Latest / Deep Dive / Deep Dive: Work, Identity & Inequality in Modern Australia
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine you spend years of your life, you know, countless late
- 0:03nights, thousands of dollars to earn not one but two master's
- 0:09degrees. Right.
- 0:10And one of them is from a highly prestigious university.
- 0:12Exactly. So you enter the job market
- 0:14thinking, you know, I have done everything right.
- 0:16I'm ready. You apply for five jobs.
- 0:19Nothing. Just crickets, Yeah. 50 jobs
- 0:22total. Silence, right?
- 0:23Hundreds of jobs and all you get back are those those terrible
- 0:28automated rejection e-mail. Which is just soul crushing.
- 0:30It really is. But then someone suggests this
- 0:33totally bizarre experiment. You don't take a new course, you
- 0:37know, You don't pad your resume with fake experience.
- 0:39You just change a single word. Your first name, your first
- 0:41name. You go from Faham Samuel.
- 0:43And I mean, almost overnight, the phone starts ringing.
- 0:46It is. Wild.
- 0:47Welcome to the deep dive. There's a real story, by the
- 0:49way, and it is kind of the perfect entry point into our
- 0:51mission today, which is unpacking this massive,
- 0:56intensely debated push for diversity, equity and inclusion.
- 0:59Or, you know, DEI. Yeah, because you see it
- 1:02literally everywhere now. Right.
- 1:03You see it in your workplace. You scroll past it on your
- 1:05feeds. It's constantly in the news.
- 1:07But we really want to ask, is this movement actually
- 1:10broadening our horizons or is it, you know, fundamentally
- 1:14stifling us? Well, it is arguably one of the
- 1:18most complex cultural landscapes we have to navigate today.
- 1:21So we are going to explore the very real, very human impacts of
- 1:26these corporate and cultural initiatives, and we will look at
- 1:30the intense backlash they have sparked from people who frankly
- 1:33feel pushed out. Which is a huge part of the
- 1:35conversation right now. It really is.
- 1:37And later we are going to dive into a pretty radical economic
- 1:40critique that suggests both sides of this bitter culture war
- 1:44might actually be entirely distracted from the real issue.
- 1:47Oh, I cannot wait to get into that part.
- 1:48Yeah, it's fascinating. We are pulling insights today
- 1:51from a deeply heated multi perspective panel discussion
- 1:55from the Australian television program SBS Insight alongside a
- 1:59really provocative lecture by the academic Walter Ben
- 2:02Michaels. OK, let's unpack this because we
- 2:05want you, the listener to think about your own workplace right
- 2:08now. Or, you know, even just your
- 2:10friend group. Like how diverse is it,
- 2:12genuinely? And maybe the trickier question,
- 2:16who actually gets to decide what the word diverse even means?
- 2:19That is the $1,000,000 question. Seriously.
- 2:22So to understand the tension we're living through today, we
- 2:26really have to look at the mechanics of why these policies
- 2:28were constructed in the first place.
- 2:31Yeah, they were engineered to breakdown invisible walls in the
- 2:34job market, like walls that someone like Fahim hit head on.
- 2:38Right, because fines experience is just.
- 2:40It's a brilliant illustration of how those invisible barriers
- 2:43function. It really is.
- 2:44I mean when his name was Fahim, his resume was literally thrown
- 2:47in the trash. When his name was Samuel, he
- 2:50secured interviews. Which is just crazy when you
- 2:52think about it. It's the exact same piece of
- 2:54paper. Exactly.
- 2:56The underlying mechanism here reveals this critical flaw in
- 3:00the assumption that the job market is purely objective.
- 3:03If a recruiter ignores the exact same credentials under a Middle
- 3:07Eastern name, but you know celebrates them under an Anglo
- 3:10name, the system is not actually measuring merit or skill.
- 3:14Right, it's measuring what did the panel call.
- 3:16It it's measuring a candidate's cultural proximity to the
- 3:19dominant group. Wow, cultural proximity.
- 3:22That makes so much sense. And I mean, Famim eventually did
- 3:26find employment, but he described the entire ordeal of
- 3:29changing his name as a literal loss of identity.
- 3:33Which is completely understandable.
- 3:34You're basically erasing a part of yourself just to get in the
- 3:36door. Yeah.
- 3:38But wait, it gets more complicated, because even when
- 3:41someone from a marginalized group gets their foot in the
- 3:44door, sometimes that relief is replaced by a totally different
- 3:47psychological problem. Oh, absolutely.
- 3:49Like. Take the journalist up here.
- 3:51She shared her story on the SBS panel.
- 3:54She got her start in the media through a very specific
- 3:56diversity placement program, and she didn't feel triumphant at
- 4:00first. She actually felt deeply
- 4:02ashamed, like she battled massive imposter syndrome.
- 4:06Yeah, because she came from a working class background.
- 4:08Where, you know, everything had to be earned with blood, sweat
- 4:12and tears. So she felt like she was being
- 4:14handed a shortcut. Exactly.
- 4:16And that imposter syndrome is a very common psychological
- 4:19byproduct of targeted hiring. But Abir's perspective actually
- 4:24underwent A radical shift once she was inside The Newsroom
- 4:27ecosystem. Right when she actually saw how
- 4:30things worked. Yeah.
- 4:32She looked around and realized that the traditional, you know,
- 4:35supposedly merit based pathways her colleagues took weren't
- 4:39actually based on objective talent at all.
- 4:41No, they were based on. I love this phrase she used.
- 4:44She called it Dad taps on the shoulder.
- 4:46Dad taps on the shoulder. Yes, it was nepotism.
- 4:48It was family friends getting internships for their kids.
- 4:51So the traditional system wasn't a level playing field either, it
- 4:53was just a different kind of shortcut.
- 4:55Exactly. And this connects directly to
- 4:57the argument made by Shital, a representative from the
- 5:00Diversity Council of Australia. She argues that the very concept
- 5:04of meritocracy is often a fallacy.
- 5:06Right. It's a system designed by the
- 5:08dominant group, which naturally benefits the dominant group.
- 5:11So from her perspective, DEI is simply an intervention.
- 5:15It's an attempt to manually engineer fairness.
- 5:18I mean, it's like running a race where some people are forced to
- 5:21start, you know, 100 yards back just because of their name,
- 5:25their gender or their zip code. The diversity initiatives are
- 5:28just trying to stagger the starting blocks so everyone
- 5:31actually runs the exact same distance.
- 5:33Staggering the starting blocks is the perfect way to visualize
- 5:36the intent. It really is an effort to
- 5:38correct historical and systemic imbalances.
- 5:40Right, But creating a theory of fairness is very different from
- 5:44applying it in the real world. Oh totally.
- 5:47When we transition from the theory of staggering the blocks
- 5:49to the everyday reality of enforcing those new rules, we
- 5:53hit massive structural friction. Massive friction, which is what
- 5:58some critics in the sources are now calling the woke wall.
- 6:02Because you know what happens when staggering the starting
- 6:05blocks feels like you are actively tying the shoelaces of
- 6:09the other runners together? That's a great way to put it.
- 6:12Let's look at Corey for example. He is a veteran filmmaker with
- 6:1535 years in the industry who ran a father son production company.
- 6:19Yeah, his story was wild. Corey's narrative really gives
- 6:22us a clear look into the mechanics of the backlash,
- 6:25particularly when diversity mandates intersect with creative
- 6:28output. So he pitched a children's
- 6:30adventure series centered around a male character named Billy
- 6:34Dangerfield. OK, classic kind of setup,
- 6:36right? But the feedback from network
- 6:39executives had absolutely nothing to do with the pacing or
- 6:42the dialogue or the story structure.
- 6:44Their only note was a demand to change the male lead into a
- 6:47girl. Just a flat out swap.
- 6:49And it gets so much more restrictive than just one
- 6:51character swap, doesn't it? Oh yeah, 'cause Corey was
- 6:53working on a romantic comedy project.
- 6:55Later on he had a fully funded like $5,000,000 in private
- 6:58investment. Which is huge for an indie.
- 7:01Film, right? And a major distributor was
- 7:03already attached. They were totally ready to go,
- 7:05but when a new executive producer came on board, they
- 7:08suddenly handed Corey this checklist.
- 7:11A literal checklist. The checklist.
- 7:13He was told he could no longer direct his own script because he
- 7:16wasn't a woman. Wow.
- 7:18Then they mandated an Asian lead, an African American love
- 7:22interest. And this is the part that really
- 7:24highlights the creative clash. They were actually ordered to
- 7:27remove the jokes to make the script more woke.
- 7:30Which kind of defeats the purpose of a comedy.
- 7:33Corey describes this endless edition of diversity categories
- 7:36as Noah's Ark, the sequel. Noah's Ark, the sequel.
- 7:39That is so funny. It is, he points out, the
- 7:41logistical nightmare of trying to satisfy an ever expanding
- 7:44list of identities. You have LGBTQA Plus physical
- 7:48disabilities and over 650 different recognized ethnic
- 7:52groups. Yeah, how do you?
- 7:53Well, he calculated it. He said that in a standard 100
- 7:56minute film, if a director actually tried to give equal
- 7:59representation to every single marginalized group, each group
- 8:02would get roughly 9 seconds of screen time. 9 seconds.
- 8:06That is insane. It ceases to be storytelling and
- 8:09just becomes this mathematical exercise in compliance.
- 8:12Exactly. He argues that this enforced
- 8:14political agenda actually destroys the organic, natural
- 8:18process of making art. And this pushback isn't just
- 8:21coming from, you know, frustrated artists like Corey.
- 8:24We also hear from Andrew on the panel.
- 8:26He's an academic who taught HR management for over 2 decades
- 8:29before being sacked from his university.
- 8:32Right. And he takes an incredibly hard
- 8:33line. He argues that DEI initiatives
- 8:36are essentially Marxism by stealth.
- 8:39OK, wait, Marxism. How does he make that leap?
- 8:41Well, to understand Andrew's argument, we really have to
- 8:44unpack what Marxism by stealth actually means in this specific
- 8:48context, OK? Lay it on me.
- 8:49Traditional Marxism views society as a struggle between
- 8:52economic classes, right? The wealthy owners versus the
- 8:54working class. Right, rich versus poor.
- 8:56Exactly. But Andrew argues that modern
- 8:58DEI policies have stealthily replaced economic class with
- 9:02identity categories. Oh, interesting.
- 9:04So instead of the working class fighting the elite, it is now
- 9:07marginalized racial and gender groups fighting the dominant
- 9:11racial and gender groups. He argues This new framework
- 9:14just chisels away at the foundational concept of equality
- 9:18of opportunity, and it replaces it with an obsession over
- 9:21equality of outcome. OK, I see where he's coming
- 9:23from. And Andrew also completely
- 9:26rejects that corporate narrative that having a diverse team
- 9:29automatically makes a business more profitable.
- 9:32Yes, he is very vocal about that.
- 9:34He. Specifically targets this really
- 9:35famous McKenzie report that claimed a direct link between
- 9:39executive diversity and higher profit margins.
- 9:41Right. He dismisses that McKenzie
- 9:43report is pure confirmation bias, but the mechanism behind
- 9:46his critique is vital to understand here.
- 9:49The underlying assumption of the report was that diversity causes
- 9:51profitability. Right, like higher diverse board
- 9:53make more money. Exactly.
- 9:55But Andrew argues that inverse is actually far more likely.
- 9:59Think about it. A highly profitable multibillion
- 10:03dollar tech company has the massive surplus budget required
- 10:06to hire dedicated diversity officers, run extensive bias
- 10:10training, and launch these elaborate recruitment programs.
- 10:14A struggling start up fighting just to keep the lights on does
- 10:16not. Therefore, diversity is often a
- 10:18symptom of already being a wealthy company, not the magical
- 10:21ingredient that caused the wealth.
- 10:23Wow, that is a really compelling way to look at the data.
- 10:26I want to pause here, though, because Andrew brings up another
- 10:29really interesting point about the sheer scale of human
- 10:31disadvantage. OK, yeah, he points out that
- 10:33corporate DEI mostly focuses on race and gender.
- 10:37But you know what if you grew up in a really volatile single
- 10:40parent home? Or what if you were relentlessly
- 10:42bullied as a kid and now you suffer from severe social
- 10:45anxiety? Exactly.
- 10:46It's so complex. Right.
- 10:48If you're listening to this right now, you can probably
- 10:50think of a hidden struggle you've dealt with that no
- 10:52corporate HR checklist will ever, ever ask you about.
- 10:57If we try to mathematically account for every single type of
- 11:00human pain, doesn't the whole system of categorizing privilege
- 11:04just sort of collapse under its own weight?
- 11:06That is the absolute crux of the libertarian and conservative
- 11:10push back in these sources. When diversity is enforced
- 11:14through strict quotas, it creates A rigid hierarchy of
- 11:17suffering that totally ignores the nuance of individual lived
- 11:20experience. Furthermore, Andrew argues that
- 11:23this system ironically damages the very people it claims to
- 11:26uplift. Well, if a company mandates that
- 11:2930% of its executives must be women of color, every woman of
- 11:33color promoted into that role might secretly wonder if she was
- 11:36chosen for her or brilliance, or just to satisfy a quarterly HR
- 11:39metric. Oh man.
- 11:40It places a permanent question mark over their achievements.
- 11:43Which goes right back to the imposter center we talked about
- 11:46with a beer. So we are stuck in this massive
- 11:48tension. Like mandatory quotas feel
- 11:50rigid, they stifle creativity for people like Corey, and they
- 11:53create resentment. But pure, unguided meritocracy
- 11:58is a myth that allows hidden biases to thrive, trapping
- 12:02highly qualified people like Fahim.
- 12:04It's a real catch 22. It really is.
- 12:07How on earth do businesses actually solve this on a
- 12:09practical level? Well, we found two entirely
- 12:12different, practically opposite approaches to hiring in the
- 12:15sources. Let's examine the first approach
- 12:17which was utilized by Verity. She works in HR within the STEM
- 12:21sector. So science, technology,
- 12:22engineering, and math. Which is notoriously dominated
- 12:25by men. Very much so.
- 12:27Her company decided to implement blind recruitment.
- 12:29When Verity applied for her current role, the software
- 12:32completely redacted her name, her age, her gender and even her
- 12:35educational background before the hiring managers ever saw it.
- 12:39Wait, but if you strip away all identity, aren't you just
- 12:41ignoring the very real hurdle someone had to overcome to get
- 12:44those qualifications in the 1st place?
- 12:46Isn't ignoring someone's background entirely taking a
- 12:49massive step backward from the whole goal of DEI?
- 12:52Well, that is the precise debate surrounding blind hiring.
- 12:55The logic behind it is to force the system to focus strictly on
- 12:59measurable output and skills. You're removing the
- 13:02psychological triggers that cause bias.
- 13:04Right, like you can't discriminate against a Middle
- 13:07Eastern name if you literally can't see it.
- 13:09Precisely and very didn't even know the company was doing this.
- 13:13She admitted she actually lacked the confidence to apply under
- 13:16normal circumstances because she had faced so much gender bias in
- 13:20the past. But under the blind system, she
- 13:23got the job, and the company found that by removing identity
- 13:26markers, their senior leadership naturally became significantly
- 13:30more female, and the workplace culture actually improved
- 13:33because everyone knew they were hired purely on task
- 13:36proficiency. OK, here's where it gets really
- 13:38interesting to me. Verity's company leveled the
- 13:41field by putting a blindfold on the judges.
- 13:44They said identity shouldn't matter at all, right?
- 13:47But then we have Monique on the panel who is doing the exact
- 13:49opposite. Monique tried to enter the
- 13:51modeling industry in her 20s, but she was rejected for being
- 13:54too curvy, too short and too multicultural.
- 13:57Yeah, she didn't fit the standard mold at all.
- 13:59Right. So she started her own modeling
- 14:02agency, and she relies entirely on what she calls positive
- 14:05discrimination. Monique's approach is highly
- 14:08curated. She focuses her entire agency
- 14:11strictly on 4 pillars. You have multicultural models,
- 14:14curve models, mature age models, and models with disabilities.
- 14:18So she is hyper focused on identity.
- 14:21Extremely. But what makes her model really
- 14:23fascinating is who she intentionally leaves out.
- 14:27Yeah, this part surprised me. She explicitly refuses to
- 14:30represent trans or gender fluid models, stating she doesn't
- 14:34fully understand that cohort and believes a different agency
- 14:37should manage them right. She also refuses to represent
- 14:40models with extreme body weights, so neither excessively
- 14:43obese nor anorexic. She claims our ultimate business
- 14:46goal is selling happiness. Selling happiness.
- 14:49So Monique is basically curating a very specific cocktail of
- 14:52diversity, and she's intentionally locking the door
- 14:55on everyone. Else basically yes.
- 14:56It forces us to ask what fairness even looks like in
- 15:00practice. Like are we trying to build a
- 15:02society where identity is completely invisible, like
- 15:06verities, blind resumes? Or are we trying to build a
- 15:09society where identities are perfectly categorized and
- 15:12balanced? It's a huge philosophical split.
- 15:15It is, and this obsession with balance is even bleeding out of
- 15:18the workplace and into how people manage their personal
- 15:21lives. Yes, the story of Maggie Zhao
- 15:24perfectly illustrates this cultural shift.
- 15:26Maggie did a literal stock take of her personal friends.
- 15:30A stock take of friends. I know it sounds wild, but she
- 15:33analyzed her friend group and realized she had close white
- 15:35friends and close women of color, but she had 0 male
- 15:38friends. And she viewed this homogeneous
- 15:40friend group not as a natural, organic outcome of her personal
- 15:44interests, but as a deficit, a personal bias that she needed to
- 15:48consciously rectify. She made a New Year's resolution
- 15:51to recruit male friends for diversity of thought.
- 15:54She literally took to TikTok to advertise for male friends to
- 15:58balance out her social portfolio.
- 16:00It really demonstrates how deeply the corporate philosophy
- 16:02of diversity has permeated our psychology totally.
- 16:05Maggie treated her personal life like a corporate quota that
- 16:08needed to be met, operating on the assumption that demographic
- 16:12diversity in and of itself is a mandatory ingredient for a
- 16:15fulfilled life. It's just wild to think about
- 16:18applying HR metrics to your social circle.
- 16:22So we have all these people fighting fiercely over how to
- 16:24build a perfectly diverse system.
- 16:27But this brings us to the absolute wildest part of the
- 16:29deep dive. Oh.
- 16:30This is the best part. We've spent this entire time
- 16:32arguing about the top of the pyramid, right?
- 16:35Who gets the boardroom seeds? Who gets to direct the
- 16:37$5,000,000 movie? What if this entire fight is a
- 16:41massive, carefully orchestrated distraction?
- 16:44This is where we bring in the radical perspective of the
- 16:47academic Walter Ben Michaels. His critique fundamentally
- 16:50upends the entire premise of everything we have discussed so
- 16:53far. Yeah, it really threw me for a
- 16:54loop. He argues that the modern
- 16:56diversity push is not a threat to the corporate establishment.
- 16:59It is, in fact, the ultimate tool of neoliberal capitalism.
- 17:03OK, we definitely need to define that because neoliberal
- 17:05capitalism sounds like some very dense academic jargon.
- 17:09What does that actually mean in plain English, and why does it
- 17:12love diversity? OK, so neoliberalism is
- 17:15basically an economic philosophy that champions hyper
- 17:18individualism, deregulation, and completely free markets.
- 17:22It wants corporations to operate with as little friction as
- 17:26possible. Got it.
- 17:27Free markets, no rules. Basically now, Michaels argues
- 17:31that a neoliberal corporation doesn't actually care if its CEO
- 17:35is a white man, a black woman, or a non binary individual, so
- 17:39long as that CEO can still maximize profits, keep wages
- 17:42low, and crush unionization efforts.
- 17:45Wow, OK. Diversity fits perfectly into
- 17:47the system because it focuses entirely on individual
- 17:50representation rather than collective economic.
- 17:53So he argues that if a society becomes perfectly diverse, it
- 17:56doesn't actually eliminate poverty, it just justifies it.
- 17:59Precisely. Let's look at the mechanics of
- 18:01his argument. Imagine we succeed in creating a
- 18:04perfectly diverse elite. OK, the graduating class of
- 18:07Harvard and the corporate boardroom of every Fortune 500
- 18:10company has a mathematically perfect mix of white, black,
- 18:14Asian, male, female and LGBTQ members.
- 18:16The perfect cocktail. Right.
- 18:18Michaels points out that in this scenario, you haven't actually
- 18:21changed the stag figuring wealth inequality in the country.
- 18:25You simply color-coded. It Oh, that's heavy.
- 18:27The boardroom is diverse, but the people cleaning the
- 18:29boardroom are still living in absolute poverty.
- 18:32And the profound danger here is that the elites can then look
- 18:36down at the working class and say, well, we didn't
- 18:39discriminate against you based on your race or gender.
- 18:42Our system is perfectly fair. So they say, therefore your
- 18:46poverty is 100% your own fault. Exactly.
- 18:49Man, by removing the excuse of systemic bias, society just
- 18:53leaves the poor to shoulder all of the blame for being poor.
- 18:57Yes, and he points out something mind blowing about the word
- 18:59meritocracy. We throw that word around today
- 19:01is the ultimate goal. Like we all want a meritocracy.
- 19:04But he notes that the word was actually coined in 1958 by a
- 19:07British sociologist named Michael Young, and it was
- 19:10originally meant to describe a dystopian nightmare.
- 19:13Yes, Young's original point, which Michaels echoes, forces us
- 19:17to look at the brutal reality of the labor market.
- 19:19The fastest growing jobs in our economy are not, you know, high
- 19:22paying tech roles, right? They are grueling service jobs
- 19:26like home healthcare aids. Michael's contrast?
- 19:29A corporate lawyer making half $1,000,000 a year, with a
- 19:32healthcare worker making $19,500 a year to change bed pans and
- 19:37bathe the elderly. The wage gap is just insane.
- 19:40It is. And even if our perfectly
- 19:43diverse, perfectly blind hiring system sorted those two
- 19:46individuals Florida State based on their raw intellect and test
- 19:49scores, it doesn't change the economic reality.
- 19:52One person is living in absolute luxury while the other literally
- 19:55cannot survive on their wages. So what does this all mean?
- 19:58Like, is he saying that by obsessing over making sure the
- 20:01elite class looks like a perfectly diverse Benetton ad,
- 20:04society is just giving itself a free pass to completely ignore
- 20:08the massive growing chasm between the rich and the poor?
- 20:12That is exactly his thesis. Michaels argues that real
- 20:15justice isn't about ensuring the ruling class comes in every
- 20:18shade of the rainbow. It's about closing the wealth
- 20:20gap between the top and the bottom.
- 20:22He summarizes this with brutal clarity.
- 20:24He says if I'm poor and you're rich, I don't want your respect,
- 20:27I want your money. I don't want your respect, I
- 20:30want your money. That just cuts right through all
- 20:32the corporate HR speak doesn't. It it really does.
- 20:35And he uses the Obama presidency to illustrate the difference
- 20:37between social respect and economic justice, doesn't he?
- 20:41He does. He points out that during the
- 20:43Obama era, the political push for gay marriage succeeded
- 20:47relatively easily, whereas the push for healthcare reform was
- 20:50fought bitterly tooth and nail. Why the difference According to
- 20:54him? Because gay marriage, while
- 20:56deeply significant socially, is an anti discrimination measure.
- 21:01It costs the wealthy elite absolutely nothing to grant it.
- 21:05Healthcare reform, however, requires actual wealth
- 21:08redistribution distribution. It requires taxing the rich to
- 21:11provide for the poor. So Michaels argues that modern
- 21:14corporate society is incredibly eager to embrace anti
- 21:17discrimination because it doesn't threaten the economic
- 21:20status quo while it actively, violently resists anything
- 21:24dealing with class inequality. We have covered incredible
- 21:27ground today. I mean, we started with a very
- 21:29real, very painful mechanism of name bias, exploring the
- 21:33psychological toll on someone like Fahim.
- 21:35Yeah, a guy who felt forced to erase his identity just to get
- 21:38an automated job portal to recognize his degrees.
- 21:41Right. And we look at the immense
- 21:43frustration of people like Corey who feel that rigid creative
- 21:46quotas are just turning art into a mathematical compliance
- 21:50exercise. And we examine the vastly
- 21:52different practical solutions companies are experimenting
- 21:55with, right from the strict identity blindness of Verdi's
- 21:58redacted resumes to the highly curated positive discrimination
- 22:02utilized by Monique's modeling agency.
- 22:04And then, of course, we took a sledgehammer to the whole
- 22:06premise, with Walter Ben Michaels exploring the radical,
- 22:10unsettling idea that this entire cultural obsession with
- 22:13boardroom diversity might just be a smokescreen, the
- 22:16distraction from a massive, growing class war.
- 22:19It really forces us to interrogate what kind of
- 22:22equality we are actually striving to build.
- 22:24Are we fighting for equal opportunity to become part of a
- 22:27deeply unequal elite, or are we fighting to reduce the
- 22:30inequality of the system itself? That is such a good point, and I
- 22:34want you, the listener, to think about this tomorrow when you
- 22:37walk into your workplace, or, you know, the next time you were
- 22:40sitting around with your friend group, look around the room and
- 22:42ask yourself what kind of diversity is actually being
- 22:46celebrated here? Is it just the visible kind that
- 22:50looks good on a company brochure?
- 22:52And what kind of diversity like economic class, educational
- 22:57background or invisible struggle is still being completely
- 23:00ignored? And I will leave you with one
- 23:01final thought to Mull over, building on the history of that
- 23:05word, meritocracy. OK, let's hear it.
- 23:07We are constantly told that the ultimate goal of all these DEI
- 23:11policies, and even the goal of the critics pushing back against
- 23:15them, is to create a perfectly equal, perfectly efficient
- 23:18system where everyone gets exactly what their skills
- 23:20deserve. Right, that's the dream.
- 23:22Imagine if that perfectly efficient machine is actually
- 23:25built. Wouldn't that ultimately be a
- 23:27nightmare for the millions of people whose natural, inherent
- 23:31skills the global market simply does not value highly?
- 23:34If we ever achieve perfect, flawless meritocracy, who
- 23:39catches the people who genuinely, inevitably fall
- 23:42behind? That is a question that is going
- 23:44to stay with me for a very long time.
- 23:46Thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive.
- 23:49Keep questioning the world around you, keep looking for the
- 23:51invisible structures dictating the rules, and we will catch you
- 23:54next time.