Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / Why the Best Marketplaces Own the Payment Flow
Transcript
- Lucas: If you run a marketplace, there's a moment where you realize that the person who processes the payment holds a surprising amount of power over your business. And the best marketplaces have figured out that they should be that person. Luna: You're talking about owning the payment flow — not just taking a cut, but actually running the transaction yourself. Lucas: Exactly. Airbnb, Uber, Fiverr — they all process payments in-house. They don't hand it off to Stripe or PayPal and say 'you handle the money, we handle the matchmaking.' And there's a specific reason why that decision can be worth hundreds of millions in extra revenue. Luna: Let's talk about that. And quick aside — if you're building or running a marketplace, or just curious about the business models behind the platforms you use every day, these conversations are for you. We keep the show ad-free thanks to listeners who support it at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Just a few dollars keeps us going. Now let's get into the numbers. Lucas: So let's start with the basic math. A typical marketplace take rate — the percentage they keep from each transaction — is between 10 and 20 percent. Airbnb is around 14 percent combined from guests and hosts. Uber is closer to 25 percent. Luna: Right, and that's the headline number. But the payment processing cost alone — the credit card fees, the bank transfers, the fraud screening — that's usually 2 to 3 percent of the transaction value. If you outsource payments to Stripe or Adyen, you're paying their markup on top of that. Lucas: And that markup is typically another 0.5 to 1 percent. So by owning the payment flow, a marketplace can capture that spread. It doesn't sound huge, but on a billion dollars in gross merchandise volume, that's 10 to 30 million dollars in extra revenue — pure margin, because the fixed cost of building payment infrastructure is already sunk. Luna: But it's not just about the fee arbitrage. The real strategic reason is data. Lucas: Right. When you process payments yourself, you see the full transaction lifecycle. You know exactly when the money moves, how often disputes happen, which sellers have high refund rates, which buyers are risky. That data lets you optimize your marketplace in ways a third-party processor never would. Luna: And it also lets you build better trust mechanisms. For example, Airbnb holds the host's payout until 24 hours after the guest checks in. That's a trust signal — you can only do that if you're the one holding the money. Lucas: Exactly. Uber does something similar — they pay drivers weekly, but they process the rider's payment instantly. That float gives them working capital and leverage. And Fiverr — Fiverr is a great case study. Before they built their own payment system, they were basically a directory. The transaction happened off-platform. Luna: Right, because freelancers and clients would meet on Fiverr, then move to PayPal to actually pay each other. Fiverr had no visibility into whether the work was completed or if there was a dispute. Lucas: And no take rate. So in 2012, Fiverr launched their own payment system — Fiverr Revenue Payments, they called it. They required all transactions to go through their platform. Instantly, they went from zero revenue per transaction to 20 percent take rate. Their gross merchandise volume didn't drop — it actually grew, because the integrated payment flow made the transaction smoother and safer. Luna: That's the chicken and egg problem solved through payment infrastructure. But not every marketplace should do this. When does it make sense? Lucas: The general rule is: if your marketplace processes more than 10 million dollars in annual transaction volume, it's worth at least running a cost-benefit analysis. Below that, the fixed cost of building payment infrastructure — compliance, PCI certification, anti-fraud systems — can wipe out the margin benefit. Luna: And there's the regulatory piece. If you're holding customer funds, you trigger money transmitter regulations in the US, which means state-by-state licensing. That's a nightmare. Lucas: It is. That's why many marketplaces use a hybrid approach: they let a platform like Stripe handle the actual money movement, but they own the user experience and the data layer. Stripe Connect is basically built for this — the marketplace appears to own the payment flow, but Stripe handles the heavy lifting. Luna: So you get the data and the trust signals without the regulatory headache. But you still pay Stripe's cut, right? Lucas: Right. Stripe Connect charges around 0.5 to 0.7 percent on top of the standard processing fees. So you capture some of the margin, but not all of it. For a marketplace doing 50 million in volume, that's still a few hundred thousand dollars in savings versus using PayPal, but it's not the full 2-3 percent. Luna: And then there's eBay. That's a cautionary tale. Lucas: EBay is fascinating because for years they relied on PayPal — which they actually owned for a while. But PayPal was a separate company, and eBay didn't integrate payments deeply. Buyers and sellers could still do bank transfers or checks. The result: eBay had relatively low take rates, high fraud, and poor dispute resolution. In 2018 they finally started building their own payment system, called Managed Payments, and it took them years to roll out. Luna: And by then, they'd lost a lot of trust. EBay's take rate is still lower than Amazon's, partly because they don't own the full transaction flow. Lucas: Exactly. Amazon is the extreme case — they process payments, hold funds, manage disputes, and even lend money to sellers based on transaction history. That data moat is why Amazon can offer a 15 percent take rate while smaller marketplaces struggle to justify 10 percent. Luna: So when a marketplace says 'we're building our own payment system to improve trust,' what they're really saying is 'we want to increase our take rate without raising fees on sellers.' Lucas: Yes. And that's the smart way to frame it. Because if you just raise your commission from 15 to 18 percent, sellers notice. But if you say 'we're streamlining payments and reducing friction,' sellers might even accept a slightly higher effective take rate because the overall experience is better. Luna: Let's talk about a specific example. Fiverr's take rate is around 27 percent now — one of the highest in the industry. How much of that is due to owning payments? Lucas: Hard to say exactly, but we can estimate. Fiverr's gross merchandise volume in 2025 was about one point two billion dollars. If they were using a third-party processor, they'd pay roughly 2.5 percent in processing costs plus another 0.5 percent platform fee — so 3 percent, or 36 million dollars. By processing in-house, they probably reduce that to around 1.5 percent, or 18 million. That 18 million goes straight to the bottom line. Luna: And that 18 million is essentially free money from infrastructure they already built. But they also get the data — which lets them optimize pricing, reduce fraud, and improve seller retention. Those benefits probably add another couple of percent to their take rate over time. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the hidden value. When you own payments, you can experiment with things like instant payouts for a fee — Uber drivers can get paid instantly for a 50 cent fee, which is basically pure margin. Or you can offer buyer protection insurance. All of these are revenue streams that depend on owning the payment rails. Luna: So the advice for a marketplace founder: don't build your own payment system until you have volume, but do plan to own the payment flow eventually. Because the data and the margin are too valuable to leave on the table. Lucas: And when you do build, start with a hybrid model like Stripe Connect. You get the UX and the data, you avoid the regulatory nightmare, and you can always move to full in-house processing later once you have the scale and the compliance team. Luna: It's one of those decisions that looks like a technical detail but ends up defining your business model. The best marketplaces treat payments as a strategic asset, not a utility. Lucas: Right. And the next time you book an Airbnb or order an Uber, notice that you never leave the app to pay. That's not an accident — it's a design choice that's worth billions.