Latest / Her Chapter: Female perspectives on life, culture & society / Why We Stay: The Paralysis of Leaving It All Behind | Her Chapter
Transcript
- You packed the box three days ago, but you’re still sitting on the floor staring at the empty space where your favorite mug used to be. That specific kind of terror isn’t about the plane ticket; it’s about who you’ll become when no one knows your name. Grab your tea, because this one is going to require some deep breathing. I received a letter last week from a listener named Maya. She didn’t include her last name, which felt right for what she was writing. Maya has just been offered a dream job in Lisbon. A senior creative role, full autonomy, a salary that makes her eyes water, and an apartment with a view of the Tagus River that looks like something out of a Wes Anderson film. On paper, it is the perfect life. And yet, she hasn’t booked the flight. She hasn’t even told her mother. She wrote to me saying she feels like she is standing on the edge of a cliff, looking down into fog, and all she can think about is how heavy her own feet feel. She said, 'I know this sounds ungrateful. I know I should be jumping. But I’m just so afraid of disappearing.' I read those words and I felt my chest tighten in recognition. Because I know that feeling. Not the Lisbon part, obviously, but the disappearance part. The fear that if you step out of the frame of your current life, you might not have a face left to show up as. Let’s be real for a second. We love our comfort zones. They are warm. They are familiar. You know exactly which floorboard creaks in your hallway. You know how your friends take their coffee. You know the script of your daily interactions. There is a profound safety in being predictable. When we stay in a place that no longer serves us, or a version of ourselves that is too small, we do it because the cost of leaving feels higher than the cost of staying stuck. It’s a calculation we make in the dark, usually late at night when the house is quiet. And recently, we talked about finding purpose when the house goes still. But here’s the thing about stillness—it can become a cage if you aren’t paying attention. Maya isn’t stuck because she lacks ambition. She’s stuck because she is grieving a future she hasn’t lost yet. She is mourning the loss of her known self before she has met her new one. And that is a incredibly human, incredibly valid thing to do. We don’t just pack our clothes when we move abroad. We pack our memories, our inside jokes, our support systems. We leave behind the person who helped us through breakups and promotions and bad haircuts. Who are we without them? That question hangs in the air like smoke. There is a cultural narrative that suggests growth requires a clean break. That you have to burn the bridges to cross the river. That you must leave everything behind to find yourself. This is nonsense. It’s a story sold to us by movies and influencers who have curated their lives into highlight reels. In reality, moving across the world doesn’t erase your history. It just changes the context. Think about the women in your life who have taken big leaps. Did they shed their old skins entirely? Or did they carry their scars, their quirks, and their loves with them, learning to navigate a new terrain with the same essential core? Maya is terrified that she will lose her identity. But identity is not a fixed statue. It is more like water. It takes the shape of the container it is in. If you move to Lisbon, you don’t stop being Maya. You become Maya-in-Lisbon. You bring your humor, your anxiety, your taste in music, your way of listening. Those things travel with you. The fear is not that you will change; the fear is that you won’t recognize the change until it happens. And maybe that’s okay. Maybe not recognizing yourself is the point. Maybe the goal isn’t to stay the same, but to remain curious. Here is the hard truth that nobody wants to say out loud: staying often hurts more than leaving. Staying means watching your potential gather dust. It means answering the same questions every day about why you haven’t moved on, why you haven’t tried harder. It means carrying the weight of 'what if' like a stone in your pocket. Every time you see a postcard, every time you hear a song from that other city, that stone gets heavier. I’ve seen this in my own life, and I’ve seen it in the lives of so many brilliant women I admire. They stay because the unknown is scary. But the known can be suffocating. Maya wrote that she feels guilty for wanting more. She feels like she is betraying her stability. But let me tell you something radical: wanting more is not a betrayal. It is a biological imperative. We are wired to grow, to explore, to expand. When we suppress that urge, we don’t just stay safe; we stagnate. And stagnation is a slow leak of spirit. It’s subtle. You don’t notice it until one day you look in the mirror and wonder where the light went. That light doesn’t come back from comfort. It comes back from courage. From the decision to trust that you can handle the discomfort of becoming someone new. So, what do you do when you are standing on that cliff? How do you manage the terror of disappearing? First, you acknowledge the fear. You don’t try to talk yourself out of it. You say, 'I am scared. I am also excited. Both are true.' Dialectics is powerful. You can hold two opposing truths in your hands without letting them crush you. Second, you start small. You don’t have to book the one-way ticket today. But you can book the call with a friend who lives there. You can order the food from that restaurant online. You can learn the phrases. You can build a bridge to that new life while you are still in the old one. Make the transition gradual. Let your nervous system adjust. And third, you give yourself permission to grieve. Cry for the version of you that is staying behind. Write her a letter. Thank her for keeping you safe. Tell her that you are taking her wisdom with you, but that you need to go further. This isn’t abandonment. It’s evolution. Maya needs to hear that her fear is not a stop sign. It’s a compass. It’s pointing her toward what matters most to her. If she wasn’t afraid, she wouldn’t be doing anything significant. Fear is the tax we pay for entry into a better life. I want you to think about the box you are packing. Not the physical boxes, but the emotional ones. What are you holding onto that you could safely set down? What parts of your past are you carrying that are actually weighing you down? You don’t have to answer these questions today. Just sit with them. Take a breath. Notice the air in your lungs. Feel the ground beneath your feet. You are here, in this moment, and you are enough. You have always been enough. The job in Lisbon, the promotion, the new city—they are just opportunities to express the abundance that is already inside you. Don’t wait for permission. Don’t wait for the fear to go away. It won’t. But you can move with it. You can dance with it. You can let it guide you toward the life that is waiting for you, not somewhere far away, but right here, in the next brave choice you make. So, Maya, and everyone else sitting on the floor with the empty mug space... keep packing. One item at a time. You are ready. You are capable. And you are so deeply loved, even if no one knows your name yet. Especially then. Thank you for letting me into your evening. I’m rooting for you, always. Until next time, keep your windows open and your heart wider. Love, Erica.