Latest / Blue Leader Nation Podcast / Episode 15: The Expectation Effect
Transcript
- Edward Pallas: This is Blue Leader Nation. We're here to develop those men and women in law enforcement who want to be respected leaders and to mold you into becoming a legendary leader. If it's leadership, personal growth, and self-development, we're talking about it. Whether you're new or a veteran, you've found your new home. This is the Blue Leader Nation. Now, here's your host, Ed Pallas ⁓ Hello and welcome back to the Blue Leader Nation podcast. Have you ever had someone believe in you before you fully believe in yourself? Maybe it was a coach or a teacher or even an FTO, a supervisor, a mentor, someone that saw something in you that you did not quite see yet. And because they saw it, they treated you differently. Maybe they challenged you or they coached you. They gave you a chance. They connected with you. They corrected you, but they did not crush you. They held the standard high, but they made it clear they believed you could reach it. Now, let me ask you the opposite question. Have you ever had a leader who clearly had you labeled? Maybe they decided you were lazy or difficult, or not leadership material, or too young or too old. Or too quiet or too outspoken, or just one of those people. And once that label was there, everything you did seemed to confirm it. If you made a mistake, it was proof. If you asked a question, it was weakness. If you pushed back, it was attitude. If you stayed quiet, it was disengagement. If you tried harder, it was fake. If you stopped trying, it was exactly what they expected. That's the danger of expectations. They are invisible, but they are not neutral. And today, we're going to talk about how a leader's expectations can shape motivation, job satisfaction, confidence, effort, and performance. Today's episode was inspired by a book that I recently finished called The Expectation Effect. The full title is The Expectation Effect How Your Mindset Can Change Your World by David Robson. Robson. David Robeson. I apologize if I mispronounce that. Anyway, I'll include a link to the book in the show notes. But I want to give you full disclosure, I'm trying something new. The link is going to be an Amazon affiliate link. And that means that I earn a very small commission, about 30 cents. to help keep this channel going. If you purchase it through that link, it does nothing to your price. It just gives me that extra income to keep the podcast going. But before we get into the book, I have a breaking news story. I don't know if you heard, but the inventor of the heat index just died. He was eighty eight, but he felt like one hundred seven. All right, now let's get into why this book matters for leadership. The basic idea of the expectation effect is this our expectations don't just sit quietly inside our heads. They can influence how we experience the world. They can shape learning. They can shape performance. They can even influence how our bodies respond to pain and illness and aging and recovery. Now, I want to be really clear up front. This is not one of those just think happy thoughts and everything will magically work out messages. The point is not that mindset fixes everything. The point is that expectations influence perception. Perception influences behavior, and behavior influences outcomes. Over time, those expectations can become part of the environment. That we live and work in. One of the clearest examples of this is the placebo effect, as mentioned in this book. Most of us have heard of the placebo effect in medicine. A person receives a treatment that has no active medical ingredient. Maybe it's a sugar pill. But because they believe the treatment may help, they sometimes experience real improvement. That improvement is not simply imaginary. The pill may be inactive, but the expectation is not. The person's belief can trigger real psychological and physiological responses, especially in areas like pain, fatigue, stress, and other symptoms. And there's also a flip side to the placebo effect, and it's called the nocebo effect. That is when negative expectations can produce. Negative results. If someone expects a medication to make them feel terrible, they may experience side effects even if the treatment itself is inactive. In other words, expectations can help, but expectations can also hurt. That matters for leadership because leaders create expectations all the time. Not with sugar pills, with words, with tone. With facial expressions, with who they trust and who they coach, and who they avoid, also who they challenge, who they believe has potential, and who they have quietly written off. So here's the leadership question: if expectations can influence how people experience pain, fatigue, stress, and performance. What happens when a supervisor's expectations become part of someone's daily work environment? What happens when your people can feel that you believe in them? And what happens when they can feel you've already given up on them? This brings us to one of the most important leadership ideas connected to expectation. It's called the Pygmalion Effect. Before we talk about the psychology. We need to talk about the story behind the name. The term comes from an ancient myth of Pygmalion, most famously told by the Roman poet Ovid, or Avid, depending on if you're British or English. I think it's Ovid. Anyway, the Roman poet wrote about this in his work The Metamorphoses. In the story, Pygmalion was a sculptor from Cyprus. Apparently he was not a real ladies man. He actually gave up on talking to real women. But he carved a statue of a woman out of ivory, and the statue was so beautiful, so perfect in his eyes, that he fell in love with it. Later versions of the story often call the statue Galatia or Galatea, although the name came later. It's not a big deal. Pygmalion did not treat the statue as a cold piece of ivory. He admired it. He cared for it. He bought it gifts. He saw life in it before life was actually there. Then, during a festival honoring the goddess Aphrodite, Pygmalion prayed for a wife, like his ivory statue. When he returned home, the statue came to life. The image is powerful. Pygmalion saw potential. He treated the object of his attention according to what he believed it could become. And in the myth, that expectation became reality. That is why the name fits this leadership concept. The Pygmalion effect is the idea that our expectations of others can influence how we treat them, and that treatment can affect and impact their motivation. Their confidence, their effort, and their performance. In leadership, we're not bringing statues to life, but we are shaping confidence. We are shaping effort. We're shaping motivation, satisfaction, and performance. We're shaping the way people see themselves at work. And sometimes, whether we realize it or not, we're shaping their actual performance. In the nineteen sixties, psychologists Robert Rosenthal and Lenore Jacobson conducted a study that would challenge how we think about the relationship between teachers and students. Don't let the date fool you. Hear me out. Published in their book entitled Pygnalian in the Classroom, the experiment unfolded at Spruce Elementary School in California, and its findings were striking. At the start of the school year, teachers were told that a handful of their students had been identified through testing as likely academic growth spurters. That's the language. In other words, children poised for an exceptional leap forward in the coming months. Naturally, teachers paid closer attention to those students. They held higher hopes for them, and they may have pushed them further. There was just one problem. Those students had been chosen at random. No hidden brilliance had been detected. No special test had singled them out. The only thing that set these children apart was what their teachers believed about them. And yet, by the end of the year, the students labeled as growth spurters had made measurable academic gains. With the effect most pronounced among the youngest students. Rosenthal and Jacobson concluded that the teachers' expectations had quietly shaped their behavior in the classroom. How much encouragement they offered, how challenging the material they assigned was, how they responded to a wrong answer or a hesitant hand. Those small, daily interactions added up. The belief became the outcome. The label became the reality. Now, need to be fair here. The study became famous, but it was also criticized, as almost every study in behavioral science is. Later researchers raised questions about the methodology, the testing instruments, and how consistently the findings could be replicated. So the responsible takeaway is not Expectations magically raise IQ. That would be overselling it. The better takeaway is this expectations influence behavior. Behavior influences environment. Environment influences confidence. Confidence influences effort. And effort influences performance. That is the leadership lesson because police supervisors are not elementary school teachers, although I know sometimes we feel that way. But in leadership, the dynamic is similar. People notice what their leaders expect from them. They notice who gets trusted and who gets coached, who gets patience, and they notice who gets written off. They see who receives eye contact, time, explanation, and opportunity. They notice the leader's face before a leader says a word. And over time, Those signals shape motivation, they shape satisfaction, and they shape confidence. They shape effort. And sometimes, many times, they shape performance. The Pygmalion effect in leadership is not just about what you believe. It's about how your belief changes your behavior toward people. That's the key. Because a leader who believes someone has potential. will usually lead that person differently. They will coach them more and explain more. They will give them more. They will offer better and more consistent feedback. And they will give them more opportunities. But a leader who has already labeled someone as lazy or difficult, unmotivated, retired on duty, or hopeless will also lead differently. They may become shorter with them, colder, more sarcastic, less patient, less curious, less willing to invest. And then when that person disengages, The leader says, See, I knew it. That's the trap. The leader thinks they predicted the behavior, but there is a real possibility that they helped produce it. Let's make this practical. Imagine two officers make the same mistake on a report. Same mistake, same policy issue, same need for correction. Officer A is viewed by the supervisor as sharp, motivated, and full of potential. So the supervisor says, Hey, you missed a few important details here. You are better than this. Let's walk through what a stronger report looks like. Because this is the kind of thing that matters as you move forward. Now imagine Officer B makes the same mistake. But Officer B is viewed by the supervisor as lazy or careless. So the supervisor says, again, this is exactly what I'm talking about. Fix it. Same mistake, different expectation, different tone, no coaching, different emotional impact. Officer A walks away thinking. I need to tighten this up. My boss believes I can do better. Officer B walks away thinking, no matter what I do, this boss already has me labeled. Now, does officer B still need to fix the report? Absolutely. This is not about ignoring performance. It's not about lowering standards. This is law enforcement. Reports matter. Detail matters. Accuracy and accountability matters. But the leadership question is this Are you correcting in a way that develops people? Are you correcting in a way that confirms your negative opinion of them? That's a big difference. One of the strongest lines I want you to remember from this episode is this the Pygmalion effect is not about pretending everyone is outstanding, it's about refusing to lead people. As if their current performance is their permanent identity. Let me say that again. It's about refusing to lead people as if their current performance is their permanent identity. That matters because leaders are always telling stories about their people. Sometimes out loud, often silently. We say things like: She's a future leader. He's not ready yet. She squared away. He's a problem child. She gets it. He doesn't care. Or they are high maintenance. Or they are leadership material. And once we assign that label, we start seeing the person through that lens. This is where confirmation bias kicks in. Confirmation bias is our tendency to notice evidence. That supports what we already believe while missing or minimizing evidence that challenges it. Once we put someone in a mental file folder, we tend to keep filing the same kind of paperwork. If you think someone is lazy, every mistake becomes proof. If you think someone has potential, every mistake becomes a coaching opportunity. That's why it's so important. Your expectations do not just stay in your head. They leak. They leak through your tone, through your body language, through your facial expression. They leak through who gets assignments and what assignments they get. They leak through who gets your time, who gets mentoring. They leak through who gets the benefit of the doubt. They leak through who gets corrected privately and who gets embarrassed publicly. They leak through whether your first reaction is curiosity or judgment. And followers notice, they notice everything. Police officers are professional people watchers. They read rooms, they read threat cues, they read facial expressions and tone and posture. They read whether someone is being straight with them or whether they smell BS. So if you're a supervisor and you think your people do not know how you feel about them, there's a good chance you're kidding yourself. They know, maybe not perfectly, maybe not always fairly, but they're reading you all the time. And your body language is a big part of this. Think about how low expectation body language looks like. The officer walks into your office, and before you say a word, your face says, Here we go again. You sigh, you lean back, you check your phone, you avoid eye contact. You tend to cut them off and give short answers. You look annoyed. You listen just long enough to respond. But not long enough to understand. You may not say, I don't believe you, but your body already gave that speech. Now compare that with high expectation leadership. The standard is still high. The correction may still be direct, but your posture says, hey, I'm engaged. Your eye contact says, you matter enough for my full attention. Your tone says this is serious, but you aren't disposable. Your questions say I'm trying to understand before I judge. Your coaching says I believe improvement is possible. That does not mean you become soft. In fact, this kind of leadership can be more demanding because when you believe someone can do better, you do not let them hide behind excuses. You don't let them drift, and you don't let them settle. You say this this is not the standard, and I believe you are capable of meeting the standard. So let's talk about what needs to change. That is very different from this is not the standard, and this is exactly what I expected from you. One builds responsibility, the other builds resentment. Here's another way to think about it. Accountability without belief feels like punishment. Belief without accountability becomes wishful thinking. Good leadership requires both. You need belief and accountability, support and standards, patience and honesty, encouragement and correction. Because if you only bring belief but no accountability, people may feel supported, but they're not going to be challenged. If you only bring accountability but no belief, people may feel judged but not developed. The leadership sweet spot is a high standard, high belief. That is where people grow. Now, let's talk about motivation. When people believe their leader sees potential in them, something changes. They're more likely to engage, they're more likely to ask questions, and they're more likely to accept feedback. Why? Because the feedback feels developmental instead of personal. They're more likely to volunteer. And more likely to take appropriate risk. They're more likely to recover from mistakes and more likely to think, my boss is hard on me because they're trying to build me, not because they're trying to break me. That distinction matters. But when people believe their leader has already written them off, they often protect themselves. They put up the defensive shields. They stop asking questions. They stop bringing ideas. They do just enough to avoid getting hammered. They become defensive. They often become sarcastic. They become quiet. They disengage. They stop trying to impress someone they believe cannot be impressed. And then the supervisor says, see, they just don't care. Maybe. Sometimes people really are unmotivated. Sometimes performance problems are real. And misconduct can be real. Sometimes the person needs discipline. Sometimes they might even need the biggest hammer of all. They might need to leave the organization. Termination. This is not fantasy land. Before we decide that we have a person completely figured out, we should look in the mirror and say, What role have my expectations played in this relationship? Have I coached this person as if improvement is possible? Have I been clear about the standard? Have I given useful feedback? Have I been consistent and fair? Have I created an environment where this person can recover from a mistake? Or have I led them as if the verdict was already in? That's an uncomfortable set of questions, which is usually where the growth is. Now, let me give you a common law enforcement scenario. A new supervisor gets promoted and inherits a squad. On that squad there is an officer with a reputation. You know the one. Before the supervisor Has even had a real conversation with this officer, people start offering warnings. Watch that guy. He's a lazy one. She is always complaining. He's the problem. Or she does not respect supervisors. Now, some of that information may be useful. Leaders should not be naive. Patterns matter, history matters. The best predictor of future behavior is often past behavior. But here's the danger: if you accept someone else's label as your starting point, you may never give that employee a clean opportunity to be different with you. You may walk into the relationship already irritated or guarded or suspicious or just waiting, expecting problems. And because you expect problems, you lead differently. And that employee, they feel it. They respond differently. You would then interpret their defensiveness as proof. The cycle begins. So what should you do instead? You can be informed by history without being controlled by it. You can say, I've heard some things, but I want to build my own working relationship with you. You can even say, I'm going to be clear with you about expectations, and I'm going to give you a fair chance to meet them. Or you could say, I'm not ignoring past issues, but I'm also not going to assume the future has to look exactly like the past. That is leadership, not gullible or soft or blind, but fair and direct. Developmental and professional. And here's the bonus. Even if the employee does not change, you've led with integrity. You've given clear expectations. You gave them a fair opportunity, maybe that they've never gotten before. You've documented accurately and you've held the standard. That matters because the Pygmalion effect is not a guarantee. It's not magic. You cannot positively think someone into professionalism. You cannot body language your way out of the serious performance problem. You cannot smile misconduct in the compliance. But you can make sure your leadership behavior is not making things worse. You can make sure you're not contributing to the very disengagement you're complaining about. You can make sure you're not turning a coachable employee. into a resentful one. You can make sure you're not confusing your label with their identity. Now let's bring this into communication because expectations show up in the words we choose. Low expectation leadership sounds like this. Hey, try not to mess this up. Or I already know how this is going to go. Or this is why I don't give you anything important. Or even You're probably not gonna like this, but or worse, why can't you be more like so and so? Now compare that to high expectation language. I'm giving this to you because I think you are ready for the next level. Or this needs to improve, and I believe you can improve it. Or, hey, this is not the standard. Let's talk about how you get back to it. Or you have more ability than your current performance is showing. Maybe even I'm going to be direct because I respect you. I respect you enough to be honest. I'm not lowering the standard for you. I'm helping you reach it. This language matters because people do not just hear correction. They hear what you believe about them underneath the correction. That's why two supervisors can say similar things and get very different reactions. One supervisor corrects and the officer thinks they're trying to help me improve. Another supervisor corrects and the officer thinks they already think I'm a failure. The words may be similar, but the relationship, the tone, and the expectation are different. Now, I want to pause here and I want to speak directly to you, my first line supervisors, especially. My new sergeants, your leadership is always on display. You're being watched more than you realize. Your officers are trying to figure out who you are. They're trying to ask: are you fair, consistent? Do you play favorites? Do you only care about the superstars? They want to know: are you going to develop the quiet ones? They want to know if you're gonna avoid hard conversations. They watch to see if you listen, if you already have favorites, if you already know who the problem children are. And here's the hard part. You may be answering those questions without knowing it. By who you talk to after roll call, by who you invite into your decisions, by who you trust with meaningful work, by who you interrupt, who you joke with. And who you teach, coach, and mentor. Leadership is loud even when you're not talking. Let me say that again. So that's pretty good. Leadership is loud even when you're not talking. Your people are listening to your behavior. So what do we do with this? How do we apply the pygmalion effect without turning it into a motivational poster? Here's five practical steps. First, audit the labels you have placed on your people. Ask yourself who have I labeled? Who do I see as high potential or difficult? Who do I avoid? Who do I expect is gonna disappoint me every time? Who do I expect to shine? Then ask the harder question. How is that label, one of the ones we just went over? How is that label changing my leadership behavior? Because that's where the real work begins. All right, that was number one. Second, separate current performance from permanent identity. There's a difference between saying, This report was careless and saying you are careless. There's a difference between saying you handle that call poorly and saying you're bad at this. There's a difference between saying you need to improve your attitude and saying you're toxic. Behavior can be corrected. Identity labels, they tend to stick. So focus on behavior, focus on standards. And specific actions. Focus on what needs to change. All right, three. Communicate high standards and high belief. This is the combination. High standards without belief can feel cold, but belief without high standards can feel weak. But together they sound like this. I'm going to hold you to a high standard because the job matters, the community matters, the team matters, and I believe you are capable of meeting that standard. That is strong leadership. Fourth, watch your nonverbal communication. Before your next difficult conversation, check yourself. What does your face say? What does your posture say? Are you already annoyed? Are you already dismissive? Are you listening to understand or listening to respond? Are you looking at the person or are you looking through them? Sometimes the first adjustment is not the script of what you're gonna say, it's your face. All right, last one, number five. Create opportunities for people to rise. Belief is not just a feeling. It has to become a behavior. If you believe someone has potential, give them opportunities to grow. Let them lead a small project or let them brief part of roll call. Let them mentor someone newer or handle responsibility, extra responsibility, but with guidance. Let them stretch, not recklessly and not without supervision, but intentionally, intentionally develop people. Develop them through responsibility. And sometimes people don't see themselves as leaders until a leader gives them something worth leading. That is where expectations become developmental. Now, let's talk about the opposite of the pygmalion effect. Sometimes this is referred to as the Gollum effect. If the pygmalion effect is about higher expectations contributing to improved performance, the Gollum effect is the darker side. Low expectations can contribute to lower performance. Again, not magically, but behaviorally. If I expect less from someone, I may give them less attention or trust or feedback. Then their confidence drops. Their motivation, satisfaction, and performance drops. And then I say, see, I was right all along. This is a dangerous leadership loop. And it happens more than we want to admit, especially with employees who frustrate us. And every supervisor has them. The question is not whether someone frustrates you. The question is whether your frustration has become the lens through which you see everything they do. Now, let me give you a phrase that I think every supervisor should remember. Lead the person in front of you, not just the reputation attached to them. That doesn't mean you ignore history. It means that you do not let history do all of your thinking for you. Still document, still hold standards, still protect the needs of your people and the needs of your organization. You need to protect the team, but you also remain open to growth because the person in front of you. May not be finished developing. And by the way, neither are you. This is another humbling part of leadership. We want people to grow while we are still growing ourselves. Now, let's connect this back to David Robson's The Expectation Effect. One of the reasons I like this book is because it reminds us that expectations are not soft. They are powerful. They influence how people. Interpret stress, how people experience fatigue, and how people approach learning. They influence how people perform. So for leaders, expectations are not just private thoughts. They're part of a leadership climate. Your expectations help create the emotional weather of your team. Ooh, I like that. Your expectations create the emotional weather of your team. And every team has weather. Some teams feel tense, some feel defeated. Some are just flat out cynical. But then there are some that are energized. Some teams feel safe but sloppy. Some teams feel accountable but afraid. Some teams feel challenged and supported. That last one, that's where you want to be. Challenged and supported. High standards, high belief, clear expectations, real accountability, developmental feedback. That's the environment where people are most likely to perform well and grow. So here's the challenge for this week. Pick one person. You supervise the one that frustrates you. Not your favorite person. Not the easy one. Not the person you already believe in. Pick the person you may have quietly labeled. This is going to take a little self-awareness. Then ask yourself three questions. Number one. What story have I written about this person? Question two. How is that story affecting my tone, my body language, my patience, and my willing to invest? Third question. What would I change if I still held the standard but led them as if improvement were possible? Doesn't mean you ignore poor performance. That's not what I'm saying. It means you stop leading from the assumption that poor performance is permanent. That's the move. Hold the standard, communicate belief, coach the behavior, watch your tone, check your body language, create opportunities, and also document fairly. Stay open to growth because leadership is not just what we say, it's what people feel we believe about them. And sometimes the most powerful thing a leader can do is to see the better version. Of someone before they can fully see it themselves. This is not soft. This is not naive. This is leadership. Because expectations are never neutral. They either build people up or box people in or quietly teach them where they stand. If you want to read the expectation effect by David Robson. I'll include a link in the show notes. And again, this is going to be hopefully an Amazon affiliate link, which means I earn a small commission if you purchase through this link at no cost to you. It helps keep the show going. So I'd appreciate your support. More importantly, it's a worthwhile read for leaders, trainers, coaches, and anyone interested in how expectations shape performance. So this week, pay attention to your expectations, your people. already are. Thanks for joining me on Blue Leader Nation, where we have real talk for the next generation of law enforcement leaders. Lead well, stay steady, and remember what you believe about your people eventually leaks into how you lead them. Make sure it's worth leaking. Speaking of leaking, all right, let's here we go. Let's end this on a funny note. What do you call a room Full of cynical plumbers. A skeptic tank. You're welcome. Feel free to use that one. No, seriously, on my permission. See you in the next episode. Keep leading, keep learning. You've been listening to the Blue Leader Nation podcast. Our passion is anyone within the thin blue line who wanna take it to the next level. We hope you didn't mind the dad jokes, by the way. If you enjoyed the show, make sure to like, rate, and review. And we'll be back soon. But in the meantime, hit the website at www.blueleadernation.com.