Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Maximize Your Client's Recovery: Proven Methods for Calculating Lost Profits
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Maximize Your Clients Recovery, Proven Methods
- 0:10for Calculating Lost Profits. I'm Alla Policastro,
- 0:13Director of Education and Professional Development
- 0:15at Beverly Hills Bar Association. And today I'm
- 0:18delighted to introduce our speakers, Mary Ellen
- 0:20Siebold and Danelle Robb. Mary Ellen is a partner
- 0:24in the financial advisory services practice at
- 0:27Resolution Economics. She brings more than 30
- 0:29years of experience in litigation consulting
- 0:32and forensic accounting with particular depth
- 0:34in calculating economic damages, including lost
- 0:37profits. Her work also covers shareholder and
- 0:40partnership disputes, fraud investigations, and
- 0:43bankruptcy and corporate restructuring matters.
- 0:46A certified public accountant who is also certified
- 0:48in financial forensics and has an insolvency
- 0:51and restructure Mary Ellen has been designated
- 0:54as an expert witness and has testified in more
- 0:57than 100 trials, depositions, and arbitrations.
- 1:00Her experience spans a wide range of industries,
- 1:03including manufacturing, entertainment, healthcare,
- 1:06insurance, construction, real estate, securities,
- 1:08and transportation. Danel is a senior manager
- 1:12at Resolution Economics. His work centers on
- 1:14litigation consulting, including forensic investigations,
- 1:18financial analysis, and economic damages. Before
- 1:21joining the firm, he held accounting and advisory
- 1:23roles across both public accounting and private
- 1:26industry, building experience in technology,
- 1:29entertainment, and financial services. Danel
- 1:32is a certified public accountant in the state
- 1:34of New York. We're so excited for all the incredible
- 1:37information they bring to our program today.
- 1:40submit your questions in the Q &A box, and now
- 1:43I'm going to turn it over to them. Well, thank
- 1:46you so much, Ala. Really nice to be here today
- 1:48with everybody. And Danelle, maybe you can share
- 1:52our presentation. Today we are going to be presenting
- 1:57Calculating Lost Profits, How to Best Maximize
- 2:00Your Client's Recovery. We are hoping that we
- 2:04can provide you with some tips and tricks and
- 2:08a better understanding of how to use your experts
- 2:13wisely in your cases when those are the issues.
- 2:18Some of the things we are going to be touching
- 2:20on today, we'll have some case examples throughout.
- 2:25That way you can kind of get an understanding
- 2:27of when you would see these things occur. We'll
- 2:31be talking about lost profits damage theory.
- 2:34and that'll be one of the very extensive areas.
- 2:37We'll talk about components of lost profits,
- 2:40and then the primary areas to attack calculations,
- 2:45and also some common mistakes in calculating
- 2:48lost profits. And along the way, we'd love for
- 2:52you to put your questions in the Q &A section,
- 2:56and I'll be monitoring that during... the program.
- 3:01So if there's questions I should answer right
- 3:03away, I will. Otherwise, we will address as many
- 3:06of them as we can at the end. So thank you. So
- 3:11let's move on. So our next matter is a case example.
- 3:18This we are calling the surgical sabotage unveiling
- 3:22the cost of betrayal in vascular medicine. Basically,
- 3:27this case, we were retained So going back a few
- 3:31years now, and our client was a vascular surgery
- 3:35center and the primary physician. When I say
- 3:39primary, he was truly the most experienced and
- 3:45most successful in the group of about four or
- 3:48five other physicians. These other physicians,
- 3:54for whatever reason, decided that they They conspired
- 3:59against him. They started reporting him to the
- 4:02medical board. They were creating some issues
- 4:08in the community with respect to his reputation.
- 4:11And they ultimately voted him off the island,
- 4:14essentially out of the business. We were brought
- 4:18in by this very successful physician to calculate
- 4:22the damages that he incurred. Basically, what
- 4:27was happening was if you took a look at what
- 4:31his revenues were and his profits, he would get
- 4:34distributions and then compared along before
- 4:37this bad deed, them throwing him out, and then
- 4:42compare that to what ended up happening after
- 4:45he was thrown out, where, of course, his distributions
- 4:47dwindled. we went ahead and calculated what those
- 4:51lost profits were and calculated really what
- 4:53that impact was into the future also. It was
- 4:56a very successful case. We ended up getting a
- 4:59verdict of over $5 .2 million in damages awarded
- 5:03to our client. And so that type of matter is
- 5:07something that you can be considering as we are
- 5:10talking more about the specifics of lost profits.
- 5:13So with that, I'll turn it over to you, Danelle.
- 5:16Sounds good. Thanks for that intro, Mary Ellen.
- 5:18So yeah, we're going to start really high level
- 5:20here. So loss profits, damage theory, and then
- 5:24we'll get into the nitty gritty. So some core
- 5:26elements of loss profits theory. For those that
- 5:30are new to this, for those that are a little
- 5:31bit more experienced, we're really starting at
- 5:33the top here. So the first thing you might want
- 5:36to consider is that the defendant's wrongful
- 5:38conduct caused the loss. You really want to connect
- 5:41the action, the wrongdoing, to the economic damages
- 5:44that you are calculating, in this case, loss
- 5:46profits. So a quick example on that, let's say
- 5:50I'm the defendant. I sell widgets to the plaintiff.
- 5:54I'm supposed to sell 100 per year. I don't do
- 5:57that. And then I cause lost sales, lost economic
- 6:00damages to the plaintiff. That is one harm connected
- 6:03to one calculation. If at the plaintiff, they
- 6:06also had someone embezzling funds or something
- 6:08like that, that's a different action. It's a
- 6:11different claim with a different loss associated
- 6:13with it. So that's one, two, is we're gonna go
- 6:17over this a lot. The loss is calculated as but
- 6:20for profits less actual or quote mitigating profits.
- 6:25So, but for is the world you live in where there
- 6:29was no wrongdoing, there was no injury, everything
- 6:32is continuing as though there was no harm. Actual
- 6:35or mitigating profits is the current world we
- 6:37live in where you're living with the misdeed.
- 6:40So, we say in our industry, we have a couple
- 6:44ways of using the word actuals. And I just want
- 6:45to make sure we clarify that before we go forward.
- 6:49So actual here is the actual world where you
- 6:51are damaged. So we'll be calling that the mitigating
- 6:54profits, but we can also use it in the terms
- 6:56of actual as in historical data, things that
- 6:59have actually transpired versus projected things
- 7:02in the future that have not yet transpired. So
- 7:05just wanted to make that quick distinction before
- 7:07we keep going. So number three here, something
- 7:10to keep in mind as a little nugget of a takeaway
- 7:12is that the amount of the loss has to be estimated
- 7:16with reasonable certainty. We will go into that
- 7:19further shortly. Before we do, three more points
- 7:23for approach. So loss profits are an element
- 7:28of economic damages intended to put the plaintiff
- 7:31in the but for position, AKA make them whole.
- 7:35Two, so these matters can arise out of contract
- 7:38or tort matters. These lost profits calculations
- 7:41can usually arise from like a breach of contract.
- 7:45So third box, we have lost profits, right? We
- 7:48wanna be able to distinguish a lost profits remedy
- 7:51connected to the claim and make sure that we're
- 7:54not double counting. Well, what are some other
- 7:56remedies? We have here reliance damages, discouragement
- 8:00slash unjust enrichment, or maybe even diminution
- 8:03in value. Just as a primer, we're gonna go ahead
- 8:07and go over like a couple examples over what
- 8:10that might mean where you might be double counting.
- 8:13So here's the idea is let's say you have a law
- 8:16firm. You have a rainmaker there. They were going
- 8:19to bring in $5 million of profits, but they got
- 8:22poached, went to another law firm. So you harmed
- 8:25the plaintiff's company by taking that rainmaker
- 8:29with them. So you lost profits of $5 million.
- 8:34And you could also say, well, the value of my
- 8:36company also went down by $5 million. So 5 plus
- 8:405, that's 10. That's the double counting that
- 8:43I'm talking about. You can only pick one or the
- 8:44other. It is the same harm, but you can't double
- 8:48calculate that. And the other example here is
- 8:51disgorgement or unjust enrichment, just to give
- 8:53an illustration. Say I'm Coca -Cola. I have a
- 8:57Coca -Cola recipe. It's super important to me.
- 8:59An employee, let's say, takes it and they sell
- 9:01a million dollars worth of profits of Coke. The
- 9:05idea here is that I would be able to recover
- 9:07and be made whole if I claw back or disgorge
- 9:11those profits that were that unjustly enriched
- 9:15the defendant. Okay, so here we're going to go
- 9:20into the more detailed nitty gritty. Hope everyone's
- 9:22ready. So the components of loss profits, key
- 9:27components. So we have here three little buckets,
- 9:33but for mitigating damages. A minus B equals
- 9:38C. This easy way to think about it, put it in
- 9:40bold red for everyone. So but for profits are
- 9:43computed by estimating the revenue that would
- 9:46have been earned but for the wrongful act, reduced
- 9:49by avoided costs. That's where we get that word
- 9:52but for from. It's that sentence. What does it
- 9:55look like but for all the wrongdoing? Okay, so
- 9:59we have that amount of revenue reduced by avoided
- 10:02costs. Well, that's kind of confusing. Another
- 10:05way to think about it is but for profits equals
- 10:08but for revenue minus but for costs. But a kind
- 10:13of more layman's way to think about it is it's
- 10:14the revenue you lost out on due to the harm,
- 10:17but also the costs you avoided. to get that revenue
- 10:21due to the harm. Now we have mitigating profits.
- 10:25Mitigating profits are the actual revenue earned
- 10:27after the wrongful act, reduced by your actual
- 10:30costs. So these can include additional, quote,
- 10:34recovery costs, costs to get you back on track.
- 10:37So we have here is the formula, very simple,
- 10:40mitigating profits equal actual revenue minus
- 10:43actual costs. And those actual costs can be things
- 10:47to, let's say, clean up the mess or, let's say,
- 10:50your Coke, right? And they stole your recipe,
- 10:52caused a whole bunch of harm, and now you want
- 10:54to spend a bunch of money in marketing costs
- 10:57to preserve your reputation. You wouldn't have
- 11:00otherwise incurred those costs without the harm.
- 11:04And that's the idea here. So last bucket, damages
- 11:07equal, but for profits minus mitigating profits.
- 11:12Anything to add, Mary Ellen? No, very well said.
- 11:17Sounds great. So here we have kind of just a
- 11:20visual depiction of what our numbers look like.
- 11:23We're accountants, generally speaking here. We
- 11:25do a lot of numbers, but it's really easy for
- 11:27everyone else to kind of follow along when we
- 11:29have something visual to provide. Also helps
- 11:32to try our fact a lot. So I put this together
- 11:34here to just kind of illustrate. You start on
- 11:37the left, right? Time generally goes left to
- 11:39right. You have historical profits. You're chugging
- 11:42along. Your profits are increasing, which means
- 11:45your revenues are increasing. You have some costs
- 11:47associated with that. So this black line plots
- 11:50those profits. At some point, boom, there's a
- 11:53date of harm. Now you can go one of two ways.
- 11:56Generally speaking, your books and records show
- 11:58the blue. That's the actual world, the mitigating
- 12:01world. And it shows a dip. Now, if that didn't
- 12:05happen, the harm didn't happen, we want to calculate
- 12:08the green. So between the date of harm and today,
- 12:11those are the actual numbers. And those are the
- 12:14light colors that I tried to use to depict that.
- 12:17Going forward in the BOT4 world, the green becomes
- 12:20dark to indicate that we are projecting numbers
- 12:23from today going forward. And in the blue world,
- 12:27the actual world, the mitigating world, we're
- 12:30projecting the dark blue numbers out to the right.
- 12:34So the difference between BOT4 and mitigating
- 12:37profits is damages. That was our A minus B equals
- 12:41C. And you can see that it spans from left to
- 12:44right, right? So we know that the date of harm
- 12:47is kind of the beginning of the loss period or
- 12:50the damage period, as we call it, either way.
- 12:53But in an extent, it extends out into the future
- 12:55to a certain point in time. And you can't really
- 12:57go beyond that period of time. And that's just
- 12:59kind of like the box we're in here to visually
- 13:02depict the lost profits owed to the plaintiff.
- 13:08Okay, so we saw that green line, right? That
- 13:11green line, imagine that was higher up. Imagine
- 13:14we calculated higher but for income, higher but
- 13:16for profits. Where's the ceiling? Is the sky
- 13:20the ceiling? How high are we allowed to do that?
- 13:23Can we say that, oh yeah, absent harm? I would
- 13:26have been making a million dollars a second.
- 13:27Of course I would have. No, these lost profits
- 13:30calculations have to be quote reasonably certain.
- 13:33So I'll just go ahead and read this box. Lost
- 13:35-profits calculations do not require absolute
- 13:38precision, but must be reasonable and be calculated
- 13:42using reliable factors without engaging in undue
- 13:45speculation. So quick note on this. Remember
- 13:48in the previous slide, we have the black line,
- 13:51right? Those are historical numbers. It's a pretty
- 13:53good indication of the future. I mean, what else
- 13:55do we have to necessarily go on? It has the most
- 13:58recent macroeconomic factors, the factors specific
- 14:02to the company. So generally speaking, we want
- 14:05to use those to project out. We can't just say,
- 14:07oh, I would have totally won the lottery. You
- 14:10have to base it on something. So that's the concept
- 14:13of reasonable certainty. Right. And also, Janelle,
- 14:17there's going to be other factors that you do
- 14:19have to consider, such as what's going on in
- 14:22the market, COVID issues, things like that. So
- 14:27of course, you have to take a look at what else
- 14:30is happening, not just the financials of the
- 14:34business itself on a historical basis. Very true.
- 14:37And we'll get more into what those kind of considerations
- 14:39are soon. All right. Unreasonable certainty.
- 14:44I could have put that in quotes. It's an example
- 14:47of not being reasonably certain, in my opinion.
- 14:51So we have here projecting carried interest.
- 14:55The idea here is this is a case study. that takes
- 14:58place within the context of a PE firm. So a PE
- 15:04firm makes its revenue from companies that it
- 15:09invests in doing very well and then they cash
- 15:11out. Here in this case, we had a PE firm as our
- 15:14client. We just go ahead and go through these
- 15:17bullets here. So a startup private equity fund
- 15:19with not a lot of historicals, less than one
- 15:21year of capital deployments engaged us. The claim
- 15:25was that the plaintiff was an employee of the
- 15:28client, and they said that they were wrongfully
- 15:30terminated due to discrimination. So in theory,
- 15:34what they're owed is their salary from the date
- 15:37of harm, from being wrongfully terminated, going
- 15:39out into the future. Their other salary, their
- 15:41bonuses, and those are generally pretty predictable,
- 15:44especially based on history. But it's much harder
- 15:47to predict the, let's say, portion of 1 % of
- 15:53carried interest that she would have been owed.
- 15:56Carried interest is a form of revenue owed that
- 15:58the PE firm gets that is calculated generally
- 16:02as follows. So they raise a bunch of money, they
- 16:04deploy that money into a business or multiple
- 16:07businesses that they think are good to buy low,
- 16:11sell high. So they invest it in there. A bunch
- 16:14of time goes by. Hopefully that has appreciated
- 16:16by now, just like anyone who invests, right?
- 16:18That's kind of the goal. And then you pull your
- 16:20money out. You exit that opportunity. Now you
- 16:24have a bunch of cash. A certain amount of that
- 16:27might go into the carry pool. So let's say you
- 16:30have a pitcher full of water. Instead of water,
- 16:32it's cash. You're going to pour it down what
- 16:35is called a waterfall, which is these various
- 16:37cups along the way that absorb the money and
- 16:40the overflow goes into the next up in the next
- 16:43cup. Plaintiff's Cup is at the bottom. So if
- 16:46I had to estimate what is plaintiff going to
- 16:49be owed and carried interest, let's say, you
- 16:51know, 1 % of the total of whatever that is, there's
- 16:53a lot of estimating that has to go on there,
- 16:55right? I just said the amount of money you have
- 16:58to fundraise, you have to estimate the amount
- 17:00of money you deploy. What companies are you going
- 17:02to invest in? Okay, how much time are you going
- 17:04to sit and wait for that investment to realize
- 17:08up to a particular exit point? and then turn
- 17:10that into cash and then flow it down the waterfall.
- 17:12And that waterfall calculation is not static.
- 17:15So there's a lot of variables that I just threw
- 17:17out there, and it's very hard to predict. I mean,
- 17:21anyone can predict any kind of number, right?
- 17:23But with what kind of certainty? So we just adjusted,
- 17:26let's say, the average return. No other number,
- 17:31just that one number to a number that plaintiff's
- 17:35expert would have agreed with. plaintiff's expert's
- 17:38calculation of carried interest would have swung
- 17:41$12 million just off of a tiny tweak. So how
- 17:45sure are we about really any of these numbers?
- 17:48That was kind of the takeaway there. All right,
- 17:54continuing from left to right, the loss period.
- 17:58If you look at the X axis on one of those previous
- 18:02charts that I was showing, You have historical
- 18:05numbers. Those are your actual loss profits.
- 18:07Those are up to present. Then you have projected
- 18:10loss profits. Those are out to the future. Next
- 18:13bullet here, loss profits may include actual
- 18:15and projected data. Projected data is much more
- 18:20heavily scrutinized. Keep that in mind if you
- 18:22want to maximize your client's recovery, as calculating
- 18:24projections involves assumptions about the future.
- 18:27Fair enough. Actual and future. lost profits
- 18:31calculations cannot extend beyond the loss period.
- 18:35So let's go talk about more about the loss period.
- 18:38This is supposed to be a transition. So the loss
- 18:41period is the period necessary for the business
- 18:44to return to the uninjured state. So a few things
- 18:47to think about here, we have these numbered boxes.
- 18:51The loss period has to be tailored to the facts
- 18:53of the case. For someone who's never done this
- 18:55before, this is not a one size fits all thing.
- 18:59It can actually be the result of calculating
- 19:01lost profits. You figure out what your end point
- 19:04is going to be. So two common ways that the end
- 19:08of the loss period is calculated. When mitigating
- 19:11profits, the real world you've recovered, reach
- 19:15or exceed your but for a world where you would
- 19:17have not been harmed. So you're back on your
- 19:19feet. That's one way that you get the loss period,
- 19:22the end of it. And then the other is that the
- 19:24losses would have ended in the but -for world
- 19:26anyway. We'll go into a case study for that one
- 19:29in the coming slides. And third is for breach
- 19:32of contract claims, specifically the end of the
- 19:35contract period is often used as the end of the
- 19:38loss period. And we will get further into that.
- 19:42All right, let's start with the mitigating profits,
- 19:44reaching or exceeding but -for profits. Same
- 19:51chart, hopefully folks are familiar with this
- 19:53by now. All I did here was change the dark blue
- 19:56line. The dark blue line now meets the dark green
- 20:00line. So at that point, we're at the bottom right,
- 20:03you can see, but four equals mitigation. There's
- 20:07no more damages left. There's nothing to be owed,
- 20:10right? You are back on your feet. At this point,
- 20:12you have fully recovered. So if that is what
- 20:15we calculate, that becomes the end of the loss
- 20:17period. We obviously always triangulate, well,
- 20:20does this seem reasonable? Are any of our assumptions
- 20:23maybe flawed? Are they a little aggressive? Are
- 20:25they conservative? Should the number be higher
- 20:28or lower? All right, now I'm gonna get into the
- 20:34idea where plaintiff is not owed economic damages
- 20:41any longer because they made a career switch,
- 20:44aka you reach the end of that loss period pretty
- 20:46quickly. So let's go through this case study.
- 20:49The client here was a police department of a
- 20:52city in California. Claim was that the police,
- 20:55the plaintiff was a police officer at the client
- 20:58and claimed he was wrongfully terminated due
- 21:00to discrimination. The plaintiff's expert's first
- 21:05move. generally speaking with wrongful term cases,
- 21:08in case anyone does wrongful termination cases,
- 21:11is that they want to extend the loss period to
- 21:15the date of retirement. So let's say this police
- 21:17officer was 30 years old when he was terminated.
- 21:22The plaintiff's expert is going to say, well,
- 21:24how long would he have remained at that job?
- 21:27Well, through retirement, obviously. So that's
- 21:3132 years of damages that you're calculating,
- 21:33right? That's a lot, that adds up. So on our
- 21:37side, on the defendant's side, we wanna start
- 21:39thinking a little bit critically about that,
- 21:41or we may be making some bad assumptions here.
- 21:44So here we started, as we can see in the findings
- 21:46slash outcome section here, we started digging
- 21:49in the production. What facts are available to
- 21:52us? So by investigating plaintiff's background,
- 21:55we found that plaintiff had sold his business
- 21:57approximately five years after his termination.
- 22:00Sorry, what business? He's a police officer.
- 22:03Yeah, so he switched from being a police officer
- 22:06into an entrepreneur. So that's what we argued
- 22:09here. Plaintiff clearly began entrepreneurial
- 22:11activities no later than the date he filed with
- 22:14the California Secretary of State saying to California,
- 22:17here's my business. I am officially taking a
- 22:19step into being a business owner. So I don't
- 22:24think necessarily he would be owed damages beyond
- 22:27that point. Judge agreed. So sometimes people
- 22:30move from employee status to self -employed status,
- 22:33as we see in this next bullet here, taking a
- 22:36risk for the chance of a higher return. Cases
- 22:38with such facts require care. Defendants will
- 22:42not share in the upside of a business venture
- 22:45and should not underwrite the downside through
- 22:47a loss earnings claim. This is because they consciously
- 22:49switched careers. In the but for world, he would
- 22:53have not remained a police officer. So we always
- 22:56got to be careful about the kind of facts that
- 22:59are specific to each case. All right. Mary Ellen,
- 23:06did you want to talk about contract -specific
- 23:08loss profits? Yes, I will. And then there were
- 23:12a couple of questions in the Q &A, so I will
- 23:15address those in just a moment. So with respect
- 23:18to the loss period, as Danelle was describing
- 23:22earlier, That's one of the big things in calculating
- 23:25damages. How far out do we want to be calculating
- 23:30that loss period? So in a breach of contract
- 23:33action, that loss period is generally projected
- 23:36through the remaining term of the contract. And
- 23:41that makes sense, right? I mean, the contract
- 23:42is going to end at a certain point, and the damages
- 23:44would end. However, sometimes there are cases
- 23:47where it can extend beyond the length of the
- 23:51contract. And if you look at the box to the left
- 23:54here, number one, when could that happen? The
- 23:57first instance would be that let's say that there
- 24:01was an extension of the contract term being negotiated
- 24:06right at the time that the breach occurred. So
- 24:08there was an expectation that the contract wasn't
- 24:11over. It was going to go out for another five
- 24:14years. So that is one instance. A second instance
- 24:17is if the parties have a history of contract
- 24:21renewals. For example, they've got in their agreements
- 24:24that each year it's subject to renewal, et cetera.
- 24:30Such an extension was provided for in the contract.
- 24:33That's when you might see that there is a reason
- 24:35to extend the loss period out even further. And
- 24:42if you go to the next slide. Do that? Sure. You
- 24:47can take a look here at these two graphs where
- 24:50we've got the date of harm, we've got today.
- 24:53The contract in this case would have ended December
- 24:5631 of 2027. However, that contract was set to
- 25:01be extended for another year. And if you look
- 25:04at our lost profits, we're doing our actual lost
- 25:07profits through today and then projecting out
- 25:10past trial through an end date. And that end
- 25:15date in this situation would be through the date
- 25:17that the contract extension would have ended.
- 25:23So something to think about, because it is a
- 25:25very important area to be looking at. So one
- 25:29of the questions I just wanted to bring this
- 25:31up real quick, because it's a great question.
- 25:33The question is, for the past, when you know
- 25:35a catastrophic event happened during the period
- 25:38for which lost profits were claimed, such as
- 25:40COVID, How do you approach estimating the impact?
- 25:44So we see that so often. Over the last six years,
- 25:50essentially, once COVID happened, that was like
- 25:53a major event that impacted businesses, sometimes
- 25:56in a positive way. For example, anybody who was
- 26:01making face masks and things like that, right?
- 26:05You know, they probably were doing great, unexpectedly
- 26:08great. But so many other businesses suffered,
- 26:11businesses that were closed down, you know, people
- 26:14not going into the office, that kind of thing.
- 26:16So we have to take a look at that. And that has
- 26:19to be included in the actual projection, right?
- 26:23What we are estimating is going to happen. What
- 26:25is the impact of COVID? What is the impact of
- 26:29technology? There's so many different things
- 26:31that you can you have to consider what are the
- 26:35other things that you have to be looking at as
- 26:38you were projecting out what that business would
- 26:41have done. So yes, you've got to look at stats.
- 26:44There are so many stats out there now. There's
- 26:46so much literature on impacts by business, et
- 26:52cetera, for COVID, for other different things
- 26:59that might impact future profits or losses. So,
- 27:03great question. Yeah, that's also known as the
- 27:06concept of ex -post versus ex -ante. Can you
- 27:09use hindsight or not? And we would gladly be
- 27:11able to navigate that for all of our clients.
- 27:14Exactly. Should we keep moving or is there another
- 27:17question? Yeah. Yeah. Why don't we go ahead?
- 27:20Nice. Cool. So, calculating the components of
- 27:24lost profits, we have but for revenue. So, this
- 27:28is that light green line, right? There's a date
- 27:30of harm. What does it look like as though there
- 27:33was no harm? So this is the revenue the injured
- 27:36party would have received in an uninjured state
- 27:39for mitigating lost revenues. Revenues are known.
- 27:42That's what I refer to as like being in the books
- 27:45and records. They are what they are. So the main
- 27:47methods to calculate the but for past lost profits
- 27:51are the before and after method and the yardstick
- 27:55or benchmark method. So generally speaking, before
- 27:58and after in a vacuum, can you see the harm being
- 28:03done specifically? Like, is it as clear as that
- 28:06light blue number dipping down and then you would
- 28:09have otherwise been on track? That's one consideration.
- 28:13Another is, like Mary Ellen was saying, take
- 28:16all the facts into account. What does the industry
- 28:19look like? What are all the facts specific to
- 28:21the case? So you may want to consider something
- 28:23like, well, what similar unaffected business
- 28:26performance look like? What are non -party projections
- 28:29like? How about industry averages? Oftentimes,
- 28:32we take those into account as well. Especially
- 28:34if your industry was or was not affected by COVID,
- 28:37that's a huge one. If you were making 3M masks,
- 28:42your business spiked. But if you were in hospitality,
- 28:44what was that average looking like? So here it
- 28:48is. And now I just thought of this. So imagine
- 28:51your light blue line was a dip. and it would
- 28:54have dipped regardless of harm, kind of like
- 28:57COVID, kind of like as if you had a restaurant.
- 28:59That would be a weakness to be attacked, right?
- 29:02So you want to be able to have as strong as bulletproof
- 29:05as possible as a loss profits calculation as
- 29:08you can for your client, for your plaintiff.
- 29:12So that's what we're talking about here. We're
- 29:14talking about the light green line. I was just
- 29:16saying, what if that looks like the light blue
- 29:18line regardless in the uninjured state? So let's
- 29:22keep focusing on what we think about when we
- 29:24come up with that light green, dark green line,
- 29:27super important. It drives the Delta that you
- 29:30see here, right? So we really got to be careful
- 29:32about how we think about it. So for future loss
- 29:37profits, I just talked about the actual profits.
- 29:41So let's go into project, basically projections.
- 29:44So for future loss revenues, These are both the
- 29:47revenues expected in the buffer world and mitigating
- 29:50world because they are unknown. So the main methods
- 29:53to calculate both of those might include utilizing
- 29:56the plaintiff's estimates, their internal projections.
- 30:00They know their business well, however, maybe
- 30:03they're biased. You really got to look through
- 30:05the weeds here. The expert must verify that these
- 30:07are reasonable, understand how they were calculated,
- 30:11and confirm their reasonableness because you
- 30:13will get grilled as to how reasonable those are.
- 30:17The expert prepares their own future revenue
- 30:20projections utilizing the available relevant
- 30:22data to do so. And that kind of calls back to
- 30:24what we were just talking about. What else is
- 30:27relevant to consider in your calculation? All
- 30:30the facts, the industries, the macro, all of
- 30:32it. And you know what, Danel, if you go back
- 30:36to that slide for a second, because there was
- 30:38another question that really is very specific
- 30:40to this. There was a question that was raised
- 30:42asking Can these principles be applied to an
- 30:45individual just as they could be applied to a
- 30:49business? And the answer is yes. And in this
- 30:52person's example, they were saying, well, what
- 30:55if somebody was, for example, a stunt person,
- 30:59and they were injured, and they were unable to
- 31:02audition? But in a typical year, this person
- 31:04might have made six -figure salaries from six
- 31:08gigs or whatever. So yes, we can estimate. Obviously,
- 31:14that person is unable to work with the injury
- 31:17that he or she has sustained. But we can estimate
- 31:21into the future based on their past performance,
- 31:25what they've done in the past. But again, we
- 31:28do have to take a look at what's going on in
- 31:30the environment. I mean, over the past few years,
- 31:33you look at the LA area and the fact that the
- 31:37entertainment industry where a stunt person might
- 31:40be employed. They're not doing as much business
- 31:44here. So we'd have to look at that, consider
- 31:48that. Where has this person worked? Would it
- 31:52be expected that this person would be willing
- 31:54to travel? All of those kinds of things. So there's
- 31:57a lot that would have to go into it. But yes,
- 31:59absolutely. We can do this whether it's an individual
- 32:03or it is a business. We can go ahead and calculate
- 32:06damages in most instances. Yeah, same principles
- 32:10apply for sure. So we're going to take a look
- 32:16at this from more of the company's perspective,
- 32:19a lot of this slide and the next one. But again,
- 32:23like generally speaking, we're going to go through
- 32:24the same thought process as Mary Ellen was just
- 32:26kind of going through for an individual as well.
- 32:29So for capacity considerations, let's say you
- 32:32come up with that light green line, the dark
- 32:35green line as well. What would your revenues
- 32:39have looked like or your profits have looked
- 32:40like in the uninjured state? Now all of a sudden
- 32:44you have this pie in the sky number, these really
- 32:46high lines that create a lot of damages. Let's
- 32:49test those. Let's pressure test those. That's
- 32:51what kind of these bullets are supposed to be
- 32:53doing. So are you physically able to produce
- 32:57enough goods or services to produce the revenue
- 32:59that is estimated? You have to think about capacity
- 33:02considerations. Another thing might be, okay,
- 33:05depending on the facts of the case, what about
- 33:07the market share? So assuming you have this really
- 33:11high revenue number, are you even able to achieve
- 33:13that? Doesn't that imply that all of a sudden
- 33:16you have three quarters of whatever particular
- 33:19market that you're in? You have to consider that
- 33:22as well. Competition. Depending on the industry,
- 33:27there could be low barriers to entry. So why
- 33:30would someone choose your particular product?
- 33:32And that kind of ties in with the next one with
- 33:34product demand. Are you really able to out -beat
- 33:38the competition? Are you getting a bigger market
- 33:41share than would make sense? Or do you have a
- 33:44particular type of technology that is susceptible
- 33:48to being copied and replicated? Changes in the
- 33:52macroeconomic environment. This is always very
- 33:55common. This is where COVID comes into play.
- 33:59Even recently, if you can think about like inflation,
- 34:02how susceptible are you to it? Oil prices, are
- 34:05you very sensitive to oil prices? What about
- 34:08changes in the law or tariffs? So you have to
- 34:12consider all of these things, right? Because
- 34:13what if the company's actual revenues, they weren't
- 34:18really harmed and they would have dipped anyway
- 34:20because of changes in the economic environment.
- 34:23You really want to separate the two. As soon
- 34:25as you start conflating things, that opens you
- 34:27up for getting grilled by the opposite side.
- 34:31You also want to think about, yeah, go ahead.
- 34:34No, I'm sorry. I didn't mean to cut you off.
- 34:36To that point, one of the questions as a follow
- 34:39-up was, how are you estimating the impact of
- 34:42AI for the future? And I wondered what your thoughts
- 34:45were there, Danelle, but it seems to me that
- 34:48it's very similar to anything else that we would
- 34:52have to look at with respect to what's going
- 34:54on in the economy and other factors we have to
- 34:59consider. Any other thoughts there? Yeah, no.
- 35:03So it's kind of like estimating the effects of
- 35:06COVID as soon as it hits, right? Imagine you're
- 35:08in March or April 2020. What are the effects
- 35:11going to be? Personally, I thought it wouldn't
- 35:13have been a global pandemic. I didn't see that
- 35:15one coming. But a lot of folks, as long as you
- 35:18have a good source, For saying hey, this is the
- 35:21best estimate I have that is and there's no other
- 35:24better estimate. That's the best that you can
- 35:26use. I think that's what you have available.
- 35:28Uh, so it's whatever's available and relevant.
- 35:32Um, and ideally you don't want to just go to
- 35:34a blog that's going to say, like, ai is going
- 35:36to, you know, end the world tomorrow. You want
- 35:38to go to, you know, reputable sources for those
- 35:41assumptions. So, industry knowledge, including
- 35:46the product life cycle and possible future obsolescence,
- 35:50you may want to consult with industry experts
- 35:52that are experts on that type of technology.
- 35:55Not sure if you have any examples, Mary Ellen,
- 35:58but let's say you are selling a particular line
- 36:02of a computer, like the one that's in front of
- 36:04me. How do I know that you would have been able
- 36:06to sell this particular computer for another
- 36:0815 years? Would it not go obsolete with the revenues
- 36:12not dip regardless at some point? So if you press
- 36:15your test that revenue line, you really want
- 36:18to consider everything including obsolescence.
- 36:22Yeah, right. I mean right now with what's happening
- 36:24with the price of gasoline and fuel looking at
- 36:30how it impacts not just the the consumer who's
- 36:33driving a car on the freeway. But it's really
- 36:36impacting so many industries, agricultural, any
- 36:40industry. And ultimately, what does that do?
- 36:44It drives up the cost of product. And we as the
- 36:47consumers are the ones who have to bear that,
- 36:50ultimately. So all of these things have to be
- 36:53considered. There are going to be things that
- 36:55may happen in the future that we don't know about,
- 36:59and we wouldn't have had a way to know about.
- 37:02So when we're doing our calculation, we're using
- 37:06the information that we have available and estimates
- 37:09about what, or not really estimates, but information
- 37:12we have about future activities. Right. And if
- 37:17you're using the best available information,
- 37:20I mean, both sides are going to have that, right?
- 37:22It's not like they're going to be able to attack
- 37:24you for it because they have nothing better,
- 37:26generally speaking. Correct. Okay. So we're going
- 37:32to go into just a few more considerations here
- 37:33because this is so important. Remember that we're
- 37:37talking about our but for line here, right? This
- 37:40really drives the damages. So we really kind
- 37:44of wanted to focus on that. So first here, if
- 37:46you take a look at the company's historicals,
- 37:50what caused previous spikes, what caused previous
- 37:53dips, you want to be able to incorporate that.
- 37:55Because sure as heck, the other side will, right?
- 37:58Generally speaking, as we mentioned, historicals
- 38:01are the best indicator that we have of the future,
- 38:03or at least a very good data point. Number two,
- 38:07analyze projected growth rate in the business
- 38:09plan and projections. So we want to be able to
- 38:12use management's internal projections. They are
- 38:14generally a subject matter expert on their own
- 38:17company. So you want to look at projected growth
- 38:20rate in their business plan and in the projections
- 38:22that they have, as well as, of course, outside
- 38:24sources. Number three, short -term growth rate
- 38:28versus long -term sustainable growth rate, another
- 38:31factor to consider here. So is your company young?
- 38:35Are you in tech and you have this like hockey
- 38:39stick graph looking type of revenue? It may truly
- 38:42be that way, right? But how long will that be
- 38:45sustained for? If your damages period, if your
- 38:48loss period covers a good amount of time, are
- 38:51you getting speculative at all? Are you going
- 38:53to start marginally decreasing those revenues
- 38:57for the long term? So that would be a more long
- 38:59-term sustainable growth rate. If you calculate
- 39:01all of these things correctly and you have all
- 39:03these considerations, short -term versus long
- 39:05-term, you have a more very solid loss profits
- 39:09calculation to deal with with that is less open
- 39:12to less vulnerable to counterattacks. Number
- 39:16four is industry and economic conditions and
- 39:18outlook. We've kind of covered this a couple
- 39:20times already. See how in see how sensitive this
- 39:23industry is to the overall economic conditions
- 39:26and outlooks. Five, a production capacity and
- 39:30constraints manufacturing and marketing. So If
- 39:33I were to be making, let's say, customized desks
- 39:37takes a long time to build 1, but they're freaking
- 39:39pieces of art and all of a sudden I'm injured.
- 39:43And I, and I maybe make 5 desks a year if my
- 39:46revenue is implying that I'm making like 20 desks
- 39:49a year or 30 desks a year. Am I really even able
- 39:53to do that? Do I have the production capacity?
- 39:56Imagine you could argue, oh, well, you can just
- 39:58hire someone. Well, are they gonna make the same
- 40:00type of desk that I do? I'm the artist that's
- 40:03like, this is my firm. That wouldn't really be
- 40:06possible. There's a little bit of weakness there
- 40:08to that basis. Six, so capital expenditures and
- 40:13working capital needs to sustain growth and operations.
- 40:17Cash. is used to grow your operations, like let's
- 40:22say the reason I'm able to make these desks or
- 40:24the reason I'm able to make this business that
- 40:26I have is from this really expensive piece of
- 40:29equipment. Do I have enough to be able to expand
- 40:32my operations and use these capital expenditures
- 40:35to be able to expand it? That's something that
- 40:37you have to think about to be able to sustain
- 40:39growth in your operations. Seven, along the similar
- 40:43lines, are you able to obtain financing? What
- 40:46if your credit's not very good? What if banks
- 40:48don't want to lend to you? What if your reputation
- 40:51isn't good enough? You want to be able to obtain
- 40:56financing, right? So it's another important piece.
- 41:00The facts show that you wouldn't have been able
- 41:02to obtain financing. Are you sure you could have
- 41:04expanded and reached those revenues? Something
- 41:06to consider. Lastly, here we have special considerations
- 41:10related to a newly established business or product
- 41:13line, kind of similar to the short -term versus
- 41:16long -term growth rate factor. If you're in AI,
- 41:22that's going to have a whole new special set
- 41:25of considerations to the point of whoever brought
- 41:28that up. You have to look at it differently.
- 41:32You have to look at it with a whole kind of thing
- 41:34outside of the box. Definitely take all the case
- 41:37facts into consideration, especially if it's
- 41:40a newly established business or product line.
- 41:42And it's especially risky, not risky, but harder
- 41:46to predict the future without a bunch of historical
- 41:49data with which to rely upon. Exactly. And I
- 41:53think in our examples, we're assuming that there's
- 41:57been several years of financials. And in our
- 42:00world as experts, we're doing the happy dance
- 42:04when We see that there's five years worth of
- 42:07historical financials. We're able to model that.
- 42:10We're able to project that out where it's great.
- 42:13However, there are a lot of startups. And startups,
- 42:17as frequently or even sometimes more frequently,
- 42:20find themselves in litigation with very little
- 42:24historical information. So it's in those situations
- 42:27that we sometimes have to look at comparable
- 42:29businesses. look at some of the available information
- 42:33out there that as experts we oftentimes look
- 42:38to for guidance. So having that history is great,
- 42:44but it's not always the case. Very true. All
- 42:50right. So we're about halfway through the slides
- 42:54and it is 1043. Yes, we are going to zoom through
- 42:58this here. So we've been talking about lost profits,
- 43:01but early on we mentioned avoided costs. So avoided
- 43:06costs, just for your information, are those costs
- 43:09that the plaintiff did not incur as a result
- 43:13of the defendant's actions. And those costs should
- 43:16be deducted from the calculated lost revenues
- 43:19in order to calculate those lost profits. there's
- 43:26going to be some expenses that you normally would
- 43:29have incurred, but for this event that happened,
- 43:34you no longer will be incurring them. So why
- 43:36don't you go to the next page? There's two types
- 43:40of expenses. They're bucketed into variable and
- 43:43fixed. So when we talk about variable costs,
- 43:46those are the costs that are in general going
- 43:48to be impacted by a but for event. So for example,
- 43:55production labor. If there is an event and all
- 43:59of a sudden a client's contract or the plaintiff's
- 44:06business is going down, they are not producing
- 44:11as much, their customers have left them, so they
- 44:14need less labor. They're not paying out sales
- 44:17commissions because they can't seem to sell this.
- 44:20They're not buying as many supplies. They're
- 44:22not buying as much inventory or any raw materials.
- 44:26Those are things that the expenses of the business
- 44:29are going down. So we have to make sure that
- 44:32we account for that when we are calculating the
- 44:34lost profits. If you go to the next slide, we
- 44:39talked about fixed costs. And fixed costs are
- 44:41those costs that remain the same regardless of
- 44:44the amount of product produced. So everybody
- 44:47knows. If you're in a five -year lease and this
- 44:51event happens in the first year, you've still
- 44:54got four years of the lease that you have to
- 44:56pay, and every month that check is due. So there
- 44:59are certain things that you really can't avoid.
- 45:02So this is really what we normally do in our
- 45:05analyses is go through and identify what are
- 45:07fixed and what are variable costs for that particular
- 45:10business. And there are times where fixed costs
- 45:14over time will become variable, but that would
- 45:17that would really be the case when you've got
- 45:18a longer period of time of the loss period. So
- 45:23anyway, just wanted to kind of explain those
- 45:26two quickly as we move on to our next slide,
- 45:31which is components of loss profits. Yep. So
- 45:34here we're calculating mitigating revenue and
- 45:37expenses. So we were just talking about BUP4,
- 45:40did a whole thing on the BUP4. Now we're going
- 45:42to the mitigating side, which Largely has a lot
- 45:45of the same considerations. Generally speaking,
- 45:48here we're looking at the instead of the green
- 45:50lines, we're looking at the blue lines just to
- 45:52kind of bring everyone back onto the same page
- 45:54here. So we will move right along. So these are
- 45:59just some considerations that are kind of like
- 46:03very straightforward, super summarized. So we
- 46:05have on the left an item, let's say revenue in
- 46:08the but for world. This represents the hypothetical
- 46:11absent. misconduct, so the hypothetical world,
- 46:14without the misdeed. Then you have mitigation,
- 46:17which is the bottom blue lines. Those are actual
- 46:20or reasonably achievable revenue. In order to
- 46:24maximize your client's profits or your recovery,
- 46:27the defendant will attack, generally saying the
- 46:32plaintiff has underestimated the mitigation revenue.
- 46:34They have actually recovered more, so they are
- 46:37owed less damages. Along the same lines, we have
- 46:40costs, but for a world, those are the normal
- 46:43operating costs. Mitigation will include incremental
- 46:46mitigation costs, kind of like we were talking
- 46:48about at the beginning. If you have marketing
- 46:50costs, you have these recovery costs, kind of
- 46:53like damage control costs to get you back. And
- 46:57so the defendant might say, well, you know, those
- 46:59costs are excessive or unnecessary. For example,
- 47:02if in your calculation you include fixed costs,
- 47:06kind of like what Mary Ellen was saying, well,
- 47:08that seems unnecessary and that's actually using
- 47:11the wrong kind of methodology. So that's where
- 47:13the defendant will attack. The timing. So here
- 47:17we have kind of the loss period come back again
- 47:20into the conversation. So in the but for world,
- 47:23we have the normal growth trajectory. And in
- 47:26the mitigation world, you have the recovery period.
- 47:29So Generally, the defendant is going to want
- 47:31to think that the plaintiff has recovered much
- 47:34faster than claimed. Obviously, we have this
- 47:37box here at the bottom that drives all of the
- 47:39defendant's attacks mindset, like the mindset
- 47:42for those attacks, which is that they'll analyze
- 47:45underestimated revenue and overestimated costs
- 47:49in the mitigating world, or just in general as
- 47:52your damages. So those are driven by the things
- 47:55that we mentioned here, and this is how the defendant
- 47:57will think about them. In one of the matters
- 48:01I testified in about a year ago, it was in federal
- 48:05court. And it was our client had developed a
- 48:09very niche software for a small industry, but
- 48:15it was doing very, very well. And the allegation
- 48:21was that one of the software developers left
- 48:25with a flash drive and started a competing company,
- 48:28which we see so often in our cases. And one of
- 48:32the ways that our client continued to survive
- 48:35was through advanced marketing, excessive marketing,
- 48:39to really just continue to be out there and add
- 48:41to other venues or other avenues to be able to
- 48:46get the word out about who they were. So those
- 48:50additional marketing expenses were added to the
- 48:53damages. Okay. Components of lost profits discount
- 49:02rate. So let's, I'll just go ahead and read this
- 49:06first here. The discount rate is an annual percentage
- 49:09rate whereby amounts of money in future years
- 49:11are discounted to a present value. So as we remember,
- 49:16there's historical, there's actual costs, and
- 49:18then there's projected costs, there's projected
- 49:20profits. So all of those future profits have
- 49:24a value as of quote today. Let's say we use the
- 49:27date of trial as like the valuation date. Everything
- 49:30up to trial is in the past. Everything after
- 49:32trial is in the future. You know that there's
- 49:38going to be a judgment generally on a particular
- 49:39day, right? So that's why we use trial date as
- 49:42that valuation date. So when you go out further,
- 49:45we're not going to stick around to see how the
- 49:47company does, right? We want to see what those
- 49:50future values are worth. today so first bullet
- 49:53future loss profits must be discounted to consider
- 49:56both the time value of money and the risk inherent
- 49:58in the projected cash flow i think we generally
- 50:01understand the time value of money you know if
- 50:03i have a hundred dollars in my savings account
- 50:05and it earns one percent per year that's kind
- 50:09of the value of that money in the future i would
- 50:12assume that it would be growing at a particular
- 50:14rate uh likewise um that's kind of what the discount
- 50:18rate does instead of Your let's say return or
- 50:22your savings account, you know interest rate
- 50:24going forward We're trying to bring it from that
- 50:27future value to the present using that 1 % rate
- 50:30as the discount rate So loss profits calculations
- 50:34commonly use the subject companies weighted average
- 50:38Cost of capital which we call a whack as the
- 50:42discount rate this is generally kind of like
- 50:44the risk inherent the time value of money that
- 50:47you know, the cash flows are going to be increasing
- 50:49or whatever it is that you project, this is the
- 50:52kind of risk and reward that you have for those
- 50:55cash flows. So the WAC is the blended because
- 50:58this is how it's calculated. It's the blended
- 51:01cost of equity and after -tax debt capital weighted
- 51:05by the subject company's market -based percentages
- 51:08of equity and debt relative to total invested
- 51:12capital. That's a mouthful. No one's getting
- 51:14quizzed on this, but let's go through a really
- 51:17quick example. You have two pieces. Yeah, you
- 51:19have equity. You have debt. That's what that
- 51:21mouthful was talking about. You have them in
- 51:23total. That's your total invested capital. So
- 51:26let's look at each piece. Let's say, for example,
- 51:29you have a cost of debt, 7%. Just call that the
- 51:32interest rate. Cost of equity, 15%. That gets
- 51:36a little bit more complicated, but that's where
- 51:38a lot of the risk is captured. And interest rate,
- 51:40that's just a term on a piece of paper, right?
- 51:42You're getting 7%. Tax rate is 40%. Let's just
- 51:47use that as a given. And then the company's invested
- 51:50capital is comprised of 75 % equity and 25 %
- 51:55debt. So that 25 % is getting the, this is all
- 51:58calculated in the next bullet, but I'm just going
- 52:00to try to explain it more easily. You have the
- 52:0325 % debt at that 7 % rate. So you're going to
- 52:06multiply those two together, multiplied by the
- 52:09amount it would look like after taking taxes
- 52:12out. So that's 1 minus 40%, AKA 60%. That's your
- 52:16cost of debt. Then you have your cost of equity.
- 52:19We already assume that there's 15%, and it takes
- 52:22up 75 % of your total invested capital. So we
- 52:25get to a number like 12 .3%. Now, we want to
- 52:29kind of think Does 12 .3 % kind of land us exactly
- 52:34where we need to be? Generally, there's a little
- 52:37bit more judgment involved in the cost of equity.
- 52:41In the cases that I've worked on, we usually
- 52:43use a buildup method, which starts with a risk
- 52:46-free rate. So if you were going to take some
- 52:48risk or not take risk and put your money somewhere,
- 52:52the USA Treasury yield is generally what we look
- 52:55at as pretty much a safe haven for your money.
- 52:59what kind of return do you get on that? Let's
- 53:01say about 4%. And then to get to investing in
- 53:06the stock market, let's say the S &P, that's
- 53:08going to require a little bit more risk, right?
- 53:10So you're going to build up the method, use the
- 53:13buildup method to build up your discount rate
- 53:15from that 4 % to let's say, add on another 5%.
- 53:18That's kind of the risk and reward that you would
- 53:20get or expect from investing in the S &P. So
- 53:25let's go ahead and take that in mind. So before
- 53:27I get into the next slide, The 12 .3%, remember,
- 53:30that's what we're earning year after year. It's
- 53:32compounded. It's like a compound annual growth
- 53:34rate. So if that number is higher, my number
- 53:38is growing up higher each year. And if I start
- 53:40with that future value, that means to bring it
- 53:42back to present value, the higher the discount
- 53:45rate, the lower my present value is going to
- 53:47be. Because remember, I have 100 bucks today,
- 53:49but if it grows at 100 % per year, that's a really
- 53:52aggressive growth rate. That's just the general
- 53:55concept to keep in mind. So let's go on to the
- 53:57next slide. Okay, in this case, I'm running this
- 54:03back to the carried interest. I told you there
- 54:05was a whole bunch of different things that you
- 54:07have to estimate. Generally in private equity,
- 54:09these are boom bust type of revenues. You may
- 54:12not get anything in one year, but the next you
- 54:14cash out, like you do great. There's a lot of
- 54:18risk involved. In this particular case, plaintiffs
- 54:22expert had a discount rate for those cash flows
- 54:25that was quite like investing in the S &P. but
- 54:28we all kind of known based on what I've described
- 54:30that this is a lot riskier than an investment
- 54:32in the S &P. S &P, you put your money in, plug
- 54:35and play, you sit back and you get about 9%.
- 54:38This is a whole lot less predictable. So we used
- 54:42a higher discount rate. Ultimately, plaintiff's
- 54:45expert agreed with us because these things are
- 54:48risky and that decreased his damages. All right,
- 54:54so this is just, I think, showing you the future
- 54:57values, right? You have the dark green lines,
- 54:59you have the dark blue lines. And the difference
- 55:02is the lost profits there for the future. You
- 55:04want to discount those to the present. Exactly.
- 55:10So let's talk for a minute about the primary
- 55:12areas to attack in any lost profits calculation.
- 55:16So some of the things that jump out to me are
- 55:20lack of sufficient relevant data. I mean, in
- 55:23order to do a calculation, we need to have information
- 55:27that is relevant to the case. We have to make
- 55:31sure that we've considered industry, the impact
- 55:34of location, the impact of things that are happening
- 55:38in the world. But looking at that relevant data,
- 55:43do I have enough historical information? Do I
- 55:46have enough information about the industry, about
- 55:48that particular business itself, about the competition?
- 55:52So that is one of the areas that can be attacked
- 55:55if you did not cover that. Your assumptions,
- 56:00you know, people always ask, oh, did you, where'd
- 56:03you come up with these assumptions? And it can't
- 56:04just be, well, the client told me. I mean, we
- 56:09have to do some due diligence to make sure that
- 56:11we are comfortable with the assumptions that
- 56:14we're making and they are well documented as
- 56:16to. what we're relying on. A misuse of accepted
- 56:21methodology. Just like in law, there are certain
- 56:25things that you do and certain things that you
- 56:28don't do. Within the accounting profession, in
- 56:31particular in this expert world, there are certain
- 56:36rules or methods that are accepted. And if you
- 56:41start going rogue and going in a different direction,
- 56:45there are going to be some situations where there
- 56:48might be a reason for changing direction or coming
- 56:55up with something that is a slightly different
- 56:58and not normal methodology. But in most instances,
- 57:02there's methods in place, and it's advisable
- 57:04to be looking at those and considering which
- 57:07one or ones are the most applicable to the matter
- 57:10at hand. your data reliability and verifiability.
- 57:16I can be given, for example, a QuickBooks report,
- 57:20but I don't want to just assume that what's in
- 57:23there is accurate. I want to be able to look
- 57:26at, for example, bank statements to see if, yes,
- 57:28that is the cash balance, or look at information
- 57:32around the inventory to make sure that the levels
- 57:34as reported appear accurate. So we do a lot of
- 57:37verifying of information before we just accept
- 57:41it as gospel. Let's move on to the next slide.
- 57:45Sure, it looks like we only have a couple minutes.
- 57:47Yeah, so other areas to attack. And we've gone
- 57:51through all of these. So discount rate, forgetting
- 57:54to incorporate mitigation. Was there a way that
- 57:56the party that was wronged could have fixed things
- 58:01a little bit to carry them over or even to make
- 58:04the loss not as bad? Very important to me, including
- 58:08that length of the damage period, again, big
- 58:11thing, the estimation of those avoided costs,
- 58:14et cetera. So we can move on, because I know
- 58:17that we are up against the clock here. But a
- 58:21couple of common mistakes in calculating lost
- 58:23profits. Again, drawing conclusions that are
- 58:27not supported by the underlying data. I mean,
- 58:29you've got the data, use it, and make calculations.
- 58:33Sometimes the numbers don't come out the way
- 58:35we want. or we expect. And sometimes there's
- 58:40difficult conversations with clients when it
- 58:43comes to results not being exactly what they
- 58:46would have expected. We don't want to do anything
- 58:50that's speculative or unreasonable, using unreasonable
- 58:54growth rates. We don't want to be double -dipping,
- 58:57calculating lost profits and lost business value.
- 59:01and a few other things, assuming the defendant's
- 59:04responsible for all of the losses, not considering
- 59:06any other impacts of environment, competition,
- 59:10et cetera, and focusing on the gross profit level
- 59:13instead of the incremental profit level, not
- 59:16deducting all of the avoidable costs. So those
- 59:19are some of the common mistakes that we find
- 59:21ourselves having to deal with in calculating
- 59:24loss profits. Yep, generally speaking, we've
- 59:28gone over these, so hopefully everyone's, you
- 59:30know, well equipped on these regardless. So in
- 59:33conclusion, there is no one size fits all. We
- 59:36gave you guys a ton of considerations to think
- 59:39about when you're calculating loss profits, when
- 59:42you hire an expert to calculate these things.
- 59:44These are the types of things that we think about.
- 59:47So you can consider the earlier case studies
- 59:49for the nuances involved in creating a defensible
- 59:51loss profits calculation. And lastly, if you
- 59:54guys need any assistance with this and you really
- 59:56want help thinking this through, we're always
- 59:58available. Please reach out. Let us know if there's
- 1:00:02any questions, but if not, with you today was
- 1:00:05Mary Ellen and myself, Danelle. Thanks so much,
- 1:00:09everybody. Sure thing. Lastly, we have an appendix.
- 1:00:15That's all we've got for today. Yeah, and if
- 1:00:18there are any other questions, please feel free
- 1:00:20to email us and we can answer them that way.
- 1:00:24Thank you. This concludes today's presentation.
- 1:00:27Thank you so much, Mary Ellen and Denelle for
- 1:00:29an excellent presentation today and thank you
- 1:00:31to our audience for joining us. Have a great
- 1:00:33day, everybody. Thank you. Bye bye.