Latest / Home After 50™ / Multigenerational Living and Siblings: Do You Need a Trust Fund to Keep It Fair?
Transcript
- Juli: Welcome to Home After 50. I'm Julie Ford and this is a show about reimagining what life can look like in this next chapter. Here we explore home, family, reinvention, and the evolving ways that women after 50 are shaping lives that are meaningful, grounded, and true. I'm so glad that you're here. Welcome back to Home After 50 and a new season. It's October. It is strangely warm here in Massachusetts. It has felt like fall for going on a month now, but somehow yesterday and today it's hot and humid, which the weather changes quickly here in New England. I know that won't last, but it's it's kind of a funny shift of events as I'm preparing to Unveil a new season of the podcast. And I have so many things planned for October, November, and December this year, and I'm really excited about them. I do wish the weather was cooperating and feeling kind of crisp and cool so that the seasonal shift really felt like it was upon us, but that will be back soon enough. Today I thought it would be really fun to start this new season by sharing a comment or two with you from my audience and answering it with you here on the podcast. These are the messages that I get every day. And I thought it would really be helpful to share with you how I respond to these messages and try to help families navigate what they're going through in this next chapter of life, how they're navigating multi-generational living, how they're supporting their aging parents, how they're facing the challenges of what home can look like, what finances can look like, what family dynamics and support can look like in this chapter of our lives after 50. So let's jump in. This is a comment from someone who I think is probably in the real estate industry, given their handle on Instagram. He said, The biggest single thing I've seen hold families back from multi-gen living is the siblings. It doesn't work if mom and dad don't have a serious trust fund to equal out the inheritance with their children because one child gets a large equity boost in their home. Okay. Let's get into this. This is a great question, actually. And this is one of the topics that comes up most frequently if there are siblings involved. So when I meet with a family, and you may know that I offer free clarity calls to families who are thinking about multi-gen living and just need to figure out where to get started. So I talk with families every week who are thinking about multi-gen homes. And one of the first questions that I always ask them is. Are there other siblings? Cause oftentimes when we have these Zoom meetings, what happens is I'm meeting with it's usually a set of parents and an adult child. And either, you know, one of the parents or the adult child has initiated this conversation with me, but we all get on Zoom together, which is great. I love that we're having this conversation with the family that's thinking of living together. But one of the first questions I always ask is: Are there any other siblings that will not be living in this home or have an ownership stake in this home? And have you talked to them yet? How are they feeling about it? What is their involvement or lack of involvement? And we really have to talk about those things because David, who made this comment, brings up a great point, but I do think he's got it very wrong on some levels. So here's what I think he's got wrong. He's he's making a statement, and this happens a lot on social media, but he's making a statement that's pretty dramatic. He's saying that it's not gonna work. Unless the parents have a trust fund for every other sibling because they'd be making a big equity investment in the multi-gen home that would benefit the one child that would be living with them. So let me give you an example of how our family handled this. And we don't have trust funds. And my mom did not have a lot of money. So eleven years ago, when we purchased our multi-gen home with my mom, my mom made a contribution towards the down payment. We put, I think it was 20% down, and she put probably maybe a little more than half of that 20% as her investment in the multi-gen home. And that helped make the buying this home possible for us. My mother did not want an ownership stake, and that's a conversation we'll get into on a different podcast episode, why that may actually be a great idea and when it works and when it doesn't, but that we'll we'll table that topic for now and get back to it. But Essentially, my mother made an investment in this house that we were all going to live in together. She saw that as being the equivalent of what would have been at that time like five years rent for her in the apartment that she was living in. And we had the conversation with my brother that if my mom had passed before those five years were up, anything that was left in her estate, we would do the math differently to a cut to account for the fact that she had made an investment in this home and that we were the beneficiaries of that in terms of the ownership and the equity build that was happening in this home. So that didn't happen, obviously that was 11 years ago. So it's a moot point now. But we were all on the same page, my mother, my brother and I, and my husband and my brother's wife, about how that would play out were my mom to pass before the five years had sort of exhausted what she had considered a rent contribution for five years. That is just one possible way that you could do it. But the point is, we did not, as David said, have a trust fund. My mom did not have a tremendous amount of money to share around. So there are other ways that you could handle this. I have talked with many families who are, there are siblings that are part of the family conversation, but not part of the financial dynamic or the financial contributions or the ownership structures. And I have seen many times where those siblings were very happy to not be a part of that and to have the other sibling who would be living in the multi-gen home with their aging parents be the beneficiary of the investment in the equity build in exchange for the care and support that they were going to provide for their parents. Many siblings, like my brother, are very grateful that their parents are living with other close families with their siblings. So that they know that their parents are being well cared for. Now, of course, you have to have healthy family relationships and a healthy family dynamic in order for that to work. And it also has to be put in writing. It also has to be legally documented. So I hope that's helpful for you to hear. Sometimes you see these kind of inflammatory statements on social media that make it sound like certain certain things are impossible to work out among families and I'm here to tell you that is just not true. Of course there are complexities, but many, many solutions can be found if families are willing to work together. Okay, let's do another one. This is a question, not a statement. How do you find property that will allow for more than one dwelling on the land? This is a complicated question and answer. And here's why. The rules For what is allowed to be built on property very wildly across the world. So I get questions sometimes from seems like people in Canada and Australia often will reach out to me and ask if my US-based materials are applicable where they live. And my answer is always I focus a lot on family conversations and arrangements and agreements and boundaries. And those things are like 90% applicable to anybody in the world. But when it comes down to two things, financing tools that may vary from country to country, and land and property zoning rules and regulations, those things need to be looked into on a hyper, hyper local level. Even just here in the US, the rules vary so greatly from state to state. So you may know I host these monthly. Multi-gen coffee chats. It's a free Zoom call that I host once a month. You're welcome to join us. You can always check out my website, julieford.com, to see when the next one's coming up. It's usually the last Friday of the month from 12 o'clock to 1 o'clock Eastern time. Just check the calendar though, and then you can get you can register and get a link. It's always free, but I'll send you a Zoom link. So because I host these calls, now we've got 20, 30 people coming every month, which I love. We started with five, I think, and we've grown a lot over the past eight or nine months of hosting these calls. And we have people from generally all over the US on the call. So I get to an opportunity to hear from many families who live in states that have very different rules. So for instance, here in Massachusetts, we have pretty good ADU accessory dwelling unit regulation as of about a year and a half ago. So we had an act Called the Affordable Homes Act that made it a right for any single family property to add an ADU, an accessory dwelling unit. So maybe that's build out an in-law apartment in the basement. Maybe that's add a backyard bungalow or transform a garage. But now, and there are certain guidelines to it. There are some setbacks that are regulated by the town and city that you live in. Of course, there are septic or sewer requirements, and you have to follow building code. There are There are a lot of things that still dictate what you can actually do. But the bottom line is you are allowed to have an extra unit on your property here in Massachusetts. In California, you all you also are, and I think you can have up to three in California. Don't quote me on anything outside of Massachusetts, as I'm not an expert outside Massachusetts in terms of what the regulations are, but I am paying attention. So there are some states though where that's really difficult to do. So, the answer to this question is you really need to understand what the government regulations are where you live. So, let's say you're in the United States, make sure you understand the state regulations and your local city and town regulations. So, I always recommend go to your city hall or your town hall and talk to the building department. Ask them what the rules are and Make friends with them because most people who work in planning departments and building departments really do want to support the community and the people who live there and they want to help you figure this out. And they can help you figure out what the rules are and then how to navigate through those rules and make this property happen. Hopefully it can. Now, in some places the the regulations are still too restrictive. The the old zoning regulations have not caught up with where we need new. regulations to be to support the world that we're living in now, where we're supporting aging parents and we're trying to help young adult kids be able to afford property. Those old rules restricting properties from adding an additional unit onto the property, especially for family, but even for rental opportunities, they just don't fit the world that we're living in today and the economic reality that we're living in today. So The answer to that question is you need to do your homework, research at the local level, but also research at the state level or whatever, wherever you live, the next level of government up from that is. And the reason I say that is because, you know, say Massachusetts has about 350 cities and towns. It is the job of those cities and towns now to comply with the new laws in Massachusetts, but imagine very small towns with minimal resources, trying to like keep up with exactly what is allowed, there's a learning curve there. And your state regulation should help you navigate better with your local city and town, what that learning curve looks like, because there may be some delays in the local level of what they're how they're interpreting that new law and how they're applying that. So I say that so that you don't get met with a wall and just give up. I hope that's helpful. Okay, that's it for today. Next week I'm going to bring you a few more, and I think we're going to get into talking about some financing questions that I have received and probably also some family relationship questions as well. So I hope I'll see you again next week. Please like, subscribe, share this episode with your friends, follow along if it resonates with you. And I will see you next time. Thanks for being here. Thanks so much for joining me for this week's episode of Home After 50. If this episode resonated with you, please make sure you're following and subscribing so you never miss a thing. And you can find more resources at my website, julieforbes.com. See you next time.