Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / "Aliens Built the Pyramids" is Rooted in Racism (with archaeologist Dr. Andrew White)
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. My guest today,
- 0:57Doctor Andrew White is a research archaeologist for the Illinois State Archaeological Survey.
- 1:04He is an educator, and he also shines the white hot light of scrutiny
- 1:11on pseudo archaeology. Doctor White, it's good to have you man. Thanks
- 1:15for the opportunity. All right, let's do definitions pseudo archaeology. What do
- 1:22you mean, so archaeology is the study of the human past through material remains.
- 1:26Pseudo Archaeology wants to appear to be addressing those same kinds of questions,
- 1:30but they don't actually use any method that I would say is science. But
- 1:34they like to appear as if they're science. So it's not just bad science,
- 1:38it is fake science. And that's where the pseudo comes in. It's
- 1:42not just somebody being lazy or connecting the dots and a wrong way. Are
- 1:46they just purposeful? Like with agency, they are distorting the past? You
- 1:51know, I think there are a variety of motivations. It's not always intentional.
- 1:55That is definitely part of it. You get people in the pseudo archaeology
- 1:59business, and oftentimes it is a business that I would say are grifters and
- 2:02their cons and they know what they're saying is wrong. But you also get
- 2:06a lot of people who are genuinely curious, who like the fantasy aspect of
- 2:09it, who want to live in and believe in a world that is maybe
- 2:14different or more exciting than the world that they see in front of them.
- 2:16So they're kind of vulnerable to those kind of ideas and claims, and that
- 2:22helps kind of feed this wheel that keeps going around and around, And a
- 2:25lot of these ideas have been around for a very long time, for hundreds
- 2:28of years since the oh come on, Doctor White, when we all we
- 2:31know that aliens built the pyramids. There's no way human beings could have done
- 2:35this. It had to have been extra terrestrials that they landed. And I've
- 2:38seen stargate, you know what I'm saying. I like, I know I'm
- 2:42going to come back to the Pyramids in a second, and ancient aliens for
- 2:46sure, But I want to talk about this. I guess it was a
- 2:49quiz you gave to a live audience at the University of Southern Indiana made me
- 2:53feel really smart because you had a list of questions that you asked the audience
- 2:57that Aristotle had in his life. If I gave you a quiz, which
- 3:02I'm going to do with a few questions on it, we'll see how smart
- 3:06you are and how smarked Aristolois. The organ is at the center of the
- 3:07universe. True false false. You're correct. The organ used for thinking is
- 3:12the heart or the brain. Some animals spontaneously generate from the mund That's false.
- 3:19All things are composed of air, water, earth, and more fire.
- 3:22False. The lung served to cool a body. You're a little bit
- 3:24unsure about that one, but you know that it's false. Aristolo would have
- 3:29answered every single one of those wrong. It doesn't mean that you are smarter
- 3:31than him. That means that you benefit from the five hundred years of inquiry
- 3:36in the natural world that has been done during the modern era. We know
- 3:39a lot about the world, and it's because of science. It's not because
- 3:43of yesing well. So I used to use that example with my students.
- 3:47We where we are sitting today benefit from hundreds of years in the modern period
- 3:53of scientific inquiry of people using trial and error and theory and induction and deduction
- 3:59to try to figure out how the natural world works. So you and I
- 4:01know things that would have been complete mysteries to the ancient Greeks. And so
- 4:06I like to give this quiz where I basically demonstrate to people that they know
- 4:11more about the natural world than Aristotle. They are almost certainly well. I
- 4:15can't say for sure, but most people in the audience are probably not smarter
- 4:17than Aristotle. But they benefit from this cumulative production of knowledge that science gives
- 4:23us. That's actual science. So I think it helps people to understand that
- 4:28getting things wrong and having an idea and testing it are kind of central to
- 4:32the scientific method, and in a lot of ways, we live our lives
- 4:35like that every day, through trial and error and through building up a cumulative
- 4:39knowledge of the way things work. Now, the downside of that is,
- 4:44with this plethora of knowledge, the wealth of information and the information era,
- 4:48it's also the misinformation the disinformation era. It's chaos out there. It's the
- 4:54wild West, right it is. I think the Internet has a lot to
- 4:57do with that. There's a really interesting per and history in the eighteen hundreds
- 5:00as a lot of new science and technology was coming online, where there was
- 5:03a great and growing interest in the occult and magic. You know, as
- 5:08we were learning about electricity and magnetism, getting better telescopes and able to kind
- 5:13of look outside of the earth more and look inside the earth with geology and
- 5:15things like that, and trying to understand deep time. So a lot of
- 5:19these observations were incorporated into kind of magical or supernatural explanations of the world,
- 5:25and you get all these secret societies and things like that. But as technology
- 5:29progresses, what we need to attribute to magic and the supernatural keeps getting winnowed
- 5:33away, right, So more and more we can explain things in a way
- 5:38that we can understand through observation, through science and physically touch and hold and
- 5:44observe. But now with the Internet, I feel like there's kind of a
- 5:46new dimension of the spread of information, and there are there's no good set
- 5:51of filters. So it really has brought new life into a lot of these
- 5:56ideas. Things that we have known for a very long time are wrong about
- 6:00the world we live in today and about the way the past played out,
- 6:03But it doesn't seem to matter. There's no way to stop this flow of
- 6:08nonsense other than I think to teach people how to think critically and evaluate things
- 6:13and scrutinize on their own. And so that's one of the things that I
- 6:15like to try to teach my students. I think it's a skill that is
- 6:18sorely, sorely lacking in our country today. And if you look at the
- 6:23results of the last election and what is continuing to happen. Yeah, I
- 6:28don't think you really need to look any farther than that. Now, I
- 6:30wondered if perhaps we deserve to killer asteroid, But that's a whole other conversation.
- 6:35So I mentioned the pyramids. Give me examples if you would. I
- 6:41mean, I hate to put you on the spot, but this is your
- 6:43wheelhouse. Give me some examples, specific examples of conspiracies or pseudohistory, pseudoscience,
- 6:49pseudo archaeology that you have had to address recently. Well, I mean,
- 6:54we can start with the pyramids. Everybody's heard of the pyramids, already
- 6:57knows about the pyramids. You if you google all the pyramids, the Egyptian
- 7:01pyramids, you will find some good information, and you also find hundreds and
- 7:04hundreds of repetitions of the same kind of set of wrong facts or conclusions.
- 7:11But how they could not possibly have been built, that we have no evidence
- 7:14of how the ancient Egyptians built them, That they encode secrets about the Earth
- 7:17and their dimensions and their proportions, that they are aligned to the cardinal directions
- 7:23with the precision that would be impossible for us to duplicate today. That we
- 7:26could not move the rocks that it took to build the Great Pyramid, and
- 7:29all of these things are nonsense. If you scratch the surface, you can
- 7:30pretty quickly figure that out. It's not to take away from the pyramids.
- 7:35They are fantastic, interesting constructions, and there's a reason why they're the you
- 7:41know, one of the wonders of the world that still exist. But it
- 7:44doesn't mean that the ancient Egyptians couldn't build them, and in fact, we
- 7:46have a lot of evidence of how they did just that. But there's this
- 7:50kind of drive to point to them and say those structures should not exist.
- 7:55We can't possibly explain it any other way. And now people wi laughingly say,
- 8:00oh, the pyramids were built by aliens. We all know that before
- 8:03the ancient aliens was a thing, which really was a post World War two
- 8:07phenomenon where we started seeing UFOs and then all of a sudden, the ancient
- 8:09past is filled with aliens. Earlier than that, it was, well,
- 8:13it had to be white people because there's no way that dark skinned people could
- 8:16have built these constructions, because white people are the only ones capable of civilization.
- 8:20And so that's the kind of if you follow the history back in the
- 8:24intellectual ancestry of these ideas, like that's where you're led time and time again
- 8:28that a lot of these ideas came about as justifications for colonialism, slavery,
- 8:33imperialism, and a lot of pretty ugly stuff. So you're saying that there
- 8:37is a sinister element attached. It's not just bubble gum. Oh, come
- 8:43on, we all know it's you know, even if it people think it's
- 8:46aliens, it's harmless. You're saying that there are actually some layers under the
- 8:52top that need to be addressed. Yeah, And you know, I wouldn't
- 8:56say that everybody that believes the ancient astronaut theory is automatically a racist, Like
- 8:58that's not what I'm saying. But there's if you make a diagram of people
- 9:03who believe in atlantis and ancient aliens and everything else, and then you have
- 9:07another overlapping circle that is white supremacist. The white supremacists almost all know and
- 9:13believe that stuff. Hitler and Himmler. They loved atlantis and ancient arians and
- 9:18things like that. It was central to their philosophy. If I were going
- 9:22to embrace an idea there was an explanation for the human past, like,
- 9:24I would want to vet that somewhat and know where those ideas are coming from.
- 9:28And I would want to know who my bedfellows were. So not only
- 9:31can we show factually that these things are wrong, but you can look at
- 9:33where these ideas come from. And if you are operating outside of the scientific
- 9:37framework, there's no way to test those ideas, and so it actually does
- 9:41matter where they come from, and the stuff about Atlantis really kicks off in
- 9:46the late eighteen hundreds, and it's racist to its core. And I'm not
- 9:50talking about you know, the Disney Atlantis with the Little Mermaid and stuff like
- 9:52that, Like I'm talking about this idea that there was a sunken continent that
- 9:56was the mother civilization for all other civilizations around the world, and that that
- 10:00continent had to have been populated by arians because they are the ones who are
- 10:03capable of civilization and that would trickle down to the rest of the world.
- 10:05So they were responsible for the civilizations in Central America, you know, rather
- 10:09than the Maya or the Aztec the responsible for the Inca civilization, rather than
- 10:13the Incoans the responsible for Ancients, sumer They're responsible for Egypt, and the
- 10:16responsible for stuff in Europe in any place else where people were able to stack
- 10:20stones, that had to be white folks. That's the idea, and that
- 10:24idea gained popularity along with this continued need to disenfranchise people that were being subjugated
- 10:31by colonial powers. To make sure that I'm tracking two things. First,
- 10:35you are not saying everybody who has held to this conspiracy theory is in league
- 10:39with Hitler. Yeah, I'm saying that I can't say that Vandgie. There's
- 10:43some overlap is to what they believe, but you're not making that blanket statement.
- 10:48But what I'm hearing is the Egyptians could not have built the Pyramids because
- 10:54only white people were advanced enough intellectually to have had the tech technology to do
- 11:01it. Therefore, Aliens was that the claim. Yeah, so you're missing
- 11:05a few dots in there, but that's basically it. If you go agead
- 11:07will fill the dots for me. Go ahead. Okay, So people have
- 11:11known about the Pyramids for a long time, like they've always been exposed.
- 11:15So Europeans knew about them. But Egyptology really starts when Napoleon invades France around
- 11:18eighteen hundred. People start studying Egypt. They find depictions of all kinds of
- 11:24different races and ethnicities in ancient Egypt, people with light skin, with dark
- 11:28skin, with very dark skin. The racists in the world cannot justify white
- 11:33supremacy and have a civilization that is as grand as ancient Egypt was not have
- 11:37been built by white people. So they look at those pictures and they say,
- 11:41obviously these are the builders and the rest of these people are the slaves
- 11:46or whatever. It's always seen through kind of a lens of in your hierarchy
- 11:50of societies, you have to put the ones built by white Europeans on top.
- 11:54And this is part of the whole colonial enterprise that was ongoing in the
- 11:58from the fifteen hundreds to the nineteen hundreds. Say that idea gets expanded as
- 12:03people discover other ancient civilizations around the world, like those in India, ancient
- 12:07India, in the Indus Valley, and in Central America, South America,
- 12:11and even in North America. So eventually there needs to be an explanation in
- 12:16their view for how white people are responsible for all the rest of those also,
- 12:20and that's where Atlantis comes in as a geographical area where there would have
- 12:24been a white civilization and it's now submerged, which is very convenient because we
- 12:28can't go do any poking around and looking there because it's beneath the Atlantic Ocean.
- 12:31And it's that same package of ideas. All you have to do is
- 12:35replace Atlantis and ancient arians with aliens, and you've got the ancient astronaut theory.
- 12:39It's all the same. You know, the local people could not have
- 12:43built this. There's all of these things that don't fit. There's white gods
- 12:48and you know, stuff that can only be seen from the air, So
- 12:50there's a layer added on to it. But it's essentially Atlantis is responsible for
- 12:54civilization throughout the world trope, just with a tie to outer space. That's
- 13:01it in a nutshell, doctor. Why do you sit down and watch the
- 13:05History Channel then making notes? You know, when I first started doing this
- 13:09about ten years ago, actively I watched one of those programs. But it
- 13:16tends to be the same thing over and over again. And I've got two
- 13:20kids and a real job. There is nothing new under this. Well,
- 13:24they do a lot of the then you know Hitler and the Occult shows.
- 13:28We talk a lot about you know, Hitler and his weaponization of religion,
- 13:33whether it's Christianity slash Catholicism, et cetera. But he did have some ties
- 13:37to the occult. Can you flesh that out? Yeah, I've actually got
- 13:45it. I know it's a broad question. No, you don't have to
- 13:50answer it, but I can give it a shot. So, Okay,
- 13:54once you get and you've talked about enough of this stuff that you know,
- 13:58once you get into the occult and see societies, it is a maze of
- 14:03rabbit holes. Oh god, yeah, go down, It's awful. So,
- 14:07like, I've got a book that'll probably arrive today on the Occult and
- 14:09the Nazis, and I've been reading up on Rill and Blavatsky and theosophy and
- 14:16what that has to do with the Nazis. So yeah, like I read
- 14:20and I take notes, but I cannot connect all of those dobts. For
- 14:24you. One of the things about secret societies is they're supposed to be secret,
- 14:26so I think it's sometimes it's hard to tell fact from fiction. And
- 14:31interesting thing about the Nazi connection to me is that, like if you look
- 14:33at ancient aliens they swallow, hook line and sinker. Not only that Hitler
- 14:39and the Nazis were interested in the occult, but that they actually had these
- 14:43supernatural powers from the aliens. So it's kind of like they're buying into the
- 14:48the propaganda a little bit in a way that I think is kind of shocking
- 14:54and horrifying. You know, I think it's one thing to study it as
- 14:56a subject, but if you are studying it as a sub because you think
- 15:00it's real and there's something too the ancient aryan master race, you know,
- 15:05then it becomes a lot more problematic. So I'm interested in it from a
- 15:09like an objective, you know, historical, like trying to understand the context
- 15:13of these ideas. But I think a lot of the believers in Ancient Aliens
- 15:16will go several steps beyond that, like thinking that maybe they actually did discover
- 15:22these you know, supernatural sources of power and maybe they came from outer space
- 15:26or to me, I'm hearing that. The idea then is it's kind of
- 15:31like Indiana Jones Hitler is really, according to shows like Ancient Aliens was really
- 15:37on a quest for the Arctic Covenant and the Holy Grail and all those types
- 15:41of things. They're selling this as, if not science fact, as a
- 15:48distinct possibility. Yeah, and I mean you you will see that, and
- 15:52that may be the most accurate part of the Indiana Jones movies. Hitler was
- 15:58into that stuff. He was looking for relics, they were looking for sources
- 16:02of power. But again, I'm not an expert on all of the ins
- 16:06and outs, so it's harder for me to authoritatively separate fact from fiction and
- 16:11what these secret societies really were and what they really believed. But those are
- 16:15the notions that are out there that they were so into this stuff and this
- 16:18occult stuff because of the way it tied into ancient Arians and the Master Race
- 16:23and where those qualities of the Master Race came from and how they could reproduce
- 16:27it, and trying to kind of synthesize, which is what a lot of
- 16:30the occult and theosophy does, like synthesize like a religion or a philosophy from
- 16:34all of the different kinds of spirituality and mysticism. You know, you take
- 16:40stuff from Hindus and Hinduism and Tibet and you know, ancient esoteric symbols on
- 16:48the pyramids, and you can tie all this together and as long as you
- 16:51can point towards that being related to why Arians are awesome and they should take
- 16:55over the world again, you know, you just embrace it. There's not
- 16:57kind of this. There's not mechanism for saying, well, you know,
- 17:00maybe maybe the Bible isn't true, you know, maybe maybe there is no
- 17:03ark of the Covenant like that wasn't I don't think that was the mindset it
- 17:07was. It was very much a pseudoscientific world that they were operating in.
- 17:12More conspiracy theories on the way plus I want to talk about the Ancient Aliens
- 17:18guy. You've seen the meme and the dude with the hair. Who the
- 17:23hell is a We're going to find out next talking here with research archaeologist and
- 17:38professor doctor Andrew White. It's a classic conundrum, isn't it. Where conspiracy
- 17:47theories are easy to brush off, but the fact that history has had more
- 17:52than its share of actual conspiracies primes us maybe to lean more into even absurd
- 18:00claims. Well, they will, conspiracies have happened throughout human history. Why
- 18:03would this be impossible? And I think that it's almost like the fog of
- 18:07war. You're trying to find your way around to see it, to separate
- 18:11the wheat from the chaff. If I may draw from the Bible. Can
- 18:15you tell me about the ancient Aliens guy? Oh? I don't know much
- 18:18about him either. I mean, he's an entertainer. His name is Giorgio
- 18:22Sucolos. The wild hair is probably intentional because he's a TV star. He
- 18:27is kind of the second wave. Eric von Dannakin in the nineteen sixties was
- 18:33the one that really popularized Asian alien's theory. He wrote the book Chariots of
- 18:36the gods and that's you know, that was a phenomenon. They got an
- 18:40Academy Award nomination for Best Documentary for that movie, which is ridiculous looking back
- 18:45on it, but that's that happened, and it was a big deal.
- 18:48And he connected all the dots worldwide with ancient civilizations and mythology, archaeology,
- 18:55the occult and UFO stuff. He did a good job doing it because he
- 18:59sold a lot of copies. He made himself famous, and he has kind
- 19:02of passed that mantle on now Ancient Aliens. The TV show has been on
- 19:07for over ten years. I don't remember the number off the top of my
- 19:10head, but Sucolos, the guy with the hair, is kind of the
- 19:14it seems to be the apparent figurehead, kind of the air apparent to Von
- 19:18Danikin. And he's good at what he does of getting on TV and talking
- 19:22and seeming convincing. Whether he actually believes any of that stuff, I have
- 19:25no idea, no idea. At the very least, he's good at branding
- 19:27because we're all talking about him. You say, and correct me if I
- 19:33got it wrong. Throughout history, most of if not all, of the
- 19:37world's worst atrocities have been imbued with these types of conspiracy theories, aliens,
- 19:44the occult, etc. Did I hear that right? I would say that
- 19:47pseudoscience and human atrocities walk hand in hand, and we have multiple examples of
- 19:52that. So I wouldn't say that everything that goes wrong in the world has
- 19:55related, you know, to these particular examples. But like if you look
- 19:59at the justifications for slavery, a lot of those came from incorrect answers to
- 20:03how do we explain human variability? What does human variability mean? Why do
- 20:07some people have dark skin and different hair than others? And what kind of
- 20:11significance do we attach to that? And if you take a pseudoscientific approach to
- 20:15it, you can come up with any answer that you want to. And
- 20:18the answer that they came up with was that these are lesser people, these
- 20:21are subhumans. There were multiple creations. God did not just create you know,
- 20:23Adam, and even were all related, like there was something else that
- 20:26happened, and that's polygenism, and that was absolutely fundamental, fundamental to the
- 20:32justification of slavery, at least in North America, which is the example that
- 20:34I know because that's where I'm from. If you look at things like the
- 20:37Holocaust and the Nazis. In general, pseudoscience is everywhere, everywhere in that
- 20:45and all it's all about, you know, constructing a narrative of the human
- 20:49past that articulates with, resonates with, and justifies your agenda, whatever that
- 20:56is. And it worked for slavery, it worked for the Holocaust, for
- 21:00the removal of Native Americans, the Native American genocide that went on in this
- 21:03country in the early eighteen hundreds, where most Native American peoples from eastern North
- 21:07America were dispossessed and forcibly moved westward to make room for the growing United States.
- 21:14That had to do with the pre contact Native American societies, which is
- 21:18what I study and have been for thirty years, created an incredible landscape filled
- 21:23with sophisticated architecture, earth and architecture all over eastern North America. They're earthen
- 21:29mounds. So as European settlers moved in and cleared forests and farmed and started
- 21:36finding these mounds, it became a problem because if you have very sophisticated structures,
- 21:41those are signs of civilization. So who were the people that built these
- 21:44mounds where they couldn't have possibly have been the Native Americans, because if they
- 21:47were, then that would make them a civilized people, and we have no
- 21:48business pushing them out. So this thing called the mound builder myth emerged where
- 21:53there was a separate, earlier civilization that was before the Native Americans that built
- 21:57all these mounds, and therefore the name of Americans have no more claim to
- 22:00this land than the white Europeans do, and it's okay for us just to
- 22:03push them out because they are unrelated to the civilization that was there before.
- 22:10Total pseudoscience. We know, and we knew at the time from archaeologists,
- 22:14very early archaeology digging into those mounds, that they were the products of Native
- 22:17American cultures. But it didn't matter. And in fact, if you go
- 22:21look at the speeches of Andrew Jackson, who's the president who's most famous for
- 22:23pushing Native Americans out of the eastern part of the country, he he cites
- 22:26the you know, the relics of this long forgotten race, the mounds.
- 22:30And it has to do with I don't know if you've heard claims about giant
- 22:33skeletons being found in mounds. It's all data points or i'd say, fake
- 22:37data points that people used to separate Native Americans from their history so that they
- 22:41are a savage people and not a civilized people. And I'm using the Victorian
- 22:45era terms for that. I wouldn't actually use those terms in order to dispossess
- 22:49them and push them out. And that was a one of the two great,
- 22:52you know, original sins of this country, that and slavery, and
- 22:56both of those had to do with an intentionally incorrect or blind interpretation of the
- 23:02human past that did not articulate at all with facts and evidence or any kind
- 23:06of genuine desire to understand. And that's a problem. So to make sure
- 23:11I'm understanding, are you saying that the History Channels broadcasts of shows like Ancient
- 23:18Aliens isn't just bubblegum entertainment. Even if they're sincere and they sincerely got it
- 23:26wrong, this becomes a moral affront because they are essentially selling stuff that's laced
- 23:32with atrocity, division, bigotry, racism, etc. I would say,
- 23:37at the very least, it's irresponsible. It's entertainment, so it's for the
- 23:42money, and I get that, but let me come out it this way.
- 23:48When I was first started being a professional archaeologist. I've always been interested
- 23:52in these kinds of ideas and claim since I was a kid. I grew
- 23:53up on In Search of and you know, other programs like that. I
- 23:57was into the unexplained mysteries. So I get it. As I became more
- 24:03and more aware of the actual human past and how we know about it and
- 24:07using scientific methods and things like that, my mentors who are older would tell
- 24:11me, don't talk about that stuff, don't engage with it. You're wasting
- 24:15your time. You're making it worse by giving them oxygen. If you look
- 24:19at polling, like actual polling data by Chapman University, there's something like I
- 24:25want to say, it's half of the country believes in Atlantis now and maybe
- 24:30a third believes in visits by ancient aliens, and they ask all kinds of
- 24:33questions, you know, down into bigfoot and lizard people and other stuff.
- 24:37But I think those numbers are assigned that our strategy of not engaging with these
- 24:41ideas has not worked. And the fact that these ideas have these submerged white
- 24:48supremacists us versus them themes that have been running through them for hundreds of years
- 24:52means they are not harmless, and it doesn't take very much scratching to find
- 24:57out that, even if every body who believes in Atlantis is not a white
- 25:00supremacist, that most white supremacists believe in Atlantis, and a lot of people
- 25:03who are putting out the books and who are active online. You know,
- 25:07there's one guy who's got the Nazi Eagle as his publishing house logo on his
- 25:12books, and it's all about arians and UFOs and Atlantis and stuff like that.
- 25:18And so when you have shows on mainstream television that are feeding that narrative
- 25:22and legitimizing it and making it glamorous and kind of bringing it into the culture
- 25:27in a way that is socially acceptable, that is troubling to me. And
- 25:30it doesn't matter whether the talking heads on Ancient Aliens even know or understand where
- 25:36these ideas come from, but they are feeding it and pandering in a lot
- 25:41of ways to this base that does understand the implications. And so yeah,
- 25:47I think it's irresponsible, and if I were them, I would be ashamed
- 25:49of myself. Honestly. I grew up listening to a late nine AM radio
- 25:56show with a guy named Art Bell. If you heard the name Art,
- 26:00but who had all kinds of it was always alien and I never escaped the
- 26:03idea that he was just he was just full of it, like he may
- 26:08have believed, but I really felt like was he just knew his stick and
- 26:12he knew how to get ratings. And we're still talking about him long after
- 26:15his death. But he was always UFOs and the Aliens built the pyramids and
- 26:22secret chambers of the Illuminati type stuff, and you know, and he was
- 26:27popular. We tend to be primed for conspiracies. We love a good story,
- 26:33and the idea that the Egyptians hauled a bunch of rocks and stacked them
- 26:37is not nearly as sexy as extra terrestrials visited us and put it all together
- 26:44and maybe left us some technology. That's another one, right, The reason
- 26:48we have some of the technologies we have now is that the Aliens sort of
- 26:52gave us the starter pack. Did I read that right? Yeah? I
- 26:57mean again, the show's been on the air for over ten years now,
- 27:00so they I mean, I'm not saying it was just the show saying,
- 27:03but there are beliefs out there that the reason that we were able to develop
- 27:07things like Wi Fi and satellite technology is because at some point the elements were
- 27:14given to is at least in basic form to build on. So I don't
- 27:18know if you'd heard those or not. Yeah, and again that is an
- 27:19adaptation of a very old idea. So, you know, cultures share information
- 27:25between them, ideas, technologies. That's called diffusion, right. An idea
- 27:30can go from one culture to another by any number of means. If you
- 27:34put the white supremacist spin on it, and this is historical, they would
- 27:40call it hyper diffusionism. And then the assumption is that technologies and ideas always
- 27:45flow in one direction, from the superior to the inferior. So they come
- 27:48from civilized people down to the savages, or they come from the aliens down
- 27:52to us. So there's this kind of directional arrow and that becomes like part
- 27:56and parcel. And you see arguments about, you know, people saying that
- 28:00our societies in the Holocene ten thousand years ago couldn't even have come up with
- 28:03the idea of agriculture without some super civilized ice age society or aliens or whatever
- 28:10teaching us about the idea of how to plant things. And it's anybody who
- 28:12does any kind of anthropological research or anything like knows it's that's total garbage.
- 28:18But that's kind of what's out there that So you look at like new technologies
- 28:22and like, where did that come from? I don't understand it myself.
- 28:23It must have come from something else. But one of the great things about
- 28:27having this longitudinal perspective that we have is we can actually trace all these things
- 28:33out. You know, a guy figured out in the eighteen thirties that electricity
- 28:37and magnetism were connected together, that if you moved a magnet through a coil
- 28:41of wires, you would produce a current. Michael Faraday figured that out in
- 28:44like eighteen twenty five. At the time, it was magic. You couldn't
- 28:48see the magnetic field, you couldn't see the electric field. Nobody understood how
- 28:51these things worked. And then you know, from there we can come up
- 28:52with things like telegraph and telephones. We can send current through wires. All
- 28:56this stuff was impossible. Does anybody now say that that was you know,
- 29:00the aliens that taught us how to do that, because we can look at
- 29:03all the steps and see where it came from, the same thing goes with
- 29:06agriculture, like we can see for thousands of years people domesticating plants slowly.
- 29:11We can study it, we can look at it, we know, but
- 29:15yeah, it's sexier to go like, you know, the five G that's
- 29:17got to be aliens, right, it's got to be. And the contrails
- 29:21coming out of the jet engines, you know those are chemicals and they're controlling
- 29:25the weather. I mean, sure, that's better. I guess. I
- 29:26don't know. I don't know. I've been people I was dunning. I
- 29:30was saying, people talk about intelligent life out there, and I'm a little
- 29:34nervous about intelligent life down here. And I've had my share of bad ideas
- 29:38I think we all have, right, And this idea that smart people can't
- 29:41be fooled, that's totally bogus. I'm sure you've bumped into a lot of
- 29:45very very intelligent people who had that series of boxes in their brain. Maybe
- 29:51they'd compartmentalize some horrible ideas. You would agree with that, right, I
- 29:55mean, there's some brilliant people who can believe stupid stuff. Sure, And
- 29:59I think that our archeology is particularly vulnerable to that, because it's hard for
- 30:03us to explain how we know what we know because I wasn't there, you
- 30:07weren't there. So does that mean that your idea about aliens and not you,
- 30:11but a person's idea about aliens building the pyramids is you know, just
- 30:14as valid as the egyptologist who studied it for twenty years and has all kinds
- 30:18of evidence because nobody was there, so we're not really sure which one is
- 30:21correct. So it's hard. So yeah, I run into doctors and dentists
- 30:25and lawyers who you know, I tell them I'm an archaeologist, like they
- 30:29want to talk about aliens building the pyramids. My dad was an engineer for
- 30:33thirty years. He had a rock that he found that he swore was a
- 30:37tool because it fit nicely in your hand. And you would not if I
- 30:40had a dollar for every time somebody told me about a rock that fit nicely
- 30:42in their hand, and he would not believe me. Even after I'd gotten
- 30:45my PhD in archaeology, he would not believe me that that was That was
- 30:48nothing. It's not a tool. So the way we have to learn about
- 30:52the past. You know, humans are really really tough to study in the
- 30:56present. Try studying them in the past. And it's not like we're studying
- 30:59a crime. I've seen a series of events that occurred half an hour ago
- 31:02or three hours ago, we're talking about stuff that is a really impoverished record
- 31:07of human behavior from thousands and thousands of years ago. Say like, it's
- 31:11really hard to get at that human behavior, which is what we want to
- 31:12study. So not only is it hard to do it, it's hard to
- 31:15explain to people how we know what we know, and why we're more confident
- 31:19in some explanations than others, and how we separate. I'll use your analogy
- 31:22the week from the chaff, and that's a lot of fertile ground for well,
- 31:26then anybody can just propose any idea about the past and they're all fine.
- 31:30Like it would be insane if I went to a biologist and I said,
- 31:34well, you know, I know you've studied this for a long time
- 31:37and you have all kinds of data, but I'm going to tell you about
- 31:38a much better taxonomy for horses than you because I had an idea about this
- 31:42and you weren't there. You didn't see those horses evolve. You know,
- 31:45if I went to an astronomer and I gave them my theory of how the
- 31:48universe should be as an outsider, I don't have any of that expertise It's
- 31:55a very weak argument though, to tell somebody that you should believe what I'm
- 31:57saying because I've been to school and I've studied this a lot. So we
- 32:01need to be able to explain how we know what we know. And that's
- 32:05a tough job for archaeologists, and it's an especially tough job when you have
- 32:07your mentors and a lot of people around you saying, don't waste your time
- 32:10on that. But if we don't waste our time on that, then we
- 32:13get fifty percent of the population believing in Atlantis and guess what, they can
- 32:15elect any president they want. So rather than just write it off and say
- 32:20it's a waste of time, you would engage. If there's bunkers out there,
- 32:23you would engage. Yeah, And you can't do it in a serial
- 32:25fashion. I can't go out and convince every person that I meet and you
- 32:29know, and have a one on one argument. So my strategy has been
- 32:32to create resources online so that they are findable if people are actually curious or
- 32:37they want a different perspective on something having to do with the Pyramids or you
- 32:43name it. Giants. I used to write a lot of stuff about claims
- 32:45about ancient giants, which are another thing that ties into the Bible. There
- 32:51has to be something for them to find. I cannot individually convince people one
- 32:54by one on Facebook. Those arguments are often take a lot of energy,
- 33:00and you don't convince anybody anything. But if somebody is really curious and they
- 33:02can go and they can find a YouTube video or a blog post or something,
- 33:06go, oh, you know what, that makes a whole lot more
- 33:07sense to me now. So we need to have voices out there or resources
- 33:13out there that will provide an alternative to the pseudoscience stuff which is pervasive.
- 33:17It's everywhere cable TV, it's online and social media in so many different forms.
- 33:23So I encourage all archaeologists who kind of see that point to get off
- 33:29the bench a little bit and do something. You know, it's not my
- 33:32job. I don't get paid to do this stuff anymore like I did when
- 33:36I was teaching it. So I do it on the weekends in the evenings
- 33:38when I have time. But I think that's what you can do, you
- 33:42know, if you are serious about getting the human passed right and communicating with
- 33:45the public and trying to help people understand what archaeology actually is and how we
- 33:50know what we know, then we need those voices out there. After the
- 33:54break, I want to get some resources for how you and I can vet
- 33:59claims as and perhaps better engage in our discussions with the aliens built the Pyramids.
- 34:07Crowd will continue after this another few minutes with my guest doctor Andrew White,
- 34:19who is an archaeologist debunking pseudo archaeology. With all the bad information out
- 34:25there, what are some resources where we might be able to tool up and
- 34:31have better information? So, I mean, I have my own YouTube channel.
- 34:36I'm pretty easy to find right now. The name of it is Nobody
- 34:39Listens to Andrew, which is named after a book that I had as a
- 34:43kid because I was the younger sibling and I always felt like nobody listened to
- 34:45me at all, and as a Generation xer like I don't like to be
- 34:50branded as one certain thing. So I talk about a bunch of different stuff
- 34:52on my YouTube channel, but a lot of it is related to pseudo archaeology
- 34:54and pseudoscience. There's a group on Facebook now Fraudulent Archaeology Wall of Shame.
- 35:00It has one hundred and thirty three that's right. I started that group.
- 35:07I don't know how it maybe maybe ten years ago and it was just me,
- 35:10so I was the first, first and only member for a while.
- 35:14But I realized that there were so many of these pseudo archaeology platforms that were
- 35:17just spreading nonsense. So it was a place for professional archaeologists to come together
- 35:22and talk about stuff and share information. And it has since grown to over
- 35:27one hundred thousand members now, so that's a good source. People will help
- 35:30you find specific answers to things there if you post there. There are a
- 35:36lot of people who blog and who do YouTube videos, too many to mention,
- 35:39but they're out there and they're they're findable. They're much more findable than
- 35:45they were, say ten years ago, or maybe even five years ago,
- 35:47so that gives me a little bit of hope. Actually, one of the
- 35:52largest purveyors of pseudo archeology, Graham Hancock, had a Netflix series on last
- 35:57year which was hugely popular. He has a big following. He's very well
- 36:01spoken, He's written a lot of books. He's into the Atlantis stuff,
- 36:06not the Aliens stuff. But he appears on the Joe Rogan podcast, which
- 36:10I think is like the largest podcast on YouTube yet. It's huge. It's
- 36:14got millions millions of views, and he finally got an archaeologist on there to
- 36:17debate him, guy by the name of Flint Dibble, and I thought Flint
- 36:22mopped the floor with him. It took four and a half hours, but
- 36:25you know, that's what happens. So one thing that pseudo archaeology does is
- 36:29it tries to insulate itself from scrutiny. They don't necessarily want to engage,
- 36:34so when you do, you get a variety of reactions, some angry.
- 36:37I've been threatened with lawsuits for calling people out on stuff that was obviously false.
- 36:40And you know, but you have truth on your side, it's pretty
- 36:44easy to be confident. So I go ahead. Sorry, I'm sorry,
- 36:49just on and on. Yeah, oh no, no, Well you got
- 36:52host and a communicator in the same room, and I've really enjoyed the conversation.
- 36:58I'll link to your YouTube, chante and the awesomely named Facebook page,
- 37:02which I may borrow part of that for the title of our conversation. But
- 37:07thanks for your great work and for bringing to my attention something that I had
- 37:10never thought of before. To me, it was always just kind of,
- 37:14oh, come on, it's wacky, it's weird, it's you know,
- 37:17it's even stupid. The idea is being stupid. But I never thought that
- 37:22they were all that sinister, except for maybe priming people to think in conspiratorial
- 37:29ways. You know, they say that like religious children. And I'm biased
- 37:32here because I came out of a hardcore, high control Christianity. But when
- 37:37you program young people to think in magical terms, it's harder for them to
- 37:44tether themselves to reality as they get older. And that's what I thought.
- 37:49The big problem was, I had no idea that there were white supremacy ties
- 37:53to these types of things. So, you know, none of these ideas
- 37:57come out of thin air, like. They all have a history and a
- 37:59contact, and when you start going back in it, like, it can
- 38:01get pretty ugly and pretty disturbing pretty quickly. As an academic, like I'm
- 38:07interested in that, like I like to understand the history of ideas and thought
- 38:09and that sort of thing. But that's not pleasant, it's not it's not
- 38:15it's not a nice world to be in. It's necessary and it's appreciated.
- 38:19Doctor Andrew White, You've been generous with your time today. Thanks for chatting
- 38:22with me. Thank you. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter.
- 38:28For a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts
- 38:31featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details
- 38:37on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist
- 38:43dot com.