Latest / Bourbon Bytes Podcast / High West Bourye 2025 Review + Maker’s Mark Cellar Aged & Penelope Big LE Drops!
Transcript
- 0:00Today on the Bourbon Bytes podcast, we're keeping the news train rolling with tons of new whiskey
- 0:05releases for 2025, including the new Maker's Mark Cellar Ages release, High West's first
- 0:11bottled-in-bond bourbon, and Penelope's new Estate Collection. Plus, I'm reviewing the
- 0:152025 release of High West Distillery's Bourye Whiskey. Hello everyone and welcome to the
- 0:33Bourbon Bytes podcast. I'm your host, Clifton, and this is the week of Thursday, August 28th,
- 0:382025. And do I have a show for you today? Right off the heels of last week's episode with a bunch
- 0:44of limited edition bourbon announcements, we have even more to talk about this week.
- 0:49And this is to be expected as we get closer to fall. That seems to be the season where
- 0:53all these new releases come out. There's so much to keep up with and I just want to make sure to
- 0:58give you guys the highlights as soon as I find out about them. Whether or not we get to try
- 1:02them on the podcast or the YouTube channel, that just depends on one, if I can find them on the
- 1:07shelves. Two, if brands want to send me a sample for review, contact@bourbonbytes.com. Or if
- 1:12friends are generous enough to let me try a sample from their bottles. But today we do have a fun
- 1:17limited edition review of High West Bourye. I'm looking forward to getting into that with you
- 1:23guys for this week's Byte Sized review. But first, we got to get through some news stories that I
- 1:27think you should know about. I know I'm not the only one excited about this LE season, as we
- 1:33call it, in bourbon and whiskey. But especially for me this year, one of the commitments I made
- 1:38for the channel and the podcast this year is I was going to make sure to try some limited editions
- 1:43that I normally would, you know, maybe miss just because they're high priced or harder to get.
- 1:48But this year is all about finding them and giving you guys my honest thoughts on them.
- 1:53I've done quite a few already, but hopefully some of the ones I talk about in this week's podcast
- 1:57we get to try in the near future. So stay tuned to make sure to subscribe on YouTube and follow
- 2:03me on your favorite podcast platform to be notified whenever I get a chance to try and
- 2:08review these upcoming releases. Putting it out into the universe now, just just come on, bring
- 2:13on the releases. The first new release I want to talk about today is Maker's Mark's Cellar Aged
- 2:19Bourbon is back in 2025. So they started this back in 2023 originally, and they basically are
- 2:26blending together some of their bourbon that has been aged at least half of their maturation cycles
- 2:31in Maker's Mark's limestone cellar as opposed to the usual rickhouses where they spend most of
- 2:37their aging. And this is a pretty rare process in whiskey. We see cellar aging a lot with wine,
- 2:41but they are experimenting with it and it seems to be a really successful collection.
- 2:46I did have a chance to try one of the previous releases and thought it was a unique take on
- 2:50Maker's Mark, but this year they are blending an 11, a 13, and a 14 year old whiskey to make the
- 2:58Maker's Mark Cellar Aged 2025 release. That's some really highly aged Maker's Mark. As you remember,
- 3:04Maker's Mark doesn't typically do age statements on their standard releases. It's relatively new
- 3:09for them to be doing it, so for them to be blending some of this oldest whiskey that
- 3:13Maker's Mark has ever produced into a release is really, really cool. Now this is going to be
- 3:18bottled at 56.45% or 112.9 proof. I'm assuming that's cask strength. I don't see it labeled as
- 3:26cask strength here, but I think previous releases have been considered cask strength as well.
- 3:30And it's going to be available first at the Maker's Mark gift shop. They're having a few
- 3:34bottles available before anyone else in the country can get it. So if you are in Kentucky
- 3:39and you are looking to get a bottle of that, they're going to release it on September 5th
- 3:45before a wider nationwide release in mid-September. They haven't announced the number of bottles, but
- 3:50we do know a little bit more about the blend. So 74% of it is an 11 year old bourbon, 10% is the
- 3:5713 year old, and 16% is the 14 year old bourbon. They say that the whiskey is rich and balanced
- 4:03and drinks more easily than its proof might suggest and settles into a refined finish.
- 4:08So the reason that this is some of the oldest Maker's Mark we've ever seen is because the
- 4:13cellar age process does kind of limit some of the oak impact on the bourbon. You know, if we had like a
- 4:1914 year old Maker's Mark that was sitting in the rickhouses, they're saying that, you know, that
- 4:23could lead to astringency or bitterness. You know, we've seen that before with some older bourbons.
- 4:27Older doesn't always mean better. And I imagine they've probably done some experimenting with
- 4:31older Maker's Mark and they didn't really find it up to par to release it at that age. But moving
- 4:36it into these cellars, they could kind of round it out, give it a little more age without that
- 4:41massive, you know, heat influence from the rickhouses. So that's really exciting. I would
- 4:46love a chance to try this release. If you guys get a hand on it, let me know, especially if
- 4:50you can compare it to the previous releases. Like I said, I had a sample of the 2023 one, I believe.
- 4:55Didn't get a chance to do it side by side with any other Maker's Mark releases, but I do remember
- 5:00really, really enjoying that. So I will definitely be keeping an eye out for this bottle. Pricing on
- 5:04it is going to be $175, which is steep, but I think for a very well-aged Maker's Mark, that's
- 5:12a pretty fair price. I think if you can get it close to retail, it's definitely worth trying,
- 5:16especially if you're a Maker's Mark fan and you like their high age, high proof releases.
- 5:21All right, well, I'll keep the ball rolling with new releases. High West Distillery out of
- 5:26Park City, Utah just announced their first bottled-in-bond bourbon that's been distilled exclusively
- 5:33at their distillery in Utah. So High West is mostly known for their rye whiskey. They've
- 5:38previously released a bottled-in-bond rye, but this is their first bottled-in-bond bourbon that
- 5:43they've had that's, you know, made at their distillery. They used to source a lot from MGP
- 5:48when they were first getting started. They're, like I said, mostly a rye distillery. When I
- 5:52went to do the tour, that's basically all we talked about was the rye. The bourbon was something that
- 5:56they were, you know, you know, I felt like more of like an experimental thing for them, but rye is
- 5:59where they excelled at. So I'm really curious to see how this bourbon is. My experience with their
- 6:05bourbon is relatively limited. Mostly their rye is what I gravitate towards. But like I said,
- 6:10today's review, we're going to review their Bourye, which is a blend of straight whiskeys. Now,
- 6:14it's not all distilled at their distillery. We'll get into the mash bill and all that.
- 6:19But this is a pretty exciting release. It's going to sell for $80. It's available for pre-sale now
- 6:24on their website. It's supposed to ship mid to late August. So either like very, very soon,
- 6:31maybe by the time this podcast comes out, they'll be available. The mash bill is 36% rye and 64%
- 6:37non-GMO yellow corn. So there's no malted barley in this bourbon, which is interesting. They just
- 6:43stuck with a corn and rye mash bill. This has been aged for four years and five months, and
- 6:48it's bottled at 100 proof, as are all bottled-in-bond bourbons and ryes. So not only is it going to
- 6:53be available on their website at the distillery, but it's also going to go nationwide for a
- 6:58suggested retail price of $79.99. It's not that I'd be interested in trying, you know, their bourbon
- 7:04is not really what they're known for, but it doesn't mean they can't make a good spirit. But
- 7:09congrats to them for having a bottled and bond bourbon that they've distilled themselves. That's
- 7:13not something I expected to see out of High West, at least this soon with their focus being so much
- 7:17on rye whiskey, but good for them. All right. Last piece of new whiskey news comes to us from
- 7:24Penelope Bourbon. They just announced their 2025 Estate Collection, which is a highly anticipated
- 7:30collection showcasing higher age statements, new innovation and increased allocation across
- 7:35each release. So this year they're having five different expressions with minimum age statements
- 7:40of 10 years old. It includes a reimagined Founders Reserve Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey,
- 7:44the introduction of new Omega straight bourbon whiskey finished in Omega French oak barrels,
- 7:51and the award winning single barrel and private select bourbons. So they released the Penelope
- 7:56Estate Collection last year and ended up winning a ton of awards. So I'm excited to see what they
- 8:01have to bring to the table this year. I think one of the highlights is the Founders Reserve 13 year
- 8:07old Kentucky straight bourbon whiskey that they have, um, suggested retail of $199.99. It is a
- 8:14mash bill of 78% corn, 10% rye and 12% malted barley age for 13 years and bottled a cask
- 8:21strength at 121.4 proof. Now, interestingly enough, this is a Kentucky bourbon. So, um, I would
- 8:27imagine this is probably sourced from one of the legacy distilleries, um, because most of what
- 8:32Penelope does is out of Indiana. So it's exciting to see some, uh, Kentucky bourbon in the mix this
- 8:38year. Now, like I said, they're also introducing a new addition to the lineup, which is an Omega
- 8:4211 year straight bourbon whiskey. And this kind of feels like an evolution of their Architect
- 8:46series. Um, they're working with the same Cooperage, um, that's known for their OakScan technology,
- 8:51which scientifically select staves with the exact chemical composition needed to achieve the
- 8:57desired flavor profile. If you've been following these releases, they have like the OakScan on the
- 9:00back of the bottle, but this one is using their Omega barrels, which are considered the pinnacle
- 9:05of French oak innovation. They say this is crafted with rare tight grain oak and meticulously designed
- 9:11toast profile. Of course, starting with the 11 year old distillate and then putting it into these
- 9:16finishing casks, you're adding even more depth and, um, nuances to that bourbon. The mash bill
- 9:22on this one is going to be 78% corn, 10% rye and 12% malted barley. And it's going to be bottled
- 9:27at 109.8 proof. These are going to come in at $129.99. Um, there's going to be a limited allocation
- 9:34of 1800 cases of 750 milliliter bottles and available in select markets starting in September.
- 9:41Now this next one's interesting. They're having two different releases of their single barrel,
- 9:4510 year bourbon, both of which are going to be going for $89.99 retail. The first of which is
- 9:52a mash bill of 75% corn, 21% rye and 4% malted barley bottled at 99 proof. The second of which
- 9:59is going to be a mash bill of 60% corn, 36% rye and 4% malted barley bottled at 103 proof. So
- 10:07there's a bit of a lower rye bourbon and a higher rye bourbon, um, both at different proof points,
- 10:11but same price point. They say that these hand selected barrels, uh, showcase the nuanced
- 10:16complexity of the finest stock of well-aged bourbon, um, and deemed too exceptional to blend.
- 10:22So exciting to see two different releases of that. I love both of those mash bills from Indiana.
- 10:28Um, curious to see that they are bottled at lower proof than cask strength. I'm wondering what that
- 10:33decision was, was for, was it to get more of the bottles or was it just because they felt like they
- 10:37excelled at those proof points? Would be curious to, to try those though. Some very, very interesting.
- 10:42And lastly is the private select 10 year bourbon at $79.99 retail. This is also aged 10 years. Um,
- 10:50it has a mash bill of 74% corn, 20% rye, 1% wheat and 5% malted barley. Now, even though this is
- 10:57called private select, it is a blended bourbon. So that's what sets it apart from those single
- 11:01barrels we saw earlier. This one is bottled at 106.8 proof. Now, according to Michael Palladini,
- 11:08who is the founder of Penelope bourbon and vice president of strategy of MGP ingredients,
- 11:13he says that this year's collection is their most exciting and accessible yet.
- 11:16It's going to be available this September in select markets with first access to the entire
- 11:21collection exclusively at Lux Row Distillers beginning on Friday, September 5th at 9am EST.
- 11:27They also have a product locator on their website. If you want to look for it outside of the area.
- 11:31Now I'll leave it to you fine folks to decide if you're in the area to go to pick up either
- 11:35these releases or the Maker's Mark Cellar Aged, both are coming out on the same day.
- 11:40Um, so you can make me make a whole day of it. Maybe I would probably start out at Maker's Mark.
- 11:45I don't know what time they're opening, but, um, yeah, I imagine those Cellar Aged releases are
- 11:48going to go fast and then make your way over to Lux Row to get this one, but we should be a fun
- 11:53day to do some bourbon hunting. I wish I could make it out there. All right. Well, that does it for
- 11:58our news this week. No video game news. Um, I know there's a Nintendo Direct supposedly rumored to
- 12:02be coming out in September, so we'll have lots of new updates then, but I think it's time for us to
- 12:07move into our Byte-Sized review. All right. Well, earlier in the podcast, we talked about High West
- 12:20new bottled-in-bond bourbon. So I thought the closest thing I had to it was this brand new
- 12:252025 release of their Bourye. Now, when I saw this at my local grocery store, I was a bit confused
- 12:32because I thought that they had changed boo ride to being a distillery only release. Turns out that
- 12:38was a temporary decision because the 2025 release is back available nationally. So definitely picked
- 12:44this up when I saw it. Um, if you're not familiar with Bourye, it is a blend of straight whiskies.
- 12:49Um, Bourye comes from the name bourbon and rye, and this one is a blend of several. It's marrying
- 12:56two straight rye whiskey mash bills with three straight bourbon whiskey mash bills. So this is
- 13:01going to be a mouthful, but let me, let me go for it. So of the five, the first is a 95/5 rye from MGP.
- 13:08The second is an 80% rye, 20% malted rye from High West distillery. Next up is another MGP
- 13:15mash bill of 75% corn, 21% rye, and 4% barley followed by another MGP mash bill of 60% corn,
- 13:2236% rye, and 4% malted barley. And lastly, a 78% corn, 10% rye, 12% malted barley from an
- 13:29undisclosed Kentucky distillery. Now doing a quick Google search shows that to be a Heaven Hill
- 13:36mash bill, particularly the one used for Elijah Craig. So not to confirm or deny, but that does
- 13:41seem to be where that whiskey is sourced from. Now what's interesting is that all of these
- 13:45components have been aged for a minimum of 10 years old and new charred white American oak
- 13:49barrels, um, before being blended and bottled without chill filtration and bottled at 92 proof.
- 13:56So that means the High West distillate in here, the 80% rye, 20% malted rye is at least 10 years old.
- 14:02That's gotta be some of their oldest stuff I've ever seen them, you know, put out. That's pretty
- 14:05cool. And of course we love some high age MGP and 10 years from Heaven Hill, you know, nothing to
- 14:11snuff at as well. Retail on this bottle is $124.99. I think I paid about that. Maybe a little
- 14:18bit more. It was a Gelson's, so a little bit higher end of a grocery store, but I knew I wouldn't pass
- 14:24up the opportunity to give it a try for close to retail, especially because I was very confused,
- 14:29which led me to finding out that they are no longer distillery only. So I picked up a bottle.
- 14:33So let's go ahead and open up and see how it tastes. So there is a batch number on my bottle.
- 14:38It does say batch 25A28. Not sure how many batches of this, but just want to give that in
- 14:43case you had the same bottle, but this is indeed a 2025 version of Bourye. All right, let's go
- 14:48and give this Bourye a nose. Oh, that's beautiful. Wow. Not really what I expected. It kind of has like
- 14:55a menthol kind of note, kind of similar to like a Vicks Vapor Rub. I don't mean that in a bad way, but
- 15:00I wasn't expecting that to be the first thing I got on the nose here. But that is followed by a sweet
- 15:06fruitiness, almost like cherry. Very, very bright on the nose. Wow. I mean, I don't know what I
- 15:13expected a Bourye to smell like, but that's definitely not it. Once I've kind of gotten more
- 15:18into it, the menthol kind of goes away a little bit. It still does read really herbaceous and bright.
- 15:23I'm getting almost an apple note to it now, but like a freshly sliced green apple, not a, you know,
- 15:31apple pie or anything, but just really crisp apples. That cherry is still there, but it's kind of reading
- 15:36more of like a candied cherry, almost like the filling of like a chocolate covered cherry.
- 15:41I don't know if I'm getting as much of the chocolate of it, though, just the cherry and the
- 15:45sugar filling. Really beautiful, though. I could see this being made into a candle. I think it would be a great
- 15:49holiday candle. The menthol is still there. And, you know, sometimes I feel like that could come
- 15:53across as a bit medicinal, especially with blended with the cherry. But to me, it's coming across
- 15:58more of a very light, delicate, bright, fruity dessert. All right. I've been intrigued by this
- 16:06nose for far long enough. I'm going to go in for a taste. Cheers. Oh, wow. Definitely a different
- 16:14experience than the nose. It's still fruity, but it kind of goes a little more citrus on the
- 16:19palate. And the oak is showing up as well, but it's not the typical oak you would expect for
- 16:24something so old. It's definitely more of like a like a cedar chest kind of note of oak. It's got
- 16:29that like antique kind of dusty quality to it. I'm going for a second taste of that because that was
- 16:33interesting. Wow. Yeah. I mean, completely unexpected. You know, there's a very specific
- 16:37thing that comes to mind when I taste this, and it's sometimes when I go to a really nice cocktail
- 16:42bar or whiskey bar and I get an old fashioned, they have the orange slice, but they put in the
- 16:46cloves into the orange slice and they do a bit of a char on it. And then they put that into the old
- 16:51fashion. To me, it's kind of like a culmination of those flavors. The bitter orange peel note,
- 16:55but combined with that clove and that like little bit of char, it's really, really nice. I think
- 17:00this in a cocktail would be fantastic. I mean, it's nothing like I expected, especially seeing
- 17:04that everything's 10 years old. It's not that it doesn't have that depth of character. It does. It
- 17:08is expressing itself very differently than I expected. Normally I expect it to be super
- 17:12oak forward, a bit tannic and, you know, or even some really like saturated oaky notes,
- 17:17kind of like a Jim Beam product. But this is bright. It's fruity. It's refined. And it does
- 17:24taste like a limited edition release. I always say certain whiskeys have a LE note, and this is
- 17:30exactly what I'm talking about. This is unique. This is unlike anything I've had before. And
- 17:34I dig it. I will say the only, I guess, downfall is with the finish. It's just, it's so bright and
- 17:40fruit forward. The finish doesn't really linger in a way that I kind of expected to be with it
- 17:44being so old. It's kind of a short to medium finish, but it does leave you with a nice spice
- 17:50note. I think it's like that clove and orange combo that I was getting earlier. And it does
- 17:54leave you with a bit of a coated mouth. Like I do feel the oil is still kind of lingering,
- 17:57even though the finish is gone. It's still kind of leaving some of those lingering elements,
- 18:01just covering my palate. How interesting. This is a unique one, especially when I go into like
- 18:06my overall thoughts and score and recommendation. I will say price-wise, you know, $124.99 retail
- 18:13is a bit up there, but this is a unique experience. It's something I've never really
- 18:17had before. It's very different from what their other LEs are, like A Midwinter's Night Dram,
- 18:23which is one of my favorite bottles. Still brings in a lot of similar elements, but it's expressing
- 18:27itself way differently here. I think it's worth a buy for the price. If you're a fan of High West
- 18:32flavor profiles, I don't necessarily see myself picking up a second bottle of it. Maybe next
- 18:37year's release though, for sure. I'd be curious to see how this evolves over time. So this is one
- 18:41I would say to grab one, see how you like it. And if you absolutely love it, go out, buy more. But
- 18:47if you're like me and you feel like it's delicious, it's great, but not something for you every day,
- 18:51maybe wait until each year's release. Scoring this one, I mean, this is really nice and unique.
- 18:56I think I'll have to give this one a 8 out of 10 for my score. I've been trying to do scores more
- 19:01often now, especially when I'm doing the written reviews of these on Reddit, which I've started
- 19:04posting more recently now. Sometimes it's an easy way to kind of quickly gauge if something is worth
- 19:09buying. For me, this is an 8 out of 10 because it's so unique. It's something I've never had before.
- 19:14It's not that crazy of a price. It's not that hard to find. At least it wasn't in my area.
- 19:18Even though that can be seen as a really high rating, I think it's, you know, on par with what
- 19:23I expect some limited edition bourbons to be. I want them to be unique. I want them to be something
- 19:28I've never experienced before or at least have some qualities that I associate with being,
- 19:32you know, either well aged, well blended or just a damn good whiskey. And this checks a lot of those
- 19:39boxes. So, yeah, that's my thoughts on High West's Bourye for 2025. I like it. I'm surprised by it.
- 19:46I am bewildered, should I say, but definitely going to keep an eye out for these in the future.
- 19:51I'm curious to see how it compares to other batches. All right. Well, thank you guys so much again for
- 19:56listening. As always, feel free to leave me your comments and thoughts of the podcast. You can email
- 20:01me, contact@bourbonbytes.com. Send me a message on social media @BourbonBytes or give me a call
- 20:07at 916-64-BYTES. That's 916-642-9837. Leave me a voicemail with your questions or suggestions or
- 20:17comments and I will feature them on next week's show if you want me to. Or if you want to keep it
- 20:22private, just let me know and I'll keep it between us. I'll talk to you guys next week. This has been
- 20:26the Bourbon Bytes Podcast, a whiskey podcast with a gaming twist. Cheers. And I'll talk to you guys
- 20:31next episode. Bye.