Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Strategic Reserves, Fiscal Insanity, and the Bitcoin Explosion Ahead with Alex Thorn
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey.
- 0:27OK, I say when we sell. Washington is quietly counting
- 0:34its Bitcoin, and when the White House finally publishes that
- 0:37number, estimated to be about 200,000 Bitcoin, it could be one
- 0:41of the biggest catalyst of the year.
- 0:43That is what Alex Thorne, head of firm wide research at Galaxy
- 0:46Digital, said on this episode of The Last Tree, really a sign
- 0:49that there is far more juice and catalyst left in the cycle.
- 0:53We've heard a lot of bullish things in 2025, but many haven't
- 0:56materialized yet and so that's exactly what we discussed.
- 0:59Ultimately though, none of this matters if you cannot secure
- 1:01your Bitcoin for the years to come, which is exactly why On
- 1:05Ramp exists. It's why I work here and I use
- 1:07On Ramp for my family's Bitcoin Nest Aid.
- 1:11On Ramp was built to help people like you secure their Bitcoin
- 1:14with confidence and achieve Peace of Mind with multi
- 1:16institution custody, baked in inheritance and insurance from
- 1:20Lloyd's of London at no extra cost.
- 1:23Whether you're safeguarding family wealth or corporate
- 1:25treasury or client assets, head to On rampbitcoin.com, book a
- 1:29consultation or you can get started in 10 minutes.
- 1:32Now. I hope you enjoyed the episode.
- 1:34All right, we're recording. We're back.
- 1:36It's the last trade and we're back.
- 1:38I'll say we're back because of our loyal audience because
- 1:42people decided to show up last week.
- 1:44I did not get fired. Alex.
- 1:46We can we can tell you later in the episode, but Michael has
- 1:48been threatening to fire me for several weeks at this point.
- 1:52And because of our loyal audience, the last trade, not
- 1:55only did I not get fired this week, but we were also able to
- 1:58bring on Alex Thorne, who is the director of firm wide research
- 2:02at Galaxy Digital. Alex, thank you for joining us.
- 2:04How you doing? Yeah.
- 2:05Hey guys. Great to be here.
- 2:07You know, first time caller, long time listener.
- 2:12Actually director, Director of research and memes, by the way.
- 2:15Like you have some memes, I spend a, you know, that's that
- 2:18is research. OK, My memes have a research
- 2:21quality to them. Absolutely.
- 2:24And well, funny enough, you were on the podcast one time before
- 2:27and it was actually when the ETFs were approved and launched
- 2:32January 10th, the price of Bitcoin was $46,000.
- 2:35We've come a long way. Yeah, we've come a long way.
- 2:40We're looking at 103 today. So we're going to pull up.
- 2:43We are going to pull up the price just very quickly because
- 2:47I have a question that's been top of mind is the top in is,
- 2:52but did we already see the top this cycle?
- 2:55Did we double peak AT110K? Alex, what?
- 2:57What do you think man? Am I too bearish right now?
- 3:00Yeah, I don't think so. I don't think we have topped.
- 3:02That's a a blanket statement. Look, there are fears of a
- 3:07double top pattern, right? Everybody saw that in 21 and and
- 3:10then you're looking at it here and you only got to what like
- 3:121-12 the other day or last two, you know, two weeks ago wanted
- 3:17to see that go to like 120. Like I think to feel like it
- 3:19definitely wasn't a double top. But The thing is, is like there,
- 3:23there, there haven't been that many catalysts actually have
- 3:27happened. There's plenty of good stories,
- 3:30right? People in the government saying
- 3:31nice things about Bitcoin and stuff.
- 3:33Most of it hasn't even happened. Retail's not really here like I,
- 3:37I don't see a lot of reason for Bitcoin to go down and I see
- 3:41plenty of reasons that it for it to go up, but I also see plenty
- 3:45of reasons in the near term. I mean, I, I'm basically sort of
- 3:47targeting mid-july to maybe sort of restart this when the
- 3:50presidential working group delivers its report to the White
- 3:53House. And then maybe there's some a
- 3:54catalyst there. But you're in sleepy early
- 3:58summer here and I think now you're sort of just trading on
- 4:00macro headlines for the near term.
- 4:02But I don't see a huge, I don't see a reason for a, a big drop
- 4:06in the near term. It's widely owned, to be clear,
- 4:08like whales have been selling like they're the, the corn
- 4:11that's being sold is being sold by like people that bought in
- 4:14like the 15K and lower range an enormous amount, right.
- 4:17So apparently they all made money and they're not huddling
- 4:20anymore. And not all of them, obviously,
- 4:22but like that you've had an enormous amount of selling and
- 4:25we're still over 100K. Like it just seems I, I, I don't
- 4:28know where from, where else, like more corn to be sold is
- 4:30going to come from, you know, so like, I feel pretty sturdy here.
- 4:35Yeah, it would be a very, it'd be a very interesting, uh, top
- 4:38if retail never showed up because I think anecdotally you
- 4:40see retail hasn't come in. It'd be kind of maybe bullish
- 4:43for them. So they don't get rugged by
- 4:44whatever is going to happen because there's going to be no
- 4:46shortage of mousetraps when this thing really takes off that they
- 4:49just got to bypass a whole bull market.
- 4:50But that's never happened in bitcoins history, that retail
- 4:53hasn't come in and droves and then also probably gotten rugged
- 4:56along the way. Here it is.
- 4:58Here's the yeah. Maybe we pull up some of the
- 5:01exceptional research that Alex has been doing.
- 5:03We have a great meme that he shared yesterday on on Twitter
- 5:07or X maybe retail is here, but they're buying Bitcoin, treasury
- 5:11companies. Alex.
- 5:12Can you can you walk us through this meme here?
- 5:14What's going on in? This, yeah.
- 5:17So basically I'm just sort of cataloguing some of the eras
- 5:21metas, the big narrative metas since 2017.
- 5:26I've been working on Bitcoin and crypto full time since 2017,
- 5:31like first at Fidelity, now a Galaxy.
- 5:34And this is just what we came up with remembering sitting around
- 5:37and obviously IC OS that's easy to to remember and was a huge
- 5:42deal. It created tons of new altcoins.
- 5:45It separated people from their Bitcoin.
- 5:47Many of them failed. Some of them are still around
- 5:50like Cardeno was a 2017 ICO right Tezos they exist not all
- 5:55of them literally were frauds. Some of them might just be, you
- 5:59know, crappy networks that did actually launch, but it was the
- 6:02fraud and scam from that that then led to which I don't even
- 6:06have on here. The like the later meta of VC
- 6:10coins right of of doing these private token deals through VCs
- 6:14and then releasing them through secondary sales rather than
- 6:17primary sales to the retail. Then I don't know, 2018 was a
- 6:20bit tough to come up with one, but we do recall bit Max trading
- 6:23on leverage and bit Max was like that was like the first time
- 6:25that everybody was doing that and then 2019 also a bit of a
- 6:28lull. I remember being at the Bitcoin
- 6:30conference in June 2019 with Bitcoin, you know, after the
- 6:34depths of this post 2017 bear, it was rallying from like 8 to
- 6:3713 K and we're like, oh, are we back and then it it failed to
- 6:41consummate and later we all learned that it was a giant
- 6:44Ponzi scheme in China called plus token that you had to buy
- 6:47into with Bitcoin. That was probably the reason for
- 6:49that rally defy summer, the food yam finance sushi swap like algo
- 6:56stables big big in 2020 when everyone was locked at home.
- 7:01Then remember Elon in January, they said Tesla was buying
- 7:04Bitcoin for their balance sheet. It was super bullish.
- 7:06Then later he said, wait a SEC, I didn't realize that Bitcoin
- 7:09uses electricity. I'm rugging.
- 7:10And then Bitcoin. And then that was also right
- 7:12around when China supposedly yet again banned mining.
- 7:15And so we dropped from 60s to to, you know, 25 and in in the
- 7:20spring of 2021. And then obviously Dogecoin hit
- 7:24$0.69 with Elon on the on SNL and blah, blah, blah.
- 7:28And then yeah, 22 is when all the yield stuff came to a head,
- 7:32right? With all the lenders going
- 7:34bankrupt, I should probably have in 22.
- 7:35Also the GBTC discount was a big, big part of that year.
- 7:40And then 23, Bitcoin opens the year at 16 five.
- 7:43Great, great to buy there by by March on the collapse of SVB, it
- 7:47runs all the way to like 2627. So it's the bank failures.
- 7:51Then it was BlackRock in June announced that they were doing a
- 7:53Bitcoin ETF and then Grayscale won the US District Court of DC,
- 7:59the federal, the sorry, the US appeals ruling at the appeals
- 8:02court in DC in August of 23. That ultimately paved the way
- 8:07for the ETF, which launched in 24.
- 8:09Basically the story of last year was like ETFs and meme coins and
- 8:12then later Trump embracing Bitcoin.
- 8:15I think that's pretty much the whole narrative of last year.
- 8:18You, you had that barbell market where it was like the the lowest
- 8:22quality, low cap penny stock cryptos, meme coins were
- 8:25rallying and pushing Solana up with them and Bitcoin and
- 8:28everything else in the middle, like sat it out.
- 8:30He's had a terrible year last year, while Bitcoin, you know,
- 8:33doubled practically or did double ultimately.
- 8:37And then I'm saying like, I think the meta right now is
- 8:40Bitcoin treasury companies. We're tracking like 35 of them.
- 8:43It is getting blown out. There's now I, we saw there's a
- 8:47Chinese limousine company that's going to start an XRP strategy.
- 8:51So it's starting to go down the, the shit coin waterfall a bit.
- 8:54But that's, that's a huge part of the story, right?
- 8:58You've got Cantor, SoftBank, Tether, you've got obviously
- 9:02micro strategy. You've got now Bitcoin magazine,
- 9:05right? You've got BTC Inc with
- 9:06Nakamoto, you've got ones that are geographic based in Hong
- 9:11Kong and China and Japan and, and, and South America, right?
- 9:14Like there is a whole range of ways to do it now and you've got
- 9:20like 20 to 35 of them at least. And that seems like a huge part
- 9:24of the story this year. It's a excellent montage to run
- 9:28through, had eerily resemblance of a TFTC back in the day that I
- 9:32think Marty owes everyone a montage through Bitcoin or
- 9:35crypto's history. I think actually there's a lot
- 9:37of alpha if we ever clip this up and share it, because most
- 9:41people coming into these markets have no idea of half of those
- 9:43narratives, let alone all of them.
- 9:45And ultimately, I think that the meta to the meta is that there's
- 9:49always a contraption to take people's Bitcoin, and some
- 9:51people maybe make a little bit more Bitcoin, but a lot of
- 9:53people in the past 10 years have ended up with a lot Bitcoin.
- 9:56So TBD on where this all goes for everyone.
- 9:59Yeah, and, and, and like when I made that meme, like I'm not
- 10:01explicitly, I hadn't intended it to be.
- 10:04All of those were bad things. Like I was just trying to recall
- 10:07like what what the the big story was of the year.
- 10:12It turns out though, that like pretty much outside of owning
- 10:15Bitcoin, like most of the other things that have happened in
- 10:19crypto just haven't panned out right.
- 10:21So I, I feel bad because I'm not actually saying that sailor with
- 10:24his laser Galaxy brain is equivalent to like food based
- 10:27finance. I'm not saying that, just saying
- 10:29like that's the current story. And but it turns out a lot of
- 10:32the current stories end up, you know, being short lived, gone
- 10:37through a lot of them. It's an epic saga of, of crypto.
- 10:39It's been an epic, continues to be an epic saga.
- 10:42I don't know how we keep coming up with these new things.
- 10:45I. For one, am excited about K Wave
- 10:47Media, which is the prominent K pop group that is planning to
- 10:51raise $500 million for a Bitcoin treasury strategy.
- 10:56You know, it's a music based Bitcoin product.
- 11:00Who knew? Yeah, I'm.
- 11:02Curious, like to your point, Alex, it's not inherently a bad
- 11:05thing that these Bitcoin treasury companies exist and
- 11:08it's still, we'll still see how it pans out in terms of Bitcoin
- 11:12obviously plays a massive role in corporate adoption from just
- 11:15a vanilla, let's accumulate some Bitcoin on the balance sheet,
- 11:18preserve our company's cash for the long term, etcetera.
- 11:21And then there's of course, these other companies that are
- 11:23using capital markets, equity, debt, etcetera to accumulate as
- 11:28much Bitcoin as possible. And to your point, I mean, there
- 11:30are companies out there that are viable and have a strategy, but
- 11:33then there's also just going to be a lot of excess that we're
- 11:35just starting to see in this cycle pan out.
- 11:37I'm curious from, from your point of view, as you've done
- 11:40research at Galaxy in the space here, just like how do you think
- 11:44about assessing the Bitcoin treasury landscape?
- 11:47I mean, what, what excites, what are you excited about, if
- 11:50anything, in this, in that part of the space?
- 11:53Well, one thing I'm am definitely excited about is the
- 11:56rising prominence of talented Bitcoin evangelists, and there
- 12:00are many now and the these companies, if nothing else, give
- 12:04them a strong platform right to explain and promote Bitcoin in
- 12:09equity markets, and that's a positive.
- 12:12I look, I'm an operating company maximalist.
- 12:14I believe in owning equities that are companies that build
- 12:17stuff. I don't need to get a tiny
- 12:19little, you know, bips on my M NAV at a Bitcoin treasury
- 12:23company. That's not I'm not interested in
- 12:25that really personally, I simply don't care.
- 12:29I mean, for that way, I basically no opinion, I'm fine
- 12:33with it. I, I think the big question that
- 12:35people have is do these end up like looking like a closed end
- 12:38fund? And what happens if they end up
- 12:40trading at a discount to their Bitcoin holdings?
- 12:43And I think David Bailey's been very straightforward and
- 12:46transparent about this. He says they will sell Bitcoin
- 12:48and use the proceeds to buy their stock back, right?
- 12:50Which is, by the way, that's what they should do, right?
- 12:53GBDC couldn't buy their own stock because they weren't
- 12:56public like there was no way for them to close the gap.
- 12:59And because you couldn't redeem, there was no way for anyone else
- 13:02to close the gap. Now you can't redeem here in a
- 13:05Bitcoin treasury strategy, but the issuer themselves can close
- 13:07the gap. So the fear is that if they end
- 13:10up having to sell some Bitcoin, if it's a lot of Bitcoin, then
- 13:14that can create a vicious cycle in the market, not just in spot
- 13:18Bitcoin prices, but also in with the other Bitcoin treasury
- 13:21companies. But but there's not that much.
- 13:25There isn't a lot of debt like it's not really that big of an
- 13:27issue. It's just that like people
- 13:30should know that most likely if these trade their, their stock
- 13:33prices trade below the value of their Bitcoin, a prudent
- 13:38executive would sell Bitcoin and use it to buy their stock back.
- 13:41So then you're going to, and you really just don't want to see
- 13:43that, particularly from somebody like Michael Saylor.
- 13:45Like imagine if Michael Saylor has to sell Bitcoin, right?
- 13:48And that's why he doesn't say this.
- 13:49I, I'm, but I'm quite confident that he might do it if he had
- 13:53to, right? And so it's just a bad narrative
- 13:56if someone like, you know, if any of these people who are
- 13:58hyper bullish Bitcoin end up having to sell Bitcoin, it's to
- 14:01me it's more about the signal that that would send to the
- 14:03market that like, well, I thought these were the most
- 14:06diamond handed people in the world, right?
- 14:08It's just it's just a strange vehicle.
- 14:10And in general, like I feel comfy in spot, you know?
- 14:15Yeah, it's it's strange. And it's also not like it's not
- 14:20long standing in the sense that if you really extrapolate into
- 14:23the future, let's say these all went up into the right.
- 14:26Well, ultimately everyone's journey maps pretty similarly.
- 14:29Once you find out about Bitcoin, you naturally end up in wanting
- 14:32spot, you learn about counterparty risk.
- 14:33So you have to assume that all these never lose any asset,
- 14:35never get too far on the risk curve and blow themselves up,
- 14:37which I think we all agree is not going to happen.
- 14:40And then once that happens to the first one, everyone starts
- 14:42to wonder, well, like what am I actually holding?
- 14:44And it's the logical progression from the micro individual to the
- 14:47pension that's the most sophisticated.
- 14:49Wait, why don't I just hold the underline?
- 14:51And so it's just like it's a trade and anchoring back to the
- 14:55montage or that you shared. Like the plus token stands out
- 14:58because I remember specifically in 19 when the price went from
- 15:02like the bottom, it was like that.
- 15:04It like bottomed in like March or April and then went up until
- 15:07like that November up to 1213. And everyone was super long,
- 15:10thought we were going into a market.
- 15:11And then literally it all fell apart and everyone lost a shit
- 15:14ton of Bitcoin because they were either levered up that was like
- 15:16a holder or just part of the deal.
- 15:19And so that montage I think is just like the first innings and
- 15:22what we're going to see in the next decade because everything
- 15:24we're seeing like it's been done in the like off channel, non
- 15:27tratify way. We're just going to see that
- 15:29like basically in the new world and people aren't prepared for
- 15:33that and they're just going to get wiped out.
- 15:35That's at least especially why this business was started,
- 15:37because what happened in 2022, we're like, Oh my God, the same
- 15:39thing is just going to happen again with the lack of
- 15:41transparency and counterparty risk that existed in 22.
- 15:45Yeah, I mean, it is a new class of counterparties that have
- 15:48emerged, right? And, and it's not just in
- 15:51Bitcoin or crypto, but in in all of finance.
- 15:53Humans make the same problem mistakes over and over again.
- 15:56Like we've seen this story before.
- 15:58When you mix leverage with volatility, like it's highly
- 16:01risky, right? Like so and that's what this is,
- 16:03this is that's expressly what it is.
- 16:06Like these companies are harvesting the volatility in
- 16:08their own stock, you know, like, and it's quite clever.
- 16:11Like you have to admire the financial engineering that
- 16:14someone like Michael Saylor is, is doing.
- 16:16It's, it's truly historic in some ways.
- 16:19I mean, when his, his company, when his stock was running in
- 16:22the fall like this, MSTR was the talk of all of Wall Street, like
- 16:28everybody was standing in awe of what he pulled off like in this
- 16:33crazy thing, right? He announced in summer 2020 that
- 16:36he was buying Bitcoin for his long running, mostly obscure and
- 16:40pop probably failing software company.
- 16:43And and four years later it was worth $80 billion.
- 16:46Like he was right again and again and again, like it's,
- 16:51it's, it was epic, right? But, but not everyone is as
- 16:53smart as Michael Saylor. Not everyone's as good as
- 16:55financial engineering. And this this hasn't existed
- 16:58before. So we don't know exactly how,
- 17:01when or why it could blow up. But everything can blow up,
- 17:05right? You know, the only certainty in
- 17:07life is, you know, death and, and you know, and 10 minute
- 17:10blocks. Basically when you start putting
- 17:13stuff into weird financial structures, it's you just don't
- 17:16know. I mean, it's the thing we put
- 17:17out a report on crypto lending and we're showing how we got a
- 17:21bunch of the centralized lenders that are alive like Galaxy to
- 17:25give us their data. And we we're showing the
- 17:27aggregate loan and the aggregate like loan book, outstanding loan
- 17:30book size of the centralized lending markets.
- 17:32Plenty of other stuff in that report to including a bunch
- 17:34about this leverage in the Bitcoin treasury companies.
- 17:37But that yeah. So this chart though, so it's
- 17:40last quarter, Q1 was the largest since the top since Q122, right?
- 17:45But The thing is, is like the companies that are doing it now
- 17:48or that made it through, like they, they learned a lot of
- 17:52those lessons. Like it's a significantly more
- 17:54mature lending market than what was happening in 21 and 2.
- 17:58So and one of the criticisms and constructive feedback I got
- 18:02about this report was somebody saying, Alex, like if you're
- 18:04looking back at the way it blew up last time, you need to be
- 18:07looking for the way it's going to blow up this time.
- 18:09And a lot of people are are worried that it's these treasury
- 18:12companies that are the new, you know, X Factor that if there is
- 18:15a cascade liquidation cascade blow up that it could come from
- 18:19them. I think I think that's
- 18:21intuitively right to worry about.
- 18:23But like, again, we also pulled the data like there's not a lot
- 18:25of debt. Like it's not really that it's
- 18:26not nearly as big as people think.
- 18:28And honestly, it's mostly just micro strategy.
- 18:31Most of these other ones are just super small.
- 18:33Like even if it even if the K pop one does 500 million, that's
- 18:36nothing like that's not remotely big enough to like cause a huge
- 18:40problem. But yes, if like, you know, if
- 18:43the K pop company isn't, you know, good enough it managing it
- 18:47and they have to puke their Bitcoin and then that causes
- 18:49another slightly small one to also have to puke their Bitcoin
- 18:52and then then, you know, then that's the that's the fear, the
- 18:55positive feedback loop. But we're not there yet.
- 18:57But this is the I think this is like still the top story of the
- 19:00of the year. And and like I said, it's not
- 19:02just Bitcoin anymore. There's soul, there's several
- 19:04soul ones. Joe Lubin is launching an ETH
- 19:05one. I said there's a Chinese
- 19:07limousine company launching an XRP one.
- 19:09Like I don't know how far this goes.
- 19:12He's actually a good question because something Brian and I
- 19:14have been, you know, battling for the past few months is about
- 19:17Bitcoin dominance and he kind of sees he going up and to the
- 19:20right. And I feel like it's the
- 19:21opposite. Obviously over a long enough
- 19:23time horizon, I think up and to the right.
- 19:25But because of this, like this, there's an unforeseen bid for
- 19:29altcoins. And I think this is the play as
- 19:31you're going to wrap securities around other assets and the
- 19:34market doesn't really recognize it.
- 19:35Where do you do you have a stance on either way?
- 19:38I mean, I on Bitcoin dominance, yeah, I would say his store like
- 19:41in a long enough time frame, it should go down and not even
- 19:44because bitcoins importance doesn't go down, but you can
- 19:47launch unlimited altcoins, right?
- 19:48So like eventually, like even if it's orders of magnitude bigger
- 19:52than the others, there's still unlimited numbers of those that
- 19:56can emerge. You only need, you know, 5000
- 19:59like $10 million ones to to challenge dominance, right.
- 20:02And that's like to me that it actually should go lower over
- 20:05time just naturally, even if it's absolutely dominating.
- 20:10In fact, I think this looking at that chart like I think it's
- 20:15pretty remarkable given like that.
- 20:18I mean, you, you really did have a Bitcoin native and Bitcoin
- 20:21only, excuse me, Renaissance over the last 18 months.
- 20:26Like even with the ETF's, if you look, I mean, it's paltry
- 20:30compared to the Bitcoin ETF's. You know, I think it's like, you
- 20:33know, a couple 100 million in net flows.
- 20:35I think they're they're actually, I think ETF's are
- 20:37minus a billion net because of because of what do you call it?
- 20:42Whatever, what was the GBC one called?
- 20:44I forget whatever the Grayscale 1 is.
- 20:47Whereas the Bitcoin net flows in the USETPS are 60 billion,
- 20:51right. So it's just not even close.
- 20:54And you know, I just having been in this market a long time, like
- 20:58usually the historical thing has been Bitcoin runs.
- 21:02If the altcoin runs, then you have a giant outside the risk
- 21:04curve, all of the shittiest, all coin runs and then the whole
- 21:07thing collapses and then you get a bear market.
- 21:09Like that's that's how it went in 17.
- 21:11It's basically how it went in 21 and just hasn't played out like
- 21:15that at all. You don't have a parabolic move.
- 21:18You have a pretty nice slow and steady rise basically.
- 21:21I mean, you know, if you watch every day like we do, sure there
- 21:24it's felt volatile at some points, but you know, Bitcoin
- 21:28crashes to one O 3. It was the price that it was
- 21:31like 3 months ago. It's five months ago.
- 21:34I mean, basically Bitcoin is the same price it was in
- 21:37mid-december, right? It's like it's almost like
- 21:39nothing happened at all in six months, right?
- 21:41So it's like we're just sort of grinding and and I think there's
- 21:45a lot of positives for Bitcoin in particular that are still
- 21:49playing out right. So it's like, I don't know if
- 21:51the all I mean, maybe the stable coin legislation will be buoyant
- 21:56for like Ethan soul because the stables probably move on Ethan
- 21:59soul. And if you get like some giant
- 22:01like explosion of these stable coins, maybe that's a catalyst.
- 22:04But sort of like the other metas in altcoin land, you know, the
- 22:08metaverse gaming like NF, TS, etcetera, defy, like they're
- 22:13just not resulting in coins going up.
- 22:15Not not mostly right. And so, but while Bitcoin grinds
- 22:19higher, so that that dominance chart has just been grinding,
- 22:23but even like ebtc is like I've been, I'm a long time ebtc
- 22:27watcher and I think we bottomed recently in like the point O1 8
- 22:32range, which is super low, to be clear, like historically low,
- 22:37almost basically at, at the historic lows for that chart.
- 22:41And you know, it's rebounded a little bit here.
- 22:43It's like point O2 four or something like that.
- 22:44Point O2 three. That's still super low.
- 22:48Like that's still super low. It's, it's reasonable, I think
- 22:51just from a pure market standpoint to say like, well, it
- 22:53probably will rebound probably, but it hasn't.
- 22:57And it's part of this Bitcoin, you know, I still think it could
- 23:00go lower. I mean, it's, it's like you look
- 23:02at the ETFs and it's just just orders of magnitude.
- 23:05I mean, the Bitcoin ETF flows are more than 60 times more than
- 23:09the ETH ones. Bitcoin is a lot bigger than
- 23:11ETH, but it's not 60 times bigger.
- 23:13Like the the ETFs are skewed heavily way above the market,
- 23:17like market share of the two assets in favor of Bitcoin.
- 23:21Yeah. I I think that tells you
- 23:22something about the demand for Bitcoin as an institutional
- 23:25asset versus these other cryptos.
- 23:26Yeah, absolutely. That that's sort of been a key
- 23:29point of my thinking around dominance in general is looking
- 23:32at those ETF flows and just assessing the appetite from
- 23:36larger pools of capital for all of these other assets X Bitcoin.
- 23:40And I think, you know, part of what we're also saying is like,
- 23:42well, the question is, is that moving out the risk curve is
- 23:46now, is that now just Bitcoin treasury companies?
- 23:48Like does that sort of replace that demand for some form of
- 23:52leverage or more risk effectively?
- 23:54And I want to go back just briefly to the point around like
- 23:59the actual indebtedness of these companies.
- 24:01And, and I think, you know, sailors been very intelligent,
- 24:06like intelligent leverage is, is sort of a phrase coined from,
- 24:09from this. But like, I think that right now
- 24:13you're totally right. Like it is muted.
- 24:15But where my concern or question comes in is like, OK, so for for
- 24:19all of these other imitators and latecomers, yeah, it's, it's not
- 24:23like excessive right now. But ultimately how do they
- 24:26compete? How do they try to catch up in,
- 24:29in my mind, like it probably involves taking more, taking on
- 24:32more leverage because I think there's, you know, in your mind,
- 24:36is there a point of saturation where like do you need 12 dozen
- 24:40tickers of proxy Bitcoin exposure or like 'cause
- 24:44otherwise, like how do they, how do they differentiate?
- 24:46Like obviously there's jurisdictional differences like
- 24:49Metaplanet has its, has its niche and I think that'll
- 24:51that'll sort of replicate across other jurisdictions as well.
- 24:55But like, how do you, how do you think about that point of
- 24:58saturation? We're clearly not there yet.
- 24:59And like, if I'm being honest about it, it probably could
- 25:02persist longer than, you know, I anticipate.
- 25:04But is there a point of saturation where like in order
- 25:07to differentiate, they will take on more leverage?
- 25:10Yeah, that's a great question. I don't know the answer.
- 25:12I think you're right about the differentiation problem.
- 25:15If if we think of it as a problem, why do you need all
- 25:18these? And I I don't know, you start to
- 25:20I mean, part of what you're part of what they're the suggestion
- 25:23is, is that you pay the premium on Bitcoin because you get the
- 25:26intelligent leverage, the management there in particularly
- 25:30in strategies case like 25 year old stock, like deep and liquid
- 25:34options market, right? I mean, at sometimes it's been
- 25:37like the highest traded equity on the entire in the entire U.S.
- 25:40stock market and you get the intelligence of the team there,
- 25:44right, Michael Saylor, Cherise Jodia, like Ed and like right
- 25:48there are talented financial engineering talented like these
- 25:52are truly epic types of new securities that they're creating
- 25:56like that. Just they're super interesting
- 25:58if you're a nerd for financial engineering, right, That is
- 26:01everyone as good at that? I don't know.
- 26:02So maybe that's one way that they differentiate.
- 26:05But again, is the average person that buys these capable of
- 26:08evaluating the financial engineering talent of the man?
- 26:10No, probably not. So then you're talking about
- 26:12like, oh, is it the spokesperson, right?
- 26:14Like, you know, got like a Jack Mallers, for example, or David
- 26:17Bailey, right, who's they're both talented marketers, right?
- 26:20And, and, and let alone Michael Saylor, who's probably the most
- 26:23famous person in the world that likes Bitcoin over the last like
- 26:263 years at this point, like he's sort of the, I was, that's what
- 26:30I loved about the fact that Trace Mayer is back on the scene
- 26:32a bit because I was like, dude, Trace was pretty much the most
- 26:35famous Bitcoiner in a prior era and he kind of left the public
- 26:38sphere right after Michael Saylor came on.
- 26:40So it's like you've never really had the monetary philosopher
- 26:44balance to the Michael Saylor, like hardest asset in the human
- 26:48history balance. I don't I think there has to be
- 26:51a point of saturation. Even if you just look at like
- 26:53convertible debt markets, like there's there's a lot of money
- 26:56there. But like, I mean, how much,
- 26:58right? Like at some point it's like, do
- 26:59I buy MSTR debt or do I buy this other one's debt?
- 27:01Like presumably there's not an unlimited source of buying
- 27:05there, right? So yeah, trace ticker.
- 27:09Yeah, we need a trace ticker now.
- 27:11Like maybe it's too, it's too, too much coincidence.
- 27:14I think if you had like, I think the jurisdictional 1 is
- 27:16interesting. It's very similar to like in
- 27:1914151617 doing venture investment in crypto exchanges.
- 27:24Like there were whole firms that did very clear strategies like
- 27:28invest in the next coin base in this jurisdiction, in that
- 27:31jurisdiction, in that jurisdiction over and over
- 27:33again. Like tons of them.
- 27:34You know, like a Filipino exchange, Indian exchange, a
- 27:37South American exchange, like that was done excessively and,
- 27:41and eventually many of them like failed as companies because like
- 27:45there's only so much trading, right?
- 27:47Like at some point you just go to the one that has the most
- 27:49volume and then you're done. Like, and, and you could see
- 27:52something similar happen here. But I still again, like there
- 27:55are plenty of capital markets that have enough, that are big
- 27:58enough, I think to support one of these companies.
- 28:01And that's people are doing that.
- 28:02They're going around to every jurisdiction to launch them.
- 28:05But, you know, beyond that, like, I don't know how many can.
- 28:07How many. I think there is a point.
- 28:10And I think you're right, Brian, to worry about the fear that
- 28:13when that point is hit, if you're facing like death or, or
- 28:18something, what is that something that you end up doing?
- 28:21Yeah. And and Jackson, I'm sure you
- 28:23probably want to move on so we can transition.
- 28:25But one, one final thought on all this stuff is like, it is,
- 28:28it is, it's all very nuanced because on one hand, like, I
- 28:31think it's entirely rational for basically every business on
- 28:35earth to want to store some of their value in Bitcoin, use it
- 28:38as a reserve asset. And I think that's the
- 28:40trajectory we're on is, is every company realizing that over
- 28:43time? The core distinction though, is
- 28:45that that doesn't make every company that decides to do that
- 28:49a wise investment for the individual.
- 28:51And I think that's what's being lost in this broader discussion
- 28:53is like people just chasing these returns and and not
- 28:56necessarily recognizing that these are trades versus owning
- 29:00spot Bitcoin is savings technology and and those are two
- 29:03just very different things. Yeah, I, I agree with that.
- 29:05I think look, the empirical data is quite clear like the owning
- 29:11some Bitcoin in any in a portfolio basically almost no
- 29:13matter how you construct it. And we've done research on this
- 29:16and basically the single best benefit to the Sharp and Sortino
- 29:20ratios of our portfolio with Bitcoin goes from just adding
- 29:23any from zero to 1 basically, right.
- 29:25I mean, there have been times when the optimal amount was to
- 29:28have 100. But like from a pure
- 29:29mathematical standpoint, but that's true.
- 29:33The benefits that Bitcoin can bring to a portfolio or has
- 29:36brought historically is true for individual portfolios.
- 29:39It's true for institutional investors.
- 29:41It's true for endowments and pensions.
- 29:43It's true for why it could be true for a company.
- 29:46That's fine. Owning Bitcoin is a has been a
- 29:49smart move. It has been a smart move, right?
- 29:52I continue to believe it will continue to be a smart move.
- 29:55That doesn't mean you have to run a company that is 100%
- 29:58capitalized with Bitcoin and whose only job is to issue new
- 30:01shares or debt for the purpose of buying Bitcoin.
- 30:02That is a different thing than just, you know, using Bitcoin
- 30:06for its saving technology. And the other thing I would say
- 30:09too about the saving technology and it kind of plays into not
- 30:13just the treasury companies, but game stocks, meme coin, game
- 30:17GameStop style meme stocks, meme coins, sports gambling.
- 30:22Like there is a malaise among the global youth about the state
- 30:26of the economy, a fear that their life won't be as good as
- 30:29their parents was, that their prospects for making it in the
- 30:33world are dim and, and diminishing further right?
- 30:36That they, they'll never be able to buy a house that, you know,
- 30:39decades of corruption and wealth inequality and, you know, an
- 30:42economy that is not designed for, you know, young people has
- 30:47created this global fear and, and, and, and deep seated
- 30:52malaise that has led to the rise of much more speculative Fiat
- 30:57activities. And in that spot, people, a lot
- 31:01of people, particularly young people, would rather gamble than
- 31:04learn about the savings technology that is Bitcoin.
- 31:06And that's sad. Yeah, I mean, that's that's
- 31:10fundamentally why I keep and won't stop about the whole
- 31:13treasury stuff is because it effectively plays on the naivete
- 31:16of the traditional 6040. And most people don't know where
- 31:19to put Bitcoin in. So at best they're looking at 1
- 31:21to 2%. So that's where the treasury,
- 31:24the publicos come in. And then on the other side,
- 31:26because we hear this all the time, people feel like 100K
- 31:28Bitcoin, they missed it. And so now you're looking to
- 31:31make that back up and that's where the speculation comes in
- 31:33and attend to 100 bagger and that's where it ends up being
- 31:36kind of like a pervasive set up for people.
- 31:39Yeah, everybody wants. I mean, look, you've been
- 31:41rewarded for buying stocks basically every single day since
- 31:442008, right? Like that's the it's been up and
- 31:47to the right. Retail is conditioned to buy the
- 31:49dip and it's and it's been it's worked in stocks, right?
- 31:54It's also worked in Bitcoin. And so there is this idea that
- 32:00you need fast gains. And, and I think the reality is,
- 32:03and I think we all know as, as you know, Bitcoin believers in
- 32:05Bitcoin that like, look, I believe life is about working
- 32:09hard and saving and growing your money and, and working right.
- 32:12And I think people are jaded because a lot of the employment
- 32:15opportunities in this world aren't paying enough.
- 32:18They're not that you're declining in real terms, right?
- 32:21Like the, the, the, the, that's what I mean about the economy
- 32:25not working. So they have to like, they feel
- 32:27they have to look for these fast gains and easy money.
- 32:30And you know, it's I, I, I, it's a symptom of, of the, the way
- 32:36the economy, you know, but the boomers, man, they really
- 32:38screwed this thing up. They did.
- 32:39They screwed up the economy and we're all paying the price well.
- 32:44Now they're aping into MSTR, so like, somebody's gonna have to
- 32:46pay somewhere. Well, they should also buy some
- 32:49Bitcoin. That's what, yeah, yeah.
- 32:51We were chatting last week about the housing market in the US and
- 32:56I saw something. You could just pull it up
- 32:57quickly. But then I want to get Alex your
- 32:59thoughts and some other things. But the concentration of wealth,
- 33:02I think it's probably obvious to all five of us on the call and
- 33:05maybe a lot of our listeners, but this chart really puts it
- 33:08into perspective. I mean, this is about 3 decades.
- 33:11And the amount of wealth it's been concentrated in the hands
- 33:15of people who are over the age of 70 has moved from about 19%
- 33:19to about 31%. And so to your point, Alex, I
- 33:22mean, it's really hard to get ahead.
- 33:24Like we were joking on the last podcast, my wife and I went to a
- 33:27few open houses and just getting crazy outbid by boomers with
- 33:32unlimited Fiat money. But anyways.
- 33:35Houses basically exactly no. Utility just store a value
- 33:41homes. But point being is, yeah, if
- 33:43your wage is increased by like 2 or 3% per year, money's debased
- 33:478% or so per year past couple of decades, it's pretty bleak for
- 33:51people generally my age. And so it's not surprising to
- 33:54see just, you know, whether it was the D5 summer of 2020 or
- 33:59now, it's just speculating on the next Bitcoin treasury
- 34:01company. People just kind of are grasping
- 34:03at straws, trying to find something that maybe they can
- 34:06get ahead with and not really recognizing that Bitcoin is
- 34:08something that you'd get ahead with, but you just need to think
- 34:11maybe a decade or two out. Yeah, I agree.
- 34:14I mean, this is a devastating chart.
- 34:15That is a devastating chart. And you know, I, I don't, I
- 34:21don't know how this gets fixed truly in the, in the long run.
- 34:24I mean, I guess maybe if the, if young people can harness Bitcoin
- 34:29and or be the leaders in the AI boom, like maybe you need like
- 34:33an industrial revolution basically of some type, I think
- 34:35to, to really reverse this. Otherwise, you know, the status
- 34:39quo is always standing in opposition to revolution.
- 34:42That is why it's called the status quo and that's why it's
- 34:44called a revolution, right. So like the, the, the, the
- 34:47powers that be always want you to believe that, that, that
- 34:50nothing can change, that everything's in its right place,
- 34:53that it's all been thought of already.
- 34:55And I think the, you know, the young, every generation has to
- 34:59try to rethink it and come up with a way to change the world.
- 35:02And we're still, I mean, look at I'm, I'm looking on the other
- 35:04side of the screen here watching the Senate waiting for the
- 35:07stable coin vote to happen at some point.
- 35:09It's not going to happen today probably.
- 35:10But and like, dude, I mean, it's like the Jackson pull up the
- 35:14chart of the average age of a member of Congress.
- 35:16I mean, it's the same chart. That's the same chart.
- 35:19It's just up and to the right, like right.
- 35:21So I don't know, someone's got to give hope.
- 35:24You're enjoying the episode. If you could do me a favor and
- 35:26leave a like comment or subscribe that would really help
- 35:29me out. You heard at the start of the
- 35:31episode, Michael is going to fire me if we do not get more
- 35:34likes more comments, more subscribes on the podcast.
- 35:38So please do me a favor if you liked the episode if you're
- 35:41excited and looking forward to tuning into these episodes each
- 35:45week really would mean a lot doesn't take much of your time
- 35:48or effort. Leave a comment throw a like it
- 35:52goes a long way now I hope you enjoyed the rest of the episode.
- 35:55Thank you. That's a good segue to just
- 35:58talking about what's going on in the United States from a policy
- 36:01perspective institutional appetite.
- 36:03I did see that chart. I tweeted about it earlier this
- 36:05week or quote tweeted and shared it on LinkedIn.
- 36:07But fascinating chart you put together, Alex, on the success
- 36:13or appetite rather of particularly Bitcoin ETFs in the
- 36:17United States versus the rest of the world.
- 36:20And I'd love to get your thoughts on what what is driving
- 36:23that. There's obviously been a
- 36:25remarkable shift in the Trump administration and how they're
- 36:28far more favorable than any other, any other cabinet White
- 36:34House administration that came before.
- 36:36And then there's of course, to your point, there is legislation
- 36:38on the horizon that I think will allow for just institutional
- 36:41allocators to come in more confidently know the rules of
- 36:45the road as it relates to this asset class.
- 36:47But I mean, this is insane, right?
- 36:49Like 60 billion inflows in about 18 months in the US and then
- 36:53about 2 billion about flows in the rest of the world.
- 36:55Why is the divergent so so massive?
- 36:59Yeah. Well, and I should say I said
- 37:00that ETH was net outflow, but actually I was thinking of this
- 37:03rest of world number. I think ETH is like plus 900
- 37:05million versus the 60 billion of Bitcoin.
- 37:08But yeah, at the at the nation's level, I mean, look on the one
- 37:13hand, you have I think a huge part of the story about US
- 37:17versus the rest of the world is just our capital markets are so
- 37:19much bigger and deeper and better.
- 37:21So you can invest in the US stock market from abroad, like
- 37:26that's totally possible. So like, why would you own like
- 37:28the Swiss one when you buy like FPTC or BTCO or IBAD or whatever
- 37:33in the US, right? So there I think there's a,
- 37:35there's a flight from some of the existing vehicles that had
- 37:38existed publicly tradable vehicles in Switzerland and
- 37:44France and Germany and Australia, right?
- 37:46Like you'd rather just again, it's the same story.
- 37:50Liquidity gets liquidity rather be in the US version once they
- 37:52launched. I do also think though, if we go
- 37:57back and look, there wasn't 60 billion in those foreign
- 37:59vehicles. So like this is net new demand
- 38:01coming to Bitcoin vehicles in general and crypt.
- 38:05I mean there's ether is in there too.
- 38:06I think in a couple sole well known.
- 38:08That's the US. We don't have sole ones yet.
- 38:10But you know, the, you know, you look at a river, Sam Baker at
- 38:15river puts out great research on this, though, like something
- 38:17like, you know, 19 of the top 25 hedge funds in the world, almost
- 38:21all of them basically American have bought the ETFs.
- 38:24You know, I mean, they're they trade, But so, you know, it's
- 38:27there are wide, you know, is the state of Wisconsin, Wisconsin
- 38:30Investment board, there's foreign sovereign wealth funds
- 38:34buying it, right. Like it is significantly easier
- 38:37for an institution to buy a pure Bitcoin ETF, spot based ETF than
- 38:42it is for them to buy spot Bitcoin.
- 38:45Like that's just they they are already set up to do that.
- 38:47They can buy any, any stock trades on like the NASDAQ or the
- 38:51Nyze is very easy for people able to buy, right?
- 38:54There's a reason for that. It's decades of like financial
- 38:56infrastructure, right? You can buy it from your
- 38:58Fidelity account, your Robin Hood account, you can buy them
- 39:00in your cash app account. I mean, obviously you can buy
- 39:02Bitcoin in cash app too, which I recommend.
- 39:04It's a good experience, but like it they're that they did unlock
- 39:08significant capital, right? And, and so I think it's a combo
- 39:11of, I think the main reason US versus the rest of the world is
- 39:14just that like our capital markets are so much bigger and
- 39:16deeper and, and we have a better rule of law and you know, than
- 39:19than most other places. And that and that's that's why,
- 39:23but I do think the US being supportive is also a big part of
- 39:28the story. I mean, being not hostile.
- 39:30I mean, those ETFs launched in the last year of Joe Biden's
- 39:33presidency when his administration was extremely
- 39:35hostile and they still did great right last year.
- 39:38So, you know, it cuts through and and those I mean, it's just
- 39:42so funny though, that like you spend years calling for these
- 39:46ETS rightly so. I mean, I am a firm believer
- 39:49that, you know, Bitcoin should be available everywhere in
- 39:52basically every vehicle, right? You want to buy it at your bank,
- 39:54you should be allowed to. You want to buy it in an ETF?
- 39:56You should be allowed to like, you want to buy it on the
- 39:58street? You should be allowed to.
- 39:59You want to buy it from on ramp and store it in multi sig
- 40:02custody. Like you should be allowed to.
- 40:04Hey, like, I don't think it's bad for Bitcoin that like ETFs
- 40:07exist, but the fact that we spend so long calling for that
- 40:11and now people are doing the treasury strategy.
- 40:14Rather than just buying ETFs. Like it's, it's crazy to me that
- 40:17like, that's where this is gone, you know, but you're constantly
- 40:21surprised. I do think the US stands alone
- 40:23when it comes to capital markets, and that includes
- 40:25Bitcoin capital markets. Yes, Speaking of that makes a
- 40:29lot of sense. And Speaking of the research
- 40:31report that River put together, I don't have it in front of me,
- 40:33so I won't pull it out. But I want to get your general
- 40:35thoughts just on the state of the US economy and the fiscal
- 40:40position. I thought it was.
- 40:42I just can't take it at face value.
- 40:43But Elon talking about how he needed to be a part of DOGE and
- 40:47then recognize that the interest expense was larger than like he
- 40:50obviously had to know that before he got involved, but then
- 40:53he's talking about it on an interview.
- 40:55And so why it's interesting now that in the zeitgeist you have
- 40:58people like Elon Musk, insane amount of wealth and influence
- 41:01talking about the fiscal position of the United States
- 41:05maybe being at a point of no return.
- 41:07And I'm curious, like what you make of that because dollars
- 41:10down about 9% this year. Yields are spiking.
- 41:13Other nations are accumulating gold. the United States is
- 41:17looking more favorably at Bitcoin with SBR, states are
- 41:20passing legislation. Just how do you think about
- 41:23what's going on from a fiscal perspective?
- 41:25How does Bitcoin from a policy and just more of a strategic
- 41:28perspective fit into the US playbook now?
- 41:31Yeah, it it fits in well and I think it really does.
- 41:36And and look, it used to be like the swan song of doom saying
- 41:41gold bugs that like the debt was going to be too big or whatever,
- 41:45like that used to be. And then it was limited.
- 41:48Then it was like, OK, I'm a couple hedge fund managers here
- 41:50and there, you know, Ray Dalio, like ringing the alarm bell.
- 41:55The secret is out. Like the the world is net buying
- 41:59gold and net selling treasuries. Like that is a fact, right?
- 42:02You can see that in the data. You can see Bitcoin all time
- 42:05highs, you can see gold all time highs.
- 42:08And you see like, I mean, not literally all time highs for
- 42:11treasury yields, but you know, bad like it's like a beach ball
- 42:14underwater, right? Like you can't, they just can't
- 42:16get those rates, those yields down.
- 42:18And that that signals A declining appetite for U.S.
- 42:22debt, which makes sense. Like because we continuously as
- 42:28a country show an inability to spend wisely and maintain a
- 42:33healthy budget. It's not possible.
- 42:35There hasn't even been a budget in like a decades.
- 42:37Like, dude, they just keep passing continuing resolutions
- 42:41and stuff, right? Like they've they've never,
- 42:43they're not even doing the budget.
- 42:44OK. And and you know, look, Elon has
- 42:47a long history of pretending he didn't know something obvious
- 42:51like as with the Bitcoin proof of work, electricity use, which
- 42:55he obviously must have known. And, and, and I would say and
- 43:00using that as a smokescreen for something that is self-serving
- 43:05In the case of Bitcoin mining, while he needed to be pro ESG
- 43:08and he was probably getting pressure, right?
- 43:10In the case of the big beautiful bill, it doesn't include EV tax
- 43:13credits. And like, he's probably pretty
- 43:15upset about that since almost most of Tesla's revenue over the
- 43:18years has been from selling those tax credits to other
- 43:21companies, right? So, but he's not wrong.
- 43:24He isn't actually wrong. He's definitely right.
- 43:26I think more people know it than ever.
- 43:28I think, you know, it's like pretty much just during this
- 43:32podcast, we'll have added like, like, you know, $300 or
- 43:36something of debt for every person in America, right?
- 43:38Like the the number just keeps going up.
- 43:41And I think it's not just it's not just the macro in the
- 43:44fiscal, but it's also the geopolitical one.
- 43:48Other countries don't we're, we're clearly in the packs
- 43:51Americana of like post 1991, even if it may even have ended,
- 43:57you know, on 9/11, it's certainly basically ended now.
- 44:01We no longer have the ability to unilaterally project for us all
- 44:03around the world. We, we have strong ability,
- 44:06right? But like the dollar is no longer
- 44:09the de facto thing. You've got Russia and China
- 44:12settling trades and rubles and, and, and maybe instead of in
- 44:16dollars, you've got an increasing amount of that
- 44:18continuous chatter about whether there'll be a bricks currency.
- 44:22You're clearly entering a more multipolar world.
- 44:25And I think in that spot, non sovereign commodity monies like
- 44:29gold and Bitcoin should do quite well.
- 44:31I, I, I think, I think it's a little tricky with the US
- 44:35government. I think just like I said, I mean
- 44:36basically any portfolio should own one of the best performing
- 44:40assets in the history of the world, especially one that has
- 44:42these. I mean, Bitcoin is perfect to be
- 44:46a strategic asset, right, because you know, it's yes, it
- 44:50it lacks obviously certain functionality.
- 44:52It's hard on the L1 to send small amounts or it's a little
- 44:55bit slow 10 minutes. I mean, it's orders of magnitude
- 44:58faster than traditional system, right?
- 45:00It's it's transparent. It's not very private, but like
- 45:03for like reserves or like international trade, those don't
- 45:08really matter. This has non sovereign issuance,
- 45:12no issuer, right, no liability to any issuer at all.
- 45:15It's able to be held cryptographically and securely.
- 45:19Can't can't really. I mean, if it with good custody
- 45:22and multi sing and you know the the standards of custody can't
- 45:24really be stolen by your adversary.
- 45:26And if you want to spend it, you know, I can send a billion
- 45:29dollars across the Bitcoin network in 10 minutes.
- 45:31If you want to send a billion dollars of gold, you have to
- 45:33send a literal warship, right? It's just simply not useful,
- 45:37right? Gold.
- 45:38Gold's biggest transactional use over the last like 50 years has
- 45:41been one dude taking it out of a cage in the basement of the New
- 45:44York Fed and rolling it across the floor and putting it in a
- 45:46different cage. That's literally how like a
- 45:48foreign country settles with another foreign country.
- 45:50They just call up the New York Fed and be like, can you just
- 45:52like move those gold bars from that room to that room?
- 45:54Like that's the only way it works as a settlement vehicle.
- 45:57So that it sucks as a settlement vehicle.
- 46:00Now it is really good because like it's been around for, you
- 46:03know, all of all of time and has, you know, multi millennia
- 46:08of establishment as this, you know, non debasable commodity
- 46:13money. And it's got all those features,
- 46:14right. It's it's scarce, but it's not
- 46:16too scarce. It's like just just right,
- 46:18right. But Bitcoin, just like Satoshi
- 46:20said in that early post about what you know, imagine it's a
- 46:23thought experiment, like a weightless, colorless, odorless
- 46:25version of gold. I mean it, it's just really good
- 46:28and I think Jackson like, I think that's why countries
- 46:32states like sovereign wealth funds like it's, it's, it's
- 46:36useful. It's undeniably useful in that
- 46:38world and we are heading towards it.
- 46:40But yes, not just the macro and fiscal, but also the
- 46:43geopolitical, I think all point to growing Bitcoin adoption and.
- 46:46Maybe maybe to extend that sort of like strategic strategic plan
- 46:52or concepts of the US, we are talking a bit about this before
- 46:55we hit record. But like where do stable coins
- 46:57fit in into that strategic playbook?
- 46:59Because I think there's this notion of maybe you can continue
- 47:03to exert dollar dominance across the world if you allow stable
- 47:07coins to proliferate. And I think you're seeing that
- 47:09in sort of the order of operations of the legislation,
- 47:11right? Like Genius Act comes first,
- 47:13then we'll do some market structure, then we'll get to the
- 47:15SBR. Like how do stable coins fit
- 47:18into And Groman, Luke Groman has talked about this a ton as well
- 47:22of sort of, you know, this tacit sort of, you know, admission or,
- 47:31you know, allowing the citizen to invest in Bitcoin or hard
- 47:35assets while still transacting in dollars.
- 47:37So spread stable coins, allow citizens to save in Bitcoin,
- 47:41sort of remove the toxicity from Bitcoin.
- 47:43You could even go back to the approval of the ETFs as like the
- 47:45first signpost of like this is OK now.
- 47:49Yeah. So I guess all that is to say,
- 47:50where where do stable coins fit into this strategic playbook?
- 47:53I think that's right. Luke's point is right, That is
- 47:56obviously the way to for the government, probably the
- 48:01government's, but certainly the US government to allow the
- 48:04proliferation of Bitcoin is in that way as a store of value
- 48:07asset, not as a money, right. And I think this is an
- 48:10interesting contradiction here with the US strategic Bitcoin
- 48:14reserve concept, which is like a lot of the ideas of funding it,
- 48:18I think are totally unpalatable to the government because like
- 48:22any acknowledgement that the dollar needs further backing,
- 48:25right? Like people have talked about
- 48:26using this thing, the exchange stabilization fund at the
- 48:28Treasury, which is a fund set up literally to let the secretary
- 48:31of the Treasury like basically buy and sell FX in order to help
- 48:35protect the dollar, right? In general, they, I don't think,
- 48:40I don't know the last time they've used it, decades
- 48:42probably, right? But it's sitting there and some
- 48:44people said, well, they should buy some Bitcoin with that.
- 48:46And I'm saying if you buy Bitcoin with that, you're going
- 48:48to collapse the dollar. Like people are going to say,
- 48:50wait a second, I thought the dollar wasn't backed by anything
- 48:53but the full faith and credit. Now you're like backing it with
- 48:55something like it wouldn't matter if they bought popsicle
- 48:57sticks in that thing. It would spook markets, right?
- 49:01Same thing with bit bonds, like, you know, have the treasury
- 49:04issue, like some fixed income securities that have a Bitcoin
- 49:06element. Everyone in the that could, that
- 49:09could spook the debt markets badly and harm the dollar,
- 49:12right? So they got to figure out for
- 49:14the SBR how to fund it in a way that is that doesn't harm the
- 49:17dollar, if for no other reason than that the president for whom
- 49:20they all work has called for the dollar to remain the global
- 49:23reserve currency, right. And so transitioning a little
- 49:26bit closer now, Brian, to your question, like at the crypto
- 49:29round table in the White House on what March 6th or March 4th
- 49:33or whatever day that was, Scott Basson literally said we will
- 49:37protect and grow the US dollar reserve status and we will use
- 49:41stable coins to do that. It's what he said.
- 49:44And I think they have a strategy here, which is, look, you don't
- 49:47want to buy our debt or you don't want to own as much of it
- 49:49or you don't want to transact in our dollars, fine, we'll just
- 49:52dollarize the smartphone of every one of your citizens.
- 49:54Like it is a subversive and powerful American empire play.
- 49:58And it should be seen as that. It's not a crypto bill.
- 50:00Like watching some of the, you know, long time antagonists like
- 50:03Senator Elizabeth Warren rail against the genius act like it's
- 50:07some kind of handout to crypto. It's like, hello, we can all
- 50:09issue these today. We're not the ones that need
- 50:11this. I mean, there's 200 billion of
- 50:13of U.S. dollar denominated stable coins already in
- 50:15circulation from crypto firms, right?
- 50:18Like it's not a handout to crypto.
- 50:19It it should be seen as a dollar dominance bill.
- 50:22That is the plan. I think it's a good idea.
- 50:24I think it it is a powerful idea.
- 50:27Like, it is a big, big, big idea.
- 50:31And yeah, I mean, look, in the end, every global reserve in the
- 50:34history of the world has failed. Like, I see no reason to believe
- 50:37that the dollar, you know, will for it until the end of time
- 50:40when the sun engulfs the Earth will still be the global
- 50:43reserve. It's just you have to believe in
- 50:44the end of history to think that's true.
- 50:46But that doesn't mean that you should give it up willingly,
- 50:49right? And I don't believe any rational
- 50:52country would, no matter how much they like gold or Bitcoin
- 50:54or whatever, Like it's practically the core of what
- 50:58being a sovereign is, is the ability to issue money like,
- 51:01and, and you'll never get the US or any other country that has
- 51:05the ability to be the reserve to willingly give that up.
- 51:09It's funny, like, you know, when the president was saying that
- 51:11the trade imbalances that we have were unfair, right?
- 51:15And, and I'm like, Sir, not only is it not unfair, it's
- 51:18explicitly what we signed up for.
- 51:20Like that is the triff and dilemma like you, the global
- 51:22reserve has to, it has to be a net exporter of currency and a
- 51:26net importer of goods. And by the way, it's great.
- 51:28We basically get to trade depreciating paper for a bunch
- 51:32of good stuff that other people make.
- 51:33Like it's actually a it is a privilege, right?
- 51:35Like it's a but it naturally results in a trade imbalance.
- 51:38And the, the idea is that, and this is what's so perplexing,
- 51:42There's a, there's a contradiction between tariffs
- 51:46and being the global reserve. Because when you're the global
- 51:48reserve, like I said, you have to net export dollars.
- 51:50When you add tariffs on imports to your country, you are
- 51:53increasing the cost of global exporters buying your dollars
- 51:57with their goods, right? You don't want to be increasing
- 51:59the cost. You want to be streamlining it,
- 52:02making it super easy to have people have wallet dollars in
- 52:05their wallet, right? So countervailing that is how I
- 52:08look at stable coins. The idea as well, we're doing
- 52:10tariffs here and and the other stuff that's multi polar trends
- 52:14and whatever is an impediment, A headwind to dollar reserve
- 52:17status. How can we put a tailwind behind
- 52:20it? And I think that to me, that's
- 52:22how I view stable coins as strategic, which is that we can
- 52:26just put dollars everywhere, right?
- 52:28We can just doesn't mean that the dollar, the DXY is going to
- 52:32go up, probably not probably just continues to go down
- 52:35forever the value. But but like it's reserve status
- 52:39is different than the strong dollar, right?
- 52:40Like you were talking about distributing the dollars, not so
- 52:43much like how much they are valued versus other things.
- 52:45I think the US needs a weaker dollar like to help us pay our
- 52:49debt, right? Like that's obvious.
- 52:52But I think I see stable coins as highly strategic.
- 52:54I also see them as benign in the face of Bitcoin.
- 52:58I don't see, you know, I know a lot of Bitcoiners, right, who
- 53:00want Bitcoin to be itself the global reserve currency.
- 53:02Like I, I, I really don't think that will ever happen.
- 53:06And I think that's OK. Like you can, I think Bitcoin
- 53:08can win massively and will win massively.
- 53:10It doesn't need to be the, the global reserve.
- 53:14I, I don't think. And I'm not saying I'm not
- 53:17offering a qualitative assessment.
- 53:18I'm saying I predict that there will never be a Bitcoin backed
- 53:23dollar. There will never be.
- 53:25We're not going back to the gold standard.
- 53:26You're not going to get the Bitcoin standard.
- 53:28I don't believe that will ever happen.
- 53:29So in the face of that, you may as well.
- 53:32I'd rather have it be the dollar with us allowed to buy and hold
- 53:35Bitcoin then, you know, Chinese renminbi or like bricks, bricks
- 53:39currency. Like, I mean, still the best of
- 53:42the, you know, what was the Winston Churchill like?
- 53:44Democracy is the the worst one except for all the others.
- 53:47Like the dollar is the worst one except for all the others.
- 53:49So why not upgrade the rails? It's an upgrade to the dollar.
- 53:53To me. This shouldn't be controversial.
- 53:54They should have done it years ago.
- 53:56I don't know, like if there's any better technology, if you
- 53:58could, you know, if if there's a new type of physical wire that
- 54:02will make it easier to be the global reserve, they should do
- 54:06it. I mean, it's just purely logical
- 54:08and strategic. Yeah, a few.
- 54:10A few things to call out. We had a podcast earlier in the
- 54:12week with Jacob Shapiro and there was a little bit of, I
- 54:16don't know if it was an antagonistic, but it was a
- 54:19little bearish on like Trump strategy.
- 54:20And it was referencing pulling forward like 20 years of what
- 54:23was going to happen to today. And we had a conversation this
- 54:26morning with Brahman the way I was able to the time I wasn't
- 54:28able to. But today think about like the
- 54:30US is running a startup playbook and basically trying to disrupt
- 54:33themselves effectively. There was innovator's dilemma
- 54:36and that's where Bitcoin adoption and the stable coin
- 54:40proliferation comes into play of like how do we actually, you
- 54:42know, prolong this? And one of the things that
- 54:47doesn't get talked about is the structural demand for, for
- 54:51stables at the banking level, if they're going to hold Bitcoin,
- 54:55because we're talking about the proliferation outside the US.
- 54:58But if banks are going to start custody in this, which I think
- 55:00we all expect they will be, there's going to be some
- 55:02standard, at least we believe in that was set up where they have
- 55:04to hold some amount of dollars or treasuries, which would be,
- 55:08you know, the demand for treasuries, not stable coins.
- 55:11But then the other one to call out is the banks.
- 55:14I, I think like I got really bullish on where the price of
- 55:18Bitcoin goes once I saw this bill starting to to look like it
- 55:21was going to get passed because of what Tether and BTC end up
- 55:24being in that trading pair. And I think we under appreciate
- 55:27once the notion of a digitization or a digital dollar
- 55:30exists in everyone's bank account and how that can be
- 55:32traded into another digital currency and what that looks
- 55:34like and then how that proliferates to get through
- 55:36capital markets through the Internet.
- 55:38Like I think that's super bullish for Bitcoin long term.
- 55:41I will make a bet to Alex on whatever he wants that Bitcoin
- 55:45will eventually. We don't say this a lot because
- 55:46it's not commercial, but you were so emphatic that it won't
- 55:48be as the, the reserve. It's just an inefficient way for
- 55:52like us to transfer between 2:00.
- 55:54Because this is something that Parker, I think keyed in on is
- 55:56we've never had a, a currency and a a currency and a
- 56:02commodity, right? Like Bitcoin is like gold is a
- 56:05commodity and then you had to shave it off into creating a
- 56:08currency and that's where you ended up or you had to like
- 56:10create dollars and 2nd layers. But Bitcoin is a commodity and
- 56:13as a currency, that's what gets hard to, you know, via Satoshi.
- 56:17So at the end of the day, like Satoshi's will be priced in
- 56:19there because it's just the most efficient way and people will
- 56:21want the SAT versus the the dollar.
- 56:23Now, what is that time scale? Is it 100 years?
- 56:25Is it 20 years? I don't know.
- 56:26But I would feel fairly confident Bitcoin wins.
- 56:29It ends up being the thing that people want.
- 56:30And so that's what naturally would be the most efficient way
- 56:32to transact. I think there's that.
- 56:35That's true. I, I think, but I think here's
- 56:37the other thing, like, you know, you're, you're talking about
- 56:40sort of like, I'm thinking more of like a Gresham's law concept
- 56:43here. Like yes, we all want Fiat.
- 56:45You all want the unshaved coins, not the shaved ones, right?
- 56:48But The thing is, is like, I'm sorry, we all want Bitcoin.
- 56:51You don't want the shaved coins, you want the unshaved coins,
- 56:53right? That's why the orders have the
- 56:55ridges on them because you could shave off and then meltdown the
- 56:58value of the coins. And I can't now because our
- 56:59coins aren't even valuable in a in a metals sense.
- 57:04I think this though, like I don't want to spend Bitcoin on
- 57:07anything that's not hard. I don't want to pay.
- 57:09I personally like I'll buy a house out of stone and brick
- 57:12with Bitcoin, but I don't want to buy Amazon fucking credits
- 57:15with Bitcoin like you need. There is a need for I believe
- 57:19and not just in a like a anti Bitcoin standard way for fast
- 57:23crappy money like because there are.
- 57:27But the kicker is, let's pretend like the zero to 1 is finite
- 57:30scarcity. The layers will figure out,
- 57:32right? Because if you can figure out
- 57:33finite scarcity, the easy part is how do you make it fast?
- 57:36The kicker is whatever you want, somebody's going to want Bitcoin
- 57:39for. So you have to make the decision
- 57:41that's actually how you fix everything else.
- 57:43That's the counter like. Possible, but I mean again,
- 57:45think about it, we're it's not just layers now there is no gold
- 57:49backing the dollar. It's pure Fiat.
- 57:50Like we so like you're talking about a devolution back to a
- 57:54commodity money based world and I just feel like the world is
- 57:56not going back. We might all want Bitcoin, sure,
- 57:59but like, well, I don't know, I guess.
- 58:01Yeah, theoretically if everyone refuses to accept anything but
- 58:05Bitcoin for goods and services, then yeah, it will.
- 58:07That's what being global money will mean, right?
- 58:10I mean that is what it is. I don't I don't think it's going
- 58:13to happen, but you know, power to it.
- 58:15I mean, I'm I'm long Bitcoin, you know, have you guys have you
- 58:18guys not seen? I mean, I sure I'd love it.
- 58:20I just feel the main reason I make this point, though, is to
- 58:23tell people that it doesn't have to happen.
- 58:25You don't have to believe that happen to be bullish Bitcoin.
- 58:28That's my main take because I I talked to a lot of institutional
- 58:31investors and they're like, oh, I heard this.
- 58:32I'm not going to name any many of them my friends.
- 58:34I heard this Bitcoin influencer saying that like everything will
- 58:37be Bitcoin. I just think that's crazy and
- 58:39I'm like, oh, you don't have to agree with him to be bullish
- 58:41Bitcoin, though, like there's a whole other world where you know
- 58:44it takes out gold, right? Gold now is what, 25 trillion or
- 58:48something? It's up a lot since we used to
- 58:50say 20 trillion, right? Like dude, that's a that's a 12
- 58:53bagger from here. If Bitcoin's as valuable as
- 58:54gold, right, And and there's plenty there, like beyond
- 58:57whether it's used his money. I definitely.
- 59:01Agree there, because that's like literally the founding of this
- 59:03whole business is meeting the market where they're at.
- 59:05And there's a difference between being right.
- 59:07You want to make money or you want to be right.
- 59:09And making money is what you just said is like meeting the
- 59:11market. Nobody wants to hear.
- 59:13Nobody wants to hear the dollar is going to end and we're going
- 59:15to use it, but just be on the record maybe.
- 59:19That's right. I mean, I agree with you.
- 59:20It's totally possible and I'm fine with it.
- 59:22But the reason I like to be hyperbolic with that statement
- 59:25is so that there's somebody out here saying you don't have to
- 59:28agree with that. And you can still be mega
- 59:30bullish on Bitcoin in its adoption as as in a variety of
- 59:33different things. And you are right, by the way.
- 59:35You know, gold is a commodity money.
- 59:37You did have actual gold coins. There wasn't always layer twos,
- 59:41right? Like, I mean, the Romans
- 59:43themselves probably recapped and debased the the coins like 3 on
- 59:46three different occasions, major occasions over their long
- 59:50empire. And it was true gold coins.
- 59:53But you don't have to believe that like it's going to be, you
- 59:56know, the only money in order to see a world where Bitcoin is
- 1:00:00widely adopted and useful and not just useful like a store of
- 1:00:03value could be useful in some other way.
- 1:00:05Maybe it's the money, but only for big giant purchases or big
- 1:00:08long distance purchases. Or maybe it is an interbank
- 1:00:11money. Or maybe it is closer to what
- 1:00:13you're saying, Michael, And it's like what half any sentence
- 1:00:15Bitcoin banks and it really is the foundation of a of a new
- 1:00:18layer. All of those are possible.
- 1:00:20Any one of them, I think, means Bitcoin can win.
- 1:00:26So, Alex, please entertain me. Let let me operate under the
- 1:00:29assumption that the top is in. The.
- 1:00:32Start of the episode the top is in.
- 1:00:35I want to hear why the top isn't in.
- 1:00:36I mean, we you said something I think at the start of the
- 1:00:38episode where there's like a lot of bullish things have been
- 1:00:41announced, but actually haven't happened yet.
- 1:00:43Yeah, I. Don't actually believe the top
- 1:00:45is in. I just, I don't, I want to say
- 1:00:46it to say it, but yeah, we have seven months left.
- 1:00:49Against the top is in, yeah. I want to hear like we had seven
- 1:00:51more months of the year in theory cycles.
- 1:00:54Maybe they don't need to happen anymore to the same extent they
- 1:00:57have in the past. But I just want to hear your
- 1:00:58unfettered thoughts, like what are you paying attention to?
- 1:01:01What's exciting for the the rest of the 2025?
- 1:01:03Business and market cycles will always exist, right.
- 1:01:06I think that sort of Bitcoin having and crypto Bitcoin having
- 1:01:11driven crypto market cycle, I think probably doesn't exist
- 1:01:14anymore and and it really shouldn't exist.
- 1:01:17I mean to the extent it was ever the halving actually causing
- 1:01:20that, like the halving is an immaterial supply difference now
- 1:01:24versus daily Bitcoin float. Like it's not material whether
- 1:01:27you go from 900 to 450 coins per day on average like that does
- 1:01:30not matter. Bitcoin trades 10 to $50 billion
- 1:01:33a day of Bitcoin, right? But I think I think why?
- 1:01:38So you still have many shoes to drop on that, that ETF story.
- 1:01:43And I had forgotten that I was on the IT was like a year and a
- 1:01:44half ago, I guess at this point, But I'm sure I talked about it
- 1:01:47in January 2024 when I was on the show of the wire houses, the
- 1:01:52RIA, like the family offices. There's still an enormous amount
- 1:01:55of technical unlock that still has to happen like just today or
- 1:01:59yesterday said JPM said they'll start allowing you to margin
- 1:02:02your Bitcoin ETFs, right? There's still a lot like that to
- 1:02:06happen. And so and, and it's we're
- 1:02:08finally like a year in now. And so like it's going to
- 1:02:11actually finally start happening with the big banks.
- 1:02:13The big asset manager is actually finally allowing people
- 1:02:16to buy the Bitcoin ETFs. So there's that benign sort of
- 1:02:19passive story on the underside that I think does lead to more
- 1:02:23ownership over time. You, you have basically all of
- 1:02:28the like state or national level SPR related stuff.
- 1:02:31And like literally right now think about what the USSPR
- 1:02:34ordered in March to buy, to hold and try to buy Bitcoin and to
- 1:02:40hold or sell if they want all altcoins, literally Bitcoin put
- 1:02:44in buy only mode, literally every altcoin put in sell only
- 1:02:47mode, they're actually prohibited from buying altcoins
- 1:02:50in that executive order. 30 days after that, they had to deliver
- 1:02:53an audit to the president of how much Bitcoin the government
- 1:02:55thinks it owns. Actually much, much more
- 1:02:58complicated than people think. And then 30 days after that, so
- 1:03:0160 days after the EO deliver a a list of possible budget neutral
- 1:03:05strategies to require more. None of that's public OK has not
- 1:03:09been released publicly. We don't know how much BTC the
- 1:03:11government thinks it owns. We don't know what they are
- 1:03:15thinking of as possible budget neutral acquisition strategies.
- 1:03:18We don't know. We we think we might find out in
- 1:03:22July when the other EO mandated Presidential working group
- 1:03:25report is released. But technically there's nothing
- 1:03:27about the SBR in that EO and therefore it doesn't have to be
- 1:03:31in that report. There might not.
- 1:03:32Who knows if we'll find, if you read the EO, it doesn't mandate
- 1:03:35that those strategies or the audit be made public.
- 1:03:38It mandates that Treasury and Commerce deliver that to the
- 1:03:40White House. So I do think there is a point,
- 1:03:43at a minimum, forgetting whether we buy, OK, just when we get the
- 1:03:47number, when the US government says we officially own, you
- 1:03:51know, 100,000 BTC, that's going to be a huge catalyst, I think,
- 1:03:55whenever that is. And I think it will happen, I
- 1:03:56mean, at some point, like, dude, they've got to tell us.
- 1:03:59It's actually tricky because so many of the coins that the
- 1:04:01government has are encumbered in various legal or civil asset
- 1:04:05forfeiture states of being, right.
- 1:04:08And the government, there is federal law that says the
- 1:04:10government can't just take stuff like and make it and move it
- 1:04:14into its own account, right. So they got to go through all of
- 1:04:17those US attorney districts, 94 of them, and be like, do you
- 1:04:21guys have any Bitcoin? What's the current state of it
- 1:04:23like? Oh, do you owe it?
- 1:04:24Like for example, Razzlecon's bit Fenix hacked coins, right?
- 1:04:28Like it's a lot. It's like 100,000 or something,
- 1:04:30I forget. We think the government has
- 1:04:32about 198 K Bitcoin. That's what we think.
- 1:04:34That's what the market thinks. That's what Arkham shows these
- 1:04:37explorers think a huge portion of that is recovered stolen
- 1:04:41funds. And it's not like the victim is
- 1:04:43dead, like they presumably will be returned to the victim,
- 1:04:46right? And or they'll be like creditor,
- 1:04:49like bankruptcy proceedings in a lot of these.
- 1:04:51So we don't know. And it's actually pretty hard,
- 1:04:54like just laborious for the government to figure out like
- 1:04:56what the current status is of all these.
- 1:04:58But at some point they will and at some point we'll learn it.
- 1:05:01And that's not talking about hopefully at some point they'll,
- 1:05:04you know, follow the president's order and actually buy some,
- 1:05:06right? So those are obvious catalysts.
- 1:05:08I mean, I think everybody knows that.
- 1:05:09But merely finding out the audit results, I think would be highly
- 1:05:12positive. Then you've got all the macro
- 1:05:14stuff, right? That is, I think, uniquely
- 1:05:16supportive for hard non sovereign assets.
- 1:05:18And then you've got a bunch of crypto stuff that I think
- 1:05:21ultimately is still positive for Bitcoin, even if it's only
- 1:05:25tangentially related, right? People normalizing the use of
- 1:05:28public block chains and public key cryptography around assets
- 1:05:32is naturally going to lead to more Bitcoin adoption.
- 1:05:34Like now it's probably going to lead to a lot of altcoin
- 1:05:37adoption too. But again, like, you know, it's
- 1:05:41a free market. Hester Purse told the Bitcoin
- 1:05:43audience in in Vegas, like Bitcoin or stop asking for the
- 1:05:46government to arrest shit corners.
- 1:05:48All right, like it's a free market like just you have the
- 1:05:50best asset. Just exalt it.
- 1:05:52It's literally what Hester Purse from the SEC said to the giant
- 1:05:55audience in Vegas. And I've always believed that
- 1:05:57like I don't need others to lose so that Bitcoin can win.
- 1:06:00I think Bitcoin can win on its own and that's fine, but I I
- 1:06:04actually think Bitcoin benefits long term from the institutional
- 1:06:07use of things like stable coins of something like defy.
- 1:06:10We also look now here's some some more cute ones I'll throw
- 1:06:13out here Jackson one Bitcoin credit cards like Gemini's card
- 1:06:16right. They have to buy Bitcoin.
- 1:06:17If those become widely adopted, think about how nice it is for a
- 1:06:20turbo normie to just go about their life and be acquiring
- 1:06:23Bitcoin in pieces. Like I think it's actually a
- 1:06:25very, very powerful retail product.
- 1:06:28And if they get big, they have to buy Bitcoin every day, right.
- 1:06:31So like those could be an interesting catalyst.
- 1:06:33I think also the Bitcoin layer two-story is a big positive
- 1:06:36catalyst actually, and you know, we're we're an investor in one
- 1:06:40Citria, but you know, there's alpen.
- 1:06:42These are ZK roll ups. I think that's powerful.
- 1:06:45Like I I don't know where Bitcoin Maxis have landed on
- 1:06:48this. You know, for a long time it was
- 1:06:49like don't do it on my L1, do it on the L2.
- 1:06:51Then some of them are like, well, we don't like the L twos
- 1:06:53either because they're going to be filled with shit coins.
- 1:06:55And it's like some point like we just need more block space and
- 1:07:00people want to do stuff on Bitcoin and, and some of these
- 1:07:03are really, really powerful. Like I also like arcade and arc
- 1:07:06and and light spark spark L2 and like there's a bunch of
- 1:07:10interesting layer 2 stuff being built that like could could
- 1:07:13really drive a lot of usage. And ultimately I think it's very
- 1:07:17likely not just with Bitcoin, but basically we think this for
- 1:07:19almost all layer one block chains, they end up being like
- 1:07:21solely filled with like proofs for layer twos, right?
- 1:07:24That that is what drives the block space demand and you know
- 1:07:27Bitcoin less likely to get there soon than something like
- 1:07:30Ethereum because like bitcoiners like to hold L1 Bitcoin in their
- 1:07:34self custody and I get that I do myself right That's but like I
- 1:07:37think it is the best network. Also, it's the highest fidelity
- 1:07:41blockchain in the world. It's the most transparent, most
- 1:07:44predictable, most secure. So like they're there, there's
- 1:07:47data anchoring that people want to do on it, right?
- 1:07:50And those are going to start coming pretty soon.
- 1:07:52The the, the, the, these new one.
- 1:07:54I mean, the, this is literally like what a lot of people said
- 1:07:56where it was like all coins or test Nets like the Alpin and
- 1:08:00Citri are literally taking the bet.
- 1:08:02There have been enormous developments.
- 1:08:04I don't Bitcoiners may not realize this if they don't
- 1:08:07follow block chains. There have been enormous
- 1:08:10advancements and cryptographic ledgers enormous way beyond
- 1:08:14anything that we do. Even Lightning the, the rest of
- 1:08:17the world move beyond state channel payment channels like 7
- 1:08:21years ago because they're not that good.
- 1:08:23They are good in some ways. They're good because they're
- 1:08:25they're they're more private. They're good because you can be
- 1:08:28more self sovereign. There's no, but there's no
- 1:08:30global state. You can't do any type of that.
- 1:08:32I mean, I'll be stunned and I and I love the teams at
- 1:08:35Lightning Labs and Tether, but I will be absolutely stunned if
- 1:08:38USD UT on lightning becomes remotely big at all.
- 1:08:41Lightnings not made for that, right?
- 1:08:43It's so easy to do tokens on a different type of blockchain,
- 1:08:46but there's a bunch of interesting ones coming.
- 1:08:48And these Citri and Alpin are ZK roll ups and like this is an
- 1:08:52enormous advancement in distributed ledgers, right?
- 1:08:56And and I think it would be fascinating to see what happens
- 1:09:00if if people start doing those. I don't think it's just going to
- 1:09:02be monkey pictures. I think there is going to be
- 1:09:04some interesting finance that can be done with Bitcoin as the
- 1:09:07base asset in a highly secure L2.
- 1:09:10And so that that's one that I'm excited for.
- 1:09:12Don't know exactly when those are really coming, but and then
- 1:09:15again, the DLC based ones and these, I don't even know how
- 1:09:17arcade works yet. I've got somebody who's looking
- 1:09:19into it to explain it to me. There's a lot of interesting
- 1:09:22stuff on the L2 front, on the dev side.
- 1:09:24And then sort of I said the cards, the institutions, the
- 1:09:28states, the where do you help? I was going to say where do?
- 1:09:31You where do you put just global liquidity generally?
- 1:09:34Because we've all seen the charts of M2 versus Bitcoin on
- 1:09:36the leg. And I think that's the, to me
- 1:09:38that's the biggest difference. If you're trying to compare the,
- 1:09:42what looks like a similar double top is like, well, back then we
- 1:09:46were about to enter the fastest rate hike cycle in history and
- 1:09:49constrain liquidity. And now we're sort of entering
- 1:09:52the opposite we're. Probably going to enter a lower
- 1:09:54interest rate environment probably, although I would say
- 1:09:57the Fed is and and power to them by the way, like keeping rates
- 1:10:01high. Is the Fed like being an adult
- 1:10:02in the room, Like to be honest, right.
- 1:10:04Like it's, it's every time they cut rates, they're being, you
- 1:10:07know, profligate and every time they keep them high or hike
- 1:10:09them, they're being conservative and like that's you got to
- 1:10:12respect that. But yes, I think we're much more
- 1:10:15likely to have rates come down than we are to have them go up.
- 1:10:18So you're right. I don't I think when it comes to
- 1:10:19like global M2, like I'm not a huge fan of this metric.
- 1:10:22It's not really a good measure of money, but it but also like
- 1:10:25bank bank reserves might be better.
- 1:10:27But like, you know, but it but it is also kind of the same.
- 1:10:30So like I think the chart actually works.
- 1:10:32It's just probably not the actual right instrument to
- 1:10:34measure it against. Yeah, I mean it's same thing.
- 1:10:37That's the other reason I say an even more sort of crass reason
- 1:10:41why Bitcoin or should be fine with stable coins.
- 1:10:42Like dude, the dollar is a the dollar depreciating means
- 1:10:46Bitcoin appreciates against it. Like, like, you know, OK, so
- 1:10:51Bitcoin doesn't go to Infinity because it's the only asset, but
- 1:10:54like, it's perfectly fine trading it against a
- 1:10:56perpetually, you know, debasing dollar.
- 1:10:59And that's what we have. And we know we have to debase
- 1:11:01it. We know liquidity, like an
- 1:11:03issuance of the dollar has to go higher.
- 1:11:06Cannot afford to pay off this debt.
- 1:11:07It is truly impossible. I, I look back to Elon on that
- 1:11:10too. Like, I guess look, he's
- 1:11:12throwing up his hands. Like I tried.
- 1:11:13I knew it was a problem and I just didn't realize like how big
- 1:11:16of a problem it was and like whatever man, good for him.
- 1:11:19I mean, if he didn't actually know, like he learned like
- 1:11:21everybody else, eventually everyone gets there.
- 1:11:24The odds of this government are our government design coming up
- 1:11:28with a way to save this fiscal and debt situation.
- 1:11:31Extremely unlikely, right? Extremely unlikely.
- 1:11:34Most likely in five or ten years we have 100 trillion in debt
- 1:11:38almost. I would like that's a safe bet,
- 1:11:41I think, right? Way more likely than we actually
- 1:11:43reduce it. And Bitcoin looks great in that
- 1:11:45way. And it's not just us.
- 1:11:47The Chinese are printing a ton. Like, there's plenty of printing
- 1:11:50going on. And yeah, you probably enter a
- 1:11:53more printing era pretty soon, I would think.
- 1:11:57I mean, this is the big question with macro is like, look, stocks
- 1:12:00are almost at all time highs still.
- 1:12:01They're like a 1 1/2% off all time highs, right?
- 1:12:03Like we're back. I mean, April was, you know,
- 1:12:06April 7th Liberation Day was like the bottom it turns out.
- 1:12:09And we basically have done a full V like we were up at the
- 1:12:11start of the year all the way down a bunch.
- 1:12:13I mean 20% or something in equities down then basically all
- 1:12:16the way back. And so stocks look OK, inflation
- 1:12:22is low. I think core PCs 2.1%, like CPI
- 1:12:26is 2.5%. If you told the, and
- 1:12:28employment's like like 4 1/2 or unemployment's like at 4:00
- 1:12:31somewhere in the forest, if you told the Fed like 2 years ago
- 1:12:34that they'd have two point 1% core PCE and 4% unemployment,
- 1:12:37they would literally be standing up cheering.
- 1:12:40It worked. They did it quote UN quote,
- 1:12:41right? So why aren't they cutting like
- 1:12:43that? That's the question.
- 1:12:44Like they're, they're having the stiff upper lip about it.
- 1:12:47And I think the, the, the fear is there's a lot of sort of like
- 1:12:50latent indicators that the employment market is going to
- 1:12:52crack and it's going to get bad. And housing is a great one to
- 1:12:55look at. It's like totally drying up.
- 1:12:57Like it's, there's like virtually no transactions like,
- 1:13:01and, and it's so tight. Like if that turns, then you'll
- 1:13:05see then, then, then what would he do in that response, right?
- 1:13:08It's like when the asteroid comes down and the dinosaur
- 1:13:10turns to the other and he says quick print money, right?
- 1:13:13Like, I think that's, it's, it's more that's the reason they're
- 1:13:16not doing it yet because they worry that they might do it
- 1:13:19later, right? And I think that's, but again, I
- 1:13:22don't think there's like 0 likelihood of higher rates
- 1:13:25anytime soon. So you're right, Brian, when
- 1:13:27that the liquidity is going to come back at some point, I think
- 1:13:32they're trying really hard not to, you know, jam inflation,
- 1:13:35right? Because also tariffs are going
- 1:13:36to be inflationary. I think the trade deficit
- 1:13:38numbers came out and it's like, oh wow, our trade imbalance
- 1:13:40declined a lot. Well, yeah, that's because
- 1:13:41people stop shipping us stuff over the last couple months
- 1:13:43because they're worried about tariffs, right?
- 1:13:45So tariffs are inflationary by design by definition, right?
- 1:13:48Like goods will become more expensive.
- 1:13:50You know, it's not structural so much as it is trade.
- 1:13:53But like they, they're really, I mean, inflation is like the, you
- 1:13:57know, it's like the, it's like the devil to a central bank and,
- 1:14:00and to a country and a people. It's a terrible, terrible thing
- 1:14:02that hurts everybody and hurts the poorest people the most.
- 1:14:04And they can't, they really are afraid.
- 1:14:06And I think otherwise, you know, they're just kind of like battle
- 1:14:10scarred or like a, they have PTSD from the inflation that
- 1:14:13happened under COVID that they're just being super
- 1:14:15cautious. But they will open the printer
- 1:14:17soon I think at some point. Yeah, that the juxtaposition.
- 1:14:21I know we got to wrap up here in a few minutes.
- 1:14:23I thought it was an interesting juxtaposition about Trump and
- 1:14:27Senator Warren agreeing on scrapping the the debt ceiling
- 1:14:32or the debt limit. Meanwhile, we have Trump, they
- 1:14:35both said. Wow, we both agree.
- 1:14:38It's, yeah, it's remarkable, right?
- 1:14:40So then you have that. And then on the flip side, you
- 1:14:42have the Trump family is Uber bullish on Bitcoin.
- 1:14:46They're attending the conferences.
- 1:14:47They're involved in mining the was like last Week 2 1/2
- 1:14:51trillion they were looking to raise through equity and debt
- 1:14:54financing to. The Treasury strategy, yeah.
- 1:14:57The S1 as well for a ETF product too.
- 1:15:01So I think it's just interesting to watch how that plays out
- 1:15:04where you have Trump. I mean, they did a lot of
- 1:15:06deficit spending in the first term as well. 45 out of the last
- 1:15:1050 years the US has run a deficit.
- 1:15:11So it's a. Populist.
- 1:15:12I mean, they're populist. That's, that's, I mean, you
- 1:15:14don't get elected telling people you're going to give them less
- 1:15:16and tax them more. And that's the problem.
- 1:15:18I mean, that's, that's the issue.
- 1:15:21So we're going to give people more and tax them less, which is
- 1:15:24bam, there's the problem. That's the debt.
- 1:15:26Maybe Elon will come back and be become an advocate for Bitcoin
- 1:15:30since he's a little upset that he doesn't get his tax credits
- 1:15:32in this new bill. Close.
- 1:15:34I don't know why he hasn't like revisited his 2021 love of the,
- 1:15:39of the Bitcoin because like he's so close.
- 1:15:42Like his stuff about the debt dude, like hello.
- 1:15:44Like that's what we've all been saying for years.
- 1:15:47You know, I don't know, Maybe in like 20 years he'll fly back
- 1:15:49down from Mars and grace us plebs with his presence.
- 1:15:52And, and you know, he'll, we'll be able to leave this debt
- 1:15:56collapsing nation and hop on the Starship with him and live
- 1:15:59gloriously in the stars forever. That's my hope.
- 1:16:03Well, yeah. Before we let you go, is there
- 1:16:05anything Alex you wanted to touch on with Galaxy now trading
- 1:16:09on NASDAQ? I'm not sure if you wanted to
- 1:16:10discuss anything there or better.
- 1:16:12Well, we're just. We're we're super happy.
- 1:16:14It's been a long road. Galaxy has been publicly traded
- 1:16:16since it launched in 2018. But in Canada, the unit we know
- 1:16:19we love our Canadian friends, but the United States, as I said
- 1:16:22earlier on this pod is the premier capital market in the
- 1:16:24world. We're just really proud to tell
- 1:16:28our story. I mean, we're about to be, we,
- 1:16:30we think we're going to be one of the biggest data center
- 1:16:32providers in the world. And so you got a data center
- 1:16:36business with a giant crypto capital markets business on top.
- 1:16:40And I think we're a leader in both.
- 1:16:42So we're, we, we think it's a very interesting company.
- 1:16:45I mean, we, I've been at Galaxy for 4 1/2 years at this point
- 1:16:48and this was a huge milestone for us and our, our employees
- 1:16:52and our investors. So we're just happy to be here.
- 1:16:54But you know, the, the game is the game doesn't stop like the,
- 1:16:57the show must go on. We have a lot of exciting things
- 1:17:00that we're excited to do and announce over the coming, you
- 1:17:02know, months and and years. Congratulations Alex.
- 1:17:06Thank you for your generosity with the time.
- 1:17:08It was a fun conversation as well.
- 1:17:10For those who are not following you, where do you want to point
- 1:17:12them to? Do you want Twitter research?
- 1:17:15Follow me at Intangible Coins on Twitter GLXY Research on
- 1:17:19twittergalaxy.com/research You can read all our reports there
- 1:17:22and get your. Daily dose of memes.
- 1:17:25Yes, and see my memes please. Please like my memes guys.
- 1:17:29Thanks, Alex. Thanks.
- 1:17:30For. Having me.
- 1:17:32Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:17:34If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:17:36episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:17:39app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:17:41today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:17:44Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:17:46for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 1:17:49nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:17:52Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:17:55to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com Contact
- 1:17:58to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:18:01advisors.