Latest / New Teacher Talk / Ep 200: Are You Accidentally Triggering Your Students? 6 Teacher Behaviors That Cause Classroom Disruption

Transcript

Ep 200: Are You Accidentally Triggering Your Students? 6 Teacher Behaviors That Cause Classroom Disruption · New Teacher Talk

So Beth, I have a confession to make.
Uh-oh.
Should I be worried?
Maybe a little.
Last week,
I caught myself doing something I tell new teachers not to
do.
I was stressed about getting through a lesson and I snapped
at a student who was off task.
My tongue was sharp.
My body language was tense.
Within five minutes, three other students were acting out.
That doesn't sound like you at all,
because I know you're so effective in the classroom.
And let me guess, you were thinking,
why are all these students misbehaving today?
Exactly.
Until I realized it was me.
I triggered the whole thing with my stress and my tone.
You know what?
I think this is one of the hardest truths in teaching.
Sometimes we are the trigger for challenging behavior.
And today, let's just talk about that.
Welcome to New Teacher Talk,
where we help early career educators navigate the realities
of the classroom.
I'm Dr.
Bass.
And I'm Dr.
Anna.
Today we're tackling something that requires real
vulnerability and self-reflection,
the ways that we as teachers can unintentionally trigger
challenging student behavior.
And I want to be clear right from the start.
This is not about blaming teachers.
I have enough of that going around in the world.
Teaching is incredibly complex.
And we all have moments where we don't show up as our best
selves.
Right.
This is about empowerment.
When we understand how our actions, our words,
and our classroom structures might be contributing to
behavioral challenges, we can make intentional changes.
Exactly, Anna.
So today we're going to walk through six categories of
teacher created triggers,
and we will give you some reflection questions as we go
along to examine your own practice.
Think of this as a mirror, not a magnifying glass.
We're looking at ourselves with curiosity, not judgment.
That's perfect, couldn't agree more.
Let's just dive on in.
The first category is communication and language triggers.
This is where I got myself into trouble last week,
with my tone.
Tone is huge.
Students are incredibly attuned to how we say things,
not just what we say.
When we use sarcasm, when we speak sharply,
when we have a condescending edge to our voice,
our students pick up on that immediately.
And especially students who've experienced trauma or who
have a heightened sensitivity,
they may interpret that tone as a personal attack,
which then triggers a defensive or aggressive response.
Mm hmm.
Yeah.
The other big one is public correction.
When we call out a student's behavior in front of their
peers,
we are essentially asking them to choose between compliance
and saving face.
And adolescents especially,
they're gonna choose saving face almost every time.
You're right.
So instead of a simple redirect,
now you've got a huge power struggle on your hands.
The third piece is our language choices.
When we use absolute language,
you always interrupt or you never follow directions.
That feels like attacking.
Because it's a character judgment,
rather than a description of a specific behavior,
the student hears,
you are a bad person instead of this particular action
needs to change.
So, reflection questions for listeners.
How does your tone change when you're stressed?
Do you address behavior publicly or privately?
And are you using I statements?
I need you to instead of you, accusations.
I versus you statements, so well said Anna.
Those small shifts in communication can create massive
changes in your classroom climate.
The second category is relationship and respect triggers.
And here's a truth that's hard to hear.
Students are more likely to challenge our authority when
they don't feel known, valued or connected to us.
Without relationship,
there's really no motivation to cooperate.
I always tell new teachers,
students don't care how much you know until they know how
much you care.
I know that's cliche, but it's true.
Absolutely.
And the flip side is inconsistency.
When students perceive that rules apply differently to
different students, resentment builds fast.
And we have to be honest about bias here.
Here's some reflective questions to think about.
Are we giving more leniency to students we like?
To students who look like us?
To students who don't push our buttons?
That's the hard self-reflection work,
because we all have biases.
The question is whether we're aware of them and actively
working against them.
And I would add the other piece here is cultural
responsiveness.
If we are imposing cultural norms that don't align with
students' backgrounds, we are going to create conflict.
Right.
Like expecting direct eye contact when some cultures view
that as disrespectful,
or misinterpreting culturally specific communication styles
as defiant.
So listeners, ask yourself,
do I know something personal about each of my students?
Have I had a positive interaction with each one of them
this week?
Am I applying consequences consistently?
Do I know my students' cultural backgrounds?
Good questions, Beth.
Now let's talk about environment,
because this is category 3.
I think we underestimate how much the physical space
impacts behavior.
It has to be taken into consideration, Anna.
I completely agree.
A classroom with excessive visual clutter,
that constant noise, harsh fluorescent lighting,
that can overwhelm students,
especially those with sensory sensitivities or ADHD.
And what looks like misbehavior might actually be sensory
overload or a need for movement.
Exactly.
The other big environmental trigger is unclear
expectations.
When students do not know what's expected of them or when
routines are inconsistent,
anxiety goes up and anxiety often looks like off-task
behavior.
So is your classroom visually overwhelming?
Are routines clearly taught and practiced?
And do students have opportunities for movement and brain
breaks?
Category number four is instructional and academic
triggers.
And Anna,
I think this is where we often miss what's really happening.
Yes, because when work is too difficult,
students get frustrated.
When it's too easy, they're bored.
Either way, they might avoid the work, act out,
or shut down.
And as teachers,
we see the behavior and think it's a discipline problem
when actually it's a curriculum problem.
Exactly.
And the other piece is relevance.
When students can't see why they're learning something,
motivation plummets.
Disengagement often looks like disruption.
Mm-hmm.
I agree.
We need to differentiate based on students' readiness,
connect lessons to their interests and lived experiences,
and make sure they can articulate why what they are
learning matters.
And we need to celebrate their strengths,
not just correct their deficits.
Constantly highlighting what students can't do erodes their
confidence fast.
Here are some reflection questions based on all of this.
Am I differentiating?
Do I offer choices?
Do I notice and name students strengths regularly?
And now, on to category 5, Power and Authority Triggers.
This is where things can escalate quickly.
Absolutely.
Power struggles rarely end well for anyone.
When we insist on immediate compliance,
refuse to negotiate, make everything a battle for control,
your students are just going to dig in to maintain their
dignity.
Especially tweens and adolescents.
They're developmentally wired to seek autonomy.
If we don't give them appropriate ways to exercise agency,
they'll find inappropriate ways.
Right, and the other issue is over-reliance on punishment.
If we are constantly punishing but not teaching
alternatives,
students learn what not to do but not what to do instead.
resentment builds,
which then creates a cycle of misbehavior.
So reflect on this, listeners.
Do you give students choices within boundaries?
Can you let them say face while maintaining expectations?
Do you teach desired behaviors before expecting them?
And do students have input into classroom decisions?
Because sharing power doesn't mean losing control,
it means building investment.
The sixth and final category is emotional climate triggers,
and this one hits close to home for a lot of us.
It does.
Because here's the truth.
Students are incredibly attuned to our emotions.
When we bring our stress, our frustration,
our negative mood into the classroom, it affects everyone.
Students may react with anxiety and withdrawal,
or even acting out,
essentially mirroring the emotional climate that we have
created.
And when we dismiss or ignore students' emotional states,
you're fine, just get to work.
We communicate that their feelings don't matter.
So they escalate to be seen in her, that's just natural.
And the hard truth is we can't expect students to regulate
emotions we haven't learned to manage ourselves.
We can't pour from an empty cup.
Mm hmm.
Here's some questions to reflect on.
Do you have strategies for managing your stress before it
enters the classroom?
Do your students feel emotionally safe to make mistakes?
Can they communicate when they need support?
And do you validate emotions when you can't change the
situation?
These are tough questions that require real honesty.
They do, and as teachers, we are naturally reflective,
so it's very possible to dig deep.
So let's talk about moving forward,
because recognizing these triggers is only the first step
in us.
Right.
The next step is to committing to ongoing self-reflection
and adjustment.
And we want to offer some practical strategies for you.
First, we recommend keeping a reflection journal,
and I know a lot of us feel like we don't have time to do
that, or you see it as a very long process or task.
Maybe you're not a natural writer, but trust us on this.
After some challenging moments, this is simple.
Write down about what happened, what you did,
and what you might do differently next time.
Three sentences, that's it.
And second, ask for feedback.
Ask a trusted colleague to observe in your classroom and
identify potential triggers you might not notice yourself.
Third, listen to your students.
Create opportunities for them to share what helps them feel
successful and what gets in their way.
Fourth, start small.
Choose one trigger area to focus on.
Make incremental changes rather than trying to overhaul
everything at once.
And fifth, this is crucial, practice self-compassion.
All teachers have moments when they trigger challenging
behavior.
What matters is our willingness to reflect, learn and grow.
I love that bath because this isn't about perfection.
It's about awareness and a continuous growth.
And here's what I know from working with hundreds of new
teachers.
The teachers who are willing to look at themselves honestly
and make changes.
They're the ones who build the strongest classroom
communities.
They're also the ones who have fewer behavior issues over
time because they're addressing root causes rather than
just managing symptoms.
Agree.
So let's wrap this up, Anna.
We've talked about six categories of teacher-created
triggers, communication and language,
relationships and respect, environment and structure,
instruction and academics, power and authority,
and emotional climate.
For each category,
we've given you reflection questions to examine your own
practice,
and we've offered strategies for moving from awareness to
action.
Remember, this work requires humility,
but the payoff is totally worth it.
Stronger relationships, fewer behavior issues,
a more joyful classroom community.
And if you want to go deeper,
we've created a free downloadable guide with all of these
triggers, reflection questions, and strategies.
You can find that in the show notes.
Thank you for listening to New Teacher Talk.
If this episode resonated with you,
share it with a colleague who might benefit.
New episodes released every Monday and Wednesday on Apple
Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen.
Connect with us on Instagram and BlueSky @newteachertalk.