Latest / Shades of Jade Podcast / Raphael Cohen-Almagor on Multiculturalism and the Israeli-Palestinian Peace Process
Transcript
- 0:12Hey everyone. My guest today is Rafael Cohen
- 0:14Almagor, who is a distinguished Israeli, British academic,
- 0:18educator and human rights activist, renowned for his
- 0:21extensive contributions to political theory, media ethics,
- 0:24medical ethics and Israel studies.
- 0:26He earned his doctorate in Philosophy in political Theory
- 0:29from the University of Oxford in 1991.
- 0:32And holds BA. And MA degrees both meghna cum
- 0:35laude from Tel Aviv University. Currently, he serves as
- 0:39professor of politics and founding director of the Middle
- 0:41East Studies Center at the University of Hull, UK, and as
- 0:45president of the Association for Israel Studies.
- 0:47Elected in 2023, Kohen Almagor has held prestigious positions
- 0:52including as visiting professor at UCLA, Johns Hopkins
- 0:55University, London University, and Distinguished Visiting
- 0:59Professor at University College London.
- 1:02He is also a fellow at the Israel Institute for Advanced
- 1:05Studies in Jerusalem and a Global Fellow at the Woodrow
- 1:08Wilson International Center for Scholars.
- 1:10With over 19 books and 300 articles published, his notable
- 1:14works include Confronting the Internet's Dark Side from 2015,
- 1:18Just Reasonable Multiculturalism from 2021, and The Republic,
- 1:22Secularism and Security from 2022.
- 1:26His scholarship emphasizes themes of mutual respect, human
- 1:29dignity, and social responsibility, particularly in
- 1:32the context of free expression, multiculturalism, and peace
- 1:35negotiations. Welcome, Raphael.
- 1:39Thank you. Good to see you.
- 1:40Yes, you. Too you are coming from you're
- 1:42speaking from the UK today, correct?
- 1:44Yes. Yes, yeah, I really.
- 1:47Appreciate you taking the time to talk to me.
- 1:49All right, So like I said, your credentials are you have a very
- 1:53interesting life. So it was hard to choose where
- 1:57to even begin. So I'm just going to kind of
- 2:00start with the first topic I found interesting.
- 2:04Are liberalism and multiculturalism reconcilable?
- 2:10Yeah, well, this is something that I've been working on for a
- 2:14very long time. 1992, quite a while ago, I helped to establish
- 2:23a think tank at the Vande Jozalem Institute that aimed to
- 2:28understand the relationship between Israel and Europe, to
- 2:31what extent Israel is influencing Europe and to what
- 2:35extent Europe is influencing Israel.
- 2:38And I decided to focus my attention on the issue of
- 2:41culture or multiculturalism. And at that time I was
- 2:45specifically intrigued by two major issues.
- 2:49One is the issue of female circumcision that was taking
- 2:53place among Bedouin tribes in the South of Israel and among
- 3:00some Arabs. And the second one that troubles
- 3:04me a great deal is women coercion by Jewish law, Allaha
- 3:11Jewish law. To what extent is it justified
- 3:15that secular women who do not believe in God, who are normally
- 3:23Jewish but not religious, to what extent they should adhere
- 3:27to all the Jewish law norms and dictates they'll discriminate
- 3:33against them. Essentially, I don't like
- 3:36discrimination. So I, I thought that's these are
- 3:39good topics. So these were two major issues
- 3:43that I tackled. It was a three-year sort of a
- 3:47project. We were financed by the
- 3:49Volkswagen Foundation from Germany.
- 3:52And as you know, because you know something about me, I do
- 3:57many, many things. So it's about 1995, I decided to
- 4:01do some of the some other things and I left you there.
- 4:05And then at 2011, I was already living in the United Kingdom and
- 4:12my Prime Minister, David Cameron, came out with what I
- 4:17deemed to be a very irresponsible statement in which
- 4:22he said that multiculturalism in the United Kingdom failed and
- 4:28that multiculturalism doesn't benefit the UK.
- 4:33That it increases or promotes polarisation in society, that it
- 4:41brings about political extremism, that he discriminates
- 4:46against women and that it might lead to terrorism.
- 4:52And I said, wow, no, I was utterly flabbergasted by these
- 4:59statements that I didn't to be utterly irresponsible coming
- 5:04from the office of the Prime Minister.
- 5:07So I decided to go back to my research about multiculturalism
- 5:13and to examine to what extent multiculturalism and liberalism
- 5:18are reconcilable, if they are reconcilable.
- 5:22And this was a project that started in 2011 and completed in
- 5:272021 when I published my book Just Reasonable
- 5:31Multiculturalism. So in this book I developed a
- 5:35theory. I'd like to originate theories
- 5:39and to examine case studies in light of theories.
- 5:42So this is a theory about the relationship between liberalism
- 5:47and multiculturalism, and to what extent one can live
- 5:50without. So the the theory is based on
- 5:54several layers of arguments. 1 is the layer of justice, which I
- 6:02believe is the most important value.
- 6:05If you all be just people, I don't think that there will be
- 6:09many problems in the world. We'll be able to sort this out.
- 6:12The second is the issue of reasonable or reasonable
- 6:15reasonableness. To what extent some parties as
- 6:18reasonable. So we need to have some
- 6:21yardsticks to decide this thing. And I also invoked the harm
- 6:30principle. This is something that
- 6:31philosopher by the name John Stuart Mill had said.
- 6:34Essentially, the harm principle said that you can do whatever
- 6:38you want provided you don't harm others.
- 6:42So this is the harm principle and the issue of different
- 6:49cultures living in the certain democratic societies.
- 6:52Now, I'm not interested in multiculturalism outside of the
- 6:56spheres of liberal democracy. The book is about the
- 7:00concealability between liberalism and multiculturalism.
- 7:04So if you're talking about authoritarian regimes, not
- 7:09interested. I mean, all, all the theory that
- 7:12I'm going to invoke is going to be fooled within seconds because
- 7:17of the values that I believe in, I endorse, which are liberty,
- 7:20tolerance and pluralism and respect for art.
- 7:24There's not arming others and so on.
- 7:27These are not applicable in authority and regions.
- 7:31So once I invoked the theory, then I started to examine case
- 7:35studies and I separate between case studies that are physical
- 7:41harm. So if I punch your nose, you're
- 7:45going to bleed and this is noticeable.
- 7:47So some physical harm. And I then went to examine harms
- 7:54that are not physical. I think that physical harm is
- 7:58easier because it's noticeable. It's more problematic when we're
- 8:05talking about non physical harm. So by physical harm, I mean
- 8:10cultural rights that some groups are there too, unfortunately
- 8:17also in the United Kingdom and in the United States and in
- 8:22Canada in liberal societies. So one is murder for family
- 8:27owner. So to preserve the honour and
- 8:33the dignity of the family. In some communities there is a
- 8:40dictate to murder a member of the family who misbehaves and a
- 8:49surprise surprise 100% of these members are females.
- 8:55But this is to show us the dominance of the men over the
- 8:59female. What is allowed to men is not
- 9:01allowed to women. So in some communities and if a
- 9:07girl or a woman is going outside and is working together with a
- 9:16man who is not a husband or family member, she might be
- 9:22killed. I'm not saying kiss or God
- 9:27forbid, having sex, just showing herself in public with a foreign
- 9:34man that might lead to her assassination.
- 9:40And I think this is despicable. I don't have any other words.
- 9:47OK, so I don't think that any liberal democracy, any liberal
- 9:52society should tolerate such parties.
- 9:56That's my belief. So this was one claim and I best
- 10:00is all the the theory that I developed and I think it's quite
- 10:05easy to persuade people who believe in equality between
- 10:11genders. Seven, physical harm is female
- 10:20infanticide. So in some cultures, if your
- 10:25baby is born and her gender is female, she might be killed.
- 10:35Why? Because to have a baby girl,
- 10:41then a girl, then an adult girl, then a woman, for some people
- 10:48it's a hustle. It's a constant worry.
- 10:55She, according to that culture, she doesn't bring much utility
- 10:58to the family, but she brings a lot of pores.
- 11:02She can't help in physical work that is needed in the house, in
- 11:06the farm, in the in the household, in the factory, in
- 11:12the family business. She's not qualified, she's not
- 11:18smart enough. She's a girl nuisance.
- 11:25So in some cultures they'll kill such girls.
- 11:29I think it's horrible. Yeah, yeah.
- 11:34OK, it is horrible physical harm.
- 11:37These are easy cases. And then I'm going to more
- 11:41questionable cases like female circumcision that has several
- 11:49scales of harm from very, very rough torture.
- 11:56I would kill, I would say to symbolic sort of scar on the
- 12:02hotel labia. I don't have much issues with
- 12:05scarring the hotel labia have to say because it's much like bell
- 12:10circumcision, which I also study.
- 12:15And I argue that if you tell it come to symbolic sort of harm in
- 12:21a way they try to reconcile between culture and liberal
- 12:25democracy and respect for others and not harming others and so
- 12:28on. This is something that I am
- 12:31willing to tolerate. Torture I'm unwilling to
- 12:35tolerate. So that's out of question.
- 12:37This is not something that I wouldn't tolerate.
- 12:41There's also the issue of fasting, fasting to starvation.
- 12:46And the argument is that if it's done by the consent of the
- 12:51person. And here we have also men
- 12:53actually that are doing this fast.
- 12:55It's, it's happening in some cultures in India that they
- 12:59believe that when people come to an elderly age and they become
- 13:04some sort of a liability of society in the community, they
- 13:07should retire. In some, you know, it's Eskimo
- 13:12tribes, they go and die in the snow fields.
- 13:19When it comes to people, grown up people with the full capacity
- 13:23of the mine, with no coercion, we decide to take their own
- 13:27lives. I don't find it extremely
- 13:31problematic. It's not something that I
- 13:33endorse. I would endorse the community to
- 13:36hub this person, to embrace this person, to show this person that
- 13:41we appreciate all the journey that he went or she went all her
- 13:44life contributing to community. Now it's the time to give them
- 13:48back. So to compensate them for all
- 13:51the hard work and actually to help them.
- 13:54That would be my attitude. But if the culture is endorsing
- 13:59another aspect of and define dignity in such death that I
- 14:04think I'm willing to tolerate this.
- 14:07This is about physical harm. Now, I said there's also no
- 14:09physical harm. That for me is as important to
- 14:13tackle because it is no less harmful, although it's not
- 14:18physical. One is denied education to women
- 14:24and children. Again, it's never a denied
- 14:27education to men. It's always women who have to
- 14:32succumb to the whims of men. But there's some cultures in
- 14:35which women are not allowed to study or denied education.
- 14:40And I think this is wrong because it prevents women from
- 14:45cell development. They cannot really develop to
- 14:48the extent that autonomy may wish.
- 14:51So I think this is terribly wrong and similarly I think it's
- 14:55wrong to deny children's education.
- 14:59This is happening, for instance, in Haredi communities, Haredi
- 15:04meaning ultra religious Jewish, and it's also happening in the
- 15:08Amish community in North America.
- 15:11In the Amish community, they receive education.
- 15:15Children have civil education, not to have terribly good
- 15:17education, but they say education at the age of 16, and
- 15:21then the expectation from them is to go and work in the farm.
- 15:26I think this is wrong. I think that they should be
- 15:29educated in accordance to the curricula of the States, either
- 15:33United States or Canada, Not according to the Amish
- 15:37curricula, which doesn't support the study of sciences, doesn't
- 15:41support the study of mathematics, doesn't support the
- 15:46study of history, American history, Canadian history, and
- 15:51so on, but supports agricultural life, religious life and so on.
- 15:56And by cripping them with this very, very minimal education,
- 16:02those Amish people, when they grow up, would like to leave the
- 16:05community. They have very limited options.
- 16:09They have the ability to integrate into the life.
- 16:12Society is not great. They can do most of the time
- 16:16manual work, but of course they lack any kind of education.
- 16:20They have to start really all over again just to catch up to
- 16:24the standards of the average American or Canadian.
- 16:28So I think this is wrong as well.
- 16:31So this is a an issue of how do people not by physical way, but
- 16:37by non physical way. And then I'm going to, in the
- 16:41last two chapters of the book, I examine in two case studies. 1
- 16:46is about Israel, the other is about France.
- 16:50In both countries, security is invoked to restrict minorities
- 16:58and to restrict women in both of them.
- 17:01So in the name of security, it is allowed to discriminate
- 17:05against arms, which I'm very much against in the name of
- 17:09security in France. Some things that you and I, I
- 17:14think just looking at you the way you dress, I think that two
- 17:20of us think that it is prerogative to decide how to
- 17:26dress. I mean, we do this every day.
- 17:32Every day we dress up some, some of us may want to keep ourselves
- 17:38with our pyjamas if we don't go out, but still it is our
- 17:42decision. And some of us, when we go out,
- 17:44we decide to to dress accordingly.
- 17:47If you go to a party, we dress in one fashion, we go to work,
- 17:51we dress in another, we go to do some sport activities, we dress
- 17:54accordingly and so on. In France, this wonderful
- 17:59society, big society with huge influence on the world, they are
- 18:06obsessed by the way that women dress.
- 18:09And I simply could not get it. Why do you care how women dress?
- 18:15We do it every day. Why do you care?
- 18:18It's none of your business. Some of of the women like to
- 18:22dress mini, the French people say it's absolutely fine.
- 18:27Some of the women like to dress mini, the French people say it's
- 18:31absolutely fine. Some of the women likes to dress
- 18:35maxi, the French people say it's absolutely fine.
- 18:39But if a woman decide to put a veil around the face, or God
- 18:44forbid, to put a veil on their face, this is not acceptable.
- 18:50Why do you care? Why suddenly this is the state
- 18:55business? I was very intrigued with this
- 18:59issue, so I went to France to study this and to listen to
- 19:04people with all walks of life, those who endorse this practice
- 19:08and those who do not endorse the parties, just to try and
- 19:11understand. And from this, the result was
- 19:14another book that I published in the field of multiculturalism
- 19:17that came in 2022, which is called Security, Liberty and
- 19:24Individuality. And this is about the French
- 19:29secularism that prohibits women dress.
- 19:33And as you can understand, I don't think that it conformed
- 19:38with liberal ideas. It's interesting to me that I
- 19:43don't know if people don't like the veil because they think
- 19:47maybe the women are oppressed and they're trying to fight.
- 19:51They're trying to fight for that, that woman, you know, But
- 19:55if she, if she wants to dress that way, that should be her
- 19:59right to wear those clothes, you know?
- 20:02Yeah, but those, those who argue for a cohesion say that the
- 20:08women are not free to voice their opinion.
- 20:11So they are coerced to be dressed like this.
- 20:14And therefore we are going to free them.
- 20:17We are going to let them free, notwithstanding what the woman
- 20:20says. The woman, they may say, I hope
- 20:23to do this, this is my choice. But the friends say, no, no, no,
- 20:26no, let me save you. It's like the Boy Scout who
- 20:32coerces an elderly woman to cross the street.
- 20:36That would be his good deed for the day.
- 20:40I think that we have to listen to these women now if we need
- 20:43help because they are living under duress, because their life
- 20:49are coheres and they are not free to lead their lives.
- 20:52The suicide of course need to help them.
- 20:54I'm not saying to deserve them, God forbid no.
- 20:57But if a woman says listen, this is my choice that will live my
- 21:01life. I don't like to be gazed at.
- 21:04I don't like to be people to stare at me.
- 21:07I like my privacy, so I when I'm working with the Booker, with
- 21:11any cab or whatever, I want to feel secure.
- 21:15This is the way that I feel secure.
- 21:17By the way, there's some women say that if they're not going to
- 21:21adhere to this, their men are not going to let them out of the
- 21:25of the house. So, you know, all the research
- 21:30that I have conducted, I did not find any persuasive argument to
- 21:37deny women the right to dress as they wish.
- 21:41I think this is something that should be given to all people by
- 21:47the very virtue that we believe in liberty and tolerance being
- 21:52living in liberal society. Yeah, sorry to interrupt.
- 21:56I just wanted to tell you about one of my sponsors real quick.
- 22:02Sometimes I need a boost before my bike ride, but pounding an
- 22:04energy drink or coffee beforehand just isn't an option.
- 22:07What I love about Quantum Energy Squares is that they're made
- 22:10with 10 grams of plant protein and 100 milligrams of natural
- 22:14caffeine, equal to an 8 oz cup of coffee.
- 22:16I get. The boost I need without having
- 22:18to drink the fluids that weigh me down.
- 22:20Or cause a pit stop. During my ride, they have over
- 22:232500 reviews with customers raving about their delicious
- 22:26flavors like Caramel, Almond, Sea Salt, and my favorite Dark
- 22:30Chocolate Pink Himalayan Salt. My discount code gives you 25%
- 22:34off your entire order and it's currently the best deal
- 22:36available. Just visit quantumsquares.com
- 22:40and enter in my promo code JADE. That's JADE at checkout.
- 22:47Do you think a A2 state solution is viable?
- 22:52We are moving away now from multiculturalism to the Israeli.
- 22:55Power. Oh yeah, sorry, I kind of did a
- 22:57hard shift. OK, well, fair disclosure, I
- 23:02have to say that I'm, I'm in the time a person of peace and I've
- 23:08been very much involved in the peace camp in Israel long before
- 23:14I was an academic, OK, I started to be involved in Israeli
- 23:19politics in the early 1980s. I was fortunate to work with
- 23:23some of the leaders of of Israel.
- 23:27So I know politics from close and I became, if you like a
- 23:32politician or small politician with a small P before I was, I
- 23:38became a political scientist. So this is before I started,
- 23:41before I went to uni, OK. And I still belong to the peace
- 23:45camp. I believe in peace.
- 23:46Peace is extremely important to me.
- 23:50And I've been active in the peace camp, as I said, from the
- 23:551980s. I still remain active.
- 23:59In 2013, I decided to write a book about resolving the Israeli
- 24:04Palestinian conflict. Yeah.
- 24:08And this is the title of the book that, God willing, is going
- 24:11to be published next year by Cambridge University Press.
- 24:14So this is a work that has been occupying my mind now for 13
- 24:20years or 12 years, 13 years. I believe that the present
- 24:30situation is horrible. I also believe it is
- 24:35unacceptable. I told you that the most
- 24:39important value for me is justice.
- 24:43And if you come to Israel and you visit the occupied
- 24:49territories, the West Bank, Gaza, you see that the way that
- 24:56the Palestinians live is unjust, is unjust because the occupation
- 25:01is unjust. The occupation denies basic
- 25:05freedoms of humans. And I came to see the occupation
- 25:11from clothes when I visited the Occupy territories was back back
- 25:15in 1985. And I was horrified to see that
- 25:20we Jews, Israelis, we subject people to such living conditions
- 25:28that for me are unacceptable. So I would not be able to live
- 25:33in such a state. I would probably live.
- 25:36I would go away. I would find a way to go out
- 25:39because denial of freedom for me is something that is not
- 25:45acceptable. I, I can't accept this.
- 25:47I can't accept that someone is going to tell me today you
- 25:52cannot go and work your farm today, you cannot go and study.
- 25:58Why? Because I feel like it, Because
- 26:02I am the person with a rifle and you don't have a rifle.
- 26:07I stand in the checkpoint and today I decide you do not pass.
- 26:12And this is just one example of the restrictions that many
- 26:15Palestinians have to endure as a result of the occupation.
- 26:20So my starting point is that the present situation is
- 26:24unacceptable. That means that the present
- 26:27situation has to be replaced and it has to be replaced by a just
- 26:32situation, a situation that is going to be just for both
- 26:36communities, for the Israelis and for the Palestinians alike.
- 26:42Nothing short of that is acceptable to me and is nothing
- 26:47short of that should be acceptable to any human being
- 26:50across the planet and including the Palestinians, of course,
- 26:54because these are the people in concern.
- 26:58They have to suffer the position of this occupation.
- 27:03When Israel occupied the West Bank and Gaza in the Golan
- 27:08Heights in the north back in 1967 as a result of the Six Day
- 27:13War, I do not think that when the war started, Israel, Israeli
- 27:21leaders thought that first Israel is going to occupy all
- 27:25this territory. It was a magnificent
- 27:28achievement, magnificent victory to conquer all this space
- 27:33territory within a span of six days.
- 27:38This glorious victory became a curse because with this
- 27:44territory that the Israeli leader wanted came all the
- 27:48people with it. Today, between the Jordan River
- 27:54and the Mediterranean Sea, the number of Arabs and Jews is
- 28:00almost identical. It's around 7.5 million Jews and
- 28:067.5 million Arabs. Israel is about 10.4 million
- 28:15people, 21% of the Israelis, million, 1.51.7 something like
- 28:24that, million people. Even Israelis are Palestinians.
- 28:30These are Palestinians who would like to reside in Israel.
- 28:33However they are, so I don't count them together with the
- 28:36Palestinians in the West Bank, in Gaza.
- 28:39But still, we're talking about different people with different
- 28:43ideologies, with different religions, different
- 28:46nationalities while living in this territory between the
- 28:49Jordan River. We have to make this territory
- 28:56something that's amicable and just for all, not only for the
- 29:00Jews. And I believe that in the long
- 29:07run, I'm not talking about the next 50 years.
- 29:11I'm not talking about the next 100 years.
- 29:14I'm talking now for generations to come.
- 29:19Israel is in a very isolated place in the Middle East.
- 29:24It is surrounded by many Arab countries and by many Muslim
- 29:28countries. There are no Christian countries
- 29:31and said there are no Jewish countries around.
- 29:34Israel is the only Jewish country in the world.
- 29:36So in the long run, when you're talking about history, hundreds
- 29:40of years, the key for Israel's survival is its integration into
- 29:46the Middle East. Israel must find a way to
- 29:50integrate itself and be accepted as part and parcel of the Middle
- 29:56East by its name. If it's not going to be
- 30:00accepted, then there will be constant hostilities, constant
- 30:05fighting, and many wars. And I don't like war.
- 30:09Actually, there's something I really don't like that abhor is
- 30:13war. War.
- 30:14War is the most horrible thing that can.
- 30:17Whatever happened to you? The key for Israel is
- 30:22integration into the Middle East is to resolve the Israeli
- 30:25Colossian conflict. Now the book is about the
- 30:29solution. So the book is the book is when
- 30:34I started, when I did the book in my mind before writing it,
- 30:39what I wanted to do, I wanted to do 3 things.
- 30:42I wanted to examine all the key junctions, these junctions from
- 30:46Oslo 1993 until now, and to see why we're still yearning for
- 30:53peace, why we didn't achieve it despite really extreme effort
- 30:58that were invested by Israelis, Palestinians, Americans,
- 31:03Europeans, others, why we're still yearning for peace.
- 31:08Secondly, I wanted that if an opportunity won't present
- 31:14itself, that my book will serve as a toolkit to do it right.
- 31:21So the diplomats, the politicians, they can use my
- 31:26book to understand how to do negotiations in the correct way.
- 31:31What are the keys for successful negotiations?
- 31:34Mediation and facilitation. And thirdly, to review some of
- 31:39the proposals to solve the problem, the the conflict and to
- 31:44invoke my solution. So these are the three things
- 31:48that I wanted to do before I started the book.
- 31:52Writing a book just started the research.
- 31:56I started to write the book in 2022 after nine years of
- 32:01research. Majority of the time was spent
- 32:06by going to archives. I went to archives in London, in
- 32:10Jerusalem, in Washington and in Oslo.
- 32:14And by in depth interviews with people around the table who
- 32:20negotiated peace presidents, prime ministers, foreign
- 32:25ministers, royalty, deputy prime ministers, senior diplomats from
- 32:3210 countries and United Nations. It's gold.
- 32:38What I found more than 100 interviews, each interview more
- 32:44than two hours. So in depth interviews with very
- 32:47similar people. The book is based on the
- 32:49archives and on the interviews, and when I started writing, my
- 32:56first chapter was about Oslo. When I finished writing about
- 33:02Oslo, I examined how much I wrote of the book and it was
- 33:0825,000 words. And that means that I could not
- 33:12cover all the key junctions because a book has to be
- 33:18limited. Otherwise I'm not going to write
- 33:20a book, I'm going to write encyclopedia.
- 33:22And that's my intention. I want to write a book, one book
- 33:26to start with. So I decided to lean myself to
- 33:29three junctions. Oslo.
- 33:32Kim, David. 2000A Negotiation between Prime Minister Woodall
- 33:36met and President Mahmoud Abbas. These were the three main
- 33:42important key junctions in which peace will seem achievable but
- 33:49did not materialize. So this is one major section of
- 33:54the book. This occupies the majority of
- 33:59the book. There's a theoretical chapter,
- 34:01chapter, my theory, always there is a theory and opinion theory.
- 34:04Then the chapters and then in the last two chapters I speak
- 34:09about the keys for successful negotiation, media facilitation
- 34:13and my proposal. Now, because the book is not
- 34:17published yet and I don't want to spoil the publication, I want
- 34:22you and your listener to actually read the book,
- 34:27hopefully to buy the book. I'm not going to tell you what
- 34:31is my solution. You'll have to wait, OK?
- 34:34What I can tell you is that it is just solution, OK?
- 34:39It's just, it's reasonable and I think it's doable.
- 34:43I think it is the most practical and realistic solution.
- 34:49Not today, OK? I'm a very, I'm very optimistic
- 34:54person. I believe in peace, but I'm also
- 34:56very realistic person. Now the two societies, the
- 35:01Israeli and the Palestinians, are under trauma.
- 35:05We're talking about two traumatized, very angry, full of
- 35:13hate societies, deep hatred. So even if there were peace,
- 35:22peace necks between the Palestinians and the Israelis,
- 35:27the Christics understand that now it's not the right time to
- 35:30push this because we have to think of of a time that is ripe.
- 35:39What do I mean by ripe? I mean by a situation in which
- 35:45the two leaders, the Israeli and the Palestinian, believe that
- 35:48they have to seize the opportunity now because
- 35:51otherwise the future is going to be worse.
- 35:55So better do it now. And we are not there now.
- 35:59We, we are, we're aching. The Israeli society is aching
- 36:05because of what happened on the 7th of October 2023 when the
- 36:10Hamas terror organization entered into Israeli territory
- 36:15and killed about 1200 people, raped women, torched houses,
- 36:24killed babies and took with them 251 Israelis into into Gaza. 50
- 36:34of the hostages are still there. And I can tell you last year I
- 36:40lived in Israel for one year. Usually I'm living in the UK,
- 36:44but last year I returned to work on my book at AB University in
- 36:49Jerusalem. I can tell that each and every
- 36:52day I was aching over the hostages and as the war
- 36:59proceeded, I was aching about what's growing in Gaza.
- 37:04And in the late stage I was calling to end the war.
- 37:09And this is what I'm doing now in the social media, almost on a
- 37:14daily basis. I'm calling to retrieve the
- 37:17hostages, to end the war and to start rebuild Gaza.
- 37:22I think that this war is at this point, it is futile.
- 37:27If I were a Prime Minister of Israel, I would not conduct the
- 37:31war in such a way. My highest priority would be to
- 37:351st bring dosages back home. It's against all the values on
- 37:40which I was raised to live. So many Israelis in Gaza in a
- 37:48state of torture, this is against all that.
- 37:52I believe some of these people, many of these people are either
- 37:57soldiers or people who lived very, very close to the border.
- 38:03And the Cortesque thing is that's many of the people who
- 38:07established this kibbutzim, the settlements outside of Gaza.
- 38:12They came there from ideology, from peace ideology.
- 38:17They came there to be close to the Gazans in order to help
- 38:21them. That's why they came there.
- 38:24They came to live a life in hopefully that they would be the
- 38:28bridge to Gaza so they can support them, offer them work,
- 38:34communicate with them, find a way to make the situation less
- 38:40worse for the Gazans. And when 7 October happened,
- 38:47Hamas didn't ask about the political or ideological views.
- 38:51They just massacre everyone. And now these people who have
- 38:55been fighting all their life for Israel and for peace are in a
- 39:00state of torture. And I found it unacceptable.
- 39:05I don't understand how the Prime Minister can sleep at night.
- 39:09I, I, I don't, I, I think it's irresponsible.
- 39:14We, we need to be responsible for our citizens.
- 39:20Each leader needs to be responsible for his or her
- 39:24citizens. And I can't imagine that, you
- 39:28know, if something like this happened and they spent.
- 39:33I don't know. And how many days now it's 260.
- 39:36You know what? In two years, it's almost two
- 39:39years. Now in October, it's going to be
- 39:41two years. It's it's yeah.
- 39:44I I don't have any words for that.
- 39:46So there will be peace. But I'm afraid, I think it's not
- 39:50going to be in my my lifetime. I hope maybe in my children's
- 39:54lifetime, maybe in my grandchild lifetime.
- 39:57I don't know. I have one grandchild so I hope
- 39:59maybe he will see the light, but I think the Israeli children and
- 40:04the Palestinian children deserve better and want to see the day
- 40:08in which they play together while they then shoot each
- 40:10other. Yeah, I I can see why it would
- 40:14take a long time to get there, especially with everything still
- 40:18being they're still hostages. You know, to say everything is
- 40:22fresh isn't even a good way to explain it because it's still
- 40:27happening in, but I'm excited to for when your book comes out to
- 40:33read the solution that you propose to that, OK.
- 40:37And maybe we can have another meeting and discuss the
- 40:39solution. Yes, I would love that.
- 40:42Yeah. I was gonna ask you what your
- 40:45solution is, but that was obviously a smart move not to
- 40:48talk about it today. So all right.
- 40:51And your other books are available on Amazon, correct?
- 40:56All of them. Well, the IBU one's not.
- 40:59I don't think so, but there are those in English, the majority
- 41:02of the book on Amazon. Thank you very much.
- 41:06Yes. And, and I hope they, those who
- 41:11listen to you, may have the appetite at least to read the
- 41:16books that I've mentioned. Yes, I really appreciate you
- 41:19talking about this because we here in the United States, I
- 41:23don't believe we get too much information from people actually
- 41:28living in the area, actually experiencing what's going on.
- 41:32We only hear the headlines. So you definitely offered some
- 41:37information that will be new to the people who listen to this
- 41:41episode, so. I really.
- 41:43Appreciate it. I I want to emphasize that there
- 41:45are no angels in this story. Don't don't think in angelic
- 41:50terms because Israel is not angelic.
- 41:53The policy are not angelic. Both societies made many, many
- 41:56mistakes, but it's time to makes prepare time to change, time to
- 42:04think about the future in positive way.
- 42:08Too much blood has been shed and too much energies were invested
- 42:13in hatred and blood shedding. I think that that should be
- 42:17enough. We don't know the exact number
- 42:20of dozens who were killed in this war, but estimates range
- 42:24between 64 to 82,000 people. That's a very large number of
- 42:30people. Swaths of Gaza, large swaths of
- 42:34Gaza are demolished. It will take years to re
- 42:40establish Gaza. And these people don't have a
- 42:43job, they don't have work, they don't have horizon, they don't
- 42:47have future. I hope that the people in Gaza
- 42:53understood what the organization that they elected Hamas, they
- 42:58elected them to power what they did, that they should understand
- 43:04that what they did is not resistance, but actually it's
- 43:08pure terrorism resistant. You resist occupation, you
- 43:13resist soldiers. But to go to a house, rape the
- 43:18woman is there, torture her, kill her, kill a baby in front
- 43:26of his slightly older brother, take the husband with them to
- 43:33Gaza and do a score of atrocious things?
- 43:39This is not resistant. This is gruesome brutality,
- 43:46terrorism. He doesn't have any other name.
- 43:51The Palestinians should understand by now.
- 43:54They try to resist and to resort to violence and terror.
- 43:58Since 1967, even before unsuccessfully, if at all,
- 44:04Israel grew bigger and bigger and bigger, and it's a side that
- 44:10thrives. What about you, Palestinians?
- 44:14What did you get until now? What did you get?
- 44:19What this violence has brought upon you?
- 44:22The only thing that the violence brought upon you is more
- 44:25violence. That's the only thing that
- 44:28violence actually yield more violence.
- 44:32Does it really worth it? I'm not condoning the Israeli
- 44:36occupation. I said no, it's aborable.
- 44:38I would not be able to leave there, so I'm not condoning it.
- 44:41I want it to end. But you also have to work
- 44:46together with Israel, that Israel should feel safe next to
- 44:51you. Because what 7 October did is to
- 44:55say we can't trust you. We Israelis cannot trust you
- 45:00because we're afraid that on another day, 8th of October
- 45:052027, you'll do it again. You put the Israeli society into
- 45:11trauma, severe trauma, because Israelis never believed that, A,
- 45:19that it can happen and, B, that you want it to happen.
- 45:24I mean, you don't get anything from that.
- 45:27See what kind of a state you are now.
- 45:29Now Palestinians say, oh, we are missing Gaza of 2022 with all
- 45:35the, you know, horrible situation that we're in.
- 45:37But now they miss their life then, because their very
- 45:40miserable life. Yeah.
- 45:43I don't think that violence is ever a solution.
- 45:46It's not a solution for Israel, it's not a solution for
- 45:48Palestinians, it's not solution for Russia, It's not solution
- 45:51for Ukraine. We should know better.
- 45:54They we are excelling killing each other.
- 45:56Humanity excels in killing each other.
- 45:59But we know better. We also produce the magnificent
- 46:03brains that ever work with this planet.
- 46:06Of all the animals we should work out brains to to bring
- 46:11peace, not war. Yeah, I agree.
- 46:14Good to see you. Yes, thank you so much.
- 46:17I really appreciate you sharing all of that.
- 46:20I am excited for the new book. To come.
- 46:23Thank you very much I. Appreciate.
- 46:24Yes, thank you. Very good to see.
- 46:25All right. Thank you.