Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Psychological Theories vs Phenomena: How Psychology Explains Behavior
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. Yes. Welcome.
- 0:02I mean, we really have to start with a question
- 0:04for you all listening. Have you ever noticed
- 0:06that when you go to the grocery store without
- 0:09a list? Oh, the worst mistake. Right. You walk
- 0:13in so confident, like you know exactly what you
- 0:16need, but then you only remember the very first
- 0:20thing you meant to buy. Maybe like the very last
- 0:22thing you thought of while you were parking the
- 0:23car. Exactly. But you completely forget the entire
- 0:27middle of your mental list. So you walk out with,
- 0:30I don't know, milk and paper towels. And completely
- 0:32forget the chicken. the pasta and the apples.
- 0:35Yeah, that happens to all of us. It is so incredibly
- 0:38frustrating. It is. But what's fascinating is
- 0:40that this everyday quirk, this thing we all do,
- 0:43isn't just a failure of your personal memory.
- 0:45Right. It's actually a thoroughly documented
- 0:48psychological concept. It's called the serial
- 0:50position effect. Which is just wild to me. Yeah.
- 0:54And it actually perfectly sets up our mission
- 0:56for today's deep dive into the source material,
- 0:59because today we're going to untangle the absolute
- 1:01foundation of psychological science. I am so
- 1:06ready for this. I've been cramming this material
- 1:08for my own understanding anyway. Same. We are
- 1:11basically going to figure out the crucial difference
- 1:13between the what of human behavior, like the
- 1:16phenomena, and the why, which are the theories.
- 1:20And getting a handle on this difference, I mean,
- 1:22it's like getting a backstage pass to how human
- 1:25behavior is actually studied. It really changes
- 1:28how you read the news or how you interpret studies.
- 1:31And how you view your own habits, honestly. Yeah.
- 1:33So let's just unpack this. We have to start with
- 1:35the observable facts before we try to explain
- 1:38them. Let's start with phenomena. Which is the
- 1:41plural of phenomenon, just to be clear. Right.
- 1:43Exactly. So how exactly are we defining this
- 1:46in a rigorous scientific context? So in research,
- 1:51a phenomenon is a general result that's been
- 1:53observed reliably in systematic empirical research.
- 1:56OK. To put it simply, it's basically an established
- 1:58answer to a research question. It's something
- 2:01we have watched happen, we've measured it, and
- 2:03verified it repeatedly. So I have this memory
- 2:06trick I use to keep this straight. Let's hear
- 2:07it. I just think of phenomena as the physical
- 2:11facts. Both start with P. It's what we can see
- 2:14or tally or measure directly. I love that. Physical
- 2:17facts. That's perfect. Because if you think of
- 2:19human behavior as this massive chaotic scatter
- 2:22plot graph, the phenomena are the individual
- 2:26verified dots of data on that graph. The dots
- 2:29on the graph. OK, yeah, that makes sense. And
- 2:32looking at our sources, there are some absolutely
- 2:34wild phenomena out there. Oh, completely. But
- 2:37they're often presented just as facts without
- 2:39the mechanism. Like, let's dig into a few of
- 2:42these because a lightning round of these physical
- 2:43facts is just mind -bending. Let's do it. OK,
- 2:46take blind sight. Ah, yeah, that's a crazy one.
- 2:48Right. This is where people with actual physical
- 2:51damage to their visual cortex, meaning they are
- 2:54completely consciously blind, can still somehow
- 2:58respond to visual stimuli. Right, like they might
- 3:00catch a ball thrown at them. Yes. while genuinely
- 3:03claiming they can't see anything at all. Like,
- 3:06how is that dot even on the graph? I mean, it
- 3:08sounds like literal magic, but it comes down
- 3:10to evolutionary biology. OK, break that down
- 3:13for me. So the visual cortex handles our conscious
- 3:16processing of sight. But we have these older,
- 3:19more primitive neural pathways. Like the lizard
- 3:22brain stuff. Basically, yeah. Like the superior
- 3:25colliculus. And that processes movement and location
- 3:28completely under the radar of our conscious awareness.
- 3:31Oh, wow. So the eyes are still sending signals
- 3:34and the brain stem is reacting to them even though
- 3:37the conscious mind is entirely in the dark That
- 3:40is just wow. Okay. How about the McGurk effect?
- 3:42This one is famous on like internet video Oh
- 3:45the audio illusion one exactly if you watch a
- 3:48video of someone's mouth making one sound like
- 3:50yeah, but the audio playing is a completely different
- 3:53sound like Your brain essentially just hallucinates.
- 3:56Yes, it creates this weird intermediate third
- 3:58sound da that isn't actually there in the audio
- 4:02or the video It just invents a sound because
- 4:04the brain absolutely despises sensory conflict.
- 4:07You just can't handle it Right, we rely so heavily
- 4:09on visual cues for speech. So when the visual
- 4:13input from the eyes contradicts the audio from
- 4:15the ears, the brain's integration centers are
- 4:18forced to negotiate a compromise. So it just
- 4:20makes up a middle ground. Yeah, visual processing
- 4:22usually overrides auditory processing, so your
- 4:24brain just constructs an illusion to make the
- 4:27world make sense. That is so cool. Okay, next
- 4:30dot on the graph. Spontaneous recovery. Oh, going
- 4:34back to classic condition. Yeah, like Pavlov.
- 4:36This is when a conditioned response, let's say
- 4:39a dog learns to salivate to a bell and then eventually
- 4:43stops doing it because you stopped giving it
- 4:45food with the bell. Right, the behavior is extinguished.
- 4:48Exactly. But then, it suddenly comes back out
- 4:51of nowhere after a long period of time without
- 4:53any new training at all. Which tells us something
- 4:56really profound about learning. What does it
- 4:58tell us? It shows that extinguishing a behavior
- 5:00doesn't actually erase the original neural pathway.
- 5:03Oh, so it's still in there. Yeah, it merely builds
- 5:06a new inhibitory pathway over it. And when time
- 5:09passes, that inhibitory pathway can weaken, and
- 5:12the old behavior just suddenly bleeds through
- 5:14again. That explains so many bad habits, honestly.
- 5:16Doesn't it? OK, we also have the other race effect,
- 5:19where people are demonstrably more accurate at
- 5:23recognizing faces of their own race compared
- 5:25to faces of other races. Yeah, that one is heavily
- 5:27studied. I was just saying that was just like
- 5:29a social construct. But the sources point out
- 5:31it's actually perceptual narrowing. Right, starting
- 5:34in infancy. Yeah. Infants start out able to distinguish
- 5:37faces of all races equally well. But by nine
- 5:41months old, the brain just prunes the synapses
- 5:44it isn't using. It optimizes for the faces it
- 5:47sees most often in its immediate environment.
- 5:49It's cognitive efficiency at the cost of broader
- 5:51accuracy. Speaking of cognitive efficiency, the
- 5:55last one in our lightning round is the mere exposure
- 5:57effect. A classic. which is just the more you
- 6:01are exposed to something, the more you like it.
- 6:03Which probably explains why I eventually ended
- 6:05up liking that terrible, repetitive pop song
- 6:08that played on the radio every single morning.
- 6:10Oh, I know exactly what song you mean. It's shameful.
- 6:13Well, why does my brain do that? That mechanism
- 6:15is known as cognitive fluency. Basically... The
- 6:19more your brain processes a specific pattern,
- 6:21like that terrible pop song, the less metabolic
- 6:24energy it takes to process it the next time.
- 6:27Oh, so it's just being lazy. Essentially, yes.
- 6:30The brain interprets easy to process as safe
- 6:33and pleasant. It literally feels good to your
- 6:35brain to recognize something familiar. OK, so
- 6:38these are all established phenomena. The dots
- 6:40on the graph, the physical facts. Exactly. These
- 6:43physical phenomena are fascinating quirks of
- 6:46the brain's wiring. But what happens when these
- 6:49observable facts start challenging like our sense
- 6:52of morality? That's where it gets heavy, right?
- 6:55I want to pause on two specific phenomena from
- 6:57the material The bystander effect and the fundamental
- 7:01attribution error to absolute foundational effects
- 7:04in social psychology So the bystander effect
- 7:06says that the more people who are present at
- 7:08an emergency The less likely anyone is to help
- 7:10right and the fundamental attribution error is
- 7:13our tendency to blame people's behavior on their
- 7:16core character rather than the situation they
- 7:18are in. And those often make people really uncomfortable
- 7:21when they first learn about them. Because doesn't
- 7:24this kind of challenge our basic assumptions
- 7:26about being a good Samaritan? How so? Well, we
- 7:29like to think that morality is a fixed internal
- 7:31compass. You know, that if we are a quote -unquote
- 7:34good person, we will step up and help someone
- 7:37in need, regardless of the context. Right, that
- 7:40it's just who we are. Yeah. But these phenomena
- 7:43suggest our moral actions aren't fixed at all.
- 7:45They're highly dependent on something as random
- 7:48as how many strangers happen to be standing next
- 7:50to us on the sidewalk. I mean, it's a completely
- 7:52valid philosophical reaction to the data. It
- 7:55does challenge that intrinsic, unshifting view
- 7:59of human morality. It's a little existentially
- 8:01terrifying, honestly. It is. But before we let
- 8:04this trigger a full existential crisis about
- 8:07human nature, we have to lean on the most crucial
- 8:09process in science. Which is? Replication. Okay,
- 8:14meaning we don't just take one shocking study
- 8:17and completely rewrite our moral philosophy based
- 8:19on it. We test it again. We have to. We only
- 8:22know these phenomena are real and worth questioning
- 8:25our moral compasses over if we can replicate
- 8:27them reliably. So the researchers just do the
- 8:30exact same thing again? Either exactly the same
- 8:32way, or with slight controlled modifications,
- 8:35just to ensure it produces the same results.
- 8:38If a replication fails, we have to consider that
- 8:41the initial result might have just been a statistical
- 8:43fluke. Right. Just random chance. Or it could
- 8:46mean that the replication differed in some hidden,
- 8:48crucial way. But even when a study replicates
- 8:51beautifully, time and time again, our textbook
- 8:54says psychologists still don't call them laws.
- 8:57Right? Great. In physics, you have the universal
- 8:59laws of motion. In chemistry, you have the conservation
- 9:03of mass. But psychology rarely, if ever, uses
- 9:07the word law. And that's an incredibly important
- 9:09distinction to draw. Psychology rarely has universal
- 9:13laws. We deal in effects. Because a law implies
- 9:15it's always true. Exactly. A law implies that
- 9:18a phenomenon is universally true across the board,
- 9:21without exception. But human behavior is incredibly
- 9:24messy, and it's highly contextual. Right, because
- 9:27we aren't predictable hydrogen atoms. We're highly
- 9:30socialized people. Precisely. Even the most robustly
- 9:33established effects are often heavily culturally
- 9:35dependent. Oh, like the fundamental attribution
- 9:38error we just talked about. Yes, exactly. Where
- 9:41we judge someone's character rather than acknowledging
- 9:43the situational pressures they're facing. Right.
- 9:45Cross -cultural research shows that this error
- 9:47is committed much more frequently in individualistic
- 9:49societies like North America than it is in collectivist
- 9:53societies like East Asia. Oh, wow. Why is that?
- 9:56In East Asia, people are culturally conditioned
- 9:59to look at the broader context of a situation
- 10:01first. So, it's a real phenomenon, it's a real
- 10:04effect, but it is not an inescapable universal
- 10:07law of human nature. Okay, so if phenomena are
- 10:11just the observable facts, the dots on the scatter
- 10:14plot, how do we actually make sense of them?
- 10:16We need a bridge. Right. We need a line of best
- 10:19fit that reveals the trend. A bridge between
- 10:22the observation and our understanding. And according
- 10:25to the source material, that bridge is a theory.
- 10:27Yes. This is where we finally cross over from
- 10:30the what to the why. OK, I have to bring up a
- 10:33major pet peeve of mine right here. Let's hear
- 10:35it. You hear this all the time in casual conversation
- 10:38or like online debates. Someone disagrees with
- 10:41a scientific concept, usually something they
- 10:44find politically or personally inconvenient,
- 10:46and they say, oh, well, that's just a theory.
- 10:48Oh, yes. They use the word to imply it's a wild
- 10:51guess or a hypothesis cooked up in a break room
- 10:54somewhere. It is arguably the most persistent
- 10:57and damaging misunderstanding of scientific terminology
- 11:00by the general public. It drives me crazy. Because
- 11:02in science, a theory is a coherent explanation
- 11:05or interpretation of one or more phenomena. It
- 11:09absolutely does not mean untested or just a guess.
- 11:12Right. Like, the theory of evolution by natural
- 11:15selection is a theory because it is the organizing
- 11:17framework that explains the diversity of life.
- 11:19Not because biologists are just spitballing.
- 11:21Exactly. Or the germ theory of disease. It's
- 11:24a theory, but it's extensively tested, massively
- 11:27supported by data, and accepted as the most accurate
- 11:31explanation. we have. So if phenomena are the
- 11:33physical facts, what's our memory trick for theories?
- 11:35Think of theories as the thoughts and threads.
- 11:38Thoughts and threads, I like that. Yeah, theories
- 11:40go beyond what we can just directly see or measure.
- 11:44They introduce unobservable variables, internal
- 11:47cognitive processes or organizing principles,
- 11:50the threads that link those physical facts together.
- 11:52So they connect the dots on the graph. Exactly.
- 11:55If phenomena are the individual dots, the theory
- 11:58is the elegant mathematical equation that connects
- 12:01them all and explains why they are placed where
- 12:03they are. Let's look at the ultimate example
- 12:06from our sources to show how this works in practice.
- 12:09This is the story of Robert Zejong. Oh, this
- 12:12is a great case study. It really is, because
- 12:14it's a great example of science being really
- 12:17confusing at first. Early psychology studies
- 12:20were looking at how people perform tasks when
- 12:23they're being watched by an audience. What is
- 12:24basic performance anxiety stuff? Right. And the
- 12:27physical facts, the phenomena were completely
- 12:29contradictory. Because some of the earliest studies
- 12:32showed that people performed much better when
- 12:34they were being watched by others. But then later
- 12:36replications by different researchers showed
- 12:38the exact opposite. People performed significantly
- 12:42worse when an audience was present. So how can
- 12:45both be true? Did the researchers just mess up
- 12:47the replications? Not necessarily, they were
- 12:50actually observing different phenomena under
- 12:52different conditions without realizing it. Oh,
- 12:54interesting. Yeah, Zazhong solved this puzzle
- 12:57in 1965 by identifying a hidden variable. He
- 13:00looked at the type of task the person was actually
- 13:03doing. Okay, so what did he find? He found that
- 13:06people perform better when watched on highly
- 13:08practiced, relatively easy tasks. That phenomenon
- 13:12is now categorized as social facilitation. OK,
- 13:15that makes sense. But they perform worse when
- 13:17watched on unpracticed, difficult tasks. And
- 13:20that phenomenon is social inhibition. OK, so
- 13:23he found the pattern. He sorted the dots on the
- 13:25graph. But that's still just the what, right?
- 13:28What was the why? How did he explain the mechanism
- 13:30behind it? To answer the why, Zajonk proposed
- 13:33what he called a drive theory. Drive theory,
- 13:35OK. He suggested that being watched by others
- 13:37creates a general state of physiological arousal
- 13:39in the nervous system. Like your heart beats
- 13:41faster. Exactly. You get a little surge of adrenaline,
- 13:44your heart rate shifts slightly. This unseen
- 13:48arousal increases the likelihood of a person's
- 13:51dominant response. Wait, what does dominant response
- 13:53mean? It just means the behavior they are naturally
- 13:56most likely to execute in that given moment.
- 13:58Okay, let's translate this to the real world
- 14:01so I can wrap my head around it. Think about
- 14:02it like an Olympic gymnast. Okay, I'm picturing
- 14:05it. If you are an elite athlete who usually hits
- 14:08your floor routine perfectly in an empty gym,
- 14:11Perfection is your dominant response. Right,
- 14:14because you've practiced it a million times.
- 14:16Exactly. So the physiological arousal of a huge
- 14:19screaming stadium crowd makes you even sharper,
- 14:23faster, and better. It facilitates your success.
- 14:25Social facilitation. But if you are a complete
- 14:28novice who usually makes mistakes and falls over,
- 14:31mistakes are your dominant response. Oh, no.
- 14:34Right. So the crowd's arousal just amplifies
- 14:36that anxiety making those mistakes way more likely
- 14:39and you crash. Social inhibition. That captures
- 14:42the mechanism perfectly. But to add a layer to
- 14:46that, Zajonk found that this doesn't just apply
- 14:48to packed Olympic stadiums. Really? Yeah, just
- 14:51having one other person in the room triggers
- 14:53that baseline physiological arousal. Just one
- 14:55person, wow. Yep. The drive theory uses unobservable
- 14:58concepts like internal physiological arousal
- 15:01and cognitive dominant response to elegantly
- 15:04explain the highly observable and previously
- 15:07contradictory phenomena. So Zajonk's idea started
- 15:10as just a hypothesis, right? I feel like we need
- 15:12a quick vocabulary breakdown here. because people
- 15:14mix up theory, hypothesis, and model all the
- 15:17time. They do, and it's crucial for understanding
- 15:20the literature. So how do we keep these straight?
- 15:22What is a hypothesis? A hypothesis usually refers
- 15:25to a very specific, testable prediction about
- 15:28a new phenomenon that is based on an existing
- 15:30theory. So it's narrow. Yes, it's what you are
- 15:34testing in one specific isolated experiment.
- 15:37OK, and a model. A model is a much more precise
- 15:40localized explanation of a specific phenomenon.
- 15:43It's often expressed in mathematical equations
- 15:45or step -by -step flow charts. And what about
- 15:47a perspective? The textbook mentions that too.
- 15:50A perspective is a very broad approach to explaining
- 15:54phenomena, like looking at a behavior through
- 15:56an evolutionary perspective versus a purely behavioral
- 16:00perspective. Got it. But the golden rule to remember
- 16:03for all of this, it all comes down to the fundamental
- 16:06distinction between observations, which are phenomena,
- 16:10and interpretations, which are theories. OK,
- 16:13so theories interpret the facts. But what is
- 16:17their actual day -to -day utility to researchers?
- 16:21Because a theory can be incredibly useful without
- 16:23being perfectly accurate, right? Absolutely.
- 16:25Our notes mention the multi -store model of memory
- 16:28as an example of this. Oh, that's a perfect example.
- 16:30Because it's still cited all the time in textbooks.
- 16:33It's so useful for understanding how short -term
- 16:35memory works, even though modern neuroscience
- 16:38has shown us that some of its specific architectural
- 16:40details are, you know, technically inaccurate.
- 16:43That's a great point. Theories don't just exist
- 16:45to be true in some abstract way. They have to
- 16:48do heavy lifting in the lab. Specifically, they
- 16:50have three main jobs in science. OK, what's job
- 16:53number one? The first is organization. Theories
- 16:56organize chaotic phenomena so researchers can
- 16:59think about them clearly and efficiently. Right,
- 17:01like that multi -store model of memory. It takes
- 17:04a bunch of separate phenomena, like the fact
- 17:06that short -term memory has a limited capacity,
- 17:09the fact that verbally repeating things helps
- 17:11you lock them in. And that grocery list issue
- 17:13we talked about at the very start. Yes, the serial
- 17:15position effect. And it organizes all of those
- 17:18into one cohesive, easily understood structure.
- 17:22And when organizing data, scientists rely heavily
- 17:25on the principle of parsimony, commonly known
- 17:27as Occam's razor. I love Occam's razor. It's
- 17:30essential. This principle dictates that a theory
- 17:33should only include as many concepts or variables
- 17:35as are absolutely necessary. The simplest explanation
- 17:39that accounts for all the observed facts is usually
- 17:41the best one. It's so elegant, because it connects
- 17:44to how we structure so much of our thinking outside
- 17:46of science, too. Like what? Well, think about
- 17:48how we organize moral frameworks. The most enduring
- 17:51moral teachings almost always boil down to one
- 17:54simple parsimonious rule. Like the golden rule.
- 17:57Exactly. Treat others how you want to be treated.
- 18:01It takes massive, incredibly complex webs of
- 18:04human interaction, conflict, and empathy and
- 18:07organizes it all in the one simple foundational
- 18:10concept. That's a really interesting parallel.
- 18:13Right. The best scientific theories... do the
- 18:15exact same thing. They don't add unnecessary
- 18:17baggage if they don't have to. Simplicity really
- 18:19is elegant whether you're dealing in moral philosophy
- 18:22or cognitive psychology. Now the second purpose
- 18:25of a theory is prediction. Okay, predicting the
- 18:28future. Basically, a good theory allows us to
- 18:31guess what will happen in new entirely untested
- 18:34situations. Taking Zajon's drive theory with
- 18:37our gymnast. Because we have that theoretical
- 18:40framework, we can predict before the competition
- 18:42even starts whether a specific athlete is likely
- 18:45to thrive under the pressure or choke. Based
- 18:47entirely on how well practiced their routine
- 18:50is. Exactly. Okay, and what's the third purpose?
- 18:52The third purpose, which is perhaps the most
- 18:54important for the ongoing engine of science,
- 18:56is the generation of new research. Okay, so it
- 18:58keeps the ball rolling. Yes. Good theories don't
- 19:01just provide answers. They raise entirely new,
- 19:05better questions. Do we have an example from
- 19:07the source material? We do. Consider the clinical
- 19:10theory that some people engage in self -harm,
- 19:13like cutting themselves, because it temporarily
- 19:15reduces negative emotional states by releasing
- 19:18endorphins. Right, okay. And that theory immediately
- 19:21prompts the next wave of research questions.
- 19:24Exactly. Like, is that relationship truly...
- 19:27What is the actual neurobiological mechanism
- 19:30in the brain that allows physical pain to suddenly
- 19:34down -regulate emotional pain? Are there specific
- 19:37neurotransmitters we can target instead? You
- 19:39can't just stop at the theory. The theory is
- 19:41the starting line for the next race. It sparks
- 19:43the next generation of studies. It pushes the
- 19:46boundary of what we know just a little bit further.
- 19:48And here is the most comforting part of the scientific
- 19:50method for an undergrad trying to learn all this.
- 19:53Even an inaccurate theory is incredibly valuable.
- 19:56Why do you say that? Because when a theory is
- 19:58slightly wrong, it eventually generates inconsistent,
- 20:02weird answers in the lab. And those inconsistent
- 20:05answers force researchers to dig deeper, revise
- 20:08the theory, or abandon it entirely for a better
- 20:11one, which is exactly how progress is made. That
- 20:13is spot on. Science is fundamentally a process
- 20:16of getting less wrong over time. Getting less
- 20:19wrong. I love that. Which leads us to a complex
- 20:22reality. If theories are so great and they help
- 20:25us organize and predict the world, why don't
- 20:28we just have one master theory for everything?
- 20:31Seriously, if you've ever looked at a psychology
- 20:33textbook, they're like 800 pages long and filled
- 20:37with competing ideas for the exact same behavior.
- 20:40Why isn't there just one accepted answer? Simply
- 20:42because human behavior is staggeringly complex,
- 20:45for any set of phenomena, researchers usually
- 20:47have to consider multiple theories simultaneously.
- 20:50So they don't just pick one? Right. Sometimes
- 20:52these theories are complementary, like two different
- 20:54puzzle pieces that fit together to show a wider
- 20:56picture. Okay, like a biological theory about
- 20:58genetics might perfectly complement a behavioral
- 21:01theory about environment. Exactly. But often,
- 21:05theories are competing. Meaning, if one theory
- 21:08is right, the other one is almost certainly wrong.
- 21:11Let's do a deep dive into a really heavy, but
- 21:14deeply fascinating example of this from the text.
- 21:18Okay, let's do it. Dissociative identity disorder,
- 21:21or DD, which used to be known as multiple personality
- 21:24disorder. A very complex topic. Super complex.
- 21:28So the phenomenon, the observable dot on the
- 21:30graph, is that the prevalence of DD diagnoses
- 21:34increased massively in the late 20th century.
- 21:36That is the empirical observation. But how do
- 21:40we explain it? Because the source material outlines
- 21:42two intensely competing theories here, and we're
- 21:44just reporting what the sources say, not taking
- 21:46sides. Right, strictly looking at the theoretical
- 21:48divide. On one side, we have the post -traumatic
- 21:50theory. Okay, what does that argue? This theory
- 21:52posits a specific mechanism. DD alters, or different
- 21:56personalities, develop as an extreme psychological
- 21:59coping mechanism in response to severe, inescapable
- 22:02childhood trauma. So the brain splinters to protect
- 22:05itself. Yes, exactly. It's a biological and psychological
- 22:07defense mechanism. And on the other side, we
- 22:09have the socio -cognitive theory, which suggests
- 22:12a completely different mechanism. What's the
- 22:15argument there? It argues that patients are highly
- 22:18aware of the cultural features of the disorder.
- 22:21Maybe they saw it portrayed dramatically in the
- 22:23media. and they are inadvertently encouraged
- 22:25or socially reinforced to exhibit those specific
- 22:29symptoms by highly suggestible therapeutic practices.
- 22:32Wow. Those are vastly different interpretations
- 22:35of the exact same phenomenon. Night and day.
- 22:38One is rooted in a biological defense mechanism
- 22:40against trauma. The other is rooted in social
- 22:43suggestion and role play. So how do scientists
- 22:46decide which one is right? They have to weigh
- 22:49the evidence generated by the research. And looking
- 22:52at the sources, there are several compelling
- 22:54lines of evidence that heavily support the sociocognitive
- 22:57model. Like what? For instance, the massive spike
- 22:59in DDD diagnoses didn't happen randomly. It happened
- 23:03right after the release of the wildly popular
- 23:05book and subsequent film, Sybil. Oh, which highly
- 23:08popularized and dramatized the concept of multiple
- 23:11personalities to the general public. Right. And
- 23:13to build on that cultural point, the sources
- 23:15note that if D were purely a universal biological
- 23:19trauma response, we would expect to see it diagnosed
- 23:22relatively evenly across the globe wherever trauma
- 23:25exists. Because trauma is universal. Exactly.
- 23:28But the epidemiological data shows the disorder
- 23:31is almost exclusively confined to North America,
- 23:34which strongly points to a cultural sociocognitive
- 23:37influence. Right. And what about the clinical
- 23:39data? So the clinical data showed that a very
- 23:41tiny percentage of therapists were responsible
- 23:44for diagnosing the vast majority of DD cases.
- 23:47Wait, really? Just a few therapists? Yeah. It
- 23:50wasn't spread evenly among mental health professionals.
- 23:53It was clustered around a few practitioners who
- 23:55likely used highly suggestive hypnosis techniques.
- 23:58Which makes perfect sense when you consider the
- 24:00laboratory evidence. Experiments like those conducted
- 24:03by Nicholas Spanos have shown that even every
- 24:05day, normal people without any history of severe
- 24:08trauma can perfectly recreate these specific
- 24:11alter symptoms. Just from suggestion? Yeah, if
- 24:13they are given just a little bit of suggestion
- 24:16and role -play direction in a simulated therapy
- 24:18setting. When you lay it out like that, strictly
- 24:21from the sources, it's clear how the socio -cognitive
- 24:24theory just organizes the data so much better.
- 24:26Having multiple theories doesn't mean that anything
- 24:29goes in psychology or that it's all just a matter
- 24:32of subjective opinion. Not at all. Scientists
- 24:35rigorously and constantly compare competing theories
- 24:37based on those three purposes we discussed. How
- 24:40elegantly do they organize the data using Occam's
- 24:43razor? Exactly. How accurately do they predict
- 24:47new outcomes? And how effectively do they generate
- 24:50fruitful new research? The theories that fail
- 24:53those rigorous tests are eventually abandoned.
- 24:56The strong ones survive. Okay, my brain is officially
- 24:58full, so let's recap our study session. Let's
- 25:00do it. We have successfully learned to separate
- 25:02the phenomena from the theories. Phenomena are
- 25:06the observable facts, the physical realities
- 25:08we can measure, the physical facts. Like the
- 25:10fact that blind individuals can still react to
- 25:13movement, or that the placebo effect works. And
- 25:16theories are the unseen mechanisms, the frameworks
- 25:18that explain why those facts happen, the thoughts
- 25:21and threads. We learned that theories organize
- 25:24our chaotic world, they make predictions about
- 25:26the future, and they spark the next big questions.
- 25:31perfectly fine and actually necessary to have
- 25:35multiple theories battling it out in the arena
- 25:37of science to find the truth. It is truly the
- 25:40only way we move the boundary of human knowledge
- 25:43forward. And I want to leave you, the listener,
- 25:45with a final thought to mull over. Well, yeah,
- 25:47on us. Next time you observe a reliable pattern
- 25:50in your own life, maybe you notice that your
- 25:52friends always seem to argue when they are hungry,
- 25:54or you realize you consistently feel anxious
- 25:57when you walk into one specific room in your
- 25:59house. ask yourself a question. Okay. Are you
- 26:02just passively observing a phenomenon or have
- 26:05you quietly built a personal theory to explain
- 26:07it? That's good. And more importantly, if you
- 26:10apply Occam's razor, is your personal theory
- 26:12actually the simplest explanation or is it time
- 26:15to abandon it and build a better one? I love
- 26:17that. Time to go test some personal theories
- 26:19using parsimony. Thank you all so much for joining
- 26:21us for this deep dive into the foundations of
- 26:23psychology. Catch you next time.