Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / My Take on NCUA's Record Retention Regulation Proposal
Transcript
- 0:03Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:30Hey everyone.
- 0:30This is mark Treichel with another episode of, with flying colors.
- 0:35And today I.
- 0:37Have a little bit of a different way.
- 0:39I'm going to be doing this podcast.
- 0:40And you'll hear about that shortly, but the NCAA board on April 18th.
- 0:45Approved a UN.
- 0:47Advanced notice of proposed rulemaking on records, retention.
- 0:51The board action bulletin.
- 0:53Chairman Harper was stated as saying is important that
- 0:56federally insured credit union.
- 0:58Maintain a robust records preservation program.
- 1:01Program whereby vital records can readily be reconstructed.
- 1:06Chairman Todd Harper said.
- 1:08Maintaining all vital records is central to a credit union's ability
- 1:11to properly serve its members.
- 1:13And to the NCUA is ability to fulfill its supervisory enforcement
- 1:17and liquidation functions.
- 1:19Now the board meeting was unique.
- 1:21In one way in that chairman, Todd Harper was not at the NCA
- 1:25building when he did the podcast.
- 1:27He was on video as a reminder, they skipped March.
- 1:30So he wasn't there.
- 1:32, in April and maybe they're tiptoeing into doing these remote.
- 1:35Like they've got most of the people working remote, but in
- 1:37any event, That caught my eye.
- 1:39When I watched the YouTube video.
- 1:42Because vice chairman, Kyle Houtman was sitting right next to Tanya Otsuka.
- 1:47The newest of the three board members.
- 1:49And it was fitting because this was a proposed rulemaking that
- 1:54vice chairman, Kyle Helpmann was taking a lot of credit for pushing.
- 1:58He made some great points about the fact that credit unions don't really
- 2:03particularly small credit unions.
- 2:04Don't really understand what it is they're supposed to keep.
- 2:08What it is, they're not required to keep.
- 2:09There was a lot of reference to the fact that.
- 2:12Are the attachments guidance.
- 2:14Or are they not Bidens?
- 2:16There was a lot of reference to questions that were being asked as part of the
- 2:22advanced notice for proposed rule making.
- 2:24So if you.
- 2:25R one who likes to comment, take a look at the questions and get your comments in.
- 2:29However, they didn't highlight any of those questions, which I probably will
- 2:33highlight a few of them here today.
- 2:35So again this was pushed by Kyle Houtman.
- 2:38He actually did something very clever.
- 2:40And he had sent out to some credit unions, smaller credit unions and
- 2:44said, show me your storage space, where you keep your records.
- 2:48And he talked a lot about, When he was in the the.
- 2:51When he worked at.
- 2:53Stockbrokers how the sec required.
- 2:56That they keep records seven years and that there's different rules for the IRS
- 2:59and that there's different rules for NCUA.
- 3:02But that people in credit unions, err, on the side of keeping everything so NC so
- 3:06that they can't get in trouble with NCUA, particularly smaller credit unions because
- 3:10they don't have the time to hire attorneys to tell them what the rule actually means.
- 3:14So a lot of good content here.
- 3:17And he makes a good point that this is a good proposal.
- 3:21Should it be come final ever?
- 3:23For small credit unions and that their burden is so high at the end.
- 3:27I'll say why.
- 3:28That's great.
- 3:29I agree with it.
- 3:30But what the other things, the NCAA board is doing.
- 3:33Is actually hurting small credit unions, but I'll save that for the end.
- 3:37All right.
- 3:37And as far as particular questions that they.
- 3:42Are asking.
- 3:43They have questions such as.
- 3:48Does the definition of vital records in the rule?
- 3:52Contain all.
- 3:53And only those records you would consider to be vital for the credit unions.
- 3:58. Next question.
- 3:59Are there additional types of documents not listed as vital
- 4:02records that you think should be.
- 4:04As they are critical for business operations and to properly serve members.
- 4:09Next question.
- 4:10Are there other industry standards or methodologies outside of the rule
- 4:14that the agency should consider?
- 4:16Preserving vital records.
- 4:18For defining what vital records are and for determining minimum retention periods.
- 4:24Next question, the primary focus of the records, retention guidance
- 4:28in appendix B relates specifically to catastrophic act preparedness.
- 4:34Are there any terms, definitions, or standards that the board should
- 4:37consider updating in appendix B?
- 4:40The next question.
- 4:41Are there any other changes to appendix B that you would recommend.
- 4:45Next question.
- 4:46How long, and in what format does your credit union store?
- 4:50It's vital records.
- 4:52Next question.
- 4:53Does your credit union maintain and store any vital records in a physical
- 4:57format due to a regulatory requirement or a supervisory expectation?
- 5:04Next question, what impact.
- 5:06Pediments including estimated costs.
- 5:08Does your credit union encounter with storing vital records?
- 5:13Next question.
- 5:14What records do you deem vital for business operations that a credit
- 5:18union should be required to keep permanently for the purpose of
- 5:21restoring vital member services.
- 5:25Next question other than for records, that must be kept permanently.
- 5:29Are there specific timeframes that you would recommend?
- 5:32That other vital records be retained.
- 5:36Next questions.
- 5:37What are the pros and cons of storing vital records physically
- 5:40electronically or in other formats, such as cloud computing storage.
- 5:46Next question.
- 5:46Does your credit union rely on third party vendors to
- 5:49accurately maintain vital records?
- 5:52And if so, what are some of the challenges that these arrangements present?
- 5:56Next question.
- 5:57How would you suggest the agency create a more effective framework for credit
- 6:01unions to preserve vital records?
- 6:04Next questions.
- 6:05What are some challenges for smaller credit unions defined as
- 6:08credit unions with less than a hundred million dollars or less?
- 6:12In maintaining vital records and what has worked.
- 6:16Next and last question.
- 6:18What additional support training or tech.
- 6:20Nicola assistance.
- 6:21Could the NCUA provide if Annie to assist credit unions with both
- 6:26understanding and implementing.
- 6:28Retention requirements.
- 6:31If any of those questions are something that you have a strong
- 6:34opinion on, I highly encourage you.
- 6:36To comment to the AMPR.
- 6:38I do believe the NCUA board is going to take these comments into
- 6:43consideration and truly would like.
- 6:45To make this regulation better.
- 6:48Now there's reference to the appendixes relating to disaster recovery.
- 6:53Type situation.
- 6:54There was reference in the board meeting.
- 6:57To the federal building.
- 6:58In Oklahoma that blew up that did have a credit union.
- 7:02Headquarters in it.
- 7:04And I can relate to that.
- 7:06Reference because when that.
- 7:08happened, I was a supervisory examiner in Dallas.
- 7:11I had peers and friends that were supervisory examiners in Oklahoma.
- 7:16They were actually doing exams down the road from the federal
- 7:20building when it blew up.
- 7:22And I was supplementing their exam teams with some of my examiners.
- 7:25So when that happened there's a lot of chaos in the United States.
- 7:29From the trauma of it, but I have friends and colleagues who had to
- 7:33work with the credit union to get the operations back up and running.
- 7:37So it's a very important reg from that perspective.
- 7:40And kudos to Kyle Hartland for bringing this up.
- 7:44He also.
- 7:46I wanted to touch on this.
- 7:47If I haven't already, he also.
- 7:49had credit union sent pictures of their storage space.
- 7:52I think I touched on that, but.
- 7:53I've got a blog where I took a picture of what was provided and it
- 7:58it shows exactly why it's an issue.
- 8:00You've got boxes and boxes.
- 8:02They're paying for storage.
- 8:03They don't know what they need.
- 8:04And NCUA improving the regulation, I think would go great towards
- 8:08helping these smaller credit unions.
- 8:10All right.
- 8:10And so the new thing I'm doing here is Discovered some new software.
- 8:14So I was able to take One's entire speech at the board meeting and
- 8:19narrow it down to that and improve the sound quality a little bit.
- 8:22And so what's coming up next.
- 8:24Are the words of vice chairman, Kyle Hartman.
- 8:26The advocate for this proposed rule.
- 8:29And I will have some comments at the end.
- 8:31To close out this podcast.
- 8:33That concludes my remarks.
- 8:35And I now recognize Vice Chairman Hoffman.
- 8:38Thank you, Mr.
- 8:38Chairman.
- 8:39Thank you, Kelly and Matt, for the presentation and Ghira for
- 8:41being available for questions.
- 8:43I want to also thank Kelly for taking the time.
- 8:45I would like to look into the impact of NCOA regulations on records
- 8:49preservation as they're currently written.
- 8:51And I definitely want to thank the leaders of small credit unions, which
- 8:55I think are the reason we're here.
- 8:57We had a meeting a few months back, these small credit unions, they
- 9:00brought up a few actionable items.
- 9:03And I believe that meeting and then our subsequent ones and discussions
- 9:07with Kelly are why we're here today.
- 9:10My point is a broader one, that we actually do listen and there is a point to
- 9:15talk to us and it can actually have value.
- 9:17So, I think there are only maybe three or four credit union leaders on that
- 9:21call we had, but they're going to wind up helping thousands of other people.
- 9:27So, I want to thank those folks.
- 9:29They did a real job and I want to thank our staff for that, that meeting,
- 9:33bringing something to our attention.
- 9:35Actually, it's going to bring, uh, real results to a lot of people.
- 9:41To wit, the crush of regulatory burden weighs more heavily
- 9:44on small credit unions.
- 9:46We cannot talk about financial inclusion or talk about helping small credit unions
- 9:50unless we're doing the sort of things we're doing here today, providing clarity
- 9:53that frees up scarce resources to focus on their actual credit union members.
- 9:57If you go to the extreme, regulatory burden is often cited as a reason
- 10:01why otherwise healthy credit unions.
- 10:04Uh, merge out of existence.
- 10:07But you know what's worse than a regulatory burden?
- 10:09Finding out you're doing things that your regulator didn't even need you to do.
- 10:16We found out credit unions were storing boxes of records from decades ago because
- 10:22they thought that we at NCUA wanted them.
- 10:25Now we're aware that other agencies, et cetera, may require records, but
- 10:28they said we thought you wanted that.
- 10:31Some were paying for storage facilities.
- 10:33And unfortunately, it made sense to do all of this hoarder like record retention.
- 10:39Because as long as you get in trouble for not having a document, and you never
- 10:45get in any trouble for having extra documents, the behavior is fairly obvious.
- 10:51Credit unions and banks talk about this with suspicious activity
- 10:54reports, why they file so many.
- 10:55They never get in trouble.
- 10:56for filing too many.
- 10:57They only get in trouble for not filing one.
- 10:59Their behavior obviously flows from that.
- 11:03Uh, yesterday, and I wish you thought of it earlier, we had the idea to email
- 11:07two people and ask about their specific, uh, credit unions records practices.
- 11:12Um, we got a couple photos at 5.
- 11:1430 p.
- 11:15m.
- 11:15last night.
- 11:15Slide, please.
- 11:21Franz, you got a slide?
- 11:22Yeah, alright.
- 11:23This is what we got back last night at 5.
- 11:2530.
- 11:26Uh, you can see on the right how deep, this is just one credit
- 11:29union, which by the way is not particularly large, I can say it's
- 11:32under 100 million in assets, okay?
- 11:35They're paying for this, um, you can see the yellowed old papers, and so,
- 11:42if someone says, you know, these days we have cloud storage, just scan it.
- 11:48Well, anyone that thinks the answer is just scan it hasn't had to go through
- 11:51all those, and even if, You will scan.
- 11:54Wouldn't it be a pain to find out you scanned a hundred boxes of documents
- 11:57and you only had to scan five?
- 12:00You have to often do it one at a time for old crinkled documents because
- 12:04you have to get the whole document.
- 12:06Otherwise, why are you retaining it?
- 12:07You can even see if any of you are old enough to remember
- 12:09the old dot matrix printers.
- 12:11You literally can't feed them in a stack into a modern scanner.
- 12:15They have those perforated edges on the side with the holes in it
- 12:19and you have to pull them off.
- 12:20I just looked it up.
- 12:21That's called continuous feed paper.
- 12:23Um, and so it's not very easy to do.
- 12:29Um, nobody can argue the need for keeping records.
- 12:34It's important.
- 12:34It's important for NCWay.
- 12:35It's important for the credit union.
- 12:37If I was a new credit union CEO, I'd want them to have good practices.
- 12:40It's very helpful for new management.
- 12:43But we, after 15 years, it's time to re evaluate the unforeseen effects of
- 12:47Part 749, as it's currently written.
- 12:50Uh, even if they are maintaining, um, documents digitally,
- 12:54do they have to do that?
- 12:55That costs money too.
- 12:56Uh, this agency pays for cloud storage as well.
- 12:58We get it.
- 13:00Uh, and I will say that those boxes, uh, to credit this small guy, It's
- 13:04piles of old boxes that probably the people who put the ones in the back
- 13:08aren't, don't work there anymore.
- 13:10And I'll say, I had a storage unit.
- 13:11This is more organized than the one I had.
- 13:14And, uh, I want to thank a couple people at NCUA that cleaned out our supply
- 13:18closets in the hallway on this floor.
- 13:20I can tell you they were a lot messier than that.
- 13:24So even if you have the wherewithal to digitize, do we actually need to digitize
- 13:27papers from 1985 because you think NCUA?
- 13:32If the unintended consequences of a regulation run counter to what was
- 13:35intended, a responsible regulator will re evaluate and adjust.
- 13:40Many of you know that NCWA annually reviews one third of its regs
- 13:43for updates over three years.
- 13:44That means all of them are addressed.
- 13:46On many occasions, the NCA has taken that opportunity to clarify, re
- 13:50evaluate the impact of the regulations.
- 13:53Today's action is an example of that.
- 13:55And although I do want to take credit for bringing this to the board's
- 14:00attention, I'll take credit for that, I want to clarify that I don't
- 14:04think that the reg was written wrong.
- 14:07I don't think it was written incorrectly.
- 14:10I think back then I may well have written the exact same thing, um,
- 14:14it's just the result of it and the incentives that it winds up giving
- 14:18to any regulated institution.
- 14:20And one more thing, uh, we talk a lot about how important it is for small
- 14:24credit unions to have, uh, well, any credit union, but particularly small
- 14:26credit unions to have succession planning.
- 14:28Well, one way we can help with that as an agency is make the job more appealing.
- 14:34Records retention is the example of the straw that can break the camel's back.
- 14:37It's one of the many important but tedious requirements that can make
- 14:40running a small credit union less attractive than it could otherwise be.
- 14:44Thus right sizing the regulatory burden is one way that NCUA can
- 14:47make it easier for credit unions to survive once a long time CEO retires.
- 14:51The job shouldn't have to be a labor of love.
- 14:54NCUA can't control what records a credit union is required for
- 14:57their state or other agencies.
- 15:00But we can reduce unnecessary burden by ensuring our rules are clear and
- 15:03do not require more than is needed.
- 15:06And so the next step here is we're going to look for ideas from the public
- 15:12on what should we actually write, what will actually help that, right?
- 15:19That's what a credit union is going to want.
- 15:20So we can find ideas that reduce the cost, make it less so people are
- 15:27digging through old heavy documents.
- 15:29You probably don't need anything that uses the dot matrix printer.
- 15:32But we need to actually publish something.
- 15:35The good news is, we can probably get some easy ideas from other agencies.
- 15:38Just, second slide, Franz, please.
- 15:41From my Wall Street days, I remember everything was seven years, okay?
- 15:44This is from the SEC.
- 15:46This is kind of what we're looking at.
- 15:48Seven years records, and then they say what exactly that means.
- 15:52Seven years, okay?
- 15:53I remember anything we wrote, even in our Bloomberg chats.
- 15:56With seven years, right?
- 15:57And you knew that, right?
- 15:58This is just an example.
- 15:59Uh, it happens across government.
- 16:02Um, if you filed your taxes on Monday, the IRS, just so you know, is, you are
- 16:08supposed to only have three years worth of records to back up that 2023 return.
- 16:13If they audit your 2023 return, they can ask you for
- 16:16information related to your 2021.
- 16:20The IRS itself is published.
- 16:22We're not going to ask you about 2015, 2021.
- 16:24Uh, uh, records, okay?
- 16:27It's, it's the exact same reason.
- 16:29It's the same reason that in criminal justice, there's a statute
- 16:31of limitations for most things.
- 16:33Because over time, memories fade.
- 16:35Uh, uh, things get lost.
- 16:37People die.
- 16:39Um, and in terms of which year they can audit, just so you guys know,
- 16:43uh, Chairman Harper, you're off the hook from 2017 and earlier to C& L.
- 16:47Uh, they can only even audit the last seven years, uh, from
- 16:50when you filed it, at least.
- 16:51Okay?
- 16:52Um, yeah, right.
- 16:56So thanks again for the staff working this.
- 16:58I just have one question, which is, uh, what I alluded to.
- 17:01I think credit unions, you know, the people who sent that photo in are gonna be
- 17:05like, oh man, I'm glad they're doing this.
- 17:07What happens next?
- 17:08They can't, after this meeting, go and throw out the old stuff just yet.
- 17:13What is the next?
- 17:15I can take that question, Vice Chairman.
- 17:17So, what happens next is really a question for the board.
- 17:21Today's action is an advance notice of proposed rulemaking to solicit feedback
- 17:26from commenters and stakeholders, and we expect to get robust feedback
- 17:31which can then inform any future action that the board decides to take.
- 17:34And that could be, well, be a notice of proposed rulemaking,
- 17:38but that would be a future action.
- 17:39Somebody wants to send us a link, an idea, you know.
- 17:43Can they do that today?
- 17:44They can.
- 17:45Okay.
- 17:45They can provide feedback all the time, just as you received feedback prior to.
- 17:50So, uh, to have an easy idea that would also serve NCOA's
- 17:55purposes, we do need records kept.
- 17:57Um, khautman, ncoa.
- 17:59gov, um.
- 18:01But a lot of these things, the notice comment period, it has an official
- 18:04start date, it has an official end date, and the comments are public.
- 18:08Uh, anyone can email or call anybody anytime.
- 18:12But, so if someone today is hearing about this, they can
- 18:16send something in today to whom?
- 18:20They could send comments in to the NCUA on our website, but specifically in
- 18:26response to this ANPR, this Uh, document once the board approves it, it will be
- 18:34published in the federal register and we provide specific instructions for
- 18:37how the public can comment and it's a transparent process available to all.
- 18:44But if it is top of mind for anybody out there who watches this or hears
- 18:47about it, there's nothing stopping anybody every time, uh, for, you know,
- 18:51Calling or emailing say, here's an idea.
- 18:53Here's what my state regulator does.
- 18:54You know, something like that.
- 18:55Uh, if it's top of mind, that's the time to take action.
- 18:58I'm pleased that I believe all three board members are.
- 19:01Uh, supporting this item and that I believe all three board members
- 19:06know how important it is to not make the life of a small credit union
- 19:11CEO any harder than it has to be.
- 19:14And I think the board is all in agreement that we know that sometimes regulations
- 19:18can make that less attractive, that when a little credit union goes away
- 19:21and that field of membership loses their own credit union, sometimes
- 19:26that's because government has made the job harder than it needs to be.
- 19:30That concludes my remarks.
- 19:31Back to Chairman Harper.
- 19:33Okay.
- 19:33A lot of good information.
- 19:35A word for word from Kyle Houtman.
- 19:37I may do a little bit more of this in the future.
- 19:39Let me know if, if you like this style and, , okay.
- 19:42So, he made some great points about how this will help small credit
- 19:45unions, however, , it's a little bit of a deck chair on a tech Titanic
- 19:49type statement because of what the.
- 19:51Democratic led board is doing right now, tied to fees, tied to overdrafts, tied to.
- 19:57, two.
- 19:59, fees for overdrafts, NSF fees, et cetera.
- 20:01The fact that NCUA, , is talking about a concentration risk, , being
- 20:06a risk tied to fee income.
- 20:09All of those efforts are going to increase mergers.
- 20:11All of those efforts are going to lead to less credit unions and
- 20:14ironically create more of a monopoly type issue situation, in one of his
- 20:20speeches, chairman Harper talked about.
- 20:22The fact that two of the three biggest bay banks don't are don't charge share
- 20:27overdrafts or checking account overdrafts.
- 20:29Well guess what, those guys are going to survive, regardless of whatever happens.
- 20:33So as.
- 20:34The government takes an approach that fees are in and of themselves evil.
- 20:39It's going to create more mergers and banks, more murders and credit
- 20:42unions lead to consolidation and lead to the point where.
- 20:46The big banks.
- 20:47And the big credit unions are all that's left.
- 20:49And is that really what's in the best interest of credit union members
- 20:52and the United States of America?
- 20:54I think not.
- 20:55So again, kudos to Kyle Hartman.
- 20:57I think perhaps if he had another Republican vote, He would change
- 21:01the direction of what's going on in the fee income arena,
- 21:05because that is a very partisan.
- 21:08Topic and I will leave it at that great job.
- 21:11Kyle Hartman.
- 21:12On this particular action and I hope it leads to a board.
- 21:16Proposed rule, which will be followed by a final rule down the road.
- 21:20So it's going to take a while.
- 21:21Probably at least another, it's going to take a while.
- 21:23Probably at least another 12 months to 18 months.
- 21:27To get any final traction on this, but this was a fabulous first step.
- 21:32All right, this is mark.
- 21:33Treichel signing off with flying colors.
- 21:34I hope you'll listen again soon.