Latest / Portfolio Talks / Ep 2: Use your TFSA or just invest inside of your CORP?
Transcript
- Portfolio Planning: What's up everyone? On portfolio talks today, you're gonna be learning about tax-free savings accounts for doctors. So you tune into this episode, if you watch this episode, you're gonna learn, you know, should you invest inside your TFSA or inside your corporation? What are the differences between the two? And then we'll tackle some myths. And as always, make you subscribe, like, share, and follow along to learn everything you need to know about finances to make sure that ⁓ you running your finances, not your finances ⁓ running right, everyone, welcome to episode two of Portfolio Talks. This is the revamped version, the better version, to be honest. We had a lot of great feedback from our first episode, and we're excited to bring you episode two, which is gonna be talking about tax-free savings accounts versus corporate investment accounts, and where should doctors be investing first? As always, you have myself, Vishal, Tyson Nagasaki, both from Portfolio Planning. We are your financial planners. We will be prescribing your financial plan. And like most things, that you guys know in the healthcare world, preventative health is so important. Hence why your dentists are telling your patients to floss and mouthwash and the tongue scrubbers and ⁓ are saying to ⁓ salt and exercise, optometrists ⁓ good eye health and ⁓ drops. All this stuff is preventative health. This podcast is to be preventative health, but for your finances. So if we can help you ⁓ the ⁓ and financial issues that we see our clients. have by the time they hire us. It's so hard to go back and fix things and you know, sometimes the damage is done. You can fix it going forward, but you can't go backwards. We hope those of you that listening are able to learn and navigate the financial world a little bit better. And if you're joining us from our Facebook group, it's fantastic. We're going to tackle those mail-based questions as always. before we jump into it Tyson, anything to add to get the audience all excited about Tax Free Savings accounts? Tyson Nagasaka: No, a tax-free savings account is one of those things that's funny because of the naming structure, right? I mean, it's given. We didn't choose it. It's a government thing. just leave it to the government to screw up how to name things and create the worst acronym possible. And there's a whole bunch of the other ones. We're not going to talk about them on this episode. ⁓ yeah, ⁓ I see a lot of people. They have a literal savings account at the bank. with cash in it and they feel like they've accomplished their tax-free savings account mission. it's because the education around it is terrible. Portfolio Planning: Yeah, honestly, I thought the government always does it perfectly every single time, right? No misses at all. But that's not the case with the TFSA. So here, let me paint a picture for you guys on the podcast, those of you that are watching and listening in. So the problem is, your doctor, you earn more than you need to spend, so you're starting to have money swell up inside of your corporation or your corporate investment account. So that's kind of like your pain point, is you have money that's sitting there, everywhere you look, people are telling you to invest things differently. but that's as simple as possible. You have more money than need to spend, you've incorporated, now that money's sitting in your corporate account, and you don't wanna pull all that money personally because you're scared of being taxed, but you don't know what to do with it corporately, so you're sitting in the purgatory and you don't really know what's going on. But when you think about your life goals, what you really wanna have is flexibility in the long term. You don't wanna always be stuck working in clinics, in your patient's metals or looking into their eyes. You want to that as a hobby, right? Not so much as a job, but you want to stare into people's eyes as a hobby. You know, all those things need happen, but I don't know how to get there. That's what we're going talk about today because probably what happens if you're like most of our clients, ⁓ when start talking to your colleagues, you hear four different opinions from three different people ⁓ and like, ⁓ no, you should do this. ⁓ my guy told me to do this. ⁓ I read this online. And then you get processed by analysis. You don't know what to do. So you do nothing. Here's what we're going to tackle. Tax-free savings accounts. versus corporate non-registered accounts. So just to kind of give a of things, your tax-free savings account ⁓ on your personal side. We talk about this all the time. Think of yourself as two different entities, ⁓ it's happening now or in the near future, if you're a brand new doc, probably isn't relevant for you yet because you're just running as a sole proprietor, but usually you're three-ish ⁓ going forward, you'll have two separate entities. So it'll be your corporation or your Medco or your professional corporation, and then you personally, and you have... Running your finances two different ways, two different bank accounts, is like two different people essentially. So your tax-free savings account can only be held on the personal side. know, ⁓ planning can't hold the TFSA, the shawl can. So a tax-free savings account is under my name, it's personally registered with the CRA, so it's gotta have preferential tax treatment. That's your TFSA. Your non-registered investments are basically sitting inside your corporation. So... you get paid, you bill out, let's say for example, MSP, pay you and that money is sitting in your corporate account, that is now corporate dollars. And if you start investing it or have it sitting in a GIC or a hydrosamins account, you're gonna be getting non-registered investment income and they are taxed very differently. They serve very different purposes. But when we're talking about non-reg versus a TFSA, that's kind of where things are at. So Tyson, let's just jump right into the first segment, which is Mythbusters, things that we hear all the time. What we hear often when people first meet with us is, heard like it doesn't, T-physicists don't really matter if you're a high income earner because you can just leave your money inside your corporation and invest it. So talk to the audience about that. Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, mean, there's only so many things in Canada as a Canadian that are tax free. And so to not utilize it ⁓ make any sense. I'm going to talk a little bit about what those things are in the later segment. But there's only four things that are ⁓ free in Canada. And if you're not utilizing it, it's not going to change your life if you've got millions and millions of dollars inside your corp as retained earnings. but not using it, it causes a big missed opportunity. So I ran some numbers, some really simple ones. If you had $100,000 in your tax-free savings account and it's invested, it's growing at 9%. And you had $100,000 in your corporate investment account, it's growing at 9%. The tax-free-ness of the tax-free savings account, over 30 years, you'd grow to $1.3 million. inside your non-registered corporate investment account, you'd grow to $775,000. the Delta is like half a million dollars on that opportunity invested over the long term. That's not including adding new money. And the government decides to have years where you can contribute more to your tax-free savings account, those numbers could be even more beneficial to you. So as a investment vehicle, there's there's really nothing else that's totally tax free for you. Seems silly to not. Portfolio Planning: 100%, silly is one word for it. yeah, definitely just to add onto that, what a lot of docs don't understand is at some point you need to get your money out of the corporate side onto the personal side. That will have to happen. It's definitively true. of your money has to go from the corporate side to the personal side at some point. You can choose to whether do it while you're alive ⁓ when die. or when you retire and do like a huge dividend payment on the personal side and really sucks. We see people do that because they weren't well prepared. I always argue that it makes far more sense to do it while you're ⁓ strategically on annual basis. And sometimes it'll be more opportune times. For example, if you're going on Prenta leaf and you're going to have a little bit lower income than usual, but you have extra money inside your corporation. That's a good way to still keep yourself in the same tax bracket because we have a progressive tax system here in Canada. But if you have a little bit less income, let's say in 2026 than you did in 2025, that you will in 2027, you can use some of that corporate leftover money or retained earnings to pull back onto the personal side and bump you back in the same bracket that you're used to. But now that money is on the personal side, you can invest it in your tax-free savings account and you're only given a certain amount of room every single year. So once you fill it, You you can't do anything more with it until the next year, the next calendar year when you open up the new room for 2027, 2028, 2099, and so on and so forth. So it really is very, very important to do that, especially those of you that are young doctors, because the compounding effects of tax-free growth to Tyson's point is astronomical. And you really start to see it in the latter parts of your career that you have all this money on the personal side. And we start to run retirement projections. This can solve a lot of your problems because within your tax-free savings account, you're not going to clawbacks of like all their security or ⁓ of that type. So can really benefit you having a robust, ⁓ well tax-free savings account because that money has to leave your corporate structure at some point. And the tax-free savings account is one of the only ways that it can continue to tax-free. There's other things like your RRSP that can be tax deferred. We'll talk about that later episodes, but your TFSA is the only one that can continue to grow that tax-free and you can invest ⁓ in wide array of stuff. TFSA definitely if you open it, it doesn't matter if you're a high income earner. We hear that all the time and the follow up question is, oh, okay, interesting. Why do think that is? I don't know, I just heard it. So it's definitely not true. That is definitely a myth. Whether you're high income earner or not, it really is imperative that you take advantage of your tax free savings account and then invest inside of your tax free savings account. Don't just have the money set there. So that is definitely a myth. Consider it busted. What we want to go through now is teach you guys a little bit about some benefits of the Tax Free Savings Account and some high leverage things you can learn about. So, Tyson, you talked about the tax-free growth, but let's give them some hard numbers. Like the Rule of 72 in a TFSA, what does that look like? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, well, rule of 72 is a concept that we use when we're educating to talk about how money grows, how it doubles, and how we can kind of project the timeline. So if you take the rule of 72 and you divide it into the rate of return that you're getting. In the example, we used 9%. So nine divided into 72 means your money's doubling every eight years. That becomes really important when we're talking about wealth building and wealth accumulation. because we want to know, if I'm 40, when I'm 65, what is this going to look like? And I have approximately three doubling periods in my lifetime, lifetime. You know, like those things are really important to give us an idea of like, ⁓ the finish line? What is it going to look like? ⁓ amount of risk do I have to take? That's a huge part of our financial planning conversations. And we to break down a lot of the pieces it takes for somebody to accomplish like the objective, it actually starts to remove the idea of risk. So now they're focused on like, that 100,000 is gonna double to 200, then it's gonna double to 400. So my efforts today is $400,000 24 years from now. That's awesome. Now they have an idea of where they're going to, and it's easier to hit the goal when you understand what the result is gonna look like. Portfolio Planning: Absolutely, really well said. I'll give you guys this as a real case scenario. So ⁓ love math, obviously, as financial planners. That's our second language or third language. ⁓ tax growth is so good because when it comes to ⁓ us plans ⁓ for guys, ⁓ it's a reverse engineering of the math. So if we know how much you're going to be spending in retirement, roughly based on your current cash flow and inflation and things like that, we can have a future value number that we need to get to at. let's say age 55, that's presumably when you want to retire. Once we have that finishing point, we can reverse engineer the math and figure out what our annual contributions need to be and then what our annual rate of return needs to be to hit that finish line. And a great example is a client that we had a couple of weeks ago, a husband, wife. The husband is a business owner and the wife was a physician. And when we looked at their investment portfolio, it was super high risk. There was a crypto in there, mostly capital gains, investments and individual. It was TechSoc called the make seven. So they're individually holding like Microsoft and Apple and things like that, which isn't horrible, but a lot of volatility. And when we were asking them about how they feel about their investment portfolio, they're both stressed about it all the time. like, don't know what's up and down. But we need to invest, we need to invest. When we did the math, they only really needed to get a 4.6 % rate of return to get to their future value number. And that was considering recessionary periods, a new vehicle every five years. education funds for their kids, so on and so forth. But because of their income and the annual contributions they're able to do, you can actually look like, okay, well, you don't like the risk and you also don't need to take the risk. Because you're taking advantage of the tax-free savings account and the compounding effects that it'll have, and it's also not going to hurt you in your withdrawal period of giving back all the security money and things of that type, they can significantly ratchet down the risk. And to get a 4.6 % return, you're looking at a very balanced portfolio, or if not conservative. right away they're like, that's amazing and they can just relax and only be taking big swings but they don't want to and they don't need to and if anything sometimes that can actually have an adverse effect on your plan because you're taking the swings and missing them and now you need to recover from that which we'll talk about in future episodes but the rule of 72 within your tax free savings account is really great for your financial planner because that's very easy math for us to do so you know what is your return net of fees net of taxes And the net of taxes is quite easy to calculate in your TFSA because there is no taxes in your tax-free savings account. So we really, really love that math. So hopefully that helps you guys. The other thing we want to talk about is the asset allocation strategy. So asset allocation, for those of don't know, it's kind of like that pie chart. I don't know, if you're driving and listening audio only, you can't see me talking with my hands, which I tend to do often. But if you think about that chart that shows... different slivers of fixed income and bonds and equities and cash, that's a diversified portfolio. So you don't have all your eggs in one preferable basket. You want to have them into different asset classes. So, Tessa, how does that tie into a TFSA and like, know, where does a TFSA fit inside of building a actual balanced diversified approach? ⁓ Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, funny because the advisors that we talk to, the amount differing opinions is kind of hilarious. When we're looking growth-focused vehicle to build, accumulate, and retain wealth, my personal view ⁓ is tax-free savings account a growth vehicle. Some advisors will say, because there's no tax on it, your tax-free savings account should be holding all of your fixed income. cause ⁓ interest is taxed at the highest tax rate of all of the ⁓ that you can have in your portfolio. but rule of 72 on a, you know, a thousand dollar basket that's growing at 3%, it's not super impressive ⁓ and not fully taking advantage of the tax-free capability. The other thing that we want to look at when we see portfolios and we kind of look under the hood, it's kind of like a doctor, right? Like a doctor seeing tons of patients naked, nothing surprises you anymore. when we look at client statements, sometimes they feel like they're bearing their parts to us, but we look at it and we say, you know what, one of the things that we see that's quite common ⁓ ⁓ ⁓ that pay US dividends ⁓ a Canadian tax-free savings account. What most people don't know is if you held the same stock in an RRSP or in a non-registered account, you're gonna get the full benefit of those US-based stocks and their dividends. Whereas inside a tax-free savings account, there's no tax treaty with the IRS, and IRS does not like things that are tax-free, so they actually withhold 15%. So if you held ⁓ Microsoft your tax-free savings account and you held it in your RRSP, ⁓ it'll look like the rate of return and the dividend is higher inside your RRSP, not because it's a better investment or anything. It's just because there's a tax treaty in place and IRS is not withholding or like restricting the flow through of that dividend and they keep 15%. It's like a sales tax on your dividend. Portfolio Planning: Yeah, and a lot of people don't realize that when we look and analyze investment portfolios, they have US stocks and they go, yeah, it's performing well. Oh, no, I never have. I don't have callbacks or chargebacks. I don't need to pay tax on it. But you don't realize it because it's on the sale or the crystallization of your returns. So if it's a fixed income one, for example, or if it's in a I don't know, it's a index fund that gets rebalanced, it's going to be withheld then. So you don't really notice it until you pick up the hood or, you know, put the stethoscope on it and look a little bit deeper. yeah, so I don't have anything to add onto that one. I think you nailed it perfectly. ⁓ ⁓ Tyson Nagasaka: No, I think the only thing that I would add onto that is like, so like, what's the solution? I just talked about the problem. What's the solution? It be to buy a Canadian based version of what you're wanting. So if you're just buying the S &P 500 and you're having fun in this last week or so with that, but ⁓ you just bought the S &P 500 and you bought the US version of it, you'd have to buy a Canadian version of it. Portfolio Planning: Hahaha Tyson Nagasaka: So in Canada, we have like an iShares version. have, I think we have SPY, SPY, there's VU. a bunch of different ones. And so we don't really prescribe indexes for you for those I have a for what I would use, but we would direct people to utilize a Canadian based version so that your tax treatment is already baked in and you're gonna get, if it says, it's giving a 9 % rate of return or 5 % dividend, you're getting all of that. Portfolio Planning: Yeah, and that's a good quick note is when you're looking to buy those indexes and you're looking at this, those tickers, a Canadian, usually there's a Canadian and a ⁓ one. So just make sure you're buying the right one and ⁓ slow down and do a little extra due diligence and just buy the right one based on what portfolio. And it really is only mostly your TFSA that you want to be careful of. So when you're looking to buy inside of tax-free saving account, just make sure you're looking at the Canadian version. But yeah, I think to Tais's point, A lot of people will have different opinions on should you hold a fixed income in that portfolio or should you have your capital gains or your growth stocks inside that portfolio? What I would definitively say is you don't want to have high speculative investments inside your tax-free savings account. So had some clients that were trying to buy like... crypto or pre IPO stuff inside the TFSA, was a huge no-no for us because if it ⁓ you're losing that contribution room that you'll never get back. ⁓ you can't ⁓ it to offset gains elsewhere, which don't get over complicated with it, but ⁓ basically there's any risk of you losing, not any risk, if there's a higher risk of you either hitting a home run or you striking out. ⁓ Don't do that in your tax free savings account because the most important thing in your TFSA is the contribution room that you have accumulated up until that point. from 09 to basically 2026, it's been accumulating and you've been granted or given extra contribution every single year. You don't wanna throw that down the drain because you buy some. I don't know, some pre-IPO thing that someone that you met at some event one time was like, this thing's a home run. Trust me, I'm in on it too. all that kind of stuff. they want to bring a lot of people in and then they'll sell their position first. Once it plummets, then you guys are just left holding the bank. ⁓ we call those rug pulls. There's place for those sometimes if you want to some chances, cool, but don't ever do it in your TFSA because you don't want to lose that contribution room. And if you do have a miss, you can't... use that to offset gains on a different investment that performed well. definitely never do that in your TFSA. But two schools of thought in there. Wrong is it depends on your situation. But ⁓ if have your dividend paying inside your corporation, you get smashed with tax, which we'll talk about in a second. But if you have those same fixed income investments held inside your TFSA, you're good. And you're not going to be taxed on the fixed income that gets triggered every single ⁓ time you it. But as long as you have a diverse portfolio, you can take a look and see where's the best place to hold it for each person they're gonna have a different share, right? So like some people, you might have an 80-20 mix, whereas your colleague might have a 90-10 mix and your other colleague might have a 70-30 or 60-40. So depending how much fixed income you need to hold, you can have it different areas, but definitely don't hold speculative high-risk stocks. It just doesn't make any sense inside your TFSA. Moving on to the next one. So this is one that a lot of you... will be confused about and make mistakes on, which is, talked about that, we painted this picture before. You're a doc, you have extra money that you don't need to spend, so it's been sitting inside your corporation. So naturally, ⁓ just start investing because you don't want it to sit there and do nothing. So there's corporate passive income traps that are very, very common for those of you to fall into. And we see this. countless times a week. And when we look at people's portfolios, they're investing inside the corporation and they don't realize the taxable impacts of it. So teach them some ⁓ passive income traps. What that? How does it impact the ⁓ Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, so I think there's a lot of fear around this and because of that the negativity is people don't invest and so that's ⁓ number one that we see. ⁓ so they might have hundreds of thousands or even a million or two in cash or cash instruments ⁓ the power of that dollar is slipping away every day. And so you want to have that money growing at a minimum keeping pace with inflation. ⁓ but we do see a lot of business owners that are conservative and they get their financial advice from the teller at the bank. so naturally they have hundreds of thousands of dollars in GICs. GICs are interest instruments inside your core. And so when we look at the tax schedule for what those are, you're taxed at 50%. And so if you're getting a 3 % GIC inside your corporation, you're netting 1.5. That's not good. It's not a lot and it's not good. If you have foreign dividends, so if you're investing in those like Microsoft, Exxon Mobil, any of the big banks in the States, so if you're holding ⁓ foreign companies they're paying foreign dividends, they're also taxed at 50 % and you don't get any rebate on there. If you're holding eligible inside your corporation that ⁓ eligible dividends, you're to pay 50 % tax, but you're going to get a refund. So we get something that's, we're not going to cover it in this episode. It's another acronym, but it is called refundable dividend tax on hand or RDTOH. So you're going to get a little bit of a rebate on that. The best one that we see is gains treatment ⁓ on And so what capital gains inside your corporate investment account allow you to do is have it kind of like a corporate RRSP. You got $100, it gets invested, it grows, it's now $300. When you go to cash that out, you have to pay tax on the $200 of gains. The tax inclusion is 50%, so 50 % of the $200 is $100, and then you're taxed at 25%, so you're paying 25 bucks on that $200 gain. So it sounds like a lot, they say it's 50%, but it's actually 50 % inclusion and then you get taxed on that. And it typically works out to about a 25 % rate on capital gains. So it's much more favorable. And when we have clients that are investing, you can build even a conservative or a moderate portfolio that will be capital gains tilted. And it's going to give you a favorable tax treatment to grow that money inside your corporation. I hit on all the points on that one? I kind of went on a rant. Portfolio Planning: Yeah, just to, you know, I'll bring it in and kind of simplify it. when you are investing inside your corporation, anything that's not your active business, so let's say for example, you're an automatrist, anything that's not your active business, so your clinic income or your eyewear or treatments, things like that, that's all active income. Anything besides that inside your corporation would be passive income. you're a dentist. Same thing, your treatments, your billings, all that stuff is active income. Any investments is passive income. That's not included in that. If you're a doctor, MSP, know, fee-for-service, whatever your billing model is, that's active income. Anything else besides that is all passive income. So that gets really complicated for people. like, okay, well, it's not passive. I had to sit there and think about what to buy. That doesn't matter. It's still passive income. If you're owning real estate inside of your corporation and you're renting it out, That's also passive income and people are like, okay, well, if I do fairly frequently, I can count it as active income. mean, not really as a gray area. I think the general rule of thumb is if you have like some more than six employees, then you can actually count it as an active, proper business. Less than that, it's going to be passive. So there's basically a lot of things that go into the passive income bucket. And the reason the CRA does that is they're not... They know that people are going to leave their money inside the corporation and grow it and grow it and grow it and eventually, yes, they'll have to pull it over on the personal side, but the government doesn't know when that's going to be. So if you let people defer indefinitely, you cannot really see an income for 40, 50 years, you know, per doc, which doesn't really make sense for the CRA. So what they want to do is like a game of whack-a-mole and force you to panic and bring your money onto the personal side. And we're not here to say that you shouldn't invest inside your corporation. You should. but you just need to be aware of the impacts of your investment. So basically everything that's not gonna be your income as a doctor is gonna be counting in the passive income bucket, which is gonna be, talked about RDTLH, but half of that ⁓ gains ⁓ fine, but the other half is gonna be taxed at 50%. So there's a lot of tax that comes into it. And then once you get over $50,000 of passive income, so again, as a reminder, it's not your clinic income, it's... everything else, all your GSEs, your high interest savings accounts, your capital gains, your index funds that are balancing, that are triggering capital gains, positions that you're selling, like if you own Apple and you're selling that position, all that stuff will go into rental income, all that stuff will go into your passive income. So once you are realizing $50,000 or more than $50,000 of that income, you're going to run into a basically a clawback of your small business rate. So if you're in Canada, and you're incorporated, you know the most important thing for you is your capital dividend account and your small business limit. If you stay within a small business limit, that is ideal. That's probably why a lot of you, if you pay attention to your accountant or you recall those conversations, why you're paying salary as opposed to just dividend everything out is because it affords your corporation a large deduction. If you're paying yourself $180,000 a year, you get $180,000 deduction for your corporation, which may bring you down into a small business limit. So if you're earning $650,000 of net income, you're going to be taxing a higher rate on that $150,000. If you push it over to the personal side via a salary, now your corporation gets a deduction and you're going to be under that $500,000 small limit. So if you're earning too much passive income, anything over $50,000 a year is a one to five ratio. So for every $100 above that $50,000, you're losing $500,000 every small business which again can sound very scary, like, ⁓ my God, I can't do that at all. Like, I just can't invest then. You can look at your tax returns, ⁓ unless really at that $500,000 and you're tiptoeing that line consistently, it's not that big of a deal because, you know, sometimes you'll have, I mean, sounds like a down year, but maybe you have a slower year where you're on vacation a little bit more and you're... just turning out like $300,000 or $250,000 or whatever it is. So it's not really impacting you as much as you may think because you have a lot more wiggle room before you start running into the issue where now your income is gonna be that general tax rate inside your corporation. So for each person it's a little bit different, but that is a general rule of thumb is once you get around that 50,000 or getting close to it, you wanna be wary, but it's not gonna impact each person the same. And there's sometimes quick fixes we can do like, you know, maybe you just. notice that, I didn't calculate this properly, I'm actually gonna be in that general tax bracket problem, we just pay yourself a little bit more of a salary, get yourself a bigger deduction, and then just take that money in the personal side ⁓ and it into your RSP or put it into your tax-free savings account or put it your primary residence mortgage or something, and then it's okay. And if you make that mistake, sometimes it makes sense to just bring over more money anyways, since you're in ⁓ that tax bracket anyways, we just might as well send some money over. And then if you're around that... then perhaps you want to start doing some other stuff. Like if you're having too much passive income, of investing inside your corporation and having more passive income problems, ⁓ you want to start to pay down some corporate debt, ⁓ perhaps you want to hold actual ⁓ Like you want to hold Apple or hold Microsoft or hold Shopify or something like that. And then you can decide when you eventually sell that position. So you're not going to have any problems of ⁓ passive income that's just happening for you. You actually choose when to trigger. that sale and when to trigger that capital gains. But know, Tyson kind of painted a picture of a GIC. So we just had this last week, we a client that had about like three and a half to $4 million inside the corporation that was all invested in GICs. And they weren't like super amazing GICs. It was like 2.8 to 3 % in the GIC and it about 4 million sitting there. And they didn't even realize when you look at the tax return, how that was adding to their passive income problem. So you know, you may have this problem, you may not, but it's worth just having a conversation with your accountant or financial planner or both ideally, and just looking through your tax return to see what's happening and where is that problem coming from. It's the same thing when you go to see your doctor, it's like, I got this pain over here. It's usually been caused from something else and somewhere in the kinetic chain. So same kind of idea when it comes to finances. There's a lot of corporate passive traps. It's like you're walking through the forest and there's bear traps all over the place. So you kind of got to need to know how to navigate around it. doesn't mean you should not invest. You should just do it correctly as per your own individual plan. Because again, as a reminder, all of you listening and watching need to get all of your money from the corporate side onto the personal side at some point. You can do that while you're working. If you have a sellable business, some of our dentists that have clinics they can sell and use the lifetime capital gains exemption, that's great. For some of our physician clients, almost all of our physician clients, you don't have a sellable business, so. you don't have that lifetime capital gain, so it's about doing it during your working career. So you just want to be aware that you can invest inside your corporation, but there's a lot of rules for it, and it's really just deferring the problem that you need to get on the personal side. Anyways. So I think that's all for the learning side. Let's move to our next segment, which is our prescription pad. So this is the part where we want to give you guys a prescription. Hopefully you can read our writing and send you out of the office with something to action right away. So. Tyson for all of our listeners prescription pad. What do you got? Tyson Nagasaka: Well, kind of like what I alluded to at the beginning of the podcast, there's four things that are tax free. And so we want to make sure we take advantage of every tax free vehicle that we have. Number one is your principal residence, right? They threatened to take that away. Thank God they didn't. Principal residence is tax free. If you bought a house in 1990 for $100,000 in Vancouver, today it's worth $2 million. You don't have to pay tax when you sell that house. Number two, is life insurance. And so if you have life insurance in place, personally, in your corporation, wherever, as long as it's put together properly, it is tax-exempt and you won't pay tax on that. Number ⁓ lottery If you win the lotteries, call me. I know what to do. And we help you ⁓ stay rich Number four is tax-free savings account. And so you want to make sure that you realize there's only a few things that are tax free. You want to be very aware of what you're doing and you want to be investing properly in your tax free savings account. mentioned biased earlier. I multi-manager, ⁓ strategies make a lot of sense. It's ⁓ true diversification. takes a lot of the risk out of the picture for clients. ⁓ The scary thing that we've been seeing is people who want to do it themselves. Because you can YouTube everything, you can chat GBT everything, we get a lot of people who want to do it themselves. I was just saying to Vishal before we hit record, I took apart my dryer because I'm going to do it myself. I need to fix something. And right now it's in pieces because I needed to order a part. I'm paying the price for doing it myself. When you do it yourself for your investment portfolio, sometimes you can't see the mistakes or you don't understand some of the biases that you have internally. And we want to make sure that as a team, we work together to show you, hey, you know, that is called recency bias just because those AI stocks did a rip of 180 % growth in the past four years. It doesn't mean that it's going to in the next four years. And here's some of the things you want to consider. So having that sounding board I just to also tie back to what Vishal was saying about talking to your accountant about the risks of tax and taxation and how all that stuff ties together, we're a huge proponent of building and assembling your financial team. You don't wanna go it alone when you have substantial income, when you have the ability to be a major wealth accumulator, you wanna ensure that you have a team that's built. they're talking to you, building a plan based on what you're trying to achieve, and they're all talking together. The last thing you want is to have a team of four or five professionals, and they have four or five plans for you and for your future, and of those plans are not gonna be in alignment, and that's gonna waste your time, that's gonna waste your money, ⁓ and might not be able to achieve all of that you could had they been in alignment. Portfolio Planning: Yeah, and my prescription pad for those of you that are listening would be for almost all of you, it makes sense before you start investing inside your corporation, have your TFSA maxed out. What you're going to invest in is going be different for each and every one of you based on your own situation and your goals, but that is almost, it's very rare in finance that we have a blanket statement, but I would say that's almost entirely all of you should have your TFSA maxed out. before starting to invest inside of your corporation. that's ⁓ simply my prescription for you. ⁓ that opened up at whatever your institution is and just invest it. Don't just open your TFSA, put money in it, open it, put your money in it and invest it. And every single year on January 1st, you'll have more contribution room that comes up every single year. So just have a reminder of your team. Your team should be reminding every single year. But when the calendar rolls over, you're to have more contribution room. So kick some money from your corporation into your TFSA, but have that maxed out before you start investing inside your corporate structure, aka non-registered. Awesome. Ending off here, we're go to our mail bag. So these are questions that are given to us from our Facebook group. So if you don't know, we have a closed Facebook group for doctors across Canada. Really a spot for you guys to learn from each other, ask questions. ⁓ We go live there and educate you guys further than the podcast, just kind of deep dive into some topics. what we want to do is get the questions from you guys and bring them over here and answer them. So ⁓ questions that came to the TFSA. First one was... ⁓ Should I invest personally if I have corporate cash? So Tyson, why don't you lead us off? Should I invest personally if I have corporate cash? Tyson Nagasaka: ⁓ Short answer is yes. Like what you were saying is ⁓ money out of the corp is gonna have to happen at some point. You wanna have cash on the personal side, cause if you have incidentals, if you need a roof, if you need to replace your car, if the need to go to school, like you wanna have cash on the personal side. ⁓ Sorry? Portfolio Planning: You need to buy a new dryer after you DIY it? If you need to buy a new dryer after you DIY it? Tyson Nagasaka: Yeah, yeah, yeah. So yes, you should be investing personally and taking advantage of your registered accounts. Just like Vishal was saying, you get RSP room when you take money out of your corp. Yes, you pay tax on it. But if you put it into your RSP, you get a refund on the personal side. It's not a net zero, but it's pretty close. And so ensuring that you have taken advantage of the registered accounts that are available to you. is part of the planning that your financial team should be doing to look at how do we help you achieve and maximize and take advantage of all of the things that you can do to ⁓ your situation better and more efficient with your cash flow. You know, that being said, sometimes you're to have cash in your corp and you're saying, I'm going to wait ⁓ my We're in March right now. My corporate year ends not till November. I don't want to really do anything. Well, you can invest that and you can even be conservative with that while you wait for your year end to wrap up because you might have new purchased, you might have to do something inside the business and so you do need cash there as well. I understand that. So we're not saying that it's all ⁓ or for either way. But yes, you should have some personal investments and you should have some corporate investments. Portfolio Planning: Yeah, I agree. Just to add on to that is, yeah, definitely invest personally if you have corporate cash because I keep it in the same thing. Home is you need to have your money on the personal side at some point. So if you have debt that's incurring interest, not so much credit card, lot of our clients, I don't even know if any of our clients really have huge credit card issues. It's more so like a student line of credit or things like that. If you have that, that's investing it kind of because you're taking what would possibly cause you a tax problem investing inside your corporation. bring to the personal side and paying off debt that will give you risk-free rate of return. So if you have like a 7 % interest rate on your line of credit, you can take that money, pay off your line of credit, get a guaranteed rate of return of 7 % before any market volatility is even in the question. You also have your tax-free savings account. We talked about it earlier about the math of the rule of 72 in your tax-free savings account. So that's always really important. So yes, you should almost always invest personally if you have corporate cash. until the point that you kind of fill up your TFSA, you got rid of your bad debt, and then it's a conversation of, you know, winning if RRSP makes sense for you, and we'll talk about that in later episodes, but you should definitely fill up those spots if you have the money on the corporate side. And I should also preface that by saying, doesn't mean you take all of your money out right away. All money you take from the corporate and the personal side is going to trigger personal attacks, so you want to make sure it's, you know, blended, and that's kind of the good thing. As much as people... for lack of a better word, shit on the Canadian tax system. The nice thing about it is it's very integrated and blended. So you're paying the tax somewhere, whether it's corporately or personally, the math usually ends up being the same. But if you have years of fluctuating income, then we can kind of foresee that as your planners of knowing that you're starting a family the next little bit, or you got this large vacation, or you go back to school to on a new specialization. Those are kind of things that we can see of like, we'll defer this and pull the money out a little bit later, things of that type. But anyways, go to the next one is, investing smart inside of your corporation or your tax free savings account. We kind of talked about this, but let's answer quick again, Tyson. Dividend investing is a smarter inside of your corporation or personally. Tyson Nagasaka: I think you're going to end up having some dividend paying investments inside both portfolios. think just being aware of how they're taxed ⁓ ⁓ the correct setup ahead time makes a lot of sense. ⁓ So you're holding foreign dividend companies in your corporate investment account, just understand that you're going to pay tax on that. When you get those dividends, it's a little bit higher tax rate. It's kind of equivalent to having the foreign investments inside your tax-free savings account, they're gonna pay a dividend to you and it's gonna get cut down by 15 % by the IRS before it exits the US to come to you. And so having the investment vehicle in the right bucket, it does make a lot of sense. There's usually Canadian versions of what you want. And so have a look at what's going on there and then like all of the investment partners that you know most Canadian advisors use They ⁓ be set up properly from the get-go. So you're not gonna have a ton of that foreign dividend interference But ⁓ receiving inside your portfolio, it's always nice Portfolio Planning: Yeah, I don't really have anything else to add to that. only thing I would say is just be aware of when it becomes a problem. And I hope this episode provided that for you of when it will become a problem for you, more so on the corporate side up until you get closer to that 50,000, it's not really a huge problem. ⁓ don't, you know, ⁓ and get paralysis by trying to figure out this perfect thing for a problem that's not even relevant for you right now. And honestly, it may never be relevant depending how much you want to work, how much you're earning. If you're not even real close. super close to that small business limit, it's not really going to impact you all that much. that's one thing I would add on, Tyson nailed it, but I would just add on is, you know, don't worry about trying to solve a problem that's not relevant for you. It's just going to cause extra complexities to an already complex problem, which is your finances. So that's it for us today for episode two of Portfolio Talks. We really hope that you took away a better understanding of the tax-free savings account versus just investing all your retained earnings inside your corporation. Not to say you should never invest. you should, but there's a couple landmines that you want to be aware of. Things like the passive income, things like, you know, just losing compounding effects of your tax-free savings account, things like not investing correctly inside your tax-free savings account, aka use Canada, not US, everything kind of in between. So as always, Make sure you share, like, subscribe. It really helps us on this front of just trying to educate you guys in preventative health when it comes to your finances. And if you want to join the Mailbag segment and get your questions answered, you can join our Facebook group. We go live in there. We answer questions and a little bit of deeper analysis because we have really more space and we're not confined to trying to hit this episode on a basically we want to keep it a commute level of duration. So if you're driving from, you know, back and forth from the clinic. or working out, that's what I do. I listen to podcasts when I'm working out, which sometimes is a controversial thing. People are like, what? You listen to podcasts when you work out? I think it's good. One hour podcast, one hour workout, I'm good to go. But if you wanna get your questions in, join our Facebook group. We'll link it in the episodes on whatever platform you're watching. And feel free to follow us also at Portfolio Planning on all social medias across the channel. And we hope to see you guys next time. Thanks everyone.