Latest / The Buckeye Weekly Podcast / Is Michigan The Best Football Team In The Nation?
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everybody, Welcome to the Buckeye Weekly Podcast. I am Tony Gerdeman
- 0:04here as always with Tom Moore. Tom. How's it going? Oh,
- 0:09Tony, it is as always because it's Michigan Monday, and you're not going
- 0:13to believe this, but Michigan played an overmatched opponent and won by pretty much
- 0:19exactly thirty points or so again and gave up one score in the game.
- 0:25Again, Tony, do you remember the movie Groundhog Day? M Yeah,
- 0:32I do. But Tom, this was actually a little bit different because with
- 0:36this win, Michigan now moves to improves to one and four against the spread
- 0:40on the season. So good job Michigan covering this game by plenty and doing
- 0:47so I think by the end of the second quarter, so at the first
- 0:51half there twenty eight nothing of their forty five seven win. This was something
- 0:57at performance and what we're gonna talk about Michigan. We're gonna talk out the
- 1:00rest of the nation as well in this and talk about Ohio State as well.
- 1:03But this was as dominant as we've seen them, and they've been dominant
- 1:07all year long. They were more interested in being dominant in this one for
- 1:11a while, and then it just it's this, it's the matter of factness,
- 1:19the coldness. The Nebraska is helping them a great deal, but Michigan
- 1:25does a great job of taking advantage of gifts that you give them, and
- 1:30the the the undermatch, the overmatched opponent that they are against Michigan. Michigan
- 1:37is like, that's that's right in our wheelhouse. This is right in the
- 1:38sweet spot. And this was another one and forty five seven. Nebraska was
- 1:46never in this. Michigan had what one bad drive one three and out.
- 1:49Other than that, they are moving the ball down the field, running it,
- 1:55throwing it well enough, making ridiculous catches I'm sure we'll talk about.
- 1:59And it's still just four hundred and fifty seven yards of total offense. It's
- 2:07it's nothing blows you away. But at the end, it's just like this
- 2:10was never a game, This was never in doubt. This was complete and
- 2:15utter domination. And Nebraska could have played this game a thousand times and lost
- 2:20on and ten. This did look like the most dominant performance we've seen from
- 2:24Michigan so far this year. And this is the best probably of the teams
- 2:30that Michigan has played so far this year. And I don't think that's a
- 2:34complete coincidence, because Michigan has four long, long stretches in this first month
- 2:40just look bored. And it was just, you know, they knew you
- 2:45could write a W on the schedule for Michigan for each of the first four
- 2:49probably five games in sharpie, and you could have done it in January and
- 2:53not had any concern that you were going to have to figure out a way
- 2:55to get that W off the schedule and change it to an L. They
- 3:00were never in any danger in the first month. This was the first one
- 3:02where it was like, Okay, this is a team that's theoretically has like
- 3:07an actual coach and some decent players, and okay, there, you know,
- 3:13it's not Rutgers, it's not Bowling Green. Okay, it's I guess
- 3:16theoretically kind of an interesting game. And Michigan came out and just went boom
- 3:23boom boom boomm. And I mean you mentioned the incredible catch that was J.
- 3:25J. McCarthy to Roman Wilson, and it was pretty good coverage.
- 3:30It was not necessarily a great idea to throw it. But we've talked last
- 3:35week about J. J. McCarthy and Roman Wilson seeming like they probably had
- 3:38gotten you know, kind of figured something out and had a pretty good connection,
- 3:42pretty good chemistry, and they just you know, J. J.
- 3:46McCarthy put it in a spot where only Roman Wilson in the back of the
- 3:49defender's helmet could catch it, and those two things stayed together and they had
- 3:53a real fancy touchdown that everyone went ooh, And you saw that on the
- 3:55highlights all day and all night, but it was just it was just sort
- 4:00of very efficient, very effective, and they just sort of strangled the life
- 4:03out of Nebraska. And you know, I saw you on Saturday, Saturday
- 4:08or Sunday tweeting out, you know, information about how terrible the passing offenses
- 4:14at Michigan has faced so far this year are And you know, I think
- 4:16that's useful context here because I think we have and we can get to what
- 4:23I tweeted over the weekend response to that later in the show. You know,
- 4:27I think anytime you say anything positive about Michigan, everyone wants to do
- 4:30well. Actually you about how you know, well they haven't played anyone,
- 4:34It's like, yeah, yeah, we agree, we completely agree. And
- 4:39then if you want to say, well, Michigan hasn't played anyone yet,
- 4:42then everyone wants to well, actually they didn't play anyone last year, and
- 4:45then they beat Ohio State, so and it's like, yeah, again,
- 4:47we agree, we all recognize the facts on the ground here. But you
- 4:51know, this is this is there are things to learn from some of these,
- 4:55you know, some of these games, whether they're good or competitive games
- 4:59or not. And so that's what we're here to do, is to discuss
- 5:00them and not necessarily take a side and make a you know, this is
- 5:04not stephen A. Smith and Skip Bayliss, you know, Oh no,
- 5:08actually, actually, you know, Michigan's never won a football game. Like,
- 5:13that's not what we're here to do. We're here to you know,
- 5:15sometimes where you're going to hear things you like. Sometimes you're gonna hear things
- 5:17you don't like. That's okay, you're you're not actually a three year old.
- 5:21You're allowed to do that. That's okay. As long as you hear
- 5:25things, do you know you're doing okay? I did like some of the
- 5:30responses to you know, Michigan not playing anybody. Then they're like, did
- 5:33you see what Bowling Green did the Georgia Tech Like, I'm not sure that's
- 5:38the proper barometer. We want to use. Also, the quarterback for Bowling
- 5:42Green against Georgia Tech was kind of bays Lack, who did not play against
- 5:46Michigan. Not that Bowling Green as any great shakes. I mean, they're
- 5:48one and three on the season against FBS opponents like and the one being the
- 5:54Georgia Tech and got annihilated at home last weekend by Ohio University. Ohio,
- 6:00I actually beat them worse than Michigan did, thirty eight seven to thirty one
- 6:03six. So you know, is Ohio better than Michigan? Well, I
- 6:09mean what I'm hearing is it's the what was that twenty thirteen NCUBAA tournament twenty
- 6:14fourteen incidentally one of those all over again. I mean, I don't know
- 6:16what other conclusion you could possibly draw, Tony, Well, let's draw some
- 6:20conclusions about Michigan's running game, because it's still two hundred and forty nine yards
- 6:25and I can knitpick it if we want. We have talked about the influx
- 6:30of J. J. McCarthy running running the ball and projected that that would
- 6:34happen and it would make things look better and make things better, and I
- 6:38just look look better. They are better. And he did that rush two
- 6:42times for thirty yards, but a twenty one yard touchdown just using his legs
- 6:46being involved. There was a carry early on which on a read where you
- 6:50now know that he will do this, you have to recognize that you have
- 6:56to pay attention to it, and so it is helping. It still has
- 7:00necessarily opened up any big plays in the running game. Blake or sixteen carries
- 7:04for seventy four yards, long rush of fifteen yards, Donovan Edwards fourteen for
- 7:10forty eight another just pedestrian outing by him, long carry of nine yards.
- 7:15Kalle Mullings had a twenty yard touchdown. Right, he's playing more now and
- 7:18I've seen people say maybe Blake Korm is banged up. If he is,
- 7:21I don't know why you run him nine times in the first half of this
- 7:25game. Jim Harba has had an interesting way of letting his players heal by
- 7:31using them on the field and running them. If that's the case, going
- 7:34back to last year at Blake Korm, but they were it looked like they
- 7:39were trying to get Downovan Edwards going in this one and he was getting the
- 7:42ball early, and it's still just not happening. I went through and check
- 7:46to the success rate success rate this week twenty one point four percent. Just
- 7:51three of his fourteen carries met the success standards of five yards on first and
- 7:58ten seventy percent of the yard, your yards on second down, or all
- 8:01of your yards on third or fourth down. Just three of his fourteen carries.
- 8:05And it continues to be something that I can harp on just because you
- 8:11know, it's better than saying, boy, these guys are really good.
- 8:15Again, like now that I'm trying to be critical, but we've got to
- 8:18find something to talk about. And just the way he closed this season last
- 8:22year, the last you know, six to eight weeks, is so completely
- 8:26different than what we're seeing here. Although Michigan did bring out they I think
- 8:31they've finally solidified their offensive lines and maybe things will pick up there. But
- 8:35overall, two hundred forty nine yards four point nine yards and carry, you
- 8:39can't really criticize it, even though I just spent a couple of minutes trying
- 8:46and so much of this is the game was over at halfway through the third
- 8:52quarter. They're putting Jack Tittle, the backup quarterback in so like at that
- 8:54point everything is done. That's that's where you just stop the stack count,
- 9:00right, there and analyze from there. Overall, just I still want to
- 9:03see more explosion, but they're getting They're getting the job done, especially on
- 9:07short yardage. Yeah, the rushing attack was what they needed it to be.
- 9:13And it feels like Blake corm is what he has always been when he's
- 9:16been reasonably healthy and they're moving. You know, it's not incredible, he's
- 9:20not. He didn't rip off any crazy long runs. He didn't, you
- 9:24know, it was it was just sort of efficient and they kept the chains
- 9:26moving. It feels like they maybe have found something with Kalle Mullings in short
- 9:31yardage and the way that Ohio State has maybe taken Chip train him, who
- 9:35maybe started the year as kind of the third guy and then now might be
- 9:39the second guy. It feels like Kalle Mullings might have kind of taken that
- 9:43role where he had a bunch of those kind of third and one, fourth
- 9:46and one carries for them just very efficiently, very effectively picked up first downs.
- 9:52It just they made it look very easy. He had the twenty yard
- 9:54er as you mentioned for the touchdown on one of them. It just it
- 9:58feels like they're doing what they need to be doing on the ground, and
- 10:03you know he's the the I looked up. I don't know if you're familiar
- 10:09with you. Probably I'm sure. Sure, I'm sure Tony, But I'm
- 10:11just not sure if the listeners writ large or familiar with college football nerds and
- 10:16they're One of the things they do is they have they measure how effective you
- 10:20are on a per play basis against your opponent compared to your opponents average.
- 10:26So if your opponents on average give up let's just say ten yards per pas
- 10:31attempt, and you throw for twelve yards per pass attempt against that same opponent,
- 10:37then you're twenty percent better than the you know, than than average against
- 10:41them. Michigan in rushing offense this year on a per harry basis against their
- 10:48opposition against these you know the Yes, the opposition has been weak, but
- 10:52the opposition has been weak when they've played other teams too. Ohio State,
- 10:56Michigan, sorry, has been third in rushing offense per harry against their opponents
- 11:01against their opponents averages, so they are among the best in the nation as
- 11:07far as being way ahead of what everyone else is doing against those same opponents.
- 11:09So that's way a way to sort of adjust for opponent and also adjust
- 11:15for tempo, so it's like a per play thing, but it's also an
- 11:18opponent adjusted thing. And the rushing offense is third in the country, and
- 11:22that they're thirteenth in passing offense pert tempt opponent adjusted per play as well.
- 11:28So I mean the offense has been you know, they're in the thirties.
- 11:31They haven't been. They got into the forties over the weekend against Nebraska,
- 11:33but you know, they have not put up the eighty one points that all
- 11:37Oregon put up in the one game, or you know, they're not putting
- 11:39up usc point totals. But they've been very effective on offense. I will
- 11:46tell you later there will there will be a quiz on where Michigan has not
- 11:50been up to standards and like not even close to up to standards. We'll
- 11:54get to that a little bit later, but I just thought that was very
- 11:56interesting, just for comparisons sake, Ohio State forty fifth in rushing, sixteenth
- 12:01in passing by those same metrics. Georgia, since we're gonna be talking about
- 12:05Georgia later, ninety fourth in rushing, thirty third in passing, So you
- 12:07know, Michigan is ahead of Ohio State in rushing ahead of Ohio State slightly
- 12:13in passing there in that per play sort of opponent adjusted metrics. So I
- 12:16just thought that was interesting. Contact to this whole conversation. Football is back
- 12:24in full swing with another week of epic games, and who's got you coming
- 12:26on the action for every single one of them. Draft Kings sports Book,
- 12:28an official sports betting partner of the NFL. New customers can bet five dollars
- 12:33on football and get two hundred dollars instantly in bonus bets. Nobody's missing out
- 12:35on the action this season. All Draft Kings customers can take advantage of two
- 12:39new offers every game this September. Get in on the NFL re action with
- 12:43Draft Kings sports Book. Download gap now and use code huddle up to sign
- 12:46up. New customers can bat just five dollars and take home two hundred instantly
- 12:48in bonus bets only in Draft King sports Book with code huddle lot. The
- 12:50crown is yours gambling problem called what a hundred Gambler or visit www dot one
- 12:54eight hundred gambler dot net. In New York call eight seven seven eight hope
- 12:58and y or tech hope and why. In Connecticut, help is available for
- 13:01problem gambling called eight eight eight seven eight nine seven seven seventy seven or visit
- 13:05CCPG dot org. Please play responsibly on behalf of Booth Hill, Casino and
- 13:09Resort, Kansas twenty one and over age varies by jistiction void in Ontario.
- 13:13See sportsbook, bat Draft, Kings dot com, slash football terms of responsible
- 13:16gaming resources bonus best expire seven days after a shoe in knowligibility and deposit restrictions
- 13:20apply. There is plenty of context to go around in terms of who they've
- 13:28played and what they've done. One thing I will say about Jim Harbaugh,
- 13:33he is trying to get everybody a varsity letter this season. Like he is
- 13:39putting anybody out there. If you're on the team, if you got up
- 13:41in the morning and you made it to the stadium, you are gonna see
- 13:45action. And I applaud him for that. He's getting everybody involved. Like
- 13:48he doesn't. Somebody would probably ask him like, hey, you know,
- 13:52why aren't you stat padding And he'd be like, what is stat padding?
- 13:54I don't, I'm not familiar with these two terms. What is this that
- 13:56you're I'm not You're gonna have explain this to me because like that has no
- 14:01interest for him. He's not trying to J. J. McCarthy's Heisman campaign
- 14:05is not something that pops into his head or anything like that. It's just
- 14:09like, well, we've done this and now let's go and do the next
- 14:13thing. And just very robot robotic in a in a like a mean robot
- 14:20way, like an AI Jason will Smith around type of way, not a
- 14:24robot like you know, Pauli's robot and Rocky four or whatever, you know,
- 14:28I Rocky three. I think this is these are dangerous robots, not
- 14:31that rock not the Pauli's robot couldn't be dangerous. I mean if that fell
- 14:35on you or running running over your toe or something like that. But let's
- 14:39talk about the Michigan defense and who they have faced this year, Tom,
- 14:45because I'm trying to figure out among these quarterbacks that they have faced this season,
- 14:50who who who has been the most impressive? Has it been Mason Garcia
- 14:54or Alex Flynn or Doug Bromfield or Jaden Majava or Camden or or Hayden team
- 15:01of Shack or Gavin Wimpst or Heinrich Harberg who opened the season as a tight
- 15:05end like they have faced absolutely nobody in terms of the quarterbacking on their schedule,
- 15:13and that's the schedule they got, so that's what they're playing. But
- 15:16the twenty five games that Michigan's opponents have played, the opposing quarterbacks, the
- 15:24quarterbacks that they faced have thrown for two hundred yards and two games. So
- 15:28that of the twenty five games, a quarterback that they have faced has thrown
- 15:33for two hundred yards twice. This year. Ohio State, they've faced four
- 15:39quarterbacks, three Power five or three FBS quarterbacks. Those guys have eleven two
- 15:43hundred yard passing games this year. One of them was against Ohio State.
- 15:46That was Austin Reid. Like with Western Kentucky throwing for two hundred and seven,
- 15:50Sam Hartman didn't do it. But you look at comparatively who they have
- 15:58faced, and it gets gets interesting because Michigan, the quarterbacks in Michigan has
- 16:03face Basically Michigan's past defense past efficiency defense right now is one oh eight and
- 16:10yet like if you remove the Michigan game from those quarterbacks, their past efficiency
- 16:15of those quarterbacks is like one ten point five one. Like, there's very
- 16:18little difference between those quarterbacks playing their normal schedule and playing Michigan, which is
- 16:26a little concerning other than the fact that Michigan continues to do what they're supposed
- 16:30to be doing, But it just gives you an idea of they're doing a
- 16:34Michigan's defense is doing against these quarterbacks what everybody else's defenses are doing against these
- 16:40quarterbacks. So that is a concern. Maybe compared to Ohio State, the
- 16:45quarterbacks that they've faced, their past efficiency is one hundred and fifty five point
- 16:51seven six. Now when those quarterbacks face Ohio State, the efficiency drops down
- 16:56to one oh four point two. So like there's a stark difference between everybody
- 17:00else for these quarterbacks when they face Ohio State as opposed to there's literally no
- 17:04difference when these quarterbacks are facing Ohio versus Michigan. Now, this is the
- 17:12numbers that I was giving you earlier on the opponent adjusted yards per play,
- 17:18So you know what what teams do versus you versus everyone else they've played on
- 17:22their same schedule. Those line up very closely with what you just talked about.
- 17:26So Ohio State and Michigan both very good against the rush. Michigan twelfth
- 17:32and per Harry Rushing, Ohio State eighteenth and per carry rushing past defense.
- 17:37Tony, Hey, you're not going to believe this. Ohio State eighth in
- 17:41the country in per play opponent adjusted passing Michigan one hundred and eight. That's
- 17:48that's what you're talking about there, where you know, you look at the
- 17:52top line numbers and it's like, yeah, well they've held all these teams
- 17:55in like almost no passing yards. But everyone's held those teams, you know,
- 17:57passing yards because they're all so it's actually Michigan giving up that many passing
- 18:03yards per play and like that's actually that's actually a little bit concerning. I
- 18:08strongly suspect they will not end up one hundred and eighth in the country in
- 18:12at you know, passing defense per attempt and on a per play oppon an
- 18:15adjusted basis. But if they're even half that, if they're fifty fourth,
- 18:21like that's a little bit concerning because that's you're going to face a Penn State
- 18:26team that can throw the ball a little bit. You're going to face an
- 18:27Ohio State team they can throw the ball a little bit. You're gonna face
- 18:30a Maryland team they can throw the ball a little bit. So you know,
- 18:33they're probably not going to look invincible forever this year. So you know,
- 18:37that's that if you're looking for something to you know, it's not a
- 18:41worry right now, but it's just something to kind of keep an eye on.
- 18:45I think I think that's it. And they just right now it's just
- 18:48kind of a question mark because they haven't faced anyone that can really stress them
- 18:52in that way, and they've been missing Will Johnson first a couple of the
- 18:55games. Yes, let's acknowledge that as well, but broadmore, yeah,
- 19:00I mean, so you've had there's a little bit of a reason, but
- 19:02you shouldn't need all of your starters to fold UNLV or East Carolina or Rutgers
- 19:10to you know, virtually nothing through the air. So that's just that's just
- 19:15sort of something to keep an eye on. And just again we'll provide some
- 19:19context here with Georgia. Georgia fifty sixth in the country against the rush and
- 19:25that same metrics sixth in the country against the past. So Michigan's one hundred
- 19:27literally one hundred and then one hundred and two spots behind Ohio State and Georgia
- 19:33right now in that just in the passing her pass opponent adjusted compared to what
- 19:38they do against everyone else. So just something to sort of keep an eye
- 19:42on there if you're looking for something. You know, if if you're a
- 19:45Michigan fan who's like I am uncomfortable with all of this success and do not
- 19:48care for it, you can feel you can feel free to at least be,
- 19:52you know, mildly concerned keeping an eye on the past. Yeah,
- 19:57once you start tasting excess, you should never be happy with any level of
- 20:02success other than a national title. Just let me just reassure you. So
- 20:07I tweeted out those numbers on Sunday that the quarterback numbers, and somebody responded,
- 20:12you gotta take out the fourth quarter. Yeah, of course, we
- 20:17gotta take out the fourth quarter. So in the first three quarters, Michigan's
- 20:21past efficiency defense this year is one oh five point seven in the fourth quarter
- 20:25one twelve point four eight, like very little difference than the first three quarters
- 20:29for them, compared to what the quarterbacks against everybody else are now. First
- 20:36first three quarters for Ohio State one oh five point seven two, which is
- 20:40better than Michigan's one h five point ninety seven, and then in the fourth
- 20:42quarter Ohio State's even better ninety nine point two four passer rating. So and
- 20:48I tweeted those numbers out and people and there's some Michigan fans you know,
- 20:52telling me, oh, the transitive property, you're trying to spend things.
- 20:55You're gonna say this and like this is this is literally just I don't even
- 20:59know numbers are gonna come up. I'm just gonna post the numbers and this
- 21:02is what it is because I was interested to see because we've watched Michigan for
- 21:07five games now, and we have seen a collection of quarterbacks that are going
- 21:14to be going pro in something other than sports. Some may not even go
- 21:18pro in something other than anything. And no offense to those people. Some
- 21:22of them may just hopefully they have a family trust something like that. Because
- 21:26the quarterback play that we've seen, I could I guarantee you that there's not
- 21:33five percent of Michigan fans that at five or to list all of these quarterbacks
- 21:37the nine or ten that they have played, that five percent of them could
- 21:42get like eighty percent match on where everybody the teams are. Like Doug Brumfield,
- 21:48tell me where he played. I'm not asking you to, I'm just
- 21:51the listeners out there, please tell me where and who Mason Garcia. Where
- 21:56might he have played? Like this is a bit much. Yeah, he
- 22:00was the guy with the mullet who played with the South Carolina like fifteen years
- 22:04ago. Right, that's now, Stephen Garcia. Shoot, no, no,
- 22:10not reading any bells. I gotta tell you, I have watched all
- 22:14of these games and I was hearing some of those names and going all right,
- 22:18orth, I know played for Bowling Green wait, which one was the
- 22:22East Carolina quarterback? Again, it is an anonymous It is an anonymous parade
- 22:27of people who probably could not win the football throwing game at like a carnival
- 22:32like it has been. It has been bad, bad, and you know,
- 22:36Michigan has gotten slagged a lot for their their schedule, and they kind
- 22:40of deserve it because they did bag out on the UCLA series. But you
- 22:44know, I mean, like everyone kind of plays crappy teams this time of
- 22:45year, that's just sort of what you do. Michigan has just been blessed
- 22:49with a corn ucopia of crap this year and last year as well, so
- 22:55you can't you know, it's not entirely on them, but it's also you
- 22:59know, it's also partly on them, and they just they have just looked
- 23:03so bored for such long stretches the first month of the season. And it
- 23:07was a little better on Saturday against Nebraska, at least in the first half.
- 23:11But again, Nebraska is not, you know, not going to be
- 23:14one of the better Big Ten offenses they faced this year. Rutgers obviously not,
- 23:19just like Indiana was not for Ohio State. So yeah, I mean,
- 23:25this is this is a Michigan team that I think we're you know,
- 23:26we're five games into the season and I don't think we've really learned anything materially
- 23:30about this Michigan team above and beyond. Like you said, they probably have
- 23:36the offensive line more set now, and it feels like maybe they're sort of
- 23:38changing some of the roles in the running back rotation, but other than that,
- 23:42I don't know how much we've really learned any of them well, and
- 23:48we'll learn much more this week at Minnesota against the Gopher team that's sure lost
- 23:53to Northwestern and sure had to I think come back against Louisiana Lafayette, you
- 24:00know, but this this will be the latest test against the quarterback who's never
- 24:03good and just just barely beat the Nebraska team that we just saw Michigan strangle
- 24:10into a million little pieces. Yeah, and you know, I think you
- 24:14talked about the response to your your quarterback stats, and you know I I
- 24:18said on Twitter over the weekend that after watching Ohio State all season, it's
- 24:25remarkable how effortless Michigan makes converting third and one and fourth and one. Look,
- 24:27And yeah, I mean, will you disagree with any of that,
- 24:30Tony, No, Tom, I wouldn't. I'm sorry I got I got
- 24:37so much feedback about, well, they're not playing Notre Dame every Look,
- 24:41are they playing Notre Dame this week? No? Was Ohio State playing Notre
- 24:45Dame every week? No turns out over a hose State look like crap,
- 24:47trying to run the ball in short yardage against Youngstown State too. I mean
- 24:51this is and you know, well J J. McCarthy didn't throw three picks
- 24:56this week, but see him throw three picks against Bowling Green, Like,
- 24:59yeah, that's not responsive. That's not an actual answer to what I wrote
- 25:02about, Like it's and it's okay, Like we're allowed to say positive things
- 25:07about Michigan when Michigan does positive things, and we're allowed to say, oh,
- 25:11positive things about Ohio State when Ohio State does positive things. That doesn't
- 25:14mean that we're Michigan homers or Ohio State homers or anything else. It means
- 25:18like we're talking about what we see. There are people who are upset that
- 25:23that Tony and I were talking about Michigan. On side, it's like,
- 25:26well, Ohio State's not playing? Who who else do Ohio State fans care
- 25:30about? If Ohio State's not playing? Because I would suggest the answer might
- 25:33be Michigan, and I don't know it was. I had someone suggest that
- 25:37we needed to join the Michigan beat, which I mean we could. I
- 25:41sold my house in Michigan about fifteen twenty years ago at this point, so
- 25:45that would be a little bit inconvenient of a commute, but I mean we
- 25:48could do that. But yeah, I don't Tony. I guess I have
- 25:52questions about online discourse. And you know why people in other realms of their
- 25:57lives would feel like they just need to get things spoon fed to them that
- 26:00agree with everything they you know, all of their prior opinions. I'm not
- 26:04sure why they would feel like that anyway. As I've said before another context,
- 26:11I'm just glad this isn't representative of society. On the on the whole,
- 26:15in large, in a larger context. So I'm with this feedback from
- 26:19the internet. Have you have you ever thought that maybe you should just die?
- 26:22I've considered that, and I will probably get around to that eventually.
- 26:27Right now, I'm too busy to do that. I don't have time,
- 26:30but you know, I mean I will. I will eventually. Musslem promised
- 26:33you is I will eventually probably get around to that. Yes, you mentioned
- 26:37the short yardage, and I went through and checked that out for this game
- 26:41from Michigan. And while the game was still like in the first three quarters
- 26:47when it was still a game Michigan was. They finished five of six with
- 26:53Kalo Mullings and Blake Korum, and the one that they missed was third and
- 26:59three corn except two yards, and then picks up the first down on fourth
- 27:02and one, so it's like they got it into attempts, so they pick
- 27:06up their short yardage. And I keep meaning to go back and look at
- 27:08all of Ohio states over the course of these four games, and I should
- 27:11probably do that so I can get it done and then just continue to measure
- 27:15it from there rather than seven games in. I just I don't feel like
- 27:18it, but the reaction from the internet time on Saturday, when Michigan was
- 27:23going so well, I asked, I just tweeted out, is Michigan the
- 27:27best team in the country? And that was not the right thing to tweet
- 27:30out. That was how did that show follow at a fan base for a
- 27:34following largely made up of Ohio state fans? Did it go over? Well?
- 27:37I bet it went over well, no, no, Tom, it
- 27:41didn't, because that was that is when I found out that, did you
- 27:44know, Tom, Michigan hasn't played anybody, so until they play somebody,
- 27:48you can't really know if they're any good. I gotta say, this is
- 27:52the first time hearing of any of this, and you know, I mean,
- 27:55it feels like if that was true, we would have acknowledged that at
- 27:57some point on this show or previous versions of this show, which I don't
- 28:00recall ever doing, you know. And I think that the main reason I
- 28:04asked that was because Georgia was losing at Auburn and if Georgia is number one,
- 28:11at Michigan is number two then and I had many many people saying,
- 28:17how can you even consider that? I'm like, well, I mean,
- 28:18they're already number two. They're ranked number two. And if we're talking about
- 28:22rankings, which you know, I just found out, like fifteen minutes before
- 28:25we started this show that five teams received first place votes in the AP So
- 28:29even even the voters are pretty torn on things, and Michigan now has twelve
- 28:33votes, Texas has ten first place votes. I was just looking for some
- 28:37feedback and also maybe trying to, you know, just choose some numbers.
- 28:41That's all, you know, engagement, it's all you know. Everybody loves
- 28:45engagement. But this is more every reaction to Michigan playing well, Georgia playing
- 28:51well. But I think for me, if I'm ranking, I think the
- 28:53most deserving is Texas, and if we're talking about deserving versus and I don't
- 28:59know if serving is also best until I'm doing an AP vote. I'm not
- 29:03gonna maybe put down what I think I would do because I don't want to
- 29:07be hypocrite later on when I actually have to do it. But from what
- 29:10we've see from Georgia and Michigan at this point, I don't think either one
- 29:14of them deserved to be number one. But also the performances of the respective
- 29:19performances of those two teams, I think it is a legit question, because
- 29:22this is the best we've seen Michigan look in a long time. And it
- 29:27took not that it caught me by surprise, but it made me take notice.
- 29:32I will let you know, here's a little context to this whole conversation.
- 29:36When I just while you were talking and I googled Ape College Football Top
- 29:40twenty five, the link that came up was blue because I had not clicked
- 29:42on it, and however many months that was. So if that gives you
- 29:45any indication how closely I'm paying attention to the polls this time of year.
- 29:48Yeah, Georgia won. They've got thirty five first place votes, Michigan two
- 29:52with twelve, Texas three with ten, Ohio State four with one, Florida
- 29:56State fifth with four. On a sleep of all the stuff on here,
- 30:02Penn State six, Washington seven, Oregon eight, USC nine, Notre Dame
- 30:07ten. I think, honestly, the thing that I'm most surprised about on
- 30:10any of this is that Washington has zero first place votes. Like Washington,
- 30:15there are lots of ways you can do your your vote, and it's I
- 30:17vote Number one is whoever won the national championship last year? And then I
- 30:21don't move them down until they lose that. That is the argument for Georgia
- 30:23with thirty five first place votes, because they've looked like crap and also not
- 30:26really played anyone. So Michigan has been also not playing anyone, but looked
- 30:30slightly better than Georgia has. Texas has the best win of the season,
- 30:36probably going on the road and beating Alabama. Ohio State has a very good
- 30:40win, going on the road and beating Notre Dame. Florida State has a
- 30:44couple of good wins. They beat LSU, they beat Clemson. I think
- 30:47there's an argument for them Washington, though. Washington has you know, they
- 30:51have not played a murderers row here, and they looked bad at Arizona on
- 30:56Saturday, but you know, they beat they went, they beat Boise State,
- 31:00they beat Tulsa easily. They killed Michigan State, they beat cal they
- 31:03beat Arizona. I mean there's not a signature win there because Boise State,
- 31:07you're thinking Boise State they're really good, not no more, they ain't,
- 31:10but they're you know that. I think we'll find out more about Washington in
- 31:14two weeks when they play Oregon. I think there's a decent argument for the
- 31:18Washington Oregon win winner should be number one in a couple of weeks. That's
- 31:22a possibility. Yet Georgia, I can't really make a compelling argument for Georgia
- 31:27other than well, they haven't lost a football game in like but two and
- 31:33a half years something like that. I mean, what else is the case
- 31:37for having Georgia number one? That's it, and it's it's just like,
- 31:41well, we know Georgia as the best. Meanwhile, they've been in one
- 31:44score games in a fourth quarter against South Carolina and Auburn, a two teams
- 31:48who have combined like five hundred record at this point. So yes, championship
- 31:52game championship teams win close games, but that shouldn't earn quote UoT earn you
- 32:00a top spot in the rankings. And again we talked about the rankings with
- 32:02such disdain. Why don't we talk about the Heisman next? But I will
- 32:07say Texas Oklahoma being five and zero and down at number twelve is pretty crazy
- 32:13because they're blowing everybody out. They had like a close ish game, like
- 32:16a fifteen point game against not so great opponent, but they played Texas this
- 32:21week, So if they would that, maybe they'll move into the top ten,
- 32:23we'll see, but overall it Alabama still in there. I do wonder,
- 32:30Tom, what is the scenario we asked, and we were asking a
- 32:34listener questions episode last week, what is the scenario where like a one loss
- 32:37Ohio State team misses the playoffs. I think it is possible if a two
- 32:45loss LSU wins the SEC West and then Beach Georgia and the SEC Championship game
- 32:52and everybody else's every other conference champion is a one loss or undefeated, you
- 32:58cannot put an SECT in the playoffs in es scenary. You cannot put a
- 33:02two loss SEC champ in over one loss as one loss champs from any of
- 33:07the other conferences because those other conferences are going to have some decent wins.
- 33:14This is presuming Florida stacks undefeated. Well, and you know, I was
- 33:17just scrolling down the rankings and I'm going to disagree with you on the Oklahoma
- 33:23at twelve being the most shocking thing in there. Can I can I talk
- 33:27you into number twenty three. LSU, who got absolutely got their doors blown
- 33:31off by Florida State, gave up fifty five points to Ole Miss last weekend.
- 33:37In the loss, has their signature win against an FBS team this year
- 33:42is forty one fourteen against Mississippi State. They also beat an absolutely terrible Arkansas
- 33:46team by three at home and then a big win over Grambling. So I
- 33:52mean, incredible quality there on that schedule. Definitely deserving of a spot in
- 33:58the top twenty five Tennessee. Also in that conversation, Boy Tennessee, the
- 34:04loss to the loss to Florida looking just aging better and better like a fine
- 34:08wine. I mean, Tony, they beat Virginia, they beat Austin p
- 34:14they beat Utay, and they beat South Carolina and only lost by thirteen points
- 34:20against a Florida team that has gotten murdered by a quarterback list Utah and got
- 34:28murdered by who did they lose to last weekend? It was someone terrible.
- 34:30Oh Kentucky. Yeah, got murdered by Kentucky. I mean, And then
- 34:34you know, listen, if you've got a thirteen point that's a very competitive
- 34:37thirteen point loss to a team that lost to Kentucky and Utah. Tony,
- 34:39So, I mean, you say that they can't let a two loss SEC
- 34:44champion in over a one loss, But where do I always tell you to
- 34:49look, Tony when we're talking about the College Football Playoff Committee and what they
- 34:52want to do. When you look at the bottom of the polls, I
- 34:53feel like you look at the bottom of the ap pole right now and go,
- 34:57well, I mean, Tony, they're in the SEC. How bad
- 35:00could they beat? Kentucky right now? Five ranked twenty. If they go
- 35:04to Georgia this weekend and win, you'll see the highest rise of the twentieth
- 35:09ranked team in the history of college football because they will jump to the top
- 35:13five and maybe the top three. Because can I run you through Kentucky's murderers
- 35:20row that they've played so far, Ball State Eastern Kentucky, which of all
- 35:24the directional Kentucky's is one of them. Akron they won at Vanderbilt. That's
- 35:30a quality SEC road win. Tony and then Florida, who again, I
- 35:35mean was almost competitive against Utah team that almost has an offense. So I
- 35:39mean, listen, you've you've got to you've got to respect it. Here's
- 35:45here's the great thing. Someone's gonna win those games. And if Georgia beats
- 35:47Kentucky, well, I mean they beat a five and oh ranked team Tony
- 35:51and and if Kentucky's not enough to get you excited? Can I interest you
- 35:54in an unbeaten missoo I mean no, no, no, no, they
- 36:00have they have wide receivers, Tony, I mean I'm not sure if you've
- 36:01heard they have wide receivers. So yeah, I mean it is. It
- 36:06is an incredibly deep and talented SEC. Kentucky has to play Georgia and Missouri
- 36:13back to back. They have Missouri at home so and this weekend Missouri hosting
- 36:19LSU So man, just the the SEC heavyweight slugfest we are in for.
- 36:22Boy, can't wait? Could you interest me in Missouri? No? No,
- 36:28no, it couldn't possibly no show me no, thank you, more
- 36:31likely no, thank you state if you ask me. So there you have
- 36:37a time, anything, anything, any other rants that you want to go
- 36:39on and anger people on social media please by all means no, I'm just
- 36:45gonna be turning off my notifications and we'll be back with a different show.
- 36:49I'm sure tomorrow of some kind we will. So we thank you all for
- 36:53tuning in. As always, please find us at Buckeyhaddle dot com. Become
- 36:58a member there, support us that way if you would like. Also continue
- 37:00to find us at YouTube dot com. Slash bucket Huddle, Facebook, dot
- 37:04com, slash bucket Huddle, wherever you can find us, go ahead and
- 37:07find us. So thank you all for tuning in, and we'll talk to
- 37:08you guys later