Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 19)
Transcript
- 0:04Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:07Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:10where we left off with Alex Acosta and his interview
- 0:14with the OIG Inspectors. Question, Okay, what is your view
- 0:19of whether the Criminal Division's review encompassed the NPA itself. Answer? So,
- 0:24the Criminal Division, by its terms, did not encompass the NPA.
- 0:29I would say that's different than the Deputy's review that
- 0:32encompassed the totality of the circumstances. Question Okay, did you
- 0:37discuss did you have conversations with DAG with Mark Phillip
- 0:41about the case? Answer not to my recollection. Question okay,
- 0:45and we've already talked about submission that Redacted made on
- 0:48behalf of your office. Answer which yes, which I thought
- 0:53was a fulsome submission and included the draft indictment the NPA.
- 0:57I believe it included the term sheet and the other
- 0:59docors documents. Question did you or anyone else, to your
- 1:03knowledge asked DAG to review or assess the NPA or
- 1:07approve it. Answer not to before signature, Not to my recollection,
- 1:12but it was part of the ultimate review when Redacted
- 1:14submitted the matter to the deputy He included the agreement question.
- 1:18It was included their very first brief letter. You remember
- 1:22the letter that authored that he authored addressed really only
- 1:26the issues of the appropriateness of the case for prosecution
- 1:30in your office. It did not in any way reference
- 1:33the disposition, the plea agreement, or the NPA answer. So
- 1:37it was the brief letter based on redacted submission. I
- 1:40would have read that letter as they had all the
- 1:43material in front of them, and they were saying that
- 1:45there was no misconduct or abuse of discretion question. That's correct,
- 1:49But they did not say that they contacted, that they
- 1:53had addressed or assessed, reviewed even they didn't say that
- 1:56they reviewed or approved the NPA answer. Again, and you know,
- 2:00if the letter is here, I don't know gets cut
- 2:03off question. Yeah, I have it right here. It's not
- 2:06marked as an exhibit. But this is redacted's letter to
- 2:09Jay Lefkowitz and Ken Starr, dated June twenty third, two
- 2:12thousand and eight. It states that this office, meaning the
- 2:15Office of the Deputy Attorney General, has completed a thorough
- 2:19review of the US Attorney's handling of the matter involving
- 2:22your client and addresses or states that they've received and
- 2:27reviewed submission from both parties, and then states that the
- 2:30Deputy Attorney General will intervene only in the most unusual
- 2:34of circumstances in a US attorney matter, and we do
- 2:38not believe such intervention is warranted here. Even if we
- 2:42were to substitute our judgment for that of the US Attorney,
- 2:46we believe the federal prosecution of the case is appropriate. Moreover,
- 2:50having reviewed your allegation of prosecutorial misconduct and the facts
- 2:54underlying them, we see nothing in the conduct of the
- 2:57US Attorney's office that gives us any reason to alter
- 3:01our opinion answer. And so, if I could point out,
- 3:04this office has completed a thorough review of the US
- 3:07Attorney's handling of the matter, and so handling is a
- 3:10broad a broad term, and in reference to we believe
- 3:14that federal prosecution of the case is appropriate. The way
- 3:18I recalled reading that is, the federal prosecution of this case.
- 3:22The argument that was the agreement was inappropriate because this
- 3:26case should not have been prosecuted, and therefore that's the disposition.
- 3:31The federal prosecution of the case was appropriate, and so
- 3:35the handling of the matter. We reviewed, the handling of
- 3:37the matter, not the agreement, but the handling of the matter,
- 3:40and that the ultimate disposition you know, is at least
- 3:43not an abusive discretion or is appropriate? Question That's how
- 3:48you read it? Answer, That's how I read it. Question.
- 3:51And did you ever discuss that Did you ever discuss
- 3:53with anyone in ODAG what the scope of their review was? Answer?
- 3:59Not to my recollection. It was a fulsome submission question. Correct,
- 4:03But the issue presented by the defense were essentially federalism issues, right. Answer.
- 4:08So again this is based on you know, as much
- 4:12recollection as contemporaneous record. The issue presented by the defense were,
- 4:17in essence, it was the heart of the non prosecution agreement,
- 4:20which was it an abusive discretion to proceed in this
- 4:24case in the way that we did on the grounds
- 4:27that there may not or there should not have been
- 4:29a federal prosecution in the first place, or that we
- 4:33are using federal criminal law to elicit a civil outcome.
- 4:37And so I don't think it's fair to sort of
- 4:39narrow You can't say that our handling was you know
- 4:42that their handling was revised without reviewing the non prosecution agreement. Question,
- 4:47do you have any reason to believe that either ODAG
- 4:50or a criminal division. Well that the ODAG, let's stick
- 4:54with that, did in fact review the NPA, other than
- 4:57that it was where it existed, whatever it's dat as
- 5:00might have been. Answer. So it was clearly submitted, it
- 5:03was clearly referenced, and it was clearly part of the complaint.
- 5:07The complaint. The heart of the complaint about our office
- 5:10was that we were using this agreement to impose civil liability.
- 5:14And so I think it's fair to infer if the
- 5:16complaint implicates the agreement, that the agreement would have been reviewed. Question,
- 5:21but that's your inference. You don't have any specific communication
- 5:26with ODAG to that effect. Answer. I don't recall any
- 5:30specific communication. Question. All right, I would like to take
- 5:34a short break. We're getting there. Answer. I hear you, redacted.
- 5:39We appreciate your time that you've put into this. You've
- 5:42been here for quite a long time. Acosta, Yeah, redacted.
- 5:46The area that I want to discuss after the break
- 5:48has to do with the ultimate notification of the victims
- 5:51about the resolution of the case, the state plea and
- 5:54the result of the federal investigation. And there is going
- 5:58to be we have documents that are that are already marked.
- 6:01That might be helpful if you take a look at
- 6:03a couple of them so we don't have to go
- 6:05through maybe during the break, so you don't have to
- 6:07go through them one by one, or I can just
- 6:09give you a very quick overview of sort of where
- 6:12we're going. I want to find out basically how we're
- 6:15getting from there. That would be the state asking for
- 6:18the US Attorney's Office to make the notification to the
- 6:21victims about the upcoming state plea that happens in November
- 6:25of two thousand and seven. That would be document thirty
- 6:28two B to the defense. Then finding out that the
- 6:31government want to notify the victims by letter, and then
- 6:34demanding that they see the letter and have some kind
- 6:36of comment on it. That would be document thirty three,
- 6:39an email from lef Quwitz. Then we have an exchange
- 6:42of letters. But the one I'd like to look at
- 6:45is at document thirty seven, which is a letter coming
- 6:47from redacted to the defense. And now, but you know,
- 6:50during the break, so I want to find out how
- 6:53we got from that Document thirty six where redacted is
- 6:57writing as letters saying that citing the CVRA regulation saying
- 7:02that the government is obligated to notify the victims about
- 7:05the resolution of the case, and attaching a draft letter
- 7:08to the victims telling them the time and date of
- 7:11the state resolution and plea, inviting them to come to
- 7:15ultimately a letter from you coming on nineteenth of December
- 7:19two thousand and seven, which is number forty one B
- 7:22agreeing to notify the victims of the state plea and
- 7:25agreeing with the defense to have the state be responsible
- 7:29for putting out that notification. And then we end ultimately
- 7:33with a letter or draft letter that we have that
- 7:35goes out to the victims in the case hon or
- 7:38after the plea in July. Well, we have the draft
- 7:41I'm going to show you which comes in June, showing
- 7:44that the letter was clearly meant to be sent after
- 7:47the plea as per the agreement. And that's document number
- 7:50fifty one. So that's a lot to unpack there. Answer.
- 7:55That's a lot to unpack. We should probably take it
- 7:57a step at a time. Answer. Yes, I just wanted
- 8:00to give you an overview because I think that's some
- 8:03of what you had mentioned earlier. I know it's been
- 8:06a long time, so I'll try to orient you from
- 8:09the timeline. So if you I have highlighted the section
- 8:13of those letters that we want to talk about, and
- 8:16if you have a chance while we're taking a break
- 8:18to look through them, that may be helpful to orient
- 8:21you so that we're not spinning our wills on this.
- 8:24I don't want to waste any of your time. Answer
- 8:26a fair question, all right, off the record. Back on
- 8:29the record now, questions begin again. Question Okay, great, So,
- 8:33I know I gave you a lot to unpack over
- 8:35the short break. We just had one. Basically, what we're
- 8:38trying to get to find out is how your decision
- 8:42making process regarding the victim notification issue. So maybe if
- 8:46you could just give anything with your December nineteenth decision,
- 8:51could you give us an explanation about how you got there? Answer? So,
- 8:55I think we should probably take this in stages. Question okay. Answer.
- 8:59As a general matter, I recall that there was back
- 9:02and forth regarding after the agreement regarding how to notify
- 9:05the victims, and there was back and forth between redacted
- 9:08and Jay Lefkowitz and redacted around all that. Sorry I'm
- 9:12losing my voice. I recall that there was an issue
- 9:15in particular that was raised that I tried to address
- 9:18in the letter and I recall at the end of
- 9:20the day, it was my impression that once there was
- 9:22an agreement for him to plead, that there was an
- 9:25attempt I redacted to provide notice to the victims. But
- 9:28it was a very It was I think on a Friday,
- 9:31and he was pleading on a Monday morning or something
- 9:34along those lines. And finally, I recall that the view
- 9:37of the office was that the CVRA did not apply,
- 9:41and so that this was a discretionary balancing that included
- 9:45consideration of what impact notification of the twenty two dot
- 9:49fifty five s would have at a trial the twenty
- 9:52two to fifty five provision if we had to go
- 9:54to trial. So we can unpack that. But those are
- 9:57my general recollections. Question, okay, answer, and look, let me
- 10:02add I think it's important. So I came in and
- 10:05out of the case at stages, and I was involved
- 10:08in certain aspects more than others. And while we had
- 10:10a long discussion about the term sheet and matters like that,
- 10:14while I was clearly involved in at least one dispute
- 10:17around the twenty two to fifty five, the nuts and
- 10:20bolts of how victims were notified is not something that
- 10:23I have a recollection about Okay, fair answer, but we
- 10:26can unpack it. Answer or question? I mean, okay, let's
- 10:30start with the exhibit thirty three. So there we have.
- 10:33As you can see, it's an email from left Qwitz
- 10:36to you and to redacted, objecting to a letter being
- 10:39sent to the victims unless the defense gets to review it.
- 10:42And later on in some of your other correspondents, you
- 10:45discussed that you you extended to the defense the courtesy
- 10:49of allowing them to review these letters. Is this the
- 10:53genesis of that courtesy? Answer? I don't have a recollection
- 10:57as to what the genesis might be. I know that
- 10:59there are well us back and forth between our office
- 11:02and the defense about the letter. Question. Okay, but as
- 11:05you can see on thirty three that you're not the
- 11:08response from redacted, but redacted instructs redacted to send the
- 11:12proposed letter to left Quitz, and I assume that redacted
- 11:15would have done that had you objected to it. Answer again,
- 11:18I don't recall any specific conversation. As general matter, this
- 11:23is not something I was getting into the weeds unless
- 11:26I had to. There was a lot of back and forth.
- 11:29Question uh huh. Answer, Redacted is someone that I trusted
- 11:33he was handling this matter. He's incredibly experienced. I know
- 11:36that there were concerns and issues around the impact that
- 11:39notification would have on the witnesses. I know that there
- 11:43were issues around the language, and I trusted that folks
- 11:46were working those out. Question Uh huh. One of the
- 11:50criticisms that's compost. You know the CVRA litigation, that's been
- 11:54the government allowing the defense to have review of these
- 11:57letters or potential victim notification letters coming out of the government,
- 12:02and that's very unusual. Have you had any other cases
- 12:05where you let the defense review such documents. Answer? I've
- 12:09had no other cases where I'm even aware of the
- 12:11victims being notified, because I assume it all operates without
- 12:15it rising to the management level. Question mm hmm. Answer,
- 12:19and so this is the first and only time that
- 12:22how individuals are notified to my recollection was even in
- 12:26the executive suite. Question isn't that usually done or accomplished
- 12:30by almost a computerized task? Answer? I would assume so, yes. Question,
- 12:36given that the unusual way the notifications are made by
- 12:39victim witness specialist, who is usually that person? Answer yes,
- 12:43question do I have that right? So the FBI has
- 12:46their victim witness specialist. Answer yes, question, and your office,
- 12:50the US Attorney's Office has dedicated people who do that
- 12:53job as well. Answer correct question. So why in this
- 12:58case not direct the notification to that person to be
- 13:02done in the usual course? Why elevate to something that
- 13:05the defense is going to be able to review? So
- 13:09I can't address the second half of that, but the
- 13:11first half of the question, why why was it elevated?
- 13:14You know, I think Redacted address some of that in
- 13:17her was it twenty seventeen af A, David and so on?
- 13:21So we had an agreement that had been signed, and
- 13:24we also had substantial questions as to whether that agreement,
- 13:27whether ultimately Jeffrey Epstein would plead in court or not.
- 13:31And so one of the questions is how do you
- 13:33deal with notification of a possibility where the possibility could
- 13:37be used to impeach potential future witnesses who are also
- 13:41the victims. And that's a matter that was being worked
- 13:44out by the ausas in the office question and the
- 13:48impeachment is what answer? So impeachment I would believe Redacted
- 13:53went into some detail, is you stand miss victims stand
- 13:57to gain quite a bit of money if there's a conviction, correct,
- 14:01weren't you aware of this agreement? If we have to
- 14:03go to trial? Weren't you aware of this agreement? And
- 14:06this isn't based on my recollection. This is based on
- 14:08redacted Zaffid David, where she says that she had concerns
- 14:13that the impeachment go along somewhere along the lines of
- 14:16were you aware that if mister Epstein's convicted you stand
- 14:19to receive substantial sums? Yes? Were you influenced by this?
- 14:23And there were some according to Affidavid. This isn't my
- 14:27independent recollection. This is according to Affid David, there had
- 14:30already been dispositions of the victims of at least some
- 14:33of the victims that raise these issues. And so I
- 14:36do think that it was a valid concern by the
- 14:39ausas how the notifications took place. Question Okay, but isn't
- 14:43that the type of line of cross examination the same
- 14:46for any case where they're super wealthy defendant? Answer? It
- 14:52may be the twenty two fifty five may make it
- 14:55a little different because it's automatic, But ultimately these are
- 14:58the judgments that line attorneys make, and a US attorney,
- 15:01I think it's appropriate to back up their judgment unless
- 15:04there was some reason for me to believe it was incorrect. Question,
- 15:08was there any thought ever to just giving the victim
- 15:12notification that there will be a proceeding that will end
- 15:15the federal case, just separating that in maybe a later
- 15:19notification about the twenty two to fifty five answer, I
- 15:23can't speak to what we thought there was or was not.
- 15:27I can say around this timeframe, it was far from
- 15:29clear that there would ever be that Epstein would ever
- 15:32go into court, and we were thinking we may have
- 15:34to just go to trial because these collateral attacks keep going.
- 15:39All right, folks, we're gonna wrap up right here, and
- 15:41in the next episode, we're gonna pick up where we
- 15:43left off. All of the information that goes with this
- 15:46episode can be found in the description box.