Latest / Signal & Noise: Bringing Clarity to Media, Data, Tech and AI / When Boundaries Disappear: Erez Levin on TABOOS, Antisemitism & Moral Accountability
Transcript
- 0:13Hey everybody. Welcome back to Signaling Noise
- 0:16with my Co host Rio Long Anchor. I'm Brett House and today we've
- 0:20got a very special guest who I'm thrilled to talk to.
- 0:23Rio knows him well. I'm getting to know him.
- 0:25His name's Erez Levin, he is a a self-proclaimed media futurist
- 0:31and AD quality evangelist. I'm reading some of the stuff
- 0:33for me to LinkedIn and I think it it gets funnier.
- 0:36A pro social engineer and a paternity leave de advocate
- 0:42advocate. Which I thought was that a de
- 0:45advocate or a de advocate? De Advocate.
- 0:48AD advocate. OK, so you're you're in favor of
- 0:52paternity lab. I thought something when I read
- 0:53it quickly skipped. I thought I read D advocate.
- 0:56D advocate. But you're a principal at Emmett
- 0:59advisor. You run your advisory firm,
- 1:01you're on advisory firm. You're a long time Google
- 1:03employee, like almost a life or 13 plus years right?
- 1:07And as of did you day, I think a whistleblower too, so.
- 1:10And as a senior transformation lead, supporting agency Holdco
- 1:14and Opco companies on priority tech solutions across Google's
- 1:18ad buying platforms. So you're super technical, you
- 1:21know, the industry, ad tech, martech, etcetera.
- 1:23And you went to the you went to school in the great state of New
- 1:26Jersey, where I'm podcasting from right now at Rutgers.
- 1:30So eras, welcome to the show and tell tell the audience a little
- 1:34bit about yourself. And if I missed anything
- 1:36critical. Thanks for having me.
- 1:38What can I add that I didn't already elaborate on in my
- 1:42LinkedIn? Yeah, I think, you know, some,
- 1:46some folks in the ad industry might be familiar with me.
- 1:48But yeah, I think at a high level and where it's relevant to
- 1:51this discussion, I like changing things for the better.
- 1:56I guess. I don't know.
- 1:57I've, I've been fortunate to, especially in my time at Google,
- 2:01be able to affect some big change and see sort of positive,
- 2:06you know, progress and innovation from some of the
- 2:09things that, that I identified. And I got a little bit addicted
- 2:11to it. And, you know, the example of
- 2:13paternity leave at the time, very few men at Google were
- 2:17taking their full paternity leave and taking off.
- 2:20And I realized this through a friend that it was such a huge
- 2:24boon to society, to women, to gender equity, to men, to dads,
- 2:28to divorce rates, like all these things.
- 2:30And I said like, Oh, I'm going to help make this a norm.
- 2:32And so I sort of got thousands of, you know, men to take their
- 2:36leave and made that sort of the default now.
- 2:39So once, once I saw I was able to do that, I keep looking for
- 2:44those opportunities. Was that in partnership with
- 2:46like the human resources department?
- 2:48You probably that was sort of in addition to your day job.
- 2:50I tried to work with them, they they, they helped a little bit,
- 2:55but it, it honestly, a lot of these changes require sort of
- 2:57top down and grass roots sort of movement.
- 3:00And so I sort of this one. 'S cultural, right?
- 3:02I mean, I can see why grassroots is going to be maybe more
- 3:05effective. Yeah, we had to do both for
- 3:08sure. Yeah, no.
- 3:09And I and Rio and I are both fathers.
- 3:11I got 2, two boys that are older ones in college now.
- 3:14And I do remember friends of mine when they were really young
- 3:17that just honestly weren't able to bathe their kids at night.
- 3:20They're at work all the time, right.
- 3:22So just like the simple experiences of the ABC's and the
- 3:25giving the kid a bath and putting them down and doing all
- 3:28that stuff during the week, which so precious and you only
- 3:31get it once, right? You know.
- 3:34Twice if you have two kids, I guess.
- 3:36Yeah, twice. If you have two kids.
- 3:37I knew a lot of people that just didn't experience, didn't see
- 3:39it. It was.
- 3:40I. Literally asked for their wives.
- 3:42I was at a BIG4 firm. I got 0 like they offered zero.
- 3:45Like you had to take vacation or going.
- 3:47One guy went in disability. I couldn't believe how how awful
- 3:50and stingy it was. It was a good dis and it kind of
- 3:52shamed you. And then work culture was very
- 3:55macho. People work all night and you
- 3:57were like publicly shamed at the company if you if you did
- 4:01anything like that. So I'm glad, like kudos to you
- 4:03for fighting for that. Well, at the time, that was the
- 4:05thing I had an easy job because Google gave this really generous
- 4:09policy and said that they supported it, but no one took
- 4:12it. So all I had to do was sort of
- 4:13shift that norm was help make it the norm, right?
- 4:16Help people identify that this is a thing that the company
- 4:19wanted you to do. So yeah, it was a cultural
- 4:20shift. It wasn't a policy change.
- 4:22There were some things later on, but that's what I always like
- 4:25Anchor on. What's the collective action
- 4:27problem that we can help just sort of shift the norm?
- 4:31So Speaking of fighting for things and trying to make the
- 4:33world a better place, eras and you know, we a friend of the
- 4:36pod, friend from the industry, really excited to have you on
- 4:40because this is an important conversation.
- 4:42I really think we need to have. I mean, I've been following all
- 4:45the stuff you've been doing about outcomes versus quality
- 4:48then versus some quality. I mean, it's great, but I
- 4:51actually think this is just as, if not more important the topic
- 4:54we're going to delve in today. And what I like about this, and
- 4:57I think this continues on that thread that you've been pulling
- 5:00about identifying things that are maybe important but make
- 5:03people uncomfortable. And this one really, I think
- 5:07does make people uncomfortable. And this this is going back to
- 5:11the the topic you've been promoting on social media, what
- 5:14you're calling your taboo campaign, which really aims to
- 5:17re establish clear social lines about culture, speech.
- 5:21And what you see is a dangerous erosion to kind of quote.
- 5:25Would you been saying a dangerous erosion of taboos,
- 5:28especially around hate and hate speech.
- 5:30So really, I think this is a really interesting discussion,
- 5:34especially following what's happened in the last two years,
- 5:36right? This incredible rise of of
- 5:39anti-Semitism, this incredible rise of hate that really almost
- 5:43feels like for me came out of nowhere.
- 5:44We're going to dig into that a little bit.
- 5:45But you know, this isn't really supposed to be about politics.
- 5:48We might go into that a little bit.
- 5:50I'm more looking to understand your views on norms,
- 5:53accountability, and how, Kenneth, is it healthy for
- 5:57society not to have natural taboos about things?
- 6:00And how do we balance that with censorship?
- 6:02So I think this is going to be a really interesting, meaty
- 6:05discussion about a topic that again, makes people
- 6:07uncomfortable, but we should be having.
- 6:09Yeah, I I agree. To be honest, I don't think it's
- 6:13that uncomfortable of a conversation.
- 6:15This can dovetail into things that are uncomfortable, but from
- 6:19all the conversations I've had on it, it's very commonsensical.
- 6:23And so people do have some concerns and challenges and, and
- 6:27reservations, but we're generally talking about things
- 6:31that I think the vast majority of at least, you know, I'm
- 6:35talking to Americans, Americans, Westerners, they're appealing to
- 6:39the common values that we all hold.
- 6:41And so it's generally hopefully not too uncomfortable for anyone
- 6:46here in the conversation or listening.
- 6:51Yeah. So before we jump into to that
- 6:53topic, because it's certainly going to be a lion's share of
- 6:56the conversation today and I'm hoping listeners are excited to
- 6:59hear what the Arias has to share about that.
- 7:01You've been let's let's talk about your sort of your
- 7:03botafides in in in media and advertising.
- 7:06You've been spending a lot of time and we talked about this at
- 7:08Advertising Week talking about quality of our outcomes in paid
- 7:11media really pushing back based on your your Google experience
- 7:15on on sort of cheap reach, you know, kind of hollow KPIs or
- 7:19metrics race to the bottom optimization what?
- 7:231st the vanity metrics. You spent a.
- 7:25Lot of vanity metrics. Especially from the platforms,
- 7:27right? Yeah.
- 7:28What, what pulled you towards that, that mindset?
- 7:31What did you see on the ground, you know, at Google and
- 7:34otherwise and, and and what do you think you know, some of the
- 7:37biggest challenges that we have as an industry overcoming that
- 7:40are. Yeah, So, you know, I studied, I
- 7:43loved marketing since I was a kid.
- 7:44I studied undergrad and then later did sort of a like a mini
- 7:48MBA. I understand the fundamentals of
- 7:50marketing. And I think from even my early
- 7:52days at Google, even though I was enamored with search and we
- 7:55thought we were solved Wanamakers, I saw all these
- 7:58issues, right even back then, branded ads taking most of the
- 8:01conversions, these blended Cpas and CPMS and CPCS and all this
- 8:05stuff. And I was like sort of always
- 8:06this cognitive dissonance, but I went into the ad tech world
- 8:09again, this excitement, we're going to fund the open web.
- 8:13But I kept seeing these things breaking things that sort of
- 8:16violated the, those principles of marketing effectiveness that
- 8:20and, and people knew it right as a correlation or causation when
- 8:23we're talking about attribution. And so every time I pulled on
- 8:27little threads, the sort of the illusion that we were in that
- 8:31this all work, the system was all working great for everyone
- 8:34started to crack and it became more and more obvious to me.
- 8:38And fortunately, I was actually in a role.
- 8:41And you know, I give Google so much credit like that it's their
- 8:44fault they made me this way. Like they told me to fight for
- 8:47like look around corners, fight for effectiveness, don't be
- 8:50evil, all this kind of stuff. And so I was constantly doing it
- 8:53and I was rewarded for it. Not with money, not with fame,
- 8:56like I was not, I never like achieved the senior level, but I
- 8:59made my impact and people that did appreciate that I was sort
- 9:02of fighting for the right things.
- 9:03And I was able to sort of earn my seat at the table in various
- 9:07situations because of that. And so I felt good about what I
- 9:10was doing and and it worked well, but at some point Google
- 9:14changed a little bit and didn't want me fixing those things
- 9:17well. They stopped using a Don't be
- 9:18Evil, didn't they? Yeah.
- 9:20Well, I I think of it as sort of the hypothesis, right?
- 9:23The early days, the hypothesis and then this, the thesis.
- 9:26This is angle, right? And then the thesis, right,
- 9:29which is the don't be evil. And then the antithesis, which
- 9:32is probably what you sort of dissent, at least like
- 9:35thematically, stuff that was happening, the monopolistic
- 9:38behavior, all that sort of stuff that kind of rubbed you the
- 9:41wrong way, I'm assuming. That's right.
- 9:44Eris, can we have both quality and outcomes?
- 9:48Can we have both or isn't either or?
- 9:50We must have both. That's not even a question.
- 9:53The problem to me is outcomes. Like there's, they're really
- 9:57easily game there. They could be a vanity metric,
- 10:00like there's all these issues. But then there's a bigger sort
- 10:03of issue with outcomes, I believe as a term itself, which
- 10:06is it generally implies or is generally measured in a single
- 10:10point of time. And most advertising has its
- 10:12impact over both the short and the long term.
- 10:15And so when you consider quality, you inherently have to
- 10:18think quality is only defined based on its likelihood of
- 10:21driving an outcome. But then you ask yourself like,
- 10:24oh, this level of quality drove us this type of outcome in the
- 10:28short term, in this type of outcome in the long term and
- 10:30these proxies, and we should be comfortable with proxies, but I
- 10:33think the outcome is the North Star is much more dangerous.
- 10:36It's basically what we've had for the last 1020 years.
- 10:40Quality will inherently make us think twice and think about what
- 10:44are those best proxies to effectiveness.
- 10:47Yeah. Do you think, do you think it
- 10:49just on a side note on that topic, do you think the ChatGPT
- 10:53adds, you know, not released last week on, on Friday, I mean,
- 10:59do you think that is anything different than what we've seen
- 11:01before? And then I sort of, I put out a
- 11:03post on LinkedIn that there's this shift towards sort of trust
- 11:07first monetization, trying to preserve the customer
- 11:10experience, the relevance, right, as opposed to sort of
- 11:13injecting advertising almost interruptively into the, the
- 11:18consumer experience. I mean, do you, do you think
- 11:20what they're doing is, is the right shift the, the, is it
- 11:23different than what we've seen before?
- 11:25I don't, I don't think they have much of A choice, but I'm not
- 11:29optimistic for the company or for ads in AI services.
- 11:33I think trust is sort of the main reason why users and I, I
- 11:38started to write it out and I'll post it at some point.
- 11:40But like, there's a really simple difference between
- 11:43traditional search and AI search, which is traditional
- 11:45search ads are on the top and users are OK with that because
- 11:49they're not expecting this like really concise answer with AI,
- 11:54users want just the answer right away.
- 11:56And so you can put ads underneath and some people will
- 11:59Scroll down and they'll click on them, but far fewer people will
- 12:02click on them. And why would they?
- 12:05Because the best answer was already up top that the Super
- 12:09smart AI already told them. And so I think AI ads work if
- 12:14there's a discount, if they can say like, OK, these, those are
- 12:16the two best running shoes. Here's a third option that's
- 12:18offering you 20% off. That's a great ad, but for a
- 12:22normal price ad, why would I pick the 4th place or worse when
- 12:26the AI already gave me the? The best recommendation, the
- 12:28question like search ads worked well in my opinion.
- 12:31Big reason was because of that incredible intent data, right?
- 12:34And you think about, and I think over time it's become more
- 12:39obvious or like it's become less obvious what's an ad versus
- 12:43what's an inorganic search listing, which is a problem in
- 12:46my opinion. I think that's really and
- 12:47should, if I the Google experience right now you have a
- 12:50whole page of, of ads and it's hard to tell which ones, which
- 12:53used to be very obvious. So I think that with the
- 12:55incredible, even better intent data they have with AI searches,
- 12:59if the ads are done the right way, that it could be a, it
- 13:03could be even better experience because I look, I personally
- 13:06like guys, maybe if people don't want ads, they should be able to
- 13:08opt out of it. If you pay $200 a month, you
- 13:09probably shouldn't get ads, right?
- 13:11But should a free, should a freemium user or user paying 20
- 13:14bucks get some ads? If they're really good ones?
- 13:16I don't see why. I don't see why they can't be
- 13:18very effective and not diminish the experience at all if the UX
- 13:21has done right. Yeah, I think that like it gets
- 13:24down to the user wants the answer, they want the best
- 13:28answer and they expect the AI to just give them the answer, not
- 13:31the thing that they were paid the most to recommend.
- 13:34They we can do both. I think I agree they can be
- 13:37respectful, but most people are just going to trust the AI
- 13:40organic answer because it was it was given to them.
- 13:43If you look on Google for any of these things for the best sheets
- 13:46or the best shoes or something else, the organic answer, the
- 13:50organic listings are like review sites.
- 13:52The Google isn't telling you this is the best thing the AI
- 13:55will and that one you might trust while you still sort of
- 13:58trust the system. So once it gets into the
- 14:00advertising, this is going to be messy.
- 14:02I'm not, I'm not optimistic about ads in AI by there's a,
- 14:06there's a market, it's a tiny fraction of what we sort of are
- 14:09replacing or cannibalizing. Yeah, and, and Jim and I just
- 14:13had the UCP announcement, right, the universal commerce protocol,
- 14:16which which injects commerce or you know, the into, into the,
- 14:21the answers, but that's generally aligned to questions
- 14:24specifically about product, right.
- 14:27So somebody's asking for a recommendation on X, you know,
- 14:30the top five running shoes for, you know, outdoor cross country
- 14:36running. And and then it would, it would
- 14:38be injected into that response. So there's a certain relevance
- 14:41built in it. Are you, are you hearing
- 14:42anything else about, you know, UCP and.
- 14:46I don't, I don't follow closely, but I sort of the, the
- 14:49competition, while there's still competition in the AI space,
- 14:52they're all competing to give users the best answers that they
- 14:55possibly can, not the best ads or the most relevant ads.
- 15:00And so this is like they're they're kind of in opposition to
- 15:03each other. And I think it's going to be
- 15:05really challenging, especially if Gem and I can just hold out
- 15:07and say like, we won't do ads, go ahead, go use open AI, let
- 15:11people get annoyed there. Maybe they'll get annoyed, or
- 15:13maybe they won't, but Gem and I can just hold out.
- 15:16Well, Google has such an advantage, right?
- 15:18They have, you know, they have the, they have the frontier
- 15:20models, right? They have the own chips, right?
- 15:23They have the data centers that I mean, they have everything,
- 15:25right? So it's, it's a huge advantage.
- 15:27And you're right, they can probably wait everyone out.
- 15:29So, but I also think that they've been, I mean, they're an
- 15:31advertising business. If anyone's going to get it
- 15:33right, it's probably going to be them.
- 15:34But but I think we digress a little bit.
- 15:36How about we get back to the the topic at hand here, because we
- 15:39could probably talk about about this all day.
- 15:42Looking at the, your the taboo topic there is maybe we start
- 15:46with, I mean, let's just maybe take it out back a few years
- 15:49looking at cancer culture. You've been very vocal that you
- 15:52feel cancer culture didn't just silence and ruin people and ruin
- 15:57their lives or remove some shared guardrails that as a
- 15:59society we probably underestimated the importance
- 16:03of. Maybe we can talk a little bit
- 16:04about this. Do you think it did any long
- 16:07term damage to people or maybe underestimating?
- 16:10Yeah, it did indeed. And there's a lot of root causes
- 16:13here. So without going too deep, you
- 16:17know, you know, reading the Coddling of the American Mind
- 16:20many years ago is sort of what started to give me a sense of
- 16:24what was happening and where these things were starting.
- 16:26Obviously cancel culture sort of permeated and we saw that and
- 16:30everyone really understood that viscerally without even being
- 16:33able to define it very well. And then there was a great book
- 16:36a few years ago called The Canceling of the American Mind,
- 16:38which was a follow up to the coddling from one of the
- 16:41co-authors of that group, Greg Lukyanov and Ricky Schlott.
- 16:44And that was super eye opening for me.
- 16:47And this is all actually in the context of October 7th.
- 16:52So I giving a little bit of like background and, and context
- 16:56here. I was born in Israel.
- 16:58I moved to the US as a kid, still always had sort of close
- 17:01ties, spent a lot of time in Israel, identify as a, you know,
- 17:05culturally Jewish proud, Israeli proud, very proud American and
- 17:10always have been. But I'm also very like I came
- 17:14from the left politically, not far left, but I was always like
- 17:18leaned left on most causes and issues.
- 17:21And, but I, I really pride myself.
- 17:24I've always tried to be, or at least in the last few years,
- 17:27very sort of non tribal right. I, I struggle with, with feeling
- 17:33and being hypocritical. Like if I could call out a thing
- 17:36and then they sort of call out an example and I'm not judging
- 17:38the the opposite side, then that that didn't sit right for me.
- 17:42And so I've always tried to be, and I've especially the last few
- 17:44years become very, very principled in how I think about
- 17:48things and making sure that I sort of have that principled
- 17:50approach. And that brought me, let's just
- 17:53Fast forward through my, you know, political partisan journey
- 17:58to October 7th, which was obviously a terrible thing.
- 18:01But October 8th, that was the first crash of these taboos
- 18:06being violated, right? Everyone's big shock when people
- 18:09are so. What was wild to me areas like
- 18:11on October 8th before the Israelis.
- 18:13Look, I mean, I've lived in Israel a couple times.
- 18:15I'm, I'm Jewish as well. And you know, I, I'm also my
- 18:19entire adult life, I've voted for Democrats and always felt
- 18:23myself more, I would say a progressive, but more of a
- 18:25liberal right where I, you know, I've, I, I just, you know, the
- 18:29toxicity of the, of the right and Republican Party always
- 18:31turned me off and I, although I always discern myself a moderate
- 18:34right. So, but I mean, that was such a
- 18:36surprise to be October 8th. Bodies were still not even
- 18:39buried yet. Israelis hadn't even done an
- 18:42offense, a counter offense, you know, done a counter offensive
- 18:45to actually do anything about the fact that people were
- 18:47kidnapped and 1200 people have been slaughtered and people were
- 18:50protesting already saying accusing them of genocide.
- 18:53I mean, I could not believe what I was seeing.
- 18:55It was like. And then the people that I felt
- 18:57politically were on my side, the people and I always, always have
- 19:01felt right that I should be fighting for a society that's
- 19:05more free, more open and more accepting of difference in
- 19:08diversity. And I always felt that that's
- 19:10not only the right thing to do, but that was, that was the smart
- 19:12thing to do, you know, being a being a minority, right, that
- 19:15you want to be, you want to be on that side.
- 19:17But to see the people on, to see many of the people on the left
- 19:20completely, almost like in invert reality and make
- 19:28accusations that I felt were true.
- 19:29I mean, I, I just felt like that I, I couldn't believe what I was
- 19:32seeing. So it, it was, it was, it was a
- 19:34really shocking time. So I hear what you're saying
- 19:36like it started on October 8th and it hasn't really stopped.
- 19:40Yeah, I remember the oh, yeah, Sir.
- 19:42Go ahead, go ahead. No, I remember.
- 19:43I remember. I remember a friend of ours and,
- 19:45and Rio and I have have, you know, our own little trust
- 19:48groups that we text about a lot of these topics that, you know,
- 19:51I hadn't, you know, not being Jewish.
- 19:53I hadn't. But most of my friends being
- 19:55Jewish, I'd sort of culturally been aware and sensitive, but I
- 19:58hadn't really done deep dives into the topic of of what it
- 20:02means to be Jewish, what it means to be Israeli, what it
- 20:05means to be a Zionist. How are these things being
- 20:07defined right. And and October 8th, same thing.
- 20:11I had my Jewish friends from Brooklyn texting and just almost
- 20:15like it, not in hysterics, but in sort of fear going, you're
- 20:18not going to believe the things that I'm hearing from people in
- 20:20our own school groups, social networks, right.
- 20:24And it's exactly what Rio said it was This, this.
- 20:26This backlash and, and what I wanted to do was just triple,
- 20:30double click into where foundationally, culturally in
- 20:34the last 30-40 years. I mean, none of us are naive
- 20:37enough to know that this kind of thing wasn't possible again, but
- 20:41but I'm like, where is this coming from?
- 20:43And that's when we started diving into not only the history
- 20:47of the region and of the people, so to speak, of your people, but
- 20:52also this, this notion of an oppressor versus oppressed sort
- 20:57of system, right? Where it which was a very black
- 21:00and white read of history to me. And there was, I went to college
- 21:04after that, right? I mean, so that was kind of
- 21:06alien to me too. I mean, I graduated College in
- 21:08the mid 90s, right? That was not really yet a thing.
- 21:10So I think that it obviously it became a thing and that it it
- 21:14seems to paint the entire world view of people.
- 21:17And I think that getting, you know, I like looking back to
- 21:19cancel culture, I think that was the those were some early
- 21:23warning signs that this was going off the rails, right?
- 21:25That there was this this this this oppressed or oppressed
- 21:28worldview that that was going to I think have some really
- 21:31uncomfortable outcomes for a lot of people starting October 8th
- 21:34and start we cut you off errors, but but go ahead and and.
- 21:37Yeah, that was that was all. That was all sort of part of my
- 21:39journey. So I started reading so many
- 21:41books and obviously having a million conversations.
- 21:43So the cancelling of the American Mind was one really,
- 21:45really foundational book for me. And there were a lot of others
- 21:47as well that talks about sort of this like idea of neo Marxism
- 21:50and oppressed or oppressed and sort of that framing and how we
- 21:53got here. And this is not a new thing.
- 21:54This is not five years, 10 years.
- 21:56This is really going further back of this like sort of long
- 21:59game, which, you know, I can identify because I was at
- 22:03Google, right? Like I was in a place where this
- 22:06stuff was really seeping in and becoming more normalized, even
- 22:09with really, you know, moderate, you know, pragmatic people
- 22:14looking at these things. I fell for it to do a degree,
- 22:17right? I wasn't out there to the Max,
- 22:19but I saw it. I saw sort of the these
- 22:22narratives and they made sense because I'm an empathetic
- 22:24person. And but I think I think the the
- 22:27combination of the oppressor, oppressed and this idea of
- 22:32cancel culture and this idea that at the core and what I
- 22:36identified right away is that self censorship is really the
- 22:40root of all of the issues. Because people were seeing, I
- 22:45saw this at Google, you see somebody teaching some oppressor
- 22:49versus oppressed thing. And you're kind of like, I don't
- 22:52know, that seems a little discriminatory, right?
- 22:54Like, that's a little, that's a little reverse discrimination.
- 22:57But you But you couldn't say anything you.
- 22:58Can't say it if you say you get accused.
- 23:00And so this idea, cancel culture was just so strong.
- 23:03And I realized I have to unfortunately, going back, I
- 23:07built up a little bit of a reputation on LinkedIn for just
- 23:10being a good guy, right? I'm advocating for paternity
- 23:12leave, for gender equity, like all of this stuff.
- 23:14And I felt like I'm not going to get cancelled because like no
- 23:18one's going to accuse me of being like a racist or a bigot
- 23:20or anything else. Like, I have a really good
- 23:22reputation and I'm coming out there on LinkedIn.
- 23:26Was that true? What?
- 23:29Did you ever? Did they did they try to accuse
- 23:31you? You know what, nothing stuck.
- 23:33Anyone who tried like it failed because no one's going to be
- 23:37like, and they're like, no, I know Eris, he's a good guy.
- 23:40And and and none of my texts. I didn't say anything hateful.
- 23:44I'm like, hey, these are important conversations would we
- 23:47should be having. And I'm getting pings from
- 23:49people on the side saying thank you for speaking up, people that
- 23:52were scared to like my posts. And so I felt, you know, like
- 23:56almost a duty that I needed to to continue to speak these
- 23:59things and and. People would be scared to like
- 24:02your posts. I mean, I find that so to
- 24:05dystopian, yeah, it's it's almost like.
- 24:06Signaling, like if you signal this right, if you don't include
- 24:11your pronouns on your and I got it.
- 24:13I got an e-mail from a former company that that literally
- 24:16stated if you don't show your pronouns within your e-mail,
- 24:20that could be considered a negative signal to those in that
- 24:25group that have chosen to select a specific pronoun, right?
- 24:28And I'm like, to me, that is a relatively illiberal statement,
- 24:33right, to say, you know, because I'm not signaling anything, I'm
- 24:36just choosing not to represent my own pronouns as as a just a
- 24:41right, a freedom of speech, right?
- 24:43And I'm not signaling against any other norm, any other
- 24:47identity or personal value at all, right?
- 24:50But the feeling, and I think that's what you're getting at
- 24:52eras is that is that you feel like either you're being
- 24:56typecast, right, because of who you are.
- 24:59You know, you could be, you know, we, we won't even go to
- 25:01the details and people could assume that you are, you know,
- 25:05one of the oppressors versus the oppressed, right?
- 25:07That you're and you get typecast and put into that box and then
- 25:10suddenly people are afraid to like your comments.
- 25:13Well, but I'm glad to hear nothing stuck.
- 25:14I mean, that is good to hear Errors.
- 25:16Yeah, you are a good guy, have good reputation.
- 25:18I mean that that that should go a long way.
- 25:19And it helped. It helped, honestly.
- 25:21Like, are there other people telling me they wish they could
- 25:22say these things and they just didn't feel comfortable doing
- 25:25it? So I felt like, you know, that
- 25:26responsibility And so, so yeah, so that was my journey.
- 25:30And I think we can like Fast forward because things have just
- 25:32gotten crazy over the last two years, even crazier.
- 25:35And it took me some time. There were a lot of things that
- 25:38I was sort of identifying overtime and, and really only in
- 25:41the last few months did it really like materialize for me.
- 25:45And that that word taboo, which is what I sort of identified.
- 25:50This is the thing that's wrong. And I've done a lot of research
- 25:54and I've really thought about this and had a lot of
- 25:56conversations. But that is to me what the
- 26:00biggest danger we have in society because taboos, if you
- 26:05think about taboos like they're it's a big term.
- 26:07It can mean anything like picking your nose in the
- 26:10conversation, like that's taboo. But taboos are generally things
- 26:14that society, yeah, society shuns, right?
- 26:17Like mostly society thinks society or it could be a
- 26:20subculture, doesn't have to be all of society, but sees a sort
- 26:23of this like non, you know, non acceptable behaviour, speed or
- 26:27behavior. And since time immemorial, like
- 26:32when we were literally like living and, you know, tribes, if
- 26:35you committed a taboo, you potentially get shunned out of
- 26:39society and experience not just social death, probably real
- 26:43death. And that was the idea of cancel
- 26:45culture. It was so painful that now that
- 26:47social death doesn't necessarily equate to real death, but we are
- 26:50so allergic to it. And so we generally try to
- 26:52conform within some bounds to our society.
- 26:56So that's the role of taboos have played and played very
- 26:59important roles, right? They protected the tribe from
- 27:03something sometimes really dangerous.
- 27:05Now taboos change over time. They change with culture, they
- 27:08change with norms, they change with laws.
- 27:11Things that were taboo around, you know, slavery, let's say
- 27:14when we had slavery or with sled segregation, it wasn't taboo to
- 27:18say the N word. Now it is taboo, right?
- 27:21So that is how like the laws and the norms have changed.
- 27:25What I think are the timeless, sacred, essential norms that
- 27:31society cannot allow to erode are around hate, bigotry like
- 27:38overt bigotry, dehumanization, and the endorsement of violence.
- 27:43Those are ones that if we permit, we get into really big
- 27:48trouble and we can see multiple examples throughout history,
- 27:51including the Holocaust, which Holocaust Remembrance Day is
- 27:55coming up, that show us what happens when these things become
- 27:59tolerated and then. Normalized.
- 28:01Normalized. So, so it sounds like you're
- 28:03kind of drawing a straight line. You're saying cancer culture,
- 28:05the stifling of speech kind of resulted in people being afraid
- 28:09to speak up and it and it seems like this is almost encouraged.
- 28:13I mean we start we talked about what we saw on the left in terms
- 28:16of accepting, you know, incredible anti-Semitism and
- 28:18insane behavior, But like on the right too, right that you know,
- 28:21the woke. I mean, I know we both listen to
- 28:24trigonometry epic constant and kissy and I love I love his.
- 28:26He talks about the woke left and woke right, how this kind of
- 28:28horseshoe theory, they kind of meet and meet in this insane
- 28:31place, right. So I think that it sounds like
- 28:33you're drawing a straight line and saying cancer culture
- 28:36stifling of norms like forcing people to, you know, be afraid
- 28:39to speak up. Yet I think encouraging people
- 28:42who yet at the same time somehow encouraging hate speech and not
- 28:46giving people the ability to speak up against it seems like
- 28:49that's the argument you're making.
- 28:50I am sorry if I'm paraphrasing you.
- 28:52No, no, it's great. It's a, it's actually like a
- 28:54really important nuance here. And it's something that took me
- 28:56some time and I'm still trying to push this narrative out.
- 28:59So Greg Lukyanov and Ricky Schlaf who wrote the Canceling
- 29:02the American Mind. And Greg runs FIRE, which is the
- 29:04foundation for individual rights and expression.
- 29:07And I respect both of them so much.
- 29:10And everything that Greg is doing, like donated to FIRE
- 29:12many, many times, but he sort of promotes this narrative.
- 29:15He's so anti cancel culture, which I understand, but he
- 29:18promotes this narrative of opinion absolutism.
- 29:20And nobody should be fired for sharing their opinion.
- 29:23And I'm trying to tell him actually, there are opinions
- 29:26that people should be fired over.
- 29:28Like universally everyone would agree they should be fired, not
- 29:33just can be, but should be. And this is the the nuance that
- 29:37it took me some time and it was Charlie Kirk's actually
- 29:39assassination that helped solidify a lot of this for me.
- 29:43Like it really came into clear sight of what's cancel culture
- 29:47and what is a sort of inappropriate response,
- 29:49consequence culture, whatever you call it.
- 29:52And the way that I saw it, and I don't know how much time you
- 29:53guys spent online after that, there were, I'd say three types
- 29:57of responses that I saw directly from Charlie Kirk's
- 30:00assassination. There were probably most people
- 30:04that sort of publicly responded. They were, you know, they, they
- 30:07were, they were horrified. Whether it doesn't matter.
- 30:09It doesn't matter what you thought of him or not, whether
- 30:12you knew anything about him. You were like, that's terrible,
- 30:14that's a terrible thing. He shouldn't die, most people.
- 30:16Don't didn't even know who he was right exactly, but yeah.
- 30:19Yeah, And then you had a second group and these people I call
- 30:22the remorseless, right? These people, like literally
- 30:25went out there and just said, like, he was a jerk, he was a
- 30:28Nazi. I don't care that he's dead,
- 30:30right? They just had no remorse for
- 30:32him. Then there was AI.
- 30:33Know a lot of people who said things like that.
- 30:35Yeah, exactly. And then there was a third
- 30:36group, and those were the rejoicers.
- 30:38Those are the people that were celebrating it and were happy
- 30:42and were saying yes and yeah, get bench, bench.
- 30:47Now, what happened was very interesting and I immediately,
- 30:50like everyone had the visceral reaction to that third group and
- 30:52said that is awful. Like everyone knew it right
- 30:54away. What happened was interesting.
- 30:56Some people online, probably more on the right and Charlie
- 30:58sort of fans, they started a whole website that had named
- 31:02every single person that was in Group two or three, the
- 31:06remorseless or the rejoicers. And they said these are the
- 31:08people they tracked down their names, where they worked, who
- 31:11their bosses were and reached out to try to get all of them
- 31:14fired. And what happened by and large,
- 31:16and I was there defending the remorseless.
- 31:19I was defending them and saying, hey, that that's OK, that's in
- 31:23bounds. But what happened is basically
- 31:25the taboos held. Naturally, the people who
- 31:28rejoiced got fired. The people who were remorseless
- 31:32did not get fired. That's how the taboos should
- 31:35work. And so when they were tested,
- 31:37society basically responded to them the way that they should.
- 31:41The problem as I see it is that we are not forcing people to
- 31:44respond to these. So when someone stands on the
- 31:47street and says kill all the Jews, I support Hamas or
- 31:50whatever else, you know, sort of crazy taboo violations, not just
- 31:53against Jews, against any group. Kill, kill then, you know, kill
- 31:58anybody. Those things, nobody's testing
- 32:01it. No one is saying that person
- 32:03must lose their job or that person must be sort of pushed
- 32:05back against. It's interesting if you look at
- 32:08you know, what's going on in the Middle East, I would say the
- 32:11three groups probably looking at the protests here, probably a
- 32:14very similar right. You have your people who were
- 32:16holding up signs saying, you know, they love Hamas and from
- 32:19the river to the sea or slaughter all the truth, right?
- 32:22You there are people doing things like that, right?
- 32:24And I think you have a small group of people who are saying
- 32:27this is great, we support it. And I think you have a slightly
- 32:31larger group of people are saying, I don't have a problem
- 32:33with, I wouldn't do that. I don't endorse it, but I don't
- 32:35have a problem with it either. Then I think you have a majority
- 32:37of people are saying this is messed up.
- 32:38They probably shouldn't be doing that at all, right?
- 32:40So I think there's the three, three groups.
- 32:42That example is probably can be applied to different situations.
- 32:46Yeah, and. And and what I think, and I
- 32:49think you can apply that same logic right around those sort
- 32:51of, you know, those three things were sort of seen in October
- 32:548th, right? They were seen after the Renee
- 32:57Goode killing, right? And coming from the right in the
- 33:02extreme. And I think some of this taboo
- 33:04culture is being sort of usurped or undermined by, you know, our
- 33:10commander in chief, right? And it's and it's and it's
- 33:13trickling. It's trickling down, you know,
- 33:16just the type of rhetoric that you see, which I know to a
- 33:20degree is hyperbolic rhetoric to get some to some underlying sort
- 33:24of goal, right? Often times I'm not sure how in
- 33:27control and in five dimensional chess, he's actually playing
- 33:31there. But point is, is that's the type
- 33:33of rhetoric that's being passed down and heard everywhere you
- 33:38go, every feed you look at every social media feed, our kids are
- 33:42seeing this, right? And it's, and I think it's, it's
- 33:45making us more coarse and crude and, and, and we're starting to
- 33:50forget the taboos, right? That are sort of the, I think of
- 33:54the taboos as sort of the cultural context that it's the
- 33:57rules of engagement around culture can vary by culture.
- 34:01And, and you have to, you have to know what that context is and
- 34:05abide by it just as a simple means of respecting your fellow
- 34:10person, right? That, that, that's in my, my
- 34:13wife is Japanese. And there's a tons of context
- 34:16where you go into a conversation and you've got to know the
- 34:19unspoken context and be able to read between the leaves to not
- 34:22be sort of castigated culturally for being just completely
- 34:27oblivious to what's going on. And I think we we've which?
- 34:30Is easy to do in Japan. Which is easy to do in Japan.
- 34:33You sit in the wrong seat, you can get in trouble, right?
- 34:35Yeah. Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 34:36It's so it's so it's interesting to see your perspective.
- 34:39And it seems like you're saying that that taboo has this
- 34:42application it regardless if it's if it's you, you wrote neo
- 34:46Marxism, right? On the opposite side of that
- 34:49spectrum is neo fascism, right? And they both are, I think,
- 34:53equally illiberal, right? Meaning they're going against
- 34:57classic, not progressive, but classic liberal philosophies and
- 35:03approaches to, to kind of modern civilization and culture, right.
- 35:06As you're saying, it's that it's not one side or the other.
- 35:09It's these norms that everybody needs to abide by because it's
- 35:12being abused by the extremes on the right and the left.
- 35:15Yeah, and that's actually. So the two root causes, I
- 35:17believe the two biggest root causes for why these taboos have
- 35:20eroded 1 is starting with that sort of oppressor oppressed
- 35:25where we we've almost normalized and permitted these taboo
- 35:28violations as long as it was against an oppressor, right?
- 35:32Like you couldn't be right. You could say kill Whitey,
- 35:35right? Like that new people got away
- 35:37with saying those things because, oh, they're the
- 35:39oppressor. And then obviously, even in a
- 35:41more like intellectual academic way, we've normalized some of
- 35:44these things. But the other one, and this
- 35:46speaks to it and this is absolutely a problem with both
- 35:48the left and the right, is this idea of, you know, no enemies to
- 35:52the left, no enemies to the right.
- 35:53We've become so hyper polarized, hyper polarized that if you are,
- 36:00and I fell in that trap, right? I wasn't a crazy partisan, but
- 36:03if what I was a Democrat, like if somebody on my side, a
- 36:07Democrat violated, maybe not the most crazy taboo, but something
- 36:11else. My default is to want to defend
- 36:13them. My default is to to protect them
- 36:15in some way. And this is just normal
- 36:17tribalism that you cannot totally avoid, right?
- 36:20It's going to be natural. But this is where we have to
- 36:22push back and say, guys, let's have principles here.
- 36:26If somebody Charlie Kirk's death, if people on the far left
- 36:29or the far right, we're celebrating this or anyone else
- 36:31pick and the the you know, Democrat, the Minnesota
- 36:35congressman that were shot like this has to be a universal.
- 36:39And I came up with principles that we can apply in a way where
- 36:43you don't have to worry about what side you're on.
- 36:45Did somebody violate explicitly this taboo?
- 36:48Well, they then they must face social consequences for it.
- 36:50And that's a very important. It's interesting.
- 36:53I mean, I think 1 outcome of what you're describing is the
- 36:56polarization is the radicalization, right?
- 36:58And I think it and it gives us a bunch of false choices, right.
- 37:01And I, I the example of, you know, the Democrats wanting to,
- 37:04to like no enemy to the left, Republic is no enemy to the
- 37:07right. It's it's gotten us to a really
- 37:10toxic place. And I I would, yeah, like, I
- 37:12actually am independent now. And I actually feel it's been
- 37:14kind of liberating, right, to not feel like I have to defend
- 37:17anyone. But it's but I've noticed too
- 37:18with some friends, like I will, I think being independent, I
- 37:22think, I think the president, I mean, I think he's generally 95%
- 37:25of what he does is pretty awful. But you know, like, like a
- 37:28broken watch is still right twice a day.
- 37:30You know, there are some things he's done that maybe I don't
- 37:32think closing the border was the worst idea in the world.
- 37:34And I think having a same same integration policy is probably
- 37:36not a bad idea. But but there shouldn't be a
- 37:39choice between like, but I don't think what ICE is doing is
- 37:42great. They shouldn't be like
- 37:43brutalizing people and rating it's crazy, right?
- 37:45So, but it's like this. But there shouldn't be our two
- 37:47choices. It shouldn't be binary between
- 37:49ICE rating like rating cities and like be arresting people for
- 37:54no reason versus an open border with 10 million people streaming
- 37:57over. So I think this like the
- 37:59polarization has given us this false choice between those two
- 38:02when the reality is we should have be able to have nuanced
- 38:04discussions and nuanced policies that are probably take the best
- 38:07from both sides, right? And and I'll, I'll add to that.
- 38:10So, you know, I've been a big advocate for voting reforms for
- 38:13a long time. I think that's at the root cause
- 38:15of sort of that polarization and and this sort of like lesser of
- 38:18two evils that we're always choosing between.
- 38:21It's going to be really hard to solve this taboo problem when it
- 38:24comes to elected officials, when it comes to, you know, sort of
- 38:28the pundits and celebrities and like these people at the top,
- 38:32you can't it's going to be hard to sort of like directly cancel
- 38:35them and affect them. What I want to do is sort of
- 38:38like. Are they are they gerrymandering
- 38:40themselves into into? That's exactly what you're
- 38:43saying. Yeah, yeah, they're they're not
- 38:44competitive district, 83% of our congressional districts are non
- 38:48competitive. And so you're only Democrat or
- 38:50Republican is always going to win and so.
- 38:53And they're and it's reinforcing.
- 38:54The primary. The primary is a reelection,
- 38:56right? They're like, I'm not speaking
- 38:58to the the middle, the norm of the mean.
- 39:01The primary Americans have said it and.
- 39:02You lose if you do that. Yeah, I'm, I'm speaking
- 39:04specifically to this contingent that's been gerrymandered so and
- 39:08I have to speak to the tribe in the tribes language.
- 39:11And if I don't, then somebody else is going to come and speak
- 39:14to that tribe in the more tribal language than me.
- 39:17And that's, that's the biggest risk, right, is getting
- 39:19primaried and not somebody beating you from the other side.
- 39:23So, and, and that's the, you know, look, we're going to try
- 39:26to solve that. We're working on solving that.
- 39:28It's going to happen slowly but surely.
- 39:29But in the meantime, this is something that everyone can do
- 39:33is just look at the people around you and who are they
- 39:36cozying up with? So the other example that I, I
- 39:39think is really, really helpful here is thinking about the KKK,
- 39:42right? David Duke and the KKK were
- 39:44clearly violating these moral taboos, right what they were
- 39:48advocating for now. There was a consensus, yeah,
- 39:52every like. Everyone.
- 39:53Every consensus, you know, maybe like there's like a few crazies,
- 39:56like generally everyone accepted these, these people outside the
- 39:58outside of the pale, right? So they wore masks, right?
- 40:01Because if they didn't, what would happen?
- 40:03They would lose their jobs. They would lose their friends.
- 40:04No one would be able to publicly associate with them.
- 40:07Even if they did, they were sympathetic to their cause in
- 40:09some way. Why?
- 40:11They were toxic. They were social pariahs.
- 40:13No one, no politician could say, you know, could hold their hand
- 40:16around David Duke and expect to get elected because they'd lose
- 40:19all these moderates. These people would say, no, no,
- 40:21no, That's an inviolable taboo. So we need to do the same thing
- 40:24today, right? This is the where I got really
- 40:26frustrated in this part of the the road I led to.
- 40:29And this was with the Democrats. It's with Republicans too.
- 40:32Mamdani is a perfect example. He is he's friend.
- 40:36You could say he hasn't violated A egregious taboo explicitly
- 40:39himself. If he is cozied up with people
- 40:42who certainly have Tucker Carlson, you could argue, you
- 40:45could argue, OK, maybe he hasn't, but he's friends with
- 40:48he's having the cuentas on. You should not be allowed to
- 40:51associate those people become toxic.
- 40:53Now, if you're going to interview them and really
- 40:55challenge them and make it clear to your audience, I don't
- 40:58subscribe to those taboo views, that's OK.
- 41:00But if you're not, if you're leaving it ambiguous and you're
- 41:03basically letting your audience believe you're trying to appease
- 41:06the sort of normals and, and normalizing and sort of, you
- 41:09know, sanitizing the these taboo violators and their views, that
- 41:14to me is deserving of social consequences.
- 41:16And I think we're seeing that a little bit with Megyn Kelly, for
- 41:18example, that some people are saying, you know what?
- 41:21Like you're too cozy, you're too cool with Candace Owens saying
- 41:25her things, which are clear taboo violations.
- 41:27Candace Owens still has a top three podcast globally.
- 41:30I mean, I think that's what's so like she like the, the things
- 41:33she's saying are completely insane.
- 41:34She was saying. The ability to be there was an
- 41:36Egyptian. Plane there so receptions plus
- 41:39Mossad anonymous of his own organization killed him.
- 41:43Yeah. I mean, listen, we're going to
- 41:45have, we're going to struggle here in the digital age.
- 41:47There's anonymous people. We have global audiences,
- 41:50whatever money is behind it, clicks and eyeballs and
- 41:53everything else. So we can't get Candace to 0
- 41:56followers. There's always going to be
- 41:57people or some people just want to watch the train wreck and
- 41:59they're just curious, sort of watching on.
- 42:02So. But The thing is, no 118 year
- 42:05old kid, a 16 year old kid or somebody else shouldn't be going
- 42:09out there and saying like I love Candace Owens.
- 42:10She's the best. If you say that, huge red flag,
- 42:13right? Like everyone around you should
- 42:15say, never say that publicly. Well, I, I was up at parents
- 42:18weekend at Syracuse and my son Miles, he was not a maybe I
- 42:22shouldn't name him, but but he was not political in any
- 42:25respect. We were talking about the
- 42:28Charlie Kirk assassination just as, as a topic because it was
- 42:32All in all in front of us, right?
- 42:33And try, you know, just at dinner.
- 42:35And he started quoting as, you know, evidence what he'd been
- 42:39watching on TikTok, which was, you know, that it was a
- 42:41conspiracy theory, right? And so I, you know, had to spend
- 42:45some time with him to talk about the charlatan and that
- 42:49narcissist that is Candace Owen, that is that is selling crackpot
- 42:53theories to a gullible public through social media with no
- 42:58investigation, no physical evidence.
- 43:01This is an investigative journalism.
- 43:03This is just charlatanism in the modern age.
- 43:06And yet, you know, not these non political 18 year olds in
- 43:09college that don't know any better and aren't aren't you
- 43:12know, particularly well read maybe on the topic are taking it
- 43:15as potential fact. And that is shocking to me,
- 43:20right, that that even should be considered.
- 43:23How much of this, like, how much of this crazy behavior do you
- 43:25think is like a consequence of cancel culture?
- 43:27Because you know, if you cancel things, if you say you can't say
- 43:30these things, they're going to be people that say, I don't
- 43:32care, this is edgy. I'm going to do it anyway.
- 43:34I mean, how much of this, I mean, because I, I think that's,
- 43:37I think they're probably related, right?
- 43:38As soon as you tell someone something's forbidden, it's
- 43:41going to become more attractive to certain people.
- 43:43I, I, I totally agree. I understand where that's coming
- 43:47from. But ultimately consequences can
- 43:50be more powerful than the allure, right?
- 43:53You tell someone that if you go out there and say, I hate X
- 43:56group, you will lose your job, you will lose your social
- 44:00standing. People won't do that.
- 44:01Maybe they're going to go online and they're going to find ways
- 44:03to do it, but most people can't survive those consequences and
- 44:07those are deserved, right? This is something that is
- 44:08universally believed. So I think there's like a moral
- 44:11case now. There's something really, really
- 44:14important here in sort of my principles and how I'm
- 44:16approaching this, which is to differentiate this from cancel
- 44:20culture. And this is really clear, not
- 44:21just cancel culture is usually like a fringe offense, right?
- 44:26It's something that only a small group as opposed to these
- 44:28universal moral taboos that everyone agrees is wrong, right.
- 44:33Maybe somebody will say, like, I don't think it's so wrong to say
- 44:36I hate the Jews. Well, can I say I hate the
- 44:37blacks? No.
- 44:38OK. Then that's the taboo, right?
- 44:39You can get them to sort of understand even if they're
- 44:42they're sort of like partisan and tribal in nature.
- 44:44But the really important part is offering grace and forgiveness.
- 44:48And so cancel culture was universal.
- 44:51You got socially canceled. That's it.
- 44:52That's it. Like a death sentence.
- 44:54You don't like come back. People find their ways back, but
- 44:56almost in these alternative spaces, they never sort of like
- 44:59fully renown, like the, you know, get their sentence
- 45:01commuted. What we have to do.
- 45:04And the example here that I gave Charlie Kirk's, the people that
- 45:07were celebrating that day, all of them in my opinion deserve to
- 45:11lose their jobs. Any employer, any employee that
- 45:15their their fellow Co worker should say, I don't feel safe
- 45:17working with this person that wants to see people killed for
- 45:20their speech. So that person should lose their
- 45:22job, but every single one of them should be able to come
- 45:25back. I don't know if it's a week
- 45:26later, a month later and say I have reflected, I'm sorry.
- 45:29I realize just how wrong that was.
- 45:32Like I was caught up in the mob. Everything else, good excuses,
- 45:35bad excuses, doesn't matter. But if they truly renounce those
- 45:38bad taboo views they had and they're not like then doubling
- 45:41back and going to their friends and being like, fuck those guys,
- 45:43like kill them. Sorry for cursing.
- 45:45But unless if they're not doing that, we have to let them back
- 45:49into polite society. Even the KKK and my one of my
- 45:51favorite examples. I don't know if you guys have
- 45:53heard of Darrell Davis. He was a a Blues drummer, I
- 45:57believe, a famous Blues driver, a black guy.
- 46:00And he I think a clan member went to a show like accidentally
- 46:05saw him and was like, I didn't know black people can drum that
- 46:08well. And Darryl Davis is like, are
- 46:10you kidding me? Like here's this like XY and Z
- 46:13the fit, the most famous drum. They became friends.
- 46:16Darryl Davis befriended multiple clan members, like over a dozen,
- 46:20if not more, got them to disrobe right just by getting having the
- 46:24conversations with them. And so I think anyone can be
- 46:27reformed, can be saved. That's a lot of work.
- 46:30And I'm not going to assume like, oh, let you violate your
- 46:34taboos as much as you want and maybe one day we'll convince you
- 46:37not to. No, you're going to suffer
- 46:38consequences today for violating these taboos.
- 46:41We all must sort of agree on those.
- 46:44And then if you decide to say, you know what, that's not worth
- 46:47it to me, or you truly reform, then you come back and you stop
- 46:49violating them. Yeah.
- 46:52And how much? Well, let me let me one comment
- 46:54before I ask my question is that that might the term cancel
- 46:57culture, it to me seems tribal by definition.
- 47:02It seems fundamentally left to right, right.
- 47:06It seems fundamentally, you know, the the, the woke left
- 47:09cancelling the right, right. And and I don't think what
- 47:13you've described in some of these cases with the Charlie
- 47:15Kirk assassination could could be considered right, left,
- 47:18right. So, so do we should we use
- 47:21terminology that isn't triggering?
- 47:23Because I think cancel culture in a sense is possibly
- 47:25triggering as unidirectional and is pointing the finger the blame
- 47:30for sort of the Balkanization of our country on one side of let's
- 47:35say a political ideology spectrum?
- 47:37I mean, is that, what do you think about that?
- 47:38Yeah. I mean, I think that's what it's
- 47:40become because everything's become so hyper partisan.
- 47:43It's sort of turned into that and it's the default right.
- 47:48Like you are on the left and you commit a taboo and the right
- 47:51tries to cancel you. You can count on people on the
- 47:54left defending you, and even if their best defense is well, the
- 47:58right did it too. Most.
- 48:01People on the right say now that they're cancelling people that
- 48:03say, oh, the left started it right.
- 48:04I mean, so that there's a lot of that going on.
- 48:06Yeah, yeah. So, so how much responsibility
- 48:08do you place on him? And we, you know, I've talked
- 48:09about my son's own experience with Candace Owens and such
- 48:14social media social platforms. How do you think that's impacted
- 48:18discourse? How do you think it's, you know,
- 48:20and, and my supposition is that is that there is there's an
- 48:24underlying mean of just American specific society that actually
- 48:30kind of really drifts towards the center and that these
- 48:33extremes aren't reflective of the overwhelming majority of the
- 48:36population. And and social media is maybe a
- 48:39megaphone for the extremes. It's kind of like statistics.
- 48:43You know, the people that are likely to put a five star Yelp
- 48:46review or a one star Yelp review are the extremes.
- 48:50They're not. But they give the most.
- 48:52Reviews, Yeah. So.
- 48:54So what do you think about social media?
- 48:55And it's sort of nefarious or even positive impact on American
- 48:59culture and some of these things.
- 49:02Mostly nefarious, mostly negative, right?
- 49:05In all the ways people are willing to say things online
- 49:07that they would never say to someone in person.
- 49:09The ability to be anonymous, the ability for somebody to say a
- 49:12terrible thing and have 50,000 likes.
- 49:14You don't know who those could be.
- 49:16Bots. Those could be from outside the
- 49:17country. But it seems there's social
- 49:19proof that comes from that. And that person doesn't get
- 49:22cancelled. And so you create those
- 49:24permission structures. That's what every time a taboo
- 49:26does not get sort of receive consequences, it creates the
- 49:30permission structure. So October 8th, very few people
- 49:32were coming out there and saying like we support Hamas.
- 49:35If they did, they actually, I, I laugh, Mia Khalifa, that's her
- 49:39name, the, the porn star, she came out and said something and
- 49:42she got cancelled because it was like within that week.
- 49:45But if she'd like waited 3 weeks and said that same thing, it
- 49:48would have been fine because all of a sudden people started
- 49:50tolerating these things. And so the permission structures
- 49:53just increase and increase over time until it spills into actual
- 49:56violence. And so to your question, social
- 50:00media is a big, big part to blame and we can't do much
- 50:05about. There are some things that I
- 50:06would love to see done, policies within the platforms and things
- 50:09like that. What you did with your son, I
- 50:11think is really, really interesting.
- 50:14This is like one of the other narratives and I decided not to
- 50:16like focus on it, but we need to bring.
- 50:18It was interesting in a good way.
- 50:20Yeah, yeah. No, you did the right thing.
- 50:21You did it. There was a good parenting
- 50:23thing, right? Like there, there's a one I
- 50:26thought about. We need to bring shame back.
- 50:28Shame is a really powerful tool and society needs it like
- 50:33taboos. Most taboos, you actually
- 50:35respond to somebody. If you, if somebody isn't being
- 50:37malicious or really hurtful, you respond with a little bit of
- 50:40shame, a little bit of prodding, right.
- 50:43You weren't necessarily shame your son, but you were kind of
- 50:45saying like, Hey, let me educate you.
- 50:47And if you don't get educated and you do this like you're
- 50:50going to sound like an idiot. You're going to you're going to
- 50:52like all these bad things will happen to you, including maybe
- 50:55getting cancelled, right? Including like all these other
- 50:57things. And so I want the I'm super
- 51:00empathetic person. Let's envelope the people when
- 51:03they violate a taboo, unless they're going out there and
- 51:06saying the most vile thing, which we're not going to be able
- 51:09to like through love, convince them.
- 51:11But most other people need to be corrected.
- 51:13So when 18 year old kids or whoever else are following Nick
- 51:16Fuentes and Candace Owens, I'd love all their parents to get
- 51:18involved with them and say like this is bad.
- 51:21Those are bad people. I don't care if he tells you
- 51:24some other things and he's right the clock twice, right twice a
- 51:28day. Like you said, Rio, that could
- 51:30be true and it's OK. You can like those things that
- 51:33he says about this. You also have to be very clear
- 51:37that there is a line. And so I think that's the.
- 51:41Make it human, right? Make it human.
- 51:43Make it make people feel something like Imagine you in
- 51:46this scenario. Imagine you in this seat.
- 51:49Look through these other. Or like that guy he met that
- 51:51drummer who is black guy. You realize, wow, this guy's is
- 51:54is cool. Like, maybe my beliefs were
- 51:56mistaken, right. So I think I think there's
- 51:57something there. Brad.
- 51:58Yeah. That's interesting.
- 51:59Coming out, coming out with facts just doesn't do the job
- 52:02that does it because facts are sort of removed from human.
- 52:04The inhuman feeling. It's also, yeah, it's also like
- 52:08I have, I've had a lot of debates now on on social media
- 52:11about this and somebody saying like, no, no, you can't, no
- 52:13consequences, just refute the facts.
- 52:15I'm like, they're not using facts.
- 52:17They're just hate, right? Somebody's saying I hate black
- 52:20people. There's no facts.
- 52:22That's going to probably get me to change their mind.
- 52:25And so if my options are let them say that and let them be
- 52:29continue to be employed or instill social consequences, I
- 52:33think the choices, it's really clear, especially when we know
- 52:36what happens if we let these things go unpunished.
- 52:40So looking at social, I mean like it's gotten, I mean, trolls
- 52:45bought farms, racist, crazy people.
- 52:48I mean, it's the it's, it's it's a place where it gives them a
- 52:50place where they can be anonymous.
- 52:51They can say the worst things. And I think, you know,
- 52:54especially if they're anonymous, maybe there are no consequences,
- 52:56right? But it's funny, I mean, I, I
- 53:00don't use Facebook a lot because I got so sick of like my liberal
- 53:04friends and my conservative friends just fighting.
- 53:05It just was so toxic. I'd say I just checked out,
- 53:08right. I said, I've had enough of this,
- 53:09right. But I still am on X mostly
- 53:11because all of ad tech is on X, right?
- 53:12And you are, and a lot of people that I really respect and I
- 53:16think are super witty and, and say some interesting and fun
- 53:18things are on there. But it is a really toxic place.
- 53:21So, and I always get asked by friends, why are you still on
- 53:24there? And I say, well, you know what?
- 53:26Yeah, there's lots of garbage. But if you just ignore the
- 53:29garbage, you curate your feed, there's some amazing
- 53:31discussions. You're granted all the news
- 53:33organizations left, all the scientists left, but looking at
- 53:35ad tech and tech, there's some amazing content on there.
- 53:39There's lots of great things on X and you just have to learn how
- 53:42to avoid this. The, you know, the cesspool that
- 53:46exists. So unfortunately, it it works
- 53:48for me. Not that I feel great after
- 53:50reading it because I'm seeing like the worst things about the
- 53:53world, but I'm seeing like really interesting perspectives.
- 53:56But I've been very active. I mean, I don't know how much
- 53:58you see, like I'm there calling out and trying to normalize this
- 54:01term like taboo, right. It's a thing that when you say
- 54:04to people, not everyone knows exactly what it means.
- 54:06But as you articulated people, Oh, and then when someone sees
- 54:09it getting violated, it becomes really easy to identify and then
- 54:13agree punishments are warranted here.
- 54:17So I think that'll work on the actual people who are just maybe
- 54:19misguided. But I mean, I think so much of
- 54:20the activity is driven by foreign intelligence services
- 54:23bought for, I mean, a lot of the biggest, biggest shit posters,
- 54:27right? It turns out they were like
- 54:28Pakistan, Nigeria or like India or like, so a lot, a lot of them
- 54:31were actually based in other places.
- 54:33A lot of the people were spreading the most, you know,
- 54:36disinformation and hatred. I thought that was pretty
- 54:39interesting. But but that is a good point.
- 54:41I mean, if people are posting terrible stuff, there should be
- 54:44consequences. I don't think we should restrict
- 54:46speech. I think that is a slippery
- 54:47slope. And and I think just making
- 54:50those those taboo views shameful, right?
- 54:53So Nick Fuentes says all his these terrible things.
- 54:57Kanye West comes out with a song called Hail Hitler and everyone
- 55:01thinks it's funny and everything else.
- 55:03But the more that these things are sort of seen as taboo,
- 55:06people will feel ashamed listening to them.
- 55:08I'm not saying like don't listen to them, but like you should
- 55:10feel a sense of shame to in any way support or align with.
- 55:15And if you mentioned the word Nick Fuentes, like say his name
- 55:18and say, I think he's a terrible person in XY or Z ways.
- 55:22But he did say this interesting thing here that was totally
- 55:25unrelated, right? Like that's OK.
- 55:27He he's not wrong on every single thing he's ever said, but
- 55:31the ability for sort of to create that like moral shame, I
- 55:35think for for especially young people, but even others that
- 55:39will defend them because they're a part of their political tribe.
- 55:42Like that's a Hassan Piker. Like how many people are
- 55:45following Hassan Piker because he's sort of in the democratic
- 55:49socialist and, you know, maybe they're Jewish and they don't
- 55:52like all of these things, but they don't I.
- 55:54Could not believe the New York Times gave that guy a puff
- 55:56piece. I mean, I, I couldn't believe
- 55:58it. So they should be shamed for it,
- 55:59right? Like imagine these.
- 56:00David. Research.
- 56:02Imagine they did that for David Duke.
- 56:04So, so they should be shamed, right?
- 56:05Like all of these people, Anyone who is enabling these taboo
- 56:09violators, it should be shamed for it.
- 56:12Who defines who defines the, the the taboo?
- 56:15Who defines the set of taboos? And I think culturally the US
- 56:19obviously is, is a melting part, but it's the meeting point of
- 56:21multiple cultures around the world.
- 56:23So you don't have the homogeneity of a place like
- 56:25Japan where everybody knows what the context is and the taboos
- 56:28are some might be, you know, egregiously outdated, but
- 56:32because they haven't had to deal with sort of constant change and
- 56:36constant adaptation to kind of multiple perspectives and
- 56:40backgrounds, right? the US doesn't have that.
- 56:42We're a messy democracy. How do you actually create some
- 56:45sort of norm that everybody can agree on without going back into
- 56:48the tribal battles of like, no, that's not a taboo, Yes it is.
- 56:52No, it's not. Yes, it is.
- 56:54How do you actually? Where we are now.
- 56:56A base level of yeah. So This is why I define them
- 56:59like really, really specifically like they're the ones that tied
- 57:02directly to sort of our liberal values right in in the US,
- 57:06Western values, American values, liberal values, whatever that
- 57:08is. So overt bigotry, dehumanization
- 57:11and endorsement of violence. Like it's really just those
- 57:14three. There's a, there's a third one
- 57:16that's I think a little bit apart and I try not to delve
- 57:18into it. It is a very interesting
- 57:19conversation, which is around censorship, which is like
- 57:22blocking speakers. That is actually a taboo, right?
- 57:26It like violates our First Amendment And so that one, but
- 57:29that's a little bit more of a university specific, but it's
- 57:31really about hate, right? It's a really about these
- 57:34things, hating a group or hating a person based on the group
- 57:38they're in, or hating a group just because of that group that
- 57:41they're in. Now, there are nuances, there
- 57:43are exceptions. Do I hate the KKK?
- 57:46Yes, because they are taboo violators.
- 57:48Right? Like you can be intolerant of
- 57:50intolerance, but otherwise, like there's a tolerance is, is
- 57:56really what it is. Like we we're sort of accepting
- 57:58of everyone in society unless they are socially destructive in
- 58:03this taboo way. Not in a oh, Republicans want to
- 58:07take away abortion. Well, they're doing it by legal
- 58:10means. I don't like all of it.
- 58:11And they're certainly like there's there's lots of issues,
- 58:14but very rarely are there like really egregious taboo
- 58:17violations. And if there are, those things
- 58:19need to be punished. So I think that's it's like it's
- 58:22kind of clear. Now that's not to say it's
- 58:25always clear cut. There are plenty of nuances.
- 58:29And I think that we should only punish people when they've
- 58:32egregiously and explicitly violated a taboo.
- 58:36So what we need to do, and one of the principles is give people
- 58:39an opportunity to sort of like clarify their views, right?
- 58:43Give them people to to retract if they said something that
- 58:46could be perceived as a taboo. So if you talk about crime
- 58:49statistics or something else, right, those are taboo things,
- 58:52right? You talk about crime statistics
- 58:53by race or something like that. Taboo, that's dangerous.
- 58:57No, you're allowed to talk about those things.
- 58:59But if you do it and try to sort of perpetuate some sort of
- 59:03hateful consequence to create some dehumanization around that
- 59:07is a taboo. And so I can say, hey, there's
- 59:09higher crime in this population. And you and anyone else should
- 59:12be able to ask me like, well, what do you mean by that?
- 59:15And what's, what are the implications of that?
- 59:16And if I, if I and. If you're not and if you're not
- 59:19intending and if you're not intending harm or dehumanization
- 59:22or whatever marginalization, then then you're not breaking a
- 59:26core Tibet. Let me ask you, this is where do
- 59:28people go? Because we you've been talking a
- 59:29lot about this. You talked a little bit about
- 59:31sort of gerrymandering and, and, and vote voters, not voter
- 59:34suppression, but voter manipulation.
- 59:37Maybe where do, where can people go to actually act on some of
- 59:41this stuff to be part of either community groups or are you
- 59:45launching an organization? Are you part of organizations
- 59:47that you can share with the audience?
- 59:49So there's a bunch of organizations about voting
- 59:51reform, so open primaries and rank choice voting.
- 59:54So every state basically is doing this on their own and
- 59:56there's some really interesting ones.
- 59:57So definitely look and support them however you can.
- 1:00:00And certainly if there's a ballot initiative in your state,
- 1:00:02vote for that. What I'm launching right now
- 1:00:04today is starting with the sub stack.
- 1:00:08I'm trying to sort of mainstream this idea of taboo.
- 1:00:10So like I'm calling it holding the line and really just trying
- 1:00:13to encourage everyone in your day-to-day who you see, right?
- 1:00:17Like the taboos? It only works if we enforce it.
- 1:00:21We as all of society. This does not come from
- 1:00:23government. Speech is always free from legal
- 1:00:26consequences. But the social consequences only
- 1:00:29work if all people are sort of, most people are involved.
- 1:00:32And So what we need to do is start to recognize when you see
- 1:00:36somebody on the street saying kill the Jews or globalize the
- 1:00:41intifada, and you know what that means and you see a politician
- 1:00:43that is cozying up to them and not denouncing them, that is a
- 1:00:47problem, right? And you decide if if you're
- 1:00:49going to vote for them, support them, write them a letter.
- 1:00:52We have to draw that line both within our sort of like normal
- 1:00:56polite society, but also within our leaders, our political
- 1:00:59leaders. You can't have a person on your
- 1:01:01podcast who's violated taboos unless you're going to challenge
- 1:01:04them on those taboos. And that's what.
- 1:01:06We but. I think there's a there's an
- 1:01:08issue with monetization, right? Because a lot of these, you
- 1:01:10know, Candace Owens, I don't know if she believes in any of
- 1:01:12the the crap she's spewing, but I mean, she makes a lot of money
- 1:01:16on it, right? She she was the number one rated
- 1:01:17podcast for a long time. She's definitely driving a lot
- 1:01:20of eyeballs. No, no, it may be a third of
- 1:01:22those people errors. Maybe just be going to watch the
- 1:01:24train wreck, but people still are going right.
- 1:01:26So under under Biden and during that period there was like a lot
- 1:01:31of prominent conservatives were demonetized, right?
- 1:01:34There were some were even debanked, right?
- 1:01:35I mean, so like, is it a slippery slope?
- 1:01:39Like, does it ultimately lead to that?
- 1:01:40I mean like like how do you draw the line?
- 1:01:43Yeah, So no, I'm I, I won't. I don't think we should de
- 1:01:46platform demonetize anyone else. I want to get the audiences off
- 1:01:50of their platforms, right? I want to get people to say I
- 1:01:53refuse not just to watch Candace.
- 1:01:56I don't want to be friends with someone who watches Candace and
- 1:01:59likes her, right. This is the the power of
- 1:02:01association. I call it the moral guilt by
- 1:02:04association. And so Zoran Mandani maybe is
- 1:02:07not guilty of the taboo, but he's he's buddied up with one of
- 1:02:10the al Qaeda lawyers and whoever else that.
- 1:02:14He continues to pack his administration with Total.
- 1:02:16It's OK if he went, if he went there exactly.
- 1:02:19He's normalizing and laundering and sanitizing these people in
- 1:02:21their views. If he went there and said I
- 1:02:24disagree with him, right. He's he's buddied up with Hassan
- 1:02:26Piker who said America deserve 9/11.
- 1:02:29If he does not, he can go go talk to Hassan, make it really
- 1:02:33clear to the world that you don't agree with him because
- 1:02:35otherwise you're trying to basically get and this is what
- 1:02:37is happening. They want the problem.
- 1:02:39Is he does agree with him, I think he.
- 1:02:40Does it's possible? It's possible.
- 1:02:42Like I, I don't know and I can't know that for sure.
- 1:02:45He needs to make it clear because he is not allowed.
- 1:02:48What I don't want is our politicians, they're not allowed
- 1:02:50to have both their radical audiences, you know, far left or
- 1:02:54far right and the moderates. They have to pick.
- 1:02:56We have to make them pick. And this is I'll say one more
- 1:02:59thing, but what bothered me so Charlie Kirk gets gets killed.
- 1:03:04I don't know if you remember Bernie Sanders made like a 4
- 1:03:06minute video this appeal and my fellow Americans and this isn't
- 1:03:10us and we know violence doesn't have a home and blah blah.
- 1:03:13And all these people are praising him.
- 1:03:14What a great video and I was mad.
- 1:03:17I said what a failure because what he didn't do and what he
- 1:03:20needed to do was say anyone who is celebrating this murder.
- 1:03:23You were out of my party right because I guarantee most of them
- 1:03:26were democratic socialists of America.
- 1:03:28And if he does not denounce them specifically, they basically
- 1:03:31think they're free reign, right? All he said was like, we don't
- 1:03:34do violence. Well, those people didn't do
- 1:03:36violence. They just said, well, violence
- 1:03:37is great. My concern is you're going to
- 1:03:39take over the party, right? I mean, you know, the
- 1:03:41Republicans have been taken over by some more extreme elements,
- 1:03:44right? And I think the same things
- 1:03:45happening in the left now. I mean, that, that, that, that
- 1:03:47that's the future. I unfortunately see the sliding,
- 1:03:49sliding to. Maybe if you do the taboo thing
- 1:03:52right it might stop it. This is where we have to draw
- 1:03:54the line and say we need a brave leader, right?
- 1:03:56There needs to be a brave Democratic moderate leader who
- 1:04:00steps up and says, I'm going to denounce that far left and make
- 1:04:04clear to everyone in the middle, especially all the Democrats who
- 1:04:07left to go vote Republican or become independent because they
- 1:04:10saw the party went too far left and they're making that bet now.
- 1:04:14I think the only one that we saw come a close to that was Dean
- 1:04:17Phillips in the the last election and it did not work out
- 1:04:21well for him. I'm not sure anyone else is
- 1:04:23going to be brave enough to do that, but that's going to be.
- 1:04:25Andrew Yang left the party, right?
- 1:04:26I mean, he, he tried for one cycle and he's great so.
- 1:04:29Well, he realized it's a systemic problem, right?
- 1:04:32He needs we need to change the election system in order to to
- 1:04:34make that change happen. Yeah, the angry centrists of
- 1:04:38America unite and rise up right and radical.
- 1:04:41Centrism. Yeah.
- 1:04:42And then the radical centrism gets it gets criticized for not
- 1:04:46choosing sides. And it's like, you know, we're
- 1:04:48trying to, we're trying to rise above or beyond this paradigm,
- 1:04:54right? This let this black and white,
- 1:04:55you know eye for an eye paradigm which is, which is not having
- 1:04:59positive effects on our country. You wonder how much of this
- 1:05:01though you you brought up social media before, Brett, like how
- 1:05:03much of this like you think about in history, like these new
- 1:05:06technologies come out. The printing press came out and
- 1:05:08I've heard arguments that are pretty persuasive that the
- 1:05:11Reformation wouldn't have happened if it weren't for the
- 1:05:13printing press, right. I mean, Martin Luther was used
- 1:05:15it to print out things and distribute them And and I think
- 1:05:18you could argue the rate radio and telegram came out like
- 1:05:21telegram, then radio, right. And then, you know, we had World
- 1:05:23War One and World War 2 and like a horrific period.
- 1:05:26I'm not saying it was, you know, not, you know, that was the only
- 1:05:29reason. There are obviously other ones
- 1:05:30as well. But it certainly made it much
- 1:05:33easier to have these conflicts and you can look at it was, I
- 1:05:36would think one of the forces that certainly made it happen.
- 1:05:41So you wonder, social media comes out and then we end up
- 1:05:43with this prolonged period of radicalization conflict that
- 1:05:48we're not at the end of it now. I mean, I'm, I think it's, we'll
- 1:05:50probably have another decade, right?
- 1:05:51A society maybe becomes accustomed to these technologies
- 1:05:55and I don't even know if laws are required, but I think it's
- 1:05:58more like understanding social norms, understanding that when
- 1:06:02you go to these things, how you should be acting and, and
- 1:06:05becoming accustomed and acting the right way.
- 1:06:07And, and I, I don't, we're not there yet.
- 1:06:10I'm wondering like, how much of this instability is at least
- 1:06:12partially being driven by technology?
- 1:06:16I yeah, I think that's there. I've seen also compelling
- 1:06:19arguments that sort of every time there's a new medium of
- 1:06:21communication, like that's when we see these sort of big, you
- 1:06:25know, disruptions. It's not just technology, but
- 1:06:27especially on communication. And so, yeah, I think that's a
- 1:06:30very fair argument. I don't think there's much that
- 1:06:32we can do about it right now on the policy side.
- 1:06:36We're not going to get Facebook to enact or X enact certain
- 1:06:40moderation policies or anything else.
- 1:06:41Like we're kind of stuck in this gridlock.
- 1:06:43We should still push, but I'm not optimistic about those.
- 1:06:46What I do think that we have the power for, and This is why
- 1:06:49literally I'm dedicating most of my time to this, right?
- 1:06:52Like I'm doing the quality stuff that's like a side project at
- 1:06:54this point. And, and it's humming and it's
- 1:06:57moving along and I'm really excited about it.
- 1:06:58But to me, the stakes of this taboo thing could not be bigger
- 1:07:05if we do not restore these taboos.
- 1:07:07Think about what happens. Imagine that it just becomes
- 1:07:11more and more normalized to say whatever you want.
- 1:07:14Imagine you're in a workplace and someone could say just
- 1:07:18discriminate openly against Jews.
- 1:07:20Like we get to a Holocaust like situation and it's not just
- 1:07:24about Jews. Like everyone lost Germany when
- 1:07:26Germany, everyone lost when they had a Holocaust.
- 1:07:30And not just short term, long term, like all of these things.
- 1:07:32This will be so destructive. It destroyed their entire
- 1:07:35society. It will destroy all of America
- 1:07:38and the world. We have to restore these taboos.
- 1:07:41There is no option. And the longer we wait, the more
- 1:07:44normalized they become, the harder it's going to be because
- 1:07:46some people are going to double down.
- 1:07:48Some people are going to say, like, you know what, that's me.
- 1:07:50And I'm fine to be outside of play society.
- 1:07:52And there's a there's a world they can survive, right?
- 1:07:54There's enough money to be made from this online grift, but not
- 1:07:58everyone can. And my view is that we need to
- 1:08:00say there was always like a far right, white supremacist fringe
- 1:08:03right. They lived underground, they
- 1:08:05lived in shack somewhere. They were not part of mainstream
- 1:08:08society. Let's we have to bring them
- 1:08:10back. We have to take the far right
- 1:08:11and the far left, move them out of play society and out of our
- 1:08:14politics. Right A.
- 1:08:15Politician. A politician.
- 1:08:19Duke it out the shacks together, right?
- 1:08:21Let's let them, you know, kill it.
- 1:08:23Kill yourselves. Go on.
- 1:08:28Yeah, so we're saying get the left story together in those
- 1:08:29shacks, let them Duke it out together.
- 1:08:31I mean, get away from society. That may not be a bad outcome.
- 1:08:35Yeah, you know what, I like them being divided a little bit,
- 1:08:38although they're uniting more and more, unfortunately.
- 1:08:41But as long as we don't have to take them seriously, as in we
- 1:08:46don't have to consider their viewpoints for society, right?
- 1:08:49Like they might be a physical threat and they might be us.
- 1:08:53A number that like is is scary, right?
- 1:08:56Like the whoever hate groups and things like that, they can cause
- 1:08:59real harm, but our politicians cannot cater to them.
- 1:09:03Our normals are at our workplaces say that stuff is
- 1:09:07unacceptable. If you wear a KKK robe, even
- 1:09:11outside of the office, you're not part of this company.
- 1:09:15And if you wear a KKK robe, you cannot donate to a politician
- 1:09:20and get them to sort of sway things.
- 1:09:22What I want to do, this is not going to solve everything.
- 1:09:25If we restore these taboos, far from solving what it does is
- 1:09:28sort of sideline all of the most extreme viewpoints.
- 1:09:32Some of them I hope will say that's not worth it.
- 1:09:35Those consequences are too big. They have no consequences, so
- 1:09:38why not? They're making friends.
- 1:09:39They're famous on social media by saying cool, all the Jews.
- 1:09:42But as soon as you sort Nick Fuentes is is rich and famous in
- 1:09:46in all of these ways. As soon as you start to punish
- 1:09:48these people they will decide either I'm going to double down
- 1:09:52and live in that world and make my money from the the Internet
- 1:09:54and anons or I'm going to say I want to rejoin the the
- 1:09:58mainstream and polite society and just be more normal and not
- 1:10:02be so hateful. You know, it's interesting.
- 1:10:04I mean, I almost think that like you can look at anti-Semitism as
- 1:10:07almost a Canary in a coal mine, right?
- 1:10:09That it's a sign of a society that's going off the rails,
- 1:10:12right? I mean, look, I mean, I don't
- 1:10:13think it's specific necessarily about Jews, but I think in
- 1:10:16general, no one likes this. I mean, no one likes this
- 1:10:19successful minority, right? They're usually become a target.
- 1:10:22I mean, Jews are the poster child for a minority that's
- 1:10:24successful. Not the only one right there,
- 1:10:25others too. I mean, I think Asians
- 1:10:27experienced some of this during like the the anti Asian hate
- 1:10:29hate stuff that was going on a few years ago.
- 1:10:31I think that that was that was shocking.
- 1:10:33And I think it's kind of comes from the same place, but I think
- 1:10:35it's a society. It's a sign of a society that's
- 1:10:37tolerating horrific, horrific behavior, horrific beliefs is
- 1:10:41taught and these things are becoming normalized.
- 1:10:43I think you have a very good point.
- 1:10:45That's kind of why we wanted to have this discussion, not
- 1:10:47necessarily about anti-Semitism, but about this being, I think a
- 1:10:50sign of something really gone wrong.
- 1:10:52And how do we course correct? Yeah, and and like, let's let's
- 1:10:57give people a way back. It's so important to me.
- 1:11:00I don't know what's happened since I don't know if you saw
- 1:11:01like a few weeks ago, Kanye West sort of like came out and said
- 1:11:04like, oh, I'm sorry for what I said.
- 1:11:07And then I didn't hear anything. And what I'm hoping is happening
- 1:11:09behind the scenes is some of his, you know, friends, Jewish
- 1:11:12friends and and rabbis or something else are saying, you
- 1:11:15know what? Don't publicly come.
- 1:11:17You got to do a journey, right? Like we need to like help you
- 1:11:20really understand everything that went wrong.
- 1:11:23And we want to understand that you truly understand and and are
- 1:11:26reformed so that when you come out to the world and say like,
- 1:11:29no, I'm changed, we endorse that.
- 1:11:32And what he needs to do is go out and say to all the
- 1:11:35supporters, everyone who follows him and loves him and say, what
- 1:11:38a mistake I've made. Please don't follow me down this
- 1:11:41path. It leads to rot, right?
- 1:11:44A moral rot. Forget financial ruin.
- 1:11:46Forget I've lost sponsorship deals.
- 1:11:48It ruined me. I was surrounded by hate all the
- 1:11:51time, blaming, you know, this one group that has nothing to
- 1:11:55do, right? You had a bad, bad record deal
- 1:11:58with a Jew like that is not the Jews''s fault, right?
- 1:12:01Give him that opportunity to come back.
- 1:12:03He could be a spokesperson for for you know, like for anti
- 1:12:07anti-Semitism. But to me, all of these people,
- 1:12:10like no one is beyond reform forever.
- 1:12:13We can bring people back into the fold, but we have to use
- 1:12:16carrots and sticks. And right now there's a lot of
- 1:12:18people that we first need to lead with the stick real
- 1:12:21consequences. And later on, we can sort of try
- 1:12:24to bring them back and say, hey, like, there's, there's a,
- 1:12:26there's a home for you here in this sort of moderate, more
- 1:12:30moral world. And I think people are looking
- 1:12:33for a way back, right? I think the majority the mean of
- 1:12:37American public, yeah. Society.
- 1:12:40Yeah, society in general and I and I think, yeah, giving people
- 1:12:43just the right way to conduct discourse civilly, morally,
- 1:12:48ethically right, without the wild swings left and right is
- 1:12:52where I think people generally want to go.
- 1:12:54And and, you know, it's it's almost like a a right.
- 1:12:57It's this is, you know, there's like, and and maybe it is a
- 1:13:00social media addiction that's driven some of this.
- 1:13:03And, and there's been fuel added to that fire, to your point,
- 1:13:06Rio, about, you know, external actors sort of fueling the fire
- 1:13:11of American division, right, which is, which is affected all
- 1:13:15of us. And it's affected our politics.
- 1:13:16It's affected our place in the world, how the how the rest of
- 1:13:19the world thinks that is. I mean, you should see my my
- 1:13:21Japanese relatives, how they look at us and how we're
- 1:13:25perceived now, both politically, foreign policy as just an
- 1:13:30American sort of body. And I mean, people are in utter
- 1:13:35shock, right? Just told like there's probably
- 1:13:38an underlying disgust in shock and and they just cannot believe
- 1:13:44that our leadership is behaving this way It's it's.
- 1:13:48This is appearance of a society going off the rails.
- 1:13:50Like I have a friend who moved. He lives in Amsterdam.
- 1:13:52He and he has a business where he helps expats prelocate.
- 1:13:55He helps them, you know, find apartments in schools, you know,
- 1:13:57because moving to a foreign country can be challenging.
- 1:13:59He says his phone is ringing off the hook right now.
- 1:14:01People are hitting him up all the time, you know, from and I
- 1:14:04don't think they're all just progressive people.
- 1:14:06I think it's, it's, it's just generally people are they, they
- 1:14:10see the, they see the people bang for blood, calling for
- 1:14:16violence, saying things that they should not be saying.
- 1:14:18The the hatred and the, and the chaos and it, it's certainly
- 1:14:21we're not in a good place. So if they're social, fabricate
- 1:14:23back errors. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:14:25That's, that's sort of like restoring these guardrails of
- 1:14:28what's like acceptable. There's still going to be a lot
- 1:14:30of the things that people can say and do, but there are some
- 1:14:33guardrails that we need to sort of bring people back within.
- 1:14:37Yeah, well, I think that's AI think that's a great ending to
- 1:14:40this episode and eras. This is different from the
- 1:14:42topics we've covered, which have been largely tech and data and
- 1:14:46AI and and maybe this will be the episode that that sort of is
- 1:14:50the the tipping point for signal and noise, right?
- 1:14:52People are going to lead and go wow, these are talking about,
- 1:14:54they're talking about some really hard things, some really
- 1:14:56hard topics. Well, now they're independent,
- 1:14:58Brett, we can have the, we can have these more uncomfortable
- 1:15:00discussion. I don't think there's a very
- 1:15:01uncomfortable errors. I mean, I I love that you said
- 1:15:03that in the beginning and this was a great discussion.
- 1:15:06Yeah, and thank you for what you're doing and the dedication
- 1:15:08you're putting to it because it's it's you know, and I've
- 1:15:10heard this was kind of the first time that I heard full detail
- 1:15:13around a lot of this and it's inspiring for sure.
- 1:15:17Eras and and, and you know, we're we're behind you and
- 1:15:19anything we can do to support in the audience should look into
- 1:15:23Eras 11. Yeah, tell our guests how they
- 1:15:26can, how they can find out more. Yeah, so my sub stack is
- 1:15:29launching today. It's called Holding the line,
- 1:15:32but it's under my, my name, 1111 ELEVIN 11.
- 1:15:37It's called Holding the line. It's just going to be sort of
- 1:15:39weekly, like essays and writing about taboos from different
- 1:15:42angles and interviews with folks and really just trying to get
- 1:15:46people to to recognize it, really understand what taboos
- 1:15:48are, recognize, you know, when they see them, and understand
- 1:15:52why we have to impose social consequences not just on the
- 1:15:55violators, but on the people who are helping those taboos spread.
- 1:16:00Thank you very much. This is great.
- 1:16:02Thank you and thanks audience for joining us for this
- 1:16:05wonderful conversation. A. 100% talk soon.