Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / God & Horrendous Suffering
Transcript
- 0:01A semio the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheists in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the
- 0:19truth, it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand
- 0:23on a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian
- 0:32wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and
- 0:39start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. A
- 0:56friend and fellow activist John W. Loftis Jess reached out to me a few
- 1:00days ago. He had published kind of a distilled down version of a book
- 1:07that he released in November of twenty twenty one. The books called God and
- 1:11Horrendous Suffering, kind of a deep dive into what we call the problem of
- 1:18evil. I like to call the problem of needless suffering. John would call
- 1:22it horrendous suffering. And it's a good problem to bring up, because when
- 1:27you and I engage with these sort of blank eyed, happy clappy Christians who
- 1:33say God is good all the time. He is perfectly just and omni benevolent.
- 1:38Right, Everything happens for a reason. And then you and I ask
- 1:41reasonable questions. We're like, well, hang on just a second. Twenty
- 1:45five thousand people are going to starve to death today. I think they might
- 1:49take issue with the bumper sticker on your car that says God is good all
- 1:55the time. Jesus never fails. We've got war and famine and disease,
- 2:00natural disasters and corruption and just horrible stuff happening all the time. This does
- 2:05not seem like a master blueprint by a perfect creator. And then often we
- 2:12will see the casual believer kind of drift into these conversation stoppers. You know,
- 2:16well, free will, it's a fallen world. Free will, it's
- 2:20a fallen world. Or worse. When you talk to apologists, they get
- 2:23into how God uses evil for his own glory. Well, you know,
- 2:28in order for God to be good, you have to have something to contrast
- 2:30the good with, so God kind of needs evil. As it says in
- 2:35the Book of Isaiah, right, God created evil. Why would a good
- 2:38God create evil? I remember this was way back when my channel first started.
- 2:44I guess it's been fourteen years. One of the first videos I ever
- 2:49produced was called The Story of Susie, and the character of Susie spent her
- 2:54Christian lying with their hands to the sky, thanking and praising God for his
- 2:59goodness. Says, planes were falling out of the sky and her grandma gets
- 3:02hit by a car. Just just shit's going down all around her, and
- 3:07she's like, praise Jesus, Praise Jesus. Right, Christianity Today, I
- 3:13think it was. Christianity Today did a feature on me and the Story of
- 3:19Susy video when it released. Now, strangely, they weren't able to get
- 3:24a hold of me to participate in the piece, even though I'm a public
- 3:30figure online, my website, my emails, they were all right there,
- 3:34no, no. The author of the piece couldn't get a hold of me,
- 3:38but she was able to get comment from a Christian apologist, a guy
- 3:43named Norman Geisler. So he shows up and he says this. He says,
- 3:49well, in order for us to know what a straight line looks like,
- 3:53we have to know what a crooked line looks like. So God allows
- 3:59the crooked line so that the straight line will make moral sense. This is
- 4:05like the kind of crap that you and I hear all the time. Geisler
- 4:10wrote a whole article this decades ago on the problem of evil. He titled
- 4:15the article God, Evil and Dispensations. It's a very lofty piece, lot
- 4:20of big words, and he says kind of the same stuff. God doesn't
- 4:24really get glory from evil, but when evil happens, the fact that he
- 4:30allowed free will to produce evil, that will bring glory to God. He
- 4:38talks about Paul in the New Testament, saying that we exalt in our tribulations
- 4:44because tribulations bring about perseverance, which prove character, which bring hope. That's
- 4:49out of the Book of Romans Tewod Corinthians four seventeen. For momentary light affliction
- 4:58is producing for us in it weight of glory, far beyond comparison. In
- 5:04my first book, d Converted, I was I think I did a whole
- 5:08section on this. I'm like, what is considered light and momentary affliction in
- 5:13the eyes of the apologist? Child leukemia, people losing their arms and legs
- 5:19in horrible car crashes tsunamis that wipe out a quarter of a million people in
- 5:27US single day. I'm sorry, momentary light affliction, somebody qualify that,
- 5:31well, you have to have the crooked line. Seth. That crooked line
- 5:38helps us know that God made the straight line. Essay. Of course,
- 5:42the Book of Isaiah says that God created evil. Right, God created all
- 5:47things, This must include evil. I'm going on and on and on.
- 5:51Anyway, back to my original point. John Loftis has distilled the book down
- 5:58into some major points, and I think these will be useful to you and
- 6:01me in our own conversations, and we need to be talking more about this
- 6:06specific counter apologetic and he asked if I would voice it to do an audio
- 6:13version so that people had the option to listen instead of reading. And I
- 6:16asked John for permission to read it for you here on the podcast now,
- 6:25because I don't want to interrupt the piece once we get started. Let me
- 6:28take a short break right here, and I will come back and read for
- 6:32you the article. The text version is linked in the description box God and
- 6:39Horrendous Suffering. I'll do it next, Okay, as promised, allow me
- 6:49to read for you uninterrupted this piece. It's about thirty seven minutes long.
- 6:57I think it raises a lot of good points. It will benefit you in
- 7:00the conversations you are having out there God and horrendous Suffering. First published in
- 7:10the Trinity Journal of Natural and Philosophical Theology in the spring of twenty twenty three.
- 7:19The evidential problem of horrendous suffering is one of the most powerful refutations of
- 7:26the theistic God as can be found. If there's an omni everything God,
- 7:31one who is omni benevolent or perfectly good, omniscient or all knowing and omnipotent
- 7:40or all powerful, the issue of why there is horrendous suffering in the world
- 7:46requires an explanation. The reason is that a perfectly good God would want to
- 7:51eliminate it, an all knowing God would know how to eliminate it, and
- 7:57an all powerful God would be a to eliminate it. So the extent of
- 8:01horrendis suffering means that either God does not care enough to eliminate it, or
- 8:09God is not smart enough to eliminate it, or God is not powerful enough
- 8:13to eliminate it. The stubborn fact of horrendus suffering means something is wrong with
- 8:20God's goodness, his knowledge, or his ability. Just think of this in
- 8:26terms of who has the greatest moral obligation to help someone who is suffering.
- 8:31It's the person who knows of the suffering, who cares the most to alleviate
- 8:37it, and who has the greatest ability to alleviate it. Therefore, the
- 8:41person who has the greatest obligation to alleviate horrendous suffering is a theistic omni good.
- 8:50If he exists, anyone who is wholly good would be morally obligated to
- 8:56prevent horrendous suffering, especially if all all it would take was a snap of
- 9:01the fingers. There are two categories of horrendous suffering that must be adequately explained
- 9:07by apologists. For God. One moral evils that is suffering caused by the
- 9:16choices of moral agents. Examples include the Holocaust, the atomic obliteration of Hiroshima
- 9:22and Nagasaki, terrorist beheadings, childhood molestation, torture, slavery, gang rapes,
- 9:31wars, and so on. Then there's two natural evils that is suffering
- 9:37caused by natural disasters. Examples include pandemics, tsunamis, hurricanes, tornadoes,
- 9:46volcanic eruptions, droughts, earthquakes, massive wildfires, and so on, Including
- 9:52the enormous suffering caused by the kill or be killed law of predation. In
- 9:58the animal kingdom, there are several levels of suffering, stretching from mere hunger
- 10:03pangs to the horrors of the Holocaust. But we don't need to determine the
- 10:09exact demarcation point when the suffering becomes too horrific for an omni everything God,
- 10:16or the greater the suffering is, then the greater the problem of evil is
- 10:20for an omni good. My focus is on horrendous suffering, the kind that
- 10:26turns our stomachs. It's the best kind of suffering to test the probability of
- 10:33a good God. If believers cannot solve this problem except by focusing on hypothetical
- 10:39possibilities rather than on probabilities, or by punting to ignorance by saying God's ways
- 10:48are above ours, then that God has allowed more suffering in the world than
- 10:52is reasonable for reasonable people to accept. Surely, a God who created reasonable
- 10:58peace people should provide what reasonable people need if he wants us to believe.
- 11:05If we think exclusively in terms of probabilities, the more horrendous suffering that exists,
- 11:11the less probable an omni everything God exists. And there is too much
- 11:18horrendous suffering for God to exist. In legal terms, the theistic omni good
- 11:24could easily be convicted of the crime of depraved indifference. This is when a
- 11:31defendant's conduct is so wanton, so deficient of concerns, so lacking in regard
- 11:37for the lives of others, and so blameworthy that it warrants the same criminal
- 11:43liability imposed upon the person who intentionally causes the crime. The strength of the
- 11:50problem of horrendous suffering depends on one's religious views. It's much greater for evangelicals
- 11:58who believe in a God who is spired the horrific tales of the Bible,
- 12:03including sending people into an eternal conscious torment in hell. So apologists like William
- 12:11Lane Craig have said, the problem of evil is certainly the greatest obstacle to
- 12:16belief in the existence of God. When I ponder both the extent and depth
- 12:22of suffering in the world, whether due to man's inhumanity to man or to
- 12:28natural disasters, then I must confess that I find it hard to believe that
- 12:33God exists. Apologist James Sennet echoed what Craig said. He said, by
- 12:39far, the most important objection to the faith is the so called problem of
- 12:45evil. I tell my philosophy of religion students that if they are Christians and
- 12:50the problem of evil does not keep them up at night, then they don't
- 12:54understand it. The strength of this problem is perhaps the greatest for Calvinists who
- 13:01believe in theological determinism as opposed to non Calvinists who believe in free will,
- 13:09but every believer faces this problem. Pantheists believe suffering is an illusion or maya,
- 13:18but they cannot avoid suffering throughout their lives. For polytheists, their multiple
- 13:24gods aren't powerful enough to decisively overcome suffering and are believed to cause much of
- 13:31it. Process theologians like John B. Cobb and David Ray Griffin believe their
- 13:37God can't force free willed agents to do good. Their God can only persuade
- 13:43people to do good. But given the fact of horrendous suffering, such a
- 13:50God as shown to be useless in the face of natural disasters and powerless when
- 13:56it comes to the choices of liars, thieves, molesters, rapists, kidnappers,
- 14:01and killers who refuse to be persuaded. For protest theologians like John Roth,
- 14:07God's continual inaction must mean God is directly responsible for the suffering in the
- 14:13world. Their response should be to protest the lack of divine action, in
- 14:20hopes that publicly shaming him will goad God into doing good. For deists,
- 14:26suffering has little force, but only because they already admit there God is an
- 14:31absentee slum landlord of a world that should be condemned as unsafe for habitation.
- 14:39Then there are the misotheists from the Greek word messaiah to hate, who hate
- 14:46God. Their view is a moral position, not a stance on the existence
- 14:52of God. For them, it's immoral to praise and worship any moral monster,
- 14:58including a divine one, real or conceptually held in the minds of believers,
- 15:05so scorn, mockery, and rebellion against religious authorities are their appropriate responses.
- 15:13By contrast, for atheists who don't believe any God exists, the fact
- 15:18of horrendis suffering is not an intellectual problem at all. Suffering, even horrendous
- 15:24suffering, is what we expect to find in a world that evolved by natural
- 15:30selection. Let's turn now to consider four moral concerns that an omni good should
- 15:37have considered when creating a world. Suppose a perfectly good deity exists who didn't
- 15:43need or want anything, yet decided for some mysterious reason to create a world
- 15:50to test free creatures. Okay, then such a deity should have four moral
- 15:58concerns. The first moral concern for God would be that we don't abuse the
- 16:03freedom given to us. The giver of a gift is blameworthy if he or
- 16:11she knowingly gives gifts to people who will terribly abuse them. Any parent who
- 16:17gives a razor blade to a two year old is culpable if that child hurts
- 16:22himself or others with it. Good parents give their children more and more freedom
- 16:27to do what they want, so long as they are responsible with their freedom.
- 16:33If children abuse their freedom, parents will discipline them by taking away their
- 16:38freedom to make bad choices. It's that simple. Furthermore, children shouldn't have
- 16:45to suffer draconian kinds of punishments for their actions when they err When my children
- 16:52misbehaved, I didn't send a proverbial hurricane their way. In fact, as
- 16:57a parent, I sought to protect them as much as I could from the
- 17:02severe consequences of their actions. A little pain was a good thing, so
- 17:07they could learn from their mistakes. But no caring father would let his children
- 17:12suffer the full brunt of their mistakes, certainly not broken bones or being beaten
- 17:18within an inch of their lives. If a father sat by and did nothing
- 17:23while his children suffered these and similar horrendous consequences for their misdeeds, the father
- 17:30would be morally culpable for letting it happen. He would certainly want all predators,
- 17:37killers, and rapists locked in jails and prisons away from his children.
- 17:42Since God doesn't do this for us in our world, he's not even as
- 17:48loving as a typical human parent. An omni God should have kept us from
- 17:53abusing our freedom by creating us with a stronger propensity to dis like wrongdoing.
- 18:02In much the same way that we have an aversion to drinking motor oil.
- 18:06We could still drink it if we wanted to, but it's nauseating. Such
- 18:11a deity could easily keep a person from molesting a child or raping someone if
- 18:18at the very thought of it, the person began to suffer severe nausea.
- 18:23We have the ability to do this with alcoholics when it comes to drinking,
- 18:29so it shouldn't be a problem for a good deity to do this with respect
- 18:33to the most heinous of crimes. Nothing of value to God would be lost
- 18:40by him doing so. Since God supposedly can read our minds, he can
- 18:45still judge our character by our intentions alone. After noting our intentions to do
- 18:52harm, God could implant good thoughts into our heads to prevent us from actually
- 18:57carrying out our bad intentions. An omni good has many other means at his
- 19:04disposal to keep us from harming others. A heart attack could have killed Hitler
- 19:11and prevented World War II. Timothy McVeigh could have had a flat tire or
- 19:15engine failure while driving to Oklahoma City to blow up the Murrah Federal Building and
- 19:22the people in it. The militants who flew planes into the Twin Towers on
- 19:26nine to eleven could have been robbed and beaten by New York thugs before they
- 19:32could do so. There's utilitarianism at its best. A poisonous snake bite could
- 19:38have sent Saddam Hussein to an early grave, averting the Iraq War before it
- 19:45happened. The Zyklon B pellets dropped down into the Auschwitz gas chambers could have
- 19:51simply malfunction by being miraculously neutralized, just like Jesus supposedly turned water in to
- 20:00one. The second moral concern for God would be that the environment he placed
- 20:07us in will not cause us excessive suffering. At the very minimum, an
- 20:12omni good should prevent all natural disasters if such a god exists. The two
- 20:19thousand and four Indonesian tsunami that killed approximately a quarter million people should never have
- 20:26taken place if God had prevented it with a miracle by stopping the underwater earthquake
- 20:33before it happened, no one would have been the wiser, precisely because it
- 20:38didn't happen. By doing so, God could have remained hidden for some hidden
- 20:45reason. Then with a perpetual miracle, he could keep it from happening in
- 20:49the future. Such a God could stop all naturally caused horrendous suffering in this
- 20:56manner, and none of us would be the wiser. We would just conclude
- 21:02that this is how the natural world works, with much less suffering in it.
- 21:07An Omnigod should not have created predation in the animal world either. The
- 21:12amount of animal suffering is atrocious, as creatures prey on one another to feed
- 21:19themselves. The extent of animal suffering cries out against the existence of a good
- 21:26God. This horrific suffering is perhaps the most difficult problem of all. To
- 21:32say these creatures do not feel pain is to reject the overwhelming evidence of evolution
- 21:38that proves we are all related as creatures. In lieu of this, an
- 21:44omnig good should have created all living things as vegans, like herbivores such as
- 21:49rabbits, deer, sheep, cows, and hippos, And in order to
- 21:55be sure there's enough vegetation for all of us, God could have reduced our
- 21:59mating cycles and or made edible vegetation like apple trees, corn stalks, blueberry
- 22:07bushes, wheats, and tomato plants grow as plenteous as wild weeds do today.
- 22:14An all powerful God didn't even have to create us such that we needed
- 22:18to eat anything at all. Since theists believe their God can do miracles,
- 22:25he could sustain us all with miraculously created nutrients inside our biological systems throughout our
- 22:33lives, and we wouldn't know anything different. Such a deity could simply do
- 22:38a perpetual miracle here as well. In fact, there's nothing prohibiting God from
- 22:45feeding us by the process of photosynthesis, just like plant life, thereby not
- 22:52requiring animals at all. Given that God didn't do this. Many animals are
- 22:57farmed for human concents asumption, under horrible conditions in intensive factory farms, abused
- 23:06in experimental labs, or trapped in horrible ways without any condemnations of animal abuse.
- 23:14In God's alleged revelation in the Bible, the third moral concern for God
- 23:19would be that our bodies provide a reasonable measure of well being. All that
- 23:26seems to be necessary for God and his plan of salvation is that we have
- 23:30rational powers to think and choose, the ability to express our thoughts, and
- 23:37bodies that will allow us to exercise our choices. So we could have been
- 23:42created much much differently. An omni good should have created all human beings with
- 23:49one color of skin. There that was easy. There has been too much
- 23:55institutional racism, race based slavery, and too many tribalistic wars because we don't
- 24:03all have the same color of skin. Such a deity could have also made
- 24:07all creatures capable of sexually self reproducing, like zebra sharks, komodo dragons,
- 24:15some reptiles, and other species. If God had done this, it would
- 24:21eliminate gender discrimination and gay hate crimes. Since there wouldn't be any gender or
- 24:26sexual differences between us. An Omnigod should have created us with much stronger immune
- 24:34systems, so there would be no pandemics that decimate whole populations, or chronic
- 24:41diseases like cancer, emphysema, leukemia, or for that matter, babies born
- 24:48with deformed limbs, blindness, deafness, muteness, and so on. This
- 24:53is horrific suffering that God should never have created or used as any so of
- 25:00punishment for our misdeeds, or allowed for any good, overarching mysterious purpose.
- 25:07Such a God could have created us with self regenerating bodies. When we receive
- 25:12a cut, it heals itself over time, as does a sprained ankle or
- 25:18even a broken bone. But why can't an injured spinal cord heel itself?
- 25:25Why can't an amputated leg grow back in a few weeks. If that's all
- 25:30we experienced in this world, we wouldn't know any different. Many animals can
- 25:36regrow new parts of their bodies to replace those parts that have been damaged.
- 25:41Lizards can grow new tails, Sharks continually replace lost teeth, Spiders can regrow
- 25:48missing legs. An octopus can regrow severed arms. Starfish can regrow new arms
- 25:56and even grow an entirely new body out of a severed arm. We find
- 26:03lots of examples in nature that an omnigod could have created in us but didn't.
- 26:08Such a god could have created us with a much higher threshold of pain.
- 26:14He could have given us fish like gills to keep us from drowning.
- 26:18He could have given us wings on our backs so we could fly to safety
- 26:22if we fell off a cliff, or he could have made us much smaller
- 26:26in size, so if we accidentally fell off that cliff, we wouldn't get
- 26:33hurt, just like ants who have a very low terminal velocity. A fourth
- 26:38moral concern for God would be to prevent a wide diversity of religions in the
- 26:45world. If there is an omni good, he should have made it a
- 26:51priority to prevent religious diversity by clearly revealing himself in this world, such that
- 26:57only people who consciously refused to believe would do so. There would be no
- 27:03such thing as reasonable non belief in the one true sect specific religion, regardless
- 27:11of when and where we were born or how we might be culturally indoctrinated.
- 27:15Otherwise, such a God would have made his revelation available to every culture and
- 27:22buttressed it with some astounding evidence based miracles. This deity would provide a naturalistic
- 27:30moral code for everyone that excluded all religions that were misogynistic, racist, homophobic,
- 27:38nationalistic, and otherwise barbaric. In this way, he'd prevent religiously motivated
- 27:45wars, crusades, inquisitions, witch burnings, suicide bombers, and terrorists.
- 27:52Given the horrendous suffering caused by religious diversity, the probability that an omni good
- 28:00exists is directly proportional to the amount of religious diversity that exists, and there
- 28:06is way too much of it to suppose he does to sum up so far,
- 28:11Given these four moral concerns, it is crystal clear for many of us
- 28:17that a god who created this world just doesn't care about us. God had
- 28:22a reckless disregard for our safety by giving us the gift of freedom before we
- 28:27could use it responsibly. He placed us in an environment that causes us excessive
- 28:34suffering and gave us bodies that don't provide a reasonable measure of well being.
- 28:41On top of all that, he failed to let us know which religion is
- 28:45true. Out of a great diversity of religions. Only if theists expect very
- 28:52little of their divine being can they defend what their God has done. Either
- 28:56their God is not smart enough to fi figure out how to create a good
- 29:00world, or God doesn't have the power to create it, or God just
- 29:07doesn't care. These appear to be the only options given this world. Four
- 29:14apologetic strategies. Marilyn McCord atoms admits this. She says the standard of apologetic
- 29:22strategies for solving the problem of evil are powerless in the face of horrendous evils.
- 29:30When it comes to animal suffering, C. S. Lewis admitted that
- 29:33the Christian explanation of human pain cannot be extended to animal pain. So far
- 29:41as we know, beasts are incapable either of sin or virtue. Therefore,
- 29:45they can neither deserve pain nor be improved by it. Still, there are
- 29:52four apologetic strategies used in solving the problem of horrendous suffering. According to one's
- 30:00strategy, God won't help us since he's more interested in building our character and
- 30:07horrendous suffering bill's character. This is one of the least successful strategies for answering
- 30:12the problem suffering is one thing Horrendous suffering is another we're talking about the supposed
- 30:21value horrific suffering produces for the very people who suffer, not lessons for future
- 30:29generations that can be learned with hindsight. It's also improbable that the virtues we
- 30:34learn in this world, such as compassion for the poor, patience and times
- 30:40of turmoil, forgiveness for someone who has wronged us, and the like,
- 30:45will even be needed in a heavenly bliss, where there is no pain or
- 30:49suffering for which to have compassion, patience, or to grant forgiveness. I
- 30:56am a white male who is not but ugly, or so a few people
- 31:00tell me, who grew up in a middle class family, with all the
- 31:04privileges that entails. To date, I have never spent a night in a
- 31:10hospital bed, nor have I gone hungry. I've had my wits about me
- 31:15most of the time. Anyway, Yet life has been hard for me.
- 31:18This life has tried me to the core, though I haven't experienced any horrendous
- 31:25suffering in it. So this world doesn't need horrendous suffering. If my life
- 31:32is any indication, all that a good God must do is eliminate the horrendous
- 31:37kinds of suffering in our lives. There's plenty of suffering left in this life
- 31:42to challenge us. A second strategy used by apologists is to maintain that God
- 31:48can't help us when free will is involved, or he cannot help us very
- 31:55much. God needs to let our free choices play themselves out. But as
- 32:00it stands, theists are the first ones to say unrestricted freedom is not a
- 32:07good thing. In the case of heinous crimes. We put criminals in prison.
- 32:12We do not let them roam the streets. Once they are discovered,
- 32:16they lose their freedom in the interests of having a safe society. Safety is
- 32:22a higher value than freedom. The theistic God has a mixed up sense of
- 32:29what is more valuable. For that God thinks human freedom is more valuable than
- 32:34having a safe society. All of us have a very limited range of free
- 32:39choices anyway, if we have any at all. The limits of our choices
- 32:45are set by our genetic material and our environment. It does absolutely no good
- 32:51at all to have free will and not also have the ability to exercise it.
- 32:58Some people don't have the strength needed to stop an attacker, while others
- 33:02don't have the rational capacity needed to spot a con artist, I could not
- 33:08be a world class athlete even if I wanted to. Our free will to
- 33:14do what we want is limited by our age, race, gender, mental
- 33:19capacity, financial means, and geographical locality. Since we already have limited choices,
- 33:27then God should further limit our choices if we seek to cause horrific harm
- 33:31to others. A third strategy is to say that God cannot do away with
- 33:37horrendous suffering because suffering is a necessary byproduct of causal natural laws. To have
- 33:45the one is to have the other. However, the apologist believes God created
- 33:52the universe from nothing along with the laws of nature, So if God can
- 33:58do that, he can also create a different universe with different laws of nature
- 34:04without any horrendous suffering in it. It just doesn't make any sense that God
- 34:09chose to create this world with so much horrific suffering when he could have created
- 34:15a better one without it. Even if God failed to create a good universe
- 34:21initially, he could still do miracles in this world to correct any errors in
- 34:25it. An omnipotent, miracle working God can do anything in the material universe,
- 34:32or he's not a miracle working God. Even apologist Richard Swinburne agrees.
- 34:39He says God is not limited by the laws of nature. He makes them,
- 34:45and he can change or suspend them if he chooses. He can make
- 34:50planets move in quite different ways, and chemical substances explode or not explode under
- 34:57quite different conditions from those which now govern their behavior. In a two thousand
- 35:02and three debate on the existence of God with Eddie Tabash, chair of the
- 35:07Center for Inquiry, Swinburne said God could quote raise this stadium into the air.
- 35:15However, from what I can see, all God does in today's world
- 35:20is to imprint an image of Jesus on a potato chip. Since this world
- 35:25is causing so much horrific suffering, the question for the theist is why the
- 35:30laws of this world are fixed and necessary when God could intervene to alleviate the
- 35:37most horrific kinds of suffering. If changing the world requires some miraculous adjustment,
- 35:45what's the problem people should matter enough for God to do that. I wonder
- 35:50if theists have really thought through the implications of a God who prefers this present
- 35:55set of natural laws with its sufferings, over constant miraculous maintenance. Does their
- 36:04God care? Is their God lazy? When apologists defend the miracles in the
- 36:09Bible and elsewhere, they will talk about an omnipotent God who created the world
- 36:15out of nothing, who sent fire down from the sky, and part of
- 36:20a sea that allowed six million Hebrews to pass on dry ground, Hebrews who
- 36:25lived in the desert for forty years where their sandals never wore out, and
- 36:31who were fed by manna from heaven. An omnipotent God can do anything,
- 36:37they'll say. It even says so in Matthew nineteen twenty six. With God,
- 36:43all things are possible. Their God is a miracle working God, so
- 36:49it shouldn't be difficult to believe God does miracles, they'll add. Yet,
- 36:54when it comes to alleviating horrendous suffering, many apologists seem to argue so that
- 37:00God can't do that. This appears to be nothing less than intellectual dishonesty.
- 37:07I maintain that the burden of proof is upon apologists to show why any of
- 37:13my suggested changes to the world are improbable. For an omnipotent, miracle working
- 37:19God, nothing short of this will do. I'm suggesting there are several things
- 37:24an omni good could do to eliminate horrendous suffering without producing a chaotic world or
- 37:32inhibiting our character development that would help draw us to Him, all of which
- 37:38are easy to conceive and already found in the animal kingdom. Since God,
- 37:45if he exists, could have done differently but did not, he is to
- 37:51blame for all horrific suffering in this world. A fourth strategy used by apologists
- 37:59is to hunt to mystery by claiming we simply cannot understand God's reasons for allowing
- 38:06horrendous suffering in this world. The truth is that it seems very likely we
- 38:12should be able to see God's reasons for allowing it, since most theists also
- 38:17claim God wants us to believe in him and will condemn us in the afterlife
- 38:22if we don't. More importantly, this answer cuts both ways. We're told
- 38:29we can't understand God's purposes, and this is true. We can't begin to
- 38:35grasp why there is so much suffering in our world if a good, omnipotent
- 38:40God exists. But if God is omniscient, as claimed, he should know
- 38:45how to create a better world, especially since we do have a good idea
- 38:52how he could have created it, So which is more likely that we cannot
- 38:58begin to understand God God's omniscient ways, or that we can have some kind
- 39:02of idea about them. If we consider the idea that we are all created
- 39:08in God's image, the answer seems obvious. We should indeed have some kind
- 39:15of idea about God's omniscient ways. Since this is so, and since we
- 39:21have good ideas on how God might have done things differently, the most reasonable
- 39:25conclusion is that an all powerful, omniscient, perfectly good God does not exist.
- 39:35Conclusion. If you name any specific example of horrendous suffering in this world,
- 39:42I can show you how an omni good could have eliminated it, which
- 39:45would still leave plenty of suffering for an omni good to test us in this
- 39:51world if that's important to a God who can predict what we will do.
- 39:55Anyway, in order to evade my challenge, I have found Christian apologists to
- 40:01be experts at cherry picking God's supposed divine attributes of omnipotence, omnicience, and
- 40:10omni benevolence, depending on the problem to be solved. When it comes to
- 40:15God's omnipotence, apologists embrace this attribute when it comes to believing he created an
- 40:22unfathomable and mysterious universe that continually surprises us. But when it comes to horrendous
- 40:30suffering, apologists conveniently negate it by saying God cannot create a better world than
- 40:37he did. One apologist, Thomas Ord, has stated this forthrightly, saying
- 40:44God cannot interfere in the world he created or with free willed choices intent on
- 40:51doing harm. According to him, God simply doesn't intervene in the world.
- 40:57How do apologists like Ord know this? They don't. They just affirm it
- 41:02because of the need to believe. So in order to save their faith from
- 41:07refutation, they must allow God's omnipotence to only go so far and no farther.
- 41:15This is where God's power arbitrarily ends where the apologist needs it to end
- 41:22to solve a problem for faith when it comes to God's omnitionis Apologists embrace this
- 41:30attribute when it comes to God reading our minds, hearing billions of prayers at
- 41:35the same time, and knowing everything that can be known, including minute details
- 41:42into the distant future billions of years from now. But when it comes to
- 41:46horrendous suffering, apologists negate it by claiming God didn't know how to create a
- 41:53good world without animals, or without natural disasters, or one in which free
- 42:00willed creatures do no harm. Many apologists, such as William Hasker and Greg
- 42:07Boyd have come to embrace open theism, which denies that God can fore no
- 42:14free willed human actions, so their God isn't to be blamed for what we
- 42:20do. How do apologists know this? They don't. They just affirm it
- 42:27because of the need to believe. So in order to save their faith from
- 42:31refutation, they must allow God's omnitions to only go so far and no farther.
- 42:38This is where God's knowledge arbitrarily ends where the apologist needs it to end
- 42:45to solve a problem for faith when it comes to God's omni benevolence. Apologists
- 42:52embrace this attribute when it comes to God's love and sending his son Jesus to
- 42:59pay the ultimate price by dying a horrible death for our sins, But when
- 43:05it comes to suffering, apologists like Michael Peterson and Bruce Little appear to negate
- 43:12it by claiming God does not care that much about our daily lives. In
- 43:17their view, God does not care enough to micro manage the world, so
- 43:22they claim that God is off the hook for much of the suffering we experience
- 43:28in the world. How do apologists know this? They don't. They just
- 43:35affirm it because of the need to believe so in order to save their faith
- 43:39from refutation, they must only allow God's omni benevolence to go so far and
- 43:46no farther. This is where God's omni benevolence arbitrarily ends where the apologist needs
- 43:54it to end to solve a problem for faith. If this is not the
- 44:00point, then what is it. Certainly an omniscient God knows how to intervene.
- 44:05Certainly an omnipotent God has the ability to do so. Shouldn't an omni
- 44:10benevolent God have the motivation to do so so? The evidential problem of horrendous
- 44:19suffering is one of the most powerful refutations of the theistic God as can be
- 44:25found. Okay that article God in Horrendous Suffering. I have linked the text
- 44:36version in the description box of this show. I hope it helps you as
- 44:42you engage the culture out there. Thanks to John for letting me share it
- 44:45with you, and I will see you back here next time. Follow The
- 44:50Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos.
- 44:55Products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logos, to atheist pages
- 45:00and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto
- 45:06our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com