Latest / Bloomberg Law / Montana Residents’ Toxic Cleanup Demands in Jeopardy
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: Welcome to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. I'm June Grosso. Every
- 0:07Speaker 1: day we bring you insight an analysis into the most
- 0:09Speaker 1: important legal news of the day. You can find more
- 0:12Speaker 1: episodes of the Bloomberg Law Podcast on Apple Podcasts, SoundCloud
- 0:16Speaker 1: and on Bloomberg dot com slash podcasts. After more than
- 0:19Speaker 1: a decade of court battles, one hundred residents of the
- 0:23Speaker 1: tiny town of Opportunity, Montana, went head to head against
- 0:27Speaker 1: one of the largest corporations in the world at the
- 0:29Speaker 1: Supreme Court on Tuesday. The residents ay Atlantic rich Field
- 0:33Speaker 1: is responsible for removing the lead and arsenic deposited on
- 0:36Speaker 1: their properties in decades of copper smelting operations. The outcome
- 0:41Speaker 1: could affect how the billion dollars super Fun clean up
- 0:43Speaker 1: law works, and during oral arguments, the joices seemed wary
- 0:48Speaker 1: of interfering with that. Joining me as pat parento or
- 0:51Speaker 1: professor at Vermont Law School. So pat Arco, which is
- 0:55Speaker 1: owned by BP, has already spent hundreds of millions of
- 0:58Speaker 1: dollars in cleaning up the area. Tell us what the
- 1:01Speaker 1: situation there is now? Well, this is one of the
- 1:04Speaker 1: largest super fun sites in the country and one of
- 1:07Speaker 1: the most heavily contaminated. It's an old copper smelter in Montana,
- 1:14Speaker 1: and the property owners that live within the area where
- 1:17Speaker 1: the smelter has been operating. The smelter is taller than
- 1:20Speaker 1: the Washington Monument. It's huge, and it's deposited arsenic and
- 1:25Speaker 1: lead contamination over an enormous area three square miles, including
- 1:31Speaker 1: the property of the plaintiffs in this case. And it's
- 1:34Speaker 1: contaminated the soil and the groundwater. There's been a remedial
- 1:39Speaker 1: action under way for over thirty years. It's still not finished.
- 1:43Speaker 1: So it's a big mess. What's the basic legal issue
- 1:46Speaker 1: before the court? So the property owners have said the
- 1:50Speaker 1: e p A. The remedy that you're requiring Atlantic Ridge
- 1:53Speaker 1: Field to carry out is not going to restore our property.
- 1:57Speaker 1: They live within the boundary of the National Priority Lists
- 2:01Speaker 1: site and their soil has contaminated, their groundwater is contaminated,
- 2:05Speaker 1: and they want more work done to restore their property.
- 2:08Speaker 1: And under state law, they have a claim for this
- 2:11Speaker 1: kind of nuisance and trespass of contamination on their properties.
- 2:15Speaker 1: So they want money from ARCO to conduct additional remedial
- 2:20Speaker 1: action to restore their property. What is the argument of
- 2:24Speaker 1: ARCO and also the Trump administration right. So ARCO is
- 2:29Speaker 1: saying e p A should have the final word on
- 2:32Speaker 1: any remedy. We've already spent over four hundred million dollars
- 2:36Speaker 1: that e p A s direction. We don't think it's
- 2:39Speaker 1: right or fair or lawful that we should be also
- 2:42Speaker 1: subject to liability from these landowners, and we don't want
- 2:46Speaker 1: individual state courts ordering additional remedial action when e p
- 2:52Speaker 1: A is the one that makes those final decisions. ARCO
- 2:56Speaker 1: is arguing there should be uniformity in the way that
- 2:59Speaker 1: super Fun clean ups are done and that e p A,
- 3:01Speaker 1: as the expert agency, should have the final word on that.
- 3:04Speaker 1: The problem that ARCO has is that circle of the
- 3:08Speaker 1: super Fun law contains what's known as a savings provision,
- 3:11Speaker 1: which actually allows private property owners to pursue state common
- 3:16Speaker 1: law remedies when the remedy that e p A has
- 3:20Speaker 1: ordered doesn't go far enough to restore their property. So
- 3:24Speaker 1: that's the tension in this case, the balance between a
- 3:27Speaker 1: law that tries to preserve the rights of property owners
- 3:31Speaker 1: to pursue additional remedy, but a remedy that doesn't conflict
- 3:36Speaker 1: with the one that e p A has ordered, So
- 3:38Speaker 1: the Montana Supreme Court ruled for the landowners. What was
- 3:43Speaker 1: its finding. The Montana Supreme Court said, this case should
- 3:46Speaker 1: go to trial, and at this stage we can't determine
- 3:49Speaker 1: whether whatever remedy is ordered after trial would conflict with
- 3:54Speaker 1: e PAS remedy or not. As they put it, that's
- 3:57Speaker 1: a hypothetical potential conflict, but not a real actual conflict.
- 4:02Speaker 1: So the Montana Supreme Court said, you should be able
- 4:05Speaker 1: to put your case on in front of a Montana
- 4:08Speaker 1: jury and see if you can convince the jury that
- 4:11Speaker 1: you're entitled to further compensation from ARCO. And by the
- 4:15Speaker 1: same token, ARCO is going to be able to present
- 4:18Speaker 1: evidence that what you're asking for either isn't necessary or
- 4:22Speaker 1: that it would conflict with e PAS remedy, in which
- 4:25Speaker 1: case it wouldn't be ordered. So the trial would resolve
- 4:30Speaker 1: the dispute between whether what their landowners want is inconsistent
- 4:34Speaker 1: with what E p A has ordered. But it seemed
- 4:37Speaker 1: during the oral arguments that most of the justices seemed
- 4:41Speaker 1: inclined to stop a trial from going forward. Well, it's
- 4:45Speaker 1: clear that the court is struggling with balancing the rights
- 4:49Speaker 1: of the landowner. And if you will the rights of
- 4:51Speaker 1: ARCO are more properly probably the deference to e p
- 4:55Speaker 1: a s judgment about what should be done here, and
- 4:58Speaker 1: the justices are trying to find a way that whatever
- 5:02Speaker 1: remedy the landowners want to get from their state court
- 5:06Speaker 1: action would be approved by e p A. This is unusual.
- 5:10Speaker 1: I'm not sure the mechanism by which e p A
- 5:12Speaker 1: could do something like this, But clearly a number of
- 5:15Speaker 1: the justices are not comfortable just letting this case go
- 5:19Speaker 1: to trial before a state court. They want to make
- 5:22Speaker 1: sure that e p A retains control over whatever ultimately
- 5:26Speaker 1: happens to this site. Well, could they write an opinion
- 5:30Speaker 1: and you know insert e p A must have control
- 5:33Speaker 1: over sight when there is no regulation that seems to
- 5:37Speaker 1: allow the landowners to say, e p A, can you
- 5:40Speaker 1: approve this right? And Justice Sotomayor was saying, why didn't
- 5:44Speaker 1: the landowners approach e p A with their proposed remedy,
- 5:49Speaker 1: and and Arco's lawyers, I think properly said, well, they
- 5:52Speaker 1: did try to convince EPA to do more, an EPA
- 5:55Speaker 1: declined to do it, and so there's a disagreement about
- 5:58Speaker 1: what really should be done at this site. But in
- 6:01Speaker 1: the end, The one thing EPA could possibly do is
- 6:05Speaker 1: to certify that whatever remedy is ordered to restore the
- 6:10Speaker 1: private owner's property doesn't conflict with the remedy that e
- 6:14Speaker 1: p A has required. The problem there is e PAS
- 6:19Speaker 1: remedy is still ongoing and won't be completed until at
- 6:23Speaker 1: the earliest. So it's going to be very difficult for
- 6:26Speaker 1: e p A to approve a remedy that might be
- 6:30Speaker 1: ordered by the state Court before e p A has
- 6:33Speaker 1: actually completed its remedy. It's a very complicated situation, unprecedented,
- 6:38Speaker 1: I would say, under super fun at this point, What
- 6:41Speaker 1: was the Chief Justice John Roberts getting at when he
- 6:44Speaker 1: said that the residents digging up a yard to put
- 6:47Speaker 1: in a sandbox for children could quote stir up infected
- 6:51Speaker 1: dirt that could harm your neighbors many miles away. Getting
- 6:55Speaker 1: it that they're not supposed to do anything on their property, Well,
- 6:58Speaker 1: he's certainly saying if they shouldn't be allowed to do
- 7:01Speaker 1: something that would cause further damage. But my response to
- 7:05Speaker 1: the Chief Justice would be that's the purpose of the trial,
- 7:09Speaker 1: and that's what the Montana Supreme Court stressed, is that
- 7:13Speaker 1: if what the landowner is requesting from ARCO would either
- 7:17Speaker 1: make things worse, conflict with e PAS remedy or simply
- 7:21Speaker 1: not be justified, then they will not be awarded that remedy.
- 7:25Speaker 1: So the landowners have a number of hurdles they've got
- 7:28Speaker 1: to get over before they could ever recover anything from ARCO,
- 7:32Speaker 1: and one of those is going to be what kind
- 7:34Speaker 1: of restoration are you requesting? Is it justified? And is
- 7:38Speaker 1: it consistent with what e p A has required. Those
- 7:41Speaker 1: are three major questions that we don't have answers to
- 7:44Speaker 1: right now. Is there any middle ground that you can
- 7:47Speaker 1: see the justices ruling on hard to see, but there.
- 7:51Speaker 1: Here's one idea. The justices could say that the property
- 7:56Speaker 1: owners lawsuit in state court will be held in abeyance,
- 8:00Speaker 1: ending e p a's final remedy, which, as I say,
- 8:02Speaker 1: isn't going to be concluded until at that point it
- 8:07Speaker 1: should be pretty clear whether there's remaining work to be
- 8:11Speaker 1: done on the private property. There probably will be, but
- 8:15Speaker 1: at least it will be clear that the federal remedy
- 8:17Speaker 1: phase will have ended, and it will be much easier
- 8:21Speaker 1: to determine whether what the property owners are seeking is
- 8:24Speaker 1: consistent with that remedy or not. Right now, it's almost
- 8:28Speaker 1: impossible to make that determination. If the Supreme Court rules
- 8:31Speaker 1: against the residents. Do they have other options to pursue?
- 8:35Speaker 1: Hard to see. I mean, they've tried to get e
- 8:38Speaker 1: p A to do more unsuccessfully. I suppose they could
- 8:42Speaker 1: keep trying to do that. They do have remedies, by
- 8:46Speaker 1: the way, for trespass. The issue that we're talking about
- 8:50Speaker 1: in this case is restoration of their property, which would
- 8:53Speaker 1: mean removing additional contamination from the soil or groundwater. An
- 8:58Speaker 1: alternative remedy would be simply trespass, and that's a much
- 9:02Speaker 1: easier remedy to prove because you're basically saying you have
- 9:06Speaker 1: physically invaded my property with your contamination, and that's certainly true.
- 9:12Speaker 1: The difference is that you might not get as much money,
- 9:15Speaker 1: you might not get additional work done on the site,
- 9:18Speaker 1: but you could get some compensation. For example, the property
- 9:22Speaker 1: value of this property has undoubtedly gone down significantly just
- 9:26Speaker 1: by virtue of the fact that it's this close to
- 9:29Speaker 1: a superfund site, So recouping those kinds of damages would
- 9:34Speaker 1: be possible even if they couldn't get restoration. Finally, Pat,
- 9:38Speaker 1: do you agree with our co and the Justice Department
- 9:43Speaker 1: saying that if the Supreme Court interferes here, it could
- 9:47Speaker 1: affect how the superfund clean up law works. I think
- 9:52Speaker 1: that's overstatement and tilting it windmills. Frankly, this is a
- 9:57Speaker 1: this is a fact based case um. And the question
- 10:00Speaker 1: is has this private property been damaged by our co
- 10:05Speaker 1: and is it going to be damaged even after e
- 10:08Speaker 1: p A's remedy is complete? And are the landowners entitled
- 10:11Speaker 1: to some compensation for that? That doesn't seem unreasonable to me,
- 10:15Speaker 1: and I don't think that's going to bring the whole
- 10:16Speaker 1: super fun programmed down by any stretch. Congress deliberately carved
- 10:21Speaker 1: out an exception for private property owners to seek compensation
- 10:26Speaker 1: beyond the remedy that e p A ordered. That's what
- 10:29Speaker 1: these landowners are trying to do. Thanks Pat. That's Pat Parento,
- 10:33Speaker 1: professor at Vermont Law School. Thanks for listening to the
- 10:37Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can subscribe and listen to the
- 10:41Speaker 1: show on Apple Podcasts, SoundCloud, and on Bloomberg dot com
- 10:45Speaker 1: slash podcast. I'm June Brosso. This is Bloomberg Ye