Latest / Public Health Review Morning Edition / 1056: Keeping the Public Health Workforce Strong: What Data, Leadership, and Flexibility Tell Us
Transcript
- 0:01This is Public Health Review Morning Edition for Thursday,
- 0:03January 22nd, 2026. I'm John Sheehan for the
- 0:07Association of State and. Territorial health officials,
- 0:10today we take a look at the public health.
- 0:12Workforce and ask what these professionals need to stay
- 0:16engaged, supported and committed, and how leaders can
- 0:19act on those insights. Heather Krasna, associate Dean
- 0:23of career and professional development at Columbia
- 0:25University Mailman School. Of public health.
- 0:28Joins us to breakdown new research on what younger.
- 0:31Public health workers. Value most at work and later.
- 0:34Asto's director. Of workforce Omar Khalid will.
- 0:37Walk us through. Key findings from the 2024.
- 0:40Public health workforce. Interests and Needs survey or pH
- 0:44wins the only nationally representative survey of the
- 0:47governmental public health. Workforce, he'll discuss.
- 0:51Why? High turnover, burnout and loss
- 0:53of institutional knowledge remain urgent concerns, along
- 0:57with encouraging signs of improved supervisor
- 1:00relationships and workforce commitment.
- 1:03But first. Here's Heather Krasna discussing
- 1:05a recent study from the Mailman School of.
- 1:07Public Health. Showing that younger workers
- 1:09prefer non traditional work benefits.
- 1:11To a degree. More than older workers, things
- 1:15like flexible schedules, remote work, and more training.
- 1:18I wanted to know how public health agencies should interpret
- 1:22these responses. Many local and state tribal and
- 1:26territorial health departments have had trouble keeping younger
- 1:29employees at the organization and there is the opportunity to
- 1:35try to improve retention by offering some of these less
- 1:39traditional benefits. Our study shows that younger
- 1:43workers value these sort of non traditional benefits.
- 1:47So as an example, if the organization has the option to
- 1:51offer remote work from time to time at least, or hybrid
- 1:56options, that could be a way of helping retain some of the
- 2:00younger workers. It's also shown that they
- 2:03appreciate flex time if that's another option.
- 2:07Some people have workplaces where they might work four days
- 2:11a week, a few a few extra hours or extra hour each day and then
- 2:15have that maybe the Friday off. One of the other things that we
- 2:18saw in our study was that certain benefits that have to do
- 2:22with childcare, lactation facilities, things like that are
- 2:26also really attractive to younger workers.
- 2:28And one reason possibly is, is that as probably many people
- 2:33know, overall the public health workforce does tend to skew more
- 2:38towards female workers. So because of that, those
- 2:42particular benefits might be a bit more attractive to this
- 2:46group. And the other thing that we
- 2:49noticed is that supporting lifelong learning, professional
- 2:53development or student loan repayment or forgiveness
- 2:57programs are very, very important for the younger
- 3:00workers. And this also is common sense
- 3:02that people who are younger most likely have finished their
- 3:06degrees more recently and they also unfortunately are more
- 3:10likely to have debt. And so options where there might
- 3:14be public service loan forgiveness or some of the other
- 3:18healthcare related loan repayment programs through the
- 3:21National Health Service Corps, those types of options can be
- 3:25really beneficial, especially to younger workers.
- 3:29Yeah. And it strikes me that's sort of
- 3:31the the story of the broader workforce across the country
- 3:35that younger workers have gotten used to non traditional
- 3:38benefits, flex time, remote work.
- 3:41It also strikes me that in healthcare that's particularly
- 3:44challenging. It sounds like you're sort of
- 3:46prescribing a combination of, you know, of, of flex time, but
- 3:52also other, other benefits that they they want as much such as,
- 3:57such as training, such as as more maneuverability and and
- 4:01debt repayment. And it's true that not every
- 4:04single job can offer these types of flexibilities.
- 4:07Not every health department has that option to allow hybrid
- 4:10work. Certain jobs just can't be done
- 4:12remotely. If you imagine the health
- 4:15inspector, for instance, environmental health specialist,
- 4:18for instance, they may not be able to do that work remotely,
- 4:22but there could be days where they're doing reporting and
- 4:25paperwork. Maybe those days can be done
- 4:27remotely. These are things just to be
- 4:28creative and think about if the job can be structured a certain
- 4:32way. One thing I have to say that is
- 4:34really important to say out loud is that the most beneficial
- 4:40thing is often times to increase the salaries, if that's
- 4:44possible. But knowing how hard that is,
- 4:47that's where we would suggest to think outside the box a little
- 4:51bit. And if you can't increase
- 4:52someone's salary, what could you do that might make the job
- 4:56easier for them to stay? And if that includes helping
- 5:00them get student loans forgiven or repaid, or offering those
- 5:04flexibilities or training benefits, that's something
- 5:07that's a little easier to do for many organizations than to
- 5:10increase the salaries. Absolutely.
- 5:12And all of the solutions that you're talking about, you know?
- 5:16There are long term. Implications there.
- 5:18It's, it sounds like a much bigger culture shift across
- 5:24across all workforces, but particularly in public health, a
- 5:29shift that kind of has to happen and has been happening no matter
- 5:32what. Exactly.
- 5:35You know, I would say some people make a big deal about how
- 5:39there are different generations of people in the workforce, and
- 5:42that's somewhat a case. There's something to be said for
- 5:45that. There may be Gen.
- 5:47X and the Millennials and so forth, and they might have
- 5:50different values at work, but there's also the fact that
- 5:54people are in different phases of their life.
- 5:56And if someone is younger, maybe they're starting a family, they
- 6:00may have certain needs or things that you can do to support them
- 6:05with their life in that take in that phase of their life.
- 6:09Or if it's a younger person and they just want to get as much
- 6:12experience as possible and they want to have the opportunity to
- 6:17learn more things or take on new responsibilities, if there's the
- 6:21opportunity to allow that, that's something that can be
- 6:23really beneficial. So when people are starting out
- 6:26their career, which is also what happens when people are younger,
- 6:30what can a supervisor do to be not just a regular supervisor
- 6:34but possibly a mentor or to help the person identify other people
- 6:39that could be a support or a mentor?
- 6:42And Heather, could I ask you to maybe expand on that?
- 6:46A. Little.
- 6:46More for, say, maybe an agency head who's staring down these
- 6:52cultural shifts and is resistant to change.
- 6:55But sees this. Small but growing cohort of
- 6:58their workforce, you know, asking over and over again for
- 7:02these kinds of accommodations. What's your advice there?
- 7:05What's what's what are some baby steps to getting some changes in
- 7:09place? Great question.
- 7:11I think that the very first thing is to listen to people.
- 7:16There are lots of ways you can do a what they call a climate
- 7:20survey or some other way to gather anonymous feedback from
- 7:25people in the workforce. There's also plenty of data now
- 7:28from the public health Workforce Interest and needs survey. pH
- 7:31wins. And if you are a supervisor of
- 7:34people and you need to justify why you need to make a change in
- 7:39the workplace, that data will probably support that decision.
- 7:43And the other thing which I always will say out loud is that
- 7:47turnover is really expensive. And it's not just expensive
- 7:50because your community is now going to be missing someone
- 7:55whose job is is to support the community's health, whether that
- 7:59person is inspecting restaurants or dealing with the vital
- 8:03statistics and birth certificates and so forth, or an
- 8:07epidemiologist that's tracking some outbreaks.
- 8:11The community's health could suffer if you don't have
- 8:14sufficient workers and they're engaged in their job doing that
- 8:17work. That is a really huge challenge.
- 8:20And so putting dollars on that lack of workforce is something
- 8:25that health department leaders can try to do And to to, you
- 8:30know, tie it back to things that have an impact on the community.
- 8:34What is the economic impact if you suddenly have more cases of
- 8:40an infectious disease? How is that impacting all the
- 8:44employers in the region where their workforce is having to
- 8:47call out sick or something? And then the piece about
- 8:50turnover itself is that's also very expensive.
- 8:53If somebody leaves, now you have a vacancy and you have to fill
- 8:57that vacancy. And it's not just the maybe the
- 9:00cost of trying to advertise the job or something, but you could
- 9:04end up taking up so much staff time to hire a new person to
- 9:08train that new person to onboard them.
- 9:11So it's not just harming the community.
- 9:13It's also expensive to the taxpayer if there is a lot of
- 9:17turnover in a health department. These are all just different
- 9:20arguments. People can try to make the case
- 9:22for why public health is so important and why the people
- 9:25doing that hard work who are on the front lines in public
- 9:28health, their work really matters and supporting them is
- 9:32essential. Heather Krasna is associate Dean
- 9:36of career and professional development at Columbia
- 9:38University's Mailman School. Of public health.
- 9:43The results of the 2024 Public Health Workforce Interests and
- 9:46Needs Survey, or pH Wins, were recently released, and it's the
- 9:50only nationally representative survey of the governmental
- 9:53public health. Workforce.
- 9:55Here's Asto's director of workforce Omar Khalid, to talk
- 9:58more about the results, specifically that a significant
- 10:01portion of the workforce is considering leaving the field.
- 10:05Of course, it's a snapshot in time.
- 10:06There was a window in the second-half of 2024.
- 10:10But we know there were some really big changes after the
- 10:12pandemic, right? Maybe that was a little more
- 10:14gradual as things returned closer to normal, though.
- 10:17Never. Things were never quite the same
- 10:19again. Haven't been since 2020, but we
- 10:22also know that the workforce was struggling and letting us know
- 10:25important needs of theirs even before the pandemic.
- 10:28But we did see that even in the 2024 data that there was what is
- 10:33really troubling data about the the conditions of some
- 10:37individuals in terms of burnout and, you know, looking to leave
- 10:40the profession. So we know this is an urgent
- 10:43message in the data. And we also know that things
- 10:46have not gotten easier in 2025 and then, you know, the weeks
- 10:49really that followed the completion of the fielding of
- 10:52the 2024 survey. There's still need for support.
- 10:56There's still need for enhancing training around certain topics
- 10:59so that people feel more supported in their day-to-day
- 11:03work in public health agencies. So I think that's one of the
- 11:05main takeaways of these findings in 2024 is that we still have
- 11:10some work to do even if things had stayed at an even keel from
- 11:15the time of fielding. And all the difficulties that
- 11:17we've seen since then, including, you know, reductions
- 11:20in force, losses of funding, some confusion around future
- 11:24directions with maybe the absence of some guidance and how
- 11:28to plan for the continuation of some of these programs has just
- 11:31been an additional challenge that we know we have to meet as
- 11:35well. Yeah.
- 11:37And perhaps a complimentary take away from the most recent report
- 11:41shows that there are a lot of new workforce members, about
- 11:45half have been at their agencies for five years or less.
- 11:50So how does that add difficulty to the situation?
- 11:53How does that sort of color the results?
- 11:55Well, it's great. I think we do always want to,
- 11:58you know, welcome new ideas and new perspectives represented
- 12:03from these new people coming to the workforce.
- 12:05That's a a great thing recruiting and, you know,
- 12:08advertising how great public health is as a career.
- 12:11It is something we want to see, even though it it is always hard
- 12:14to replace the institutional knowledge and the experience of
- 12:18the people who have laughed. So of course there's kind of two
- 12:21sides to that coin. The first one is we have a great
- 12:23opportunity to have a fresh perspective in public health,
- 12:26maybe new voices, maybe people who weren't previously
- 12:29represented in health agencies are being able to see a few more
- 12:33of those perspectives. But at the same time,
- 12:35realistically coming to terms with the fact that especially in
- 12:38a relatively short amount of time, losing a lot of those
- 12:42longer tenured employees from our agencies and thinking about
- 12:46how do we address that loss first and foremost.
- 12:49And then also how do we plan for doing it better?
- 12:53How do we plan for those separations affecting agencies
- 12:57and critically, the work that we provide to keep communities
- 13:00healthy without interruption going forward?
- 13:03And I think it's a great reminder that that's something
- 13:05you have to design a system for, which we're so great at doing in
- 13:08public health. You know, how do we design a
- 13:10system to mitigate the damage from loss of institutional
- 13:14knowledge, whether it's succession planning?
- 13:15And, you know, that doesn't just mean, you know, how are you
- 13:18going to replace someone in a position and say, OK, great,
- 13:20that's not a vacancy anymore. Really succession planning is
- 13:23how are you planning for that transfer of, you know, the most
- 13:26important knowledge? How do you keep some of these
- 13:28initiatives on track despite key personnel leaving?
- 13:31And that's really something you have to be intentional about and
- 13:33plan for. And I think the last few years
- 13:36have really highlighted the need for that.
- 13:38And we're hearing a lot of ways that people are taking that more
- 13:43seriously and being more intentional about doing it, to
- 13:46have it be a net positive that we're getting a lot of new
- 13:49staff. And of course, people are
- 13:50choosing to end their careers, hopefully at a time of their
- 13:53choosing, without affecting the work of public health too
- 13:56greatly. Yeah.
- 13:58And the report calls for investments, serious investments
- 14:03in a permanent workforce, moving away from those temporary roles.
- 14:07And you know, that cost money. How does that happen and who
- 14:11needs to be convinced to make those investments?
- 14:14Well, we're currently operating under the historic investment in
- 14:19public health infrastructure, including workforce through the
- 14:23CD CS public health infrastructure grant.
- 14:25That has really allowed a lot of really all of the state public
- 14:30health agencies and as well as state and territorial really
- 14:34associated States and some big city, local health departments
- 14:37and city health departments to make those hires to hire people
- 14:41that are committed to doing the work of workforce, right
- 14:44thinking about infrastructure full time and how to support the
- 14:47workforce. And I think that the successes
- 14:50and the examples of all of those jurisdictions, you know, midway
- 14:54through roughly that investment show that this can work.
- 14:58An investment in public health workforce does really have an
- 15:01impact. Of course, nothing is permanent
- 15:03in government and especially in public health funding.
- 15:05We're used to a a sort of grant cycle and that does have a
- 15:08natural ebb and flow to it. But our hope is that we'll be
- 15:12able to tout the success of investments like the Public
- 15:16Health Infrastructure Grant and others that focus on
- 15:20infrastructure to really improve how health agencies operate so
- 15:24that they can do the best job they can do to keep our
- 15:28community safe. And the report isn't all bad
- 15:33news. 2024 showed improvements in workforce commitment and
- 15:38supervisor satisfaction, and a reduction in burnout.
- 15:41So do we know or can we pinpoint any policies or shifts that
- 15:46contributed to that? Well, I'll first give a caveat
- 15:49that it is difficult to provide, you know, with certainty and
- 15:53point to something and saying, you know, this had this effect,
- 15:56especially when you're talking about things that, you know,
- 15:59maybe they're a little fuzzy. They're talking about how people
- 16:00feel and you know, what's behind their complex decisions to to
- 16:03stay or to leave or around morale.
- 16:05But we still know that it's real, even if we can't draw a
- 16:08crystal clear line between inventions that that we do in
- 16:11the workplace and why people want to stay.
- 16:13We, we can't listen to what people are saying they want and
- 16:16what is working. We can start by asking them and
- 16:19communicating with them. But one of my favorite pieces of
- 16:22data from the 2024 pH wins is that people have increased
- 16:28support and, and they enjoy their relationships with their
- 16:31direct supervisor. And that is often the number one
- 16:35retention tool than any agency has.
- 16:37You know, there's the adage that people don't quit their jobs,
- 16:40they quit their supervisors. And and, you know, luckily,
- 16:41we're seeing that more people are satisfied with that
- 16:44relationship in public health agencies.
- 16:46But at the same time, the people who are reporting the highest
- 16:49levels of burnout are those same supervisors.
- 16:52So you've got something that's working.
- 16:53You've got something, you know, despite all the difficulties
- 16:56that face us in the field, you've got something that's
- 16:58working. How do we pinpoint that piece of
- 17:02supporting supervisors? And that means giving them
- 17:05training to be effective? You know, people are put into
- 17:07supervisor roles usually because of the job, how good of a job
- 17:10they do, right? Not always because they have
- 17:12vast experience they can point to of what a great job they do,
- 17:15supervising through no fault of their own.
- 17:17So how do we support them? With training, with examples.
- 17:21And also supporting them, you know, in other more logistical
- 17:25ways, right? Like what is your work day like?
- 17:27Do you have flexibility? Do you have an unrealistic
- 17:30workload? You can be the best supervisor
- 17:32in the world, but if you've got more work to do than hours of
- 17:34the day or more reports, then you have time to meet with in a
- 17:38meaningful way, then you're not going to be successful.
- 17:42Taking that into account, is there a big take away of the
- 17:45report or is there something that maybe should be prioritized
- 17:49for the year going forward? I think that one thing that we
- 17:52know that there is a need for is better communication.
- 17:56And that's a big term. And it can show up in a lot of
- 17:59different ways in a health agency, whether it's executive
- 18:01leadership, talking through and acknowledging uncertainty and
- 18:05the difficulty in the field right now or trying to make
- 18:07sense of things where there's not always a lot of information.
- 18:10But it does take some, you know, very brave leadership to come
- 18:13out and say to the entire organization, you know, we're
- 18:16together. We may not have all the answers
- 18:18and there may be some tough times ahead, but we're committed
- 18:21to standing with you. And the other side of that is
- 18:23even communication all the way down to the team level.
- 18:25You know, how are supervisors trained to, you know, filter
- 18:29down some of that information and give people the information
- 18:31that they need to know while also getting information they
- 18:34need from their supervisors? So how are we able to
- 18:36communicate those things? What tools are we giving to
- 18:38everyone and our staff, the entire public health workforce,
- 18:42to be better communicators? It's such an important part of
- 18:45our job. And not asking anybody to be
- 18:47perfect, but making that attempt and recognizing it as a priority
- 18:51is the first step. Nomar Khalid is Asto's director
- 18:54of workforce. Earlier we heard from Heather
- 18:56Krasna, associate Dean of career and professional development at
- 19:00the Columbia University Mailman School.
- 19:02Of public health. Strong public health starts with
- 19:05strong communication. Getting the right information to
- 19:07the right people at the right time can build trust, counter
- 19:10misinformation, and shape healthier communities.
- 19:13That's why Asto is highlighting practical.
- 19:15Resources to help health. Departments strengthen their
- 19:18communications infrastructure, from media templates and risk
- 19:21communication strategies to tools for talking with
- 19:24legislators about public health funding and impact Explorer
- 19:28training opportunities, tool kits from the de Beaumont
- 19:30Foundation, field tested messaging strategies and expert
- 19:33insights on crisis communication and public trust.
- 19:36And learn how public health infrastructure grant funding can
- 19:39support this foundational capability.
- 19:41You can find links in the show notes.
- 19:45The ongoing effects of climate change impact every part of our
- 19:48lives, including our individual and community level health from
- 19:52rising temperatures. Increased occurrence and
- 19:54magnitude of natural disasters. Expanded vector borne disease
- 19:58patterns to increase the transmission of waterborne
- 20:01diseases. The changing natural environment
- 20:03in which we live. Will affect our health these
- 20:06issues have. Led to significant negative
- 20:08health effects on both individuals and populations,
- 20:12particularly high risk communities.
- 20:15As such. Public health departments must
- 20:16address how best to respond to this ongoing crisis, and ASTO
- 20:20has compiled. Resources to help.
- 20:22You can find a link in the show notes.
- 20:25This has been Public Health Review Morning Edition.
- 20:27I'm John Sheehan for the Association of State and.
- 20:30Territorial health officials.