Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / The Great Ziegfeld (1936)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you to your
- 0:17best picture nominee from 1927 to today. I'm
- 0:20Kyle. I'm Ryan. How do you feel about Broadway
- 0:25producers? Broadway producers, boy. You know,
- 0:28everything I know about them, I know from the
- 0:31pictures. Go ahead. The Broadway melody. Which
- 0:34one? Both. You know? There's actually more than
- 0:39two. Both that I've seen. And what's the other
- 0:41one? 42nd Street? We've got... Those are the
- 0:44two. He was in old airs. Raoul Walsh. Yeah. Is
- 0:49that his name? Yeah, yeah, yeah. The man. The
- 0:51actor. That's the director. The man? The guy
- 0:54who plays... Yeah. Warren Baxter. That's his
- 0:58name. Warner Baxter. Raoul Walsh was who was
- 1:00supposed to play him. Correct. And then he got
- 1:02attacked by the rabbit and lost his eye and couldn't
- 1:05do it. warner baxter all this sounds made up
- 1:08i know it's true and i know what you're saying
- 1:10i just need you to know it is true that if someone's
- 1:12listening to this they're like he's having a
- 1:14stroke you know the man who was attacked by a
- 1:16rabbit in the eye yeah guys if you thought those
- 1:19are some cool facts be sure to listen to our
- 1:21previous episodes because it's full of stuff
- 1:23like that uh how do you feel about broadway producers
- 1:26i'm pro oh yeah cool Glad to hear it. No, I'm
- 1:31pro of what I know. I think that of the 1930s,
- 1:35they loved to make a movie about a Hollywood
- 1:37producer. Sorry, a Broadway producer. Yeah. And
- 1:40we have seen it in spades. What we haven't seen
- 1:43is the glorification of that Hollywood producer.
- 1:47Dang, I did it again. Broadway producer. And
- 1:49we have not seen a great man story of a Broadway
- 1:53producer. There you are with the great man again.
- 1:55Until today. Until today. Well, until 1936. Yeah.
- 2:00You know, today. Today we're covering the great
- 2:03Ziegfeld. Now, a lot of people know who this
- 2:06is based off just the name alone. You know, I
- 2:09was telling my dad that I was watching this movie
- 2:11and he was like, oh yeah, the Ziegfeld Follies.
- 2:13And just from the get -go, he was like, oh yeah,
- 2:15I know what that is. Wow. So he just could pull
- 2:17that out. I was like, oh, what do you know about
- 2:18him? He's like, not much. Just that. Like, I
- 2:20just know that's basically all I can tell you.
- 2:22And he knew what it kind of resulted in and what
- 2:25he's known for. And we'll get there. But this
- 2:28movie tries to provide some context around who
- 2:32the individual was. And the thing that I think
- 2:34is interesting is we do see kind of like, you
- 2:36know, it's his life. It's a biopic. But it really
- 2:38does start at the 30, 40 year mark. Like, it's
- 2:42not him as a child. Right. We're not doing the
- 2:44Marty Supreme. Yes. And you mentioned like David
- 2:47Copperfield and some other movies that when we
- 2:50last talked about the story of Louis Pasteur,
- 2:52you mentioned some movies that kind of show him
- 2:55from the beginning, like them as a child. Yeah.
- 2:57You mentioned the one that starts with his grandmother,
- 3:00like his aunt. Aerosmith. Aerosmith. Yeah. So
- 3:03we see them like growing up. And in this point,
- 3:05it really is just like we see him as a barker
- 3:07and we get up there. Yeah. So this really is
- 3:10like a biopic in that sense. And it's also. This
- 3:13was cool to see, a return of our Thin Man cast.
- 3:17That was the most exciting thing about this to
- 3:20me. I didn't anticipate it. I was like, William
- 3:22Powell, cool. And I was like, Myrna Loy. Yeah,
- 3:24yeah. So some interesting things to talk about,
- 3:27but it's not all sunshine and rainbows. We'll
- 3:30go and get to that when we do. But let's talk
- 3:33about the nominations first. Great Ziegfeld was
- 3:36nominated seven times at the Academy Awards.
- 3:39And in this, it was nominated for Dance Direction
- 3:42for Seymour Felix, A Pretty Girl is Like a Melody.
- 3:46We'll talk about that. Writing Original Story
- 3:49was William Anthony Maguire. Film Editing for
- 3:52William S. Gray. Art Direction for Cedric Gibbons,
- 3:56Eddie Imazu, and Edwin B. Willis. And director
- 3:59Robert Z. Leonard, this was the nomination for
- 4:03Best Director. It was directed by him, but just
- 4:06clarifying. Best Actress in a Leading Role was
- 4:09Louise Rayner as Anna Held. And Outstanding Production
- 4:13was on behalf of Metro -Goldwyn -Mayer, MGM.
- 4:17Yeah. So you mentioned this was directed by Robert
- 4:20Z. Leonard. It also stars the return of the Thin
- 4:24Man cast with William Powell and Myrna Loy. William
- 4:26Powell, of course, plays our titular Flo Ziegfeld
- 4:31Jr. Ziegfeld Jr. It's going to drive me nuts.
- 4:34I'll do my best. Myrna Loy, small role actually
- 4:38here as Billy Burke, his eventual wife. Louise
- 4:41Rainier plays Anna Held, the French star, I guess,
- 4:47that becomes his first Ziegfeld girl. Ziegfeld
- 4:50girl flipping a table right now. Frank Morgan
- 4:53as rival Billings and then other Ziegfeld girls.
- 4:59Fanny Bryce as Fanny Bryce and Virginia Bruce
- 5:01as Audrey Dane. A lot of people playing themselves
- 5:04in this. Yeah. And by a lot, I guess I have two
- 5:07examples, but that's just more than I would have
- 5:09expected. So you have, you have, like you mentioned,
- 5:15Fanny Bryce reprising her role as herself. Roy
- 5:18Bolger. You see him in this. I believe he's playing
- 5:21Roy Bulger as well. Yeah. Is it Bulger? Bulger?
- 5:24I think it's Bulger. Bulger? Yeah, I believe
- 5:26so. Wizard of Oz fame, no? Now, so there's a
- 5:31couple things in this, actually, that tie to
- 5:32the Wizard of Oz. One of them is going to be
- 5:34that you mentioned Frank Morgan as Billings.
- 5:36Oh, yes. He's the Wizard of Oz. Welcome back.
- 5:39Roy Bulger, you mentioned that he is in the movie.
- 5:43He also plays the Scarecrow in Wizard of Oz as
- 5:47well as, you know, in the beginning. Farmhand?
- 5:49Is that? Yeah. He's related to, I don't know
- 5:53if he's an uncle. I've never understood the relationship
- 5:54with the three men on the farm. We'll see. There's
- 5:57a couple of other things that tie it to that.
- 6:00But the cast alone, like to see those two reunited.
- 6:04I think there actually might be a third person.
- 6:05I don't know if they like auditioned and they
- 6:07didn't get it. You know what I love? The Wizard
- 6:11of Oz is like this tether point for so much of
- 6:15the podcast where we're like, here's a connective
- 6:17piece. And I don't know how many movies, like,
- 6:21we'll be able to say, like, oh, here's a connection
- 6:24to this. Like, use that movie in that same way.
- 6:27I think that there will be some connections that
- 6:30we can make, but Wizard of Oz is just such a
- 6:32milestone for a number of reasons. And I think
- 6:35we'll, like, when we get to Gone with the Wind,
- 6:37same year, when we get to Casablanca, when we
- 6:40get to, like, larger movies of that perspective
- 6:43year, I think we'll be able to make some kind
- 6:46of, like, tether points. But for the most part,
- 6:49you're right. It's like a milestone of a landmark
- 6:51achievement, which Wizard of Oz is not the only
- 6:54one. But in the 1930s, it's one of the biggest.
- 6:58Yeah, yeah. If not the biggest. It's just always,
- 7:00it brings along a bigger question, I think, of
- 7:03what movie do you think of first and foremost
- 7:07for the Academy Awards? Oh, interesting. And
- 7:11we don't have to talk about it right now. That's
- 7:13a great question. That's a huge thing. But it
- 7:14is like at the forefront of my mind just because
- 7:17we're constantly like, here's a connection to
- 7:19the Wizard of Oz. That's true. I'll go ahead
- 7:22and set up a great Ziegfeld, a good bit here.
- 7:24Hit me with it. Just a... Tiny, not a good bit,
- 7:27just a little bit. The story of Florence Ziegfeld
- 7:31and his start, specifically from a carnival barker
- 7:36all the way up to the legendary Broadway producer
- 7:38that he is. And seeing the trials and tribulations
- 7:42that he gets into, both in and off the stage,
- 7:44and how that can affect the Broadway world at
- 7:48large. That is the general synopsis of The Great
- 7:52Ziegfeld. Kyle. How did you feel about this movie?
- 7:56This is a long movie. This movie is three hours
- 7:59and eight minutes. Is that right? Might be five.
- 8:02It's not far off. Three hours and five minutes.
- 8:05I was going to say, did it feel like five hours?
- 8:08Oh, five hours, yeah. Yeah, it's long. I think
- 8:13this is the longest movie we've watched for the
- 8:15show yet. It is, yeah. Okay, it is. The only
- 8:17one that I was questioning was Wings. Wings is
- 8:20actually very long as well, but I think this
- 8:22beats it. This does beat it because it did require
- 8:24an intermission. Oh, boy. And just like Midsummer
- 8:29Night's Dream, it did have that interlude at
- 8:31the beginning. Yeah. That is the biggest thing
- 8:36weighing this movie down, I think, is its runtime.
- 8:38It is so long, and I don't... think that we've
- 8:43reached kind of the quality of storytelling yet
- 8:48to really warrant that runtime you know i think
- 8:52there are certain genres of movie that serve
- 8:55that runtime better and and a biopic is just
- 8:58not it for me now do you mean at the time or
- 9:01in general at the time yeah at the time i agree
- 9:04with at the time um i think offenheimer is still
- 9:07the movie that i like will you know, site as
- 9:09look what you did. You mad scientist. Like you
- 9:12made a three hour biopic about a scientist and
- 9:16it's one of the better movies of that decade
- 9:19or like, you know, the year, like at least. So
- 9:21it's possible. But at the time you're absolutely
- 9:23right. Like this was, this just was unheard of.
- 9:26Yeah. And it just, it went on forever. And it.
- 9:29I struggled a bit with this one. I won't lie.
- 9:32And you see it with epics, right? Like with epics,
- 9:34it feels like it earns that runtime. Right. But
- 9:36with this, it's more of an epic of a personality
- 9:39and not an epic of like events. Yeah. And I think
- 9:42a lot of that, like you've got to really enjoy
- 9:45the character. You do. I'll be honest, as excited
- 9:50as I was to see the return of William Powell,
- 9:52who we both love in The Thin Man. Yep. Another
- 9:55Thin Man. nominated this year as well, and I
- 9:58will absolutely be watching it. Not for Best
- 10:00Picture, but it was nominated. Absolutely going
- 10:02to be watching it. Myrna Loy, like, I was excited.
- 10:05I think that William Powell is the least interesting
- 10:09character in this movie, and I think one of the
- 10:12dullest performances in this movie. Interesting.
- 10:15So this is why I say this is going to be an interesting
- 10:17episode. I dug this. I had a good time with this.
- 10:21It's not the best movie of the year, but I had
- 10:24a good time with it for... well the face that
- 10:27kyle made so it's not the best movie of the year
- 10:30by a long shot based on who you ask and i don't
- 10:34think it's the best use of william powell but
- 10:36where i draw some differences from your opinion
- 10:39is that to me it's still william powell so i
- 10:42was invested sure right like he's he's still
- 10:45giving off william powell um another person who
- 10:47is also showing up here in a you really don't
- 10:50act do you this is just more who you are award
- 10:53That's another great title, is Frank Morgan as
- 10:56Billings. Frank Morgan, and this isn't a criticism.
- 10:58This is just more like he has found, like Edward
- 11:01Everett Horton in the Ginger Rogers and Fred
- 11:04Astaire musicals, or movies, he really has found
- 11:08what works, and he is just doing that character.
- 11:11And that's what Frank Morgan is doing here, is
- 11:13he is continuing that same character of the bumbling
- 11:17guy that's also kind of the foil, but only by
- 11:20his own naivety. He is a rival producer alongside
- 11:24Ziegfeld. Yeah, yeah. So I think to me, I have
- 11:30found the charm in these characters finding themselves.
- 11:33Sure. And there is one sequence in this film
- 11:37that I think you can hold the great Ziegfeld
- 11:40up to and say, well, this is why. This is why
- 11:43this movie was made. This is why this movie is
- 11:46remembered the way that it is. But can you say
- 11:48that about everything else? And as a fan of the
- 11:50movie, I don't think you can. I think there is
- 11:53one sequence that holds this movie together,
- 11:55and it is over before the first, well, only intermission.
- 11:59Yeah. Well, that's the interesting thing about
- 12:01this, too, is this is kind of a pseudo -musical.
- 12:06Pseudo, yes. Yeah. Like, everything I've criticized,
- 12:09the Broadway melody, not of 1936, because that
- 12:12is just a musical. Yeah. But the Broadway melody,
- 12:15or Flirtation Walk. Like, the things I criticized
- 12:18about that, where I was like, are you even a
- 12:20musical? are prevalent here but to me it is not
- 12:24a musical it is a film that features music in
- 12:26it yes so you saw on the nominations that there
- 12:30is a dance direction nomination and as a spoiler
- 12:33alert win as well here and it is i mean i don't
- 12:37know i know your rating of this and i know you
- 12:39weren't a fan we got to go ahead and just say
- 12:42we won't talk about it right now but we got to
- 12:43say that that is well learned it is uh it's not
- 12:47my favorite sequence for a musical though in
- 12:51this movie or in general in general in this year
- 12:53well we've only seen two movies so far this year
- 12:55but and one of them was not a music and i think
- 12:57it's okay like that is a -okay for this not to
- 13:00be like your favorite like musical sequence sure
- 13:02in any movie ever yeah i just i just i don't
- 13:05know if i like it did win for the dance direction
- 13:08here and i don't know if it deserved that I think
- 13:11it's a cool sequence. I mean, we'll talk about
- 13:14this right now to get it out of the way. The
- 13:16whole point here is one of the musicals that
- 13:19Ziegfeld is producing has the song A Pretty Girl
- 13:24is Like a Melody. And the setup for this dance
- 13:27is you're looking at a stage production of this
- 13:30Broadway play. It is actually happening on a
- 13:33stage. Yes. And they built this kind of lazy
- 13:36Susan contraption that rotates very slowly. And
- 13:40it almost looks like a tiered wedding cake behind
- 13:43a curtain. And when the first curtain comes up,
- 13:47you're looking at the lowest level of this three
- 13:49-tiered wedding cake or whatever. Everything
- 13:52else is covered by another curtain. And as the
- 13:56camera is kind of set just... at an angle so
- 13:59you see thing as this platform rotates you see
- 14:03scenes coming towards the camera and then making
- 14:06their way out of frame well layer is a big part
- 14:08of this right so the layering of it makes it
- 14:11to where it's not your eyes aren't on the curtains
- 14:13thinking what's behind that right it's more what's
- 14:16happening on the outside so you're just admiring
- 14:18it for what it is right and the curtains are
- 14:20when they're lifted that is an additional piece
- 14:23that you weren't expecting yeah so the camera
- 14:26is Kind of stationary at the beginning of this
- 14:28as the stage rotates. And there's not a lot of
- 14:31dancing or anything going on on this bottom tier.
- 14:34There's not. That's true. It's a lot of different
- 14:35scenes showcasing costumes and things and little
- 14:39set designs. Pagliacci is actually like kind
- 14:42of referenced and present in one portion of the
- 14:45bottom section. Yeah. And then as the song goes
- 14:50on. The camera starts to move up a little bit
- 14:52as the next curtain and the next layer of this
- 14:55tiered wedding cake set moves upwards. So that's
- 15:00when you get a little more dancing and stairs
- 15:01are revealed to lead up to that second tier.
- 15:04And as you're going up the stairs towards the
- 15:06second tier, you have dancers come down in these
- 15:08cool kind of like bat bird costume things. And
- 15:13it's fun. It's a really unique use of this spinning
- 15:17stage design. But the dancing itself is kind
- 15:21of mediocre. There's not a whole lot going on
- 15:25here. I take Umbrins with the word dance. I think
- 15:29direction, like a musical direction, 100%. Yeah.
- 15:32Because the way that the camera follows up the
- 15:35stairs, because you're right that the camera
- 15:36is just kind of like stationary and then watching
- 15:38this spin. But as it comes to a second section,
- 15:41and this is, you know, it appears to be one take.
- 15:43It was filmed in two. They just spliced it in
- 15:45an area where they could. easily reference another
- 15:48cut if they needed to but pretty much when the
- 15:51curtain opens up on the second portion of the
- 15:54cake if we're calling it that of the stage that's
- 15:57when the camera cuts and then from then on it
- 15:59is another one take and instead of being stationary
- 16:03it starts following up the stairs so as it's
- 16:06turning it's not just staying stationary it's
- 16:09looking up to kind of capture how high up the
- 16:12or everything that's happening on the stairs.
- 16:14Yeah. And it's moving up the stairs with the
- 16:17cake. And I agree with you, the dancing is fine.
- 16:21I don't think there's anything incredible about
- 16:22the dancing itself, but it is the choreographing,
- 16:25choreography, that's the word, the choreography
- 16:28of that set design. So I think set design alone
- 16:31in that sequence. beautiful set design is great
- 16:34and it blew my mind this is i think the biggest
- 16:37when i when i say biggest i mean tallest but
- 16:39like the biggest production we have seen of like
- 16:42a musical end of sentence like that we have seen
- 16:44up until this point uh later on we'll see but
- 16:48and it's great because you know it doesn't feel
- 16:50like a rehash of what we've seen previously.
- 16:54It doesn't feel like, oh, we saw Busby Berkeley
- 16:55once and now we're doing Busby Berkeley. I criticize
- 16:57that with Flirtation Walk. It feels inspired
- 17:01by things, but it's not ripping anything off.
- 17:03It's like, well, this is what we're going to
- 17:05do in this. Now, again, this is based off a real
- 17:08person. This is based off of a real, like, multiple
- 17:11real productions that he put on. So this is a
- 17:13thing that they did, or at least it's a dramatization
- 17:16of something they did. But this sequence felt
- 17:20so out of place. But in a good way of like, oh,
- 17:23well, this is like leading up to the greatness
- 17:25of this man. Greatness of what he did. Right.
- 17:28And that... to me, when it follows all the way
- 17:31up and then you see what's at the top of the
- 17:33cake and then it pans out to show you the entire
- 17:35thing, is still in place. These were not separate
- 17:38sets that were filmed separately. The camera
- 17:41cut at one point, sure, but this is still one
- 17:44big set where everyone is in place. And when
- 17:46the curtain falls back down and everything closes
- 17:48the way that it opened, but in reverse, and then
- 17:51it just ends with the curtain closing and then
- 17:53cutting to intermission, I was just like... Let's
- 17:55go. Like, I'm so on board. And I loved that sequence
- 17:59so much that even though dance is in the name
- 18:02of dance direction, and you're right, the dance
- 18:04wasn't very, the dancing wasn't very inspired,
- 18:08intricate or anything. Although it requires a
- 18:11lot of like choreography of like, well, I'm going
- 18:13to go up these stairs backwards without looking.
- 18:15It almost requires more choreography for the
- 18:18crew. In the back. Correct. Hey, make sure we're
- 18:21marching in time to rotate the cake at the right
- 18:23speed and all of that. That's right. But I do
- 18:26want to say that it is the dancers too, because
- 18:28the bat creatures that you're talking about,
- 18:31at one point they have to go backwards up the
- 18:34stairs. That is rotating. So they can't be like,
- 18:37okay, well, I have to look at this and then start
- 18:38walking backwards. It requires some like, you
- 18:40know, it's difficult. I'm not saying they're
- 18:43skillless. Right. Yeah. But I will agree with
- 18:45you that the dance portion. is not what I focused
- 18:49on here. It is the set design, it is the way
- 18:51that the camera moves, and that whole sequence
- 18:54deserved the nomination. Now, is that fair to
- 18:58say it's the best dance direction when instead
- 19:01what I love about it is kind of everything but
- 19:03the dance? That is a good question to ask. Yeah,
- 19:06yeah, and I don't know. I was almost, while I
- 19:09was watching this whole sequence, I was like,
- 19:11I kind of wish I was sitting in the audience
- 19:14for this one. I don't really like what they've,
- 19:17Chosen to do with the camera. Interesting. Yeah.
- 19:20Oh, no. For me, I enjoyed seeing like the tight
- 19:23close up of that and then revealing the whole
- 19:26thing afterwards. Yeah. I don't know. It's almost
- 19:29like if you go to watch a parade, like I'd rather
- 19:32be at the Macy's Day Parade than watch it on
- 19:36TV because there are so many moments where I'm
- 19:38like, well, I don't want to be looking at what
- 19:39you're making me look at. I want to look at the
- 19:42intricacies of this set and all of the different
- 19:45things going on at once. interesting that's a
- 19:48personal thing i know for sure but for me i i
- 19:51would disagree because what's happening at the
- 19:53bottom tier is not they're basically just standing
- 19:56still yeah like they're not like dancing or moving
- 19:59in unison with what's going on which is a criticism
- 20:01of the the dance as well sure so then when everything
- 20:05pans out and everyone's like moving a bit more
- 20:07or like being covered again like To me, I think
- 20:11it works best when the camera is there for that
- 20:13purpose. Now, if it's a criticism of the dance
- 20:16or the choreography or lack thereof that everyone
- 20:19on stage is not moving the same way or doing
- 20:21something at the time to where the camera can't
- 20:23expose it, sure, that's a criticism. But still,
- 20:27I thought this was just... This was, I don't
- 20:30want to keep using breathtaking, but this was
- 20:32really inspired. And I thought this was great.
- 20:34And then it cut to intermission and I was able
- 20:36to take a break and just come back to it. Yeah.
- 20:39So, I mean, if there's anything to see this movie
- 20:41for, I think it's this. I think it's a Pretty
- 20:44Girls, like a melody sequence. And Seymour Felix,
- 20:48in my eyes, deserves this. but also with the
- 20:51criticism that there isn't much dance to it.
- 20:53And also when you say dance in a era of like
- 20:57Rogers and Astaire existing. Sure. You got to
- 21:01compete with that. And they were very lucky to
- 21:03not have to this year. So good job on that. Well.
- 21:06In terms of. Best picture, at least. Oh, in terms
- 21:10of best picture. Because Swing Time. Swing Time
- 21:11came out this year and was nominated. That's
- 21:13the tough thing is like now you have to start
- 21:15asking questions. And I think this is what you're
- 21:17leading to is, is it better when it's just two
- 21:20individuals, maybe even a little bit more, but
- 21:23two individuals who are dancing the way they
- 21:24are dancing? Or is it the scale and scope of
- 21:27something like this set piece that they built?
- 21:29I think either way, it's got to be about the
- 21:32dancing and not the set piece. Yeah. I think
- 21:33you're starting to bleed into production design,
- 21:36set design. with this particular instance here.
- 21:39So that's just my own personal criticism. But
- 21:42do you think at the time they were like, because
- 21:44production design wasn't an award, do you think
- 21:46when they see dance direction and they look at
- 21:48that whole dance sequence, do you think that
- 21:50they're taking into consideration the production?
- 21:52Yeah. I mean, I, I totally understand why it
- 21:54was nominated. And even though there wasn't a
- 21:56production design there, there is a set design
- 21:58or a set decoration, which it was also nominated
- 22:01for. Yeah. Was it? Yeah. Art direction. Oh, yeah,
- 22:04yeah, with Cedric Gibbons and all of that. Yeah,
- 22:06so like I understand that. And the interesting
- 22:09thing there is it didn't win for the art direction.
- 22:11Yeah, but it did win for the dance. So if you
- 22:13have those two categories, it's like, hey, your
- 22:15art on this stage looks great and the dance isn't
- 22:18great. So I think you guys got it wrong on this
- 22:20one personally. But I agree. I think that this
- 22:24is like the standout because it is doing something
- 22:26unique and interesting and something you haven't
- 22:28seen yet before. With it being something that
- 22:31I wasn't completely blown away by. That doesn't
- 22:34bode well for the rest of the movie, which I
- 22:37think we can talk about now. Yeah. So it's interesting
- 22:40because I see everything you're saying. Like,
- 22:42it's not like, man, what do you, I kind of feel
- 22:44that way about the pretty girls, like a melody
- 22:46where I'm like, ah, man, I just, I hear what
- 22:48you're saying, but I disagree. Everything else
- 22:50that you've told me, or at least I've kind of
- 22:52like signified about how you feel about this
- 22:55movie, I get. Like it's not, oh, dude, you got
- 22:58to admit this is pretty cool. It really is a
- 23:01biopic of one man and his many mistakes that
- 23:05he makes and how he still kind of like stumbled
- 23:08into greatness every once in a while. Yeah. And
- 23:11honestly, I think it's the William Powell of
- 23:12it all. I think I like William Powell so much
- 23:15that I was willing to follow him in this character
- 23:17because he is charming to a fault and he is adventurous
- 23:23to a fault and he believes in himself. But not
- 23:27for a good reason. It's just more like, yeah,
- 23:30I'll just keep gambling this and one time it'll
- 23:31work. And if I land on my face, so be it. I'll
- 23:36figure it out. We'll make it work. And I don't
- 23:38think we've seen someone fail so many times in
- 23:40a movie up until this point. Not unless you want
- 23:43to talk about Marty Supreme. Oh, that's true.
- 23:45Well, let's say up until 1936. We have not seen
- 23:49someone fail as many times as... flow as you
- 23:53called him uh ziegfeld does in this yeah and
- 23:57that is it it's an interesting story i with marty
- 24:00supreme i struggled following him because i'm
- 24:02like this guy isn't great william powell as ziegfeld
- 24:06here he's not great either a lot of the things
- 24:09he does are kind of at the expense of others
- 24:12he's kind of a playboy throughout this and he'll
- 24:16kind of use his ziegfeld girls just for stardom
- 24:23in a way you know to to promote and benefit his
- 24:27own personal gains and he's kind of a bad businessman
- 24:31where he's just making decisions and taking these
- 24:34gambles that don't pay off and it's like it really
- 24:37worked out for this guy and he definitely left
- 24:39his mark on history but at what cost yeah maybe
- 24:44that's the biggest criticism of the movie is
- 24:47that it just it it feels like he finds himself
- 24:50in these wins but he drives himself towards failures
- 24:53and he just happens to win sometimes and he thinks
- 24:57that that's a characteristic of his like personality
- 25:01Yeah. Like I just win sometimes. Before we get
- 25:03too far from it, I do want to point out that
- 25:05the Pretty Girl is like a melody sequence that
- 25:08we talked about. Some details around it. So we
- 25:11mentioned it's two longer takes, right? As the
- 25:13second curtain lifts up around the middle, that's
- 25:15when it kind of cuts and can be seen, but still
- 25:18impressive. Two weeks of filming and rehearsals,
- 25:21if you count that. 180 performers. It cost $220
- 25:25,000 to make, and it was 4 ,300 yards of silk
- 25:29that were used for the curtain itself. So I think
- 25:32when you do the conversion of $220 ,000 to today,
- 25:37like just, my God. So this is obviously a very
- 25:40expensive movie to make. Yeah. Makes it back,
- 25:42no problem. I mean, this is we're far and away
- 25:45from what we talked about previously with like
- 25:47Broadway melody of like what musicals can do.
- 25:49And then Busby Berkeley, like clearly now Hollywood
- 25:52is paying attention of what they can do with
- 25:54like musical sequences and everything. And they're
- 25:56willing to foot the bill. Yeah. Depending on
- 25:58the stardom behind it. And I mean, again, like
- 26:00you pointed out, this is a three hour plus William
- 26:03Powell biopic. So you have to have some like
- 26:06faith in your cast and in your director to know
- 26:10that this is going to land. Yeah. Do you think
- 26:12the music element of this is what the studio
- 26:16was like, oh, we have faith in this because it's
- 26:18a musical? Well, I think it's everything. Outside
- 26:20of an action adventure, I think it's just about
- 26:22everything. So you can say it's a drama. You
- 26:24can say it's a comedy. You can say it's a musical.
- 26:27You can say it's dance. You can kind of throw
- 26:30everything in there. And because they know that
- 26:32everyone likes Ziegfeld Follies so much, they're
- 26:35going to continue to come back for the movie
- 26:37about it. So I think it's a pretty sure thing.
- 26:40Yeah. I just kind of feel like... I actually
- 26:43feel the same way about my double feature. Oh,
- 26:45do you? I think that... will make sense later.
- 26:47I think the music is really the selling point
- 26:49here. And I think that the cast could, while
- 26:51it is a huge selling point, I do feel like the
- 26:55music is the element during the thirties. That's
- 26:59really like, Hey, come see this spectacle. You
- 27:02know, if you were to just have a three hour movie
- 27:04telling the story of a man's life, I don't know
- 27:07that it hits as hard. It does kind of require.
- 27:09And, and really we've already said like a pretty
- 27:12girl is like a melody. If there's a reason to
- 27:14watch this movie, this is it. So it almost enforces
- 27:17that a little bit. Yeah, I think there might
- 27:18be one or two other moments that I would say
- 27:20are worth watching it to, but you just can't
- 27:22compare them. Yeah, yeah. So to touch on the
- 27:25plot a little bit here, we've said like Ziegfeld
- 27:28himself, he's kind of a bad businessman. He does
- 27:31these risky gambles and things. And to me, his
- 27:36character is not super likable because of these
- 27:39elements, but I can get behind a story like that.
- 27:43that type of character. William Powell worked
- 27:46much better for you than he did for me. But regardless,
- 27:49I'm okay with the idea of this story. And I like
- 27:52following this guy who's obviously a very prominent
- 27:54historical figure that I'm just not super familiar
- 27:57with. I actually, I was mowing the lawn the other
- 27:59day and listening to another film history podcast,
- 28:03You Must Remember This, which is great. She was
- 28:05talking about Rita Hayworth, who was a Ziegfeld
- 28:08girl. And I was like, oh. I know what that means
- 28:11now. Cool. Fantastic. You know who else appeared
- 28:15as a Ziegfeld girl in this? Pat Nixon. I don't
- 28:19know who that is. That is the first lady of the
- 28:22United States. That is Richard Nixon's wife.
- 28:25Wow. Pat Nixon appears in this film as a Ziegfeld
- 28:28girl, which I was just like, what is going on?
- 28:31That's cool. But you're right. There are a lot
- 28:33of people. It's like a Mickey Mouse Club of that
- 28:35time. Yeah. Where there are just people who appeared
- 28:38in this. And whether that be a way to get into
- 28:41Hollywood or, you know, there's a very real reason
- 28:45for this. And, you know, part of it is. And I
- 28:47want to get back to, you know, how he started.
- 28:49But part of this with the Ziegfeld girls is that
- 28:54at the time it was just models. At the time it
- 28:57was just, well, we got to find like the most
- 28:59attractive women and they have to be the ones
- 29:01in this. And it was Flo who said, no, no, there's
- 29:04people all around. There are women all around
- 29:06that want to be here. And we need to instead
- 29:08not market this for men, but market it for women.
- 29:11Yeah. And we need to market these shows of like
- 29:13the costume designers. This is another one where
- 29:16you mentioned in a previous episode, Adrian being
- 29:19the costume designer. Gowns by Adrian is still
- 29:23in big show lights at the beginning of this movie.
- 29:26Makes sense with MGM. Totally. Yeah. So I thought
- 29:29this was interesting too, because this instead,
- 29:32like they could have very easily played this
- 29:33as this man is just a love hungry. or sex hungry
- 29:39uh individual who was just trying to find women
- 29:41in every corner and they could have made the
- 29:43movie like that they obviously didn't because
- 29:45while it was true about the character of florence
- 29:48ziegfeld and that they could have put that in
- 29:52the movie obviously the code isn't going to allow
- 29:53them to show multiple affairs and everything.
- 29:55They definitely kind of like hint at it a couple
- 29:58of times because he finds himself with Anna Held
- 30:01and they do get married. And while he's with
- 30:03her, there's still some like flirtations. There's
- 30:06like a kiss that's given and some inappropriate
- 30:09things. But for the most part, he's kind of like
- 30:11affable and he's just like, whoa, this just happened
- 30:14to me. This is crazy. They try to touch on it.
- 30:16I think that they did a pretty good job of trying
- 30:19to like flip that and show, well, no, he is actually
- 30:22trying to make this more progressive. And he
- 30:24is trying to like, not just sexualize women,
- 30:27but instead put them in a position to where they
- 30:29can like, there's even a shot later on where
- 30:32when he starts like making musicals that he wants
- 30:35to make, you see women in the audience that are
- 30:38like, oh my God, look at her dress. How do you,
- 30:39where do you think she gets that? Oh, where did
- 30:41she get this dress? Counts by Adrian. There you
- 30:43go. So. That is more of the appeal and it's less
- 30:47like these show girls and it's more just like
- 30:49I am a Ziegfeld girl, which sounds negative.
- 30:52But the positive connotation behind that is you
- 30:55are now seen as more than just like a symbol
- 30:56of sex. You are like fashion. You are grace.
- 30:59Yeah. And you are like the every woman. Which
- 31:02I think is interesting because that's how it's
- 31:04showcased in the movie. Sure. But historically,
- 31:07like I think there's that that whole like. Is
- 31:10that how they were seen in real life? Yeah. Like.
- 31:12I really appreciate the amount that they show
- 31:16Ziegfeld like messing up, you know, or not being
- 31:20great. And he fails so many times. He does. And,
- 31:22you know, he marries Anna Held, who I want to
- 31:27talk about her because she's kind of the highlight
- 31:28of the movie for me as well. But, you know, he
- 31:31has like a minor affair. And in the movie, they
- 31:34show it as a very minor thing, an accidental
- 31:36thing almost, which surely this man, that's not.
- 31:40exactly how things happened with him so i appreciate
- 31:43the movie showing the like negative elements
- 31:47of this character anna anna held louise rainer
- 31:50right she is the one the actress that was nominated
- 31:53she did win the academy award here for best actress
- 31:56she almost feels like a side character a side
- 32:00plot in the grant like when you when you get
- 32:03to the end of the movie you're like oh she was
- 32:05just in this Briefly, really. I would kind of
- 32:09argue that the moment that he creates the Ziegfeld
- 32:12Follies is kind of like, where is Anna Held in
- 32:16all of this? Right. She kind of is kind of kept
- 32:21at arm's length throughout a good bit of the
- 32:23movie. When she first shows up and he's like,
- 32:25I'm going to make a star out of her. And he kind
- 32:27of does all of this weird publicity stunt type.
- 32:31stuff to to make her a star you're talking about
- 32:34the milk bath the milk bath story where he he
- 32:37creates this crazy story that crazy amounts of
- 32:41uh milk are delivered to her her house every
- 32:44day two gallons every day i think it's more than
- 32:47that i think it's like 25 gallons or something
- 32:49that she she bathes because can you bathe in
- 32:51two gallons of milk that's true yeah you're right
- 32:53you're right um but she's she takes a bath and
- 32:55milk every day that's 12 gallons even that feels
- 32:59low but every day 12 gallons every day that you're
- 33:02taking a bath in? You got to be laying like flat
- 33:05in the tub and just kind of sloshing around hoping
- 33:07it covers you. You got to remember what kind
- 33:10of bath she's in. I don't know. Maybe it's 24.
- 33:12I don't know. It's a lot of milk. It's a lot
- 33:15of milk. It's not Claudette Colbert signing the
- 33:18cross levels of milk, but it's a lot of milk.
- 33:21We're getting there. But yeah, he makes this
- 33:24whole thing. And I think when she's first introduced.
- 33:27She feels very much like a main character. And
- 33:29you're having scenes where it's her and Ziegfeld
- 33:33isn't even on screen. It is very much just here's
- 33:36her story and how she's coping with the false
- 33:40stories and the false narrative that Ziegfeld
- 33:42is creating to promote her. And also how she
- 33:46feels about Ziegfeld in general, you know, and
- 33:48the amount of time he spends with other women
- 33:51or the interest he shows in other women, whether
- 33:53it is. on a business level or a personal level.
- 33:58I think it's interesting how much time you spend
- 34:00with her only for her, as the movie progresses,
- 34:03to be kept at a distance. And the movie shifts
- 34:07to where you are following Ziegfeld once again,
- 34:09and she's just lingering from that point on.
- 34:13Yeah, I mean, for me, she is still a significant
- 34:15part of the movie and still has a heartbeat in
- 34:18it. I think that the problem with this movie
- 34:20is it's too long. Right. I think it's too long.
- 34:22And because it's too long, there's a significant
- 34:24portion without Anna Hilde. And that makes it
- 34:27seem like, well, where is she this whole time?
- 34:29Because she is the thing that you're most interested
- 34:31in, or the aspect of this movie you're most interested
- 34:33in. There's a sequence towards the end of this
- 34:35movie where Louise Rayner, as you mentioned,
- 34:38has earned or did win the Best Actress nomination
- 34:41here. For good reason. There's a sequence towards
- 34:45the end that's kind of just, like, believed as,
- 34:46like, well, this is the cinch. Like, this is
- 34:48just, she kind of nailed it. Or locked it in,
- 34:50at least. When she's on the phone. And we're
- 34:53jumping ahead all over the place here. Because
- 34:55how can you, you know. It's three hours. It's
- 34:57three hours plus. But there's a sequence where
- 35:01she's on the phone with Siegfeld. And she's talking
- 35:03with him. Is it Siegfeld? You'll have to remind
- 35:06me of the sequence. I don't even know. She's
- 35:08on the phone and she's like, I want to talk to
- 35:09him. And when she's talking to him, it's very
- 35:11clear that he is committed to this other person
- 35:14and he's not coming back because they have gotten
- 35:16a divorce. She has left and she is the one who
- 35:19left him. She's like, you know, I'm leaving.
- 35:21I'm kicking you out like you're done. Right.
- 35:23And she's hoping that this is a continuation
- 35:25of what they've done their entire life together,
- 35:27which is that she will say no. And as he's leaving,
- 35:30she'll be like, oh, actually, you want to come
- 35:32back. and she asks him to come back this happens
- 35:35multiple times in the movie where she even tells
- 35:37her like maid like hey you know let let him out
- 35:40grab his stuff actually give him his stuff back
- 35:42he's gonna stay here come in yeah and he will
- 35:44come back and he doesn't come back this time
- 35:46and there's a scene where she's on the phone
- 35:49and she's telling him how happy she is for him
- 35:51but she's crying and this is the scene that people
- 35:54will hold as like well that's This is like her
- 35:57locking it in. She's great beforehand. I'm not
- 35:59saying she's not, but that this is the scene
- 36:01where everyone's like, my God, the acting that
- 36:03you're doing in this is just breathtaking. So
- 36:05I agree. I think this sequence, I kind of heard
- 36:07like a phone scene and I was like, I don't know
- 36:10what that means. And then towards the end when
- 36:11that scene happened, I was like, oh yeah, no,
- 36:13she's absolutely destroying this. Yeah. And she
- 36:16looks so sad, but she's keeping up like the character
- 36:20and the voice and how supportive she is. And
- 36:23I thought she just absolutely earned this win
- 36:25with that scene alone. I agree. I think that's
- 36:28the bummer of the movie for me is you're introduced
- 36:31to her story and her story is very important.
- 36:34And the movie requires you to be invested in
- 36:38her story. And because her acting is so good
- 36:41and it is such an interesting stance to take,
- 36:44this woman who is kind of being strung along
- 36:47by this man, like that's the story I'm sitting
- 36:51here watching. And I'm like, OK, I like this.
- 36:53I want to know more. But then we shift over back
- 36:56to, of course, Ziegfeld, because he is who this
- 37:00movie ultimately is about. But I'm like, well,
- 37:02I don't care. I want to know more about Anna
- 37:04Held. And I think as the movie progresses and
- 37:06you get to that that scene with her where she
- 37:10is on the phone and she basically takes her exit
- 37:13from the movie. She's like, OK, well, I wish
- 37:15the best for you. I'm crying. I've lost you,
- 37:18but I'm done. Farewell. And now the rest of the
- 37:21movie is Ziegfeld and William Powell. And you're
- 37:24like, well, I don't know that I care as much
- 37:26about you as I do what was going on with Anna
- 37:28Held. And at that point, there are many more
- 37:32women introduced in Ziegfeld's life. And none
- 37:35of them are nearly as interesting as Anna Held
- 37:38and Louise Rayner playing her. You have Fanny
- 37:41Bryce who comes in, Virginia Bruce who plays
- 37:44Audrey Dane. And like one of them is an alcoholic,
- 37:47so he's got to... kind of navigate that with
- 37:49her. But all of that was so dull in comparison
- 37:53to what came prior that it was really kind of
- 37:56like, I'm not into it. I'm losing interest. I
- 38:00could see why you'd feel that way. For me, I
- 38:03didn't lose interest because I did like Myrna
- 38:04Loy as Billy Burke, even though she's not introduced
- 38:06until like two hours and 15 minutes. Yeah, I
- 38:09wrote it down. It's almost as bad as Bruce Wayne
- 38:12in The Dark Knight. Help me out here. Rises.
- 38:15Help me out here. Isn't he introduced to Billy
- 38:19Burke in the very beginning of the movie? They're
- 38:21like, this is like Mrs. Burke. Because doesn't
- 38:24Billings have Mrs. Burke with him? And he says
- 38:27something about like, oh, no, don't talk to her.
- 38:29It's fine. Leave her alone. And he just kind
- 38:31of walks off screen. Because he definitely mentions
- 38:34Miss Burke. If she is, I think it's only by name.
- 38:38Because I was camped out waiting for Myrna Loy
- 38:41to show up. So that confused me. But I mean,
- 38:44you are right. I looked it up. Yeah, two hours
- 38:45and 15 minutes is. correct of when Myrna Loy
- 38:48appears on screen as Billy Burke. Yeah. So she
- 38:51doesn't even have like an hour of screen time.
- 38:53No. She's got about 43 minutes of screen time.
- 38:56Well, true. I was going to say the run time,
- 38:58but yeah, I mean, she's not in every scene. Oh,
- 38:59yeah, yeah, yeah. Sure. But I will say that I
- 39:02did like her with Flo. I like the two of them
- 39:05together, which I mean, of course. It's William
- 39:07Powell and Myrna Loy. Yeah, they're going to
- 39:08absolutely chew the scene around them. Yeah.
- 39:11One thing I noticed too, I wanted to talk to
- 39:13you about this. There's a couple of movies now
- 39:14where I've noticed that Grant's Tomb, is mentioned
- 39:17all the time. And I think, did it just open?
- 39:20I don't know. I don't know the history of Grant's
- 39:22Tomb. Because this is mentioned in a movie in
- 39:24the future too, but this is the second William
- 39:26Powell Myrna Loy movie where Grant's Tomb is
- 39:28mentioned a good bit. Yeah. In The Thin Man,
- 39:31he sends her to Grant's Tomb instead of helping
- 39:34him investigate. Yeah. And then in this one,
- 39:36they're just talking about how Grant's Tomb is
- 39:38one of the most impressive things they've seen.
- 39:40And I was like, are you funding? Grant's tomb?
- 39:43Like, what are you doing? Why is this coming
- 39:45up so much? Secret lobbyists. But there's a scene
- 39:48of the two of them sitting and obviously they
- 39:50meet through Billings. You know what? I want
- 39:52to provide some context. We talk about the romance
- 39:55of this movie being like between Louise Rayner
- 39:58as Anna Held and Myrna Loy as Billy Burke. But
- 40:01the reason that both of these romances even happen
- 40:03in the first place is because the true romance
- 40:06in my eyes, yeah, I see you clocking this, is
- 40:10between Ziegfeld and Billings. Right. And even
- 40:13the opening of this movie is that they are both
- 40:15carnival barkers. And Billings is doing better
- 40:18than Ziegfeld in that moment. And Ziegfeld is
- 40:21trying to take whatever Billings has. Right.
- 40:23And he even sees like in his strong man. that
- 40:27he has, he realizes that no one's really impressed
- 40:29by how strong he is. They just kind of want to
- 40:31like ogle at his like, you know, muscles and
- 40:34that women are able to like, not able, but are
- 40:37more likely to be impressed by his muscles and
- 40:39like how they feel and look then by the strength
- 40:41of it. So the appearance matters more. So he
- 40:45leans into this and then begins like, you know,
- 40:47looking at whatever Billings is doing, gets all
- 40:49this money, spends it on something, gambles,
- 40:51loses. And then he goes back to Billings as the
- 40:54well. And tries to take from him. And he notices
- 40:57that Billings is interested in going to England.
- 41:00And he wants to find this new talent. Follows
- 41:03him there. Just kind of happens to be on the
- 41:04same cruise ship as him. Follows him to England.
- 41:07Sees that he's interested in this individual
- 41:08who ends up being Anna Held. He's interested.
- 41:11Wants to take that from her. He's able to charm
- 41:13her more than Billings is. And he can take everything
- 41:16from Billings. And Billings just has to secede.
- 41:20That this is... the better man. He is the more
- 41:23charming individual. He is the one who's willing
- 41:26to take these chances and he will lose, but he
- 41:28will get back on his feet as well. Even the end
- 41:31of this movie wants you to know that like the
- 41:33first person we see Ziegfeld with is the last
- 41:36person that we get to see Ziegfeld with, which
- 41:38is Billings. Right. And is not his wife, his
- 41:41partner, his love interest. It is that these
- 41:44two keep coming back to each other. So I think
- 41:46that this movie is way more of a romance between
- 41:48these two. And I think that's the... great man
- 41:51biopic of always there is a man in his foil and
- 41:53in this one it paints a little bit more of like
- 41:55a these two men actually kind of make uh peace
- 41:59with that yeah whereas i think with like you
- 42:01know in the previous episode i mentioned amadeus
- 42:03or oppenheimer i think those two are still very
- 42:05much at odds throughout the movie but i think
- 42:08in this one it's more of like a they've accepted
- 42:10that this is the game that they're playing together
- 42:12So the whole reason that he has a relationship
- 42:15with Anna Held or ends up in a relationship with
- 42:17Billy Burke is because Billings is the first
- 42:20to notice them. Right. He's Mr. Steal Your Girl.
- 42:22He is Mr. Steal Your Girl, Ziegfeld is. That's
- 42:24so funny. Yeah. No, I do really like that, that
- 42:27their friendship or rivalry persists through
- 42:32the entire movie. So when Anna Held does disappear,
- 42:35I'm like, ah, bummer. I liked her. Billings is
- 42:38there still. And I do like their rivalry. Billings,
- 42:43he's so much more interesting to me than Ziegfeld
- 42:45is. Well, it's funny because it's so easy to
- 42:47say when it's a rivalry that you kind of expect
- 42:50that he's like, ha ha, look, I got this girl
- 42:52and you don't. But instead, every time that,
- 42:55it's almost like he's this debonair man. And
- 42:59every time that Ziegfeld shows up, he's like,
- 43:01ma 'am, how are you? And Billings is like, go
- 43:03away. Get away from her. Don't talk to her. He's
- 43:07even telling the woman, don't look him in the
- 43:08eyes. It's like Quagmire. He's like, just don't
- 43:11look at him. Or Joey, when Rachel's sister comes
- 43:15over and he's like, how are you doing? And Rachel's
- 43:17like, no! It's exactly that. That's a great scene
- 43:21because of the way that Joey moves back, where
- 43:24he's just kind of stunned. What a great show.
- 43:27It's a great show. But I think that's what I
- 43:30like about their relationship, is that it's not
- 43:32like, I'm going to fight you. It's just more
- 43:34like, man, don't do this to me. It really is.
- 43:37He's just annoyed the entire time. And I really
- 43:40like Frank Morgan. I really, really like Frank
- 43:43Morgan a lot because I mentioned that he has
- 43:45found his character. He has found, maybe that's
- 43:48just who he is. His character is Carnival Barker.
- 43:50Yes. And he is like, he is, he believes he is
- 43:53one of the best things to happen. But the minute
- 43:55that's questioned, he's like, don't make me prove
- 43:57this. Right. Come on. Yeah. He's kind of entering
- 44:00that Ned Sparks, Edward Ever Horton thing that
- 44:03I mentioned where it's like the way that they
- 44:04react. is more important than who the character
- 44:07is because that's just that's what the scene
- 44:09needs man is it needs that guy he's like i don't
- 44:13know like you need that character and frank morgan
- 44:16is that every time we've seen him on screen so
- 44:18far you know not to talk about the wizard of
- 44:20oz again but it's so tied to this i love that
- 44:23we're getting so much frank morgan kind of leading
- 44:26up to that because i'm just like what a great
- 44:29choice to play the great and powerful oz this
- 44:33guy who's just like Come on, man. I bring a woman
- 44:37around and immediately, like, just back off.
- 44:40Let me have one thing. It's so perfect. It is.
- 44:43And it shows great casting all around there.
- 44:46But that is the reason that they even have these
- 44:48relationships and that we even see these things
- 44:50happen is because of Billings and Frank Morgan's
- 44:53trajectory that he sets Flo on for the rest of
- 44:56the story. Now, a couple things to kind of back
- 44:58this up. One thing that I thought was interesting,
- 45:00certainly not the last, which, you know, we've
- 45:03talked about a couple already, but this is the
- 45:05first biopic to win Best Picture. Yeah. So this
- 45:08and... What we talked about with Jack Warner
- 45:12realizing the success of something like the story
- 45:15of Louis Pasteur. This then brings on everyone
- 45:18being like, well, we got to make some damn biopics.
- 45:20Yeah. In the late 1930s, early 1940s. And boy,
- 45:24do they. And they keep doing it. We talked about
- 45:26Oppenheimer multiple times now. They're still
- 45:29doing it. This continues to happen. It's crazy.
- 45:32This is before it got to be like too much of
- 45:34a problem. I think we've seen a couple of these
- 45:36biopics, but I don't think we've seen an overabundance.
- 45:40I think we're about to. But then we'll get to
- 45:42the war and that'll change things too. Yeah.
- 45:44So another thing I want to mention is that this
- 45:47had some contentious behind the scenes stuff
- 45:50happening. Specifically, Universal bought the
- 45:52rights in 1933 to the great Ziegfeld. Okay. And
- 45:56they were gonna... make the movie, but then they
- 46:00actually sold them to MGM after they committed
- 46:03to Showboat. They decided they wanted to put
- 46:05more money into Showboat, which, you know, it's
- 46:07funny because that was a Ziegfeld production.
- 46:10Right, yeah. But they wanted to put more money
- 46:12into that, so they wanted to sell it to MGM,
- 46:14and they did while it was in pre -production.
- 46:17Funny thing about this, Billy Burke was actually
- 46:19slated to play herself. Oh, interesting. But
- 46:23MGM thought that she would be too old to play
- 46:27that younger version of herself. So they instead
- 46:29brought in Myrna Loy. You know, which is funny
- 46:31because by the time Ziegfeld meets Myrna Loy,
- 46:35he is older himself. So like it kind of makes
- 46:39sense. It does. And also like Billy Burke plays
- 46:42herself. Roy Bolger plays himself. So it's easier.
- 46:45Not Billy Burke. Not Billy Bryce. Fanny Bryce.
- 46:47That's what I meant. I'm so sorry. So Fanny Bryce
- 46:49plays herself. Roy Bolger does the same. So there
- 46:53are people that are reprising their age at that
- 46:55time. Right. But I guess she was a little bit
- 46:57older. They just wanted Myrna Loy. I mean, that
- 47:00makes the most sense. The selling power of them.
- 47:01Yeah. But also, come up with a better excuse
- 47:03than telling a woman she's too old. Also that.
- 47:05Yeah. Maybe don't tell her you're too old if
- 47:07that's not the issue. You know what? Even if
- 47:10that's the issue, don't say it. Yeah. Let's go.
- 47:12Hold your tongue, guys. Let's land with that.
- 47:14Let's do that. So I want to talk about Roy Bulger
- 47:17in this. Because I actually didn't know who he
- 47:20was at first. We just see him as a janitor just
- 47:23sweeping. But while he's sweeping, he's kind
- 47:24of tap dancing. Right. And obviously, Ziegfeld
- 47:28notices this and wants to include him in some
- 47:31way. And he ends up being a large entertainer
- 47:33for him in his follies to come. Of course, he
- 47:37goes on to play the scarecrow in Wizard of Oz.
- 47:40But his dance sequence, I forget the name of
- 47:43it, but there's a very large stage where he's
- 47:46surrounded by a number of women and he has to
- 47:48like kind of dance up and down a platform. Yeah.
- 47:50And then go center stage, curtain closes, and
- 47:52he kind of tap dances himself. This, to me, didn't
- 47:56rival the Pretty Girls Like a Melody musical
- 48:00number. But instead... It was a nice alternative
- 48:03because it was instead of just a large production,
- 48:06it was one person and their dance and the full
- 48:09pan out, right? Like we just get to see him dance.
- 48:12And the way he dances, I thought was really,
- 48:15really entertaining. I mean, it is a beautiful
- 48:17dance, but also he adds the comedy to it. There's
- 48:21the whole aspect where it looks like he's kind
- 48:22of losing himself as he's like dancing and he's
- 48:25going to fall multiple times. Great scarecrow.
- 48:27Great scarecrow. This was pretty much his audition
- 48:29to be like, if you need a scarecrow, I got you
- 48:31right here. And he's so good. Yeah, he's fantastic.
- 48:35You almost kind of forget when you watch a movie
- 48:36like The Wizard of Oz. I'm so sorry. Do you have
- 48:38a scarecrow button? Where? I see it. Oh, yeah,
- 48:42yeah. Bottom right of the orange. By the gremlin,
- 48:44actually. By Gizmo. That is so funny. I was looking
- 48:47and I was like, am I just projecting or is that
- 48:49actually the scarecrow staring right at me? You
- 48:50summoned him. It's Roy Bolger. Summoning Roy
- 48:55Bolger sounds like a really funny bit for this.
- 48:58That'd be great. Where it's like, I cast Pikachu.
- 49:00Well, I summoned Roy Bolger. And he just shows
- 49:03up and he's like, which way are we going? And
- 49:05he's all noodley and stuff. Yeah. His number
- 49:09is great. Did you like his number? Yeah, yeah.
- 49:12I think just getting to see the scarecrow doing
- 49:16anything else, I'm like, oh, cool. I get to see
- 49:18how he got here. I think, like, it's right after
- 49:21the intermission that the movie lingers around
- 49:25the musical genre for a little while because
- 49:28there's also the sequence with the beds. Yes,
- 49:31the stage. There are multiple beds on stage where
- 49:34there's women dancing on almost like a sleepover
- 49:36kind of thing. And then the stage is broken into
- 49:39four or five quadrants. And those quadrants reach
- 49:42out and stretch out onto the pit area. And this
- 49:46is where I think that it's nicer to see it on
- 49:49camera than it is in person because you might
- 49:51have an obstructed view. With this one, it has
- 49:53a higher up camera to where you can just see
- 49:54the stage going in and out. The production design
- 49:57in this is fantastic. But like you mentioned...
- 50:00Production design is not a nomination at this
- 50:02time or a category. So they have to find it in
- 50:05areas like art direction or dance direction where
- 50:07it's kind of right. But that's not the thing
- 50:09you're really talking about. During the bed sequence,
- 50:12was there ever a moment where you were expecting
- 50:13Lon Chaney to come out? Yes. And get them? 100%.
- 50:16Yeah. You're telling me that there's multiple
- 50:18women on stage having a sleepover and they aren't
- 50:21worried about getting got by Lon Chaney? I think
- 50:23that's a great sign of Universal seeing this
- 50:27and being like, somebody get... Lon Chaney Jr.
- 50:30on the horn. We've got to fix this. There's not
- 50:32enough worry about the Cheneys. You better watch
- 50:35out. He's going to get you. Lon Chaney's going
- 50:38to get you. So something I want to talk about
- 50:40real quick. Go for it. Is the similarities here
- 50:44to what I think eventually kind of unanimously
- 50:48becomes one of the best biopics of all time.
- 50:52Citizen Kane. Yeah. Very, very similar here.
- 50:55You're following a man who kind of changes an
- 50:58entire industry but does so in a way where he
- 51:02is full of faults and he makes some pretty poor
- 51:06decisions that affect a lot of people in his
- 51:08life. And ultimately it culminates in his death
- 51:12where he drops the most important thing in his
- 51:16life in a way. And this predates Citizen Kane.
- 51:21Yeah, yeah. By a few years. So it was Orson Welles'
- 51:23Ziegfeld guy. Yeah. I wonder. It is interesting
- 51:27because I saw so many similarities to Citizen
- 51:29Kane and I was like, wow, Orson Welles really
- 51:32did take like this formula and just perfect it.
- 51:36Yep. And I thought that was pretty cool. I would
- 51:39double feature it personally. It'd be a long
- 51:41one, but it'd be pretty good. We're going to
- 51:45get there in a couple of months. 1940. I think
- 51:49we'll be covering it in March or May, April.
- 51:53I was like, you skipped a month. Yeah, I think
- 51:57you're right. And I think it's, you know, people
- 51:59are going to remember Citizen Kane more than
- 52:01they're going to remember Great Ziegfeld. But
- 52:02that's another instance, an example, where these
- 52:07movies are taking influence from other movies
- 52:10and making it their own. And that's far more
- 52:13interesting than when you just try and rip something
- 52:15off completely, right? Yeah. So if you take the
- 52:17Great Man story like this, but then you add a
- 52:19different kind of context behind it that isn't
- 52:21a musical. but add some drama behind it, is that
- 52:24remembered more? And of course the answer is
- 52:25yes, especially when Orson Welles does it. Yeah.
- 52:28So I'm excited to get there. Another thing I
- 52:31want to mention about this is that this isn't
- 52:32the only time that William Powell plays Florence
- 52:34Ziegfeld. Was he in the Ziegfeld Follies? Boom.
- 52:39Nailed it. He reprised the role for the 1945
- 52:41film Ziegfeld Follies. Nice. So, I mean, clearly
- 52:44he had some interest in this character if he's
- 52:46willing to reprise him. I mean, also maybe...
- 52:49Maybe a little payment here and there. Yeah,
- 52:50a little cheddar. A little cheddar. But otherwise,
- 52:53I have not heard of this movie before. Ziegfeld
- 52:56Follies? No. The Great Ziegfeld. The Great Ziegfeld.
- 52:59I have not heard of The Great Ziegfeld before
- 53:01this, or even who Florence Ziegfeld was. Yeah,
- 53:04I'll say the same. That's always a weird statement
- 53:07from me because I've spent so much time just
- 53:09staring at all of the titles for Best Picture.
- 53:12Right. But yeah, I didn't know anything about
- 53:14this going into it. I'd heard the term Ziegfeld.
- 53:17Follies or Ziegfeld women, but I didn't know
- 53:20what those were. And I'm honestly learning now
- 53:24that like he was a real person and like this
- 53:26was a real thing. So I don't know if this was
- 53:29the best movie to have like a firm grasp of the
- 53:32true to life person. This feels kind of like
- 53:35a fantastical depiction of him that maybe doesn't
- 53:39showcase his faults enough. I think it's I didn't
- 53:43pair with this. I think this is a really good
- 53:44pairing with Michael. The Michael Jackson biopic.
- 53:47Ah, okay. The reason I say that is that the person
- 53:50behind the rights to Michael Jackson is his mother.
- 53:53And his mother wants him to be remembered a certain
- 53:56way, which is why that movie just completely
- 53:57skirts any kind of controversy. Anything that
- 54:01is needed to be explained about Neverland or
- 54:04anything like that is explained just in how much
- 54:06he loves Peter Pan, and that's it. He doesn't
- 54:08take a lot of medication. He only had surgery
- 54:11once or twice for his nose, but maybe a few times
- 54:13more. Who's just saying? But line in the sand,
- 54:17he doesn't take medication. No drugs ever, which,
- 54:19as we know, not true. So I think that this is
- 54:23a great comp to that. Again, not my official
- 54:25double feature. Yeah. Because I think that Billy
- 54:28Burke had a lot to do with this. And I think
- 54:30Billy Burke is like, yeah, sure, there's other
- 54:32women. But at the end of the day, it really was,
- 54:34I was the love of his life. Yeah. And there was
- 54:36a lot of importance in Louise Rayner. So I think
- 54:38it kind of like subverts the, and I'm not necessarily
- 54:41saying that Billy Burke had like an iron fist
- 54:43in this because the production code also doesn't
- 54:46want multiple affairs to be on screen or anything.
- 54:48So it benefits them ultimately. But. It does
- 54:52feel kind of like maybe it was a slight sanitization.
- 54:55What I like about it, though, is that it doesn't,
- 54:57to your point, shy away from his failures. Yes.
- 55:00And doesn't shy away that he was wrong multiple
- 55:02times, and he got it wrong. And ultimately, he
- 55:05dies. It didn't feel like a movie that was overly
- 55:08sanitized, and it was like a romance. Romance
- 55:11was in it, but it felt like, if anything, the
- 55:13true companion in his life was Billings. And
- 55:17we see him start that way, and we see him end
- 55:19that way. And I thought that was interesting.
- 55:22Him ending, like, not ending his life, but him
- 55:24passing while looking at, like, out the window
- 55:27and seeing his signs and everything for him.
- 55:30And then being in the chair and having this,
- 55:32like, flashback. And I really like this scene
- 55:35of him, like, just staring at the camera and
- 55:37then him reliving these moments. And we see those
- 55:39moments on screen kind of faded in and out of
- 55:43his consciousness. I thought it was great. And
- 55:45all of this happens with Billings. There's a
- 55:47great line from Billings after he talks with
- 55:51Ziegfeld. He's like, hey, you know what? I'm
- 55:52going to fund your next production. Don't even
- 55:54worry about it. We'll make it work. We're going
- 55:56to fund it together. We're going to do it. And
- 55:58both of them know that that's not going to happen.
- 56:00Yeah. And they both know that they're lying to
- 56:02each other to get the best out of each other.
- 56:04And that they know this is the last time they're
- 56:06going to see one another. And I thought this
- 56:08was great. And I really liked this. But it does
- 56:12feel a little bit like... the people involved
- 56:14with it probably would have prevented some of
- 56:17the worst things that were involved in his life.
- 56:19Right. And I think that the dramatized, severe
- 56:23version of that is Michael. I think Michael is
- 56:25way more sanitized and clean than something like
- 56:28Ray Ziegfeld. Yeah. So I do have some praise
- 56:30for that. I'm glad we got to see some of the
- 56:32negatives that this man's life was seemingly
- 56:36full of. So do you want to hop into ratings for
- 56:40this? Let's do ratings. Yeah. So... Is Letterboxd
- 56:43back up? I don't know, but I have mine. So this
- 56:46was very long. I didn't love William Powell.
- 56:50Louise Rayner was the highlight of the movie
- 56:52for me. And the biggest dance number on screen
- 56:55that really is the highlight of this movie didn't
- 56:59wow me the same way I think it does for a lot
- 57:01of people. So I gave this movie two stars. I
- 57:04wasn't into it. It's long. I was into it. Yeah.
- 57:09I think I gave it four stars. Wow. I think I
- 57:13did. I would normally check Letterboxd. It's
- 57:15still down. So we're panicking here at Once Upon
- 57:18a Time at the Oscars. I really enjoyed this.
- 57:24And maybe it's like I enjoyed it in spite of
- 57:27every reason that I shouldn't. I shouldn't enjoy
- 57:29it because he is this flawed character. If anything,
- 57:32that probably makes it more interesting. I shouldn't
- 57:33love it because it's three plus hours. I shouldn't
- 57:36love it because the things that I didn't like
- 57:37about Midsummer Night's Dream, some of them are
- 57:40present here. The interlude, the intermission.
- 57:42Why the interlude is in its full length, but
- 57:45the intermission is not, I won't understand.
- 57:48I assume because like an overture is normally
- 57:51played. For the interlude and the intermission
- 57:54is just like a pause it here. Well, right. But
- 57:57I mean, like in the theater, it is played where
- 58:00the intermission is all the way through. Right.
- 58:02So if you're going to interrupt one, interrupt
- 58:04both. But the intermission, pause it. I'm just
- 58:09going to skip the overture. Oh, well, how dare
- 58:13you? Well, I mean, at this point. wow like if
- 58:16it's 10 minutes of just like an overture guy
- 58:18well i'm not really an either guy to be honest
- 58:21i think this conversation is over sure sure over
- 58:24sure sure so stupid four stars for me because
- 58:29i really liked william powell i i love a great
- 58:31man movie as we talked about on the story or
- 58:34the story of louis pastor um not all of them
- 58:37But as you know, I'm a big Amadeus guy. I love
- 58:40Amadeus. And I saw a lot of that in Billings
- 58:42and in Ziegfeld. Yeah. So for me, I liked that
- 58:48they were hinting that the true romance was probably
- 58:51between Billings and Ziegfeld and not with Anna
- 58:56Held and Ziegfeld or Billy Burke and Ziegfeld.
- 58:59So I really like that. I love, love, love the
- 59:04Pretty Girls melody. uh moment that we talked
- 59:07about i think that's great i loved seeing roy
- 59:10bulger on screen and like seeing a little bit
- 59:11more about this so i had a great time with it
- 59:13i can't tell you the next time i'm going to revisit
- 59:15it i'll be so honest with you yeah i own it i
- 59:17was able to pick up a dvd before i saw it and
- 59:20i'm glad that i did um some good bonus features
- 59:22on there i don't think that you need to go out
- 59:24of your way for a two -star movie but uh is this
- 59:28no Was F1 the furthest we've been? Oh, I'd have
- 59:32to go back and look. But this is a pretty big
- 59:35gap between how much we enjoyed the movie. Yeah.
- 59:38Yeah. Yeah, it was this one. I think Marty Supreme
- 59:40had a pretty big gap as well. Okay. But... I
- 59:43don't think I was five stars on Word of the Supreme.
- 59:45I think I was maybe four and a half. Yeah. And
- 59:47I think you may have been two, two and a half.
- 59:49Something like that. Yeah. Interesting. Yeah,
- 59:51but it is up there. You're right. But what a
- 59:54great conversation. I knew this was going to
- 59:56be a fun episode because we weren't going to
- 59:58be on the same page of some things. So I was
- 1:00:01very excited. I like when we have some disagreements.
- 1:00:03I think it makes... I disagree. Oh, well... And
- 1:00:07that's great. Get it over with. I brought it
- 1:00:10back, baby. No, I agree. I think that makes for
- 1:00:12the better conversations between us. So, good
- 1:00:16job. Thanks. Double feature? Look, I'm just going
- 1:00:19to do it. 2017, Michael Gracie's The Greatest
- 1:00:21Showman. Oh, okay. Yeah, yeah. This felt like
- 1:00:25the easiest comp in terms of there's a bit more
- 1:00:27musical in The Greatest Showman, but the idea
- 1:00:30of how a man can go from ordinary to greatness.
- 1:00:35I'm not going to say that I love The Greatest
- 1:00:38Showman. One of my favorite jokes is it's the
- 1:00:40okayest showman. Oh, yeah. I think it's pretty
- 1:00:43okay. It's good. But the idea of like a carnival
- 1:00:47Barker, like P .T. Barnum himself, like the idea
- 1:00:51of him starting as a Barker, Ziegfeld, and then
- 1:00:54becoming a Broadway producer made the most sense
- 1:00:57of something like this, where you see a guy who
- 1:00:59wants to achieve greatness and settles, not settles,
- 1:01:03but like strives to make the circus the best
- 1:01:06that it can be. So Greatest Showman is my double
- 1:01:09feature. I like that. That's a movie whose soundtrack
- 1:01:11I like more than the movie. I can agree with
- 1:01:14that. Like, I will put on that soundtrack sometimes,
- 1:01:17and I'm just like, yeah, these are good songs.
- 1:01:19Do we want to agree that This Is Me is the worst
- 1:01:22thing to happen to daytime television because
- 1:01:26of pharmaceutical commercials? Ooh. I don't know
- 1:01:30how often I see that. Because We Go V. We Go
- 1:01:32V. There is an ad where they sing We Go V to
- 1:01:36the tune of This Is Me. And they're, like, marching
- 1:01:39down the street, and they're like, We Go V. It
- 1:01:41is. That's rough. It's rough, dude. I'm not familiar
- 1:01:44with that, but I hate it. All the times I'm watching
- 1:01:45Price is Right, I'm like, ugh, this sucks. But
- 1:01:48yeah, This Is Me is definitely the most notable
- 1:01:51song off that. Yeah. That opening song on Greatest
- 1:01:54Showman is pretty great, too. Oh, I love it.
- 1:01:56I love the finale song as well. I don't know
- 1:01:59if I'm familiar. From Now On. Oh, yeah. Yeah.
- 1:02:03Big fan of that one. Yeah. Big fan of that one.
- 1:02:05My double feature. I had a movie that told the
- 1:02:09story of people kind of navigating their way
- 1:02:12through the industry and kind of damaging the
- 1:02:16industry and themselves and others at the same
- 1:02:18time. But I actually want to save that for the
- 1:02:21future. Okay. So instead, I went with the relationship
- 1:02:24of two men kind of trying to undercut one another
- 1:02:28towards their ultimate goal, but finding friendship
- 1:02:32along the way. Oh, I don't think that's what
- 1:02:34I was thinking. I went with X -Men First Class.
- 1:02:38I was going to say The Prestige. Nope. I went
- 1:02:42with X -Men First Class. Charles Xavier and Eric.
- 1:02:46Uh -huh. Oh, wow. I don't know his last name.
- 1:02:49I forgot. Magneto. I forgot his name. I think
- 1:02:51it's Eric Magneto. I forgot his last name. I
- 1:02:53think you got it. Strauss? Is it Strauss or is
- 1:02:56that a real person? I think Eric Strauss might
- 1:02:58be a real person. Hold on. I have to look it
- 1:02:59up. Eric Lensher. Oh, it's Lensher. Magneto.
- 1:03:02Yeah. Wow. I don't know that I ever would have
- 1:03:04gotten. I'm going to be so honest with you. I
- 1:03:06kind of want to keep Eric Magneto around. Eric
- 1:03:08Magneto? Yeah. I mean, if he's Professor Xavier,
- 1:03:11then why isn't he Eric Magneto? You know, I love
- 1:03:16the idea of the third companion for that duo
- 1:03:19is Dr. Captain Peter Blood. He's back, baby.
- 1:03:23I forgot about Dr. Captain Peter Blood. Yeah,
- 1:03:25but I thought that was kind of similar to Ziegfeld
- 1:03:29and Billings. Yeah, great pivot. Yeah. Not at
- 1:03:34all what I expected. Who do you think is who?
- 1:03:36I would think that, you know, I actually think
- 1:03:40that Xavier is Billings. Yeah. And Ziegfeld is
- 1:03:44Magneto. Because think of how many times Magneto
- 1:03:47has taken, like, mystique from Xavier. Yep. And,
- 1:03:50like, corrupted people from, yeah. Yeah. Yeah,
- 1:03:53you're right. And then at the end, I mean, I
- 1:03:55don't feel like Ziegfeld would be forgiving of
- 1:03:58Billings, but Billings at the end is like, there,
- 1:04:01there, my friend. You did a lot of bad things,
- 1:04:05but I'm nice. I am looking for a number here.
- 1:04:08Yeah. How many times do you think we need to
- 1:04:10see on screen Charles Xavier get blown up? I
- 1:04:14think we're just starting to tap the possibilities,
- 1:04:17Ryan. What were we at now? Two? Keep it coming.
- 1:04:20Three? Not enough. He's dying in Doomsday, right?
- 1:04:23Like, he's going to get blown up in Doomsday.
- 1:04:25I don't know. He dies once a week, really. At
- 1:04:29this point, he's basically a red shirt. Don't
- 1:04:32do that to Picard. I think that was a good reference.
- 1:04:35That was a great reference. Thank you so much.
- 1:04:36Anyway, that's our thoughts and our double features
- 1:04:39for The Great Ziegfeld. As well as Star Trek.
- 1:04:42Yeah, yeah, it was. If you have thoughts on this
- 1:04:45movie, let us know your favorite biopic. Oh,
- 1:04:49yeah. What is it? Go into the Discord in the
- 1:04:52Patreon. Let us know your favorite biopic. Also,
- 1:04:55don't forget, every 13th of the month, we did
- 1:04:58just have this not too long ago, our Horror of
- 1:05:00the Overlooked. We'll cover that for every year.
- 1:05:03Also, go to the Patreon to check out our many
- 1:05:06exclusives that we have, including movie reviews,
- 1:05:09posting about the physical media collection that
- 1:05:13we have here and there, our bonus episodes, and
- 1:05:15getting those episodes early. Yeah. That's patreon
- 1:05:18.com slash OUTAOPodcast and OUTAOPodcast at gmail
- 1:05:24.com for the email if you have thoughts on the
- 1:05:26show. Yep. Let us know if you have thoughts on
- 1:05:27the show, how you felt about these movies if
- 1:05:29you're watching along. If you've seen this one
- 1:05:31in the past and if you think we got it wrong,
- 1:05:32if we got it right, let us know. Yeah. What are
- 1:05:35we covering next episode? Next episode, we're
- 1:05:37going to be covering Mr. Deeds Goes to Town,
- 1:05:40the return of Frank Capra. What up, Frank? We're
- 1:05:44going to be talking a good bit about Frank, and
- 1:05:45I got to watch the 4K of this. Kyle is going
- 1:05:49to watch the 4K or Blu -ray of this and be very
- 1:05:53happy about these special features, I think.
- 1:05:54And we will talk about it on the next episode.
- 1:05:56Yeah, so until then, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And
- 1:06:00we'll see you at the movies. Wow, what was that?
- 1:06:03No, don't press that button. And we'll see you
- 1:06:06at the movies. Why'd you do it that way? Thank
- 1:06:16you.