Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / What’s New in California Privacy 2026
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to What's New in California Privacy 2026.
- 0:07I'm Christina Tustin. I'm the chair of the Beverly
- 0:09Hills Bar Association Privacy and Cybersecurity
- 0:12Law Section. I'm delighted to introduce our speakers,
- 0:16Sarah Bruno and Lawrence Burns. Sarah Bruno is
- 0:19a partner at Reed Smith LLP San Francisco office
- 0:22and a trusted advisor to companies in the entertainment,
- 0:25technology, beauty, consumer product, and healthcare
- 0:27industries on privacy, intellectual property,
- 0:30and advertising matters. She counsels clients
- 0:32on data privacy compliance, product launches,
- 0:36marketing strategies, and IP protection, helping
- 0:38them navigate complex and evolving legal frameworks
- 0:41across jurisdictions and media platforms. Sarah's
- 0:44rightly recognized for her leadership in cyber
- 0:46law, privacy, and trademarks and has been consistently
- 0:49ranked by the Legal 500 and Daily Journal. We
- 0:54also have Lawrence L .B. Burns, who's an associate
- 0:57with Reed Smith's Emerging Technology Group,
- 1:00where his multidisciplinary practice focuses
- 1:02on privacy, intellectual property, data innovation,
- 1:05and artificial intelligence. He advises clients
- 1:08on navigating complex U .S. risk mitigation strategies
- 1:13and supports advertising, marketing, and technology
- 1:16initiatives, while also bringing significant
- 1:18experience in privacy litigation, data breach
- 1:21initiatives, class actions, and IP disputes.
- 1:25Albie regularly speaks on AI -related topics,
- 1:28including generative AI, AI -specific contracting,
- 1:31and open -source data consideration. I'm thrilled
- 1:34to have them joining this panel today, and let's
- 1:37get started. We will accept questions at the
- 1:40end. Feel free to put them in the chat as we
- 1:43go along, but there will be time for questions
- 1:45at the end. I'll turn it over to our esteemed
- 1:50panelists. Great. Thank you, Christina. Hi, everyone.
- 1:56Sarah Bruno, I'm going to kick us off today.
- 1:58Thanks for joining. Thanks for sharing your lunchtime
- 2:02with us. As Christina mentioned, we're going
- 2:04to be talking about what's new in California
- 2:07privacy. Elbie, if you can move to the next slide.
- 2:11We have a brief agenda here. Yep. We're going
- 2:16to start with just a summary. We're going to
- 2:19look back for a minute just at what has happened
- 2:22on the enforcement side in 2025, because I think
- 2:24that'll set the stage for what we have in front
- 2:27of us in 2026. Then we're going to talk a little
- 2:31bit about the regs. That'll be more about, you
- 2:35know, the actual paper that we're looking at
- 2:38in 2026 and what's coming. And then LB is going
- 2:42to talk a little bit about what we're seeing
- 2:45That's interesting and practical, a lot of the
- 2:47practical guidance we're giving right now. And
- 2:50then we have time for questions at the end. And
- 2:54also, feel free to put some questions in the
- 2:56chat. And if we don't have time for questions,
- 2:58we will circle back with you by email after the
- 3:02conversation, certainly, and get back to you.
- 3:04And with that, we can move to the first section
- 3:07of this. OK, so like I said, we're going to start
- 3:11by talking about some of the cases. I don't know
- 3:15how familiar everyone here is with the California
- 3:17Consumer Privacy Act, but it's been around now
- 3:20for five years. The point of this conversation
- 3:22is to not give a summary of the CCPA. It's what's
- 3:26new with California privacy. So again, we're
- 3:29going to be talking as if there's a general awareness
- 3:32of California, the CCPA. And with that, we're
- 3:36talking about some cases that came out in the
- 3:39last couple of months of 2025. We have the California
- 3:45Privacy Protection Agency had a few interesting
- 3:48cases that we're highlighting at the end of 2025.
- 3:52And one was with Tractor Supply Company. I wanted
- 3:55to highlight that most of these cases have a
- 3:57very familiar theme, and if you listen to the
- 4:01agency and you go to some of the regulatory chats
- 4:03across the board, the regulators in all of the
- 4:08states that have these comprehensive privacy
- 4:11laws, there's now 19 of them, the regulators
- 4:14are pretty consistent in what they're looking
- 4:16for, and that's outward -facing compliance. Showing
- 4:20up on your website that you have systems that
- 4:23demonstrate that you're compli - with the law
- 4:25and that is having those opt -outs if the law
- 4:28requires it. California is one of those states
- 4:30that has the strict requirements that do not
- 4:33sell or share and again that's if you meet the
- 4:35thresholds for the CCPA compliance and if you
- 4:38do you have to have that do not sell or share
- 4:41link if you are selling or sharing data. With
- 4:46that comes the opt -out. And a lot of the focus
- 4:49of the California enforcement is on these businesses
- 4:53that when the CPPA, the Privacy Protection Agency,
- 4:59is doing their checking, they're noticing that
- 5:02some of these companies don't have that outward
- 5:04-facing compliance. And they've made it very
- 5:06clear that that's where they're starting. They're
- 5:08sending those check -in emails. They're seeing
- 5:11if you're responding to consumers' access requests.
- 5:15They're checking to see if you have your opt
- 5:17-outs correctly processing on the website. And
- 5:21if not, you're going to start to get those inquiries
- 5:23from the agency. So a lot of these cases, that's
- 5:27where it starts. And here with Tractor Supply
- 5:30Co, that's what we had. The actual end result
- 5:34is they determined that there was an ineffective
- 5:36opt -out. They also had an older privacy policy
- 5:41that didn't have the appropriate language for
- 5:43current CCPA compliance. So that was a need to...
- 5:48need to be updated. You should, if you aren't
- 5:51already and you're working with your clients,
- 5:53you need to make sure they have regular updates.
- 5:55It used to be you could get away with every year,
- 5:58every 18 months, no longer. You should really
- 6:01have clients that are looking at their privacy
- 6:02policies every six months to make sure they're
- 6:05up to date. Not only for California, but there's
- 6:08all these new laws that are coming out routinely
- 6:10and you need to make sure your clients are routinely
- 6:13updating their privacy policy. With the Tractor
- 6:16Supply Code, it was an older policy. It wasn't
- 6:18up to date. They also weren't complying with
- 6:21the employee notices. That's important, too.
- 6:24California is the one state where you have to
- 6:26have employee privacy notices. They were behind
- 6:30with that as well. And then finally, data processing
- 6:34agreements. They didn't have that either. Again,
- 6:37we need to make sure that the transfer of data
- 6:39to third parties is covered with an agreement.
- 6:42That's something that's you know required now
- 6:45in California and that was lacking as well. So
- 6:49that's a good one to start with because we had
- 6:50a lot of issues. Next we'll move to Sling TV.
- 6:54This one really had the opt -out issue and it
- 6:57was part of an enforcement sweep and we'll get
- 7:01to this in a second but one of the things that
- 7:04Bonta does, and California does, is they announced
- 7:07that we're doing an enforcement sweep. And one
- 7:09of the enforcement sweeps they announced was
- 7:11streaming TVs. Sling got wrapped up in this,
- 7:14which is part of the problem. Here was, again,
- 7:17the opt -out. But they also focused a little
- 7:20bit on the fact that there was complicated to
- 7:23opt out. It was more steps to opt out. It took
- 7:25longer for the consumers to have to go through
- 7:27that opt out than it did for consumers to opt
- 7:30in. So if you make it more complicated for consumers
- 7:34to do, the thing that you don't want them to
- 7:36do, which is maybe opt out or remove their data
- 7:39or whatever it may be, that can be considered
- 7:41a dark pattern. And you could have an, you know,
- 7:45again, the California Privacy Protection Agency
- 7:47is checking on this stuff and suddenly you have
- 7:49an inquiry and then they're going behind the
- 7:51curtain to see whether what else you have going
- 7:54on. So and then the other issue here is they
- 7:56didn't have the opt ins for teenagers. You need
- 7:59to make sure if you're selling Personal information
- 8:03for targeted advertising that you have 13 to
- 8:0616 year olds opting in on your site and they
- 8:10didn't have that. We can move to the next slide.
- 8:15Jam City was similar, a little bit similar to
- 8:17Slang. I mean, we had that opt -in issue. They
- 8:19didn't have the dark pattern issue. But again,
- 8:21it's important that you're looking to see what
- 8:23you're doing with team data. You're figuring
- 8:25out if you have teams on your site. And if you
- 8:28are, and you're selling or you have that targeted
- 8:30advertising that you're making sure you have
- 8:32an opt -in. And then again, it was the opt -out.
- 8:36Otherwise it was the opt -out for their other
- 8:37mobile games and they weren't having that compliant.
- 8:41Again, these are just outward facing things that
- 8:43the CPPA was checking on. This last one is a
- 8:46little different. You see how small that settlement
- 8:48was, 56 ,000. Not a big deal. I like to highlight
- 8:53this one. One, because it's a data broker. Again,
- 8:57this was another part of another sweep. I mean,
- 9:00the CPPA is focused on data brokers and making
- 9:04sure that there's this registration. And we'll
- 9:06talk about that for a minute in a few slides.
- 9:09But this was an advertising agency that didn't
- 9:12register as a data broker. And they found them
- 9:16to be a data broker. One of the things they said
- 9:22is, a sale is a sale. And what a data broker
- 9:24is is that they've defined this quite clearly.
- 9:30If you are a company that is selling the personal
- 9:34information, collecting and selling the personal
- 9:37information of a lot of consumers or two third
- 9:41parties, and you've collected it and you're selling
- 9:45it to third parties, And even if you've collected
- 9:49it from a cookie on the website, if the consumer's
- 9:53intention wasn't to have that data go to you,
- 9:57then that's considered a third party collection
- 10:00and you're selling it to a third party. That's
- 10:03considered a data broker. Basically, it's like
- 10:05an indirect collection of mass amounts of data
- 10:08and you're selling it. So a lot of these advertising
- 10:10agencies are essentially doing that because they're
- 10:14collecting data on behalf of they're collecting
- 10:19data essentially as a third party and selling
- 10:22it to another party. Because the consumer is
- 10:25not intending that data to go to that party.
- 10:28They're intending the data to go to the first
- 10:31party, which is the company that they're buying
- 10:32the shoes from on the website. They're not intending
- 10:35it to go to the advertising agency. or whatever
- 10:38party it is that's collecting that data and selling
- 10:41it to other parties. So that's a data broker,
- 10:44and that company has to be registering at the
- 10:48CPPA on the California Cal Privacy site as a
- 10:52data broker. And so this is an interesting one
- 10:55because 56 ,000. So a lot of people were like,
- 10:58do I really care? A lot of companies are like,
- 11:00well, I don't really care. I like to highlight
- 11:03this because it also requires them to, the other
- 11:06part of this was they need to have DPAs. So in
- 11:09a lot of situations, we have these advertising
- 11:11agencies that may not want to DPA. And this was
- 11:14also highlighted as part of this case. On the
- 11:17other hand, we have some that are saying, well,
- 11:20it's 56 ,000. And so it kind of goes back and
- 11:25forth. Because in the other cases, if you saw,
- 11:27they have really big penalties. And this one
- 11:30didn't. But they still highlighted this and have
- 11:34this up on their site as one that they're going
- 11:36after as part of their data broker enforcement
- 11:40sweep that they've been doing more recently.
- 11:42OK, we can move to the next slide. Again, these
- 11:46are just some of the sweeps. They did a sweep
- 11:49with employee data. They did a sweep with data
- 11:52brokers. That's the purple one. Geolocation was
- 11:55part of their sweep. As part of that, they did
- 12:01automotive data, data collected from cars, part
- 12:06of the geolocation. And then that last one is
- 12:08just the streaming, to reference the streaming
- 12:12sweep that they did. We can go to the next slide.
- 12:15And now we're into 2026, and this was just recently,
- 12:20they announced an investigatory sweep into the
- 12:24hotel, retail, and grocery industries with surveillance
- 12:27pricing. And this is actually, I think, showing
- 12:30that the CPPA, well, this is Bonta, but California
- 12:34in general is getting a little bit more specific
- 12:38with what they're looking at, a little bit more
- 12:41in depth at what they're looking at. in that
- 12:44this is surveillance pricing, which is a layer
- 12:46below those outward -facing compliance measures.
- 12:49We're now doing a little and more in -depth investigation.
- 12:53So surveillance pricing is essentially when you're
- 12:57providing, you're collecting data, running it
- 13:00through an algorithm, and determining a price
- 13:02that a consumer may be willing to pay for something
- 13:05based on the location they're at. And in order
- 13:09to provide that pricing, The theory is that it
- 13:12involves personal information in addition to
- 13:15other information that may be relevant, which
- 13:18is just demographic information and other aggregated
- 13:20data that you've collected based on me being
- 13:23in San Francisco, for example, and what I'm willing
- 13:26to pay for an airfare ticket or whatever it may
- 13:29be for a pair of shoes or whatever I'm shopping
- 13:32for versus someone in Seattle shopping for the
- 13:37same thing. Banta's note is that it may be a
- 13:44violation of the purpose standard of the CPPA,
- 13:48which is that you can only collect and use the
- 13:52data for the purpose for which the consumer expects
- 13:54you to be using it for, which is me buying a
- 13:58pair of shoes. And that's why you're using my
- 14:00data. You shouldn't be repurposing that data
- 14:02to determine what I would be willing to pay for
- 14:06an airfare ticket. And so the investigatory sweep
- 14:10is to check in with these companies to see if
- 14:15they're actually tagging and using the data in
- 14:17accordance with what the purpose the consumer
- 14:20believes that they're providing the data to the
- 14:21company for and not some other purpose. So this
- 14:25is a good reminder. I like this one just because
- 14:28I think it's gonna be really interesting to see
- 14:30where this lands and if anything comes out of
- 14:32it. And it also just shows that we're getting
- 14:36a little bit more in depth with what California
- 14:39is starting to look at. It's also showing the
- 14:42data minimization standard because it's going
- 14:44to hit on retention as well. You are supposed
- 14:46to be telling your clients to dispose of data
- 14:49after a certain amount of time. If you're using
- 14:52data to be trained on algorithms, you may not
- 14:54be disposing of it. So it hits on a lot of points
- 14:57that we are, as practitioners in this space,
- 14:59telling our clients. We can move to the next
- 15:01slide. This is just a hot list, what we are talking
- 15:06about in this space. And I've hit on a lot of
- 15:10it. Kid safety, we didn't talk about, but that's
- 15:13certainly, I mean, we talked about a little bit
- 15:14with the opt -outs, but that's certainly coming
- 15:16up a lot in our practice. Sensitive info is coming
- 15:19up a lot with making sure we're. We're talking
- 15:22about that AI is going to come up soon and then
- 15:25also LB is going to talk about that in his section.
- 15:27And one I would add here is dark patterns. We
- 15:31mentioned that with the sling case, but that's
- 15:34something else that is coming up. We can move
- 15:36to the next slide. OK, now this is the wordy
- 15:40part of the presentation. We're going to talk
- 15:42a little bit about the regs. I'm going to move
- 15:44quickly through this section somewhat because
- 15:47it's the regs and it can be a little bit more
- 15:50heavy handed. but we want to make sure we have
- 15:53time for questions at the end and also the practical
- 15:56part of this, which is more a little bit more
- 15:58fun to talk about. So there was some clarification
- 16:01in the regulations that came out. some help,
- 16:05I think, that we got in the most recent final
- 16:09regs, which were announced in September of 25.
- 16:14One of them is that now, when you recognize GPC
- 16:19signals, global privacy control signals on the
- 16:21site, so when someone actually has the global
- 16:26privacy signals deployed, you have to, as a site,
- 16:30make sure that your you're making sure that you're
- 16:34letting them know that it's been honored. And
- 16:37this is just an example. They actually have an
- 16:39example in the regs that they've provided or
- 16:42on the site they've provided. But you have to
- 16:45be making sure that you're doing this. One issue
- 16:47I've had with a few clients is just making sure
- 16:50it works properly everywhere. And you saw that
- 16:52in the cases as well. I mean, checking on this
- 16:56routinely is really important. I mean, we're
- 16:58all so busy. It's very I mean it shouldn't be
- 17:02what you as a lawyer are worried about But unfortunately
- 17:05do check to make sure that everything's functioning
- 17:09properly because unfortunately that's where it's
- 17:12not your problem But that's a you know, it's
- 17:13not your fault. I should say but that's where
- 17:16it becomes your problem When you think everything's
- 17:19up and running but something's just not working
- 17:22properly But this is now part of the regs that
- 17:24you have to show that it's been honored This
- 17:27is a helpful clarification is that a consumer
- 17:30closing or closing or navigating away from a
- 17:33pop -up window on a website that requests consent
- 17:36without affirmatively selecting the equivalent
- 17:40of an I accept button shall not constitute consent.
- 17:44Such a method for obtaining consent is consumer.
- 17:47It's confusing. I've always thought that. I'm
- 17:48sure we all have. Like if you just leave that
- 17:51cookie banner on and, you know, click on the
- 17:53page and suddenly it disappears, you haven't
- 17:55known what you're actually doing. That's no longer
- 17:59considered consent in California. So this is
- 18:03helpful for you to know if you have clients that
- 18:05are working or, you know, aiming to do business
- 18:08in California and have to comply with CCPA, that's
- 18:11not going to be considered consent. And then
- 18:15symmetry and choice is actually called out here.
- 18:18I mean, in the decisions that we've seen for
- 18:21CCPA, that's been stated that if you have a red
- 18:26accept, you have to have a red reject. It's symmetry
- 18:29and choice all around, but now it's actually
- 18:32included in the regs. Another little part of
- 18:35the regs that were helpful is if you're sharing
- 18:37data with service providers, you have to now
- 18:40include in the privacy policy, the categories
- 18:43of service providers you're sharing with. We
- 18:46can move to the next slide. Here's the data broker
- 18:51section. I've already talked about this. In 2026,
- 18:56you must not only register with CalPrivacy, but
- 18:58you also must comply with the drop, which is
- 19:01that you have to delete data within 45 days if
- 19:06someone has registered on CalSight to have their
- 19:09data deleted from data brokers. And so that's
- 19:14been, I'm sure if you're practicing in this area,
- 19:17that's been heavily publicized. And I think we're
- 19:19gonna see a lot of enforcement coming up soon
- 19:22after the requirement date from California as
- 19:27well. And it'd be interesting to see what the
- 19:28fines are coming from that. Like I said, that
- 19:31one fine was a little bit smaller. Moving forward.
- 19:37Okay, so this is a big part of the regs. Those
- 19:41were little things. This is the bigger section
- 19:44that everyone was talking about. Automated decision
- 19:47making technology was finally flushed out. Everyone
- 19:50was waiting on this. We are one of the first
- 19:54here. We are the first to really have this heavily
- 19:57flushed out part of our privacy law. And here
- 20:03we have a business that's subject to the California
- 20:06Consumer Privacy Act that uses ADMT to make a
- 20:11significant decision concerning a consumer must
- 20:15comply with this. So what's a significant decision?
- 20:18That's the first thing we have to ask. And here's
- 20:22the list, and it's straight up within the act.
- 20:25So yay, this is helpful. Many of my clients at
- 20:28least find this to be helpful because they immediately
- 20:32think, well, we're not going to do this unless
- 20:34the employment space. And I know a lot of clients
- 20:37are using AI in the employment space at least
- 20:41to try to screen applicants. So I do know it
- 20:44comes up here, and it certainly is helpful in
- 20:47that space in particular, given the number of
- 20:50applications, especially up here in the tech
- 20:52space, and I know all over, but we have so many
- 20:55applications for certain tech opportunities that
- 20:59it is a way to try to minimize those. So we can
- 21:02move to the next slide. And Albie, I think you
- 21:06were going to cover this one to give me a break.
- 21:09Yeah, thank you, sir. Um, so what is a DMT? A
- 21:12DMT has, uh, three, three and a half ish elements
- 21:16process personal information using computation
- 21:18or automation to replace human decision making
- 21:20or substantially replace human decision making,
- 21:22um, replace human decision making is easy. You
- 21:25know, if you're using a DMT and I'm sorry, if
- 21:27you're using, if you're processing personal information,
- 21:29um, and automated or with a computative analysis,
- 21:32um, in a way to make a significant decision,
- 21:34you're gonna have to provide an opt out in a
- 21:36way that involves no human. No human decision
- 21:39making whatsoever, but what is substantially
- 21:40replace human decision making really mean if
- 21:42you have an automated process that process personal
- 21:44information to make a significant decision and
- 21:46the human is, you know, has some type of general
- 21:49oversight or their fact checking is that enough
- 21:51human interaction to make it so this is no longer
- 21:53a DMT. We don't know the regs are pretty new
- 21:56on this California like Sarah mentioned that
- 21:58the forefront of this. So if you're taking a
- 22:01conservative standpoint, I think unless. Unless
- 22:04ADMT is being used basically ancillary to a lot
- 22:08of human interaction, you really want to lean
- 22:10on the side of being conservative and having
- 22:12those opt -outs if ADMT is anywhere near close
- 22:15to making decisions that could be considered
- 22:18significant under the CCBA. And we do have some
- 22:22clarity, so we don't know very much about what
- 22:24substantial replace human involvement is or human
- 22:28influence is. But we do know what ADMT is not.
- 22:30It's not what web hosting, domain registration,
- 22:32networking, caching, website loading, data storage,
- 22:35firewalls, antivirus, and all this good stuff.
- 22:37But the main one that it does include is profiling.
- 22:39And profiling is basically drawing and using
- 22:41ADMT to draw inferences about consumers in a
- 22:45way that's going to be able to, again, going
- 22:47back to the definition of significant decision
- 22:49making. Yeah, it'll be interesting to see if
- 22:52the California Legislatures give us some more
- 22:54clarity about how much human involvement is going
- 22:56to be needed to kind of get us out of that ADMT
- 22:59framework. But for now, we're going to definitely
- 23:03be advising leaning towards providing those opt
- 23:06-out mechanisms for ADMT. Yeah, so the two things
- 23:11you should be looking at when you're advising
- 23:13is one, significant decision, if that's being
- 23:16made. And then two, if it is being made, how
- 23:21much human involvement and looking at that substantially
- 23:24replace human involvement decision that we saw
- 23:28there. And then if you are checking those boxes,
- 23:32we move to the next slide, which is, why does
- 23:34it matter? Why does it matter? Because here we
- 23:38go to the next slide, which is you have to have
- 23:40an opt in or opt out. We move to the next slide,
- 23:45actually. You have to have it opt out for the
- 23:49ADMT and you have to have a pre -use notice.
- 23:54So you have to have a separate notice. It can
- 23:56be part of your longer privacy notice that explains
- 23:59how you're using ADMT and the process, what decision
- 24:05it's actually making for the consumer. And it
- 24:10has to be presented. at or before the point of
- 24:13collection. So this is where it gets a little,
- 24:15it can be a little bit much for an applicant,
- 24:18let's say. And again, if you're giving them the
- 24:21ability to opt out, it can be a little bit complicated
- 24:24again, if you have an applicant. So that's where
- 24:28some of the clients that we're working with are,
- 24:31you know, debating how they can do this, or if
- 24:33they can do it in the employment states, or if
- 24:35it's worth it. And we can move to the next slide.
- 24:42And so you also have to give access. The consumer
- 24:46may request a business provide information to
- 24:48the consumer about the business use of the ADMT.
- 24:51So similar to what you have for general access
- 24:55rights for consumers being able to write to a
- 24:58company and ask to access their PI. Here you
- 25:01have the consumer can access why you're using
- 25:05ADMT. They can also appeal the decision that's
- 25:09made by the ADMT if they want. And again, these
- 25:13rights can be addressed in the privacy notice
- 25:15that you provide. Next slide. Okay, so the next
- 25:20big chunk, and this is... I think this is what
- 25:24I'm getting the most questions about right now
- 25:26is the risk assessment. And this is another part
- 25:30of the regulations, the risk assessment that
- 25:33has to be completed and provided to the CPPA.
- 25:40And here we have the why, the why the risk assessment
- 25:45must be completed. And we have the phrase significant
- 25:48risk again. significant risk to consumers' privacy,
- 25:54and then we have a list of what is a significant
- 25:56risk. Selling, sharing, or processing. PI, using
- 26:01ADMT. So here we have the reasons. Selling, sharing,
- 26:04to use ADMT to make a significant decision about
- 26:08a consumer. Using automated processing to infer.
- 26:14So the ones I like to highlight here. We have
- 26:17significant decision, which again, was defined
- 26:19back a few slides ago. So those are employment,
- 26:23housing, credit decision, financial, I think
- 26:28credit decision, a few others. But we have that
- 26:30significant decision defined there. What I like
- 26:34to hide here, maybe because I do a lot of in
- 26:36the advertising space in particular, is the inferences
- 26:41that we have here, which is the using automated
- 26:46to consumers, ability, aptitude, performance
- 26:48at work, health, personal preferences, interests,
- 26:52reliability, predispositions, behavior. It's
- 26:54that fourth bullet point. So that one is pretty
- 27:00broad in a lot of ways. So we get a lot of questions
- 27:03with respect to that. And there in particular,
- 27:08we have to really think about how broad that's
- 27:10meant to be interpreted and whether, you know,
- 27:14we, I mean, in most instances, we have clients
- 27:16that are doing risk assessments because of that
- 27:18one in particular. Also, we have clients that
- 27:21are just deciding to do them because it helps
- 27:23them sort through what it is that their business
- 27:28teams are doing because a lot of times they may
- 27:31not have business teams that are 100%. They have
- 27:35an end, an end result in mind that they're working
- 27:41through that frankly sounds more ominous from
- 27:46a privacy standpoint. So they start with, they
- 27:49work through a risk assessment for that reason.
- 27:52And we'll get to why this could be problematic
- 27:54in a few slides. But that bullet point there
- 27:58is very broad. And so for that reason, we have
- 28:01a lot of clients that are doing it. The last
- 28:04one. obviously makes sense, facial recognition,
- 28:07emotional recognition. I mean, that to me is
- 28:10high risk as it is, but we can move to the next
- 28:12slide. Here's the contents of a risk assessment.
- 28:17Probably most of you, if you're working with
- 28:18clients, have a risk assessment, especially if
- 28:20you have clients in the EU. A lot of the clients
- 28:23we're working with have been working off of their
- 28:25EU risk assessments just to modify for the US.
- 28:29But here's what we have. A lot of them, the clients
- 28:33that LB and I are working with have just modified
- 28:36their current risk assessments to address ADMT.
- 28:40Some of the things we talked about in the ADMT
- 28:43portion of this, they're modifying their risk
- 28:45assessments to include levels to address that.
- 28:48Again, benefits and consequences of that is very
- 28:53important because that's one of the main reasons
- 28:56you have a risk assessment is to talk about the
- 28:59benefits of the use of the Whatever the technology
- 29:04it is or whatever you're developing, their whole
- 29:08purpose for the risk assessment, which again
- 29:10is when that business team comes to you with
- 29:13this end result they have in mind, when you ask
- 29:15them the benefit, this can help you and it also
- 29:19can help them realize some of the risks. And
- 29:21then that can help you flush out where this may
- 29:25land as far as. the end result, which is that
- 29:28at the end of the day, we have to bring this
- 29:30to someone to sign and approve. Data retention
- 29:33and like one of the issues is now we have to
- 29:37delete the data at some point as part of our
- 29:39retention schedule and can we delete it? And
- 29:42if we can't delete it, we have to come up with
- 29:43some basis for that and some retention schedule
- 29:48and plan for that data and how we're going to
- 29:51dispose of it and or track the use of that data.
- 29:56for data minimization purposes. Okay, we can
- 30:00move to the next slide. So when we have some
- 30:05time for this, and again, this information is
- 30:09included so that we have it as we move forward,
- 30:13but we do have some time here. But the big thing
- 30:17is, is once this becomes a requirement every
- 30:20year on April 1st, you have to submit these risk
- 30:23assessments. And this is the next slide is to
- 30:26me, one of the bigger issues, which is the WHO.
- 30:29The report must also include a test station signed
- 30:33by someone sufficiently knowledgeable and directly
- 30:36responsible member of the business's executive
- 30:39management team under penalty of perjury under
- 30:42the laws of state of California. So back to the
- 30:46ominous reason your business team may have for
- 30:50the risk assessment. When they come to you with
- 30:53this idea, knowing that they have to have this
- 30:55plan signed or this risk assessment signed by
- 30:58someone on a member of the executive management
- 31:02team, they better have a really good idea and
- 31:05we better be really weighing out those risks
- 31:08and benefits because at the end of the day, someone
- 31:11with this level of authority has to sign this.
- 31:13And this is again, something we're talking to
- 31:15clients about because you really have to think
- 31:18through a lot of things with this part, which
- 31:21is making sure, do we want to have this document?
- 31:24confidential and privileged. On the other hand,
- 31:30does this document have to go to Japan to be
- 31:34signed? Does it have to go to Turkey to be signed?
- 31:38So we really have to think through this part.
- 31:42And again, back to, do we want this risk assessment?
- 31:47Hello, do we want this risk assessment? This
- 31:51is a very important process and it's one that
- 31:54you have to, as the inside counsel, you have
- 31:56to really, inside or outside counsel, you have
- 31:58to really make sure you're asking those initial
- 32:00questions as to why, the why, and making sure
- 32:05you're drilling down on all of that process as
- 32:08you move through the risk assessment. It also
- 32:11creates an obligation for teams to kind of work
- 32:14closer together. A lot of the times with our
- 32:15clients, you see the business teams be separate
- 32:17from the engineering team that's actually doing
- 32:19some of this more high -risk data processing.
- 32:21So again, you want to make sure that when you're
- 32:23advising clients on this, they know from the
- 32:25outset that eventually someone may be a little
- 32:27bit higher than them is going to have to know
- 32:28about this and sign this. Great. That's good,
- 32:32LB. OK, we move to the next slide. All right,
- 32:35this is the last part of the regs that we're
- 32:39going to cover. This is the one we're going to
- 32:41move most quickly because it's more technical
- 32:43in nature. We've given this in a very abbreviated
- 32:46fashion. I do suggest. if these are lawyers on
- 32:51the line, I do suggest you read this in tandem
- 32:53with someone on your IT. I mean, not this, the
- 32:56slides, the section of the regs in tandem with
- 32:59someone on your IT. It's not that you won't understand
- 33:02it. It actually is written for lawyers. You will
- 33:05understand it, but it would have been a lot of
- 33:07words on the slides about the nature of the technical
- 33:10and administrative safeguards. You need to make
- 33:14sure the boxes are checked. It can be a list
- 33:19that can be put together by your team, but it
- 33:23is the general list that we're used to seeing
- 33:26as lawyers for what is needed in a cybersecurity
- 33:31audit. I mean, of course, it's fleshed out in
- 33:33length, but. At the end of the day, you're going
- 33:36to have to make sure your IT is reading that
- 33:39list against mapping that list against the standards
- 33:42that are current right now and making sure they
- 33:47they are working with either a third party or
- 33:48someone internal that's not biased to create
- 33:51the audit. So we did not include all those words
- 33:53on these slides. And so. That's my disclaimer
- 33:58for this is just a broad overview of what you
- 34:02should be thinking about with the audit outside
- 34:04of what those requirements are. Here's the requirements
- 34:07for actually the companies that need to get the
- 34:09audit. I had a few clients that were very happy
- 34:12when they saw this because they were like, that's
- 34:14not us. So here are the requirements. And then
- 34:19you can see it's bigger organizations and significant
- 34:23risk. And then you can see that, again, they
- 34:27have significant risk as part of it. And then
- 34:31they tell you what significant risk is. And if
- 34:34you earn 50 % or more of your gross global revenue
- 34:38from selling or sharing PI, or it's a revenue
- 34:41threshold and a data threshold. So we can move
- 34:45to the next slide. So if you meet that, then
- 34:48you have to worry about the cybersecurity audit.
- 34:51I included this because I think it's good to
- 34:54know. It can either be an internal auditor, but
- 34:58if so, it has to be highest ranking auditor must
- 35:02report to a member of the business who is not
- 35:05responsible for the cybersecurity program. So
- 35:08there's a very specific requirement if it's an
- 35:10internal, but it could be someone external. Obviously,
- 35:16in any event, it has to be someone impartial
- 35:19and independent from the business decisions.
- 35:22So we can go to the next slide. Here's what needs
- 35:26to be considered. These are clearly delineated.
- 35:30You have to make everything available and. I
- 35:36like the middle one. No audit may rely solely
- 35:39on assertions or test stations made by the business
- 35:42management. Again, I think that's aimed obviously
- 35:45at the internal auditor, but we get that they
- 35:49put that out there. And the auditor gets to determine
- 35:55the documents that are appropriate to review.
- 35:59You can't have the business team telling the
- 36:01auditor what they should be reviewing. Move to
- 36:04the next slide. Here, we just want to highlight
- 36:11some of the things that they should be considered.
- 36:15But frankly, like I said, you should take a look
- 36:18and review the actual sections of the regs with
- 36:22someone on your IT. Again, if you've been practicing
- 36:25in this area for a while, you're used to seeing
- 36:28the standard terms for technical and administrative
- 36:35security. requirements that are in the regulations
- 36:40that need to be included. You can move to the
- 36:43next slide. The report has to say essentially
- 36:49there's why I included this is that it's very
- 36:52specific with what the report has to cover. And
- 36:56as the lawyer, you should know that It actually
- 36:59says that it must articulate the process, activities,
- 37:03and components of the program. What criteria
- 37:06are used? The evidence examined. So if you have
- 37:10an auditor preparing the report, you should be
- 37:12looking at the regulations and making sure that
- 37:15it matches what is required in the regs. Explain
- 37:19the why, why the processes, the activities, and
- 37:22the components were assumed. I've looked at reports
- 37:24done by third parties. A lot of times it doesn't
- 37:27really necessarily explain the why. So this may
- 37:29be a new level to these reports is why these
- 37:34things were appropriate, why the evidence. Often
- 37:37it just tells you what and of course the how,
- 37:40how things can be fixed by the auditor, the auditor
- 37:43security, you know, whatever the third party
- 37:44is. But the why is interesting. And so I do think
- 37:49that's a level that may not be included in some
- 37:52of these reports that has to be added. And then,
- 37:57the effectiveness of the components in preventing
- 38:00um p .i. loss so what they're suggesting to you
- 38:03and what needs to be what they found was working
- 38:07and wasn't working so they also suggest that
- 38:11that has to be explained again i thought that
- 38:13these were interesting because they actually
- 38:15went into the detail of what has to be included
- 38:17in the report so i i I think this is good for
- 38:21the lawyers to know that there is a checklist
- 38:23or there is a list of what the CCPA regs say
- 38:27has to be included in the report. You can go
- 38:29to the next slide. And then the title of up to
- 38:36three qualified individuals responsible for the
- 38:39business's cybersecurity program. So those individuals
- 38:42have to be named. The auditor's name, affiliation,
- 38:45and qualifications have to be named. And then
- 38:48a statement from the highest ranking auditor
- 38:51that certifies they completed an independent
- 38:54review of the business's cybersecurity plan.
- 38:57So again, this is serious stuff. And we've moved
- 39:00to the next slide. I think this is notable. If
- 39:06you had a data incident, a copy of any notifications
- 39:09that were sent to the affected consumers has
- 39:12to be included. and any notifications to an agency
- 39:16with jurisdiction over privacy laws in California
- 39:18have to be included. To me, as lawyers, we just
- 39:25have to be aware that this is all going to be
- 39:27in that report. Move to the next slide, please.
- 39:31Good news is that if you have an audit that was
- 39:35prepared for another purpose but meets all of
- 39:38these requirements, you can use that. So I don't
- 39:42know if that will ever be the case, just given
- 39:44the nature of the scope of this. But if you do,
- 39:48that you can use that. You can move to the next
- 39:50slide. But the reason I said that this is so
- 39:56dense and why it can be a problem, you know,
- 39:59we should all be thinking about it is yes, we
- 40:01have to submit it to the agency and have it with
- 40:04the certification that it was completed. And
- 40:07that, of course, is going to be. you know, daunting
- 40:11for many companies. And with that, we can move
- 40:17to the next slide. So now we get to the more
- 40:22fun, I think more fun part of our discussion,
- 40:24which is going to be led by LB, which is more
- 40:27into I think what probably if all of us or any
- 40:32of us are practicing in the privacy space we're
- 40:34all dealing with, which is the California Invasion
- 40:37of Privacy Act and the claims we're seeing, and
- 40:41also just some of the more interesting components
- 40:43of it, which is some of the practical guidance
- 40:47with respect to counseling in the area of AI.
- 40:53Yeah, so the California Evasion of Privacy Act
- 40:56makes it unlawful to intercept or record confidential
- 40:58information without consent or aid third parties
- 41:00in doing so. And that is like, I think that was
- 41:03intentionally drafted broadly, and we've since
- 41:05been trying to figure out what it means. So initially
- 41:08it was intended to govern telephone conversations,
- 41:11but not even recently in the last maybe like.
- 41:15Five to ten years has been back and forth about
- 41:17what it actually governs. So last year, the California
- 41:21legislature added this language to the actual
- 41:23statute saying the legislature hereby declare
- 41:25that advances in science and technology have
- 41:27led to the development of new devices and techniques
- 41:29for the purpose of eavesdropping upon private
- 41:31communications at the invasion of privacy resulting
- 41:33from the continual and increasing use of such
- 41:35devices and techniques has created a series that
- 41:37the free exercise of personal liberties and cannot
- 41:38be tolerated in civil society. So what does that
- 41:41actually mean? That means that now, in addition
- 41:44to telephones, we have chat bots and virtual
- 41:46assistants that can replace software, tracking
- 41:48pixels and beacons, customer service, car recording,
- 41:50mobile and cordless communication search bars,
- 41:52and the FunOne AI is now being governed by SIPA
- 41:55because it's allowing the transfer of communications
- 41:58from party A and party B to a third party, party
- 42:00C. So under SIPA, you have the right to consent.
- 42:04The important distinction here is that California
- 42:06is an all -party consent state. which means that
- 42:09all parties with the communications have to consent
- 42:10to the communications or the transferring the
- 42:13communications to a third party alleged eavesdropper
- 42:15could be a SIPA violation. That's different than
- 42:18a one -party consent state. So I'm going to just
- 42:21kind of slow down and explain what that means.
- 42:23So the way we commonly see this is you have website
- 42:25owner, communicant or party A, consumer, that's
- 42:30party B, and then you have the third party that's
- 42:32providing the tracker. It's like meta, Facebook,
- 42:34whatever. So under a one -party consent statute,
- 42:37If the website owner consents to the communications,
- 42:40it's literally going to be enough for the tracking
- 42:41of that communication to go to party C to not
- 42:43be considered an unlawful wiretap. California
- 42:46is not like that. You need the consent of everyone,
- 42:49including the consumer, for the communications
- 42:51to travel between party A and party B to over
- 42:54to party C, which is going to be the provider
- 42:55of the tracker, the cookie, the whatever. So
- 42:58how do you get consent? How do you get consent?
- 43:00I'm sorry. Consent can be explicit or implied.
- 43:02But these days, we're definitely going to lean
- 43:04more towards explicit because these claims, as
- 43:06we're going to talk about a little bit later,
- 43:07are very prevalent throughout the US and California
- 43:09in particular. So we've always seen 1 ,000 of
- 43:12these. The way you get consent or trackers on
- 43:14a website is loosely a cookie banner. And you
- 43:16want to have an accept all or reject all. And
- 43:19you want to, like Sarah talked about previously,
- 43:20you want it to be synchronized so that you don't
- 43:23want the... accept all to be a huge and in red
- 43:26and have to reject all be like hidden like a
- 43:28weird different font you want you want them to
- 43:29be parallel and symmetrical and the other big
- 43:33one is under the new rags clicking that x top
- 43:36right corner is no longer going to be considered
- 43:37consent if you click that if you click that x
- 43:39is going to basically essentially be a reject
- 43:42all so if you're a website owner your clients
- 43:43are website owner you would advise that certain
- 43:46cookies need to not be dropping until accept
- 43:49all is clicked and clicking that x is not going
- 43:51to be valid consent under SIPA. So SIPA and digital
- 43:57wiretap claims are prevalent throughout the U
- 43:59.S. There's been 4 ,000 digital wiretapping claims
- 44:03in the U .S. since 2022. California is number
- 44:08one in number, because of course it is, but what's
- 44:11interesting is Florida and Illinois are number
- 44:14two and three. And that makes sense, because
- 44:15Florida and Illinois are both two particles and
- 44:17statutes. So it makes sense that they are also
- 44:18seeing a bunch of CIPA claims. Now, what we did
- 44:20want to flag for you guys is, although this number
- 44:22may seem high, depending on what kind of lawyer
- 44:23you are, if you're a privacy attorney, you're
- 44:24probably not very surprised. But this does not
- 44:27include presuit demands. And presuit demands,
- 44:29at least in our experience, tend to be the more
- 44:31numerous of these claims. We typically have a
- 44:34consumer or a plaintiff's counsel reach out to
- 44:37a website owner defendant. And they basically
- 44:40want to be paid to go away. in these, you know,
- 44:42these often settle outside of court. So I think
- 44:44the owner of the tracker said that if these cases
- 44:47included the number of pre -suit demands, it
- 44:49would triple or maybe even quadruple. So that
- 44:51four thousand is not the entire scope of these
- 44:53claims. They're very, very prevalent. And the
- 44:55other thing to note is the claims are almost
- 44:58always more expensive when cookies and trackers
- 45:01are dropping after a user clicks. No, it's different
- 45:04than it's different than having no cookie banner
- 45:06at all. That's not that's not good either. But
- 45:08you really want to make sure that if you have
- 45:10a cookie banner, And your client is saying, hey,
- 45:13these cookies are no longer firing. That is actually
- 45:15the case. Camplison, I might just call this Adidas
- 45:19because Camplison is hard for me to say. But
- 45:22anyway, on Monday, JD Supra and National Law
- 45:25Review released a report flagging Adidas as a
- 45:27clear sign that super demands aimed at everyday
- 45:29digital tools and cookies such as pixels and
- 45:31analytic scripts are likely to pick up throughout
- 45:32the year. So, playing through the data over TikTok,
- 45:35Pixel, and Microsoft Bing trackers on website
- 45:37-led trackers and collected IP addresses, browser
- 45:40info, and PII without consent, claimed device
- 45:43fingerprinting violated SIPA. Now, why is this
- 45:45a big deal? So, we already talked about how SIPA
- 45:47has expanded from being about phone conversations
- 45:51to being about all different types of technology.
- 45:53But we're now seeing a lower threshold for what
- 45:56confidential communications actually means. We...
- 45:59We're pretty square under California law that
- 46:01something like Session Replay, which is essentially
- 46:03a recording of everything that a consumer does
- 46:05on a website, was going to be considered communications
- 46:07under SIPA. But now we're seeing that even things
- 46:09like clicks, IP addresses, browser info, that's
- 46:13enough to be considered communications under
- 46:15SIPA and at least get a planted or claim pass
- 46:19the motion to dismiss stage. So again, if you
- 46:22have a tracker and it's only collecting what
- 46:24we would consider to be very rudimentary. You
- 46:27know, computation computer related data device
- 46:29fingerprinting, even that's going to be enough
- 46:31to kind of give rise to these claims. So you
- 46:33really want to make sure that you cookie banner
- 46:34consent flow is is kind of airtight. Again, I
- 46:38think Sarah and I saw at least four to five California
- 46:42rulings last year that kind of went the other
- 46:44way and said that these type of this type of
- 46:47information clicks, IP addresses, browser info
- 46:50wasn't going to be enough understood. We're now
- 46:52ping pong in the other way, so we still don't
- 46:54really have a clear understanding of what this
- 46:56means, but confusion is good for Plaintiff's
- 46:57Console. So by all that we mean, you definitely
- 47:02want to make sure that your trackers are following
- 47:04your implemented cookie consent flows, and you
- 47:07don't want to be relying on arguments that you're
- 47:09not actually tracking proper communications.
- 47:11It's not going to be enough, at least not to
- 47:12get you to the point where you don't have to
- 47:14at least file something. And then those motion
- 47:17system is based on those arguments may fail.
- 47:20based on the last 50 digital years. What about
- 47:24AI? Like we mentioned at the outset, SIPA is
- 47:28going to govern more than phone conversations.
- 47:30It's going to govern basically any technology
- 47:32that's being used to transfer communications
- 47:35from party A and party B to party C, which AI
- 47:37can obviously do. Sarah and I have a client recently
- 47:41that wanted to roll out AI -empowered headphones
- 47:45that had a recording feature. And they were surprised
- 47:47to know that this kind of brought them under
- 47:49these like the SIPA purview because the headphones
- 47:54could take communication data and then transmit
- 47:57that data to a third party LLM. So we're now
- 48:00talking about communication between party A and
- 48:02party B going over to party C. So, you know,
- 48:05I think we. Yeah, yeah, I want to jump in on
- 48:08this quickly just to right. Yeah. So everything
- 48:13you're saying, absolutely. Just can you reset
- 48:17with the party A to party B to party C on this?
- 48:21Yeah, so SIPA governs the interception of communications
- 48:25without consent. So usually there's going to
- 48:27be consent between party A of the communication
- 48:29and party B of the communication. Party C tends
- 48:32to be the provider of the pixel, the provider
- 48:34of the provider of the tracking technology, aka
- 48:37a meta pixel, Facebook pixel, something like
- 48:39that. That's going to give rise to a SIPA claim
- 48:41on a website. But you're also going to see rise
- 48:43to SIPA claims with technology such as this that
- 48:46has the data that you're collecting going to,
- 48:48and what was in our case, Sarah, that that third
- 48:51party LLM, which brought these headphones under
- 48:53the purview of SIPA. But again, we kind of have
- 48:56a better understanding of how you get consent
- 48:58on a website. But the question for me and Sarah
- 49:00was, how do we get consent when we're using headphones?
- 49:04So we came up with a couple of different ideas,
- 49:07but the main one was we want to have an audible
- 49:09disclosure. Hey, your communication is now being
- 49:11recorded. You wanted to have some type of light,
- 49:13a prominent light that shows that recording is
- 49:14taking place. But you also wanted to have some
- 49:16other features that kind of toggled the recording
- 49:19off if the headphones picked up that there is
- 49:22now more parties to the communication that reprompted
- 49:25the need to get this consent. We also tried to
- 49:27make it clear for the client, because I think
- 49:29they wanted to use these headphones in Zoom.
- 49:32And we wanted to make it clear for the client
- 49:33that if Zoom got consent to recording, that wasn't
- 49:37enough consent for the headphones to be recording.
- 49:39Consent has to be based on each different recording
- 49:42flow. But we tell that to say that SIPA is going
- 49:45to be governing all different types of technology
- 49:47now. So the question you want to be asking yourselves
- 49:49or advising your clients on asking is whether
- 49:51or not communication is being, recording is being
- 49:54done with full consent, especially in all party
- 49:55consent statutes. And if you're rolling out this
- 49:58type of technology, and all party consent statutes
- 50:00like California, you want to have very conservative
- 50:02default settings. So you want to make sure that
- 50:04recording is not going to be taking place. From
- 50:07the outset, you want to force the consumer to
- 50:09actually do things to make the recording take
- 50:10place. And then, what else do I want to say?
- 50:15I had one more thing. OK, maybe it'll come back
- 50:20to me. Yeah, and then chat bots. Chat bots are
- 50:24another thing that are governed by SIPA. Why?
- 50:26Because chat bots tend to be, so they're on websites,
- 50:28obviously, but they tend to be powered by third
- 50:31parties. So once, so again, if you have the consumer,
- 50:36party A speaking to website, party B, if that,
- 50:39if party C is the provider of the chat bot and
- 50:42party C is the one that's processing the communication
- 50:45prompt to ultimately generate a response. then
- 50:47that's now within the per view of SIPA, because
- 50:49it could be an alleged wiretap. So you want to
- 50:52have your disclosures. You want to say, this
- 50:54chatbot is powered by XYZ. By using the chatbot,
- 50:58you can send to your communications being shared
- 50:59with XYZ, if that is, in fact, the case. And
- 51:01there's also a couple other interesting laws
- 51:04that govern the use of chatbots. For example,
- 51:06in Utah, if a consumer asks if it's interacting
- 51:09with AI, you have to give a direct answer, like
- 51:11you are now interacting with AI or a human. Under
- 51:14California's bot disclosure law, it prohibits
- 51:16using bots knowingly to deceive consumers in
- 51:18commercial interactions. This is an interesting
- 51:19one. I think the context that came up for me
- 51:22and Sarah was if we have an AI chatbot or chatbot
- 51:25-like feature that gives product recommendations.
- 51:29Say you're on website a and you're talking to
- 51:31the chat bot and the chat bot gives you recommends
- 51:33a product from Amazon. If website a has a commercial
- 51:36relationship with Amazon, you want to disclose
- 51:38that because it could be. It could be considered
- 51:40knowingly deceit deceitful if you don't. And
- 51:42then the FTC Act gives the FTC broad powers to
- 51:46govern any unfair or deceptive practices in the
- 51:49marketplace. So again, you want to make sure
- 51:52that you're not using the chat bot in a way to
- 51:54get more PI, that you're not using in a chat
- 51:56bot a way that deceives. And I think the context
- 51:57that this came up, believe it or not, was we
- 51:59had a, there was some company that was using
- 52:03a chat bot that pretended to be turning and didn't
- 52:05disclose that it was good. Yeah. And I think
- 52:08one of the biggest points we have here is just
- 52:10the use of Where we see this being a really big
- 52:14issue is the collection and use of sensitive
- 52:16personal information as well. And then also children's
- 52:21data. So it's just really important. We want
- 52:24to turn this back into the privacy conversation
- 52:26as well. With these chat bots, not only do we
- 52:30have what LB has highlighted here, which is the
- 52:34Utah and the bot disclosure, which is making
- 52:36sure you do have these Again, if you're interacting,
- 52:40you have somebody saying, if they ask, yes, I'm
- 52:44a bot, if they ask. And then also, if you have
- 52:47a prompt about selling something, you make sure
- 52:50that there's a disclosure that you're interacting
- 52:53with a bot. But then you also have to consider
- 52:55the privacy issues if there's sensitive information
- 52:59or personal information that's being disclosed
- 53:02as part of these. These engagements then you
- 53:07do have to think back to the privacy Conversation
- 53:12that we had previously which is making sure that
- 53:14you have Considered all of the disclosures and
- 53:18opt -ins and opt -outs that we've already talked
- 53:21about Previously and whether there was the compliance
- 53:23processes in place for that Which I think that's
- 53:28what you're getting in here with the last bullet
- 53:30point right lb. Mm -hmm. Yeah, that's and then
- 53:34Oh, actually, let me go back, because I remember
- 53:36what I wanted to say. For these, I know we're
- 53:38talking about a lot of required consent gathering
- 53:41protocol. And obviously, if you are advising
- 53:44companies that are rolling out AI technology
- 53:46like this, it's not really practical for them
- 53:47to ensure that every consumer follows that protocol.
- 53:49But what you want to do is have these mechanisms
- 53:52in place. And you want to be advising consumers
- 53:54to use them in the terms of use. And that way,
- 53:56you can argue back against any allegations that
- 53:59you're aiding and abetting the recording of communications
- 54:03without consent. It's good. Yeah. And then lastly,
- 54:07this slide is just to show you that we're using
- 54:09the word chatbot in ChatAsian, but I don't want
- 54:12you to limit your mind to only what you see on
- 54:14a website with the general idea of a chatbot.
- 54:17We're seeing Alexa, we're seeing AI conversational
- 54:22cars, we're seeing AI conversations in refrigerators.
- 54:24So anything where you're communicating with AI
- 54:26or your clients communicating with AI, you want
- 54:28to be advising them to at least be thinking about
- 54:30this and this kind of frame with this kind of
- 54:32risk. Yeah. And I think one of the issues that
- 54:39we're seeing with this back to the sensitive
- 54:42and the PI collection is where the disclosures
- 54:45are. And one of the things with California in
- 54:49particular, especially with some of those cases
- 54:52we talked about is you do have to have the disclosure.
- 54:56Most of these have an app. and an app that you
- 55:00download at the start. So there should be disclosures
- 55:03at the time of the app. And one of the questions
- 55:05we're getting from clients is should there be
- 55:07a disclosure, another disclosure, at the time
- 55:10you start to engage with the actual device? Because
- 55:15that's another, potentially another connection
- 55:20point between the consumer and the device that's
- 55:23outside of the app, and it could be a whole other
- 55:25person. And so that's one of the questions we're
- 55:28getting. And unfortunately, the answer is not
- 55:31consistent across devices to LB's point, because
- 55:34you have a headset that's different than possibly
- 55:37a headset that's connected to the app right in
- 55:42front of you or whatever. It may be a screen.
- 55:44While you're doing it, it's different from a
- 55:49stove or something that you may have an appliance
- 55:52in your house that may be entirely separate from
- 55:55a screen that you're connected to. So it does
- 55:59depend I think on the device and the level of
- 56:01connectivity as to the nature of what the disclosure
- 56:05is and when the PI is collected and how it's
- 56:08collected. But these are all questions that we're
- 56:10dealing with and of course it's as always it's
- 56:13complicated with privacy but it's similar to
- 56:16I know what a lot of the gaming companies are
- 56:18dealing with with VR headsets and whatnot. So
- 56:21with that, we will wrap it. And I guess we have
- 56:24a few minutes for questions. Otherwise, I think
- 56:28we can say adieu. We do have a couple of questions
- 56:33from the chat. So I'll read those out. out if
- 56:36you all wanna answer some of those. The first
- 56:39one is, can you express an opinion or view on
- 56:42banking practices where a new call and they sometimes
- 56:45ask for your name and social security number
- 56:47and address and other PI on a recorded line?
- 56:50This appears problematic to me. One of the questions.
- 56:56Yeah, I mean, that's very, so good question.
- 56:59And it's very state specific too. Since you're
- 57:03in California, I assume it's a California exchange.
- 57:10I agree that that's problematic. I don't know
- 57:17what bank you're calling, but I agree that that's
- 57:24problematic. To me, that's more sensitive information
- 57:28that's needed on a recorded line at the gate.
- 57:32but my bank doesn't do that, so. Mine either.
- 57:36Yeah, mine either. And like anything, right?
- 57:40I mean, there's disclosure issues and concerns
- 57:43about who's looking at that, right? Yeah, and
- 57:45just to be clear, that's Gramm -Leach -Bliley,
- 57:48which has specific requirements for financial
- 57:52institutions and notice requirements. And so
- 57:56I don't know if you're given, like, you know,
- 57:59there's requirements there. In itself and then
- 58:04you as a consumer that's highly sensitive info
- 58:06that's like the most you know that falls into
- 58:09sensitive info and then the fact that it's recorded
- 58:11line to you know what lb was talking about the
- 58:15transfer of that so yeah i see a lot of issues
- 58:17not to say they can't do it legally maybe they
- 58:20are but. There's a lot of compliance issues in
- 58:23order to do that that they'd have to step through
- 58:26in order to do that so. We have another jurisdictional
- 58:30question. What are the points of attachment for
- 58:33CCPA? Do you have jurisdiction over California
- 58:35companies delivering to a UK customer or UK company
- 58:39delivering to California customers? The points
- 58:44of attachment. So I guess you mean like when
- 58:46would the CCPA apply? I think that's what it
- 58:49means. Yeah, to a California customer company
- 58:52delivering to the UK. So there's thresholds for
- 58:56compliance with the CCPA, and you'd have to meet
- 58:59those thresholds for compliance. There's a revenue
- 59:01threshold, and then there's a data threshold.
- 59:05The revenue threshold, I believe, is currently...
- 59:08$250 ,000. I think it's $250 ,000. The data threshold
- 59:14is 100 ,000 data sets, or I think it's 50 % of
- 59:19your revenue from selling personal information.
- 59:25And so you have to either meet one of those thresholds,
- 59:29and then you have to comply with the CCPA. And
- 59:33then if you do, yes, you comply with the CCPA,
- 59:38but once the data's in, if you're selling into
- 59:41the UK, then you'd also have to, you'd have a
- 59:45touch point in the UK, so you'd have to comply
- 59:47with the GDPR as well. And then, yeah, they would
- 59:52make you comply with the GDPR to sell, I mean,
- 59:55the UK GDPR to transfer the data back to the
- 59:57US. Great. Well, I think we are at time now.
- 1:00:02So I really want to thank our panelists for this
- 1:00:05really insightful presentation. Everybody should
- 1:00:07be getting the materials through a link, as well
- 1:00:10as your MCLE certificate. So we, again, want
- 1:00:13to thank the panelists and for everybody who
- 1:00:15joined. Appreciate it. I look forward to seeing
- 1:00:19you at future events. In fact, we have another
- 1:00:21privacy event tomorrow that we'll be hosting
- 1:00:25that should be interesting as well. So thanks
- 1:00:27for joining everyone.