Latest / Teach Me to Father / Why Sensationalism in Church Attracts - Part 1
Transcript
- 0:00We are in trouble, my friend.
- 0:02We are in deep, deep, deep trouble, and it's gonna get us,
- 0:08and if it's not already gotten us
- 0:12W- it's a fight to keep it away from us.
- 0:14It's a fight to keep it out of our lives, our homes, and our community of faith.
- 0:19In fact, we're already inhibited with it.
- 0:22It's sensationalism.
- 0:24We're in trouble.
- 0:26This is Barry with FatherSeekers.
- 0:28This is the podcast Teaching You to Father, Restoring Fatherhood
- 0:31to Original Design, Reconciling Men to the Fatherhood of God.
- 0:46Here's the question.
- 0:48I want you to grab this.
- 0:50Are we stewarding the senses in the service of truth?
- 0:55Hearing, seeing, tasting, our senses in the service of truth for
- 1:01the sake of the kingdom, or are we using senses to manufacture the
- 1:05appearance of spiritual reality?
- 1:10I've been in a deep dive on this thing for months now, and I wanna tell you that we
- 1:14are in significant and serious trouble.
- 1:18Sensationalism is inescapable.
- 1:20It is omnipresent.
- 1:23I want you to focus on this, this really tight field that we're talking about today
- 1:27with this, not all over the board, not everywhere, not, not all over creation,
- 1:32but I want, I wanna fine-tune it down to that, and here's what I'm talking about.
- 1:38Sensationalism in your life, your family's life, and in your community of faith.
- 1:44Th- that's the cluster we're gonna talk about.
- 1:47We're gonna move fast.
- 1:48I've got a lot to share with you.
- 1:49Some of it I'm gonna read because I don't wanna mess it up because
- 1:52it is absolutely mind-blowing.
- 1:56And if you never studied sensationalism, you should because you're
- 2:00already addicted to it probably.
- 2:04Some of you are not 'cause you, you, you're just not 'cause you don't
- 2:07buy the, you don't buy the Kool-Aid.
- 2:11Um, back home we would say you can smell the chicken litter on that one.
- 2:16Okay, here we go.
- 2:18Sensationalism is attractive for reason
- 2:24It's addictive.
- 2:26It works on the body before it reaches the mind, and it works on the crowds
- 2:30faster than it does the individual.
- 2:33Listen to that
- 2:36Emotion is contagious by design.
- 2:39Psychologist Elaine Hatfield, John Cacioppo, and Richard Rapson defined
- 2:44emotional contagion as the tendency to automatically mimic and synchronize
- 2:50facial expressions, vocalizations, postures, movements with those of
- 2:55another person's, and consequently to, to converge emotionally
- 3:05The process runs in three stages: mimicry, feedback, and contagion.
- 3:11A man can catch a room's emotion without even evaluating whether
- 3:14the room is right or it's wrong
- 3:19We're in trouble.
- 3:21Okay, here's, here's how in trouble we are
- 3:29I saw a pastor of a church of 10-- this week, 10,000 people plus with campuses.
- 3:37He drove a Rolls-Royce coupe on stage.
- 3:39He got out and he did this analogy about, uh, Christ needs to be driving
- 3:47your car, your life, and he, he was making the argument about it being
- 3:53foolish and mimicry and over the top, driving a, a Rolls-Royce on stage.
- 4:00And he says, "If, if the communicator at your church is boring you
- 4:06and it's not entertaining, then it's not a good church."
- 4:14Hmm, no
- 4:18Here we go, more.
- 4:20Music reaches the brain's reward system directly.
- 4:25A study in nature neuroscience found that music and abstract stimulus can arouse
- 4:32feelings of euphoria, craving similar tangible rewards with eq- equitable
- 4:39and similar to dopamine released at peak emotional moments and distinct
- 4:45dopamine during anticipation of the peak.
- 4:50The buildup is its own reward.
- 4:54Here's more.
- 4:56Moving together bonds people, and it can help make them,
- 5:01make… I can't even say this.
- 5:04It makes them compliant
- 5:09Moving together bonds people and it, it can also make them compliant
- 5:23Oxford researchers note that synchronization is an important
- 5:27mechanism by which social bonding can occur, and that music-making by w- by--
- 5:33and which involves sensory overload physically activity-- physical activity,
- 5:40strong emotional arousal, and social behavior is especially suited to it.
- 5:46USC researcher Scott Wiltermuth went further.
- 5:51His studies found that synchrony can boost compliance and obedience, concluding
- 5:57that synchrony can not only be used for good, but also as a tool to promote evil,
- 6:04and noting that the marching and the chanting are still used in political and
- 6:09religious rallies to influence people
- 6:17I've been in churches that do this
- 6:28And there's more.
- 6:30The culture's already moved from being to appearing.
- 6:35Being to appearing
- 6:39Christ calls us to be, not to appear
- 6:47Okay
- 6:50The culture has already moved from being to appearing.
- 6:52Guy Debord's 1967 critique still names our moment.
- 6:56The spectac- the spectacle is not a collection of images.
- 7:01Rather, it is a social relationship between people that is mediated by image.
- 7:08Neil Postman applied that same concern is for the church.
- 7:14When we present religion as nothing different from a Broadway
- 7:18show, I think it trivializes and corrupts the religious experience
- 7:26If you go to a church that does this, you need to run
- 7:33run and take your family
- 7:39We'll talk a, we'll talk more.
- 7:41I'm not saying don't be emotional.
- 7:43I'm not saying don't respond physically.
- 7:45I'm saying that there is a thing that's crept into our culture
- 7:49and our churches and our homes
- 7:53into our own personal life, your life and our home, our kids, our wives.
- 7:57And it's on this little box that we carry around with us
- 8:04Let's keep going.
- 8:06So, so I wanna throw some terms out to you, and I want to, I want to
- 8:11introduce you to this idea, this concept, if you're not aware of it.
- 8:14If you are aware and you've got feedback, hit me up on the bottom
- 8:18or email me and let's talk.
- 8:20Here is a term, I wanna give you what it means, and then I wanna give
- 8:23you the biblical parallel to it.
- 8:26Spiritual spectacularism, seeking spectacular as evidence
- 8:28that something spiritual
- 8:33has happened
- 8:37Here's what Jesus said, "An evil and adulterous generation seeks for a
- 8:41sign, but no sign will be given to it except the sign of the prophet Jonah."
- 8:48Listen, I'm not hammering churches.
- 8:51I've been a churchman for… This is the 39th year.
- 8:58I've been vocationally engaged in churches for 39 years, so I'm not slamming.
- 9:08I'm raising an alarm because what's crept into our lives as
- 9:12dads and husbands and fathers
- 9:18is creeping into the church by default because we are not attacking
- 9:22it in our homes and our kids are not recognizing it in the church
- 9:29Spiritual sensationalism, amplifying extraordinary stories and
- 9:33manifestations to provoke a response.
- 9:36In other words, infatuation, inf- in- inf- inflating and
- 9:42lying, just lying about stuff.
- 9:45I have seen it and I've heard it
- 9:50And stretching the truth a little bit to get them a, a manipulative response
- 9:54from people because you can manipulate them with guilt and music and song.
- 9:59What about your kids?
- 10:01What are they looking at on social
- 10:05What about your wife?
- 10:06What is she looking at on social?
- 10:10Whether we engage or not, we are being subject to it by exposure
- 10:18Herod was hoping to see some sign from Jesus to prove he was Messiah, and maybe
- 10:25that would've influenced Her- Herod's
- 10:28decision.
- 10:30But Jesus gave him no answer
- 10:34Engineered encounters.
- 10:36If I have heard this one time, I've heard it one million
- 10:39times, that we have to create an atmosphere for people to respond.
- 10:44Bull
- 10:48Bull stuff.
- 10:50No.
- 10:52Arranging sensory and emotional conditions to produce a perceived encounter with God.
- 10:57Nabat- Nadab and Abihu offered unauthorized fire before the Lord,
- 11:02which He commanded… He did not command the fire to be burned, and
- 11:06He killed them in, in, in place.
- 11:11I'm telling you, there's a reckoning coming, not just to us as men in our
- 11:15personal life because we love sensation, sensationalism, spectacularism.
- 11:20It all leads to sensuality.
- 11:24That's where it leads to, and if it's in us, it's in our
- 11:27wives and it's in our kids.
- 11:29And probably it's in our churches because we are not pushing back
- 11:33against it because we like it, and we don't wanna buck the system
- 11:39Is this hard, straightforward, tough?
- 11:41Yes.
- 11:43Yes.
- 11:44Yes
- 11:47Yes
- 11:52Atmospheric spirituality depending on music, mood, lighting, and crowd
- 11:57to generate the spiritual feeling.
- 12:00Having, having, having the appearance of godliness but denying the
- 12:06power, it may look good and it may appear to be godly because people
- 12:12wouldn't know God if he walked in the room, but it sure feels good.
- 12:16Have you ever heard somebody… I heard this growing up all my life.
- 12:19You ever heard somebody say, "Oh, oh bro, we had church today"?
- 12:22You know what?
- 12:23You didn't have-
- 12:27They're ran around like a bunch of dancing bears and a bunch of dancing fools.
- 12:31Listen, nobody loves emotion in church more than me.
- 12:34Nobody loves to see people weeping and crying and bent down at an
- 12:39altar encountering God face to… Nobody loves that more than me.
- 12:45But nobody hates more than me to see people be manipulated by,
- 12:50by other church leaders, pastors
- 12:57who are trying to get an emotional response.
- 13:01Now, pause.
- 13:03Most, most pastors, th- they were trained to respond and to do that.
- 13:11My problem is not that they were trained, my problem is that they
- 13:18believed it and never checked it out.
- 13:22My pro- And I've, I've done it.
- 13:24I've fallen prey to it.
- 13:28I used to think that if we could get kids, as a youth pastor and a, and a district
- 13:32youth director for the Assemblies of God, if we could just get kids in the right
- 13:35moment in, in the, in the convention or in the youth meeting, if we could just,
- 13:41if we could just set the atmosphere to
- 13:45may be good intention, but ill effect.
- 13:49It's not good
- 13:54I'll talk about it later, but it, it's called the law of diminishing returns.
- 13:57If you do a little now to get a little now, then you're gonna have to do a little
- 14:01more later to get a little more later
- 14:05Let's keep moving.
- 14:06Ex- experientialism, letting experience become the primary
- 14:09test of spiritual truth.
- 14:12The scripture says in 1 John, "Test the spirits. Test everything."
- 14:18Does it compare to scripture?
- 14:19Does it coincide?
- 14:21Does it agree with scripture?
- 14:24Is it truthful?
- 14:30Effective manipulation is another one.
- 14:33Stimulating emotion in order to steer belief and behavior or response.
- 14:39Paul's message was not in plausible words of wisdom so that your faith
- 14:44might not rest in the wisdom of men, but in the power of God.
- 14:49It is not fake and foolery to get people to respond to God.
- 14:53He, the, the, the, the God does not need your help.
- 15:02He has the Holy Spirit and His Son who did the work
- 15:09The sinless life, born of a virgin, death, burial, resurrection,
- 15:12and now sits at the right.
- 15:13He does not need your help.
- 15:15He does not need my help.
- 15:18He needs us to focus and keep things Christocentric, centered
- 15:22upon Christ, so that we may hear the gospel, and that we may be changed,
- 15:28and that we may be different than ever be- we will never return.
- 15:34Spiritual entertainment, I've touched on that already.
- 15:38If we can entertain people, we can get them to come back
- 15:44Synchronizing people.
- 15:46Here's the danger, here's the manipulation, and here's the coercion.
- 15:50And I've seen it.
- 15:51I've seen it happen.
- 15:52I've been in the room when it's happened, and it is diabolic,
- 15:56di- diabolical and demonic.
- 15:59Synchronizing people emotionally and behaviorally through
- 16:04rhythm, repetition, and cadence.
- 16:08I've seen it happen.
- 16:11It's demonic
- 16:15You will never find another guy who loves worship more than the
- 16:18one you're looking at right now.
- 16:22You won't find him.
- 16:23You won't find a guy who loves to yield corporately to the presence
- 16:30of Holy Spirit when He is working corporately in a room with everyone.
- 16:36He does not need to be manipulated.
- 16:38He does not need to be coerced.
- 16:39He does not need to be convinced
- 16:43He is God, the third person of the Trinity.
- 16:46He does not need us
- 16:51So why would we manipulate?
- 16:54The scripture says that the spirits of the prophet are subject to
- 16:56the prophet, for God is not a God of confusion, but of peace.
- 17:03Here's some contrast.
- 17:04Here's, here's manipulation and sens- sensuality and sensationalism and
- 17:10spectacularism and, and enthusiastic, bombastic bombs bursting in air,
- 17:15rockets' red flare kind of foolishness.
- 17:19Here's what we manufacture.
- 17:21Here's what God says.
- 17:22Here's what He produces.
- 17:24We-- Okay, spectacle versus substance.
- 17:29Stimulation versus formation.
- 17:32Sensation versus sanctification.
- 17:35You seeing the different?
- 17:37Excitement versus obedience.
- 17:38Experience versus truth.
- 17:40Atmosphere versus presence.
- 17:43Emotional response versus spiritual transformation
- 17:50How many people have gone into a church, had an amazing experience,
- 17:55perhaps influenced and experienced, uh, an encounter with the Holy Spirit?
- 18:05But with all the other fluff and mess going on, they walk out the
- 18:08door and three hours later, with a little bit of challenge and pushback,
- 18:13there's no emotion, there's no high, there's no instruction or
- 18:18fallback to what scripture says.
- 18:20There's no, there's no obedience to difficult times.
- 18:25There's this experience I remember and this emotion I had.
- 18:29I want every day to be like that.
- 18:32No manufactured momentum.
- 18:37I've been in so many services over the years.
- 18:39I can't even tell you how people have tried to manufacture energy
- 18:47I tell you, my friend, if you're in a church like that, you need to run.
- 18:50You need to run, run, and get out.
- 18:53You need to find so- you need to find a better church.
- 18:57If you feel a little manipulated, and I'm not just talking about
- 19:00giving money, come on, man, grow up.
- 19:02Come on.
- 19:04We're supposed to contribute to the, to the faith.
- 19:06We're s- we're supposed to contribute to community of faith.
- 19:09I'm talking about being m- manipulated and being, having manufactured momentum
- 19:17versus Holy Spirit conviction, crowd synchronization versus Christian
- 19:22communion, consumption versus stewardship, the fantastic versus the real.
- 19:32Most of us are so far sucked into the, to the sensational funnel that we wouldn't
- 19:38know real if it smacked us in the nose.
- 19:42The larger movement underneath all of this is spectacularism of spirituality.
- 19:49Truth becomes spectacle.
- 19:51Formation becomes stimulation.
- 19:53Discipleship becomes experience.
- 19:56Participation becomes consumption.
- 20:00Reverence becomes excitement.
- 20:02Conviction becomes emotional response, and presence becomes atmosphere
- 20:14If you don't think we're in trouble, I would encourage you to, to go back
- 20:18and restart this or really pray.
- 20:22And I w- I will tell you, this is probably the most convicting
- 20:27message I've ever seen, but I've s- uh, uh, uh, ever dropped.
- 20:30B- but I'm telling you, I've spent the last two-plus years investigating
- 20:33this, investigating my own faith, not falling away from Christ, not
- 20:38denying Him, not believing Him as Savior, not believing that there's a
- 20:41Trinity, third person, Holy Spirit, Hashim, Yahweh, Elohim, God the Father.
- 20:48I've not faltered on that, but I have sure faltered on some of the theology
- 20:52that I've learned over the years in the foolishness in churches, in the
- 20:56charismatic Pentecostal churches.
- 20:59Now, if you wanna know my background, I was raised Southern Baptist,
- 21:03but ordained and reared and, and educated in the Assemblies of God.
- 21:08Love the Assemblies of God.
- 21:11Love them
- 21:14They got problems right now, but so does everybody.
- 21:17But we're not talking about them.
- 21:19We're talking about you, we're talking about me, we're talking
- 21:21about our families, and we're talking about our community of faith.
- 21:25That's what we're talking about.
- 21:27We can get so distracted with what's going on way over here and way over
- 21:31there that we forget what's going on right here, and our kids are grown
- 21:35and out the door and in college, and then that's where the real war starts,
- 21:40'cause that's where all the crap hits the fan for them to be challenged
- 21:43in their faith and their belief.
- 21:46Now, what is it that sensationalism does to a man?
- 21:51It trains him to measure God by intensity
- 21:59This, this was proven all false and upside down in the Great Awakening.
- 22:06Jonathan Edwards, who pastored through the Great Awakening, wrote this.
- 22:09He said, "It is no sign one way or the other that religious affections are very
- 22:16great or raised very high, or no sign that they have great effects on the body.
- 22:22Intensity proves nothing either way." Jonathan Edwards
- 22:31Boom, mic drop.
- 22:32He didn't have one, but mic drop.
- 22:36Here's another concept I did.
- 22:38It produces, sensationally pr- produces hearers who enjoy
- 22:42the word without doing it
- 22:47You know, church conferences, religious conferences with all the big dogs
- 22:53Multi-billion, B, billion dollar industry a year
- 23:09Wake up, McFly.
- 23:13We have to guard our hearts as men.
- 23:15We have to guard the hearts of our homes.
- 23:20We have to guard the hearts of our community of faith.
- 23:25That is my argument.
- 23:26That is my fight today, not the rest of the world.
- 23:31Spectacularism produces hearers who enjoy the word without doing it.
- 23:38Enough said, man.
- 23:40Here's another one.
- 23:41It makes him a consumer.
- 23:44What does sensationalism do to a man?
- 23:46It makes a man a consumer of Jesus rather than a disciple, a talmidim,
- 23:52the Greek word for disciple, talmidim.
- 23:55I'm sorry, Hebrew word.
- 23:59Or Greek.
- 24:00It's, it's disciple, talmidim.
- 24:02So what I'm saying to you is, is that we can fall into this trap of
- 24:07seeking experience and emotional bump.
- 24:10Here's the danger.
- 24:13Here's one.
- 24:15Most of us fatherless fathers are wrecked in some or most parts of our emotions.
- 24:22What is it that we look for that's healthy and beneficial, that we want
- 24:27to have healthy experiences with?
- 24:31Good spiritual in- interchange, good spiritual exchange
- 24:37with what we think is God.
- 24:39I've seen more people get off track emotionally, who are broken emotionally,
- 24:45and they begin to seek experience, and then they fall away from the faith,
- 24:48and they fall away from the Father.
- 24:50Because when you walk with Him, and you hear His voice, and you get up at
- 24:565:00, 4:30, 3:00 in the morning and you seek Him, there's no emotion in that
- 25:04Now, the guys I run with
- 25:08Nobody likes to get up at 4:00 or 30 or 5:00, but we're excited about getting
- 25:13up and searching scriptures and reading and praying, but it's still difficult.
- 25:19What I'm saying to you is sensationalism builds into us this,
- 25:22this loose, uh, soft, shallow, experiential relationship with God.
- 25:30And as you know, it's, it's not soft, it's not shallow.
- 25:35In fact, that's how many people fall away.
- 25:38Sensationalism makes a man a consumer of Jesus rather than a disciple.
- 25:44Couldn't say that more enough.
- 25:46It leaves him defenseless against counterfeit power.
- 25:49Now, here's the other reason I'm on this trumpet, on this alarm.
- 25:54We are certainly closer to the end of time than we were when you and
- 25:59I were born or we were coming up.
- 26:01So, so there's that alarm system.
- 26:05The second alarm system is this, is that if we are not locked in, the scripture
- 26:11says, Paul says, Timothy says, Peter says, that in the last days, many will
- 26:17fall away because they were deceived
- 26:22If I am walking with Christ, if, if the Holy Spirit is engaging
- 26:27with me and I him each day
- 26:32Then I'm not gonna be deceived because He is speaking to me.
- 26:35I know His voice, and I'm not going to be sidetracked with difficulty, hard times,
- 26:39or turmoil, or problems, or martyrdom.
- 26:45I'm not gonna be afraid because I know His voice, and I know one bre- my last
- 26:49breath here is my first breath there.
- 26:52So we won't be deceived, but what about our kids?
- 26:55What about our brothers?
- 26:56What about our wives?
- 26:57What about our family?
- 26:59We have to fight this battle against sensationalism about truth.
- 27:04Now, again, you will never find a guy who loves to have the opportunity to stand
- 27:11corporately with 100 or 10,000 and have genuine, legitimate worship of Christ.
- 27:18Ne- you will not find a guy who loves it more.
- 27:22You won't find it.
- 27:23He's right here
- 27:27But sensationalism and spectacularism and things being fantastic and bombs bursting
- 27:33in there today, every day's gotta be huge.
- 27:35It's gotta be big.
- 27:36We're gonna win big today
- 27:41That's the world, bro.
- 27:43That's the, that's the world
- 27:46A man who is stuck on sensationalism will be deceived in the end
- 27:52And he will be one of those who stand before Jesus, and Jesus says,
- 27:58"I do not know you." And they will say to him in that day, "Lord, Lord,
- 28:02did we not do this in your name?
- 28:04Did we not prophesy?
- 28:05Did we not do all these things?" And he said, "Depart from me.
- 28:09I never knew you." That's the end result of sensationalism.
- 28:15That is the drumbeat I beat this day.
- 28:18I never knew you
- 28:28Mm. The worst words in the universe
- 28:38I'm skipping a bunch.
- 28:40I'm, I'm dro- I'm landing
- 28:48Here's a scenario right here.
- 28:50So your, your, your son goes to a retreat and he comes home
- 28:59And he says, "Dad, it was great, man.
- 29:03It felt so great, the music, the people preaching, the dude preach--
- 29:07I gave my heart to the Lord
- 29:15A few days later, it's back to the same and he says, "Man, I wished I, I wished
- 29:19every day could be like Saturday night."
- 29:26What I'm saying to you is this, there, there is either,
- 29:31there is, there is this idea of
- 29:36I'm certainly glad you had an encounter with the God, son, but there's
- 29:40more to it than the feeling and the emotion, not to discredit the ex-
- 29:44experience that he had with the Lord.
- 29:48But perhaps, like many of us, he's equated that experience to the feeling
- 29:52and the emotion, and he falls away
- 29:57You see, we have to teach our families
- 30:01That, that, that coming to Christ is about formation, being reformed, being changed.
- 30:12It will be difficult.
- 30:14It will be challenging because there's no one that likes us, likes to hear no
- 30:19more than us, more than saying no to our-- more than becoming like Christ.
- 30:26That is not a fun feeling sometimes
- 30:34I will never get through this, so there's gonna be a part two.
- 30:37I hope you like it.
- 30:39This is Barry with Father Seekers.
- 30:40Hey, if you've enjoyed it today, you found it beneficial, like, share, subscribe,
- 30:46push it out, help us get the word out, and most certainly, if you've enjoyed it,
- 30:52you wanna be a part of this, link below.
- 30:55Support us monthly.
- 30:56We would love it.
- 30:58It's costing us a little bit to get this out on all the platforms
- 31:01right now, so we need your help.
- 31:04We need your help.
- 31:04Link below.
- 31:05Click it.
- 31:06This is Barry with Father Seekers.
- 31:08This is the podcast, Teach Me to Father.
- 31:10Go get 'em, man.
- 31:11You can do this