Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Final Settlement E003: Rearchitecting the Internet with David King
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29in Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company. On Ramp's multi institution
- 0:35custody is a segregated institutional grade vault
- 0:38requiring two of three institutions at any point in
- 0:41time to sign once a client's unique permissions have been met
- 0:45at on RAMP We understand that your Bitcoin journey is a multi
- 0:48generational pursuit catalyzed by the ideals of perseverance,
- 0:52aspiration and legacy. That's why we're proud to
- 0:55introduce on RAMP Heritage, a suite of private client services
- 0:59dedicated to ensuring your Bitcoin legacy is preserved and
- 1:02passed on, embodying the true essence of wealth that goes
- 1:06beyond mere numbers. If you would like to learn more,
- 1:08please schedule a consultation. As we prepare for the Bitcoin
- 1:11having and the next wave of global adoption of this nascent
- 1:15and growing asset class, we are halving all annual maintenance
- 1:18fees for clients that secure their wealth before the next
- 1:21Bitcoin epoch. It all comes down.
- 1:26To computers, communicating the information superhighway can be
- 1:31a confusing mix of on ramps and off ramps.
- 1:34Bitcoin is worthless artificial goal.
- 1:39Is it still rat poison? Probably rat poison squared.
- 1:42We need to get into the world of, OK, This is actually
- 1:45foundational technology. What the Internet of Money does
- 1:49is it creates a single network which can do a microtransaction
- 1:55to a giga transaction. The Internet is going to be one
- 2:01of the major forces for reducing the role of government.
- 2:05The one thing that's missing that that will soon be developed
- 2:09is a reliable E cash. Welcome to the third episode of
- 2:16Final Settlement, a Bitcoin podcast brought to you by On
- 2:20RAMP where we take a look at Bitcoin really more from a
- 2:23technological perspective. Going beyond the digital gold
- 2:26thesis, Bitcoin is more than just an asset in your portfolio.
- 2:31Bitcoin is an open source piece of software that people are
- 2:33building on top of and and enabling all sorts of new and
- 2:37innovative forms of utility in the real world.
- 2:40And so with us today, we have David King, also known as
- 2:45Curious DK on his YouTube channel and Twitter.
- 2:50David is an entrepreneur and Angel investor with over 2
- 2:53decades of experience in Silicon Valley, building technologies,
- 2:57products and informing relationships.
- 3:01And he's also a content producer and an educator sharing his
- 3:04knowledge about technology, Bitcoin and Noster on his
- 3:07YouTube channel. I'm really excited to have you
- 3:10on, David. How's it going?
- 3:12Glad to be here. Thanks for thanks for the
- 3:13invite. I saw you had my boy Max Webster
- 3:16on for episode #2. So when you reached out, I said,
- 3:19all right, these are the good people.
- 3:20Let's do it. Love it.
- 3:22Love it? Yeah.
- 3:24I think one place to start is really just your background
- 3:28because it's fascinating to me, you know your the the amount of
- 3:33time and and sort of effort that you've put in on the, you know,
- 3:36technology side of you know you worked at Google previously and
- 3:40in various startups in Silicon Valley.
- 3:42I I'd really just love sort of a deep dive on your background,
- 3:46your career trajectory and experience learning about new
- 3:49technologies and you know, really honing in on some of your
- 3:53early learnings about software development and and
- 3:55technological evolution from your your time at Google and and
- 3:58elsewhere across Silicon Valley. Yeah, and and I could even back
- 4:02it up because a lot of the foundation for that was laid
- 4:05when I was, you know, like 6 years old or something.
- 4:08My father used to it back. Yeah, so, So my father, you
- 4:12know, he's like a kind of a a nerd math type guy and he was
- 4:15like ACPA professionally, but he was really into figuring out
- 4:19computers like in the early 80s and how they could be used to
- 4:23like make his business better. So he was buying us a new family
- 4:26computer like every two years. And that was like magic box of
- 4:30cool things you could do. So I just started to like play
- 4:33with it and I started programming and he would never
- 4:35let us get video game systems, but we could, he would always
- 4:38say you can build better games yourself.
- 4:39So it's like, OK, you got to figure out how to program.
- 4:41So I would get into that and along that path, like
- 4:46programming, you know, building games and stuff.
- 4:49He got a modem when you know probably I think it's 150 Watt
- 4:53modem probably in like 1984 or something and you know so super
- 4:58slow. But what you're doing is you're
- 5:00you're connecting to these BBSS, these local BBSS, right dial up
- 5:04to Avbs and it's kind of like what I call a proto version of
- 5:08what the Internet is today. And so I was getting to play
- 5:11with like connecting to people and meeting new people and
- 5:15downloading software and all of the stuff that we kind of take
- 5:18for granted on the Internet. Now it's a very primitive
- 5:20version and it was not open at all, but it was like the same
- 5:25types of feelings you get when you're on the Internet.
- 5:28And I was like, OK, like I had no idea where it was going.
- 5:30I was not trying to predict the future.
- 5:31I was just having fun. And I, you know, we sort of
- 5:34graduated from those DBSS to these, these services like, you
- 5:38know, Prodigy, CompuServe, America Online and and then
- 5:42eventually the open Internet. And each one of these things I
- 5:45think was like a formative experience.
- 5:47And seeing, you know, in a sense, I'm like, you know, kind
- 5:50of a software guy, but I'd say like more so an Internet guy
- 5:53because my whole kind of life and career has been watching and
- 5:59participating and figuring out like what's next on the
- 6:01Internet. And I think it's just like an
- 6:03endlessly fascinating, open set of kind of questions and answers
- 6:08you can be playing with. There's always something fun to
- 6:10play with and stuff to hypothesize.
- 6:11So that that sort of, you know, led me to study computer
- 6:15computer engineering and I studied computer engineering and
- 6:19you know, did some internships at Intel and Microsoft and kind
- 6:22of thought maybe I was going to go like big tech route and and
- 6:26but I'd always wanted to do startups.
- 6:28And so I ended up kind of, you know, right after school getting
- 6:32involved in a few different startups and eventually making
- 6:34my way to Google. And at the time, it was not very
- 6:38obvious to people that that was like going to be interesting.
- 6:42I mean, I used it all the time, but.
- 6:44But people didn't really know how Google was going to make
- 6:46money or didn't. You know, Google was making
- 6:48money, but people didn't really understand it.
- 6:50There was no Twitter. It was very quiet.
- 6:52So it was just this thing that I loved, used all the time.
- 6:55It helped make all of this information super accessible.
- 6:59And you know, it it, it reminded me of why the Internet was so
- 7:04great. But it's like magnified, you
- 7:05know, several orders of magnitude over.
- 7:08So that kind of, you know, that's sort of how I got
- 7:12involved at Google. And then I I've just always been
- 7:15involved in startups and excited about like new technologies that
- 7:18could be built. So when I left Google, I
- 7:20actually ended up creating one of the first gaming companies
- 7:24when Facebook was launching the platform and you know, built
- 7:27that for several years and sold it.
- 7:29It's now part of Walt Disney. And and that was right around
- 7:32the time that, you know, like Bitcoin was getting launched and
- 7:36invented and and sort of shared and discovered.
- 7:39And so that's sort of been another piece of like weird
- 7:42early technology and stuff that you know, even sort of can look
- 7:45forward a bit and see where it's going.
- 7:47And I think this pattern of like stuff sits raw and weird and
- 7:52nobody really understands it, but it sort of grabs you for one
- 7:54reason or another and you're just like, wait, how does that
- 7:56work? Why does it work that way like
- 7:58that? Those are the types of questions
- 8:00that I think you know that's always what drives my curiosity
- 8:03and interest to continue pursuing things and you know
- 8:06sort of happened with you know BDSS and early Internet and and
- 8:09you know Internet connectivity and and you know search and
- 8:13information retrieval with you know Google and sort of what was
- 8:17happening in social networking you know in the mid arts and and
- 8:19and I think you know what happened with Bitcoin and kind
- 8:22of what's happening with Noster now and you know has been you
- 8:26know for for kind of a maybe a year and change now really
- 8:29getting some strong momentum. So I'm the type who's like
- 8:32always curious to play with the new stuff and try to form an
- 8:35opinion and you know I don't always get it right the first
- 8:37time but like if I just follow my curiosity I keep finding the
- 8:41things that are you know that that you know many of which end
- 8:44up being interesting. So that's kind of what I've just
- 8:46committed to continuing to do. I love.
- 8:50I love the thread on the curiosity because, like, I think
- 8:53we forget that we're just in the early innings of the Internet,
- 8:56let alone Bitcoin, right, And commercial Internet, you know,
- 8:59twenty 2000s and then bitcoins, right after that.
- 9:02So we're still just seeing how they play together.
- 9:04But this whole notion of just being curious leads you to
- 9:07realize that, like, things aren't actually what they seem
- 9:10or they're not as good as they seem.
- 9:11We generally people accept things as they are just because
- 9:14I think that's just how human nature works.
- 9:16But if you're always looking at what's the next thing because
- 9:18this current thing doesn't really feel right or there's
- 9:21tailwinds that may not feel right.
- 9:22And then sooner that's how you land on, whether it's different
- 9:25businesses like a Google or you know, Bitcoin or Noster.
- 9:30And it's it's awesome that you were at Google that early
- 9:32because I was at Google, but it was a completely different
- 9:34business. You were at Google.
- 9:35That was like with the talent that was the best human capital,
- 9:37probably on the planet Earth. That went off and did a lot of.
- 9:39Things. Yeah, it's pretty crazy.
- 9:40Yeah. And that's and that's awesome
- 9:43because I'm sure you've seen and we'll continue to see the world
- 9:46through a lens of like those individuals and innovation that
- 9:49most people don't get to see. And so you get to spot things
- 9:51that most are looking at it from like, oh, that's kind of
- 9:53interesting versus like that's interesting, but it's not really
- 9:55right yet versus oh, that's interesting and it's the right
- 9:58time because I've seen this before.
- 10:01Yeah, and and I think we see that too.
- 10:03Like when I when I joined Google, it was just a search
- 10:06engine there. There was no Gmail, Maps,
- 10:09YouTube, Android from none of that stuff existed.
- 10:14But it was very focused and narrow and I think a lot of
- 10:17people, a lot of people dismissed it and even my parents
- 10:20said are you gonna go work on a website?
- 10:22isntthe.com stuff over? Did that stuff die?
- 10:26And I think when something really, it only has to be
- 10:30narrowly focused and served like one purpose really well and you
- 10:33can start to see how well if you get that right and that grows
- 10:36and impacts a lot of people, there's adjacent that don't
- 10:39necessarily look that adjacent but actually are adjacent.
- 10:43And those adjacent like the the power of the the core thing will
- 10:48expand to also fill the adjacent and transform adjacencies.
- 10:51And I think you see that as a that's a pattern in technology
- 10:54that happens again and again and again.
- 10:55There's almost like, it's almost like the story of technology is
- 10:58these unintended positive side effects that happen when you get
- 11:03one thing really working well. And I think that's, you know,
- 11:06part of the story of the Internet and the story of Google
- 11:08and the story of social networking, the story of
- 11:11Bitcoin, story of an oster, you know, all kinds of future stuff
- 11:13that's going to happen. Yeah.
- 11:15So was was that sort of mental model or heuristic, Was that
- 11:18known while you were at Google? Like, yes, we're narrowly
- 11:21focusing on this thing. Search got to make this the
- 11:23best. But was there sort of a vision
- 11:25internally that, you know, this is going to be the foundation
- 11:28for a lot of things on the Internet and that and how things
- 11:30work out? Yeah, I I I mean when I got
- 11:33there, there was already a really great ads business
- 11:36humming, you know, I think it was you know, generating already
- 11:40you know hundreds of millions of dollars in in revenue.
- 11:44So it wasn't like super speculative, but it was just not
- 11:46talked about anywhere. They kept it very quiet because
- 11:48there's no reason you don't want to like you know tell everybody
- 11:50even how what a great business you have.
- 11:52You know, maybe other people come after it.
- 11:54So it was the kind of thing that was pretty pretty quiet.
- 11:59But the people there, you know, there was like unbounded
- 12:03ambition and you know, like any anything you would come up with
- 12:07an idea and and Larry Page would say, what if it were 10X that,
- 12:11right. Like, how do you make it bigger.
- 12:13And. And people were talking about.
- 12:14Yeah, even even then I remember people talking about like
- 12:17building hardware. And I remember Sergio and said,
- 12:19well, maybe someday we'll want to build a phone.
- 12:22And this was, you know, this was like probably, I don't know, 8-8
- 12:26years before there was ever any phone before, before Google had
- 12:29even acquired Android. So it was very early.
- 12:32But there was always this sense that like you know organized
- 12:35world's information is not just you know make a search engine
- 12:38for websites but it's like maps as information and you know and
- 12:44and you know Chrome as a as a browsing experience is really
- 12:48important for how people choose to access information, right.
- 12:52So you sort of you get one thing going really well and then you
- 12:56define it in a fairly abstract set of ways.
- 12:59But I think really smart people and you know I think it was a
- 13:01lot of really good good talent there at that time.
- 13:04You know, you just start to see ways that it bleeds into other
- 13:07things and can actually transform all kinds of
- 13:09adjacents. And in the case of Google, it
- 13:11turned out to be kind of like the whole Internet in a sense.
- 13:13Yeah, that that reminds me of. It's something that I've just
- 13:16been thinking about for a long time, coming from big tech and
- 13:19then into the Bitcoin space and why I just, like always anchor
- 13:21back to like human capital is the only capital that matters.
- 13:24Because until it gets here, the bright businesses won't be
- 13:27built. And what you're referencing is
- 13:28like, I've heard from multiple anecdotes and Chris Stock was a
- 13:32popular one back. And I think it was a similar
- 13:33time frame about being there. Being able to walk into rooms,
- 13:37show up and like provide feedback in the stories about
- 13:39like buying data centers under like different CS, 'cause you
- 13:42didn't want Yahoo and others to know that you were actually like
- 13:45growing at that scale in like the fiber auction that I was
- 13:48actually part of the access team that did the fiber.
- 13:50And that was like in in 17, but that was like 10 years if not
- 13:55more probably 13 years versus winning that like some of that
- 13:59like infrastructure to go and lay it out which is half a
- 14:02decade later. It's just incredible to hear
- 14:05like what's there because you can see like the inklings of
- 14:08like the next wave and if you can build those companies and
- 14:10you get the right people, it's all about the human capital.
- 14:12Then there's no shortage of different ways that an
- 14:15organization can grow and actually really like impact the
- 14:17world. Yeah, 100%.
- 14:19And I think it's both organization as well as like
- 14:22protocols or open source software.
- 14:24So I don't think it always has to be one organization that
- 14:27drives it forward. Like sometimes that works and I
- 14:29think we've seen that work well. We'll see more of those.
- 14:32But I think also things like like Linux, everybody likes to
- 14:34poo poo. But like that, that's not a
- 14:36business. But also like we wouldn't have,
- 14:38you know, Google or Facebook or probably wouldn't have Bitcoin
- 14:41or Noster if we didn't have, you know, Linux, you know, an open
- 14:45source version of Unix used to be crazy expensive to to do
- 14:49these things. You could build out big data
- 14:50Centers for a free service if you didn't have Linux.
- 14:53So I think like these examples are both organizational, but I
- 14:57think also like non organizational and kind of
- 15:00collaborative Internet stuff. And that's the stuff that's I
- 15:03don't think we have really great, we don't have tons of
- 15:06history and tons of examples to look at and point to.
- 15:08So I think people sometimes dismiss it.
- 15:11It's just like, oh, there's some crazy hackers.
- 15:13But like, I think we're going to see a lot more of that kind of
- 15:15stuff happen in the future. Yeah.
- 15:17And it's it's great that you mentioned sort of you know the
- 15:20difference between building out in the open.
- 15:23This is something I've I've heard you talk specifically a
- 15:24lot about you know open systems versus closed systems in terms
- 15:28of you know the pace at which software development can occur.
- 15:31And I'm curious like you know, your time at Google and even
- 15:35beyond that sort of working in Silicon Valley, you know what,
- 15:39what did you see in terms of how the Internet was evolving in
- 15:42terms of, you know, open versus closed source and generally the
- 15:46trajectory of things were on. You know, could you see the
- 15:49centralizing forces starting to play out from an early stage or
- 15:53or you know, how did you think about, you know, maybe the the
- 15:57sort of ways that the Internet was being built out like early
- 16:00infrastructure, some of the errors that that may have
- 16:03happened in terms of centralization versus things
- 16:06that could be more decentralized?
- 16:08Yeah. I I think I I think I did not
- 16:12recognize it as early as I, you know, hoped that I could.
- 16:15I I remember distinctly some some calls I had with my
- 16:19brother. He's he's quite a skeptic.
- 16:20So I was telling him how great Google was and how exciting it
- 16:22was. Everything's going.
- 16:23So he's like, well, yeah, but I mean someday you know, stuff
- 16:26will slow down and and sort of what happens then and how do you
- 16:29sort of optimize the world given that you sort of are in a
- 16:32certain situation. And I I don't think at that
- 16:34time, I don't think I could quite see how this thing could
- 16:37become that. So I'd maybe chalk it up
- 16:40somewhat to my naivete. But also, you know, I think
- 16:46these things are like, I think you sometimes need centralized
- 16:52examples of these things before you can really build great
- 16:55decentralized versions. Because the centralized one kind
- 16:59of shows you it's like really easy to iterate and move fast
- 17:02and like it. It compromises in like long term
- 17:04stuff, but it gets all the short term stuff right.
- 17:06And I think by getting the short term stuff right, you can
- 17:08actually iterate and make things better for people and you can
- 17:11understand, oh, people are complaining about that feature,
- 17:13OK, turn it off. People are asking for this
- 17:15feature, OK, turn it on. So centralized actually makes it
- 17:18very easy to build great things fast, but it ends up
- 17:21compromising long term, which is why, you know, a lot of stuff
- 17:25trends toward a lot of decentralized systems because,
- 17:27you know, people don't experience the long term pain
- 17:30until the long term. They experience the short term
- 17:32kind of wins. So you look at like I was
- 17:35talking about BBSS and the, you know, the centralized providers
- 17:38before the Internet, I think like they were kind of a healthy
- 17:42natural step toward getting the more open Internet that we have
- 17:46today. Now, the Internet's not perfect,
- 17:48but it's really good. There's like some critical flaws
- 17:51to the architecture. But like, but it also works and
- 17:55it helps us do what we want. So I sort of think of, like
- 17:58centralized, you know, as a great starting point to show
- 18:03what kinds of products and services serve people's needs.
- 18:07And then over time we can kind of rebuild or, you know, build
- 18:12new forms of things that show revealed preference and show
- 18:15people's needs, but can do it in a way that doesn't kind of have
- 18:19those long term kind of negative aspects to them.
- 18:23Yeah, that's actually a really good point in the sense that a
- 18:26lot of times going through the Bitcoin journey, you kind of, if
- 18:29you go full circle, you end up where you just described.
- 18:32Because initially you look at and you're like, we're going to
- 18:33change everything, right? We're going to reinvent the
- 18:35wheel when we're actually going to repurpose it and it's going
- 18:38to look a lot more like the existing world with just certain
- 18:41like nuances and governance that's a little bit different to
- 18:43keep everybody honest And if if somebody's honest, you can
- 18:46change very easily and that's what makes the whole thing work
- 18:49versus like you know just changing the whole, whole system
- 18:52and maybe some will completely. But I think more often than not
- 18:55it ends up looking more like the the existing world with like
- 18:58this like tweak to keep everybody playing fair versus
- 19:00like just re architecting the whole system.
- 19:03Right. You You do run into the problem
- 19:04though that if you have a centralized system that's good
- 19:06enough, then a more decentralized system isn't
- 19:10always apparent to people why it should matter because you've
- 19:12sort of well, we've got the thing, it's sort of all our
- 19:14short term means what do we care.
- 19:16So I think it really takes some bridging to figure out where the
- 19:19decentralized services if it's just the decentralized clone of
- 19:22a centralized service, you know, maybe it's fun and interesting
- 19:25for people who like to play with these things, but I don't think
- 19:28it's easy to get mass adoption of those things until people
- 19:30experience the more near term pain.
- 19:33That the, the, the. Centralized service is causing
- 19:35them and they have a reason such or the thing that we don't talk
- 19:38about enough is I think we should be focused on new
- 19:42experiences that couldn't exist with the centralized services.
- 19:46And I think if we start thinking about those and building towards
- 19:49new experiences that just like fundamentally you can't do on
- 19:53the centralized services, but they're close enough to some of
- 19:55the things that we can see work, then I think that becomes like a
- 20:00huge propelling, you know, kind of huge tailwind to propel these
- 20:04things forward. Yeah, I know.
- 20:06It's a really good point. I think, you know, adoption of
- 20:10something that is more decentralized and open can
- 20:12happen in a variety of ways. Like one it's, you know, pulling
- 20:15on basically new use cases, things not possible on the
- 20:18incumbent rails. But also it's a greater and
- 20:21broader recognition of some of the pitfalls of centralization
- 20:24over time, which I think you know in sort of the current
- 20:27climate maybe the most prominent example of that is like content
- 20:30moderation, right. And so I think that that's been
- 20:33sort of a a push on some folks at least you know opening their
- 20:36eyes to sort of the the pitfalls of of centralization over time.
- 20:40So maybe you could talk a little bit about like you know sort of
- 20:43the history of of content moderation on the Internet and
- 20:46sort of where we are today and you know if that could be
- 20:49somewhat of a catalyst for more open networks over time and you
- 20:52know sort of maybe where where are we in that timeline?
- 20:55Right. Yeah.
- 20:56I mean I think, I think content moderation is a is a good
- 20:59framing for a lot of the arc of this stuff because so a lot of
- 21:03times it's the it's the kind of content that we might not always
- 21:07talk about. As you know like in a sense if
- 21:09you could be published in the New York Times then you kind of
- 21:13don't have the problems of free speech or like your your content
- 21:17maybe doesn't. It doesn't play in a Gray area,
- 21:20so it doesn't really have a need for technologies that serve
- 21:22that. Whereas if you play in a more of
- 21:24a Gray area, you know, an area that it's not clear that society
- 21:27has yet decided is an OK thing to publish.
- 21:30But maybe we should be asking the question, should it be like
- 21:34what, you know, why did we decide that?
- 21:36Or why do we collectively believe that?
- 21:38And it's not always like even one one versus the other.
- 21:41But I think I think if you sort of look like a content
- 21:44moderation like you know back it it it, you know often times
- 21:48there's like a if there's a business like Google there's a
- 21:49centralized business. You run ads.
- 21:52You send people to websites you you you you you you're imbuing
- 21:57some amount of taste and you have policy that you have to
- 22:00deal with to describe like I I used to help some of the ads
- 22:05policy teams and there's like questions like what kinds of
- 22:08what kinds of ad creative is reasonable to show And like some
- 22:12stuff's very clear. OK that's fine.
- 22:13And some stuff's kind of like borderline and maybe it's around
- 22:16like is this nudity for medical purpose or is this like adult
- 22:20content And like if you're in the business of adult content
- 22:24you might want to try to pose it as nudity for medical purpose.
- 22:27You know and usually for medical purposes can be allowed in
- 22:30certain circumstances and and I think it's, you know, central
- 22:34organizations, you know they they are incorporated companies
- 22:37they they need to follow a set of strict guidelines in the kind
- 22:43of jurisdictions in which they're established.
- 22:45I think that's like that's just sort of the way the world's set
- 22:48up right now and it's totally fine.
- 22:49It's just like they're just, you know, everybody's responding to
- 22:51incentives now is there, there's a bunch of layers to those
- 22:56incentives. Like what does Cloudflare, what
- 22:58does Cloudflare think of the content?
- 22:59What is Visa or MasterCard think of the content?
- 23:02And there's all these layers that now have to weigh in and
- 23:06have, you know, they have their own jurisdictions that they have
- 23:08to comply with. And so in a sense, like the
- 23:11world has gotten very ossified around a few of these platforms
- 23:15and a few of the kind of, you know, the Cloudflare's the
- 23:17world, the Visa's the world, the Google's the world where you
- 23:21kind of have to limit what can be said or done because of
- 23:25those. And then there's other ones
- 23:26where it's just like we have a business interest to not have
- 23:29people leave our website. So we're not going to let you
- 23:31share links or something. And like you know, as a
- 23:34independent business they're free to do that.
- 23:35But then you're like really changing the way people, you
- 23:40know, if you change what people are allowed to say or you let
- 23:43them say anything, but you only promote or give distribution to
- 23:48stuff that complies with maybe your own agenda or your business
- 23:53interest. Totally fine.
- 23:55Totally fair. Like everybody can run the
- 23:57business they want, but then it's like maybe we need
- 24:00something different. That doesn't restrict that.
- 24:02We've seen the problems with this.
- 24:03I think. I think in politics this comes
- 24:05up all the time, right? Because there's people who are,
- 24:09you know, really identify with one or the other of these poles
- 24:13that have been set up. And you know, content moderation
- 24:15is great as long as it's the other side being moderated.
- 24:18But like, I shouldn't be moderated.
- 24:19Like, you know, free speech, right.
- 24:21So I'm I I think we've sort of seen this at you know every step
- 24:27in all these stages. And the thing that excites me
- 24:29about this kind of these new this new world noster and stuff
- 24:33that we can do and kind of more decentralizing speech is we can
- 24:36actually decentralize everything about it including like can it
- 24:39be published and in in what gets surfaced to who and who's
- 24:43allowed to ask for what to be surfaced in their own favorite
- 24:46ways. Like when it's all centralized,
- 24:48you kind of have like one way to publish, one way to read, and
- 24:51you kind of just have to deal with whatever the centralized
- 24:53provider decided to do. And when you start to move that
- 24:55outside of centralized providers, people could publish
- 25:00whatever they want in all kinds of different ways.
- 25:01People could choose to read in very, very different ways.
- 25:04They can choose clients, different algorithms.
- 25:05There's all kinds of kind of flexibility and diversity of
- 25:09ideas of even just like, how do I access the ideas that I might
- 25:12want to see. Those are things that are like,
- 25:15they're all up in the air. They're still to be invented
- 25:18really. Like we're just at the very
- 25:19beginning kind of on the starting starting line of this
- 25:23with some of the stuff we're doing in Oster today.
- 25:24But yeah, I think I think that's kind of stuff that I'm excited
- 25:28about for kind of having having a more custom experience of the
- 25:34web. And the I think the only way to
- 25:36do it is to take it out of the hands of, you know, of a
- 25:40centralized provider because they just have a different set
- 25:42of incentives. It's like all very rational,
- 25:44just, you know, I want to see something different.
- 25:48Yeah, I think, I think it's a big part of this.
- 25:50It's like a lot of this stuff sometimes gets like ideological
- 25:53or tribal and it's really just rational and from a game theory
- 25:56perspective like what is, what is the path we're on.
- 25:59It reminds me, I always like track back to like, you know,
- 26:02Bitcoin and finance in the sense of like Operation Choke Point.
- 26:06It reminds me the same thing. It's like, oh, you know, we can
- 26:08censor you. And it's OK until it's like as
- 26:10long as that can happen, then you're just on the curve of when
- 26:13that can happen to you in the same way being censored via your
- 26:15speech. And this notion of that, like
- 26:21it's, it reminds me of also like the currency because like every
- 26:24time in the West, this is generally like it's like, well,
- 26:26the dollar is fine and other currencies are a lot weaker.
- 26:28It's like, well, they're all the same thing on a different line,
- 26:30like different point on the curve.
- 26:31That's the same side of the speech where you're at.
- 26:34And so if that is to be true, then everybody should care about
- 26:37this because at some point on that curve, your dollar, your
- 26:41currency will, will not be what you think.
- 26:43It preserves the wealth it is in the same way that your speech
- 26:46will not always be there when you need it and it's just TBD
- 26:49win. And so like I don't fall on the
- 26:51like Noster like campus like I've just I I social, social and
- 26:56it's great. And from a few and probably I
- 26:57don't actually give it enough credibility as it should because
- 27:00I use it and that's how I produce, consume content.
- 27:03I think the money is the most important.
- 27:04But then I also go back to this idea of like, well if you don't
- 27:07have a way to express yourself, then a lot of you're not
- 27:09necessarily free. And so that's where this all
- 27:11like it obviously makes sense. You need it And if you have a
- 27:13form of money to run the relays to keep things humming, that's
- 27:17what you need because there's always that operation choke
- 27:18point that hangs in the background that we saw in the
- 27:21like the 2000 Tens when it came to whatever prostitution or
- 27:24gambling. And so all these things start to
- 27:26just play off of each other and they become very rational that
- 27:28you at least wanted open architecture to, like, allow for
- 27:30these things. If we never use them, sure.
- 27:32But if you may, if you end up using them, then you may want to
- 27:35actually know they exist and maybe have some kind of like
- 27:38perspective on it. Yeah.
- 27:40And I think you can always like layer in, you know, if you have
- 27:42regulatory environments, you always layer that stuff in and
- 27:45say like, hey, like instead of the system can only work in a
- 27:50certain way because we've got, you know, a choke point on a
- 27:52particular org. It's like you're not allowed to
- 27:55use this client on. You know, you can only use
- 27:57client X if you live in jurisdiction Y, OK, fine.
- 28:00Like, there's ways to layer that in.
- 28:03I'm not saying I'm a fan of that kind of stuff, but I'm saying
- 28:06there are ways to do that if you know, the people with guns, you
- 28:09know, decide to do that. Like, it's not really, it's not
- 28:13really a negotiation at that point.
- 28:14But, but I think it is the kind of thing where you you want to
- 28:19provide alternatives and you want to allow people to choose,
- 28:24you know, if there's nobody telling them what they have to
- 28:27do given where they live and let people choose what they want and
- 28:30help people be more informed about the kinds of choices
- 28:32they're making. Yeah, you want a more resilient,
- 28:35robust architecture for anything that you do just in life.
- 28:39And so you don't want to be cut off of the rails because
- 28:42somebody determines that you can be.
- 28:44Yeah. And and also like things get
- 28:46shaped like if you are not allowed to say things or you
- 28:49know that the things you say given the central algorithm are
- 28:52going to get nerfed, you'll stop saying them.
- 28:55And you know, when you stop saying them, you actually change
- 28:57your thought process to think, oh, you know, I I'm not going to
- 29:01share that link on Twitter because I know, like, it's just
- 29:03going to get nerves anyway. So then you start to think about
- 29:07things differently. You say, well, what is free
- 29:09speech if it's actually upstream of speech, is your thoughts.
- 29:12And you're not, you know, you're not allowed to speak of things.
- 29:15So you start to you start to modify your thoughts in fact.
- 29:21Right. Yep.
- 29:22Self censoring is a is an output of of some of this.
- 29:26I'm curious just taking sort of a step back back to your sort of
- 29:29timeline and your trajectory and into, you know, very much
- 29:32leaning into Nostra as a thing which we will get to soon.
- 29:35But I want to take a jump back to when you first heard about
- 29:38Bitcoin. I'm assuming you came at it from
- 29:41a technological lens like this open source piece of software is
- 29:44interesting to me. I think, you know, most people
- 29:47come at it from a money or an investment or a speculative
- 29:51perspective. But giving your background, I
- 29:53assume it was more on the technology side.
- 29:56And I'm curious, you know, first of all, when, when did that
- 29:59happen? When you when you first came
- 30:01across Bitcoin and then when did it click that oh this is you
- 30:04know an open platform that things will be built on top of
- 30:07and you did you envision in in sort of the back of your mind
- 30:09something like Noster existing but just didn't know what what
- 30:12form it would take. Yeah, well, yeah, that involves
- 30:16like a lot of history and a lot of trying to remember what
- 30:19exactly I was feeling at each time.
- 30:21I think you're right to to point out that, like the the
- 30:25technological stuff is what really grabs me.
- 30:29But I would say that the reason that I didn't spend more time
- 30:33and effort on Bitcoin when I first heard about it was because
- 30:37people were talking about it like, it's digital gold.
- 30:39And I was like, I'm not really into gold.
- 30:41And it's kind of this financial product.
- 30:43And like, I don't know, like do I want a digital version of a
- 30:45thing that I don't otherwise, you know, I'm not otherwise in
- 30:47love with. It's like I in a sense, I was
- 30:50like, cool, like, it's fine if people like it and want to use
- 30:53it for that. But it didn't grab me because I
- 30:56don't think I studied the technology side of it initially.
- 30:59I didn't really understand in detail all of all of what from a
- 31:04technology perspective. And by the way, technology is
- 31:06always social. Like technology is never purely
- 31:10code, but it's how people choose to use code.
- 31:13And I think unless you like a really, you know, you read the
- 31:15white paper again and again and then try to understand like why
- 31:19this system can't be replicated a second time.
- 31:21Like it's it's the one time or like the whole thing either
- 31:25works in this instance or probably just fails.
- 31:27But like there's not kind of a second version of this thing
- 31:30because of its sort of, you know, the the strange nature
- 31:34through which it sort of came to be.
- 31:37But I think it's that like interplay between what the code
- 31:40does and who the people are who choose to use it.
- 31:44So like, there's users and there's minors and there's
- 31:46people who run full nodes. And there's a lot of features to
- 31:50the network that are really, it's like an conglomeration of
- 31:53human choice that causes it to be that way.
- 31:56And I think when I first was hearing like, OK, computer
- 31:59science, breakthrough Byzantine general problem, like cool, I
- 32:01kind of get that's cool that we now have that.
- 32:05But I didn't see how like a new financial asset was particularly
- 32:11itself that interesting. And I think I, you know, I wish,
- 32:14I wish I could see more of that. And I think that's a little bit
- 32:16of what the Silicon Valley kind of I think the reason, you know
- 32:23when Bitcoin first got started and you know people were
- 32:26starting to think like in Silicon Valley, what can you do
- 32:28with this? People were like, OK, you can
- 32:29build like exchanges, you can build wallets, but like you're
- 32:33not building like new, you know, new revolutionary technologies
- 32:37for how communication and media and information and like gaming
- 32:40and like all of these, you know, these, these categories that I
- 32:43think, you know, we haven't yet seen a ton in, but I think we're
- 32:46starting to see. And at the time it was just
- 32:49like, well, here's a new financial asset.
- 32:52So I think it took a lot more study from kind of first hearing
- 32:56about it to realizing that it's kind of this technological
- 32:59social interplay that makes it work the way it does and which
- 33:03is like really exciting to me. And then I I did take, you know
- 33:07I think around the time that Ethereum was getting launched, I
- 33:09did sort of poke around and try to understand that ecosystem
- 33:12because like all of you know my network of builder friends and
- 33:15stuff like oh, Ethereum, you can actually build stuff now like
- 33:17before we were encumbered when it was just financial.
- 33:19I said now you can build stuff. And so I was kind of like trying
- 33:22to explore that and understand like really like what can you
- 33:24build, what are the things that we want to build like.
- 33:27And and I think I kept coming back to the the fact that like
- 33:32the the things that allowed Bitcoin to work, you know, being
- 33:36very neutral, you know, kind of not having a a visible or active
- 33:40founder were really important to it working as a financial asset.
- 33:48But it didn't necessarily leave a lot of space to build new
- 33:52things. So I think there's like a lot of
- 33:53the idea of it wasn't obvious that it left a lot of space to
- 33:56build new things. I I do believe there's lots that
- 33:58can be built, but I think at the time it didn't, It wasn't clear
- 34:01besides exchanges and wallets like what?
- 34:04What could you build on this? What was this thing all about?
- 34:07And I think, you know, you know, as time progressed and sort of
- 34:11got more conviction about both what Bitcoin is as a
- 34:15technological primitive for the Internet.
- 34:19And then as well, like hearing the narratives of all the other
- 34:22things that were tried, you know, and sort of ending up
- 34:28ultimately kind of like this not, not super excited, sort of
- 34:33dissatisfied with like the results of what the other things
- 34:36were. I think I, I became kind of like
- 34:40a little bit more cautious about what what's what's like the next
- 34:44step here, Like how do you take this new foundation and build
- 34:47something on it. And I think everybody, I think
- 34:49it's like very common to take the era of like well you know
- 34:52once, once you see Bitcoin then you're like oh what about
- 34:55Bitcoin with a tweak in a sense like it's not about Bitcoin with
- 34:58a tweak. It's like let Bitcoin be
- 34:59Bitcoin. That's a great layer.
- 35:01It's a new money fine. But let's build other things
- 35:04that assume that that's new layers same way as we have like
- 35:06we have TCP IP. And when it was time to go like
- 35:09build like application layer like web browsers and and you
- 35:12know in search engines and other stuff, you didn't have to like
- 35:14re prosecute the TCP IP question again and again just like OK
- 35:17peace like that thing works. It's good enough, there's lots
- 35:19of problems with it, but it's like fundamentally we have
- 35:22enough consensus on it. Let's let it be great at that
- 35:25and then let's focus our building energy on what we can
- 35:28do at layers above that, that assume that as a primitive.
- 35:31I think we're just starting to see that now and I think Noster
- 35:33is like a great early example of that, another one that I love.
- 35:37Have you guys played with Stacker news?
- 35:39Yeah. So, so Stacker News is another
- 35:41one. It's like I'd call it Noster
- 35:43adjacent in some ways. It doesn't look like a
- 35:45traditional social media client of of you know, like a like a
- 35:49lot of the Noster clients do. But it actually you know has
- 35:53some bridges to publish and I think there's more coming.
- 35:55But what I like about that is it kind of it says we're not
- 35:58inventing any money, we're taking this money and now we're
- 36:01building a centralized product that assumes the use of that.
- 36:06Now if you get the centralized product going and you have the
- 36:08right ideology and ethos, could you, could you do things like
- 36:12could you make it more noster based or primarily a noster
- 36:16experience over time? Like, I don't see any reason
- 36:18that that couldn't happen. And I think you have a whole new
- 36:20set of incentives than you had 20 years ago.
- 36:22Like the web is a very different place and you can have direct
- 36:24payments to any, you know, anybody in the world as long as
- 36:29the person has like a tool to help them do math, like a little
- 36:31calculator, you can actually send payments and that's like a
- 36:34big new primitive. So I think the incentives are
- 36:36now like radically different. So even if you start a new
- 36:39centralized thing today, I don't think it means it has to remain
- 36:41centralized forever and there might be business opportunities
- 36:45that that support centralized providers choosing to
- 36:48decentralize most of the important parts of of their
- 36:51infrastructure. So yeah, I'm.
- 36:54I'm trying to remember where we. No, you you made a lot of really
- 36:57good points in there and I wanted to touch on one that I
- 37:00think and and I just pulled this up because you had a tweet a few
- 37:03weeks back that I wanted to, I wanted to share because it
- 37:07resonates with what you were just saying.
- 37:08Cryptography can be helpful for for building new things even
- 37:12with the without attaching a new currency.
- 37:14And I think that's a very salient point that gets lost in
- 37:18sort of everything we've seen post Bitcoin and all these other
- 37:21cryptocurrencies, these other protocols, they're trying to
- 37:25build the other things on top without having that solid
- 37:27foundation, right. And then you know, I think what
- 37:31what bitcoiners have been saying for a while is like all of these
- 37:34things can be built on Bitcoin. Ultimately it's just going to
- 37:37take more time because genuinely there's just a more conservative
- 37:40approach to protocol development even on 2nd and 3rd layers.
- 37:45And I think that that's purposeful and and probably
- 37:47rightfully so, but but the reality is, is that you know if
- 37:51it if it has product market fit, if there's a utility for it, I
- 37:54think it ultimately gets built on Bitcoin and you don't need
- 37:56some other token to to do these things.
- 38:00Right. Yeah.
- 38:01And and I think that's like if this, this happens again and
- 38:04again in technology, which is like when somebody comes with a
- 38:07new breakthrough product or idea or concept, it's I think a
- 38:11fairly healthy exploration that goes on where people say, well,
- 38:15great, we have a new primitive, what else can we do with it?
- 38:17And people tried to explore in all kinds of different
- 38:19directions. And you saw, I mean you saw this
- 38:20was like social networking, right?
- 38:21It was like like Friendster was the first social network that I
- 38:24ever signed up to that felt like it was like a real social
- 38:26network. I think it was like 2003 kind of
- 38:28felt, you know, the the first closest thing to you know, what
- 38:32a social network is today. And I was like, OK, great, this
- 38:34is this is done. I, you know, put all my, you
- 38:37know, put all my information into it like it's it's set like
- 38:39this is the winner. I'm not going to do that the
- 38:40second time. And then and then Myspace
- 38:42happened. I was like, OK, second time but
- 38:44not a third. And then you do Facebook and
- 38:46you're like, hey, third time. And and then that idea gets
- 38:50divided into like, well, what if there's, like a social network
- 38:53for, you know, people who like to knit or social network for
- 38:55people who like to, you know, have dogs?
- 38:57And a different one for people who like to have cats and people
- 38:59who like to watch movies and people who like to read books.
- 39:01And so a good idea like social networking then gets explored in
- 39:05like, you know, thousands of different ways and, you know,
- 39:08ultimately, like, you know, one of them kind of ends up amassing
- 39:12kind of most of the attention and value and kind of, you know,
- 39:15improves. And I think in the case of like
- 39:17technology, that's very common. I think in the case of money,
- 39:20it's even more extreme that there's only really like like
- 39:24single, you know, there's only like a single answer to like,
- 39:28the money question because money is such a network network thing
- 39:32and almost like a featureless thing.
- 39:33Like it just has the features of money and it doesn't have, you
- 39:36know, whiz bang features. But I think when you see
- 39:39something like it's a good idea, people start trying to explore
- 39:42the space. And I think what's happened is
- 39:44people tried to explore the space by saying oh, what if you
- 39:46could, you know, add smart contracts on it?
- 39:49Oh, what if you could like make it faster transactions?
- 39:51Or like people tried to explore all these new hypothesis like
- 39:55new technological hypothesis, but they end up compromising
- 40:00sort of using pattern matching to what Bitcoin did and then
- 40:03kind of trying to extend it in different ways versus kind of
- 40:06saying, OK like. Instead of extending that good
- 40:08idea, let's come up with a new good idea.
- 40:10There's so many, there's infinite good ideas out there in
- 40:12the world. But instead of trying to redo
- 40:14the money thing and then attach the technology with a new
- 40:17feature to it, my view is kind of like peace.
- 40:20The money thing is the money thing.
- 40:23That's the decentralized money thing.
- 40:25And this is, this is weird, but I'm open.
- 40:27If you have a better idea than Bitcoin, I want to hear about it
- 40:31first. I don't want to be like the
- 40:33thousandth person here, but I want to hear it first.
- 40:35But it has to actually beat Bitcoin.
- 40:37It can't be like, well, it's not so good at money.
- 40:40We compromise in all these ways, but look at these whiz bang
- 40:42features. It's great technology.
- 40:43It's like, OK, fine, that's not really something that I want to
- 40:46spend a lot of time on. But if you actually have a
- 40:48better Bitcoin, like, let me know.
- 40:49But, but I think it's just like a very high threshold just like
- 40:52if you had a better you know if you had a better protocol for
- 40:55for networking the Internet together I'd be interested to
- 40:57hear like tell me what are your hypothesis.
- 40:59But it has to be really good at that but the threshold to beat
- 41:02it today is insanely high and it can't compromise on a bunch of
- 41:06the core things that matter. It has to actually just be kind
- 41:08of substantially better in some way that you know we were we
- 41:12were failing at before and money it's just coupling with energy
- 41:16it seems like seems like an impossibly hard thing to to you
- 41:20know impossibly hard wall to climb which I think is kind of
- 41:24how I settle out as like bit kinds of money let's move on and
- 41:26like focus on other things like TCPI, PS, the Internet Protocol
- 41:29bit kinds of money let's just let's build great things on top
- 41:32of it. It's not.
- 41:33It's not like we have to be static and stayed and just say
- 41:36like accept the world as it is. We're very conservative.
- 41:38Nobody touched anything. It's like no, fine touch, be
- 41:40crazy, build lots of crazy things, but do it like assuming
- 41:43that this is the money. Because if you reinvent the
- 41:46money and compromise it, then the whole thing just feels kind
- 41:49of thin. So that's why when I see like
- 41:51things like Noster that don't have any attachment to any
- 41:55particular money, like you could use any cryptocurrency you want
- 41:59in the noster protocol, they just turns out that it has a lot
- 42:02of, you know, shared ethos in sort of, you know, with with
- 42:06it's appealing to bitcoiners, right.
- 42:08So it tends to be because it's appealing, it tends to sort of
- 42:13have a lot of that kind of talk on it.
- 42:15But I think like really thinking about the world and the layers
- 42:18and and and then building new technologies and like
- 42:21accelerating the development of new technologies that can be
- 42:24built now that we actually have a global neutral digital money.
- 42:30Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 42:32exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 42:35about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 42:38allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 42:43We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 42:46I think there's a a really fascinating part that you you
- 42:49shared and I think Max kind of falls in the same bent of almost
- 42:53like like I I take this stance of we're so early that we
- 42:57haven't even figured out how do you custody this thing because I
- 43:00don't think like custody of a 40 or $50,000 asset is the same as
- 43:03500,000 or 5 million. And so that angle of I think
- 43:08everybody would not be comfortable with how it is today
- 43:11where it's custody. And a good example of this is
- 43:13effectively like you mentioned Gold and I really like how you
- 43:17reference social layers with the technology because when I think
- 43:21about what we're dealing with multi institution custody and
- 43:23how it scales globally, you're basically having a social
- 43:26construct built into the protocol.
- 43:28And I think of it, you know there's differences but that the
- 43:31only difference between gold and Bitcoin is literally multi
- 43:33signature because it's what keeps everybody honest and
- 43:36transparency where where gold ultimately failed.
- 43:39And if that's even remotely true, then there's a lot of
- 43:41market structure that comes from that Whether like this whole
- 43:44notion of execution is always just given up that somebody has
- 43:47to send the dollars first and somebody has to send the
- 43:49Bitcoin. It's like wait, that doesn't
- 43:50seem good. If trust breaks down or you have
- 43:52to send a billion dollars who sends it first, right.
- 43:55And and that's just one angle of the money and why it's important
- 43:59to have diverse backgrounds building on open protocol.
- 44:01Because you and Max I think come from a social perspective of
- 44:03like, you know, the different ways that the Internet was
- 44:06fundamentally like fracture, not completely made whole.
- 44:09And where if we assume this is the money now we can actually
- 44:12start leveraging the other things that are part of this
- 44:14form of money to build these other areas.
- 44:15And they end up converging in different ways at certain
- 44:18points, but they're looked at from completely like not
- 44:20opposite lenses. But one's almost like matter of
- 44:23fact figured out almost when it's still like in its infancy
- 44:26or just starting, if that makes any sense.
- 44:29Yeah, I mean it's it is so early like you know when you think
- 44:33about something like gold, I think it's existed about 5000
- 44:35years. And so there's tons of history
- 44:37and tons of social consensus that it's the thing and you know
- 44:40based on the stock to flow and the mining ability and
- 44:43difficulty and and just like the acceptability of gold.
- 44:47So it had all these features that have sort of been brewing
- 44:49for 5000 years and now here we are with Bitcoin, we're 1515
- 44:53years in, right. So it basically has like almost
- 44:55no real history, but you know it has about the same amount of
- 44:58history as the Internet as far as you know gold is concerned.
- 45:02So it it has like a very kind of Internet primitive length of
- 45:06history. You know roughly like it
- 45:08couldn't really worked that well before the Internet.
- 45:10Like it's you know if you think bitcoins weird with the you know
- 45:14existence the Internet, imagine it sort of before the Internet.
- 45:16Like you can argue yeah you can like do all your hashing by hand
- 45:19and mail it in but like it's just it's sort of unrealistic
- 45:23right. I think the Internet and kind of
- 45:24free information flow is kind of a required foundation, but it's
- 45:28very short history compared to gold and the acceptability of
- 45:32gold that like even just like how are you going to cut C gold?
- 45:35And then are you going to have these, you know, these kind of
- 45:38paper currencies that are sort of backed by gold and then you
- 45:40sort of decouple the backing. And there's a lot of history
- 45:43that causes us to be where we are today.
- 45:46And we have almost none of that history of Bitcoin.
- 45:48We have like, you know, the invention of the thing, you
- 45:50know, some exchanges, wallets, people buying it.
- 45:53Now we have ETFs. But like effectively it's just
- 45:56kind of a financial asset we don't really have.
- 45:57We don't really have the payments thing figured out to
- 46:00any real extent. I mean and I'm I use I use
- 46:03Lightning like every day. But like it's not perfect.
- 46:05Like there's a lot of challenges.
- 46:07Doesn't mean we've got really great people working on it.
- 46:10And I'm optimistic to hear what you know as that future unfolds.
- 46:16There's a lot of a lot of really great people who've dedicated
- 46:18their you know, entire life's work to making that that work.
- 46:20But it's still very hard problems.
- 46:22I've played with E cashes but there's a bunch of E cash hypose
- 46:25pediments and and and you know cashew and stuff like that.
- 46:30There's all kinds of these things that are you know
- 46:34possible but we're only 15 years into like the base layer assets.
- 46:37So you know we we've got a lot to figure out still and I don't
- 46:41think it's going to take 5000 years.
- 46:42I think you know given that we now have the Internet we can
- 46:44communicate, we can collaborate faster.
- 46:46We can try new ideas faster. You know, I would suspect that
- 46:50it's you know, measured on the order of years or maybe half a
- 46:53decade or a decade like, but it's not like another 5000 years
- 46:57for us to all figure out how Bitcoin fits in.
- 46:59And I think we also are going to Co evolve our digital systems
- 47:03now that we have digital scarcity.
- 47:05I think that's a big deal because we didn't have a way to
- 47:08evolve our digital systems with these new primitives and we're
- 47:13only now with like you know maybe lightning and E cash and
- 47:16various things. We now have ways to start
- 47:18experimenting with how do digital systems work given that
- 47:21we have digital scarcity because it was just like we didn't have
- 47:24any way to do that before. And I think that's that's what I
- 47:27get excited about like for the future that and I think I think
- 47:30you know Noster is one example of that Stacker news, an example
- 47:33that you know, but I'd love to see thousands of experiments in
- 47:36those directions, centralized, decentralized, like I don't
- 47:39care. It's just tons of building and
- 47:41tons of pushing the frontier of what can we do now that we have
- 47:43digital scarcity. It's a huge invention for a
- 47:47digital communication network. Yeah, it was something you you
- 47:50said or I don't know if it was you or somebody on the the pod,
- 47:53the first one on the from Apple or you said like New York or I
- 47:57think it was you about new architectures.
- 47:58Basically will there'll be new winners.
- 48:01And you mentioned like this this excitement around everything
- 48:03happening here, this realization whether it's AI, Bitcoin or open
- 48:07source technology as a as a whole, like just working in the
- 48:10markets and you've been in the middle of them like either so
- 48:13disruptive that the incumbents will just like fight tooth and
- 48:16nail because it just disrupts the whole model.
- 48:18So there will be all new winners in this landscape, at least in
- 48:21my opinion. And so that just is an exciting
- 48:23you know lens to look at the world through because you're
- 48:25looking at it through again that curious mind of how do you like
- 48:28allocate capital, how do you build and how do you think about
- 48:31this to like where everybody else has seen the old world and
- 48:34like it's going to be the status quo and it's just not the case.
- 48:37Yeah. And it and it may be that like
- 48:38the future, I think we have this model of like, OK, like, you
- 48:42know, Google was a big Internet winner, Facebook was a big
- 48:44Internet winner, Twitter, etcetera.
- 48:46And then I think people are looking at like what are the
- 48:48next companies that are going to win.
- 48:50And it may be that the next things that win at the same
- 48:54scale, like there's just there aren't companies that win at
- 48:56that scale, but there's there's open source projects and there's
- 49:01lots of businesses built. Maybe there's thousands or
- 49:03millions of businesses that get built, but there's not like A1
- 49:07single central one the way there were, you know, a handful of
- 49:11them the way there were on the Internet, just because, like,
- 49:13the foundation is very, very different.
- 49:15I believe that wholeheartedly in a different lens, but at the
- 49:18same side of I think about like the golden handcuffs that are
- 49:21very much real and like these centralized entities are very
- 49:25non organic and how large they've gotten for through a lot
- 49:28of reasons. And that when you have a form of
- 49:30money that appreciates in value and you have ideas, you
- 49:32naturally do not get that large because people can leave with
- 49:35their capital and go actually start competitors and do
- 49:37different things versus this like large scale.
- 49:40And I think that is what we'll see.
- 49:42I mean we live it like a lot of these concepts it's just like
- 49:44natural from a perspective of my own like if you if you save in a
- 49:48better form of money that appreciates then you can
- 49:49actually take your ideas and go and do things versus having to
- 49:52be stuck on that that hamster wheel.
- 49:54And so I think that just continues to expand or or grow
- 49:58as this proliferation of a better form of money is is with
- 50:00any people that save. Yeah, in a sense it's like a way
- 50:04for I almost feel like this, everything that can be built is
- 50:07effectively like open source, free.
- 50:11There's all kinds of opportunities just like have
- 50:12everything open source. Everybody can remix every can,
- 50:14add their own features and raise PRS and merge things in or fork
- 50:19and clone and just do something totally different.
- 50:21I think there's all kinds of opportunities to do things that
- 50:25are different. And it's not so much about,
- 50:27like, you know, oh, you're mistreating me.
- 50:29So I need to leave. It's more like, oh, this idea
- 50:32over here just grabs me. And I'm just going to, like, put
- 50:34my energy and weight behind it. Not so much because it's like
- 50:37I'm being abused by some central authority.
- 50:38But it's just like, I just want this thing that maybe only, like
- 50:41100 people in the world want, but I'm one of them.
- 50:43And I'm going to put my energy into it.
- 50:45You know, I think like it's a beautiful world when we have
- 50:48everybody doing and getting what they want and doing their own.
- 50:51You know, kind of let creativity, let human creativity
- 50:54flourish. And you know, maybe empower
- 50:56human creativity with open source AI is that everybody can
- 50:59use and payments maybe flow to relays or or maybe there's like
- 51:05cloud providers or maybe there's like small scale cloud compute,
- 51:09you know, you know, like like GPU clusters that you can use
- 51:13and run something for a little bit get you know get a model out
- 51:16and then kind of use imprints locally or something.
- 51:18So I think this is like lots of opportunities for more diverse
- 51:22things to flourish. And I mean just like orders of
- 51:25magnitude more than any of the stuff we've seen so far.
- 51:28I think it'll be like, you know, new central providers that win
- 51:32some aspects of things. But I think there's going to be
- 51:33a lot more like, I think the decentralized open source be
- 51:37like everybody gets to be creative and have exactly what
- 51:40they want is to me what feels like radically new.
- 51:44And that's that's the stuff that I get excited about.
- 51:45Like, yeah, there's going to be great big new companies built
- 51:48too and that's fine. But like the pattern of all the
- 51:52crazy new exploration, creativity, stuff that that's
- 51:57the stuff that, like, really gets me, gets me excited for the
- 51:59future. Yeah.
- 52:01One key thing you, you reference about like 100 people also think
- 52:04of like a 1100 of the the cost, right.
- 52:07When we think about relationary nature of tech and one thing
- 52:10we've been talking about, me and Brian is like this whole notion
- 52:14of like hardware to software. You know is you go from like
- 52:18hardware to software in the like growth and there's this natural
- 52:20kind of slow from like a mainframe computer to like AWS
- 52:24and like how you're actually managing.
- 52:25And it took years And then this idea of going from like software
- 52:29to software and I think the the first like larger scale version
- 52:32of this was ChatGPT, right, like having a lot of sign ups in that
- 52:36like first month. But it's this idea of going
- 52:38software to software to software.
- 52:40If you go like software to AI to programmable form of money is
- 52:46like this craziness that you start to see growth that we've
- 52:48never seen at a scale and like we're just barely, like
- 52:52squinting to see it. Yeah.
- 52:54And I think it's hard to like when we think about money, we
- 52:58think about money the way it touches our lives, which maybe,
- 53:01you know, people always talk about like, OK, money is an
- 53:03asset. You can own it.
- 53:04Maybe it's like real estate or maybe money is something used to
- 53:07buy, you know, a coffee until all of our mental models and our
- 53:11narratives end up sort of going to what we do with money today.
- 53:15But we don't have any way to think about money as a protocol
- 53:19for AI machines or to dispatch a job to get something done by a
- 53:23farm that you know, happens to publish, offering a service that
- 53:27you want. Maybe it's only 100 Satoshi's to
- 53:29get that done, and then your job comes back and then dispatch it
- 53:32to something else. We just don't have like good.
- 53:36We don't have a good, like, kind of feeling for how to think
- 53:40about that yet. But I think that's like the most
- 53:42important stuff you can do with digital scarcity with like a,
- 53:44you know, an Internet native, neutral money as you can
- 53:47actually now have all kinds of machines that do things for us
- 53:52or for other machines or for the software you want to use at like
- 53:55such a small scale that you'd never be able to, you know, the
- 53:59old payment rails would be like crazy too expensive.
- 54:01You couldn't. You couldn't do it.
- 54:02Plus, not everybody knows everybody, not everybody's in
- 54:05the same jurisdictions, people just like all over the world
- 54:07offering these services, you know, and setting up machines
- 54:12and building software that offer these services.
- 54:14And it's just like kind of super all over the place.
- 54:18And I think that's actually the model of what, you know what
- 54:20Bitcoin is most important to kind of align the incentives to
- 54:25let that ecosystem thrive. Yeah.
- 54:27No, it's a, it's a really good point And it sort of Harkins
- 54:30back to what you were saying earlier around, you know, how
- 54:32does that adoption of a decentralized system happen?
- 54:35And and part of it is actually enabling things that are not
- 54:38possible in the old system, in the old world, right.
- 54:41And I think maybe taking a step back just to, you know what
- 54:46you're talking about earlier around, you know, Noster is sort
- 54:48of an adjacent protocol to Bitcoin.
- 54:50Maybe you can just dive a little bit deeper there and just give
- 54:53sort of an overview, particularly around like the
- 54:55architecture of Noster, just at a high level to better sort of
- 54:59explain that relationship between master and Bitcoin and
- 55:03how they sort of work complementary to each other.
- 55:06Yeah. So, you know, I think one of the
- 55:08core pieces, you know, that that works with Bitcoin is that there
- 55:14is no centralized issuer of accounts.
- 55:17So it, it feels weird, like you're familiar with, oh, money.
- 55:19You go to a bank, you go to a brokerage, you set up an
- 55:21account. And with Bitcoin, you just do
- 55:25some math, right. You can use a calculator, but
- 55:27you basically like do some math and you have like this address
- 55:30that you can do things with and nobody can tell you you're not
- 55:33allowed to do that math because if you have a calculator, you do
- 55:35the math, right. That's kind of a profound
- 55:37concept that there's nobody who who who tells you you're allowed
- 55:43to be in the system. You just do the math.
- 55:45When you're in the system, you know you can participate.
- 55:48And so when I saw Noster, I was initially intrigued because it's
- 55:53very similar. You don't, you know, think about
- 55:55traditional social networks. You go to a sign up page and
- 55:58then you put in your username or your desired username and your
- 56:01e-mail or something, maybe your birthday.
- 56:04And then then they create an account for you, just like a
- 56:07bank would, right? And with nostery, it's it's none
- 56:10of that. You're just like, OK, I'm going
- 56:12to use a little calculator, do some math, you know, plenty of
- 56:14software that'll do that math for you, but but nobody can tell
- 56:17you're not allowed to do the math.
- 56:19So you can create an account kind of as easily as doing that
- 56:23math using these calculators. And so it feels like it has that
- 56:27same underpinning of, you know, I've seen a lot of people try
- 56:31various approaches to like, you know, decentralizing social
- 56:34media and stuff. And often times they're still
- 56:36like, you know, collecting an e-mail address or or you know,
- 56:40like having having a centralized issuer for a namespace.
- 56:45And those kinds of things kind of mean that you're a little bit
- 56:48more like the old system than you are like the new system.
- 56:50And I'm like much more excited about the new system.
- 56:53So I think like really that voluntary opt in nobody can tell
- 56:58you no is like a really important feature of these
- 57:01things and and you know sort of first became like quite aware of
- 57:05it the way sort of you know Bitcoin addresses get generated
- 57:09and and then I think when I saw Noster and I think that's why
- 57:12there's a lot of overlap and interest between people who
- 57:15understand Bitcoin and people who understand Noster's you know
- 57:18has very similar just like voluntary you know opt in
- 57:22yourself to create because you want to participate.
- 57:25The specifics of how kind of the architecture of Nostra work are
- 57:29vastly different than the specifics of the architecture
- 57:31for how Bitcoin work and that's actually a good thing.
- 57:33You don't need a blockchain to do free speech or to do you know
- 57:38speech that can you know is censorship resistant.
- 57:42But because the Bitcoin idea was so powerful for censorship
- 57:46resistance, people have been trying to like create block
- 57:49chains for censorship resistant speech.
- 57:52I mean it's kind of like trying to shoehorn a good idea in a
- 57:55bunch of different ways. Like it's fine, I think people
- 57:56should experiment and try things.
- 57:58But ultimately, like Noster is a very, very different
- 58:01architecture to solve the important pieces about, you
- 58:05know, censorship resistant speech.
- 58:06And So what I mean by that is, you know, one of the things, one
- 58:09of the reasons that blockchain, the blockchain was invented,
- 58:13kind of Co invented with the existence of Bitcoin is because
- 58:17of the need to understand global state.
- 58:19You have to know if if you're trying to prevent the double
- 58:22spend problem, right? So you have to know everything
- 58:24that anybody's spending anywhere.
- 58:26You have to have visibility into that so that you can be sure
- 58:29that like if you sent me something you didn't also send
- 58:31to somebody else, I need to be able to verify that, right?
- 58:34And in speech it's not the case at all.
- 58:36Totally doesn't matter, like if some random person X sends a
- 58:40message to a random person Y that I'm never going to see.
- 58:43It doesn't need to be like trackable by me.
- 58:45We don't need to like some sort of strong guarantee that I can
- 58:47read that message like, I don't know, just almost doesn't matter
- 58:51and speech maybe, I don't know, maybe several orders of
- 58:54magnitude more volume than financial transactions.
- 58:57I don't know if somebody's really done the analysis, but I
- 59:00would guess just empirically that, you know, that's kind of
- 59:03like my, my observation about my experience in the world.
- 59:08So the architecture is very, very different.
- 59:10It's not a blockchain architecture at all.
- 59:12And the insight is that there could be like a set of relays
- 59:16that relay messages and there's a set of clients that are just
- 59:20like apps that you can download from an App Store or you know
- 59:22websites you can navigate to on the web.
- 59:24But they agree to use the same protocol for signing and sending
- 59:27messages and and you know, pulling messages to be able to
- 59:31compose a a view of those messages.
- 59:33And what it does is it really severs the link between the
- 59:36client and the data store. And that is a really important
- 59:40thing, is to sever that link because when that link is
- 59:43connected like it is and, you know, say like Twitter, right,
- 59:45there's like there's a database that holds all the tweets and
- 59:48then use the Twitter client you download.
- 59:50And then, you know, Twitter's awkwardly in the middle, they're
- 59:52trying to decide, well, which tweets should we show from the
- 59:54database. And like that tweet may be
- 59:57illegal in a certain jurisdiction or that tweet
- 59:59doesn't help our business interest because it includes a
- 1:00:01link and people going to leave the the site.
- 1:00:03So sort of having those having a.
- 1:00:06A front end and a back end like you know, a client and a
- 1:00:08database tightly coupled means that you unfortunately have, you
- 1:00:13know this kind of taste, you know gets imbued by whoever it
- 1:00:16is that's running those two. And I think the big thing with
- 1:00:18NOSTER is you just like have separated those so you have you
- 1:00:21know, the relays are the data stores you can sign.
- 1:00:23Anybody who wants can create an account, sign messages, send
- 1:00:27them to 1 relay or more relays, 10 relays.
- 1:00:29If you want 50 relays, you can run your own relay, but the
- 1:00:32relays are going to present the messages to whoever asks for
- 1:00:35them and so I can send it to 50 relays.
- 1:00:37Now the interesting thing is that puts all the relays into
- 1:00:41into heavy competition with each other and if they know that
- 1:00:44everybody else is in competition to serve those messages, they
- 1:00:47don't really have like the incentive to try to suppress
- 1:00:49them. Because like well, if I suppress
- 1:00:50it, if I choose not to carry it, fine.
- 1:00:52But like next relay over is going to carry it and so by
- 1:00:56putting relays in competition with each other, it actually
- 1:00:59means that it serves the users needs better.
- 1:01:01Like if I want to write something, I can write
- 1:01:02something, I can write it with one client or a different
- 1:01:04client, or if that client hates me, fine I go to another client.
- 1:01:07But I'm still operating the same protocol.
- 1:01:09I can send it to 1 relay, 10 relays, 50 relays, my own
- 1:01:12personal relay and people can reliably get whatever message
- 1:01:15they want from me. But nobody has to have one
- 1:01:17record of everything that happened on master, every piece
- 1:01:20of speech or communication. So that's why it's like a bit of
- 1:01:23a, it's a very different insight for a different problem to
- 1:01:27solve, a different problem which is like resistance of speech
- 1:01:30suppression is very different than resistance of kind of
- 1:01:32financial transaction suppression.
- 1:01:35Yeah, that's a, that's a very helpful overview.
- 1:01:37And I think you know one of the sort of earliest applications or
- 1:01:44or clients that we've seen popularized on Noster is largely
- 1:01:47just Twitter clones, right. And I think there's there's some
- 1:01:50sort of natural reason they're just given, you know that is a a
- 1:01:56very top of mind application for most users that you know, we
- 1:01:59would want to try to replicate in a more decentralized fashion.
- 1:02:01But I'm curious from your perspective like go beyond just
- 1:02:05the the Twitter clones, like what are the implications of
- 1:02:08this architecture in this structure for sort of you know,
- 1:02:11more open and decentralized communications networks More
- 1:02:14broadly, what other things could this potentially enable in the
- 1:02:17future be? Careful, Brian gets you to leak
- 1:02:19alpha. No, it's all good.
- 1:02:25I mean, I I hope to just leak all the alpha possible and
- 1:02:27everybody knows about everything, you know, as as soon
- 1:02:30as possible. I don't want to hold anything
- 1:02:32back. You know, I I think like we were
- 1:02:35saying before, there's like the centralized examples help inform
- 1:02:40user behavior and demand and needs and reveal preferences.
- 1:02:44But then that actually causes like a little bit of a headwind
- 1:02:47for a decentralized thing that's just a clone because like, well,
- 1:02:49we already have the other thing like, like long term maybe it's
- 1:02:52bad, but like short term, day by day it's fine.
- 1:02:55So I think like, you know, the Twitter clones I think are a
- 1:02:58great starting point because they help everybody take
- 1:03:01something that we're generally familiar with and at least get a
- 1:03:05chance to play with it. It's like a little bit of a
- 1:03:06water cooler. We can be like, oh, cool, like
- 1:03:08we get how this works and we get kind of what it's supposed to
- 1:03:11do. And it's really those of us
- 1:03:12using it very, very actively are typically doing so because we're
- 1:03:16very curious about how the thing evolves and how it was built and
- 1:03:20what may come next and how it could be used.
- 1:03:23But it's, you know, I I don't personally go to Noster because
- 1:03:25like Twitter is censoring my speech.
- 1:03:27I go there because I think there's like really interesting
- 1:03:30technological foundations being built.
- 1:03:33But I do think, you know, I would like to see and you know,
- 1:03:36I I would like to see I think more experiments that are sort
- 1:03:41of different in nature that are trying to explore the edges of
- 1:03:45what can be or trying to serve use cases that are underserved
- 1:03:49by existing tools on the web. So like, you know, you know,
- 1:03:53early Internet, you know, and people don't like to talk about
- 1:03:55this, but like early Internet was like a lot of adult content,
- 1:03:57a lot of gambling like those, those are just things that like,
- 1:04:01you know, you set up a way to get people connected and
- 1:04:04everybody's like a lot of people choose to do that stuff.
- 1:04:07And so I think there's probably categories within adult and and
- 1:04:12gambling that are underserved. And you know, I don't consider
- 1:04:16myself an expert either space, but there's probably, you know,
- 1:04:19there's people who like are not allowed to be on certain
- 1:04:21platforms or there's things where like the payment providers
- 1:04:24prevent certain things from being said or being done and
- 1:04:27they're very jurisdiction dependent.
- 1:04:30But but I think those those categories are often at the edge
- 1:04:34of what's allowable and there's a lot of consumer demand for
- 1:04:38those. Now, we don't have a lot of
- 1:04:40experimentation with that kind of stuff yet in Noster or
- 1:04:43Bitcoin, but I suspect that some of that kind of stuff might be
- 1:04:47early kind of novel applications that can, yeah, we kind of know
- 1:04:51people want it and a lot of people do want to use it, but
- 1:04:55there's a lot of like friction in how they get used in the
- 1:04:58centralized providers. You know, I think things like
- 1:05:00prediction marketplaces, I've been playing around with a bunch
- 1:05:02of those recently that, you know, some people don't kind of
- 1:05:05like hack projects on Noster. I think that's like a a super
- 1:05:08cool category where like you know people love to you know
- 1:05:12sort of hypothesize about the future or try to like make odds
- 1:05:16or bet on something and that you know in a sense you can't really
- 1:05:22do that the way you know jurisdictions and and money
- 1:05:26works and transmission and stuff.
- 1:05:28It's it's kind of messy to do but there is, you know there's
- 1:05:32demand for it. And so is there a way to just
- 1:05:34like is there a way to make kind of tools that help people
- 1:05:39accomplish the thing that they want to do but but do it with
- 1:05:41kind of this new infrastructure where like they can't do it with
- 1:05:43the old infrastructure they can't do it with new
- 1:05:44infrastructure. And then I think you know and
- 1:05:46and you know I'm I'm a fan of always you know following the
- 1:05:51law in the jurisdiction that you live in.
- 1:05:53Like I'm not sort of saying like try to be like radical against
- 1:05:56it. But I do think there are things
- 1:05:57that are at the edges of what is really like specifically defined
- 1:06:02or sort of the incentives, the organizations that are running
- 1:06:05that. And I think you want to try to
- 1:06:07find where you can serve people's needs that are not
- 1:06:11illegal in the jurisdiction where you reside and
- 1:06:13incorporate, you know set up whatever your your entity is,
- 1:06:16where you're you're building these things, but they can serve
- 1:06:20some of the needs that that are not served by the other ones.
- 1:06:24So I, you know, I think things like I have some, I have some
- 1:06:27some friends who who do like those like fantasy sports.
- 1:06:32Like I think fantasy sports is like a, you know there's there's
- 1:06:35money flowing. There's communication.
- 1:06:37I don't, I'm not like a big, you know, sports guy.
- 1:06:40So I don't really know all the details.
- 1:06:41But it feels like an area that like there's a lot of people I
- 1:06:45know who do it a lot and it involves communication and money
- 1:06:47and like we don't really have products for it because like
- 1:06:50it's you can't really do those commercially.
- 1:06:53But maybe if you can build non custodial wallets and and you
- 1:06:57know decentralize the speech so that there's nobody really you
- 1:07:01know sort of acting as a as a money transmitter has to be kind
- 1:07:04of a choke point for taking these things down.
- 1:07:06I think like let innovation like that flourish and you know help
- 1:07:10help people try out new things that then sort of create these
- 1:07:14ground swells and get get more people involved in kind of the
- 1:07:18the you know, the technologies and sort of explore the edges of
- 1:07:20what what can be built now. Yeah, I think this anchors back.
- 1:07:23It's like a drum I continue to be is about the talent in like
- 1:07:27the human capital is like I believe fundamentally like the
- 1:07:29best and the largest Bitcoin companies or companies even
- 1:07:32adjacent to this have not yet even been like started simply
- 1:07:35because it's just a function of like we're almost excited about
- 1:07:39100K. Bitcoin is simply because of the
- 1:07:41market awareness and then the individuals that you're
- 1:07:44referencing at all of these different pain points that exist
- 1:07:46in the market don't probably even know about Bitcoin or know
- 1:07:48about like the thing maybe they think digital gold like you
- 1:07:51first came into it versus programmable nature.
- 1:07:54And so I think of that lens of like we need the Forex trader or
- 1:07:58the Visa exact that gets the tech and then it's like, oh, I
- 1:08:01know how to map this, not the person that gets the tech.
- 1:08:03And it says, oh I know how to fix like payments.
- 1:08:05And we still are just like starting that in one of the the
- 1:08:11angles on a late night trip with Marty, he may know of he he
- 1:08:15coast on the last trade and he we were sitting there like
- 1:08:19riffing on. And this isn't very kosher in
- 1:08:22the sense of like what you're describing.
- 1:08:23It's like I don't know where this would be stood up, but it
- 1:08:26makes sense from a productivity and utility perspective.
- 1:08:29What you were describing is like a Torrance and this idea with
- 1:08:32like I was thinking about like with Bitcoin there is no such
- 1:08:34thing. Like everybody talks about
- 1:08:35putting like you know data on the blockchain or some kind of
- 1:08:38like information. But the reality is that's like
- 1:08:41not the right way to think about it.
- 1:08:42It's just whoever stores it has the right marketplace.
- 1:08:45And there's always an equilibrium where somebody's
- 1:08:46willing to pay and somebody's willing to take the chance to
- 1:08:48store it and give it up. And it was this idea, once you
- 1:08:51have Bitcoin, you can always like create torrents and you can
- 1:08:54never shut them down. Because every time you pop it
- 1:08:56up, you can just say like you can create a program on nature.
- 1:08:59You you see it or whatever, you download it and then if you want
- 1:09:02to see it and take that next like baton and get that money
- 1:09:04back has that thing, you know he's created.
- 1:09:07And it was this idea we said we never talked about it again.
- 1:09:09And I were like, because this is highly legal, it doesn't make
- 1:09:10any sense. But this?
- 1:09:12Is a concept of like nostrum in the sense of like you're always
- 1:09:14just like paying somebody that if they're willing, somebody's
- 1:09:17always going to be willing to broadcast that data because you
- 1:09:19have a form of money, somebody's going to value to accept they
- 1:09:22cannot be censored. And so you take that mental
- 1:09:26model. Then everything's possible.
- 1:09:28Yeah. And I think there's always like
- 1:09:29an edge of what, you know, sort of what people want and what can
- 1:09:34be done and what's not explicitly illegal.
- 1:09:38So stuff that's kind of, you know, it's like nobody's really
- 1:09:41sure, nobody really weighed in on that or we didn't have a
- 1:09:44framework for thinking about that.
- 1:09:45But now you can actually do these things.
- 1:09:46I think that's like the sweet spot of of what great would look
- 1:09:50like. And you know, I think it's it,
- 1:09:53it takes a ton of imagination. So it's not like, oh,
- 1:09:56everybody's just being lazy. It's just like it takes a lot of
- 1:09:58imagination and trial and error. And it's actually, it's very
- 1:10:01risky in a certain way because like, you know, you don't know
- 1:10:05if it's going to be adopted and you don't know, like if you're
- 1:10:08going to connect with the audience of people.
- 1:10:10Like, I mean, you know, Bitcoin may be great, but maybe without
- 1:10:12payments, maybe the, you know, the adult or gambling use cases
- 1:10:17wouldn't really work so well. Like that's that's possible,
- 1:10:20right. And so maybe you actually need
- 1:10:22more success with Lightning or more liquidity or more people
- 1:10:25having it for other reasons. But then those those things can
- 1:10:29emerge. There's like, you know, there's
- 1:10:30like a little bit of a push and pull, you know like a, you know
- 1:10:34two sides to it that kind of need to grow up together.
- 1:10:38And it's hard to say that we're like at point X that everything
- 1:10:42now can be done. It's like we need to get a
- 1:10:44little bit more infrastructure so we can get a little bit more
- 1:10:46a little more apps and a little bit maybe more scaling
- 1:10:49technologies with payments to allow us to get more app
- 1:10:51experiences that work in non custodial ways.
- 1:10:54And it's kind of a a constant progress almost like a like A2
- 1:10:58sided marketplace in some sense. Maybe it's the inside of
- 1:11:00marketplace, but it kind of always needs to keep creeping up
- 1:11:03and balancing and it's not just like OK now unleash everything,
- 1:11:07it's more like OK we've got enough there.
- 1:11:09I mean, I think this is actually kind of a lot about, you know,
- 1:11:11Noster today is a, you know, it's a it's a it's a protocol,
- 1:11:16it's technology idea. And we have some clients, but we
- 1:11:19haven't, I'd say we haven't seen a ton of radical exploration on
- 1:11:24like what new apps could be built.
- 1:11:26We have a lot of Twitter clones because they're kind of like,
- 1:11:28you know, they're safe and they're useful, Like people want
- 1:11:30them and we know what they should look like.
- 1:11:33We know what features they should have.
- 1:11:34But we haven't really explored the edges of, like what are the
- 1:11:37new types of apps that you just couldn't build before Noster?
- 1:11:40Like it's, you know, it's something that only works in
- 1:11:42this kind of ecosystem. Yeah, there's precedent for this
- 1:11:45with bit Mex and nitrogen sports are both examples in different
- 1:11:49forms of like they were both Bitcoin on and Bitcoin off.
- 1:11:52So they never had the rail touch anything and one was offering
- 1:11:54derivatives. You know bit Mex lasted for a
- 1:11:57very long time and that's The funny thing.
- 1:11:58And they had like a three or four multi sig all over the
- 1:12:00world. So even when they were in
- 1:12:02handcuffs, they were still able always to like deliver Bitcoin
- 1:12:04because they always signed once a day to deliver.
- 1:12:06So they're going and then the other one is Nitrogen Sports,
- 1:12:09which is gambling across the world, but it's just Bitcoin on
- 1:12:12and off. And so they like, I think
- 1:12:14operate in a certain jurisdiction from like whatever
- 1:12:16DNS are being able to have their website always hosted, but they
- 1:12:19don't deal with any rails outside of Bitcoin.
- 1:12:22That was actually my first instance in Bitcoin as I moved
- 1:12:25to New York City and there was nobody there.
- 1:12:27And so I was like Googling and then the.
- 1:12:29Price. Kept running up because you're
- 1:12:31holding it and it's sitting in this account, but the dollar
- 1:12:34amount kept going up, but nothing had changed.
- 1:12:35And I was like, what is happening here in the rest of
- 1:12:38the history? Yeah.
- 1:12:40One one thing I wanted to ask you about TK is, is you know, I
- 1:12:44think this sort of falls under the umbrella of things that are
- 1:12:48now possible on Noster that aren't possible in, in sort of
- 1:12:53the incumbent systems and that would be sort of in the realm of
- 1:12:56micro payments. So if you're talking about like
- 1:12:58the value for value sort of thesis or zaps which you know
- 1:13:02take place across various Noster clients.
- 1:13:06If you could talk a little bit about that just because you know
- 1:13:08I've, I've sort of wrestled with it in my own mind around how how
- 1:13:12a tool like that gets sort of adopted by the masses.
- 1:13:16I see. I I see the value of it in terms
- 1:13:19of and we talked with Max about this a bit in terms of like you
- 1:13:23know you could create these new systems for sort of market
- 1:13:25ranking or value ranking creating these like webs of
- 1:13:28trust where there's actual you know skin in the game related to
- 1:13:32the value of a piece of content or you know whatever whatever it
- 1:13:36may be. I'm curious your thoughts just
- 1:13:39around that notion around that sort of use case of sort of
- 1:13:42rapid instant final settlement payments that now enable
- 1:13:47different micro payments use cases.
- 1:13:48But then also like, what is the tipping point for that getting
- 1:13:51adopted? Because I've, you know, I've
- 1:13:52talked with some of my normie friends about this in the past
- 1:13:55and they they the retort is so why would I pay money?
- 1:14:00Bitcoin, this thing that you say is the best asset of all time.
- 1:14:03Why would I pay money to like something when I am used to
- 1:14:06liking it for free? Right.
- 1:14:08Yeah. I mean, I think, I think micro
- 1:14:10payments is this thing that everybody always like, you know,
- 1:14:12shies away from her says, oh, that'll never work.
- 1:14:14It's too much, too much friction, you know, to think
- 1:14:17about making a micro payment. But we actually do micro
- 1:14:19payments all the time historically, like we would have
- 1:14:23these. We have like a data plan with
- 1:14:25our mobile phone, right. Sorry, it's the dog.
- 1:14:29We have a little puppy who's excited about this concept I
- 1:14:31guess. But we have these, we have you
- 1:14:35know these these payment systems like you know maybe you have
- 1:14:38like a certain amount of data that you buy from your mobile
- 1:14:41phone carrier and then like you draw down on that balance and
- 1:14:44little micro payments every time you like visit a website on your
- 1:14:47mobile phone. So I think that concept we
- 1:14:49already have like bundled and then paid out, but it's all done
- 1:14:52kind of with a single provider instead of with multi providers.
- 1:14:55All we're doing now is we're taking that sort of mobile phone
- 1:14:57data plan package idea and now we're saying it doesn't have to
- 1:15:01all be drawn down an account directly with my carrier, but
- 1:15:05actually could be sent out to various websites or creators or
- 1:15:08all kinds of different. So I actually think that we
- 1:15:10actually heard plenty of experience with micro payments.
- 1:15:12We just don't have them baked in at the application layer for our
- 1:15:16Internet services yet. We have them.
- 1:15:18You know, maybe most people have experience with it in kind of
- 1:15:20the data carrier provider space. So I think once you, once you
- 1:15:25have these things, you can actually shape the applications
- 1:15:29to, you know, I think it's right to say like the in the short
- 1:15:32case, like why like it here when I have to pay where I like it
- 1:15:37here and it's free. But then there's the whole
- 1:15:38system that you need to be thinking about, not just the one
- 1:15:41interaction of pay versus free, but it's like what content is
- 1:15:44showing up there, What content is showing up to me because it's
- 1:15:48created in that way. And maybe there's a totally
- 1:15:52different type of content, but it would show up if the right
- 1:15:55incentives were in place. Like today people do content
- 1:15:59that works with an ad supported, single algorithm driven
- 1:16:03platform. That's kind of how Twitter
- 1:16:04works. That's how TikTok works.
- 1:16:07That's how YouTube works. Like all of these systems are
- 1:16:10built to serve content that aligns with the the needs and
- 1:16:14the optimization of a free system that's ad supported which
- 1:16:18which is fine, like that's how the business grew up.
- 1:16:19Like I get it no problem at all. But we have a new primitive.
- 1:16:22So instead of saying like what are the, you know, why would I
- 1:16:26pay when I could otherwise have it for free.
- 1:16:28It's like what kinds of new content might get created or
- 1:16:32what kinds of new platforms or protocols might you choose to
- 1:16:36use if you could actually have a very different experience with
- 1:16:38the web. So instead of being like like
- 1:16:40maybe I don't want to just do the most dopamine inducing app
- 1:16:43that I can, but actually want to do something like like I'll go,
- 1:16:47I'll go buy a book and read it on a Kindle for like, you know,
- 1:16:5110 hours. Like that's a choice and a
- 1:16:53different experience. And I'm paying money and that's
- 1:16:55fine. Maybe I could have a similar
- 1:16:57type of experience to buying a book, but I could do it as a way
- 1:17:01to unlock content that may be locked up.
- 1:17:03Like, there's people who I know of from a lot of the free
- 1:17:07content they make. And then they, they have like
- 1:17:09paywalls. And then, you know, if I want to
- 1:17:11get access to like their whole library or a monthly
- 1:17:14subscription, like, I'm willing to pay for that.
- 1:17:17But there's a lot more friction because I don't necessarily want
- 1:17:19like hundreds of, you know, hundreds of these things that
- 1:17:21I'm signed up to with monthly recurring.
- 1:17:24But maybe I could see a thinker or see a piece or see a preview
- 1:17:28of a piece. And instead of having to like
- 1:17:30sign up for like a monthly subscription to unlock the
- 1:17:32piece, I could just like unlock it because I have a way to
- 1:17:35interact with the web with this digital scarcity primitive.
- 1:17:38And if I think that future to me seems kind of like obvious, but
- 1:17:42it's just not here yet. Like it's obvious that we're
- 1:17:44going to have digital scarcity baked into all of our Internet
- 1:17:49experiences and we're going to use that digital scarcity to
- 1:17:53dole out in small amounts micro payments in all kinds of
- 1:17:57different places. But you know, and it'll be used
- 1:18:01to unlock content that we want. You know, it's not just all out
- 1:18:04of I think it's like goodwill, oh let's, you know, support our
- 1:18:06favorite creators like that's fine.
- 1:18:08But I think that doesn't really, I don't think that recognizes
- 1:18:13people you know, actually human incentives though I would like I
- 1:18:17would love to see somebody build something.
- 1:18:19You know, maybe it's a TikTok driven, you know, TikTok style
- 1:18:23app with like short form video but every time you swipe it
- 1:18:27costs you a SAT or every time you like it costs you ten sets
- 1:18:30or something like that And and now why does that work?
- 1:18:34Well creator, some creators realize that like you can come
- 1:18:38on here and maybe you can make a whole Bitcoin every day if you
- 1:18:42have great kind of like that's an insane idea.
- 1:18:45It sounds like that could never work, but like all the pieces
- 1:18:47are there like that that could actually work where a creator
- 1:18:51could come on and through creating content in a new
- 1:18:55environment with a very different set of incentives, not
- 1:18:58the old ad driven incentives, but with you know, with kind of
- 1:19:01digital scarcity baked in, you actually just shape, you know,
- 1:19:04you reshape the kind of content that gets created, gets
- 1:19:06rewarded, you give people more direct relationships.
- 1:19:09It's not out of charity or out of sort of patronage, but it's
- 1:19:13because I actually, you know, already have a wallet
- 1:19:16established, already have value. And so it's just kind of like
- 1:19:19fine, it's easy for me which is not today, but like if we have
- 1:19:23the tools it could be easy for me to to make that kind of
- 1:19:25payment and maybe it's like around unlocking.
- 1:19:28So I think there's just like you know, it's like we're very early
- 1:19:31in the exploration. I haven't seen a lot of people.
- 1:19:33I mean it's a very risky idea to do kind of what I just suggested
- 1:19:37there and maybe it wouldn't work until people haven't tried it.
- 1:19:41But I think there's just like infinite space of ideas of
- 1:19:43things that could be built. But but we we sort of you know
- 1:19:47we have enough examples of micro payments working and ways that
- 1:19:51micro payments can work and the way that they do work with
- 1:19:54within kind of Bitcoin ecosystem.
- 1:19:56I think it's just like it's an inevitability that the Internet
- 1:19:58is going to get like all information communication media
- 1:20:01is going to be coupled with digital scarcity.
- 1:20:03But like the actual path to get there, is it gambling first, is
- 1:20:06it adult content first, is it some sort of other free speech
- 1:20:10issue first? Like I think the only way to get
- 1:20:12there is through kind of a lot of exploration, like lots of
- 1:20:16people building a lot of different things with different
- 1:20:18perspectives and different, you know, potential customers and
- 1:20:20users in mind. Yeah, I think.
- 1:20:24I think that's right. Yeah, I mean.
- 1:20:26That's fascinating. I think it's a great idea.
- 1:20:28I say this a lot. I don't think you've heard.
- 1:20:30It's like generally in the space, if you have a good idea,
- 1:20:32it's really a good idea. It just hasn't been done yet.
- 1:20:34We're in the regular world. Good idea.
- 1:20:36It's probably a bad idea. It's work out.
- 1:20:40But like the the Stacker news is a good example of that right?
- 1:20:43Like the essence, you're just providing some your requirements
- 1:20:46and proof of work to surface content to the top in the same
- 1:20:49way that you would change the dynamic from the the video
- 1:20:52content on a TikTok or whatever it would be called.
- 1:20:55And then it goes back to like Max's version.
- 1:20:57And it's not just Max's but this idea of like getting the
- 1:21:00tightest fidelity with energy. Because that energy you're
- 1:21:02produce, you're you're you're putting all out in the world
- 1:21:05you're consuming and then you have to require energy by the
- 1:21:08form of Bitcoin to to like see more of it or to like it and it
- 1:21:12just tightens a feedback loop of like actual value versus like
- 1:21:15garbage and that starts to re architect a lot of things.
- 1:21:18So yeah, no I think that makes makes a lot of sense.
- 1:21:20Yeah. 100%. Well, maybe maybe just one more
- 1:21:25final question before before we wrap up.
- 1:21:27Just curious, you know, how are you spending your time today?
- 1:21:30What excites you most in the world's of Bitcoin and Noster?
- 1:21:33And then finally you know where can people find you?
- 1:21:35Because I think your YouTube, your YouTube channel in
- 1:21:39particular and and your podcast are extremely informative and
- 1:21:43and some of the best content on this super nascent space of
- 1:21:47Noster. So really appreciate you putting
- 1:21:49that stuff out there and helping myself and others learn about
- 1:21:53this. So yeah, what are you spending
- 1:21:55your time on, and where can people find you?
- 1:21:57Yeah. So I'm, I would say I like
- 1:22:00continue to be super excited and interested in the interplay of
- 1:22:05like how you know, sort of digital scarcity and information
- 1:22:10kind of quality, let's say gets sort of reinvents the Internet.
- 1:22:14And so you know, I spend my time in part trying to help some
- 1:22:19entrepreneurs who are already working in those spaces.
- 1:22:21So people are maybe building things on Noster.
- 1:22:25You know, I try to play with their tools and get feedback.
- 1:22:27It's like a big part of what I do is, you know, play with new
- 1:22:30tools that people are building and try to give feedback or
- 1:22:32share my perspective on what what I like about it, what
- 1:22:35doesn't make sense to me, where I'm getting confused, where I'm
- 1:22:37stuck. And and that helps me learn
- 1:22:41about new technologies, you know, sort of just getting broad
- 1:22:45exposure to lots of new things. I do that both in kind of the
- 1:22:47nostril Bitcoin space, but I also do it in spaces like, you
- 1:22:51know, I think that there's a category in AI storytelling.
- 1:22:54I think storytelling is like super underserved in AI.
- 1:22:58And so like just thinking about an entrepreneur, you know,
- 1:23:01messaging constantly every day. I think we we trade notes on a
- 1:23:04product he's building to help help people become better
- 1:23:08storytellers. You know, help sort of if you
- 1:23:09have an idea for a script, you can now, you know, you know,
- 1:23:12build a Hollywood movie, right? Like that's, you know, long term
- 1:23:14vision, but but in the short term there's like steps to get
- 1:23:17there that he's actively pursuing.
- 1:23:19So I always love to play with those kinds of things.
- 1:23:21I play with a lot in kind of the Noster ecosystem.
- 1:23:25I have a close friend collaborator who's very active
- 1:23:29in the Bitcoin community. And so we sit down every week
- 1:23:32for, you know, maybe a couple hours and play with new kind of
- 1:23:35Bitcoin or Lightning related tools and just try to like you
- 1:23:38know, try to run into roadblocks and kind of force.
- 1:23:42It's a forcing function to help us understand better because
- 1:23:44then we end up with a whole list of questions.
- 1:23:47So all of that is you know I'd say kind of exploration around
- 1:23:51like these very, you know, nascent edges is is you know
- 1:23:56kind of where I spend, I'd say like most of my time I've also
- 1:23:59been, yeah, like you mentioned kind of podcasting and I've been
- 1:24:02writing a bit. I'm just trying to like digest
- 1:24:05you know and synthesize ideas that I hear from people and and
- 1:24:09and try out new things. And then and I've actually got a
- 1:24:12a project that I'm sort of little bit of like a hack
- 1:24:15project with a friend. You know we've been talking for
- 1:24:19actually for years about like why is it, you know, why is it
- 1:24:23that, you know, I think I think so much energy goes into these
- 1:24:27like very horizontal platform related work which is like all
- 1:24:32good. Like you know whether it's
- 1:24:34whether it's wallets or or social media apps and Noster and
- 1:24:38and it feels like there's an opportunity to make something
- 1:24:42that is more relatable. It's easy for people to just
- 1:24:45sort of see and play with and digest and it feels new.
- 1:24:48So we've been brewing up this idea of something like a a a a
- 1:24:52global game show that you get you get you can win anybody who
- 1:24:56wants to play at home and you can win Bitcoin just by showing
- 1:25:00up and you know sort of playing trivia game at home.
- 1:25:03So we're we've been kind of hacking around on that idea and
- 1:25:05and we're going to start play testing soon.
- 1:25:08But I think you know anything that really makes Bitcoin master
- 1:25:13these open source technologies more accessible to people,
- 1:25:16easier to engage with. You know tighter feedback loops
- 1:25:20on like what's working about the new stuff and what's challenging
- 1:25:23about the new stuff. So we can sort of get to the the
- 1:25:26stuff that's working faster. Like that's those are those are
- 1:25:29things I'm passionate about this where I spend my time.
- 1:25:31It's another night asking, sorry, I was just another good
- 1:25:35idea. It was something we meant to do.
- 1:25:36We just have it implemented. I'm sure you're familiar with
- 1:25:38MASH and a lot of the tooling that they're creating about
- 1:25:40making this show or the last trade more interactive from like
- 1:25:44what are the topics we talk about?
- 1:25:45And just like dynamics of like winning Sats and like doing like
- 1:25:49threads or like voting on Twitter before we go and we
- 1:25:53really haven't done it. But yeah, I think that's an
- 1:25:56awesome idea in the sense of like, especially if it's intro
- 1:25:58stuff where people are interested in learning, what
- 1:26:00better way than to get a better to get a form of money and then
- 1:26:03learn actually getting a wallet or whatever, however you're
- 1:26:06going to like get delivered that Bitcoin.
- 1:26:09Right. And if you if you played with
- 1:26:10like like there's a a wallet called Mutiny that you can just
- 1:26:14like they have a really great gifting flow where you can just
- 1:26:17like send a link to somebody and then they have a wallet directly
- 1:26:20in the browser. It's kind of amazing.
- 1:26:22You know, how simple it is and how I think it's like a great
- 1:26:24way to help new people learn about, you know, learn about
- 1:26:30Bitcoin because they like, they don't have to start with
- 1:26:31anything. Just click on the link and now
- 1:26:33you've got some Bitcoin link. Oh, how did that happen?
- 1:26:35You know we. Meet you may need Ben or Tony or
- 1:26:38Paul on the pot or he's joke. They're they're like Wizards.
- 1:26:41They're literally like, so hold on to what?
- 1:26:43They're doing doing some cool stuff.
- 1:26:45We've we've got some mutual friends, but I I don't know them
- 1:26:47personally, but I've heard heard really good things about them.
- 1:26:50Yeah, they're really, they're really exceptional.
- 1:26:53Yeah. Well, awesome.
- 1:26:55Want to thank you again DK for for.
- 1:26:57Making your time. This is.
- 1:26:58DK off he was gonna. There was a second part to the
- 1:27:01that he was referencing. Oh no, I I was just trying to
- 1:27:04follow up your your original thing asked where people can
- 1:27:06find me. So Oh yeah, Twitter.com,
- 1:27:09twitter.com/DKSF. And that links to curiousdk.com
- 1:27:13which is kind of my personal website where you can find, you
- 1:27:15know, the newsletter and you know my end pub.
- 1:27:19Find it hard to list my end pub. It was on Twitter before but of
- 1:27:22course my account gets nerfed. So so easiest thing to type into
- 1:27:26a browser is just you know like curiousdk.com and you can sort
- 1:27:29of find everything from there. Beautiful.
- 1:27:31Well, thanks again. Really great conversation and
- 1:27:34hopefully have you have you on again sometime as things
- 1:27:37continue to develop at a rapid pace in the Noster world and
- 1:27:40you're on top of it that. Was a lot of fun.
- 1:27:43All right. Until next time, next final
- 1:27:45settlement, guys.