Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline For Thursday, August 24, 2023
Transcript
- 0:10Dave Wilson in the big chair, sitting in for Hoppy Kirchival as the Goat
- 0:16continues his vacation. Lots to talk about today after the big debate last night,
- 0:21Metro News talk Line is underway. Welcome radio turned off from the studios
- 0:36of w VRC Media and the Metro News Radio Network, the voice of West
- 0:41Virginia comes the most powerful radio show in West Virginia. This this he Metro
- 0:47News Talk Live with Hobby Kirchival Activated switch network chill from Charles stand by you,
- 0:56Hoppy. You're on Metro News talk Line with Hoppy Kirchible is brought to
- 1:00you by in Covia Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care
- 1:06about most. Visiting coovid dot com to learn more. Good morning, Welcome
- 1:10to Metrodows talk Line from the Incoba Insurance studios. Dave Wilson sitting in for
- 1:14Hoppy Kirchiville. Today we'll react to you last night's Republican presidential primary debates.
- 1:22Also, Brad McElhenny will stop by. We'll chat with Brad. There was
- 1:26all there was a record settlement reached in an absolute atrocious abuse case out of
- 1:33Harrison County. We'll talk to the attorneys in that case. I want to
- 1:38hear from you this morning as well. Eight hundred and seven six five Talk
- 1:41is the phone number and three or four Talk three or four is the text
- 1:42line. Joe Nelson, audio producer Today and Luke Rowsy is our video producer
- 1:49for Today's Affairs. Got a poll up on Twitter the higher X Excuse me,
- 1:53I guess it's an ex poll up on what used to be Twitter.
- 1:59Highly scientific, as they say, but I want to know if you watch
- 2:01the debate last night, the Republican presidential debate last night, who won?
- 2:07Simple question right? Your choices are on the Twitter poll Trump even though he
- 2:13wasn't there, Rod de Santis, Vivic Rossaswamy or Nikki Hailey. And I'm
- 2:19just not going to stop calling a Twitter. I hope that's okay with you.
- 2:22My Twitter handle is at day Wilson, m N final results at the
- 2:25end of the show. I put him on the spot yesterday. He was
- 2:30kind enough to come back again this morning to post view last night's Republican presidential
- 2:35primary debate. Contributing columnist for The Washington Post, former executive with the West
- 2:38Virginia Republican Party. Gary Abernathy joins us again on talk Line this morning.
- 2:45Is the question that's simple, Gary, who won the debate last night?
- 2:47Well, that's always a good question after debate, And the answer you cited
- 2:52is probably right, Dave, because no one really did anything to knock Trump
- 2:58off that top spot. There were some good performances, and we'll talk about
- 3:00that, I'm sure, but you know, no one had that knockout punch
- 3:05or really did anything that's going to Trump support is so calcified. I don't
- 3:10think that's going to change. But last night, if you like politics especially
- 3:15it was it was kind of a fun event. It was an opportunity.
- 3:20I think without Trump there, Gary, it allowed if you watched it,
- 3:23it allowed you to for the first time, really get to know these eight
- 3:29candidates. Certainly, I think most folks are familiar with the names, but
- 3:32to get to hear where Nicky Haley is on the abortion issue, or Ronda
- 3:37Santis, to hear Mike Pis, to get to hear them state where they
- 3:40are. I think that was a good a good opportunity without Trump in the
- 3:45room to just take take everything away, that was a good opportunity last night.
- 3:50I think that's a very good point, Dave. I think that people
- 3:52got to, you know, maybe look at a field and some of whom
- 3:55might be open or up for a future consideration, even if people aren't considering
- 4:00them this year. And some people, let's be honest, a couple people
- 4:03on that stage were probably auditioning for the role of Trump's vice president. When
- 4:09he gets around to making that, I'm sorry, who stood out to you
- 4:13last night? Well, I think, well, first of all, and
- 4:15again, this is not necessarily auditioning for vice president. I thought Nicki Haley
- 4:18had a strong night. If I were to rank how everybody did, I
- 4:24would say Haley was best. I would say Mike Pence did very well,
- 4:29and I expected him too. Frankly, I thought he would be given more
- 4:31of an opportunity. And I think Ramaswamy did well. But again, he's
- 4:38very glib. This kind of a debate is right up his alley. He
- 4:42comes in talking, he leaves talking, and he's smart, and he's glib,
- 4:46and he's very good. I was a little surprised, you know.
- 4:49Today I saw a graphic from the Washington Post which showed how much time each
- 4:55candidate was a lot, how much time they ended up speaking, and I
- 5:00was a little surprised that Nicki Haley was pretty down lower in the pack.
- 5:06She only spoke for about eight minutes. Toad. I think the leader,
- 5:11I forget which one that was spoke for about twelve minutes, but Haley only
- 5:15had about eight minutes, and yet it seemed like she was speaking much longer,
- 5:19which I think is a testament to how effective she was being when she
- 5:24did have a chance. So I thought, you know, she was the
- 5:28best at really seeming experienced, seeming logical, and was kind of looking ahead,
- 5:33you know, past just the Republican primary, but with looking ahead to
- 5:36the general election, realizing whoever comes out of this has to have some appeal
- 5:43to a broader electorate beyond Republicans. Gry Abernathy joining us this morning, contributing
- 5:47columnist for The Washington Post, former executive with West Virginia Republican Party. What
- 5:53moments of the debate or what moment stood out to you the most. I
- 5:58think that, you know, a lot of the back and forth with Ramaswamy
- 6:01was obviously attention getting. That's the kind of television that they're shooting for.
- 6:08I thought Mike Pence was strong when he talked about January sixth, when he
- 6:13talked about the decision he had to make. Now a lot of us have
- 6:15heard him make this comment before, but here he is on the debate stage,
- 6:18and the question came to all the candidates, did Mike Pence do the
- 6:23right thing on January sixth? That that was really the question, And when
- 6:26it was finally his turn to address it, he talked about the you know,
- 6:30the difficult position he was put in and having to defend the constitution over
- 6:36over Donald Trump. And it's a good point that probably a lot of people
- 6:41were hearing for the first time. But Dave, what also struck me and
- 6:44this whole debate was, Frankly, how a little time they spent talking about
- 6:47Trump. I mean, and I thought, frankly, that was wrong.
- 6:50And I think that's that's that's a function of the network it was on,
- 6:56you know, Fox News didn't want to make it's audience too upset. But
- 7:02you've got a situation here where Trump has a thirty, forty or fifty point
- 7:06lead in this primary race, depending on what poll you're looking at, and
- 7:10yet he's facing four indictments and a lot of time in court. And the
- 7:15question should have been Should Trump be charged? Should Trump be indicted? You
- 7:23know? Should? They did ask will you raise your hand if you're going
- 7:25to support Trump? But there's and I'm someone who thinks there's actually a defense
- 7:30to be made of Trump, you know, but make them make it.
- 7:33These candidates should have been forced to either defend Trump and say, here's why
- 7:38I think this is wrong. Here's because he's going to be the nominee,
- 7:42Dave. And yet only really Christy and Hutchinson were willing to take that on
- 7:47because they wanted to. That's their whole that's their whole strategy. So I
- 7:50was surprised. I think this if it had been on any other network,
- 7:55Trump would have been much more of a conversation piece. Yeah, I was
- 8:00surprised, but not surprised that it took an hour to get to the nine
- 8:05hundred pound gorilla in the room. I want to play a couple of clips
- 8:07here, and these are the Trump questions. First, here's Nicky Haley on
- 8:11Trump that it is time for a new generational conservative leader. We have to
- 8:16look at the fact that three quarters of Americans don't want a rematch between Trump
- 8:22and Biden, and we have to face the fact that Trump is the most
- 8:26disliked politician in America. We can't win a general election that way. She
- 8:33got some booze, but I think she's right. Gary, Yeah, I
- 8:35do too. I think she was very right on target, very smart to
- 8:39bring up those points. This is what people have to consider. Even if
- 8:43you still like Trump. I still like Trump. I'm just upset at what
- 8:46he did, not accepting the election results. I'm still glad he was president.
- 8:50When he was president, but he you know, he had his chance
- 8:54and he blew it, in my opinion, So Nicky Hale is exactly right
- 9:00to face reality. Even if you like Trump, don't you want to win
- 9:03in twenty twenty four? Don't you want Biden not to be president anymore?
- 9:07If you're a Republican, And the way to make sure that happens is frankly
- 9:11not with Donald Trump. And I think that Nicki Haley made a really strong
- 9:15case for that. And of course, Chris Christy's kind of based his whole
- 9:18campaign on being I guess the anti Trump. Here is his response. Here's
- 9:22the bottom line. Someone's got to stop normalizing this conduct. Okay, now
- 9:33and now, whether or not, whether or not you believe that the criminal
- 9:39charges are right or wrong. The conduct is beneath the office of President of
- 9:46the United States. Okay, a little mix of applause and booze there,
- 9:54but I don't find myself disagreeing with that statement. Gary. Yeah, well,
- 9:58Chris Christie's going to win the non MAGA vote in the Republican Party.
- 10:05Unfortunately for Chris Christie that's only ten to twenty percent and it's not going to
- 10:09get him very far. But he's clearly cornering the market on that. And
- 10:13frankly, Dave, if you're going to get into the race, if you're
- 10:16going to run for this nomination, that's the way to do it. You
- 10:20have to take on Trump. If you're going to defend Trump, if you're
- 10:24gonna if you're gonna say he's a victim of a deep state attack, etc.
- 10:28Etc. Then just support Trump. Don't be running against him, because
- 10:33you're not really running against him. People were hearing what you have to say
- 10:35and say, yeah, that's why I'm supporting Trump. It just doesn't make
- 10:39any sense. So at least Chris Christie is taking a logical approach to the
- 10:45campaign. The guy I don't hear a lot of folks talking about this morning,
- 10:48is the supposed number two in the race. That's Ron de Santis.
- 10:52Nothing really stood out to me. I still think Gary he may be the
- 10:56best to govern, But just thing in that debate stood out to me from
- 11:01Ron de Santis last night. No, I think you're right. You know,
- 11:05he did fine, and doing fine is not what he needed if he
- 11:11was going to make any more inroads. You know, a few months ago,
- 11:13DeSantis had had the momentum. Everyone was talking about how he was going
- 11:16to overtake Trump. He was going to be the alternative to Trump. People
- 11:20who liked Trump and like what Trump stood for could transfer that to DeSantis because
- 11:26he was kind of Trump without the baggage. But again, people are going,
- 11:30well, yeah, we kind of feel that way, but we have
- 11:33the real thing. We have Trump, and so DeSantis needs to really excel
- 11:39and he did. He did fine, but doing fine is not good enough.
- 11:43He seemed pretty rehearsed. Anybody who follows politics, most of what DeSantis
- 11:48said is what he says every day on the campaign trail, on the stump,
- 11:52it was just like, you know, push button, see here comes
- 11:56that answer, and he didn't really do anything to stand out for the crowd.
- 12:01Final question, moving forward from today on Gary did. Did one of
- 12:03these candidates separate themselves from the race for number two? And that's what it
- 12:09is right at the moment, the race for number two. Yeah. Again,
- 12:13I think Nicky Haley did. And I don't know if anyone's ever asked
- 12:16Haley, would you would you run with Donald Trump? Would you be his
- 12:20vice president if he asked you to be? I don't know if she's answered
- 12:24that. If she has, she's probably given the standard answer that I'm not
- 12:28focused on that, I'm focused on winning, and so probably probably would avoid
- 12:31it. But if anyone, you know, if Donald Trump was watching,
- 12:35and you know he was last night, or he'll watch it at some point,
- 12:37he's got to be thinking to himself, you know, if she would
- 12:41run with him, And again, a lot of candidates wouldn't run was Donald
- 12:43Trump, But if she would do it, she would strengthen that ticket quite
- 12:48a bit and have a broad broader appeal. I think I think if anyone
- 12:52came out last night better than when they went into it, it was Nicky
- 12:54Haley. Did you watch Trump on Twitter or X with Tucker Carlson at all
- 13:00last night? I thought I heard some excerch from I heard some some quotes
- 13:03from what they talked about. No, I hadn't seen any of it.
- 13:07Mean, I can only focus on one thing at a time, Gary,
- 13:09right exactly. I heard that it went for about forty minutes, and they
- 13:15didn't really break any new ground. He kind of repeated the same old,
- 13:18same old. But I don't I don't know, because I'll get around to
- 13:20hearing it eventually. Problem I'm sure, Well maybe no, I'm sure we'll
- 13:24hear from the former president later today. Right, Well, yes, against
- 13:30what's he's supposed to turn himself in tonight? Do we have a time I
- 13:35thought I wouldn't say yesterday. He's going to arrive in Atlanta in the afternoon
- 13:37and show up in the evening. So maybe he's shooting for that time that
- 13:41primetime audience. Dave, he would surrent for his surrender. Gary Abernathy,
- 13:48contributing columnist for The Washington Times. Yes, it is former executive with the
- 13:52West Virginia Republican Party. Two days in a row, Gary, I appreciate
- 13:56it, thanks so much, Thank you day appreciate it absolutely. I want
- 14:00to hear from you this morning. Eight hundred and seven six five talk the
- 14:01phone number three or four, Talk three or four is the text line,
- 14:05did you watch what did you take away? Were Who were you impressed with?
- 14:09Who are you not impressed with? Or were you watching reruns of Seinfeld
- 14:15last night? It's a viable option. Eight hundred and seven six five talks
- 14:18the phone number. Three or four Talk three or four is the text line.
- 14:22Dave Wilson setting in for Hoppy Kirchibile Indian Coba Insurance Studios. We're back
- 14:26in a moment. Are you tired of joint pain or muscle injuries holding you
- 14:30back? Trust the experts at CMC Orthopedics and CMC Orthopedic Trauma for personalized treatment
- 14:37options tailored to your needs. CMC offers comprehensive orthopedic treatment for all types of
- 14:41pain and injuries. Our specialists provide tailored options from diagnosis to rehab with state
- 14:48of the art facilities for top quality care. Visit CMC dot org slash Orthopedics
- 14:54to learn more. Metro News Talk Line with Hobby Kirchiblas brought to you by
- 15:09in Coca Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most.
- 15:15Visitingcoca dot com to learn more. Three or four Talk three or four
- 15:18is the text line eight hundred and seven six five eight two five five.
- 15:20That is the phone number. Twitter pole at Dave Wilson m N is my
- 15:26Twitter handle? Who won the debate? Trump? DeSantis, Pavek, Nicky,
- 15:31Haley way In at at Dave Wilson m N my Twitter handle. Let
- 15:35me see it's pretty well. Here's the overwhelming takeaway from the highly unscientific and
- 15:43anecdotal Twitter pole. DeSantis is fourth and I did spell Vvec's last name wrong.
- 15:50I do apologize. I don't have the edit button on my tweets.
- 15:56Ramaswamy with thirty almost thirty four percent, then Haley thirty two, Trump twenty
- 16:00one, and De Santa's twelve the early numbers in the highly unscientific anecdotal Twitter
- 16:07flash poll final results at the end of the show, let me get to
- 16:11some text. I want to hear from you what you thought of the debate?
- 16:15Who won, who lost? Or were you watching something else? Three
- 16:18or four Talk three or four. Dave Biden won the debate last night.
- 16:25Dave. I'm sorry, but someone who tries to steal and cheat during election
- 16:26should not be allowed to run again. Trump should not be allowed to run
- 16:30again. It's not fair It's like letting someone cheat on a test and giving
- 16:33them an a. Dave, anybody who watched the debate as a loser get
- 16:40a life, Dave. Good job strong arming mister Abernathy to coming back today.
- 16:45I didn't intend that, but I really did put them on the spot
- 16:48yesterday. Dave. I'm glad they did not address Trump in the first debate.
- 16:56I wanted more time to hear their views on the issues. There's time
- 17:00for them to focus more on the Trump issue and in further debates. You
- 17:03know, there is a there is an argument to be made that the Republican
- 17:10base, the Republican voters do want to hear from the issues rather than where
- 17:15you want where you stand on Trump. Now, I do think that needs
- 17:18to be addressed. I would have addressed it earlier and then moved on to
- 17:22issues such as Ukraine, abortion, energy policy, foreign policy, et cetera,
- 17:29et cetera. That did get addressed last night. But you could not
- 17:33go through the debate. You could not not go through the debate without mentioning
- 17:37Trump. Double negative. That was grammatically a train wreck. But you get
- 17:40my point. It had to be brought up, It had to be addressed.
- 17:45But I do understand the argument, and I do understand the sentiment that
- 17:48the Republican base wants to hear policy. And which of these candidates do you
- 17:56find yourself agreeing with policy? Three or four? Talk three or four?
- 18:03Dave, your guest is high of Christy getting ten to twenty percent of the
- 18:07vote, Dave House Trump the GOP front runner when he's not participating in the
- 18:11GOP nomination process and refuses to agree to support anyone else if they win the
- 18:17GOP nought, he's already admitting his intent to deny voters of their voice.
- 18:22Why is the front runner Because he's leading in the polls for the Republican nomination.
- 18:26That's why he's the front runner. I do get your broader points that
- 18:30he's not really participating in debate, he's not facing challenges from the other contenders.
- 18:37And you're right, he's said, not said that he would support one
- 18:42of the other contenders if they would win the nomination. If your broader point
- 18:48is that he's really not supporting the Republican Party, yeah, you've got a
- 18:52good point, Dave. I had an early meeting today, so I was
- 18:57sleeping last night, Dave. More people watch the Tucker interview than the debate
- 19:04twenty three million that voted in twenty twenty eighty seven million views. Keep in
- 19:08mind those views can be I think twenty seconds, that's a view. I
- 19:15think a lot of people did drive bys last night. I don't I don't
- 19:18know if there's data or if it would be published. How many people stuck
- 19:21around for the entire forty minutes. Dave Trump will win the nomination for two
- 19:26main reasons. One because Republicans love what he did as president. Two,
- 19:32they're not going to stand by and let these Marxist Democrats take out the nomination
- 19:36with third world political hit jobs. Trump may win the nomination, he will
- 19:45not win in November. That I am very very confident of. He will
- 19:51not win in a general election. So do you want to nominate him to
- 19:56flip the bird to the left, or do you want to nominate somebody that
- 19:59can beat a sitting president. That's the question for the Republican Party, that's
- 20:04the question for Republican voters. Between now and the end of primary season,
- 20:11we'll continue to discuss. Coming up a little bit more, Robert Bolton's going
- 20:15to join me, political science professor at Fairmont State University, will get his
- 20:18take on the debate. Also, speaking of President Trump, he'll be turning
- 20:22himself into authorities in Georgia today for his fourth indictment. We'll discuss. We'll
- 20:29take your calls, text and tweets as well. Eight hundred seven six five
- 20:32talks. The phone number at three or four Talk three oh four is the
- 20:34text line Dave Wilson in for Hoppy kirchible from the Incovia Insurance Studios. It's
- 20:40the talk linel Metro News, the voice of West Virginia. Metro News.
- 20:56Talk line continues from the Cove Insurance Studios. Work security a serious business,
- 21:00and sitting net is serious about protecting your business and your employees from today's constant
- 21:07branch of cybersecurity threats. Let's sitting net be your cybersecurity hero. Learn more
- 21:11at sittynet dot NEM. We're gonna talk to Robert Bolton, political science professor
- 21:15at Fairmont State University, but first let me squeeze in a call Dwayne in
- 21:18Morgantown. Let's react to the last night's debate. Hey Dwayne, Hey day,
- 21:23though you do on the day doing great? Dwayne? What do you
- 21:25think? Well? I tell you the thing that someone when when someone says
- 21:30that Trump should have taken part in this. And again, I don't like
- 21:33Trump or Biden. I'm an independent. I try to try to go with
- 21:37what I think is best for my family and my country. But Biden is
- 21:41on the record he's not going to debate Robert Robert F. Kennedy Junior,
- 21:47which he's got like thirty almost thirty percent, twenty five percent of support right
- 21:52now. So for someone to say that that Trump should be in that debate,
- 21:56there's people in that debate that have less than two percent support. I
- 22:00wouldn't. I wouldn't do that if I was him, just as a why
- 22:03would I do that? Right? Yeah, here's the sad thing. The
- 22:07sad part of it is that we're probably going to be stuck having to choose
- 22:11between Biden and Trump. I mean, there's probably just no other way of
- 22:15getting around it the way they've got to set up, which is unfortunate to
- 22:18us as a because I think that Trump sounds like an idiot when he talks.
- 22:22But we had the lowest cash prices I've ever remembered. Our country wasn't
- 22:26near nuclear war with Russia, even though they said that we were going to
- 22:30be. And now we've got a guy in office that can barely function,
- 22:33and we're probably closer to nuclear war with Russia than we've ever been he has.
- 22:40It just makes no sense why we can't have a better system to pick
- 22:42from. I guess that's what I'm getting too. Well, Dwayne, maybe
- 22:45I'm I don't know. Maybe I've had too much coffee this morning. I
- 22:48didn't have a centimon roll with breakfast today, So maybe I'm being naively optimistic.
- 22:52But go back to twenty sixteen, or I guess it would have been
- 22:56twenty fifteen. You know, August of fifteen, was anybody saying with confidence
- 23:02Donald Trump was going to be the nominee? Then, I mean if twenty
- 23:04sixteen tons anything, Dwayne, anything can happen. So yes, all the
- 23:10data points that direction. But for some reason today I'm saying, let's wait
- 23:15and let's see what happens over the next couple of months. So we'll see.
- 23:18Did you did you see how many views? I just checked the views.
- 23:22I didn't watch it, but I wanted to see how many views the
- 23:25Donald Trump thing with Tucker Carson Tucker had on Twitter. Did you see how
- 23:29many views? It was like one hundred thirty million? I think the number
- 23:32I saw d and seventy million call it this morning. Yeah, I said
- 23:37in the previous segment though, though, Dwayne, that could be that could
- 23:40be drive by. You don't have to stay very long for the for a
- 23:42view to count, and I think a lot of people were probably interested to
- 23:45see what he said and then moved on. So I don't know what to
- 23:51make of that. To be honest, let's say that. Let's say that
- 23:52ten percent watched it completely because they support him. Okay, that's still seventeen
- 23:57million views versus what Fox, because it's going to get Fox will probably get
- 24:00four or five. Yeah, it's not insignificant at all. Hey, Dwayne,
- 24:06gotta move on. I want to get to Robert here, but I
- 24:07appreciate the calls always Seyboddy, how is he? Amen? Dwayne and Morgantown.
- 24:11Let's bring in Robert Bolton blakele science professor at Fairmont State University, Friend
- 24:15of the show, Robert, Good morning, How are you hi, Dave.
- 24:19It's always good to be back on. I'm doing well today. Oh
- 24:22what did you make of the debate last night? Well? I definitely thought
- 24:26it was entertaining, as the candidates themselves and the moderators acknowledged obviously the significant
- 24:34absence of Donald Trump was felt. But even with his absince, you did
- 24:40see some rhetorical fireworks between some of the candidates. I think probably the two
- 24:45who engaged to the most fierce verbal combat were Governor Chris Christy and the new
- 24:51candidate vavec Rama Swamy. And it was certainly interesting to hear what they had
- 24:56to say. It was also somewhat surprising, or at least it was for
- 25:00me to hear how many of the Republican candidates were supportive of Mike Pence's position
- 25:07concerning the issue over the January sixth vote counting in the Electoral College. That
- 25:15actually surprised me a great deal. How So why because that seems to me
- 25:19like it would be a no brainer to be supportive of Pence. But why
- 25:22would that surprise you? I think ultimately many of these candidates are trying to
- 25:29keep their feet in two different positions when it comes to well, we are
- 25:34obviously running for president. We believe that we're the best candidates, but at
- 25:40the same time, we want to portray sympathy for former President Donald Trump,
- 25:45and certainly within the Republican Party base, obviously, Donald Trump is leading in
- 25:52the polls, and I think a significant, probably majority, but certainly at
- 25:56least a significant minority of Republican Party voters feel that Donald Trump was treated unfairly
- 26:03in the twenty twenty election and are actually in opposition to Mike Pence's position on
- 26:08whether or not the electoral votes should have been counted. On January six,
- 26:12twenty one, talking to Robert Bolton, political science professor at Fairmont State University,
- 26:18did any of the candidates separate themselves in your opinion? Well, I
- 26:22think the two that certainly separated themselves or the audience separated them were Governor Chris
- 26:29Christie and Governor Asa Hutchinson of Arkansas. When you were seeing the inner reductions
- 26:34for each of the candidates, I thought it was very telling that those two
- 26:37governors were the only ones that were generally booed by the audience. One person
- 26:45who I think certainly did distinguish themselves and will probably see a bump of their
- 26:49poll numbers is Vivek Ramaswamy. I felt that he was willing to engage in
- 26:56verbal combat with the other candidates and was certainly on to stake out some positions
- 27:02that were consider I would consider more confrontational, confrontational than many of the other
- 27:07candidates. The thing about Vavec Robert that came across to me and maybe this
- 27:14is old guy syndrome sneaking in on me here, but he felt like,
- 27:19have you ever had that job where they hire the hot shot college kid to
- 27:25be your boss for the job that you've been doing for years that you know
- 27:27inside. Now, now he's going to come in and tell you that you've
- 27:30been doing it wrong and here's the right way to do it, and you
- 27:33just kind of want to slap him. That's kind of I just kind of
- 27:37wanted to slap him last night. Well, and Chris, Chris the at
- 27:41one point did specifically call him out concerning that the chat GTP comment, right,
- 27:45Yeah, the chat GPT, I mean Governor Chris the Supporter opposed him.
- 27:51He certainly is someone who can gauge in some pretty whip witty wepper repartee.
- 27:56But yeah, Vavec is thirty eight years I'm thirty four years old.
- 28:02Now I could tell you certainly if I was running for president, that would
- 28:04be an extremely daunting task. And the VEC certainly cast the appearance that he
- 28:11was very confident. One thing that did surprise me, or I shouldn't say
- 28:15surprised me, but to strike my interest is what was concerning his proposal to
- 28:21slash significant parts of the federal budget concerning Department of Education, Department of Labor,
- 28:27many of the other government agencies currently in existence. But by and large,
- 28:33none of the Republican candidates talked about one of the single biggest line items
- 28:38in the federal budget, which is the fence spending or Social Security, or
- 28:42at least if they touched on it, it was only a momentary passing comment.
- 28:48But yeah, I think the vex certainly when he said that everyone else
- 28:52on the stage that evening was beholden to paid interest. That was the one
- 28:57moment I noticed that many of his comments received booze from the audience, and
- 29:03I certainly think generated some ill will on his part among the other candidates.
- 29:08And it will be interesting to see whoever does ultimately win the nomination whether or
- 29:14not they would make any type of cabinet position to offer to him after those
- 29:18comments. Robert Bolton, joining US political science professor at Fairmont State University.
- 29:22Let's pivot to former President Donald Trump, who was not there last night but
- 29:26is scheduled to surrender to authorities in Georgia later today. What should we expect
- 29:33Well, by and large, these arraignments are very closely organized, and given
- 29:40Donald Trump's high profile position as a former president, you can rest assured that
- 29:45the Secret Service has already scoped out the area and made sure that there's going
- 29:49to be a security clearance before he would ever step foot in any courthouse or
- 29:56jail. Donald Trump is being charged with thirteen counts, primarily under the reco
- 30:03Act. That's the most notable offense that he's alleged to have violated under Tile
- 30:08sixteen of the Georgia Code. What you're going to see happen is is he
- 30:12will appear before the judge. He will have his bond set at two hundred
- 30:18thousand dollars. This will be the first of the four cases he's currently under
- 30:22indictment where he will actually have to post a cash bond. The others have
- 30:27been a personal recognizance bond up to this point, so that is something that
- 30:33is especially surprising. He's also going to be booked and processed where he will
- 30:37be fingerprinted, his information will be entered into their database, and you're likely
- 30:41going to see the release of a mug shot later today or possibly tomorrow.
- 30:48It ought to be interesting Robert mug shot of a former president. Yes,
- 30:52don't know. Hopefully we never see that ever again, and it's going to
- 30:56be interesting. That's I just don't know where to go from there. It's
- 31:00it's a weird time. Yeah, it certainly is. I've always felt since
- 31:04the beginning of Donald Trump's legal woes after he left the presidency that the Georgia
- 31:10case was actually the one where he was facing the greatest peril when you look
- 31:15at the other three cases, one of them is in state court, the
- 31:18New York cush money case, and most legal experts, or at least among
- 31:23the commentary I've read, have regarded that as a relatively weak case. Even
- 31:30the district attorney who's prosecuting at Alvin Bragg initially was opposed to using this particular
- 31:36legal theory to charge Donald Trump. The two federal cases concerning the classified documents
- 31:41and the events related to January sixth, are both being pursued in federal court
- 31:47with the special prosecutor Jack Smith. And in those cases, if Donald Trump
- 31:52is able to delay the trials until after the election, and that's a big
- 31:57if, but if he's able to delay them or delay any sentencing until after
- 32:02the election, and he is able to be sworn in on January twentieth,
- 32:10twenty twenty five, he can order his Attorney general to dismiss any pending prosecution,
- 32:17and if there's a conviction already in place, theoretically Donald Trump could pardon
- 32:22himself. There's a law debate on whether or not a president has that power
- 32:27to pardon themselves, but it's certainly something where it's been There have been multiple
- 32:31law review articles are in on the issue, and there's no clear cut answer.
- 32:36Georgia, on the other hand, is a state prosecution, so even
- 32:39if Donald Trump is elected president, Georgia's state authorities, this Fulton County prosecutor
- 32:49Missus Willis, can go forward with the case. And finally, the last
- 32:53thing to remember that is is if he is convicted. Under Georgia law,
- 32:58with a few limited exceptions, a defendant is not eligible for a pardon until
- 33:05five years after their criminal sentence has been discharged. So Donald Trump couldn't go
- 33:10to Governor Kemp for example, and say, hey, would you please pardon
- 33:15me? That wouldn't be something that would be likely to happen under current Georgia's
- 33:20state law, and I believe they have a The governor can't even just issue
- 33:23that they have a panel down there as well, so we're gonna have to.
- 33:27It's gonna be interesting to watch this all play out. Robert Bolton,
- 33:30political science professor, Fairmont State University. Robert appreciate it as always, Buddy,
- 33:34Hey, thank you. Dave. Good to be back on absolutely at
- 33:37Dave Wilson MN is my Twitter handle. Highly unscientific anecdotal pulled up there for
- 33:43today. Who won the GOP presidential debate last night? Trump, de Santis,
- 33:46Vivic or Nicky Haley? Final results at the end of the show.
- 33:52Come it up your thoughts at eight hundred and seven and six five Talk in
- 33:55three or four Talk three or four plus more national attention on WV We'll get
- 34:00to that coming up as well. Dave Wilson in the big chair for Hoppy
- 34:02Kirchbill. It's talk line from the Cove Insurance Studios Metro News talk Line with
- 34:19Hobby Kirchabill is brought to you by in COVID Insurance, encircling you with coverage
- 34:22to protect what do you care about most? Visit incovid dot com to learn
- 34:27more. Jack pots are in the millions, and we're here in West Virginia,
- 34:30and who does not want to be a millionaire? Get in the powerball
- 34:32drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturday's Mega Million strawngings are Tuesdays and Friday's Will you
- 34:37be the next Big Winner? Play today? The powerball jackpot is three hundred
- 34:42and forty five million dollars. Mega Millions is fifty two million dollars. Let's
- 34:46go to the phones. Bill reacting to last night's debate. Hey, Billy
- 34:52Bye, you know not too much gets me in trouble. Sometimes I'm gonna
- 34:55take your lead and go a lottles Tana. But first, but I've heard
- 35:00media reports that a President Biden is vacation at a mansion in Lake Tahoe with
- 35:06no visitors log about who's visit being there with him. Maybe he invited a
- 35:10bunch of people to watch the Republican debates, but nobody's talking about that.
- 35:15Maybe that's where Hoppy is he could be. That would be the inside scoop
- 35:22of all inside scoops. That would put Hoppy number one chopper with a gold
- 35:29wing on the back. Yep, it would go all right? What about
- 35:31the debate bill, Okay, debate, Okay, what a little bit I
- 35:36heard and saw. Whatever the inflation rate that this country has, I don't
- 35:42care. If you're a Republican Democrat, you're the age of Jim Nelson,
- 35:45you're talented, the producer, or your age yourself. It will affect everybody
- 35:52until at least Labor Day of next year. Not how much, but how
- 35:55much it increases four dollars gass next summer. Whatever Disney World tickets are,
- 36:04student debt's coming up. Christmas is just around the corner. How much are
- 36:07you going to do for the kids and the soccer moms? Okay, all
- 36:13of that failed, in my opinion, miserably to be front end center.
- 36:17It is the voting of the country that will take that head on in the
- 36:23next eight to ten months because it's not going away. So what you said,
- 36:30if I don't care, if Abernathy or the professor from fair Must State
- 36:32doesn't matter, Trump is a less of an issue for everybody, from the
- 36:39soccer mom to the student kind of paintings, debt loans, the teachers just
- 36:45trying to make it after ten years of teaching and raised or salary, to
- 36:50the bus truck drivers bus driver pick one, so en of where this goes.
- 36:55If that second tier, i'll put it politely, doesn't address that come
- 37:01February, then I have no idea how they're gonna beat Trump. Yeah,
- 37:07they'll appreciate the phone call. Always good to hear from you, buddy,
- 37:09gotta taken tell you what's coming up our number two. We'll do that in
- 37:13a moment. Dave Wilson sitting in for Hoppy Kirchball. It's mentioned news talk
- 37:15line from the Cove Insurance Studios. Dave Wilson sitting in for Hoppy Kirchball,
- 37:30who is enjoying some time off. Coming up second hour, mentioned news talk
- 37:35line. We're gonna speak to the co Cancils for the victims of the Miracle
- 37:39Meadows Boarding School. They reached a record settlement in just an absolute, atrocious,
- 37:49horrific case of abuse at that now defunct religious boarding school in Salem.
- 37:54We'll talk to Jesse Forbes and Guy DeAndre coming up at the top of the
- 37:58hour. Also Brad McElhenny, we'll stop by. Brad has a piece at
- 38:01wv metronews dot com this morning exploring he asked the governor about hosting the live
- 38:07golf tournament the saladi Backs Live Golf tournament at the Greenbrier, and Brad has
- 38:13a story this morning at wv metronews dot com. Let me get to a
- 38:15couple of texts here before the top of the hour. Hey, Dave,
- 38:20a good job standing in and holding down the fort, listening to the previous
- 38:23gentlemen talk about the inflation rate on and on. You know it's hard right
- 38:28now. Sure it's been harder than heck. When my husband and I bought
- 38:31our nine hundred square foot home in Fett County, interest rates were twelve point
- 38:36nine and continued up to fourteen. Nobody was screaming, yelling and stamping their
- 38:39feet wringing their hands. Lee was I wish people could have some could have
- 38:44a bit of perspective. It's like nothing mattered, there's no comparison. It's
- 38:47only this moment, on this day. Oh Lord, we have to get
- 38:52lots to be sorry about. Now, we got so much to be thankful
- 38:54for. At least I do every day. Appreciate your holding down the fort.
- 38:58Thank you, says the text. Dave Ramaswamy the only one with America
- 39:06first foreign policy. David scores political points to blame gas prices and inflation on
- 39:12Joe Biden. But anyone who bothers to look beyond their own backyards knows that
- 39:15inflation and gas prices are high all over the world. Gas prices began plummeting
- 39:20in late twenty twenty, not because of anything Trump did, but because things
- 39:22were getting locked down and the interest and the interstates were almost empty. The
- 39:27pandemic affected the world socially, culturally, economically in ways that we simply had
- 39:31no frame of reference for. I think that's valid points. But if you
- 39:37are the president, you are the one in office. You will either get
- 39:39the blame or you will get the credit. Whether you deserve it or not
- 39:44is another story. Dave, the governor Georgia does not have pardon powers.
- 39:49I think we pointed that out. Dave, I've already more ordered my Trump
- 39:53mug shot, T shirt and coffee mug. Our number two I've mentioned new
- 40:00talk line is on the way. You're listening to talk line on Metro News.
- 40:01The Voice of West Virginia our number two Metro News talk line from me
- 40:15and co Insurance Studios. Dave Wilson filling in for Hoppy Kirchibal enjoying some time
- 40:21off. I'm sure relaxing, just taking it easy, hoppy. Actually,
- 40:28we're back week after next. You're stuck with me all next week as well.
- 40:31Eight hundred seven six five talk is the phone number. Eight hundred seven
- 40:36six five eight two five five, three or four Talk three or four is
- 40:38the text line coming up this hour. Brad mckalheney will be by also,
- 40:43we'll check him with Fox News. Is Jeff Manasso get the reaction from the
- 40:47Spin room following last night's GOP presidential debate. I want to hear your thoughts
- 40:52as well at Dave Wilson MN is my Twitter handle. Have a highly unscientific
- 40:58anecdotal flash poll up to day. I want to know from you who you
- 41:01think won the debate last night. There are four options Trump, who wasn't
- 41:07even there, Rohn de Santis, Vivic Ramaswamy or Nicky Haley. Those are
- 41:13your four choices, final final numbers at the end of the show again eight
- 41:19hundred seven and six five talk to fun number three or four talk three or
- 41:21four of the text line. We'll get back to the debate in just a
- 41:23little bit. But I have a story posted at wvmtronews dot com this morning
- 41:29dozens of children victimized at a religious boarding school in Harrison County have reached a
- 41:34record settlement over the abuse they suffered at the hands of the Holmes employees.
- 41:37Lawyers announcing a one hundred million dollars settlement for the victims who had lived at
- 41:43Miracle Meadows School in Salem. Joining us on the program this morning is the
- 41:47co council for the victims, attorneys Guy de Andrea and Jesse Forbes. Guy
- 41:53an attorney out of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Jesse out of Charleston, West Virginia.
- 41:58A gentleman. Good morning, good morning, good morning, good morning
- 42:01day guys. Absolutely, I appreciate you coming on. Jesse. We'll start
- 42:07with you. For folks who don't know the background of this case, I
- 42:10think most folks are probably familiar with it. But it's it's just a horrific
- 42:15story that came out of this now defunct religious boarding school in Harrison County.
- 42:22That's right, Dave. I mean, this is an absolute nightmare. It's
- 42:24the type of stuff that you wouldn't believe in a Hollywood movie script, much
- 42:29less to actually happen in a small area in West Virginia. It's just unbelievable,
- 42:35but it actually occurred these children. From nineteen eighty seven to twenty fourteen,
- 42:38hundreds of kids were at the Miracle Meadows Boarding School where they were locked
- 42:44in isolation cells, chained to beds, handcuffed, routinely beaten, made to
- 42:50work in fields, sexually abused, starved. I mean, it's just you
- 42:54name it. The absolute worst types of things you can imagine happen to these
- 42:59small children from the ages of about six to seventeen, which is just absolutely
- 43:05devastating. Luckily, we've been able to through the efforts of Guy DeAndrea and
- 43:09his office, Latty BC Kent and Philadelphia, Scott Long and Hendrickson A.
- 43:15Long and Charleston and myself Jesse Forbes, we've been able to have a really
- 43:21strong legal team that handles these types of cases. There's experienced representing child victims
- 43:27and those how to navigate through this, and we've been able to get really
- 43:30a record breaking settlement amount for these children in West Virginia. And it's really
- 43:35a testament to how brave they were and how they were willing to go through
- 43:37this process and shine the light on this because they don't want this to happen
- 43:40and any other school anywhere here or elsewhere across the country. Guy, you've
- 43:45prosecuted homicide cases in your career. How did this case compare to some of
- 43:52the some of the cases you've had to deal with during your career. Yeah,
- 43:57Dave, thanks to that question. You know, when I heard these
- 44:00facts now as a private civil attorney coming from handling dozens and dozens of homicide
- 44:07cases, I know this is a sad thing to say, but not one
- 44:12of those was a close second in terms of the level of atrocities that were
- 44:16committed on these children. I have never seen anything like this. I know,
- 44:22you know, the Epstein victim, the Jerry Sandusky to Bill Cosby victims,
- 44:25all victims, all deserved their justice, and those stories get so much
- 44:30pub publicity because of the nature of the offender. Here, these children,
- 44:36like Jesse said, for years, we're just I'm not saying this lately.
- 44:40They were truly tortured by the USA's definition of torture. I have never seen
- 44:47anything in my sixteen or fifteen years of practicing law even close to what happened
- 44:53to these children. Guy DeAndrea and Jesse Forbes. They were co counseled for
- 44:59the vict of the Miracle Meadows School in Salem breached one hundred million dollars settlement
- 45:04in that case, director the school's director, Gil Clark, by the Way,
- 45:08was convicted of chah neglect and the failing to report in Harrison County and
- 45:12sentence to six months in jail five years probation. Uh Jesse. For the
- 45:16victims that you've had to that you've worked with here, the competitive the damages
- 45:24that are being awarded, that's one thing, But what what was their goal?
- 45:30What did they want hope to get out of bringing this case? But
- 45:32beyond just the damages that were awarded, sure, Dave, you know,
- 45:37there was one thing that kind of echoed through the sentiments of each of these
- 45:40child victims that we represented who are now adults, and that was that they
- 45:45wanted this to be a message to other schools, to insurance companies that write
- 45:50insurance policies for these schools, to say, hey, you've got to come
- 45:53in and change your standards. You need to see what's happening there. I
- 45:57mean, this was a school where they weren't conducting appropriate background checks, they
- 46:01didn't have appropriate real teachers or staff members. This school was religiously affiliated and
- 46:07was going on mission trips and finding staff members and countries that in some cases
- 46:12they would put someone in a room to supposedly teach English who didn't speak English.
- 46:16These are they were bringing people in that were totally unqualified and our clients
- 46:22in this they want this momentous settlement. It's one hundred million dollars total settlement
- 46:29here. They want this to be a message that goes broader and says,
- 46:32look, you've got to fix this on the front end. Because you can
- 46:37fill rooms with dollar bills, that doesn't change the trauma to each one of
- 46:39these children. Now, hopefully what we've done here with each of these children
- 46:45is is through this settlement is give them a chance at life and a chance
- 46:47to change the things and get the treatment and care that they all need.
- 46:52I mean, this school advertised itself as a place for children with special needs
- 46:55and behavioral disorders. They had no counselors, they had no psychologists, they
- 47:00had none of the things that you need to teach that or deal with that.
- 47:02Instead they were locking children up and chaining them up in some kind of
- 47:07house of horrors. It was just absolutely devastating. But hopefully this sends that
- 47:10message loud and clear. To other institutions that they need to fix these problems.
- 47:16Guy, how are these victims? How are these you know, children
- 47:22doing now? You never would I can't even imagine, to be honest,
- 47:28it's hard to even ask a question because I can't imagine what they have had
- 47:30to go through and what they still go through every day. Sure they'll never
- 47:36ever forget, will completely feel from what happened. Right, these children,
- 47:43now young adults have to learn what I call to live their second best life,
- 47:46because their best life would have been if this never happened to them,
- 47:50right, And so now in learning that the benefit. You know, it's
- 47:52not all about the money. Everything Jesse said that was first and foremost changing
- 47:57policies and procedures and making sure that another child doesn't go through this. But
- 48:01this money, what it will do for that do for these children who because
- 48:07they were there for years, they didn't have any skills, they had no
- 48:08education, they had no guidance, Their formative years were ruined. And so
- 48:14now what this money can do for them is give them ability to have a
- 48:16home. Many of them were homeless. It gives them of an ability to
- 48:20have the mental health treatment they so desperately need. It gives them the simplest
- 48:24things of being able to get a reasonable car so they can still go to
- 48:28work, you know, the things that we all take for granted. They
- 48:31now can have this settlement fund that can help them start a life that they
- 48:37should have had years prior, and so we are very proud of that.
- 48:42We are proud of them. I still love getting the messages from clients,
- 48:45the text messages, look at my first home. Look at you know,
- 48:50in their modest home, but it's their first home. And it just brings
- 48:53joy to your heart to know that Jesse, Scott and I and everyone else
- 48:58in the team did every thing in our power, working tirelessly to make sure
- 49:02that we could give these kids their second best life and that they can start
- 49:07anew Jesse, I'll give you final word here, and we're speaking to Guy
- 49:12Deandrey and Jesse Forbes Co Council along with Scott Long on this case involving the
- 49:17victims at the Merricle Meadow School in Salem. Jesse, final word, What
- 49:22do you hope folks take away from this in the end, Well, what
- 49:25we would hope folks take away is is that the West Virginia civil justice system
- 49:30is strong a lot of these children felt that much more time should have gone
- 49:35to the perpetrators here. The director you know, as you mentioned, was
- 49:37sentenced to six months. A lot of the perpetrators fled the country immediately after
- 49:43the acts, and the law enforcement in Harrison County did an excellent job of
- 49:46shutting the school down and really tried for years to do something. But these
- 49:51children, these survivors, through the civil justice system, have achieved accountability and
- 49:55they've achieved a strong message of record breaking settlement amount we believe given the numbers,
- 50:02and every West Virginian should be proud of how strong the civil justice system
- 50:07was for these kids here. It's really it's an impressive settlement for them,
- 50:12but it needs to be a message that goes a lot broader that this type
- 50:15of abuse and atrocity will not be tolerated in West Virginia or elsewhere. Jesse
- 50:21Forbes and Guy Deandrett gentlemen, thank you for joining us. Good job with
- 50:24the case and we'll talk again day. Thanks for having us. Absolutely you
- 50:30can read our story Chris Lawrence as it posted for you over at the website
- 50:34wv metronews dot com. Again, a record settlement in this case, hundred
- 50:38million dollars for those victims at the former Merricill Meadow School in Salem. We'll
- 50:45get back talk about reactions to last night's debate. Jeff Nasso, Fox News
- 50:49Radio. We'll join us. I want to hear from you as well at
- 50:51three or four Talk three oh four, or you can call love to have
- 50:54you on the show eight hundred seven and six five. Talk is the phone
- 50:57number, three or four Talk three or four the text line. More debate
- 51:00reaction coming up. Brad mcalhenney will join us bottom of the hour. Dave
- 51:04Wilson in for Hoppy Kirchibable in the Incovid Insurance studios back in a moment.
- 51:19Metro News talk Line with Hoppy Kirchibill is brought to you by Incovia Insurance,
- 51:23encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visiting coovia dot
- 51:29com to learn more. Dave Wilson sitting again for Hoppy Kirchible today and we'll
- 51:34continue to be in the big chair for the rest of this week, all
- 51:37of next week as well. Hoppy just taken some time off to rest and
- 51:42relax, so well deserved as well. More of your reactions to the GOP
- 51:47debate last night. We'll get to those also. I want to mention I'll
- 51:51bring this up a little more with Brad mcalhenney coming up bottom of the hour.
- 51:55The American Federation of Teachers President Randy Winegarten sent a letter out to the
- 52:00w Board of Governors to protest the proposed cuts to majors. Of course,
- 52:07thirty two majors on the chopping block, one hundred and sixty nine faculty could
- 52:12lose their jobs as well. The letter, addressed to the Board of Governors,
- 52:22condemns the cuts, calls them draconian and catastrophic, jeopardizing the institutions standing
- 52:28as an R one university. I'll try to summarize this as best I can.
- 52:34Blames the cuts on the administration's fiscal missmanagements. Blames the cuts on the
- 52:42legislatures reduced funding for WVU. I see. The letter does propose a solution.
- 52:57Weingarten states, rather than proceeding with the cuts, disrupt student's mid degree,
- 53:00weaken the economy of the local community and the state, and undermind the
- 53:05university's mission, the Board of Governors, together with the university administration, should
- 53:09advocate for increased state support to make up the projected budget shortfall and the short
- 53:14term and to adequately fund w going forward. The funding could provide the university
- 53:20community with a blah blah blah blah. That is not even an option.
- 53:24That's it takes you two pages to get to the end of the letter.
- 53:31It's just not an option. That's not going to happen. That is not
- 53:34a real solution today, tomorrow, or next week. There's a forty five
- 53:38million dollar budget gap that has to be addressed. The state is not coming
- 53:44in with forty five million dollars today. It is not coming in with forty
- 53:47five million dollars tomorrow. So to say that is a solution is to be
- 53:52ignorant of the situation. Back to the text line three or four Talk three
- 54:00or four reaction to last night's debate, And you can also weigh in on
- 54:05my highly unscientific and anecdotal Twitter poll. And yes, I'm not going to
- 54:09stop calling a Twitter It's a habit that I'm not going to be able to
- 54:13break anytime soon. Who won the debate last night? Your options are Trump,
- 54:17de Santis, Ramaswamy, or Haley. The leader on the back nine
- 54:24right now is h Ramaswamy. Hailey second, then Trump, then de Santis.
- 54:31It was not It was not a good night for Ron de Santis last
- 54:36night. I don't think so at all. Three or four talk three or
- 54:38four Dave, Who cares? They're all terrible candidates. Dave Biden won the
- 54:45debate. We are not a country and decline. We will continue to be
- 54:47the most successful country in history if we keep our heads and trust ourselves and
- 54:52each other. David did not watch the debate and do not care till the
- 54:57field is cut down. Will never ever vote for Trump, says the Texter.
- 55:05David didn't. No. Little Debbie made a cinnamon role These were homemade.
- 55:09A co worker brought them in. His wife made him. They were
- 55:12delicious, Dave. I watched the HBO docuseries John Adams. In it,
- 55:20the founding father said they wanted a government of laws, not a government of
- 55:22man. How and why have Republicans trade so far from that ideal and now
- 55:28want a government of a man, that man being Donald Trump. It seems
- 55:30antithetical to American values. I have been wanting to watch that on a side
- 55:36note and cannot seem to get around to it. Fox News Radios Joff Manasso
- 55:44in Milwaukee. He was in the spin room last night. He joins us
- 55:46on Metro News talk line this morning, Jeff, good morning, begging more
- 55:50of my friend. All Right, what was the what was the feeling coming
- 55:53out of the spin room last night? Who won the debate according to the
- 55:57spin room? Every candidate ing the bates according according to the spin room.
- 56:02I mean that's what they do. They have their surrogets, or they come
- 56:06in and say, look, we had a great night. Vac. Ramaswami
- 56:09he's the one that outright said, look, I think I want to debate.
- 56:14No doubt he get a good night. He was very responsive to criticism.
- 56:17Candidate's really piled on to the vac last night, which actually kind of
- 56:22saved It's spared Rhonda Santis. You know, both Rhonda Santis and Ramaswami are
- 56:30pulling ahead of the pack abate. You know, one of the biggest applause
- 56:34moments was de Santis railing on how President Biden's COVID lockdown policies hurt our country,
- 56:39though some of the voters said that it was one of the topics that
- 56:44wasn't discussed enough. The pain, the you know, the hell that this
- 56:46country went through also economic issues in terms of the pain at the grocery store,
- 56:52the paint at the pump, the fact that we're paying seven hundred dollars
- 56:55more a month than we were three years ago just for necessity things like that.
- 57:00But the RNC says the Republican Party as a whole last night one because
- 57:06it was a subsident debate on on important issues, you know, crime,
- 57:12abortion, Ukraine. Nicky Haley had a pretty good night. I don't think
- 57:15many people were even considering her last night, but she she had a strong
- 57:20showing. You know, truthfully, I think going into the debate, everybody
- 57:23thought, you know, president former president Trump was going to take all the
- 57:28oxygen out of the room, even though he wasn't there. But it was
- 57:30a pretty good debate. I mean, he came up I think once early
- 57:36and then once the moderators Martha and Gret you know, brought him up.
- 57:39And but you know, in the in the spin room, it was it
- 57:45was interesting. Me. Yeah, you have the surrogates, but sometimes you
- 57:50have the candidates come in. And Chris Christie, he was a no show.
- 57:54Nicky Haley, Tim Scott, Ron De Santist, they all did a
- 57:58quick hit with Hannidy and the they took off, But Rama Swammy spent about
- 58:02a good and half an hour forty minutes talking to every reporter, as did
- 58:07former Vice President Mike Pence. And it was an opportunity for these candidates and
- 58:13perhaps they didn't get some of the get to say something they wanted to say
- 58:16on that debate stage. They got to say it there to local states,
- 58:22uh, you know, national international press, and so it was an opportunity
- 58:25for them to do that. But all candidates, even Doug Bergham, North
- 58:30Dakota governor, telling me last night that he had a good he had a
- 58:32good debate, and you know, it was an opportunity for him perhaps to
- 58:37introduced himself to a larger audience. Yeah. I think a lot of people
- 58:40finally got an opportunity to meet these candidates per se here where they stand on
- 58:45the issues. I thought Ramaswamy had moments. I thought Nicki Haley certainly had
- 58:51moments. I really came away impressed with her. I just didn't think Ron
- 58:53De Santis had moments. Maybe one, maybe it was the COVID lockdown comments.
- 58:59I just did not think he took the step he really needed to last
- 59:04night. Yeah, I think I think you're not not alone in that thinking.
- 59:07But ultimately it's going to be up to voters to decide he didn't have
- 59:10some strong moments, isn't enough to carry him to the next debate Again,
- 59:16he is leading the the field of eight, but the RNC is actually today
- 59:22they they've upped the anti in terms of qualifications for the next debate in Southern
- 59:28California next month. Instead of one percent Poland nationally if not three percent,
- 59:34and instead of forty forty thousand unique donors, it's now fifty thousand. So
- 59:38some of these candidates are going to be forced out of the debate process.
- 59:44It's just how it is, and we'll see. But you know, we're
- 59:49talking about it day a day later and we're waking up this morning and still
- 59:52all these candidates last night they're fighting for second place. Fox News Radio is
- 59:58Jeff MANASO. Jeff, appreciate it, Thank check it in this morning.
- 1:00:00You bet absolutely coming up. We'll talk too much. News Statewide Correspondent Brad
- 1:00:05mackel Henny, Oh, we got a plethora of topics to bring up with.
- 1:00:07Brad. Still want to hear from you. Still time to weigh in
- 1:00:10on the Twitter poll at Dave Wilson m N is my Twitter handle Dave Wilson
- 1:00:15sitting in for a Hoppy Kurtzwilt's talk line on Metro News, the Voice of
- 1:00:17West Virginia. It's eleven thirty in time to get a news update. Let's
- 1:00:22check in with the Metro News radio network. Find out what's happening across the
- 1:00:25great state of West Virginia. Metro News talk line continues, Dave Wilson in
- 1:00:44the big chair in the Incoba Insurance studios. Hoppy taking some time to himself.
- 1:00:49Don't worry, he'll be back, but you're stuck with me for now.
- 1:00:52Eight hundred and seven six five Talk the fun number three of four.
- 1:00:54Talk three of four is the text line. More of your reaction to last
- 1:00:58night's GOP president shill debate. I have the Twitter flash pole. Who won
- 1:01:02the GOP presidential primary debate last night? Trump descandus Ramaswamy, NICKI Haley are
- 1:01:08your options. We'll have final results at the top of the hour. Right
- 1:01:13now, it's Ramaswamy and Haley neck and neck And yes I did misspell his
- 1:01:17vivic's name. Sorry, Well, you know you had a little phone,
- 1:01:23a little keyboard on your phone and sausage fingers like I do. Made a
- 1:01:30mistake. I apologize to Vivic. Metro News statewide correspondent Brad Maco and he
- 1:01:34joins us on Metro News talk line. Good morning, Brad, Good morning
- 1:01:37Dave, and good morning to Hoppy, who is at the spa today.
- 1:01:44Do you think Hoppy was, you know, at the spa watching the debate
- 1:01:46last night? Yeah, I think so. With those comfortable slippers and maybe
- 1:01:50you speed up, I think so. I can totally picture, totally pictured.
- 1:01:54All right, we'll get to the debate in a moment. But I
- 1:01:58did bring up the American Federation of Teachers President Randy Winarten sending a letter to
- 1:02:01the w Board of Governors, Brad, and it's it's not unexpected, advocating
- 1:02:07for the programs, advocating for higher education, advocating for the faculty positions,
- 1:02:13although she does call on the BOG to seek more state funding. And I
- 1:02:17said, that's that's just not going to happen. That's just not an option.
- 1:02:21Yeah, it's notable because Winegarten has been prominent in national politics. The
- 1:02:24American Federation of Teachers has been influential in the national political discussion and what Winegarten
- 1:02:32herself said was that the proposed cuts are draconian and catastrophic. She said,
- 1:02:38the scope and nature of these cuts raise fundamental questions about wvu's commitment to its
- 1:02:45students, it's surrounding community, and the state. Those are, you know,
- 1:02:50sentiments that a lot of folks share in this discussion. The question is
- 1:02:53what to do about it? And as you alluded, Winengarten proposed that the
- 1:03:00Board of Governors that others connected with WFU should prevail upon the state to provide
- 1:03:08more funding for the university at least to buy additional time to more fully consider
- 1:03:15the way WFU could change shape. But like I said, we've already Senator
- 1:03:20tars already on the record. Mike Aliverio joined us last week. Brady.
- 1:03:23That is that is just not going to happen. It's not even an option
- 1:03:27right now. Governor Justice met with the media yesterday. Brad. You were
- 1:03:31there, well, there virtually, and you asked the governor about the Greenbrier
- 1:03:37Resort and hosting the live golf tournament earlier this summer. I'll let you quote
- 1:03:45your question and what was the governor's response, m Well, live golf has
- 1:03:52been controversial nationally groups representing nine eleven families representing people who's loved one died in
- 1:04:00the September eleventh attacks have accused live golf as being a form of sportswashing for
- 1:04:08Saudi Arabia, the largest bank roller to wipe away the reputation of its human
- 1:04:13rights abuses. So a couple of things. A live golf event did come
- 1:04:17to the Greenbrier owned by Governor Justice and his family earlier this month. The
- 1:04:24Governor was there, was photographed at least one day, and acknowledged being there
- 1:04:27several times during my question to him. And then finally, he is not
- 1:04:31just an average West Virginia and he is a person who is running for US
- 1:04:35Senate and the polls show him favored. If he's elected, Justice would be
- 1:04:42one of one hundred people weighing in regularly on foreign relations issues, including Saudi
- 1:04:49stuff like weapons sales. So all of those are things to consider. And
- 1:04:56Metro News wanted to know a few things, whether Justice believes it's appropriate for
- 1:05:01a candidate for US Senate to interact with a golf tournament backed by the Saudias.
- 1:05:08And then the second thing was that the nature of any interactions, whether
- 1:05:13Justice had discussions with representatives of Saudi Arabia's Public and Investment Fund. What were
- 1:05:18the nature of those? Was there any potential for direct or indirect support for
- 1:05:25justices senatorial campaign? Well, the governor answered some of those, but not
- 1:05:31everything. In particular, the aspect of my question about did you have any
- 1:05:35meeting did you have any talks with representatives of the Saudi government was not addressed
- 1:05:41at all by the governor. But then bottom line, he said, absolutely,
- 1:05:46Saudi Arabia is a great ally of the United States. And Justice said,
- 1:05:50and I thought the event was great. I thought the great the event
- 1:05:54was great for West Virginia. It's just more good stuff in Justice's opinion that
- 1:05:59comes to West Virginia. Justice did acknowledge going several days to the event,
- 1:06:03which coincided with a special session of the state legislature, and rather than addressing
- 1:06:11my question about appropriateness or whether he had any consequential meetings, he said,
- 1:06:15I was there on two or three different different occasions. Enjoyed the event.
- 1:06:19Thousands of people were there, and Justice said, they enjoyed it. I'll
- 1:06:23just conclude by saying at least four West Virginia's died in those September eleventh attacks,
- 1:06:29you know, Brad, those are legitimate questions. And as the Senate
- 1:06:33campaign moves forward and we get, you know, closer and closer to the
- 1:06:38primary, there are a lot of people watching this Senate race, particularly the
- 1:06:42primary, and we'll really be watching it if Senator Mansion does run for reelection.
- 1:06:48Outside media sources beyond you know us here in West Virginia who've been covering
- 1:06:53Governor Justice all these years, they're going to start asking those same questions.
- 1:06:57They're going to start poking around our legitimate questions to be asking at this point,
- 1:07:01because they're going to be asked, is my point, by a lot
- 1:07:05more people than just you know you and others here in West Virginia. The
- 1:07:10outside media is going to be at one and know the same things as well,
- 1:07:14for sure. And around the time of the liv golf event earlier this
- 1:07:16month at the Greenbrier, it did receive some national attention and questions about Justice
- 1:07:23and the decision making about whether it's appropriate to be engaging with a golf tournament
- 1:07:30bank rolled by the Saudis at your resort at the same time you run for
- 1:07:34US Senate. I think it's likely that democratic campaigns, particularly if Senator Mansion
- 1:07:42runs. People weighing in on Mansion's behalf may go after Justice about this.
- 1:07:46It's trickier for Republicans. What's right ahead of us is the Republican primary,
- 1:07:51and of course Congressman Alex Mooney is the main competitor against Justice. The Mooney
- 1:07:57campaign declined to comment on this, as Club for Growth, the Political Action
- 1:08:00Committee that's going back to bat for Mooney against Justice. The complication for them
- 1:08:05is, you know the other prominent Republican whose golf courses host live golf that'll
- 1:08:11try Trump, right. Brian mackawhey mentioned your statewide correspondent joining us. There's
- 1:08:15also concerning the Senate race. A deadline approaching for Governor Justice. As a
- 1:08:20candidate governor Justices finances have been complicated, of course, and there is a
- 1:08:29deadline to report on your finances to the Senate itself. This is different from
- 1:08:33a federal Elections Commission filing. This is your own finances. It goes to
- 1:08:40the Senate and Justice so far should typically would have done this within thirty days
- 1:08:45of filing to run, did not sought an extension and received it at this
- 1:08:50point that filing is due today, but haven't gotten it yet so still looking
- 1:08:57for that. It is possible the campaign could look for a second extension,
- 1:09:01but these are six year terms, so if Justice wins sometime over those six
- 1:09:06years, he would have to file. I mentioned new state wide correspondent Brad
- 1:09:10Machney. Brad, before I let you go, everybody else is weighing in
- 1:09:13on the debate last night. What did you watch one and two? If
- 1:09:15you did, what'd you take away? I did watch, and I was
- 1:09:19stunned that it took so long for that crowded field to go after the guy
- 1:09:26who wasn't there, the guy who was a mile ahead in the polls.
- 1:09:30They were. They were having a crash up derby among themselves and eventually finally
- 1:09:34got around to mentioning the name of the front runner, Donald Trump. You
- 1:09:39know, I thought that as well, Brad. But I also think that
- 1:09:43clearly you're this is a Republican audience who's watching, and I would venture to
- 1:09:47guess, and a lot of Texters have said this this morning. Into the
- 1:09:50show, people wanted to hear about the issues, wanted to hear about what
- 1:09:56do you think about Ukraine, what do you think on abortion, the economy,
- 1:10:00etcetera, etcetera, And I don't know that. The Republican Party.
- 1:10:04I'm sure there was. I was certainly, you know, Amanda Carpenter joined
- 1:10:08US yesterday, was interested. I guess you could make the argument that people
- 1:10:13wanted to hear about the issues and didn't want to spend two hours debating Trump
- 1:10:17and his legal woes. You could make that argument, I think. Yeah.
- 1:10:24And Fox was the host. Yeah, they had, they had the
- 1:10:27moderators. Trump had declined to appear, So, you know, looking at
- 1:10:31it from that point of view, why would the moderators steer it toward the
- 1:10:35topic of the guy who had elected not to be there. So, you
- 1:10:39know, I don't blame them for thinking, well, well, we'll let
- 1:10:42these candidates differentiate themselves. And so you heard a lot about other issues and
- 1:10:48not the elephant in the room for the first hour or so. What do
- 1:10:51college football coaches tell you when you ask about the player who's hurt and won't
- 1:10:55play on Saturday. I want to talk about the other guys who are here,
- 1:10:58and the other guys are going to be availab That's what they tell you.
- 1:11:00Just mentioned News State. Why coursepot of Brad macwinning. Brad always appreciate
- 1:11:05it, buddy, Thanks so much thanks. The rest of the show is
- 1:11:09yours. What did you think about last night? Eight hundred and seven and
- 1:11:12six five talks the phone number three or four Talk three or four as the
- 1:11:15text line, and your last chance to weigh in on my highly unscientific and
- 1:11:19very anecdotal Twitter flash pole. Who you think won the GOP presidential debate last
- 1:11:25night? Trump, DeSantis, Ramaswamy or Hailey. Dave Wilson filling in for
- 1:11:29Hoppy Kerchival will continue from the Cove Insurance Studios in just a moment. Are
- 1:11:33you ready to advance your career? Workforce West Virginia is here to help you
- 1:11:38take that next step toward fulfilling employment. With our customized training programs, you
- 1:11:43can enhance your skills and knowledge, aligning yourself with high demand industries. But
- 1:11:46that's not all. Workforce West Virginia connects you with employers who value your expertise.
- 1:11:51Will help you showcase your talents and secure that dream career advancement opportunity today.
- 1:11:57So, if you're ready to start advancing your career, start with Workforce
- 1:12:00West Virginia. Visit Workforce wv dot org to learn more. This outreach campaign
- 1:12:04is financed by federal funds. Metro News talk Line with Hobby Kirchibill is brought
- 1:12:21to you by in Covid Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect What do
- 1:12:26you care about most? Visit incovi dot com to learn more. A child's
- 1:12:30brain is an amazing place. From birth to age five, the brain develops
- 1:12:33more than any other time in life. That's why it's so important to entrust
- 1:12:38your child's neurological care to the experts at WW Medicine Children's Neuroscience Center, nationally
- 1:12:45ranked as one of the top fifty programs in the nation by US News and
- 1:12:47World Report. A comprehensive center combining all the neuroscience disciplines into one team in
- 1:12:54one place, treating conditions affecting the brain and spinal cord, including epilepsy,
- 1:12:58multiple sclerosis, cerebral palsy, traumatic brain injury, and more. Call eight
- 1:13:02five five Www Care or visit www kids dot com. All right, let
- 1:13:08me get to some texts. Three or four talk three oh four. Oh
- 1:13:14boy, there's a lot to get to, Dave. Unfortunately, Trump will
- 1:13:16will be the next president. Biden's green energy policies are economic failure. Big
- 1:13:21oil producers of the world have chosen Trump, and then next year prices,
- 1:13:27Next year energy prices will inflate beyond belief and make Biden appear an idiot.
- 1:13:32Dave. If you have to choose between Biden or Trump in twenty twenty four,
- 1:13:35I'm going to pick Trump. Here's why. Do oj FBI and the
- 1:13:40mainstream media have done everything they can to make Trump look bad and everything they
- 1:13:45can do to protect Biden. Ask yourself why that's happening, and follow the
- 1:13:48money, Dave. The people who talk about the cheap gas prices when Trump
- 1:13:54was in office need to understand that that was due to low demand during the
- 1:13:57pandemic. If Trump had been in office this time around, when demand shot
- 1:14:00up after COVID, the gas prices would have gone up just the same,
- 1:14:09Dave. The Independent who called said it best may not like Trump, but
- 1:14:12he got the job done. The debate was a circus. Where was the
- 1:14:15clown? Biden? Can't see any of them working like Trump. Fox News
- 1:14:18as a joke full of liberals now used to be good globalist bought and paid
- 1:14:23for the reports who are owned by now progressives, says the Texter. Dave,
- 1:14:30are you a flaming liberal? You sure sound like one. Yep,
- 1:14:34you got me pegged, Dave. You said you don't think Trump could be
- 1:14:41our next president. Again, let me ask you a question. Are you
- 1:14:43better off now than you were when Trump was president? Is our country better
- 1:14:47off now than when Trump was president? Now? Do you think Trump can
- 1:14:51can't be reelected? No, I don't because there's no data to indicate that
- 1:14:58that is the case. Now, I do see a path to get there
- 1:15:00if and right now he is the leading the front runner for the Republican nomination,
- 1:15:06But I do see a path to get there and involves low voter turnout
- 1:15:10and a strong third party candidate. Low voter turnout if you have apathy on
- 1:15:15the Democratic side, you have low voter turnout. There you have a third
- 1:15:19party candidate Mansion question mark, who is a strong independent moderate who would probably
- 1:15:30draw votes away from the Democratic nominee more than the Republican nominee. Yeah,
- 1:15:33there's a path there. And it's not just the poll numbers that indicate this.
- 1:15:40What success has Trump had in the twenty eighteen midterm or the twenty twenty
- 1:15:45two mid term? And by Trump I mean candidates that he endorsed or handpicked
- 1:15:49in the states that he needs to win Georgia, Wisconsin, Arizona. I
- 1:15:57don't see it. All that being said, I've got two articles here in
- 1:16:02the stack from August of twenty fifteen, and they're talking about Jeb Bush being
- 1:16:09the front runner for the GOP nomination. We all know how that played out,
- 1:16:13So it's we've got a long way to go. Anything can happen,
- 1:16:16and that's probably what we should remember from the twenty sixteen election. All Right,
- 1:16:23I gotta take final break back to wrap things up in a moment,
- 1:16:40jack potts stirring the millions here in West Virginia. Who does not want to
- 1:16:44be a million? Are kant? In? The powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays,
- 1:16:46and Saturday's Mega Millions drawings are Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the
- 1:16:51next big winner? Play today? The powerball jackpot is three hundred and forty
- 1:16:55five million dollars and the Mega Million jackpot is fifty two million dollars. Let
- 1:17:00me get to some more text before we call it today, Dave, there
- 1:17:03is an independent running by the name of Anthony Hudson. I believe people should
- 1:17:06give him a look, Dave, Can we have a poll if we should
- 1:17:11change the elephant to Trump's mugshot for the GOP mascot, The Elephants don't deserve
- 1:17:15to be associated with the criminals. Hashtag save the Elephants. Dave just heard
- 1:17:21about Governor Justice and his golfing buddies. Baby dog will look so cute in
- 1:17:26a burka. How loo can he go? Dave? Republicans don't care about
- 1:17:38this country. They would sell their souls to Mega Dollar. They caught our
- 1:17:41vets, suckers and losers. Rest my case. Biden won by a landslide.
- 1:17:48Dave, Trump won the debate. Dave, if enraged by liv golf,
- 1:17:54don't fill up your gas tank with Exxon Mobile, Shell, Sitco or
- 1:17:57any other gasoline. It comes from Saudiabia. Thanks Joe Biden, says the
- 1:18:00Texter. Dave, did you hear this hot take last night? If you
- 1:18:12want three hours filled, call a Dave. If you want excellence in broadcasting,
- 1:18:16call a goat. I think that is a goat emoji. Dave Weingarten
- 1:18:26is so interested in public schools she owns a charter school. Piece of work,
- 1:18:29says the Texter. All right. Final results of the highly unscientific anecdotal
- 1:18:33Twitter poll. Who won the GOP presidential primary debate last night. Vivic Ramaswamy
- 1:18:40with thirty seven percent of the vote, Nicki Haley at thirty percent. Trump
- 1:18:43twenty two not a good night. I was not a good night for Rond
- 1:18:46De Santis didn't even get ten percent of the highly unscientific anecdotal flash pole on
- 1:18:55x I. Guess Dave was the one wearing the rubber Nixon mask last night
- 1:19:01at the debate. Appreciate all the Texters weighing in today. Sorry if I
- 1:19:12did not get to you, there was a lot of them. There were
- 1:19:15a lot of them to get through today. I do appreciate you sitting your
- 1:19:17thoughts along. Coming up tomorrow Steam release at eleven thirty three. Also,
- 1:19:25Joe Bracado will stop by. We'll preview the first week of high school football
- 1:19:28season. There are three games tonight. Scores will be posted at wvmtrodews dot
- 1:19:32com. We also have highlights, photos, and a recap of last night's
- 1:19:36SSAC kickoff game, Saint Mary's defeating Doddridge thirty fourteen. The broadcast look great.
- 1:19:44All the guys working on the crew did an awesome job, and of
- 1:19:46course the guys on the coverage last night as well. For the website.
- 1:19:49Excellent job. As usual, we'll talk to you tomorrow. Talk Line on
- 1:19:53Metro News, the voice of West Virginia,