Latest / Epic Fury: The US-Iran War Podcast / Iran War Day 73: Trump Rejects Iran’s Uranium Offer as US Monitors Nuclear Stockpile
Transcript
- 0:16The letter arrived Iran sent its response to the US peace
- 0:20proposal through Pakistan's mediation channel on Sunday
- 0:23morning. Trump reviewed it and called it
- 0:26totally unacceptable and then told Truth Social he is watching
- 0:29the uranium. The Wall Street Journal reported
- 0:32that Iran offered to transfer some of its highly enriched
- 0:35uranium to a third country, not the United States, but refused
- 0:39to dismantle its nuclear facilities.
- 0:42Iran agreed to halt enrichment, but not for 20 years.
- 0:45Trump separately said the US has Iran's uranium stockpiles very
- 0:49well surveilled and warned that anyone who gets near them will
- 0:52be destroyed. Netanyahu said on CBS 60 Minutes
- 0:56there is work to be done in Iran and that Trump agreed with him
- 0:59on the importance of physically removing Iran's stockpile of
- 1:02highly enriched uranium. Iran's President Posseshkian
- 1:05said Iran will never bow its head before the enemy.
- 1:09Oil rose more than 3 1/2% to $104.00 a barrel, and the war
- 1:14entered its 73rd day, with Trump's rejection and Iran's
- 1:17partial offer both on the table simultaneously, the uranium
- 1:21stockpile under American surveillance and no defined path
- 1:24to a ceasefire ending. It is Monday, May 11th, 2026,
- 1:30day 73 of Operation Epic Fury. The letter arrived and was
- 1:34rejected. The nuclear question remains the
- 1:37wall Iran's offer on uranium moves partially toward
- 1:41Washington but stops short of what the US says it requires.
- 1:45And the distance between Iran's third country and America's full
- 1:48physical removal is the specific distance this conflict has yet
- 1:51to close. This is episode 73 of Epic Fury,
- 1:56the US Iran War podcast. Follow on Spotify and Apple
- 2:00Podcast to stay with this story as it develops.
- 2:03Let's get into it. Begin with the response and what
- 2:06it contains. Because after five days of
- 2:08waiting, the letter's arrival defines the specific remaining
- 2:12gap between the two sides with precision no public statement
- 2:15had previously achieved. And that gap is smaller than the
- 2:18public rhetoric of both governments has suggested, and
- 2:20larger than any single negotiating session has yet been
- 2:23able to close. Iran's official news agency IRNA
- 2:27confirmed on Sunday afternoon that Tehran had sent its
- 2:29response to the US peace proposal to Pakistani mediators,
- 2:33who passed it on to the Trump administration's
- 2:35representatives. The response was the document
- 2:38both governments have been publicly expecting since
- 2:40Wednesday's 48 hour window announcement.
- 2:43Erna described the current phase of negotiations as focusing
- 2:46exclusively on the cessation of hostilities in the region,
- 2:49language consistent with Iran's sustained public position that
- 2:52nuclear questions are separate from the immediate war ending
- 2:55arrangement. Iran's public framing of the
- 2:58response is a war ending document.
- 3:00The Wall Street Journal reporting describes a document
- 3:03that includes nuclear concessions, however partial.
- 3:06The gap between those characterizations reflects the
- 3:09same strategic ambiguity about what exactly Iran has and has
- 3:13not conceded in the document it sent.
- 3:15The Wall Street Journal reported the specific nuclear terms in
- 3:19Iran's response on Sunday afternoon, based on sources with
- 3:22knowledge of the documents contents.
- 3:24Iran offered to transfer some of its stockpile of highly enriched
- 3:28uranium to a third country. It agreed to halt uranium
- 3:32enrichment. It refused to dismantle its
- 3:35nuclear facilities, and the halt to enrichment would not be for
- 3:3820 years, the duration the United States has demanded.
- 3:42Tehran is also prepared to agree to a shorter moratorium, the
- 3:46Wall Street Journal reported, without specifying the duration
- 3:49offered. Those four elements together
- 3:51define Iran's nuclear concession package as it currently stands,
- 3:55partial uranium transfer to a third party, an enrichment halt
- 3:59of uncertain duration, nuclear facilities intact, and a
- 4:02destination other than the United States for the transfer
- 4:05material. Every one of those elements
- 4:07falls short of what Washington described as its requirements in
- 4:10the framework document. The gap on uranium transfer is
- 4:14the most consequential. the US wants all of Iran's
- 4:17approximately 440kg of highly enriched uranium removed from
- 4:22Iranian territory. Iran is offering some, not all,
- 4:26of that material transferred to a third country.
- 4:29The precise fraction Iran is offering to transfer has not
- 4:32been publicly specified. A partial transfer that leaves a
- 4:36significant remaining quantity of 60% enriched uranium on
- 4:39Iranian soil is, from Washington's nuclear
- 4:42verification perspective, an incomplete solution.
- 4:46The material remaining in Iran could be enriched to 90% weapons
- 4:49grade in a matter of weeks using Iran's remaining centrifuge
- 4:52infrastructure if the moratorium ends, is broken, or if the
- 4:56agreement collapses. David Albright's warning from
- 4:59earlier this week that any significant part of the
- 5:01stockpile remaining in Iran constitutes a bad deal applies
- 5:05directly to Iran's partial transfer offer.
- 5:08The destination gap is simultaneously symbolic and
- 5:11deeply strategic. the US wants the material moved to the United
- 5:15States. We're at minimum to AUS
- 5:17supervised facility where American officials can verify it
- 5:21is not being returned to Iran. Iran wants to transfer it to a
- 5:24third country, which almost certainly means Russia, given
- 5:28that Putin made the uranium custody offer in early April and
- 5:31Arachi flew to Saint Petersburg specifically to discuss it.
- 5:35Russia as custodian of Iran's enriched uranium is a
- 5:38fundamentally different strategic outcome from the
- 5:40United States as custodian for both sides.
- 5:43Russian custody means the material is accessible to a
- 5:46country that has been providing Iran with intelligence on U.S.
- 5:49military movements and that pledge to do everything that
- 5:52serves Iran's interests. American custody means the
- 5:55material is physically in US hands and cannot be returned to
- 5:59Iran without explicit US cooperation.
- 6:02The destination gap is not a procedural detail.
- 6:06It is the entire geopolitical question of who controls Iran's
- 6:09nuclear future. The gap on duration remains
- 6:12significant, but is at least structurally within a negotiable
- 6:16range. Iran has now confirmed it is
- 6:18willing to halt enrichment for some defined period, a
- 6:21meaningful shift from its early position that the nuclear
- 6:24program is non negotiable. the US wants 20 years.
- 6:28Iran's initial position was five years.
- 6:31The 12 to 15 year landing zone that Axios described earlier
- 6:35this week as the likely outcome is still positioned between
- 6:38Iran's current offer and the US demand.
- 6:40That specific gap, unlike the facility dismantlement gap,
- 6:44could in theory be bridged through a series of revised
- 6:47proposals. Trump described Iran's response
- 6:50as totally unacceptable. His subsequent statement added a
- 6:54new element to the nuclear standoff that had not been
- 6:56previously disclosed publicly, he said.
- 6:59We have that very well surveilled.
- 7:02If anybody got near the place, we will know about it, and we
- 7:05will destroy anyone who approaches that statement.
- 7:08Is Trump publicly asserting that the United States has
- 7:10intelligence infrastructure, surveillance assets, almost
- 7:13certainly a combination of satellite imagery, signals
- 7:16intelligence and possibly human intelligence monitoring the
- 7:20location of Iran's enriched uranium stockpiles in real time
- 7:23throughout the ceasefire and the diplomatic process.
- 7:26He is saying that the US knows where the uranium is, who is
- 7:29approaching it, and what is happening to it at any given
- 7:32moment. And he is warning explicitly and
- 7:35on the record that any attempt to move it, enrich it further,
- 7:39secure it outside of AUS approved arrangement, or
- 7:42transfer it to a non agreed destination will be treated as a
- 7:45triggering event for an immediate military response.
- 7:48That assertion transforms the nuclear standoff from a purely
- 7:51diplomatic question into one with an immediate military
- 7:55dimension. The uranium is not merely the
- 7:57subject of negotiations, according to Trump, it is under
- 8:01active American military surveillance in any party,
- 8:04Iranian, Russian or otherwise, that approaches it in a manner
- 8:08inconsistent with what the US has agreed to will face
- 8:11destruction. That warning is directed
- 8:13simultaneously at Iran, at Russia, and at any other party
- 8:16that might be considering taking custody of the material on
- 8:19Iran's behalf before or outside of an agreed framework.
- 8:23It is also Trump's most explicit assertion to date that the US
- 8:26regards itself as having unilateral military authority
- 8:30over what happens to Iran's enriched uranium.
- 8:32Regardless of whether a deal is signed, is rejected, or is still
- 8:36being negotiated. The uranium's fate, in Trump's
- 8:39telling, is effectively already under American control through
- 8:43surveillance and the threat of force.
- 8:45Iran's proposal to transfer some of it to a third country is in
- 8:49Trump surveillance, framing a proposal the US can accept or
- 8:53can destroy the moment any party attempts to implement it outside
- 8:56of Washington's approved terms. Netanyahu appeared on CBS 60
- 9:00Minutes in an interview broadcast on Sunday.
- 9:03He said there is work to be done in Iran, and he offered the most
- 9:07direct Israeli assessment of the current state of the US Iran
- 9:10negotiations from outside the administration.
- 9:13He said Iran has not given up its enriched uranium, it has not
- 9:17dismantled its nuclear sites, it has not stopped supporting its
- 9:21regional proxies in Lebanon, Iraq and Yemen, and it has not
- 9:25agreed to any limits on its ballistic missile program.
- 9:29In other words, Netanyahu is saying that despite 73 days of
- 9:32war ceasefire, Islamabad talks, proposal exchanges and a
- 9:36framework document, nothing of substances change about Iran's
- 9:40nuclear and military position. From Israel's strategic
- 9:43perspective, Iran still has the uranium, the centrifuges still
- 9:48exist, the proxies still operate, the missiles are still
- 9:52there. The wars core objectives as
- 9:55Israel defines them have not been achieved.
- 9:58Netanyahu said that Trump agreed with him on the importance of
- 10:01removing Tehran stockpile of highly enriched uranium.
- 10:05He described his preferred outcome as the US physically
- 10:08going in and taking the uranium out.
- 10:10That formulation physically going in is not a diplomatic
- 10:14transfer arrangement, it is a military operation.
- 10:18Netanyahu is describing a scenario in which American
- 10:21forces physically enter Iran's nuclear facilities, remove the
- 10:25enriched uranium, and take it out of the country under
- 10:27American custody, the most maximalist version of the
- 10:30stockpile removal demand, and the most interventionist outcome
- 10:33in the framework of any current US Iran negotiating scenario.
- 10:37Whether Trump has agreed to that as the preferred outcome, or
- 10:40whether Netanyahu's characterization reflects a
- 10:43stated Trump preference that the administration's diplomatic team
- 10:46is not currently pursuing, cannot be verified from the CBS
- 10:49interview alone. What Netanyahu's statement
- 10:52definitively confirms is that Israel's definition of a
- 10:54satisfactory war outcome includes the physical removal of
- 10:58Iran's nuclear material by U.S. forces, not its diplomatic
- 11:01transfer to Russia, which is Israel's most probable least
- 11:04acceptable outcome. Iran's partial transfer to
- 11:07Russia offer is, from Netanyahu's perspective, the
- 11:10opposite of what is required. U.S. ambassador to the United
- 11:14Nations Mike Walt said on Fox News Sunday that the US has laid
- 11:18out a very clear red line in its latest proposal.
- 11:21He said President Trump has been clear.
- 11:24They will never have a nuclear weapon and they cannot hold the
- 11:26world's economies hostage. That formulation, clear red
- 11:30line, never world's economies, is Waltz describing the US
- 11:34nuclear floor in its most publicly unambiguous term since
- 11:38Vance stated the same position at the first Islamabad session.
- 11:41It does not describe what comes next after the totally
- 11:44unacceptable rejection. It does not specify A revised
- 11:48deadline. It does not lay out a counter
- 11:51proposal. It reasserts the core position
- 11:54while leaving open the question of whether the response is
- 11:56diplomatic or military. Whether the administration
- 12:00returns the document to Pakistan with specific revisions
- 12:03adjusting the enrichment duration downward and the
- 12:05uranium destination toward US custody while maintaining the
- 12:08core nuclear constraint, or whether it uses the rejection as
- 12:12the authorization for a new military phase is a decision
- 12:15that defines the next stage of the war.
- 12:17Iran's President Mehsud Posseshkian posted on X on
- 12:21Sunday that Iran will never bow its head before the enemy.
- 12:24He wrote if talk of dialogue or negotiation arises, it does not
- 12:29mean surrender or retreat. That post is Iran's civilian
- 12:32elected leader, maintaining the defiance position that has
- 12:35characterized every Iranian public statement throughout the
- 12:38week of framework deliberation. Posseshkian is elected and his
- 12:42statements carry domestic political weight, but he does
- 12:45not hold strategic decision making authority in the Islamic
- 12:49Republic's governing structure. That authority belongs to
- 12:52Common, a who an unnamed official confirmed on Friday is
- 12:55incomplete health and will eventually appear publicly, who
- 12:58receive Iran's proposal on its contents before Sunday's
- 13:01submission and whose specific authorization of the partial
- 13:04uranium transfer offer and the shorter than 20 year enrichment
- 13:08halt has not been publicly confirmed or commented on.
- 13:11Iran's response also contains the additional demands that
- 13:14Iran's negotiating team has been attaching to every proposal
- 13:17since the first Islamabad round, according to Tiznim news agency
- 13:21and Arab diplomatic sources cited by multiple outle outlets.
- 13:25The demands include Iran's oil exempted from U.S. sanctions
- 13:28within 30 days of any deal, the full lifting of the US naval
- 13:32blockade of Iranian ports, a ceasefire in Lebanon as part of
- 13:35any Iran US settlement, recognition of Iranian
- 13:38sovereignty over the Strait of Hormuz, and war reparations for
- 13:42damage caused by Operation Epic Fury and the Israeli parallel
- 13:46operation. Those demands sit in two
- 13:48distinct categories that determine how negotiable they
- 13:51are. The first category is
- 13:53economically negotiable. Sanctions relief and blockade
- 13:56lifting are explicitly offered in the US framework document,
- 14:00and the timing, sequencing and conditions under which they
- 14:03apply are legitimate negotiating questions rather than structural
- 14:06incompatibilities. The 30 day oil exemption demand
- 14:09is Iran trying to front load the economic relief relative to the
- 14:12nuclear concessions, which is the sequencing dispute that has
- 14:16defined the entire process. The second category is
- 14:19structurally more problematic. Horma's sovereignty recognition
- 14:23that Iran has the legal right to control who transits the
- 14:26waterway directly contradicts the International Maritime law
- 14:30position the United States and 30 other countries have
- 14:32maintained throughout this conflict.
- 14:34War reparations are something the United States has never paid
- 14:38to any country it has bombed, and Lebanon as part of the Iran
- 14:41US settlement is the linkage that Israel and the US agreed to
- 14:45exclude on April 8th. These are not merely negotiating
- 14:49positions that can be adjusted through revised wording.
- 14:52They represent Iran score political demands, the
- 14:55conditions on which the Islamic Republic civilian diplomatic
- 14:58track would need to justify the nuclear concessions to its IRGC
- 15:02hardline establishment. Whether they are the opening bit
- 15:05of a negotiation that will ultimately drop them or genuine
- 15:08red lines that make the deal structurally impossible is the
- 15:11question the counter proposal process must answer.
- 15:14The ceasefire continued to strain on Sunday on multiple
- 15:18fronts. The UAE said its air defenses
- 15:21dealt with two Iranian drones that have been launched from
- 15:23Iran. Kuwait reported hostile drones
- 15:26entering its airspace. Israeli strikes continued in
- 15:30southern Lebanon. Iran's Internet blackout, which
- 15:33has been enforced since the war began, entered its third month
- 15:36with no indication from the Iranian government of when or
- 15:39whether it will end. Pakistan's Ambassador to Russia,
- 15:42Faisal Nayez Termizy confirmed in a statement to task that
- 15:45talks have not reached a deadlock and continue with
- 15:48Islamabad acting as mediator. That confirmation, not a
- 15:51deadlock continuing, is Pakistan publicly maintaining the
- 15:55channels operative status even after Trump called the response
- 15:58totally unacceptable. Oil processed the mutual
- 16:02rejection of Sunday's proposals by rising more than 3 1/2% to
- 16:06approximately $104.00 per barrel, a level not seen since
- 16:09the war's most acute phase in late April.
- 16:12That price movement reflects the markets updated probability
- 16:15assessment of a near term deal following Trump's totally
- 16:18unacceptable rejection. The 3 1/2% rise is a meaningful
- 16:23market signal. It says that the combination of
- 16:26Iran's partial offer and Trump's rejection has, from the market's
- 16:29perspective, reduced rather than increase the probability of an
- 16:32imminent deal. But it does not price in a
- 16:35return to full scale bombing or the complete collapse of the
- 16:38ceasefire. If the market believed the
- 16:40totally unacceptable rejection was the last communication
- 16:43before a military escalation, oil would be considerably higher
- 16:47than $104. The market is pricing the
- 16:50rejection as a new round of a process that has produced
- 16:53rejected proposals before and is likely to produce another cycle.
- 16:58That interpretation is supported by Pakistan's ambassador to
- 17:01Russia confirming a task on Sunday that talks have not
- 17:04reached a deadlock and continue with Islamabad acting as
- 17:07mediator. That statement, made after Trump
- 17:10called Iran's response totally unacceptable, is Pakistan
- 17:13explicitly maintaining the channel's operative status and
- 17:17confirming that the rejection does not end the diplomatic
- 17:19process. The next communication through
- 17:22Pakistan, whether AUS counterproposal that revises the
- 17:25uranium destination, adjust the duration downward from 20 years
- 17:29or modifies the facility dismantlement requirement, or a
- 17:32new Iranian offer that moves closer to US custody and a
- 17:35longer moratorium, is the operative question to market.
- 17:38And the world is waiting to hear.
- 17:41Iranian Nobel Peace Prize laureate Narges Mohammadi was
- 17:44granted bail and transferred to a hospital in Tehran on Sunday,
- 17:48according to a statement from her family's foundation, the
- 17:51Nargis Foundation. Mohammadi has been imprisoned
- 17:53for a human rights activism. She is serving a 10 year
- 17:56sentence and is the most internationally prominent of
- 17:59Iran's imprisoned dissidents, having been awarded the Nobel
- 18:02Peace Prize in 2023. Her release on bail for a
- 18:06medical furlough is a small and specific development.
- 18:09It does not represent a systemic liberalization of Iran's
- 18:13treatment of political prisoners or a change in the Islamic
- 18:16Republic's approach to internal dissent.
- 18:18But it is an action by the Iranian government during the
- 18:21ceasefire and the diplomatic period that takes place
- 18:23precisely when Iran's international credibility and
- 18:27its image outside the country have value as a negotiating
- 18:30asset. It's timing, on the same day
- 18:32Iran submitted its peace proposal through Pakistan is
- 18:34unlikely to be coincidental. Is the kind of small, visible,
- 18:38internationally resonant gesture that Iran's civilian diplomatic
- 18:41track can produce at moments when the government needs to
- 18:44signal flexibility without making explicit concessions on
- 18:47the nuclear question. If this podcast is helping you
- 18:50make sense of what's happening, take 2 seconds to leave a five
- 18:53star rating on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
- 18:56It makes a huge difference to how many people find the show
- 19:00and if you want the deeper breakdown of what's really going
- 19:02on and where this is heading, you can unlock the premium
- 19:05episodes directly in Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
- 19:09This has been episode 73 of Epic Fury, the US Iran war podcast.
- 19:14The letter arrived. Iran offered partial uranium to
- 19:18a third country, not the US, refused to dismantle facilities,
- 19:22agreed to enrichment halt, but not 20 years Trump.
- 19:26Totally unacceptable. He is watching the stockpile.
- 19:30Netanyahu work to be done. Posseshkian will not bow.
- 19:35Pakistan confirms talks continue, oil to 104.
- 19:40The gap is defined. The war is not over.
- 19:44We will be back very soon.