Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Virginia Roberts 2nd Amended Response To Ghislaine Maxwell's 1st Discovery Request (Part 3)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
- 0:03In this episode, we're going to pick up where we
- 0:05left off with the Rule fifty six dot one Court
- 0:09Document nine. Identify any employment you have had from nineteen
- 0:14ninety six until the present, including, without limitation, the name
- 0:18of your employer or the name of any person who
- 0:21engaged you for such employment, and the address and telephone
- 0:25number for any such employment, the beginning and ending dates
- 0:29of any such employment, your job title in any such employment,
- 0:33and your income from such employment. Response to Interrogatory number nine,
- 0:38Miss Roberts subjects to this request in that it is
- 0:41overly broad and unduly burdensome, and seeks information that is
- 0:45not relevant to this case. Miss Roberts responds as follows.
- 0:49Miss Roberts worked at mar A Lago as a locker
- 0:52room attendant for the Spy Area. Records produced in this
- 0:55case identify the date of employment as two thousand, as
- 0:59she recalled being there in the summer. Miss Roberts previously
- 1:02attempted to gather employment records from mar A Lago see
- 1:06Roberts zero zero two seven two six. She earned approximately
- 1:11nine dollars an hour. The address is eleven hundred South
- 1:14Ocean Boulevard, Palm Beach, Florida, thirty three four eighty with
- 1:18the telephone number of five six one eight three two
- 1:22two six zero zero. Miss Roberts worked at Roadhouse Grill
- 1:26as a waitress in approximately two thousand and two, but
- 1:29Miss Roberts is unsure of the exact dates of employment.
- 1:32Her wages primarily consisted of tips. Miss Roberts does not
- 1:36recall the location of the Roadhouse Grill. A Google search
- 1:40for the same yields and address of eighty eight sixty
- 1:43five Southern Boulevard in West Palm Beach, Florida. Miss Roberts
- 1:47worked at Employment Training and Recruiting Australia from approximately two
- 1:51thousand and five through January of two thousand and six,
- 1:55but Miss Roberts is unsure of the exact dates of employment.
- 1:58Miss Roberts was a receipttionist, earning approximately fifteen dollars per
- 2:02hour to the best of her recollection. Upon information and belief,
- 2:07this corporation is currently located in a different location from
- 2:11the location at which Miss Roberts was employed. Upon information
- 2:15and belief based on an Internet search, the new location
- 2:19of this entity is one two three Donna Forne Street,
- 2:22Gotford and sw Miss Roberts worked at Gemma Catering wedding
- 2:27receptions in approximately two thousand and four. She received approximately
- 2:32ten dollars an hour. She does not recall the name
- 2:35of the proprietor nor its location. Miss Roberts worked at
- 2:39Manway Logistics in approximately two thousand and three. Miss Roberts
- 2:43recalls it located in or around Sydney, Australia. An Internet
- 2:48search yielded an address of two forty six Miller Road. Ten.
- 2:53Identify any income from any source other than your employment
- 2:57that you have received from January first, ninety nine until
- 3:01the present, including the person or entity providing such income,
- 3:05the amount of the income, the dates on which any
- 3:07such income was received, and the nature of the income,
- 3:10whether alone, investment proceeds, legal settlement, asset, seal, gift, or
- 3:16other source. Response to Interrogatory number ten, Miss Roberts objects
- 3:22to this interrogatory in that it violates Local Rule thirty
- 3:25three three. Miss Roberts objects to this request in that
- 3:28it is overly broad and seeks confidential financial information. Miss
- 3:33Roberts objects to this interrogatory in that it seeks information
- 3:36covered by confidentiality provisions. Miss Roberts objects to this information
- 3:41in that any payment information for the sexual trafficking she
- 3:45endured at the hands of Jeffrey Epstein and Glen Maxwell
- 3:49is in possession, custody and control of the defendant and
- 3:52Jeffrey Epstein. Miss Roberts is in possession of a responsive
- 3:56document that contains the confidentiality provision and obtains and produces
- 4:01to Miss Roberts a written waiver from her co conspirator
- 4:04mister Epstein of the confidentiality provision, freeing Miss Roberts from
- 4:09any liability whatsoever under the confidentiality provision. She will produce
- 4:14that document eleven. Identify any facts upon which you base
- 4:18your contention that you have suffered as a result of
- 4:22the alleged defamation by Glen Maxwell, pasted in future lost
- 4:26wages and passed in future loss of earning capacity and
- 4:29actual earnings precise amounts yet to be computed, but not
- 4:33less than five million. Response to interrogatory number eleven, Miss
- 4:38Roberts objects to this interrogatory in that it violates local
- 4:41Rule thirty three three. Miss Roberts objects to this interrogatory
- 4:45in that its prematurely seeks expert witness disclosures. Miss Roberts
- 4:50incorporates by reference herein her revised Rule twenty six disclosures,
- 4:54which includes her computation of damages. Twelve. Identify any healthcare
- 5:00from whom you received any treatment for any physical, mental,
- 5:04or emotional condition that you suffered from subsequent to any
- 5:09alleged defamation by gland Maxwell, including A the healthcare provider's name, address,
- 5:14and telephone number. B the type of consultation examination or
- 5:18a treatment provided. C the dates you receive the consultation
- 5:22examination or the treatment, D whether such treatment was on
- 5:27an inpatient or outpatient basis. E the medical expenses to date,
- 5:32F whether health insurance or some other person or organization
- 5:36or entity has paid for the medical expenses, and g
- 5:40for each such healthcare provider. Please execute the medical and
- 5:44mental healthcare Records release attached Heier two as exhibit a
- 5:49response to Interrogatory Number twelve. Pursu into this Court's order,
- 5:53Miss Roberts will provide information for healthcare providers from nineteen
- 5:58ninety nine through the present. Ms Roberts continues to search
- 6:01for medical providers that appear in documents. Doctor Stephen Olsen,
- 6:07doctor Mona Devin Shawn, doctor Chris Donahue, doctor John Harris,
- 6:12doctor Wah Wah, doctor m Cell Thori Royal Oaks Medical Center,
- 6:19doctor Carol Hayik, New York Presbyterian Hospital, Campbelltown Hospital, Sydney
- 6:25West Hospital, Westmead Hospital, and as defendant requested, medical releases
- 6:30have been provided for doctor Karen Kudakov, Wellington Imaging Associates
- 6:36and Growing Together. Thirteen. I identify any healthcare provider from
- 6:42whom you received any treatment for any physical, mental, or
- 6:46emotional condition, including addiction to alcohol, prescription or illegal drugs,
- 6:51that you suffered from prior to the alleged defamation by
- 6:54Glenn Maxwell, including A the healthcare provider's name, address and
- 6:58telephone number, b D the type of consultation, examination or
- 7:03treatment provided See the dates you receive the consultation, examination
- 7:07or treatment. D Whether such treatment was on an inpatient
- 7:11or outpatient basis See the medical expenses to date. F
- 7:16Whether health insurance or some other person or organization or
- 7:20entity has paid for the medical expenses and G for
- 7:25each such healthcare provider. Please execute the medical and mental
- 7:28health records release attached. Heer to as exhibit a response
- 7:33to interrogatory Number thirteen. Miss Roberts objects to this interrogatory
- 7:38in that it violates local Rule thirty three dot three.
- 7:40Miss Roberts objects to this request in that it's overbroad
- 7:44and seeks confidential medical information of a sex abuse victim
- 7:48and is not limited in scope to the issues in
- 7:51this case. Miss Roberts objects in that it seeks information
- 7:55protected by attorney client privilege, the attorney work product privilege,
- 7:59joint defense, common interest privilege, and any other applicable privilege.
- 8:03Miss Roberts objects to this request and that is not
- 8:05limited in scope to the medical information relating to the
- 8:09abuse she suffered from the defendant and Jeffrey Epstein. Number fourteen.
- 8:15Identify any person you believe subjected you to, or with
- 8:19whom you engaged in any illegal or inappropriate sexual contact,
- 8:23conduct or assault prior to June nineteen ninety nine, including
- 8:27the names of the individuals involved, the dates of any
- 8:30such illegal or inappropriate sexual contact, conduct, or assault, whether
- 8:36income was received by you or anyone else concerning such
- 8:39an event, whether a police report was ever filed concerning
- 8:42such event, and the outcome of any such case, as
- 8:46well as the address and the location of any such event.
- 8:50Response to Interrogatory Number fourteen. Miss Roberts objects to this
- 8:54interrogatory in that it violates local Rule thirty three dot three.
- 8:59Miss Roberts objected to this request in that it is
- 9:02overbroad and seeks confidential medical information of a sex abuse victim.
- 9:06Miss Roberts objects to this request and that it seeks
- 9:09sexual assault information for a period of time prior to
- 9:13the sexual abuse that issue in this matter, for a
- 9:16period when she was a minor child, from the time
- 9:18Miss Roberts was born until she was fifteen. Miss Roberts
- 9:22objects to this request in that it sought solely to
- 9:25harass and intimidate Miss Roberts, who is a victim of
- 9:29sexual abuse by the defendant request for production one all
- 9:34communications and documents identified in interrogatories one through fourteen above
- 9:40response to Request number one. Miss Roberts objects to this
- 9:44request and that defendants interrogatories violate local Rule thirty three three.
- 9:49Miss Roberts objects in that it seeks information protected by
- 9:53the attorney client privilege, the attorney work product privilege, joint
- 9:56defense common interest privilege, the public interest privilege, and any
- 10:00other applicable privilege. Miss Roberts objects to this request on
- 10:04the grounds that it is overly broad and unduly burdensome,
- 10:07incorporating the interrogatories that total fifty nine subparts, and calls
- 10:12for the production of documents that are irrelevant to this
- 10:15action and not reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery
- 10:19of admissible evidence. Miss Roberts objects to this request in
- 10:23that it seeks to invade the privacy rights of a
- 10:25sex abuse victim and is meant for the improper purpose
- 10:29of harassing and intimidating this victim. Subject to and without
- 10:33waiving the above objections, Miss Roberts is withholding production of
- 10:37documents that are privileged pursuing to the attorney client privilege,
- 10:41the work product privilege, and the public interest privilege. Miss
- 10:45Roberts is also withholding electronic renditions of photographs that depict
- 10:49the faces of her minor children, including school portraits and
- 10:53other photographs taken that reveal the faces of her minor
- 10:56children Subjection two. And without waving the above objection. Ms
- 11:00Roberts has already produced documents baits labeled Roberts zero zero
- 11:05zero zero zero one and Roberts zero zero five to
- 11:08three five three, and will produce non privileged documents responsive
- 11:13to this request limited to documents that do not depict
- 11:16images of her minor children as described Supra, and will
- 11:20continue to supplement her production. All right, folks, we're gonna
- 11:23wrap up right here, and in the next episode discussing
- 11:26the topic, we'll pick up where we left off. All
- 11:29of the information that goes with this episode can be
- 11:32found in the description box.