrow, Jed you
- 16:06know some experience there. With Carson Beck, he's been in the program for
- 16:11a while. I think the big thing with with Georgia is, so this
- 16:15is a kind of three way battle at this point. How do you massage
- 16:19that with some of the younger guys. I mean, these are all pretty
- 16:23highly recruited players. Um, you know, portal entry for you know,
- 16:30the loser. I mean, how how are they going to you know,
- 16:33the roster management component of this. I think it's very interesting for Georgia.
- 16:36I mean kind of how how are they massaging that? So everything we've heard
- 16:41on a UG sports this spring has has indicated that that Brock Vandergriff is not
- 16:45transferring. He's going to stay through the fall. I believe he'll be graduating
- 16:49in the fall. So that's that's another kind of layer to this. But
- 16:53um, and he's he's from the Athens area, so Georgia degree probably means
- 16:59a lot to him. But yeah, I mean it's interesting because, like
- 17:03I said, any of these guys are highly recruited. There's a lot of
- 17:04schools that would be interested in them. And if we haven't really heard much
- 17:07about Gunner Stockton leaving either. So, and the funny thing is last spring,
- 17:11it seemed like it would have been easy for Carson Beck to leave because
- 17:15he's a guy. He at that point he had two years of Georgia Stetson
- 17:18Bennutes not going anywhere after winning a national title once HENLC was coming back obviously,
- 17:23so and when you ask him, he's like, Hey, I just
- 17:26love the University of Georgie. I didn't want to leave. I like it
- 17:29in Athens, I like the coaches, I like all that. And I
- 17:32think that that's part of what these other guys have. They went from Todd
- 17:36Munkin to Mike Bobo at offensive coordinator, but for the most part, the
- 17:38offense is staying the same most of the same terminology. And then Mike Bobo
- 17:41is an offensive analyst last year, so he's a guy that they are from.
- 17:45They're familiar with too. So I think as far as experience, what
- 17:51I'm curious with Beck or any of these guys is how do they react in
- 17:56game? Like talking about that leadership stuff, I mentioned earlier. Okay,
- 17:57Carson Beck. You know, last year Georgia was at Missouri and they were
- 18:02down I think ten in the fourth quarter. Situations like that are gonna happen,
- 18:06even when you roll on and go fifteen or no win a national shape.
- 18:08But hip, how does Carson Beck rally the troops? How does he
- 18:11react when you know an offensive lineman has a crucial holding puter? You know,
- 18:15stuff like that is the stuff that you can't really simulate in a game.
- 18:21You can talk about going against one of the best defenses in the country,
- 18:23getting better, all that kind of stuff. It's the intangibles that I
- 18:26think are the game experience that you can't really replace. And even you know,
- 18:30in the games he's played in, Okay, guy gets a holding penalty,
- 18:33it doesn't really matter because you're up forty points in the fourth quarter,
- 18:37you know. So that's what I'll be interested to watch early in this season,
- 18:41although there's there's gonna be a lot of forty points in the fourth quarter.
- 18:47Again, Earland's just just the fact of what their schedule looks like.
- 18:49It's ut Martin, It's ball State. You know, UAB is probably a
- 18:53little better than those two, but still a group of five opponents. So
- 18:59it's going to be in to see how that shakes out later in the season
- 19:02when jointer plays, you know at Auburn, they play at Tennessee obviously in
- 19:04November versus Florida. Um. That's really what I'm gonna be watching throughout the
- 19:08especially the early part of the season. Gerd Um. You know, it
- 19:14looks pretty stable for Ohio State as far as the transfer portal. You know,
- 19:18I think we've we've received confirmation from from both mccordam Brown that they were
- 19:23they're not going to be going anywhere, um in advance of fall camp.
- 19:29Ohio State's schedule UM. And they start with Indiana on the road, which
- 19:34you know should be a win, but you never know with these openers,
- 19:37these conference openers can kind of be weird. But then they play what Western
- 19:42or Youngstown State in Western Kentucky are their next two games before that big road
- 19:47game at Notre Dame at the end of September. Could the Buckeyes pull a
- 19:51Michigan and uh do what Michigan did last year with McNamara and J. J.
- 19:59McCarthy and kind of flip flop starts and almost let this thing play out
- 20:03in September. I've I've also thrown that out there as a possibility now,
- 20:08the difference being Indiana's vastly better than anything Michigan had on their non conference schedule
- 20:15last year. I think their first two games were Colorado State in Hawaii and
- 20:18Yukon was in there as well as their other other game, and Jim Harball,
- 20:23knowing who he actually wanted at quarterback that year, gave J J.
- 20:26McCarthy the Hawaii games the second game of the season. Let let everybody get
- 20:32the run up in the first game. That's Kay McNamara. Then they go
- 20:34to J. J. McCarthy and it's like, oh, j J.
- 20:37McCarthy much better, so let's go with him. I don't think they can
- 20:40do that now. If things are completely even, you gotta you play both,
- 20:45you gotta see I think George's a great example a couple of years ago.
- 20:49You're trying not to play the guy that leads you to the national championship.
- 20:52You got to find out who who are your leaders. Doesn't matter who
- 20:56the best thrower is, the best passer is. It's the guy who moves
- 20:59the ball. It's the guy who leads the team. It's the guy who
- 21:02gets everybody together. It's a guy that picks up the first downs and you
- 21:06think you know who that is by the time the first game rolls around.
- 21:11But sometimes you find out through the you need a guy to come in on
- 21:15an emergency. Sometimes Alabama took them the last game of a national championship season
- 21:19a couple of years ago. You get turned to a guy that gets the
- 21:22job done and you think you know who it is. And Ohio State has
- 21:26done very well with their quarterbacks. Ryan Day. I think every year he's
- 21:29been at Ohio State, he's had the All Big Ten first team quarterback.
- 21:33I would expect that to continue just because of the offense that they're in,
- 21:37but you don't know. And so you're actually out there, and I think
- 21:41playing on the I believe it's a road game, and playing on the road
- 21:44for the first game of the year, you'll get a better idea of what
- 21:48you have than starting off with Youngstown State in Western Kentucky. So you'll have
- 21:55a decent idea playing at Indiana and if if Kam a quarter or whoever starting
- 22:00handle it, you can't afford to lose that game. So you got to
- 22:03see you've got to try to win it with the whoever gives you the best
- 22:06opportunity, and if it happens to the happens to be the backup, then
- 22:11now you've got two games where you're like, Okay, we're gonna give you
- 22:14each a start and see how it goes there. I gotta think short leash
- 22:18there, right, Yeah, for whoever whoever starts the opener. Yeah,
- 22:23I mean it depends on the defense, right, you know, also depends
- 22:26on how well at Ohio State defense is playing. And so yeah, I
- 22:30think not not a long leash, especially if if you Ryan Day can go
- 22:36into the two weeks leading up to the game saying we're going to play both
- 22:38guys, and he should tell them that. That way they understand if I
- 22:41do call you, that was the plan all along, so it doesn't look
- 22:45like you've been benched. Good point there. Kind of another fascinating component to
- 22:52all of this is there are significant offensive changes to the staff at all three
- 23:00of these programs. In addition to trying to find the quarterback, you're trying
- 23:06to marry that potentially with with new play callers, new coordinators. Tony Sukalism,
- 23:12you know, what have you seen from Tommy Reese so far? And
- 23:15you know how much I guess how much control is does he have over the
- 23:19offense under Nick Saban, who I know likes to keep a close eye on
- 23:23things. Yeah, so it's still gonna be Alabama's offense. Alavima never really
- 23:30drastically changes their offense. But I do think you're gonna see Tommy Reese have
- 23:33different wrinkles. And I think that, you know, the biggest thing that
- 23:37ALBM is looking at is the last two years, you know, mostly because
- 23:41they could you had kind of the offense revolve around Bryce Young kind of making
- 23:45things happen, you know, and I think you just kind of let him
- 23:48do his thing, and they became over reliant on Bryce Young. So I
- 23:53think you're going to need to add especially with a young quarterback. And if
- 23:56you look at what Alabma does have, they of what should be an improved
- 24:00offensive line, a really deep running back unit. They do have weapons at
- 24:04receiver, although they didn't look great in the spring game. So I think
- 24:08that you know, you're gonna see more balance on offense with Tommy Rees.
- 24:12I think you're gonna see maybe more two tight end sets. That's another thing
- 24:15that Alabama should have is is decent tight end play. They brought in CJ.
- 24:19Dupree from Maryland. They also have a Marian and Black, so that
- 24:23that's a you know, interesting kind of one two duo right there. And
- 24:29so I think you're going to see them kind of run the ball a little
- 24:32bit better and you know, kind of I don't think it's going to be
- 24:37drastically just a ground and pound, but I think they're going to have more
- 24:41of their identity and you're gonna have things to set up the young quarterbacks and
- 24:45kind of put them in better situations, whereas before I think you could just
- 24:49kind of let Bryce Young kind of run the show. You're not going to
- 24:53have no matter who they bring in, they're not going to have anybody that
- 24:56reaches anywhere close to that level. So you're gonna have to do things differently
- 25:00in order to move the ball. Yeah, Jed offensive coordinator change there,
- 25:06um at u Ga, how does that impact things? Um? As far
- 25:11as just the whole evaluation process for these quarterbacks. Um Bobo was on staff
- 25:18previously. Um kind of yeah, I mean advantages disadvantages I guess for for
- 25:23the quarterbacks. As far as having a new OC, Yeah, I mean
- 25:29he was on staff actually during the mark rickda as offensive coordinator and drew the
- 25:33ire of of fans a lot for like like every offensive coordinator, Will Um
- 25:40and then and then last year came back as an analyst and now was like
- 25:44when Todd Munkin left. It was actually I think at the same day Todd
- 25:48Munkin announced he was going to the Ravens, and um Bobo was promoted the
- 25:51same day. It wasn't there was not a huge, like nationwide search.
- 25:56You know, we're gonna, we're gonna settle for this guy. This was
- 25:59a move Kirby Smart kind of had in mind since the end of last season.
- 26:03So I think one interesting wrinkle Gunner Stockton was committed to South Carolina when
- 26:07Mike Bobo was on staff there. I don't think. I mean, obviously
- 26:14those two have a good relationship, but I still think Gunner is below the
- 26:18level of Beck and Vandergriff in this competition right now, just because he's younger,
- 26:22he had been, the offense is long, you know, all that
- 26:25kind of stuff. So um, I think it's gonna be Beck or Vandergriff
- 26:30that ends up winning this thing. But what that does help Gunner the fact
- 26:32that he's got a relationship with Mike Bobo. But these guys, it's kind
- 26:37of like Tony just said, it's still the Georgia offense. There will be
- 26:40you know, slightly different wrinkles, terms changed, whatever, m but what
- 26:45it's still the Georgia offense at the end of the day, which which helps
- 26:48when especially in the case of a Beck and Vandergriff, those guys has been
- 26:52multiple years in this thing, so they know him, they know the offense.
- 26:56I think it's you know, it's a little interesting their relationship with with
- 27:00Stockton and Bobo, but I still think at the end of the day,
- 27:03it's probably going to be either back or Bandergriff. Slightly different situation at Ohio
- 27:11State, um gird, you know it's this is always going to be Ryan
- 27:15Day's offense. But Kevin Wilson, um offensive coordinator gets the Tulsa head coaching
- 27:22job. Brian Hartline is elevated UM talk that he's going to be the play
- 27:27caller. Well maybe see it to believe it. Kind of how do you
- 27:30think this is going to play out with the new play caller? And and
- 27:33you know how you know, how difficult is this for a high state with
- 27:37an inexperienced quarterback? And now you don't You don't necessarily have an experienced play
- 27:41caller if they're going to actually give Brian Hartline the reins. Yeah, and
- 27:45you also have the history of promoting guys because you don't want to lose them,
- 27:49which hasn't gone well for Ohio State over the years. You make a
- 27:52guy a coordinator because you don't want to lose them or you feel you have
- 27:56to, and it doesn't doesn't work out. But everything that Brian Hartline has
- 28:00done at Ohio State has worked out. And so he called plays this spring.
- 28:06He has Ryan Day right there in his ear as well. And the
- 28:10thing about Ohio State the offense, like all of the plays essentially get decided
- 28:15midweek, so it's everybody's input and then actually calling the play, they tell
- 28:19you it's the easy part. Even though Ryan Day has been one of the
- 28:22best play callers I think nationally since he's been at Ohio State. And so
- 28:27now is this, um, you know what happens now with Brian Hartline doing
- 28:32that? Is it a net that positive? Because now Ryan Dale will be
- 28:34more focused on defense and special teams, which have been the area of concern.
- 28:38But I'm I'm interested to see how it goes with Brian Hartline because Kevin
- 28:42Wilson and Ryan Day are two of the best, and Ryan Hartline has never
- 28:47called a play other than you know, video games in spring and spring practice
- 28:52basically, And I think Ohio State has made it look pretty easy over the
- 28:56years. I promise you it isn't. But the week eating up and the
- 29:00game planning makes it easier. So I think I'm expecting it to go okay.
- 29:07But as you said, it's two new quarterbacks, and whoever wins it,
- 29:10it's going to be a different guy than c. J. Stroud,
- 29:12going to be a different guy than justin fields. So you're gonna have to
- 29:15tie the offense to what they do, and it is Ryan Day's offense,
- 29:19but it's still going to be Guys have to be precise and be careful with
- 29:26the ball, and the play calling has to reflect that as well. And
- 29:30you can't you can't forget about the running backs because it's a loaded running back
- 29:33rooms, and Brian Highline has to dial back his want to throw the ball,
- 29:36assuming he does being a former wide receiver. All right, last thing
- 29:41for you, guys, we'll go around the horn here. Start with Tony
- 29:45Suklis Okay, I'm not even gonna say September because I think that's I think
- 29:52that's too early almost for a lot of these situations. I think a lot
- 29:56of guys there may be quick leashes at all three of these places by October
- 30:03one. Who was Alabama's starting quarterback? Is it Milrow? Is it Simpson,
- 30:08or is it transfer portal to be named later? I honestly don't know.
- 30:14I really would have to see the transfer Portal edition, and even then,
- 30:18I'm not sure if you're asking me right now. Jalen Miller was the
- 30:22first team quarterback during the Aday scrimmage, so he's also started a game.
- 30:29If everything's even Nick Saban usually goes on the side of experience, so I'm
- 30:34leaning the slightest razors been edged to Jalen Millrow. But you know, if
- 30:40this was one of those confidence picks, I'm not putting a lot of confidence
- 30:44points on it. So I really don't even know. I don't know if
- 30:48Alvin's next quarterbacks on the roster. I don't know if the quarterback they start
- 30:52with in game one will be the quarterback they start with in game three.
- 30:56You know, just there's so much uncertainty that I guess the only other time
- 31:02that I've seen this much uncertainty with the quarterback position, you know, since
- 31:06I came onto the Beat in twenty and sixteen was that first season for me
- 31:08on the Beat with twenty and sixteen when Jalen Hurts kind of came out of
- 31:12nowhere and won the job in the fall. You know, So who knows,
- 31:17maybe following that model will be one of the two freshman quarterbacks on the
- 31:19roster. I have no idea at the moment, but if you're making me
- 31:23pick, Jalen Miller would be my current pick. So definitely Jaylen Milroe bording
- 31:30to Tony Suklis one thousand percent Jaylen Milrow for the jed who we got October
- 31:38first, when the dust stall settles and they've made their decision and everyone's just
- 31:41got their quick hooks out of the way and everything else. I think it's
- 31:45Carson Back. I think he's got the most amount of time in the system,
- 31:51He's got by far the most game experience, and I think he came
- 31:56into spring looking probably like the favorite. You know, every quarterback had their
- 32:00ups and downs through the spring, and then at G Day he looked fantastic.
- 32:05So I think it's his job to lose. I don't foresee him losing
- 32:09it. I think the only question, because he got all the natural ability
- 32:13in the world. I think the only question is how has he handled those
- 32:15leadership things, the confidence, all that kind of stuff. And I think
- 32:20he has grown by leaps and bounds in that area of the past probably years
- 32:25or so, Like talking to some high school coaches that coached him, they
- 32:30met with him last spring, last fall and everything like he is. He's
- 32:32not even the same person he was when he started his career at Georgia.
- 32:36So I think he's got that side of things kind of figured out. And
- 32:38I think that confidence is only going to grow the more reps he gets with
- 32:43the ones through the summer and obviously through the fall. So I think it's
- 32:46Carson Beck and I think, you know, and George's with the supporting casts.
- 32:51They've got around, and they've they've got a shot to do something.
- 32:52Just do some more good things on offense, even without the mailman making the
- 32:57deliveries anymore. All right, Gerd, who's it going to be? McCord
- 33:01brown, Yes, yes, it will be one of those two. Coming
- 33:07into the spring, I was forty five, McCord I think I'm sixty forty
- 33:12now, and you know, nothing that I saw made me think it wasn't
- 33:15going to be klmiccord, other than the fact that at some point maybe could
- 33:22he have taken more reps from Devin Brown with the ones. But the spring
- 33:25is for finding out what exactly you have, so they gave everybody the same
- 33:30number of reps. But I believe it will be klm accord. He's got
- 33:32the most experience. He's I think he's the most experienced leader as well,
- 33:38and that's something that he has been focused on since he arrived at Ohio State.
- 33:44Because remember he came to Ohio State, he was he was competing to
- 33:46start as a true freshman, and so since then he's been working on his
- 33:50leadership skills. He's he's taken ownership of this team. Once you know,
- 33:53c. J. Stroud was here, he was still one of the leaders.
- 33:57Now that he's gone, he's definitely one of the leaders. And this
- 34:00is his third year. So you're a veteran now, and so i'm can
- 34:05you go with Kyle McCord. But you know, Devin Brown, former number
- 34:09one player in a nation, you know, maybe not a bad second.
- 34:15We will see lots of time left. It sounds like all these battles are
- 34:19going to go into the fall so probably be one of the biggest storylines around
- 34:22college football when you've got you know, three of the top four or five
- 34:25ranked teams in the country going into fall camp without a quarterback. So it's
- 34:30almost unprecedented really to think about that, in combination with the quality of quarterback
- 34:36every school these schools are replacing, so my thinks can be one of the
- 34:39biggest storylines in college football this year. I think it's you know, these
- 34:43decisions are probably gonna shape the national championship, if not certainly the college football
- 34:47playoffs, so we will we will keep up on this and appreciate it again.
- 34:52Can you can find Tony Suklist at Tie Illustrated dot com does a great
- 34:55job there, Jed May at UGA sports dot com, Tony German Buckey Huddle
- 34:59dot com for all your high state coverage. Thank you guys, and thanks
- 35:04everyone for watching and listening. Please subscribe to the channel and we're on the
- 35:08podcast feed. You know, we will have it on your podcast platform with
- 35:13choice, so you can catch us there if you'd rather listen. But thanks
- 35:15everyone for watching, listening, and we will see you next time.