Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / The Golden Daughter Who Hired Her Parents' Killers… | The Jennifer Pan Case
Transcript
- Nicholle: November eighth, twenty ten, Markham, Ontario. Inside the Pan family home, everything looks normal. is downstairs. just got back from line dancing. Their daughter Jennifer is also home, but Jennifer has already unlocked the front door. No forced entry, no shattered glass, just a door left waiting. At around ten PM, three men walk in. VIP access. What follows lasts fourteen minutes. And in those fourteen minutes a family is destroyed. Bich Ha Pan Bich Ha Pan is dead. Han Pan Han Pan is shot in the face and shoulder, but he survives. And Jennifer, she's tied to a banister, loose, no injuries. At first police believe she's a victim. But they're about to discover something very chilling. The killers were invited in. Welcome to Coffee and Crime with Mom, I'm Nicole. Zalle: And I'm Zalle Nicholle: And today we're diving into the Jennifer Pan case and a wild one. ⁓ the perfect daughter who spent ten years building a life of lies. And when it all came crashing down, she chose murder over the truth. Netflix made a whole documentary about it. After this episode you'll understand why. Zalle: ⁓ yeah. Nicholle: But first, coffee moment. What are you having Zae? Zalle: So today I am having my coconut cream latte. my little version of it. Yas, yoss. Yes. It was hot. But you know, ⁓ a mom and I do stuff and now its cold. And so ⁓ just Nicholle: ⁓ That sounds delicious. Mm-hmm. Children. Zalle: gonna drink it cold. Yeah. What are you drinking? Nicholle: Just make sure I'm not showing Thank you for asking, Zalle. So ran out of milk. All milk. Oat milk, regular milk. There's no milk in there. So luckily still have some creamer. So I'm just having, you know, that ⁓ espresso type coffee. They wanted it comes in the yellow brick thing. Boost or something, I think it's called. Zalle: Mm-hmm. Mm the brick, the yellow brick thing. Nicholle: You know, it comes in a yellow can or when you get the ones that's in a little vacuum sealed pack. Anyway, it's yellow. And it's like a Mexican coffee. So it's like really strong type. got me. ⁓ I have that but just a little bit of my vanilla cream of today. So we're just doing basic coffee today. Zalle: Right, right. Mm, yep, yep. Mm-hmm. I know what to talk about, yep. That's funny because I used the that brand espresso to make my Yes, yes, yes, yes. Yes. But this case is super wild, mom. Okay. Because one Jennifer faked like her entire life. She forged diplomas, graduation photos, paycheck stubs. Nicholle: ⁓ really? Look great minds and all. Great minds. Entire life. Zalle: And s all of this started back in high school and she was doing this with Photoshop. Okay. One, that's a gift because I don't know how to use Photoshop. And from the picture that they showed in the documentary, it looked like if she did a good ass job, she could have made it a career. Okay. And she was just one class short right. Anything. And she was just one class short of graduating from high school from what you were telling me because I didn't see that. And Nicholle: En heist. Mm-hmm. ⁓ yeah. ⁓ yeah. She could have, if she did anything. Mm-hmm. Yeah, she needed after they found out she needed like a summer class in something that she felt. Zalle: And she never told anybody. Right. But and then kept lying after that for a decade. Mm-hmm. Nicholle: Right. Just kept going. So in when you lie like that about the aspects of your life, the pressure gets serious. It's real. ⁓ her parents were Vietnamese immigrants who worked at Magna International and they wanted the dream for their kids. Straight A's, piano, pharmacy school. And when Jennifer couldn't deliver, instead of disappointing them, she invented a whole other life. Like literally. Zalle: Yeah. Nicholle: Like Zalle was saying starting in high school and just going right on through college, which she didn't go to. Zalle: My whole entire life. Yeah kept going. this shit tells you like how humble her people were. ⁓ At the place that they worked at, the mom was a manager, some kind of ⁓ and the dad worked ⁓ under her as one the employees there ⁓ at the at the place. so was just doing what they had to do. know what I'm saying? They was it, okay? Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. ⁓ really? Yeah. Zalle: And then they found out about Daniel Wong, which was her boyfriend, and he was a drug dealer. And we're not gonna I mean we're not gonna make it seem like he was out here. It was no like BMF. He wasn't yeah, yeah, it wouldn't g right. like gas money. You know? Gas money. No. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. He did not ha he was not the head of a cartel. It was like selling a little weed. Right. Yeah, yeah. He's not big balling. He's not moving, you know, the cocaina or anything, it's just a little bit of wheat. Zalle: Right. Just a little little dime bag or whatever. But that didn't matter 'cause they went full lockdown. They took her phone. They started to drive her everywhere, basically like tracking her 'cause if she'd be gone too long they'd be calling and like where d where you at, what are you doing? And Han told her that she had to end it or wait until he was dead for her to be with Daniel. Which is crazy. Yeah. It it Nicholle: Yes. Right. Hm, which is chilling. Which is chilling. And Zalle: But also all of this happened right after she had graduated high school once they started doing all of the like took her phone and started driving her everywhere. And all of that came out like people started to realize how bad it was 'cause she broke down at one of her piano lessons and told her, piano teacher Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Zalle: Like I can't do this anymore. My dad is so controlling. He doesn't want me to be with Daniel. And that's what she kept he kept the piano teacher was saying Jennifer just was freaking out the whole time about her not being able to be with Daniel and that her dad was basically like on her throat. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right, right. And we have to kinda understand when we say that there were, you know, immigrants, Vietnamese immigrants, that there was no room for failure with in that situation, you know, with the tiger parenting as they say. There was no room for failure. Not only that, but even when you succeeded, that's what you're supposed to do. That's that's what we expect of you. So I mean Zalle: No. Yeah, yeah. Nicholle: You don't you want a cookie or something? Like you did what you're supposed to do. Zalle: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And one of the people she went to high school with was saying like that was across the board for all of the students at the high school. Like every wo everybody was expected to be doctors, engineers, things like that. And apparently Jennifer was nowhere near like the top of her class or she was like obviously because she needed a whole summer class to graduate, she was skating by and that is not for ⁓ Nicholle: Mm. Right. Mm-hmm. Right. That is not no. Zalle: her culture at all. And they were saying her mom was worried about, you know, Jennifer and her grades. And then she graduated and she couldn't get a job. And they were trying to figure out why. Well, 'cause she didn't graduate. She didn't graduate. She lied. Yeah. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. She didn't graduate. And I know as a parent that that is so frustrating. Like I don't I don't think you would call me a tiger parent. I was I expect I had my expectations, definitely. But to just feel like I'm talking to you, I'm having this conversation with you, you're saying okay. Like you're not you're saying like it seems like we agree, but as soon as I'm not around, that's not what you do. And that is so frustrating. Like we we have I've discussed it with you like you're an adult. Like you want me to treat you. ⁓ changing. You know, I understand their frustration because I wanna make sure that ⁓ we're speaking on it how tiger parenting kinda kinda kinda works, it's not Zalle: I feel like that would be different for her though. Like it wouldn't have been there sitting down having the conversation and she saying how she feels about like, hey, I'm not doing well or whatever. Clearly if she had to hide all of that, it wasn't a household where it could be brought to the table. Nicholle: No. No, that's not what I mean. That's not what I mean. You're right. I don't think that that happened. But when her well, like when you were saying her mom was concerned, although I don't think there's an open dialogue where she could say what she thinks, I'm pretty sure her mom was saying something to her about it. Now and whether I'm just saying from the parent side, because I'm sure her perspective is totally different. Zalle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Nicholle: But as a parent, I'm saying this I'm giving you very explicit directions, instructions. And you're nodding along, you're saying, Yes, ma'am, whatever you say, and then you just don't do it. You know, that's frustrating. And then to keep finding out that not only are you just not applying yourself, but you're lying about very important things. But here's the part that sits with me the five hundred thousand dollars. Zalle: Yeah. Lots of things. Nicholle: Jennifer was going to get half a million dollars in life insurance if her parents died. And in this situation, that seems like a big pull. Zalle: Yeah. Yeah. And so it wasn't just about her freedom, it was about money too. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Always follow the money. Always. All right, so let's get into it. like we were saying, Jennifer was supposed to be the golden child. She her her parents' intention was that she would make straight A's all the way through school. She would, you know, play piano, which I've heard is like more of an acceptable instrument, you know, it means you're smart. And go to college and become a pharmacologist. There were Zalle: And she excelled as a pianist. She was Her teacher said she was amazing and her parents spent thousands of dollars ⁓ her so she could like do the piano and she performed in all of these competitions and was winning. Nicholle: There there were no apps. Mm-hmm. Yeah. I know. Right. And so I mean, but where did they I I don't know. I guess because that was great that she was doing that, but she still was not killing it at school. So she had just been lying all the way, like you were saying through high school. I think in one of the documentaries that I watched about it, 'cause I've watched a few, they were saying since about fourteen years old. That's when she started, when her grades started failing and she started, you know forging report cards and doing crazy things. Zalle: Right. Doesn't say. Nicholle: Like it wasn't gonna catch up. But the crazy thing is that she was class short of graduating, just one class. And for whatever reason, probably because it wouldn't have been acceptable to her parents, she never said anything, but she just needed one class and ⁓ that would have been it. Zalle: Yeah. ⁓ you know, it doesn't speak it a lot if just go off the documentaries, but she has a whole brother named Felix. And he was said that yeah, her his dad was ⁓ Both of their parents were strict, but he w they were loving. wasn't because it was like ⁓ you know, you're gonna do what I say just because I wanna grow older you take care of me. It's because I want you to have a life better than what I have. Nicholle: Right. Mm-hmm. Right. Right. Mm-hmm. Zalle: And so he was like, I don't understand where she got that from. He even testified against her in court. Right. And and and he said that, you know, it's bewildering because I didn't know she lied about all of this, all the forged report cards, acceptance letters, the bachelor degree from ⁓ Ryerson in Toronto. She even photoshopped herself in graduation photos. Nicholle: Right. As as he should have. Zalle: And told her parents she was living near campus during the week when she was really staying with Daniel Wong, her boyfriend. And the brother was like, I didn't know about any of this the whole time. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. That's cra not even a brother knew. I I think that bends my mind because I always assume if something's going on with one of you, at least one of the three of you knows what's going on. I may not know, but I assume that if it's serious enough, of the other siblings know. And maybe that's my misconception, but I just think that had be so stressful. And then comes Daniel, the former drug dealer. Zalle: Yeah. No, yeah. He said I felt bamboozled. Mm-hmm. Nicholle: And he had a criminal record. And it's like she just went out and said, Who is the guy that my father will hate the absolute worst? And that's who she picked. Zalle: Well the crazy thing she said that made them stu like whatever made her stick with him was s something was happening. I don't know. She went somewhere and she was having an asthma attack and he helped her. And she was like that just it made me feel so special and then, you know, I got to know him and then my parents were like, Yeah, I can't talk to him it was like a piece of me was missing and her friend was like, Yeah, it just seemed like she didn't Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: feel like sh she was worth anything. She just felt like he was worth everything. And I never understood why she felt that way, which is Nicholle: That's crazy. Well, even one of her friends was saying that she, or maybe it was on a podcast that I listened to, but she was they were saying that she saved up money working her job, summer job, or whatever. She saved up all this money and then she spent it on something for him, like some game system piece or something. And when her friend was like, Why would you do that? She was like, Well, it seemed like he was the only place for yeah, what else would I do with it? You know, not even for herself. Zalle: Yep, yeah. Yeah. I have nothing better to spend it on. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Nicholle: That's just sad. But even with all that, their relationship was really just on and off again because they were toxic, as you could see, according to her friends. But if anybody feels that deeply about someone and he seems to be like she's okay, there's there has to be something going on there. But I guess it didn't hurt that they lived across the street from each other, so they near each other. But When her parents found out, of course they were furious. This on paper, I don't even have to meet him. On paper he's horrible for you, not what I want for you. And so they took her phone they literally drove her ⁓ that she had to go. And they forbade her from seeing Daniel, which s never never works. Yeah. And Han told her, like you said, end it or wait until I'm dead and that just makes my stomach flip over every time I hear that. Zalle: Yeah. Apparent. Never turns out well. Yes, it's because she took it literally. And then her mom, big worried, like I was saying, that Jennifer couldn't find a job and obviously this was because Jennifer had never graduated. She wasn't a pharmacist, she wasn't anything. She just kept saying that like the pressure was crushing and she told people that there was in the interview with the cops while this was happening after she came out, she said that it was just too much expectation. She couldn't live up to what they wanted for her. Nicholle: Mm. Zalle: So she just made it all up to like satisfy them, so she could live her life. Nicholle: I mean that's I I don't I don't understand that. So the pressure's too hard. So I'm just gonna absolutely collapse and lie my that has to be more pressure. Lying your way through. Yeah, then just talking to your teachers. Even if you can't talk to your parents, like I'm not getting this, do something. I don't know. And if everybody in this school had the same expectations, it seemed like you could study with somebody. It just seemed like she didn't want that was it didn't interest her, so she didn't try. Zalle: To keep up two lives, yeah. Yeah, no. ⁓ Nicholle: And it didn't it didn't hurt, you know, when we're talking about what she did to her parents that she was likely to get five hundred thousand dollars if they died. Which sounds like a lot of freedom, especially to a young person. I mean, I'm fifty and it sounds like a lot of freedom. Imagine if you didn't even know what money was worth, that would sound like everything. Zalle: Right. Right. And then the crazy crazy part is that this wasn't Jennifer's first attempt. Earlier in twenty ten, she actually contacted a friend while they were out at a bar and said that she wanted to kill her dad. And so he introduced her to Ricardo Duncan and then Jennifer claimed that she paid fifteen hundred dollars to have her father killed. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Zalle: And that it got up to that point and she gave Duncan the money and then he gave it back to her. but ⁓ denied that she gave him that much. He said that she gave him two hundred dollars for a night out, which again he said he returned that part. But the real plan for her came later because that didn't work out. He was just like, I didn't believe her. I was just trying to see if she would go through it and then she gave me the money and I like, ⁓ yeah, she's you know, she tripping. Hear your money back, yeah. Nicholle: Yeah. Yeah, she crazy. Mm-hmm. But that didn't stop Jennifer. Yeah, it didn't stop her. I'm sorry, go ahead. Zalle: But that in itself, how do you nope, nope. Again with the planning. I say no, I'm just saying aga again with the planning to kill like your parents, another case of that Nicholle: Yeah. It would just seem like and she seems very dedicated when she wants something. So it doesn't make any sense that she failed. Look at how hard she worked to lie So all she really had to do was try and then how committed she was is this friend didn't do it. That didn't stop her. That that wasn't like okay, maybe I should slow down. Because somebody clearly doesn't think it's a good idea. Nope. She just reconnects with Daniel and then Zalle: Mm-hmm. Right. Right. Yeah. Nicholle: Him being the great guy that he is, he connects her to Lenford Crawford, who is also a drug dealer, and then Crawford connects them to Eric Sniper Carty, who Brings in David. Zalle: Mig Mylvaganam Nicholle: Okay. the price was ten thousand dollars, half of his usual rate, because Jennifer was Daniel's friend, so she got the family and friends discount. ⁓ her payout was gonna be five hundred thousand dollars in life insurance for her parents, and what she was looking for was freedom and money, and that freedom for her meant that she could be with Daniel. Zalle: Yeah, she could do what she wanted to. And so in the picture, first we have David and then we have Eric Carty. And the first picture that I pulled up, the older picture, that was ⁓ Crawford. And then obviously Daniel Wong and Jennifer. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: started talking again. And so Daniel had already started to move He was with somebody else, right? But they're still texting. And Daniel is being like up front, right? So Jennifer sent a text message like, Do you love me and want to be with me? And Daniel told her, like, what you feel for me, I feel for this other girl. Nicholle: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. I think her name was Christine. Zalle: Christine. Yeah, that's just you know, it is what it is. He never lied, but he kept kinda trying to push the issue, right? And so he connected all of them and then Jennifer based like the count the text messages they released in the doc the Netflix documentary Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: It seemed like Jennifer was kinda doing all of this on the basis that Daniel would want to be with her. And so every time Daniel answered one of these text messages and he like, No, I don't want to be with you or no, I feel for the other girl for whatever, then she would be like, Okay, well call homeboy and cut it off. Right. And so yeah, then he w at one point he was like, Well, you said that you wanted this with or without me, like Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Zalle: started tripping on her and was like, contact Homeboy and make it happen. And so they had talked for a while before it actually happened. Like ⁓ her Homeboy, and he was like, You know, tonight's the green line. She'd be like, No, we're having a family dinner or whatever, this and this would happen. ⁓ And would be because her and Daniel would be going back and forth with whatever. And then on November eighth, two thousand and ten, they finally agreed to it. And it started with Nicholle: Yeah. Yeah, he didn't. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: BichPan she made dinner her and Jennifer ate together and she left to go line dancing like she did every Monday and she came back around nine thirty and she's sitting there soaking her feet ⁓ and at this the dad has gone upstairs to go to bed. And then it's supposed to be just like a normal night. Everything's you know, nothing's unusual. Well, when Bich came back before soaking her feet and the dad went upstairs, Jennifer came down. to basically say goodnight, but she was pretending and acting like she was checking the door when in actuality she unlocked the door. Nicholle: Okay. Wow. This is crazy. Zalle: Right. And then right. And then just went back upstairs and acted like nothing was happening. she got a text message. Jennifer got text message from Homeboy that said game time. Right, once she went upstairs and the police said they believed she flickered her lights on and off to cue for them to come inside. And then that's when they came in. They just walked in the door. Yeah, and then Bich asked for Han to come downstairs. And so Jennifer went to her doorway and that's when she said all of this started happening where grab like one of grabbed her. ⁓ Nicholle: 'Cause Yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: And the other one made her dad come downstairs ⁓ took her downstairs first to the living room to try to like get where their money is and all this other stuff. Nicholle: Very good. Uh-huh. Mm-hmm. Yeah, I know in one of the documentaries that I was watching they were showing like a camera from someone else's house where you could kind of barely see the guys running up to the door. But right before that you could see her turn all the lights on upstairs and then turn ⁓ off. Zalle: I didn't even notice that when I actually watched it. Which is insane 'cause I definitely watched it. ⁓ okay. Nicholle: So it wasn't in the what Jennifer did Netflix. It the Netflix one. It was the one I found on YouTube but you could see from the camera from somebody else's And it's kinda like you could see them come like you it's dark and you see the lights go on and them go off and then you see three guys go up to the door. Zalle: That is insane. Nicholle: Yes. Absolutely crazy. So at around 10 PM, three men enter the house. Han is beaten and taken to the basement. Jennifer is with the gunmen. She's walking around, talking to them, whispering, like she knows them. The parents are separated. Bich Ha is taken to the basement too. Zalle: So Jennifer says that she hears shots from the basement, two shots, and then silence. And then this time she's back upstairs, and this is supposedly she's tied to the banister by the upper part of her arm, right? Her arm right here is tied to the banister and her hands are tied behind her back, which ⁓ ⁓ ties people up like that? ⁓ that's suspicious, right? ⁓ anywho, so then she hears another two shots. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. By the top of their arm. Zalle: And you can hear her dad calling and like screaming. And then she said that they shot one more time and then they left. But she manages somehow during that time of them leaving to get the phone out of her pocket while she's still tied up and called nine one one. And supposedly her phone was supposed to be unreachable. They don't even understand she was able to do that. And so I just want to ⁓ Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Right. Zalle: play the snippet of this nine one one call because insane. Nicholle: It's crazy. every time I hear him ⁓ there, I can't tell what he's saying, but I know she's trying to hollow. Zalle: goodness. Trying to and then the fact that she said, My dad just went outside screaming. First of all, all of this stuff first you hear the fear and like anguish in him and when he's screaming, why would he leave his daughter in the house with these three men and his wife inside? Why would he go outside? Nicholle: Inside. Mm-hmm. Yeah, I remember seeing that detective say that was the first thing he thought was what makes a man run out of the house that he was just shot in and leave his daughter inside. That was the first thing he thought. Zalle: Right. Right. Nicholle: And what's crazy is that nine one one call and how totally insane everything sounds, her supervisor at Han's company later said Jennifer kept a sad voice, but she didn't seem to be crying like you'd expect her to be. So it was like she was performing. And then thirty four seconds in, moans in the background ⁓ and he's crawling up stairs. He drags himself outside screaming. A neighbor calls nine one one and Hann is rushed to the hospital and falls into a coma. unfortunately Bich Hann dies. And she's telling her story. Zalle: I mean she's telling something. She's telling something. November twenty second, two thousand and ten, which was day fourteen after the murder, Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: then all of this happens, ⁓ So so obviously the nine one one dispatchers, the police came, right? They find Bich she's dead. Right after this, they bring her in, she's telling her story, she's saying the only reason why she thinks that she survived is because she cooperated. Nicholle: Mm. Zalle: they talked for a while then her first interview ended at 4 30 AM the night of the murder. they bring her back for a second interview. this is after ⁓ they find out about Daniel Wong. ⁓ They were out canvassing neighborhood, talking to people, trying to get Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: information for like six hours and then somebody told them about Daniel and Jennifer. So then they bring her back in and they're like, okay, well he's a drug dealer. This ⁓ horrible thing just happened. You never brought it up. ⁓ maybe he's connected. So ⁓ they talk to her. all fidgety. She's super nervous. w if you guys watch the documentary Netflix, you can see she's so Nicholle: Right. ⁓ she is so it is all over her from the moment they bring her in there. Zalle: nervous. Yes. Yes. It was just horrible. She's playing with her hair. She doesn't know what to do. And they were saying you even in the call, she's not crying. She has a sad voice. She kinda did the same thing in the interview. Like this is the face she had, the interview. ⁓ And point she did cry, but for somebody whose parents, like you were your house was invaded by three people ⁓ and mom is killed and your dad was attempted. You're not you're not crying and reacting like you should be. Right. But so they bring her back. Nicholle: Yeah. Right. Mm-hmm. Zalle: So then they're talking about Daniel, why you didn't tell Dani tell us about Daniel. And she was like, Well, because, you know, he moved on, We're not together. He has somebody else. ⁓ mind you, she doesn't that they've already talked to Daniel. And so Daniel was like, Yeah, we're still cool. You know, we could keep in contact. We have lunch together, you know, stuff like that, blase blase. ⁓ But it's not a whole big deal. you I moved on. She knows I moved on. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Zalle: then he the police that he had been getting weird text messages that him and Jennifer both were getting these weird text messages and they didn't know where it was coming from. so the detective brought up when he was interviewing Jennifer in the second interview and she was like, Yeah, well, I think it was his girlfriend because she messaged me on Facebook one time, but I don't, you know Nicholle: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Zalle: Same basically saying to leave Daniel alone, but I don't want to for sure say it's her because I don't know. But the cop was like, I mean, you keep saying it's her, but you keep saying that you don't want to say it's her, but you saying it's her, right? And this is when she told them that she didn't graduate that she was lying, and she first said that ⁓ her parents ⁓ never knew she was they never questioned it. Nicholle: Right. It's her, yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Zalle: They just because she brought all this stuff home, so they never brought it up, right? But she admitted to all of that. She said that she still wanted to be with Daniel. And that if her parents did not like disapprove of him, then they would still be together. And that when she wasn't allowed to be with him, then it felt like a part of her was gone. Nicholle: Thank you. Mm-hmm. Amen. Zalle: Insane. And sh Nicholle: It's to me it sounds like a teenage girl talking. Like a part of me is talking. Zalle: Right, and you would think it right, and you would think if something crazy just happened to your parents, you would tr bring up the text messages in the first interview when they're trying to figure out, do you know anything? But she didn't mention it, Nicholle: Right. Zalle: but the text messages were basically saying that we were watching you. the last message that Jennifer got said, ha ha, bang, bang, ha ha. And so that's why the officer was like, why would she not bring that up? Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. But another thing in the that last third interview when ⁓ Detective Goetz was talking to her, she's kind of bent over and she's starting to kinda talk he ⁓ her, How did it all start? You know, how did she find these people? And she was like a friend. And he said, Who was the friend? And she said, Just ⁓ I can't I can't I can't reach anymore. And when I first heard it, I was like Zalle: Someone I can't reach anymore. Yeah. Nicholle: while she is talking about Daniel. And she's talking about how even after this, she did all this for him, but she doesn't know. He's still wrapped up in this other girl. He's moved on. And they were saying how they think the only reason that he even s tried to help, you know, well, help her, but get her in touch with these people and even kept talking to her was he knew that she was probably gonna come into some money and he wanted to keep her on the line just in case. Zalle: Right. Right. Right. And so in the second and ⁓ go ahead. Mm-hmm. Nicholle: So he could probably benefit from that money. Zalle: And so because of her reaction and because of what Daniel said, obviously by then the cops are getting the warrants for her phone and this is when they get in her phone and they can see all of the messages between her and Daniel and her and homeboy. And so then on November twenty second, two thousand and ten, which is day fourteen, Detective Bill Getz brings Jennifer in for her third interview, and this time she is an actual suspect, and she's super fidgety and playing in her hair and rocking like horrible. Mm-hmm. ⁓ Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yeah, so detective get uses the read technique. it's a debated technique because and that's why a lot of places they can't use it because it do does away with the presumption of innocence. So basically Zalle: Well, it's known to cause false confessions. Right. Nicholle: Yeah, so they start with, Okay, you did this now, why did you do it? And kind of giving excuses along the way like they understand why she would have done it. So they're never talking like it's like she didn't when when they're using this technique. And like you were saying, he tells her that they have technology that can see inside the house so that they can see what was going on, where everybody was as these things were happening. And that is what Zalle: Because she kept saying she had nothing to do with it. Yeah. Nicholle: breaks her. I mean that's what she is like yeah she is so through all of the it's it's hard to explain. You have to see how nervous she looks. Like if there was a picture or a video example of someone who is lying and they're nervous, she would be itched. She's fidgeting all over the place. At one point I couldn't even tell what she was doing until she moved. Like she is just her ponytail just going going Zalle: It would be her. ⁓ her ponytail. Yes. Nicholle: The whole time like she cannot handle it. Zalle: No. And so the detective pushes her and he and he even offers her two outs. Was it because her parents abused her or because they kept her from Daniel? And then the moment that breaks her. Nicholle: What about your mom, Jen? Don't you want justice for her? Zalle: But what happens to me? Nicholle: Bat line, what happens to me? Not who killed my parents, what happens ⁓ me. Totally self focused. Zalle: Yes. And she's still whole time head down. She's not and she wasn't crying when she said it. Not a a Nicholle: Head down, she's rocking. Mm-mm. And he had to keep telling her to sit up, like we can't hear, I can't hear you. And she just stayed, leaned over. Zalle: Right, okay, but then so after this she admits that she did hire the men to come in, that she left the door unlocked to all the calls and the text message. But she's saying that that's not how it should have happened. It wasn't about her parents. It was supposed to be a suicide plot. They were supposed to come in and get her and kill her. Like just come in, take her with them and kill her wherever. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: And so she said that she paid $2,000 to have herself killed and that somehow in all of this the wires got crossed and she tried to call it off. Obviously, the police don't buy it because neither would I. They arrest her. after was arrested, they find her And in her diary, it literally just is her complaining about the fact that her dad, ⁓ her parents won't let her be with Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: And that, you know, she loves him. It was all butterflies and and hearts and Daniel's name all over the place and she was just frustrated with her in her situation. And so at the end of the third interrogation, Nicholle: Good. I'm surprised it took him that long the way she was acting in that in those interrogations. Zalle: I mean, it just she looked just straight guilty. in March of 2014, the trial begins and that was ten months with fifty witnesses and two hundred exhibits, and the crown case is This they have the cell phone records, the financial motive, and obviously Han Pan, the father. Nicholle: did. Mm-hmm. Zalle: he because he survived. ⁓ ⁓ woke up from his induced coma after all of this because he was shot like n in his skull near his eye ⁓ it traveled and went through his jaw into his neck and so they had to put him in an induced coma to save his life. But he was there to speak up and tell the police about what his daughter did to them. Nicholle: And then And then That's crazy. And he testifies against Jennifer. he should have. And he describes her right. He describes her whispering with the gunman and her unbound hands, her calm demeanor. And to me, that tells you how certain she was that they were not gonna walk out of the situation. That she's just walking around talking to these guys in front of her dad, untied all of that. ⁓ It's crazy. Zalle: Yeah, and so did the brother. Right. Right. Right. Nicholle: And he walks away from that blind in one eye, permanently scarred, he's here to make sure she doesn't get away with it. He tells what he knows. Zalle: Right. And so apparently from what he said happened is that it did happen is you know, how she said it started. The mom made dinner ⁓ her and Jennifer ate, ⁓ the dad went to bed eight thirty, the mom home and Jennifer went downstairs to go check on Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: the mom and to say goodnight and that's when she unlocked the door. She went back upstairs. Like you were saying, she did the light thing. ⁓ homeboy texted game time. and then something VIP access. I'm not sure if she texted him that or if he texted her that either way it was their way to make sure that they could get in the house. And so they just walked in. Mind you, the mom was still on the couch soaking her feet. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Zalle: So they grab her tell her to get everybody down there. She calls for the husband. And so he comes downstairs not knowing what's happening and was taken as soon as he came down. And so they're in the living room. And while they're in the living room the dad is being pistol whipped, Jennifer walks in with I believe it was Crawford. It might have been Carty. Nicholle: Okay. Mm-hmm. Amen. Zalle: But she walks in, she's talking to one of them, they're just having conversations. after that, one of the men takes the both of them down to the basement, the mom and the dad shoots the mom, then shoots the dad, then shot again, and then they left. Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: And ⁓ before that they went upstairs and obviously play tied her up And they dipped out. just to being Hann to have to live through that. Nicholle: Yes, yes. To realize not only were you shot and now you're blind, but it was your daughter who did it. Not only did she set you up, but she had your wife killed. And she was there in the house. Like every layer of this just makes it worse and worse. Cause she's in the house, she's hearing all of this. Zalle: Your wife. Yep. The whole way Yes. Nicholle: And then like I said, I believe when she called 911 and you can hear the dad in the background screaming, that she started hollering back at him because she clearly didn't care what he thought, right? So she's hollering back at him to cover up whatever he's saying. So they can hear that he's hollering, but not what he's saying. Zalle: So what I heard was Right, what I heard now I don't know how true that was. What I heard was that that last time that he yelled right before she said that he ran outside. It wasn't he ran outside and that wasn't like it was her dad, but it was also one of the in the background talking. So that's why she started screaming like that over his scream to try to cover up the guy talking to her. No. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. ⁓ because she wasn't even hushing. She wasn't even stopping when the lady kept saying, Ma'am, ma'am, ma'am. She just keeps hollering. Zalle: Yeah. Yeah, because the guys were talking the to her about was going on. So it's trying to cover up that and the fact that the dad is saying, Jennifer, like you know, I obviously had to have at this point. How can you what are you doing? Yeah, like what's happening? So Jesus, Jesus. But yes, dad and the brother Felix Pann all they both testified. And thankfully at this time Felix was away at Manchester University studying for engineering. Nicholle: That is horrible. What is this? You know, whatever. Mm-hmm. Zalle: he had no idea, like I said, about ⁓ of the lies that his sister had going on until after she was arrested and charged with the murder ⁓ the parents. And it's crazy because they went to the funeral and everything and it was like nothing. Nothing. Nicholle: Wow. And I just think if you could do this to your family, none of us are safe. You could stand next to your brother who you and you know you just killed his parents, even if you don't care about them as your parents, if you could do that, you could we're nobody's safe. Zalle: Yeah. Yeah. And it no I don't know, it just doesn't she just looks frustrated even in the picture. It doesn't she doesn't necessarily look sad to me. But he also just looks frustrated too. So, you know, maybe it's a grief thing. Nicholle: Right. Right. Yeah, maybe it is. It's hard to for in normal situations it's hard to gauge how someone reacts to horrible things. So for him, you there's no telling. For her, she is just a cold blooded killer. And and my she is a narcissist to the nth degree. I again I have no degrees myself, but this is my opinion. That she is a huge narcissist she ⁓ Zalle: Yeah. Yeah, she's evil. Nicholle: has to be some type of sociopath because she doesn't she only cares what she looks like to other people. It doesn't matter who she really is. And the stand, of course, Felix is emotional. A lawyer blocks his view of his sister so he doesn't have to look at her. ⁓ my goodness. He gets choked up describing the funeral arrangements for his mother. And when the defense ⁓ the defense lawyer, Lawrence Cohen, asked if he loved and respected his sister. Zalle: ⁓ yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Nicholle: Wow. If she manipulated the family into believing she was in college, Fees Felix says yes to both. Felix Dad. Dad was old school. He was very controlling. It's just the way my dad is. It's sort of like tough love. Zalle: Yeah, and he also talks about their mom. ⁓ that we had a closer attachment to our mom. We could talk to her about things. So that tells you the dynamic and obviously the police also were saying the main person for the attack was the dad. It wasn't even about the mom, but I mean she just got her out of the way. Nicholle: Right. And how horrible is that? And that shows because that's who she tried to have killed the first time was her dad. So I don't know. And Felix cooperates something crucial for the defense. That his mother was more lenient. Yeah. That his mother was more lenient, that she would protect Jennifer from Han during arguments. That she gave Jennifer access to her phone when Han confiscated it. Zalle: Mm-hmm. Nicholle: He even believed that if their parents ever split up, he and Jennifer would live with their mother. But Felix also confirms the pressure, the strict expectations, the academic demands, and the control. Zalle: That just makes it so much worse because you did not have to you didn't have to do any of this. But if you were going to off somebody, why both of your parents? Why not do this while your mom was out line dancing and then it could have just been your dad since that was the problem? I don't understand. Nicholle: We didn't. Mm-hmm. Right. Mm-hmm. Or how about you just leave your parents' house? How about you just be a big fucking girl, put your big girl panties on, and say, I'm not doing what you said, I'm leaving. And I know this is a different culture, but when we are talking about somebody killing their parents, you have other options. It's not like she was being abused. It's not like she was being in this house in the basement or something. This these she had options. She chose not to take. Zalle: I mean that too. That too. Since you were sneaking around anyways. Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Well she chose to take the stand, right? And she claimed that she was a victim. She cries. She says she loves her parents, but obviously the jury is not buying it because your dad is literally telling us the truth. We're there when all of this happened. Yeah. Nicholle: Mm. Exactly. Right. You didn't you didn't count on that part. So on December thirteenth, twenty fourteen, BJ's birthday, the verdict. Jennifer Pann guilty of first degree murder and attempted murder. Daniel Wong, guilty. Lamford Crawford, guilty. David ⁓ four life in prison, no parole for twenty-five years. Zalle: Right, and so Eric Carty, he was tried separately and he pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit murder. He got eighteen years, but he died in prison in April of twenty eighteen. However, Felix ⁓ Han both wrote victim impact statements and Felix wasn't in court that day, but his statement was read out loud. Like a dark shadow, this is something that I cannot hide from. I lost my mother. Nicholle: Yeah. Khan's statement revealed the depth of the fracture. He wrote that Felix was silent and distant and wouldn't talk to him. My son doesn't want to hear his sister's name. I hope someday my daughter can become a good and honest person. Zalle: that even after all of this, you standing up there taking the stand and you still are trying to have some kind of faith in your daughter. That's parents love, okay? But however the judge grants two noncommunication lifetime noncommunication orders for the brother and for the dad. One banning the defendants from contacting each other and one at the family's request of banning Jennifer from a ever contacting either her brother or her father again. Nicholle: Mm. That is. That is. Mm-hmm. Zalle: And Jennifer's lawyer addresses it in court. Jennifer is open to communicating with her family if they wanted to. They obviously did not. And I don't know why you would think that they would want to have any kind of communication with you. Nicholle: And she doesn't deserve it. She doesn't deserve it. Don't I don't care if what you're open to. You're crazy and you killed my wife and my mother. And you shot me in my face. Zalle: My wife and my and shot me in my face, the center of my face. Nicholle: centered. Now I I can't see. And that is a reminder, beside the utter heartbreak of losing my wife and my daughter, is I ⁓ see. So every day I remember why I'm in this situation. So ⁓ nearly a decade the verdict stands. And then in May of twenty twenty three, the Ontario Court of Appeal orders a new trial. Zalle: My wife You you. Nicholle: The trial judge erred by not letting the jury consider lesser included offenses, like manslaughter or different options. Zalle: Which is diabolical. Diabolical. And I actually if you even if you just Google it, for those who just wanna know, just Google their names. You know, the Jennifer Pan suspect and they you can the appeals and they show up. You they pop right on up and you can read their appeals. Insane. Nicholle: Time about. Yeah. Zalle: Insane, but you know what? That is the justice system because it's really not a justice system, it's just a legal system, it has nothing to do with justice, just the law. So in April 2025, the Supreme Court upholded seven to two, in March of this year, 2026, the retrial began. Okay, February 2nd ⁓ this year, Daniel Wong Nicholle: That is our justice system. No. Yes. Zalle: plead guilty to manslaughter and then march thirteenth, Leonard Crawford pleads guilty to conspiracy Lenford Lenford Lenford. Nicholle: Just not linen. Mm-hmm. It's a stupid name. Zalle: Lenford Crawford pleads guilty to conspiracy to commit murder. And on March eighteenth, Jennifer Pan pleads guilty to manslaughter, which nobody was expecting because all of the whole reason why they were fighting was because she kept holding on to her innocence. But then you're gonna plead to manslaughter, right? But she says, I'm ashamed of what I did. She alleges that Han was abusive and controlling that she only wanted to kill him, but concedes she should have known her mother would be in harm's way, obviously. Nicholle: Right. She did it with it. Mm. Zalle: You knew that. And the crazy part about this, the crazy part about this is both Ricardo Duncan, which is the original guy that she connected with to try to do this, he just got in trouble not too long ago for some kind of crazy shit. And then Lenford Crawford, while right after he pled guilty, I think it was like a couple of weeks after he pled guilty, he was found with they said it was like a whole bunch of Nicholle: Yeah. Yeah. Zalle: Either the drugs or the money from drugs like selling drugs in prison. Nicholle: Wow. So he's just gonna be a criminal wherever he's at. Zalle: So Yeah. Yeah. Mind you, I don't know how you're able to do that in prison to like bank up 'cause it was like ten thousand dollars worth like it was big, big amount of either you know, weed Nicholle: So and So just like I am willing to believe almost anything about our government these days, I am also willing to believe that people do whatever they want in prison as long as normally they don't get caught. But but unfortunately, Jennifer is now eligible for parole on the manslaughter charge, but the attempted murder conviction still stands, complicating any release. That's what I was wondering. And here's the kicker. Jennifer still says that Zalle: Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Nicholle: That she's innocent. Zalle: How? Nicholle: How? You just said you just you pled guilty and you said you're ashamed of what you did. But you didn't do it. You absolutely didn't do it, but I'm ashamed of it. Zalle: Play guilty. What you did, but then you're still but you didn't do it. Absolutely. Yeah. So I mean, where does that even leave us? One, Han Pan is blinded, betrayed, but he is alive. Unfortunately, had to go through this horrible experience. Bich Ha Pan she's dead. The mother of two who tried to protect her daughter and the daughter who ordered her murder. Her literally her last words were Please don't hurt my daughter. Insane. Felix Pann the brother who testified against Jennifer, who wrote about the dark shadow that follows him, got a restraining order and then disappeared from public life. He was like, I don't have time for this. Yeah. Yeah. Nicholle: Don't hurt my dog. Good for him. Good for him. Yeah. And then we have Jennifer Pann. she is eligible for parole, still claiming her innocence, still performing. Was this tiger parenting pushed too far or a manipulative narcissist who chose murder over honesty? I choose option two. The twenty fourteen jury believed the latter. The twenty twenty six court settled somewhere in between. Zalle: Option two. Okay, but here's what we know so far f for sure. Right? On November eighth, two thousand and ten, Jennifer Pan unlocked her front door. got the text game time, and then three men walked in and destroyed her whole family. Everything else, the lies, the trial, the appeals, the parole hearings. ⁓ just the aftermath of that one choice. Because regardless, you unlock the door. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. That's right. You unlocked the door, possibly flashed the lights, you had the conversations before all of this, you listened to all of this happening. Yeah, you knew you deserve to be in jail for the rest of your life. She spent ten years pretending to be someone she wasn't, and when the facade crumbled, she didn't choose therapy or honesty, she didn't choose any of that. She didn't even choose to run away, like I was saying. She chose Zalle: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Nicholle: murder. And the only thing more elaborate than her lies was the plot to cover them up. This girl is evil and she needs to remain in prison for the rest of her life. Zalle: Evil. Yeah, I concur. Well, if you guys liked this episode, please like, comment, review. Even if you just review our podcast as a whole, we need. We need it. We need it. Nicholle: Do we need it? We need to hear what you think. We need we need some feedback, peep please. Zalle: Yes, yes. And if you guys are interested in being on the podcast or if you guys have any cases or topics or whatever the case is, please reach out to us at Coffee and Crime with Mom at Gmail or at Coffee and Crime with Mom at Hotmail. You can even check us out on any of the socials at the same name, okay? Nicholle: And it's G S Coffee and Crane with Mom at G Mail, not hotmail. Zalle: I say happen. Nicholle: You did. You acted like an old. Zalle: either it was supposed to be out it was supposed to be Outlook, not hot mail. A hot yeah. Yeah. I did. It's it's Nicholle: It was you said Outlook, but then you said hot mail instead of Gmail. So you got the Outlook right. It was the other one. It's okay. Zalle: Yikes. Well, we're we we've we've got email accounts. And you can email us. Nicholle: Yes, if you search for Coffee and Crime with Mom, you will find us on just about every social. ⁓ we have a nice little group we started on Facebook where we do some special posts and polls and things like that. So please just find us, tell us what you think, share us with your family and friends if you enjoy us. And I'm Nicole. Zalle: Yeah. Nobody said thanks to listening to Coughing Carmine. Nicholle: You did. That's what you said at first. Thanks for listening to Cough and Cry of Mine, right? Zalle: Think so. Nicholle: Okay, say it. Zalle: Thanks for listening to Coffee and Crying with Ma. Nicholle: I'm Nicole, Mom. Stay caffeinated, stay curious, and we'll see you next time. Bye guys. Zalle: And I'm Zalle Too-daloo.