Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Blastoff: The Legal Countdown to Nuclear in Space
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Blast Off, the Legal Countdown to Nuclear in
- 0:10Space. I'm Olive Holy Castro, Director of Education
- 0:13and Professional Development at Beverly Hills
- 0:15Bar Association, and I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:18our speaker for today, Stuart Forbes. Stuart
- 0:22is counsel at Hogan Lovells Cadwallader's Energy
- 0:26Regulatory Practice Group, where he draws on
- 0:28his expertise as a senior attorney at the U .S.
- 0:30Department of Energy to help developers and businesses
- 0:34navigate complex legal, regulatory, and policy
- 0:37challenges across the energy and advanced technology
- 0:40sectors. His clients include advanced nuclear
- 0:43reactor developers, major U .S. manufacturers,
- 0:46and appliance manufacturers subject to DOE efficiency
- 0:50regulations. a speaker on topics ranging from
- 0:54DOE authorities and nuclear development to AI
- 0:57-driven energy infrastructure. We can't wait
- 0:59to hear what he has to share with us today. So
- 1:01I'm going to turn it over to him. Thank you very
- 1:04much. I appreciate it. And I know the name of
- 1:07the firm is a mouthful. So this is the joys of
- 1:10the legal practice for all of us, as you're probably
- 1:13all aware. So as Alice said, I'm Stuart Forbes.
- 1:16This is a really exciting topic for me, something
- 1:20that I've been speaking on quite a bit lately.
- 1:23And although the title is blast off the legal
- 1:26countdown to nuclear in space, the title itself
- 1:29is a little bit of a lie, because the reality
- 1:32is we've been doing nuclear in space for a very
- 1:36long time. So my goal today, as we walk through
- 1:40this presentation, is to give each and every
- 1:43one of you a grounding in the statutory regulatory
- 1:49treaty and executive branch policies that make
- 1:54up the framework for nuclear space launches to
- 1:58walk you through a little bit of the history
- 1:59of what the United States government and industry
- 2:02have done and to then talk about some of the
- 2:05issues as we move into commercial space. nuclear
- 2:09launches. Now this is an exciting time and this
- 2:12presentation is very timely just in the last
- 2:14two weeks. One of the first commercial nuclear
- 2:18-powered batteries made it into orbit. And this
- 2:23is, it actually happened after I had finished
- 2:26this slide deck, so we won't go into great detail,
- 2:28but it is, it does prove that this is an active
- 2:31area of development, an active area of the law,
- 2:34and something that may be a little bit of a niche,
- 2:36but is very timely at least. So if we go down
- 2:40to the first slide, what you'll see here is that
- 2:45the nuclear Space Launch Authority and Nuclear
- 2:49Authority are two separate domains of law that
- 2:54intersect really in one specific point, and they
- 2:58were never designed to be co -located. Nor has
- 3:02Congress ever gone through and created a program
- 3:07of record, a master program between NASA and
- 3:10the Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the Department
- 3:12of Energy that covers every nuance, every facet
- 3:17of nuclear space activities. And in fact, what
- 3:20you'll see throughout this presentation is that
- 3:23this is really a hodgepodge of statutory and
- 3:27regulatory practice that's kind of brought together
- 3:30to meet a specific technological need, but without
- 3:35a full wholesale approach that just says for
- 3:39all nuclear space launches, by virtue of this
- 3:42act of Congress, you will do it this way. So
- 3:45where do you begin? Commercial space launch approval
- 3:49requires the Federal Aviation Administration
- 3:52to provide authorization. It's required if you're
- 3:57a U .S. citizen or company and you're launching
- 3:59anywhere in the world, or if you're launching
- 4:02from U .S. soil or the soil of a U .S. territory,
- 4:06or if you're re -entering U .S. territory. There's
- 4:09no specific, within this framework for commercial
- 4:12launches, there's no specific nuclear provision.
- 4:16Now, NASA has for years been doing nuclear space
- 4:21launches with DOE materials, nuclear materials
- 4:26from the Department of Energy, and we'll get
- 4:29into those in a bit. Under those launch frameworks,
- 4:32There's a safety analysis requirement. There
- 4:35are inter -agency agreements that are put in
- 4:37place. There's the inter -agency nuclear review
- 4:40board or INSERV, which we'll talk about a little
- 4:42bit later. And this is all done under kind of
- 4:46a melange of DOE authorities, NASA authorities,
- 4:51sometimes Department of War authorities, as well
- 4:53as memoranda of agreements and understanding
- 4:56between the agencies to make sure that all of
- 4:59the relevant authorities that each agency has
- 5:02can be used to facilitate the launch. So going
- 5:07forward, this slide, what you'll see, we can
- 5:13go forward there. As I said, there's no current
- 5:19nuclear regulations that deal with this. You
- 5:21have these kind of mix of launch activities,
- 5:26but we've been doing space launches, both NASA
- 5:31space launches and commercial space launches
- 5:33for years. NRC has some authorities, the NRC,
- 5:37the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, to regulate
- 5:40nuclear materials at the launch pad. The Department
- 5:42of Energy can authorize nuclear prototypes, first
- 5:47of a kind deployments in space. Department of
- 5:50War, they have some organic authorities on their
- 5:53own. to put in nuclear reactors or nuclear material
- 5:58powered systems on orbit if it's done for military
- 6:02purposes. And when you think about it from a
- 6:06regulatory perspective, this does kind of make,
- 6:08this breakdown kind of makes sense. When you
- 6:11look at nuclear regulatory commission licensed
- 6:14activities terrestrially in the US, there's often
- 6:19an on -site inspector There are regular audits.
- 6:24There are enforcement actions that can be taken
- 6:26if something goes wrong. The purpose of the licensing
- 6:31structure is for safety and compliance with all
- 6:34of the regulations and requirements that the
- 6:36government has imposed. Once you launch a nuclear
- 6:39system in orbit, you can't really launch an inspector
- 6:43to go with it. I mean, you could, but that's
- 6:45probably not a good idea. And so quite simply,
- 6:49once once a system is launched, space is just
- 6:52too big to regulate. And so when you think about
- 6:56nuclear powered systems, what you're really thinking
- 6:59about are the launch systems, the potential reentry
- 7:06of those systems. And that is where all 99 .9
- 7:12% of the regulatory consideration comes into
- 7:15play. And we'll talk about some of the that documents
- 7:18some of the concerns and questions that have
- 7:20been brought up over the years with some of the
- 7:22nuclear launches that we've done. So, if we can
- 7:24move forward a slide or two, I guess, actually.
- 7:30When you think about space, there are a whole
- 7:34series of treaties that come into play. For purposes
- 7:38of discussing nuclear space activities, really
- 7:42these four that are on your screen are the most
- 7:45pertinent. The Partial Test Ban Treaty of 1963,
- 7:50in which all the signatory nations agreed not
- 7:53to carry out nuclear weapons testing beyond the
- 7:56Earth's atmosphere. A very clear delineation
- 8:00of responsibilities and obligations there. The
- 8:03Outer Space Treaty of 1967, one of its key tenets
- 8:07is that space, and specifically Earth orbit,
- 8:12will be nuclear weapon free. And that space itself
- 8:17becomes a common domain, free exploration by
- 8:22all. Liability Commission and Convention of 1972
- 8:28states that when something re -enters the Earth's
- 8:32atmosphere, this is either through a degradation
- 8:35of its orbit or through some other fault collision.
- 8:39in orbit that results in re -entry, the launching
- 8:42states are liable for damage on Earth. Now, think
- 8:47about this from a nuclear context. This is strict
- 8:50liability for the launching state. And to date,
- 8:55as far as my knowledge goes, there have only
- 8:57been two nuclear launching states that have put
- 9:01systems on orbit or beyond orbit, being the US
- 9:05and the Soviet Union slash Russia. If one of
- 9:09those systems were to have its orbit decay and
- 9:14were to collide and damage material on Earth,
- 9:18then there's a liability regime that kicks in
- 9:21and the launching state becomes strictly liable.
- 9:23This has actually happened with a Soviet -era
- 9:27reactor that its orbit decayed and it landed
- 9:31in Canada, in northern Canada, in the 1970s.
- 9:35In addition to those three treaties, you have
- 9:37the moon agreement. So there's a lot of talk
- 9:40in the industry right now about the moon being
- 9:43a spot that's ideal for the deployment of a surface
- 9:48fission power system. the Moon Treaty, the Moon
- 9:55Agreement of 84, the celestial bodies declared
- 9:59a common heritage mankind, it emphasizes international
- 10:02cooperation, and it prohibits the deployment
- 10:05of nuclear weapons. but not nuclear reactors
- 10:08or power systems. And this distinction is important.
- 10:11I sometimes take it for granted that I've been
- 10:15having practices in this area for the better
- 10:17part of a decade now. The distinction is clear
- 10:19to me, but for many people who are new into this
- 10:22space, it's worth noting the physics of a reactor
- 10:26design are not the same as the physics of a nuclear
- 10:31weapon. It is a different reaction. It's a controlled
- 10:35reaction that allows for the gradual release
- 10:38of energy for a nuclear power system as compared
- 10:44to a nuclear weapon. So it makes some sense then
- 10:47that this agreement, as the other agreements
- 10:51have kind of outlined a peaceful use of space,
- 10:54that it would allow for reactor deployment, but
- 10:57not for the weapons deployment. So that gets
- 11:00you through the space trees. These are our international
- 11:02obligations. US is party to many, if not all
- 11:06of the major treaties that deal with this area.
- 11:09And then we go on to what's happening in space
- 11:14legislation and nuclear legislation. So the history
- 11:18here dates back actually further than this chart
- 11:21goes. It dates back to the... mid -1940s. As
- 11:25most of you know, the nuclear technology in the
- 11:29United States developed out of the Manhattan
- 11:31Project. The Manhattan Project was a Army Corps
- 11:35of Engineer effort to build the first atomic
- 11:38bomb. Once World War II was over, the the project
- 11:44kind of morphed into a government monopoly of
- 11:48nuclear technology. In 1946, Congress passed
- 11:51the first Atomic Energy Act. This act created
- 11:55a monopoly. of nuclear power and technology in
- 12:00the United States, that only the AEC and its
- 12:04partners in the interagency, the Department of
- 12:07Defense, and the other civilian agencies would
- 12:11have access to nuclear technologies, and that
- 12:14the AEC itself became the clearinghouse for that
- 12:19development. As a result of that act in 46, you
- 12:23saw a rapid build out of the national laboratory
- 12:26systems with the labs that came out of the Manhattan
- 12:30Project, Los Alamos, Soak Ridge National Laboratory,
- 12:34Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, names
- 12:36that you have heard of undoubtedly. California
- 12:39has a rich history with Lawrence Berkeley and
- 12:42Livermore and the Stanford Linear Accelerator
- 12:45and others. All of that was an outgrowth of the
- 12:50government investment in the passage of the 46th
- 12:53Act. By 1954, Congress and the Eisenhower administration
- 12:59had also noted through AEC reports and experimentation
- 13:04that there was a potential for domestic clean
- 13:07civilian, well, they weren't worried about clean
- 13:09at the time, but at least civilian energy production
- 13:12from nuclear technology. And so Congress passed
- 13:15the 1954 Atomic Energy Act that ended the exclusive
- 13:20government monopoly over this technology and
- 13:23created a more civilian oriented AEA. And here
- 13:29the idea was that the government will open up
- 13:33access to this technology for utilities to build
- 13:38new power plants. It would keep its priorities
- 13:41with the weapons system. This is the height of
- 13:43the Cold War. And obviously there were all kinds
- 13:46of experiments on that end, everything from nuclear
- 13:49powered bombers, which they never deployed, through
- 13:53to nuclear powered satellites, which we'll get
- 13:56into again in a second, as well as obviously
- 13:59nuclear weapons. there was this other use that
- 14:06the 54 Act really was trying to unlock. Through
- 14:10the years, it wasn't moving as quickly as Congress
- 14:13wanted. So in 1957, they established and passed
- 14:17the Price Anderson Nuclear Indemnities Act. This
- 14:21allowed for the government to indemnify for a
- 14:25nuclear accident any third party that might be
- 14:28found liable for a public liability following
- 14:32a nuclear incident or precautionary evacuation.
- 14:35This act then basically underwrote some of the
- 14:39risk and some of the perceived real and perceived
- 14:42risk of nuclear deployment in the civilian world.
- 14:49Often it has been characterized as a huge underwriting
- 14:52of the industry. There's probably is some validity
- 14:54to that especially at this time. In addition
- 14:58to this in 58, There is this move that really
- 15:03started back in the 30s as aerospace as an industry
- 15:07continued to evolve, going from the Wright brothers
- 15:11and biplanes all the way to jumbo jets during
- 15:15the war. And now we're looking at space -based
- 15:18communications, space tourism, not tourism yet,
- 15:22but the competition with the Soviets following
- 15:25Sputnik and some of the other things that the
- 15:27U .S. really needed to focus on space as a domain,
- 15:32both for national power, but as well for exploration.
- 15:37And the National Aeronautics and Space Act of
- 15:3958, who set up NASA, gave NASA pretty broad authorities
- 15:44in creating a civilian space program. And then,
- 15:50like with the AEC, also had left a lot of the
- 15:53military activities with DOD. This situation
- 15:59then worked really well for many years. The two
- 16:03departments, the Atomic Energy Commission and
- 16:06the National Aeronautics and Space Administration
- 16:09worked together on multiple projects and kind
- 16:12of built a tradition of collaboration that persists
- 16:17really to this day. In 74, a major change occurred.
- 16:23The Atomic Energy Commission had been criticized
- 16:25for failing to control costs for its perceived
- 16:28conflict of interest and in some instances real
- 16:31conflict of interest in advocating for nuclear
- 16:33development as well as for failing to regulate
- 16:40the companies for which it was also actively
- 16:42advocating. As a result, Congress passed in 74
- 16:46the Energy Reorganization Act, which abolished
- 16:48the AEC and created the Nuclear Regulatory Commission
- 16:53and the Energy Research Development Authority.
- 16:56ERDA went on to become DOE in 1977, and it maintained
- 17:01a lot of its responsibilities to develop radioisotope
- 17:05space systems for NASA, NRC took the responsibility
- 17:09to regulate the civilian nuclear applications,
- 17:14which could, although at that time didn't because
- 17:16it wasn't really an industry, could include nuclear
- 17:22commercial space launches. So moving forward,
- 17:26and I don't need to go through all of these pieces
- 17:29of legislation. I could, but for our purposes
- 17:32here, you can read through in the material later
- 17:34on. Important is the commercial space launch
- 17:39amendments, because these really did, starting
- 17:41in the 80s, They really did create the framework
- 17:46for the commercial space industry that we know
- 17:49today. And they also created the framework for
- 17:52the potential of a nuclear commercial space industry,
- 17:56which we are just now really starting to see
- 17:59come into fruition. These acts together imposed
- 18:06a regulatory structure for the launch authorizations.
- 18:10like what the AEA of 54 did for nuclear, they
- 18:14opened the door for private space industry to
- 18:16move forward. They also created the liability
- 18:20insurance and indemnification regime, which we'll
- 18:22touch on in a little bit, that covers accidents
- 18:27in space launch as should one arise. Now, mind
- 18:32you, this is all from 84 on. We're all in the
- 18:35post -challenger period. We are seeing a kind
- 18:38of a pullback and a questioning of NASA practices
- 18:41and a questioning, like with what the AEC faced
- 18:46in the early 70s, whether or not the government
- 18:49is really looking at the industry. with a safety
- 18:54conscious mindset and whether it really needs
- 18:57to improve what it's doing in order to achieve
- 19:00its potential. So let's move on to the next slide
- 19:04because this really comes to a head in 2019 under
- 19:09the first Trump administration. As I had said,
- 19:13the government nuclear launches for much of the
- 19:18the 20th from the when they started back in the
- 19:22mid late 50s early 60s were kind of an ad hoc
- 19:27process. There is there is a apologize if you're
- 19:33hearing beeping on my computer evidently I didn't
- 19:35put myself on mute. There is there was a kind
- 19:40of tendency amongst the agencies to take one
- 19:45-off activities as they came across. There was
- 19:49not a risk -based structure. It was something
- 19:52where the agencies themselves would just simply
- 19:55move forward as a project came up and it was
- 19:59not a comprehensive process -driven approval.
- 20:05Not to say that there were not safety analyses
- 20:08done, but what NISPOM, the National Security
- 20:12Presidential Memorandum 20, did in 2019 was to
- 20:16bring in line an informed risk safety analysis
- 20:21for all nuclear launches across government. And
- 20:25what it did is it established a risk profile.
- 20:29Are there significant risks to the public of
- 20:33a total effective dose that are serious, well,
- 20:37then we really need to go, those fall in the
- 20:40third tier of our review process. The president
- 20:43must authorize the launch safety. You have to,
- 20:48this would be for any non -low enriched uranium
- 20:50power system, for example. The entirety of the
- 20:55system must be reviewed and you have to go through
- 20:58the entirety of the interagency, the Nuclear
- 21:01Regulatory Commission, the Department of Energy,
- 21:03the Department of War, Coast Guard, EPA, Department
- 21:06of Transportation, the whole of government reviews
- 21:09these significant launches before they get the
- 21:13okay to move forward. You also have the lower
- 21:16two tiers, the tier two, which would include
- 21:19low enriched systems, but where the risk of public
- 21:22exposure is significantly less, well, the agency
- 21:25head, the NASA administrator, can authorize such
- 21:28a launch. minimal risk. It's a routine review.
- 21:32We don't need to get the whole interagency together.
- 21:35We will just move forward with it and the agency
- 21:37head will authorize it. So this system is now
- 21:42being used and was deployed for the first time
- 21:44with the recent launch in the past couple of
- 21:47weeks of the Tritium battery that you probably
- 21:50have seen in the trade press recently. So moving
- 21:54on to the next one. This was Trump 1. This is
- 21:58was a significant step forward in kind of systematizing,
- 22:03as I said, nuclear launches. When the second
- 22:07Trump administration came back into office, though,
- 22:10they moved forward pretty quickly with a very
- 22:14robust set of executive orders. And most of you
- 22:17are probably aware of this at this stage. Excuse
- 22:22me. These executive orders together did something
- 22:28that I think is a little bit unique, at least
- 22:31in my experience over the last decade in this
- 22:33space. They created a circumstance in which a
- 22:38lot of industry, a lot of latent authorities,
- 22:42let me put it this way, that existed within the
- 22:45interagency could be exercised. by the agency
- 22:50to support commercial operations. We're seeing
- 22:52this right now in the nuclear space. We're seeing
- 22:54this in AI. We're seeing this in access to federal
- 22:58lands. Things that, yes, perhaps Congress had
- 23:02never prohibited in the organizing statutes or
- 23:05things that maybe we did at a small scale as
- 23:08a country back in the 1950s or 60s were now being
- 23:11actively encouraged. Again, in this vein, these
- 23:1610 multiple EOs, I didn't count them before coming
- 23:21on here, sorry about that, together have really
- 23:24changed the framework of what is possible in
- 23:29the nuclear space, specifically, and in the nuclear
- 23:33space launch space. The Department of Energy
- 23:36has been tasked to no longer just model, which
- 23:40it had been kind of its modus operandi for the
- 23:43last decade or so. computer simulations, a lot
- 23:48of paper reactors, if I may paraphrase the late
- 23:51Admiral Rickover. Instead, they have been tasked
- 23:55to build pilot programs, pilot machines, with
- 24:00developers, many of whom are targeting... data
- 24:03center clients, obviously, but also targeting
- 24:07space and maritime deployment. And so this is
- 24:12then, along with the executive orders dealing
- 24:14with commercial space industry, has really lit
- 24:19a fire under the developer community to work
- 24:22together to move forward with deployment, as
- 24:24well as really engage NASA, the DOE, the Nuclear
- 24:29Regulatory Commission, and other agencies to
- 24:32push for a more rapid acceleration and deployment
- 24:38of these systems. Now, these systems, to deploy
- 24:44these systems, this is not new. And what I really
- 24:46want to do in this next part, going through this
- 24:48history, and by all means, if you have questions,
- 24:50please feel free to put them in the Q &A. But
- 24:53it's to go through kind of where the authorities
- 24:56are. Because this is not, as I said before, NASA
- 25:00doesn't hold the authorities. DOE doesn't hold
- 25:03all the authorities. The NRC doesn't hold all
- 25:05of the authorities. So let's go to the next slide.
- 25:07And let me walk you through a little bit of what
- 25:10is required. Now, you'll notice the image on
- 25:12your right is the Mars Perseverance Rover. This
- 25:15is really my introduction to nuclear space technology.
- 25:21In the back side of this, in the upper right
- 25:24of the image of the rover is a MMRTG, a multi
- 25:29-emission thermoelectric electric radioisotopic
- 25:32generator. It's a mouthful. It's easier to say
- 25:36it's a plutonium battery. This system was launched
- 25:41in the early 2020s and is still operating without
- 25:46flaw on Mars to this day. How was it done? Well,
- 25:52the Atomic Energy Act, which I mentioned previously,
- 25:56set up in 1954, established a a system of licensure
- 26:01for developers who wanted to work in nuclear
- 26:06space. And it said specifically that utilization
- 26:10facilities, reactors, fission reactors, would
- 26:14be held, would require a license in order to
- 26:20be built and operated. Likewise, non -fission
- 26:25systems, power systems, either be they from uranium
- 26:30source material, byproduct material that's reprocessed
- 26:34or removed from, that's created in the handling
- 26:38and processing of uranium, or special nuclear
- 26:41material, including things like americium and
- 26:44plutonium. All of those also require a license
- 26:47for handling and building into new systems. So
- 26:51these licensing, this licensing requirement is
- 26:54true of every individual on this call. It's true
- 26:57of almost every government agency, including
- 27:00NASA, the FAA, the Department of Transportation.
- 27:04It is true of the Department of Defense or Department
- 27:09of War, except in one circumstance. It is not
- 27:13true of the Department of Energy or the Nuclear
- 27:17Regulatory Commission. These are for purposes
- 27:19of law. These are legal non -people. who do not,
- 27:24according to AEA 101 and 110A, require a license
- 27:30to build a reactor, to possess special nuclear
- 27:34by -product or source material. Likewise, the
- 27:37Department of War would, if it was operating
- 27:40in just a normal manner, they would also require
- 27:46licensure, but if operating for military purposes,
- 27:49and the President says so, and the Secretary
- 27:52of Energy says, yes, Mr. President, indeed, they
- 27:55can operate and these systems without a license.
- 28:01It's a very strange structure. I don't know why
- 28:04Congress created it that way, but that is what
- 28:06they did. So when you get into a question of
- 28:11NASA space launch, well, NASA then needs to have
- 28:17either a license from the Nuclear Regulatory
- 28:20Commission, or they need to proceed in partnership
- 28:24with the Department of Energy or the Nuclear
- 28:25Regulatory Commission. Now, you can't talk about
- 28:28licensing without also talking about liability.
- 28:31And I mentioned this earlier in talking about
- 28:33the Price Anderson Act of 1957. This act sets
- 28:39up a system whereby nuclear incidents are the
- 28:44individuals who may be held liable for a nuclear
- 28:47incident. can be indemnified by the federal government.
- 28:51Within the DOE framework, what it means is that
- 28:54any individual contractor who has an incident
- 29:00tied to a DOE contract and they are performing
- 29:07under instruction by DOE, they can be indemnified
- 29:12for public liability. This is an important point.
- 29:17it's a mandatory clause in all such contracts
- 29:20with the Department of Energy. So we'll get into
- 29:24how this works in just a second. Let's go to
- 29:26the next one because we'll walk through this.
- 29:29I covered most of this. So the NRC system for
- 29:32our purposes here is a little bit less important.
- 29:35It's tied to output. There's an insurance component.
- 29:40In both instances, the system caps the per incident
- 29:47indemnification to about 16 billion dollars.
- 29:51Yeah move on to the next slide if you would.
- 29:55Thank you. In addition to this there is public
- 29:58law 85804. This is an indemnification that comes
- 30:03out of the cold war and excuse me it allows the
- 30:08government to grant extraordinary contractual
- 30:12relief to its contractors that operate in the
- 30:16national defense. Oftentimes in the nuclear enterprise,
- 30:19this will be granted oftentimes for those individuals
- 30:23who are looking to find sealed sources or special
- 30:28nuclear material in a war zone. Often that's
- 30:31done by contractor staff who will go behind the
- 30:33line, track down material and bring it back to
- 30:36the U .S. It's also provided to DOE contractors
- 30:42who are doing a lot of the testing work at the
- 30:45national laboratories or elsewhere, dealing with
- 30:48nuclear materials in more dramatic situations.
- 30:55So it covers a lot of activities. It is available
- 30:59to the Department of Energy, to NASA, DOT, DOW.
- 31:05It does require secretarial sign -off, although
- 31:07there was a slight change recently making it
- 31:10a little bit easier for the Secretary of War
- 31:12to delegate the authority. It is unique though,
- 31:16while Price Anderson has a cap, public law 85804
- 31:20is potential unlimited liability for third party
- 31:23claims against government contractors, which
- 31:26is why for years it has required secretarial
- 31:28sign -off. So theoretically, it would be possible
- 31:31under a federal contract for to put a nuclear
- 31:35powered satellite or a surface power system on
- 31:39Mars or on the moon by NASA for NASA to provide
- 31:43publicly 85804 coverage to that contractor. Okay,
- 31:47I'm going to take a drink and let's move to the
- 31:49next slide. The joys of losing your voice in
- 31:54the middle of a CLE. So there's a deep history
- 31:58of US nuclear space launches, as I've mentioned
- 32:01before. This goes back even before the list here.
- 32:05I just captured some of the big ones. Back into
- 32:09the 1960, you have Transit 4A being launched.
- 32:17The Apollo 11 program brought a radioisotope
- 32:22thermo electric generator onto the lunar surface
- 32:25in the mid late 60s. My personal favorites, just
- 32:29because showing my age, they're as old as I am.
- 32:32The Voyager probes, which are still operating
- 32:33to this day on the plutonium batteries that were
- 32:37attached to them in the mid 70s. all the way
- 32:42down to the Perseverance rover, which landed
- 32:45on Mars in 2021. How is this done? So let's go
- 32:49to the next slide. This is through kind of an
- 32:56inter -agency collaboration. As I mentioned,
- 32:59NASA must have a license under normal circumstances.
- 33:03It's a person for purposes of the Atomic Energy
- 33:05Act. What the departments do in order to prevent
- 33:09NASA from needing to go through the rigmarole
- 33:12of a NRC license is they create a partnership
- 33:16between the interagency departments. NASA becomes,
- 33:22through this MOU and a related interagency agreement,
- 33:26a contractor essentially for the Department of
- 33:28Energy. to deliver a nuclear battery in space.
- 33:33I'm being a little glib. This isn't exactly how
- 33:35it works, but for purposes of our understanding,
- 33:38it is an MOU to an Economy Act transaction wherein,
- 33:45Economy Act transactions for those who aren't
- 33:47aware, this is under 31 USC 1535, an agency can
- 33:53procure from a sister agency goods or services
- 33:56that are generally unavailable on the marketplace.
- 33:59Well, generally, you can't go to the local store
- 34:02to buy a plutonium battery to put on your voyage
- 34:05or spacecraft. You just can't. So the Economy
- 34:09Act allows NASA to enter into an agreement with
- 34:12the Department of Energy for these systems. The
- 34:15Department of Energy, kind of a little bit tongue
- 34:18in cheek, says to NASA, great, here's the system
- 34:21that we want to deliver you to deliver in space.
- 34:24they sign the interagency agreement because it's
- 34:28an interagency agreement with the writ or an
- 34:30agreement with the risk of public liability for
- 34:33a nuclear incident, DOE's Price Anderson Act
- 34:37automatically applies by virtue of the way AEA
- 34:41170 or the Price Anderson Amendments Act is written
- 34:44to that relationship. And if you look at the
- 34:48most recent MOU between the department and NASA
- 34:51excerpted on the right, the department and signed
- 34:55by the Secretary of Energy and the NASA Administrator
- 34:57pursuant to presidential instruction, the Department
- 35:03of Energy was required to provide this coverage,
- 35:08this Price Anderson indemnification coverage,
- 35:10to NASA in addition to the materials for future
- 35:13NASA fission systems. All right, that was a lot.
- 35:17Let's go to the next slide because this system
- 35:20works fairly well for NASA authorizations and
- 35:26civilian space launch. Likewise, if the Department
- 35:29of War wants to produce a uranium -powered satellite
- 35:34into space, they have similar authorities. They
- 35:37could use Section 91B of the Atomic Energy Act.
- 35:42which would allow them to self -regulate for
- 35:45purposes of nuclear licensing. And then they
- 35:49can, as the Department of War grant public liability
- 35:5185804 indemnification to their contractors for
- 35:56the construction and launch of that vehicle.
- 35:59That works really well. It's less clear how well
- 36:03this works in a commercial space because there
- 36:08are no, there's no one clearing house agency
- 36:11to manage all of this. Space nuclear systems
- 36:15have distinct risks, and most of the risk lies
- 36:18in two domains, launch hazard and reentry, which
- 36:24is why perhaps the new regulatory considerations
- 36:27should be brought in. How do you handle a purely
- 36:30commercial launch with a purely commercial power
- 36:35system that's nuclear -based if the NRC is not
- 36:40regulating it? Now, let me take us down a little
- 36:44aside here. Historically, the NRC hasn't been
- 36:48willing to. Now, we are seeing with the executive
- 36:51orders that were listed earlier and some of the
- 36:53work that's going on in regulatory reform at
- 36:56the NRC, a greater willingness to work in this
- 36:59domain. But historically, it has been the position
- 37:03that the NRC will regulate only on the ground
- 37:07and only in the domestic US. That makes some
- 37:12amount of sense here and in truth week There's
- 37:14a way that you could do that for commercial launch
- 37:18if you're just licensing the material and not
- 37:22dealing with What happens to it when it gets
- 37:25into space now? that's that you'll still do a
- 37:29safety analysis report, you'll still have to
- 37:31have authorization authority from the launch
- 37:33authorities, but the NRC could play a role as
- 37:37a licensing authority for the possession and
- 37:39handling of that material while it's sitting
- 37:44on the launch pad and before it goes up. However,
- 37:51the questions of Is that enough? And does the
- 37:55system work? They're really coming into focus
- 37:57now with some of the activities that are going
- 38:00on at NASA and within the rest of the federal
- 38:05government. So next slide. If you've been tracking
- 38:08this area, the president in April, or the NASA
- 38:13administrator actually in April, and the, oh,
- 38:16no, one too many. Back. There you go. Sorry,
- 38:26the White House and NASA have started and kicked
- 38:30off a series of activities that are really designed
- 38:34to put humans back on the moon. This is the Project
- 38:37Ignition. has started now. NASA is actively putting
- 38:45out requests for proposals. The DOE national
- 38:48laboratories as well as the Jet Propulsion Laboratory
- 38:51are actively seeking to improve the space infrastructure
- 38:56and the manufacturing infrastructure to meet
- 38:59the requirements. Phase two of the project will
- 39:03require the establishment of moon base operating.
- 39:07by 2029, or at least to start in 2029 with a
- 39:11semi permanent crew presence in 2032. This will
- 39:16depend, you know, to a large degree on the presence
- 39:20and availability of nuclear power systems on
- 39:25the moon. Okay, let's go into the next slide.
- 39:29And we'll talk a little bit more about it. This
- 39:31project is going forward on a phased approach.
- 39:35As I said, we're in this early stages. By 2028
- 39:39though, and this is one of the bigger ones, NASA
- 39:43intends to launch Space Reactor One Freedom.
- 39:47So SR -1 Freedom, it will be a nuclear thermal
- 39:49propulsion reactor that would be a first of a
- 39:54kind system. Word on this, the Department of
- 39:59War had started a similar program. back while
- 40:03I was still working at DOE, which I helped partner
- 40:05on, called Project Draco, which was a nuclear
- 40:10-powered cislunar, so between the Earth and the
- 40:13lunar orbits, system that would use a nuclear
- 40:19reactor that, and I'm gonna get out on the edge
- 40:23of my knowledge of physics, but basically would
- 40:25have a... I like to think of it as a funnel,
- 40:29an exhaust, I don't know, a propulsion system
- 40:31that would allow for photons, hydrogen photons,
- 40:35to power the reactor and lift it into different
- 40:38orbits to move it around between the Earth and
- 40:42the Moon. SR1 freedom, to my understanding, is
- 40:45intended to operate in a similar space. And we'll
- 40:50use that nuclear thermal propulsion system for
- 40:53mobility. operating in Earth orbit. But this
- 40:59is all obviously a step towards future systems
- 41:02that will use nuclear thermal propulsion to get
- 41:05us to Mars and beyond. As I mentioned, by 2030
- 41:09NASA intends to have a nuclear reactor deployed
- 41:12on the lunar surface. Now, all of this is, from
- 41:16a regulatory and statutory perspective, relatively
- 41:20easy. It can be done as NASA did the Voyager
- 41:25program or Mars 2020 in partnership between NASA,
- 41:29the Departments of Energy and then war and the
- 41:32Nuclear Regulatory Commission, as well as using
- 41:35the NSPM 30, sorry, I said the wrong one, NSPM
- 41:4120, excuse me, requirements authorizing launch.
- 41:46That can be done, but What I am seeing in industry
- 41:51is an increased interest in pure commercial place.
- 41:54How do I get my data center on orbit powered
- 41:59by a nuclear battery? Well, that's a different
- 42:04question. And if you want to use a SpaceX or
- 42:07a Blue Origin rocket, it's even more of a question.
- 42:12So such an activity right now would be purely
- 42:14commercial. And so it would be subject to the
- 42:18commercial spaces. Launch Act and its obligations
- 42:23as well as the NRC licensing. So let's walk through
- 42:25a little bit of what that means in the next slide.
- 42:28As I mentioned, for the nuclear payload itself,
- 42:32you would need an NRC license under such a system.
- 42:35You would need to go through the most likely
- 42:38a possession, specific authorization, specific
- 42:42license. Under part 70 or maybe part 40 or 630
- 42:47depending on whether it's source byproduct or
- 42:50special nuclear material And you would move forward
- 42:53in With that license NRC has to show a willingness
- 42:58to do that You'll have to run through all of
- 43:00the traps to get that license, which is not an
- 43:04insignificant ask Then you need to get through
- 43:08the authorization authority of the FAA under
- 43:12the FAA's regs, part of which would require insurance
- 43:18and indemnification. And this is where we are
- 43:22seeing, from legal perspective, this interface
- 43:25between industry and insurance industry and developers
- 43:30of significant disconnect. The CSLA itself gives
- 43:35a three -tier liability structure. Tier one,
- 43:39the licensee launch provider would have to obtain
- 43:46liability insurance or demonstrate financial
- 43:50responsibility for the reasonably expected maximum
- 43:53probable loss of third party claims not to exceed
- 43:58$500 million. So let's stop there. That means
- 44:01$500 million of insurance at the outset. When
- 44:07you tack on a nuclear system as part of the payload
- 44:10of the launch, the availability or the willingness
- 44:14of insurers to cover up to 500 million, it becomes
- 44:19much more questionable. And I've talked with
- 44:23companies in the industry who are working primarily
- 44:25with government clients right now. When looking
- 44:28at a pure commercial launch, this becomes a deal
- 44:33breaker for them because the insurance industry
- 44:35has yet to say, as far as I have seen and as
- 44:39far as my contacts in the industry have seen,
- 44:42a willingness to move forward and provide insurance
- 44:46to meet the tier one obligations when a nuclear
- 44:49payload is part of the equation. If you can get
- 44:53past that, then tier two is relatively easy.
- 44:57This is a government indemnification up to 1
- 45:00.5 billion as adjusted to inflation and subject
- 45:03to appropriations by Congress. That's fairly
- 45:07straightforward that it's not necessarily deal
- 45:11breaker. Tier three then kicks in and becomes
- 45:14another potential concern. If there's an incident
- 45:18it's above and the incident results in liability
- 45:21exceeding two billion dollars total aggregate
- 45:24between the insurance and the 1 .5 from Congress,
- 45:28the licensee would be responsible for any and
- 45:31all financial harms or liabilities above that
- 45:35point. It's unlikely, to be frank, for an accident
- 45:41to result in $2 billion of liability. As I said
- 45:45towards the outset, a nuclear power system is
- 45:49not the same as a nuclear bomb. You're dealing
- 45:52with much smaller quantities, much lower hazard
- 45:56categories. it is unlikely that two billion dollars
- 46:00wood of damage could occur. However, if it did,
- 46:04that becomes an existential threat to many businesses.
- 46:08There is this question then whether or not the
- 46:13CSLA as a system is even set up to deal with
- 46:17a nuclear launch. There's also a question of
- 46:18whether or not insurance will get comfortable
- 46:21with ensuring nuclear power systems. Now, this
- 46:25could happen right now. The data set is in the
- 46:2820s of launches, all government -based. As NASA
- 46:32moves forward with Project Ignition and with
- 46:36the requirements under NSTM 3, there's going
- 46:38to be more data that's available to the marketplace.
- 46:42So perhaps this is something that will work itself
- 46:46out in the months and years to come. It's really
- 46:50a little bit unclear right now, but there is
- 46:52at least from my vantage point in talking to
- 46:55industry, a bit of a regulatory gap that exists
- 46:59here wherein the risk of a radiological incident
- 47:04is overblown to some degree by the insurers who
- 47:09are risk -averse, to put it mildly. So let's
- 47:13move on to the next slide. So you have this gap,
- 47:19and I've talked about this, current space nuclear
- 47:21systems you're still reliant upon an indemnification
- 47:26framework that's focused on launch, but that
- 47:33when considering a nuclear payload, the insurance
- 47:37industry is very skeptical. There is no government
- 47:41specific under CSLA. indemnification coverage
- 47:46for a nuclear issue. And if you're purely commercial
- 47:50because the DOE Price Anderson requirements are
- 47:53driven out of contract for DOE, that's unavailable.
- 47:59And the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's Price
- 48:01Anderson indemnification coverage extends solely
- 48:04to reactor developers. So the most likely scenario
- 48:09for a satellite developer would be for a radioisotope
- 48:13power system, not a reactor. You'd be under a
- 48:17possession license, which does not then come
- 48:20with the identification coverage of Price Anderson.
- 48:23So that is all problematic for nuclear -specific
- 48:28payloads. Space launches would also likely not
- 48:35have public law 8504 coverage. because that coverage
- 48:40is really limited to incidences of national security.
- 48:45And so it's probably not available for commercial
- 48:48play. This means that you have a really big first
- 48:52mover problem where it's unclear how a developer
- 48:56who wants to just purely operate in the commercial
- 48:59space will ever get their system put on a satellite
- 49:04or put on a rover, a commercial rover that would
- 49:07land on Mars. or the moon's surface. So a new
- 49:11framework and some adjustments to the existing
- 49:14licensing and indemnification framework for commercial
- 49:17operations seem likely to be needed. So let's
- 49:20go to the next slide and we'll wrap up here with
- 49:23if we have time for any questions. You could
- 49:27potentially, the Congress could potentially amend
- 49:31the Price -Anderson Act. I think this would be
- 49:34very hard, to be frank, in part because the Congressional
- 49:39Budget Office has a scoring requirement for changes
- 49:44to statute like this that would potentially implicate
- 49:47the federal treasury. Because this, you're talking
- 49:51about 16 billion or more per incident of liability,
- 49:57this is going to be very hard for CBO to get
- 50:00behind. Such costs would need to be offset elsewhere
- 50:05in the federal budget in order to move forward
- 50:08pursuant to congressional rules. And I have a
- 50:12very hard time personally seeing that ever happen.
- 50:15That's one thing. You could potentially amend
- 50:18CSLA. You could raise the indemnification totals.
- 50:22You could raise the insurance totals requirements.
- 50:26You could create a potential carve out for payload
- 50:30-specific insurance that might be separate and
- 50:35distinct. This is potentially doable, although
- 50:39I think it may face the same problems as Price
- 50:42Anderson if you're requiring a government indemnification,
- 50:47same issues with CBO scoring. You could potentially
- 50:51develop specialized insurance markets that are
- 50:53government -backed, perhaps a government reinsurance
- 50:56for potentially hazardous space launches. This,
- 51:01I think, has more likelihood of success, simply
- 51:04because you could fund something going forward,
- 51:08have people pay, industry pay in, and then it
- 51:11becomes a simple matter of reinsuring and it's
- 51:14less direct exposure, uncapped exposure to the
- 51:18treasury. In addition, you could for the authorization
- 51:23and licensing of these systems, there's a potential
- 51:27to modify the Atomic Energy Act itself and the
- 51:31regulations that go with it. Most of the regulations
- 51:34tied with Reactors fall within the section 50,
- 51:4151, 52, 53, 57 of the Title X of the Code of
- 51:47Federal Regulations. They're designed for terrestrial
- 51:51reactor operations, power reactors. A fission
- 51:54surface power system is fundamentally different
- 51:57because it's not running critical. The fuel is
- 52:02not irradiated. It is really material, uranium
- 52:05material, in standby mode until it's delivered
- 52:08to the surface of whatever celestial body will
- 52:12receive it. So you could potentially say, yes,
- 52:15this is a reactor once landed and deployed, but
- 52:19we're going to regulate it as material and assess
- 52:23its risk as material. If you do that, then you're
- 52:27into the easier, relatively speaking, licensing
- 52:31structures that the NRC and a lot of industries
- 52:35are familiar with in terms of possessing source
- 52:38byproduct and special nuclear material. That
- 52:41could work. And that's probably the most likely
- 52:45path forward for commercial, pure commercial
- 52:50space launches going forward in the years to
- 52:53come. That is a lot to digest, I know. And I'm
- 52:58happy to take any and all questions that you
- 53:01might have at this point. And I think that is
- 53:04my last slide. Oh yeah, there's me. So please,
- 53:09I'd love to hear anything that you might have
- 53:11to ask. I'm currently not seeing any questions
- 53:21so far, but might just be a moment. Do you have
- 53:25any other closing remarks that you'd like to
- 53:27make while I check our help desk for requests?
- 53:30Yeah, no, I would say that this seems like a
- 53:37scary possibility to a lot of people. The notion
- 53:42of blasting a nuclear reactor into space May
- 53:48seem unnerving. I've been in this industry. I
- 53:51had no background in nuclear when I came into
- 53:53this industry when I joined the Department of
- 53:55Energy. And there are things that can go seriously
- 53:58wrong. We've all read Chernobyl, Midnight in
- 54:01Chernobyl, or watched the miniseries. We know
- 54:05what happened at Three Mile Island. The thing
- 54:08that gives me great hope, though, generally,
- 54:11is that this is an industry that because the
- 54:14things that have gone bad have gone so bad, they
- 54:17are highly safety conscious. And most of the
- 54:21developers understand that one faux pas, not
- 54:26to be glib about it, is existential for their
- 54:30business, for their reputation, and could be
- 54:32for human life. And so I find that most of them
- 54:36are very much aware. of safety work culture and
- 54:41the need to operate in a safe environment, as
- 54:43are the regulators. So when you look at the history
- 54:48of space launch in the US, of nuclear space launch,
- 54:52the United States has done it safely. You have
- 54:54not really seen or heard of incidents here that
- 54:59are that have posed any real threat to the human
- 55:04environment. The Soviets and the reentry in the
- 55:071960s is a different matter. The Soviets did
- 55:10a lot of things very poorly. And so I don't think
- 55:14I would ever advocate for a full and open transformation
- 55:17of the nuclear space for every nation without
- 55:22a safety culture and without safety regulations
- 55:24in place. But for us, here in the US, even with
- 55:28regulatory reforms, I feel fairly comfortable
- 55:30about this. So first question, I think. All right.
- 55:36Can you talk more about legal considerations
- 55:39for nuclear propulsion versus RTGs? Propulsion
- 55:43likely would be considered a utilization facility.
- 55:46So would propulsion technology being included
- 55:48in Price Anderson coverage? Yeah. Let me get
- 55:50into that. So Radiothermal electric generators,
- 55:55radio heating unit, radio isotope heating units,
- 55:58these are systems that support space operations
- 56:02based on decay heat. So the New Horizons spacecraft
- 56:05that's currently moving out of the atmosphere,
- 56:08the Voyager spacecrafts that are moving out of
- 56:11the atmosphere, these are powered by RTGs. The
- 56:16plutonium decays. It produces heat. The system
- 56:19transforms that heat into electricity. It is
- 56:23a very, I think it's very static as far as I
- 56:27understand it. There aren't moving parts in this
- 56:29really. And they operate safely with minute amounts,
- 56:34relatively speaking, of material and will for
- 56:37years. Obviously the Voyagers are running almost
- 56:4050 years now. Those systems are low risk. They
- 56:45are relatively, they are easily tested. They
- 56:50are, if you were to do them commercially, they
- 56:52would be, they would be governed under possession
- 56:57licenses for nuclear material, most likely. Nuclear
- 57:01thermal propulsion is, as Maxine writes here,
- 57:06would be considered a utilization facility. Utilization
- 57:10facilities under law, under the Atomic Energy
- 57:12Act, are really those that split the atom. That
- 57:15there's an active nuclear reaction that would
- 57:17split uranium. most likely, and then produce
- 57:23a self -sustaining criticality and reaction in
- 57:26the system. Those are the ones that we have in
- 57:29our operating nuclear power plants in this country.
- 57:32And so they would be likely considered a utilization
- 57:36facility. The distinction I was getting at early
- 57:39towards the end there was that it doesn't necessarily,
- 57:42that is the way the regulations are written right
- 57:44now. The designs are in that way. But in the
- 57:48event that you are putting a propulsion system
- 57:51or even a fission surface power system on the
- 57:53moon and you're not operating it until you're
- 57:56in orbit, you theoretically could regulate it
- 58:01as material here terrestrially. I don't know
- 58:05if it's a great idea. It is an option that I
- 58:08think I personally view it as legally viable
- 58:11under the current Atomic Energy Act. It's not
- 58:14in reg. but there's not a lot in the NRC reg
- 58:18about space launch anyway, so this is an area
- 58:20that we'll keep an eye on and see what develops
- 58:22over time. As to Price Anderson coverage, if
- 58:26it was considered a utilization facility under
- 58:29NRC regulations, and it was regulated as such,
- 58:35then presumably the NRC's regulatory structure
- 58:38would also necessitate Price Anderson coverage
- 58:40for it. It's unclear whether or not If you start
- 58:45it on terrestrially, put it in orbit, and you
- 58:48consider it a utilization facility subject to
- 58:51NRC regs that whole way, then yeah, potentially
- 58:54Price Anderson could kick in for the entire time.
- 58:58And if it was a private sector developer, then
- 59:00they would have to pay into the Price Anderson
- 59:02fund under the NRC regs under AEA 170C. And if
- 59:08there was an incident, then there would be a
- 59:10payout. I think it's unlikely that that would
- 59:13happen simply because the utilities who pay into
- 59:18the Price Anderson fund under the NRC regulations
- 59:20would likely not want to bear the risk of reentry
- 59:25of such a facility should reentry occur because
- 59:29it's likely that a decayed orbit that results
- 59:32in reentry of a nuclear thermal propulsion craft
- 59:35that's regulated as a utilization facility, it
- 59:38would be a high profile topic. It would be subject
- 59:41to immense litigation and potentially a lot of
- 59:44potential liability, whether real or imagined,
- 59:48for the developers. So I think that it's, I think
- 59:51it's, you'll need an amendment some way down
- 59:53the line to deal with it and that it's unlikely
- 59:56to be fully regulated and fully brought into
- 1:00:00the current NRC Price Anderson. If it's a DOE
- 1:00:03authorized system. It's a DOE contract. It's
- 1:00:07going to be DOE Price Anderson. It's very straightforward.
- 1:00:11That is what NASA will do with SR1 freedom. Unless
- 1:00:16they do it on their own under 85804 authority,
- 1:00:19they're going to use the DOE Price Anderson coverage,
- 1:00:22as they've done historically. All right. All
- 1:00:30right. Next scene says thank you. All right.
- 1:00:34for questions today. Thank you so much Stuart
- 1:00:37for an excellent presentation today and thank
- 1:00:39you so much to our audience for joining us. Have
- 1:00:41a great day everybody. Thank you all.