Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Conformity & Obedience: Asch, Milgram & the Psychology of Social Influence
Transcript
- 0:00In 1999, researchers basically discovered that
- 0:03you are practically a mirror with legs. A mirror
- 0:07with legs. I love that. But seriously, without
- 0:10even realizing it, you are constantly copying
- 0:12the posture, the breathing rate, and just the...
- 0:17general mannerisms of the person sitting next
- 0:19to you. It's wildly unsettling when you actually
- 0:21think about it. Right. Anyway, welcome to the
- 0:24psychology undergrad. Grab a coffee, pull up
- 0:27your notes, and let's get into our late night
- 0:29study session. We are two psychology undergrads,
- 0:32and tonight we're reviewing chapter six. Chapter
- 0:33six, influencing and conforming. Huge major midterm
- 0:37topic. Oh yeah, massive. And you... our fellow
- 0:40student and honorary third study buddy are gonna
- 0:43help us just completely tear this material apart.
- 0:46And we really do need to dig deep into this one
- 0:48because the mechanics of social influence, I
- 0:50mean, they're everywhere. We are exploring how
- 0:52the people around us subtly and sometimes aggressively
- 0:56shape what we think, how we feel, and what we
- 0:58actually do on a daily basis. Okay, let's unpack
- 1:01this because our mission in this deep dive is
- 1:04to basically figure out the invisible forces
- 1:06that are dictating our lives. Yeah, from the
- 1:08bottom. all the way to the top exactly we're
- 1:10going from the harmless stuff like why we unconsciously
- 1:13mimic people all the way up to the really profound
- 1:16moral questions. Like why ordinary people can
- 1:19be pushed to commit just absolute atrocities.
- 1:23Yeah, it gets dark. It does. By the time we finish
- 1:25these notes, you are going to seriously question
- 1:28how many of your own thoughts are like actually
- 1:30yours. It is a totally jarring concept to realize
- 1:34we aren't as independent as we like to think
- 1:36we are. I mean, to understand the extreme high
- 1:39stakes forms of conformity, we really have to
- 1:41establish the baseline first. We have to look
- 1:44at spontaneous mimicry. Okay so that's the the
- 1:47Chartrand and Barg study yeah right from 99.
- 1:49Yes. They put a participant in a room with a
- 1:51confederate and obviously for this study session
- 1:55we know that means a researcher secretly playing
- 1:57a role. Right an actor basically. Yeah and they
- 1:59have them work on this really basic photo task.
- 2:02But the task itself was just a total distraction.
- 2:05Oh, obviously. The real experiment was just watching
- 2:07how the participant reacted to the Confederate's
- 2:10physical movements. So in one condition, the
- 2:13Confederate would just casually rub their face.
- 2:15And in another, they would, like, shake their
- 2:17foot. And the participants just copied them.
- 2:19Yeah. The researchers found that participants
- 2:21unconsciously mirrored those exact behaviors.
- 2:25Hold on. Let me play devil's advocate for a second
- 2:27here. Go for it. Is this just, um... evolutionary
- 2:31flattery, like are we just trying to suck up
- 2:33to the person next to us so they don't perceive
- 2:36us as a threat? To me, it feels kind of like
- 2:39when you're walking across the quad between classes
- 2:41and you just unconsciously speed up or slow down
- 2:44to match the walking pace of the person next
- 2:47to you. It's just a way to make the physical
- 2:49space feel, I don't know, less awkward. That
- 2:54instinct actually points to a secondary experiment
- 2:57that Chartrand and Barr ran. They wanted to test
- 2:59that exact idea. Oh, really? Yeah. They wanted
- 3:02to know the actual why behind the mimicry. So
- 3:05this time, the Confederate deliberately mimicked
- 3:08the participant. every single shift in posture,
- 3:11every hand gesture. That sounds so creepy if
- 3:13you notice it. Right. But afterward, the researchers
- 3:16asked the participants to rate the interaction.
- 3:19And the participants who had been mirrored reported
- 3:21liking the confederate significantly more. They
- 3:25noted that the interaction just flowed really
- 3:27smoothly. Oh, wow. OK, so the mechanism here
- 3:30is bonding. Mimicry equals harmony. Exactly.
- 3:34We unconsciously conform just to coordinate our
- 3:37social interactions. It's essentially like social
- 3:39glue that reduces friction between strangers.
- 3:42That is the perfect way to summarize it. Yeah.
- 3:44But unconscious mimicry is passive, right? The
- 3:47real psychological heavy lifting happens when
- 3:50we actively consciously choose to change our
- 3:52behavior to match a group. Right. The conscious
- 3:55stuff. Yeah. And the textbook splits this conscious
- 3:57conformity into two very distinct drivers. There's
- 4:01informational social influence. and normative
- 4:03social influence. Let's use an analogy to separate
- 4:05these two because honestly they can get tangled
- 4:07up in my head. Yeah, they sound similar. So think
- 4:10about having to use a completely new super complicated
- 4:14software program at your internship. Informational
- 4:18social influence is like reading the manual,
- 4:21and trusting the developer's instructions because
- 4:23you genuinely want to do the job right. But you're
- 4:25seeking accuracy. Exactly. You assume they have
- 4:28the correct information. The textbook uses the
- 4:30example of getting off a plane at an unfamiliar
- 4:32airport. You don't know where baggage claim is,
- 4:35so you just follow the herd of people walking
- 4:37purposefully down the concourse. Because you
- 4:39assume they know the way. Right. And the crucial
- 4:42mechanism behind informational influence is that
- 4:45it creates private acceptance. Because you are
- 4:48using the crowd as a source of valid data, your
- 4:51internal belief actually changes. Like you genuinely
- 4:54believe the crowd is lading you to your luggage.
- 4:56Now, contrast that with normative social influence.
- 5:00Using that same software analogy, this is when
- 5:02you don't read the manual. You just click the
- 5:05exact same buttons your coworker is clicking
- 5:07solely so you don't look stupid in front of your
- 5:09boss. You're not trying to be right. You're just
- 5:12trying to fit in and avoid rejection. The classic
- 5:15textbook example is smoking cigarettes with friends
- 5:18even though you know all the health risks. Right
- 5:20and the outcome of normative influence is usually
- 5:23public compliance rather than private acceptance.
- 5:26The friction here is totally internal. How so?
- 5:29Well you're performing the behavior to maintain
- 5:32group cohesion. But internally, your belief hasn't
- 5:36actually changed. You might be smoking, but your
- 5:39brain is screaming that it's a terrible idea.
- 5:41I have to push back on the textbook, making these
- 5:43seem like two completely isolated boxes, though.
- 5:46Oh, interesting. Why? Think about obeying that
- 5:49boss at the internship. Aren't you usually doing
- 5:52it both because you want to be accurate, which
- 5:54is informational, and, Andy, because you want
- 5:57them to like you, which is normative? like they
- 5:59happen at the same time. What's fascinating here
- 6:01is that you're actually hitting on a major debate
- 6:03in social psychology. Yeah, the researcher Turner
- 6:06pointed this out back in 1991. In the real world,
- 6:09the distinction is incredibly blurred. Our desire
- 6:12to be right and our desire to belong are almost
- 6:15always overlapping. We rely on our social groups
- 6:18for our sense of reality and our sense of security
- 6:21simultaneously. That makes so much more sense.
- 6:23But for the midterm, we definitely have to know
- 6:26the textbook extremes. Oh, absolutely. So, fellow
- 6:29undergrads, here is a mnemonic for your flashcards.
- 6:32Are you ready? Let's hear it. Informational equals
- 6:35inner belief. It's private. Normative equals
- 6:39nodding along. It's public. Informational, inner,
- 6:43normative, nodding. That is a solid way to encode
- 6:46it. So, if we understand that we conform to be
- 6:48right or to be liked, how many people does it
- 6:51actually take to override our independent judgment?
- 6:53We're talking about the power of the crowd here,
- 6:55Muzaffar Sharif and Solomon Ash. Let's analyze
- 6:58Sharif's Autokinetic Effect Study from 1936 first.
- 7:02Sharif basically placed participants in a pitch
- 7:05-black room and showed them a single stationary
- 7:08pinpoint of light. Due to the natural involuntary
- 7:12movements our eyes make in total darkness, the
- 7:15stationary light actually appears to dart around.
- 7:18So the environment is just completely ambiguous.
- 7:20There's no objective truth to find because the
- 7:22movement is literally an optical illusion. Exactly.
- 7:25When participants guessed the distance the light
- 7:27moved while they're alone, their answers were
- 7:30all over the map, just random. Makes sense. But
- 7:32when Sharif put them in groups of three and had
- 7:34them call out their estimates, a fascinating
- 7:37mechanism took over. Trial after trial, their
- 7:40answers began to converge. Wow. Yeah, they organically
- 7:43built a shared reality, a group norm. Because
- 7:46they were starved for objective data in the dark
- 7:49room, they just used each other as the data.
- 7:51Informational influence in action. But then Solomon
- 7:54Ash comes along. in the 1950s and essentially
- 7:56calls Sharif out. He totally did. Ash argues
- 7:59that, well, of course people conformed in a dark
- 8:01room staring at an illusion. He wanted to test
- 8:04if the crowd could force someone to deny objective
- 8:06reality. Enter the Ash Line study. Right. So
- 8:09you walk into a room with several other participants
- 8:12for what you think is a vision test. You are
- 8:14shown one card with a standard line and another
- 8:17card with three comparison lines. Your only job
- 8:20is to say which of the three lines matches the
- 8:22standard line. And it is incredibly obvious.
- 8:25Super obvious. But everyone else in the room
- 8:28is a researcher in disguise and you are seated
- 8:31near the end of the circle. The first few rounds
- 8:34are totally normal. Then on a critical trial,
- 8:37the first person gives an answer that is just
- 8:39laughably wrong. Like clearly the wrong line.
- 8:41Right. And then the second person gives the same
- 8:44wrong answer. By the time it gets to you, a unanimous
- 8:47group has confidently declared that a short line
- 8:49is actually the longest one. The psychological
- 8:52friction here is immense. I mean, 76 % of the
- 8:55real participants gave an incorrect answer at
- 8:57least once just to agree with the crowd. 76%.
- 8:59Yeah. They didn't suddenly go blind. They just
- 9:02couldn't handle the social pressure of being
- 9:04the sole dissenting voice. It is pure normative
- 9:07influence. And what blows my mind is how task
- 9:10importance changes this dynamic. Oh, the Barron
- 9:13study. Yeah. Barron did a later study using eyewitness
- 9:16lineups. He manipulated two variables. First,
- 9:19how hard the task was and second, how important
- 9:22it was to get it right by offering like a $20
- 9:26prize for accuracy. Which is a decent amount
- 9:28of money for a student. What's the logical assumption
- 9:30there? You'd think high stays would make people
- 9:32focus more and conform less, right? Right, but
- 9:35the results were totally counterintuitive. When
- 9:38the task was easy -like, they had plenty of time
- 9:41to look at the photos, and there was money on
- 9:43the line, conformity dropped, people trusted
- 9:45their own eyes. Okay, that tracks. But when the
- 9:47task was incredibly difficult, the photos flashed
- 9:50for just half a second, and there was money on
- 9:52the line, conformity spiked. The mechanism there
- 9:55is desperation. When the stakes are high, but
- 9:58we are really unsure of our own competence, we
- 10:01lean entirely on informational influence. We
- 10:04basically panic and assume the crowd caught a
- 10:06detail we missed. Here's where it gets really
- 10:08interesting though. Group size matters, but Ash
- 10:11proved that the real weapon of the crowd is unanimity.
- 10:14Yes. If you are facing a unanimous crowd of 16
- 10:18people, the pressure is suffocating. But Ash
- 10:21found that if just one single person in that
- 10:24group breaks ranks and gives the correct answer
- 10:27before it's your turn, your likelihood of conforming
- 10:30plummets. Just having one ally completely shatters
- 10:33the illusion. And the mechanism doesn't even
- 10:35require them to be an ally. Wait, really? Yeah.
- 10:38If the crowd says line two and the dissenter
- 10:40says line one, but the real answer is line three,
- 10:43Conformity still drops dramatically. The psychological
- 10:46kill switch is simply breaking the consensus.
- 10:49Once the group is no longer unanimous, you are
- 10:51no longer isolated against the entire world,
- 10:53and you finally feel permission to trust your
- 10:55own judgment. Okay, that is wild. So to keep
- 10:59Sharif and Ash straight for the test, Sharif
- 11:01equals shifting light. It's ambiguous, relying
- 11:04on informational influence. Ash equals absolute
- 11:07lines. It's obvious, driven by normative influence.
- 11:11Excellent. Now, if unanimity is such a powerful
- 11:13force that it literally forces us to deny reality,
- 11:15how does society ever change? That's a good point.
- 11:18But how does a new, unpopular idea ever take
- 11:20hold? We have to shift from how the many change
- 11:24the few to how the few change the many. Serge
- 11:27Moscovici and minority influence. Moscovici basically
- 11:31ran the Ash study in reverse. He put six people
- 11:35in a room. Four were real participants, so they're
- 11:37the majority. Two were Confederates, the minority.
- 11:39Okay. He showed them a series of slides that
- 11:41were unambiguously blue. But the two Confederates
- 11:45consistently declared that the slides were green.
- 11:47It sounds like a ridiculous premise. Two people
- 11:49trying to convince four people that blue is green.
- 11:52It does. But 32 % of the majority group participants
- 11:56ended up calling a blue slide green at least
- 11:58once. Wow. The mechanism that made it work, however,
- 12:01was absolute consistency. So the minority only
- 12:04had power if they never wavered. Precisely. If
- 12:07the minority occasionally caved and said blue,
- 12:09their influence just evaporated. They had to
- 12:11be stubbornly, persistently consistent. I think
- 12:14the Nemeth and Kwan anagram study perfectly explains
- 12:17why consistency works. They had participants
- 12:20unscrambling letter strings, like T -D -O -G
- 12:23-T -O. It's clearly dog. Right, the obvious answer
- 12:25is dog. But a consistent minority in the room
- 12:29insisted the answer was god. The researchers
- 12:31actually tracked the cognitive load and problem
- 12:34-solving strategies of the participants afterward.
- 12:37And what they found was that exposure to this
- 12:39stubborn minority forced the majority to think
- 12:42more divergently on subsequent puzzles. Yeah,
- 12:44it shakes them up. A unanimous majority just
- 12:46bludgeons you into public compliance. You just
- 12:49nod along to stop the awkwardness. But a consistent
- 12:52minority breaks your autopilot. You sit there
- 12:54thinking, why are they so convinced? What am
- 12:56I missing? It forces you to actually reevaluate
- 13:00the data. which leads to true private acceptance.
- 13:04Minorities force us to do the cognitive work.
- 13:06It is the engine of societal progress. But, and
- 13:10this is a big but, this exact same machinery
- 13:12of influence, this deep -seated desire to fit
- 13:15in and obey, has a horrifying dark side. We have
- 13:18to cover the textbook section on obedience, morality,
- 13:21and the Holocaust. Yeah, it's a heavy, devastating
- 13:23part of history. And as we look at the historical
- 13:26analysis of Reserve Police Battalion 101, it's
- 13:28important to remember we're looking strictly
- 13:30at this through a psychological lens. Right.
- 13:32We are neutrally evaluating what the behavioral
- 13:36data suggests about conformity, just removing
- 13:39all other political context for a moment to understand
- 13:41the mechanisms at play. Right. And the textbook
- 13:44uses Battalion 101 as a case study. These were
- 13:47ordinary middle -aged German men ordered to round
- 13:50up and execute Jewish civilians in Poland. Interrogations
- 13:54of 210 members of this battalion showed they
- 13:57did not have prior histories of violence. The
- 13:59records show that 80 to 90 percent of them were
- 14:02initially physically disgusted by the orders.
- 14:04Yet almost 90 percent ultimately committed murders.
- 14:07The historical and psychological analysis presented
- 14:09in our text suggests that alongside ideology,
- 14:12a massive driving force was conformity. At fear
- 14:15of the group. Exactly. The men reported an intense
- 14:18terror of isolation, of being ostracized by their
- 14:21unit, and of appearing weak to their peers. They
- 14:23traded their moral compass to avoid sticking
- 14:25out. It is the absolute darkest manifestation
- 14:28of normative social influence. And it was paired
- 14:31with obedience to destructive authority, which
- 14:33leads directly to Stanley Milgram's shock experiments
- 14:36in the 1960s. Oh, Milgram. He was actually a
- 14:39student of Ash, and he was profoundly disturbed
- 14:42by how ordinary people could commit atrocities
- 14:44under orders. So he built a terrifyingly effective
- 14:48laboratory setup. You are assigned the role of
- 14:51teacher. A man in a lab coat instructs you to
- 14:55read word pairs to a learner who is strapped
- 14:57to an electric shock machine in the next room.
- 15:00For every wrong answer, you flip a switch and
- 15:02deliver a shock. The panel starts at 15 volts
- 15:05and goes up to 450 volts, labeled danger, severe
- 15:08shock. And just to clarify, the learner isn't
- 15:11actually being shocked. It's a recording. Right,
- 15:13it's fake. But as you increase the voltage, the
- 15:16learner grunts, screams about a heart condition,
- 15:18begs to be released, and eventually falls dead
- 15:20silent. If you hesitate, the authority figure
- 15:22in the lab coat simply says, the experiment requires
- 15:25that you continue. Psychiatrists predicted maybe
- 15:281 % of people would go to the maximum voltage.
- 15:31But 65 % of participants went all the way to
- 15:34450 volts. 65%. And the mechanism here isn't
- 15:38just blind obedience. It's the slippery slope.
- 15:41Because the shocks increased in tiny 15 -volt
- 15:44increments, Milgram created a trap of cognitive
- 15:47dissonance. If a participant shocks someone at
- 15:50210 volts, how could they logically justify stopping
- 15:53at 225? Right. The incremental nature just broke
- 15:57down their resistance. Philip Zimbardo, who ran
- 15:59the Stanford Prison Experiment, provides a crucial
- 16:03perspective on this in the textbook, especially
- 16:05regarding religion and morality. This raises
- 16:08an important question, though. Zimbardo forces
- 16:10us to confront how our internal moral compasses
- 16:13fare against overwhelming situational pressure.
- 16:16We all like to think our deep moral or religious
- 16:19convictions make us immune. We think, oh, my
- 16:21faith would stop me from doing that. But Zimbardo
- 16:23argues that assuming we are inherently good leaves
- 16:26us deeply vulnerable. Totally unprotected. External
- 16:29circumstances can completely hijack our behavior.
- 16:32The textbook suggests that acknowledging our
- 16:34own human capacity for evil and recognizing the
- 16:37staggering power of the situation is the only
- 16:40way to actually inoculate ourselves against it.
- 16:42We obey because authority holds power. But what
- 16:45actually constitutes power? The textbook breaks
- 16:48down French and Raven's five types of power,
- 16:51detailing the mechanics of how authority figures
- 16:53bend us to their will. Let's run through them.
- 16:56First is reward power, the ability to give positive
- 16:59outcomes like promotions or money. Second is
- 17:01coercive power, the ability to dispense punishments.
- 17:04And coercive power forces public compliance,
- 17:08but it builds a toxic environment based on fear.
- 17:11People will only obey as long as the authority
- 17:13figure is physically watching them. Third is
- 17:16legitimate power. This is authority vested by
- 17:19the rules of society. We obey a judge or a police
- 17:22officer because we accept their designated role
- 17:24in the system. Makes sense. Fourth is referent
- 17:26power, which is influence through admiration.
- 17:29You follow someone because you identify with
- 17:30them and want to be like them. And fifth is expert
- 17:33power. You listen to a surgeon because they possess
- 17:36superior knowledge that you lack. If we tie this
- 17:39back to religion and morality, highly effective
- 17:42religious leaders often wield a fascinating blend
- 17:44of these. They hold legitimate power because
- 17:47the community explicitly grants them spiritual
- 17:50authority. But they also wield massive referent
- 17:53power because the congregation admires their
- 17:55grace or wisdom. That's a potent mix. When legitimate
- 17:58and referent power combine, it doesn't just create
- 18:01public compliance. It creates profound private
- 18:04acceptance. That combination fundamentally changes
- 18:07internal beliefs. OK, fellow undergrads, here
- 18:10is your mnemonic for the five types of power.
- 18:13Are you ready? Cats really like extra rats. Coercive,
- 18:17reward, legitimate, expert, referent. Cats really
- 18:20like extra rats. I will absolutely be thinking
- 18:22of a cat hoarding rodents during the exam. Good.
- 18:25But this brings us to the final critical piece
- 18:27of the chapter. With the crowd, the authorities,
- 18:30and all these situational pressures constantly
- 18:32bearing down on us, are we just helpless? Fortunately,
- 18:36no. We have a psychological immune response called
- 18:38reactants. Psychological reactants is a strong
- 18:41motivational state that flares up the second
- 18:43we feel our personal freedom is being threatened.
- 18:45We have an inherent need for autonomy. When someone
- 18:49tells you that you cannot do something, the illusion
- 18:51of lost freedom triggers a desperate need to
- 18:54reassert your independence. The Pennebaker and
- 18:56Sanders graffiti study from 1976 perfectly captures
- 19:00the mechanism. Researchers put up signs in college
- 19:03restrooms to stop people from writing on the
- 19:06walls. In half the restrooms, the sign read,
- 19:09please don't write on these walls. In the other
- 19:12half, the sign was aggressively authoritarian.
- 19:15It said, do not write on these walls under any
- 19:17circumstances. And two weeks later, the restrooms
- 19:20with the strict authoritarian signs had significantly
- 19:24more graffiti. Because the strict sign was a
- 19:26direct threat to their autonomy. People felt
- 19:28their freedom was restricted, so they rebelled
- 19:31just to prove they still had free will. This
- 19:33is the psychological equivalent of a parent forbidding
- 19:35a teenager from dating someone, which immediately
- 19:38makes the teenager fall madly in love with them.
- 19:41Oh, totally. Or like the parents in the Fantastics
- 19:43building a fence just to make their kids fall
- 19:45in love. It's weaponized reactants. We fight
- 19:47back to protect our identity. But this book also
- 19:50notes that who you are, your individual person
- 19:54variables, interacts with these situations. For
- 19:57example, individuals with high self -esteem generally
- 19:59conform less because they don't rely on the group
- 20:01for their self -worth. The textbook also dives
- 20:03into the nuance of gender differences in conformity,
- 20:06which is really interesting. It is highly context
- 20:09dependent. Statistically, in public settings,
- 20:12men are slightly more likely to resist conformity.
- 20:15This traces back to socialization. Society often
- 20:18conditions men to demonstrate status by holding
- 20:21their ground and acting independently. Conversely,
- 20:24women are often socialized to prioritize connection
- 20:26and group harmony, making them slightly more
- 20:29likely to conform in a public setting to prevent
- 20:31conflict. But the crucial mechanism here is that
- 20:34when the conformity tests are moved to private
- 20:36settings, like when no one is watching and the
- 20:39social pressure is removed, those gender differences
- 20:42virtually disappear. It's just an act. Exactly.
- 20:45It proves that a lot of public conformity is
- 20:47just a performance of societal expectations.
- 20:50Exactly. The situation constantly interacts with
- 20:52how we were socialized. So what does this all
- 20:55mean for us as we close our notes? Fellow undergrads,
- 20:58social influence is the water we swim in. We
- 21:01mimic people unconsciously just to survive social
- 21:03interactions. We conform to the crowd because
- 21:06the psychological friction of being wrong or
- 21:08being rejected is just too painful to bear. We
- 21:11obey authorities because of the incremental traps
- 21:13they set and the power they wield, sometimes
- 21:15sacrificing our own moral compasses in the process.
- 21:19And yet we possess a fierce internal drive for
- 21:22autonomy that fights back when pushed too far.
- 21:24It is an endless tug of war between our desire
- 21:27to be unique individuals and our absolute terror
- 21:31of being separated from the pack. Which leaves
- 21:32us with a final, slightly haunting thought to
- 21:35mull over before the exam. Uh oh. Based on all
- 21:38the empirical data we just reviewed, our behaviors,
- 21:41our opinions, and even our most profound moral
- 21:43actions are constantly being sculpted by the
- 21:45size of the crowd, the unanimity of the room,
- 21:48and the subtle cues of whoever is wearing the
- 21:50lab coat. If the situation is that powerful,
- 21:56how much of your core personality is actually
- 21:58yours? And how much of your identity is just
- 22:01a temporary reflection of the social situation
- 22:04you happen to be standing in right now? terrifying
- 22:07question to end on. Thank you so much for joining
- 22:10our late night study session. Good luck on the
- 22:12midterm everyone and thanks for pulling an all
- 22:14-nighter of Psychology Undergrad.