Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP174: The Love Triangle
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Hi Tania, Hi Talia. Welcome back
- 0:36everybody to this week's episode of Crimes in Consequences. I hope everybody is doing
- 0:42amazing. Are you doing amazing? No? Absolutely not. I hope everybody
- 0:47else is, man, I hope everybody else is. That takes place in
- 0:52twenty and twelve, and there's a woman. Her name is Carrie Farber.
- 0:56She's a single mother from Counsel Bluffs, Iowa, and she had this chance
- 1:02encounter with Dave Krupa in Omaha, Nebraska. The two quickly hit it off,
- 1:08and it was clear that the relationship wasn't going to be just a flame.
- 1:15Sparks were flying nice, but just two weeks into dating, something inside
- 1:22Carrie Fiber changed forever. She was no longer the woman who lit up the
- 1:27room, and she'd become obsessed with Dave after two weeks. What That's why
- 1:33I said, this wasn't going to just be a flame. Yeah, no
- 1:36kidding, damn he was magic. This would be a mystery that would prevail
- 1:42for years, and when the truth was finally exposed, it was really shocking.
- 1:49This is a story of Carrie Fiber, Dave Krupa, and Liz Golier.
- 1:56Do you know what I think? I listened to a date line Yeah,
- 2:00dateline dateline podcast about this case. Okay, well it's a wild one.
- 2:07Everybody needs a buckle off. But twenty twelve, Carrie Fiber, who
- 2:12was thirty seven years old, was living this happy and stable life in Council
- 2:15Bluffs, Iowa. Her son and she'd given birth to him in her late
- 2:22twenties. He was flourishing in school and she couldn't wait to see like the
- 2:27life that he made for himself. She was a good mom and she loved
- 2:31him and he look I said, he was doing well. But as we
- 2:35know, things aren't always sunshine, rainbows and ponies. Ain't that the truth?
- 2:40Shortly after giving birth to her son, she was diagnosed with depression and
- 2:44bipolar disorder. Slowly, with the help of medication and a lot of therapy,
- 2:51Carrie was able to get her condition under control, and she ended up
- 2:54getting a job working as a computer programmer. Carrie's office was your Omaha,
- 3:00Nebraska, and it was only about four and a half mile drive across state
- 3:05lines. One day in autumn of two and twelve, Carrie took her car
- 3:08in for service and repair at a garage right by her office. Carry left
- 3:14her car with the mechanics in the morning and then she had it off to
- 3:16work. When she returned that afternoon, she met with one of the mechanics
- 3:22that was working on her car. And this is Dave Krupa. Oh,
- 3:25that's how they met. That's how they met. As the two looked at
- 3:30each other, something inside of them, just like I said, sparks started
- 3:36flying. Dave told ABC. Quote, when we looked at each other,
- 3:40there was this little spark. She's showing me something inside the vehicle, and
- 3:46we're standing there and we're really close, and there were just some sort of
- 3:50tension. Ooh end quote. But I think it was a good tension.
- 3:54Yeah, sexual sexual tension. Dave found himself conflicted. He was really attracted
- 4:03Carrie and appeared that she reciprocated his feelings. But there was one issue.
- 4:10Dave knew it was wrong to flirt with a customer and it would undoubtedly be
- 4:14out of bounds for him to ask for her number. Now we're attorneys,
- 4:18so yes, and we do divorces. That's inappropriate, yes, but a
- 4:24mechanic, Yeah, is it really inappropriate? Don't I don't feel like it
- 4:27would be. No, I don't think it would be, but I guess
- 4:30he did. There was a subtraction between the two, but he felt powerless
- 4:35to ask her out. He wanted to remain professional, and he hoped that
- 4:40some sort of divine intervention would make their past cross again and again. I
- 4:45mean I had a hot mechanic. I know, I wouldn't feel like I
- 4:47was crossing any boundaries thing all right? Like, hey, can I get
- 4:53your number? Right? In early twenty and twelve, Dave had recently gotten
- 4:58out of a long term relationship the woman named Amy Flora. The two head
- 5:02two children together, and from reports, it appeared that they maintained a civil
- 5:10relationship and they managed to co parent really well without like dragging their children into
- 5:15their relationship wos. By all accounts, Dave was a good father, He
- 5:20was a good friend, and everyone who met him had nothing but nice things
- 5:25to say about him. It is nice. After breaking it off with the
- 5:30mother of his children, Dave gave himself some time alone. He wanted to
- 5:34focus on himself before doing what most singles do and going like dating apps or
- 5:41rebound relationships. He really just wanted to take some time off. He ended
- 5:46up after a while going on a dating app. He filled out his profile,
- 5:50he added his picture, and he dived into the ce of singles.
- 5:57After swiping left and right, he matched with this woman named Shana Elizabeth Golier
- 6:03who went by Liz. The two instantly clicked. Liz was also a single
- 6:09mother of two kids, and they could relate to all their co parenting issues
- 6:14and trying to date in the modern age with dating apps and stuff. From
- 6:18the start, though, Dave made it very clear that he wasn't looking for
- 6:21another serious relationship and was just really looking more for a casual companion to hang
- 6:28out with. Dave was new to this whole bachelor lifestyle and he just didn't
- 6:34want to jump back in it right right, like he's working on himself and
- 6:41I mean, I kind of get it. This seemed to be okay with
- 6:44this. The two set up a first date and they were both instantly attracted
- 6:47to each other. For the next few months, the two continue to hook
- 6:51up at each other's apartments and spend some time together. So I guess when
- 6:56he says casual, like a casual companionship include the include sex. Yes,
- 7:02he's not looking for someone to go hiking with him? Yeah, and like
- 7:05it's not a movie companion it's everything about a commitment. Apparently exactly. So
- 7:12they hooked up at each other's apartments, they spent some time together, but
- 7:15Liz really wanted more. She wanted to be Dave's girlfriend, something that just
- 7:23made him uncomfortable, and she actually talked to him about like, hey,
- 7:29can we be exclusive and he basically said no, it didn't feel right to
- 7:35him, but they continued to hook up. Ten months later, in mid
- 7:40two thousand and twelve, that's when Dave met Carrie Barber and that's when everything
- 7:46changed. So, even though they were instantly attracted, Dave again didn't ask
- 7:51her out. But remember he hoped that fate would intervene, and it did.
- 7:58He was going through one of his dating apps. Oh there she was,
- 8:01and there she was. Oh wow, to be right. Her profile
- 8:05detailed that she worked as a computer programmer Nebraska, but lived with her son
- 8:09in Council Bluff, Saiwa and Dave's heart just start beating out of his chest.
- 8:16Divine intervention had brought them together, and he immediately sent a message to
- 8:22carry. Minutes later, his phone ring. He took a deep breath,
- 8:28covered his eyes slightly, and he picked up the phone to read the message.
- 8:31As he's peeling his fingers away from his eyes. He got really excited.
- 8:37Carrie had said yes to going on a date with him, so obviously
- 8:39he gave Carrie his phone number and everything was slowly coming together, but just
- 8:46weeks later everything would fall apart. They set up the date and they went
- 8:54out, and they ended up going back to Dave's apartment in Omaha. They're
- 9:00hanging out there and then there's a knock at the door. Oh shit.
- 9:05Dave wasn't expecting anybody, especially at this hour. When he opened the door,
- 9:09it was Liz. She arrived unannounced during Dave and Carrie's first date.
- 9:16Oh, how awkward to collect things that she left behind at Dave's apartment during
- 9:22their very brief fleeing. Carrie awkwardly introduced herself and watched as Liz collected her
- 9:28things. Okay, that's so fucking awkward. The head is so uncomfortable.
- 9:33Yeah, the entire encounter was bizarre and awkward for everybody. I mean,
- 9:37that's just not the way you want your first date to go. But luckily
- 9:43this encounter didn't put Carrie off today, and the two continued to text and
- 9:48call each other when they weren't together. Several more dates followed, and then
- 9:54in November of twenty twelve, Carrie found herself putting in extra long hours at
- 9:58the office because she this major project that she was working on. Now,
- 10:03the two had spent so much time together that they began to reconsider their status
- 10:09of the relationship. Really, Like Dave, Carrie had gone in just expecting
- 10:15a fleeing and she didn't want anything serious. But his kind and carrie nature
- 10:20made her change her mind, and Dave also started thinking about his future with
- 10:26Carrie. He still wanted to take things slow, but he was considering having
- 10:31a future with Carrie. In November, Dave invited Carrie to State's department for
- 10:35the week while she finished that project at work. And that's a week.
- 10:41Yeah. Dave's apartment was a lot closer to her office and it would eliminate
- 10:46the long commute that she would have and take a lot of the added stress
- 10:50off of this like twelve to thirteen hour day work schedule she had because of
- 10:56this project. She arranged childcare for her son Max, so Max ended up
- 11:01being with her mother, and Carrie was looking forward to spending a slice of
- 11:07her life with Dave at his place. Yeah, I mean, she was
- 11:11incredibly close to her son, but she felt confident because her mom's caring for
- 11:18him. On November twelfth, Carrie finished up at work and said good night
- 11:22to her colleagues, and then she headed to Dave's apartment, where the two
- 11:26shared a meal together and they watched some TV before going to bed. Carrie
- 11:31felt this sense of warmth and security in the presence of day, and as
- 11:35the days went on, their connection grew even stronger. One night, Carrie
- 11:41and Dave jumped into bed it was nighttime, and they set their alarms for
- 11:46the following day. When Carrie's alarm went off, she jumped out of bed,
- 11:50got ready for work, and kissed Dave goodbye. Neither knew that that
- 11:54would be the last time they would ever see each other. But before I
- 11:58tell you more, we're going to take a quick break as far as Dave
- 12:05was concerned. November thirteenth, which just another day, Carrie headed to the
- 12:09office early to get a head start on this project, and he himself he
- 12:13was just getting ready for another day working at the shop. He put on
- 12:18his overalls and he made the short drive to the garage where he worked.
- 12:22The first half of day's work day was unremarkable, and then his phone buzzed.
- 12:28It was a text from Carrie. Dave was expecting Carrie to send,
- 12:33you know, lighthearted text about her day or something, you know, hey,
- 12:35what's up kind of a thing, but it was something much more sinister.
- 12:41In the text, Carrie told Dave that she'd been thinking while she was
- 12:45staying with him, and that she wanted to move in with him. This
- 12:50freaked him out. He made it clear at the start of the relationship that
- 12:54he wasn't looking for anything serious, although he was starting to consider it and
- 13:00leave. Carrie had felt that same way, So even though they started becoming
- 13:03more serious, this was just a shock, like, oh, you want
- 13:07to move in? Yeah? A little too fast? Right? Why is
- 13:09this all of a sudden? He wondered whether Carrie had misinterpreted his kindness,
- 13:16and he sent a text to gently let her down. Then just a few
- 13:22minutes later, he got another text from Carrie in which she said, quote,
- 13:26fine, I don't ever want to see you again, go away.
- 13:30I'm dating somebody else and I hate you end quote. It seems like a
- 13:37weird thing to say. Dave was confused, right, yeah, I confused
- 13:41right, concerned, like what, how'll just happen? She'd always been very
- 13:48calm and level headed, and she seemed happy with the status of the relationship.
- 13:56Dave ended up putting the text just in the back of his mind,
- 13:58hoping that Carrie would calm down and maybe lead her apologize for her outburst,
- 14:03but that didn't happen. Dave wasn't the only one to receive a bizarre text
- 14:09from Carrie that day. Carrie's mother, her name was Nancy Rainey, received
- 14:13a text from Carry too, and she knew that Carrie was staying at Dave's
- 14:18apartment for the week. In that text, Carrie addressed her mother, Nancy,
- 14:24and her son Max, telling them that she had quit her job and
- 14:28moved to Kansas. She asked her mom to take care of Max while she
- 14:33arranged to collect him after she gets her life going and bring him to Kansas.
- 14:39Nancy immediately send something was off and she kept trying to call Carrie over
- 14:45and over again. Knowing Carrie's history of bipolar disorder. Her mother was afraid
- 14:50maybe she got to take her medicine, maybe she was having some sort of
- 14:54manic episode. Nancy reached out to the police, but they didn't do much
- 15:00because here is an adult. She wants to move to Kansas, Kansas,
- 15:03Kansas. She wants squitter job and moved to Kansas. She Nancy continued to
- 15:11text and call Carrie, but would never get any responses, at least not
- 15:16from the phone calls. There were very sparse messages here and there, and
- 15:20none of them sounded like something that Carrie would write. From late twenty twelve
- 15:26to mid twenty thirteen, Carrie missed two significant events. First it was her
- 15:33half brother's wedding and second her father's funeral. So we're talking about months of
- 15:39her just being gone. When Carrie failed to attend her father's funeral, her
- 15:45family knew that her life was something something is really wrong. And again the
- 15:50police said basically they were powerless because she's free to disappear. Huh. To
- 15:56me, this is just kind of shocking, because, all right, an
- 16:00adult can disappear if they want. But she had a son, Max Yea,
- 16:03and she was a devoted mom. So if you think the police might
- 16:08take this a little bit more seriously, especially considering she was last known to
- 16:15be at some guy's apartment and then just not paying her bills, not seeing
- 16:23her son, not seeing her mom, not going to her dad's funeral.
- 16:26I know it seems suspicious. Yeah, it's one way describe it. After
- 16:34Carrie disappeared and moved to Kansas, Dave and his ex girlfriend Liz Memberless Yeah,
- 16:41found themselves in the center of basically a harassment campaign. Carrie would send
- 16:47hundreds of texts daily to Dave and Liz, threatening their lives damn. Some
- 16:52of the text read quote, I hate you, You've ruined my life.
- 16:56You're a terrible person. Another one said I will do what I can and
- 17:00make you suffer, and then there was another one that said we belonged to
- 17:03gather Dave. It wasn't just texts that Carry sent either. She somehow got
- 17:10a hold of Dave and Liz's email addresses and began to fill their inboxes with
- 17:15threats and taunts. She was referring to Liz as a whore, stating that
- 17:19Dave could do much better. Than her. This harassment brought Dave and Liz
- 17:26closer to each other, and once again in twenty thirteen, they began seeing
- 17:30each other. I mean they took comfort in each other as both could understand
- 17:37yeah, right going through they're they're victimized and by the same person. The
- 17:41two try to go to the police, but as Carrie had never physically harmed
- 17:45them, there was little the police could do. At this point, everyone
- 17:49assumed that Carrie was offer meads and was on some rampage. One day,
- 17:55Liz called Dave in a flood of tears. She told Dave that someone had
- 18:00quote poor from Dave inside her garage with spray paint. What Nancy also started
- 18:08receiving malicious texts from her daughter. Those texts said that Nancy was never a
- 18:12good mother and that she was too controlling. According to ABC, Nancy noticed
- 18:18something strange about these texts. The weird thing wasn't that her own daughter was
- 18:22cursing her out, but these texts were filled with punctuation and grammatical errors.
- 18:27Carrie was well educated woman, and she was really good at her job,
- 18:32and Nancy told ABC that Carrie quote was always a stickler for punctuation and spelling.
- 18:38Thanksgiving came around and there was one empty seat at Nancy's table. Nancy's
- 18:45concerned by now, like it was just over the top. Carrie did have
- 18:51that mental illness and had issues with not taking her medicine before and stuff,
- 18:57but I mean, it's at the point now, it's ridiculous. The family
- 19:02eighth their Thanksgiving meal and they prayed that Carrie would return soon. Then Nancy
- 19:07and Max celebrated Christmas alone. The only present that Max wanted that year was
- 19:15for his mom to come home. Oh, that's so sad. Carrie continued
- 19:19to send bizarre tax to Max. Really, I guess Max had a phone
- 19:25and Nancy, but neither of them could get a coherent answer from her.
- 19:29When they would respond to the tax, they would plead with her come home.
- 19:33The cries fell on deaf ears. Just because it was a holiday season
- 19:37didn't mean that Liz and Dave had any reprieve from Carrie's harassment either. The
- 19:41two spent November and December looking over their shoulders, fearing Carrie would turn up
- 19:45at any time. Because we remember they're getting threats. Christmas lost its spark
- 19:52for Dave and Liz. To them, it was like just another day of
- 19:55harassment. Then the new year rang out and there was still no sign of
- 20:00Nancy had made so many appeals to the police, but according to them,
- 20:04again, what can we do? As glasses cleaned and people cheered, Dave
- 20:10and Liz hoped that the new year would bring him a new start. In
- 20:15January, the harassment towards Dave and Liz it escalated and it became physical.
- 20:21Dave recalled to ABC quote on one specific occasion, I was sitting in my
- 20:26lazy boy with my feet up watching TV, was trying to relax. It's
- 20:30nighttime, and I get a text saying, quote, I see you.
- 20:33You're sitting in your chair with your feet propped up, wearing a blue shirt.
- 20:38Oh that's creepy. Carrie had now graduated to stalking Dave and Liz and
- 20:45was even maybe camping outside of his home peeping on him. Again. Omaha,
- 20:51police, what can we do? You haven't been harmed physically. Dave
- 20:55and Liz lived in fear, wondering what Carrie would do next. After that
- 21:00spying incident, Dave arrived home to the apartment complex he lived in, and
- 21:04as he pulled his car into his spot, he froze just across the road
- 21:11he saw Carrie's Ford Explorer. Oh shit, he knew that she was watching
- 21:15him, and he called the police and he demanded, Okay, you have
- 21:21to do something. Officers were sent out to the car and they dusted it
- 21:25for fingerprints. The car was immaculate aside from one fingerprint, and it would
- 21:30be later determined that fingerprint didn't belong to Carrie, So who to belong to?
- 21:37While David Liz were at the receiving end of this barrage of hate,
- 21:41Nancy and Max were desperately trying to establish contact with Carrie. Max even sent
- 21:47a message to his mother on Facebook and asked her to answer three questions to
- 21:52prove that she was really in charge of her profile because Carrie was active on
- 21:57Facebook. He asked her what his middle name was, what their first dog's
- 22:03name was, and his best friend's name stuff only she would know. Yeah,
- 22:07but Carrie didn't reply to Max, and that's when Nancy began to suspect
- 22:12that it wasn't Carried that had been messaging them on Facebook and texting them and
- 22:19all those things. Liz and Dave continued to get her asked whenever the two
- 22:26hung out at Dave's apartment. Their phones would blow up with texting emails from
- 22:29Carry. One time, when Dave was at his apartment without Liz, Carrie
- 22:33sent a photo of a woman tied up in the boot of a car,
- 22:36implying that it was Liz. It wasn't Liz. He later found out,
- 22:41and she was fine. Carrie then sent Dave a fake obituary for Liz.
- 22:45Oh no, this is crazy, and yeah, they were terrified. Things
- 22:49were slowly coming to a crescendo. On May eighteenth of twenty thirteen, Carrie
- 22:56posted a bizarre rant on her Facebook page. It read quote, I have
- 23:02answered enough questions to prove myself to everyone. I'm done. You can't either
- 23:07believe I'm your daughter, mother, or sister and friend that you have known
- 23:11your whole life, or you can't just leave me alone. I've proved myself
- 23:15over and over and I'm done. I left on my own free will,
- 23:18and I'm sick of everyone giving me a hard time for doing what I needed
- 23:22to do. I'm not missing I just don't want to come home right now.
- 23:26I'm a grown woman and that was spelled wrong. And if I feel
- 23:32like leaving home, I have the right. I asked my son Max to
- 23:37come with me, but he didn't want to. So when I'm ready to
- 23:41come back home, I will. I'm sorry for hurting everyone and just up
- 23:45and leaving. I know I've upset some of you, but I need to
- 23:48do this for me. Sorry, and I hope some day you can forgive
- 23:52me. I love you all very much, but I need time to sort
- 23:55things out. Well, that's a weird thing to post on Facebook on August
- 24:00seventeenth, So not some times gone by. It's been like over a year
- 24:04since she's been gone. It hasn't been quite a year. A year.
- 24:07Yeah, So I was telling you about multiple texts that she'd been sending in
- 24:11messages through the months, and those were the texts that I just described in
- 24:15messages. It's on August seventeenth of twenty thirteen. Liz awoke to the faint
- 24:22smell of smoke in her home. Opening her eyes, she discovered that there
- 24:26was a fire raging through her house. Her children were there, remember she
- 24:30had two children. Luckily, her and her children were able to escape,
- 24:33but Liz's two dogs, her cat, and her snake died in the fire.
- 24:41The fire department was called immediately they arrived at the scene. The blaze
- 24:45was extinguished, and Liz called Dave in a panic, telling them what happened.
- 24:49Minutes later, Dave received an email from Carrie that read, quote,
- 24:55I'm not lying. I sat that nasty horse house on fire. The horror
- 25:00and her kids die in it. I quote damn. Liz was understandably shaken
- 25:07by the incident, as was Dave. If Carrie could set Liz's house on
- 25:11fire, what's the next thing she's going to do? Fearing for his life,
- 25:17Dave moved. He ended up moving to Counsel Bluffs, Iowa, hoping
- 25:21that the move would get Carry off his trail, but he was wrong.
- 25:26The harassment continued, and she continued to stop Dave, texting him what he
- 25:30was wearing and what he was doing at the time. The relationship between Dave
- 25:36and Liz that slowly broke down. And what's interesting is as the relationship between
- 25:42Dave and Liz faded, the harassment began to peter out too. Really,
- 25:49that's when Dave started thinking about things like, hmm, this is weird.
- 25:55Carry's not harassing me now that Liz is out of my life. He started
- 26:00looking at everything from a new angle, and he wasn't the only one,
- 26:06Ryan Avis and Jim Dody, and they were from Pottawa, Tommy County Sheriff's
- 26:11Office. Sure, okay, in Council Bluffs, Iowa. They've been assigned
- 26:15to dive into this disappearance of Carrie in April twenty fifteen, so finally the
- 26:22police are actually taking it seriously. Interestingly, Ryan decided to investigate gate the
- 26:29case as if Carrie had been murdered really before. They always thought she was
- 26:37alive, but he looked at this angle and it led him down a really
- 26:40wild road. He told Oxygen, quote, there are things that would lead
- 26:45us to both conclusions. You know, she's still active, sending text messages
- 26:51and sending pictures too, so maybe she's alive. But she's also missed so
- 26:56many significant events and hadn't been physically seen by anybody in so long. Time
- 27:03goes on, and the investigators are still trying to figure out the mystery behind
- 27:07Carrie's disappearance, and by this time it's been years. According to Ryan Avis,
- 27:12their big break came in late two fifteen when Liz arrived at the Sheriff's
- 27:18office to file another complaint of harassment. As Liz walked through the details of
- 27:25what happened. Ryan's interest was piqued when Liz announced that the harassing messages had
- 27:32becoming from someone else other than Carrie. She's now being harassed by someone else.
- 27:37Really, this time she was receiving harassing messages from Amy Flora, the
- 27:44mother of Dave's children. Woh what Liz believed that Amy had been the one
- 27:52all along masquerading is carried Oh shit? What spoiler alert? Holy shit,
- 28:00this just took a weird ass turn. Might now and some of them now
- 28:06makes some sense, but we still don't know how happen to carry. Yeah.
- 28:08It was also around this time that Dave discovered one of his guns,
- 28:12which he had hidden in a safe place in his bedroom, was missing.
- 28:17So we're talking a couple of years. Very few people knew about this gun
- 28:22and where he kept it, and he was pretty terrified. Just one day
- 28:26after Liz went to the Sheriff's office to report Amy Flora for harassment and stalking,
- 28:33the Sheriff's received a panicked nine call from Liz. During the call,
- 28:37she told dispatchers that she'd been walking in Big Lake Park in Council Bluffs when
- 28:44a woman approached her. Liz later identified the woman as Amy Flora, and
- 28:48according to Liz, Amy pulled out a gun and shot her in the leg.
- 28:52What she was shot in the leg? Shit? The Sheriff's office arrived
- 28:59at the scene and they called an ambulance. Liz wasn't seriously injured, and
- 29:03the Sheriff's office, Okay, now they're all over Amy. They're looking for
- 29:07Amy. They get her and they bring her to the station. But it
- 29:11became very obvious to them after talking to her she wasn't involved. She had
- 29:18an alibi that was solid backed up by a lot of witnesses for the evening
- 29:22that the shooting took place. So if it wasn't Amy, who wasn't was
- 29:27it? What the fuck? Liz's story slowly began to unravel in front of
- 29:33investigators, and yeah, she's a crazy pitch, let's just say. In
- 29:40mid two thousand and fifteen, investigators ramped up their investigation and Carries disappearance,
- 29:45and they ended up searching her abandoned car more thoroughly. A forensics examination of
- 29:51the car revealed a blood stain that had been hidden under the fabric of the
- 29:56passenger seat. After confirming that that blood was human, a sample was attained
- 30:00and a tested for DNA and they were shocked when they found out that it
- 30:07was Carrie's blood. Oh shit. A mint container also found in the car
- 30:12that bore one single fingerprint, And remember I told you about that fingerprint yea,
- 30:17When they tested it it belonged to Liz. Really, so why was
- 30:22Liz and Carrie's car? Why didn't Lize shoot herself in the leg Let's just
- 30:26be honest with each other here, because she's cuckoo. Cuckoo. When Liz
- 30:33had recovered from the attack, investigators brought her in and they began forensically examine
- 30:40her phone and her tablet. They got you warrants for it. It was
- 30:44quickly established that Liz shot herself in an attempt to frame Amy, like that's
- 30:51so wild. But what they would soon uncover just sent their blood boiling.
- 30:56On Lize's tablet, a digital forensic expert found a deleted photo of Carrie's corpse.
- 31:03No, yes, oh no, she kept a photo of the fuck.
- 31:10That's so disgusting. What the hell? There are also up to twenty
- 31:14or thirty fake email addresses, and they were made to look like they're carries.
- 31:18Oh man, crazy bit Lizz's phone also contained an app that allowed her
- 31:26to send fake messages from Carrie's number. Do you remember that they had that
- 31:29before? Oh yeah, so she of course sent all these fake messages from
- 31:34Carrie's number to herself and Dave. According to ABC quote, the app allowed
- 31:40or to schedule future messages so that we like when she was with Yes,
- 31:45and she got messages. Yes, that is crazy. Isn't that insane?
- 31:49Yes? That takes a lot of fucking planning. So she could be sitting
- 31:52on the couch next to Dave and then be like, oh look I just
- 31:55got this message, or he's just getting one too. Yeah, she couldn't
- 31:59have sent it, And all investigators believe Liz sent over fifteen thousand emails god
- 32:06and fifty thousand texts to herself and Dave posing as Carrie. That's crazy.
- 32:13She needed like a hobby. That's a lot of time. Wow. The
- 32:19image of Carrie's corpse, and to be fair, Liz did delete it,
- 32:22but they were able to find it on her either her phone or her tablet.
- 32:27Of course, implicated her in Carrie's murder, and they had a clever
- 32:30way of getting her to admit it. They asked Liz to correspond with Amy
- 32:36and see if she could get them any information about Carrie's death. Like,
- 32:39yeah, they were going along with the story. Yeah, investigators knew Liz
- 32:44would write emails back posing as Amy. It was fucked up and therefore incriminate
- 32:52herself. Yeah, which is crazy, Like why are She's got an email
- 32:55the fake Amy and then respond as the fake Amy? Yeah. You know,
- 33:00if she had any intelligence, she would wonder why the police would want
- 33:04her to reach out to the person that shot her in the well man,
- 33:07you know, people are stupid. I need you to do some undercover works
- 33:12for us. Okay. She obviously didn't have an attorney. Liz told investigators
- 33:17that in an email, Amy had confessed to stab and carry three to four
- 33:22times in Carrie's car before putting her body into a bin bags trash trash bag.
- 33:31The IP addresses from Amy's email, of course, led them right back
- 33:35to Liz. Dumbassy, dumbass, but she got away with it for years.
- 33:43This was enough evidence for Omaha Police Department to arrest and charge Liz with
- 33:46first degree murder. During her trial, the prosecution showed the deleted images of
- 33:52Carrie's body, including a photo of her foot that showed Carrie's distinct tattoo.
- 34:00Lizze's defense team trying to argue that the evidence was circumstantial at best. You
- 34:07got a picture of her body that sounds circumstantial, while they said there is
- 34:12no body, so therefore, if there's nobody, you can't say that Liz
- 34:15committed a murder. But we know that's not true, and of course the
- 34:19jury saw through Liz's defense. It took until two thousand and seventeen before she
- 34:24was found guilty of first degree murder and second degree arson. Oh yeah,
- 34:29that's she burned her fucking house and killed her animals, pets. She killed
- 34:34her pets and her children were there. What a fucking horrible person. No,
- 34:37I mean, of course she's a horrible person. I'm saying, but
- 34:40she put her children and killed her pets for what for some guy? Yeah?
- 34:45I guess this is crazy, And she might have gotten away with it
- 34:50if she didn't show up to the police and say Amy's now harassing her?
- 34:53Like why do that? Some more dramas she needs? I guess couldn't she
- 34:57just move on and I don't know, find the new guy? Yeah?
- 35:00Right, God, I don't get it. I don't get people. Sometimes
- 35:04she was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole. She's currently
- 35:08housed in Nebraska's Correctional Center for Women. Her next parole board review is in
- 35:15twenty twenty seven, and it's I mean, it's not likely that she'll be
- 35:17granted parole anytime soon. Of course, she maintains her innocence, of course,
- 35:23saying she should be free. Of course, the real murderer is still
- 35:27out there. In the wake of her daughter's murder, Nancy set up a
- 35:32scholarship in Carrie's name, and she told ABC quote, Carrie was only thirty
- 35:37seven years old when she died. If I could talk to Carrie right now,
- 35:42I'd say, I love you. I'm so glad that you were in
- 35:45my life. You have a beautiful son who's got a wonderful life coming,
- 35:47and I miss you terribly. And they never found her body. Well,
- 35:54no, to admit where it is, she'd have to admit she killed her
- 35:58right, and they just never found what the fuck? She probably put it
- 36:00in a dumpster. Yeah that's what I'm thinking. Maybe yeah, shit,
- 36:06Well that's crazy story that is so so crazy, Like why especially why she's
- 36:13with Dave, Why is she she's got Dave. Yeah, they're together.
- 36:16Why would she still pretend? Maybe that brought the sense of that brought them
- 36:22together, but even I mean, okay, so you're together, he's with
- 36:24you, everything's going fine. Do you still need to continue? It's true?
- 36:29Why do you still need to continue? You're right because she's crazy,
- 36:31Because she's crazy, and she needed to make it maybe look like Carrie was
- 36:36still alive. But fifteen thousand emails and fifty thousand texts, that's insanity.
- 36:42Is insanity. So I want to think you guys were all listening to this
- 36:45crazy story. I think that's it. I think that's it. I think
- 36:49that's enough. Crazy's story. Man, people are wild. Anyway, Poor
- 36:53poor Carrie, I know your Max man. Yeah right, like she missed
- 36:58her son growing up all because for what I want to know exactly how it
- 37:04all went down. I know that's crazy. Yeah. Anyway, Well until
- 37:08our next episode, don't kill each other. Bye,