Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Excuse Me, Are You Recording? AI Glasses, Privacy Law, and Compliance
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program.
- 0:07Excuse me, are you recording AI Glasses, Privacy
- 0:10Law, and Compliance? I'm Alla Policastro, Director
- 0:13of Education and Professional Development at
- 0:15Beverly Hills Bar Association. And today I'm
- 0:18delighted to introduce our speaker, Joseph Lazzarotti.
- 0:22Joseph is a certified information privacy professional
- 0:25and principal at Jackson Lewis, where he co -leads
- 0:27the firm's Privacy, AI, and Cybersecurity Practice
- 0:30Group. His practice focuses on the intersection
- 0:33of laws governing data privacy, cybersecurity,
- 0:36and AI. He advises multinational and regional
- 0:40companies across industries on compliance, risk
- 0:43management, data breach response, and emerging
- 0:46technology issues in the workplace. A recipient
- 0:49of the Florida Legal Awards Distinguished Leader
- 0:51recognition for 2026, Joe also counsels employers
- 0:55and plan sponsors on employee benefit matters,
- 0:58including health and welfare plan compliance
- 1:00under Arisa, HIPAA, and the ACA. We're so excited
- 1:04to hear what he has to share with us today on
- 1:05this topic, so I'm going to turn it over to him.
- 1:09Thank you so much. Good afternoon, everyone.
- 1:11Thank you to the Bentley Hills Bar Association
- 1:14for having me. As mentioned, my name is Joe Lazzarote.
- 1:17I'm a principal with Jackson Lewis. I co -lead
- 1:20our National Privacy AI and Cybersecurity Group.
- 1:22And also, as mentioned, I do a fair amount of
- 1:25work in employee benefits, which is anyone who's
- 1:27done both will tell you it's a strange but oddly
- 1:30complimentary combination, especially when it
- 1:33comes to HIPAA and ERISA issues. But we're going
- 1:37to talk about AI glasses and I want to start
- 1:42with the title of this talk because it kind of
- 1:45tells you everything that you want to know about
- 1:48why we're here. Excuse me, are you recording?
- 1:51Which, you know, a few years ago, you might have
- 1:55only asked someone holding up a phone or video
- 1:59camera that question. Today, you might ask it
- 2:02if the person next to you is at a deposition
- 2:05in a courtroom and simply has glasses on because
- 2:08the technology has advanced so far. Indeed, These
- 2:12tools are not novelties anymore. They look like
- 2:15ordinary glasses. And that's the entire design
- 2:18philosophy, right? That they can record video,
- 2:21capture audio, run AI tools, and stream what
- 2:25they see, all while looking like an ordinary
- 2:29pair of glasses. These devices are not something
- 2:36that you can't find. There are 7 million pairs.
- 2:39evidently already out there, and other manufacturers
- 2:41are racing to ship their versions this year and
- 2:47going forward. So the question, is that person
- 2:50recording me, is no longer someone being paranoid?
- 2:54It may be just some due diligence, as we'll see.
- 2:57I think for lawyers specifically, Whether you
- 3:00litigate, whether you advise employer clients,
- 3:03whether you sit on an ethics committee or just
- 3:06want to get through a deposition without an evidentiary
- 3:10mess, this technology sits right at the intersection
- 3:13of privacy law, professional responsibility,
- 3:17a regulatory environment that is rapidly changing,
- 3:20and a number of other laws, and we'll cover many
- 3:23of those today. A little quick housekeeping on
- 3:26the next slide is a disclaimer. in your materials.
- 3:30Again, this is an educational program. It's not
- 3:34legal advice. You need to get legal advice in
- 3:37specific situations. You can read that as well.
- 3:42And with that, we'll get right into it on the
- 3:44next slide. We'll lay out the agenda that we
- 3:46want to cover. The roadmap for today's presentation.
- 3:50First, we'll talk a little bit about the technology
- 3:53itself, what these devices actually do. Then
- 3:57the bulk about time, we'll run through some of
- 3:59the regulatory landscape, including biometric
- 4:02privacy, recording and consent laws, some general
- 4:06data privacy and AI statutes and developments,
- 4:10including workplace surveillance. After that,
- 4:13we'll touch on... some of the legal and ethics
- 4:16and professional responsibilities that come with
- 4:18these devices, as well as some things that the
- 4:21California bar has said. And we'll close with
- 4:24some practical governance framework, whether
- 4:26that's for you and your practice or for what
- 4:29you might want to convey to some of your clients.
- 4:32So on the next slide, let's jump into what can
- 4:36these AI glasses do if you're not already. aware
- 4:40of them, and you see the image on the screen.
- 4:43This is from wire .com. You'll see that there's
- 4:47nothing that screams this is a surveillance device
- 4:50if you just saw one of these sets of glasses
- 4:53in person. And that's not, again, that's not
- 4:56an accident. The entire value of this. tool this
- 5:00product is that value proposition that you can
- 5:02do all these things with a simple set of eyewear
- 5:05not a complex piece of equipment or even something
- 5:09that we are used to seeing more generally that
- 5:12records and performs similar tasks. So what can
- 5:15they actually do? There's five things that are
- 5:19worth considering or inventorying if you're going
- 5:22to use a device like this, this new piece of
- 5:24technology. One is hands -free camera and audio
- 5:27capture, including, in some cases, live streaming.
- 5:30You can perform AI -assisted transcription, translation,
- 5:35and real -time analysis of what the device is
- 5:38capturing. There's Wi -Fi and Bluetooth connectivity,
- 5:42so that means you can store data that you're
- 5:45capturing with the device in places that you
- 5:47may not always control. There's a heads -up display,
- 5:50as you can see there, overlaying AI -powered
- 5:52information in real time. And there may be biometric
- 5:55sensing, including some implementations for facial
- 5:59and voice recognition, although that's seen some
- 6:01controversy in the last few months. We'll talk
- 6:03a little bit about that. So there are some real
- 6:07values to this with hands -free workflows, better
- 6:11training capabilities. A partner, for example,
- 6:14or an associate can literally see what others
- 6:16in the firm are doing on, let's say, a site visit
- 6:19if they wanted to get more information about
- 6:21their case. There might be abilities for enhanced
- 6:24client interactions and some useful ways to document
- 6:28things like inspections or witness walkthroughs
- 6:31and so on. These same capabilities that we're
- 6:35talking about, as we'll see, create some compliance
- 6:37challenges many existing laws never really anticipated.
- 6:42Recording statutes assumed tape recorders sitting
- 6:45visibly on a table. Biometric statutes were written
- 6:49before a camera built into eyewear was a realistic
- 6:52fact pattern. We're applying 20th century tech
- 6:56statutory language to a wearable that didn't
- 6:59exist when the language was written. So it creates
- 7:02a gap that we need to be thinking about as we
- 7:05adopt these types of technologies. On the next
- 7:09slide, what you'll see is a slide after that.
- 7:17Sorry. This slide will get at the list of policies
- 7:24that you will find applicable to meta glasses
- 7:29if you want to really dig into it. And this is
- 7:32the actual list from the website of legal documents
- 7:34that governs these tools. So there's a supplemental
- 7:38meta platform technology terms of service. There's
- 7:42a privacy policy. There's a supplemental. Facebook
- 7:46view policy in terms of service. There's a US
- 7:49regional privacy notice, health and safety information.
- 7:53There are voice controls privacy notice. There's
- 7:55even a risk input privacy notice. That's right.
- 7:58There's a separate notice just for the wristband.
- 8:01There's a meta view. third party notice, an early
- 8:05access program agreement, a creator affiliate
- 8:08program agreement, so in total about 11 documents.
- 8:13Just as an aside, if you are also providing advice
- 8:16to clients about adopting these tools and you
- 8:18bill by the hour, reading all of this for a client
- 8:21may not be a bad project to get. But seriously,
- 8:27the reality is that very few consumers will work
- 8:31through all of these documents before buying
- 8:36these glasses. And so again, that creates a gap
- 8:40between what is technically disclosed in the
- 8:42documents and what a user comes to understand
- 8:45before using them. And that really is a key issue
- 8:48that also is the subject of a litigation we'll
- 8:51get to in a minute. So on the next slide, we'll
- 8:56see that we're going to... jump into some of
- 8:59the regulatory landscape that is facing these
- 9:03technologies and companies that want to use them.
- 9:07AI glasses really sit at the crossroads of biometric
- 9:10privacy laws, two -party consent states like
- 9:14California, basic data privacy and AI statutes
- 9:19and cybersecurity rules, as well as labor and
- 9:21employment law, and we'll take each of those
- 9:23in turn. So first, want to consider biometric
- 9:28compliance issues. There are federal laws that
- 9:31address biometrics generally, along with other
- 9:34types of data that fall into the particular regulatory
- 9:37environment. For example, if you're collecting
- 9:41a biometric in the context of being a healthcare
- 9:44provider, you're probably going to be focused
- 9:46more on HIPAA. It's really the state laws that
- 9:49raise a lot of the issues for entities or individuals
- 9:53that are collecting and using biometric data.
- 9:56In California, you're probably very familiar
- 9:58with the California Consumer Privacy Act. There
- 10:01are similar laws, similar comprehensive privacy
- 10:04laws in about 21 or 22 states, but the CCPA obviously
- 10:10is going to be most important for those listening.
- 10:13And it, too, captures biometric information as
- 10:18a type of personal information. In fact, it's
- 10:20in the category of sensitive personal information
- 10:23under the CCPA. If you're not familiar, there's
- 10:27the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act.
- 10:29And that's really important because it has a
- 10:32pretty robust enforcement scheme that allows
- 10:36agreed individuals to sue and get $1 ,000 in
- 10:41remedy without showing any actual harm if a company
- 10:44that collects their biometric information doesn't
- 10:46comply. And there are other states with similar
- 10:50biometric privacy laws, specifically Colorado,
- 10:54New York, Texas, Washington. They all have their
- 10:57own frameworks now, and the use of these glasses
- 11:00could trigger those frameworks depending on certain
- 11:02circumstances. One thing to note when you look
- 11:05at those other state laws, including with California,
- 11:08is Biometric information isn't always defined
- 11:10the same way. But in general, it will include
- 11:13the collection of a face scan or a voice print.
- 11:18But it could also include someone's gait, how
- 11:20they walk, for example. That is considered biometric
- 11:24information, which is something that biometric
- 11:28glasses with biometric capabilities can capture.
- 11:33Functionally, AI glasses, again, can capture
- 11:36face prints and voice prints, even gay, just
- 11:39by being near people. You may not even intend
- 11:41to do it, but that information potentially can
- 11:44be collected and meet the definitions that I
- 11:47mentioned under these statutes without someone
- 11:49deliberately trying to do it. For attorneys specifically,
- 11:54wearing these around clients or opposing counsel
- 11:56or witnesses may capture these markers from people
- 11:59who never consented to it, never got a notice
- 12:02of it or any idea that it happened. If, for example,
- 12:07you're working on a healthcare matter and you're
- 12:08visiting your client and you're walking through
- 12:10the facility, you might be capturing information
- 12:13about patients or family members or physicians.
- 12:16Again, that could be considered PHI or just simply
- 12:21personal information about those individuals,
- 12:24not just biometrics. And so you want to be thinking
- 12:26about that as you're using these devices in those
- 12:29contexts. And so, you know, when you think about
- 12:33the unintended data collection that can undermine
- 12:36even a carefully built data minimization program
- 12:40for CCPA purposes, that can become a significant
- 12:43issue. To kind of take a step back, if you're
- 12:46subject to the CCPA, it requires that you only
- 12:49use data that you have a need to. In other words,
- 12:51you want to be thinking about only collecting
- 12:54the data that you need, and that presents an
- 12:56issue with these types of glasses because As
- 12:58you use them, you're collecting a lot of information.
- 13:01And you may not really need it for the purpose
- 13:03that you're using it. I mentioned something about
- 13:06facial recognition. And it was recently reported
- 13:09that one manufacturer of AI smart glasses had
- 13:13included an unactivated software called Name
- 13:16Tag, which was an unreleased facial recognition
- 13:19system. And then that manufacturer removed it
- 13:22entirely and has no active plans to launch that
- 13:24feature. Facial recognition, though, the point
- 13:29is that it is not necessary to have facial recognition
- 13:33to also collect biometric information. So while
- 13:36you may have heard in the news that facial recognition
- 13:38is being withdrawn, it doesn't mean that the
- 13:40tool is not also collecting biometric information.
- 13:45I want to also mention one other thing, and that
- 13:46is that we mentioned inventorying earlier. inventorying
- 13:51the different features of these devices. And
- 13:54that's really important, not just for AI glasses,
- 13:57but for any tool that you're using in practicing
- 14:01law. Knowing what those devices do will become
- 14:05really important, particularly as we discuss
- 14:08later on some of the ethical rules. And consider
- 14:10that for any device or technology that you deploy
- 14:13in your business, it's really critical to understand
- 14:15and to inventory what those features are, and
- 14:19when they're being used, and how they're being
- 14:21used. We're discussing here the potential ability
- 14:24to collect biometric information, but as we'll
- 14:27see, there are other capabilities that these
- 14:29devices have that you need to be aware of in
- 14:31order to be able to assess your legal, ethical,
- 14:34and business risks. Next slide, please. So the
- 14:39second area is consent and recording laws. And
- 14:41as you know, California, under its California
- 14:43Invasion of Privacy Act, It makes California
- 14:46a two -party consent state for audio recording.
- 14:50So everyone being recorded has to consent, in
- 14:53essence, unlike federal law and a lot of other
- 14:55states where you only have a one -party recording
- 14:57requirement. Video capture in areas with a reasonable
- 15:01expectation of privacy raises separate state
- 15:04law exposure, and AI note -taking and transcription
- 15:08raises the stakes further. Someone can now generate
- 15:11a full verbatim transcript of a conversation
- 15:14continuously without anybody in the room knowing,
- 15:17just having a pair of glasses on their face.
- 15:19Companies including law firms are grappling nationally
- 15:22with AI note taking and transcription tech as
- 15:25they raise client confidentiality, privilege,
- 15:29data security, and a host of other issues. And
- 15:31that is for the application of a more deliberate
- 15:35application. In other words, The issues that
- 15:38companies are dealing with with transcription
- 15:40is something that people have to enable or at
- 15:43least allow the default to go through. These
- 15:46devices are designed to be passive. You wear
- 15:48it on your face and they will work and capture
- 15:51this kind of information and produce these transcripts.
- 15:54And it may become second nature. So you really
- 15:57want to be careful and be aware of what the tool
- 15:59is doing to avoid unintended consequences. So
- 16:03think practically, who's wearing the device?
- 16:06Is it a client? Is it a witness? Is it one of
- 16:08your associates, the attorney themselves? When
- 16:11are you doing it? Is it at client meetings, in
- 16:13courtrooms, at depositions? One concrete scenario
- 16:17is a manager may be wearing a set of AI glasses
- 16:20while doing a performance discussion with a subordinate
- 16:23who has no idea they're being recorded. They
- 16:25may be biometrically profiled or assessed, or
- 16:28there may be a transcription of that conference
- 16:31that they're having with that person. So it really
- 16:34isn't hard to imagine a situation in which an
- 16:36individual present in a courtroom wearing glasses
- 16:40could create a stir. This includes the Los Angeles
- 16:44County Superior Court, for example, where recording
- 16:47generally is prohibited. Lawyers whose clients
- 16:52have those devices should not be surprised if
- 16:54they sit in a courtroom and the judge discovers
- 16:56it. and orders everyone wearing the glasses to
- 16:59remove them immediately and to delete any data
- 17:01that is captured by the device or held, or they
- 17:04may be held to be in contempt of court. So as
- 17:08noted above, the design of these devices is intended
- 17:12to be integrated naturally into an everyday traditional
- 17:16pair of glasses. And users may forget that they're
- 17:19wearing them. They may not think about it before
- 17:21stepping into a courtroom or a deposition. And
- 17:24that may become a significant issue in the case.
- 17:27So when you're prepping a client or a witness
- 17:30or yourself for a deposition, you want to be
- 17:33having that front of mind. You don't want to
- 17:35assume that people will volunteer that information.
- 17:39And they may not even genuinely think about it.
- 17:42So in your pre -hearing checklist, right next
- 17:45to where you say to silence your phones, you
- 17:48may want to add a question about does anybody
- 17:50have glasses or other recording devices that
- 17:52we need to be aware of. Next slide, please. So
- 17:58another issue with AI glasses is the ability
- 18:02to collect information as we've been talking
- 18:04about. But then there's this, in addition to
- 18:07biometrics, in addition to generally recording
- 18:10video and audio, it's the type of data that you're
- 18:14recording that you want to think about. So you
- 18:15want to kind of think about this set of privacy
- 18:19and cybersecurity laws that we've been grappling
- 18:21with over the last few decades, really. in terms
- 18:26of data breaches and uses of that data and a
- 18:30lot of regulatory frameworks that we've seen
- 18:34develop over the years to address this issue.
- 18:39One thing is I've noticed in just speaking with
- 18:42companies is that particularly for smaller business
- 18:44and some law firms, people in retail, people
- 18:48in customer service business, people who like
- 18:50to advertise and reach out to their consumers
- 18:51on social media, What they find is that using
- 18:54these glasses really facilitates advertising
- 18:58and getting the word out about their business.
- 19:00They could be at an event, and they can have
- 19:03their glasses and record a snippet of a video
- 19:05and very quickly share that experience with a
- 19:10client or an opportunity on Facebook or LinkedIn
- 19:14and showcase their business. And in that process,
- 19:18they might use or have someone's image in that
- 19:21video. but never get their consent. And in many
- 19:24states, including California, there's an obligation
- 19:26to get someone's consent before you use their
- 19:29image or likeness for commercial purpose. And
- 19:32sharing someone's image to help promote the business
- 19:36might very likely be a commercial purpose. So
- 19:38you want to really be careful about, despite
- 19:41having the ease of the technology that allows
- 19:43you to do that, making sure you're getting that
- 19:46consent and using that video only with the consent.
- 19:51In addition, you might be collecting sensitive
- 19:53information and really not be taking appropriate
- 19:57steps to protect it. And you can be capturing
- 20:00that information, whether it's on a screen or
- 20:03a document or really anything in the user's field
- 20:06of view. And we're not just talking about, you
- 20:09know, a social security number, sensitive personal
- 20:12information, information that could be subject
- 20:15to an obligation to have to notify someone of
- 20:19a data breach. is pretty broad. California has
- 20:23a beach certification statute and it goes far
- 20:25beyond just a name and social security number.
- 20:28It includes financial account numbers. It includes
- 20:31biometric information, which we talked about.
- 20:34It includes medical information. It includes
- 20:36account credentials. It includes other state
- 20:40identification numbers. So if you're walking
- 20:41around with glasses and you're pointing at a
- 20:44desk and it's capturing documents or you're at
- 20:47a counter where other customers are paying a
- 20:50bill or talking about information about their
- 20:54health or family members' health, you may be
- 20:56capturing all of that information and storing
- 20:58it somewhere that may be in an account you're
- 21:02responsible for, and that account may get hacked.
- 21:05And then you'll potentially be obligated to notify
- 21:09those individuals, some of whom you may not even
- 21:12know, but you may have had an incident like that
- 21:15that triggers that kind of obligation. Taking
- 21:18that a step further, Depending on the context
- 21:21in which you're creating that information or
- 21:23capturing that information, you know, you may
- 21:25have a different set of requirements. I mentioned
- 21:28earlier walking around a hospital or visiting
- 21:31a healthcare provider client. Again, in that
- 21:34case, if you're representing that... healthcare
- 21:37client, you will likely be a business associate.
- 21:40In that case, you have obligations on the HIPAA
- 21:42to safeguard that information and to notify your
- 21:45client if there's a breach of that information.
- 21:48So again, thinking about how you normally interact
- 21:51with clients, how you walk around, these glasses
- 21:54are intended to basically be second nature and
- 21:58the collection of that kind of information could
- 22:00create some unintended consequences. if you don't
- 22:03have the appropriate safeguards and controls
- 22:05to protect that kind of data under a particular
- 22:08regulatory environment like HIPAA. So you'd definitely
- 22:13want to be aware of that and think about limiting
- 22:16your risk there. And then lastly, on the types
- 22:21of legal points that might be generated by the
- 22:25tool, there are a set of emerging AI laws that
- 22:30And you'll see this in legislative proposals
- 22:33that are creating this bevy of new AI requirements
- 22:37for certain use cases that could affect these
- 22:40types of tools. And that centers around particularly
- 22:44decision -making tools. So suppose your glasses
- 22:46will capture a meeting with a job candidate,
- 22:48and it will permit the... the assessment of impressions
- 22:53about the candidate or even make or substantially
- 22:56make a decision about that candidate. Whether
- 22:57they move to the next interview or whether it
- 23:01ranks them among other candidates. These applications
- 23:05are potentially something that could be used
- 23:07with these types of devices. That type of decision
- 23:11-making might trigger obligations, including
- 23:14under the CCPA. If you look at some of the new
- 23:17rules around automated decision -making technologies,
- 23:20you might have obligations to provide notice.
- 23:22You might have... obligations to allow the applicant
- 23:25or another individual to opt out of the use of
- 23:28that information. Or you might need to think
- 23:30about whether it is creating a bias. Now, that
- 23:33may not be with the glasses specifically, but
- 23:36it may be with the tool that the glasses incorporate
- 23:39that allow those analyses through AI to be performed.
- 23:44So the collection of information generally triggers
- 23:48concerns about the types of general data privacy,
- 23:54security, and AI laws that I mentioned. And again,
- 23:58I want to emphasize the issue about the concept
- 24:02of data minimization. You really want to think
- 24:04about how much data you're collecting, and when
- 24:07you're using it with this technology. And is
- 24:09it really necessary? Do you need to keep it?
- 24:13So you'll want to think about data storage, and
- 24:15you'll want to think about document destruction
- 24:18as well. also who has access to that data when
- 24:22it's stored. So all of these types of things
- 24:24could, again, not at the moment, but maybe down
- 24:27the road, create some liability should something
- 24:30happen to that data. You'll also want to make
- 24:34sure that you think about when you're processing
- 24:38data, including with the types of cybersecurity
- 24:42controls that you have. This will include monitoring
- 24:45how the product or the terms of use may change
- 24:48over time, and that may affect your risk as well.
- 24:52So you may only purchase a device with a certain
- 24:56set of tools or capabilities, and that may change
- 24:59as you continue to use that tool. You may have
- 25:03new features that... are deployed by default.
- 25:07And you want to make sure that you're compliant
- 25:10with that. You may have contractual obligations
- 25:13with your clients about how you're using a particular
- 25:16device. And it may address how you store their
- 25:21information. And so you want to be aware of that,
- 25:24aware of what your device can do, and make sure
- 25:26that's consistent with what obligations you have
- 25:29to collect client data. Next slide. Another issue
- 25:36we want to talk about, which is kind of related,
- 25:38but more in terms of how it works at your workplace
- 25:42and what you're doing with your employees and
- 25:46other personnel at the office. For those also
- 25:50doing employment counseling, you may want to
- 25:53think about this as well with your clients. Pervasive
- 25:57monitoring in a workplace can raise certain state
- 26:01privacy issues. It could run into common law
- 26:05protections when someone has a reasonable expectation
- 26:07of privacy. It could raise issues under the ADA
- 26:11for protection of confidential medical information.
- 26:15GINA for genetic information could raise CCPA
- 26:18issues. There may be other state laws that get
- 26:21triggered depending on what's captured and how
- 26:23it's used. In states like New York, Connecticut,
- 26:26Delaware, New Jersey, and most recently Maine,
- 26:30monitoring employees may come with certain specific
- 26:32requirements that may include notice and acknowledgement
- 26:35by individuals, consent even. Those obligations
- 26:39could be triggered by one or more features of
- 26:42these glasses. In California, in particular,
- 26:46the CCPA recent regulations create an obligation
- 26:50to perform a risk assessment, for example, with
- 26:52respect to certain types of processing that you
- 26:55want to be aware of if you're subject to the
- 26:57CCPA. So, for example, with limited exceptions,
- 27:02processing sensitive personal information, which
- 27:04is a defined term, like geolocation, racial or
- 27:09ethnic origin, religious beliefs, genetic data,
- 27:12biometric information, health information, sexual
- 27:15orientation. Processing that type of information
- 27:18requires a risk assessment. Also, profiling a
- 27:22California resident through systematic observation
- 27:25while acting in their capacity as a job applicant
- 27:29or a student or employee or independent contractor
- 27:31also can trigger a risk assessment requirement.
- 27:34And that includes having to submit a report to
- 27:37the California Privacy Protection Agency on a
- 27:40periodic basis. So you really want to understand,
- 27:43is your device performing these functions, and
- 27:46that may trigger this obligation to perform that
- 27:49kind of an assessment. And for purposes of systematic
- 27:52observation, that means the methodical or regular
- 27:56and continuous observation and includes video
- 28:00or audio recording or live streaming features
- 28:03that are very common to these classes. Another
- 28:06issue I wanted to raise is that the NLRA, the
- 28:10National Labor Relations Act, deserve some attention
- 28:14even if you're not a company that has bargaining
- 28:17employees because that law requires that you
- 28:22make sure not to chill protected concerted activity.
- 28:25Now my non -labor definition of protected concerted
- 28:29activity is a right that employees have to engage
- 28:34with one another about working conditions and
- 28:37one of the concerns about the National Labor
- 28:38Relations Board is that a a sweeping surveillance
- 28:44environment might chill an employee's belief
- 28:46that they could engage freely with other employees
- 28:48without being monitored by the employer and might
- 28:51have some repercussions from talking about workplace
- 28:55conditions that they're not happy with. So a
- 28:57blanket no recording devices anywhere policy
- 29:00might become a problem because it might be suppressing
- 29:04Section 7 rights. And so you need to think about
- 29:07a policy that's narrow to survive that kind of
- 29:10scrutiny but broad enough to actually manage
- 29:12the risk. Unions disputes also can arise from
- 29:17wearable technology if it's not bargained with
- 29:20in appropriate situations. And even without a
- 29:24union, As I mentioned, there's this big brother
- 29:26atmosphere that, you know, pervasive recording
- 29:29can correlate with negative worker engagement.
- 29:32So you don't need a lawsuit to have a problem.
- 29:34You can just have a workforce that no longer
- 29:36trusts. having ordinary conversations. And so
- 29:39those are some of the workplace law issues I
- 29:41wanted to address before moving on to a potential
- 29:44law in California that you might want to be aware
- 29:46of on the next slide. I think this is going to
- 29:49be an important development to watch in California,
- 29:51but also in other states as well. If you haven't
- 29:54seen it, SB 1130 is moving through the legislature
- 29:59right now. And it's likely going to be one of
- 30:01the first laws that are written specifically
- 30:03to deal with this type of technology. The law
- 30:06was introduced by Senator Eloise Gomez Reyes.
- 30:10And it would prohibit recording individuals in
- 30:14certain business settings without explicit consent.
- 30:17It would prohibit disabling the required recording
- 30:21indicator light. If you're not familiar with
- 30:23these technologies, they have a light that shows
- 30:27up that indicates that they are actually recording
- 30:30and so blocking that or inhibiting that alert
- 30:33to other persons is it would be a violation.
- 30:37They also prohibit selling or manufacturing.
- 30:39The law would prohibit that technology designed
- 30:41to circumvent the notice requirement. So this
- 30:45is not the statute of this bill is not stuck
- 30:47in committee and likely to die. It seems like
- 30:51it may have some legs as of late last month.
- 30:55passed the Senate and moved to the assembly in
- 30:57California. And it does have some penalties associated
- 31:01with violations up to $2 ,500 and up to a year
- 31:06imprisonment for individuals with separate provisions
- 31:09that also reach manufacturers and distributors
- 31:12of certain technologies. So the issue about the
- 31:16indicator light isn't theoretical. There are
- 31:18actually tutorials on how to circumvent that.
- 31:23And so it's something that I think is potentially
- 31:25can become an issue if the statute gets passed.
- 31:30So if you have clients that are in retail, hospitality,
- 31:34health care, or other customer -facing, client
- 31:37-facing businesses, you may want to put this
- 31:39development on their radar. Next slide, please.
- 31:45There's also some litigation around these devices
- 31:49in Baratone. versus Metta that was filed earlier
- 31:54this year in the Northern District of California.
- 31:57Plaintiffs are alleging that the companies marketed
- 32:01the glasses as being designed for privacy and
- 32:05controlled by the users, but maybe... from the
- 32:09plaintiff's perspective failed to disclose how
- 32:12data would be collected and how it was actually
- 32:14processed. The allegations include that the glasses
- 32:17continually collect audio, visual, and contextual
- 32:21data when AI features are used. That data may
- 32:25be transmitted off the device. Portions of the
- 32:29recordings, which may include, in this case,
- 32:33footage from inside people's homes, are reviewed
- 32:36and labeled by contractors overseas as part of
- 32:40training. The plaintiffs also alleged that they
- 32:43were never clearly told about that review and
- 32:47about the features of the product. Although,
- 32:50as we talked about a little bit before, there
- 32:53are certainly a lot of policies and disclaimers
- 32:56that we saw on the meta site. So whether these
- 33:00allegations are true, what they do highlight
- 33:03is a critical aspect of this and really any technology
- 33:07that is being deployed by an organization, particularly
- 33:10any device that collects sensitive personal information
- 33:13about clients, which for us as lawyers, we owe
- 33:17an ethical duty of confidentiality. So it really
- 33:20is important to remember the long list of terms
- 33:23of use and policies we referenced. It's critical
- 33:26to review those. and those policies and understand
- 33:30how the technology works, not just when it's
- 33:32purchased, but as functionalities of those tools
- 33:36change and expand. So you really have to keep
- 33:39up with updates to be sure you understand what
- 33:42the default configurations are, how you might
- 33:45be using a particular feature that you weren't
- 33:48aware of or thought was available at the time
- 33:51of purchase. One thing to remember is that in
- 33:55a separate but related context, the most popular
- 34:01password that is currently in use is 123456.
- 34:06And that's not because people select that password,
- 34:08it's because that's the default in many cases.
- 34:11And the same is true with a lot of technologies
- 34:13that are rolled out. The default option may be
- 34:17to record or to apply an AI tool to analyze data.
- 34:22And you may not always want to use that. You
- 34:24may not always be permitted to use that in certain
- 34:26circumstances. So you want to understand what
- 34:28the default requirements or configurations are
- 34:31so you can make the right decision about whether
- 34:34you want to use that functionality or not. Also,
- 34:38if you do. consumer protection or class action
- 34:41defense. This particular case is testing how
- 34:44far designed for privacy marketing can stretch
- 34:47before becoming actionable false advertising.
- 34:52If you do employment counseling, the same expectation
- 34:58mismatch problem applies to your corporate client's
- 35:01own policies with or without AI glasses. And
- 35:05really for anyone, if you're a potential bystander
- 35:09in someone's recording, maybe you're in a courthouse
- 35:11or somewhere else, you may have to think about
- 35:15these issues. So really in short, undisclosed
- 35:20recording device worn by someone you don't know
- 35:23or may not be someone that you would expect to
- 35:27misuse that information could become a significant
- 35:30issue. And that's showing up here in this case,
- 35:33and we'll see how that turns out. On the next
- 35:36slide, there was some. guidance that was issued
- 35:40a few years ago that I think is relevant to mention
- 35:44by the EEOC. This guidance deals with wearable
- 35:48technology generally and it mostly deals with
- 35:52imposed wearables or situations where employers
- 35:55are requiring their employees to share data from
- 35:59personal devices. But the underlying principles
- 36:02here I think also apply even for devices that
- 36:07you may use voluntarily. In that guidance, the
- 36:10EEOC warned that employer -imposed wearables
- 36:14could collect medical status information like
- 36:17heart rate, for example, and that could implicate
- 36:21the ADA. A mandated wearable collecting vital
- 36:27signs needs to have an articulable business necessity.
- 36:31You can't just go around requiring employees
- 36:34to provide their heart rate and other certain
- 36:37biometrics. And, you know, it's worth noting
- 36:40that some smart glasses can collect and analyze
- 36:43a user's health data, such as heart rate, blood
- 36:46sugar levels, blood pressure in real time. So
- 36:49suppose you require an associate to wear glasses,
- 36:53AI glasses, while visiting a client's location,
- 36:56perhaps to better understand the facts of your
- 36:58case and so you can get a better sense of it
- 36:59without actually going on site. And those glasses
- 37:02could be collecting health information about
- 37:05your associate and that could raise inadvertently
- 37:07an ADA issue that you really hadn't thought about
- 37:10because you weren't thinking about what those
- 37:12glasses, what that device actually does. And
- 37:16the same logic really applies in a Title VII
- 37:19case where a wearable might inaccurately differentiate
- 37:24between certain protected characteristics. In
- 37:28the EOC's case, the example that they give is
- 37:32reduced accuracy in facial scans for darker skin
- 37:35tones. And adverse action may follow from that.
- 37:38potentially causing a Title VII problem. Employees
- 37:41may need accommodations for religious pregnancy
- 37:44or disability related issues when dealing with
- 37:48certain wearables. Again, something to think
- 37:51about when you're using those types of devices.
- 37:55So as a practical matter, you really want to
- 37:58run any type of AI glass capability or wearable.
- 38:02technology through the same individualized documented
- 38:06analysis as any other workplace technology requirement,
- 38:10thinking about business necessity, thinking about
- 38:13disparate impact, thinking about accommodations
- 38:15that may be helpful before you actually roll
- 38:18that technology out. Next slide. So I want to
- 38:26pivot a little bit to the issue of legal ethics
- 38:30and professional responsibility that we have
- 38:34as attorneys in connection with the use of these
- 38:38types of devices, what AI is involved. How are
- 38:44the glasses configured? What does that mean for
- 38:47our professional responsibility as lawyers? I
- 38:50had the opportunity yesterday to, as a member
- 38:54of the Cybersecurity and Privacy Committee for
- 38:56the Florida Bar, to present to attorneys there
- 38:59at the annual Florida Bar Conference about incident
- 39:02response plans and data security generally. And
- 39:07we emphasize that the duties we all share and
- 39:10struggle to apply become even more pronounced
- 39:14as various technologies advance. Rules like confidentiality,
- 39:20client confidentiality, and attorney competence,
- 39:24and supervising associates and others present
- 39:28challenges in the practice of law, particularly
- 39:31as circumstances and technologies change. And
- 39:34this is really no different for attorneys who
- 39:37want to integrate AI glasses into their practice
- 39:40or attorneys who have to consider the use of
- 39:44those devices, not by themselves, but by clients,
- 39:47by adversaries, and others. And so maybe in terms
- 39:52of a place to start, thinking about this generally
- 39:54on the next slide, even when you have strong
- 39:58organizational AI governance or similar policies
- 40:02and procedures, lawyers carry an independent
- 40:05layer of ethical obligations. So this goes beyond
- 40:08just the policies that your organization may
- 40:10have. You as a lawyer have to think about this
- 40:13individually. A firm's AI policy is not a substitute
- 40:18for an individual's professional responsibility.
- 40:21And those two run kind of on parallel tracks.
- 40:26So types of common risks that we see are confidentiality
- 40:30and privilege exposure with regard to prompts
- 40:33or uploads that may happen. again, not just in
- 40:37an AI LLM that you're using, but also now on
- 40:40these types of devices, which again may occur
- 40:44without you even thinking. You may kind of forget
- 40:47that you have these glasses on and that the tool
- 40:50is working as intended. Remember that anything
- 40:54that is captured or processed through an AI on
- 40:58a backend carries the same risk as pasting a
- 41:02confidential document into a chatbot, into an
- 41:07environment that you may not have vetted, may
- 41:09have accessibility from other sources that are
- 41:13not permitted. You may also have to think about
- 41:16how do we supervise the tools that are used by
- 41:20our associates, our non -lawyer staff. And in
- 41:24the process, what effects are there on how we
- 41:28bill? What effects are there on the scrutiny
- 41:31of the efficiency that we get from using these
- 41:34products? And how does that translate into what
- 41:37we disclose to clients, how we're charging them
- 41:39for our services? And then, of course, what happens
- 41:42when we go to court? How does that affect our
- 41:45duty to have candor to tribunals, including Again,
- 41:49we see the issue of fabricated hallucinations
- 41:53and so on with AI -generated materials. So these
- 41:58are all issues that we'll cover in the next couple
- 42:00of slides, but this just kind of gives you an
- 42:03outline of the requirements that we have to think
- 42:06about, not just the statutes that we talked about
- 42:10and that we're probably familiar with and our
- 42:12clients are asking about, but our own ethical
- 42:14obligations to use them. So on the next slide,
- 42:18just to start, talk about ABA formal opinion
- 42:23512 that was issued a few years ago. And it talks
- 42:27about generative AI risk and applies them to
- 42:31the model rules. And given the capabilities of
- 42:35AI glasses, these issues need to be explored
- 42:39by attorneys that use these tools. When we think
- 42:43about some of the common rules that apply to
- 42:46us as attorneys, I've listed a few of them here
- 42:49that I think are relevant for us as we apply
- 42:52these technologies to our practice. And the first
- 42:55is competence. So really understanding, as I
- 43:00mentioned before, how these glasses work is critical
- 43:03to making sure that we're acting as competent
- 43:07attorneys in our practice. As I mentioned earlier,
- 43:14going through that inventory, understanding the
- 43:16capabilities is going to be really critical to
- 43:22satisfying this duty. And again, it's not just
- 43:25with AI glasses. but it's with any technology.
- 43:29And the point, I think, under this rule is not
- 43:32that you have to become an expert or you have
- 43:34to become an IT expert or an AI expert in order
- 43:38to satisfy this duty. It's really just understanding
- 43:42the practical uses of the tool, how it works,
- 43:45what data is collected, where the data is stored,
- 43:48who has access to it. Claiming not to be an IT
- 43:51person is not going to satisfy this rule. You'll
- 43:57have to dig into a little bit of understanding
- 43:59the things that I mentioned, but it's okay also
- 44:02to get some help. Maybe it's through the company,
- 44:05maybe it's through reading the policies, maybe
- 44:07it's through your managed service provider to
- 44:10say, hey, how are these tools working? Where
- 44:12are the pitfalls? What if I did this? What if
- 44:15I did that? What's happening to the data? What
- 44:19is it actually collecting? Answering these questions,
- 44:22asking these questions more importantly. will
- 44:25help you to improve your level of competence
- 44:28and then to make decisions based upon that information
- 44:30that are in line with your overall set of ethical
- 44:33rules as well as the obligations, the statutory
- 44:37requirements, and in some cases your agreements
- 44:39with your clients in order to meet this duty.
- 44:43There's also a duty of confidentiality. Obviously,
- 44:46that's implicated whenever client information
- 44:48is collected. This includes video, audio, AI
- 44:51prompt. Of course, this raises the attorney -client
- 44:55privilege. Over the past couple of months, we've
- 44:57seen courts take positions. regarding the use
- 45:00of LLMs and the impact on the privilege that's
- 45:03beyond the scope of our discussion here today.
- 45:05But considering how easily these devices can
- 45:08passively capture information and how communications
- 45:11could be accessed by persons or entities that
- 45:14should not have it, it really does raise the
- 45:16issue of making sure that we are vigilant around
- 45:20securing the privilege for clients. Candid toward
- 45:24the tribunal, a significant risk here may be
- 45:27kind of what we've been talking about in terms
- 45:29of just wearing these glasses and becoming used
- 45:32to them and then showing up in court. And the
- 45:36tool is recording and you may not be aware of
- 45:38it. And as a result, you may not disclose that
- 45:41to the court, even if they ask, you may not just
- 45:43be aware of it. So we have to be concerned about
- 45:46that as well. And then I think... Perhaps one
- 45:49of the bigger issues here is supervising other
- 45:53attorneys and staff at the firm because you may
- 45:58have perhaps younger attorneys and staff who
- 46:00may be more inclined to adopt this technology
- 46:02and sensitive to its risks. Partners should not
- 46:06just be thinking about their own use. They may
- 46:08need to think about who else in the firm is using
- 46:11these devices and what steps they should be taking
- 46:14when they're using them in the practice when
- 46:17doing work for clients. On the next slide, we'll
- 46:20talk a little bit about what the California bar
- 46:27Standing Committee on Professional Responsibility
- 46:30and Conduct has spoken about recently regarding
- 46:33AI. I think there's some issues there that will
- 46:38have an impact on AI classes. The guidance that
- 46:42was issued in 2003 is not a new rule. It really
- 46:45just interprets and applies some existing, including
- 46:48some of the existing rules we just talked about
- 46:51for professional responsibility in the context
- 46:55of AI. But again, I think that this is going
- 46:58to be relevant for AI glasses, particularly which
- 47:03is using this technology, again, perhaps passively,
- 47:06and we're not aware of it. So in addition to
- 47:09the items that we discussed above around competence
- 47:11and confidentiality, the guidance that's represented
- 47:15here advises attorneys to consider whether clients
- 47:19should be informed that AI will be used in the
- 47:22representation, particularly where AI could materialize
- 47:26materially affect the representation or create
- 47:29risks that the client may need to have an opinion
- 47:31about. So if you're planning to use these devices
- 47:36in some way as part of your work, you want to
- 47:38consider whether client notice needs to be provided.
- 47:41And that notice might need to address how you'll
- 47:44use that tool, as well as the benefits and risks
- 47:47so that the client could make a decision about
- 47:49whether they think that makes sense or not. It's
- 47:53important to know that this guidance was recently
- 47:54updated in 2006 to expand its coverage to address
- 47:58emerging agentic AI and really the concern there
- 48:02being AI tools that could be more autonomous
- 48:05and how they perform workflows and tasks. The
- 48:08standing committee emphasized that even when
- 48:12AI acts with a high degree of autonomy, lawyers
- 48:16obviously still retain responsibility for competence
- 48:19and confidentiality and supervision and all the
- 48:22rest of the ethical rules that we talked about.
- 48:25So the more autonomous you find that a tool is
- 48:29operating, the more important that oversight
- 48:32and preparation and inventorying becomes, including
- 48:37with respect to AI glasses, which may not now,
- 48:40but certainly in the future, have greater autonomy.
- 48:44when they are integrated with AI tools and technologies.
- 48:50Next slide. So pulling together a lot of what
- 48:59we talked about, should a client call tomorrow
- 49:02and start asking about AI glasses in their operations,
- 49:08in their workplace, or maybe they're thinking
- 49:12about how you may be using them on a particular
- 49:14matter that you're working on for them. It can
- 49:17be helpful to have a bit of a defensible framework,
- 49:22not just for your firm, but maybe your client
- 49:24needs help with making sure it has taken appropriate
- 49:28steps to integrate this technology into their
- 49:31operations. So we wanted to kind of close out
- 49:35the program by kind of going through some compliance
- 49:39and best practices. steps that you can take to
- 49:44help minimize the risk while also maximizing
- 49:46the benefits of these types of technologies that
- 49:50are becoming available. So, you know, a practical
- 49:55kind of punch list of things to think about.
- 49:57First, as I mentioned, you know, inventorying
- 50:00and assessing the risks of specific features
- 50:03and then deciding, you know, should we permit
- 50:06them? Should we deploy them in the environment?
- 50:10is really a critical step. I would also think
- 50:14about, I know we talk a little bit about policies.
- 50:17One of those policies should be thinking about
- 50:20who in the organization is gonna be the ones
- 50:23managing this. And what obligations do they have
- 50:28to address changes that may come? So you can
- 50:32imagine a company adopts, These devices hands
- 50:36out glasses to employees for certain use cases.
- 50:40And maybe it's the IT team that is managing them
- 50:44and has the direct relationship with the provider.
- 50:48And six months later, after you've gone through
- 50:50a pretty detailed analysis and assessment of
- 50:53risk and made the decision to deploy, six months
- 50:57later, there's a new feature that is made available.
- 51:00And the question is, does the IT team come to
- 51:04you with that and say, hey, this is a new feature.
- 51:06Should we deploy that? They might just make that
- 51:09decision on their own. The point is you might
- 51:11want to have a policy that says, hey, we need
- 51:13to consider that policy. We need to have the
- 51:15appropriate people analyze that and make sure
- 51:18we really want to deploy that. So understanding
- 51:21at all times, again, what the tool can do and
- 51:24what you want it to do is really going to be
- 51:26an important point. And then, yeah, having policies
- 51:30and procedures addressing how these tools are
- 51:34used can really be a critical issue. And also,
- 51:38once you make the policies where you want them
- 51:41to be, you want to also make sure that employees
- 51:45are aware of them, they understand how to use
- 51:47them. what tools they may need to deploy them
- 51:52properly. So for example, if you do happen to
- 51:55have a use case that might require a consent
- 51:58of someone whose image gets captured, you might
- 52:01want to have a sample consent that employees
- 52:03can use. You also may want to have the policies
- 52:06make clear what you don't want. to be used. You
- 52:09may want to make clear what locations should
- 52:11not be in view or captured by the device. You
- 52:16may want to lay out specific permitted uses and
- 52:19impermitted uses of the technology. That may
- 52:22include making sure that any data that's uploaded
- 52:25is only uploaded to firm -owned systems and not
- 52:29a personal data storage account or someone's
- 52:32personal Dropbox account or what have you. you
- 52:35know, make that clear in the policy. So there's
- 52:38a lot of different policy considerations and
- 52:40that's going to depend also on what are the use
- 52:43cases for those policies and what clients may
- 52:46want or not want you to do. So again, it's something
- 52:49to really think about and dig into as you decide
- 52:52whether to deploy this particular technology.
- 52:56As I mentioned, training is going to be critical,
- 53:00not just about, you know, when and under what
- 53:03circumstances, but also how to use the device,
- 53:07when to require notice, having employees understand
- 53:12what the capabilities are, what the privacy boundaries
- 53:15are, what some of the limitations are, and just
- 53:19general awareness. I think having a way of reminding
- 53:24employees about this is going to be critical,
- 53:27as well as understanding even if your firm decides
- 53:30you don't want to use glasses, I think even some
- 53:32type of training and awareness so that your lawyers
- 53:36and staff understand when other people are wearing
- 53:39them so that they can be sensitive to the issue
- 53:41as well because Someone else capturing that,
- 53:46maybe your adversary. If you're not aware of
- 53:48the technology, you may miss something that could
- 53:50be an advantage in your case if an adversary
- 53:54is using this technology improperly. So that
- 53:57can be something that can also help the practice
- 53:59as well, just by creating that awareness. Thinking
- 54:03about the kind of the technical controls that
- 54:07exist in these devices. you again want to think
- 54:11about what all the default settings and Making
- 54:14sure that if you don't want something to be operating
- 54:17that it's disabled and that you test That it's
- 54:21disabled properly. I'll just tell you a quick
- 54:23quick story that we had a client that Had decided
- 54:28that they did not want to permit users of company
- 54:32-owned laptops and tablets to be able to sign
- 54:35on using a biometric and they In addition to
- 54:40having a policy, they also disabled that feature
- 54:43on all of the devices. What happened was when
- 54:46they rolled out a new operating system, the operating
- 54:49system restored all the devices to default settings
- 54:53and default settings permitted those biometric
- 54:57sign -on features to be reactivated. And no one...
- 55:02thought about that. The IT team wasn't thinking
- 55:04about that feature. And so what ended up happening
- 55:07was all of a sudden, employees again became able
- 55:11to enroll in that feature and begin to log into
- 55:16the device using a face scan, which created a
- 55:18significant risk in states like Illinois and
- 55:22California and Colorado. And that had to be addressed
- 55:26once it got brought to the attention of the company.
- 55:28But the point is that Continually managing those
- 55:32technical controls is really going to be pretty
- 55:35important to ensure that you're compliant. In
- 55:39addition, you may have the technical controls,
- 55:43the technical features managed by a third party.
- 55:46You may have an outside IT firm who really helps
- 55:48you with this. Again, going back to the... ethical
- 55:53rule of competence. It's not enough to just turn
- 55:56that over to a third party. You really want to
- 55:58understand what that third party is doing, what
- 56:01their capabilities are, have a dialogue with
- 56:05them about the tool, about what it does, about
- 56:07what you want it to do, and some verification
- 56:10that it's actually doing that and that they're
- 56:12performing the services that you're expecting
- 56:14them to perform within the guidelines that you
- 56:16communicate. It's not going to be a good idea
- 56:21to just pass that along. You do want to be engaged
- 56:24with the third party. You also want to assess
- 56:27their capabilities in terms of data storage in
- 56:30the event that the vendor is storing data from.
- 56:34these AI glasses, you want to make sure that
- 56:37the vendor has appropriate safeguards in place.
- 56:40And you may find that in some cases, depending
- 56:42on the type of data you're collecting, you may
- 56:44need to have certain contractual clauses in your
- 56:47agreement to satisfy things like HIPAA. If you're
- 56:50a business associate or if you're subject to
- 56:52the CCPA, the vendor may be a service provider
- 56:55and there may be some required contract provisions
- 56:59you have to have. I'll also mention that If you
- 57:05haven't already done so and just thinking about
- 57:07the conference I was at yesterday, updating your
- 57:10incident response plans to think about this technology
- 57:13that could have data that's caught up in a data
- 57:18incident and how to... protect the technology,
- 57:21and also how to understand what data may have
- 57:24been captured if there was some type of compromise
- 57:26to your systems because that could create obligations
- 57:30to notify. It could become something you have
- 57:32to make sure gets investigated as part of an
- 57:35investigation of a breach. And so that's something
- 57:38that you want to think about as well as you're
- 57:40going through and putting in place some best
- 57:42practices. And so really to kind of close it
- 57:47out, you know, this idea of, excuse me, are you
- 57:51recording? Again, it used to kind of sound paranoid
- 57:54and something that you weren't always thinking
- 57:57about, but today it's really just a matter of
- 58:00simple due diligence, understanding what's going
- 58:02on around you, understanding what kind of information
- 58:05you're collecting, whether you're prepping for
- 58:08a deposition, walking into a courtroom, client
- 58:12meeting, or just going down the hall. What these
- 58:14glasses can do, create a whole range of issues.
- 58:19Something you see might just be glasses, but
- 58:21they might be a very complex device that you're
- 58:24wearing. And it is something that you want to
- 58:27really think about carefully to avoid legal risk
- 58:30and making sure you're meeting your ethical obligations.
- 58:34So with that, I'm happy to look and see if there's
- 58:38any questions. I don't know if there have been
- 58:40any submitted, so I'm checking here. I don't
- 58:44see any. I don't know if there are any in the
- 58:46chat. Doesn't look like there are any. So here's
- 58:56one. The question here is, on the opposite end
- 59:01of professional practice, how does one protect
- 59:03oneself from non -consenting recording in public
- 59:07when you have a certain presumption of privacy
- 59:10from biometric recordings, et cetera? I think
- 59:16at some point, There may be some inadvertent
- 59:19collection. I think you want to try to be careful
- 59:22of that. I mean, I think that's part of having
- 59:24that indicator light in SB 1130. Arguably, you
- 59:31may have an argument that the indicator light
- 59:33would have provided notice, and the person who
- 59:35spoke after having seen that light may have given
- 59:40implied consent. That may be one argument. If
- 59:45you come into a room, I mean, I don't know that
- 59:46many people are going to announce to a room full
- 59:48of people that they have AI glasses. But I do
- 59:52think that's one possibility that having that
- 59:55light be conspicuous and not blocking it may
- 59:58be one way to protect yourself from that. Another
- 1:00:01way is to be thinking about, you know, do you
- 1:00:06want to be recording in a particular environment
- 1:00:08and disable that feature when you get into that
- 1:00:11environment? So I hope that answers the question
- 1:00:14on that one. If there's any other questions,
- 1:00:17I'd be happy to answer them. Okay. Well, thank
- 1:00:23you very much. I appreciate you listening to
- 1:00:25the presentation. I hope it's been helpful. Laurie,
- 1:00:28this concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 1:00:30so much, Joe, for your time and for educating
- 1:00:32our members today. And thank you so much to our
- 1:00:35audience. Have a great day, everyone.