Latest / Cult of Conspiracy / Cajun Knight Live 13
Transcript
- 0:09Speaker 1: Good evening, everybody, and welcome to another edition of the
- 0:12CA Tonight Live. I am your host, Jacob Mok and
- 0:16uh yeah, we got a couple of things we wanna
- 0:18we're gonna get into on this evening. Most of it's geopolitical,
- 0:21as it is. Some of it's more of the environmental
- 0:25side of things, just some unanswered questions of what the
- 0:28heck is going on in this world. We got some
- 0:31things going on as far as what Trump has been
- 0:33saying and hinting at. We got some things surrounding China,
- 0:36what they have been doing and what they are hinting at.
- 0:39We're gonna be talking Venezuela. We're gonna be talking Russia.
- 0:42We're gonna be talking Israel. We're gonna be talking Iran.
- 0:45We're all over the place. We are gonna be all
- 0:46over the place on this episode. And if anybody has
- 0:50anything that they have liked to bring and share with
- 0:52the class, by all means, drop it in the comments
- 0:54and I will pull it up. And for anybody listening
- 0:57to this on the Cult of Conspiracy on the following day,
- 1:00I might as well just give the shameless plug. Now
- 1:02if you would like to join in on the conversation
- 1:05next Wednesday Night. We do this every Wednesday night at
- 1:07nine pm Central Standard Time. Then come check me out
- 1:11Cajun Night on Patreon. The link is in the description below,
- 1:14and I do this on the Culture Conspiracy, but I'll
- 1:16do it here too. If you would like to listen
- 1:18completely commercial form, then please come check it out on
- 1:22the Patreon. That's also where I post all the videos
- 1:24to get the commercial free listening associated with the Cajun
- 1:27Night lives. All right, with all of that mumbo jumbo
- 1:32pish posh things out of the way, let's just dive
- 1:34straight in. So this article, as a matter of fact,
- 1:37was sent by a Raven Lee and it is tall.
- 1:40It's a Reuter's article. Now, I know Reuter's is going
- 1:43to be a little a little skewed, a little biased, right,
- 1:47But at the same time, every now and then they
- 1:49do have a little bit of a kernel of truth
- 1:50associated with it that is worth diving into, at least
- 1:54I believe, so Justice Micro quick, so I'm get closer.
- 1:57I'm telling you all, my eyes are getting worse by
- 1:58the day. I I've actually got to start like moving
- 2:01up to read because you know, all right, so this
- 2:05is actually from April first. This is on April Fool's Day.
- 2:09I'm a damn China to sell first global green sovereign
- 2:13bond on Wednesday. A global green sovereign bond. I don't
- 2:19I don't really know what to think of that with China,
- 2:21they're not exactly known for being a very green country.
- 2:23But let's check it out here. This is published in
- 2:26London on April first. China is set to finalize it's
- 2:29long way to debut global green sovereign bond on Wednesday
- 2:32and what is expected to be the first in a
- 2:34series of sales that will expand its footprint in the
- 2:36market as a pivotal time. Having signaled it was ready
- 2:40last month, top Chinese financial ministry officials laid out the
- 2:44details at a meeting with the investors in London on Tuesday,
- 2:47where the six billion WAND which is about eight hundred
- 2:50and twenty five million dollars bond is set to be
- 2:53issued on the London Stock Exchange. Oh oh, okay, China's
- 2:59trying to break into the London Stock Exchange with a
- 3:01green bond. That's it's bold strategy. But all right, I
- 3:06could I could see the appeal on it. The green
- 3:09bond market has ballooned to be worth roughly three trillion
- 3:13dollars in recent years. China's firms, including a state run
- 3:17once which would be all of them everything in China's
- 3:20state run have contributed significantly to that growth, but international
- 3:24investors have long been waiting for the government to make
- 3:26its move for years. Chinese Finance Ministries Director General Wu
- 3:31Yong I'm sorry, U Hong jeez yeah, is and his
- 3:36deputy Director General Xi Chao Hong. I'm sorry, I'm not
- 3:43mature enough to try to pronounce Chinese names without laughing.
- 3:47Because yep, all right outlined that it would come in
- 3:51two parts, one with a three year maturity or end date,
- 3:56and the second with a five year maturity. Both will
- 3:58have fixed interest rates and they are expected to be
- 4:01sub two percent really, although it will depend on demand
- 4:05during the formal sale process, which is being overseen by
- 4:09no fewer than eight banks from both China and Europe. Okay, yeah,
- 4:11that sounds more believable. Two percent, I mean, don't even
- 4:14me wrong. That's solid, But I also I feel like
- 4:18that would fluctuate a bit. I'm glad at least they
- 4:19gave a little addendum to say it will depend on demand,
- 4:23we'll see a Chinese global bond, one issued in one
- 4:28of the main international finance centers. Has long been anticipated
- 4:32given the country size. China's plan finally emerged earlier this
- 4:35year after British Finance Minister Rachel Reeves met China's Vice
- 4:39Premier he Liffing in Beijing to discuss pragmatic cooperation quote
- 4:45unquote on financial services, trade, investment, and climate issues. Climate
- 4:51issues from China Jesus. China is the world's largest producer
- 4:54of climate warming greenhouse gases. Yeah, that's that's kind of
- 4:59the irony that I've been kind of giggling at this
- 5:01whole time. It's no secret that China does not give
- 5:06two rats asses about the environment or the globe, or
- 5:09clean air or clean water or feeding their people. I digress.
- 5:13But to say that they're going to come up with
- 5:15a green bond, it's like, hmmm, that the irony here.
- 5:19It just anyway, anyway, like Ethiopia coming out with a
- 5:24food bond, Like I'm sorry you're doing what But I digress.
- 5:29China is the largest producer of climate warming greenhouse gases,
- 5:32but has said it wants to bring its carbon dioxide
- 5:35emissions to a peak before twenty thirty and become carbon
- 5:38neutral by twenty sixty. Wow, that is quite That is
- 5:46one of the most claims I've ever heard in thirty years.
- 5:50They want to go from being the number one producer
- 5:53to being carbon neutral. Oh wow, that's it's a ball strategy, Cotton.
- 6:01Let's see if it works out for them, monus, But
- 6:03I don't know. In February, the Finance Ministry published it's
- 6:07Green Bond Framework, calling it an effort to quote attract
- 6:11international funds to support domestic green and low carbon development. Yeah,
- 6:17so you're trying to take other people's money to make
- 6:21you more environmentally friendly, because everybody knows that what solves
- 6:27global warming is money. Obviously, what cleaned up the plastic
- 6:31from the oceans. Giving money to wealthy financiers obviously to
- 6:38read a book right. It flagged climate change mitigation, climate
- 6:43change adaptation, natural resource conservation, pollution prevention and control, and
- 6:49biodiversity conservation as its five key priorities. I'll bet it did.
- 6:54One investor who attended Tuesday's meeting said some of the
- 6:56details on what exactly the money raised would be useful
- 7:00included the country's electric vehicle charging network and its national parks.
- 7:06Yep again, because I know, depending on what media outlet
- 7:11we're looking at, oh Man electric cars totally cut down
- 7:15on the carbon emissions, never mind what the manufacturing facilities
- 7:19for those batteries does to the environment, which is what
- 7:22this whole thing is actually about. You know, macro, not
- 7:25the micro but sure, that's that's a whole thing. Uh Raven,
- 7:30I see your hand raise, please chime in.
- 7:33Speaker 2: So apparently there was on I don't know if it's
- 7:37that actual website. There's another website talking about China's electrical
- 7:42like electric car sales have like quadrupled in the last
- 7:46two months for some reason. And there I mean during COVID.
- 7:51They're the ones that decided that they were going to
- 7:53make make their nuclear energy push, and so they really
- 7:59wanted to gain nuclear energy. They are also the ones
- 8:02that leading the charge right now in fusion, like they
- 8:04have actually stabilized it the longest because they wanted to
- 8:08break apart from everybody because like fuck everybody else. But
- 8:11that also means that they've kind of ostracized themselves when
- 8:14it comes to the green push, and with a lot
- 8:16of the money being up for grabs right now with
- 8:18the green stuff. And with America is stepping away from NATO,
- 8:22then that means that if they keep pushing forward, then
- 8:25they'll be able to gain quote unquote more funds to
- 8:28be more green.
- 8:31Speaker 1: Now not considered green? What is nuclear not considered green?
- 8:37Speaker 3: No?
- 8:38Speaker 4: Not really?
- 8:39Speaker 1: It is like the cleanest and planet. How is that
- 8:42not considered green?
- 8:44Speaker 2: The green ones are solar, which is ridiculous, wind and rious. Yeah,
- 8:51and I think that the newest version of water is
- 8:56maybe potentially. But the thing about the I mean with
- 8:59anybody that knows anything about solar and wind like you're
- 9:02talking about, they have braveyards of parts because they can
- 9:06never be disposed of.
- 9:07Speaker 4: They're so chemically toxic that like.
- 9:09Speaker 2: You're just making more waste than you're doing any good.
- 9:13And it doesn't even generate that much power compared to nuclear,
- 9:17nuclear by far is the safest type of energy that
- 9:19we currently have. Obviously, fusion if it happens one day,
- 9:23dot dot dot can power the whole world.
- 9:26Speaker 4: But that's a one day thing.
- 9:29Speaker 1: So I still understand how nuclear is not considered green. Like, yes,
- 9:33there is waste at a certain point, right the depleted
- 9:37uranium has to be disposed of in some way, But
- 9:41we're talking about like realistically big picture here, micro and macro. Honestly,
- 9:47we're talking about pounds, not tons, pounds of depleted uranium
- 9:53to be disposed of which we put in ammunition to
- 9:56be shot out of the A ten and like we
- 9:58have a thing for that. It's all good. That's like
- 10:01the only waste in byproduct that really comes out of
- 10:04that other than steam. But how is this not considered green?
- 10:10This is kind of new to me. I honestly thought
- 10:11nuclear was within the conversation of green energy. That's okay,
- 10:15fair enough. So that's the end of that article. So
- 10:19if I and maybe I'm excuse me, maybe I'm missing
- 10:23the overarching theme here, but it sounds like China is
- 10:26trying to fund their new electric everything from outside international funding,
- 10:33and the way they're gonna do that is to try
- 10:34to sell it with a green bond and that's gonna
- 10:39attract international investors. Sounds like they're just gonna take the
- 10:42money and run. I could be very very incorrect here,
- 10:46but boy oh boy, that's what that sounds like to me.
- 10:48But okay, well that is story number one. If anybody
- 10:54would like to chime in on that, then bio means
- 10:56let's talk about it, Tony, you got anything, you go?
- 11:02U mute to yourself. I know if you're about to
- 11:03chime in or not.
- 11:05Speaker 5: Well, I was just looking up nuclear power in China
- 11:08and it says only about five percent of their electricity
- 11:11comes from nuclear energy, but I think they're planning on
- 11:14increasing it, and they're even building an attempt at a
- 11:19fusion nuclear power plant by twenty thirty, which would be
- 11:24I don't think any of these exist yet, but these
- 11:26are the kind that confuse hydrogen, which is way more
- 11:29efficient than fission. And I got a whole article fear
- 11:33about it. But you know, the sum total of it
- 11:37is that they really want to make fusion and more
- 11:41nuclear power, and I would agree that it is very green,
- 11:43especially compared to coal, which they've been using a lot of.
- 11:47Speaker 1: Yeah, China's been running off of coal for forever. Well,
- 11:50I mean, yeah, they got some oil too, and I'm
- 11:52sure they use some LNG for certain things, but by
- 11:55and large, I would say coal would be their bread
- 11:57and butter as far as energy production goes. The cool
- 12:00that you sent in the chat, is that what you're
- 12:01talking about that you had pulled up?
- 12:04Speaker 5: Yeah? I got it pulled up I can even read
- 12:05it if you want.
- 12:06Speaker 1: Oh, go for I got to pull up on screen,
- 12:08but by all means, brother, if you want to read
- 12:10floor yours.
- 12:11Speaker 5: China is poised to start building the world's first fusion
- 12:13power hybrid nuclear power plant, with the goal of generating
- 12:17one hundred megawatts of contiguous electricity and connecting to the
- 12:20greed the grid by the end of the decade. The
- 12:23Hong Kong based South China Morning Post, which by the way,
- 12:26is very pro Beijing and kind of anti us, but sure,
- 12:32that's my editorial, he says. The project is to cost
- 12:38twenty billion yuan, which is two point seven billion dollars.
- 12:43And you know, I'm gonna I'm gonna stop here because
- 12:46the article is just too long. But I think I
- 12:49captured the gist of it.
- 12:50Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, don't get me wrong. It's it's wonderful
- 12:54that any country anyone. Yes, I want America to be
- 12:57first to make a fusion fission hybrid nuclear power plant, absolutely,
- 13:04but honestly, even if China does it, that's still a
- 13:06net positive. We will be able to reverse engineer that
- 13:08on our own or even maybe work with them in
- 13:11some way, maybe buy the blueprints. Though a little money
- 13:13their way. I'm sure that you know the CCP is
- 13:16down to take a little extra to open open the
- 13:20books a bit. But uh, but yeah, so they're talking.
- 13:24I didn't know that the exchange rate was twenty billion
- 13:26to two point seven billion dollars, so it's like a
- 13:29ten to one exchange rate. I didn't know that, well,
- 13:32a little less than but yeah, that's that's pretty remarkable
- 13:35as well. I could understand why. But still but uh, yeah, actually,
- 13:40I'm gonna read a little bit more on this article
- 13:41just for a second.
- 13:42Speaker 3: Here.
- 13:42Speaker 1: It uh, it says the Wing Shoot, the high temperature
- 13:46er superconducting reactor, has entered its first phase with a
- 13:48public tender for an environmental impact assessment. According to the website,
- 13:53a platform that aggregates bidding and procurement information in China. Interesting.
- 13:59Speaker 3: Uh.
- 13:59Speaker 1: The facility will be built on Wohu Science Island in
- 14:03the high Tech zone of Nanchang Jang z Province, Okay
- 14:07in central China. According to the tender, the environmental report
- 14:10will include baseline studies, impact evaluations on airwater noise ecology,
- 14:15as well as risk analysis, pollution control measures and monitoring plans. Hm.
- 14:23I'm a little trepidacious though. Honestly the reason why, and
- 14:27I know when I say this, I am not intending
- 14:30to offend anybody of Japan. I understand that Japan and
- 14:34China are very different countries with very different cultures and
- 14:37all the stuff. I get it. I'm not trying to
- 14:38make a South Park episode out of this. Just hear
- 14:40me out. The Fukushima incident is still putting currently radioactive
- 14:48waste into the ocean, like, that's still happening, and Japan
- 14:53has They're the ones that literally wrote the book on
- 14:56QA and QC right, quality assurance and quality control. Quite literally. Actually,
- 15:00when I was in college, we did a whole class
- 15:02on it, and all of the big dogs as far
- 15:05as QAQC was concerned, were Japanese and they let that slip.
- 15:10And it's still to that level of bad. If China
- 15:14had this nuclear reactor and something went a little fukunushi
- 15:19with it, right, someone went a little fugezy and it
- 15:22goes sideways, I can't imagine China doing all that would
- 15:28be needed to stop it from damaging the planet even worse.
- 15:33Maybe I'm just a bit of a pessimist and I
- 15:35just have all of the distrust possible when it comes
- 15:38to the CCP. But I just m that's a tough
- 15:41pill for me to swallow. Raven, I see your hand
- 15:44raise go ahead.
- 15:47Speaker 2: Oh, I was just gonna say that I dropped an
- 15:49article from green Peace saying, well, my nuclear wasn't considered
- 15:53green underneath Tony's. But the whole thing about there's actually
- 15:59the really cool YouTube videos on like the Race for
- 16:03Fusion and like where like the progresses and it breaks
- 16:06it down like kind of like what's going on with
- 16:08it and how it is and stuff.
- 16:10Speaker 4: China is.
- 16:12Speaker 2: I think they're right now at like almost eleven seconds
- 16:15holding it stable. And that's a huge thing because once
- 16:20that actually stabilizes, then it will power the entire universe.
- 16:24And so that's why everyone is trying to universe, excuse me,
- 16:27the Earth. That's why everyone's trying to monopolize on it
- 16:30is because whoever can get it is going to be
- 16:32in control of all power period. And so that is
- 16:37the huge push because everybody else is going joined up
- 16:40together and then China is all by themselves, so like
- 16:43everybody is in one boat and then here's China.
- 16:45Speaker 4: So that's why it's a big issue with that.
- 16:48Speaker 1: So it's the same as any other thing in this
- 16:50current modern day Cold war. It's a race, right, just
- 16:53like the AI race and the data race between China
- 16:55and US. So the nuclear fusion slash fission high conversation,
- 17:01it's a race between US and China because whoever gets
- 17:04it first will dominated in that regard. That makes a
- 17:06lot of sense to me. Actually, Okay, I'm actually gonna
- 17:09read this article because I've I'm very curious what the
- 17:12green peak of all of all the sources, Of all
- 17:16the sources, they would be the one to just shit
- 17:19all over nuclear one hundred percent. So six reasons why
- 17:23nuclear energy is not to a green and peace is
- 17:27not the way to a green and peaceful world. Okay,
- 17:30let's go Number one, Nuclear energy delivers too little to matter. Wow,
- 17:37well that's incorrect, but all right. In order to tackle
- 17:41climate change, we need to reduce fossil fuels in the
- 17:44total energy mix well before twenty fifty to zero percent yep.
- 17:50According to the scenarios from the World Nuclear Association and
- 17:54the Nuclear Energy Agency, doubling the capacity of nuclear power
- 17:58worldwide in twenty fifth would only decrease greenhouse gas emissions
- 18:02by around four percent. In order to do that the
- 18:06world would need to bring thirty seven new large nuclear
- 18:10reactors to the grid every year from now year on
- 18:14year until twenty fifty. The last decade only showed a
- 18:18few to ten new grid connections per year. Ramping that
- 18:22up to thirty seven is physically impossible. There is not
- 18:25sufficient capacity to make large foragings like reactor vessels. There
- 18:30are currently only fifty seven new reactors under construction or
- 18:34planned for the coming one and a half decade. Doubling
- 18:38nuclear capacity different from the explosive growth of clean renewable
- 18:42energy sources like solar and went wow, is therefore unrealistic
- 18:47And that only and that for only four percent we
- 18:50already need to reduce one hundred Okay, yep, I knew
- 18:55that this article is gonna be overly biased. I going wrong.
- 18:59I knew that going into it. But they legitimately just
- 19:04said that nuclear is not as effective as the explosive
- 19:10growth of clean renewable sources like solar and wind. They
- 19:15just said that like it was the legitimate statement and
- 19:18not dripping with lie and deceit. But okay, okay, so
- 19:22number one, it's not effective enough to be considered green.
- 19:26But somehow wind turbines are but I Digress number two.
- 19:30Nuclear power plants are dangerous and vulnerable. Nuclear factories and
- 19:34plants are easy targets for malevolent acts, terrorist threats, the
- 19:38risk of unintentional or voluntary airline crashes, cyber attacks, or
- 19:42acts of war. The enclosures of plants and certain ancillary
- 19:46buildings containing radioactive materials are not designed to withstand this
- 19:50type of attack or shock. Nuclear power plants present unique
- 19:53hazards in terms of the potential consequence resulting from from
- 19:57a severe accident. Nuclear reactors and their association high level
- 20:00spent fuel stores are vulnerable to natural disasters, as the
- 20:04Fukushima Dachi showed, but they are also vulnerable in times
- 20:09of military conflict. For the first time in history, a
- 20:12major war is being waged in a country with multiple
- 20:14nuclear reactors and thousands of tons of highly radioactive spent fuel.
- 20:18The war in southern Ukraine and Zaparigia around Zaparisia rather
- 20:22puts them all at heightened risk of a severe accident.
- 20:26Nuclear power plants are some of the most complex and
- 20:28sensitive industrial installations, which require a very complex set of
- 20:31resources in ready state all at all times to keep
- 20:35them operational. This cannot be guaranteed in a war. Okay.
- 20:40So I don't know if anybody listening has worked in
- 20:44a nuke before, a nuclear plant. Okay, I've worked around
- 20:49them before, and I have a ton of buddies that
- 20:52have helped build nuclear plants and sites and things. Boy
- 20:57oh boy, the incorrect statement that was said up here.
- 21:02I'm not saying that they are not vulnerable to terrorist attacks.
- 21:06What I am saying is the security forces and security
- 21:09guards that they have surrounding nuclear sites are not Paul
- 21:14Blart mall cop Okay, these guys are like a legitimate
- 21:18swat team that are standing by waiting for some stupid
- 21:22shit to go off on the side of the fence. Okay,
- 21:25just throwing that out. Number one. Number two cyber attacks,
- 21:29You got me there. Sure there's everything's hackable, and I
- 21:32can at least understand that. But it's not like you're
- 21:35gonna be able to hack into this thing to make
- 21:37it go into a catastrophic meltdown. Because there's so many,
- 21:40at least in the United States, I cannot speak on
- 21:43behalf of other countries and their way of doing things.
- 21:46And yes, I understand people are gonna look at chernobyl.
- 21:48I understand people are gonna look at Fukushima. I get it.
- 21:51Fukushima was a title wave to hit it and drastically
- 21:54cool the reactor to such a degree that they couldn't
- 21:57expect or waiting for. And all the stuff. Yes with
- 21:59you in America. Quick, quick little story here, one of
- 22:06my buddies was a pipe fitter and he was fitting
- 22:09up a piece. I think it was like a one
- 22:11inch or a one and a half inch pipe. And
- 22:12for anybody who's not really familiar with materials or anything
- 22:16like that, it's the diameter of the pipes like that big.
- 22:18It's not. It's not a large pipe by any means.
- 22:21And they basically had to get it from point A
- 22:23to point B. They had bolted down jersey barriers, and
- 22:27if anybody doesn't know what that is, those would be
- 22:29those giant concrete barriers on either side of an inner
- 22:31state when they're doing like roadworking stuff. Not the plastic type,
- 22:34the concrete type. And they had this thing bolted down
- 22:38like every foot and a half strapped to this jersey barrier.
- 22:42And my buddy asked the guys like, look, I mean
- 22:45it's I understand that things got to be secure here
- 22:47and everything. But why does it have to be this secure?
- 22:50Like everything we do has to be secured to this fashion.
- 22:54The planner told him, this whole plant was designed so
- 22:58that if a volcan know, an earthquake and a tidal
- 23:02wave hit this plant at the exact same time, these
- 23:05reactors would not go down. That's the level of ingenuity
- 23:10that is put into the American nuclear programs as far
- 23:13as nuclear energy is concerned. So again, I'm not saying
- 23:19that green Peace is like completely full of shit here,
- 23:22because they are speaking on behalf of the world and
- 23:24everybody's nuclear programs, and I cannot speak on behalf of
- 23:28everyone else's safety protocols and things. But in America that's
- 23:32pretty much a non point. But like, all right, and
- 23:38I get what they're saying. In a time of war, sure, yes,
- 23:41I'm with you. Like the nuclear reactor could be hit
- 23:43in these things. Do they think that if like you
- 23:48hit a nuclear reactor with a with a bunker buster
- 23:51or something that like a nuclear bomb would go off.
- 23:55I think they think that's how that works.
- 23:58Speaker 5: Yeah, I think they might think it's like a dirty
- 24:00bomb where even if you don't get the nuclear explosion,
- 24:05just scattering all that stuff might be bad for people.
- 24:09Speaker 1: And I get that the nuclear waste from like the water,
- 24:13if you're like on an island Fukushima as an example,
- 24:15I get what they're saying here the stuff into the air.
- 24:18I'm with you one hundred percent. It's not like you're
- 24:21gonna make a crater with the mushroom cloud and the
- 24:25whole nine from a reactor getting hit. That's not it's
- 24:28not the same at all. Actually, but yeah, all right, yeah, Raven,
- 24:34go ahead.
- 24:36Speaker 2: So my mom actually because my mom worked for the
- 24:40my parents worked for the electrical company for forty plus
- 24:42years in Oregon. We have like we did the company
- 24:46that she worked for, they they have some of the
- 24:49fields where they keep the nuclear waste and like, uh,
- 24:53they the government actually renigged on the nuclear like power
- 24:57because they he was in charge of it, because of
- 25:02they didn't want to help with a waste any longer.
- 25:05And like we have a steam plant there we I
- 25:08think it's still operating, but it was like it worked
- 25:10in a cycle to be able to use the steam
- 25:13and the steam energy actually was fantastic. And like there's
- 25:16a whole bunch of stuff. I was just looking glancing.
- 25:19So this is actually a really good book about like
- 25:21it's called Sustainable Energy Choosing among Options, And this is
- 25:25a book all about like actual sustainable energy and like
- 25:28the different types of energy and what breaking it down to,
- 25:31like the super smart level, which I'm like brough math
- 25:34Amede not a thing, but it's talking about different options
- 25:38and stuff, and it's just it doesn't make sense to me,
- 25:41Like there is there's been a couple new energy types
- 25:45in the last few years that they've tested and it
- 25:47has better options, but it keeps getting shut down.
- 25:50Speaker 4: For whatever reason.
- 25:52Speaker 2: Then the one I like is the hydro energy that
- 25:55they actually have the new turbines that don't destroy the
- 25:58rivers and it actually like help smooth the fish around,
- 26:01and it's a whole thing.
- 26:02Speaker 4: They only have one of them.
- 26:03Speaker 2: They might have more now it's been a few years
- 26:05since they've looked into it, so they might have more,
- 26:07but it actually produces a ton of energy and that's
- 26:11super clean. I kind of laughed about the Green Peace
- 26:14That's why I.
- 26:14Speaker 4: Had to drop it in there.
- 26:15Speaker 2: But I mean I could understand some of what they're saying,
- 26:18like nuclear plants are a bigger target quote unquote, because
- 26:22if you hit the wind turbine fields in California. You're
- 26:27not going to have like an actual meltdown of anything. Yes,
- 26:31they do have toxic chemicals in the actual you know, blades,
- 26:36but it's not going to kill anybody as like leeching
- 26:40out tons of chemicals. If they did hit a nuclear plant,
- 26:44potentially it's there.
- 26:45Speaker 1: But yeah, I see what you're saying, and I don't disagree.
- 26:50I haven't heard much about the new hydro. I've heard
- 26:53that there is a new hydro. I haven't really looked
- 26:55into it. And that's the thing. I'm only looking at
- 26:58hydro from the perspective of how it has been done
- 27:01in the past, and the dams and how that affects
- 27:04the things downstream and upstream, the flooding that takes place,
- 27:07all of that. If they have a better way of
- 27:09doing it, then like I'm all here for it. But
- 27:12I would have to look more into that for sure.
- 27:14But anyway, so going back into the green peace thing here,
- 27:17nuclear energy is too expensive. Let's see, I'm not going
- 27:21to read the whole thing here. The cost of generating
- 27:23solar power ranges from thirty six dollars to forty four
- 27:26dollars per megawatt hour. Yeah, in the perfect conditions. My god.
- 27:32The World Nuclear Energy World Nuclear Industry Status Reports said
- 27:36while onshore wind power comes in at twenty nine to
- 27:39fifty six dollars per megawatt, it's already counterintuited to what
- 27:43they just said. Nuclear energy costs between one hundred and
- 27:47twelve and one hundred and eighty nine dollars per megawatt.
- 27:51So they just kind of renigged on their sentence prior.
- 27:54But like, okay, anyway, Yeah, so apparently, according to them,
- 27:57nuclear is too expensive, your energy is too slow. Number four.
- 28:02The twenty twenty one World Nuclear Industry Status Report estimates
- 28:06that since two thousand and nine, the average construction time
- 28:08for reactors worldwide was just under ten years, well above
- 28:12the estimate, well above the estimate given by the World
- 28:16Nuclear Association industry body of between five and eight point
- 28:20five years. There's probably a reason for that, the same
- 28:23reason why most big industrial projects go on longer than
- 28:27planned and scheduled, because OSHA and things like that get
- 28:31in the way. But when it comes to nuclear I
- 28:33would rather than take the extra time and make sure
- 28:34they build it right. That's just me. That's kind of
- 28:37how the cookie crumbles here and number five, nuclear energy
- 28:42generates huge amounts of toxic waste. That is also not true.
- 28:45There is waste that comes off of it, and it
- 28:47can be toxic to people, but we have uses for that. Again.
- 28:51The A ten warhog shoots bullets made out of depleted
- 28:54uranium the size of red bull cans. It's beautiful, it's amazing,
- 28:58and it pierces armor. But you know whatever. Okay, so
- 29:02green peace is Oh I forgot number six. I'm sorry.
- 29:05There was a six one here. There wasn't. No, there
- 29:10was not literally the oh here it is, and number
- 29:13six the nuclear industry is falling short of its promises. Okay,
- 29:19none of these things would make sense as to why
- 29:22it's not considered green. I maybe I'm missing something here.
- 29:28They said how it wasn't as good as solar and wind,
- 29:30which mathematically that's laughable. But I didn't see one thing
- 29:35as to why that wouldn't be considered green.
- 29:39Speaker 5: But right, I just see it depends on the definition.
- 29:42If your highest priority is to get rid of carbon dioxide,
- 29:46they do a really good job at given power without
- 29:49producing that. But if you're really afraid of a dirty bomb,
- 29:53which is a legitimate fear, then it just depends what
- 29:56your priority is. I learned something just in the last
- 30:00few minutes about how France has so much nuclear power,
- 30:03because I've heard about this for years. They've been between
- 30:08seventy and eighty percent of their electricity coming from nuclear
- 30:11and it's a direct result of something called the Mesmer plane,
- 30:15which was invented after nineteen seventy three with the big
- 30:19oil crisis with one of the Arab Israeli wars, the
- 30:24Young Kapur War, and it was named after Prime Minister
- 30:27Pierre Mesmer, who announced that it was going to be
- 30:30a hugely ambitious nuclear power program aimed at generating most
- 30:35of France's electricity from nuclear power, and they got up
- 30:38to about eighty percent. It's lower than that now and
- 30:41they do have a significant amount of renewables. This I guess.
- 30:45I've heard Europe has much higher electrical power costs than
- 30:50we do here in the US because we have something
- 30:52like ten cents of kilowatt hour, but over there it's
- 30:55like four times higher. So maybe nuclear is more competitive
- 30:59over there. But yeah, they gave the figures in the
- 31:04green Peace article as one hundred dollars per mega waite hour,
- 31:08and that's just the same thing as ten cents of
- 31:10kill a wat hour, just so people can convert that
- 31:13ratio in their head.
- 31:14Speaker 3: I don't know.
- 31:16Speaker 5: I guess at the largest scales, people calculating gigawatt hours
- 31:19and megawat hours and tarawat hours. But for your house,
- 31:24you get charged in kill a WoT hours. In France,
- 31:27most of their power plants make well over a thousand megawatts,
- 31:31as opposed to the Chinese one we were talking about,
- 31:33which is only one hundred megawatts. So the Chinese one
- 31:37that I was just talking about is apparently pretty small
- 31:39by comparison.
- 31:41Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean the picture at least, and I don't
- 31:43know if that was a model or if that was
- 31:47their current construction of it, but you saw people standing
- 31:49next to it, and it didn't look nearly as large
- 31:51as the reactors that we have in America. So I
- 31:54don't know if that's because it's the new hybrid type
- 31:56and maybe it's not as big and it doesn't require
- 31:58as much space or what the case is.
- 32:01Speaker 5: But yeah, well, hydrogen deuterium fusion, I don't know the
- 32:08exact number, but it's something like ten or one hundred
- 32:10times more energy dense than uranium, which is already incredibly
- 32:15energy dens. Yeah, and I don't know what the figure
- 32:18is on it, but any any supplementing they can do
- 32:20with hydrogen, it's basically free energy, and hydrogen is not radioactive,
- 32:26so that's really the best source we could possibly hope for.
- 32:30Speaker 1: In my opinion, I may be wrong, but isn't that
- 32:32also the same Not to bring it to nuclear bombs,
- 32:36but bear with me in that the same kind of
- 32:39process or at least concept behind the hydrogen bomb versus
- 32:41the atomic bomb. Hydrogen has a lot more energy to
- 32:44be expelled or used in this case.
- 32:47Speaker 5: One hundred percent. Yeah. The first nuclear bombs in Almagordo
- 32:51and Hiroshima and Nagasaki used uranium, and I think the
- 32:55Nagasaki one might have used plutonium two. But those work
- 32:58by fission, and when those elements split, they give off
- 33:02an enormous amount of power. But hydrogen fusion is when
- 33:07hydrogen when it has to be deuterium. Okay, there's got
- 33:10to be a proton and a neutron in it, and
- 33:13I forget what ratio of hydrogen that is, but it's
- 33:15like one percent or zero point one percent of all
- 33:17the hydrogen in the universe is deuterium and it's got
- 33:21the necessary neutrons that it needs in order to fuse
- 33:24the helium. And the way you make a hydrogen bomb
- 33:27is you use a uranium fission bomb and put it
- 33:33right next to a bunch of deuterium that gets compressed
- 33:38into a tiny space somehow. And when you compress the
- 33:44deuterium that much at high enough temperature, it replicates the
- 33:49fusion process in the Sun. But it's actually even more
- 33:52hardcore than the Sun, because the Sun's core only gets
- 33:55up to about two or three million kelvin or two
- 33:58or three million celsius, and a hydrogen bomb gets to
- 34:01two hundred or three hundred million calvin. Yeah, because when
- 34:05you think about it, the Sun's fusing this hydrogen, but
- 34:08over the course of millions of years, the amount of
- 34:10deuterium there as a percentage of its mass, barely changes
- 34:14it at all, which is why I just can keep
- 34:16burning it forever and ever and ever practically speaking, But
- 34:19a hydrogen bomb needs to needs to get all that
- 34:22energy out right away, so it needs the temperature to
- 34:24be way, way, way way higher.
- 34:26Speaker 1: Dude, I just I stumbled upon and on the cult
- 34:31of conspiracy. You know, we dive into all the conspiracies,
- 34:35and there are some people out there that don't believe
- 34:38the nuclear bombs are real. Yeah, that is a actual
- 34:42conspiracy that certain people who are like voting adults, really believe,
- 34:49and their evidence behind it is like on the surface,
- 34:53without doing any digging of your own. To an uneducated person,
- 34:58they'd be like, yeah, that's true. Like Hiroshima and Nagasaki,
- 35:01people live there today. If nukes went off, how is
- 35:04there not radioactive fallout? And blah blah blah blah blah
- 35:07blah blah, and like that's the basis of their whole
- 35:10talking point. To put this into perspective for everybody, that
- 35:14would be like somebody's saying, I don't believe gunpowder is
- 35:17real because every time I fire a bullet, the casing
- 35:21comes out, but there's no gunpowder inside of it. That
- 35:24is about a one to one comparison for anybody who
- 35:27doesn't know why there's no nuclear fallouts after a bomb
- 35:32goes off. Now, yes, there is initially some radiation in
- 35:35the air, and there's radioactive burns that happened, sure of course,
- 35:38But why we don't have that thirty five year half
- 35:41life or things like that after a bomb goes off
- 35:44is because all of the radioactive materials get burned and
- 35:49used as the fuel for the kaboom. They don't have
- 35:53the long half life and all these things. And for
- 35:56the people who also believe that nukes are fake, all
- 35:59the testing that was done in the Nevada and New
- 36:01Mexico desert back in the day, the people who lived
- 36:04around there that got all kinds of horrible radio radiation poisoning.
- 36:08They're called down winders. Anybody would like to look into them,
- 36:11and the crazy lawsuits they had to fight for years
- 36:14to finally get compensation and acknowledgment for him. Yeah, nukes
- 36:19are one hundred percent reel. They are one hundred percent.
- 36:22It blows my mind that people people thinking.
- 36:26Speaker 5: And you might have heard of Richard Ramirez. He was
- 36:28a serial killer from El Paso and see that Juarez. Yeah,
- 36:31and he was a downwinder. His family suffered birth defects
- 36:35and trauma when he was a kid as a result
- 36:38of that. Yeah. Well, another thing, the uranium bombs over Japan.
- 36:42They only had a yield of about ten to twenty
- 36:45thousand kilotons, but hydrogen bombs are normally in the thousands
- 36:48of kilotons, and the largest couple that ever were detonated
- 36:51were the Sonder BOMBA and the Castle Bravo at one
- 36:55hundred megatons or one hundred thousand kilotons. Yeah, that's so
- 37:01hydrogen is just a whole different order of magnitude bigger
- 37:04in terms of power. As far as the radiation in Hiroshima,
- 37:09I don't know why, but you know, people do live
- 37:12there now obviously, and I've heard that the radioactive fallout
- 37:15from more recent nukes would be even worse. But I
- 37:18don't know why. But yeah, the nuclear bomb does not
- 37:21burn one hundred percent of the isotopes. It's maybe only
- 37:25like fifty percent, and the other fifty percent do get
- 37:28scattered and they can't make people sick.
- 37:30Speaker 1: Absolutely.
- 37:31Speaker 5: In fact, the no nukes people, I think part of
- 37:33the conspiracy theory from their angle is that Hiroshima was firebombed,
- 37:39but they also dropped a bunch of radioactive uranium at
- 37:43the same time to make it look like there was
- 37:46a nuclear bomb, although I still agree that there was
- 37:49really just a nuclear bomb.
- 37:50Speaker 1: Well, they say it also because Tokyo was firebombed, right,
- 37:53so we because most of Tokyo at this time, and
- 37:57I would assume it's not like this today. During World
- 38:00War Two, most of their buildings were made out of
- 38:02wood and paper, but it was traditional Japanese homes and things.
- 38:06And so dropping the World War II equivalent of napalm
- 38:10in that city goes hard, goes really hard, and it
- 38:14does the job. It was like one hundred thousand people
- 38:17died in the course of it wasn't like a day,
- 38:19maybe it was like two days or three days or
- 38:21something ridiculous. And yeah, the fire bombing in Tokyo was
- 38:25way more devastating to life than the nuclear bombs that
- 38:29happened to Hiroshima and Nagasaki. But like also this is
- 38:33another historical fact that America really doesn't want to acknowledge.
- 38:38We dropped a nuke on the Christian epicenter of Japan.
- 38:42If I'm not mistaken, Nagasaki was like the biggest Christian
- 38:47as far as faith and religion goes, The biggest Christian
- 38:49conglomerates of that country was there, and we nuked them.
- 38:53And of course we had to push that one to
- 38:56the side and all the things later on because at
- 38:57that time, especially the Bible Belt wasn't exact just in
- 39:00the south. That was a pretty much a whole country
- 39:03vibe and uh, yeah, yeah, that's a whole thing that happened.
- 39:06And yeah there's radiation burns and it's not one hundred
- 39:08percent burn for sure, there's gonna be some fallout, but
- 39:11it's not it's not what people are thinking, like, Yeah,
- 39:13they rebuilt those towns relatively quickly because they can, and
- 39:18you can go there with your Uh, I forget, it's
- 39:20not a meger because that's an electric device. I forget
- 39:22what it's called. Whenever they like use the wand to
- 39:24tech for radioactive isotopes and things like that and like
- 39:28tiger counter, thank you, not a Meger tiger counter. And yeah,
- 39:33you can find certain spots where there is a radiation signature,
- 39:38but it's not it is nowhere near which you'll find
- 39:40at Chernobyl. Reason why is because Chernobyl is still currently
- 39:44burning and it's still putting off those the waste and
- 39:47the isotopes and all the stuff. Fukushima, same thing. It's
- 39:49still putting these things off. It didn't burn it all
- 39:51in an instant like a bomb. So anyway, Ravenly, I
- 39:56see your hand, go ahead.
- 40:01Speaker 4: All right.
- 40:02Speaker 2: While we've been talking, I've just realized that I'm looking
- 40:05at all this stuff about China. So China has a
- 40:08new mega project for the mountain dam. Also they are
- 40:12trying to do their one hundred billion dollar impossible Himalayan dam.
- 40:19Speaker 1: And then sure, by the way.
- 40:21Speaker 2: That's one of that is the engineering or disaster that's
- 40:24talking about the I think that's talking about the one
- 40:27that's the mountain dam.
- 40:29Speaker 4: I'm just I found a twelve day old YouTube video.
- 40:32Speaker 2: And then Canada has a twelve billion dollar megadam that
- 40:37they're also pushing forward. So it looks like hydropower is
- 40:41actually coming back into popularity. To the articles they sent
- 40:45you are just about hydropower and stuff. But yeah, so
- 40:48that's something that's going on.
- 40:50Speaker 1: I mean that makes me happy. I mean, especially if
- 40:52there's a it's a better and more efficient way than
- 40:56it has been done in the past. Like I'm all
- 40:58yours absolutely. Matter of fact, let's watch little bit of
- 41:00this video. It's only like six minutes long. We don't
- 41:02have to watch the entirety of it, but at least
- 41:04to get the gist. I'm all here.
- 41:05Speaker 6: Embarking on a project of unparalleled scale and ambition, constructing
- 41:10the world's largest hydropower dam on the Yar Lung Chung
- 41:13Po River in Tibet. This enormous undertaking, which could cost
- 41:18as much as one hundred thirty seven billion dollars, is
- 41:21set to produce three hundred billion kilowat hours of electricity annually.
- 41:27That's nearly three times the output of the Three Gorges Dam,
- 41:32currently the world's largest hydropower facility. While Beijing touts the
- 41:37project as a major step forward in renewable energy and
- 41:41economic development, its implications are raising serious concerns across environmental, geopolitical,
- 41:49and humanitarian spheres. Harnessing the power of the yar lungchang Po.
- 41:55The yar Lung sang Po River, originating from the Angsi
- 41:58Glacier in the Tibetan place, flows through the world's deepest canyon,
- 42:03the Yarlungsangpo Grand Canyon. This region boasts an extraordinary combination
- 42:09of natural features that make it ideal for hydropower generation.
- 42:14In a single fifty kilometer stretch near Namchabarwa Mountain, the
- 42:18river drops and astonishing two thousand meters, creating one of
- 42:22the most hydropower rich zones on Earth. China's plan to
- 42:26harness this power involves drilling multiple twenty kilometer long tunnels
- 42:31to divert the river's flow, enabling the generation of unprecedented
- 42:36levels of electricity. Once operational, the dam could play a
- 42:40pivotal role in China's broader strategy to meet its climate
- 42:44neutrality goals and shift toward renewable energy, as outlined in
- 42:49its fourteenth five Year Plan. Promises of progress or ecological catastrophe.
- 42:55Chinese state media describes the dam as a safe project
- 42:59that prioritizes ecological protection, but such assurances have done little
- 43:04to assuage the concerns of environmental experts and human rights organizations.
- 43:10The Tibetan Plateau is one of the most biodiverse regions
- 43:14on Earth, home to unique ecosystems that could face irreversible
- 43:18damage from this development. Altering the river's natural flow, coupled
- 43:23with large scale construction in a tectonically active area, poses
- 43:28significant risks, including landslides and seismic instability. Furthermore, the displacement
- 43:35of local Tibetan communities is almost certain, although Beijing has
- 43:40yet to disclose how many people will be affected. For context,
- 43:45the construction of the Three Gorges Dam required the relocation
- 43:49of one point four million people. In the case of
- 43:52the Yarlungsangpo Project. Affected populations could face loss of ancestral lands,
- 43:58cultural heritage, and livelihoods. Activists and Tibetan advocacy groups argue
- 44:05that this is yet another example of China's exploitation of
- 44:09Tibetan resources under the guise of development.
- 44:13Speaker 1: Okay, maybe I'm just a little jaded, but I don't
- 44:17think China cares about displacing one point four million when
- 44:23they have like a population of a billion, give or take.
- 44:27And I know for a fact they don't care about
- 44:30the Tibetan culture. They're currently occupying a portion of Tibet
- 44:35right now, and the Dalai Lama is in hiding or
- 44:38in exile or whatever you want to call it in
- 44:40India because of this, so.
- 44:45Speaker 6: Right, okay, deepening the historical tensions in the region, geopolitical
- 44:53ripples Downstream, the yar Lung Tangpo River doesn't end in Tibet.
- 44:59It flows south northward into India, where it becomes the
- 45:02Brahmaputra River and eventually reaches Bangladesh. For millions of people downstream,
- 45:09the river is a critical lifeline supporting agriculture, fishing, and
- 45:14drinking water supplies. By controlling the flow of this trans
- 45:18boundary river, China gains a powerful geopolitical tool that could
- 45:23exacerbate tensions with neighboring countries. India in particular, has raised
- 45:29alarm over the potential for China to manipulate the river's flow,
- 45:34which could affect water availability and flood risks in its
- 45:37northeastern states. Indian officials have even proposed the construction of
- 45:42a competing dam and reservoir to counterbalance China's influence on
- 45:47the river. This hydropower race could further strain already delicate
- 45:52relations between the two nuclear armed nations. Engineering feet meets
- 45:58environmental challenge.
- 46:00Speaker 1: We could kind of go ahead and stop it there,
- 46:02but okay, and especially I didn't know that area was
- 46:05such a hot spot for like plate tectonic shifts and
- 46:08mud slides and things like that. Although a hydro power
- 46:13plant does not pose the same types of risk it
- 46:15like a nuclear power plant would would present as far
- 46:18as like having some sort of like earthquake happening or
- 46:20something like that. But still it's interesting, and I mean,
- 46:25I see the benefits that China would be going after here,
- 46:28and maybe that's big picture why they've been making more
- 46:31pushes into more pushes into India and all these things.
- 46:34But yeah, I don't see that going into a net
- 46:38positive direction for them. Although listen here a new vision
- 46:41for United States hydropower raven This is the article that
- 46:45you sent. Is this talking about the new form of
- 46:48hydro power that they were talking about the new form
- 46:51of it?
- 46:52Speaker 4: It's just talking let me see which our article?
- 46:54Speaker 2: Sorry if yeah, if you scroll down, it's just talk
- 46:57like it's just kind of talking about the different existing
- 47:01facilities that they're providing low cost, low carb low carbon
- 47:07stuff that they are in high value potentially to increase
- 47:12the contribute blah blah generation story. I'm just scanning really quick.
- 47:17It's just kind of talking overall about like what the
- 47:19vision is.
- 47:20Speaker 3: I just was.
- 47:21Speaker 4: You don't need to read it.
- 47:21Speaker 2: It's just pretty much what I found on the new
- 47:24version is the infrastructure is changed in how they do
- 47:29it is like what I was seeing, Like the actual
- 47:31way that they actually are getting the water and moving
- 47:34it around, it's not disturbing as much, and so they're
- 47:38trying to make it more of a popular thing. Also,
- 47:41I didn't know Australia has five massive hydroplants there, so
- 47:46there's a whole bunch of people like countries that are
- 47:50using hydropower more now, and there's a lot of debate
- 47:53going on about Canada's massive megadam so I was just
- 47:58kind of reading different stuff like that.
- 48:00Speaker 1: Hey, okay, very interesting, and thank you for sharing all
- 48:03of this, for sure. And you know what, while we're
- 48:07already kind of on the topic of China, this does
- 48:09actually present a very decent segue for something that I heard.
- 48:14And I don't know how much of this I actually believe,
- 48:17but at the same time, it's worth talking about here.
- 48:21This is an article from twenty twenty two, as a
- 48:24matter of fact, and it's saying basically, does China have
- 48:26designs on Siberia? Now? I don't Again, I don't know
- 48:31the validity of this. I do know that once upon
- 48:34a time they were talking about China invading Russia, and
- 48:38this was, if I'm not mistaken, right before the invasion
- 48:42took place. And this is a September twenty second of
- 48:46twenty twenty two. Now I don't know why, but there
- 48:51is more recently talking points about this being more realistic.
- 48:55Apparently Jizjaping and Putin are on the outs right now.
- 49:00And again, it really depends on the source. It depends
- 49:02on the source you read. I don't know that for
- 49:04a fact. I don't know Xi personally or anything old
- 49:07Panda boy himself. But this was something from a few
- 49:11years back. Here it says, actually, I'm sorry, this is
- 49:13right after the invasion happened. Chinese leaders Ji japan relationship
- 49:17with Russian President Vladimir Putin is tarnished as a result
- 49:20of Russia's unprovoked invasion and occupation of Ukraine. GI has
- 49:24been distancing China from Putin's predaceous predation gradually out of
- 49:29deference to his two biggest customers, the United States and
- 49:33the European Union, but on September fifteenth, his displeasure about
- 49:36the war became public. Putin himself admitted at the press
- 49:39conference following the meeting with Ji that China had concerns
- 49:42about his war in Ukraine, and so did India. But
- 49:45there is one more elephant in the room, Siberia, a
- 49:48region bigger and richer than any place on Earth. I
- 49:53feel like that's also a bit biased pool see with
- 49:56resources that under pin Putin's economy. It is Asian, not European,
- 50:03and one day will most likely or mostly fall into
- 50:06China's hands. Okay, g knows this and needn't lift a
- 50:11finger to speed along. This outcome to some Chinese takeover
- 50:15of Siberia may seem preposterous, but Putin's flailing war against
- 50:19the West increases the odds that the Russian Federation itself
- 50:22may atomize. Well, that didn't exactly play it off, though,
- 50:25way did it. Although again, depending on the Sorcier read,
- 50:28they're collapsing more and more by the day, and there's
- 50:30more outcries and more protests, and now they're calling for
- 50:34more coups. But I mean again, it depends on who
- 50:36you're talking to. Honestly, Putin may eventually be removed, freeing
- 50:40Russia from a dictatorship, but also liberating revolutionary and secessionist
- 50:45movements across the vast federation. Moscow's militarized center with a
- 50:49military that's been humiliated and will not hold, and there
- 50:52are dozens of active secession movements across Russia Cheshniya, Tartistan, Colingrad,
- 50:59Sokko Report, Public and others in Siberia. In twenty twenty one,
- 51:04this person whose name I can't pronounce, a lecturer in
- 51:07Eastern European studies at the University of Warsaw posted a
- 51:11six scenarios for Russia the fall of Russia under the
- 51:15influence of China, Balkanization, territorial disintegration, a gradual but peaceful disintegration,
- 51:23an imperial boom resulting from high oil and gas prices
- 51:28for years, and modernization in cooperation with the West. Cooperation
- 51:33is not in Putin's DNA and his illegal invasion. Okay,
- 51:35so this article is very very very very very biased.
- 51:38I see this, I get this. But at the same time,
- 51:41the article wasn't going on to say, just like, yes,
- 51:44you's mad at Putin, He's about to invade Siberia. Apparently
- 51:47there was some sort of a historical precedent to this
- 51:49that they were going on about. Now, again, this is
- 51:52back in twenty twenty two, right, and a lot of
- 51:55the predictions of what would happen and what things would
- 51:57look like in the near future did not exactly come
- 52:00to pass. But same time, if China was to try
- 52:06to make a move into Siberia for the resources, and
- 52:10I'm not saying a military invasion, more like a buyout,
- 52:14if you will, or something like that, or maybe they're
- 52:16waiting for Russia to collapse so that they could come
- 52:18in and fill the void. In that regard, I don't know,
- 52:21but I don't see that as necessarily a dumb plan.
- 52:25I see it as a very wise move for them
- 52:27to try to do that if the situation was to
- 52:29go a certain direction, Tony, go ahead.
- 52:34Speaker 5: Yeah. So first of all, on the Putin Shee partnership,
- 52:37they've always got pretty rosy words for each other. Who
- 52:40knows what's really going on in the background, But I
- 52:42suppose that it's actually a pretty good relationship. She is
- 52:48she Genping is going to be in Moscow for their
- 52:52Victory Day parades on May ninth of this year. So
- 52:55things look good enough. And like I think I said before,
- 52:59if China really wanted Siberia, I think they would just
- 53:02try to buy it. If not, you know, politically, at least,
- 53:08you know, just just in a private kind of way.
- 53:11Speaker 1: That's how I've been doing it. They haven't been going
- 53:13in and taking things over militarily. They've been taking it
- 53:15over in a corporation way, right the big Belton Road
- 53:18in the way. If they were going to make yeah,
- 53:22it would be with a corporate greed, A suit and
- 53:24tie would take Siberia, not a gun.
- 53:28Speaker 5: Yeah. Furthermore, there actually was a huge Sino Soviet border conflict,
- 53:33and there's a whole Wikipedia article on it, and some
- 53:35people even believe that nuclear weapons were used at that time,
- 53:38but hardly anybody saw them, and there was enough political
- 53:43pressure not to write any of this down. So I don't know.
- 53:47I'm not sure I believe that, but there was a
- 53:50there was a border conflict in nineteen sixty nine between
- 53:53the two countries.
- 53:54Speaker 1: That was And as a matter of fact, we just
- 53:56did the episode on the Cult about the Lost Cosmonauts,
- 53:59and it was around that time when one of the
- 54:00Russian cosmonauts landed in China and they scrubbed him from
- 54:05the program and made it seem like he never was
- 54:07a part of it or whatever. But he was hailed
- 54:09in China as a prisoner for a year because they
- 54:11thought he was a Russian spy who fell out of
- 54:13a spycraft of some type. Because it was during that
- 54:15time of the Cold War where China and Russia happened
- 54:18to be on the outs. So yeah, there was a conflict,
- 54:21and I sincerely doubt that nuclear warheads were used, but
- 54:26especially during the Cold War when no information was coming
- 54:29out of communist nations other than what they wanted to
- 54:31come out, I could understand why maybe the West never
- 54:34heard about it in grave detail. I don't know, but yeah,
- 54:39I'm with you one hundred percent. I don't think China's
- 54:41going to take over in some sort of a military way,
- 54:43maybe a business way, maybe a co op type situation
- 54:46like they've been doing with everything else in the Belton
- 54:48wrote initiative. But I don't know, especially now that Russia's
- 54:52economy and yes, I know they've been everybody's been saying
- 54:55the Russian economy is like on its last leg, except
- 54:58for the fact that they were able to to sell
- 55:00their oil in LNG with a different flag on the
- 55:03boat and people were buying a third party because Europe
- 55:07really wants to buy Russian oil, even if not out loud,
- 55:11which we will get to that here in a minute.
- 55:13Actually why not now? Why not?
- 55:15Speaker 5: Now?
- 55:16Speaker 1: This is actually right in line with that fact check.
- 55:19Did Europe spend more on Russian oil and gas than
- 55:22Ukrainian aid? This is from March fifth of this year,
- 55:25as a matter of fact, And this is actually pretty interesting,
- 55:28so to everybody who's thinking that, like, wait a minute,
- 55:31these European countries hate Russia and they need to back Ukraine,
- 55:35and they're gonna send weapons and manpower and blah blah
- 55:37blah blah blah blah blah. Before we just take on
- 55:41that stance, let's go ahead and look at it full pictures,
- 55:43shall we. There's a fact checking article from Newsweek about this.
- 55:48Europe has spent more on purchasing Russia's oil and gas
- 55:51than it has on assistance for Ukraine in the war
- 55:54with the country, President Donald Trump has told the US Congress.
- 55:58Trump made the comment during his address to lawmakers on Tuesday,
- 56:01in which he referred to what his administration might do
- 56:04to in the three year old conflict started at by Moscow.
- 56:07Trump compared the aid that the US has provided Ukraine
- 56:11with with what the war tour country was receiving from
- 56:14its European allies, effectively casting doubt on the commitment of
- 56:17the continent's leaders, who have raised concerns about Washington stopping
- 56:21its assistance in the fight against Russia. Isaac Levy from
- 56:24the Center for Research on Energy and Clean Air told
- 56:27Newsweek on Wednesday that the EU's purchase of fossil fuels
- 56:30from Russia are financing the Kremlins War chest and canceling
- 56:34out the support the block gives Ukraine. Yeah, I believe
- 56:37that one thousand percent. Trump said Europe has spent more
- 56:41money buying Russian oil than defending Ukraine, adding that the
- 56:44US spent has spent three hundred and fifty billion dollars,
- 56:47which was like taking candy from a baby, while Europe
- 56:50had spent one hundred billion dollars. What a difference that is.
- 56:55Over the course of the war started by Putin, the
- 56:57US had been the biggest donor of military and financial assistance.
- 57:01Trump claimed that he could end the war within a
- 57:03day entering the Oval office, and while the deadline has
- 57:06been extended to a more realistic timeframe, the US leader
- 57:09has insisted that he could still broke a swift of
- 57:12resolution to the conflict. During the address to Congress, Trump
- 57:16reiterated that his grievance about US spending on Ukraine, which
- 57:20he said provided no security, as he asked, do you
- 57:23want to keep it going for another five years? Which,
- 57:25by the way, yes, I personally believe the European countries
- 57:29want to keep it going for another five years. War
- 57:31makes money and they like that. And yes, it may
- 57:34not be making money for the European military industrial complex.
- 57:38They're able to buy Russian oil at cut rate prices
- 57:42because they know that Russia really needs to sell this oil.
- 57:46And now that they have all these crazy terrists from
- 57:48the international conglomerates and all that, the Russian ships have
- 57:52just changed their numbers and changed what flag they're flying
- 57:55and now it's some third party from Panama or from Liberia.
- 58:00And it doesn't matter because those two countries. You don't
- 58:03have to actually register the boat there in order to
- 58:05fly the flag there. You just had to file a
- 58:06paperwork and pay a fee and that's it. And so yeah,
- 58:10they're buying oil from this boat, where the boat come from.
- 58:16What language are the people on the boat speaking, that's
- 58:18not important. They're buying the oil at a really good rate,
- 58:22which is how Russia's been able to keep their economy
- 58:24going this whole time. If the European countries were that
- 58:28dead set on ending this war and crippling Russia, then
- 58:31they would be buying oil from name an Arabic country,
- 58:36name a North American country, not Venezuela. But I mean,
- 58:39there's ways that they could go about that, but they're
- 58:42just simply not doing it. And they have been funding
- 58:45both sides of this war. I understand this sounds very
- 58:48rothchild of them, but really looking at the numbers here,
- 58:52that's what they've been doing. So as much as they
- 58:54want to get on microphones and stand on podiums and
- 58:57tout their display with Russia b blah blah blah, then
- 59:02why are they funding it? I don't know, Tony, what
- 59:05are your thoughts?
- 59:07Speaker 5: Well? My thoughts are Britain and the EU are both
- 59:11facing a potential sovereign debt crisis they're afraid of and
- 59:16a great There's two ways that they've been getting around this.
- 59:21In twenty twenty, there was the great COVID panic and pandemic.
- 59:25That was a good excuse to shut everything down and
- 59:29maybe and divert everyone's attention away from the strength of
- 59:33their currency. And the other way is to say we
- 59:36all got to rally around the flag and react to
- 59:40this foreign threat that is Russia. And Germany is not
- 59:44very enthusiastic about it, but the French and the British
- 59:47are talking about sending at least small numbers of troops
- 59:50to Ukraine. I don't think they'll actually do it. I
- 59:54hope they don't, but they feel like they need to
- 59:56talk about it, and I think they think this will
- 1:00:00help rescue their economy and their sovereign debt and their currency.
- 1:00:06That's why I think that's the main motivator for doing this.
- 1:00:10Speaker 1: Yeah, I agree they're gonna they're talking. They're doing a
- 1:00:14lot of talking right about sending not just money, but manpower.
- 1:00:19And by manpower, I don't mean like a chunk of
- 1:00:22their military might, more like a couple battalions. Let's not
- 1:00:26forget that North Korea has sent ten thousand troops, so
- 1:00:31at this point, like France promising ten thousand, like ooh ooh,
- 1:00:36they're talking about matching North Korea's of donation. How magnanimous
- 1:00:42of them. It's Yeah, it's a whole lot of talking.
- 1:00:46And although it's a very ugly conversation to have, Yes,
- 1:00:49war makes money for these groups. And do you want
- 1:00:55to keep this war going on forever the European country,
- 1:00:57Sure do absolutely, And they'll tell you the reason why
- 1:01:01is because if they're fighting in Ukraine, that means that
- 1:01:03they're not coming to our doorstep. Russia I don't believe
- 1:01:08has any intentions on Germany. In France and Spain, I
- 1:01:12understand the argument for like Estonia I understand the argument
- 1:01:15for North Macedonia. I understand the argument for Poland. I
- 1:01:18at least understand the thought process of why they would
- 1:01:21think that's a real thing that needs to be concerned with. Okay, fine,
- 1:01:24I may disagree, I may agree, but I understand at least,
- 1:01:28like you know, on the chalkboard, looking at the math,
- 1:01:31how it maths. Fine, But the countries that are talking
- 1:01:35about donating all of these resources and manpower and everything
- 1:01:38else are not at risk of this becoming of them problem.
- 1:01:43But yes, they're wanting to match North Korea's charity, which
- 1:01:48is I think kind of insulting any but Zelenski's all
- 1:01:54too willing to accept whatever donations he can get because boy,
- 1:01:58oh boy, does he need it. So I get it.
- 1:02:01Speaker 5: Yeah, these Western European countries, it wouldn't be the first
- 1:02:04time they've been at war with Russia either, or the
- 1:02:06first time that they've frankly lost, for example Napoleon. You
- 1:02:11could argue the British won the Crimean War, but some
- 1:02:13people argue the opposite, And I don't know enough about
- 1:02:16it to say for sure.
- 1:02:18Speaker 1: I called the Curic victory at best, dude, I mean, yeah,
- 1:02:21maybe on paper they won, but like at what cost.
- 1:02:26Speaker 5: You know, uh huh, Yeah, they had to send a
- 1:02:29lot of troops very far away, whereas for Russia that
- 1:02:31fight was right next door. But anyway, I found another
- 1:02:35kind of funny interesting thing is this is admittedly from
- 1:02:39a Russian propagana outlet, but it seems true that the
- 1:02:43Russia Defense Ministry published a fragment of the interrogation of
- 1:02:48a Ukrainian soldier named Andre Chemer from Kiya. He was
- 1:02:52captured during the battles for Kirsk. Chamr showed a strange document.
- 1:02:57It was in French. The commanders of the armed for
- 1:03:00vers of Ukraine gave their subordinates an alleged French insurance policy,
- 1:03:06but in fact these guys couldn't read French. But what
- 1:03:10the document was was a consent for organ donation and
- 1:03:14transplantation in Canada. The prisoner didn't know about this, and
- 1:03:21the soldiers were told that if they were wounded, they
- 1:03:23would be sent to the best clinics in France for
- 1:03:26treatment and have a French life insurance policy. But in reality,
- 1:03:31allegedly when they were getting wounded, there were doctors coming
- 1:03:35up to harvest their organs. Maybe it's true, maybe it's
- 1:03:39not true. But this is just one of many little
- 1:03:42tidbits of information flying around in the fog of war.
- 1:03:47Speaker 1: Wow. Okay, so much to unpack on that one. So
- 1:03:54if that is accurate, I'm not saying it is. I'm
- 1:03:59not saying it isn't. It would really depend on the
- 1:04:03injury sustained by the person, because it's not like every
- 1:04:07organ is harvestable upon, you know, even if it's a
- 1:04:10fresh I mean, we're talking about a guy that's been
- 1:04:13living in trenches and on the front line for god
- 1:04:16knows how many months or whatever the case may be.
- 1:04:19But if it was a viable, you know, source of organs,
- 1:04:25I could envision a world where if this person's especially
- 1:04:29already being chalked up as a death anyway, you know,
- 1:04:32and we're talking about a war where there's report saying
- 1:04:36that neither side actually cares about their soldiers. So I
- 1:04:40get that I could see a world in which that
- 1:04:44would be accurate. I also think that if you were
- 1:04:47able to keep him alive long enough to make it
- 1:04:49to an AID station, and then they would, you know, say,
- 1:04:51oh no, this guy's not going to get surgery. He's
- 1:04:53going to get that other surgery. I just I don't know.
- 1:04:57I have a hard time seeing making it to the
- 1:05:00surgical room or tint or whatever the case. And then
- 1:05:03like what organs would you harvest from a frontline soldier
- 1:05:06that would be viable or sellable at that point, I
- 1:05:10don't know.
- 1:05:11Speaker 5: Yeah, part of me kind of doubts it too, But
- 1:05:15it goes on that they claim that there were doctors
- 1:05:17running around with like a thermal box containers for organs,
- 1:05:25trying to put people's organs on ice and stuff. Maybe
- 1:05:28it's not true for the record, but maybe I've heard
- 1:05:33a lot of stories about like China doing organ harvesting,
- 1:05:36and I'm not one hundred percent sure that's true either.
- 1:05:39It could be half true. But these are kind of
- 1:05:42the kind of accusations that just fly around a lot
- 1:05:44when two countries aid each other.
- 1:05:47Speaker 1: I mean, it doesn't sound out of the realm of possibility.
- 1:05:51I'll give you that. It sounds not probable, but very possible.
- 1:05:56I mean, it's it's and I know we're looking at
- 1:05:59this from an American lenns right, and on paper, at least,
- 1:06:03the American government gives a they give a rats ass
- 1:06:06about their military members and all these things, and yeah, yeah, yeah, sure, Sure,
- 1:06:11even though they let that marine stay in a Russian
- 1:06:14prison for years for nothing, and they traded Britney Griner
- 1:06:20back before him, and like that's the thing that absolutely happened.
- 1:06:24But yeah, so that's what I'm saying. There is absolutely
- 1:06:28a greater than zero percent chance that something like this
- 1:06:30has happened. And I mean, even if it's a very
- 1:06:33isolated case or cases of something like this happening, maybe
- 1:06:37it's not a big mass push that still breaks a
- 1:06:41lot of Geneva Convention walls, which I mean that only
- 1:06:45applies to the countries that actually acknowledge the Geneva Convention.
- 1:06:48So I mean, I don't believe that Ukraine wasn't a
- 1:06:52country when that was signed. And the Soviet Union was
- 1:06:56the one that was signed the Geneva Convention, not the
- 1:06:59Russian Federation.
- 1:07:00Speaker 5: So yeah, I don't know that's a good point. I
- 1:07:05could look that up. But this brings up something that
- 1:07:07is not political at all, if you'll indulge me for
- 1:07:11a minute. But yeah, I have a friend through church
- 1:07:16and he and his wife just had a baby. But
- 1:07:20I don't want to give away information or docks him
- 1:07:23or anything, but the baby did not survive. But The
- 1:07:28one silver lining though, is that they got to donate
- 1:07:33the baby's heart valve, so there's probably another baby out
- 1:07:35there who's going to get to live who wouldn't have
- 1:07:38gotten to live otherwise. So it's obviously highly emotional for
- 1:07:41them and this is like the one little silver lining
- 1:07:45of it. So I guess thank God for organ donation.
- 1:07:49And some people don't believe in it for some reason,
- 1:07:51but I think it's a good thing. Gee, what's your take, Podox.
- 1:08:00Speaker 7: Judaism does not believe in it does not believe in
- 1:08:03Oregon transplants. I'm not entirely so I don't I don't know.
- 1:08:08I knew that was gonna be the follow up question,
- 1:08:10and I will have to do a little bit more
- 1:08:11research on it, but I I'm not sure if it
- 1:08:17has to do with what we believe that there will
- 1:08:19be a a revivification of the dead.
- 1:08:26Speaker 3: Basically means like.
- 1:08:29Speaker 7: Probably probably the resurrection, just different, different, different term. So
- 1:08:34that since eventually there will be a point where, like
- 1:08:40we believe that all Jews will go to Israel, like
- 1:08:44when once our Messiah eventually comes in et cetera, and
- 1:08:48once it gets to a certain point, it could be
- 1:08:52that it's not necessary because obviously God being God there
- 1:08:56and there are there have been millions of Jews over
- 1:08:59the past, you know, a couple of thousand years who
- 1:09:02have died. So it's not like these organs are Bible,
- 1:09:06you know, hundreds of years later.
- 1:09:09Speaker 3: It could just.
- 1:09:09Speaker 7: Be because God gave it to us. I don't know,
- 1:09:14so I will have to do more research. But no,
- 1:09:17Orthodox Jews do not believe in organ donations.
- 1:09:22Speaker 1: So follow up question, I would love to hear what
- 1:09:25you find as far as that goes. Ask I would
- 1:09:27love for like some rabbis and get like the the
- 1:09:30dogmatic reasons for that. But and I understand why. For instance,
- 1:09:34like a heart valve replacement, I fully get why Jews
- 1:09:38would not want a pig valve installed in them.
- 1:09:41Speaker 3: Not true, not true, not true.
- 1:09:43Speaker 1: Actually wait, I was about saying, I know now replacements though,
- 1:09:47like a cow valve would be better than a pig valve.
- 1:09:49As far as the Jewish, you know, dog Mo was concerned.
- 1:09:52You're fine with.
- 1:09:53Speaker 3: Neither, So hold on, hold on, a hold lot. So
- 1:09:56here's the reason.
- 1:09:58Speaker 7: So there is a mitzvah in the tour that says
- 1:10:01that you should live be ahem, which means you should
- 1:10:05live through them. And one of the interpretations and reading
- 1:10:10of it is that if you are that you are
- 1:10:14required to do whatever you can.
- 1:10:16Speaker 3: To save life.
- 1:10:18Speaker 7: So for for example, my my grandmother is is not religious,
- 1:10:24for example, and I am. However, if she was having
- 1:10:29a heart attack, I would pick up my phone and
- 1:10:32I would call that, I would call if there was
- 1:10:35if there was a doctor. There are plenty of religious
- 1:10:38communities that a doctor will have their phone on during shop.
- 1:10:43Is because if you are able to save the life,
- 1:10:46you are required to do so.
- 1:10:49Speaker 3: This this is not optional.
- 1:10:51Speaker 7: So when it comes to any kind of surgeries that
- 1:10:55are uh, life giving surgeries that like, if you do.
- 1:11:00Speaker 3: Not get this pig valve, you will die.
- 1:11:03Speaker 7: You not even should you must take that heart or
- 1:11:09take take that take that valve in order to do so.
- 1:11:13Speaker 1: Orthodox Jews are not down with organ donation and all
- 1:11:16that it would Orthodox Jews be down with a heart
- 1:11:18valve replacement for a pig valve. Or is this like
- 1:11:20the different yes, modern type of judy.
- 1:11:23Speaker 3: No that no, that that no, that that's that's a
- 1:11:25different thing.
- 1:11:26Speaker 7: Those are two different One of them is giving the
- 1:11:31organs away after one has been deceased, and the other
- 1:11:35one is getting something in order to survive.
- 1:11:41Speaker 1: That kind of it's a different.
- 1:11:45Speaker 3: No, it's it's a different it's a different thing.
- 1:11:47Speaker 7: So like so when it comes to when I say organization,
- 1:11:51or we're talking about that posthumously.
- 1:11:53Speaker 3: So so after someone.
- 1:11:54Speaker 7: Has been deceased, you are the all of the organs
- 1:11:58should stay with the body, as opposed to with the
- 1:12:02example you're giving about the pig valve, is that if
- 1:12:06I were to not get the surgery, I would die.
- 1:12:12Speaker 3: As opposed to I'm already dead.
- 1:12:13Speaker 7: Therefore, the organs that I already have internally I can
- 1:12:17give away.
- 1:12:18Speaker 3: It's a different thing one is in order to survive.
- 1:12:22Speaker 1: Yeah, so you're against receiving a donated organ. They are
- 1:12:26against donating their own organs.
- 1:12:29Speaker 7: At least at the very least after you are dead.
- 1:12:33So a good question also would be if I was
- 1:12:37to say, had the same I don't know kidney as
- 1:12:40somebody and they needed a kidney transplant, would I be
- 1:12:46allowed to give my organ? I'm not sure, so that
- 1:12:50that would be a secondary question.
- 1:12:52Speaker 3: So after someone dies, for sure.
- 1:12:54Speaker 7: Not If it's to save a life, that might be
- 1:12:58permissible because you're doing something to help someone survive.
- 1:13:03Speaker 1: Wow, Yeah, please find out more on the dogma of this.
- 1:13:08I would love to learn more about. I didn't know
- 1:13:10this honestly. Wow.
- 1:13:14Speaker 5: Yeah, I'm kind of confused, but I'm interested to learn
- 1:13:17more too. One thing I could say is that there
- 1:13:20was a similar teaching in the Catholic Church that you
- 1:13:23couldn't be cremated and you're supposed to be buried because
- 1:13:27it will make the resurrection of the body easier.
- 1:13:30Speaker 7: Yeah, I mean right, it's kind of I think that's
- 1:13:35why I think catholic has got it from Jews, because
- 1:13:37Jews should not be cremated.
- 1:13:40Speaker 3: That's a it's a very bad thing.
- 1:13:43Speaker 7: And even like when it comes to laws of mourning,
- 1:13:49that that you should not or cannot properly mourn for
- 1:13:55somebody if they were cremated.
- 1:13:57Speaker 3: Obviously, the Holocaust is a completely difference.
- 1:14:00Speaker 7: Because that was something that was that was done extremely forcefully,
- 1:14:05that was not exactly done willingly.
- 1:14:07Speaker 3: But but for those.
- 1:14:09Speaker 7: Who willingly get it done, it's it is not looked
- 1:14:13upon very highly.
- 1:14:15Speaker 1: Yeah. I have an uncle who is like overly Catholic,
- 1:14:18and I'm not saying that in an insulting way, but
- 1:14:21he's like full on Knights of Columbus. Dude, and I'm
- 1:14:24not throwing shaite at the Knight's Columbus. You know, a
- 1:14:26lot of these guys are amazing organization, amazing people. But
- 1:14:29he also we were talking about that one day. My dad,
- 1:14:32his brother wants to be cremated, right. He on the
- 1:14:36other hand, was like, I don't know why I would
- 1:14:37do that. Why would I make it harder for God
- 1:14:39to put all the pieces back together once I die?
- 1:14:40And I was like, wait, wait, wait, wait, when you die,
- 1:14:43your body doesn't go with you. Your body stays here,
- 1:14:46your soul goes up. Wait do you think you're gonna
- 1:14:48have like this body? You're gonna look like you when
- 1:14:51you go there. He's like, well yeah, And I'm like, wait,
- 1:14:54where in the book does it say that? Show me
- 1:14:56anywhere where it says that. Well, I mean, it's just
- 1:14:59the way it's gonna work. I was like, who told
- 1:15:01you this? It's the way it's gonna be. And I'm like, oh, okay,
- 1:15:05that's sure. That's a thing. So I didn't know that
- 1:15:10was a whole Catholic ideology. I just thought that was
- 1:15:12a hymn being a hymn thing. So this is, uh,
- 1:15:17that's a thing. And I knew that the Jews weren't
- 1:15:19allowed to do like a cremation that. If anything, the
- 1:15:24whole burial rights of the jew is how we even
- 1:15:27got the shrouded touring from Jesus and like the burial
- 1:15:29tombs and all these things. Lazarus was in a tomb, Like,
- 1:15:31there's there's an order of precedence to this, And I
- 1:15:34know there's gonna be some people that say that they
- 1:15:36adopted that from Egypt when they were there, and it's like, dude,
- 1:15:39the Jewish culture predates that. It's it's not the same conversation.
- 1:15:43But yeah, people like to look at these things and
- 1:15:45pretend like they're comparing apples to apples. I get it.
- 1:15:48And as a matter of fact, we were having a
- 1:15:49conversation about that today with Cosmic Peach. We shot an
- 1:15:52episode with her this morning. We were talking about burial
- 1:15:55practices from different cultures around the world and it's actually
- 1:15:58really fascinating to look at like without any biases, right,
- 1:16:02just no biases from ourselves whatsoever. Certain cultures believe in cremation,
- 1:16:08just outright right, Like the Greeks and the Romans, they
- 1:16:11did funeral pyres cut two egypt Semitic religions, Hell Zoroastrians
- 1:16:17even they don't believe in funeral pyres and they worship fire, right,
- 1:16:21they bring their dead to the Towers of Silence and
- 1:16:24they set them on top of a roof, on top
- 1:16:26of this tall tower so they can rot naturally, and
- 1:16:29it's like a whole thing. There's no funeral details with it,
- 1:16:32but they're also forbidden to touch dead things, and there's
- 1:16:35this other stuff to it. Then you look at like
- 1:16:37certain Native American tribes who alle hundred percent did cremation
- 1:16:41and funeral pyres. Then you cut to the Mayans, who
- 1:16:45did a very specific way of not I wouldn't sa mummification,
- 1:16:50but we could say body preservation, and they did them
- 1:16:52in these bags and they would set the bodies in
- 1:16:54this fetal position. It was a whole thing. It is
- 1:16:56very fascinating to look at the burial practices, or I
- 1:17:00say burial loosely, let's just say how to dispose of
- 1:17:04a dead person's body. Put that to the overarching theme.
- 1:17:08It is very interesting to look at how that changes
- 1:17:11culture to culture, especially with neighboring cultures. But yeah, go ahead, zombie,
- 1:17:16I I say, raven Lee, I know you have something
- 1:17:19to say on this. You being the anthropologist and all.
- 1:17:22Speaker 2: Well, actually, I I have a question for hard Gie.
- 1:17:25I was sitting here thinking about like how does that
- 1:17:28work with like byproducts, so like can you receive other
- 1:17:33people's blood? Can you give blood? Because like blood is
- 1:17:37such like a deeply you know that that if you
- 1:17:41want to talk about anything, Yeah, blood.
- 1:17:43Speaker 4: Is life, so like could you receive that?
- 1:17:45Speaker 2: Like I mean, and then I know this is really
- 1:17:48random and like kind of gross, but like there's fecal transplant,
- 1:17:52Like can you receive that from somebody? Could you get
- 1:17:55Like I'm just really like I'm kind of I mean,
- 1:17:58I knew about.
- 1:17:59Speaker 4: Like some things, but I'm just like, huh.
- 1:18:01Speaker 2: That's and then the whole theory, like the conspiracy theory
- 1:18:04that if you have donor on your license that like
- 1:18:07they'll kill you to be able to get your organs.
- 1:18:10I don't know anybody, And when I was doing my
- 1:18:12like when I was an EMT and did my EMT stuff, like,
- 1:18:15I never looked at anyone's license. I was just concerned
- 1:18:19about making sure the person lives. So that's always been
- 1:18:23an interesting conspiracy theory. A lot of people always bring
- 1:18:26that up about the donor stuff.
- 1:18:28Speaker 1: No good question about blood so please.
- 1:18:32Speaker 3: I agree. So so as far as.
- 1:18:36Speaker 7: Blood, as far as I know, is fine to give
- 1:18:39and to be given too, so there should there's there's
- 1:18:43not a problem with that because I think that's one
- 1:18:45of those things that's replenishable as opposed to you're not
- 1:18:49going to grow a different kidney. They're not going to
- 1:18:51grow a different I don't know they name another organ
- 1:18:55that we give out. So as far as the I
- 1:19:00think that's how it goes. As far I've never had
- 1:19:03I used to donate blood all the time because I'm
- 1:19:06all positive. Uh so, I you know, they enjoyed my blood.
- 1:19:13Because so if you're doing something to save someone's life,
- 1:19:17I think that that's fine.
- 1:19:19Speaker 3: Plenty of people, I mean plenty.
- 1:19:22Speaker 7: Of juice go to the hospitals every single day that
- 1:19:25need something.
- 1:19:28Speaker 3: So that would be as far as that it's internal
- 1:19:34and you're doing it probably for.
- 1:19:36Speaker 1: The you're cutting out on his roy ah man, do
- 1:19:47we lose them? Sorry, Harry, Yeah, we can hear you, brother, sure.
- 1:19:55Speaker 3: Sorry, a bad part of the mountains.
- 1:20:00Speaker 7: As far as the Fegal transport, I would I would
- 1:20:03assume that that should be fine also because it's all
- 1:20:06about receiving good bacteria, so that you can survive from
- 1:20:10what the basic law is that you can if you
- 1:20:14can do something or if you need to do something
- 1:20:16in order to survive or to help someone to survive,
- 1:20:20that takes precedents because that's how valuable God treats human life.
- 1:20:26So anything that we can do to save ourselves and
- 1:20:31save other people. Now, then you get to these wonderful
- 1:20:34questions on well, all right, well, if you can either
- 1:20:36kill one person or five, like obviously these are not
- 1:20:40my kinds of questions, and I will I have zero
- 1:20:45desire to try to eat to like that. Morality questions
- 1:20:49sometimes are not not easy or for this scope. But yeah,
- 1:20:54basically if you can, if you can save someone's life
- 1:20:59and you can save of you'r and saved your own life,
- 1:21:02that takes pressing. And then randomly there was actually one
- 1:21:07Jew in history that actually got bummified.
- 1:21:14Speaker 1: Really like Egyptian mummified.
- 1:21:17Speaker 7: Yes, who actually said it says very very specifically in
- 1:21:24the in the Torah. I believe it was. They want
- 1:21:28to say Jacob because he traveled down.
- 1:21:32Speaker 3: Joseph. I think if I'm bad at this on one
- 1:21:37about that, but.
- 1:21:38Speaker 1: Basically, now you said the tourus would be in the
- 1:21:40first five.
- 1:21:41Speaker 7: Books correct, So not so it was either Jacob or Joseph.
- 1:21:45Speaker 3: I don't. I don't remember. I don't remember either, because no,
- 1:21:51it wasn't.
- 1:21:52Speaker 7: It wasn't just Joseph, because it was his father, because
- 1:21:55he said, please mummify me that way, because he wanted
- 1:21:58to be buried in Israel in the Cave of Mala
- 1:22:04with his with his father's so in order to preserve him,
- 1:22:08he was also momified.
- 1:22:12Speaker 1: How interesting I'm trying to think, I'm I honestly don't
- 1:22:17even know how Jacob died, like as far as the
- 1:22:21story goes and all of that. I actually just was
- 1:22:24talking about that earlier today too. If I'm not mistaken.
- 1:22:26One of Jacob's descendants became the Samaritans, right, So I
- 1:22:30mean it as a whole whole thing about that. But
- 1:22:33it's wow, So Jacob's dad, no.
- 1:22:38Speaker 7: I think, yes, So thank you very much.
- 1:22:50Speaker 3: Hold on, that doesn't sound right.
- 1:22:52Speaker 1: It doesn't sound right. I can't tell you the burial
- 1:22:56practices of the Prophets, you know what I mean. So
- 1:22:58I don't know. But of all the things, why would
- 1:23:02they go for an Egyptian burial? That that's wild to me?
- 1:23:06I mean body.
- 1:23:06Speaker 3: Preservation preserve well also know.
- 1:23:10Speaker 7: Another idea is that a someone who is a sid
- 1:23:14or a righteous person, their body does not decompose, so.
- 1:23:19Speaker 3: Like they didn't want He didn't.
- 1:23:20Speaker 7: Want to be worshiped as a deity because his body
- 1:23:24didn't decompose.
- 1:23:27Speaker 1: Interesting, all right, you learned something new every day, so
- 1:23:33this is just kind of new information to me. Honestly,
- 1:23:36I'm reading into the chat here, and you know what,
- 1:23:38can I just take a second and say thank you
- 1:23:42all of you for being adults who know your blood type.
- 1:23:45I'm it shocks me how many people, actual adults, not
- 1:23:50just like nineteen year olds, but like full fledged adults
- 1:23:53who don't know their blood type. That that bothers me.
- 1:23:57And they just they don't know. They know they're social
- 1:23:59Security number, but they don't know that. And it's like, wait,
- 1:24:02how do you not. It's not even something like well
- 1:24:06I never learned it, bro read your medical records. Just
- 1:24:09it's it's right there. It's not like it's a secret
- 1:24:12and you might need to know that one day it
- 1:24:15kills me. I don't know.
- 1:24:17Speaker 3: By the way, it was, it was Joseph So in
- 1:24:19La Tourah, Joseph So.
- 1:24:21Speaker 7: Joseph was embalmed and placed in Egyptian coffin with the
- 1:24:25promise that his bones would be taken to Canaan or
- 1:24:29Israel bias people. While Jacob was also involved with there
- 1:24:32is no mention of coffin. So both Jacob and Joseph
- 1:24:38were embalmed and Mamma.
- 1:24:41Speaker 1: Five Joseph, which Joseph is this there's a few of
- 1:24:45them in the book.
- 1:24:46Speaker 3: Uh, So we're talking about my Joseph, not you're Joseph.
- 1:24:49Speaker 1: That's all I'm asking, Like, who is he the son
- 1:24:52of or the father of? Yes, yes, Jacob's son Joseph.
- 1:24:58Speaker 5: If you went to Egypt to bec I'm a hill
- 1:25:02than all of his other brothers and his father had
- 1:25:04to come down when there was a famine. Yeah, they're
- 1:25:07all in Egypt for a little while.
- 1:25:09Speaker 1: Yes, yes, Oh my god, Joseph in the many colored cloak,
- 1:25:13that's what we're talking about. That's David. That's Joseph.
- 1:25:16Speaker 8: Nod No, No, Joseph as Joseph.
- 1:25:19Speaker 3: Yeah, not David.
- 1:25:21Speaker 5: And David's like what three hundred years later?
- 1:25:23Speaker 1: Maybe I didn't mean King David. I'm thinking there's more
- 1:25:26than one David. Okay, So Joseph he was his dad
- 1:25:28gave him favor gave him a cloak. His brothers got pissed,
- 1:25:31sold him into slavery and long stories. He ended up
- 1:25:34handling the finances of Egypt, so that would make sense
- 1:25:37why he was buried in the proper Egyptian way. Okay,
- 1:25:40I'm with you now, God It, dude, I need to
- 1:25:43do more digging into the OT I really, I mean,
- 1:25:46I know the stories and stuff, but man, I really
- 1:25:49need to reread some of these things. Honestly, I've been
- 1:25:51digging more into the Gospels here lately, but the Old
- 1:25:54Testament has so much fascinating history behind it all. Anyway,
- 1:25:58I digress. Yeah, and Royce, please let us know more
- 1:26:02about uh when you find out more about the the
- 1:26:05ins and outs of the whole organ donating versus organ receiving.
- 1:26:10How is a pig heart? Okay, I'm also very curious
- 1:26:13about that. I understand it's too like save your life.
- 1:26:15I get that, But like of all things, the bovine valve,
- 1:26:19I could see nobody really having an issue with it's
- 1:26:22a cow. Everybody's cool with that. Not the Hindi's obviously,
- 1:26:24but like for the Jews and the Muslims and the Christians,
- 1:26:26why not. It's cool. A pig valve I thought would
- 1:26:29be like haram as as hell for the I don't
- 1:26:34know that the Jewish word for forbidden. I don't mean
- 1:26:36to you. See what I'm saying, sir, So.
- 1:26:40Speaker 7: User as u r acer, Yeah, okay, is prohibited?
- 1:26:47Speaker 1: Okay, So I thought a pig valve would be aucer
- 1:26:49as hell.
- 1:26:49Speaker 9: Dude.
- 1:26:50Speaker 1: But like I, I'm not a Jew. I don't be
- 1:26:52knowing the thing. So please do some digging on that
- 1:26:55and let us know.
- 1:26:56Speaker 3: Uh yeah, I'll try to get next by by next week.
- 1:27:00Speaker 1: Absolutely, go ahead, Raven, your hand is raised.
- 1:27:04Speaker 4: I'm curious. I know this is I just I don't
- 1:27:07know much about the Jewish faith.
- 1:27:09Speaker 2: I mean I've I've watched some stuff, but like I
- 1:27:12don't know a lot about it. But what is the
- 1:27:15views on like doing IVF or like you know, like
- 1:27:20is there can you have?
- 1:27:22Speaker 3: Like yes? I guess so yeah.
- 1:27:25Speaker 7: The reason why I know that yes is because I've
- 1:27:28had friends that have used them. I have also have
- 1:27:32a good friend who had her eggs frozen, So yes,
- 1:27:36on both accounts.
- 1:27:38Speaker 3: Why I don't know, I'm.
- 1:27:41Speaker 1: To make more Jews, so anything to make Jewish babies
- 1:27:44is okay by them. I could see that.
- 1:27:47Speaker 3: Orange Jews, Apple Jews, you.
- 1:27:49Speaker 1: Know, yep.
- 1:27:53Speaker 2: Also to the burial stuff, like I dropped the because
- 1:27:56that me and Tony were talking about the South Africa
- 1:27:59is someone that I showed you a couple weeks ago
- 1:28:02about the new information coming out about the burial rights
- 1:28:07for like who they believe the cradle of faith and
- 1:28:10stuff for that area in South Africa. But that's I
- 1:28:15think that's really fascinating, the different barrieral rights around the
- 1:28:18world and how they've changed or stayed the same through
- 1:28:22so much history. I always find just all of that fascinating.
- 1:28:29Speaker 1: Absolutely. Matter of fact, let's read a little bit of this.
- 1:28:32The Homo n lady or no laddie. I'm not sure
- 1:28:35we're burying their dead at least one hundred thousand years
- 1:28:38before humans. Now that's interesting. This would be one of
- 1:28:41our evolutionary predecessors, if we are to believe in that
- 1:28:47style of evolution. But let's see here, some twenty five
- 1:28:50miles out of Johannesburg, South Africa, there is a famous
- 1:28:53paleonanthropical yep sight known as the Cradle of Humankind. So
- 1:29:00any hominin bones were found in the region that it
- 1:29:03was designated a UNESCO World Heritage Site in nineteen ninety nine.
- 1:29:07Among the many limestone caves in the region is the
- 1:29:10Rising Star Cave, where the caverns discovered fossil. Yet the
- 1:29:14caverns discovered fossil representing a new hominin species, Homoni lady.
- 1:29:21In twenty fifteen, only Hlady homon ladies remains were found
- 1:29:26in the cave, suggesting the possibility that the bodies have
- 1:29:29been placed there deliberately, although this hypothesis proved to be
- 1:29:32a bit controversial. Now the same expedition team has announced
- 1:29:36the discovery of the Nilaiti bodies deposited in fetal positions,
- 1:29:41indicating intentional burials. Now that's fascinating. This predates the earliest
- 1:29:47known burials by Homo sapiens by at least one hundred
- 1:29:49thousand years, suggesting that brain size might not be the
- 1:29:53definitive factor behind such complex behavior. The team also found
- 1:29:56crosshatched symbols engraved on the walls of the cave that
- 1:29:59could as far back as two thousand and forty one
- 1:30:03or two hundred and forty one thousand to three hundred
- 1:30:06and thirty five thousand years, although testing is still ongoing,
- 1:30:10so we're talking about realistically, over a quarter million years ago,
- 1:30:14they were doing deliberate burial styles and doing carvings, which
- 1:30:18would not necessarily indicate some sort of a religion, but
- 1:30:23more than likely some sort of burial practices which do
- 1:30:28typically tie into some sort of spirituality or religion, which
- 1:30:32is wow. Taken together, the discoveries provide evidence of a
- 1:30:37major cognitive step in human evolution in terms of mortuary
- 1:30:40practices and meaning making. The team described these new findings
- 1:30:44during a virtual press conference in a in three new
- 1:30:48pre prints posted to the bioerxiv rx iv, which will
- 1:30:54be published later this year in the journal eLife. Quote here,
- 1:30:59I think we are facing a remarkable discovery here of
- 1:31:02hominids with brains a third the size of living humans
- 1:31:06and slightly larger than chimpanzees burying their dead, something previously
- 1:31:11only found in large brain hominids, as well as etching
- 1:31:14meaning making symbols on the wall, says Lee Berger, a
- 1:31:18pale paleothropologist in the National Geographic Explorer in Residents who
- 1:31:25leads the Rising Star project. Back to the quote, this
- 1:31:28would mean not only are humans not unique in the
- 1:31:31development of symbolic practices, but they may not even have
- 1:31:35invented such behaviors. Wow, it says here that, oh Jesus, naturally.
- 1:31:41There are skeptics. For instance, Maria Marnton Torres, director of
- 1:31:46Spain's National Research Center for Human Evolution, told The New
- 1:31:49York Times that such speculations were premature based on the
- 1:31:53evidence presented so far, suggesting that funerary caching cashing. Yeah,
- 1:31:59funerary caching was a more likely scenario than burials. Hypotheses
- 1:32:03need to be built on what we have, not what
- 1:32:06we guess. She said, Isn't that the entire point of
- 1:32:08a hypothesis is an educated guess. I don't know. Still,
- 1:32:12I think the possibility of having funerary caching with the
- 1:32:15antiquity is already stunning. So she's not saying that this
- 1:32:19isn't this isn't a real thing. She's just saying that
- 1:32:22they're kind of being premature in what they're guestimating about
- 1:32:26what these things could mean. The story of homeown a
- 1:32:30Daily technically begins millions of years ago with the Cradles
- 1:32:34network of limestone caves, first formed, as Lydia Pine wrote
- 1:32:38for Ours Ars into twenty eighteen, caves in that area
- 1:32:43of South Africa form a water paracolates I guess through
- 1:32:48the cracks and fissures of the region's domolite dolomite excuse
- 1:32:52me rock and slowly erodes the rock away, forming underground
- 1:32:55caverns of all shapes and sizes. As water flows through
- 1:32:58these caves, it leads behind posits of calcium carbonates easily
- 1:33:02recognizable as concrete, hard brakiaz or sheet like deposits of
- 1:33:07flowstone found along cave walls in the Rising Star Cave system.
- 1:33:12This resulted in a network of chambers, including those where
- 1:33:16researchers have recovered Homone Lady fossils. Recreational cavers have been
- 1:33:21exploring parts of the Rising Star system since the nineteen sixties,
- 1:33:25but Berger hired a team of cavers in twenty thirteen
- 1:33:29to survey the cave more thoroughly and to map out
- 1:33:32any chambers with potentially significant fossils. The team included Rick
- 1:33:36Hunter and Stephn Tucker, who used a nineteen eighty five
- 1:33:40map to guide their explorations. The duo managed to worm
- 1:33:43their weight through a previously unmapped slot just eighteen centimeters
- 1:33:46wide and found themselves in one of the cave's chambers. There,
- 1:33:50they saw a treasure trove of fossilized bones is a
- 1:33:54quote here. When we first saw the mandible, we thought
- 1:33:57maybe this was the last guy that came down the
- 1:33:59chain and didn't make it out, Hunter told Ars in
- 1:34:02twenty eighteen, the reality was potentially much more significant. Excited
- 1:34:07by the discovery, Berger hired an additional team of six
- 1:34:10women with both scientific and caving experiences to excavate the site,
- 1:34:14using two picks and sometimes even porcupine quills, among other tools.
- 1:34:18The entire three week excavation played out live on Twitter.
- 1:34:22These are not easy sites to access. In fact, the
- 1:34:25shoot elaborate the long one portion of the route to
- 1:34:28the dun a lady chamber is known as Superman's crawl
- 1:34:33because most cavers can only manage to squeeze through by
- 1:34:36extending one arm above the head while holding the other
- 1:34:39tied against the body. It's basically a narrow, vertical, twelve
- 1:34:42meter long chimney with an average width of twenty centimeters,
- 1:34:45which is about seven point nine inches.
- 1:34:48Speaker 3: Wow.
- 1:34:48Speaker 1: Okay, this is a really really long article. I'm not
- 1:34:50going to read all of it, but essentially what they're
- 1:34:53saying is, and this is if I'm sure they're going
- 1:34:56to do some carbon dating. I'm sure there's going to
- 1:34:58be a lot more studies to go along with, but
- 1:35:01this would show like actual forethought given to funerary rights
- 1:35:07and again arguably religious practices being conducted over a quarter
- 1:35:14million years ago. That's pretty incredible. Wow.
- 1:35:20Speaker 5: Yeah. I don't think gymps bury their dead or seem
- 1:35:24to do much with them, but human religion probably evolved
- 1:35:28from what to do with people when they die, and
- 1:35:31that's how ancestor worship came into existence, and some of
- 1:35:35these ancestors were deified. So that's a running theory and
- 1:35:40I think it's a pretty good one. As for carbon dating,
- 1:35:42this is a kind of a nerdy topic, but carbon
- 1:35:46fourteen has a half life of seven thousand years, so
- 1:35:49if these if these samples are more than ten carbon
- 1:35:52half lives old, you probably wouldn't even use carbon. You'd
- 1:35:55probably use something else. And I don't know what that
- 1:35:57would be.
- 1:36:00Speaker 1: Yeah, fossilized bones. These are rocks at this point, Like,
- 1:36:03I don't even know what kind of carbon you would
- 1:36:05be looking at in this if they are Yeah, wow, But.
- 1:36:10Speaker 5: Yeah, I watched a video on this. It's really hard
- 1:36:12to get in that chamber because you can see a
- 1:36:16map of it in the video, but nobody's been in
- 1:36:18there for a long time anyway. Now I'm talking about
- 1:36:22stuff though a slightly different topic. You know, one thing
- 1:36:27that came that started really pissing me off, and I'm
- 1:36:30and I'm I hate this because, you know, my friend
- 1:36:33went through so much losing losing their child. So many
- 1:36:37people were telling telling them and and our group that well,
- 1:36:43this is God's will and God is going to have,
- 1:36:46you know, some way to make up for this. And
- 1:36:47I just thought I would never tell somebody this is
- 1:36:50God's will, you know, if they've gone through a tragedy.
- 1:36:54I don't think God wills stuff like that. But stuff
- 1:36:57like that happens by accident or negligent answer, you know,
- 1:37:01just by accident. It's not a question of God wanting
- 1:37:05it to happen. Do you have any thoughts on that?
- 1:37:08Speaker 1: Yeah, so all right, when you say it's God's will,
- 1:37:13I don't believe that God, the God that I worship, anyway,
- 1:37:17deals with dice or plays in chance, or makes mistakes
- 1:37:22or has accidents. I'm personally not of that belief. Yeah,
- 1:37:26human error is a thing, but I also believe that's
- 1:37:28all predetermined as well. I believe in free will, but
- 1:37:31I also believe in determination and destiny. I believe they work.
- 1:37:35They work in an intertwined type of scenario. But that's
- 1:37:40that's a very very very convoluted and philosophical conversation, which
- 1:37:43I mean, I guess this is getting and ready to
- 1:37:44get that way. But it depends on if somebody can
- 1:37:48find peace and solace in the fact that it was
- 1:37:52God's plan for this to happen, not to them. See,
- 1:37:55that's it depends on how it's contextualized, right, if you
- 1:38:00look at it that way, than anything that's ever happened
- 1:38:02period happened to a person rather than just happened and
- 1:38:07a person was a part of it. And it's not
- 1:38:10a fun conversation. It's the same way of like, you know,
- 1:38:14some people are born with a silver spoon in their
- 1:38:16mouth and some people are born with cancer like already
- 1:38:20as a baby, both of which are equally a part
- 1:38:23of God's plan. Whether we understand that or not. That's
- 1:38:25one of the great mysteries. Why do some people get
- 1:38:27hooked up and why do some people get screwed right
- 1:38:29out the gate? It's not fair, But no one ever
- 1:38:32said that life was going to be fair. It's not
- 1:38:34fun or comfortable, but it's still true. But it's like, uh,
- 1:38:40in Heaven forbid, if I was to suffer some sort
- 1:38:42of tragedy like that, I would personally take solace in
- 1:38:45the fact that God saw fit to bless me to
- 1:38:49be a father for the amount of time that I was.
- 1:38:52I also, to bring this up even further, Josh Monday,
- 1:38:56who does two different shows on the Cult to Conspiracy
- 1:39:00right on Sundays and Wednesdays, he just lost his child.
- 1:39:03And when I reached out to him and expressed all
- 1:39:06my condonances and all of this, he said, hey, man,
- 1:39:09it's all good. He's with this heavenly Father, which is
- 1:39:11a way better father than I could have ever been
- 1:39:13for him. Right, And like, he didn't say that in
- 1:39:16a sad way. He was saying that honestly and truthfully,
- 1:39:21and he found solace in that. But at the same time,
- 1:39:25I could understand why somebody would be very emotional and
- 1:39:28jaded and hurt in that moment and hearing that it
- 1:39:31was God's will would actually make them spurn against God.
- 1:39:34In that sense, it really depends on the person and
- 1:39:37depends on the faith, And there's so many different levels
- 1:39:40to that you know, but I understand absolutely say it.
- 1:39:44I hope it wasn't meant as a well, I guess
- 1:39:47that was God's plan, Like, don't be a dick, you
- 1:39:50know what I'm saying, But like if it was given
- 1:39:52in a sense of true love, of like this was sad.
- 1:40:00Of course you're going to mourn the loss of your
- 1:40:01child one hundred percent, but you should take solace in
- 1:40:04knowing that this child will never experience pain again. He'll
- 1:40:08never experience the hardships of this life. Yes, he may
- 1:40:11may never also experience the joys and the amazing things
- 1:40:14life has to offer. But at the same time, he
- 1:40:18is now with his heavenly Father, and we should take
- 1:40:20joy in that. Right. As Christians, we should be looking
- 1:40:23forward to death, not be afraid of it, and say,
- 1:40:26that's what I'm saying. It's a very difficult philosophical conversation
- 1:40:30I have for sure.
- 1:40:32Speaker 3: Art, So may I chime in for a quick second.
- 1:40:36Speaker 7: Yeah, so, as far as the death of a child,
- 1:40:42we do not know the reason.
- 1:40:44Speaker 3: Ultimately, Jacob, you believe.
- 1:40:47Speaker 10: Very similarly to what you do, and that everything that
- 1:40:51happens God wills it or like so, and the different
- 1:40:57the idea of.
- 1:41:00Speaker 3: Free Like what is free will? And that's it. That's
- 1:41:03a huge other topic. But like, there was a story
- 1:41:06that I read once.
- 1:41:08Speaker 8: And and basically to where there was this couple that
- 1:41:12lost a three year old's child, and like the mother
- 1:41:18was like in consolable up until I guess there was
- 1:41:21like a dream where the child came back to her
- 1:41:24or if you visited, except that wasn't a child at
- 1:41:28that point. Basically, what it needed to happen is that
- 1:41:31for some reason, this stage of this person needed to
- 1:41:34be reincarnated for a certain amount of time, and.
- 1:41:38Speaker 11: Once their time was up, then that child died, but
- 1:41:44the soul which was reincarnated was then able to ascend
- 1:41:49to heaven because we don't we don't know the status
- 1:41:53of that soul, especially.
- 1:41:55Speaker 3: Of someone who is so young.
- 1:41:59Speaker 1: Yeah, and that's it. I didn't know the Jews believed
- 1:42:03in reincarnation until you told me that. By the way,
- 1:42:06that blows my mind. But there are examples of prophets
- 1:42:11coming back through people, and I understand why that is
- 1:42:15a talking point for sure. But and again, if that,
- 1:42:18if that is what gave that mother solace in that time,
- 1:42:22then like, hey, who am I to tell her that
- 1:42:24she's incorrect, you know what I mean. I get that
- 1:42:27for sure, But Tony, I hope I answered that question
- 1:42:30without signing like a complete asshole.
- 1:42:32Speaker 5: Yeah you did. I hope they took it the best way.
- 1:42:36I don't really know. They seem to be okay with it,
- 1:42:38and they seem to be saying similar things. But I
- 1:42:41know I would not react well if somebody told me
- 1:42:45that in that situation.
- 1:42:48Speaker 1: I so a little bit of a backstory with me.
- 1:42:52Me and my ex wife miscarried our first time, right,
- 1:42:56which I understand the like, what was there statistics like
- 1:42:59ninety five percent of women miscarry their first go round
- 1:43:02and it's just like unviable and all these things, and
- 1:43:05most just think it's like a late period. They don't
- 1:43:07even realize it was a miscarriage. And all the things
- 1:43:09I read, all the literature and all this stuff. At
- 1:43:12that time, I was already struggling with my faith. I
- 1:43:16was this is what kind of led me to what
- 1:43:19I call my season of doubt, when I turned away
- 1:43:22from Christianity as a whole and started digging into every
- 1:43:27other religion that I could get my hands on. But
- 1:43:30this is what began that for me, and I felt
- 1:43:34like God had taken my child from me and all
- 1:43:37these things, and I was so angry and I cursed
- 1:43:40against God and all of these things. Right, but I
- 1:43:44never stopped to think, hey, bro, maybe you weren't ready
- 1:43:46to be a dad yet, Like, maybe there's a reason
- 1:43:49why it miscarried rather than it was stillborn or whatever
- 1:43:52the case was. And I'm not saying that that is
- 1:43:54the case for other people. This is Jacob speaking on
- 1:43:56behalf of Jacob here. But it also took me years
- 1:44:01to come to peace with the fact that life be
- 1:44:05life in you know, and it's never going to be
- 1:44:08according to our plan. We can make all the preparations
- 1:44:12we want, but in the end, curveballs are going to
- 1:44:14come our way whether we like it or not. Right,
- 1:44:17But the same way that, for instance, in the Bible,
- 1:44:20job blessed God in the highs and in the lows,
- 1:44:24we are supposed to do the same thing. Now, I'm
- 1:44:26not saying that a miscarriage or a still born or
- 1:44:30the losing of a child should be looked at as
- 1:44:33a test for us, right, that's a very narcissistic way
- 1:44:37of looking at it. However, we also need to acknowledge
- 1:44:41that we are being tested every single day, in small
- 1:44:45ways and in large ways, and we should always be
- 1:44:48putting our best foot forward because we are supposed to
- 1:44:51be that way. We're supposed to be, as we were
- 1:44:55just told to be waiting with our lamps ready rather
- 1:44:59than sleeping on the job. Right. We are always supposed
- 1:45:02to be acting as that the Lord's coming back tomorrow
- 1:45:04or right now, and sometimes we fall short of that,
- 1:45:08and that's okay. There's a reason why the Savior came
- 1:45:10and gave his life and all of these things. But
- 1:45:13we also cannot look at the lows and blame others
- 1:45:17or even blame ourselves. Sometimes sometimes it's okay to acknowledge
- 1:45:21that curveballs are going to hit us regardless, and it
- 1:45:24sometimes just our turn to get shit on, you know,
- 1:45:27and something, and that's not fair. It's not fun all
- 1:45:30these things. But that's also not something that we should
- 1:45:33wallow in. We should get through our hard seasons with
- 1:45:36as much spirit of joy as we possibly can muster.
- 1:45:39And that's why I believe that having a sense of
- 1:45:41community is also important. When I went into my season
- 1:45:43of doubt, I did not have any kind of real
- 1:45:46community or network that I could fall on, And now
- 1:45:48I mean a religious community or like being plugged into
- 1:45:50your church like, nothing like that. I was just at
- 1:45:53a really big low point in my life. My marriage
- 1:45:55was failing, my career was failing, had a misk, it
- 1:45:58was a whole whole mess. I was drinking like a fish.
- 1:46:01It was not a good time. So pretty much anything
- 1:46:04that happened to me, I thought it was happening to me, right,
- 1:46:07Oh poor me, whan wan wha. And I'm not trying
- 1:46:10to downplay the experiences. But at the same time, my
- 1:46:14perspective was very limited to my current situation, you know
- 1:46:19what I mean.
- 1:46:19Speaker 3: And it took me a.
- 1:46:20Speaker 1: Long time to step back and look at it from
- 1:46:22a different perspective and gain new insights. So when everybody
- 1:46:28or anybody is going through the tough shit, because all
- 1:46:31of us are going to go through the tough shit,
- 1:46:34whatever that may be, it's gonna be different for everybody,
- 1:46:36and not everybody's going to handle the same situation the
- 1:46:38same way. Some people can handle the worst situations with
- 1:46:42grace and with with you know, all of the amazing
- 1:46:47qualities that make you revere somebody. And then you'll see
- 1:46:50somebody who handles a broken nail like it's the actual
- 1:46:54end of the earth, and they don't mean it to
- 1:46:56be dramatic. They mean it to be real, and there's
- 1:46:58all areas in between. But yeah, regardless of what the
- 1:47:02situation is, I believe that we should still praise God,
- 1:47:05we should bless his name, and we should still try
- 1:47:07to do everything we can to bless those around us
- 1:47:10as a way to be an inspiration and if anything,
- 1:47:12build the testimony to help people when they get the
- 1:47:16shit on their front step. If that makes sense.
- 1:47:20Speaker 5: Yeah, it's just I find it easier to believe God
- 1:47:23is good and benevolent if God does not have a
- 1:47:27plan for tons of people to die for no good
- 1:47:29reason at least that I can understand, or to try
- 1:47:31to say that, oh, well, there must have been a
- 1:47:33good reason for this war or this genocide or this
- 1:47:36baby to die. Oh God must have had a reason
- 1:47:38for it.
- 1:47:39Speaker 3: You know.
- 1:47:39Speaker 5: Maybe maybe God didn't actually want that to happen, but
- 1:47:42it happened because somebody made a mistake of negligence, or
- 1:47:48it was just an accident in some other way. I
- 1:47:51gif a branch falls on somebody. Some people would interpret
- 1:47:54that as God wanted that to happen, or somebody gets
- 1:47:56struck by lightning. I had a neighbor whose brother got
- 1:47:58struck and killed by lightning. But I don't believe that
- 1:48:01it was thor striking emor that God wanted him dead.
- 1:48:04It's just now it happens. Sometimes Lightning strikes a lot
- 1:48:07of places on the earth. Normally doesn't hit anyone, but
- 1:48:09every once in a while it's gonna hit somebody, and
- 1:48:12it's just an accident. And you know, if I believed
- 1:48:17in a God that really wanted people to die and
- 1:48:20wanted all the horrible things in history that have happened
- 1:48:22to have happened precisely that way, I think I would
- 1:48:26be more likely to blame God for the bad things
- 1:48:29in the world. And the fact that I don't believe
- 1:48:32that makes me think, Okay, maybe it's just an accident,
- 1:48:34but God will help people through it, or God will
- 1:48:37help people make the best of it. Maybe there's a
- 1:48:39silver lining, like getting to donate the heart valve. That
- 1:48:42doesn't mean that, you know, God actually wanted the bad
- 1:48:47thing to happen, wanted.
- 1:48:49Speaker 1: It to happen, or it was a part of the
- 1:48:51plan for it to happen. I feel like that's not
- 1:48:53exactly the same thing, but it might equal the same result.
- 1:48:57Speaker 5: I think of it as it's got to be the
- 1:48:59same thing. If it's part of the plan and God
- 1:49:01made the plan, does that mean he wanted it? And
- 1:49:03if people say it's God's will, does that mean he
- 1:49:06wanted it? Will kind of means want. Some people soften
- 1:49:09it just to say, oh, well, God lets bad things happen.
- 1:49:12It's like, okay, well, let's is different from lands it
- 1:49:15or wills it.
- 1:49:17Speaker 1: So let's go further with this. The Garden of Eden.
- 1:49:20God didn't want man to fall from grace, but they did.
- 1:49:25I believe that was a part of the plan. But
- 1:49:27I don't believe God wanted that to happen.
- 1:49:32Speaker 3: True, But God still made the temptation. Sure, for sure,
- 1:49:35I allowed the temptation because there can't be free will
- 1:49:38without it.
- 1:49:39Speaker 1: Exactly exactly Now, he didn't want Eve to eat the
- 1:49:43fruit and Adam and all these things. He didn't want
- 1:49:45them to leave the Garden of Eden. But that's just
- 1:49:49kind of how this works. There has to be a
- 1:49:50harmonic balance. So they made their choices and everything that
- 1:49:55has fallen out after that. Sure, but that wasn't that
- 1:49:58God wanted man to sin, but it was a part
- 1:50:01of the plan in the destiny, if you will for
- 1:50:04that to happen, and that's not fair, But who said
- 1:50:08life was ever going to be fair? God never said that.
- 1:50:12Speaker 5: Well, plan and will, in my opinion, they have to
- 1:50:15be synonymous. And maybe maybe my opinion is wrong, maybe
- 1:50:19I haven't thought it through more than that. But if
- 1:50:22God makes a plan, if God scripts everything and we
- 1:50:25just followed the script, are we really responsible for anything?
- 1:50:28I would think that, you know, if free will is
- 1:50:31just an illusion, But I don't believe that. I'm a
- 1:50:33big believer in free will, not in determinism. And that's
- 1:50:35just me because I don't see him as compatible at all.
- 1:50:38Most people tell me that they are compatible, but I
- 1:50:40just don't see a way. Unless some higher dimensional reality
- 1:50:43is real and we're stuck in these three spatial dimensions
- 1:50:46in one time dimension and we're stuck here and we
- 1:50:49just can't see above that, there would have to be
- 1:50:53some you know, God's ways are higher than ours. In
- 1:50:57order to make that make sense, I can't make it
- 1:50:59make sense.
- 1:51:00Speaker 1: Have I ever told you my example of my children
- 1:51:03with the stove?
- 1:51:05Speaker 5: Maybe maybe not. Let's hear it go.
- 1:51:08Speaker 1: This is about the best example I can find as
- 1:51:11far as free will versus determinism, and how they are
- 1:51:15not the same thing but can work in harmony. And
- 1:51:17then other people will reap or reap the benefits or
- 1:51:21the punishments for something that they had no part of.
- 1:51:24And that's just how things shake out sometimes. So was
- 1:51:27living in my first trailer, me and my ex wife,
- 1:51:30actually my only trailer now I think about it. I
- 1:51:31went straight from the trailer to the house. But long
- 1:51:33story short, my son three years old. I was cooking
- 1:51:36something and he was right next to me, as a
- 1:51:38three year old will be just under your foot, right,
- 1:51:41and I had to turn to do something, and I
- 1:51:44told him, don't touch the stove, right, And he had
- 1:51:47already touched the stove before he knew it was hot.
- 1:51:49He knew he'll get burned. It wasn't like this was
- 1:51:52like the first time ever. He had already done this before.
- 1:51:55So I told him, buddy, don't touch the stove. Oups,
- 1:51:58it's hot, it'll burn you. Right. I turned around. Now
- 1:52:02I knew for a fact he was about to touch
- 1:52:06the stove. But unfortunately, some lessons have to be learned
- 1:52:09the hard way, because you can tell them a million
- 1:52:12times don't do it. The second you turn around, they're
- 1:52:14going to do it. So I already knew it, but
- 1:52:17he was at a point where it was just going
- 1:52:18to do a fingertips, not his whole whatever my point is.
- 1:52:21So I turned to do something and I heard I
- 1:52:24heard it. I already knew it was going to happen.
- 1:52:26Now pause. I told him the rules. I told him
- 1:52:31as left and right, loatteral limits. And I told him
- 1:52:32what would happen if he did it. And he took
- 1:52:35his own free will and did it anyway right, and
- 1:52:38he got the immediate justice for that. I didn't have
- 1:52:41to punish him. He just got burned, And of course
- 1:52:43I'm going to be there to take care of him
- 1:52:44and all the stuff. Now, let me take this a
- 1:52:47step further, and for the record, I believe that is
- 1:52:49a pretty fair depiction of determinism and free will working
- 1:52:53in unison. I knew what was about to happen, it
- 1:52:56was determined, it was set in stone, but he still
- 1:53:00within his free will to do it. Now, let's go
- 1:53:03to the next step. Unbeknownst to my three year old son,
- 1:53:07his one year old baby sister had just walked up
- 1:53:09behind him. When he touched the stove, he jumped back
- 1:53:13and elbowed her in the nose. Now, my one year
- 1:53:16old daughter has a broken nose. Wrong place, wrong time.
- 1:53:20She did nothing to deserve this except for just was there. Now,
- 1:53:24how is that fair? How is this justified? It wasn't
- 1:53:27a part of what I determined on that front. I'm
- 1:53:29not God as an example. Here's a contrived example. To
- 1:53:32bear with me. Now, she is suffering because of the
- 1:53:36actions of someone else's free will, who was doing what
- 1:53:40they weren't supposed to do. Now, how is this justice?
- 1:53:43How is this fair? Sometimes life happens like this, and
- 1:53:46a lot of the time our injustice that we suffer
- 1:53:50is because of someone else misusing their free will. But
- 1:53:54it is all still a part of the plan, whether
- 1:53:57it's a positive or negative. Belie believe that God kind
- 1:54:01of does similar things with us. He's got the plan
- 1:54:04laid out. He knows everything. There's good things that are
- 1:54:07gonna happen, there is bad things that are gonna happen,
- 1:54:10both of them. Yes, if we're gonna really start playing
- 1:54:12the blame game, sure, I guess everything good and bad
- 1:54:15are because of God. But I also don't think that
- 1:54:18it's not for us as humans to assign blame, at
- 1:54:22least not in this kind of context when it comes
- 1:54:24to life and stuff like like, yeah, okay, if somebody
- 1:54:27kills somebody, yeah we could assign blame. Sure, that's an
- 1:54:30easy pointing of the finger. But when it comes to
- 1:54:33the big picture of it, the macro of life itself,
- 1:54:36we are but humans. We hell, half of us can't
- 1:54:40even decide what bathroom to use or if the earth
- 1:54:42is flatter around anymore. Some people believe nukes ain't real.
- 1:54:45So how are we gonna start playing the game of
- 1:54:48blaming one side versus the other for the good and
- 1:54:51the bad in this world? It's kind of not up
- 1:54:54for us to decide. I don't know. Maybe I'm completely
- 1:54:59off base in that assumption, but at least that that's
- 1:55:02what makes it make sense to me.
- 1:55:06Speaker 3: I don't know.
- 1:55:10Speaker 5: The hand raise over here.
- 1:55:11Speaker 1: Yeah, I see that, Stephanie, go ahead. Hey, So.
- 1:55:19Speaker 12: I love this conversation, and I just wanted to add
- 1:55:22a couple of thoughts. Hopefully I can kind of formulate
- 1:55:26my thoughts, because I really don't know if they're quite formulated.
- 1:55:31But I was recently listening to our buddies, the Nephelum
- 1:55:37Desk Squad, and they had this episode called what is
- 1:55:42the Jew? Kind of hilarious, you know title, but it
- 1:55:49was kind of around this concept about obviously the Jew
- 1:55:55world order, and this guy was basically his his philosophy was,
- 1:56:03we're missing the big picture by arguing over you know,
- 1:56:08Israel and who's in control and you know what creepy,
- 1:56:13what creepy things are doing are being done behind you know,
- 1:56:16behind the scenes, we're missing the bigger picture that like
- 1:56:20this is part of God's plan and that God's always
- 1:56:23in control. And so he kind of had this and
- 1:56:28it seemed like a philosophy of just we don't need
- 1:56:33to like, we don't need to worry too much. We
- 1:56:38don't need to stress or fight or try to dismantle
- 1:56:45like the powers that be that God's already got, you know,
- 1:56:50because you know, the God's will will be fulfilled. What
- 1:56:54is written in the Old Testament will come in the
- 1:56:57New Testament, will come to fruition. And so it's kind
- 1:57:01of this same type of debate around you know, God's
- 1:57:05will and uh, you know, destiny and fate and then
- 1:57:10you know absolute chaos and agency and free will. And
- 1:57:14it was just a really really interesting topic because in
- 1:57:19some ways it's like, if you believe in God, if
- 1:57:21you believe in the God of the Old Testament, or
- 1:57:23the or the Tour or the Koran, whoever, the whoever
- 1:57:26you believe in, and you believe in this being that
- 1:57:29has all power, you then have to wrap, uh, you know,
- 1:57:34grapple with this idea of like what Zombie just posted,
- 1:57:40you should put a note about some of the most
- 1:57:42horrific things a person can't experience, and that if these,
- 1:57:48you know, biblical things are God will God's will, then
- 1:57:51then also these individual things are God's will. And a
- 1:57:57question that I heard once on a podcast when I
- 1:58:00was kind of leaving the faith, was this this question
- 1:58:03of if you were God, you know, how would you
- 1:58:08create the world, how would you create a human experience?
- 1:58:13What rules would you implement? And it kind of it
- 1:58:19kind of makes you think, is like, oh, how would
- 1:58:21you create a world? How what rules would you implement?
- 1:58:25You know, how would you protect your children? And I
- 1:58:30don't know if I necessarily had the answer, but I
- 1:58:32do believe that I do believe we're supposed to experience
- 1:58:40some of the most horrific things because they can be
- 1:58:44unfortunately the best teachers, and so I don't know, I
- 1:58:50don't think God's hand is in at all the details
- 1:58:56of our life. I think sometimes he you know, steps
- 1:59:01back and just lets us figure out some shit, if
- 1:59:06that makes sense. I don't think that, you know, God
- 1:59:11takes part in like you know, some some horrific shit
- 1:59:16that that's happening to people.
- 1:59:18Speaker 3: I don't think that's like his will.
- 1:59:21Speaker 12: I think people are making choices and he'll get you
- 1:59:24on the other side when you when you're going through
- 1:59:26that shit, But he's not necessarily like allowing allowing it
- 1:59:32to be. It's kind of like, there has to be chaos,
- 1:59:37there has to be pain, there has to be suffering,
- 1:59:41there has to be grief, because if you don't have pain,
- 1:59:45you don't know what healing feels like if you don't
- 1:59:48have And that's the whole point of the adversary, like
- 1:59:52Satan is always doing God's will, or the adversary is
- 1:59:56always doing God's will, because yeah, you know, essentially Satan
- 2:00:03is the great greatest teacher, because if we didn't have
- 2:00:08that negative shit, that darkness and those horrific things, then
- 2:00:12we wouldn't experience the the opposite of that, you know,
- 2:00:18which is love and light and you know, all the
- 2:00:22positive things So those are a couple of thoughts that
- 2:00:25I have, and I don't know if I've quite formulated
- 2:00:29my thoughts, but there you go.
- 2:00:31Speaker 1: I hear you one hundred percent. And also, I don't
- 2:00:33believe that it's God letting things happen. People are acting
- 2:00:37on their own free will one hundred percent. And yes,
- 2:00:40whether that is a part of determinism and it's not
- 2:00:44a pretty part of it, I agree with you that
- 2:00:46there has to be harmony. And for every absolute evil,
- 2:00:50there is an absolute good, and there's areas of gray
- 2:00:53and levels to that on all sides of it. I
- 2:00:56don't believe that like Raven just put in a horrible,
- 2:01:00horrible thing that took place, and I would say that
- 2:01:02is one hundred percent true evil, right with you, one
- 2:01:05hundred percent. But it's not God letting the true evil exist.
- 2:01:10It's not like it because that was my big thing too.
- 2:01:12If God is all good and all powerful, how could
- 2:01:15he let so much bad things happen on earth. That's
- 2:01:19not exactly a fair context to put it in. It's
- 2:01:21not God letting it happen. It's kim giving humans free
- 2:01:25will and people acting on the free will to do
- 2:01:27horrible things. Now, yes, could he fix it on a
- 2:01:30second with the snap of his fingers? Of course, will
- 2:01:33he know, because that's not how this goes. And unfortunately
- 2:01:38a lot of really good people suffer in the worst
- 2:01:41ways possible because of it. But it's not God's. It's
- 2:01:46not us blaming God for it. We should be blaming
- 2:01:48the true evil and the ones committing these horrible acts.
- 2:01:52So at least that's where I'm at with it.
- 2:01:56Speaker 5: Well, God does. He does let bad things happen, and
- 2:01:59I don't think there's any way to escape that, because
- 2:02:02he could micromanage the universe and just prevent every little
- 2:02:05bad thing from happening, if you want to do like
- 2:02:08you were saying. But he doesn't, so that is, by definition,
- 2:02:11letting it happen. I don't think he scripts all the
- 2:02:15bad things. I don't think that all of history has
- 2:02:18been written and all the future has been written, and
- 2:02:20that it's all going to unfold a certain predetermined way.
- 2:02:24And that's that's why I'm not a determinist. But one
- 2:02:27last thing is that one way determinists will get around
- 2:02:30this is by arguing that everything that happens is actually good.
- 2:02:34So even that horrible crime where you know a girl
- 2:02:38gets raped in her throat slip for example. Oh well,
- 2:02:41somehow everything that happens is good, and I'm just not
- 2:02:44on board with that. But this is just people have
- 2:02:46to People have to find some way to rationalize. There
- 2:02:50are religious dogmas, I think, and I.
- 2:02:54Speaker 1: Find evil though that that's crazy.
- 2:02:58Speaker 5: Well people do and well, I don't know, but people
- 2:03:03grappled with this with lots of horrible events. I think
- 2:03:05the Holocaust is probably the biggest one. It's like, why
- 2:03:08did God let that happen? Well, yeah, you can't argue
- 2:03:11that he didn't let it happen, because he did let
- 2:03:13it happen. It's just the result of people making bad decisions.
- 2:03:19People made it happen. God didn't make it happen, but
- 2:03:21he let it happen.
- 2:03:23Speaker 1: Right, right, And I mean, now that's a whole other
- 2:03:27example as well, right, because if we didn't have the Holocaust,
- 2:03:30and the nation of Israel would have never been founded.
- 2:03:32And I'm not saying I wouldn't exist.
- 2:03:38Speaker 5: Sorry, if I.
- 2:03:39Speaker 3: Said I don't know, I said I don't know if
- 2:03:41I can.
- 2:03:41Speaker 7: Fully believe or I completely agree with that statement that
- 2:03:45if not for the Holocaust, that the state of Vision
- 2:03:46would have happened.
- 2:03:47Speaker 13: Obviously that's the that's the way that it's happened because
- 2:03:51of what happened. But I think that was meant to
- 2:03:55come into fruition regardless. If it wouldn't have been this,
- 2:03:58there would have been another reason.
- 2:04:00Speaker 1: I don't see it happening from a good place though,
- 2:04:03like it was. Again, this is not me trying to
- 2:04:06take like Tony said, I'm not trying to say, well,
- 2:04:09everything that happens has to be a all ill good No,
- 2:04:12that is not what I'm saying. I'm saying that that example,
- 2:04:15like the reason why the entire world basically told the Palestinians,
- 2:04:19hey the Jews live here, now deal with it, was
- 2:04:23because they literally just survived a holocaust, and like whatever
- 2:04:26argument they were about to say was invalid.
- 2:04:31Speaker 3: I don't know.
- 2:04:34Speaker 14: I think the only thing I'm trying to say is
- 2:04:36that it would have happened regardless that that's how we
- 2:04:39know it in our.
- 2:04:39Speaker 3: Reality, because that's what has happened. If not for that,
- 2:04:44it would have happened another way. Because so.
- 2:04:48Speaker 15: I think part of the prophecy is that there was
- 2:04:50going to be Atlanta Israel again, So like it was
- 2:04:53already a part of our prophecy. So regardless of how
- 2:04:55that came into truition, it was going to happen regardless.
- 2:05:00Speaker 3: I think that's all all that I read to say.
- 2:05:02Speaker 14: So if what what, what could have happened had the
- 2:05:06Holocaust happened?
- 2:05:08Speaker 3: Who knows?
- 2:05:09Speaker 1: Yeah, who knows?
- 2:05:10Speaker 3: So that was my that was my only point with it,
- 2:05:14and that's fair.
- 2:05:14Speaker 1: I mean geopolitically, there was conversations about moving the Jews
- 2:05:18to an area in that region of the world before
- 2:05:21the Holocaust happened. So I might be completely talking out
- 2:05:24of my ass on that point. I don't know, But yeah,
- 2:05:27to your point, Tony, no, I don't believe that everything,
- 2:05:31even the pure evil in the world that's happening, has
- 2:05:34to be done in and all out good because it
- 2:05:37was all a part. Like No, I think that's that's
- 2:05:39not even a cop out at that point, that's just
- 2:05:42sticking your head in the sand.
- 2:05:46Speaker 5: Yeah, I really appreciate everyone's opinion on this. This is
- 2:05:52something that's been debated since before Jesus was around.
- 2:05:56Speaker 3: I'm immoral.
- 2:05:56Speaker 7: It's it's a big it's a big paradox a he
- 2:06:00it's a huge paradox, Like the whole idea about free
- 2:06:02will and do we have do we have free will,
- 2:06:05and how and how does it work?
- 2:06:09Speaker 14: The only thing that I have to I guess comment
- 2:06:12on is as we were talking, I was looking up.
- 2:06:15Speaker 7: This whole idea and one of the things that said,
- 2:06:19just a small paradraph, said God is be on time
- 2:06:22for him.
- 2:06:23Speaker 3: All has already occurred. His knowledge of the future is
- 2:06:26similar to our knowledge of the present.
- 2:06:29Speaker 7: That knowledge is not a cause to our deeds, but
- 2:06:32an outcome.
- 2:06:33Speaker 3: So too, God cannot help help be responsible.
- 2:06:36Speaker 9: For our misdeeds simply because he knew them beforehand. But
- 2:06:42it is a it's it is a paradox has been
- 2:06:44going on for thousands of years, and plenty of theologians
- 2:06:48and philosophers have tried.
- 2:06:51Speaker 16: To discuss this whole matter, So it's definitely something to
- 2:06:54think about that at the very least, it could potentially
- 2:06:57bring us closer to our own in faith, because we're.
- 2:07:01Speaker 14: Trying to understand and try to justify what's going on
- 2:07:07to our own capacity, whether that's everything is for the
- 2:07:12good or it happened because God willed it. You know,
- 2:07:19I think that's us putting our own understanding in this situation.
- 2:07:24Speaker 1: Yeah, it's kind of us trying to put God and
- 2:07:27his plan or his will or any of this into
- 2:07:30a box. And I don't think this is something that
- 2:07:32can fit into a box that humans can put it into.
- 2:07:35But this is in fact the place you have these conversations,
- 2:07:39and I agree. I appreciate everybody for chiming in on this.
- 2:07:42Although as I'm looking as I'm looking at who all
- 2:07:46is in attendance tonight, So a trans a Jew, a Catholic,
- 2:07:53a Pagan, and a Mountain Jew, I mean former Mormon
- 2:07:55walk into a bar and this is what the conversation
- 2:07:58leads to. I absolutely love that this is the group
- 2:08:01that we have come to with the Cajun Night Live. Y'all.
- 2:08:04Y'all have no idea. I was hoping that eventually the
- 2:08:07conversations would go more philosophical, and yeah, we do talk geopolitics,
- 2:08:11and yes we talk environmental and all these things, but
- 2:08:14these are like really amazing conversations and I mean, this
- 2:08:18is great content. So I appreciate everybody for chiming in
- 2:08:22on this one. So for anybody who would like to
- 2:08:25join in on the Cajun Night Live next week, again,
- 2:08:28please come check out Cajun Night on Patreon. Link is
- 2:08:31in the description below. And again, y'all, I appreciate everybody
- 2:08:36for jumping in on this one, and I hope to
- 2:08:38see more people in these conversations in the future. And
- 2:08:41if we do want to dive further into this conversation
- 2:08:44next week, please do, please do. I want to have
- 2:08:47it all the way through all of the depths and
- 2:08:49all of the ugly bits like this is amazing and
- 2:08:52I think that, if anything, this might be how true
- 2:08:56growth can happen. Having uncomfortable conversations in US, combining forces
- 2:09:01and sharing ideas. This is how true philosophy goes down.
- 2:09:04So again, thank you everybody for coming out and to
- 2:09:07everybody listening. As always, God bless