Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 60
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder true crime cases five four, three two one one one one one
- 0:22one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you
- 0:31are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get
- 0:34started. Deadly Love the nineteen twenty two killing of Reverend Hall and Eleanor Mills.
- 0:47Most people's wedding vows include the line till death do us part. Such
- 0:53was the case for the couple that was found dead under a crab apple tree
- 0:57in the New Jersey countryside while a man and woman were out for a morning
- 1:00walk. The problem with this vow was both of these people had given such
- 1:07a promise to another person. The downfall of Reverend Edward Hall, who was
- 1:12an Episcopalian priest from New Brunswick and a dead lover Eleanor Mills, a member
- 1:19of the choir at the same church, began when the two of them began
- 1:23an affair. Paul had married an older woman by the name of Francis Stephen,
- 1:29whom many believe was done only for the large sums of money she possessed.
- 1:34Eleanor's significant other also had ties to the same church as a sexton and
- 1:41worked as a janitor. For an elementary school. Although they tried to keep
- 1:46their infidelity a secret, it seemed their behavior was an openly known secret throughout
- 1:53the town. When the two people walked by and discovered their bodies, it
- 1:57was obvious at great care had been taken to arrange them in such a manner
- 2:02that bespoke of the intimacy between the two. Despite the already decaying bodies,
- 2:09it was clear the person who'd murdered them had placed Edward's hand lovingly across Eleanor's
- 2:15neck, with her hand rested atop his thigh. The killer also had torn
- 2:22apart the love letters they had sent to one another and littered the pieces around
- 2:27the bodies. The cause of death of the two was obvious at a glance.
- 2:32Both of them had been shot in the head with what later was determined
- 2:37to be a thirty two caliber pistol. Edward had been struck once, Eleanor
- 2:43three times. A bullet casing had also been left at Edward's feet, likely
- 2:47the one that killed him. In addition to the bullet wounds, Eleanor also
- 2:53had her throat slit open. When doctors later examined the wound, they found
- 2:58that someone had cut out her tongue in Larni's as well. When word of
- 3:02their deaths reached the town, it became an immediate sensation. Onlookers poured into
- 3:08the area and began looking to find a keepsake to document the ugly crime.
- 3:14The visitors showed up at the scene and all but destroyed or stole any evidence
- 3:19that had been left behind. Another item that came up missing was Edward's watch,
- 3:24although it was never determined if the killer or someone looking for a souvenir
- 3:29was the one who removed it. Not long after the investigation began, authorities
- 3:35decided that jealousy was the motive for the crime because the two had been cheating
- 3:39on their spouse. Police had suspected Edward's wife, Francis, and her two
- 3:46brothers might have been the culprits. The result was a media frenzy. The
- 3:51story contained the scandal a wealthy family in The gruesome nature of the crime proved
- 3:57too juicy to ignore, including the national press, which picked up the story.
- 4:02Major publications such as The New York Times and the New York Daily Mirror
- 4:08wrote extensive articles about the case and drew eyes to the small town. It
- 4:13took a full month before the trial finally ended, though most in the court
- 4:17of public opinion believed the now widowed Hall and her brothers to be guilty,
- 4:23considering they had more than enough reason to kill her cheating husband and his likewise
- 4:29lover. Despite the prosecution presenting a woman who raised hogs nearby who claimed to
- 4:34have seen the three near the area, it wasn't enough. The destruction of
- 4:40the crime scene by the many spectators that showed up that day the bodies were
- 4:45found benefited them greatly. In the end, it couldn't be proven beyond a
- 4:50reasonable doubt that they committed the murders. Today, most historical scholars believed that
- 4:57missus Hall and their brothers were the ones to kill Edward and Eleanor. Although
- 5:02the case is still officially listed as unsolved. The tale, however, is
- 5:08leak back into the public view a number of times over the years, in
- 5:12both true and fictional accounts that draw new eyes to this historic case.